YouTube2Text

She Held Her Own Head and Walked: The Survival of Alison Botha — Transcript

by TrueCrimeFM · 4,831 words · 758 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:07Hi everyone. I just wanted to give you a
  2. 0:09quick heads up before we begin. As
  3. 0:12usual, I take a break during the holiday
  4. 0:15season for obvious reasons and to prep
  5. 0:18for the upcoming year. This will be the
  6. 0:21last new true crime episode of 2025 and
  7. 0:25I'll pick up beginning on January 6th,
  8. 0:282026.
  9. 0:29In the meantime, if you haven't caught
  10. 0:31up with all of the previous episodes,
  11. 0:33it's a good time to do it. Thank you so
  12. 0:36much for your understanding. I
  13. 0:38appreciate it so much. Let's get on with
  14. 0:41this episode.
  15. 0:44Before we start, I need to warn you.
  16. 0:49This episode contains extremely graphic
  17. 0:53descriptions
  18. 0:54of violence,
  19. 0:57attempted murder, and trauma survival.
  20. 1:02It's not easy to hear
  21. 1:05was even worse to write this episode
  22. 1:09about. Felt sick to my stomach often.
  23. 1:13But we have to remember that this really
  24. 1:16happened to somebody.
  25. 1:20It's important to hear
  26. 1:23as much as we may not want to. It's a
  27. 1:25heartbreaking story, but it's also a
  28. 1:28story of resilience, of strength, and of
  29. 1:33something that borders on miraculous.
  30. 1:36If you're not in the right headsp space
  31. 1:39for that today, it's okay to come back
  32. 1:41later, or not at all. You need to take
  33. 1:44care of yourself. But I did want to let
  34. 1:46you know
  35. 1:48what you might be stepping into.
  36. 1:51I want you to imagine this for a minute.
  37. 1:56It's past midnight on a summer night in
  38. 1:59South Africa. You're 27.
  39. 2:04You've just been attacked,
  40. 2:07beaten,
  41. 2:08stabbed more times than you can count.
  42. 2:11If your throat's been slit so deeply
  43. 2:14that your windpipe is severed
  44. 2:17and somehow you're still alive,
  45. 2:21would you panic? Would you shut down?
  46. 2:24Would you even know what to do next?
  47. 2:27Allison Botha didn't have that luxury.
  48. 2:30She held her insides in with one hand,
  49. 2:34used the other hand to crawl through
  50. 2:37dirt, through broken asphalt, and when
  51. 2:41crawling wasn't enough, she stood. She
  52. 2:44stood up and walked herself to the road.
  53. 2:48Because if she died where she was, she
  54. 2:52knew that they would do it again.
  55. 2:55This is not just the story of a crime.
  56. 3:00It is the story of what happened after
  57. 3:04the survival, the justice, the scars,
  58. 3:06the system. And yeah, some of this, a
  59. 3:10lot of this might really piss you off
  60. 3:12because it it damn well should.
  61. 3:15Welcome to Beach House 34. I'm your
  62. 3:18host, Christine Worth.
  63. 3:20To understand how Allison got to where
  64. 3:24she was, we have to go back to that
  65. 3:27December afternoon, December 18th, 1994
  66. 3:32in Port Elizabeth, South Africa. Now,
  67. 3:36for those of us in North America,
  68. 3:38December might conjure up snow, cold
  69. 3:41holiday chaos,
  70. 3:43but not here. In South Africa, it's the
  71. 3:47heart of summer. And that Sunday, it was
  72. 3:50the perfect day for the beach. The kind
  73. 3:54of day that just says, "Whatever I have
  74. 3:57to do can wait. I deserve this."
  75. 4:02Ellison at the time was 27 and she had
  76. 4:05just returned back home to South Africa
  77. 4:08after spending 4 years overseas. She
  78. 4:11didn't have any big career plans. She
  79. 4:14even said herself that she wasn't sure
  80. 4:16what she was good at. still trying to
  81. 4:19find out her place in this world like
  82. 4:21most of us did in our late 20s. That
  83. 4:24day, she had hung out with friends,
  84. 4:27spent time in the sun, probably still
  85. 4:29smelled like sunscreen. Later that
  86. 4:31night, when her and her friends decided
  87. 4:33to order pizza, play some games, and
  88. 4:35just relax. It was normal. It was safe.
  89. 4:40It was familiar.
  90. 4:42Nothing about that day gave any
  91. 4:45indication of what Allison would have to
  92. 4:48face later.
