YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → She crashed my engagement, yanked my hair in front of both families....

She crashed my engagement, yanked my hair in front of both families.... — Transcript

by QuokkaReads · 5,786 words · 819 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00She crashed my engagement, yanked my
0:02hair in front of both families, screamed
0:03that the proposal didn't count without
0:05her blessing, and somehow thought she
0:07was the victim. So, I made sure everyone
0:08finally saw exactly who she really was.
0:11The first thing I felt was the snap, not
0:12pain. That came half a second later.
0:14First, it was just the pull, sudden and
0:16violent, like someone had grabbed a
0:17fistful of my future and yanked it
0:19backward. My ponytail went tight, my
0:21neck whipped, my heels left the ground
0:22for a moment, and then Marcus's hands
0:24were on my arms, catching me before I
0:25went down. And I looked up at him, and
0:27his face was doing something I had never
0:28seen it do before. He wasn't confused.
0:30He wasn't surprised. He was looking past
0:32me with an expression that was somewhere
0:34between devastation and a kind of grim
0:36recognition, like a man who had spent
0:37years avoiding the sight of something
0:39and had finally, unavoidably, been
0:41forced to look directly at it. I turned
0:42around. Natalie was standing 3 ft away
0:44in a green silk dress she had no
0:46business wearing to someone else's
0:47moment. Her chest was heaving. Her
0:49mascara was already moving. Her hand was
0:51still half-raised, fingers open, like
0:53she hadn't quite decided yet whether to
0:54reach for me again or let the gesture
0:56stand on its own. Around us, the garden
0:58path of Meridian House, this beautiful
1:00old colonial event space in Westfield,
1:02New Jersey, that Marcus had spent 3
1:03months secretly reserving, had gone
1:05completely silent. String lights hung
1:07between the elm trees. A string quartet
1:09that Marcus had hired was frozen
1:10mid-bow. Petals from the centerpieces
1:12scattered along the stone path. And
1:14Natalie stood in the middle of all of it
1:15like she had every right to be there.
1:17"The proposal doesn't count," she said.
1:19Her voice cracked, but her eyes did not.
1:21"I didn't approve it. Marcus, I didn't
1:23approve it." She turned to him like I
1:24wasn't standing 2 ft away, like I was
1:26furniture she'd already moved past. "You
1:28promised me," she said. "You promised me
1:30we'd always be best friends. She's going
1:31to take you away, and you're going to
1:33let her." Both families came running out
1:35from the inside dining room where they'd
1:36been waiting. His mother, his sister,
1:38his aunt, my mother, my father, my
1:40brother Darius, two restaurant managers,
1:43and a security guard who looked like
1:44he'd hoped for a quieter Saturday. The
1:46string quartet finally lowered their
1:47instruments. One of the violinists took
1:49a very careful step backward. Marcus
1:51held me with one arm and raised the
1:52other toward Natalie, palm out, the way
1:54you'd try to calm something wild.
1:56"Natalie," he said, "stop." She did not
1:58stop. She started listing things. His
1:59father missing his high school
2:00graduation, some 3:00 a.m. hospital run
2:02in 2019, a beach trip in the Outer Banks
2:05where she appeared in literally every
2:07photograph. She was itemizing her
2:08investment in him like she was
2:10presenting receipts for a refund, and
2:11somewhere in the middle of it, the
2:13security guard took her gently by the
2:14elbow and began walking her back toward
2:16the restaurant entrance. She went, still
2:18talking, her voice bouncing off the elm
2:20trees until it faded into the sound of
2:21the door swinging shut behind her.
