YouTube2Text

최신 과학이 밝힌 크레아틴의 항노화, 뇌인지 기능, 뼈 건강 추가 효과ㅣ닥터딩요 — Transcript

by 닥터딩요 · 6,025 words · 968 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00All right, everyone, the path of
  2. 0:02creatine has been cleared. This comes
  3. 0:04from a 17-million-subscriber US YouTube
  4. 0:06channel called "DoA," where Dr. Darren
  5. 0:08Candow, a creatine expert who has
  6. 0:10produced over 120 papers solely on
  7. 0:12creatine, appeared and stated, "After
  8. 0:14studying creatine, I couldn't find a
  9. 0:16single reason why every person on Earth
  10. 0:19shouldn't take it." He sparked a frenzy
  11. 0:22in the US by claiming that not just
  12. 0:23those who work out, but all Americans
  13. 0:25—no, everyone on the planet—should
  14. 0:27be taking creatine, and now Americans
  15. 0:29are taking it everywhere. On that show,
  16. 0:32he argued that it’s been shown to
  17. 0:34help with cognitive function in
  18. 0:36adolescents and students, plays a role
  19. 0:38in preventing bone density loss in
  20. 0:40post-menopausal women, and is obviously
  21. 0:42essential for muscle building in
  22. 0:43seniors, so shouldn't every generation
  23. 0:45across the globe be taking it?
  24. 0:48Furthermore, he discussed a study on
  25. 0:51today's main topic: its anti-aging
  26. 0:53effects. I’ve actually been taking
  27. 0:56this for over 10 years now. Creatine is
  28. 0:58in my cupboard, and since I’m
  29. 0:59obsessed with anti-aging and longevity,
  30. 1:01I couldn't help but look into it.
  31. 1:03I’ll explain why everyone on Earth
  32. 1:05should take it, and the facts behind
  33. 1:06its anti-aging properties. Yes. Yes.
  34. 1:13Hello. This is Stock T, who works out.
  35. 1:19Now, you've heard that creatine reduces
  36. 1:21fatigue during exercise. It increases
  37. 1:22your performance. It prevents muscle
  38. 1:24loss. You've heard these things often,
  39. 1:26but to be precise, it acts as a backup
  40. 1:27battery for our bodies. What that means
  41. 1:29is that our main battery is something
  42. 1:31called ATP. It is adenosine
  43. 1:33triphosphate. This means there are
  44. 1:35three phosphate groups attached to
  45. 1:36adenosine. Our cells use this as
  46. 1:38currency to power all energy, and when
  47. 1:40energy is used, it turns into adenosine
  48. 1:43diphosphate. Then, it eventually turns
  49. 1:45into monophosphate and becomes just
  50. 1:46adenosine. Ultimately. And that
  51. 1:48adenosine becomes a fatigue-inducing
  52. 1:49substance. So, when you take creatine,
  53. 1:51or use the creatine already in your
  54. 1:53body, it converts into phosphocreatine.
  55. 1:55When adenosine triphosphate becomes
  56. 1:57diphosphate, it gives it a phosphate
  57. 1:58group. It essentially provides a backup
  58. 2:00battery. Then it becomes triphosphate
  59. 2:02again. That is the principle. The
  60. 2:04principle of creatine itself is not
  61. 2:05complicated at all. We actually don't
  62. 2:07need it when we are running. So, you
  63. 2:09don't need it at all for marathons.
  64. 2:10During moderate aerobic exercise, we
  65. 2:12continuously generate ATP using fat,
  66. 2:14receiving and burning energy in
  67. 2:16real-time like a hybrid car, so there's
  68. 2:18no risk of depletion. The problem
  69. 2:20arises during short-distance sprints or
  70. 2:22high-intensity exercise. In those
  71. 2:24moments, it can be depleted instantly.
  72. 2:26That's when it helps you push for one
  73. 2:28more rep. It allows you to lift 11 reps
  74. 2:31when you've reached your limit at 10.
