Shifter: Film is Holding You Back — Transcript
Full transcript
- 1:51Man, do I
- 1:54suck so bad at this. By the way, I'm
- 1:57getting ready to ride that into town
- 2:00here in a minute. It's about a 20 mile
- 2:02rounder, 25 if I run some errands. So,
- 2:06just to give you a little
- 2:08just to give you a little background
- 2:10here because it's important. I did a 3 I
- 2:13did this film. I did a 33minute film and
- 2:17it was one of the best films I've ever
- 2:18done. One of the best recordings I think
- 2:20in terms of content, but for whatever
- 2:25reason, I was constantly dropping Fbombs
- 2:27and S bombs and GD bombs, which I
- 2:29normally don't do, but it just felt
- 2:31right. I was so in the in the groove in
- 2:33the in the mode. I was just laying down
- 2:37some fact for you slacker jackals out
- 2:40there. [snorts]
- 2:42But then I remembered that some of you
- 2:44told me that you watch these films with
- 2:45your kids and I was like that's not
- 2:48good. So I decided to redo it. So I did
- 2:52a 46inute film and talking about five or
- 2:56six different points all of which I
- 2:58think are valid. Some came from people
- 2:59writing me and asking me to uh to talk
- 3:01about this.
- 3:03And then I uploaded it. By the way, I
- 3:05uploaded both of these, wrote it, did
- 3:08everything. Keyworded, ready to go. Did
- 3:10a blog post that was ready to go about
- 3:11it. And um just woke up and was like,
- 3:15"No, I'm not going to post any of
- 3:16these." But one of the posts, one of the
- 3:20points that I spoke about in both of
- 3:21those films, I thought was interesting
- 3:23and important. But I've got to set the
- 3:25table here first
- 3:27because I think this film could easily
- 3:29be turned into a negative thing and it's
- 3:31actually a positive thing even though
- 3:32the title is film is holding you back.
- 3:35Um, and that is the gist of this film
- 3:36and I made four pages of notes
- 3:41about why film is holding you back and
- 3:43why this is important. But you have to
- 3:45know a couple of things first. Number
- 3:47one, I am at the center of a whirlwind
- 3:51of correspondence. And this is something
- 3:53I bring on myself because I ask people
- 3:55to write me, to show me things, to tell
- 3:57me things globally. So, it is
- 4:01overwhelming. Every single day, people
- 4:03are writing asking questions. They're
- 4:05asking for advice. They're asking for
- 4:07help. They're asking me to look at work
- 4:08every single day from all over the
- 4:10world. Deluge.
- 4:12Combine that with all the people that
- 4:14reach out with their blurb questions and
- 4:15and you get a blizzard of
- 4:17correspondence. That's the the negative
- 4:19side is the volume.
- 4:21The positive side is that it allows me
- 4:24to see patterns. It allows me to see
- 4:26where people are faltering, where they
- 4:30need education, where they're failing,
- 4:32where they're being misled. All of that
- 4:35is crystal clear to me because of the
- 4:38volume of correspondence and the range
- 4:40of where it's coming from is staggering.
- 4:44Like when my wife sees my inbox, she's
- 4:46like, "Why do you do this? Why do you do
- 4:48this?" It's interesting to me. The other
- 4:51thing I want you to know is that I was
- 4:53you, right? If you're, and I'm going to
- 4:55use terminology like film bros and
- 4:58YouTube film culture and all that stuff.
- 5:01Ultimately, and I'll get to this point,
- 5:03the positive outweighs the negative. It
- 5:05does. And that's the most important
- 5:06thing. The positive outweighs the
- 5:08negative. But there is some strategic
- 5:10negative things that are happening that
- 5:12are holding back tons and tons and tons
- 5:14of people. again because I see it and I
- 5:17hear it every single day. That's the
- 5:20gist of what this film is about. But I
- 5:22was you.
- 5:24I went I went digital as a professional
- 5:27photographer in 1997.
- 5:30Okay. Where were you in 97 in your
- 5:33photography career? I think most of the
- 5:37online film folks weren't even born yet,
- 5:39but most of you, you know, weren't in
- 5:40photography. I I processed my first roll
- 5:43of film in the dark room in 1988
- 5:46and I went from zero to newspaper
- 5:49assignments the day that somebody handed
- 5:52me a camera. That's not common. Most
- 5:54people start in photography and they
- 5:56kind of it's a hobby and they get into
- 5:57it. I basically photographed one time
- 6:02and I happened to photograph a very
- 6:04newsworthy event because I happened to
- 6:06be standing right there. A journalism
- 6:09instructor saw those photos accidentally
- 6:11as I was showing my friends at lunch one
- 6:13day at a community college and he looked
- 6:16on the table and said, "Who photographed
- 6:17those?" And I thought I was in trouble.
- 6:19So I said, "Not me." And then I saw the
- 6:21looks on my friends faces and I thought,
- 6:22"I don't want them to they look like
- 6:24they they're going to get in trouble. I
- 6:25thought maybe I'd done something wrong."
- 6:27And I didn't want my buddies to to go
- 6:29down for it. So I eventually said,
- 6:31"Okay, yeah, these are mine." That guy
- 6:33turned out to be Jerry Townsen, who was
- 6:34the director of the photojournalism
- 6:36department at San Antonio College. and
- 6:37Jerry said, "I'll give you a scholarship
- 6:39to be a photographer." That's how I this
- 6:41started for me. The next day, I went
- 6:43into that newsroom and Rudalfo Gonzalez
- 6:46handed me a Screw Mount Nyore and an
- 6:48assignment and said, "Basically, don't
- 6:49screw it up." Right? There was pressure
- 6:51from day one. That's typically not how
- 6:53people get into this, but that's how I
- 6:55got into it. I started processing film
- 6:57in the dark room in 1988.
- 6:59[snorts] By the 97, I went I left my job
- 7:02at Eastman Kodak and I started working
- 7:04as a professional photographer again.
- 7:06and uh working at four years for a Kodak
- 7:09professional and basically I'm giving
- 7:10you a little background here that I'm
- 7:12not a film hater. actually love film,
- 7:14but this is my history with film.
- 7:1797 I I go back to being a photographer
- 7:20and I'm fully digital. And there was a
- 7:22novelty to it. People clients were like,
- 7:25"Wow, he's fully digital." And at the
- 7:27time, think about it. It was completely
- 7:28novel. Clients were like, "What do you
- 7:31mean there's no film? What do you mean I
- 7:32can see images immediately? What do you
- 7:34mean we're not limited by how much film
- 7:36and processing we have budget for?" That
- 7:38kind of thing.
- 7:40And by the way, by the way, this this
- 7:42blows people away. Uh, and it shouldn't
- 7:44because it's called professional
- 7:45photography, but all of the film and
- 7:47processing that I did for all those
- 7:48clients for all those years was all paid
- 7:50for by the client times three.
- 7:53Everything was paid for by the client,
- 7:55and there was always a huge markup on
- 7:57film and processing. That's a whole
- 7:58separate story. Most people now are
- 8:01like, "Oh, that's no way. It's
- 8:02impossible." That's how, of course,
- 8:03that's how it worked. You don't eat that
- 8:05cost. As a photographer, everything is
- 8:07passed to the client.
- 8:09So
- 8:1197, I have a couple of years of
- 8:13honeymoon with digital. Everybody is
- 8:15telling me I shouldn't be digital
- 8:17because digital's a fad. Digital's too
- 8:19sharp. Digital, you're going to go out
- 8:20of business. You're going to go out of
- 8:21business. These are lab owners in LA
- 8:23telling me I'm going to go out of
- 8:24business if I shoot digital. Three years
- 8:27later, I'm like, "Yeah, that sucks. I
- 8:29don't want to do digital anymore right
- 8:30now." You remember, there was a reason
- 8:32for that. Everything was slow.
- 8:35Everything was slow. It was awkward. And
- 8:38so your time on the computer was
- 8:40exponentially beyond what it was on with
- 8:44film. And what I realized was film was a
- 8:46film was a lifestyle and digital was a
- 8:48lifestyle. And some people loved the
- 8:51digital lifestyle. There was plenty of
- 8:53really really good photographers way
- 8:55better than anybody who's who's online
- 8:57right now who basically the second that
- 9:00digital got to a point where it was
- 9:01feasible, they were like, "Thank God I'm
- 9:03so done with film. I don't ever want to
- 9:04go in the dark room again. I don't want
- 9:06to print again. I don't want to process
- 9:07film. I'm done with it. And they took it
- 9:09took off and ran with it. Those people
- 9:10are still mostly really successful
- 9:12today. But I was like, I kind of miss
- 9:15film. So I decided to go back to film.
