Shouting at Stars: A History of Interstellar Messages — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:12In early 1972, a probe known as Pioneer 10 was launched into space
- 0:17on a mission to the largest planet in the Solar System.
- 0:21After millennia of speculation and wonder,
- 0:24humanity got its first close-up view of Jupiter.
- 0:30Accelerated by the immense gravity of the planet,
- 0:33Pioneer 10 was then catapulted into deep space,
- 0:36destined to leave the Solar System and roam the galaxy for billions of years.
- 0:42On the off-chance that this vestige of humanity
- 0:45should one day be intercepted by an alien intelligence,
- 0:49it was affixed with a message.
- 0:51A message designed to answer three central questions.
- 0:56[Carl Sagan] Where we are, when we are, and who we are.
- 1:04More than half a century has now passed
- 1:06since the launch of our first galactic emissary,
- 1:08and in that time, we've made numerous attempts to communicate with life beyond.
- 1:13Either by attaching greeting cards to probes headed for interstellar space
- 1:17or by targeting our cosmic neighbors with high-powered beams of light.
- 1:22So far, humanity's been left on read, but that could change at any moment.
- 1:27As long as we keep making noise, there's always a chance we'll be heard.
- 1:31An exceedingly slim chance, as we'll see, but a non-zero chance nonetheless.
- 1:36Given the paradigm-shifting potential of contacting beings from another world,
- 1:40it sure would be nice to know what exactly we've been telling them all these years.
- 1:44I mean, don't get me wrong,
- 1:45"Where we are, when we are, and who we are",
- 1:48sounds really neat and all, but it's not exactly rich in detail.
- 1:52So let's start with that plaque on Pioneer 10.
- 1:55What does it say, and more importantly,
- 1:57to whom should I direct my anger when the aliens arrive to harvest my bones?
- 2:14The idea to attach a message to Pioneer 10
- 2:17was the brainchild of journalist and author Eric Burgess.
- 2:20Less than four months before the probe was scheduled to launch,
- 2:23Burgess approached famed astronomer and science communicator Carl Sagan,
- 2:27who, in turn, relayed the proposal to NASA.
- 2:30Sagan was given three weeks to devise the message,
- 2:32and with the help of his wife and artist Linda
- 2:34as well as fellow astronomer Frank Drake,
- 2:37they scrambled together a series of pictograms
- 2:39etched into a gold-laden plate of aluminum.
- 2:42In the words of Sagan...
- 2:48Near the upper-left corner, we find a diagram of hydrogen,
- 2:52the simplest and most abundant element in the universe.
- 2:56One electron bound to a proton.
- 2:59More specifically, the diagram depicts a single atom of hydrogen
- 3:03transitioning from one energy state to another,
- 3:05which is meant to be conveyed by this horizontal line here in the middle.
- 3:09This shift in energy is known as a hyperfine transition,
- 3:13and it's accompanied by the emission of a radio wave.
- 3:16That radio wave has a very specific frequency
- 3:18that's so prominent across the universe that we've given it a name,
- 3:22the hydrogen line.
- 3:24Something that beings of sufficient intelligence
- 3:26to capture a drifting spacecraft
- 3:28would no doubt be aware of as well.
- 3:30In human terms, it has a frequency of about 1420 megahertz
- 3:35which means that each cycle of the wave has a period of about 0.7 nanoseconds
- 3:41and a corresponding length of roughly 21 centimeters.
- 3:44The recipients would obviously express their measurements
- 3:47using something other than nanoseconds and centimeters,
- 3:50but what's important here is that they're measuring the same thing
- 3:53and that that thing never changes.
- 3:55The duration of one wavecycle and the distance covered during that cycle
- 4:00remains the same across the universe.
- 4:02This allows us to establish a shared unit of both time and length.
- 4:06We're basically telling the aliens to treat their measurement
- 4:09of the hyperfine transition of neutral hydrogen
- 4:12as one unit of time and one unit of length.
- 4:15That's why there's a vertical line here in the middle,
- 4:18which is meant to convey the concept of one in binary.
- 4:21But, of course, hydrogen is merely one of many
- 4:24possible interpretations of this diagram.
- 4:26The aliens could just as easily think it's some sort of language,
- 4:30technology, star system, or literally anything else.
- 4:33To help them narrow down the list, the plaque includes three outlined silhouettes
- 4:37of a man, a woman, and Pioneer 10.
- 4:40These illustrations were drawn to scale,
- 4:42so the aliens can use the spacecraft's diameter
- 4:44as a basis for deriving the height of the two figures in the foreground.
- 4:48In human terms, that would make the man approximately 182 centimeters
- 4:52and the woman about 169.
- 4:55The woman's height has been further emphasized
- 4:57by two demarcation marks along the right edge here.
- 5:00Between them is a sequence of four lines representing the number eight in binary.
- 5:05The purpose of this number is to communicate to the aliens
- 5:08that the woman is eight times as tall as the wavelength of the hydrogen line.
- 5:12In human terms, that's about 169,
- 5:15just like the woman's height relative to the probe's diameter.
- 5:19In other words, the interpretation of this as a schematic of hydrogen
- 5:24and the interpretation of this as an outline of the spacecraft
- 5:27are mutually corroborative.
- 5:29They provide the aliens with a means of deriving the height of this figure
- 5:33on the basis of two distinct measurements,
- 5:35which should help them narrow down the list of possible interpretations.
- 5:40At least, that was the idea.
- 5:43But when you actually measure the height of the couple
- 5:46relative to this sketch of the probe,
- 5:48you quickly realize they're about 10 centimeters too tall.
- 5:51While I have no way of confirming this, I suspect the source of this discrepancy
- 5:55is that the reflector dish on Pioneer 10 is not a perfect circle.
- 6:00It's slightly wider in this dimension than in this one,
- 6:03known as a major and minor axis.
- 6:05If we assume that this outline of the probe
- 6:07is oriented with the minor axis along the vertical,
- 6:10the relative height of the couple is indeed what you'd expect.
- 6:13But if that is what the Sagans and Drake intended,
- 6:16only two of the three antenna struts should be visible here in the front.
- 6:20The fact that all three have been drawn on the plaque,
- 6:22implies the probe is oriented with the major axis along the vertical,
- 6:26thereby increasing the couples' height by roughly 10 centimeters.
- 6:31Nevertheless, it's hardly surprising for an oversight like this to go unnoticed
- 6:35given they only had three weeks to assemble everything,
- 6:38and Sagan acknowledged they could have done a better job
- 6:40had they not been so pressed for time.
- 6:43Moving on to the left side of the plaque,
- 6:45we find a starburst pattern of 15 straight lines emanating from a central point.
- 6:50This is a galactic map of pulsars
- 6:52that's meant to help the aliens pinpoint the Solar System.
- 6:56Pulsars are rapidly rotating neutron stars that can easily be spotted
- 6:59from thousands or even millions of lightyears away.
- 7:03They're often described as cosmic clocks or
- 7:05lighthouses because they're not only extremely bright
- 7:08but pulsate at very consistent rates.
- 7:11This red line shooting off to the right
- 7:14represents the distance between the Sun and the center of the galaxy,
- 7:17while the green lines represent the relative distance
- 7:20between the Sun and 14 pulsars.
- 7:23To make it easier to identify the pulsars,
- 7:25each line is accompanied by the star's rotation period expressed in binary,
- 7:29marked here in blue.
- 7:31Take this one, for instance.
- 7:32This star is known as the Vela Pulsar, and it's about 1 000 lightyears from Earth.
- 7:37Its rotation period has been expressed in waveperiods of the hydrogen line
- 7:42and reads 126 726 823 when translated from binary to decimal.
- 7:50What that means is that it takes the Vela Pulsar
- 7:52almost 127 million times longer to complete one rotation
- 7:57than the waveperiod of a hydrogen atom undergoing hyperfine transition.
- 8:02In human terms, that's about 89 million nanoseconds or
- 8:05eleven rotations every second, which is about this fast.
- 8:20By scouring the galaxy for pulsars
- 8:22that match the information embedded within this map,
- 8:24the aliens could theoretically triangulate the Solar System.
- 8:28In fact, the chart not only discloses our location in space but also in time.
- 8:33As Sagan put it...
- 8:35[Carl Sagan] Where we are, when we are, and who we are.
- 8:39This goes back to the cosmic clock analogy
- 8:41because pulsars gradually wind down at highly predictable rates.
- 8:44So even though the Vela Pulsar will have a much slower rate of spin
- 8:48by the time it's observed by our hypothetical aliens,
- 8:50they could simply wind back the clock until its rotation period
- 8:54matched the one etched into the plaque.
- 8:56Repeating that process for at least some of the other pulsars
- 8:59would enable them to figure out not just from where,
- 9:02but also when Pioneer 10 was launched.
- 9:05At least, that was the idea.
- 9:08But when the plaque was created,
- 9:09the existence of pulsars had only been known for about four years.
- 9:13Astronomers have since learned a lot more about them,
- 9:15and they're not nearly as rare, stable, and long-lived as once believed.
- 9:19They can only be observed from very specific vantage points, and
- 9:23unpredictable speedups, slowdowns, and glitches
- 9:26challenge the cosmic clock analogy.
- 9:29Sagan and Drake were aware of at least
- 9:31some of these issues, but there was only so much they could've foreseen
- 9:34with the limited data available at the time.
- 9:36In fact, there was such great uncertainty
- 9:38regarding the distance of some of the featured pulsars
- 9:41that they added these breaks in the lines,
- 9:43indicating they're based on rough estimates rather than exact figures.
- 9:49Finally, on the bottom of the plaque,
- 9:51we find a plain schematic of the Solar System.
- 9:54These binary numbers represent the orbital distance of each planet
- 9:58expressed as multiples of one tenth of the mean distance between the Sun and Mercury.
- 10:04For instance, the number above Earth reads 26 in decimal,
- 10:07which means it is 26 times further away
- 10:10than 10% of the distance between the Sun and Mercury.
- 10:14The obvious problem with this approach
- 10:16is that it requires the recipients to already be familiar with the Solar System.
- 10:20Otherwise, one tenth of the distance between the Sun and Mercury
- 10:24is completely meaningless.
- 10:25We might as well have expected them to be familiar with kilometers or miles.
- 10:30To quote the creators of the plaque...
- 10:36It's unclear why the Sagans and Drake
- 10:38knowingly used an indecipherable unit of length
- 10:41when they had already gone through the trouble of creating a universal yardstick
- 10:45with this schematic of hydrogen.
- 10:47My best guess is that the wavelength of a state-shifting hydrogen atom
- 10:51was simply too small a unit to represent interplanetary distances,
- 10:56and the resulting binary strings became too long to neatly fit on the plaque.
- 11:00Again, they only had three weeks to do all of this.
- 11:04Last but not least, the trajectory of the spacecraft has been traced with an arrow,
- 11:08and the probe's main antenna is pointing at home.
- 11:19Over half a century later,
- 11:21Pioneer 10 is now more than 20 billion kilometers from the Sun.
- 11:25That might sound like a lot, especially given how I just emphasized that number,
- 11:29but it's only about three times further away than Pluto,
- 11:32and it takes less than a day for a light beam to cover the same distance.
- 11:36Even though it's darting through space at several kilometers per second,
- 11:40the probe won't surpass even the nearest star to the Sun
- 11:43for many tens of thousands of years.
- 11:47But it gets worse because Pioneer 10 is not headed for any particular star.
- 11:50It's expected to pass within a few trillion kilometers of a relatively nearby system
- 11:55in about 90 000 years or so when this star, all the way out here,
- 12:00will come closer to the Sun than Proxima Centauri is today.
- 12:04While an exoplanet has yet to be detected around this star,
- 12:07if one does exist, and that planet just so happens to be inhabited
- 12:10by intelligent beings in possession of technology that allows them to detect a
- 12:15perfectly silent and practically invisible speck gently gliding by their system
- 12:19at a distance greater than a thousand times the orbit of Pluto,
- 12:23then, yeah...
- 12:25...maybe they'll see it.
- 12:31A nearly identical probe was launched in 1973 known as Pioneer 11,
- 12:36and it was outfitted with the exact same plaque as Pioneer 10.
- 12:39Much like its predecessor, Pioneer 11 was just kind of hurtled into deep space
- 12:43with no particular target in mind.
- 12:46While a chance encounter with another planetary system is not impossible,
- 12:50even across timescales of many billions of years,
- 12:53Sagan and Drake believed it was more likely
- 12:55for the probes to be scooped up by an alien spaceship
- 12:58traveling between the stars.
- 13:00Some studies have shown that space is, in fact,
- 13:03a tiny bit big.
- 13:07It's very easy to criticize the Pioneer Plaques.
- 13:10Any message designed to be understood by beings of which we know nothing about will
- 13:14unavoidably rely upon assumptions that could easily be false.
- 13:18Will the aliens understand the meaning of an arrow?
- 13:20Will they comprehend binary notation?
- 13:23Will they even grasp the concept of conveying information
- 13:26using two-dimensional pictograms?
- 13:29While questions like these are perfectly valid,
- 13:32they're ultimately quite pointless because the answer is always the same.
- 13:36We don't know.
- 13:37We don't know what the aliens look like, how they think, or even if they exist.
- 13:42The plaque could be so at odds with how they perceive and navigate the universe
- 13:46they fail to even recognize it as a message
- 13:49or we might be foolish for thinking a civilization so technologically advanced
- 13:53they're able to locate and retrieve a derelict spacecraft from the dead of space
- 13:58will be stumped by an interstellar cave painting.
- 14:03While many believe the recipients will be nothing like us,
- 14:07we could just as easily have a lot in common.
- 14:09After all, we share the same universe
- 14:11and are therefore shaped and bound by the same physical laws of nature.
- 14:15In fact, that's what some people fear the most.
- 14:18That the aliens could be just like us.
- 14:21That they could inflict upon us what we inflict upon members of our own species.
- 14:26The Sagans and Drake tried to get ahead of these concerns
- 14:28by emphasizing the improbability of interception.
- 14:31They stressed that, even if the probes were to fall into the tentacles
- 14:34of a hostile intelligence in some distant future,
- 14:37they'd be too far away to pose a threat.
- 14:41But statistics and probability only get you so far
- 14:44because fear is a powerful emotion.
- 14:48[George Wald] And may I say so that we can have a
- 14:52somewhat warmer and livelier conversation as this meeting goes on.
- 14:58I can conceive of no nightmare as terrifying as establishing such communication
- 15:08with a so-called superior or, if you wish, advanced technology in outer space.
- 15:38A year after the launch of Pioneer 11, the Arecibo Radio Observatory,
- 15:43located deep within the jungles of Puerto Rico, received a major facelift.
- 15:47The telescope was not only resurfaced to greatly increase its sensitivity,
- 15:51but also outfitted with a powerful transmitter.
- 15:54As it happens, the man in charge of the research center overseeing the facility
- 15:58was none other than Frank Drake.
- 16:01To celebrate the telescope's upgraded capabilities,
- 16:04Drake's assistant, Jane Allen,
- 16:06suggested they transmit an interstellar message
- 16:08during the upcoming rededication ceremony.
- 16:10Unlike the tangible Pioneer Plaques,
- 16:12the Arecibo Message had to be communicated using invisible radio waves.
- 16:17Drake had previously experimented with the idea
- 16:19of transmitting an image coded in binary,
- 16:22and with the help of some colleagues and graduate students, he came up with this.
- 16:26Now, this may not look like much,
- 16:28but if we fill in all the zeros with black squares
- 16:30and all the ones with white squares,
- 16:32a highly pixelated image will emerge.
- 16:35I'll explain the different parts in just a moment,
- 16:37but first, it's important to understand how an image like this
- 16:40is converted into radio waves.
- 16:42It starts with a grid that, in this case, is 23 columns wide and 73 rows tall
- 16:48for a total of 1 679 cells.
- 16:52We then fill in the cells needed to create the image.
- 16:55Because the image is composed of only two shades, black and white,
- 16:58that means it's binary,
- 17:00and each cell can also be described as a binary digit, or bit for short.
- 17:06By convention, binary code is expressed using zeros and ones,
- 17:10but it works just as well with two different shapes, two different colors,
- 17:14two different rocks, or literally any combination of two contrasting values.
- 17:19In fact, that's why binary code is so frequently used
- 17:22to write interstellar messages.
- 17:24It's not because aliens are guaranteed to understand it.
- 17:27No, it's simply one of the least complicated methods
- 17:30of conveying information that we can imagine.
- 17:32Chinese is composed of thousands of characters,
- 17:35English has 26 letters,
- 17:37while decimal demands 10 unique numerals.
- 17:40Binary only requires two.
- 17:42Not two letters, not two symbols, literally just two of something, which we call bits.
- 17:49For instance, instead of black and white squares,
- 17:51we could just as easily express this bitmap using two different frequencies.
- 17:56If a cell is black, that's one frequency.
