Sherri Papini Interrogation by Shasta Co. Sheriff's detectives | Raw video — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00incredibly long road
- 0:02but some stuff's come up so over
- 0:05we've always had the DNA out there in
- 0:08the world
- 0:09um before we get too far obviously just
- 0:11like always
- 0:13thank you for coming we appreciate you
- 0:15taking the time to come back to us as
- 0:17always
- 0:18your presence here is voluntary yeah
- 0:21um you can go at any time and uh all we
- 0:24want is truthful statements because it's
- 0:26a crime to lie to Federal officers
- 0:30yeah sorry about that part so
- 0:34um so there's always been DNA out there
- 0:37and we've we've done testing after
- 0:39testing we've gone out to like the
- 0:42parabon which is a private company who
- 0:45does all like cool the genetics and
- 0:47we've just hit wall after wall after
- 0:48wall but recently we found some a
- 0:53familiar DNA hit so what that does it
- 0:55just tells us it came from a certain
- 0:58person so like the mother or the father
- 1:01or a son or an uncle or however that is
- 1:03it just hits that like somewhere in this
- 1:05family tree is where the DNA comes from
- 1:08okay so with that we open up the
- 1:11investigation we go into who could it be
- 1:15within the family so once we started
- 1:19opening up those doors and looking
- 1:21through those the family members and
- 1:23just trying to see Facebook stocking
- 1:25them criminal histories just that normal
- 1:29investigation that we do once we start
- 1:31looking into things we started finding
- 1:33some interesting things okay
- 1:35um so one of the things that came out to
- 1:38us
- 1:38well if you is there anything in there
- 1:40that looks of Interest or notable
- 1:44interest or
- 1:47I mean that's an awkward photo
- 1:57the table though the picture's a little
- 1:59drained out so there's I mean
- 2:02to me I see a
- 2:04table there that somewhat looks like
- 2:06something you described to be in the
- 2:08past and I said wood paneling
- 2:10talking about the room
- 2:12yeah we noted both of those things back
- 2:14in August yeah 2017 and we spoke with
- 2:17you about and you showed us this picture
- 2:20of the table do you remember that Sherry
- 2:22yes and so when we were trolling through
- 2:25this you know Facebook page it was not
- 2:28just the edge of that table Yeah Denise
- 2:31card in fact oh cool he said hey Peter
- 2:33look at this look at this table I was
- 2:36like oh wait you're right yeah and it
- 2:38has the wood paneling so we're like well
- 2:40where was that photo taken right and so
- 2:42we're trying to figure that out
- 2:44so oh okay uh so that's led us obviously
- 2:48now bound to the obviously this Facebook
- 2:51page has a person that's got like people
- 2:53tagged into it so it has uh the theater
- 2:57as of but that's still like that's still
- 2:59a valid memory right but this was the
- 3:01table Yeah a table like this was the
- 3:04table you were on when you were branded
- 3:05and we've been talking about that a lot
- 3:07because so many memories are so creative
- 3:10now it's been a long time it's been a
- 3:12really long time so like
- 3:15details and things like that we did the
- 3:17best that we could to take notes on it
- 3:19and all of that but a lot of it's really
- 3:22hard it's hard to think about
- 3:27um
- 3:27yeah no I see both those from what she
- 3:31told me okay
- 3:33that was an interesting with that we
- 3:34started looking at different people and
- 3:36who might be involved and just trying to
- 3:38figure it out
- 3:39and I wanted to show you this picture
- 3:42and obviously
- 3:46um
- 3:46people can change their weight people
- 3:49can change the color of their hair don't
- 3:52just because the photo might be a little
- 3:55bit different as you know women like to
- 3:57change their hair and
- 3:59their makeup their their weight can
- 4:01change so that that might be a little
- 4:03bit different but we wanted to take a
- 4:04look at this sit back and see if you
- 4:05recognize anybody see these six photos
- 4:08you don't feel like you have to provide
- 4:10an answer there's no right or wrong
- 4:12answer just let us know if you see
- 4:13anybody in this photo that you do
- 4:15recognize and if you do we'll talk about
- 4:16how okay
- 4:23foreign
- 4:50a little bit but
- 4:53let me say this one a little bit which
- 4:55number is it number three
- 5:01when you're ready I'll show you
- 5:03everything's really good
- 5:05there's nothing in there that says oh
- 5:07yeah
- 5:22it's a pleasant group of people
- 5:28same thing
- 5:46do you have a tissue
- 5:56it's hard because the other photos are
- 5:58distracting me can you give me another
- 5:59piece of paper if you don't mind another
- 6:02piece yeah upside down yes
- 6:06easier
- 6:08[Applause]
- 6:13it's a little distracting there we go
- 6:17thank you
- 6:38she's got that that puffy under those
- 6:40eyes but I don't know
- 6:46this is really hard
- 6:49take your time
- 6:56I mean for her like I said it's even
- 6:58close it's worth telling you guys
- 6:59obviously to look at it right well no
- 7:01it's just that need it obviously we know
- 7:03they're masked we know there's already
- 7:05hurdles to come about
- 7:07um
- 7:08it's just another tool another way to
- 7:10just another and obviously because you
- 7:12don't know the people if you knew the
- 7:13people and you'd show pictures but uh
- 7:21yeah it's I don't know for some reason
- 7:25is that harder when you're looking at
- 7:27like a crowd of
- 7:33Peterson different
- 7:36color hair and dyes and all that kind of
- 7:38stuff
- 7:43like I'm trying not to get my hopes up
- 7:54I would say right right here is what's
- 7:56drawing me to this photo so on Photo
- 7:59number five it's my biggest system this
- 8:02is the first one we showed you
- 8:07six bet number two
- 8:10but like you were saying if someone were
- 8:12to lose weight that would change you're
- 8:13drawn to photo number five yes features
- 8:16a photo number five correct and again
- 8:18just for for the record and for when you
- 8:20go back like number
- 8:22number one is when you say three similar
- 8:25she's similar to the younger female that
- 8:27we've always described in everything
- 8:30this part right here doesn't really
- 8:32match what I'm remembering but the
- 8:35hairline doesn't match another one older
- 8:37one and just because it's been a long
- 8:39time
- 8:41can you remind me what number what what
- 8:43the younger one did like the main parts
- 8:46of it compared to the older one just for
- 8:47the last like Clarity of stuff so for
- 8:51the record so the younger ones the one
- 8:53that let me go it was the nicer of the
- 8:56two okay the older one was really
- 8:59abusive and really mean and is the one
- 9:02that did all the really terrible things
- 9:05okay
- 9:07and that that's my memory too just
- 9:09trying to reference it for our notes so
- 9:13we don't have to say oh she was
- 9:14referring to the second interview back
- 9:16in 2017. the Memphis names in my head
- 9:23because number three alive in that photo
- 9:27and then one more
- 9:31foreign
- 10:04foreign
- 10:12[Music]
- 10:37foreign
- 10:44[Music]
- 10:47number three nobody
- 10:50really
- 10:56so we have more pictures we're not
- 10:58that's not the end of the road
- 11:00um yeah so like I said with the female
- 11:02the ability DNA obviously we saw that
- 11:05first picture that has a wood paneling
- 11:07um yeah and he's got the table right so
- 11:09that's that's ultimately what led us to
- 11:10those pictures which then snowballed us
- 11:13down the road that would eventually
- 11:16happen where we are so were you able to
- 11:19find like where that house is yes
- 11:32and may I ask how did we even get to
- 11:34that point how did we get that
- 11:36familiar DNA so they said they came back
- 11:39and said oh here's some people related
- 11:41in this family there's about 40 people
- 11:43total that's a good thing I guess but 40