  75. 2:34Creatine phosphate refills energy that
  76. 2:36was depleted in just one second. But
  77. 2:39this is naturally produced in our
  78. 2:40bodies. When you eat protein, you
  79. 2:42produce about 1 to 2 grams a day, and
  80. 2:44eating meat provides another gram. So
  81. 2:47you can consume or produce about 2 to 3
  82. 2:49grams a day, and daily activities use
  83. 2:51up about 1 to 2 grams. So, there’s
  84. 2:52generally no deficiency. But the point
  85. 2:54is, it refills what’s depleted
  86. 2:56instantly during high-intensity
  87. 2:58exercise. It’s not that you need 3 to
  88. 3:005 grams total, but that you need 3 to 5
  89. 3:02grams extra. Extra. Just by taking 3 to
  90. 3:045 grams, your exercise performance
  91. 3:06jumps significantly. Think of this as
  92. 3:08something proven over decades.
  93. 3:09There’s no need to fact-check this.
  94. 3:11It’s simply correct. Unless you’re
  95. 3:12in a situation where you can’t take
  96. 3:14it, which I’ll explain later, just
  97. 3:15assume every person who works out takes
  98. 3:17it. But, for example, what if you want
  99. 3:18to get it from food instead of
  100. 3:19supplements? To get 3 to 5 grams, you
  101. 3:21would need exactly 1 kilogram of beef.
  102. 3:241 kilogram of beef contains about 3 to
  103. 3:265 grams of creatine. Herring actually
  104. 3:27has a bit more. This is a different
  105. 3:29topic, but herring really is a
  106. 3:30superfood. I’ll make a video about
  107. 3:32this later, but you should definitely
  108. 3:34eat plenty of it—including Gwa-maegi
  109. 3:36—but anyway, since you’d have to
  110. 3:37eat 1kg of beef, it’s unrealistic,
  111. 3:39and supplements are just a quick fix.
  112. 3:41There’s no reason for someone who
  113. 3:42works out not to take it as a
  114. 3:43supplement. Now, Professor Darren
  115. 3:45Candow from the University of Regina in
  116. 3:47Canada wants to point out two things.
  117. 3:49First, they couldn’t find any side
  118. 3:51effects in healthy individuals. Second,
  119. 3:53they discovered new benefits for brain
  120. 3:55health and women’s health, beyond
  121. 3:57just muscles. He suggested that maybe
  122. 3:59everyone in the world should be taking
  123. 4:01it. Today, I’m going to fact-check
  124. 4:03these two points. We don’t need to
  125. 4:05talk about muscles. That part is
  126. 4:07already proven. First, let’s look at
  127. 4:08the five misconceptions about side
  128. 4:10effects. First, the idea that it
  129. 4:12damages the kidneys is a misconception.
  130. 4:13That is definitely true. The fact that
  131. 4:16creatine causes no kidney problems has
  132. 4:19been as thoroughly verified as its
  133. 4:21effectiveness for muscles. It has been
  134. 4:24for decades. But why was there a
  135. 4:26misconception that creatine damages the
  136. 4:28kidneys? This is actually quite an
  137. 4:29interesting story. It’s about what we
  138. 4:31call the kidney filtration rate. The
  139. 4:33kidneys are what filter waste products
  140. 4:35to create urine. For example, let's say
  141. 4:36I go to the doctor for a checkup. If I
  142. 4:38ask them to measure my kidney function,
  143. 4:39there's no direct way to do it. There's
  144. 4:41no way to know if it's filtering things
  145. 4:43properly or not. It’s incredibly
  146. 4:44difficult. There are methods, but they
  147. 4:46require complex nuclear medicine scans.