- 17:59If it's white, that's another.
- 18:03There you go. That's all there's to it.
- 18:17This long sequence of two flip-flopping frequencies
- 18:20can now be transmitted using a radio telescope.
- 18:23When that signal is picked up by an alien astronomer,
- 18:26they may find it difficult to ascribe such an unnatural pattern to a natural source.
- 18:31This will hopefully draw attention to the number of frequency fluctuations because
- 18:351 679 is what's known as a semiprime.
- 18:40It's disappointingly not the half-brother of Optimus Prime,
- 18:43but rather the product of precisely two prime numbers.
- 18:46In this case, those prime numbers are 23 and 73,
- 18:50which happens to be the dimensions of the original grid.
- 18:53If the aliens were to plot the frequencies onto a grid of that size
- 18:57and fill in all the cells occupied by one of the values,
- 19:00they would uncover the image.
- 19:02As for the contents of the message,
- 19:04it starts off easy enough with the numbers 1 through 10 expressed in binary
- 19:08and written from right-to-left.
- 19:10So 0-0-1, 0-1-0, 0-1-1, and so on.
- 19:15Moving on to this large cluster of pixels,
- 19:17we find a bunch of binary formulations for the building blocks of life as we know it.
- 19:22It starts with the atomic numbers of five basic elements:
- 19:25hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, and phosphorus.
- 19:29These numbers are then used to describe essential components of DNA.
- 19:33For instance, a carbon atom has six protons,
- 19:36which means it has an atomic number of six.
- 19:390-1-1-0 is binary for decimal 6.
- 19:42Because carbon is in the second column from the right,
- 19:45it means the second column of these molecules underneath
- 19:48indicates how many carbon atoms they contain.
- 19:51So these four represent an organic compound known as deoxyribose,
- 19:55which has five carbon atoms, and 1-0-1 is binary for decimal 5.
- 20:00In the center of the image, we find a crude rendition of the DNA double helix
- 20:04enclosing a large binary value
- 20:06denoting the number of nucleotide base pairs in the human genome.
- 20:10In simpler terms, it's a way of expressing the complexity or
- 20:14size of our genetic makeup.
- 20:16However, more recent measurements have since reduced that number by over a billion,
- 20:20so this figure is no longer accurate.
- 20:23A bit further down, we find a simple sketch of a human,
- 20:26alongside an expression of their height on the right
- 20:29and the estimated global population in 1974 on the left.
- 20:35Directly underneath the human is a schematic of the Solar System,
- 20:39followed by an illustration of the Arecibo Telescope.
- 20:44Now, you might be wondering,
- 20:45"How the hell were the aliens supposed to understand any of that?"
- 20:49The simple answer is, they weren't really.
- 20:51Unlike the Pioneer Plaques' commendable attempt
- 20:53to establish some sort of common ground using shared units of measurement
- 20:57and a galactic map of pulsars,
- 20:59the Arecibo Message was much more of a publicity stunt.
- 21:03For instance, the length of the message
- 21:05was largely determined by the presumed attention span
- 21:08of those invited to the rededication ceremony.
- 21:11The concern was that, if the message was too long,
- 21:13attendees might be annoyed by the sound of the transmission,
- 21:16which was planned to be broadcast over loudspeakers at the event.
- 21:20In the end, the message was constrained to about three minutes
- 21:23to mitigate the risk of a dull afternoon.
- 21:26Likewise, the selection of a target for the transmission was entirely dictated
- 21:31by what happened to be visible in the sky during the ceremony.
- 21:34Drake ultimately selected a bright cluster of stars known as Messier 13,
- 21:38which is about 24 000 lightyears from Earth.
- 21:43While this meant the message would take 24 000 years to reach its destination,
- 21:48the density of M13 also meant the signal could sweep over many
- 21:51thousands of stars upon arrival.
- 21:53At the time, this was thought to maximize the odds of the transmission being received,
- 21:58and Carl Sagan even told a reporter
- 22:00that he believed there was a 50% chance that M13 was home to an alien civilization.
- 22:06But as it turns out, more stars
- 22:09does not necessarily mean more opportunities for life.
- 22:12Not only are globular clusters like M13 typically starved of heavier elements
- 22:17essential for planetary formation,
- 22:20but the proximity of the stars makes it challenging for any planets that do form
- 22:23to maintain stable orbits.
- 22:25Considering it took billions of years before humans evolved on Earth,
- 22:29a region as densely packed and chaotic as M13
- 22:33is probably not the most conducive environment for life as we know it.
- 22:38While there is some optimism that small planets like Earth
- 22:41could survive in very tight orbits,
- 22:44out of six thousand exoplanets discovered to date,
- 22:46only two are located within a globuluster.
- 22:52Nevertheless, on November 16, 1974,
- 22:55a small crowd of astronomers, dignitaries, and others
- 22:58bopped along to a three-minute concert of two warbling tones
- 23:02as humanity's first interstellar radiotelegram was beamed into space.
- 23:27A common misconception about the Arecibo Message
- 23:29is that it will miss its target because the telescope was aimed at the position of M13
- 23:34at the time of transmission, rather than where it will be in 24 000 years.
- 23:39In reality, when Drake crunched the numbers back in 1974,
- 23:43he realized that the cluster was so enormous and slow-moving
- 23:46that even if they aimed the telescope at its location at the time,
- 23:50the message would simply strike slightly off-center rather than a bullseye.
- 23:54Presuming against all odds that M13 is home to an alien civilization
- 23:59in possession of an extremely sensitive instrument that's not only designed
- 24:03to pick up radio waves at the exact same frequency and bandwidth
- 24:06at which the Arecibo Message was transmitted,
- 24:08but also pointed squarely at the Solar System at just the right time,
- 24:12Messierian astronomers will have a non-zero chance
- 24:15to detect a non-repeating burst of energy lasting for less than three minutes
- 24:19some 24 000 years from now.
- 24:23Even though they're unlikely to decode the message,
- 24:25they might still suspect it's an attempt at communication.
- 24:28It's a bit like, even if you don't speak Swedish...
- 24:30*SWEDISH NOISES*
- 24:37If they suspect it's a transmission from another civilization,
- 24:40the aliens may choose to respond.
- 24:42Presuming there's no way to overcome the speed of light,
- 24:44such a response would obviously take just as long to reach us
- 24:48as it took the Arecibo Message to reach them.
- 24:51Based on the most recent measurements of the distance between the Solar System and M13,
- 24:55the earliest possible date we can expect a reply
- 24:58is the year 50370.
- 25:03Don't forget to mark your calendars.
- 25:06There are even more hopelessly optimistic scenarios,
- 25:09like a star or spaceship crossing paths with the signal somewhere along the way.
- 25:14But the odds of that happening are so vanishingly small
- 25:17it might as well be impossible.
- 25:19Not least of all because, as you can see,
- 25:21M13 is actually floating far above the galactic disc,
- 25:25and there's a whole lot of nothing in between.
- 25:35But, once again, these astronomical improbabilities
- 25:38were not enough to allay concerns of an alien invasion.
- 25:42A prominent radio astronomer in Britain at the time, Sir Martin Ryle,
- 25:46feared the Arecibo Message might attract a more advanced civilization
- 25:50seeking to colonize the Earth and mine its resources.
- 25:54He took issue with the fact that a small group of people had transmitted a message
- 25:58that could endanger all of humanity,
- 26:00and called for an international discussion in advance of any future transmissions.
- 26:05While these concerns largely fell on deaf ears at the time,
- 26:09Ryle was far from the only one urging caution.
- 26:42By the mid-1970s, NASA was gearing up to launch two spacecraft
- 26:46known as Voyager 1 and 2.
- 26:48Much like the Pioneer probes before them,
- 26:50the Voyager twins would be slingshot into deep space by granddaddy Jupiter
- 26:54on their way to explore the outer Solar System.
- 26:56Due to the similarity between the two programs
- 26:59and the public interest generated by the Pioneer Plaques,
- 27:02NASA engineer John Casani thought a similar message
- 27:05ought to be carried by the Voyagers.
- 27:07When Casani reached out to Carl Sagan in late 1976,
- 27:10he jumped at the chance to scribe another cosmic postcard.
- 27:14But this time, he wanted to impress upon the recipients not just how we think,
- 27:18but also how we feel.
- 27:19After consulting numerous people on how to proceed,
- 27:22two propositions stood above the rest: music and pictures.
- 27:27Sagan was partial to music while fellow astronomer Frank Drake
- 27:30thought nothing could capture the human condition like a series of photographs.
- 27:34After some additional brainstorming, it was Drake who finally realized
- 27:37they could accommodate both ideas using a phonograph record.
- 27:41A phonograph record is an analog storage medium,
- 27:44primarily used to record and replay sound.
- 27:47To record, you simply press a needle against the surface of a slow-spinning disc.
- 27:51By generating a sound, like strumming a guitar...
- 27:56...the needle will start to vibrate as it carves a thin
- 27:59undulating groove into the disc.
- 28:02To replay the sound, you simply create a copy of the disc
- 28:05using a less malleable material,
- 28:07place the needle back at the beginning of the groove,
- 28:09and spin the disc back up again.
- 28:11As the needle collides with the
- 28:12hundreds of microscopic indentations in the groove,
- 28:15it generates the same vibrations used to create it.
- 28:19When those vibrations reach your ears, you'll hear a guitar being strummed.
- 28:25The process is a bit more complicated in practice, of course,
- 28:28but honestly, not by much.
- 28:31Whether it's a single vibrating guitar string
- 28:33or the deafening crescendo of an entire orchestra,
- 28:36all of it can be recorded and replayed by tiny bumps in a grove.
- 28:41Yes, magic is real, and this is it.
- 28:44But what about the photographs?
- 28:46How do you get visual information onto a storage medium made for sound?
- 28:51It's surprisingly simple, actually.
- 28:54Remember how the Arecibo Message painted a picture
- 28:56by treating black and white squares as two different frequencies?
- 29:00I mean, it would be a bit concerning if you don't.
- 29:03That was just 12 minutes ago. You better get that checked out.
- 29:06Anyway, they basically did that, but instead of just two frequencies,
- 29:09they used a whole range of them.
- 29:11Take a gradient like this, for instance.
- 29:14If we assign a low frequency to black...
- 29:17...and a high frequency to white...
- 29:19...then every shade of gray in between
- 29:21will be mapped to a corresponding frequency of sound.
- 29:36With that translation scheme in mind,
- 29:38converting an entire photograph becomes trivial.
- 29:41For instance, this is a black-and-white image of Mercury that's actually on the record.
- 29:46All we have to do is scan every pixel in this image,
- 29:49one by one, column by column,
- 29:51and translate every shade of gray into its audible equivalent.
- 30:06Once we've translated every frequency of light into a frequency of sound,
- 30:10we end up with a brief sample of incoherent noise
- 30:12that acts like an acoustic fingerprint of the image.
- 30:20Again, I'm simplifying a lot here, and the actual process used analog signals
- 30:24rather than quantized pixel values, but it gives you a rough idea of how it was done.
- 30:30Some photographs were actually recorded three times in a row
- 30:33using filters for red, green, and blue.
- 30:36When recombined in just the right way,
- 30:38they produce an image full of vibrant colors,
- 30:40even though, individually, they're all black and white.
- 30:43Again, magic is real.
- 30:45In an effort to save space, they also recorded
- 30:47two simultaneous streams of images into the same groove.
- 30:51This was accomplished by using the side-to-side motion of the needle
- 30:54to record one stream,
- 30:56and the up-and-down motion to record another.
- 30:59The end result was this echoey stereo sound of two image streams playing at once.
- 31:22To provide the aliens with the best possible chance
- 31:24of decoding this cryptic disc of gold-plated copper,
- 31:27the record's aluminum cover was engraved with some basic instructions.
- 31:32First of all, the pulsar map makes a return,
- 31:34and so, too, does the diagram showing the hyperfine transition of neutral hydrogen.
- 31:39The latter of which is, once again, used to establish
- 31:41a shared unit of both time and length.
- 31:44Near the top left, we find an overhead view of the record
- 31:47circumscribed by a binary number.
- 31:50It's telling the aliens to spin the record about five billion times faster
- 31:54than the hyperfine transition period.
- 31:56In human terms, that's equivalent to roughly one rotation every 3.6 seconds.
- 32:01To ensure the aliens have something with which to play the record,
- 32:04a ceramic cartridge holding a diamond-tipped needle
- 32:08was attached to the mounting bracket.
- 32:10An outline of this cartridge has also been drawn along the right edge here
- 32:13to indicate the playback starting position.
- 32:16Underneath the overhead view, there's also a side view,
- 32:19accompanied by another binary number.
- 32:21This time, it's telling the aliens how long it takes to play
- 32:24one full side of the record, which is about 54 minutes.
- 32:28Moving on to the top right, we find a step-by-step guide
- 32:31for decoding the images.
- 32:33The waveform at the very top corresponds to three vertical slices
- 32:37of the record's first image,
- 32:38while the zigzag pattern underneath
- 32:40means the slices are meant to be stacked side-by-side, one after the other.
- 32:54As we already know, this angelic symphony of beeps and buzzings
- 32:57are mapped to different shades of gray
- 32:59according to a very specific translation scheme.
- 33:02A scheme the aliens are meant to reverse engineer
- 33:04with the help of these binary numbers.
- 33:07There are three slices labeled 1, 2, 3,
- 33:10and each one corresponds to roughly 8 milliseconds of audio.
- 33:13A full image is 512 slices wide
- 33:16and should form a rectangular shape with a 4:3 aspect ratio.
- 33:21Simple as that.
- 33:23On the off-chance that the aliens should somehow be
- 33:25confused by these crystal clear instructions,
- 33:28the record's first image has also been outlined here at the bottom
- 33:31to show them what it's supposed to look like when properly decoded.
- 33:35In fact, this calibration circle is the very first piece of data
- 33:39the aliens would find on the record.
- 33:41It's followed by more than a hundred images, starting with some basic math,
- 33:45units of measurement, and a speedrun of the human experience.
- 33:58The sequence ends with this image of a violin floating above a page of musical notation.
- 34:03It shows the beginning of a somber classical piece known as Cavatina,
- 34:08and once the image fades, legendary emcee Ludwig van Beethoven kicks off the mixtape.
- 34:34But the minutes-long performance of Cavatina only plays for a few seconds
- 34:38before it's interrupted by even more beeps and buzzings.
- 34:41You see, six additional images
- 34:43were squeezed onto the record at the very last moment,
- 34:46including a written statement by then President of the United States, Jimmy Carter,
- 34:50and a tedious listing of nearly a hundred members of Congress.
- 34:54This bureaucratic theme then segues back into audio
- 34:58with a speech by then Secretary General of the United Nations, Kurt Waldheim.
- 35:44The aliens will then be treated to a series of greetings
- 35:47spoken in 58 different languages.
- 36:37This is followed by various sounds of things like weather, animals, and technology
- 36:41before the record ends with a playlist of nearly 90 minutes of music
- 36:45covering a vast array of instruments, styles, and cultures.
- 36:49It starts about halfway through the A side of the record
- 36:51with an uplifting composition by Johann Bach.
- 37:13After another nine tracks, including a famous American rock single and
- 37:17many obscure folk songs from around the world,
- 37:19the music picks up again on the record's B side with another banger by Johann Bach.
- 37:36After nearly an hour's worth of additional music from countries like
- 37:39Germany, Peru, Russia, China, and India, just to name a few,
- 37:43the Golden Record comes to a somnific end with a full rendition of Beethoven's Cavatina
- 38:30Nearly half a century later,
- 38:32Voyager 1 is now the most distant spacecraft ever launched.
- 38:36Even though it was preceded by the Pioneer probes by several years
- 38:40and even its own twin by two weeks,
- 38:43Voyager 1 attained a greater escape velocity and has since overtaken them all.
- 38:47Amazingly, both Voyagers are still transmitting to this day,
- 38:51although they're fast approaching their operational limits.
- 38:55Once they go offline and fall out of range,
- 38:57they'll join their pioneering brethren
- 38:59in a timeless and destinationless trek between the stars.
- 39:05Because the interstellar medium is sparsely populated with tiny dust particles,
- 39:09the exposed surfaces of both the Pioneer Plaques
- 39:12and the Golden Records will erode over time.
- 39:15While the former is somewhat protected by its inward-facing placement,
- 39:19it's still exposed to the vacuum of space.
- 39:21On the other hand, the Golden Records are
- 39:23firmly pressed up against the body of the spacecraft.
- 39:26According to one estimate, the outward-facing B side
- 39:28could survive for at least a few billion years,
- 39:31whereas the lifespan of the concealed A side is anyone's guess.
- 39:35It's not impossible that many tens or even hundreds of billions of years from now,
- 39:40all the photographs, greetings, and one third of the music will still be intact.
- 39:47While the response to the Golden Records was overwhelmingly positive,
- 39:50they did nonetheless receive a bit of criticism.