  93. 4:50Almost as if she had been given this
  94. 4:53perfect day because the universe knew
  95. 4:56what she would have to go through later.
  96. 4:59She dropped her friend off after the
  97. 5:01night was over and picked up her laundry
  98. 5:03from her her place or friend's place
  99. 5:06before heading home. It was just like
  100. 5:08any other night. When she got to her own
  101. 5:11apartment complex, she noticed that her
  102. 5:14usual parking spot had been taken. And
  103. 5:16so what she did is she parked a little
  104. 5:18further down. That's it. That's the
  105. 5:21moment. The one tiny little thing that
  106. 5:26changed her life forever.
  107. 5:29And we've all had nights like these,
  108. 5:31right? You're walking back to your car
  109. 5:34or you're walking into your home. It's
  110. 5:36late, but it's fine. You know, you take
  111. 5:38this millisecond to weigh the risk and
  112. 5:41then shrug it off, thinking nothing of
  113. 5:43it. Who wants to live in constant fear
  114. 5:46anyway?
  115. 5:48It was then that Allison felt a knife to
  116. 5:52her throat.
  117. 5:53A man had reached in and said, "Move
  118. 5:57over or I'll kill you."
  119. 6:00What would you do? Would you freeze,
  120. 6:03fight,
  121. 6:05believe him when he said he just needed
  122. 6:07her car for an hour and that maybe if
  123. 6:09she stayed calm, he wouldn't hurt her?
  124. 6:13That's what he told her. And Allison
  125. 6:15chose to believe him. He said his name
  126. 6:18was Clinton.
  127. 6:20So, she unlocked her doors and he got
  128. 6:23in. And this is kind of where your brain
  129. 6:25goes to war with itself, right? Did you
  130. 6:28make the right decision? had you just
  131. 6:31chosen to be one of the women you swore
  132. 6:34you would never be.
  133. 6:37So, you start to mentally beat yourself
  134. 6:38up, but you're in the position now. What
  135. 6:41do you do? Do you cooperate and stay
  136. 6:43calm, play along, fight, jump out of the
  137. 6:47car?
  138. 6:49Allison chose to stay calm, and played
  139. 6:52along. He asked if she had a boyfriend
  140. 6:55and calmly spoke to her. They made a
  141. 6:58second stop. to pick up another man. And
  142. 7:02at this point, your alarm bells would be
  143. 7:04going off, right? Every instinct would
  144. 7:07be screaming at you to run, get out of
  145. 7:10the car, just leave.
  146. 7:13This new guy got in the back, didn't
  147. 7:16bother with small talk. He just slid
  148. 7:18into the seat. And Allison saw his eyes
  149. 7:22in the rearview mirror. And that's when
  150. 7:24she knew. quote, "All I saw was dead,
  151. 7:28cold evil, and I realized I wasn't going
  152. 7:32home." They drove out of town away from
  153. 7:36the street lights and into the dark. And
  154. 7:38that that's kind of one part that really
  155. 7:40sticks with me because you know that
  156. 7:44lots of lights usually mean people and
  157. 7:46other people potentially mean safety.
  158. 7:49When you see those lights disappear
  159. 7:51behind you, your hope just sinks.
  160. 7:55They drove into a secluded, deserted
  161. 7:59area near Nord Hook. This is a coastal
  162. 8:03area outside of what was then known as
  163. 8:05Port Elizabeth.
  164. 8:07One of them asked her if she was going
  165. 8:09to fight. She didn't know how to answer
  166. 8:12that. She didn't know how to fight, but
  167. 8:15would it have even mattered? It was two
  168. 8:17against one.
  169. 8:19She tried to keep her mind clear, clear
  170. 8:21as she could and tried to brace herself
  171. 8:24for what she knew was coming.
  172. 8:28The first man forced oral on her, then
  173. 8:32her. He made comments about her body,
  174. 8:35kissed her, asked her things like, "Does
  175. 8:38your boyfriend do this to you?"
  176. 8:40Let's be real clear about this.
  177. 8:43This was all about humiliation,
  178. 8:47domination, and cruelty.
  179. 8:50This is what like this want to pretend
  180. 8:54that control is consent.
  181. 8:59At some point during the assault, she
  182. 9:02learned that this guy's name, the guy
  183. 9:04who originally carjacked her, was not
  184. 9:08Clinton, but rather France.