2:23Marcus looked at me. The ring was still
2:25in his hand. "Can I finish?" he said. I
2:26laughed. I don't know what else I could
2:28have done. I laughed until my eyes were
2:30wet, and then I said, "Yes." Not to that
2:31question, but to the real one. He
2:33slipped the ring on my finger and
2:34everyone on the garden path started
2:36clapping, and my mother grabbed my
2:37father's arm, and Darius made a noise
2:39that I'm choosing to remember as
2:41dignified. We went inside. Marcus
2:42proposed again in front of both
2:44families, clean and uninterrupted,
2:46because he needed to do it right, and so
2:47did I. The ring was a vintage cut
2:49sapphire surrounded by small diamonds,
2:51set in white gold, and I remember
2:52looking at it under the restaurant
2:54lights thinking that there was going to
2:55be so much joy ahead of us. I also knew,
2:57in a way I could not yet fully
2:59articulate, that Natalie was not
3:00finished. I should go back. I should
3:02explain who Natalie was before she was
3:04the woman who grabbed my hair in a
3:05restaurant garden, because she did not
3:06start as a villain. She started as a
3:08fact of Marcus's life the same way his
3:10childhood apartment in Rahway was a
3:11fact, or the way his preference for dark
3:13roast coffee was a fact. She was simply
3:15there, woven into the history of him so
3:17tightly that when I arrived, I had to
3:18learn to exist around her before I ever
3:20thought to question why. Marcus and I
3:22met in October of 2020 at a
3:24pharmaceutical company in Parsippany
3:26where we were both in account
3:27management. I was 29, he was 32. He was
3:29quiet in the way that people who have
3:31done a lot of interior work tend to be
3:33quiet, deliberate, not withdrawn. He
3:34fixed the printer on my first week when
3:36the IT ticket I'd submitted had gone
3:38unanswered for 3 days. He lent me his
3:40good pens without making a thing of it.
3:42We started getting lunch together in
3:43February of 2021 and were officially
3:45together by April. He told me about
3:47Natalie on our third date. "She's my
3:48best friend," he said. "We've known each
3:50other since we were 17. She can be a
3:52lot, but she's loyal. I need you to know
3:54that going in. I thought that was a
3:55reasonable thing to say. I had friends
3:57from high school, too. I thought I
3:58understood. The first time he introduced
4:00us was in June of 2021 at a backyard
4:02cookout at his cousin Devin's place in
4:04Montclair. Natalie arrived in a white
4:05sundress and sunglasses and hugged
4:07Marcus for what I counted, and yes, I
4:09counted, as 11 seconds before she turned
4:11to me. She looked me over the way a
4:12customs agent looks at a passport. Then
4:14she smiled and said, with complete
4:16pleasantness, "You're not really his
4:17type." She spent the next 30 minutes
4:19explaining his romantic history to me
4:20while Marcus was at the grill. The girl
4:22from Rutgers who couldn't handle how
4:24emotionally available he was. The woman
4:26from his gym who got too competitive.
4:28The flight attendant who didn't
4:29understand his work schedule. Natalie
4:31had been there for the ending of every
4:32single one. She framed this as loyalty.
4:34As I listened, I felt something else
4:36entirely, but I couldn't name it yet.
4:38Marcus joined us and Natalie immediately
4:39linked her arm through his and pulled
4:41him toward another conversation, and I
4:43stood there holding a paper plate and
4:44thinking, "This is going to require more
4:46patience than I expected." I gave up
4:47patience for almost a year. The texts
4:49were constant. Not emergencies, never
4:51actual emergencies. Inside jokes that
4:54required context I didn't have. Random
4:56observations. Opinions on dresses she
4:58was considering. Spider problems. Once
5:00at 11:30 on a Tuesday night, she called
5:02him because she couldn't decide between
5:03two fonts for a work presentation. He
5:05took the call. I lay in the dark next to
5:06him and stared at the ceiling and said
5:08nothing. When I eventually said
5:09something, gently, over breakfast a few
5:11days later, he looked genuinely
5:12surprised. "She just calls when she
5:14needs to think something through," he
5:15said. "It doesn't mean anything." I told
5:17him I understood. sure I did. The
5:19appearances were harder to explain away.
5:21The same restaurant on a night we hadn't
5:22mentioned to anyone. The same bowling
5:24alley in Kenilworth that we'd chosen
5:25specifically because neither of us had
5:27ever been there. I don't know how she
5:28knew where we'd be. I asked Marcus once
5:30and he said she probably just wanted to
5:31say hi. I started choosing our plans
5:33more carefully. She still appeared. When
5:35we moved in together in March of 2022, a
5:37two-bedroom in Summit that we spent four
5:39weeks negotiating over before Marcus
5:41finally agreed the second bedroom did
5:42not need to be a dedicated trophy room.
