SECRET INGREDIENT FOR BETTER COFFEE: WATER (feat. PhD Chemist Dr. Smrke) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00what's up everyone Lance Hedrick here
- 0:02and I'm accompanied by Dr Salma smirke
- 0:04he is a research associate at the Zurich
- 0:06University for applied sciences So today
- 0:09we're going to take a look at water
- 0:11chemistry and how water affects coffee
- 0:13and extraction knowing that it's over 98
- 0:15of filter coffee and around 90 of
- 0:18espresso it's very important to
- 0:20understand and control your water and
- 0:21Overlook variable that has a massive
- 0:24effect on your final cup so we're going
- 0:26to look uh first and foremost at what
- 0:28buffers kind of do and then we're going
- 0:29to look at magnesium and calcium but I'm
- 0:32going to go ahead and give the
- 0:33microphone proverbial microphone to uh
- 0:35doctors hey that's that's um I think the
- 0:40water is kind of a very exciting topic
- 0:41that we've studied since maybe five six
- 0:44years the focus to have a water release
- 0:47the coffee right yeah that's about the
- 0:49time when really in the coffee world
- 0:50people start to talk about water because
- 0:52before water was just like yeah it's
- 0:54water you know it's like 98 of coffee
- 0:56but yeah don't care about what is what
- 0:58is in this water oh sure because once
- 1:00there is many water the tedious water is
- 1:02very very low but yeah it's a very
- 1:04strong impact on the coffee as we
- 1:06learned and now more and more people
- 1:07we're realizing this because it's a very
- 1:09profound impact right yeah what we
- 1:12learned is that there's two two main
- 1:13things that you mention uh buffering
- 1:16capacity and the minerals in in the
- 1:18water right yes so this is the thing to
- 1:20understand about water is that there's
- 1:22things that interact with your coffee
- 1:24yes right so so we have buffering
- 1:27capacity that's probably the most the
- 1:29the strongest impact that everybody can
- 1:31very easily feel when you have hard
- 1:34water or soft water when you brew your
- 1:35coffee especially filter coffee is very
- 1:38sensitive because the field of coffee is
- 1:39kind of very dilute yeah so the acids in
- 1:42building coffee are are
- 1:44kind of the same strength as in espresso
- 1:47if you measure pH of your you know you
- 1:49have a like a pH meter you have a pH of
- 1:51espresso and you measure pH of your
- 1:53filter Brew it's about the same price
- 1:55right yeah despite knowing that the the
- 1:58filter will be about five times more
- 2:00diluted than espresso in terms of
- 2:01concentration of your PDF right
- 2:03so so therefore filter we have much will
- 2:06be much more sensitive to to the to the
- 2:08water composition and therefore it's a
- 2:11kind of very very easy if you have the
- 2:13wrong water with all the partners to
- 2:15buff around the Assets in in your uh
- 2:17from your top in your Brew right gotcha
- 2:19so what he's saying is essentially
- 2:21buffers buffering has probably the
- 2:24biggest impact on your coffee it's more
- 2:26so on filtered than espresso filter and
- 2:28espresso have same pH as roughly
- 2:30um and if they have a similar extraction
- 2:32yield they can still have a different
- 2:33TDS obviously and so if the impact is
- 2:36much harsher on the more diluted one
- 2:38which is still for coffee so you can
- 2:40completely buffer out the acidity in
- 2:42there which is what's bringing the
- 2:44nuance and the delicacy and the the
- 2:46tasty bits to that so could you explain
- 2:48just briefly for people who may not know
- 2:49what what do you mean when you say
- 2:51buffer buffer yeah that's that's kind of
- 2:53a chemical term rubber a buffer is the
- 2:55ability of a solution to resist a pH
- 2:59change okay so so if something has a
- 3:01buffer capacity it means that it doesn't
- 3:03changes in PH so it means that the water
- 3:06has a good buffer capacity there's like
- 3:08strong alkalinity yeah it means that it