  185. 9:12He then called to his friend Tens and
  186. 9:16asked if he wanted to come over and have
  187. 9:19with the pretty lady. Tien said, "No, I
  188. 9:22want to the bitch."
  189. 9:24Words just as cold as his soulless eyes.
  190. 9:32As horrific
  191. 9:34as this is, it is not the worst thing
  192. 9:38that happened to Ellison that night.
  193. 9:41It was just the beginning.
  194. 9:43This was not the first time that they'd
  195. 9:46done this. But the other women that
  196. 9:49they'd attacked, they'd let go.
  197. 9:52And these women eventually went to the
  198. 9:54police. Why they were out, we don't
  199. 9:58know.
  200. 10:00This time though, the men wanted to make
  201. 10:02sure that she wouldn't talk, that she
  202. 10:05couldn't identify them. I mean, after
  203. 10:07all, they'd used their names, right? She
  204. 10:10saw their faces.
  205. 10:12This is when Allison knew they were
  206. 10:15going to kill her.
  207. 10:17She said one of the last things that she
  208. 10:20remembers before blacking out was
  209. 10:23Franc's hands around her throat. She
  210. 10:26remembers her bowels evacuating.
  211. 10:29Her body knew before her brain did that
  212. 10:34this was it.
  213. 10:36But that wasn't all. They then stabbed
  214. 10:39her in the abdomen over 30 times. She
  215. 10:43would later learn that it was 37.
  216. 10:47And as if that wasn't enough for them,
  217. 10:50they then moved to her throat where she
  218. 10:52was stabbed and slashed 17 times.
  219. 10:5717.
  220. 10:59Overall, Allison had been stabbed 54
  221. 11:03times.
  222. 11:05When they were done, they drove off in
  223. 11:07her car, throwing her clothes out and
  224. 11:10left her there in the dirt, naked,
  225. 11:14mutilated, and bleeding to death.
  226. 11:18She should have died. They were counting
  227. 11:20on it. And for a moment, so did she. She
  228. 11:25remembers hearing a whistling sound, and
  229. 11:28she wasn't sure where it was coming
  230. 11:30from. She didn't feel any pain, but
  231. 11:34somehow she knew that it was the sound
  232. 11:37of her breathing through her severed
  233. 11:40windpipe.
  234. 11:43It was at that moment that Allison knew
  235. 11:46she wasn't going to live. And then she
  236. 11:49said that she remembers leaving her
  237. 11:51body, floating above it. that sound that
  238. 11:55had been coming from her severed neck
  239. 11:57that was devastatingly loud was gone.
  240. 12:02She also knew that as she was looking
  241. 12:05down at herself that she had a choice.
  242. 12:09She had a choice to go back and she
  243. 12:12remembers making that choice when all of
  244. 12:16a sudden she could hear that loud sound
  245. 12:18of her breathing coming again from her
  246. 12:21windpipe.
  247. 12:24Somehow she was conscious. She knew she
  248. 12:27wasn't supposed to be. She couldn't
  249. 12:29speak or scream, but realized that she
  250. 12:33was still alive. This should have been
  251. 12:35impossible.
  252. 12:37What happened next wasn't something that
  253. 12:39was supposed to happen either. She felt
  254. 12:42something wet around her legs and
  255. 12:46realized that her intestines were
  256. 12:49outside of her body. Those 37 stab
  257. 12:53wounds had cut her so much that she was
  258. 12:57literally spilling out over the sand.
  259. 13:01Nearby was one of her shirts, one of the
  260. 13:05pieces of clothing that the two men had
  261. 13:07tossed out of her car. She grabbed it
  262. 13:10and held it over her stomach.
  263. 13:13Then she started to crawl. Yes, crawl.
  264. 13:18Think about that. Would you have the
  265. 13:20presence of mind to do that, to move, to
  266. 13:23try and save yourself after what you
  267. 13:26knew were [music] devastating injuries,
  268. 13:28to even care what happened next?
  269. 13:31She knew she had chosen to come back.
  270. 13:34And she knew that she was crawling and
  271. 13:37surviving to make sure that these men
  272. 13:40couldn't do it again.
  273. 13:42She kept trying to crawl through sand
  274. 13:45and gravel and little pieces of glass.
  275. 13:49Soon she knew that she wasn't going to
  276. 13:51go far moving this way.
  277. 13:54And so she somehow got to her feet.
  278. 13:58And this this is one of those moments
  279. 14:01where you just can't believe what you're
  280. 14:04reading.