- 9:18And the same people who told me I'd go
- 9:20out of business for going digital were
- 9:21now the exact same people that were
- 9:23telling me I would go out of business if
- 9:24I went back to film. Because by this
- 9:26time, everybody was going back was going
- 9:28digital. So I went to film. My point is,
- 9:32I love film. Let me show you a
- 9:34photograph right here. I just boxed this
- 9:37up for a friend because he did me a
- 9:39solid and he knows how and when to use
- 9:44film. He's he's not a film bro. He's not
- 9:48filling people's heads with nonsense
- 9:50about film. He just knows. He uses
- 9:51everything. He shoots digital, shoots
- 9:52film, whatever. I love sending film. I
- 9:55have tons and tons of film still. I
- 9:57rarely shoot it myself these days at all
- 9:59because it doesn't fit logistically on
- 10:01how I work. But I love sending film to
- 10:04people who who get it, who know how to
- 10:06use it. And if you look at this
- 10:07photograph, you know, there's Tri,
- 10:08there's the basics. These there's meat
- 10:10and potatoes, Trix, TMZ, Portra, and
- 10:12then there's some fringy stuff, you
- 10:14know, there's the AGA AGA stuff. There's
- 10:16a couple of other brands and films I
- 10:18can't even remember. Doesn't matter.
- 10:19Sending it off. Love it. Got plenty of
- 10:21other film. Love sending it to people.
- 10:23Don't ask, Jackals. Don't even think
- 10:26about I know how your brain works.
- 10:28you're out there and he's like, "Well,
- 10:30if he sent film to that guy, then maybe
- 10:33there's a chance." So, you're saying
- 10:35there's a chance? Yeah. No. Zero. No
- 10:38chance. [snorts]
- 10:40Um,
- 10:42this film is a long time coming and it
- 10:45got to the point where I had just seen
- 10:47and heard so much that I was like, I
- 10:50have to say something because a lot of
- 10:53people are being held back. So, I
- 10:55literally made 1
- 10:582 3
- 11:00four pages of notes for this film. This
- 11:02is going to be ugly. It's going to be
- 11:05ugly. It is, but I think it's pretty
- 11:07well well thought out.
- 11:11Again, 1988.
- 11:13I am processing. I am I'm shooting. I'm
- 11:17edit processing. Editing and printing on
- 11:20deadline. Okay. Most of you will never
- 11:23know what a deadline is. You will never
- 11:25shoot under that kind of pressure. And
- 11:28let me just explain something to you.
- 11:29Whether you're shooting for a college
- 11:31newspaper, which I did, the San Antonio
- 11:33College, the Ranger, it was it was
- 11:35arguably the single best
- 11:36photojournalistic community college
- 11:39paper in the country. I had no idea when
- 11:40I started. It turns out that was the
- 11:42case. They won awards all the time. I
- 11:45went from there to the Daily Texan at UT
- 11:47Austin, which was also considered one of
- 11:49the best student newspapers in the
- 11:50country and often competed with the
- 11:52Austin American Statesman, which was the
- 11:54paper at the time. There were a lot of
- 11:56people I encountered in the field that
- 11:57said to me, I read the Texan over the
- 12:00over the Austin paper because you guys
- 12:02are better. You know, your work is
- 12:03better, the stories are better, the
- 12:04photos are better, whatever. [gasps]
- 12:06Yeah, I won photographer the semester.
- 12:10No one cares. That is a specific kind of
- 12:14pressure.
- 12:15Again, 99% of you will never know it.
- 12:18Most of the people working on YouTube or
- 12:20working online, they will never know it
- 12:21because they're not doing assignments.
- 12:24There is no not coming back with
- 12:27something that's good, that's usable.
- 12:29There's no excuses. There's no, "Oh, it
- 12:32wasn't happening. Oh, I didn't have a
- 12:33good shoot."
- 12:35No one. There were no excuses. That kind
- 12:38of pressure
- 12:40can do a variety of things. Some people
- 12:44quit immediately. They get into that
- 12:46environment and they cannot hack it.
- 12:48They quit. A lot of people drop out of
- 12:50art school and photography school and
- 12:51they'll tell you all kinds of
- 12:53reasons about why not to go to school
- 12:56because they dropped out. 99% of those
- 12:59people are full of it. They dropped out
- 13:02because they couldn't hack it. They
- 13:05couldn't get the little pats on the
- 13:06back. They're used to Instagram. They
- 13:08can't get the pats on the back because
- 13:09the faculty actually knows what's good
- 13:12and what's not good. And when you're
- 13:14faced with putting your work up in front
- 13:16of people who know what's good and they
- 13:18tell you what you're doing is not good,
- 13:20most people can't hack that. So, some
- 13:21people get into the newspaper that kind
- 13:23of high stress environment and they quit
- 13:24immediately. A lot of the folks I went
- 13:26to school with never even got into the
- 13:28door anywhere. Other people
- 13:32take that pressure and it transforms
- 13:36them into photographic superheroes. They
- 13:40they do things on a daily basis that you
- 13:44look at and go, "Oh my god, like that
- 13:46person can do this again and again. It
- 13:48is fuel. It is calories to them and they
- 13:51perform." I was somewhere in the middle.
- 13:54There were times where the pressure
- 13:56forced me into making really good work
- 14:00because I I was so fearful of not making
- 14:02good work. And there were other times
- 14:04where I just thought, "This is not fun
- 14:05anymore. This pressure is too much. It's
- 14:07too overwhelming." You know, you're
- 14:09driving down the road and you're just
- 14:11punching the roof of your car and your
- 14:13911 pager is going off over and over and
- 14:16over again and someone is screaming at
- 14:18you, "If you don't get this, if you
- 14:20don't get it, your job is over. Your
- 14:22internship is over. don't come back to
- 14:24the paper. Your job is over. Don't come
- 14:26back. That sucks after a while, right?
- 14:29You're just like, "All right, I I did it
- 14:31for whatever and I didn't want to do it
- 14:34anymore." Plus, the industry was
- 14:35changing. But I digress.
- 14:39Um, talked about 1988, talked about
- 14:42sending my buddy the box of film.
- 14:45Um, I was promoting film
- 14:49from when I went back to film from
- 14:52digital in the early 2000s.
- 14:55The motto of the entire industry,
- 14:58professional side, the entire industry,
- 15:01the model was film is dead. Film is
- 15:05dead. Anybody who was around at that
- 15:06time, you know exactly what I'm talking
- 15:08about. Film is dead. Film is dead. Film
- 15:10is dead. And I was saying, "No, it's
- 15:12not. No, it's not. No, it's not."
- 15:14Progressively over the next few years,
- 15:16people learned how valuable film was.
- 15:19There was a lab in LA called Icon. Icon
- 15:22had done a study that if you shot 40
- 15:25rolls of 220 or 220 or more, 40 rolls a
- 15:30day or more, digital had the potential
- 15:33to save you money. If you shot 40 rolls
- 15:37or less, film was less expensive. It was
- 15:40quicker to edit. Clients loved it. So
- 15:43you saw this weird progression where the
- 15:46entire industry went all in on digital
- 15:48and kind of burned themselves and burned
- 15:50the entire industry and burned a lot of
- 15:53bridges and then some of the industry
- 15:56trickled back towards film. Celebrity
- 15:59portraiture catalog that kind of stuff.
- 16:00It was bizarre and I was in LA watching
- 16:03this happen.
- 16:05Film was not dead. Still not dead
- 16:07thankfully. So let me move on here a
- 16:09little bit because here's what we're
- 16:10going to do. I'm going to give you some
- 16:11background here.
- 16:13And then I'm going to say why film is
- 16:14holding you back. Then I'm going to give
- 16:17you the reasons why I think it's holding
- 16:18you back. And then I'm going to give you
- 16:19reasons on how to overcome film holding
- 16:22you back. Because again, the gist of
- 16:24this, it's barely positive, right?
- 16:28There's a lot. And I'm going to get to
- 16:29this right now. And I need to use a term
- 16:31here that's going to be considered to be
- 16:33detrimental. And it it is a little bit
- 16:36because I see so much nonsense and so
- 16:38much bad information bad information,
- 16:41misinformation, and I see the damage
- 16:43that that does to consumer and proumer
- 16:46photographers who tell me they're trying
- 16:48to get better, right? And and I'm going
- 16:50to use the term film bros, right? Film
- 16:53bros are like online YouTube film
- 16:56channels, film photography people. Um,
- 16:58and it's not just YouTube. It's, you
- 17:00know, I'm sure Instagram probably has a
- 17:02thousand different, you know, silly film
- 17:04groups and Flickr and everything else,
- 17:06like the whole film contingent.
- 17:08Remember, I said I like film. I still
- 17:12have, what do I have? I have uh my
- 17:15Leica, my Hasselblad, two film Nikons,
- 17:18two Voitlander film cameras. I've got a
- 17:20handmade 4x5 pinhole. I've got a lot of
- 17:22film cameras and a lot of film. So
- 17:24again, you don't think that I'm hating
- 17:26on film, [gasps] but the film bros, it's
- 17:30very, very close, but I'm still going to
- 17:32say that the overall film bro culture,
- 17:35which I find absurd because I actually
- 17:37know what I'm doing, it's still just
- 17:40there's a slight more positivity than
- 17:44negativity. So, let me just rephrase
- 17:46that so you guys calm down and don't wet
- 17:49the bed. Film Bro Culture, YouTube film
- 17:52channels, the hipster film people, their
- 17:56contribution, I would say, is 55%
- 18:00positive and 50% negative. And I will
- 18:04explain that they're doing more good
- 18:06than harm, but it's damn close. Most of
- 18:10the bro culture, the film bro culture
- 18:12online is as much about culture and
- 18:16fashion and style and a throwback
- 18:19appreciation of another time which is
- 18:2260s7s 80s 90s when film was dominant in
- 18:25the professional photography industry.