  148. 4:47Usually, it can't be done. So, what
  149. 4:49they do is measure a level called
  150. 4:52creatinine. It’s just a substance
  151. 4:54used to gauge kidney levels. It’s
  152. 4:56creatinine. When you take creatine, it
  153. 4:58breaks down into creatinine. It’s a
  154. 5:01byproduct. Creatinine is just an
  155. 5:03indicator for kidney function. The
  156. 5:05substance itself isn't toxic. It was
  157. 5:08just accidentally chosen as a kidney
  158. 5:09function marker. It doesn't have any
  159. 5:11specific meaning on its own. What does
  160. 5:13that mean? Think of a sink. There's no
  161. 5:15easy way to check if a sink is clogged
  162. 5:18or how well the water drains. Since we
  163. 5:21can't measure the filtration directly,
  164. 5:22we measure the water level instead. If
  165. 5:24the water is high, we indirectly infer
  166. 5:26that the drainage isn't working well.
  167. 5:27That water level is what we call the
  168. 5:29creatinine kidney level. So, what does
  169. 5:32it mean to take creatine? It's like
  170. 5:33pouring an extra cup of water into the
  171. 5:34sink. Even if your kidney function is
  172. 5:36normal and drainage is smooth, the
  173. 5:37level will rise slightly. Because you
  174. 5:39added an extra cup of water. That’s
  175. 5:40all it is. That’s why your creatinine
  176. 5:42level rises when you take creatine. If
  177. 5:44you stop taking creatine, your
  178. 5:46creatinine levels will drop back down.
  179. 5:48Because the drainage was working fine
  180. 5:49all along. Your creatinine drops
  181. 5:50because your kidney function is
  182. 5:51actually healthy. But if doctors
  183. 5:53don’t know that, and they draw blood
  184. 5:55from someone taking creatine...
  185. 5:56They’ll see the high creatinine level
  186. 5:58. And say, "Oh, your kidneys are in bad
  187. 5:59shape." That’s how it happens. It’s
  188. 6:01inevitable. If doctors don't know
  189. 6:02you're taking creatine, they have no
  190. 6:04choice but to say that. That’s why
  191. 6:06people hear that creatine damages the
  192. 6:09kidneys. It’s like they think
  193. 6:10you’ve added something that only
  194. 6:12increases when kidneys are failing. But
  195. 6:14the substance itself doesn’t cause
  196. 6:15damage. So, if you take creatine and
  197. 6:18get a blood test, and the doctor says
  198. 6:19your levels are high...And tells you
  199. 6:21your kidneys seem damaged, you should
  200. 6:23just say, "I'm taking creatine." You
  201. 6:26can ask them to perform a Cystatin C
  202. 6:28test instead of a creatinine test. Just
  203. 6:31ask for a Cystatin C test, which checks
  204. 6:34kidney function independently of
  205. 6:37creatine. In fact, a recent
  206. 6:39meta-analysis of 19 RCTs showed no link
  207. 6:41between creatine intake and glomerular
  208. 6:44filtration rate in healthy adults.
  209. 6:46It’s just a false positive. It has
  210. 6:48been proven in numerous studies that
  211. 6:50increased creatinine levels don't mean
  212. 6:52kidney damage; the idea that creatine
  213. 6:54causes kidney damage is a complete
  214. 6:55misconception. The second is that it
  215. 6:57causes bloating. Bloating, in medical
  216. 6:59terms, is called edema. Edema means
  217. 7:01that water accumulates in the
  218. 7:03interstitial space, not inside the
  219. 7:04cells or blood vessels. It does not
  220. 7:06mean that cells or blood vessels are
  221. 7:08filled with water. The effect of
  222. 7:10creatine is that the cells themselves
  223. 7:12swell. Water is drawn into the cells.