  281. 14:06But it happened. It really happened.
  282. 14:11After she stood up, her view of the
  283. 14:14world was skewed and she couldn't figure
  284. 14:17out why
  285. 14:19until, and honestly, this is the part
  286. 14:22that just makes me shudder and stand in
  287. 14:25awe all at the same time.
  288. 14:28The reason that she was seeing what she
  289. 14:31was seeing and the way she was seeing it
  290. 14:34was because when she stood up, her head
  291. 14:37had flopped backwards. Her neck muscles
  292. 14:40had been cut so much that they could no
  293. 14:43longer support the weight of her skull.
  294. 14:46So, she grabbed her head and held it
  295. 14:49upright as she began to walk once again.
  296. 14:53Let me say that again. She held her own
  297. 14:56head up and walked.
  298. 15:01Somehow, she made it to a road where she
  299. 15:04ended up collapsing.
  300. 15:07And then after a time there were
  301. 15:09headlights.
  302. 15:11What if it was them coming back to make
  303. 15:14sure that the job was done? She'd come
  304. 15:16so far now had somehow summoned the
  305. 15:21strength to not only keep her body
  306. 15:24together, but to walk to a place where
  307. 15:27she'd be seen
  308. 15:29only to have it all taken away again.
  309. 15:33Thankfully, it wasn't. It was a young
  310. 15:36veterinary student, all of 20 years old.
  311. 15:39Can you imagine?
  312. 15:41He stopped, saw her there naked, bloody,
  313. 15:45barely clinging to life. He held her
  314. 15:48hand, told her she had beautiful eyes,
  315. 15:52and held on to Allison for dear life
  316. 15:54until help came.
  317. 15:56The student that had stopped had a
  318. 16:00friend with him who happened to have a
  319. 16:01cell phone. Now, back in 1994, cell
  320. 16:04phones, they weren't
  321. 16:06something that everybody had. They were
  322. 16:08relatively new, but for some reason,
  323. 16:11this person had one. So, they called for
  324. 16:14an ambulance and waited and waited.
  325. 16:1940 minutes later, the ambulance arrived.
  326. 16:23Once the ambulance did get there and
  327. 16:26loaded her up, the drive back to the
  328. 16:29hospital would take another 15 minutes.
  329. 16:33And according to Allison's documentary,
  330. 16:37they the ambulance people driving the
  331. 16:40ambulance
  332. 16:41weren't in too much of a hurry.
  333. 16:45She had to encourage them to speed it
  334. 16:47up. And the reason was they didn't think
  335. 16:50that she was going to survive all that
  336. 16:53trauma, all that blood loss, all that
  337. 16:55work to get to the road, all that
  338. 16:57waiting for help, and she was still
  339. 17:01alive.
  340. 17:03When she arrived at the hospital, even
  341. 17:05the most seasoned trauma surgeons were
  342. 17:08shocked. Doctors and nurses saw the
  343. 17:12damage and they braced themselves.
  344. 17:14expected a body,
  345. 17:17if not at the moment, than soon. Not a
  346. 17:20survivor. No one believed that Allison
  347. 17:23would last too much longer. The on call
  348. 17:26anesthesiologist that night was Dr.
  349. 17:29David Cummings. He said it was unlike
  350. 17:32anything he'd ever seen, and he works in
  351. 17:34trauma and intensive care. He'd seen
  352. 17:37violence.
  353. 17:39Allison's neck had been cut from ear to
  354. 17:42ear. Her windpipe had been severed. She
  355. 17:45was breathing through a hole just above
  356. 17:48her collar bones,
  357. 17:51but somehow her corateed artery, even
  358. 17:54her jugular vein
  359. 17:57were all intact.
  360. 17:59The doctor looked at her abdomen. Her
  361. 18:02small intestine was hanging out of her
  362. 18:04body, covered in sand and
  363. 18:09grit from when she'd crawled on the
  364. 18:12ground.
  365. 18:14The general surgeon on call, Dr.
  366. 18:17Dimmitri Angelov, was called in, and
  367. 18:20Cummings spoke to him and said that they
  368. 18:22were going to need help from an ENT
  369. 18:25specialist to manage the neck repair.
  370. 18:29But Angelof looked at him and said, "In
  371. 18:31my country, I am trained as both. I can
  372. 18:33do this." And he did.
