Shinto — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00hello and welcome again now i want to bring to your attention
- 0:07the indigenous religion of japan which is called shinto. it turns out
- 0:14that it's not the easiest thing to describe what shinto actually is
- 0:20scholars sometimes argue about it and occasionally claim that it's hard to
- 0:26talk about since shinto is so localized
- 0:31and what i mean by that is since it's the most ancient religion of japan
- 0:37and since japan has isolated small villages in the mountains
- 0:43the practices of shinto did not develop in a unified way among
- 0:50everybody but this very localized aspect of shinto is what can
- 0:57also make it special and when later in history
- 1:03some japanese governments with maybe not the best intentions wanted to revive
- 1:09national pride and zealotry by using shinto as something for the
- 1:16entire japanese nation it had effects that maybe weren't so
- 1:20good and we will talk about that so let's get into it and when it comes
- 1:25to shinto it can be very helpful to start with the
- 1:29name because that can tell you something
- 1:32rather interesting it literally means way of the gods
- 1:38and in japanese you can pronounce that shintō
- 1:42more commonly however the pronunciation is kami no michi
- 1:47and we're going to talk about what this word kami means in a second
- 1:51but i want to draw your attention to the fact that
- 1:54many japanese pronunciations and words again are derived from chinese
- 2:01understandings or chinese imaginings a chinese
- 2:06imagination like the very word for japan that we
- 2:10talked about last time so in chinese if you look at these two
- 2:15characters that you see here on the screen the first one is
- 2:19shén which is something of a word for god now this means kami and kami is
- 2:25going to sort of mean god but we'll talk about that in a second
- 2:29there aren't a whole lot of words in chinese that mean
- 2:33god shén might be one of them but look at the second word the second
- 2:39word right here you may recognize both from the character and from the
- 2:42pronunciation dào and we know this word
- 2:47from daoism it means the way it means the ultimate we talked all about what
- 2:52daoism means in the context of this word
- 2:56but we can look at it in a very limited way here
- 3:01as simply being the way the path forward the way that the gods take but
- 3:07scholars have noticed that there are lots of connections between daoism
- 3:12and shinto so you can see some connections
- 3:16you can also see several connections between daoism and
- 3:20the religion that comes later which is buddhism
- 3:25and in japanese history something amazing happens
- 3:28as history progresses all of the religions
- 3:32coexist in an intermingled way you have buddhists who use shinto you
- 3:39have daoists who use buddhism you really do
- 3:44have a harmony model style of religions as
- 3:47japanese history develops it's not always harmonious
- 3:51but a lot of the time it is all right let's get to this word
- 3:55kami which i think is useful to know kami is a kind of
- 4:02god but it's more like a spirit and that spirit is pantheistic if you
- 4:11see this word right here and what pantheism
- 4:14tends to mean in this context is that the god
- 4:18is present everywhere in different materials but sometimes
- 4:26the god is associated with one animal with one material in nature like a
- 4:32particular tree or the sky or the moon or the sun
- 4:37or different elements of nature is the place that the kami is inhabiting
- 4:45and you are going to have a different kami
- 4:48protecting your family group or clan in this case
- 4:52depending upon where you live in these isolated villages
- 4:56of japan all developing alongside each other
- 5:01throughout japanese history and remember we don't have written records
- 5:05for a lot of these earlier periods so we rely on
- 5:09folk narrative and tellings that come from visitors and things like this
- 5:16so it's a little bit related to something you might call
- 5:20a totem if you know this word and that is a
- 5:24spirit that might be inhabiting something that is there for your
- 5:28protection that you honor in a certain way
- 5:31but we don't want to be too precise about it because
- 5:38as i mentioned earlier each kami in every
- 5:41village is going to be different in a certain way
- 5:45so it's probably a good idea not to translate the word at all
- 5:49and simply call it kami all the time k-a-m-i
- 5:54but this word even though it's very much associated with japan
- 5:58even gets abused within japanese culture itself you have seen this word before i
- 6:05would imagine because many of you probably are aware
- 6:09of a word kamikaze have you seen this word before right
- 6:16and this probably doesn't make you think of mountain villages
- 6:21with protector spirits and things like that
- 6:24what it probably makes you think of are airplanes during the second world
- 6:30war that deliberately crashed into american
- 6:36ships causing big explosions near the end of
