Should we allow assisted suicide? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00I hope I'm on the line. I've had all
- 0:02kinds of problems with not only my
- 0:05sound, but la yesterday uh my internet
- 0:09got cut off four times
- 0:13and uh I'm a little worried about that.
- 0:16Uh today got cut off once so I don't
- 0:18know. And just now I couldn't get
- 0:19online. So, um, if there's a problem,
- 0:23all I can say is,
- 0:26uh, when the internet comes back, if
- 0:29that's what's happening, uh, you know,
- 0:31I'll come back. Hi. [laughter]
- 0:35Okay.
- 0:37Anyways, um, uh, let me just say the
- 0:41following. Uh, first, welcome to
- 0:43rational science. Um lately lately I've
- 0:48been um contemplating suicide.
- 0:54Uh I mean you know researching in
- 0:57suicide you know understanding uh
- 0:59suicide. Okay. Um
- 1:03there's been a case about a year ago a
- 1:06little less than a year ago. And it's of
- 1:08the Pausners and they were an old
- 1:12couple. Both of them were over 95 years
- 1:14old and they could not commit suicide in
- 1:18Great Britain where it's not allowed.
- 1:20You say, "Well, what do you mean it's
- 1:22not allowed? I mean, what are they going
- 1:23to do? Arrest me? [laughter] I commit
- 1:25suicide? What are you going to do?" Now,
- 1:27we're talking about assisted suicide,
- 1:30right? And they had to go to Switzerland
- 1:33uh to to do their thing. They have a
- 1:36facility over there where they do
- 1:38assisted suicide. And this is the uh
- 1:41pausners. Uh they were old. They weren't
- 1:46sick. Okay. They they did not have they
- 1:49did not suffer from any u illness. They
- 1:52were not terminally ill or anything.
- 1:54They just were old. They said they had
- 1:56lived enough.
- 1:58And so they decided to um call it quits.
- 2:03And you know, and I guess that's what
- 2:05some people want to discourage for some
- 2:08reason. I mean it's their choice right
- 2:11and uh so so the issue is whether you
- 2:14know these people should be allowed to
- 2:16commit suicide or let's put it in a
- 2:19different way if there should be
- 2:20facilities that assist people to commit
- 2:24suicide you know medical centers uh uh
- 2:27whatever hospitals
- 2:30and there were two fellows who fought
- 2:33bitterly about this uh about 20 years
- 2:37ago and And it's these two fellas here.
- 2:39One is Jack Kavorin known as Dr. Death,
- 2:42Dr. K. And Jerry Fowl from the moral
- 2:45majority. And first one emphasized
- 2:48individual autonomy, you know, personal
- 2:50liberty. And the other guy said, you
- 2:52know, uh, you know, you you have no
- 2:55right to take someone's life. Only God
- 2:57can take your life away or mother nature
- 3:00or whatever, right? Whoever you believe
- 3:01in. And so, you know, there was this
- 3:04bitter struggle. And turns out Jack um
- 3:09uh helped assisted in over a hundred uh
- 3:13deaths. And the last one he ran into
- 3:16trouble because um he u facilitated a
- 3:20little too much. He went in there and
- 3:22helped a little too much according to
- 3:23the authorities. It was political,
- 3:25right? Just a political thing. They
- 3:27wanted to stop him. And it turns out he
- 3:30went overboard and he uh this person
- 3:32could not kill himself. So Jack held him
- 3:34a little more than what he should
- 3:36apparently. That's that's what they
- 3:37said, you know, and he s served eight
- 3:40years in prison for that. Okay. So, um
- 3:44uh he wasn't very happy about that. But
- 3:46when he came out, they made a movie
- 3:47known as You Don't Know Jack. [laughter]
- 3:53Okay. And uh you know, I told my wife,
- 3:55you know, um that maybe we could do the
- 3:58same thing as the Pausners, you know, in
- 4:00uh in the future. I mean, they lived 75
- 4:03years married together. We've been
- 4:05married for 50 years. We've had a great
- 4:07marriage. We've had a great life, a lot
- 4:10of adventures and so on. And I told her,
- 4:13you know, maybe we might reach the same
- 4:15decision, you know, of committing
- 4:17suicide at the end because, you know,
- 4:20there's nothing more to live for, that
- 4:22kind of thing. And she was pondering the
- 4:25issue. And then I said, "As you know,
- 4:30uh, I'm a gentleman.