  373. 18:37What followed was hours of meticulous
  374. 18:40and methodical surgery. Angelof cleaned
  375. 18:44each piece of Allison's intestines by
  376. 18:48hand. In some places, he had to use a
  377. 18:50scrub brush to remove debris that had
  378. 18:53become embedded. He reconstructed her
  379. 18:56windpipe, her neck muscles, and her
  380. 18:58abdominal wall.
  381. 19:00But there's no medical explanation for
  382. 19:03how Allison survived. Every textbook
  383. 19:07says she shouldn't have.
  384. 19:10Cummings later said, and this is a man
  385. 19:12of science, we must accept that it is a
  386. 19:16miracle.
  387. 19:17And sure, you can chalk it up to luck or
  388. 19:21surgical brilliance or some anatomical
  389. 19:24anomaly,
  390. 19:26but at the end of the day, you have to
  391. 19:28explain how a woman with her neck sliced
  392. 19:31open, her abdomen gutted, and a 40minute
  393. 19:34ambulance delay is alive and signing
  394. 19:38forms. Yes, signing forms.
  395. 19:43Because when Dr. Angelov handed her a
  396. 19:46consent form before surgery. Allison
  397. 19:49wrote her name clearly. She even added
  398. 19:52her mom's phone number underneath.
  399. 19:56This is a great story as it stands. A
  400. 20:00woman taken at knife point
  401. 20:03and stabbed so many times that even
  402. 20:05doctors didn't think she'd be able to
  403. 20:07survive. And yet she did.
  404. 20:10There's just one problem, though. She
  405. 20:12survived. Yes. But this didn't mean she
  406. 20:15was safe. Her attackers were still out
  407. 20:18there. Could they come to the hospital
  408. 20:21and finish the job once they learned
  409. 20:23she'd survived?
  410. 20:25The police definitely needed answers,
  411. 20:28and Allison was the only one who could
  412. 20:30give them.
  413. 20:32The night after her surgery was
  414. 20:34touchandgo, so much trauma, not only
  415. 20:38initially, but then the trauma of having
  416. 20:40to go through hours of surgery. Would it
  417. 20:43be enough? Would she survive the night?
  418. 20:47She did.
  419. 20:49But now she had to take on another
  420. 20:51battle. Justice. The police needed
  421. 20:54names. So they came to see her.
  422. 20:58Detective Inspector Melvin Hamill, who
  423. 21:01would become a major ally in this case,
  424. 21:04visited Allison and brought along a
  425. 21:07photo lineup. As she looked at the
  426. 21:10pictures, she found them, pointed them
  427. 21:13out and wrote down their names.
  428. 21:18France and teens.
  429. 21:21You'd think that would have been enough,
  430. 21:23right? Here's their pictures. Here's
  431. 21:26their names. She wrote them down for
  432. 21:28God's sakes. But the prosecution didn't
  433. 21:31think that would be enough. They wanted
  434. 21:34verbal confirmation. Yes, verbal
  435. 21:38confirmation.
  436. 21:40They said it would make the case
  437. 21:42stronger in court.
  438. 21:44One problem though, in order to speak,
  439. 21:47Allison would have to have her breathing
  440. 21:49tube removed. A incredibly inserious
  441. 21:54risk, especially with the fresh stitches
  442. 21:56that she had in and around her neck.
  443. 21:59Dr. Cummings was horrified, and I'll
  444. 22:02admit, when I learned this, I was too.
  445. 22:04They couldn't wait until she had healed
  446. 22:07some more, until she had the ability to
  447. 22:09speak. Were they not going to go after
  448. 22:11these guys unless she had said their
  449. 22:14names?
  450. 22:15That's a sight of cruel that you don't
  451. 22:18often see.
  452. 22:20But Allison, when she realized this,
  453. 22:23wrote, "Take it out."
  454. 22:26So her doctors did. And after removing
  455. 22:30her tube, she first said, "That's
  456. 22:34wonderful."
  457. 22:35And then said, "My attackers were France
  458. 22:39and teens.
  459. 22:42It's what the prosecution wanted. They
  460. 22:44got it." And a survivor, mutilated
  461. 22:47beyond belief, had just named the men
  462. 22:49who did this to her. And I know I
  463. 22:51mentioned this earlier, but here's the
  464. 22:53thing. France had already been arrested
  465. 22:56for before, not once, twice. He was
  466. 23:00walking around free. The same is true of
  467. 23:03teens.