- 18:27But most of these people seem to be as
- 18:30much about thetick the persona as they
- 18:34do about anything else. They are, in
- 18:37other words, 90% about the process and
- 18:4110% about the product. And for anyone
- 18:45who's either been to photo school or art
- 18:47school or has been in the industry and
- 18:48worked as a professional, you can see
- 18:51through that so easily, but a lot of
- 18:54people can't. And a lot of people never
- 18:56had the ability to go to photography
- 18:58school. They never will. They were, you
- 19:00know, I feel like I was a 1enter to be
- 19:02able to go to photo school. Although the
- 19:04first year was paid for, which was
- 19:06nothing. I think my scholarship was $50.
- 19:09And then when I went to photo school, I
- 19:10paid $300 a quarter. So people think,
- 19:13"Oh, you're just like some elitist. You
- 19:15got to go to photo school." I was paid
- 19:16300 bucks a quarter. You can't get a
- 19:19coffee for 300 bucks a quarter now. So
- 19:21I' I was lucky. What I was lucky in was
- 19:23my time frame because now these same
- 19:26universities are it's insane. It's like
- 19:2850 grand a year to go to this the same
- 19:30university. So, it's nuts.
- 19:32The best thing about the online bro film
- 19:36bro culture film people is that they get
- 19:39people excited about photography. That
- 19:41is the ultimate takeaway of this whole
- 19:43film. Again, it's more positive than
- 19:46negative. Excited about photography,
- 19:48right? That's great. More people out
- 19:50making more pictures. I love it. I think
- 19:52it's a great thing.
- 19:54But here's where things go off the
- 19:56rails. And again, I've got to reference
- 19:57my notes because I took four GD pages of
- 20:01notes, people. I did this all in just
- 20:02one take this morning when I thought I
- 20:04was going to be outside reading and then
- 20:06I got this bug in my you know what and I
- 20:08was like, I got to do this. The problem
- 20:10with the online bro culture with film is
- 20:12that they have convinced you that film
- 20:15is better than digital. And they've
- 20:17convinced you with just the biggest
- 20:19bunch of nonsense I've ever heard in my
- 20:22life. It is pure propaganda. It is not
- 20:26true. It's the
- 20:29It's the film is more real. Real
- 20:32photographers shoot film. Real work is
- 20:35done with film and digital is for the
- 20:36commercial stuff. That is not true. It
- 20:40is BS. And here's the reason why it
- 20:43works. The bro cultures online,
- 20:48photo, film, bro culture, they know one
- 20:51very important thing.
- 20:54They know that you are lost and you are
- 20:57gullible and you are more concerned
- 21:00about the process than the product. That
- 21:03just does not fly. I someone sent me
- 21:06this ridiculous clip of some
- 21:08photographer saying that real
- 21:09photography is on film. Utter nonsense.
- 21:13Utter nonsense. And I'll get to more of
- 21:15this later. You guys don't even know. A
- 21:17lot of you don't even know what quote
- 21:18unquote real photography is. You're
- 21:20you're completely disconnected from the
- 21:22professional industry. You don't even
- 21:24know where to look to find people who
- 21:26are working photographers. I know this
- 21:28because you write me all the time and
- 21:30say the same thing. Where how do I find
- 21:31these people? And I'll give you some
- 21:32advice later when I tell you how to
- 21:34overcome being held back by film. To be
- 21:37obsessed over the process as as opposed
- 21:39to the product is like a painter
- 21:42obsessed over his paints or it's a
- 21:44writer obsessed over pens or a guitarist
- 21:47obsessed over the guitar. And I'll tell
- 21:49you a funny story. [snorts]
- 21:51So, a long time ago, I I'm actually
- 21:54friends with two famous guitar players
- 21:57from bands that you all know, and most
- 21:59of you love these bands. These are huge
- 22:01superstar international bands. And I
- 22:03just happened over the years to meet two
- 22:06of these people, not in the music
- 22:08industry, totally unrelated, but I met
- 22:11him and I know him and we're still
- 22:12friends. So one time a friend of mine in
- 22:14California in Lagona as a joke found
- 22:17this waterlogged water damaged guitar
- 22:20and for like my birthday as a joke he
- 22:23got this guitar case and it looked like
- 22:25a real real guitar and then I opened it
- 22:28and it was just this wasted guitar and
- 22:30[snorts] it was funny and I was like
- 22:31that's great. I'm going to I'm going to
- 22:33pay this forward. So, I went to LA and I
- 22:35went to the house of one of these famous
- 22:36guitar players. And as a joke, I brought
- 22:39my water damaged, horrible guitar and
- 22:43we're sitting in his living room and I
- 22:44was like, "Oh, I got a present for you."
- 22:46And I opened up this thing and I handed
- 22:47him this water damaged guitar. He did
- 22:50not skip a beat. He grabbed it from my
- 22:54hands and just started jamming. And what
- 22:57came out of that guitar was
- 23:00unbelievable. again, you know, he's
- 23:02probably been playing guitar for 50
- 23:03years. The guy's a virtuoso on the
- 23:05guitar. I was just like, because I had
- 23:08tried to play this junk guitar and it
- 23:10just sounded horrible and I thought,
- 23:11well, this is impossible. Like, yes,
- 23:13there's strings attached, but that's as
- 23:14far as it goes. And he said something.
- 23:16[snorts] He goes, "It matters, but it
- 23:18doesn't matter."
- 23:20And here's the takeaway. He said, "It
- 23:22matters, but it doesn't matter. Did you
- 23:25put the work in?" and he knew I didn't
- 23:30put the work in. I didn't learn to play
- 23:32guitar. I never dedicated myself to it.
- 23:34And you guys are in the same boat. You
- 23:37haven't worked long enough or hard
- 23:39enough or consistently enough to get
- 23:41good and you're looking for a magic
- 23:43pill. You're looking for a fix and it
- 23:45doesn't doesn't get out there. So, let
- 23:46me just keep focused a little bit on the
- 23:48film bros and then again I'll work
- 23:50backwards to um you know, again, they're
- 23:53they're bringing more positive than
- 23:54negative.
- 23:56A lot of what you see in the film bro
- 23:58online crowd is what in the industry we
- 24:01just call retreads. These are retread
- 24:04projects in stories. They're not even
- 24:06really stories. It's the same. It's the
- 24:10same projects over and over and over
- 24:12again. And again, they know you're
- 24:13gullible. They know that you do not know
- 24:15your history. And I'm going to use
- 24:17Southern California as an example
- 24:18because I lived there for 25 years and I
- 24:21worked for Kodak Professional for four
- 24:23years. I was in every major studio on
- 24:25the West Coast in every genre of
- 24:26photography, celebrity portraiture,
- 24:28fashion, automotive, food, lifestyle,
- 24:31editorial, um, documentary. I was with
- 24:34everybody. I saw what they were doing. I
- 24:37saw how they were working. I saw how
- 24:38much time they put in. I saw their
- 24:40training, their education, all of that.
- 24:42You guys are not privy to any of that
- 24:45stuff. And that is why I think these
- 24:46online channels are appealing because
- 24:48they're just giving you something.
- 24:50They're feeding you. They're feeding
- 24:51your insecurities and your lack of
- 24:53knowledge, right? That's how it works.
- 24:55Retread assignments. [snorts] If you
- 24:57work for a newspaper, there are tons of
- 24:59retread assignments. These are things
- 25:00that come up annually. So, Ble Florico
- 25:03was one that popped into my head, which
- 25:04is a Latin American dance troop. It's
- 25:06beautiful. It's awesome. The people are
- 25:08great. It's very visual. But you shoot
- 25:10that in a January in one year. Well,
- 25:12January the next year, typically that
- 25:14same dance troop comes back and you
- 25:15might get the same assignment, right?
- 25:16It's hard. You have to reinvent how
- 25:18you're going to photograph these things.
- 25:20So, Southern California has a set of
- 25:22stories that all the hipsters and bros
- 25:24and everybody seems to like to do. And a
- 25:26lot of these are centered around Salt
- 25:28and Sea, Salvation Mountain, Slab City,
- 25:31old gas stations, old buildings in the
- 25:33desert. Now, here's the thing
- 25:36again. I ran my first role of film in
- 25:381988. I started studying photo history.
- 25:40In 1988,
- 25:42I started looking at what was out there.
- 25:44In 1988, I was working for CPRO for four
- 25:47years in LA. I was looking around at
- 25:49what was out there. Do you realize how
- 25:51many times that story has been done
- 25:55before YouTube culture came along.
- 25:58Dozens and dozens and dozens of
- 26:01photographers did those same stories.
- 26:03But they these guys bank on the fact
- 26:05that you don't know anything about that.
- 26:07You're looking at what they're doing and
- 26:08you're think you're taking it at face
- 26:10value and going, "Wow, this is really
- 26:11original." It's not. It's been done a
- 26:12million times. That does not mean you do
- 26:16not go and try to do it yourself, but
- 26:18you've got to reference what was done
- 26:20before and say like, "Wow, you know,
- 26:23Richard Mizra did this. It was really
- 26:25influential to me." Um, and I'm taking
- 26:28what he did and I'm adding my spin to
- 26:30it, but I am paying tribute to who did
- 26:32this before. Again, you're gullible. You
- 26:34don't know your history. They know this.