- 11:45is better than you just started going
- 11:47through whatever the numbers yeah we
- 11:50started looking at everything that we
- 11:51could phones online presence criminal
- 11:54history Facebook photos DMV photos
- 11:58like you said Denise obviously you guys
- 12:01are aware Denise is in a different
- 12:03location now she's the one that found
- 12:05that picture so we cast a white net to
- 12:08start finding certain houses is she
- 12:10still working on the case even though
- 12:12she's in not officially but I always
- 12:13call her and say hey what do you think
- 12:15about this what do you think about that
- 12:16but yeah she's still working on it
- 12:23so if you look at this
- 12:34obviously you know there's there's stuff
- 12:36in there now
- 12:37I'm not looking at the stuff
- 12:42I literally was cleaning papers out
- 12:45yesterday and found that you didn't
- 12:49I haven't even looked at the picture yet
- 12:51but I've seen it out
- 12:55foreign
- 13:08[Applause]
- 13:10yes I just found the original one of
- 13:14that and I was trying to explain it's a
- 13:16little bit different but
- 13:18it's pretty excuse my language it's
- 13:21pretty [ __ ] similar
- 13:24but
- 13:25it's different
- 13:28what's different what's the thing
- 13:31there's a lot of [ __ ] in the photos but
- 13:35well let's just focus on this yeah we'll
- 13:37focus on those two because there's less
- 13:39culture I really I don't walk the
- 13:41streets with my wife's in Mexico we went
- 13:43to every shop because of the color
- 13:45changes no nothing not because there was
- 13:47anything new in it it's just the color
- 13:51I'm not gonna ask a question is this
- 13:53from the same house is that okay what
- 13:57what do you see in this photo sharing
- 13:59like what
- 14:01so it looks very similar I mean this is
- 14:04what I'm remembering that feeling you
- 14:07know grabbing it and feeling that
- 14:09feeling but this part is different this
- 14:12part is different that doesn't
- 14:14definitely I'm saying this metal part it
- 14:16looks the same as what you remember
- 14:19but this piece right here this part
- 14:22doesn't look the same right and what was
- 14:24the difference in it that there was a
- 14:26lot more there was a lot more yeah
- 14:30I don't think the pictures really show
- 14:36is it more metal or like beefier like if
- 14:40you look stronger this side of it a
- 14:43little bit more eventually the width of
- 14:45a plywood sheet of plywood
- 14:47it's like a piece of plywood almost it
- 14:49didn't look like that yeah it looks
- 14:50blown up so it makes it look like it's
- 14:51that thick but it's about like three
- 14:53quarter yeah inch somewhere it's
- 14:55probably like half inches
- 15:02okay but similar
- 15:04besides the metal part anything else
- 15:06similar
- 15:08I mean
- 15:10the metal part
- 15:12what about one birth itself versus two
- 15:14shells oh
- 15:16[Music]
- 15:18I think there was two shelves but now
- 15:20I'm having trouble remembering I think
- 15:22that's true I'm pretty sure there was
- 15:23two I can't maybe there was two I don't
- 15:25know I'm focusing on this part right now
- 15:27sorry sure
- 15:31so that's why
- 15:39the window
- 15:45with the wood paneling
- 15:50trying to ignore the TV and stuff I
- 15:52don't think you had a TV with you right
- 15:54definitely not
- 15:56um
- 15:57what if what am I looking for for the
- 15:59window do you want to know if it's like
- 16:00the same height it's the type of window
- 16:03the wall itself anything you need from
- 16:05these photos that make you believe that
- 16:07this was where you were being held I
- 16:09feel like
- 16:12this wood paneling is too thick but I
- 16:17mean
- 16:18there was wood paneling but I don't I
- 16:22can't remember something like that being
- 16:23there and I I don't remember
- 16:29I just remember it going all the way up
- 16:31to the window is what I'm having trouble
- 16:33remembering the window in that photo has
- 16:36holes along the edges
- 16:43yeah
- 16:46right here we're going fast sorry we
- 16:49don't mean to overwhelm you we're just
- 16:51trying to
- 16:52draw your attention to different things
- 16:54that maybe we noted and we want to know
- 16:56how that compares with what you the
- 16:58window compared to the wood paneling
- 17:00because it getting just
- 17:03I don't I mean that's probably important
- 17:06I mean not I don't know if I'm supposed
- 17:09to talk or not but the obvious is
- 17:10because those are screw holes right is
- 17:11that where you're getting that they're
- 17:13just holes the whole screw nail
- 17:14something okay
- 17:22oh
- 17:25foreign
- 17:28so is it fair to say that this
- 17:32the paneling like wood paneling below
- 17:35and sheetrock above is what you remember
- 17:37but you can't recall details about the
- 17:41ledge and the difference in width of
- 17:44these up to the window that's exactly
- 17:46what I was drawn to is that this is
- 17:48touching it how it meets the window
- 17:49threshold yeah
- 17:51okay
- 17:53something's going funky with that
- 17:56foreign
- 18:08description is just the the weird layout
- 18:12of the bathroom so if you remember the
- 18:13layout of the bathroom yes well the
- 18:16sorry about the description best
- 18:18description and then we'll start showing
- 18:19something upstairs
- 18:20door toilet
- 18:30if I'm
- 18:32working on the world with just in
- 18:35general I am I don't know but whatever
- 18:39you walk in the door on one left or
- 18:41right you have a toilet then I want to
- 18:44say what I'm sorry that's fine
- 18:47I want to say toilet on the left okay so
- 18:50maybe toilet on the left okay hold on
- 18:51turn it on the side put it on the side
- 18:56sink tub okay and that's a unique thing
- 19:00about bathrooms yes
- 19:05it takes some take some expensive too
- 19:07yes yes I think it's the first yeah
- 19:15foreign
- 19:49the order that's nice
- 19:53this doesn't look like the bathroom to
- 19:56me but the order is
- 19:59yes this is the type of order but this
- 20:02is not what it looked like to me okay
- 20:05and so the order is correct but you
- 20:07don't recognize the bathroom as being
- 20:09what you recall
- 20:10do you remember there was a detail about
- 20:12the shower that you provided previously
- 20:15uh about the type of
- 20:20something on the tile or something like
- 20:22that do you remember there's tile in the
- 20:23tent or was it crack where was the crack
- 20:27it's not a memory test if you don't
- 20:29remember that's fine but we we
- 20:31remembered that detail when we took some
- 20:33of these poses and we just wanted to
- 20:35bump it up against what you might want
- 20:39I don't know I don't know
- 20:45in general are we talking about okay
- 20:51fine that's okay
- 20:54take your time
- 20:57I don't know
- 20:59I know I remember there's a crack I'm
- 21:00not
- 21:02so for like trying to do you remember if
- 21:04it was high or low was it any of those
- 21:07like details horizontal vertical
- 21:12one tile lots of tiles
- 21:30not sure if I'm supposed to can I talk
- 21:32yeah
- 21:34I'm sorry that's okay I'm trying to like
- 21:37get myself there and just as a reminder
- 21:39I do remember when we went to my
- 21:41grandma's house
- 21:42he didn't like her tile because it
- 21:44reminded you of that I think I said you
- 21:47sent us the picture yes that's why I
- 21:48would say that's us I just want to
- 21:49remind her because if you think of that
- 21:51because I can't even think of what her
- 21:52title looks like right now but I do
- 21:53remember you didn't like that at all
- 21:55but I can't remember the crack I
- 21:57remember he told me crack but I remember
- 21:59what he told me I know I said bring it
- 22:01up but yeah I don't know I'm I'm so
- 22:03nervous of like saying something that's
- 22:05not gonna be right so
- 22:07I I just can't remember like I said in
- 22:09the beginning we only want the truth and
- 22:11so whatever is the best