  224. 7:13So, while the cells become firm and
  225. 7:15swell, it is not edema. Simply put, the
  226. 7:17muscles are getting fuller. When you
  227. 7:19work out and take creatine, it pulls
  228. 7:20water into the cells, so your muscles
  229. 7:22look slightly fuller. That's a good
  230. 7:24thing. In fact, your muscle mass
  231. 7:25increases. Whether temporary or
  232. 7:26permanent, your muscle mass increases
  233. 7:27while fat stays the same, so your body
  234. 7:29fat percentage drops. Your body fat
  235. 7:30percentage decreases slightly. It
  236. 7:31doesn't mean fat is being burned, but
  237. 7:33rather that your muscles are getting
  238. 7:34fuller, not experiencing edema. It's
  239. 7:36actually a benefit. That's how you
  240. 7:37should think about it. As the muscle
  241. 7:39cells swell and become firm, the
  242. 7:41pressure helps prevent protein
  243. 7:43breakdown. Some papers even claim it
  244. 7:45activates mTOR. There are talks like
  245. 7:47that. But it's highly likely that this
  246. 7:48isn't true. There is no evidence yet
  247. 7:50that creatine stimulates mTOR.
  248. 7:52Regardless, taking creatine acts as a
  249. 7:54backup battery for muscle synthesis and
  250. 7:56swells muscle cells, which helps muscle
  251. 7:58recovery in sarcopenia patients. This
  252. 8:01has been proven many times over, and
  253. 8:02there is no doubt that taking creatine
  254. 8:04is beneficial for increasing muscle
  255. 8:06mass and strength training. It doesn't
  256. 8:09cause muscle cramps; rather, it
  257. 8:10hydrates muscles, which actually helps
  258. 8:12prevent cramps. This is also a
  259. 8:13misconception. Next, it causes hair
  260. 8:15loss. This is a sensitive topic, isn't
  261. 8:17it? This misunderstanding arose because
  262. 8:19when rugby players took creatine and
  263. 8:22had blood tests, their levels of DHT,
  264. 8:24the male hormone that causes hair loss,
  265. 8:26were high. However, this was an old
  266. 8:29study, and there was no way to tell if
  267. 8:31the levels increased due to playing
  268. 8:33rugby or taking creatine. Recently, in
  269. 8:36a 12-week RCT, it was revealed that
  270. 8:38creatine intake has nothing to do with
  271. 8:41male hormone levels or hair health, so
  272. 8:43this has also been debunked. So, those
  273. 8:46four myths are incorrect, and the idea
  274. 8:48that it's only for men is false. It's
  275. 8:49even more effective for women. Let’s
  276. 8:51take a look at the effects one by one
  277. 8:53from now on. Let’s now look at three
  278. 9:00factors: additional effects, cognitive
  279. 9:02function, and women’s health. First,
  280. 9:04let's look at cognition. Creatine isn't
  281. 9:06just for muscles; it's also used by the
  282. 9:08brain. Now, if you think about it, that
  283. 9:10makes perfect sense. In our body, the
  284. 9:13organ that uses the most ATP, our main
  285. 9:14battery, is number one, muscle, and
  286. 9:16number two, the brain. Just think about
  287. 9:19it. Of course, things like maintaining
  288. 9:21body temperature and life support
  289. 9:22consume a significant amount of energy,
  290. 9:24but as far as organs go, it's muscles
  291. 9:26first and the brain second. It’s
  292. 9:27famous that the brain only makes up 2%
  293. 9:29of our body mass but consumes 20%of our
  294. 9:30energy. The brain is like a massive
  295. 9:32data center that requires high power.