- 3:10doesn't like to change pH to lower and
- 3:12then when you add coffee coffee is
- 3:14acidic yeah it wants to lower the pH of
- 3:16the whole beverage right so the water
- 3:18has really strong buffer capacity then
- 3:20it doesn't change the pH so much though
- 3:22so it does not so the the acids react
- 3:24with carbonate from water and they
- 3:26neutralize each other okay so so you
- 3:29lose the acids you don't have the acids
- 3:31anymore in your coffee if the water is
- 3:32too hard yeah so the the carbonates are
- 3:34reacting with the acids and can
- 3:36essentially negate them they buffer them
- 3:38yeah so when we're talking pH we're
- 3:40talking a scale from 0 to 14 from zero
- 3:42to seven it's acidic from seven to
- 3:44fourteen it's alkaline and so uh what
- 3:46he's saying is coffee tends to be acidic
- 3:48and so uh but if you have too hot hard
- 3:50of water those carbonates can negate the
- 3:53the function of the acidity which is a
- 3:55sensory uh experience right yeah exactly
- 3:59so when we talk about acidity in coffee
- 4:01what is really important why this is
- 4:04such a big factor that we don't want to
- 4:06buffer out our assets right we don't
- 4:08want to neutralize them it's because in
- 4:10specialty coffee if we ask people how
- 4:13much they like coffee yeah and that we
- 4:15gave them different copies and we look
- 4:16at certain scores and then we give them
- 4:19uh ask them sorry to ask them how do
- 4:22they write the acidity of this copy and
- 4:24and then we had to get another set of
- 4:26numbers and then we compared those two
- 4:28sets we see they match perfectly yeah so
- 4:31it means that even though you know there
- 4:33will be maybe a different sensory
- 4:34profiles in terms of Aroma and so but
- 4:36but when you look at this course they're
- 4:38very much related to the likability
- 4:40support yeah so even if a copy has
- 4:43um very good aroma completion but it
- 4:46doesn't have acidity yeah people will
- 4:48not rate it high because it is important
- 4:51part of the whole whole flavor
- 4:53experience of a copy because the taste
- 4:55works together with Aroma and this is
- 4:56what brings then uh the pleasure in
- 4:59drinking coffee yeah that's why you you
- 5:01also if you if you mute the assets you
- 5:04also mute the Aromas of coffee because
- 5:06you perceive both together your brain
- 5:08works with tongue and your nose together
- 5:10yeah to perceive a copy as being a very
- 5:13vibrant likable and it's importance of
- 5:15Aroma and the the acid right so yeah if
- 5:18you lose acids then also the vibrancy of
- 5:20Aroma is kind of reduced yeah that's all
- 5:22works together so obviously in Darker
- 5:24roasts you're going to have a lower
- 5:25perception of acidity just in general
- 5:28right but there is still acidity that is
- 5:30creating that flavor profile correct yes
- 5:33definitely even even you know
- 5:35um you you ask people ah commodity
- 5:38because like oh I really don't like
- 5:40acidity in coffee but if you take a very
- 5:42dark roasted coffee and we ask people
- 5:44who really like only dark roast coffee
- 5:47and then we asked we asked them to do
- 5:49like a city copy and they say no but and
- 5:51they like the dark roasted coffee but
- 5:53even if you take a look at the doctor of
- 5:54the properties as its composition the pH
- 5:56the temperature the amount of acid it's
- 5:59still it still has them it's still
- 6:00acidic it's not a big difference between
- 6:02light and darkers you know like there's
- 6:04a clear difference yeah but even the dog
- 6:06grows and even a copy that's not
- 6:08considered acidic like a natural Brazil
- 6:10yeah it still has a considerable amount
- 6:13of Assets in and acidity right yeah so
- 6:15you know you are so some of the city
- 6:17can't be muted through roasting but
- 6:18you're not really negating the presence
- 6:20of the acidity you're not negating the
- 6:22presence so I think it is even for for
- 6:24doctors wrinkles it's a crucial part of