- 4:33Ladies first." [laughter]
- 4:37Well, she told me, well, I can't say
- 4:38what she told me, okay? She told me to
- 4:40do something and I can't mention that on
- 4:42YouTube, but I'll [snorts] let you
- 4:44imagine what she told me. Anyways, uh,
- 4:47there are situations and situations
- 4:49should we allow or should we help
- 4:51someone commit suicide? Okay. uh
- 4:55assisted suicide, right? And there's a
- 4:58movie that kind of illustrates this very
- 5:00well. It's known as Duel at Diablo,
- 5:04okay? Uh in the 60s or 70s, I can't
- 5:07remember when. And um this is what um
- 5:12what happens. It turns out that this
- 5:14cowboy, he's looking for this fellow who
- 5:17killed his wife and he wants to murder.
- 5:19He he wants to really get this guy,
- 5:21bring him to justice or kill him or
- 5:23whatever. And He eventually finds him,
- 5:26but it turns out that the Apaches, you
- 5:28know, they they got him first. They
- 5:30tortured him. They burned him. You know,
- 5:32he was all burned, but they left him
- 5:34alive, stuck to a wagon wheel. And this
- 5:37is the final or one of the final scenes,
- 5:40dramatic scenes of this movie. And it
- 5:44kind of illustrates very well, you know,
- 5:46what uh what assisted suicide is all
- 5:50about. Okay, listen to this.
- 5:57>> [music]
- 6:10>> Kill me,
- 6:14pity.
- 6:17Please [snorts]
- 6:18kill me.
- 6:21[sighs and gasps]
- 6:22Please
- 6:24kill.
- 6:44Okay. So I guess uh there are
- 6:47circumstances
- 6:48when uh when you want to assist someone
- 6:52and I guess this was one of them. Even
- 6:54though he hated the guy, he gives him
- 6:56his guns to shoot himself. Uh that is
- 6:59that assisted suicide. I guess you would
- 7:01call it is that right? He he did assist
- 7:03in the other guy's suicide. He could
- 7:04have left him there, right? He didn't uh
- 7:07had a little bit of heart because the
- 7:09guy was just never coming back, right?
- 7:12So you might as well you would think at
- 7:14least but there are situations other
- 7:16situations you know um there were two
- 7:19fellows uh one is name is uh Gabshake
- 7:23and the other one Kish I think I
- 7:24pronounced those correctly and uh they
- 7:28were the fellows who murdered who
- 7:30assassinated
- 7:32um Reinhardt um Hydrrich he was a very
- 7:37important man in the uh Nazi government
- 7:40and he was sent to be like the governor
- 7:43of Czechoslovakia at the time which was
- 7:45controlled by the Germans and you know a
- 7:49lot of uh people in the west hated his
- 7:50gods. They wanted to get this guy and so
- 7:53the um British government together with
- 7:56the Czech government in exile which was
- 7:59in England I guess in London and they
- 8:03prepared a a um an operation to kill
- 8:08Hydrrich. And so they sent this group of
- 8:11people and two of them were chosen. Uh
- 8:13these two fellas um again his their
- 8:16names I hope I pronounce them correctly
- 8:18Gabshik and Kubish. Okay those are their
- 8:21names [snorts] and they eventually ended
- 8:23up killing Hydridge. Okay. But they
- 8:26weren't able to get out of
- 8:26Czechoslovakia and they were cornered in
- 8:29a monastery or or uh uh some cathedral
- 8:33or church and uh and all the troops, the
- 8:37German troops were all around them and
- 8:39they had no choice but to commit suicide
- 8:43because they were getting out of there
- 8:44and if they did get out they would would
- 8:46have been tortured. So they took the
- 8:49decision to commit suicide. And here's a
- 8:52scene from uh one of the movies. There's
- 8:55several movies that depict this uh this
- 8:58uh situation, this the murder of
- 9:00Hydridge, but here's uh one of them. And
- 9:03you can see what what these two fellas
- 9:05had to do. Okay, here goes.