  468. 23:05The first woman they attacked took a
  469. 23:07week before reporting it to the police
  470. 23:10because they threatened to kill her if
  471. 23:12she did. The second woman who was
  472. 23:15pregnant, yes, pregnant, ran straight to
  473. 23:18the police and reported it right away,
  474. 23:21even after she too had received death
  475. 23:24threats.
  476. 23:26By the time the two men had gotten to
  477. 23:28Allison, they had decided that this time
  478. 23:30they would just kill her, reduce the
  479. 23:33risk of her telling anyone.
  480. 23:36The police found France and teens and
  481. 23:38brought them into the police station.
  482. 23:40They were read their rights and when one
  483. 23:42of the investigators got France alone to
  484. 23:45speak with him, he told him that he's
  485. 23:48being charged for attempted murder. That
  486. 23:51one single word, attempted.
  487. 23:56So he asked why attempted murder
  488. 24:00and he was told that Allison was alive.
  489. 24:05According to the investigator, you could
  490. 24:06have knocked him over with a feather.
  491. 24:10And here's something we don't hear every
  492. 24:12day from criminals, at least in the
  493. 24:13American justice system.
  494. 24:16France pretty much just gave up at that
  495. 24:19point. Said that he knew there was
  496. 24:21nothing he could hide from the police
  497. 24:23because Allison would tell them
  498. 24:24everything. He then took off a ring that
  499. 24:27he had on and handed it over, saying
  500. 24:31that it was Allison's.
  501. 24:33It still had her blood on it.
  502. 24:37France, it turns out, was married with a
  503. 24:39child. He would leave his place and head
  504. 24:43out with teens to go innocent women.
  505. 24:47Then came the trial.
  506. 24:50And you might be surprised to learn that
  507. 24:52the trial was 5 to 6 months after the
  508. 24:57attack on Allison.
  509. 25:00Five to six months. That's it.
  510. 25:04The thing was, even though Allison had
  511. 25:06survived,
  512. 25:08all that she did, she still was required
  513. 25:12to undergo multiple invasive exams
  514. 25:16by different cops in different rooms,
  515. 25:19having her pubic hair pulled for
  516. 25:21evidence, having to strip down so that
  517. 25:24officers could photograph the healing of
  518. 25:26her wounds.
  519. 25:28She never refused,
  520. 25:31but she shouldn't have had to be
  521. 25:33traumatized over and over like that.
  522. 25:38When it came time for a lineup, which
  523. 25:40was standard procedure in South Africa
  524. 25:42at the time, it required the victims to
  525. 25:46place a hand on the suspect's shoulder
  526. 25:49and have a photo taken.
  527. 25:52Let that sink in.
  528. 25:54You're supposed to physically touch the
  529. 25:57man who you mutilated you, left you for
  530. 26:01dead, and then pose for a photo.
  531. 26:06Allison's case changed all of that. Her
  532. 26:10investigating officer, Melvin Hample,
  533. 26:12was a huge supporter of Allison and
  534. 26:16didn't want her to have to do that
  535. 26:19thing, which frankly sounds barbaric,
  536. 26:22doesn't it?
  537. 26:23So he decided to try something new that
  538. 26:26had never happened in South Africa and
  539. 26:29pushed for a one-way glass lineup. It
  540. 26:32was the first time that it's ever been
  541. 26:34used in South Africa and today it's
  542. 26:36standard because of her and what
  543. 26:38investigator Melvin Hamble pushed for.
  544. 26:42She identified them again
  545. 26:46for the third time. And then finally, it
  546. 26:51was the actual trial. Allison had to sit
  547. 26:54in the same room with the men who had
  548. 26:57violated her and attempted to kill her.
  549. 27:01When in court, France sat there staring
  550. 27:05at her like he was trying to intimidate
  551. 27:07her. He even testified that he was a
  552. 27:11Satanist. claimed demonic possession.
  553. 27:15When it was all said and done, the judge
  554. 27:18handed down the harshest sentence
  555. 27:20possible, life in prison. He even added
  556. 27:24a special note in their records saying
  557. 27:27they should never be released.
  558. 27:30This is not something that he had done
  559. 27:32before or since.
  560. 27:35South Africa had just abolished the
  561. 27:37death penalty, but he wanted it made
  562. 27:39clear that if it had still been legal,
  563. 27:42he would have definitely considered it.