- 39:53Much like before, some people were completely undeterred
- 39:56by the near-impossibility of interception
- 39:58and feared the Voyagers might attract a hostile intelligence.
- 40:02Others focused more on the contents of the message
- 40:05because they felt it was disingenuous to paint humanity in such a positive light
- 40:09when war, crime, and cruelty
- 40:12are as much a part of the human condition as music, sports, and science.
- 40:17As one of the makers of the record, Jon Lomberg, so succinctly points out...
- 40:27The decision to exclude the uglier sides of humanity was
- 40:31partly to avoid potential backlash from people here on Earth,
- 40:34but also an attempt to make us seem less hostile to any future recipients.
- 40:39While a mushroom cloud does convey a
- 40:42shameful yet significant part of who we are,
- 40:44it could also be perceived as a threat.
- 40:48On the other hand, the exclusion of such imagery
- 40:50could, by itself, be quite revealing
- 40:52as we expose our casual willingness to deceive
- 40:55through tactful omission.
- 40:57Dating profiles, job interviews, meeting someone for the first time.
- 41:02I don't know if this is what the Golden Records team had in mind, but
- 41:05being selective with the truth to make a good first impression,
- 41:09how terribly human of them.
- 41:14The three initiatives mentioned so far
- 41:16are likely to be the only ones you've heard of before.
- 41:18The Pioneer Plaques, the Arecibo Message, and especially the Golden Records
- 41:22generated immense public interest at the time and remain well known to this day.
- 41:27But our attempts to communicate with life beyond
- 41:30did not end with the Golden Records.
- 41:32In fact, just a few years later, the silence was broken yet again,
- 41:36and this time, the target was so close,
- 41:38the minimum response time was measured not in eons
- 41:42but decades.
- 41:53In early 1983, Japanese publishing company Shueisha
- 41:57was looking for ways to commemorate the 15th anniversary
- 42:00of their most popular manga anthology magazine,
- 42:03known as Weekly Shōnen Jump.
- 42:05Due to the recent success of the film E.T. by Steven Spielberg,
- 42:08and the fact that 1983 had been declared the World Communications Year
- 42:12by the United Nations,
- 42:14they decided to launch a competition dubbed Call to the Cosmos.
- 42:17The price was a trip across the Pacific
- 42:19to visit a large radio telescope in Stanford, California,
- 42:23from which a message would be transmitted
- 42:25to a nearby star system.
- 42:26To win, all you had to do was submit a proposal for what the message should say.
- 42:31With a readership in the millions, the magazine received
- 42:34nearly 50 000 message ideas from children across the country.
- 42:37These were then compiled into one abbreviated message,
- 42:40and 15 lucky winners were selected to tag along on the trip.
- 42:44For the selection of a transmission target,
- 42:46the organizers turned to two radio astronomers
- 42:48named Masaki Morimoto and Hisashi Hirabayashi.
- 42:51They eventually chose the star Altair
- 42:53because it's very bright and relatively close.
- 42:57It was also selected because the message was planned to be transmitted
- 43:00during an annual Japanese festival known as Tanabata
- 43:03which celebrates the meeting of two celestial deities
- 43:06represented by the stars Vega and Altair.
- 43:10Furthermore, Morimoto and Hirabayashi were asked to create their own message,
- 43:13and after three days of work, they came up with this.
- 43:16A sequence of 13 bitmaps measuring 71x71 pixels
- 43:21that were clearly inspired by the Arecibo Message.
- 43:24The first four images depict things like natural numbers,
- 43:27prime numbers, basic math, common elements,
- 43:32the Solar System,
- 43:34and essential building blocks of DNA.
- 43:38The next eight illustrate the evolution of life
- 43:40from simple organisms to jellyfish,
- 43:44fish,
- 43:46amphibians,
- 43:48dinosaurs,
- 43:50apparently not Bigfoot,
- 43:52a family of humans,
- 43:54and a close-up of a woman's face.
- 43:57The final bitmap depicts a crude illustration
- 43:59of the Stanford radio telescope
- 44:01alongside information like its radius, wavelength of the transmission,
- 44:05and total number of bits in the message.
- 44:07We also find the word "TOAST" written in plain English.
- 44:11According to Hirabayashi, during the three-day stint
- 44:13when he and Morimoto conceived of these images,
- 44:16they weren't necessarily sober the whole way through.
- 44:18This may or may not have influenced their decision to include
- 44:22the Japanese and English word for "TOAST"
- 44:24equated to the chemical formula for ethanol.
- 44:28Because Weekly Shōnen Jump targets a very young demographic,
- 44:32the magazine tried to clean this up a bit
- 44:34by reframing what was clearly an afterthought
- 44:37by two half-drunk astronomers as...
- 44:43Nevertheless, for about an hour on August 15, 1983,
- 44:46the 13 bitmaps and an audio recording of the abridged fan-submitted greetings
- 44:51were beamed towards Altair.
- 45:37Altair is among the brightest stars in the night sky,
- 45:40and at a distance of less than 17 lightyears,
- 45:43it's only, what, a few quadrillion stone throws away?
- 45:46In fact, Altair is so cosmically close that enough time has now passed
- 45:50for the transmission to have made a full round trip.
- 45:54That is to say, the message reached Altair back around the millennium shift,
- 45:58and we could have received a reply as early as 2017.
- 46:03Now, the fact that we never did does not necessarily mean there's nobody home.
- 46:07Perhaps they missed the brief 60-minute window
- 46:09when the message swept across their system?
- 46:11Perhaps they did pick it up, but they're still drafting a response?
- 46:15Perhaps they took one quick look at Earth and humanity, and were like...
- 46:21While all of these scenarios are, of course, equally probable,
- 46:25the most equal is, unfortunately, the first one.
- 46:28Not only have astronomers failed to detect a planet around Altair, but
- 46:31even if one does exist, the star's only been around for about 100 million years.
- 46:36Compare that to a 4.6 billion-year veteran like the Sun,
- 46:40and things start to look a bit bleak.
- 46:42Sure, there's always the possibility that intelligent life
- 46:45typically evolves much faster than it did here on Earth,
- 46:48but we currently have no good reason to think that's the case.
- 46:51But it gets worse because even if the Altairians did respond,
- 46:55the odds of us even noticing are extremely remote
- 46:58because telescopes are expensive, in low supply, and high demand.
- 47:03Sacrificing years, months, or even just days worth of observation time
- 47:07to screen a single planetless star for alien signals ain't exactly top priority.
- 47:13It wasn't until the summer of 2023
- 47:16that a team led by astronomer Shin-ya Narusawa
- 47:18secured a brief time slot at the Usuda Deep Space Center in Japan
- 47:22to search for a belated response to the Altair Message.
- 47:25Scheduled once again to coincide with the annual Tanabata festival,
- 47:29the search began late in the evening on August 22
- 47:32and lasted for a grand total of 60...
- 47:36...minutes.
- 47:37Remaining optimistic, Narusawa told reporters the following morning
- 47:41that they wouldn't immediately know if an alien signal had been detected
- 47:44because it would take a long time to analyze the terabytes of collected data.
- 47:48But given the lack of updates since then, I wouldn't keep my hopes up on this one.
- 47:55If nothing else, the Message to Altair was received loud and clear
- 47:58by thousands of children across Japan.
- 48:01In fact, Call to the Cosmos seems to have had a bit of a rippling effect
- 48:04because a whole series of messages designed by Japanese children
- 48:07would later be transmitted for several years in a row.
- 48:11But before we get to all that,
- 48:12we're gonna take a brief detour into the dazzling world of censorship.
- 48:24As mentioned before, when the public became aware
- 48:26that NASA had bolted a plaque to the side of Pioneer 10, not everyone approved.
- 48:31But it wasn't just about the risk of attracting dangerous aliens.
- 48:34It was also about modesty.
- 48:36You see, some people were absolutely mortified
- 48:40to learn that the plaques featured line drawings of two naked humans
- 48:44engaged in the scandalous act of standing there.
- 49:20As amusing as that is, the controversy surrounding the plaques' nudity
- 49:24has been somewhat exaggerated over the years.
- 49:27These puritanical takes were "muted and few", to quote Carl Sagan,
- 49:31and it's genuinely difficult to find examples like the one you just heard.
- 49:35There were a handful of reductive headlines,
- 49:37and some newspapers opted for the Barbie- and Ken-doll treatment, but
- 49:41the vast majority published the full uncensored image and
- 49:44barely even mentioned the couple.
- 49:46In fact, some criticized the plaques not for showing the human form,
- 49:50but for not showing enough.
- 49:51More specifically, people took issue with the complete
- 49:54absence of visible female genitalia,
- 49:56considering that no such neutering had been applied to the man.
- 49:59It's unclear if the lack of anatomical detail on the lower half of the woman
- 50:03was demanded by prudish NASA officials, or a decision made by the Sagans themselves.
- 50:09Conflicting accounts makes it difficult to know exactly who's to blame.
- 50:12Nevertheless, when it came time to select material
- 50:14for the Golden Records a few years later,
- 50:17these concerns flared up again.
- 50:18Fearing a repeat of the previous debacle,
- 50:21NASA religiously vetted every song, soundbite, and image
- 50:24that Sagan and co sought to include.
- 50:26They ultimately rejected a nude photograph
- 50:28of a young man and pregnant woman
- 50:30intended to show both human anatomy and procreation.
- 50:34The reason I'm bringing this up is because, in 1986,
- 50:37an American artist by the name of Joe Davis
- 50:39decided to fight back against all this pearl-clutching
- 50:42with a project known as Poetica Vaginal.
- 50:45With the help of a few ballerinas and other volunteers,
- 50:48Davis used a custom-made device to record...
- 50:51...how do I put this...
- 50:52...contractions from within the female reproductive system.
- 50:55Those pressure oscillations were then artistically manipulated
- 50:59to create something that's meant to resemble human speech.
- 51:15After obtaining access to a radio telescope
- 51:17near the Massachusetts Institute of Technology,
- 51:20Davis and his team began transmitting the sounds into space.
- 51:23However, the broadcast only lasted for about 15 to 20 minutes
- 51:27before the project was prematurely terminated by an Air Force Colonel,
- 51:30who was apparently overseeing the facility.
- 51:33Nevertheless, according to Davis,
- 51:34those few minutes were enough to transmit brief snippets of audio
- 51:38to each of the four selected targets.
- 51:41Two of them were never publicly identified, as far as I can tell,
- 51:44while the other two are known as Epsilon Eridani and Tau Ceti.
- 51:48Epsilon Eridani is home to one confirmed planet
- 51:51with a mass nearly identical to that of Jupiter.
- 51:54While additional planets could exist,
- 51:56including ones that resemble Earth,
- 51:58Eridani is a relative newcomer to the Milky Way family
- 52:01at approximately half a billion years young.
- 52:05On the other hand, Tau Ceti is certifiably ancient.
- 52:08Its precise age remains unclear, but it's definitely older than the Sun
- 52:12and home to not just one, but four confirmed planets.
- 52:16On top of that, there's a slim chance that two of them
- 52:19are grazing the inner and outer bounds of the habitable zone.
- 52:22That being the distance from the star
- 52:24at which water could remain liquid on the surface of an earthlike planet.
- 52:29Unfortunately, both of these stars are surrounded by immense belts of debris,
- 52:34not unlike the Asteroid and Kuiper belts in the Solar System.
- 52:37The difference is that Epsilon Eridani and Tau Ceti
- 52:40retain asteroidal and cometary populations
- 52:43many times greater than what currently orbits the Sun.
- 52:47While this makes perfect sense for a youngster like Eridani,
- 52:50it's a lot more concerning for a galactic grandparent like Tau Ceti.
- 52:54It implies that something is either preventing that material from
- 52:57coalescing into planets across billions of years
- 53:00or that the system has suffered a recent cascade of instability.
- 53:04In either case, more stuff almost certainly means more impact events
- 53:08like the one that nearly wiped out the dinosaurs.
- 53:11But even if we optimistically assume that none of that's a problem,
- 53:15the mass and size of the planets orbiting Tau Ceti are highly uncertain.
- 53:19There's a good chance they have less in common with Earth
- 53:22and more so with Uranus and Neptune.
- 53:24But even if that isn't the case,
- 53:26the chemical makeup of Tau Ceti appears to be quite different from the Sun,
- 53:30suggesting its planets are composed of materials
- 53:32quite different from those that spawned life in the Solar System.
- 53:35In summary, it's not looking great.
- 53:40Now, it may seem pointless to consider the habitability of these distant worlds
- 53:44when the message we sent towards them is completely indecipherable.
- 53:49I mean, if you thought the aliens were gonna struggle with the Golden Records,
- 53:52good luck to them figuring this out.
- 54:00But just like the Arecibo Message, the artificial nature of the signal
- 54:05is a message in and of itself.
- 54:07If you want to believe there's a naturally occurring phenomenon
- 54:09capable of producing the exact same radio waves
- 54:12as those emitted by Joe Davis and his team back in 1986,
- 54:15you go right ahead.
- 54:17But somehow, I have my doubts about that.
- 54:26Presuming the message was received and correctly identified as a technosignature,
- 54:30we could've received a reply from the Eridanians as early as 2007
- 54:35or the Cetinites as early as 2010.
- 54:38I did some checking and regretfully have to inform you
- 54:41that humanity's been ghosted once again.
- 54:52About a decade after the Message to Altair,
- 54:54the National Space Development Agency of Japan
- 54:57began hosting an annual space camp event for young children
- 55:00known as the Cosmic College.
- 55:02Students could choose from a bunch of different activities
- 55:04over the course of multiple days,
- 55:06including a class on how to write and send interstellar messages.
- 55:09In fact, one of the astronomers invited to lecture at these events
- 55:13was none other than Hisashi Hirabayashi, one of the creators of the Altair Message.
- 55:18But it wasn't just a theoretical exercise.
- 55:21NASDA actually arranged for some of those messages to be transmitted into space.
- 55:25Once a year between at least 1995 and 1998,
- 55:28simple bitmap images measuring 11x11 pixels
- 55:32were sent from the Usuda Deep Space Center to various locations across the galaxy.
- 55:37These transmissions received next to no publicity at the time
- 55:40and are virtually unknown to this day.
- 55:43This makes it difficult to know exactly what was sent where and when.
- 55:47Here's what we do know.
- 55:48The first Cosmic College was held in August 1995,
- 55:52during which this image of two parents and a child
- 55:54was beamed towards some unknown destination within the constellation Libra.
- 55:59Even less is known about this image of an alien holding hands with a human,
- 56:03transmitted sometime in August 1996.
- 56:06This time, we don't even know the general region of the sky
- 56:09to which it might have been sent.
- 56:11In August 1997, two bitmaps were beamed towards a binary star system known as Spica.
- 56:17The first image depicts a smiley face,
- 56:19while the other shows a Japanese dumpling known as a dango
- 56:22next to a steaming cup of tea.
- 56:24Unfortunately, Spica is a ticking time bomb
- 56:27because the two stars are expected to slowly encroach upon one another,
- 56:31which could trigger a supernova at some point in the future.
- 56:34Even if that wasn't the case, they're far too young to host an earthlike planet,
- 56:38and even if that wasn't the case, it would take another five centuries for
- 56:42any replies to reach us.
- 56:43Finally, this image that simply says 1 + 1 = 2
- 56:47was transmitted to some unknown location in August 1998.
- 56:51Now, there could be more of these transmissions that have been lost to time.
- 56:55For instance, an image of a leaf to symbolize the nature of Earth
- 56:58appears to have been designed during the Cosmic College of 1999.
- 57:01But I couldn't find any information on whether it was actually beamed into space.
- 57:07While competitions, art projects, and recreational programs
- 57:11certainly could generate an alien response,
- 57:13their primary function is to elicit a response from us down here on Earth.
- 57:18They're inspiring, provocative, and generally attract a lot of attention.
- 57:22So it was only a matter of time before someone came along
- 57:25and began charging a fee.
- 57:37In early 1998, American entrepreneur Charles Chafer
- 57:40announced a commercial venture known as Encounter 2001.
- 57:44The project sought to crowdfund the launch of a tiny light-sailing spacecraft
- 57:48that wouldcarry samples of human DNA beyond the Solar System.
- 57:52For only $50, anyone could submit a few strands of hair
- 57:55along with a brief message and their portrait
- 57:57and join the so-called Millennial Voyage.
- 58:00Market analysis by Chafer and his team
- 58:02projected sales of anywhere between 1.5 and 4.5 million tickets
- 58:06before the launch date.
- 58:08If those figures seem a bit optimistic,
- 58:10they were nothing compared to the expectations of their customers.
- 58:33This idea that aliens might one day use your DNA to clone your body
- 58:38was surprisingly prevalent.
- 58:40For instance, the greeting submitted
- 58:41by renowned science fiction author Sir Arthur C. Clarke
- 58:44simply read, "Fare well, my clone!"