5:44Natalie showed up the first day. She
5:46brought a housewarming gift. It had
5:47Marcus's name on it, just his. She stood
5:49in our apartment for 3 hours and
5:51reorganized his side of things with the
5:53focused intensity of someone correcting
5:55a wrong. Cups in the wrong cabinet, work
5:57shirts hanging next to gym shirts,
5:59college trophies from Kean University
6:00boxed up and stacked when they should
6:02have been displayed. She unpacked his
6:03boxes with running commentary. "Oh, I
6:06remember when he got this. We were at
6:07the Prudential Center. Marcus, do you
6:09remember? It was your birthday." I sat
6:11on the couch and watched my own
6:12apartment become a Natalie museum. Then
6:14came Sundays. Sunday breakfast became
6:16her standing tradition. By a process I
6:18still don't fully understand. It started
6:20with one visit, then a second, then by
6:22June she was just arriving at 9:30 every
6:24week like someone who had a key, though
6:25she did not have a key. She cooked in my
6:27kitchen, left a mess. If I'd already
6:29started making breakfast when she
6:30arrived, she would remake it. Not
6:31loudly, not cruelly, just practically,
6:33the way you'd correct an error. Eggs
6:34needed to be done this way. Marcus liked
6:36his toast darker. When I said something
6:38to Marcus privately, he told me I was
6:39reading into it. When I said something
6:41to Natalie, she laughed and touched my
6:43arm and said, "Real couples don't need
6:44to sit together every single minute.
6:46have to feel threatened by me." I was
6:47not thrilled by the implication that the
6:49problem was mine. There was one Sunday
6:51in September of 2022 that I think about
6:53sometimes. Natalie had arrived with
6:55croissants and was settled on the couch
6:57between us, her feet in Marcus's lap
6:59going through something on her phone.
7:00I'd reached across her to hand Marcus
7:02his coffee, the mug he liked, the blue
7:03one, which happened to be on her side,
7:05and my arm had grazed her shoulder. She
7:07looked up and gave me a smile that was
7:08patient and tired at the same time. "You
7:10know," she said, "I've been his best
7:12friend for 15 years. You've been with
7:14him for 18 months. I'm not going
7:15anywhere." She said it like a fact, like
7:17a weather report. Marcus didn't say
7:19anything. I went to the kitchen and
7:20stood over the sink for a long time. He
7:22started planning the proposal in
7:23November of 2022. I didn't know it then.
7:26What I knew was that Natalie got worse
7:27in November. She grabbed his arm when we
7:29walked places. She whispered things in
7:31his ear at group dinners. Not secretly,
7:33just close enough that I could see it
7:34happening but not hear what was said.
7:36She posted a string of throwback photos
7:37on Instagram. The two of them at prom,
7:39the two of them at his college
7:40graduation, the two of them at some
7:42beach house rental with matching
7:43sunburns and sunglasses pushed up on
7:45their foreheads. She captioned the last
7:47one, "Some friendships last forever."
7:49heart. I found out through Devon's
7:50girlfriend Priya, who texted me a
7:52screenshot with no additional comment.
7:53Then Priya mentioned something else. She
7:55said Natalie had changed Marcus's
7:57contact name in her phone to my person.
7:59She made sure I saw it. She held up her
8:00phone at Devon's birthday dinner in
8:02December and laughed about something
8:03Marcus had texted her. And the name was
8:05right there in the notification bar, my
8:07person. She looked at me when she
8:08laughed. Not in a confrontational way.
8:10In a way that said, "I want you to know
8:12this exists. I want it to take up space
8:14in your head." It worked. I won't
8:15pretend it didn't. What I didn't know in
8:17December was that Marcus had already put
8:19the deposit down on the ring. He'd gone
8:20to an estate jeweler in Maplewood that
8:22his mother had recommended, looked at 37
8:24rings across four visits, and selected
8:26the sapphire. He told me later that he'd
8:28known which ring it was the moment he
8:29saw it, but he went back three more
8:31times just to be sure he wasn't getting
8:32swept up in the moment. That's Marcus.