- 22:18so then this is starting to
- 22:28it doesn't look right
- 22:31to me
- 22:33but
- 22:35so this crack is in a different location
- 22:37than this crack which is probably better
- 22:39view than this photo
- 22:44[Music]
- 22:48but this is the same bathroom we showed
- 22:50you the
- 22:52Charming magazine on the sports news
- 23:02it's nothing jumps out of you at that
- 23:03point we're not trying to overwhelm you
- 23:05obviously it's been a long road and and
- 23:08here we are
- 23:10but if we could go back to the closet
- 23:12really quick though I remember when you
- 23:15were talking about
- 23:16being changed into a closet
- 23:19and trying to figure out a way to get
- 23:21loose
- 23:22he talked about working on a screw right
- 23:26and what happened to that screw when you
- 23:28were done with it I dug a hole in the
- 23:30wall and poked it into the wall okay
- 23:33because this is
- 23:35an interesting photo as well
- 23:40is this in the closet that's in the
- 23:43closet no it was it was drywall it was
- 23:47into the driveway it wasn't too drywall
- 23:48but by the electric plug yeah okay
- 23:54maybe not that one yeah
- 23:57Okay so
- 24:01we're showing you all of this
- 24:05because ultimately this is the house
- 24:09thank you for that
- 24:11we talked to the people who live there
- 24:15sorry
- 24:18we've we found the house we found who
- 24:21was involved and we've talked to who is
- 24:23involved we talked to family who who
- 24:27knows that you were there and talked to
- 24:31a couple people that or talked to one
- 24:33guy who did see you
- 24:36during this event
- 24:38uh
- 24:39fortunately
- 24:41there's a lot of truth there's a lot of
- 24:43things that were that were said that we
- 24:46have always conferred that we've always
- 24:48said
- 24:49there's there's a lot of Truth and then
- 24:51there's some unknowns like one of the
- 24:53simple ones like well this description
- 24:55of the bathroom is just weird like that
- 24:57was like an argument in all of our
- 24:59offices where we were sitting there like
- 25:00this this part's weird but then we find
- 25:04a house with it then the the all thread
- 25:07through the thing that's just and that's
- 25:09just weird it's Unique to this place
- 25:12like that's a pretty custom you can't
- 25:15just go out to Ikea and buy a closet
- 25:17that looks like this yeah exactly right
- 25:18so once once we have all those things
- 25:21and we start talking to the person who
- 25:23lives here who had lived there who still
- 25:26lives there started talking to his
- 25:28family and starting that whole
- 25:30investigation peeling one thing back
- 25:32after another after another doing the
- 25:33same thing we've done for the last four
- 25:36years
- 25:37it led us to a specific person
- 25:41but not a female
- 25:43that led us to the car that picked you
- 25:45up but not an SUV
- 25:48so there's lots of different aspects
- 25:50that are truths and falses
- 25:53and we're to the point now that nobody
- 25:57would have ever imagined that this would
- 26:00have blown up the way that it did so
- 26:03I've been a cop 15 years I've never seen
- 26:06the media scale that that this garnered
- 26:09pretty quickly
- 26:13law enforcement now 12 years in the
- 26:15bureau so like of the minds Brian who'd
- 26:19been around 20 plus years people have
- 26:20been in my office like 25 30 plus years
- 26:24the media attention that this got out
- 26:26was was insane
- 26:30um so I think with that being said some
- 26:33choices and some decisions
- 26:35ultimately ultimately changed the
- 26:38original path of of what happened
- 26:42um
- 26:42I don't think anybody would have
- 26:45wished the media frenzy that occurred
- 26:48like for this event no matter what the
- 26:50situation if it was a kid because the
- 26:53media has skewed so many facts it it
- 26:55brought so many people in from the
- 26:57woodwork that if we didn't have the
- 26:59woodwork we wouldn't have the noise and
- 27:00that brings a lot of pressure
- 27:02when you get that kind of scrutiny
- 27:05so we we'd like to talk to you more
- 27:07about those things and we can do it with
- 27:09Keith here or we're going to ask you to
- 27:11leave to whatever you're comfortable
- 27:14with so we can
- 27:15break down some of the problems if you
- 27:19want Keith here all we want is to to
- 27:22have the truth all we want is be able to
- 27:24tell the truth
- 27:26all of that's all we've ever wanted from
- 27:28day one
- 27:30we win we've talked with you for hours
- 27:32we've been there we've done all these
- 27:34different things waiting for something
- 27:36waiting for it to break waiting for us
- 27:38to get
- 27:39Fleet something to hear
- 27:41because the DNA came back like I said to
- 27:44a specific person
- 27:45that specific person told us very
- 27:48specific things
- 27:50his family then told us specific things
- 27:55so if we can talk with Keith or without
- 27:58Keith here
- 28:00what would you like
- 28:12it's completely up to you
- 28:16and like I've always said I wanted you
- 28:18to have a voice I want you to make
- 28:21decisions I wanted you to control
- 28:22certain aspects I think I told you that
- 28:25on the first interview we ever had I
- 28:27never want to bully you I never want you
- 28:29to believe I'm bullying you I want you
- 28:31to take back control
- 28:33that's one of those things this is that
- 28:36take back control of the interview which
- 28:38I promise you to do the first time you
- 28:40talk if you remember that actually we
- 28:43were in Mount Shasta so the second time
- 28:44we talked
- 28:46um it's been a long road Journey but we
- 28:48just want to talk to you and we can have
- 28:50some kids step out that's gonna make you
- 28:51more comfortable
- 28:54it's up to you
- 28:58do you want to step out or do you want
- 28:59to stay
- 29:00obviously I want to stay
- 29:05or we can do a little bit of Bolt talk
- 29:07to your room first and then we'll come
- 29:08back in
- 29:15and it's completely up to you and that's
- 29:19why I'm not even looking at keys I don't
- 29:21care about your opinion uh
- 29:23I what we want out of this is just
- 29:27it's the truth
- 29:29so we can get ahead of some things so we
- 29:31can help control things
- 29:33how crazy things got so the unknown of
- 29:37if I say certain things what's Keith's
- 29:39reaction
- 29:40because you don't know what I'm going to
- 29:41say right so I don't know Keith's
- 29:43reaction either so if I say other things
- 29:46like oh Keith won't worry about that he
- 29:47can come back in but I'd rather give you
- 29:49the opportunity to hear things be able
- 29:53to judge it because of everything right
- 29:55I'm saying things to you that are making
- 29:57a nerve it's making Keith nervous
- 30:00it's changing value right what we change
- 30:03the tone of the interview you can feel
- 30:04it already in the room from the way you
- 30:05walked into what you're feeling right
- 30:07now
- 30:09so well I mean law enforcement has
- 30:12always been an issue so
- 30:16if if you want to keep the lead I'll ask
- 30:19Keith nicely to leave if you don't want
- 30:22to keep the lead then he can press on
- 30:26we'll move on to the next stages
- 30:29but I want to give you the opportunity
- 30:32first
- 30:40but obviously everything's fearful if
- 30:43you tell him to leave and what I'm going
- 30:45to say is benign
- 30:47then then he's gonna we can pull him
- 30:49back in the room like hey Keith come
- 30:51back again this is what this is what we
- 30:53talked about
- 30:55um so so that fear of him wigging out
- 30:58why is she trying to hide something from
- 31:00me
- 31:01there isn't then if there's been helping
- 31:03me yeah there's no trick here we're just
- 31:04trying to make sure that yeah there's
- 31:06comfortable to stop because you can't be
- 31:07able to talk to us truthfully
- 31:21if you wanted to
- 31:22chapter 10 privately that's fine too but
- 31:25we want to talk to you we can leave the