- 58:47While the Millennial Voyage was the project's main objective,
- 58:50they also promised to beam participants' greetings into space ahead of the launch
- 58:54using a radio telescope.
- 58:55A side project that would come to be known as the Cosmic Calls.
- 58:59By spring of 1999, some 43 000 people had signed up for Encounter 2001,
- 59:05including two Canadian astrophysicists named Yvan Dutil and Stéphane Dumas.
- 59:10Dutil and Dumas had been given the task of creating what's known as a primer.
- 59:13A primer attempts to gradually introduce the recipients to more complex ideas
- 59:18using some sort of step-by-step process.
- 59:21For instance, the primer of the Message to Altair
- 59:23were the 13 bitmaps sent alongside the far more complicated greeting in Japanese.
- 59:29Dutil and Dumas did something similar for the Cosmic Calls.
- 59:31They created a primer composed of 23 bitmaps,
- 59:35and this first one starts off by listing the ten digits of our decimal system
- 59:39using three different notations: unary, binary, and decimal.
- 59:44An idea they appear to have lifted from this image on the Golden Records,
- 59:48which did almost the exact same thing.
- 59:50But there is, of course, one very noticeable difference.
- 59:54The one from the Golden Records uses the familiar glyphs of Arabic numerals,
- 59:58whereas the primer to the Cosmic Calls uses these alien-looking symbols.
- 1:00:03That's because Dutil and Dumas decided to create their own
- 1:00:05rudimentary language of sorts.
- 1:00:08Now, this might seem like an odd choice
- 1:00:10because whether, say, a two, looks like this or like this,
- 1:00:14it's not gonna make any difference to the recipients.
- 1:00:16But it's not about readability. It's about redundancy.
- 1:00:20You see, there's a lot of naturally occurring radiation that could
- 1:00:23interfere with a radio transmission between the source and destination.
- 1:00:27Imagine, for instance, that we transmitted fifteen bits arranged like this
- 1:00:31to represent the number 8.
- 1:00:33If this one bit in the middle was flipped along the way,
- 1:00:35the recipients would pick up a 0 instead of an 8.
- 1:00:38Flip this bit, and the 8 becomes a 6.
- 1:00:41Flip these two, and it becomes a 5.
- 1:00:43In other words, this transmission has no redundancy whatsoever.
- 1:00:47Lose one bit and the entire message could become corrupted.
- 1:00:51The glyphs created by Dutil and Dumas were designed to be as
- 1:00:54fault-tolerant and noise-resistant as possible.
- 1:00:57There are several bits of difference between all the symbols,
- 1:01:00and that still holds true even if they were to be mirrored or rotated.
- 1:01:04But apart from the symbolic difference,
- 1:01:06the Cosmic Call primer follows a structure that should be very familiar at this point.
- 1:01:11The first five pages cover various mathematical concepts that
- 1:01:15gradually increase in complexity.
- 1:01:26The next six delve into chemistry and physics,
- 1:01:30including a schematic of the Solar System.
- 1:01:41The next eight are all about Earth, humanity, and biology,
- 1:01:45including a rendition of the Pioneer couple and a two-page map of the continents.
- 1:02:01Page 21 contains information about the transmission and telescope,
- 1:02:05while page 22 brags about our cosmological knowledge, like the age of the universe.
- 1:02:11The 23rd and final page invites the aliens to respond
- 1:02:14by asking them a series of questions,
- 1:02:16using this flower-looking glyph as a stand-in for a question mark.
- 1:02:20For instance, this means velocity while this means photon,
- 1:02:24so this question could be read as, "What is the speed of light?"
- 1:02:28But how could the aliens possibly know
- 1:02:30that these symbols mean question, velocity, and photon?
- 1:02:35Well, it all comes down to that first page of numbers
- 1:02:37to which everything else is anchored.
- 1:02:40The aliens would start by hypothesizing that these ten symbols
- 1:02:44represent ten digits in a base-ten numeral system.
- 1:02:48With that assumption locked in place,
- 1:02:49they'd move on to the next page and find 1 something 1 = 2.
- 1:02:54Okay, so they now suspect that this symbol represents addition
- 1:02:58and make similar assumptions regarding subtraction, multiplication, and division.
- 1:03:02Once they get to page four, they would know that this reads something + 2 = 3,
- 1:03:07while this reads something + 4 = 10.
- 1:03:10Given that the same symbol
- 1:03:12is used to represent what is clearly not the same value,
- 1:03:15they might suspect that this is a placeholder for a variable quantity.
- 1:03:19In other words, this variable represents something unknown,
- 1:03:23a bit like a question mark, emphasized by this symbol off to the left.
- 1:03:29By gradually introducing new symbols alongside familiar ones
- 1:03:32in such a way that logic and process of elimination
- 1:03:35can be used to fill in the blanks,
- 1:03:37it creates a lot of mutual corroboration between the pages.
- 1:03:40By page eight, they'd be introduced to the concepts of time and length via hydrogen,
- 1:03:45followed by velocity and photons via the speed of light.
- 1:03:50To be clear, there's still plenty of room for confusion and misinterpretation.
- 1:03:55Not least of all because a few typos did actually slip through the cracks.
- 1:03:59For instance, according to this line on the seventh page,
- 1:04:02uranium is said to have 116 neutrons but there is no such element.
- 1:04:07The lightest known isotope of uranium has 122 neutrons
- 1:04:11and the most abundant here on Earth has 146
- 1:04:14which is probably what they meant.
- 1:04:17But even if the primer had been flawless,
- 1:04:19there's only so much hand-holding one can do
- 1:04:22when you don't even know if the recipients have hands.
- 1:04:27In addition to the primer, the language created by Dutil and Dumas
- 1:04:30was used to write a message about the Millennial Voyage.
- 1:04:33This was followed by a copy of the Arecibo Message,
- 1:04:37greetings by the staff at Encounter 2001,
- 1:04:40as well as the 43 000 names and greetings from people around the world.
- 1:04:44With assistance from prominent Russian astronomer Alexander Zaitsev,
- 1:04:48Chafer and his team then obtained access to the
- 1:04:50Evpatoria Deep Space Center in southern Ukraine,
- 1:04:53and the first Cosmic Call began broadcasting on May 24, 1999.
- 1:06:00Unlike many other initiatives,
- 1:06:02which received very little attention from the press and public,
- 1:06:05the Cosmic Calls were a global phenomenon.
- 1:06:07In fact, the project received so much attention
- 1:06:10that officials at the National Space Agency of Ukraine
- 1:06:13got a bit spooked.
- 1:06:14The plan was to beam the message to four nearby star systems,
- 1:06:18but after the first transmission on May 24,
- 1:06:20Ukrainian officials suddenly shut the whole thing down.
- 1:06:24According to Zaitsev, rumors had begun circulating
- 1:06:26that the reason Encounter 2001 were using the Evpatoria Deep Space Center
- 1:06:30was because they'd been denied access to American facilities
- 1:06:33out of concern it might be dangerous to transmit messages into space.
- 1:06:37In reality, other radio observatories like Arecibo
- 1:06:40were simply not available on the dates requested.
- 1:06:43It had nothing to do with malevolent aliens.
- 1:06:46Zaitsev spent over a month explaining this to the agency
- 1:06:49before Chafer and his team were allowed to resume broadcasting
- 1:06:52on the last day of June.
- 1:06:56The first target was 16 Cygni A,
- 1:06:58a sunlike star that's part of a ternary system.
- 1:07:01In other words, it's a system of three stars with Cygni A
- 1:07:04being encircled by a small red dwarf labeled C,
- 1:07:07and together, they orbit another sunlike star labeled B
- 1:07:10that's nearly six times further away than Voyager 1 is from the Sun.
- 1:07:16While Cygni B does have one confirmed planet,
- 1:07:18it's an enormous gas giant that patrols the entire habitable zone,
- 1:07:22making it impossible for an earthlike planet within that region
- 1:07:26to maintain a stable orbit.
- 1:07:28While the transmission was specifically directed at Cygni A,
- 1:07:31the situation doesn't improve much because, as far as we know,
- 1:07:34it doesn't have any planets.
- 1:07:36Instead, it's orbited by Cygni C
- 1:07:38at about twice the distance between the Sun and Pluto.
- 1:07:42It's definitely possible for an earthlike planet to be sandwiched between them,
- 1:07:46but it all comes down to the precise orbit of Cygni C, which is currently unknown.
- 1:07:52The second target was Gliese 746, a binary system composed of a sunlike primary
- 1:07:58and a smaller companion, of which very little is known.
- 1:08:01The distance between them is less than that between the Sun and Mercury,
- 1:08:05so there's no chance of finding an earthlike planet
- 1:08:07in a stable orbit around either one.
- 1:08:09However, there is such a thing as circumbinary planets
- 1:08:13that orbit two stars at once.
- 1:08:15With a system as tightly bound as Gliese 746,
- 1:08:18there's plenty of space for such a planet to exist, but so far, nothing.
- 1:08:24The third target was 15 Sagittae.
- 1:08:26It could be described as a binary system because Sagittae A
- 1:08:30is orbited by this tiny companion labeled B.
- 1:08:33But Sagittae B is what's known as a brown dwarf
- 1:08:36that falls somewhere between a planet and a star.
- 1:08:39It's dozens of times more massive than all the planets in the Solar System combined,
- 1:08:43but still not quite massive enough to shine like a star.
- 1:08:47Apart from Sagittae B, no other bodies have been detected,
- 1:08:50and the system is a bit on the younger side
- 1:08:52at approximately two and a half billion years old.
- 1:08:56Finally, the fourth target was Gliese 777 A,
- 1:09:00a sunlike star that is once again encircled by a red dwarf companion.
- 1:09:04Except, this time, the two are separated by such an enormous distance
- 1:09:08that it takes them upwards of 100 000 years to complete an orbit.
- 1:09:12Nevertheless, the target was 777 A, and it's home to three confirmed planets.
- 1:09:17Two of them are many times more massive than Earth
- 1:09:20and are practically hugging the star,
- 1:09:22while the third is a bit more massive than Jupiter and is much further away.
- 1:09:26In between them lies the habitable zone,
- 1:09:28which does appear to be stable enough to host an earthlike planet,
- 1:09:32but none have been detected to date.
- 1:09:36While all of these stars are within the general solar neighborhood,
- 1:09:39we still have to wait until the 22nd century
- 1:09:42until any response could relativistically be received.
- 1:09:45A fact that might come as a disappointment to some of you,
- 1:09:48but no doubt a relief to others.
- 1:10:09But it wasn't just the general public.
- 1:10:10A growing number of experts had begun to question the ethics and wisdom
- 1:10:15of deliberate communication attempts.
- 1:10:16Among them was Carl Sagan, who, as early as 1983,
- 1:10:20began arguing in favor of "listening rather than sending."
- 1:10:24Not so much because he feared invasion,
- 1:10:26but because he felt that contacting aliens was premature.
- 1:10:29He wrote that
- 1:10:30"it is not yet clear that we have anything particularly interesting to say"
- 1:10:33due to what he described as our "backward status."
- 1:10:37In other words, a baby civilization like humanity
- 1:10:40probably won't have much to offer one that's been around
- 1:10:43for millions or billions of years,
- 1:10:45so we should prioritize intelligence gathering
- 1:10:48before we start shouting at the sky.
- 1:10:51But astronomers like Alexander Zaitsev strongly disagreed with that position,
- 1:10:55essentially arguing that we must not give into fear of the unknown.
- 1:10:58Sure enough, just a few months after the first Cosmic Call,
- 1:11:01Zaitsev and others began work on yet another message.
- 1:11:13In early 2000, a youth community center in Moscow
- 1:11:17was preparing to host a festival to celebrate the new millennium.
- 1:11:20During the preparations, an astronomy teacher named Boris Pschenichner
- 1:11:24suggested to some of his students that they should create an interstellar message
- 1:11:28to be presented during a space-themed portion of the event.
- 1:11:31The project was spearheaded by two teenagers
- 1:11:33named Egor Kiselev and Vladimir Filippov
- 1:11:36who quickly devised a message composed of both music and pictures.
- 1:11:40Once the project had been approved by a committee that included Alexander Zaitsev,
- 1:11:44it was decided to transmit the message sometime the following year
- 1:11:47to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the first crewed spaceflight
- 1:11:50by cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin in 1961.
- 1:11:54Zaitsev expanded upon the ideas of Kiselev and Filippov
- 1:11:57by suggesting the message be divided into three distinct signal types:
- 1:12:01constant,
- 1:12:06continuous,
- 1:12:13and discrete.
- 1:12:20The constant signal would be sent first
- 1:12:22to let the aliens know that they've picked up something strange.
- 1:12:25That probing beacon would then transition into a continuous signal
- 1:12:29conveying the musical component of the message.
- 1:12:31Finally, two discrete frequencies would be used to broadcast binary-coded images.
- 1:12:36According to Zaitsev, the three formats
- 1:12:38represented the language of nature, emotion, and logic.
- 1:12:42A total of nine musical compositions were selected,
- 1:12:45and Zaitsev proposed using an electronic instrument known as a theremin.
- 1:12:49Partly because it generates a smooth monophonic signal with minimal overtones,
- 1:12:53but also because the theremin was a Russian invention.
- 1:13:11The visual portion of the message was composed of 28 bitmaps
- 1:13:15primarily designed by Kiselev and Filippov.
- 1:13:17The first image depicts a wave within a circle,
- 1:13:20which is meant to convey to the aliens that the circle's diameter
- 1:13:23is equal to the wavelength of the transmission.
- 1:13:26If they correctly make that guess,
- 1:13:28the next image is meant to be scaled so that this circle
- 1:13:30with a human face in the center
- 1:13:32matches the diameter of the circle from the previous image.
- 1:13:36Doing so would enable them to decode other components,
- 1:13:38like how this wavelength corresponds to a spectral absorption line of water.
- 1:13:43Without going into too much detail here,
- 1:13:45it's meant to highlight the significance of water to life here on Earth.
- 1:13:49While some of the illustrations tried to convey information using science and logic,
- 1:13:53a lot of it was artistically motivated.
- 1:13:56Life inhabits the ocean, land, and atmosphere,
- 1:13:59represented by dolphins, humans, and birds
- 1:14:02that the aliens will, of course, have no chance of deciphering.
- 1:14:06The ten circles along the edge, numbered 1 through 10,
- 1:14:09not only symbolize our use of a base-ten numeral system,
- 1:14:13but also correspond to the next ten images.
- 1:14:16The first of which is this side-view of our galaxy
- 1:14:18with an arrow pointing at us.
- 1:14:20The second is a schematic of the Solar System.
- 1:14:24The third gets a bit closer.
- 1:14:26The fourth gets closer still.
- 1:14:29Then there's a family,
- 1:14:32a house,
- 1:14:35and a close-up of a person.
- 1:14:40Towards the end, there's also a yin and yang symbol,
- 1:14:44two games of tic-tac-toe,
- 1:14:47and an illustration of the telescope used to transmit the message.
- 1:14:51But it doesn't end there because the next image is the same emblem we saw before,
- 1:14:56except the ten outlying circles
- 1:14:58have now been filled in with the ten preceding images.
- 1:15:01Exactly why they're laid out in this circular pattern in this particular order,
- 1:15:06or even what function it all serves,
- 1:15:09I couldn't tell you.
- 1:15:10But, again, the emblem was intended to be both informational and artistic.
- 1:15:15Following the emblem sequence, the next three images
- 1:15:18contain some text written in both Russian and English.
- 1:15:21Approximately 1 000 students between the ages of 13 and 18 participated in the project,
- 1:15:26and this is an extreme abbreviation of their many proposed greetings.
- 1:15:30It very innocently ends with...
- 1:15:34Signed by...
- 1:15:37The final twelve bitmaps depict illustrations that we've already seen,
- 1:15:40each one captioned with a brief description in both Russian and English.
- 1:15:45They're meant to function as a sort of dictionary
- 1:15:47with the hopelessly optimistic goal
- 1:15:49of teaching the aliens how to read the aforementioned greeting.
- 1:15:53The three components of the message, starting with the probing signal,
- 1:15:57followed by the music, and the 28 bitmaps,
- 1:15:59were then transmitted from the Evpatoria Deep Space Center on August 29, 2001.
- 1:16:44Much like the first Cosmic Call,
- 1:16:46the Teenage Message was transmitted multiple times over multiple days.
- 1:16:50This time to six different targets.
- 1:16:52The first one was Gliese 797 A, an as of yet planetless but sunlike star
- 1:16:57that forms a wide ternary system with two smaller companions.
- 1:17:02The second target was 37 Geminorum,
- 1:17:05a solitary sunlike star that has yet to show any signs
- 1:17:08of hosting a planetary system.
- 1:17:11Target number three was another sunlike star known as 47 Ursae Majoris,
- 1:17:15which is home to three confirmed planets.