- 26:36They're throwing you out there and maybe
- 26:37you're too lazy to go study and they
- 26:40that's how this whole system works. But
- 26:42the retreads not not great. I see the
- 26:45same thing happening in New York street
- 26:47photography where people are acting and
- 26:49showing work and it kind of trying to
- 26:50pawn it off as like something novel that
- 26:52no one's done before. That's not true.
- 26:54It's been done a million times. There's
- 26:56a book called Salt Dreams about the salt
- 26:58and sea. To me, it's way better than
- 27:00anything I've seen anybody in the modern
- 27:02times do. And it was only done it was
- 27:04probably done in the '9s if I'm not
- 27:05mistaken. But I've just seen I mean, oh
- 27:10my god, just Slab City alone, how many
- 27:12projects have I seen from Slab City? How
- 27:14many old gas stations and old buildings
- 27:16in the California desert? How many
- 27:18projects? I also taught at Art Center in
- 27:20Pasadena. If you don't know what Art
- 27:22Center is in Pasadena, look it up. It's
- 27:24one of the best art schools in America
- 27:26and has been for a long, long time. And
- 27:28a lot of amazing photographers came
- 27:30through that school. Do you know how
- 27:31many students went to Salt and Sea in
- 27:33Slab City? Tons. I mean, you know how
- 27:36many people shot old buildings? Tons.
- 27:38I've just seen it a thousand times.
- 27:41Remember when the salt and sea I'm
- 27:42trying to think of the name of the the
- 27:43little bar restaurant that had a pool
- 27:45that all the skaters used to go to? I've
- 27:48seen a dozen projects on that. I shot
- 27:51that, you know? I mean, it's just been
- 27:52done over and over and over again.
- 27:54You've got to get better. You've got to
- 27:57get more rounded. And you've got to
- 27:58educate yourself. Okay. Why is film
- 28:01holding a lot of you back?
- 28:04It's not holding all of you back, but
- 28:06it's holding a lot of you back. And
- 28:08there's a lot of reasons for that. And
- 28:10again, if you're a photographer that
- 28:12spent 20 years working as a pro and
- 28:14you've shot digital and really kind of
- 28:15maximize the knowledge needed to do
- 28:17digital professionally from here on out
- 28:20and now you're kind of like reminiscing
- 28:22about film and you want to experiment,
- 28:24great. That you're in the perfect
- 28:26position. You understood how to use
- 28:28digital. You had a film background. I
- 28:30[snorts] would put myself in this
- 28:32category.
- 28:33very much a film background. It took 20
- 28:36years for me to like digital. I finally
- 28:40like digital. Took it actually took more
- 28:42over 25 years for me to like it. Now I
- 28:45do. Now I understand it. If I want to
- 28:46shoot film, I'll shoot film. But I know
- 28:48the limitations and when strategically
- 28:51to use it. A lot of you don't. So number
- 28:53one, [snorts]
- 28:55the reason it's holding you back is what
- 28:57I mentioned earlier is the false premise
- 28:59that it is better. It is not better. It
- 29:01is different. Film has a look. It does.
- 29:05It has a distinctive look. And here's
- 29:06kind of the pathetic part from the
- 29:09digital side. [snorts] A lot of the
- 29:11companies who build software and filters
- 29:14to emulate film. A friend of mine is a
- 29:16big wig at one of these companies. I've
- 29:18known him since my Capro days in SoCal.
- 29:21And he said to me, "It's pretty
- 29:23pathetic. You know, here we are in 2026
- 29:27and we're building software to emulate a
- 29:2960-year-old emulsion, which is Trix.
- 29:33There is no there is I've every time
- 29:36some digital dork says to me, "Oh, you
- 29:39got to look at this. This looks exactly
- 29:40like, you know, Trix or whatever, and
- 29:42they show me files," I'm like, "No, it
- 29:43doesn't look like film. It doesn't. It's
- 29:45just different." There's no reason to
- 29:47make your digital files look like film.
- 29:50Digital files look like digital files.
- 29:51If you want to tweak them into
- 29:52something, you can. But if you're
- 29:54adamant, absolutely adamant that you've
- 29:56got to have triex, shoot triacs. But do
- 29:59it strategically when it's not holding
- 30:00you back. [snorts]
- 30:03Film is a lifestyle, as I mentioned
- 30:05before, as is digital. Film lifestyle
- 30:08was process, send the work to the lab,
- 30:11let the lab do their thing. Digital is
- 30:12married to the computer the whole time.
- 30:14But what's happened with film and the
- 30:16bro culture online is that the style,
- 30:20the lifestyle of film has superseded the
- 30:24product. It's the tattoos, it's the felt
- 30:27hats, it's the outfits, it's the cars,
- 30:30it's the retro everything. It's it's
- 30:33100% hipster. Hipsters have never met
- 30:37someone else's idea they don't love.
- 30:40They just copy what's been done in the
- 30:42past. That is what I see driving film
- 30:45culture. It's the It's the guys in New
- 30:47York City standing that are dressed like
- 30:501980s photojournalists with leas and off
- 30:52camerara cords smoking cigarettes, which
- 30:54is the dumbest thing in the world. If
- 30:55you smoke, I'm never hiring you. Period.
- 30:57And I don't know anybody now that would
- 30:58if you walked up and you were smoking,
- 31:00people are like, "You're a problem. I
- 31:02don't want you on set with that. It
- 31:03doesn't make any sense." But they're
- 31:04like d they're caricatures of8s
- 31:06photojournalism. Now, I love '8s
- 31:09photojournalism. some of the most
- 31:10amazing people that influenced me that
- 31:13were doing projects. I love 80s
- 31:15photojournalism. Technically, I started
- 31:17in 88 80 maybe. I was kind of a tiny bit
- 31:20of residue of 80s photojournalism, but I
- 31:22was I would say I was more 90s
- 31:23photojournalism.
- 31:25I love that stuff, but it's it's not
- 31:28applicable anymore unless you're
- 31:31performing for that little click of
- 31:33people, which is exactly what those guys
- 31:35are doing. They're just dressing and
- 31:37acting like 80s photojournalists because
- 31:40that's what their buddies do. And the
- 31:42thing is, it doesn't translate out of
- 31:43that circle.
- 31:46Film is amazing because of the
- 31:48limitations. You cannot see and you're
- 31:50limited by how many exposures you have,
- 31:52whether it's a 36 or a 12 or whatever
- 31:54formats. If you're shooting 6x9, it's
- 31:56even less. Whatever it is, the
- 31:58limitations are the strong points of
- 32:00film depending on where you are in your
- 32:04educational process.
- 32:06And most of you are not near the top of
- 32:08your educational process. You are at the
- 32:10bottom or near the bottom, which is
- 32:12completely fine. That's where we all
- 32:14start. And you've got to build and build
- 32:16and build, which we'll get to. The
- 32:18second reason that film is holding you
- 32:20back is the cost. And I see this and I
- 32:23hear this all the time directly from
- 32:25you. Oh, it's so expensive. I you know
- 32:29how many times am I asked to look at
- 32:30bodies of work and I look at work and
- 32:32the first thing I see is you're not
- 32:34working scenes you're not working a
- 32:36scene you can you're only you're
- 32:38limiting yourself to whatever six frames
- 32:40you're shooting this and I'm like what
- 32:42happened next like you should have been
- 32:44here and shot you're not oh well you
- 32:46know film's super expensive
- 32:48you do not work scenes and you've got to
- 32:50work scenes actually one of my friends
- 32:52who shot for National Geographic for
- 32:53years he said that was the thing about
- 32:55digital that was to him both a posit
- 32:58positive and a negative. It was kind of
- 32:59surprised. He said, "All of a sudden, I
- 33:01could just exhaust working a scene."
- 33:04With digital, whereas with film, because
- 33:06they're in the field for whatever 3,
- 33:07four months at a time, logistically
- 33:09trying to get film into some of these
- 33:11remote places, you were more limited. He
- 33:13said, "All of a sudden, I could just
- 33:14work scenes exhaustively."
- 33:17Then he got lazy and then he said he
- 33:19would shoot and chimp and he would say,
- 33:21"Oh, I've got it. I've got it." and he
- 33:23caught himself using digital in a
- 33:26negative way of saying, "Oh yeah, I'm
- 33:29convincing myself I have it when what I
- 33:31should have done is continue to work the
- 33:33scene." So cost is a real problem.
- 33:37I worked at newspapers and I worked at
- 33:41Kodak.
- 33:43And at the newspaper, I had unlimited
- 33:45film. And when I took a job with Kodak,
- 33:48they made me sign a piece of paper, a
- 33:49non-competitive clause, meaning I would
- 33:51never take assignments while I was
- 33:53working with Kodak because I'd be
- 33:54competing with my customers, which I
- 33:56signed. I said, "I don't want to do
- 33:57assignments anymore. I'm done. No
- 34:00problem." But I made them sign something
- 34:02said, "Unlimited film, paper, and
- 34:03chemistry while I'm working for the
- 34:05company." Which I took them up on. I
- 34:06shot nonstop while for those four years
- 34:09at Kodak. I shot only my own projects.