- 6:40the war a suicide pilot essentially
- 6:44what does that have to do with shinto well the actual
- 6:52translation of kamikaze is usually divine wind so kami in this case is
- 6:58translated as divine and again it's hard to translate the word you
- 7:03really shouldn't translate it but it's that and then kazi is wind so it's this
- 7:09very fancy way of describing a suicide bomber
- 7:13which is pretty horrifying right but why well during the second world war
- 7:22the imperialist powers that ran japan they wanted to stoke
- 7:30japanese nationalism that is to say they wanted the japanese
- 7:36to be very very ardently proud of the fact that they are japanese
- 7:42to a very one might say extreme extent to the extent that
- 7:50there was a belief that somehow japanese might be better than other people
- 7:53and very similar to what hitler did in germany with the so-called
- 7:59aryan you know germans are the master race and all of this other
- 8:04nonsense so you can see that happening also in
- 8:09the japanese allies of the germans during the second world war
- 8:13but the way they did it in japan was to create something that
- 8:18we refer to as state shinto which is really bizarre
- 8:23it's a contradiction in terms shinto is the whole point of shinto is that
- 8:28it's local and that it's in one little town and it has one little kami and
- 8:34to think of it as a unified thing to make everybody proud to be japanese so
- 8:39you'll go and conquer the world or get into an airplane load it with
- 8:45fuel and bombs and then deliberately crash it
- 8:48into an american battleship
- 8:52that doesn't seem to resonate very well with the real religion
- 8:57so the imperial powers that ran japan the fascists,
- 9:02imperialists during the second world war
- 9:05they abused the ancient religion the ancient indigenous religion of japan
- 9:10and it's referred to as state shinto in our day and age religions can
- 9:16definitely be abused by people right so again i will go into this in
- 9:21more detail later but we have to be careful of
- 9:23stereotypes so you probably have read in the news
- 9:28where certain extremist groups within islam
- 9:32you know would be suicide bombers and claiming to do that in the name of
- 9:36religion whereas overwhelmingly 99.999 percent of
- 9:41muslims say that's absolutely wrong and this has
- 9:45nothing whatsoever to do with islam but sometimes it happens right in these
- 9:52very tiny extremist groups the sad part about
- 9:55state shinto was that the entire country was kind of
- 10:00whipped up in this hysteria we're going to be reading a manga
- 10:04which is a comic book later in the unit about this
- 10:11sort of collective effect that the japanese experienced
- 10:18during the second world war but it wasn't always
- 10:22appreciated so we're going to see some resistance to this
- 10:25in a manga about the atomic bombing of hiroshima and the second world war
- 10:29so do stay tuned with that all right but back to the real religion of shinto
- 10:34back to the real things that are going on there is another concept
- 10:39that is is essential to understand for understanding shinto
- 10:43and that is the concept of purity which is an intriguing one
- 10:48generally speaking i find purity to be never what it seems nothing is ever
- 10:53"pure" and if you're searching for purity you're searching
- 10:56for the impossible and you know it can it can
- 10:59it can have some problems but nonetheless
- 11:04the religion of shinto believes that the kami should have
- 11:14the most pure elements of nature as its home now remember
- 11:21within the shinto religion each kami inhabits some element of nature
- 11:28again that could be a tree that could be an animal that could be
- 11:32a rock formation it could be any number of
- 11:35things and it's not so much the formation itself it's
- 11:42the site it's the actual place so if humans are going to honor the kami
- 11:50properly they have to maintain the purity
- 11:54so what does that mean in practice how do you maintain the purity
- 11:59of the religion of the kami of everything
- 12:03if you're using human architecture for example to make a temple
- 12:08well here is a good example in the city of ise japan which is
- 12:14a large city
- 12:18there is a shrine that is the most revered shinto shrine in japan
- 12:25it's called the ise shrine and it's a shrine for a kami
- 12:29named amaterasu and amaterasu is the goddess of the sun
- 12:34that's her place and we know how important the sun is
- 12:39given that the name of japan means origin of the sun
- 12:43and this is also even more important because this is the kami
- 12:47of the japanese imperial family so that's going to be important so many
- 12:53of the objects and many of the practices that go on in this site
- 12:56relate to the japanese imperial family for example there's an
- 13:00object there called the sacred mirror which evidently contained a kind of
- 13:04wisdom if you looked into it going back thousands of years there's a
- 13:09lot of mystery about this because ordinary people the general