8:34That's exactly who he is. He told
8:36Natalie he was planning to propose. I
8:37found this out later. At the time, I
8:39only knew that December was the worst
8:41month since we'd moved in together.
8:42Natalie called him crying twice about
8:44things she wouldn't explain fully. She
8:46showed up unannounced on a Wednesday
8:47night, not a Sunday, a Wednesday, with
8:49takeout from a Thai place we'd been to
8:51together once, Marcus and I on our first
8:53real date. I don't think that was
8:54coincidence. I stood in my own doorway
8:56and watched her set out containers on my
8:58kitchen table, and wondered at what
8:59point a person stops being a friend and
9:01starts being a siege. But I said
9:03nothing, because Marcus was happy that
9:04December, quieter than usual in the way
9:06people get when they're holding
9:08something they don't want to spill. I
9:09noticed it. I thought maybe he'd gotten
9:11a promotion or was working through
9:12something personal. I gave him his
9:14space. He booked Meridian House in early
9:16January. He told both families
9:17separately and swore them to silence. He
9:19told me we were celebrating my promotion
9:21at Dunmore and Associates. I had moved
9:23up to senior account director in
9:24October. I wore the green dress that my
9:26mother bought me for my college
9:27graduation because it still fit, and I
9:29felt good in it. Natalie wore green
9:31silk. In the weeks after the proposal, I
9:32had a lot of time to think about that
9:34coincidence. Maybe it wasn't one. Priya
9:36told me later that Devon had made an
9:37offhand comment about the restaurant,
9:39Meridian House, the garden path, within
9:41earshot of Natalie at a group dinner 3
9:43days before. She must have dressed to
9:44match on purpose, or she heard about my
9:46dress somehow. I don't know. By then, I
9:48was trying very hard not to build a
9:49conspiracy in my head because building
9:51conspiracies was what she wanted me to
9:53do. It kept me occupied, and it kept me
9:55reactive. Natalie was not invited to the
9:56wedding. That was not a discussion.
9:58Marcus and I agreed on this the morning
10:00after the proposal, over coffee in our
10:01kitchen while the ring kept catching the
10:03light on my finger and startling me. He
10:05brought it up. He said her name and then
10:06said, "I don't want her there." I told
10:08him I agreed. He nodded and poured his
10:09coffee, and we moved on, the way you
10:11move on from something that has finally,
10:13conclusively been resolved. Two months
10:15later, in March, Natalie got engaged to
10:17a man named Rob Callahan. She announced
10:19it on Instagram with a photo of a
10:21round-cut diamond solitaire and a
10:22caption about not settling. She'd been
10:24dating Rob for 4 months. I know because
10:26the math was not subtle. She scheduled
10:28her wedding for June 14th. Our wedding
10:30was June 21st. She sent Marcus a formal
10:32invitation with a handwritten note
10:33inside asking him to be her man of
10:35honor. She said she needed him by her
10:37side on the most important day of her
10:38life. She said Rob understood. She said
10:40it would mean everything. Marcus held
10:41the envelope over the kitchen trash can
10:43and let it fall. We did not discuss it.
10:45My cousin Tamara worked events
10:46coordination at the Essex County Country
10:48Club, where Natalie held her reception.
10:50Tamara called me the Sunday after around
10:52noon, voice carefully neutral in the way
10:54it gets when she's about to tell me
10:55something she knows will land badly.
10:57"She talked about Marcus all night,"
10:58Tamara said. "I mean, all night. She
11:00compared Rob's toasts to how Marcus
11:02gives toasts. She said Marcus would have
11:03danced better. She told the photographer
11:05that the man of honor was supposed to
11:07stand differently and showed him a photo
11:08of Marcus at Devon's wedding as a
11:10reference." Tamara paused. "Rob left his
11:12own reception at 9:30, just got in the
11:14car and drove away. His groomsmen found
11:16him at a bar in Short Hills. The divorce
11:18was filed in September, 18 weeks after
11:20the wedding. Our wedding was June 21st,
11:22a Saturday, Southgate Manor in Randolph,
11:24112 guests. My mother cried through the
11:27entire ceremony in a way that was
11:29beautiful and also slightly alarming.