- 31:26room to give you guys the room for a
- 31:28couple minutes
- 31:29um this next stage of things could be
- 31:32could be benign could be like I've oh we
- 31:36forgot to tell you this or oh yeah all
- 31:39these things make sense now
- 31:40because I could tell you the puzzle that
- 31:43makes it all come together or I can tell
- 31:45the puzzle that crashes everything apart
- 31:46I don't know what that piece is honestly
- 31:49all I know is facts all I know is
- 31:51certain specific items that will either
- 31:54tear the castle down or is going to
- 31:55build the castle up and I don't want to
- 31:58I don't want to build tear the castle
- 31:59down and not give you the ability to
- 32:03then fix your own castle even if it's
- 32:05just a small thing here or it's the
- 32:07whole castle I want you to be able to to
- 32:11choose that so we can step out of the
- 32:13room let you guys talk because I don't
- 32:16know what information I'm going to do if
- 32:18it's life-changing news or if it's oh
- 32:20yeah everything's fine I just don't know
- 32:23what it is usually right we show the
- 32:26pictures because everybody's invested in
- 32:28this picture
- 32:29please do the drawings he's the only way
- 32:31to gave this stuff so Keith has always
- 32:34been a part of your memory for small
- 32:35details and that's why he's been into
- 32:39this whole time and that's why he makes
- 32:41me feel safe so if he makes you feel
- 32:43safe too
- 32:45much absolutely
- 32:48and again I just don't know what the
- 32:50pieces are so if I would say hey that's
- 32:52going to bring the whole world down I
- 32:54tell you
- 33:01but that's completely up to you guys
- 33:04because I don't know
- 33:06we'll be right back
- 33:23you need to stop waiting room yeah
- 33:34[Music]
- 33:58I don't know I don't want them to find
- 34:00her you're not listening to me
- 34:03because she saved my life
- 34:12looking at targeting right now right now
- 34:14I am
- 34:21I don't want to go down that road
- 34:26I don't want to go down there
- 34:29foreign
- 34:31she's the reason why I get to hold my
- 34:33children every single day
- 34:45I don't want them to arrest her
- 34:48why because she saved my life so you
- 34:52don't trust her
- 35:02okay no matter what do you think this
- 35:04just sits here
- 35:07just come down and they found the house
- 35:09it's over whatever happened
- 35:12it doesn't matter what you say they're
- 35:14getting the girls
- 35:23if you don't want to press charges
- 35:32[Music]
- 35:34you're not making sense
- 35:39point where I'm getting scared now
- 35:44you need to
- 35:47[Music]
- 35:48make
- 35:57[Music]
- 36:04and obviously hopefully you've had a
- 36:06chance to chat briefly the fears later
- 36:09maybe
- 36:12nothing that we that I'll say to you I
- 36:15won't eventually tell him if you want me
- 36:17to
- 36:18I mean
- 36:22we would love to hear what you're doing
- 36:25because we want to be able to address
- 36:26them as best we can
- 36:38I don't know I don't know
- 36:44yeah I feel like you're you're in the
- 36:46driver's seat right now I think it's
- 36:49easier to control things once you know
- 36:51what the information is let's be honest
- 36:53with you sure so the I can tell you what
- 36:56it is uh say what it is when Keith
- 37:00leaves and then you can say yes or no
- 37:03whether or not you want him in there for
- 37:04the rest of it right now he's just am I
- 37:07in the room or at my other room and I'm
- 37:10and I'm to the point where if you want
- 37:12him here we'll just go on with the
- 37:13conversation as long as you're not
- 37:15interrupting it's been awesome stay over
- 37:18here
- 37:20but if he steps out I can say a name
- 37:24and then you can choose whether you want
- 37:26you want them in here for the rest of it
- 37:27or not it's completely up to you or I
- 37:30can just continue on and
- 37:32again like I said I wanted you to always
- 37:34have control uh
- 37:36over certain aspects of stuff
- 37:51we're not to a point where anybody's
- 37:53going to jail yet or not to a point of
- 37:55any anything like that we're we're just
- 37:58still at the talking stage we're at the
- 38:00control stage yeah
- 38:03you seem scary sharing
- 38:06what is it
- 38:26what
- 38:29happened
- 38:36when you don't answer Sherry
- 38:40it makes me concerned because I want to
- 38:42hear what your answers are and I want to
- 38:44be able to
- 38:46understand
- 38:48all the way to control things
- 38:50[Music]
- 38:55I don't want you to find her
- 38:58We're not gonna find her
- 39:01she's the reason why I get to see my
- 39:03children every day
- 39:05I agree but we're not gonna find her
- 39:07she's the reason what do you mean by
- 39:08that she means the younger one Let Her
- 39:10Go
- 39:11right that's how you're referring to
- 39:15um
- 39:15We're not gonna find her
- 39:18and we can we can just skip to we can
- 39:21skip to the rock into the water and
- 39:23ruffle up the pond if we want to now
- 39:25again this is your last offer this is
- 39:29the last time if you want to do this
- 39:30alone or with Keith
- 39:31he's been through this also on a
- 39:34different level
- 39:36so I'm I'm ready just to I'm ready to
- 39:40move on and throw the dart and throw the
- 39:42Rock and see what happens to the water
- 39:44but sure look at me what do you want
- 39:48I don't want her to get in trouble she's
- 39:51not going to get in trouble
- 39:53so the DNA came back to James Reyes
- 39:58the DNA that was on you belongs to James
- 40:02Grace the picture and can I get the
- 40:04picture
- 40:05the picture of the table
- 40:09is James Rays his little brother died
- 40:12recently that he we talked to him
- 40:19we've been on a polygraph
- 40:21we talked to everybody around him we
- 40:24have the rental agreements phone rental
- 40:27car rental agreements
- 40:29we have we have everything
- 40:31that says that he said he told me that's
- 40:35James brother
- 40:36deceased Nick
- 40:38so everything you've told us so many
- 40:42truths in this situation the reason why
- 40:45you can describe the room is because you
- 40:48stayed in the room in the dark for hours
- 40:50for days on end
- 40:52the reason why you lost so much weight
- 40:54is because you stopped eating the reason
- 40:56why you got a rash on your arm is
- 40:58because you cleaned his house
- 41:00the reason why the brand is because he
- 41:03went to the store bought the brand new
- 41:04tools and branded you the reason why
- 41:07your nose was broke is because of a
- 41:09hockey stick
- 41:11I know all of those things and I know
- 41:14there was no sex I know all of that
- 41:17because he passed a polygraph test that
- 41:20said it's not an abduction she asked me
- 41:23to come get her no I rented a car and I
- 41:27drove up and picked her up
- 41:29he passed the polygraph test Sherry
- 41:33that's not what happened what didn't
- 41:34happen Sharon
- 41:39there's no way it's changed there's no
- 41:42way there's no winning the DNA doesn't
- 41:45lie his DNA his DNA was on him
- 41:48Robert saw you in the house
- 41:52while you were down there while
- 41:54everything is supposed to control his
- 41:57cousin
- 41:58why everything ran out of control on the
- 42:01initial
- 42:02there's no way
- 42:05100 Roberts or James's DNA
- 42:10even collecting blonde hairs from the
- 42:12room
- 42:14it's snowing there's no way I like that
- 42:18it is why are you saying that's not
- 42:19James
- 42:23why are you saying this no
- 42:28it hurts me what's up
- 42:31oh your friend there's no way and he
- 42:35came and got you because you asked him
- 42:37dude when was the last time you had
- 42:40contact with James
- 42:44brother died in 2017.
- 42:48that right
- 42:51hey
- 42:54was it before or after the abduction
- 42:57for
- 43:02when was the last time you saw James
- 43:07foreign
- 43:11ago when I lived in Southern California
- 43:14so the last person to person contact you
- 43:17had with him was back in 2006.