- 1:17:18They all appear to be gas giants, and the one closest to the star
- 1:17:21is grazing the outer edge of the habitable zone.
- 1:17:24Because it's more than twice the mass of Jupiter,
- 1:17:27its immense gravity renders nearly the whole outer half of the habitable zone
- 1:17:31completely off limits.
- 1:17:32An earthlike planet within this region
- 1:17:34simply wouldn't be able to maintain a stable orbit.
- 1:17:37But if such a planet were to be located further inwards,
- 1:17:40things look a lot more optimistic.
- 1:17:43The fourth target was Gliese 547 A.
- 1:17:46Once again, it's a sunlike star that forms a wide binary system
- 1:17:50with a small brown dwarf companion.
- 1:17:52Apart from that, no planets as of yet.
- 1:17:55Target number five was yet another sunlike star known as Gliese 327
- 1:18:00with no confirmed planets.
- 1:18:01It does, however, show signs of being surrounded by either one
- 1:18:04or multiple belts of debris.
- 1:18:06But the precise mass, composition, and extent of this debris remains to be seen.
- 1:18:12Finally, the sixth target was Gliese 788.
- 1:18:15It is yet another solar analog with neither stellar nor planetary companions.
- 1:18:21All but one of the targets are more than 50 lightyears away, so
- 1:18:24the minimum response time is over a century.
- 1:18:27The one exception is 47 Ursae Majoris at 45 lightyears,
- 1:18:31so we could hear back from the Majorans as early as 2092.
- 1:18:46As the name Encounter 2001 would seem to imply,
- 1:18:49the Millennial Voyage was scheduled to launch by the end of 2001.
- 1:18:53But shortly before the start of that year,
- 1:18:55the project was quietly rebranded as Team Encounter.
- 1:18:59While it's difficult to know exactly what was going on behind the scenes,
- 1:19:02it seems like they vastly overestimated the public's interest
- 1:19:05in sending messages into space.
- 1:19:07As mentioned before, the team expected to attract
- 1:19:09somewhere between 1.5 and 4.5 million customers.
- 1:19:14A few months after launch, they had sold 45...
- 1:19:18...tickets.
- 1:19:19While sales ramped up quite a bit before the first Cosmic Call,
- 1:19:2243 000 customers was still a far cry from the millions they had anticipated.
- 1:19:27With such lackluster performance,
- 1:19:29the company had no choice but to push back the launch date
- 1:19:32of the Millennial Voyage by several years and changed the name to Team Encounter.
- 1:19:37But even after significant delays, a few celebrity endorsements,
- 1:19:40and numerous attempts to get people interested,
- 1:19:43sales lagged behind expectations by a wide margin.
- 1:19:47By the summer of 2003, the company's main investor finally pulled the plug,
- 1:19:51and the project was summarily abandoned.
- 1:19:54While this meant the Millennial Voyage was dead,
- 1:19:56Team Encounter did at the very least uphold their promise
- 1:19:58of transmitting a second Cosmic Call.
- 1:20:01The composition of which was very similar to the first.
- 1:20:04Just like before, it started with a primer
- 1:20:06designed by Yvan Dutil and Stéphane Dumas.
- 1:20:09However, they actually created a new set of glyphs,
- 1:20:11even more noise-resistant than the first.
- 1:20:14The 23 bitmaps were also redesigned and combined into one large image,
- 1:20:18but the contents of the primer stayed more or less the same.
- 1:20:22This was followed by a copy of the Arecibo Message,
- 1:20:25a few images from the Teenage Message,
- 1:20:27a description of the now canceled Millennial Voyage,
- 1:20:29and greetings by the staff at Team Encounter.
- 1:20:32Last but not least was the commercial payload.
- 1:20:35This included not just the names and greetings of more than 100 000 customers,
- 1:20:39but also more unique contributions like a chatbot program called Ella,
- 1:20:44the contents of an entire website,
- 1:20:47and the song Starman by David Bowie.
- 1:20:50All of which was, of course, converted into binary
- 1:20:53before being transmitted into space
- 1:20:54from the Evpatoria Deep Space Center on July 6, 2003.
- 1:20:59[Hugh Downs] The people of the planet Earth
- 1:21:01send their greetings and friendship to you, across lightyears of interstellar space.
- 1:21:07The message we send to you today contains information about our Solar System,
- 1:21:12our planet, and ourselves.
- 1:21:14We invite you to contact us and to share your knowledge, culture, and wisdom.
- 1:21:20May this Cosmic Call open an exciting dialogue between our two stars
- 1:21:25here in the Milky Way galaxy.
- 1:21:31Much like the first Cosmic Call, the second was beamed toward multiple targets.
- 1:21:36There were five in total, and the first one was Gliese 67.
- 1:21:40It's a binary system composed of a sunlike primary
- 1:21:43and a red dwarf companion that takes about 20 years to complete an orbit.
- 1:21:47While neither one is known to harbor any planets,
- 1:21:49and the distance between them is less than that
- 1:21:51between the Sun and Jupiter at closest approach,
- 1:21:54they're still far enough apart for an earthlike planet
- 1:21:56within their respective habitable zones to maintain a stable orbit.
- 1:22:02The second target was Gliese 208 A,
- 1:22:05which is only about half the size and mass of the Sun
- 1:22:07and forms a wide binary system with an even smaller companion.
- 1:22:11No planets as of yet, and it could be as young as half a billion years,
- 1:22:15which would make it unlikely to host a spacefaring civilization.
- 1:22:19Target number three was 55 Cancri A,
- 1:22:22a star that's a bit fainter and colder than the Sun,
- 1:22:25with a distant red dwarf companion.
- 1:22:27It's the host of five confirmed planets,
- 1:22:30with the fourth one, dubbed Harriot, orbiting within the habitable zone.
- 1:22:34Now, because Harriot's mass is at least three times that of Neptune,
- 1:22:38it's not a very likely candidate for life as we know it.
- 1:22:41But it's not inconceivable for life to have emerged on an earthlike moon
- 1:22:45in orbit around Harriot.
- 1:22:47Not only that, but it is possible for an earthlike planet to maintain a stable orbit
- 1:22:52within the outer half of the habitable zone,
- 1:22:54although simulations suggest that such a planet is far more likely to have formed
- 1:22:58just outside of it.
- 1:23:00The fourth target was 47 Ursae Majoris,
- 1:23:03which was previously the target of the Teenage Message,
- 1:23:06making this the first time we've signaled the same star more than once.
- 1:23:10Finally, the fifth target was Gliese 49,
- 1:23:13which has a lot in common with the second target.
- 1:23:16It's a red dwarf about half the size and mass of the Sun
- 1:23:19that probably forms an extremely wide binary system
- 1:23:22with an even smaller companion.
- 1:23:24While a planet with a mass of more than five times that of Earth
- 1:23:27has been detected around the primary,
- 1:23:29it's unlikely to be habitable due to its proximity to the star.
- 1:23:33But even if that wasn't the case, the system is probably too young
- 1:23:36to host a communicative civilization in the first place.
- 1:23:40Nevertheless, Gliese 49 is the least distant of the five targets
- 1:23:44at 32 lightyears,
- 1:23:45meaning any potential replies could reach us no sooner than 2067.
- 1:23:55Now, two years after the second Cosmic Call
- 1:23:57in the small European Republic of San Marino,
- 1:24:00Hungarian astronomer Iván Almár proposed a ten-point scale
- 1:24:04for quantifying the risk of interstellar messages.
- 1:24:07According to this scale, a transmission like the Arecibo Message
- 1:24:11carries a risk of 8, which is characterized as a far-reaching threat to humanity.
- 1:24:16Meanwhile, the two Cosmic Calls and the Teenage Message
- 1:24:20supposedly carry a risk of 7, giving them a threat level of high.
- 1:24:25While the risk factor is partially determined by objective metrics
- 1:24:28like signal strength and duration,
- 1:24:30it's also based on the contents of a message.
- 1:24:33This makes the San Marino Scale inherently subjective,
- 1:24:36and it also fails to consider other crucial factors like the distance to
- 1:24:40and habitability of the target.
- 1:24:43That being said, the creation of the San Marino Scale
- 1:24:45is a fascinating development because
- 1:24:48it highlights just how contentious the transmission debate had become.
- 1:24:51Many prominent figures within the SETI community,
- 1:24:55that being the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence,
- 1:24:57had become a lot more hesitant or outright opposed
- 1:25:00to what had come to be known as METI,
- 1:25:03Messaging Extraterrestrial Intelligence.
- 1:25:05A term coined by none other than Alexander Zaitsev
- 1:25:08during the creation of the Teenage Message.
- 1:25:12Pushing back against this growing opposition to METI,
- 1:25:14Zaitsev reasoned that
- 1:25:16"in a galaxy where everyone is listening and no one is speaking...
- 1:25:19...someone has to make the first move."
- 1:25:21He called attention to a poll showing that 78% of more than 140 000 SETI enthusiasts
- 1:25:27were, in fact, in support of METI.
- 1:25:30What he doesn't mention is that over half of those same respondents
- 1:25:34were still unsure if the aliens they were hoping to contact
- 1:25:38were more likely to be friendly or hostile.
- 1:25:50Throughout the 1990s,
- 1:25:52there was increasing demand within NASA to launch a mission to Pluto.
- 1:25:55At the time, it was the last unexplored planet of the Solar System,
- 1:25:59and even our most powerful telescopes could resolve nothing but a nebulous disc.
- 1:26:04After numerous failed attempts to secure the necessary funding,
- 1:26:07the spacecraft New Horizons was successfully launched on January 19, 2006.
- 1:26:14[Announcer] Five.
- 1:26:15[Announcer] Four.
- 1:26:16[Announcer] Three.
- 1:26:17[Announcer] Two
- 1:26:18[Announcer] One.
- 1:26:19We have ignition and liftoff of NASA's New Horizons spacecraft
- 1:26:24on a decade long voyage to visit the planet Pluto and then beyond.
- 1:26:41After borrowing some extra speed from the almighty Jupiter,
- 1:26:45New Horizons finally caught up with Pluto in 2015.
- 1:27:23At the time of the launch, Pluto was still recognized as a planet.
- 1:27:27But only seven months into the mission,
- 1:27:29it was reclassified by the International Astronomical Union
- 1:27:32as a dwarf planet.
- 1:27:34A decision that remains somewhat controversial to this day.
- 1:27:37Although, strictly semantically speaking,
- 1:27:41a dwarf planet is still a planet.
- 1:27:43It's right there in the name.
- 1:27:46Anyway, much like the Pioneer and Voyager probes,
- 1:27:48New Horizons continued on into deep space, destined to leave the Solar System
- 1:27:53and roam the galaxy.
- 1:27:54Yet unlike its predecessors,
- 1:27:56it does not carry a message.
- 1:27:59According to lead scientist Alan Stern,
- 1:28:01the inclusion of a plaque was brought up during the planning stages.
- 1:28:04But he ultimately rejected that proposal
- 1:28:06out of concern it might spark some sort of controversy
- 1:28:09that could take focus away from the mission.
- 1:28:11Not unlike what happened back in the '70s, when
- 1:28:14actual adult human beings realized that underneath our clothes
- 1:28:17is not more clothes.
- 1:28:19Given that New Horizons was but the latest
- 1:28:22in a long series of failed attempts to launch a mission to Pluto,
- 1:28:25Stern did not want to risk yet another delay or worse.
- 1:28:29But as stern as Stern might have been regarding a deliberate message,
- 1:28:32he was not opposed to the inclusion of nine symbolic items described as mementos,
- 1:28:37placed within the nooks and crannies of the spacecraft.
- 1:28:40The most significant of which was this aluminum canister
- 1:28:43containing the ashes of Clyde Tombaugh,
- 1:28:45the American astronomer who discovered Pluto in 1930.
- 1:28:49Shortly before his passing in 1997,
- 1:28:51Tombaugh requested that his cremains be launched into space,
- 1:28:54and what better way to honor that request
- 1:28:57than to sail him past the planet that he discovered.
- 1:29:01The other eight mementos included two flags of the United States;
- 1:29:07two state quarters, one from Maryland and one from Florida,
- 1:29:10honoring the states in which the probe was built and launched;
- 1:29:14a chunk of SpaceShipOne,
- 1:29:15paying tribute to the first successful crewed spaceflight by a private company;
- 1:29:20a postage stamp describing Pluto as the only planet "NOT YET EXPLORED";
- 1:29:25an off-the-shelf CD on the port side,
- 1:29:28loaded with the names of more than 400 000 people
- 1:29:30who signed up during an online campaign;
- 1:29:33and another CD on the starboard side,
- 1:29:35loaded with notes and photographs
- 1:29:36of people responsible for designing, building, and launching New Horizons.
- 1:29:41According to Stern, these artifacts were
- 1:29:43"more efforts of the heart than the head"
- 1:29:46and were intended for us here on Earth,
- 1:29:48not whomever might stumble upon the probe in the distant future.
- 1:29:51In fact, commercial CDs degrade over time
- 1:29:54and become unreadable within decades or a few centuries at most.
- 1:29:58Although, those estimates assume an earthlike environment,
- 1:30:01not a spacecraft floating through the vacuum of space
- 1:30:04while being shielded from a lot of otherwise damaging ultraviolet radiation
- 1:30:07by a thermal blanket.
- 1:30:09Somehow, longevity estimates for a CD being stored in those conditions
- 1:30:12never came up in the search results.
- 1:30:14Anyway, the lack of a deliberate physical message
- 1:30:16bothered some people enough that in 2013,
- 1:30:19one of the makers of the Golden Records, Jon Lomberg,
- 1:30:22launched a campaign to create a digital one.
- 1:30:25The idea was for people around the world to submit
- 1:30:27sounds, images, and other material
- 1:30:29that could be uploaded to one of the memory banks aboard the spacecraft.
- 1:30:32While there was a lot of public support for the project
- 1:30:35and Alan Stern was open to the idea,
- 1:30:37the One Earth message never materialized.
- 1:30:40After a failed Kickstarter campaign in 2017,
- 1:30:43Lomberg stated in 2020 that NASA had initially said, "Yes",
- 1:30:46but later changed their minds.
- 1:30:49Even if the project had succeeded,
- 1:30:50the One Earth message would've been no less symbolic than the nine mementos
- 1:30:54because, just like a compact disc, computer memory degrades over time.
- 1:30:58Even in the most optimistic of circumstances,
- 1:31:01we're talking centuries, possibly a few millennia at best.
- 1:31:05While it is a bit disappointing that no deliberate
- 1:31:08lasting message was included with New Horizons,
- 1:31:11let's not forget that the probe itself is a message.
- 1:31:14One that would provide any recipients with immediate confirmation
- 1:31:18that they're not alone.
- 1:31:19Although, that's presuming, of course, the probe is ever found.
- 1:31:23As I'm recording this,
- 1:31:24New Horizons has not been directed towards any particular star system,
- 1:31:28but that could change in the future.
- 1:31:30Following its encounter with Pluto in 2015
- 1:31:33and this malformed space-potato in 2019,
- 1:31:35the probe is now gliding through empty space
- 1:31:37while astronomers keep searching for additional flyby targets.
- 1:31:41So far, none have been detected,
- 1:31:42but the probe has enough juice to keep going until at least the 2040s.
- 1:31:46So a few decades from now, shortly before it runs out of power,
- 1:31:50NASA could choose to steer the probe towards a star system
- 1:31:53in its general direction of travel.
- 1:31:57While such a course-corrected voyage would still take untold eons, and
- 1:32:01humanity could be long gone by the time it arrives,
- 1:32:04I think it would be quite exciting to know that one of our foremost ambassadors
- 1:32:08was headed for something rather than nothing.
- 1:32:24In early 2008, a man named Martin Lewis
- 1:32:27approached NASA with the idea of beaming The Beatles song Across the Universe
- 1:32:31across the universe.
- 1:32:33As a Beatles historian,
- 1:32:34Lewis sought to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the song's recording,
- 1:32:38and NASA seems to have agreed because the year also happened to mark
- 1:32:41the 50th anniversary of the agency's founding.
- 1:32:44Using a massive antenna at the Deep Space Communications Complex
- 1:32:47located west of Madrid in the middle of Spain,
- 1:32:50the nearly 4-minute song was beamed towards Polaris, the famous North Star,
- 1:32:54on February 4, 2008.
- 1:32:57Former Beatles member Paul McCartney approved of the message by saying...
- 1:33:03But it's highly unlikely for Polaris to be inhabited.
- 1:33:06For one thing, it's not a solitary star but a system of three.
- 1:33:11The primary is a supergiant that's about two and a half thousand times brighter
- 1:33:15and nearly fifty times larger than the Sun.
- 1:33:18Placed at the center of the Solar System,
- 1:33:20its radius would extend about halfway to Mercury.
- 1:33:23Meanwhile, its closest companion is a bit more massive than the Sun
- 1:33:27and takes nearly 30 years to complete an orbit.