  296. 9:35Since creatine acts as a backup battery
  297. 9:37, researchers tested whether taking it
  298. 9:39would help when the brain’s ATP is
  299. 9:41depleted. So, for students pulling
  300. 9:44all-nighters—I'm actually a bit
  301. 9:46worried parents might start feeding
  302. 9:48their kids creatine after this video—
  303. 9:50it seems relevant for them, as well as
  304. 9:52for emergency room staff, shift workers
  305. 9:55, pilots dealing with jet lag, or even
  306. 9:57during a World Cup final, where
  307. 9:59high-level cognition is needed. There
  308. 10:01was an opinion that giving high doses
  309. 10:04of creatine to people who need intense
  310. 10:06focus, like performers in concerts,
  311. 10:08would be helpful, so they actually
  312. 10:10tried keeping people awake for 21 hours
  313. 10:12. They deprived them of sleep, left
  314. 10:14them in a groggy state, and gave them
  315. 10:15more than the 3 to 5 grams of creatine
  316. 10:17I mentioned. They hit them with 20 to
  317. 10:1930 grams. They slammed the brain with a
  318. 10:20massive, high dose of creatine. Into
  319. 10:22the brain. Then they ran cognitive
  320. 10:23tests. The really difficult ones, you
  321. 10:24know. Where the color of the text
  322. 10:26differs from the word itself. Where you
  323. 10:27have to read "red" or "yellow" based on
  324. 10:28the color, stuff like that. They made
  325. 10:30them do that. It turned out that the
  326. 10:32group that took creatine had
  327. 10:33significantly higher scores. Since the
  328. 10:36brain consumes so much ATP, the backup
  329. 10:38battery provides immediate energy, so
  330. 10:40it makes total sense that it would work
  331. 10:42. So, how is this different from
  332. 10:45caffeine? We drink caffeine when we
  333. 10:48pull an all-nighter, and it wakes us up
  334. 10:49and restores our cognitive function.
  335. 10:51What’s the difference? Well, caffeine
  336. 10:53works because our brain breaks down ATP
  337. 10:56into ADP, AMP, and finally adenosine as
  338. 10:59it uses energy. Adenosine is actually a
  339. 11:01fatigue-inducing substance. These
  340. 11:02adenosine leftovers, accumulated from
  341. 11:04using energy, build up in the brain,
  342. 11:06making us feel tired. That’s how we
  343. 11:08feel sleepy and tired. That is because
  344. 11:10of adenosine. But caffeine essentially
  345. 11:12blocks the signal that tells you you
  346. 11:14need adenosine. So, the adenosine is
  347. 11:15still there, but your brain is tricked
  348. 11:17into thinking it isn't. It’s simply
  349. 11:18deceiving your brain. However, creatine
  350. 11:20is different; it slightly delays the
  351. 11:22depletion itself. Think of it like a
  352. 11:24smartphone—if you run games too much
  353. 11:26and it overheats, the performance drops
  354. 11:28. For humans, it’s like your brain
  355. 11:29function slowing down. We slow down
  356. 11:31when we don't get enough sleep. But
  357. 11:32caffeine is like cutting the wire that
  358. 11:34signals the heat. It’s like telling
  359. 11:36your phone it’s not hot even though
  360. 11:38it is. So, the performance keeps
  361. 11:39running. But your phone is actually
  362. 11:40breaking down; that’s what caffeine
  363. 11:41does. Creatine, on the other hand, is
  364. 11:43like adding an extra battery. It just
  365. 11:44pushes the heat off a bit longer. It
  366. 11:45slightly delays the drop in performance
  367. 11:47. Performance will still decline, but
  368. 11:49it’s delayed. Taking creatine won't
  369. 11:52make you feel sharp all night like
  370. 11:54coffee does, but it does help prevent
  371. 11:56that drop. I’ll explain minors taking
  372. 11:59it at the end, but I don’t really
  373. 12:00recommend it. Regardless, if you're an
  374. 12:02adult working all night, you could try
  375. 12:04creatine; plus, unlike caffeine, which
  376. 12:06causes sleep issues, heart palpitations
  377. 12:09, and withdrawal, creatine has none of
  378. 12:11that. Furthermore, there are many
  379. 12:13studies showing creatine helps with
  380. 12:15cognitive function. I’ve fact-checked
  381. 12:17it, and the results keep coming up. For
  382. 12:18instance, a meta-analysis of 16 RCTs
  383. 12:20showed significant improvements in
  384. 12:22memory. A recent 2025 systematic review
  385. 12:24found a positive correlation with
  386. 12:26memory and attention in five out of six
  387. 12:28studies. So, five out of six studies
  388. 12:30confirm that taking creatine improves
  389. 12:32memory and attention. There’s more
  390. 12:34too. It doubled the improvement in
  391. 12:36depression. It also provides protection
  392. 12:38against concussions. It even helps with
  393. 12:39dementia. There are many incredible
  394. 12:42studies like these, but while the
  395. 12:44memory and attention benefits seem
  396. 12:46solid, you should take the claims about
  397. 12:48depression, concussions, and dementia
  398. 12:50as findings from a smaller number of
  399. 12:52papers; regardless, it's clear creatine
  400. 12:54really helps with cognition. The
  401. 12:56cognitive benefits seem to be a fact.