- 43:20when you were living in Southern
- 43:21California I don't know
- 43:25so was it prior to your marriage
- 43:29it's him there is no way it's him
- 43:32the DNA tells us that it was his DNA on
- 43:35him
- 43:36the DNA Alone says it's him and when we
- 43:40talk to him confront them with the DNA
- 43:42he tells us what happened he 100 told us
- 43:45what happened and gave us details that
- 43:46nobody else would know and we can call
- 43:48him and we can all talk about it
- 43:51But ultimately
- 43:54can you look at me for a second
- 43:55ultimately we put him on a polygraph
- 43:57like we did Keith
- 44:00Keith was inconclusive to be honest with
- 44:03you
- 44:03students on whether he was involved or
- 44:06not
- 44:07but 100 James was telling the truth
- 44:11questions were
- 44:13did Sherry ask you to come pick her up
- 44:15he answered yes that was a truth on a
- 44:18polygraph
- 44:19we asked if you the two of you ever had
- 44:21sex the answer was no
- 44:24in 2016 during 2016 during the abduction
- 44:28he said no that was a truth
- 44:30we asked him if you asked him to Brand
- 44:32if you asked him to Brand you
- 44:35the answer was yes
- 44:37you pass the polygraph on all of those
- 44:39questions
- 44:42he took us to the stores where he bought
- 44:44the chain
- 44:45he taught me talked to the friend who
- 44:47were in the car
- 44:48a car that he rented drove over 900
- 44:50miles in a day
- 44:53on the drop-off point
- 44:57sure I know there was a lot to take in
- 45:01also it's not like we don't know the
- 45:02answers to these questions and the fear
- 45:05of fear of the Keith's reaction
- 45:07obviously now he's in the room
- 45:09the fear of the media the fear of all of
- 45:14these things are coming are coming
- 45:16forward they're in front of you now
- 45:19the only way to get a hold of it the
- 45:22only way for everybody to come together
- 45:24and heal the whole Community has to heal
- 45:26is to for us to be able to say when we
- 45:31when we presented all of the evidence
- 45:32all the stuff that came forward
- 45:36she you told us the truth
- 45:38you told us what happened
- 45:40because
- 45:41you did go in a dark room that's true
- 45:44you did explain the back seat of the car
- 45:47that's true
- 45:49you did
- 45:50lose weight you were branded your hair
- 45:53was cut you did have bruises all over
- 45:56but how those bruises got there are
- 45:59because you did it and James did so
- 46:02the reason why your nose got broke is
- 46:04because you held the hockey stick to
- 46:05your face and forced it into your nose
- 46:08the reason why the brand is in a
- 46:10straight line is because he did it he
- 46:13described exactly where it was he told
- 46:16us exactly how he did it where he did it
- 46:18how he did it
- 46:19only you and I and maybe five other
- 46:22people know where the brand was
- 46:24he told me immediately
- 46:28Robert told friends and family you were
- 46:30there his mom knew that you were there
- 46:31because of course it went news and
- 46:33everybody knew you guys dated everybody
- 46:35has nothing new you guys had a
- 46:36relationship so when it happened of
- 46:38course family reached out to him he told
- 46:40him yeah she was here
- 46:41but it said it hurt her I didn't hurt
- 46:43her
- 46:51so what are you thinking Sharon
- 46:54that doesn't make any sense why does it
- 46:57make sense
- 47:00what actions doesn't make sense
- 47:02a lot of it doesn't
- 47:06want me to talk about those
- 47:09no
- 47:13James DNA was confirmed on you on your
- 47:16phone
- 47:18two of you haven't seen each other in
- 47:19over a decade
- 47:21if you told me that you haven't been in
- 47:23his room you haven't had contact with
- 47:25him over 10 years however you described
- 47:28his bedroom to a tennis and the DNA on
- 47:31you was still a vibrant piece of DNA
- 47:3410 year old DNA dies
- 47:37the DNA that was there specifically was
- 47:40non-symmal fluidness with symbols
- 47:42fractions
- 47:45you got that from his house somewhere
- 47:48so whether he was the bed that you were
- 47:50sleeping on where it was the couch
- 47:51whether it was anywhere in there
- 47:56when somebody would come to the door and
- 47:58be around the property you would call
- 48:00James James would call Robert which is
- 48:02lives two doors down Robert would run
- 48:05people off the property
- 48:07Robert told me all of that
- 48:09James told me everything
- 48:12to the only person that hasn't
- 48:15started telling us certain facts there
- 48:17are certain facts that are true when we
- 48:20were sitting there talking to James
- 48:21there were so many truths that were a
- 48:24part of your story that it's hard to
- 48:26decipher the lies
- 48:28until we put it all together until he
- 48:31says hey why how did you pick her up I
- 48:34opened up the passenger side seat I
- 48:36opened the door you jumped in the back
- 48:38seat why'd you why'd you do that why'd
- 48:40you do that I don't know
- 48:42it was weird
- 48:44so we're sorry you are you calling James
- 48:47a liar
- 48:49do we not are we not believing James
- 48:51what he told me no
- 48:57I know I know you're I cannot believe
- 49:00that it is James
- 49:02I can't believe James told us the truth
- 49:04that's why I can't believe
- 49:08he passed a polygraph shirt so do Keith
- 49:14and he was involved so James is involved
- 49:18so James is involved but I don't pick
- 49:20you up
- 49:21called James to pick you up you may
- 49:24you missed your address
- 49:26no you use the burner phone to call
- 49:28another burner phone for James to come
- 49:31and get you you're saying since you're
- 49:32married you haven't called James
- 49:37as earlier you said you had
- 49:39contacted James
- 49:41his phone records though that you do you
- 49:44did
- 49:45the phones don't lie the DNA doesn't lie
- 49:47sharing
- 49:49his polygraph doesn't lie so we can you
- 49:51can go a couple different directions now
- 49:52his story I've already told you lying to
- 49:54me is a crime so you walk out the store
- 49:56telling lies and that's a crime
- 50:02this isn't making any sense that's not
- 50:05making fun sure
- 50:06the parts that it's James no the parts
- 50:09that don't make sense are that you're
- 50:11accusing two females
- 50:13who abducted you when it was James
- 50:16the part that you were branded James did
- 50:18it he told me you know who who would sit
- 50:21there and say no I branded her Brandon
- 50:24Sherry on her right shoulders like who
- 50:26does that until this hour and showed us
- 50:29the letters that matched the brand took
- 50:30us to the store and pointed out the
- 50:32letters
- 50:38but the problem is today today's the
- 50:40case as a result
- 50:43everything the only things well
- 50:46how do we prove that you're telling us
- 50:47the truth
- 50:49how do we prove that the truth the truth
- 50:52is that two women took you but I I'm
- 50:54telling you it's a mayor
- 50:56the the fact that you were branded is
- 50:58true the small fact is that you
- 51:01willingly lay down and did it versus
- 51:03being tied to a table
- 51:05so we could always we could do the
- 51:07polygraph and try to whatever parts are
- 51:09you're confused about
- 51:19the fears of how out of control
- 51:22everything got
- 51:23fear of all these things is the reality
- 51:28and the only people that can slow the
- 51:30train down is you and I
- 51:34you put yourself through this so when
- 51:37you came forward you can tell certain
- 51:39stories
- 51:40you missed
- 51:41the
- 51:43you couldn't control the DNA that we
- 51:46found
- 51:48you couldn't control when we talked to
- 51:50James he'd tell us what happened
- 51:57the story always was hard for anybody to
- 51:59understand
- 52:01the tragedy that the community went
- 52:04through the events that unfolded
- 52:07the fear now of what what it all means
- 52:11but there's without a doubt James's DNA
- 52:14was on you
- 52:16can Delight no the likelihood of being
- 52:20an ex-boyfriend is a problem no
- 52:23no it's astronomical
- 52:27then you add in when we go talk to
- 52:29people who never even heard of us
- 52:31always hey what's going on here they
- 52:33knew that you were at the house
- 52:35all of them never came forward
- 52:41no
- 52:48you want to call James
- 52:55this was a long road
- 52:58I had no idea what it was going to take
- 53:00me
- 53:03but right now
- 53:06continuing and saying the two girls took
- 53:08use a lie to Peter
- 53:11it's just a lie
- 53:13because we were able to prove it with
- 53:14evidence
- 53:15with a rental car agreement a person