  564. 27:45For Allison, the verdict was justice,
  565. 27:48yes, but she still said it best when she
  566. 27:52said, "They took something from me I can
  567. 27:55never get back." The bad guys were
  568. 27:57caught. They were tried and sent to
  569. 27:59prison. But that didn't mean that
  570. 28:01Allison got her life back. Recovery for
  571. 28:04her wasn't some, you know, feelgood
  572. 28:07montage. It was pain every single day
  573. 28:12and not just physical pain. Her
  574. 28:14abdominal wound had to be scraped on a
  575. 28:17regular basis until it bled just to coax
  576. 28:21new tissue to grow. She couldn't bathe
  577. 28:24herself. She moved back in with her mom
  578. 28:26who became her full-time caregiver.
  579. 28:29Eventually though, the scars began to
  580. 28:32heal and Allison tried to get back to
  581. 28:35life, but she couldn't. She spiraled
  582. 28:40into depression. The kind of depression
  583. 28:42that just doesn't care. She stopped
  584. 28:44going to work. She stopped calling
  585. 28:46people back. She didn't care if she ate.
  586. 28:49She wasn't suicidal. She was detached
  587. 28:53until it finally hit her that she was
  588. 28:56still giving France and Ten the power
  589. 28:59over her life. So she made a choice
  590. 29:03again. Just like the night she walked
  591. 29:06herself up the road. She chose to live
  592. 29:09again.
  593. 29:11The turning point for Allison came when
  594. 29:14a local Rotary club asked her to speak.
  595. 29:17just a short talk, share her story.
  596. 29:21She didn't want to. Public speaking was
  597. 29:23one of her biggest fears growing up.
  598. 29:27But she did it anyway. And when she was
  599. 29:30finished,
  600. 29:32she felt better.
  601. 29:35So she spoke again and again. She found
  602. 29:39purpose in it. Not just in giving others
  603. 29:43hope, but in taking her own story back.
  604. 29:46She started traveling and sharing her
  605. 29:49message. Here's the thing, though.
  606. 29:51People, boy, they do love a comeback
  607. 29:54story, don't they? They want the person
  608. 29:56who had suffered so much to be healed.
  609. 30:00But Allison made it clear. There is
  610. 30:02never a finality, a point where I am
  611. 30:05healed. That's what people want for me.
  612. 30:08It's what I want for me, but it's not
  613. 30:11real.
  614. 30:13Once again, Allison defied all odds. Her
  615. 30:17injuries to her abdomen were so bad that
  616. 30:21she was told she would not be able to
  617. 30:23have children.
  618. 30:24Yet, she did.
  619. 30:27Two healthy pregnancies and two healthy
  620. 30:31boys.
  621. 30:33Years passed and she had found her
  622. 30:37purpose and the path for her grew a
  623. 30:40little bit brighter every day.
  624. 30:43until she learned that France and Tins
  625. 30:47might be up for parole.
  626. 30:51Let's back up. When the judge sentenced
  627. 30:54them, he added a note to their files,
  628. 30:56never to be released. And yet somehow
  629. 31:00there was talk of early release.
  630. 31:04Make it make sense. Everyone who had
  631. 31:08been involved in Allison's story, who
  632. 31:10had tried to move on with their lives,
  633. 31:13were all of a sudden once again drawn
  634. 31:16back into that black hole that they had
  635. 31:19all tried to climb out of, especially
  636. 31:22Allison.
  637. 31:24Then it was learned that France was
  638. 31:27having a full-blown social life from
  639. 31:29inside prison. He was posting on
  640. 31:32Facebook. He was messaging women. He
  641. 31:35even had a girlfriend in America. And it
  642. 31:38was this girlfriend's mom who contacted
  643. 31:41Allison directly begging for help.
  644. 31:45Let's be clear here. This is a convicted
  645. 31:49serial rapist with multiple victims
  646. 31:52surfing Facebook like it's Tinder.
  647. 31:56Media reports show that France was
  648. 31:59active on Facebook from prison on his
  649. 32:01phone. Yes, a freaking phone in prison
  650. 32:05and maintaining a social presence.
  651. 32:08And when Allison did the right thing,
  652. 32:11when she emailed the prison authorities
  653. 32:14asking them to investigate, and please
  654. 32:17don't tell France that it came from her,
  655. 32:20they printed her email and gave it to
  656. 32:23him.
  657. 32:25A survivor reports her own rapist
  658. 32:28breaking prison protocol
  659. 32:30and the system hands her over.
  660. 32:36The public record does not provide a
  661. 32:38clear date or show that this was tied to
  662. 32:41a parole decision at the time. But what
  663. 32:44we do know is this. It was July of 2023
  664. 32:49that both men were granted parole after
  665. 32:53serving nearly 29 years of their life
  666. 32:56sentences.