- 6:27the the experience of a coffee in terms
- 6:29of the sensory perception gotcha so even
- 6:31dark roasted coffee lovers love acidity
- 6:33that's what I'm hearing yeah you're
- 6:36hearing this but they don't realize they
- 6:38don't realize so even they need to
- 6:39understand that buffer is important
- 6:41because you want the acidity for a
- 6:42lively cup even if you like darkerous
- 6:44coffees exactly yes yes let's move into
- 6:47the the normal
- 6:49um the normal factors of hardness that
- 6:51people use in normal chemicals are some
- 6:53form of magnesium and some form of
- 6:55calcium what I have here is magnesium uh
- 6:57chloride and calcium chloride but you
- 6:59know people what are other Alternatives
- 7:01people use magnesium you could use some
- 7:03magnesium sulfate
- 7:06um
- 7:08no problem right but then yeah there
- 7:11might be some sort of flavor uptase yeah
- 7:13so again things are not really known
- 7:14right exactly not everything is no when
- 7:17you start to look at these these these
- 7:19salts and adding them how they relate to
- 7:21the sensory it's kind of from Clear from
- 7:24the tasting that we were doing you know
- 7:26experience empirically they have a huge
- 7:29impact on the perception right the their
- 7:32amount has an impact and the ratio
- 7:34between magnesium and calcium has a big
- 7:35impact right okay yeah so anecdotally
- 7:38I've heard and I I've experienced that
- 7:40magnesium brings vibrant acidity vibrant
- 7:43flavors out and calcium is dull muted
- 7:45chalky but uh I heard from you that you
- 7:47have a bit of a difference yeah what
- 7:48I've done in a different uh in my double
- 7:51blind tasting I had more complexity with
- 7:53with uh magnesium but I had a little bit
- 7:55more brightness with calcium so uh the
- 7:58combination of potassium bicarbonate and
- 8:00calcium chloride was giving me the most
- 8:02kind of like bright floral fruity cups
- 8:04uh in in multiple double blind cuppings
- 8:07with a partner who is cupping as well
- 8:08but that's the thing is uh and Samuel
- 8:10can confirm but there's there's no
- 8:12objective study right now as to which of
- 8:15these minerals is giving what in the
- 8:17Final Cup now an interesting question is
- 8:19do we know if the water composition is
- 8:23important for the actual extraction or
- 8:24could that be after or could it be added
- 8:26post extraction so there is uh there's
- 8:29some knowledge about this okay so there
- 8:31was a very recently won The Bachelor
- 8:33thesis from a student published that did
- 8:36this theft trying to see from a chemical
- 8:38point of view not doing Center
- 8:40experiments from a chemical point of
- 8:41view does it make a difference if you
- 8:43add them before extraction adapter
- 8:45extraction and the result was that
- 8:46there's no difference so you could Brew
- 8:48with like distilled water and then add
- 8:50afterwards yes they actually brewed with
- 8:52distilled water and they added
- 8:53afterwards and they even added a lot
- 8:55afterwards like more than they would
- 8:56normally add like 10 times more oh yeah
- 8:58what we would normally use in your
- 9:00Brewing butter and was still the same
- 9:02effect and then it kind of there was
- 9:05some reactions chemical reactions with
- 9:07these minerals with the acids in the
- 9:11coffee okay forming complexes and
- 9:13therefore there was less availability of
- 9:15Assets in in the beverage so so it means
- 9:18that there was a reaction with the
- 9:21coffee components that you grew into
- 9:24your beverage with the minerals
- 9:26and that has an impact on on
- 9:28availability of those components of
- 9:30cropping okay how does this relate to
- 9:32sensory that's a really good question
- 9:34because there's very little systematic
- 9:36studies on this uh available okay so
- 9:40it's really a shot in the dark anything
- 9:41out there would be more anecdotal than
- 9:43anything yes I think we're really
- 9:44working here with some anecdotal