- 1:33:30This tight-knit binary system is then encircled by a third star
- 1:33:33that's many tens of Pluto orbits away.
- 1:33:36No planets have been discovered as of yet, but
- 1:33:39even if an earthlike planet with a stable orbit
- 1:33:41could be found within one of the stars' habitable zones,
- 1:33:44Polaris probably hasn't existed long enough
- 1:33:46for intelligent life to have emerged.
- 1:33:48While the two companions could be as old as two billion years,
- 1:33:52it seems like the primary has only been around for a few tens of millions.
- 1:33:56As if that was not bad enough,
- 1:33:57Across the Universe won't arrive until the middle of the 25th century
- 1:34:01because Polaris is more than 400 lightyears away.
- 1:34:15In the spring of 2008,
- 1:34:16the brand Doritos launched a campaign in the United Kingdom called
- 1:34:20You Make It, We Play It.
- 1:34:21The idea was for members of the public to create a short commercial about Doritos,
- 1:34:25and the winning entry would not only be played on national television,
- 1:34:28but also beamed into space.
- 1:34:30From a radar station in the middle of Svalbard in the Arctic Circle,
- 1:34:34a six-hour loop of the 30-second advert departed Earth on June 12, 2008.
- 1:34:54The target was, once again, 47 Ursae Majoris,
- 1:34:58meaning we've now dispatched three separate messages to this singular star.
- 1:35:02Presuming the Majorans are listening,
- 1:35:03they'll be hearing the Teenage Message in late 2046,
- 1:35:07the second Cosmic Call in late 2048,
- 1:35:10and an unprompted admission that we like to hasten our mortal doom
- 1:35:14by voluntarily consuming dusty triangles of death
- 1:35:16sometime in late 2053.
- 1:35:19Response time?
- 1:35:20Let's hope not.
- 1:35:30In the summer of 2008,
- 1:35:31a now-defunct social media platform named Bebo
- 1:35:34launched a project known as A Message From Earth.
- 1:35:37It primarily functioned as a publicity stunt to advertise the website,
- 1:35:41and like so many initiatives before it, crowdsourced the creation of a message
- 1:35:44by inviting its users to submit text and images.
- 1:35:47Some untold number of submissions, and several months later,
- 1:35:51the 501 most upvoted entries were beamed into space
- 1:35:54from the Evpatoria Deep Space Center on October 9, 2008.
- 1:36:24Considering that this was open to the internet,
- 1:36:26I strongly suspect many messages were a lot less sanitized than what we just heard.
- 1:36:30But since participation required you to be logged in and Bebo went offline in 2013,
- 1:36:35very little of A Message From Earth has been preserved.
- 1:36:39Nevertheless, the target was a red dwarf known as Gliese 581
- 1:36:43that's a lot smaller, lighter, fainter, and colder than the Sun.
- 1:36:47What this means is that an earthlike planet within this system
- 1:36:50has to orbit very close to its star
- 1:36:52to receive the same amount of energy as the Earth.
- 1:36:55So close, in fact, that the outer edge of the habitable zone around Gliese 581
- 1:37:00is closer than Mercury is to the Sun by a wide margin.
- 1:37:04With planets orbiting so close, it makes them vulnerable to flaring events,
- 1:37:08and it just so happens that red dwarfs have a penchant for sudden bursts of radiation.
- 1:37:13Not only can these eruptions have a sterilizing effect on nearby planets,
- 1:37:17but if there's one thing that life on Earth does not appreciate,
- 1:37:21it's sudden and dramatic changes to the climate.
- 1:37:24Not that we would know anything about that, now, would we?
- 1:37:26The good news is that Gliese 581
- 1:37:28has a better chance than most of hosting an earthlike planet
- 1:37:32because it's very old, and therefore a lot less active
- 1:37:34than many of its younger siblings.
- 1:37:36It's also quite close at less than 21 lightyears,
- 1:37:39meaning a reply could arrive as early as 2049.
- 1:37:43Even more promising is that shortly before
- 1:37:45and after A Message From Earth was transmitted,
- 1:37:48astronomers discovered not just one, but two planets
- 1:37:51a few times more massive than Earth
- 1:37:53orbiting within the star's habitable zone.
- 1:37:56Unfortunately, follow-up studies failed to corroborate those findings,
- 1:38:00suggesting the initially planet-looking signals were nothing more than noise.
- 1:38:06Unless additional planets can be found in the future,
- 1:38:08any remaining hope of life
- 1:38:10falls to the three confirmed planets that lie a bit further inward.
- 1:38:13However, due to their even greater proximity to the star with
- 1:38:17orbital periods of only a few days,
- 1:38:19chances are they're less earthlike and more mercurylike.
- 1:38:31To commemorate the 400th anniversary
- 1:38:33of astronomical contributions made by Galileo Galilei and Johannes Kepler in 1609,
- 1:38:39the United Nations along with the International Astronomical Union
- 1:38:42declared 2009 the International Year of Astronomy.
- 1:38:46Unsure of how best to celebrate this milestone,
- 1:38:48a representative of the Australian government
- 1:38:51reached out to a popular science magazine known as Cosmos.
- 1:38:55The magazine's editor-in-chief, Wilson da Silva,
- 1:38:57suggested they transmit an interstellar message
- 1:39:00during an upcoming annual event known as National Science Week.
- 1:39:03They were soon given the green light by the government,
- 1:39:06and after consulting a bunch of astronomers, NASA, and others,
- 1:39:09Cosmos launched a website called Hello From Earth.
- 1:39:12The project was described by da Silva as "Twitter to the Stars"
- 1:39:16because the idea was to allow anyone to submit a brief text message
- 1:39:19of no more than 160 characters in length.
- 1:39:22When the submission period came to a close less than two weeks later,
- 1:39:25the website had received nearly 26 000 messages.
- 1:39:29According to da Silva, less than 1% of the comments
- 1:39:31contained some sort of rule-breaking content like profanity, slurs, and so on.
- 1:39:36They were also forced by NASA
- 1:39:37to remove anything deemed even remotely sexual or aggressive,
- 1:39:40like the word "breast" and the phrase "all your base are belong to us",
- 1:39:44which is just a line from an old video game that later became a meme.
- 1:39:47As someone who's old enough to have been around back when this meme was still popular,
- 1:39:51this might be one of the most depressing things I've ever had to explain in a video.
- 1:39:56Painful reminders that we're all stuck on a travelator towards eternal nothingness aside,
- 1:40:00once all the messages had been vetted and approved,
- 1:40:02they were transmitted from a large antenna
- 1:40:04at the Canberra Deep Space Communications Complex
- 1:40:06in the Australian southeast on August 28, 2009.
- 1:41:32Much like A Message From Earth, Hello From Earth
- 1:41:34was also directed towards the nearby red dwarf Gliese 581.
- 1:41:39As mentioned before, observations conducted back then
- 1:41:42suggested the presence of two planets within the star's habitable zone,
- 1:41:45but those findings have since been refuted.
- 1:41:48Nevertheless, Gliese 581 is now the second star to be signaled more than once
- 1:41:52after 47 Ursae Majoris.
- 1:41:55While the International Year of Astronomy
- 1:41:57was primarily dedicated to Galileo and Kepler,
- 1:42:002009 also marked the 35th anniversary of the Arecibo Message.
- 1:42:05Something that American artist Joe Davis decided to celebrate in his own unique way.
- 1:42:18One of the most vital biological mechanisms on Earth is photosynthesis,
- 1:42:23the ability of some organisms like plants and algae
- 1:42:26to produce life-essential oxygen using water, sunlight, and carbon dioxide.
- 1:42:31Now, a crucial component of photosynthesis is a special molecule known as RuBisCO.
- 1:42:36RuBisCO is what's known as a protein, or more specifically an enzyme,
- 1:42:40that's been around for billions of years.
- 1:42:43Presuming the evolution of life here on Earth is typical rather than special,
- 1:42:47one possible way to communicate with an alien species
- 1:42:50would be to send them very basic biological information.
- 1:42:53If their path to intelligence bears any resemblance to our own,
- 1:42:57there's a chance they'll recognize an enzyme
- 1:42:59as ancient and rudimentary as RuBisCO.
- 1:43:02This was the idea that occurred to Joe Davis in late 2009.
- 1:43:06But instead of using something more conventional like binary code,
- 1:43:09he decided to map the RuBisCO gene sequence to four increasingly syllabic phrases
- 1:43:14alluding to an ancient Greek proverb.
- 1:43:17These were then vocalized and turned into a 15-minute audio sample
- 1:43:20using the text-to-speech feature on a regular iPhone.
- 1:43:24Now, if you feel like you couldn't quite follow all of that, no need to worry.
- 1:43:27There's zero chance the aliens will either.
- 1:43:29Much like Davis' previous project, the RuBisCO Stars Message was largely symbolic
- 1:43:34and primarily intended to evoke a reaction from people here on Earth.
- 1:43:38Nevertheless, using his academic connections,
- 1:43:40Davis managed to book time at the Arecibo Telescope.
- 1:43:43Then, on November 7, 2009,
- 1:43:45just over a week before the 35th anniversary of the Arecibo Message,
- 1:43:49a frequency-shifted audio recording of a synthetic voice
- 1:43:53rattling off fragmentary sentences representing the RuBisCO gene sequence
- 1:43:57was beamed towards three nearby stars.
- 1:44:24The first target was TZ Arietis, a red dwarf less than 15 lightyears away
- 1:44:29with one confirmed planet approaching the mass of Saturn.
- 1:44:32It's a very active flare star so
- 1:44:35even if an earthlike planet could be found, it's unlikely to host life as we know it.
- 1:44:40Meanwhile, the third target was Kappa¹ Ceti,
- 1:44:43a sunlike star barely 30 lightyears from Earth.
- 1:44:46While it is similar to the Sun, it's also a lot younger,
- 1:44:49making it unlikely that sufficient time has elapsed
- 1:44:52for a communicative civilization to have emerged.
- 1:44:55But the second target is a lot more interesting.
- 1:44:58It's another red dwarf known as Teegarden's Star,
- 1:45:01and while it does exhibit occasional flaring,
- 1:45:04it's a lot older and much less active than most of its kind.
- 1:45:08Furthermore, it's home to three confirmed planets
- 1:45:10with masses very similar to that of Earth,
- 1:45:13and two of them orbit within the habitable zone.
- 1:45:16To quote a recent paper,
- 1:45:18they are "among the most Earth-like exoplanets currently known."
- 1:45:23But earthlike does not necessarily mean habitable
- 1:45:26because flares are but one obstacle that red dwarf planets have to overcome.
- 1:45:31Another potential hazard is something known as tidal locking.
- 1:45:35Without going into too much detail,
- 1:45:36the simplest form of tidal locking is when the rotation of a celestial body
- 1:45:40becomes synchronized with its orbital period.
- 1:45:43The most famous example of this is the Moon.
- 1:45:45It completes precisely one rotation for every orbit around the Earth,
- 1:45:49which is why we only ever see one side of the Moon.
- 1:45:53The reason this happens is a bit complicated, but it's tied to proximity.
- 1:45:57The tighter the orbit,
- 1:45:58the more likely it is for a celestial body to become tidally locked to its host.
- 1:46:02As you can imagine, planets orbiting red dwarfs are especially susceptible,
- 1:46:07as they have to orbit very close to their star
- 1:46:09to retain liquid water on their surface.
- 1:46:12Sure enough, the three planets orbiting Teegarden's Star
- 1:46:15are all believed to be tidally locked, just like the Moon.
- 1:46:18This is less than ideal
- 1:46:20because it means that one hemisphere is cooked by everlasting starlight
- 1:46:23while the other is plunged into eternal night.
- 1:46:26Habitability estimates for such bisected worlds
- 1:46:29range from extremely pessimistic to cautiously optimistic
- 1:46:33because some climate models suggest
- 1:46:35warm air from the dayside creeps into the nightside,
- 1:46:37which pushes cold air from the nightside into the dayside, and so on.
- 1:46:42The end result of which is a planet with a surprisingly temperate climate
- 1:46:46that keeps water at perfect equilibrium between freezing and evaporating.
- 1:46:50But even if we accept the more optimistic models,
- 1:46:53the proximity of red dwarf planets
- 1:46:55also makes them less likely to retain an atmosphere in the first place.
- 1:46:59That's because stars tend to shed vast quantities of material into space,
- 1:47:04and the closer you get, the more intense that stellar wind becomes.
- 1:47:08As if that was not bad enough,
- 1:47:09this wind is occasionally interrupted by more explosive events
- 1:47:13like coronal mass ejections that can expel billions of tons of superheated plasma
- 1:47:19in a matter of minutes.
- 1:47:20Here's one being ejected from the Sun with the Earth hauntingly to scale.
- 1:47:35In the case of Teegarden's Star
- 1:47:37the two innermost planets are between 9 and 15 times closer
- 1:47:41than Mercury is to the Sun.
- 1:47:44It only takes them 11 and 5 days, respectively, to complete an orbit.
- 1:47:49According to one recent study, that's close enough for the stellar winds alone
- 1:47:53to completely strip those planets of a lasting atmosphere.
- 1:47:58While atmospheric erosion could be mitigated by a strong magnetic field
- 1:48:02like the one that surrounds the Earth,
- 1:48:04the magnetosphere of tidally locked planets
- 1:48:06would likely be reduced by their sluggish rotation.
- 1:48:09All that being said, the habitability of red dwarf planets remains open to debate.
- 1:48:14There is so much we don't know, and
- 1:48:16theories, simulations, and mathematical models
- 1:48:19can only do so much to fill in the blanks.
- 1:48:21Red dwarfs account for approximately three quarters of all stars in the Milky Way,
- 1:48:26so it would be a real shame if not a single one of them can support life as we know it.
- 1:48:32It's possible that some environments are conducive to life while others are not.
- 1:48:37The tricky part is determining where that line should be drawn.
- 1:48:40Presuming the planets orbiting Teegarden's Star
- 1:48:43have, in fact, cradled beings of sufficient intelligence,
- 1:48:46a reply to the RuBisCO Stars Message could be heading our way
- 1:48:49right this very moment.
- 1:48:51The signal would've reached the Teegardenese back in 2022,
- 1:48:55which amounts to a roundtrip ETA of 2034.
- 1:49:00Don't forget to mark your calendars.
- 1:49:02No, genuinely this time.
- 1:49:12Late one evening on August 15, 1977,
- 1:49:16the Big Ear Telescope in the US state of Ohio performed a routine survey of the sky.
- 1:49:21A few days later, a volunteer named Jerry Ehman
- 1:49:24sat down to review the collected data.
- 1:49:27What he found was a signal so exceptionally strong
- 1:49:30that he encircled the sequence on the printout sheet
- 1:49:32and famously wrote "Wow!" in the left-hand margin.
- 1:49:36The Wow! Signal remains a mystery to this day.
- 1:49:39Not least of all because it was never detected again
- 1:49:42despite numerous attempts to do so.
- 1:49:44The sequence 6-E-Q-U-J-5 is not some sort of code
- 1:49:48but merely the intensity of the signal over time,
- 1:49:51where numbers above 9 are represented by letters to save space.
- 1:49:54It makes a lot more sense if we plot it onto a graph like this.
- 1:49:58It begins with a value of 6,
- 1:49:59meaning it was six times more intense than normal background noise.
- 1:50:03The signal then jumped up to 14, followed by 26,
- 1:50:06and a peak intensity of 30 times above background.
- 1:50:09The signal then fell back down to 19 and then 5, before it disappeared.
- 1:50:14Each of the six samples were recorded 12 seconds apart
- 1:50:17and this 72-second rise and fall
- 1:50:20is perfectly consistent with the telescope panning over the source
- 1:50:24along with the Earth's rotation.
- 1:50:26In other words, the source of the Wow! Signal
- 1:50:28appears to have been more or less fixed in the night sky, much like a distant star.
- 1:50:33Had it been an earthbound source it would have moved with the telescope
- 1:50:36while things like airplanes and satellites
- 1:50:38would likely have moved too fast to remain visible for the whole 72 seconds.
- 1:50:42The Wow! Signal was also tantalizingly close
- 1:50:45to the frequency of the aforementioned hydrogen line.
- 1:50:48This makes it even less likely to be man-made because
- 1:50:50it falls within a protected band of frequencies reserved for radio astronomy.
- 1:50:55On top of that, it had a very narrow bandwidth.
- 1:50:57What this means is that, unlike a star, for instance,
- 1:51:00which emits radiation across a wide spectrum of frequencies,
- 1:51:03the Wow! Signal was very focused.
- 1:51:06It's by no means impossible for a natural source to produce such a concentrated beam,
- 1:51:10but it is unusual.
- 1:51:12This is what makes the Wow! Signal so curious.
- 1:51:15It bears all the hallmarks of a technosignature.