- 9:08[music]
- 9:13[music]
- 9:16How many you got?
- 9:18Enough.
- 9:25>> [music]
- 9:47>> Okay. So uh there are situations and
- 9:50situations and I think you got to ponder
- 9:53all of them if you're going to give a
- 9:55rational answer to the question you know
- 9:58and again some people say that there's
- 10:01no problem. I mean it's your choice and
- 10:03you should even help them if if that's
- 10:06what they want to do and other people
- 10:08say no you got to preserve life and blah
- 10:10blah blah. One thing that uh one
- 10:13question pops up is whether uh animals
- 10:17other than humans, right? We're animals.
- 10:19Uh if animals commit suicide.
- 10:23And here's a case in point. It was uh
- 10:25illustrated in a movie uh from Walt
- 10:28Disney in 1958, White Wilderness. And uh
- 10:32it's the lemmings of Norway. And
- 10:35apparently they commit suicide, massive
- 10:38suicide. They just drown themselves. And
- 10:41here, watch this. Okay, here it goes.
- 10:47>> Mass suicide by rushing into the sea and
- 10:49droves. Ahead lies the Arctic shore and
- 10:52beyond the sea. Their frenzy takes them
- 10:54tumbling down the terrace, creating tiny
- 10:57avalanches of sliding soil and rocks.
- 11:02They reach the final precipice.
- 11:05This is the last chance to turn back.
- 11:08Yet over they go.
- 11:15>> [music]
- 11:19>> But now they begin to swim, not toward
- 11:21land, strangely, but away from shore,
- 11:23toward the far horizon. And soon the
- 11:25Arctic Sea is dotted with fanny bobbing
- 11:27bodies.
- 11:31[clears throat]
- 11:38So um uh do lemmings commit uh suicide?
- 11:43Norway rats? Uh absolutely not. Okay. Uh
- 11:47first of all um the film was made in
- 11:51Canada. Okay. And the way it was done is
- 11:54u [laughter] they took a whole bunch of
- 11:56lemmings and they kind of pushed them
- 11:58over the cliff. Okay. That's one issue.
- 12:01The other issue is that uh the lemmings
- 12:05actually, you know, sometimes when the
- 12:06population expands so much, they want to
- 12:09go out there and form a new colony. And
- 12:12so they find a lake, they find a river,
- 12:14and they cross the river of the lake,
- 12:16try to get to the other side to form
- 12:18their colony, and some rats dies, you
- 12:21know, and so people have concluded from
- 12:23this that they're committing suicide
- 12:25when they're really trying to reach the
- 12:26other shore. Okay, so no, animals do not
- 12:29commit suicide. The only animals that
- 12:32commit suicide ever. The only living
- 12:35entity commits suicide are humans.
- 12:40Apparently, I [clears throat] got cut
- 12:41off again. Uh, this is a problem with
- 12:44the internet system here where I'm at in
- 12:47Germany, and I've had problems all week.
- 12:50Uh, every day it gets cut off several
- 12:53minutes, really, 5 10 minutes. And
- 12:57yesterday it happened four times. Today
- 13:00it happened twice. This was the second
- 13:01time. So, all I can do is uh postpone
- 13:04the rest of the class until tomorrow and
- 13:06hope that I'll have some internet. We'll
- 13:09see you then. Bye-bye. [snorts]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Should we allow assisted suicide? by Rational Science, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,787 words across 264 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.