11:31Marcus said his vows without notes,
11:33which was something I had not expected,
11:35and I held onto his hands through the
11:36whole thing because I needed something
11:38to do with myself while he talked, or I
11:40was going to fall apart completely. We
11:41were in Tuscany for 10 days. We came
11:43back in early July, and on August 9th,
11:45which was our first paper anniversary,
11:47we celebrated monthly that first year,
11:49the way newly married people do when
11:51they're still a little disbelieving. I
11:52answered the front door of our house in
11:54Summit at 6:15 in the evening and found
11:56Natalie on the porch. She was holding a
11:58box, small, square, wrapped in navy
12:00paper with a thin white ribbon. Marcus's
12:02name was written on the tag in her
12:04handwriting, the same looping script I
12:05recognized from Sunday mornings when she
12:07would leave passive-aggressive grocery
12:09lists on our counter. She was wearing a
12:10cream blouse and black slacks and the
12:12same perfume that had settled into our
12:14couch cushions for 2 years of Sunday
12:16breakfasts. She smiled when she saw me.
12:18"Is Marcus home?" she said. I stood in
12:20the doorway and looked at her for a
12:21moment. "You need to leave," I said. She
12:23looked past me, physically moved her
12:24gaze around my shoulder like I was a
12:26door she hadn't opened yet. "Marcus!"
12:28she called, bright voice, casual, like
12:30she was arriving for a Sunday she'd been
12:31invited to. He came from the kitchen,
12:33dish towel over his shoulder. He saw
12:35her. He stopped. Something in his face
12:36settled, not into anger but into
12:38something older and heavier. The
12:39expression of a man setting down
12:41something he'd been carrying for a long
12:42time. Natalie's face changed the moment
12:44she read his expression. The smile
12:46softened into something more vulnerable.
12:48Then the tears came. They came fast and
12:49practiced in the way things do when they
12:51have been deployed many times before.
12:53She started talking. She was lost
12:54without him. The divorce had been
12:56devastating. She had no one. He was the
12:57only person who truly knew her. She had
12:59made a mistake letting things get this
13:01far. She was sorry. She was so sorry.
13:03She needed him to just talk to her for a
13:05few minutes, just a few minutes. She
13:06listed her receipts: his dad missing
13:08graduation, the 3:00 a.m. drive to
13:10Sentara State Medical in 2019 when she
13:12thought she was having a cardiac event
13:14and it turned out to be a panic attack,
13:16but she hadn't known that yet and he'd
13:17sat with her in the waiting room until
13:194:00 in the morning, the Outer Banks
13:20trip in 2018 where she'd handled
13:22everything when the rental had a sewage
13:24problem and they'd had to move hotels at
13:26midnight. She knew exactly how long to
13:27pause after each one. Marcus listened.
13:29He did not move from the hallway. He did
13:31not reach for her. He let the list
13:32finish. "Natalie," he said. She looked
13:34up. "You shouldn't have come here." The
13:36tears stopped instantly, not gradually.
13:38Stopped the way a faucet stops when you
13:40turn the handle all the way closed. Her
13:42face went still and then it rearranged
13:43itself into something that was not grief
13:45and not anger, but was a very specific
13:47kind of calculation. I had seen it
13:49before. I had seen it in the moment
13:51after Marcus brushed her hand off his
13:52shoulder in the garden at Meridian
13:54House. Right before she reached for my
13:55hair. It was the face of someone
13:57deciding on their next move. She looked
13:58at the gift box in her hand. Then she
14:00looked at me, then at Marcus. "I see,"
14:02she said. "You've been fully converted."
14:04She turned and walked to her car. She
14:05did not look back. I want to explain
14:07what happened in the two weeks after
14:08that visit, because this is the part I
14:10almost didn't find out. The part that
14:12recontextualized everything. Marcus's
14:14sister, Renee, called me on a Tuesday
14:15afternoon three days after Natalie's
14:17porch visit. Renee is four years older
14:19than Marcus, lives in East Orange, and
14:21has always treated me with a careful
14:22warmth that I interpreted as reserved,
14:24but that I now understand was just her
14:26being thorough about trust. She doesn't
14:27extend it quickly. She extended it to me
14:29by the following March, and when it
14:31came, it was real and I valued it. "I
14:33need to tell you something," she said.