- 13:14public is not allowed really onto the site
- 13:18it's still pretty tightly contained within the imperial family remember
- 13:24shinto is local right it's very much this is
- 13:27our thing right and you have the same going on
- 13:32in issei there are all kinds of legends actually that go along with the sun
- 13:37goddess you can read about them they're super interesting
- 13:40if you take a world religions course but i'm interested in the building
- 13:45right since this is a humanities class let's look at architecture
- 13:48all right first thing is that as always agriculture farming things like that
- 13:56should have a prominent role and they do the building is based on granaries right
- 14:01where you would store whatever you're growing
- 14:04whether it's rice or wheat or sorghum or whatever it happens to be
- 14:08and natural materials can only be used and that is
- 14:12wood so here is the building that you can see here this is the
- 14:16one of the there are there are actually several
- 14:19parts to the temple eddie say in the area but this is the main one
- 14:24and only wood is used now there's a little bit of
- 14:27corrugated iron here but generally speaking
- 14:31the entire structure is only made out of wood
- 14:35the type of wood tends to be from the cypress trees
- 14:38that are in the area now that's cypress the tree, not cyprus the country
- 14:42of course but honestly isn't it beautiful i mean i absolutely love
- 14:47this temple the
- 14:52tree trunks that you see on the top of the roof look
- 14:58golden in the sunlight that effect is marvelous there is an enormous
- 15:05trunk of a cypress tree that's been whittled you know carved and made smooth
- 15:12sanded that's the word i'm thinking of it it's been sanded down
- 15:16that forms one of the main pillars that you can see here
- 15:21but this is the important pure area to honor the sun goddess
- 15:28amaterasu but there's a part that you might have
- 15:32seen in the notes that i haven't mentioned yet and this is a crucial part
- 15:36the temple that you're looking at here let me go to the
- 15:40caption
- 15:43this one is the temple as it looked in 1993
- 15:49right after it had been rebuilt but that was not an unusual event that
- 15:55the temple was rebuilt in 1993 because it's supposed to be rebuilt
- 16:00every 20 years in the same architectural style as it
- 16:06always had been so if it was built in 19 rebuilt
- 16:11in 1993 then the most recent iteration of this temple
- 16:18is from 2013. right so every 20 years again this is
- 16:22the 1993 version but you know we have that why why would that
- 16:27be the case are you looking at the authentic
- 16:31temple as it exists i just... let your mind think about
- 16:36that here's the here's the plan the there's a lot of
- 16:41wonderful design here i should i should point out that remember they
- 16:46keep rebuilding it exactly like what you're
- 16:48looking at here in this temple plan this architectural model
- 16:54there are no nails right you don't use nails
- 16:57everything is inserted you know using just weight
- 17:04and making holes and putting the wood where it belongs
- 17:10and it holds up structurally very very well
- 17:15if you look at the google maps which again i like to do let's
- 17:19look at that for a second here is the city of ise again a very large city now
- 17:25unlike the tomb of nintoku that we looked at last time
- 17:30the ise grand shrine is a little bit out into nature but not too far away
- 17:34and as we zoom in on the site you'll begin to see how it works and you
- 17:41can kind of follow it now that we have satellite imagery all right so here's
- 17:47the compound now let me use the satellite
- 17:50and look at this for a second so here we go
- 17:55now this imagery you know it's pretty recent really actually there we
- 18:00are all right that's a good one right there;
- 18:02ok so look at these site do you see the temple that
- 18:07i have the photograph of in the notes those are those beautiful
- 18:11golden logs that are on the top of the temple and you can see some of the
- 18:15adjacent buildings but look at what's next to it to the
- 18:19right you'll notice it's just an empty
- 18:21rectangle and the reason for that is that in 1993
- 18:28that's where the temple used to be so they very
- 18:33ritualistically disassembled deconstructed that temple
- 18:39and brought in new wood that was specially made
- 18:42and they reconstructed the temple here now so if that was 2013 the next
- 18:49rebuilding of the temple is going to be in 2033
- 18:53so get your tickets now maybe we'll be able to travel then
- 18:57maybe maybe there'll be no more pandemic or who knows
- 19:01right hopefully by 2033 and there we'll have the ritual take place
- 19:08and the same thing will happen new wood will be brought in
- 19:12and the new temple will be built it doesn't happen in one day it happens
- 19:15over the course of a long time right so it's very slow and
- 19:19evidently very very beautiful to to participate in but remember it's