  402. 12:59Let's look at women. Women. It's
  403. 13:01significant for women, too. Many
  404. 13:03thought creatine was only for men
  405. 13:04hitting the gym, but it turns out it
  406. 13:06influences female hormones and reduces
  407. 13:08fatigue during the luteal phase of the
  408. 13:10menstrual cycle. There’s research
  409. 13:11that shows exactly that. Now, this
  410. 13:12doesn't mean you'll lose weight, but as
  411. 13:14I mentioned earlier, since your muscle
  412. 13:15mass increases, your body fat
  413. 13:16percentage—the portion of your total
  414. 13:18mass made up of fat—goes down. Also,
  415. 13:20as I said, the remission rate for
  416. 13:21depression doubles. The key is that
  417. 13:23this depression research was
  418. 13:24specifically on female depression. It
  419. 13:25means it's even more beneficial for
  420. 13:26women. According to Dr. Beronken's
  421. 13:28claims, these studies actually exist.
  422. 13:30Now, above all, the part most worth
  423. 13:32recommending for women is bone health.
  424. 13:35Bone health. Creatine is an essential
  425. 13:37supplement for resistance training,
  426. 13:38right? Well, bones and muscles
  427. 13:39naturally go hand in hand. You can't do
  428. 13:41resistance training without your bones
  429. 13:43getting stronger. So, if it helps build
  430. 13:45muscle, it's only natural that your
  431. 13:46bones get stronger too. We know that
  432. 13:48muscle mass typically drops by 1%each
  433. 13:49year, but taking creatine and doing
  434. 13:51resistance training stops that decline.
  435. 13:52That part is well-known. But the same
  436. 13:54applies to bones. Especially for women,
  437. 13:56bone density drops vertically after
  438. 13:57menopause, but taking creatine along
  439. 13:59with strength training can help
  440. 14:00maintain bone strength. Now, here's a
  441. 14:02study that's hard to believe: it
  442. 14:03involves bisphosphonates. It suggests
  443. 14:05that the effect is comparable to
  444. 14:06osteoporosis medication. I personally
  445. 14:08find that hard to believe—it doesn't
  446. 14:10make sense that just taking creatine
  447. 14:12and lifting weights could match the
  448. 14:14effect of osteoporosis drugs—but
  449. 14:15regardless, that study exists. So,
  450. 14:17women should obviously take their
  451. 14:18osteoporosis medication if needed; I'm
  452. 14:20absolutely not saying to stop taking it
  453. 14:21or that this can replace it. That's not
  454. 14:23it, but please do take creatine and
  455. 14:24exercise, everyone. The bone density
  456. 14:26loss actually drops from 4%down to 1.2%
  457. 14:28. It's not that the loss stops or
  458. 14:30reverses, but the rate of decline slows
  459. 14:31down significantly. It basically falls
  460. 14:33much more slowly. It slows down the
  461. 14:34process. And for the record, I want to
  462. 14:37say this very seriously: women should
  463. 14:38do strength training, not just for
  464. 14:40their bones, but to increase muscle
  465. 14:41mass in general. In my 8 years of doing
  466. 14:45YouTube and 20 years as a doctor, the
  467. 14:47one thing that always gets to me is
  468. 14:49when people say, "Won't I get too bulky
  469. 14:52with big, lumpy muscles?" Are you
  470. 14:53really afraid to exercise because
  471. 14:54you're worried about getting too big?