14:34"And I need you to know I've been
14:36sitting with whether to tell you for a
14:37long time, and I'm telling you now
14:39because she showed up at your house."
14:40She told me that in November of 2022,
14:43the same month Marcus was planning the
14:44proposal, the same month Natalie started
14:46getting worse, Natalie had called Renee.
14:48She'd called to try to get Renee to
14:49convince Marcus not to propose. She said
14:51she thought I was wrong for him. She
14:53said the relationship was moving too
14:54fast. She said Marcus had always made
14:56his best decisions when Natalie was
14:58involved, and this was a decision she
14:59hadn't been consulted on. Renee told her
15:01no. Natalie then called Marcus's mother.
15:03His mother, Beverly, had not told Marcus
15:05about the call because she didn't want
15:06to put him in the middle of it, she told
15:08Renee. They'd both decided to watch and
15:10wait, but there was something else.
15:11Renee said that after the engagement
15:13party, the formal one we held in March
15:14of 2023, two months after the garden
15:16path, Natalie had sent Marcus a letter,
15:18handwritten, 12 pages. Renee knew
15:20because Marcus had mentioned it to her
15:22briefly, and when she asked what it
15:23said, he got very quiet and said it was
15:25a lot of old stuff he needed to process,
15:27and he'd put it somewhere safe. He had
15:28never mentioned this letter to me. I sat
15:30with that for an hour after I got off
15:31the phone with Renee. I sat in our
15:33bedroom and looked at the closet, the
15:34good closet, the one Marcus used for
15:36things he wanted to keep out of daily
15:38sight, winter coats, old tax returns,
15:40the box his grandfather's watch came in.
15:42I opened it. I looked at the shelf.
15:43There was a shoe box on the top shelf
15:44behind his wedding suit bag. I opened
15:46the shoe box. The letter was there, all
15:4812 pages. I won't share all of it. I
15:50won't share most of it, but I will tell
15:51you that on page four, Natalie wrote the
15:53following. I know this is not something
15:55I'm supposed to say, and I've spent
15:56years not saying it, but I love you the
15:58way that matters. I always have, and you
16:00know that. I think you've always known
16:02it, and choosing her knowing that, I
16:03need you to sit with that. I need you to
16:05decide whether you're making a choice or
16:07an escape. Page nine, if you marry her
16:09and we lose each other, that is a door
16:11that cannot be reopened. I want you to
16:13know that. I want that to mean
16:14something. Page 12, I've never needed
16:16your blessing for anything I've done
16:17with my life, but I've always needed to
16:19be your person. Tell me I still am. I
16:21sat on the bedroom floor for a long
16:22time. I thought about every Sunday
16:24morning, every whispered thing at
16:25dinner, every green silk coincidence.
16:28The letter made it retroactively true,
16:29not the fantasy of it, but the strategy
16:31of it. Natalie had not been acting from
16:33grief or confusion or simple
16:34possessiveness. She had been acting from
16:36a plan that went back further than I
16:38knew. The hair pull in the garden wasn't
16:39a breakdown. It was a calculation that
16:41had passed a point of no return. I put
16:43the letter back. Then I thought about
16:44what I was going to do. I did not go to
16:46Marcus that night. I waited three days.
16:48I thought about what I wanted the
16:49conversation to accomplish and what I
16:51did not want it to become. I did not
16:52want it to become a demand for
16:53explanation or a tribunal about
16:55something he'd withheld. I wanted it to
16:57be the thing it actually was, which was
16:58harder and more necessary, a real
17:00conversation about what we were going to
17:01do from here. I sat him down on a
17:03Thursday night after dinner. I told him
17:04about Renee's call. I watched his face.
17:06He was quiet for a very long time. Then
17:08he said, "I should have told you about
17:09the letter." I asked him why he hadn't.
17:11He said, "Because I was ashamed that
17:13she'd written it, and I was ashamed that
17:14I didn't know what to do with it, and I
17:16think I was hoping that if I put it
17:17somewhere I didn't look, the situation
17:19it described would just resolve itself.