- 34:12It's during that four years that I
- 34:14learned who I was as a photographer. If
- 34:16I was during that same time, if I was
- 34:19limited saying, "Wow, it's 30 bucks a
- 34:21roll to buy a roll of film and it's
- 34:22another 30 for processing and scanning,"
- 34:24I never would have found who I was as a
- 34:26photographer. It took me a long time to
- 34:28figure that out.
- 34:30Number three reason why film is holding
- 34:33you back. There is no immediacy.
- 34:37You are losing out on immediiacy. The
- 34:39educational component of immediiacy of
- 34:42images is being able now I'm not talking
- 34:43about chimping in the field. I never
- 34:45chimp in the field. It's coming home and
- 34:49it is
- 34:51is immediately identifying that work. So
- 34:55how many of you have written to me and
- 34:57said, "Oh, I'm a film photographer. I
- 35:00have 50 rolls of unprocessed film. I'm
- 35:01way behind. I'm way behind. I'm way
- 35:04behind. And then you show me some of
- 35:05this work and I'm like, your work looks
- 35:07like it did a year ago and you still
- 35:08don't know what you're doing. You're way
- 35:10you're so slow with the camera because
- 35:13you're not shooting enough because of
- 35:14the cost. So, you're not quick enough in
- 35:16the field. I see you working. You're
- 35:18fumbling around. You're looking at your
- 35:20controls. You're not fast enough. You're
- 35:23not shooting enough. And then you're not
- 35:25processing that film because I mean labs
- 35:27are super expensive now for film. I get
- 35:29it. Um, and so 50 rolls of unprocessed
- 35:32film, 100 rolls of unprocessed film.
- 35:34Some of you brag about having
- 35:36unprocessed film. I mean, it's like, are
- 35:40you Gary Winterrand? 500 rolls of film
- 35:42stuffed in a filing cabinet that like
- 35:44somebody's going to find after you die.
- 35:45Um, unprocessed film. I don't get it.
- 35:48And by the way, well, I was going to I
- 35:51was going to say three photographers
- 35:52that are super popular in the film bro
- 35:54world that photographers that whose work
- 35:55I don't like at all. I never have.
- 35:57That's just me personally. I have all of
- 35:59their books. Well, actually, I'll tell
- 36:01you. Gary Winterrand, Robert Frank, and
- 36:03William Egleston, I never liked any of
- 36:05that work. I have all their books
- 36:08because when I look at someone's work
- 36:10and I don't respond to it, I don't blame
- 36:12the photographer. I blame myself. Why am
- 36:15I not responding to this? I need to know
- 36:17more. So, I buy the books and I study
- 36:18them and I look at composition. And if I
- 36:21ultimately come away with it and say, "I
- 36:23don't really like this work," it's fine.
- 36:24I don't have to like everybody's work.
- 36:26You don't have to like everybody's work.
- 36:27It's not a love fest like it is online
- 36:29where everything has to be positive or
- 36:31people melt down. You brag about
- 36:34processing but you never catch up. That
- 36:36is not good for education. Again, if
- 36:38you're if you're and I could name 20
- 36:40photographers here in town that if they
- 36:43had 50 roles backed up for processing,
- 36:45it wouldn't bother me because I know how
- 36:47skilled they are. I know their
- 36:48education, their training, their
- 36:49history. And I'd be like, well, they're
- 36:50just dabbling and it's not important.
- 36:52They'll catch up eventually. But a lot
- 36:54of you are at that educational component
- 36:55stage. you. It's not helping you.
- 36:59Um, the fourth reason why I think it's
- 37:00holding you back is scanning. Scanning
- 37:03historically was always a bottleneck
- 37:06with film. It was always a problem. It
- 37:08was this weird kind of thing that nobody
- 37:11really caught up on. And I've heard
- 37:12stories of like individual photographers
- 37:14buying neritus and setting up their own
- 37:16labs. For most people, that's
- 37:19first of all, maddening. No one would
- 37:21really want to do that except for, you
- 37:22know, hardcore people. So the people who
- 37:24do it, hats off to you for for doing
- 37:26that. I would never do that personally
- 37:27myself. I would just let the lab do what
- 37:29the lab does. I can be in the field
- 37:31shooting. I can be doing business
- 37:33aspects. I can be writing. I could be
- 37:34making books as and just pay the lab to
- 37:36do what they want. Scanning has always
- 37:39been a bottleneck for but for you modern
- 37:41folks, scanning and if it was me today,
- 37:44I would just do I would get a digital
- 37:46camera and I would copy my negatives. I
- 37:48wouldn't use a scanner. I think it's
- 37:49much quicker and the quality is
- 37:51fantastic and there's enough uh
- 37:53information and enough systems out there
- 37:54it shouldn't be a problem to get
- 37:55started. And I knew people doing this a
- 37:58long time ago, 15 years ago. You know, I
- 38:01went to um a guy in LA who has arguably
- 38:04the best photo book collection in the
- 38:05world and also one of the largest photo
- 38:08archives I've ever seen. And he had an
- 38:10old Nikon digital camera and he was
- 38:11copying NEGs. I'd never seen anybody do
- 38:13that. He was the first one. And now it's
- 38:15just super streamlined and slick. So
- 38:17that's what I would do. But
- 38:20the lack of scanning
- 38:22keeps you from printing. A lot of you
- 38:25folks don't print. And that is the
- 38:27biggest tell for being an amateur is not
- 38:31printing and understanding what prepping
- 38:33for print does for you as a photographer
- 38:36in the field. It makes you better.
- 38:40Print shows what you have and it
- 38:42immediately shows what you don't. And
- 38:45you can soon as you digitize, you can
- 38:47put your work into book software. Book
- 38:49software is amazing. Even if you don't
- 38:50print it, it just shows you immediately
- 38:51what you have. That's what I do in my
- 38:53workshops. Um, in the dark room, and
- 38:56here's here's where it translated in the
- 38:58dark room. The dark room is a nightmare,
- 39:00right? There's just so many things that
- 39:02can go wrong. It's one of the beauties
- 39:03of the dark room is you've got to be
- 39:05mentally there and it's so complicated.
- 39:08And I was never a great printer. the guy
- 39:10that I was just talking about with the
- 39:12archive and the book collection.
- 39:13Amazing. Both traditional dark room wet
- 39:16printer and digital printer, master at
- 39:19both of those, which was very rare. Um,
- 39:22I showed him prints one day, which I
- 39:24thought were final prints. And he just
- 39:26immediately assumed were work prints and
- 39:28then told me how I could make them
- 39:29better. And he probably talked for 20
- 39:31minutes without stopping. And I finally
- 39:33had to stop him and say, "I don't even
- 39:34know the techniques you're talking
- 39:35about." So, the dark room was you go in
- 39:39the field and and let me just explain
- 39:41about photography school because a lot
- 39:43of there's a lot of BS especially from
- 39:45YouTubers about photography school
- 39:46because they never went or they dropped
- 39:48out and they just don't know.
- 39:50Photography school was not about
- 39:51technical anything. You there was you
- 39:54learned how to use a 4x5 like the first
- 39:56week and then you checked out cameras.
- 39:57There it's not about technical stuff.
- 39:59It's about getting assignments, finding
- 40:02stories, performing under pressure,
- 40:05making prints, showing work, being able
- 40:07to take constructive and destructive
- 40:09feedback, and and getting better,
- 40:12learning your composition. It's about
- 40:13working. And a lot of these people who
- 40:15drop out again, they can't hack it, and
- 40:18then they tell you not to go because
- 40:20they're insecure and they don't want you
- 40:21to go because they know that if you go,
- 40:22you're probably going to come out and
- 40:23you're going to be better than they are.
- 40:25So the dark room, you would go out and
- 40:28sometimes, you know, you you hit a home
- 40:29run on your assignment and other times
- 40:31you didn't and you knew you didn't and
- 40:33you'd come back to the dark room and
- 40:34you're on freaking deadline. You got one
- 40:36chance to do this because you got to
- 40:38print and mount and then show the work
- 40:40and you can't just go, "Oh, I don't have
- 40:42any work." Cuz you get an F. You're
- 40:44going to fail. So you put a negative in
- 40:46the enlarger. You mix the chemistry. You
- 40:50get your paper in the paper safe.
- 40:51Everything is good. And the whole time
- 40:52you go, I can't do this. I can't do
- 40:54this. It's not good enough. That image
- 40:56is not good enough. You're lying to
- 40:59yourself the whole time you're mixing
- 41:00chemistry. You're lying when you're
- 41:02putting the negative in the enlarger.
- 41:03And then you're sitting there and you're
- 41:04saying to yourself, "This is a half a
- 41:06day. This is a half a day of my life I'm
- 41:08going to waste on an image that's not
- 41:10good enough." And you take the image out
- 41:12and you pour the chemistry back in the
- 41:14bottles and you go back in the field and
- 41:16you try to make something good. The the
- 41:19same thing happens now in the digital
- 41:21space is you're able to take that work.
- 41:22It's not an enlarger, but it's book
- 41:24software. And all of a sudden, the book
- 41:26software shows you, "Oh man, this isn't
- 41:30good. I got to go back in the field."
- 41:32You cannot hide from your take. YouTube
- 41:36is all about hiding from the take. It's
- 41:39about what you look like and what you
- 41:41dress like and what you sound like and
- 41:43what all the cameras you're using and
- 41:45all the front-end stuff that matters not
- 41:48when you're talking about the product.