  667. 32:58They were out in public again.
  668. 33:02And the outrage was tremendous and never
  669. 33:07let up. In the meantime, just when you
  670. 33:10thought Allison had dealt with more than
  671. 33:13a human being ever should,
  672. 33:15in September of 2024,
  673. 33:18she woke up with a headache, the kind
  674. 33:21that you might shrug off, except this
  675. 33:23one was different. She collapsed at home
  676. 33:26and was rushed to the hospital.
  677. 33:29Scans showed a brain aneurysm.
  678. 33:33She couldn't speak. She couldn't move.
  679. 33:36She was in intensive care in Cape Town
  680. 33:39and doctors told her family that the
  681. 33:41road ahead would be very long. Rehab,
  682. 33:45speech therapy, the one thing she loved
  683. 33:47to do, speak about what happened to her,
  684. 33:50had been taken away.
  685. 33:52In the meantime, her attackers are
  686. 33:54roaming free, out on parole. The public
  687. 33:57was still infuriated, and even
  688. 34:00politicians paid attention. Imagine
  689. 34:02that.
  690. 34:04In February of 2025,
  691. 34:07Minister Peter Grunal announced the
  692. 34:11parole was cancelled.
  693. 34:14He said the minister's primary
  694. 34:17consideration is the imperative of
  695. 34:19protecting and securing the community,
  696. 34:22particularly in instances where acts of
  697. 34:25violence against women and children have
  698. 34:27been committed.
  699. 34:29It shouldn't have taken that long, but
  700. 34:31you know, credit where credit's due. The
  701. 34:33system finally did the right thing and
  702. 34:35as of now France and teens are back in
  703. 34:39prison right where they should have
  704. 34:40stayed all along.
  705. 34:43Ironically it was that same month that
  706. 34:46they were sent back to prison that
  707. 34:49Allison had improved enough to leave the
  708. 34:53rehab center and come home even though
  709. 34:56her therapy continues.
  710. 34:59This isn't a
  711. 35:01happy ending moment, you know, it's
  712. 35:03another chapter, and I think that's
  713. 35:05important. Sometimes the most courageous
  714. 35:08part of survival is admitting that the
  715. 35:12fight isn't over. I am in awe of
  716. 35:15Allison's continuing choice. Not just to
  717. 35:19survive again, but to live again.
  718. 35:24If nothing else, her story reminds us
  719. 35:26that the system can fail. Men can betray
  720. 35:30trust.
  721. 35:32But one human can still say no and stand
  722. 35:36anyway. And that defiance of matters.
  723. 35:40There's a few places that I want to
  724. 35:42point you to where you can read or watch
  725. 35:46more about Allison's story because I
  726. 35:49know that there's not a lot of coverage
  727. 35:51that gets done outside of the United
  728. 35:54States. Um, and I'm guilty of that. I
  729. 35:57don't often do that myself, but oh my
  730. 35:59gosh, her story, her story just had to
  731. 36:03be told. And I don't know that you have
  732. 36:06ever heard about Allison before. Um, but
  733. 36:10it was important. It was important to me
  734. 36:13because she is one hell of a woman.
  735. 36:18There are a couple of places. I'm going
  736. 36:20to have them in the show notes. There is
  737. 36:23a documentary about Allison that you can
  738. 36:27watch. It was created in 2016 and it has
  739. 36:31Allison as her older self in there.
  740. 36:35She tells the story in her own words.
  741. 36:39There was also a book written about her
  742. 36:43journey and what happened to her and
  743. 36:46I'll have a link to that as well. And
  744. 36:49there are also a couple of places that
  745. 36:52you can go if you want to help Allison
  746. 36:56along her road of rehabilitation. She
  747. 36:59has lost the ability to speak, so she
  748. 37:02cannot bring in money for herself to be
  749. 37:05able to
  750. 37:07live. Please consider donating to her
  751. 37:10trust account or any one of the links.
  752. 37:13I'll have a couple of them in the show
  753. 37:15notes. All funds go towards her therapy,
  754. 37:18her care, and her medical needs.
  755. 37:21Thank you all for listening. I'll be
  756. 37:24back soon. Bye for now.
  757. 37:37>> [music]
  758. 37:46[music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of She Held Her Own Head and Walked: The Survival of Alison Botha by TrueCrimeFM, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,831 words across 758 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.