17:20I asked him if anything in the letter
17:22was true. He looked at me. She loves me
17:24the way she's always loved me. That part
17:25is probably true. But what she called
17:27love has always been, I don't have a
17:29better word for it than ownership. She
17:30loves the version of me that belonged to
17:32her. She's never been interested in the
17:34version of me that doesn't. Then he
17:35said, I should have drawn that line 10
17:37years ago. I kept not drawing it because
17:39I felt guilty and because I told myself
17:41it wasn't hurting anyone. I was wrong
17:43about that. I know that now. I asked him
17:45what he wanted to do. He said, I want to
17:47call her in front of you and I want to
17:48say what I should have said a long time
17:50ago and I want you to be there when I
17:51say it. I said, okay. We called her on
17:53speaker. She answered on the second
17:55ring. Marcus spoke clearly and without
17:57interruption. He said he had read her
17:58letter. He said he understood what she
18:00felt and he was not dismissing it. He
18:01said he also needed her to understand
18:03that what she had done at the engagement
18:05at our house, in the months and years
18:07before, had not come from love, but from
18:09an unwillingness to accept that love
18:10sometimes means releasing someone. He
18:12said she had hurt me in ways that were
18:13real and documented and that I had been
18:15patient far longer than most people
18:17would have been. He said they were not
18:18able to continue a friendship while she
18:20was unwilling to acknowledge any of
18:22this. He said he hoped genuinely that
18:23she found what she was looking for and
18:25he said goodbye. She was silent through
18:27almost all of it. At the end she said,
18:28you'll regret this. He said, I don't
18:30think I will. He hung up. I looked at
18:31him across the kitchen table. He looked
18:33tired in the way that people look when
18:34they've finally done something they
18:36should have done years ago and the
18:37relief and the grief are arriving
18:39simultaneously. I'm sorry, he said. I
18:41told him I knew. It did not end there,
18:43of course. Nothing like this ends
18:44cleanly. Natalie called Devon in the two
18:47weeks after that phone call. Devon is
18:48conflict averse in the way that large,
18:50good-natured men sometimes are and each
18:52time he tried to remain neutral, which
18:54in practice meant he mostly listened and
18:56said, yeah, that's rough, until she wore
18:58herself out. He told us about the calls.
18:59He was apologetic about it in a way that
19:01was unnecessary, but appreciated. She
19:03sent a card to Beverly, Marcus's mother,
19:05with a very long, very carefully written
19:07note about how she was worried about
19:09Marcus, that she felt he had changed in
19:11ways that concerned her, that she hoped
19:12Beverly was paying attention. Beverly
19:14called me to read it to me. Then she
19:15said, "I want you to know I've watched
19:17my son carefully for 3 years. He's
19:19happier than I have ever seen him." Then
19:21she said, she doesn't know how to let
19:22something be someone else's. She didn't
19:24say anything else about it. She didn't
19:26have to. Priya reached out to me in
19:27September. She said Natalie had
19:29contacted her asking if I'd ever done
19:31anything that crossed a line in my
19:32relationship with Marcus. Fishing, Priya
19:34said, for ammunition. Priya told her she
19:36had nothing to report. Priya also told
19:38her to stop. There was a period of about
19:406 weeks in the fall where I felt the
19:41particular exhaustion of someone who has
19:43won the argument but still has to live
19:45next to the noise it made. I woke up
19:46some mornings thinking about the letter
19:48and the 12 pages and what it had meant
19:50for Natalie to write it and what it had
19:51meant for Marcus to put it in a shoebox
19:53instead of bringing it to me. I don't
19:55want to overstate this. My marriage was
19:56not in jeopardy. My husband's commitment
19:58was not in question. But there is a kind
19:59of grief that comes from learning that
20:01something you thought was secure was
20:02always slightly less so than you knew,
20:04that you had been living in a house
20:06where a wall you didn't know about had
20:07been under pressure for years. The wall
20:09held. The house was fine, but knowing it
20:11had been under pressure changes the way
20:12you listen at night. I gave myself
20:14permission to grieve that for a while. I
20:16also started seeing a therapist named
20:17Dr. Yana Kessler in October, whom I
20:19found through my employee assistance
20:21program and who charged me a copay of
20:23$35 and was worth approximately 10,000
20:26times that. She helped me understand the
20:27difference between processing something
20:29and carrying it. She helped me
20:30understand that what I'd experienced
20:32with Natalie wasn't just friction
20:33between a partner's friend and a new
20:35girlfriend. It was a sustained campaign
20:37by someone in genuine psychological pain
20:39who had aimed that pain very precisely
20:41at me for 3 years. That didn't make it
20:42acceptable, but understanding it made it
20:44less personal, made it hers instead of
20:46mine. Natalie moved to Portland in
20:48December. A fresh start, someone said. I
20:50heard this through Devon. I didn't look
20:51her up. I don't follow her. I wish her
20:53no specific harm and I hope, in the
20:55vague and somewhat distant way you hope
20:57for things you are no longer required to
20:58care about, that she found what she
21:00needed. I'm writing this in the spring.