  472. 14:55It's so frustrating whenever I hear
  473. 14:57that; that's just not the case. Not at
  474. 14:58all. I can say this with certainty:
  475. 15:01when I worked at a secondary hospital,
  476. 15:03I had every diabetic patient who
  477. 15:05visited me get an InBody scan. I have
  478. 15:08almost never, ever seen a woman whose
  479. 15:10muscle mass was within the normal range
  480. 15:12. Not a single one was high, and I've
  481. 15:14barely ever seen one even reach the
  482. 15:16normal range. Of course, that might be
  483. 15:18because they were diabetic patients,
  484. 15:19but they are all lacking. Male diabetic
  485. 15:21patients have varying muscle mass—
  486. 15:22some have a lot, some a moderate amount
  487. 15:24, and some very little—but women all
  488. 15:25seem to come in with the same issue.
  489. 15:27They have almost none. Women really
  490. 15:29seem to think that if they do strength
  491. 15:31training or work out at a gym, they'll
  492. 15:33turn into sumo wrestlers, weightlifters
  493. 15:35, or wrestlers. But for 90%of women,
  494. 15:39even if you put your life on the line
  495. 15:41and work out at your absolute maximum,
  496. 15:43this level of muscle mass is the limit.
  497. 15:47You shouldn't overestimate your own
  498. 15:48muscle-building potential. For instance
  499. 15:50, there might be women who are like
  500. 15:52Jang Mi-ran, right? About 0.001%of the
  501. 15:54population? Yes, such people might
  502. 15:55exist. Saying you're afraid to train
  503. 15:56because you're scared you'll get too
  504. 15:57bulky is like saying you're afraid to
  505. 15:57work because you're scared you'll
  506. 15:57become a billionaire. It's exactly the
  507. 15:58same thing. South Korea is a country
  508. 16:00with a lack of physical activity on a
  509. 16:02global scale, and among them, women's
  510. 16:03exercise levels are severely
  511. 16:05insufficient. This is all backed by
  512. 16:06data. It's simply a fact. Women, you
  513. 16:08are not exercising enough. There are
  514. 16:09many reasons for this, but I believe
  515. 16:11part of it is the misconception
  516. 16:13regarding strength training. I’ve
  517. 16:15heard those concerns so many times. I
  518. 16:16really want to lose weight, but you
  519. 16:17need plenty of muscle to lose weight
  520. 16:19effectively, too. You need muscle to
  521. 16:20boost your basal metabolic rate so your
  522. 16:21body burns more energy during your
  523. 16:22daily routine. You really need to aim
  524. 16:23for that level. It absolutely, truly
  525. 16:25will not happen that way. That person
  526. 16:26belongs in the national training center
  527. 16:28. You don't need to worry about that;
  528. 16:30for building skeletal muscle, 3 to 5
  529. 16:32grams is a proven, safe dosage
  530. 16:34established over decades. These two
  531. 16:37points are my stance on dosage
  532. 16:39limitations, and while I won't tell you
  533. 16:41to take that much, I can say with
  534. 16:43certainty that women must do strength
  535. 16:45training, and secondly, you must
  536. 16:47consume at least 3 to 5 grams of
  537. 16:49creatine while doing so. This is
  538. 16:51something I can definitely tell you.
  539. 16:54Now, although I’ve mentioned women,
  540. 16:56they weren't the main focus today.
  541. 16:58Let's look at today's main topic:
  542. 17:01longevity and creatine. The study cited
  543. 17:08by Dr. Dechend is just this one. With
  544. 17:11the release of this study, creatine
  545. 17:13became associated with longevity.