- 19:25not really a public event it's for the japanese imperial family and it's
- 19:30for a tradition that's been going on for a long time
- 19:33all right so here's my question if by some wonderful chance you were able
- 19:39to witness the the temple you were able to go there
- 19:43and visit it and look at it and you were told that this is the
- 19:48temple of the sun goddess amaterasu the oldest temple in japan
- 19:54but it was only made a few years ago how would you feel would you feel that
- 20:00you were looking at the authentic temple right would you believe that would that
- 20:06be something you that that in fact you believed
- 20:09so whoops i meant to do
- 20:13never mind there it is would you believe that this was the
- 20:19temple that was the oldest in japan to what
- 20:24degree do the materials matter remember we talked about this a little
- 20:27bit with the great wall of china because in china again same issue
- 20:32but this is even more
- 20:36part of the whole process you're supposed to do this
- 20:40right it's something that's necessary is this
- 20:44authentic or not if you believe that it's the place
- 20:48and the spirit of the place then the actual temple
- 20:52doesn't matter as much as the site the geographical site
- 20:58do you think that this is true for all historical buildings i mean if you go
- 21:01and visit an historical building i mean i grew up
- 21:04in new jersey right across the river from philadelphia and we used to go to
- 21:08independence hall where they signed the declaration of
- 21:10independence and it's the real place right it wasn't reconstructed
- 21:14every 20 years and you know there's a nice
- 21:17feeling that you get wow i'm in the same room where all of this happened and so
- 21:21on and you don't quite get that feeling in
- 21:24a reconstructed building but wow does it look beautiful
- 21:28and it's the same thing right remember the architecture has not changed
- 21:32so keep that in your mind decide whether or not you think this is
- 21:38authentic or it's not authentic all right one last story to finish this
- 21:42out this reminds me of a story that we know
- 21:46from greek philosophy and mythology
- 21:50and that story is called the myth of theseus; oops these
- 21:57i can't spell theseus right it's called the myth of theseus
- 22:02that's the name of this story and i'll briefly tell you the story it doesn't
- 22:06take very long theseus was a great hero you might
- 22:09know him from other stories but this is a different one
- 22:12theseus in this story likes to travel by ship and when he's a young man he gets a
- 22:18ship the ship of theseus right which i should have called it the
- 22:22ship of theseus why did i call it the myth
- 22:24it is a myth the proper name is in fact the ship of theseus excuse me
- 22:31when he was young he got this ship it was made out of wood
- 22:35so that turns out to be an important thing that the ship was made out of wood
- 22:41so they travel they trade they you know live their lives what happens to a
- 22:47wooden ship over the course of time some of the planks get rotten what do
- 22:52you do with a rotten plank on a ship you pick it up and you throw it
- 22:56overboard and then when you come into the next port
- 22:59you get a new plank made out of new wood and you replace it right the ship
- 23:06doesn't fall apart all at once it falls apart gradually so over the course of
- 23:11time theseus has gradually
- 23:16replaced every single plank in the ship as he gets older
- 23:20unbeknownst to theseus there is someone else in another ship who has been
- 23:25following him his entire life he has a stalker
- 23:30and what has the stalker been doing the stalker has been
- 23:34picking up the discarded rotten planks that theseus has been
- 23:40throwing overboard and what does the stalker do with the
- 23:44planks i'm sure you know the stalker reconstructs the ship and
- 23:50over time has all the rotten planks in a ship so here's the question the
- 23:55philosophers ask which one is the ship of theseus is this
- 24:00the one that theseus currently has or is it the one that the stalker has
- 24:04constructed which one is it and this leads to some
- 24:08lively philosophical debate which one is the
- 24:12ship of theseus which one is authentic what does it even matter right like how
- 24:18why would this matter in the first place right it's a lovely philosophical
- 24:22question so i invite you to think about what you
- 24:26believe about this and i'm sure you can apply this to other situations
- 24:30and i may ask you to do that at some point as you think about that
- 24:34so thank you thank you so much for your attention
- 24:37about shinto and next time we move on to a really big change and that's the
- 24:42change that comes with the religion of buddhism
- 24:45really looking forward to that so stay tuned and i will see you then
- 24:48take care bye
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Shinto by Alain Dupre, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,445 words across 311 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.