- 1:51:18Just as we have identified hydrogen,
- 1:51:20the most abundant element in the universe, as a means of initiating contact,
- 1:51:24the aliens could've done the same.
- 1:51:26Just as we tend to transmit extremely brief non-repeating messages,
- 1:51:31the aliens could be doing the same.
- 1:51:34Unfortunately, the peculiar design of the Big Ear Telescope
- 1:51:37makes it impossible to pinpoint the source of the signal.
- 1:51:41The setup was such that two large swaths of sky were scanned simultaneously,
- 1:51:45but there's no way to tell them apart when looking at the data.
- 1:51:49Even more peculiar is that the signal was only detected once
- 1:51:52despite this dual-scanning design.
- 1:51:55This can only mean one of two things.
- 1:51:56Scenario one is that the source had been transmitting for some
- 1:51:59indeterminate amount of time ahead of the first scan,
- 1:52:02yet ceased transmitting before it could be detected again by the second.
- 1:52:07Scenario two is that the source began transmitting
- 1:52:10during the roughly three minute window between the two scans,
- 1:52:13and continued to do so for who knows how long.
- 1:52:17Now, for a signal to carry information, it has to exhibit some sort of pattern.
- 1:52:21For instance, we tend to encode our messages by using a binary pattern
- 1:52:25that shifts back and forth between two different frequencies
- 1:52:28or levels of amplitude.
- 1:52:30The Wow! Signal did not exhibit any such pattern.
- 1:52:33Both its frequency and amplitude
- 1:52:35had a constant unmodulated appearance throughout the whole thing.
- 1:52:39That being said, we can't rule out the possibility
- 1:52:42that a sequence of fluctuations were present
- 1:52:44but that they fell below the threshold of what the Big Ear telescope could detect.
- 1:52:48No instrument has infinite resolution
- 1:52:51and Big Ear had some quite significant blind spots.
- 1:52:54To quote Ehman...
- 1:53:06On the off-chance that the Wow! Signal was a message from another civilization,
- 1:53:10the National Geographic Channel decided to transmit a reply on its 35th anniversary.
- 1:53:15After collecting over 17 000 tweets and about a dozen video-recorded greetings
- 1:53:20by various celebrities and public figures,
- 1:53:22the Wow! Reply was beamed into space from the Arecibo Telescope on August 15, 2012.
- 1:53:31At least that is what the public was told.
- 1:53:34But after contacting someone who worked at Arecibo when this transmission took place,
- 1:53:39they told me that the stress of beaming thousands of messages into space
- 1:53:42had caused the aging transmitter to overheat and break down.
- 1:53:46They could not recall how many messages made it through, but
- 1:53:49it could have been as few as just a single one.
- 1:53:52Now, because the details of the project had already been publicized ahead of time,
- 1:53:56and no correction was ever issued,
- 1:53:58everyone assumed the Wow! Reply went off without a hitch.
- 1:54:02But not only is it unclear how many tweets were sent,
- 1:54:05it's also unclear where they went because the Wow! Reply had three intended targets.
- 1:54:10They were all sunlike stars known as HD 54351, 37 Geminorum, and 55 Cancri A.
- 1:54:17Very little is known about the first,
- 1:54:19and it's quite some distance away at 140 lightyears.
- 1:54:23Meanwhile, the other two are much closer
- 1:54:25and have both been targeted by previous METI experiments.
- 1:54:28The person I spoke to could not recall which one was targeted first, so
- 1:54:32my best guess is HD 54351
- 1:54:35because that's the one listed first in a press release about the project.
- 1:54:39Now, with a name like Wow! Reply,
- 1:54:41you'd think the three targets were located within one of the two regions
- 1:54:44from which the Wow! Signal is known to have originated.
- 1:54:47Well, if you did think that, it might be time to recalibrate your common sense
- 1:54:51because all three targets are not only located outside these regions
- 1:54:56but in the complete opposite direction.
- 1:55:00The reason for this is very simple.
- 1:55:01The location where the Wow! Signal was detected
- 1:55:04was beyond the reach of the upward-facing and stationary Arecibo Telescope.
- 1:55:08But if that's the case, why even call it the Wow! Reply in the first place?
- 1:55:13Apart from being transmitted on its 35th anniversary,
- 1:55:17none of this had anything to do with the Wow! Signal.
- 1:55:23While the signal does have the hallmarks of an alien transmission,
- 1:55:26there's still a very good chance it was caused by a natural phenomenon.
- 1:55:30It's just a matter of identifying the correct one.
- 1:55:33For instance, one recent hypothesis
- 1:55:35tried to blame the whole episode on a pair of passing comets,
- 1:55:38but like all previous explanations,
- 1:55:40this one has failed to withstand further scrutiny.
- 1:55:42More recently, a paper published in 2024 hypothesized that a powerful flare
- 1:55:47ejected by something like a magnetar
- 1:55:50could've been amplified by a cloud of hydrogen,
- 1:55:52which would explain the signal's frequency.
- 1:55:54Whether this is the solution that will finally crack the case
- 1:55:58or be relegated to the mounting list of dead ends,
- 1:56:01only time will tell.
- 1:56:11In the early 2010s, a film editor named Pierre Fabre
- 1:56:14conceived of a project dubbed Lone Signal.
- 1:56:17Much like Team Encounter and the Cosmic Calls,
- 1:56:19Lone Signal was an attempt to commercialize interstellar messaging.
- 1:56:23The project was envisioned as a social media platform
- 1:56:26where anyone could submit text, images, audio, and video
- 1:56:29for direct transmission into space.
- 1:56:32Another similarity between Lone Signal and the Cosmic Calls
- 1:56:35was the inclusion of a primer written in a mathematical language of sorts.
- 1:56:39Constructed by planetary scientist Michael Busch,
- 1:56:42every component of this language is represented by a string of eight digits
- 1:56:46between 0 and 7.
- 1:56:48For instance, 1 + 1 = 2 looks like this,
- 1:56:51and here on the right is an example of some basic algebra.
- 1:56:54Things only become more complicated from there,
- 1:56:57but I'll spare you the details because, according to Busch,
- 1:56:59the technique used to encode the primer into the signal
- 1:57:02was far too fragile to survive the years-long trip across interstellar space.
- 1:57:07While the signal could still be detected,
- 1:57:09any patterns would become scrambled along the way,
- 1:57:12making it impossible to extract and decode the primer at the destination.
- 1:57:16In other words, alien astronomers may end up with their own Wow! Signal
- 1:57:20that doesn't seem to fluctuate in any meaningful way
- 1:57:23yet whose properties may still be difficult to ascribe to a natural source.
- 1:57:28Now, what truly sets Lone Signal apart from every other initiative mentioned so far
- 1:57:32is that it wasn't a one-time thing.
- 1:57:35Instead of transmitting the primer and public greetings all in one go,
- 1:57:38Lone Signal sought to establish a permanent beacon
- 1:57:41that would continuously transmit for years or even decades.
- 1:57:45To make that happen, they couldn't just book time at an active observatory
- 1:57:48but had to obtain long-term exclusive control over a telescope.
- 1:57:53After shopping around for a bit, they eventually secured a 30-year lease
- 1:57:56on a decommissioned telescope in southwestern California
- 1:58:00called the Jamesburg Earth Station.
- 1:58:02Then, after upgrading some of its aging equipment,
- 1:58:05Lone Signal began transmitting on June 17, 2013.
- 1:58:09But the team behind Lone Signal had even greater ambitions.
- 1:58:13Their long-term plan was to raise $100 million
- 1:58:16and to establish a network of telescopes to continuously signal
- 1:58:20multiple targets all at once.
- 1:58:22They likened themselves to SpaceX and hoped to create a global platform
- 1:58:26from which anyone in the world could beam any random thought
- 1:58:29directly into space all day long.
- 1:58:32But in a classic case of history repeating itself,
- 1:58:36the team behind Lone Signal, much like Team Encounter before them,
- 1:58:40vastly overestimated the public's interest in METI.
- 1:58:43Less than two months after launch,
- 1:58:45revenue from the website barely covered 2% of their operational costs.
- 1:58:49Pierre Fabre later wrote in a comment...
- 1:58:55...and that failure led investors to ultimately pull the plug.
- 1:58:59Nevertheless, the transmission target was yet another red dwarf called Gliese 526.
- 1:59:04It's less than 18 lightyears away and about twice as old as the Sun.
- 1:59:08While it is a relatively quiescent star with only occasional flaring,
- 1:59:12a planetary system has yet to be detected.
- 1:59:15Should it be home to a spacefaring civilization,
- 1:59:18they will have upwards of two months to notice our cosmic shouting,
- 1:59:22beginning in early 2031.
- 1:59:34Back in prehistoric times,
- 1:59:36not long after you pressed play on this documentary,
- 1:59:38I mentioned a series of METI experiments carried out
- 1:59:40by the National Space Development Agency of Japan in the mid-to-late 1990s.
- 1:59:46Designed by young students attending a NASDA space camp,
- 1:59:49these five bitmap images were transmitted from the Usuda Deep Space Center
- 1:59:53to various locations across the galaxy.
- 1:59:56Fast forward to 2013, and the successor to NASDA,
- 1:59:59the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency,
- 2:00:02decided it was time to try again.
- 2:00:04During a similar space camp event, and using the same telescope as before,
- 2:00:08JAXA retransmitted this image of two parents and a child on September 22, 2013.
- 2:00:15A similar bitmap depicting a human standing next to the Sun
- 2:00:18was then transmitted the following year on August 23,
- 2:00:22although it's unclear exactly what it looked like.
- 2:00:25Nevertheless, both images were directed at 55 Cancri A
- 2:00:28which has been targeted in the past
- 2:00:30and discussed in more detail in a previous chapter.
- 2:00:34But much like what happened back in the '90s, the JAXA Space Camp Messages
- 2:00:38flew as much through the radar as they did under it.
- 2:00:41Instead, these events were largely overshadowed by new developments
- 2:00:45in the ongoing transmission debate.
- 2:00:47Most notably, in early 2015, over two dozen scientists and SETI enthusiasts,
- 2:00:53including a pre-disgraced Elon Musk,
- 2:00:55signed a petition calling for a "worldwide consensus" regarding METI.
- 2:00:59They took issue with the fact that past METI experiments had been
- 2:01:02"based upon the wishes of a few individuals"
- 2:01:04rather than a "broadly representative body".
- 2:01:07In part because the aliens are likely to be "millions of years more advanced than us",
- 2:01:11but also because "it is impossible to predict whether [they] will be benign or hostile."
- 2:01:16The petition concluded that the potential "consequences of contact"
- 2:01:20demanded "worldwide scientific, political and humanitarian discussion"
- 2:01:24in advance of any future transmissions.
- 2:01:27To which an artist in collaboration with the European Space Agency responded...
- 2:01:43In early 2016, an artist and independent researcher named Paul Quast
- 2:01:47created a crowdsourced art project known as A Simple Response to an Elemental Message.
- 2:01:53It was similar to previous initiatives, except, this time,
- 2:01:55people were asked to frame their submissions as an answer to the question,
- 2:01:59"How will our present environmental interactions shape the future?"
- 2:02:03As the question implies, the project was about climate change
- 2:02:06and sought to capture a global portrait of humanity's thoughts and feelings
- 2:02:10about the present and future state of the world.
- 2:02:13As explained by Quast in a few interviews,
- 2:02:15the project was intended more as a time capsule for future generations
- 2:02:19than any potential aliens in outer space.
- 2:02:22This is also reflected by the selection of Polaris as the transmission target.
- 2:02:26As mentioned in a previous chapter,
- 2:02:28it's a relatively young and currently planetless system that's
- 2:02:31highly unlikely to host life as we know it.
- 2:02:34Instead, Polaris was primarily selected
- 2:02:36due to its historical significance as the famous North Star.
- 2:02:40Nevertheless, A Simple Response to an Elemental Message
- 2:02:42received nearly 4 000 submissions over the course of about eight months.
- 2:02:46In addition to the public messages,
- 2:02:48Quast also included a few copies of the Arecibo Message,
- 2:02:5181 quotes by prominent figures,
- 2:02:54and 70 photographs of Earth and humanity.
- 2:02:57All of which was then converted into binary and finally blasted into space
- 2:03:01by the Cebreros Deep Space Ground Station in central Spain on October 10, 2016.
- 2:04:17According to a subsequent review by Quast,
- 2:04:20he found that just under 20% of the responses were optimistic,
- 2:04:23just over 42% expressed some form of dread or concern,
- 2:04:27while the remaining 38% were largely neutral.
- 2:04:41In late 2017, a Spanish music festival known as Sónar
- 2:04:45began transmitting brief snippets of music into space
- 2:04:48to commemorate its 25th anniversary.
- 2:04:51Each composition was no more than 10 seconds in length
- 2:04:54and were provided by 38 musicians with connections to the festival.
- 2:04:57The first 18 were transmitted over the course of three days in October 2017
- 2:05:02from a telescope located in the far north of Norway.
- 2:05:24The remaining batch of 20 was then transmitted
- 2:05:27over the course of another three days in May 2018 using the same facility.
- 2:05:50What makes this initiative a bit more interesting, though,
- 2:05:53is the fact that all 38 compositions were preceded by a primer.
- 2:05:57In fact, not just one, but several.
- 2:06:00The first one began with two lists of prime numbers intended to attract attention.
- 2:06:04While the primes were technically expressed in binary,
- 2:06:07it would be more accurate to say that they're expressed in unary, repeated twice.
- 2:06:11So 0-0-1-1 for decimal 2,
- 2:06:130-0-0-1-1-1 for decimal 3,
- 2:06:160-0-0-0-0-1-1-1-1-1 for decimal 5, and so on.
- 2:06:21This was followed by a simple count from 0 to 255
- 2:06:24expressed using eight-digit chunks of binary code, also known as a byte.
- 2:06:29So it goes from eight zeroes representing 0
- 2:06:32all the way up to eight ones representing 255,
- 2:06:36the highest value possible using 8-bit encoding.
- 2:06:40Okay, following that introductory sequence was a second primer
- 2:06:43that differed between the two sessions.
- 2:06:45The one included with the first batch of music was written such that
- 2:06:48all 256 bytes represented a unique number, word, or concept.
- 2:06:53These bytes were then used to convey increasingly complex ideas,
- 2:06:57much the same way it's been done in previous initiatives,
- 2:06:59starting with some basic math before delving into things like physics and sound.
- 2:07:04The one included with the second batch of music
- 2:07:07was nearly identical to the one created by Yvan Dutil and Stéphane Dumas
- 2:07:10for Cosmic Call II.
- 2:07:12Some of the components have been shuffled around,
- 2:07:14and there's some updated information about the telescope,
- 2:07:17but otherwise, it's exactly the same.
- 2:07:19Immediately following that was another bitmap
- 2:07:21that tried to graphically convey the concept of a byte
- 2:07:24by counting from 0 to 255 once again.
- 2:07:29This was then followed by an image of a sine wave
- 2:07:32intended to visually convey the concept of sound and music.
- 2:07:36Now, the target of these transmissions was
- 2:07:38an ancient red dwarf known as Luyten's Star.
- 2:07:41It's a bit more than 12 lightyears away and harbors two confirmed planets.
- 2:07:46The outermost of which, Luyten b, is about three times the mass of Earth
- 2:07:50and orbits within the star's habitable zone.
- 2:07:53In fact, it is one of the nearest earthlike planets ever discovered,
- 2:07:56and it's the sole reason that this system was targeted.
- 2:07:59But as mentioned previously, the characteristic dimness of red dwarfs
- 2:08:03places the habitable zone very close to the star.
- 2:08:06In the case of Luyten b,
- 2:08:08it orbits about four times closer than Mercury orbits the Sun,
- 2:08:12takes less than 19 days to complete a revolution,
- 2:08:14and is all but guaranteed to be tidally locked.
- 2:08:18On the plus side, Luyten's Star exhibits minimal flaring due to its advanced age.
- 2:08:23Presuming Luyten b is inhabited by an advanced civilization,
- 2:08:26they'd have about 11 minutes per day for three consecutive days in early 2030
- 2:08:32to pick up the first batch of music,
- 2:08:33with the second arriving a few months later.
- 2:08:37Presuming they do so, we could hear back from the Luytenians as early as 2042.
- 2:08:52Okay, we've finally reached the most recent interstellar message
- 2:08:56as of the making of this documentary.
- 2:08:59Well, kind of.
- 2:09:00We'll get to that in a moment.
- 2:09:02Following the death of Stephen Hawking in early 2018,
- 2:09:05his ashes were interred at a famous church in London called Westminster Abbey.
- 2:09:10As the memorial service came to a close,
- 2:09:12an original score set against Hawking's iconic voice
- 2:09:15and written by Greek composer Vangelis
- 2:09:17was simultaneously beamed into space
- 2:09:19from the Cebreros Deep Space Ground Station on June 15, 2018.