- 41:50You cannot hide from the take. I spent
- 41:53my career putting work in front of
- 41:55people I could not hide from. YouTube is
- 41:58easy to hide. It's spots and strangers
- 42:00and no big deal. You don't know most of
- 42:02these people in person, whatever. You
- 42:03can get away with anything you want. But
- 42:05when you're in the field working as a
- 42:07professional, you can't get away. You
- 42:08can't get away. There's somebody
- 42:09waiting. I mean, I remember shooting a
- 42:11commercial assignment in LA that was
- 42:13absolute hell. I only did it for the
- 42:15money. I was desperate. It was horrible.
- 42:18It it was for
- 42:20uh what do you call it? Um oh, I'm
- 42:23spacing out. It was for like um faucets
- 42:26and fixtures. Huge company,
- 42:28international, big event, shot in
- 42:30Hollywood. And the whole time I was
- 42:32like, "Oh, this sucks so bad. And I am
- 42:36so bad at this kind of photography. And
- 42:38how did I get this job? And why did I
- 42:40accept this job? And I'm a and I
- 42:42hate photography and I never want to use
- 42:44a sink ever again." And I knew that the
- 42:49woman who hired me was going to be
- 42:51waiting for those images. I just shot a
- 42:54kinera portrait a couple weeks ago,
- 42:57maybe 10 days ago, as a favor to a
- 42:59family I love. My wife photographed, I
- 43:02photographed. The whole time I'm
- 43:03shooting this 15-year-old girl. All I'm
- 43:07thinking about are the parents standing
- 43:09there. They're going to It's for them.
- 43:12Sure, it's for the the the girl who's
- 43:14going through the kiniera, but I just
- 43:17know what's going on in the mind of
- 43:18those parents. I'm photographing for
- 43:21them. I know. I want them to see those
- 43:23pictures and just be like, "Oh my god,
- 43:25that's our daughter. She looks amazing."
- 43:27That's the the pressure of shooting for
- 43:29others. So, scanning is is a bummer.
- 43:33All right, my friends. Now, let's get to
- 43:35the positivity side, shall we? Take a
- 43:37break. No way. Man up, woman up,
- 43:40whatever it is. Whatever, whoever you
- 43:42are, whatever you are, step to the
- 43:44plate, my friends. How to overcome this.
- 43:47How to overcome film holding you back,
- 43:50but still using film because you love
- 43:52it. You tell me you do. A lot of you
- 43:54were like probably over the years, and
- 43:56I've had this a few times, people
- 43:57saying, "I don't really care what it
- 43:58looks like. I just like the process."
- 44:00Great. One of a guy I know, guy here in
- 44:02town, six traditionally published books
- 44:04to his name, all sold out. He told me
- 44:06his favorite part of the whole thing of
- 44:07photography in the entire idea of
- 44:10photography and he's been a doc guy
- 44:11forever. He went to Art Center.
- 44:13[sighs and gasps]
- 44:14He's like, "I just want to process film.
- 44:16That's it. I don't care what the work
- 44:18looks like. Yeah, I got six books. They
- 44:19all sold out. Yeah, I'm a great mentor.
- 44:21Yeah, I'm a well-known teacher. I just
- 44:23want to process film. Whatever."
- 44:26Okay. Number one, this is going to hurt,
- 44:28but holy crap, do you guys need this
- 44:30advice for 6 months? Number one, for 6
- 44:33months you are going to stop watching.
- 44:37You are going to stop watching
- 44:40everything. No more YouTube, none for 6
- 44:45months. No websites about photography.
- 44:47No photography books. You're not going
- 44:49to exhibitions. You're not going to
- 44:51museums. You're not going to shows. And
- 44:53you certainly sure as hell are not going
- 44:56on Instagram. If you're still on
- 44:58Instagram, you know how I feel about
- 45:00you. I feel like you're an addict that
- 45:02has no original thought. I ask you if
- 45:04you like Mark Zuckerberg and you say no
- 45:06and then I ask why you're putting money
- 45:08in his pocket and you have no answer. So
- 45:09I don't the whole Instagram thing for me
- 45:11died a decade ago and as one CEO put it
- 45:14to me, the only people left are the
- 45:15addicts. So there is no looking for 6
- 45:19months. You are going to stop because
- 45:21you have got to make a break. You've got
- 45:24to get away from me and you've got to
- 45:26get away from everybody else because
- 45:28it's the only way you're going to find
- 45:29who you actually are. Number two, you
- 45:32are going to commit. You are a bunch of
- 45:35distracted wombats. Now, I've never met
- 45:38a wombat. I don't think I've ever even
- 45:40seen a wombat in the wild, but I assume
- 45:43they're hyper fast, probably evil, and I
- 45:47don't know, maybe they would attack if
- 45:48given the chance. But I also see them as
- 45:51completely distracted. Like if they were
- 45:53going to attack and you had like some
- 45:54cotton candy, you'd be like, "Hey, what
- 45:56about this?" And and then you'd be fine.
- 45:57So I I think you're distracted wombats.
- 46:00What? Here's what you say to me.
- 46:02>> Well, I started a project and I worked
- 46:04on it for a couple of weeks and then I
- 46:05kind of got bored. If I ever hear you
- 46:08use the word bored, I am going to ban
- 46:11you from this channel forever. There is
- 46:13absolutely no reason to ever be bored in
- 46:17your life, let alone with a camera in
- 46:19your hand. Well, I started this project
- 46:21and I worked on it for a couple weeks
- 46:22and then I I got distracted and I got
- 46:24bored and then I saw so and so and so
- 46:27and so did this thing and so I went out
- 46:29and I started another project and then I
- 46:31worked on that for a couple of weeks.
- 46:32You never finish anything. You don't
- 46:34commit. You go on YouTube, you see
- 46:36somebody who did something 30 years ago
- 46:38and you go, "Oh, I'm going to do that."
- 46:39And then you go out and realize that you
- 46:41don't have the chops to do it. You don't
- 46:42have the knowledge to do it. You don't
- 46:43have the training to do it. You don't
- 46:44have the practice to do it. So you stop
- 46:46and you move on to something else. You
- 46:48have got to commit to something.
- 46:51You buy a new lens or you say, "I got to
- 46:54go to another country. I'll just travel
- 46:55to another country and because it's
- 46:57exotic and I'll make pictures, it'll
- 46:58seem like I'm making progress." No. No.
- 47:01And no. And I'm going to use a one
- 47:04person you guys all know for the most
- 47:07part, especially street folks. No. And
- 47:09then someone you may or may not know
- 47:11that was also working in the exact same
- 47:13place at the exact same time and also
- 47:15did a book that was hugely influential
- 47:17to me. You've got to commit.
- 47:21Alex Webb
- 47:24I got Oh,
- 47:27come on, Bessie. I got two copies of
- 47:30this. It's in color, by the way, of
- 47:32course. Hotlight, Halfmade Worlds. Love
- 47:35this book. This was the second body of
- 47:37work from Alex Webb that turned me on to
- 47:39Alex Webb. His his work on the border
- 47:40was what got me first. Photographs from
- 47:43Haiti. 1986 to 1988. 86 87 88. He's in
- 47:48Haiti. He's working one thing on Haiti.
- 47:51That's commitment. And that's only a
- 47:53three-year commitment. I bet you there's
- 47:55other projects he's worked on a lot
- 47:58longer than 3 years. At the same time,
- 48:02oh, it's right here.
- 48:05at the same time working in Haiti.
- 48:08Maggie Steber dancing on fire. Again, I
- 48:13don't doesn't say like how long. I know
- 48:15she was there for years. Speaks creole.
- 48:17How many of you speak Creole?
- 48:20How many learned another language so you
- 48:21can do a photo project? That's
- 48:23commitment.
- 48:25Maggie taught my first semester at UT
- 48:27Austin and the staff boned me because I
- 48:29was a transfer student and I was
- 48:31standing in the office and I was like,
- 48:32"Oh man, I'm taking her class." And
- 48:34these two facult the head of the
- 48:35department and the faculty member looked
- 48:37at each other and they looked at me and
- 48:38they go um um you can't take it. I go,
- 48:42"What are you talking about? Why?" Uh uh
- 48:44transfer students can't take visiting
- 48:46instructor classes. And I just looked at
- 48:48him and I said, "You just made that up
- 48:50right here. I know it." There were two,
- 48:52let's face it, two guys I never liked.
- 48:54Um one had some personal problems and
- 48:57the other was just kind of arrogant and
- 48:58I never really got along with them.
- 49:00Although think he's a good photographer
- 49:01and I think he was actually a pretty
- 49:03good instructor. I just never jived with
- 49:05anybody that was well one person at the
- 49:07was faculty member I jived with. The
- 49:10head of the department told me I was
- 49:11unhirable. Um and I just thought the
- 49:14program was completely behind the times.