- 53:18driving to a thousand miles in a day
- 53:21the DNA on you
- 53:23and him passing a polygraph it's three
- 53:26legs to a Three Links to the table
- 53:35now's your opportunity
- 53:38[Music]
- 53:41based on your reaction previously what
- 53:44you're telling me is you did not call
- 53:45James and ask him to come get you
- 53:48is that what you're saying
- 53:51because if that's what you're saying I
- 53:53have to understand that
- 53:56there are things he says that we can
- 53:58corroborate and whatever you say we're
- 54:00going to try and corroborate
- 54:01but right now I'm not sure what you're
- 54:03saying you're just saying you can't
- 54:04believe it's him
- 54:06and you're saying you don't understand
- 54:09but there are deals details be provided
- 54:12we know he you were in his house
- 54:14we collected pairs from that bedroom
- 54:18that's going to have DNA we already have
- 54:20your hairs that you left with your cell
- 54:22phone when you were picked up
- 54:27so that's not gonna lie either
- 54:29the descriptions you provided are that
- 54:31room and that house to a t except
- 54:35it's not a gravel driveway and it's not
- 54:38elevated
- 54:40and there's not two women who live there
- 54:45James lives there you know James lives
- 54:48there
- 54:51so you might as well get out of your
- 54:52head that James is not involved and
- 54:54exchange is clearly involved and James
- 54:56already told us he's the one that did
- 54:57the brand
- 55:00something that he admitted to Mayhem he
- 55:03admitted to the felony you can put him
- 55:04in prisoner so how would that how do you
- 55:07it doesn't just it doesn't jive
- 55:10it's now it's your opportunity to say
- 55:12were there issues between you and Keith
- 55:14is that why you needed to leave I mean
- 55:17we read your text message we're already
- 55:18aware of some issues but Enlighten us if
- 55:20that's the case
- 55:22there was a valid reason for you to
- 55:24leave let me know what that was
- 55:26James said you had your job broken by
- 55:28him and that's why I came and got you
- 55:30because you were an abusive relationship
- 55:34were you an abusive relationship with
- 55:37him
- 55:39have you told other people in your life
- 55:41that China that Keith is abused you in
- 55:45the past when that wasn't true
- 55:48China told me that day two
- 55:51[Music]
- 55:53where there was an incident at a party
- 55:55that you got heard playing like I don't
- 55:58know we or Pictionary or something and
- 56:00then you told other friends that Keith
- 56:02heard you
- 56:03when there was Witnesses at the party
- 56:05that said you just that you got hurt
- 56:06during a party
- 56:08and you go tell
- 56:10James that you were being hurt you were
- 56:13being
- 56:14couldn't come forward because Keith has
- 56:16friends in law enforcement if all of
- 56:18that's is that true
- 56:24has Keith ever been abusive towards you
- 56:27we're not talking about my husband I
- 56:31love my husband
- 56:33so why leave
- 56:36is James lying to us
- 56:42[Music]
- 56:44children you can leave them permanently
- 56:47you came back to them ultimately no you
- 56:51lost them every day at Dixon daycare so
- 56:53it's not like hey
- 56:57and James talked about that decision
- 56:59when you were driving down how hard that
- 57:00was
- 57:01you left at 10 o'clock knowing that
- 57:03Keith was going to get home late knowing
- 57:05you were going to leave the kids at
- 57:06daycare and how much that tore you up on
- 57:09the drive down
- 57:11you told us that
- 57:15then things got out of control did I
- 57:16talked about that
- 57:18amen
- 57:25from work
- 57:27what happened
- 57:32there guys
- 57:37like when you're in Eureka you give them
- 57:39a call
- 57:40did you start chatting with him
- 57:44told him some of your problems
- 57:46when did it turn from just chatting to
- 57:49his plan to get away
- 57:52no no no no
- 57:56you're getting a hold of Donovan Minsky
- 57:58the night before
- 58:00that
- 58:03we're trying to understand why you did
- 58:05that too we're trying to understand all
- 58:07of it
- 58:12I'm doing them
- 58:13[Music]
- 58:16talking to other guys that has got any
- 58:19beard
- 58:22so are you what aspect are you saying
- 58:25right how how did how does dying other
- 58:26people got you here we've gone over
- 58:34shut it down but but we took it a step
- 58:37far though
- 58:39it's a little different than just
- 58:40chatting with them I I appreciate you
- 58:43talking and being forthright about
- 58:45the other guys you were talking to
- 58:48when did it turn into something more
- 58:51obviously you never would have imagined
- 58:53that CNN in 2020 and Good Morning
- 58:56America would care about you wanting to
- 58:59leave Keith or wanting to teach him a
- 59:01lesson no or wanted to get him in line
- 59:13how are you talking to James
- 59:17sure how were you talking to James
- 59:20laughs
- 59:22on your on your cell phone or another
- 59:26cell phone works
- 59:30[Music]
- 59:34here just to flirt
- 59:36what's your work cell phone number
- 59:40what's that I don't remember
- 59:48how long were you guys talking
- 59:51I don't know
- 59:54why would you have why would he rent a
- 59:56car and come and get you you don't know
- 1:00:00if you don't know that why would you get
- 1:00:01in the car and go down to Costa Mesa
- 1:00:07those are all things we can verify
- 1:00:08Sherry the car rental
- 1:00:11the fuel the mileage
- 1:00:14the calls from you to him the burner
- 1:00:17phone all that can be brewed adorable
- 1:00:21I don't think you're a horrible person
- 1:00:22sharing I think things went a little
- 1:00:24sideways on you we started this
- 1:00:26conversation with you what this was
- 1:00:28going to turn into
- 1:00:30I didn't know that I'd have people
- 1:00:32staying on boxes in front of my office
- 1:00:33that Keith would be on 2020.
- 1:00:37stupid
- 1:00:42from talking to other guys
- 1:00:45but why did why did James come and get
- 1:00:47you
- 1:00:49I know you guys were talking I know
- 1:00:51you've said at the path that Keith has
- 1:00:53hurt you to other friends why tell them
- 1:00:56those details if that stuff's not true
- 1:00:58it's one thing to talk
- 1:01:01it's one thing to talk it's another
- 1:01:03thing to to say abuses are occurring
- 1:01:07everybody I talk to about James says
- 1:01:09he's the nicest person in the whole
- 1:01:11world yeah he may be a hockey player but
- 1:01:13he is the nicest person in the world
- 1:01:15he's nice to a fault
- 1:01:20I don't I know lots of people I don't
- 1:01:22know anybody to rent a car for and drive
- 1:01:24nine hours for It Keith James did that
- 1:01:27for you
- 1:01:32he thought he was helping him he never
- 1:01:34asked you why he never questioned
- 1:01:36anything he never put money on the line
- 1:01:38he never asked for anything
- 1:01:41he didn't ask for sexual relations he
- 1:01:43didn't ask for a relationship after you
- 1:01:46he didn't ask for anything
- 1:01:48he's never even talked to you since
- 1:01:51and he's been quiet until now
- 1:01:54and the only reason why he talked is
- 1:01:56because we have his DNA
- 1:01:58that's the only reason why we got to his
- 1:02:00door that's the only thing that led us
- 1:02:02to his closet that's the only thing that
- 1:02:04led us to the bathroom up to Goofy
- 1:02:07and that's the only reason why he
- 1:02:08started talking to us
- 1:02:10once we showed him once he showed us the
- 1:02:12bedroom and we started pointing out the
- 1:02:14holes in the wall like you used to have
- 1:02:16this boarded up huh and he said yeah
- 1:02:18actually asked me to put boards up
- 1:02:24there's nobody's ever going to be asked
- 1:02:27to be able to answer why decisions were
- 1:02:29made
- 1:02:33you don't understand what
- 1:02:40what parts are you not sure he even
- 1:02:42showed us sure
- 1:02:44he even showed us the letters that we
- 1:02:46used for the ray the numbers
- 1:02:49I have pictures of them right here
- 1:02:55how would you have known that
- 1:02:58[Applause]
- 1:03:00why did you pick that Bible verse
- 1:03:13James took the Bible verse
- 1:03:27we need to be able to control the
- 1:03:29outcome and what's going to happen next
- 1:03:32the only thing we know is going to
- 1:03:34happen right now is what you can tell us
- 1:03:36what you can shed light on and for other
- 1:03:39people to be able to
- 1:03:42try to understand
- 1:03:44if it was a mistake it was a mistake
- 1:03:46but at this point
- 1:03:48not telling us what happened not telling
- 1:03:51us the truth is another mistake it's a