21:01We live in the same house in Summit. The
21:03second bedroom is no longer a trophy
21:05room debate. It's a nursery now, still
21:07in progress. Walls the color of very
21:09pale sage, a rug we spent two hours
21:11choosing and then immediately
21:13second-guessed and then went back to
21:14because it was right the first time.
21:16Marcus assembled the crib on a Saturday
21:18in March. He did it methodically and
21:20with a level of focus that I recognized
21:21from the story he told me about going
21:23back to look at the ring three more
21:24times before buying it. He was making
21:26sure. I look at him sometimes across the
21:28kitchen or over the top of a book or at
21:303:00 in the morning when I can't sleep
21:31and I think about the garden path at
21:33Meridian House, the string lights, the
21:34frozen string quartet, the moment after
21:36the ring was on my finger and before the
21:38families came running out. When it was
21:39just us and the petals and the noise
21:41Natalie was making as the security guard
21:43walked her away. He looked at me in that
21:45moment and his face said, "I'm sorry
21:47that happened." And also, "I'm still
21:48here." Both of those things were true.
21:50Both of them still are. I think about
21:52the word that Natalie used in her
21:53letter, person, my person, as if
21:55belonging to someone is a zero-sum game,
21:57as if love is a territory and not a
21:59practice. She could not understand,
22:01could not make herself understand that
22:02Marcus loving me did not subtract from
22:04anything she'd been given. It just meant
22:06the ownership she felt had never been
22:07real. Some things I lost, I'll
22:09acknowledge. I lost the version of this
22:11story where Natalie was simply a
22:12complicated friend who found her way
22:14through this. I lost the version where
22:16the friendship reconstituted itself into
22:18something healthy after the engagement.
22:20I lost some innocence about what people
22:21who feel entitled to someone are capable
22:23of. That last one matters. It made me
22:25harder in ways I'm still untangling. And
22:27Marcus lost something, too. He doesn't
22:28say it often, but I know that 15 years
22:30is real, even when the relationship
22:32inside those years was less than what it
22:34appeared to be. He lost someone he grew
22:35up alongside. He lost the specific
22:37comfort of a person who knew his history
22:39the way only time can give you. He
22:41doesn't mourn it loudly. He moves
22:42through it, but I see him sometimes
22:44close a thought before it fully forms
22:46and I know what the thought was. The
22:47title of this story is what they used to
22:49call a trigger warning, a preview, a
22:51summary of the worst day in what turned
22:53out to be a good story. But what I want
22:55to leave you with is this. The proposal
22:56counts. It counted in the garden with
22:58petals on the ground and a frozen string
23:00quartet and a woman screaming that it
23:01needed her approval to be real. It
23:03counted because Marcus went back for it,
23:05stood up and studied me, and then knelt
23:07again inside while both families watched
23:09and said the rest of what he'd been
23:10saying when we were interrupted. The
23:11ring was on my finger either way, but he
23:13needed to finish. He needed to say it
23:15all the way through, uninterrupted, and
23:16he did. No one's blessing was required.
23:18It never was.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of She crashed my engagement, yanked my hair in front of both families.... by QuokkaReads, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,786 words across 819 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.