- 49:16So I couldn't take Maggie's class
- 49:18and uh but that's a project. Haiti
- 49:23commitment book not a street
- 49:26photographer happens to shoot some
- 49:28pictures on the street to me not a
- 49:30street photographer happens to shoot
- 49:31some pictures on the street but working
- 49:34on storydriven
- 49:36projects for the love of god you guys
- 49:38got to find story which we're getting to
- 49:40what a transition into the next point so
- 49:42let's talk about this how let me recap
- 49:44here why film is holding you back false
- 49:48premise that it's better than digital
- 49:49number two the cost number three no
- 49:51immediiacy number four scan planning how
- 49:52to overcome this. Number one, stop
- 49:54looking. Disconnect. You've got to go
- 49:56find who you are. You're not going to do
- 49:58that watching YouTube. Number two,
- 50:00commit. You've got to commit to a story.
- 50:03Not just wandering around getting bored
- 50:05every two weeks because you saw somebody
- 50:07else's work that made you think
- 50:08differently. Number three, you have got
- 50:10to commit to story.
- 50:13No more random. No more random. And oh,
- 50:15by the way, I'm a judge. I've been a
- 50:18judge on contests going back probably 25
- 50:20years. Sometimes I'm a preliminary
- 50:22judge. Sometimes I am a finals judge. I
- 50:25can tell you after speaking to a lot of
- 50:27other judges, whether it's portfolio
- 50:29reviews or contests, they have no idea
- 50:32what to make of your randomness. They
- 50:34ask me, "What are we supposed to tell
- 50:37these people? What do I tell this
- 50:39photographer? How do I explain that this
- 50:42isn't a project or a story? This is 20
- 50:44random Lisbon photographs. Streets of
- 50:47Lisbon. Yeah, it looks like Lisbon.
- 50:49Great. Now what kind of thing? You've
- 50:52got to do this. [gasps]
- 50:54I just wrote notes. No one knows what to
- 50:56do with your work. It's true. Okay.
- 50:57Number four. How do you overcome being
- 51:01limited by film? Shoot digital. Not all
- 51:03the time, but you've got to. Forget
- 51:06about making digital look like film.
- 51:08It's a waste of time. You don't need to
- 51:10do it.
- 51:12Uh I told you my friend from the
- 51:13software company said they're still
- 51:14trying to emulate a 60-y old film. It's
- 51:16And he even said kind of lame, but it
- 51:18works. people are buying the stuff.
- 51:20[sighs]
- 51:21The audience
- 51:23does not care if it's digital or film.
- 51:28The only people who care if it's film
- 51:30are film dorks or YouTube film people
- 51:33who understand that you're gullible.
- 51:36That you will eat this stuff up. That
- 51:38film is more real. Film is better. That
- 51:41is a complete BS facade meant to get you
- 51:46to hit the like button, to hit the
- 51:48subscribe button. It's not true. Film is
- 51:51a dork conversation for the public. The
- 51:54public doesn't argue about what brand of
- 51:57oil paint or what pen a writer is using.
- 52:01They are reading the final product. It
- 52:03is not about process. Digital is going
- 52:06to give you immediacy. And here's where
- 52:08we go to part number five. So stop
- 52:11watching, commit, commit to story, shoot
- 52:14digital. Five is you are going to
- 52:17perform. You have got to perform. And
- 52:20let me explain what I mean. Each day
- 52:23that you photograph on whatever story
- 52:25and project that you've come up with
- 52:26that you've committed to because you've
- 52:29stopped watching all this nonsense,
- 52:32every day you're going to come back and
- 52:34you're going to do the 10 531 exercise.
- 52:37What are the top 10 images? The top
- 52:39five, the top three, and what is the
- 52:41single most important image of the day?
- 52:44And if you want to get creative, you can
- 52:45also say what which one of those 10
- 52:47would make the best cover image of a
- 52:50book. That is this is photography 101.
- 52:55This is what you do in photo school
- 52:57every day. You shoot, process, and edit.
- 53:00A lot of you folks will come to me and
- 53:02say, I shot a thousand images. I made an
- 53:05edit of 500. That is lame. Ridiculous.
- 53:09That's not how it works. Top 10, top
- 53:12five, single, top three, single best
- 53:15image every time you go in the field. Do
- 53:18not put it off. Come home, do it. It's
- 53:20not hard. The the more you do it, the
- 53:23better you're going to be, the better
- 53:24practice. You're going to have more fun.
- 53:25You're going to feel in command and
- 53:27control of your life, of your work.
- 53:31You're also going to take those images,
- 53:32the top 10, and you're going to put them
- 53:33into a piece of book software. I don't
- 53:35care what it is. A piece of book
- 53:37software that allows you to start laying
- 53:39things out. You don't even have to
- 53:41print. Don't print. Just put it in the
- 53:43book software every single time you come
- 53:45home. And the last part of performing,
- 53:48and I don't want to hear excuses because
- 53:50I hear a lot of lameo excuses all the
- 53:52time about this. You're going to write.
- 53:54You're going to write every day when you
- 53:56come home. If you if this is difficult
- 53:59for you, if you don't think you can
- 54:00write, change your mindset because I
- 54:02know you can, you're going to just write
- 54:05what you saw or what you did that which
- 54:07is not something I think is going to be
- 54:08long-term for you, but it's a gateway in
- 54:10how to start writing every day, which
- 54:13could be this is where I went. I went to
- 54:14Fifth and Broadway in LA. I photographed
- 54:17jewelry vendors on one side. I
- 54:18photographed a Mexican food salesman on
- 54:20the other side. you know, just just to
- 54:22get yourself into the habit of putting
- 54:24pen to paper, you will progressively get
- 54:27better and more of what's going on in
- 54:28here will hit the printed page and
- 54:30that's what really people are are drawn
- 54:32to. Okay. Number six,
- 54:36you are going to learn
- 54:39to know where to look for guidance in
- 54:44photography. And it sure as hell is not
- 54:46YouTube. It's not YouTube. It's not
- 54:48Instagram. It's not bro culture. It's
- 54:51not film culture. Again, that's to me is
- 54:54a bit like empty calories. And once you
- 54:57know where to look, I think the same
- 54:59thing is going to happen. And this the
- 55:00reason I'm telling you this is people
- 55:02write me and tell me. Someone wrote me a
- 55:04couple weeks ago, hey, can you give me
- 55:05just a couple examples of like places to
- 55:08look? And I did. And they wrote back, I
- 55:09just sent two people. And I said, if you
- 55:12study those two people and they're at
- 55:14the top of the pyramid, the next six
- 55:17months of your life are going to be
- 55:18filling in on all the people that they
- 55:20are connected to, organizations they're
- 55:22connected to, galleries, museums, art
- 55:24buyers, curators, all these people.
- 55:27That's real. These are people that know.
- 55:30So,
- 55:32let me let me tell you this, and I'm
- 55:34trying to remember why I made this note.
- 55:37It's it's uh
- 55:40Okay.
- 55:42So, again, there's a lot of the film
- 55:43bros I think are in SoCal or in
- 55:45California and there is a gathering that
- 55:50happens once a year in Southern
- 55:52California. Gathering of photographers,
- 55:54invitation only. It's been going on for
- 55:5840 years. No one knows about it outside
- 56:02of the people who are invited. When I
- 56:03lived in LA, I used to be invited and I
- 56:06was the least accomplished person in the
- 56:08room by far.
- 56:12Those people are out there. They're out
- 56:15there. You guys don't even seem to know
- 56:18where to look to find them. So,
- 56:21if you go to the Palm Springs Photo
- 56:23Festival, which was by far the best
- 56:25photo event in America every year until
- 56:27COVID, [gasps]
- 56:28and you just go look at the people who
- 56:30are featured and look at the faculty,
- 56:34if that doesn't keep you busy for the
- 56:36next year, then you're not trying. Those
- 56:40people will show you the light. They
- 56:43will show you. And guess what? Inside
- 56:46that gathering of photographers and
- 56:48inside that faculty list, there are
- 56:51people who are 100% film. One of them
- 56:54has a dark room on the west side that I
- 56:56started just about started crying when I
- 56:58went in there. It was the most amazing
- 56:59thing I've ever seen. I've never seen a
- 57:01dark room that beautiful. And there it
- 57:04was. There's film people in there, but
- 57:07when you're in that gathering, nobody's
- 57:09talking about film. It's just not.
- 57:11They're talking about the product. It's
- 57:14the product people. It's not the
- 57:16process.
- 57:19Palm Springs faculty, communication
- 57:21arts. Look at communication arts. And if
- 57:24you're like, "What's communication
- 57:26arts?" Again, here, that's the next year
- 57:27of your life. [sighs] The Art Director's
- 57:30Club, it's out based out of New York,
- 57:32but it's global. Pretty much every major
- 57:34city in the world has an agency tied to
- 57:36them. You're talking about creative
- 57:37agencies. So you're talking design,
- 57:39photography, illustration, AI, motion,
- 57:42creative art directors, creative
- 57:44directors, art buyers, art directors,
- 57:47photographers, all of that stuff is
- 57:50waiting for you.
- 57:54Museums, look at who museums have in
- 57:57their collections.