- 1:03:53mistake on top of a mistake
- 1:03:56right now we can start over
- 1:03:59we can we can end we can leave without
- 1:04:02without a dirty conscience without
- 1:04:04what's going to happen next
- 1:04:06right deep down inside Sherry I know you
- 1:04:08know what's right and what you
- 1:04:11want what you think should probably
- 1:04:18why do you ask James to come here
- 1:04:30U.S Donovan the night before to meet up
- 1:04:33with you
- 1:04:34everything happened at once
- 1:04:37you were asking me
- 1:04:40the best thing about this we were able
- 1:04:42to prove that diamond never came up here
- 1:04:45but now we can prove that James did
- 1:04:47for the records to prove it
- 1:04:53you might not think it was a good idea
- 1:04:55now 2020 hentai
- 1:04:58time
- 1:04:59why did you ask them to come pick you up
- 1:05:07was that I don't know
- 1:05:09foreign
- 1:05:15what's that
- 1:05:17candy
- 1:05:19it has changed
- 1:05:22the DNA doesn't lie
- 1:05:25this DNA was on you
- 1:05:28your DNA is going to be in that room one
- 1:05:31is septillion dollars change I don't
- 1:05:34even know how many zeros of septillion
- 1:05:35is that's why despite your description
- 1:05:38of how far you had gone in the car
- 1:05:41we already went down there we knocked on
- 1:05:43his door
- 1:05:45and took those pictures
- 1:05:51he understood that the dnaemi
- 1:05:53so he came clean
- 1:05:55now it's your chance to do the same
- 1:05:58and if you don't you're going to be
- 1:06:00championing your head later and say I
- 1:06:02should have told me what happened
- 1:06:04to me like that
- 1:06:07like what
- 1:06:14there's so many fears right now that we
- 1:06:16can't even wrap our head around it
- 1:06:18there's there's too many unknowns that
- 1:06:20we can't control
- 1:06:22we can't control what what the media is
- 1:06:24going to do we can't control what
- 1:06:29what everybody's going to think
- 1:06:31the only thing we can control right now
- 1:06:33is to control that that James told us
- 1:06:36the truth and that's that's a yes or no
- 1:06:42what did James lie about what did James
- 1:06:45lie to us about
- 1:06:48of the thing of the things I've told you
- 1:06:51I don't know
- 1:06:54I just don't know there's just no way
- 1:06:57give me James I just don't know I don't
- 1:07:00know
- 1:07:02that's not even question anymore we know
- 1:07:04you're in that room that's already click
- 1:07:08you described everything in the room
- 1:07:11what you're saying is it wasn't James
- 1:07:14that came and picked you up by the
- 1:07:15mailboxes is that what you're saying
- 1:07:18they're still two females
- 1:07:24is that what you're saying sure
- 1:07:31[Music]
- 1:07:33at the at the end of everything
- 1:07:36once we've you had to have known that
- 1:07:38this was going to come at some point
- 1:07:46I was talking to you so many guys
- 1:07:52yeah but then how did we get to Costa
- 1:07:56Rica Costa Mesa
- 1:07:58how do we get to L.A
- 1:08:01there's a big jump and a leap from
- 1:08:03talking to men
- 1:08:05to
- 1:08:06getting in a car with somebody without
- 1:08:08getting into a car with somebody is
- 1:08:10somebody you had a relationship with he
- 1:08:13told us about the abortion he told us
- 1:08:15about the your guys's relationship
- 1:08:19he told us about things that I don't
- 1:08:20know if you've ever told anybody about
- 1:08:24told us so many things
- 1:08:27and he did it all for you
- 1:08:29nobody else he got nothing out of this
- 1:08:31and you're welcome to go home Sharon but
- 1:08:34right now is your opportunity to tell us
- 1:08:36the truth and
- 1:08:46are you saying that it was two females
- 1:08:48that picked you up
- 1:08:51what's that
- 1:08:55every time I ask that question it seems
- 1:08:57like you don't answer it
- 1:09:01he sat in a room you drew out two people
- 1:09:04in a sketchery
- 1:09:06or what was two people the ones I took
- 1:09:08you that said yes or no
- 1:09:11I'm pretty clear of what I asked you
- 1:09:13earlier what did what did the younger
- 1:09:14one do you said the younger one point a
- 1:09:16gun at you
- 1:09:22she wasn't it was just James
- 1:09:26was two hours late we have the rental
- 1:09:28records for 2016 for the vehicle
- 1:09:32used why because we wouldn't look for it
- 1:09:36because he told me
- 1:09:45we have to control what we can control
- 1:09:51we're to the point the two did the
- 1:09:54younger female that you've always
- 1:09:55described is she the one that put a
- 1:09:57pointer guy is that true or not
- 1:10:03you you do know you told me earlier
- 1:10:05so earlier today when we were talking I
- 1:10:08asked you what did the younger one do
- 1:10:09you told me the younger one pointed a
- 1:10:11gun at you and let you go
- 1:10:14that's what you said
- 1:10:16and you let yourself go you let yourself
- 1:10:20out of the back seat never even said bye
- 1:10:22to James
- 1:10:23never thank you never enough just an
- 1:10:25hour yeah that's what James told me
- 1:10:28until you can start telling me that
- 1:10:30James is a liar and started pointing
- 1:10:32things out James passed a polygraph
- 1:10:37y
- 1:10:41it was such a stupid thing to do
- 1:10:46sorry without my children that's
- 1:10:49understandable here's the deal though
- 1:10:51sharing flirting with other men not a
- 1:10:54crime
- 1:10:56lying to me today yes I cried
- 1:11:01big difference
- 1:11:02telling your story of what happened to
- 1:11:04you isn't a crime and I know you're
- 1:11:06scared of what Keith is going to say and
- 1:11:07do what's going to happen with you and
- 1:11:09your family those are real concerns
- 1:11:12but we also need to understand the truth
- 1:11:17and you're in the best position to give
- 1:11:19us that
- 1:11:20you keep saying that it can't be him the
- 1:11:23DNA doesn't lie it's him you were
- 1:11:25talking now's the opportunity for you to
- 1:11:27tell us
- 1:11:29[Music]
- 1:11:31I'm talking again
- 1:11:37what when her brother died sure
- 1:11:40and that makes sense
- 1:11:42the problem we have is the actions after
- 1:11:45the talking after the flirting
- 1:11:48there was a big difference between
- 1:11:49talking on the phone and getting in a
- 1:11:51car with somebody
- 1:11:52so are you saying that James got two
- 1:11:55females to to kidnap you
- 1:11:57is that what you're trying to say
- 1:12:01you what do you mean you know
- 1:12:03so if James's DNA is on you
- 1:12:07are you so either either we're still
- 1:12:09saying the younger girl pointed a gun at
- 1:12:10you
- 1:12:11or we're saying we don't know
- 1:12:14you've already told me that today that a
- 1:12:16younger girl playing a gun at you you
- 1:12:17said you didn't want her to get cut so
- 1:12:19are we still talking to the female let
- 1:12:21you go
- 1:12:26that's where we're at
- 1:12:28and and I don't know doesn't have
- 1:12:30Clarity
- 1:12:32on simple questions Sherry
- 1:12:35a very a very easy question
- 1:12:40did James pick you up
- 1:12:43you told me earlier that girl pointed a
- 1:12:45guy is that is that
- 1:12:47detail which one's true it's only one
- 1:12:50only one of those are true sharing
- 1:12:54you've told both of them I've told one
- 1:12:56you told the other
- 1:12:57which one's true
- 1:13:05does James need to go to jail for all
- 1:13:07this stuff
- 1:13:09that you asked him to do
- 1:13:19no nobody asked for this
- 1:13:21I sure I believe
- 1:13:24nobody asked for this
- 1:13:27nobody asked for ABC News to park out in
- 1:13:29your driveway there was no way you could
- 1:13:31have predicted that this was going to
- 1:13:32blow up and to be as big as it was
- 1:13:35not even cop I was going to turn into
- 1:13:37this big even when he first got the call
- 1:13:39he didn't think that CNN and ABC and
- 1:13:42everybody was going to care I'm going to
- 1:13:43find chairs in a couple days because I
- 1:13:45found donut that I found I found the
- 1:13:47people you're some of the people you
- 1:13:48were talking to I've never known about
- 1:13:50your work cell phone
- 1:13:51stupid
- 1:13:53but but we're Beyond we're beyond that
- 1:13:56small discretion we've talked about that
- 1:13:59discretion
- 1:14:00we've talked about Donovan
- 1:14:02right remember
- 1:14:04we talked about Donald
- 1:14:09who picked your was it James or was it a
- 1:14:12female that pointed again can you please
- 1:14:14answer that
- 1:14:17you're shaking your head no she will not
- 1:14:19get
- 1:14:20I'm not I'm not talking to you about
- 1:14:22that I'm not going to get anything in
- 1:14:24trouble I've told you before I do not