- 9:46evidence even this is only one study
- 9:47which probably was executed very well
- 9:50but yeah it's only one study so it might
- 9:52have a difference in different coffee
- 9:53different Rose level Etc but then again
- 9:55we're also working with a lot of
- 9:57empirical uh evidence right a lot of
- 10:01experience what people do and what
- 10:03people then um like you know different
- 10:04recipes yeah and we have different
- 10:06outcomes but but really systematically
- 10:09making different copies different
- 10:10processing methods you know we don't
- 10:12have really good picture of what is
- 10:13happening yeah no that makes sense so as
- 10:16like a wrap up essentially what you have
- 10:18is the most important part of the water
- 10:20in coffee extraction as far as the
- 10:21sensory part is definitely the buffering
- 10:23agent so your bicarbonates whether it's
- 10:25potassium bicarbonate sodium bicarbonate
- 10:27that's going to be controlling
- 10:29essentially the prevalence of the
- 10:30acidity since uh sensorily in your cup
- 10:33by the end and so if you're dialing in
- 10:36your coffee whether it's dark or light
- 10:38roast the amount of buffer is going to
- 10:39play a massive role on that Final Cup
- 10:41whereas when we're playing with hardness
- 10:43a lot of that is still up in the air as
- 10:45far as the efficacy of each of them but
- 10:48it does it does objectively contribute
- 10:50to the flavor profile yes that's
- 10:52happening the effect is so clear that we
- 10:53can say it's objective yes objectively
- 10:55Heaven okay what exactly it is it's more
- 10:58difficult it's more difficult to say yes
- 11:00so whenever we're talking in terms of
- 11:01the total PPM of a liquid the more
- 11:04important number is the PPM of the
- 11:06buffer as far as like what we can trace
- 11:09yes definitely that's the first thing
- 11:10that we want to make sure that you're
- 11:12you're in good numbers it's a buffer the
- 11:14alternative carbon and hardness yeah
- 11:15it's kind of the same thing and then the
- 11:18second thing is the total hardness the
- 11:20calcium and magnesium content absolutely
- 11:21awesome so hopefully that was helpful of
- 11:24course there's a lot more to be known
- 11:26about while water chemistry which some
- 11:28of us actually currently working on a
- 11:29course for and I'm gonna let him tell
- 11:30you about that real quick yes so what
- 11:33what I've what I've learned that despite
- 11:36someone's talking about coffee and water
- 11:37there's still a bit of fundamental lack
- 11:41of knowledge in in the water chemistry
- 11:43and understanding about the chemistry
- 11:44therefore with uh I partnered with
- 11:46coffee knowledge Hub and there will be a
- 11:48course about water and coffee available
- 11:50there for everybody to join who wants to
- 11:53join it and part of the course is
- 11:56understanding the chemistry the
- 11:58fundamentals the treatment of water but
- 12:00then also taste coffees prepared with
- 12:04different Waters as in terms of a
- 12:06tasting kit and discuss why we tasted
- 12:11what we tasted so there will be a bit of
- 12:13theory practical part and then bacteria
- 12:16explaining what what we're tasting what
- 12:18is actually happening to try to bring
- 12:20about understanding rep water and coffee
- 12:23even closer to the community so class
- 12:25you don't want to miss I'll put down
- 12:26information down below and whenever it's
- 12:28live I'll change that and caption but
- 12:30anyway thank you so much doctor thank
- 12:33you it was a wonderful time so it's a
- 12:35pleasure to talk to you always learned
- 12:36something new and uh hope you enjoyed
- 12:38this Brew something tasty today take
- 12:40into account the buffer
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of SECRET INGREDIENT FOR BETTER COFFEE: WATER (feat. PhD Chemist Dr. Smrke) by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,514 words across 357 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.