- 57:59Start there. Trust me, your mind is
- 58:02about to be blown. You're going to
- 58:04think, you're going to think back to
- 58:06this moment and you're going to think
- 58:07back to the time you wasted on YouTube
- 58:08and you're going to be like, "What was I
- 58:10thinking? What was I thinking?" Now,
- 58:12some of you don't want any of this. Some
- 58:14of you just want the you want the fairy
- 58:16tale, right? You just That's all you're
- 58:18superficial. You're skipping a rock
- 58:19across the pond. I get it. Not everybody
- 58:21wants to do be serious about their
- 58:23hobby. I get it. And that's fine. You do
- 58:25whatever you want. The last thing I'll
- 58:27say is there's a photographer in LA, and
- 58:31I'm not going to give you her name. If
- 58:33you even if you're even thinking of
- 58:35asking me, you're lazy because you can
- 58:36find her if you're if you spend half a
- 58:39minute trying.
- 58:41She's done 12 books, traditionally
- 58:44published books. 12 books in 15 years.
- 58:49That is unheard of in my experience.
- 58:5312 books in 15 years and they all sell.
- 58:58It is astounding. Now, that's half of
- 59:00her life. The other half, huge
- 59:03commercial shoots with a full team, full
- 59:06crew, huge commercial shoots, makes all
- 59:08the money, takes the money, does books,
- 59:11does books on whatever she feels like
- 59:12doing, and she does stuff that
- 59:14publishers and people say, "No way you
- 59:16can get access. No way you can do that."
- 59:18And she goes and does it.
- 59:20None of you have ever heard of her. I
- 59:24would guarantee. If someone knows her, I
- 59:26would be absolutely stunned.
- 59:29No one knows.
- 59:31Those are the people that are out there.
- 59:34They're not on Instagram. They're not on
- 59:37YouTube. They're not on Facebook.
- 59:39They're working all the time. Now, I was
- 59:43fortunate enough to have a little runin
- 59:44with her, a little encounter in a good
- 59:46way. She approached me and said, "Hey,
- 59:48I've seen what you're doing with these
- 59:50little smallrun art books. That's the
- 59:53future of publishing. You should be
- 59:55doing the same commercial shoots that
- 59:56I'm doing." And I was like, I don't want
- 59:58anything to do with those shoots. I'm
- 59:59flattered. Thank you. Love meeting you.
- 1:00:01You've been on my radar forever. I
- 1:00:03always put you on a pedestal. I was
- 1:00:06intimidated by you. Came up. Nicest
- 1:00:08person in the world. Ran into her again
- 1:00:10at Paris Photo a couple of years ago.
- 1:00:12She walked up to me and said, "When are
- 1:00:13we doing a book together?" And I was
- 1:00:15like, my knees were knocking together.
- 1:00:17I'm like, "I'm not in the league with
- 1:00:19you. I don't do projects in the league
- 1:00:20with you." And she's still emailing me
- 1:00:23saying, "When are we going to do this?"
- 1:00:24So very cool, confident person, super
- 1:00:26successful. Again, I'm still intimidated
- 1:00:28by her. Those are the people that are
- 1:00:30out there that you look at and you go,
- 1:00:32"Wow, I'm down here and they're up here
- 1:00:35and I got a big gap between us and I got
- 1:00:37to somehow start ratcheting up this
- 1:00:40ladder to see if I can get up to that
- 1:00:42level or somewhere in that
- 1:00:43conversation." [sighs]
- 1:00:45You can shoot film. I just told you I
- 1:00:48sent a box of film to my friend. But my
- 1:00:51friend shoots everything and knows
- 1:00:54project by project, story by story, job
- 1:00:56by job, there's certain things that fit
- 1:00:59and he's been doing it a long time. If
- 1:01:02you're in the consumer, proumer,
- 1:01:04educational stage of your career or your
- 1:01:07hobby or whatever, film is holding you
- 1:01:10back a lot of the time. Shoot digital,
- 1:01:13learn, go back to film. Shoot digital,
- 1:01:15learn, go back to film. That's my
- 1:01:17advice. I could have just said that and
- 1:01:21this film would have been 30 seconds
- 1:01:22long. But you know what? If I did that,
- 1:01:25I wouldn't be able to monetize my film.
- 1:01:27And just so you jackals know, the last
- 1:01:30YouTube short I uploaded, you know how
- 1:01:32much it made? Brace yourself, people.
- 1:01:36Brace yourself cuz you're going to want
- 1:01:37to be me. It made 11 cents. That was my
- 1:01:41last short. You know what? My last film,
- 1:01:42the Patagonia Workshop film, you know
- 1:01:44how much that made?
- 1:01:46I'm sitting on my mic cord.
- 1:01:50[sighs] You know how much that made?
- 1:01:52Dinner's on me. Made $15.37.
- 1:01:57So, this YouTube thing, it's paying off.
- 1:02:01I People all the time go, "Hey, man, you
- 1:02:04should just double down. Like, just do
- 1:02:07YouTube all the time. You could just
- 1:02:08kill it. Are you absolutely out of your
- 1:02:10mind? The last thing in the world I am
- 1:02:13ever going to do is do this full-time. I
- 1:02:16would lose my mind. I want to do I want
- 1:02:20to be Try to follow me here, Danny. Do
- 1:02:23you do drugs? Good. Every day. Good. Um,
- 1:02:26be the ball. Be the ball. Danny, I don't
- 1:02:29want to do this. I'm doing this because
- 1:02:33I think it can help some of you get from
- 1:02:35A to B. That's it. Tons of people helped
- 1:02:38me get from A to B. People are still
- 1:02:41helping me get from A to B. I write
- 1:02:44stuff for Blurb all the time. They they
- 1:02:46send me something. Hey, can you write
- 1:02:47something about this? I write it. I look
- 1:02:48at it. I read it. And I go, oh god, some
- 1:02:50I need an editor. Bad. Well, guess what?
- 1:02:53They edit. They help me. The social
- 1:02:55team, the design team, the product team,
- 1:02:57they're helping all the time. So, my
- 1:03:00responsibility is to help you in any way
- 1:03:02I can by trying to be honest. One of the
- 1:03:05things I consistently hear from feedback
- 1:03:07traveling the world when people come up
- 1:03:09to me and they go, "I know you from
- 1:03:10YouTube." One of the consistent things
- 1:03:12is you tell me things that no one else
- 1:03:15does. And there's a reason for that. I
- 1:03:17don't want something from you. I don't
- 1:03:19need something from you. I tell you,
- 1:03:21don't watch this. If you want to be a
- 1:03:23photographer, go shoot. I don't want
- 1:03:24your subs. I don't need your likes. I'm
- 1:03:26not doing this for that. I'm putting it
- 1:03:28out there as a road map of something to
- 1:03:30help you. That's the difference between
- 1:03:32me and a lot of folks who've committed
- 1:03:34to doing YouTube. They're kind of stuck.
- 1:03:37Look, the people I've met who were doing
- 1:03:38YouTube that are successful at it.
- 1:03:40They're they've all been nice. I mean,
- 1:03:42it's I can't maybe I've met somebody who
- 1:03:44wasn't nice, but it doesn't pop into my
- 1:03:46brain. I feel like they're trapped.
- 1:03:48They're trapped animals in a system that
- 1:03:51they cannot bend. And YouTube is
- 1:03:54constantly changing. If you look at some
- 1:03:55of the top top people outside of the
- 1:03:58photo space, I'm talking about news or
- 1:03:59journalism, whatever, they're like, "Oh,
- 1:04:01YouTube is unsubscribing people."
- 1:04:03They're looking at that content, they're
- 1:04:04getting pressure from the top, and
- 1:04:06they're unsubscribing people to try to
- 1:04:08drive those channels down. They're
- 1:04:09changing their algorithm all the time,
- 1:04:11demanding more time for less return. I
- 1:04:14don't want it. My goal in life is to
- 1:04:17disappear. The second I am financially
- 1:04:20sound enough to disappear, I will
- 1:04:22disappear. I will talk to friends and
- 1:04:24family, sure, but I am gone, man. I am a
- 1:04:27ghost. That's what I want. Got
- 1:04:29interviewed last week by a local person
- 1:04:31here in Santa Fe doing a book on Santa
- 1:04:33Fe. Asked me, really prepared himself
- 1:04:35for the interview. Asked me wonderful
- 1:04:37questions. I was very impressed by the
- 1:04:39questions. And he asked me about this
- 1:04:41like what's the what's the prize?
- 1:04:42Where's the goal? I'm like disappear.
- 1:04:44And he goes, "Yeah, but like then people
- 1:04:46wouldn't be able to share, you know,
- 1:04:48experience your work." I'm like, "I
- 1:04:49don't care. I'm selfish. I don't make
- 1:04:51for other people. I make for me." and
- 1:04:53I'm not going to do this. I'm going to
- 1:04:55go away. So, which is a terrible thing.
- 1:04:58If you're trying to make a living at
- 1:04:59this racket,
- 1:05:01if you're trying to make a living at
- 1:05:02this racket, you don't want to do what I
- 1:05:05do. In fact, take everything I said with
- 1:05:08a grain of salt. Why not? Uh, by the
- 1:05:11way, this this comes from motorcycle
- 1:05:14helmet, cycling helmet,
- 1:05:17uh, working out. This is not there's no
- 1:05:20product. This is just natural right here
- 1:05:23in case you guys are wondering. Oh boy.
- 1:05:26Oh, the old hips. Like a dog with broken
- 1:05:29hips.
- 1:05:32I'll be back.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Shifter: Film is Holding You Back by DANIEL MILNOR, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,005 words across 1,698 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.