- 2:09:24The target was a binary system nearly five thousand lightyears away
- 2:09:28known as V616 Monocerotis.
- 2:09:31It's composed of a star with about one-third the mass of the Sun and...
- 2:09:36...a black hole.
- 2:09:37At the time, it was the nearest black hole to the Solar System,
- 2:09:40although it has since been dethroned by at least a few other candidates.
- 2:09:44Now, paying tribute to Stephen Hawking
- 2:09:46by beaming his voice into space may seem like an odd choice,
- 2:09:49considering he was a very outspoken critic of METI.
- 2:09:53But as explained by his daughter Lucy,
- 2:09:55the broadcast was a purely symbolic gesture
- 2:09:57intended not only to celebrate his scientific contributions,
- 2:10:01but also to fulfill his lifelong dream of going into space.
- 2:10:05This is further reflected by the transmission target,
- 2:10:07as Hawking dedicated much of his life to the study of black holes.
- 2:10:11Besides, we're hardly gonna make contact with aliens
- 2:10:14in the vicinity of a black hole, right?
- 2:10:17Well, so, about that...
- 2:10:30This is a view of the Solar System
- 2:10:32showing all five interstellar spacecraft that humanity has launched to date.
- 2:10:38If we zoom out a bit further,
- 2:10:39we can see 23 of the nearest star systems
- 2:10:42targeted by at least one of the radio transmissions mentioned in this video.
- 2:10:47But to see the two most distant targets, we have to zoom out to a galactic scale.
- 2:10:52Here we find V616 Monocerotis, the target of Stephen Hawking's Memorial Broadcast,
- 2:10:57and finally Messier 13, the target of the Arecibo Message.
- 2:11:02But this is by no means an exhaustive list.
- 2:11:05Some radio transmissions, marked here in grey,
- 2:11:07did not make the cut because they failed to meet one of two criteria
- 2:11:11that I made up for this video.
- 2:11:13The first one is that a transmission must be deliberately directed
- 2:11:16at an extrasolar target.
- 2:11:18After all, the goal of METI is to contact another intelligence,
- 2:11:22so projects that aimlessly blast messages into space with
- 2:11:25no particular target in mind do not count.
- 2:11:28This includes signals that could accidentally be detected,
- 2:11:31like those routinely transmitted by astronomers to
- 2:11:34communicate with spacecraft or map the surface of bodies within the Solar System.
- 2:11:39To give you an example, in late 1962,
- 2:11:41a group of Soviet astronomers used this absolute beast of a telescope
- 2:11:46to bounce radar signals off the surface of Venus.
- 2:11:49For a bit of fun, they decided to modulate the radar pulses
- 2:11:52to spell out the words MIR, LENIN, and USSR using Morse Code.
- 2:11:56This is sometimes described as the first interstellar message
- 2:11:59because a lot of that radiation went right past Venus
- 2:12:03and continued on into deep space.
- 2:12:06Now, if you read about this online,
- 2:12:07you'll find claims that some portion of that excess radiation
- 2:12:10is currently heading for an obscure binary system known as HD 131336
- 2:12:15that's well over a thousand lightyears away.
- 2:12:18The phrasing can often make it seem as though this was
- 2:12:20planned by the original scientists back in 1962,
- 2:12:24but that is not the case.
- 2:12:26The true source of this claim is a forum post from 2002
- 2:12:29in which an amateur astronomer did some quick back-of-the-napkin calculations
- 2:12:33to suggest HD 131336 might have been near the path of the signal
- 2:12:38depending on the precise time of transmission, which is unknown.
- 2:12:42Given the imprecision of that guesstimate
- 2:12:45and the fact that the intended target was Venus,
- 2:12:47I decided not to include it on my list.
- 2:12:51The second criterion is that the strength of a transmitted signal
- 2:12:54must be greater than 100 megawatts.
- 2:12:57Now, for any radio astronomers watching, here I'm not talking about output power,
- 2:13:01but the much more crucial parameter, which is the effective radiated power
- 2:13:05that accounts for things like transmission frequency and gain of the antenna.
- 2:13:09For anyone curious, you can find a spreadsheet in the references
- 2:13:12with all the incredibly exciting technical details.
- 2:13:15Anyway, there's nothing special about 100 megawatts.
- 2:13:18I just needed some way to filter out some of the weaker transmissions
- 2:13:21from the stronger ones, and this seemed like a nice even number to draw that line.
- 2:13:25It's neither so high that everything is excluded
- 2:13:27nor so low that everything is included.
- 2:13:30It's just a way to rein in the scope of this video.
- 2:13:33While I tried to be as forgiving as possible with these two criteria,
- 2:13:37you could, of course, be a lot more strict.
- 2:13:39For instance, it is very common to categorize METI experiments
- 2:13:43based on how earnest or frivolous most experts perceive them to be.
- 2:13:47Take the Doritos Broadcast Project as an example.
- 2:13:50It is typically not regarded as a genuine attempt at METI
- 2:13:54because transmitting a commercial into space is obviously just a publicity stunt.
- 2:13:58It's rather silly, unscientific, and utterly indecipherable.
- 2:14:02To use the terminology favored by Alexander Zaitsev, it's "pseudo-METI".
- 2:14:07But as I've stressed multiple times throughout this video,
- 2:14:10what we say isn't all that important
- 2:14:13because we're probably not going to be understood anyway.
- 2:14:16What is important is that the signal has been
- 2:14:18modulated or manipulated in such a way
- 2:14:21that it does not resemble anything else in the universe.
- 2:14:24As long as the recipients are unable to ascribe the signal to a natural source,
- 2:14:28they will have no choice but to entertain the possibility of intelligent design.
- 2:14:33Besides, the distinction between genuine and pseudo-METI
- 2:14:36is highly subjective and inconsistent.
- 2:14:38For instance, the Arecibo Message is usually upheld as a prime example of METI
- 2:14:43despite Frank Drake himself describing it as a publicity stunt,
- 2:14:46and much of it is indecipherable.
- 2:14:48Likewise, the Message to Altair is typically regarded as genuine METI
- 2:14:53even though the Doritos Broadcast Project was about five times more powerful
- 2:14:57and lasted six times longer.
- 2:15:00Another approach would be to sort METI experiments based on the distance to
- 2:15:04and habitability of the target.
- 2:15:06You could, for instance, exclude the Arecibo Message because
- 2:15:09M13 is extremely far away and unlikely to be habitable.
- 2:15:13Same thing with Stephen Hawking's Memorial Broadcast
- 2:15:16directed at a black hole many thousands of lightyears away.
- 2:15:20But here's where things get a bit tricky because
- 2:15:22how do we determine when a target is too far away?
- 2:15:26In other words, how do we know when a signal is too weak or sufficiently strong
- 2:15:31to be detected by an alien civilization of which we know nothing about?
- 2:15:36The simplest approach would be to assume the recipients are no more advanced than us
- 2:15:40and use our present level of technology and scientific understanding
- 2:15:44as a baseline for detectability.
- 2:15:47In other words, if we can't detect it, neither can they.
- 2:15:50If that's the case, they would definitely struggle
- 2:15:53if not be outright unable to detect
- 2:15:55some of the messages mentioned in this video.
- 2:15:59But should we really make that assumption?
- 2:16:02Well, to paraphrase Carl Sagan,
- 2:16:04any civilization even just slightly behind us
- 2:16:07wouldn't be able to receive or transmit,
- 2:16:10whereas any civilization on par with or billions of years ahead of us
- 2:16:15could be.
- 2:16:16Odds are they will be more advanced,
- 2:16:18making range and detectability estimates based on the assumption that they're not
- 2:16:22feel rather pointless.
- 2:16:25But it feels equally pointless to assume that they are more advanced because
- 2:16:28then it just comes down to who writes the best science fiction.
- 2:16:32Does more advanced mean they have instruments that are similar to our own
- 2:16:35but simply larger and more sensitive?
- 2:16:38Does it mean they have long since abandoned radio technology
- 2:16:41in favor of something else entirely?
- 2:16:44Does it mean they have a more sophisticated understanding of physics,
- 2:16:47and that their technology would appear to us as nothing short of magic?
- 2:17:24Habitability estimates suffer from a similar problem because
- 2:17:27we obviously don't know if what we regard as habitable
- 2:17:30is the same as what they regard as habitable.
- 2:17:33Even if we assume that intelligent life can exclusively emerge
- 2:17:37on earthlike planets orbiting sunlike stars,
- 2:17:40that does not mean
- 2:17:42they will stay there.
- 2:17:44Perhaps there comes a time in the lifespan of any civilization
- 2:17:47when their energy requirements outpace that which can be provided by sunlike stars?
- 2:17:52Perhaps life is destined to seek out more extreme environments
- 2:17:56that we would never even think of as being habitable today?
- 2:17:59Perhaps the messages we've sent towards places most unlike our own...
- 2:18:04...are the most likely to receive a response?
- 2:18:10All this ambiguity is, of course, a big reason why many are so opposed to METI
- 2:18:14because the unknown allows us to imagine the worst.
- 2:18:18For instance, in early 2010,
- 2:18:20Stephen Hawking cautioned against deliberate communication attempts
- 2:18:23out of concern that aliens might not be too dissimilar
- 2:18:26from our past and present selves.
- 2:18:44As we've already seen throughout this video,
- 2:18:47this pessimistic view on humanity and first contact is very common,
- 2:18:51and for good reason.
- 2:18:52There are plenty of examples throughout human history
- 2:18:55in which a less developed society
- 2:18:57suffered at the hands of a more advanced one.
- 2:19:00The problem with pessimism, though, is that it's one-sided.
- 2:19:03It would be just as easy to leverage more positive trends and behaviours
- 2:19:08in support of an optimistic outcome.
- 2:19:10For instance, consider this critique by philosopher Guy Kahane.
- 2:19:43Considering how much we've improved in a very short span of time,
- 2:19:46things like child mortality, homicides, and poverty are declining
- 2:19:50while access to clean water, electricity, and life expectancy are increasing
- 2:19:55we only have to look at ourselves to see how intelligent life might develop
- 2:19:59into something we would want to meet.
- 2:20:02Perhaps not humanity of today since, you know, there's still...
- 2:20:05...plenty of room for improvement.
- 2:20:07But if we project these positive trend lines sufficiently far into the future,
- 2:20:11it's possible that much older civilizations will have long since outgrown
- 2:20:15their more destructive tendencies.
- 2:20:40Just as Hawking justified his belief that aliens will be hostile by saying,
- 2:20:44"Look at all the bad things we've done,"
- 2:20:47Frank Drake justified his belief that aliens will be friendly by saying,
- 2:20:50"Look at our capacity for growth."
- 2:20:53Neither argument is more or less valid than the other because
- 2:20:56we're obviously capable of both.
- 2:20:59But as the anti-METI crowd will often point out,
- 2:21:02this uncertainty is the problem.
- 2:21:05They will often argue that the mere possibility of an existential threat
- 2:21:08outweighs any potential benefits.
- 2:21:11To reiterate a quote from much earlier in the video...
- 2:21:32A common counterargument among those in favor of METI is that
- 2:21:35it's too late to worry about hostile aliens because
- 2:21:38we've been leaking radio signals into space for the better part of a century.
- 2:21:42Anyone within about 100 lightyears of Earth could, in theory,
- 2:21:46detect our presence by intercepting our television broadcasts.
- 2:21:50But as opponents of METI are often quick to point out,
- 2:21:53this unintentional leakage is extremely faint and diffused.
- 2:21:57While it's impossible to say what signals are
- 2:22:00too faint for an alien civilization to detect,
- 2:22:02a weaker signal is obviously more difficult to detect than a stronger one.
- 2:22:07But it's not just about signal strength, it's also about intent.
- 2:22:11An archer blindly shooting arrows in random directions
- 2:22:14is a lot less likely to strike a bullseye
- 2:22:17than the archer aiming for the target.
- 2:22:20Sure, radio leakage could accidentally expose our presence,
- 2:22:23but METI goes out of its way to maximize that outcome.
- 2:22:28It's the difference between a ship lost at sea
- 2:22:30that happens to spot the faint glow of a coastal town...
- 2:22:34...and a lighthouse.
- 2:22:36There isn't much we can do about the former
- 2:22:37because it's merely a byproduct of our civilization.
- 2:22:40But there's plenty we could do about the latter,
- 2:22:43like, you know, not build a lighthouse.
- 2:22:46While some critics advocate for precisely that, a planetwide ban on METI,
- 2:22:50such proposals are often countered by what's known as the SETI Paradox.
- 2:22:54It goes something like this.
- 2:22:56If we conclude that METI is too risky,
- 2:22:58and other civilizations reach that same conclusion,
- 2:23:01what would be the point of SETI if no one is transmitting?
- 2:23:05To quote the man who coined the term...
- 2:23:14The obvious problem with this argument is the assumption that all civilizations
- 2:23:18independently and inevitably reach the same conclusion.
- 2:23:22Even if we decided to cease transmitting tomorrow,
- 2:23:25that doesn't mean all other civilizations must behave as we do.
- 2:23:30In fact, this argument doesn't work even if METI is universally rejected
- 2:23:34because an absence of deliberate emissions
- 2:23:37does not preclude the detection of unintentional ones,
- 2:23:40even if it's a lot less likely.
- 2:23:42So the SETI Paradox isn't much of a paradox at all.
- 2:23:45It makes perfect sense to keep listening even if we never send another message.
- 2:23:50But this is just a hypothetical, of course, because we
- 2:23:53probably will send more messages in the future.
- 2:23:56After all, a planetwide ban would be extremely difficult to enforce,
- 2:24:00which is why some critics seek not to keep quiet but to regulate the noise.
- 2:24:05While there's no consensus on what form such regulation should take,
- 2:24:08popular ideas include an international treaty or policy
- 2:24:12that places restrictions on METI,
- 2:24:14some sort of review board or oversight committee
- 2:24:17elected to make decisions on humanity's behalf,
- 2:24:19or a democratic process where
- 2:24:22presumably everyone in the world gets a vote?
- 2:24:26The logistics of which I don't even dare to think about.
- 2:24:29While different policies and regulations could go a long way
- 2:24:33to reduce the number of transmissions,
- 2:24:36they're unlikely to eliminate the practice entirely.
- 2:24:38If people want to do something badly enough,
- 2:24:41there will always be a way to do it.
- 2:24:43Outlaw METI in one country, and people will go to another.
- 2:24:46Make it illegal around the world, and people will do it in secret.
- 2:24:50Hell, I wouldn't be surprised if a few messages
- 2:24:52have been dispatched in secret already.
- 2:24:55Think about it.
- 2:24:56Radio telescopes have been around for well over half a century.
- 2:24:59You're telling me not a single person has had the means and motive
- 2:25:02to beam a quick text to Proxima Centauri when no one else was looking?
- 2:25:07I'm not saying it's common, of course, but...
- 2:25:09...not once?
- 2:25:11I don't know about that.
- 2:25:47As pointed out by evolutionary biologist Wallace Arthur,
- 2:25:50we are, for better or worse, a species that cannot stand not knowing.
- 2:25:55Whether it's the other side of a mountain,
- 2:25:57the other side of an ocean,
- 2:25:59or the other side of the galaxy,
- 2:26:01the unknown will always evoke fear in some,
- 2:26:04and irresistible curiosity in others.
- 2:26:07No amount of debating is going to change that.
- 2:26:12Now, fortunately for those of you in camp fear,
- 2:26:15METI is extraordinarily unlikely to succeed.
- 2:26:19The stars we've targeted so far only account for a tiny fraction
- 2:26:23of the hundreds of billions of stars in the galaxy.
- 2:26:27Most of which are within just a few tens of lightyears of Earth
- 2:26:31even though the galaxy is about 100 000 lightyears across.
- 2:26:35For one of our messages to be received,
- 2:26:37the Milky Way is either so jam-packed with communicative civilizations
- 2:26:41that it's basically impossible to miss,
- 2:26:43or we would need to be luckier than the combined luck
- 2:26:46of all humans who have ever lucked...
- 2:26:48...and then some.
- 2:26:50It's still fun to think about, of course,
- 2:26:52in the same way it's fun to think about other improbabilities like
- 2:26:55winning the lottery.
- 2:26:57It could happen,
- 2:26:58but it's probably not going to.
- 2:27:01So, in my view, it doesn't really matter either way.
- 2:27:04But if I had to pick a side,
- 2:27:06I think I'm more persuaded by the arguments against METI than those in favor.
- 2:27:11As much as I would like to have confirmation that we're not alone,
- 2:27:14tying one end of a rope around your waist
- 2:27:17and the other end around humanity
- 2:27:19before sprinting headfirst into a dark room
- 2:27:22hoping there isn't a hole in the floor
- 2:27:24is probably not the wisest approach.
- 2:27:27Thank you for watching.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Shouting at Stars: A History of Interstellar Messages by LEMMiNO, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 21,159 words across 2,287 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.