- 1:14:27want anyone to get in trouble well
- 1:14:29you're going to get yourself in trouble
- 1:14:30at this point that's where we're at
- 1:14:32so either either James you can do
- 1:14:34anything wrong I know you didn't do
- 1:14:36anything wrong right now you're not
- 1:14:37telling the truth which is doing
- 1:14:38something wrong
- 1:14:39that's where we're at
- 1:14:41James put himself on a polygraph
- 1:14:44talk to FBI agents he talked with Peter
- 1:14:46and I for six hours
- 1:14:48damn it
- 1:14:50he told us everything Sherry
- 1:14:53you told us so many truths because you
- 1:14:57put yourself through
- 1:15:03the one
- 1:15:05[Applause]
- 1:15:08we're saying James's DNA was on you we
- 1:15:11know you were you were in that room at
- 1:15:14his house
- 1:15:17then if it wasn't the woman
- 1:15:21putting a point of gun at you and put
- 1:15:23you in the car yes or no
- 1:15:24is that where we're at
- 1:15:29till November you don't remember as a
- 1:15:32female pointed against you and put you
- 1:15:33in the car you know what you're saying
- 1:15:35sure I've always told you I don't
- 1:15:37remember getting in the car I've always
- 1:15:39told you I don't remember getting in the
- 1:15:41car but did a female point of gun at you
- 1:15:43yes or no
- 1:15:50yes or no
- 1:15:52so I don't remember the thing you've
- 1:15:54already told me that today
- 1:15:55you know
- 1:15:57you know who you do it was always
- 1:16:00yeah the lady we showed you is with
- 1:16:02another rate
- 1:16:05now I know James opened the door for you
- 1:16:08whether you want to forget how you got
- 1:16:10in the car I'm okay with that
- 1:16:12but we've already you've already
- 1:16:14established today that's why I asked you
- 1:16:16today what did the younger girl do he
- 1:16:20said she let me go and she pointed a gun
- 1:16:22at me we didn't talk about how you got
- 1:16:24in the car right now I'm asking you get
- 1:16:26a younger female point a gun at you yes
- 1:16:29or no
- 1:16:32what
- 1:16:37I know you know who she is
- 1:16:40I don't want I really get in trouble you
- 1:16:44know who she is you're getting in
- 1:16:46trouble I didn't do anything but right
- 1:16:50now ask answer this one question
- 1:16:52get a female point of gun at you yes or
- 1:16:54no I am done speaking to you until I
- 1:16:57talked to a lawyer I will not arrest her
- 1:17:00I am with my children because of her
- 1:17:05disappoint true
- 1:17:10there is
- 1:17:13n't me I agree
- 1:17:16Sherry if you want to talk to your
- 1:17:18attorney that's fine we can wrap this up
- 1:17:20if you want to keep talking to us that's
- 1:17:22a separate story but you said you wanted
- 1:17:24to talk to your attorney so like I said
- 1:17:26from the beginning you're free to go and
- 1:17:28you can go I would ask you
- 1:17:30one more question just for your own
- 1:17:32welfare do you feel like harming
- 1:17:34yourself oh I'm welfare do you feel like
- 1:17:37harming yourself
- 1:17:39okay
- 1:17:44you're free to go and do that
- 1:17:51if you change your mind you want to come
- 1:17:54forward and talk to us
- 1:18:08you might have come and started talking
- 1:18:10to me
- 1:18:12foreign
- 1:18:44foreign
- 1:19:07[Music]
- 1:19:17foreign
- 1:19:49hit me with it I know yeah because this
- 1:19:52happened Monday
- 1:19:54no you're saying you can't tell me all
- 1:19:56this stuff it's still an ongoing
- 1:19:58investigation so
- 1:19:59you're not going to find that answer I
- 1:20:01mean
- 1:20:02that's the way it is
- 1:20:04can you help me you can throw me a bone
- 1:20:06and then go I mean she made it up is
- 1:20:07that where we're going right or is she
- 1:20:09trying to come over the whole mess We're
- 1:20:10not gonna give you any additional
- 1:20:11details obviously you've heard the
- 1:20:13questions so you can read through some
- 1:20:15of those and understand you've seen some
- 1:20:16of the photos yeah so you know some of
- 1:20:18the investigations
- 1:20:20and we did yeah but you can also notice
- 1:20:23your reaction compared to her reaction
- 1:20:25yeah no 100 that's what I'm saying from
- 1:20:28my side but now now you're telling me
- 1:20:29okay you guys can go home now well do
- 1:20:31you think I want her anywhere around my
- 1:20:33kids or around me at all at this point
- 1:20:34and again we've talked a lot I don't
- 1:20:37know what the next stages of this are
- 1:20:39that's why it's not that's why
- 1:20:40whatever whatever those decisions are I
- 1:20:43don't know but from a we can all agree
- 1:20:46that she's not all there then obviously
- 1:20:49if somebody can do something like that
- 1:20:50to their body and try to trick everybody
- 1:20:52that they're probably not fit it was
- 1:20:54four years ago
- 1:20:55we can't get into that but I would say
- 1:20:57Obviously we are concerned about the
- 1:20:59welfare we don't want any kind of
- 1:21:01domestic dispute between YouTube we also
- 1:21:03don't want so give me a quick legal not
- 1:21:06legal advice give me it from a sheriff
- 1:21:08if I don't want her in my house time
- 1:21:10what options do I have maybe that's the
- 1:21:13other screen orders
- 1:21:15that's legal stuff
- 1:21:19I'm not gonna I'm gonna tell her she has
- 1:21:21to go to her sisters or something I mean
- 1:21:22she's not going through my house tonight
- 1:21:23and I got a call the next stage of this
- 1:21:27please give me the courtesy of telling
- 1:21:29me when you're going to announce it so I
- 1:21:30cannot be in my home
- 1:21:32oh God damn I don't quit well I thought
- 1:21:35you said it's ongoing now well we're
- 1:21:38going to talk about that but
- 1:21:39it's going to happen quick I actually
- 1:21:41think he's thinking tomorrow
- 1:21:43in L.A so there's a there's a hornet's
- 1:21:46nest in L.A it only takes one person to
- 1:21:48go and that say Hey I know it actually
- 1:21:50happened I want 10 grand and now they
- 1:21:53run to La news and it glows up without
- 1:21:56our control
- 1:21:57so and I don't know the strategy we we
- 1:21:59still have to we had to get through this
- 1:22:01before we get there but this did is
- 1:22:05there anything you can tell me next I
- 1:22:07thought you said you're gonna tell me
- 1:22:08something when I came back in like we'll
- 1:22:09be
- 1:22:11the person that we talked to down there
- 1:22:12is absolutely involved no I know that
- 1:22:15everything you guys that guy's number so
- 1:22:18I thought I thought
- 1:22:20so that's that's where we're at
- 1:22:22all right and then what she said
- 1:22:25prescribed to be patient let it play out
- 1:22:27I know it's going to be really hard but
- 1:22:29it also makes it easier for you though
- 1:22:31the little kids aren't going to ask you
- 1:22:32as much as the media will no I
- 1:22:34understand the members your own family
- 1:22:35members and you can look at them with a
- 1:22:37straight face and say look they're not
- 1:22:38telling me yet
- 1:22:39but like you know incredible right now I
- 1:22:41was like well she you guys can give her
- 1:22:43a ride in the house I don't even want to
- 1:22:44have a car right now I don't know that's
- 1:22:46what he told me
- 1:22:48yeah I'm assuming so good range for her
- 1:22:50to get there because I need I need to
- 1:22:52make some point if you're going to
- 1:22:53release it that soon I'd like to call it
- 1:22:55more I don't know I can call you today
- 1:22:57I'm gonna go from this to another
- 1:22:59meeting
- 1:23:01and that means it means another meeting
- 1:23:03and then then we'll be figuring stuff
- 1:23:06out are you saying you want us to help
- 1:23:07people transport for her
- 1:23:09I mean you got to give me a couple I
- 1:23:11thought you guys were gonna call me back
- 1:23:12in here with her well she has to leave
- 1:23:14so she's really additional so I think
- 1:23:17we'll talk and I'm gonna we'll probably
- 1:23:22just try another one talking here so if
- 1:23:23I got to the car and then I'll be like
- 1:23:24I'm not going anywhere if you guys want
- 1:23:27to check out the car and then come back
- 1:23:27up and tell us if you need assistance
- 1:23:30I appreciate that
- 1:23:33I think I'm handled pretty good any
- 1:23:35punching walls or nothing obviously we
- 1:23:37appreciate that I'm in the shop
- 1:23:40okay
- 1:23:42all right thank you
- 1:23:46[Music]
- 1:23:53foreign
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Sherri Papini Interrogation by Shasta Co. Sheriff's detectives | Raw video by ABC10, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,698 words across 1,717 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.