  546. 17:15However, this isn't a study that should
  547. 17:17be overlooked. It was published in 2025
  548. 17:19and focuses on adults in the U.S. aged
  549. 17:2150 and older. These are people with an
  550. 17:23average age of 68—not quite grandmas
  551. 17:24and grandpas yet, but let's call them
  552. 17:26our older peers. It only measured
  553. 17:27creatine intake from diet. This is the
  554. 17:29regrettable part. They should have
  555. 17:30included supplements, but they only
  556. 17:31looked at dietary creatine intake and
  557. 17:33biological age, excluding supplements.
  558. 17:34You know about biological age, right?
  559. 17:35It's measured through biological
  560. 17:36markers. I measured DNA methylation age
  561. 17:39. When we measured 5,000 people with an
  562. 17:41average age of 68 this way, the average
  563. 17:43dietary creatine intake for the seniors
  564. 17:45was less than 1g. 0.77 g—they weren't
  565. 17:48eating much meat. But we said we need
  566. 17:50to consume 3 to 5g. Of course, it would
  567. 17:51have been great if we had measured
  568. 17:52supplements as well. Regardless, from a
  569. 17:54dietary perspective, it’s woefully
  570. 17:55insufficient. So, how do variations
  571. 17:57within this 0.77 g intake affect
  572. 17:59biological age? Now, this is the most
  573. 18:01important conclusion for today. When we
  574. 18:03tested it, we confirmed a clear inverse
  575. 18:06relationship. The more creatine you
  576. 18:08consume, the younger your biological
  577. 18:10age. You get younger. That was the
  578. 18:12dose-response relationship. For every
  579. 18:141g of extra creatine, your biological
  580. 18:17age decreases by 1.3 years. If this
  581. 18:20paper is correct, arithmetically
  582. 18:22speaking, just by taking 3g more of
  583. 18:24creatine, you turn back the clock by
  584. 18:26four years, everyone. It's anti-aging.
  585. 18:29A 64-year-old taking 3g of creatine
  586. 18:32daily becomes 60. Now, the paper
  587. 18:34suggests six mechanisms, which seem
  588. 18:37quite intuitive. Creatine is for energy
  589. 18:39metabolism and supply, like a backup
  590. 18:40battery. It obviously helps with energy
  591. 18:41metabolism and preserves muscle.
  592. 18:42We’ve talked about this before. It
  593. 18:44prevents muscle loss and protects
  594. 18:45neurons, as we’ve discussed.
  595. 18:46Cognitive function is also being proven
  596. 18:47. As for nutrient density, foods rich
  597. 18:49in creatine are things like beef and
  598. 18:51herring. They have high nutrient
  599. 18:52density. Couldn't it be that those
  600. 18:53accompanying nutrients helped as well?
  601. 18:55These four points are almost certainly
  602. 18:57true. Actually, in terms of muscle
  603. 18:59preservation, seniors aren't
  604. 19:01necessarily experiencing longevity or
  605. 19:03anti-aging due to some magic, but
  606. 19:05rather the proven role of preserving
  607. 19:07muscle. Of course, strength training
  608. 19:10must be a prerequisite, but taking
  609. 19:11creatine while strength training
  610. 19:13definitely preserves muscle. That alone
  611. 19:15is essentially anti-aging. Even without
  612. 19:17these complex DNA mechanisms, this part
  613. 19:19is true. Doesn't it seem like we have
  614. 19:21to consider it anti-aging? I’ll state
  615. 19:24that as my conclusion for now. So these
  616. 19:27four are correct, and the paper
  617. 19:29suggests that antioxidant effects and
  618. 19:31DNA stabilization are the real, unique
  619. 19:33anti-aging mechanisms of pure creatine,
  620. 19:35so let's look at those two. It
  621. 19:39preserves methylation. Now, what does
  622. 19:40that mean? I explained this during my
  623. 19:42young science book review; there's
  624. 19:44something called DNA methylation. We
  625. 19:46use these methyl groups for various
  626. 19:48functions. For example, our bodies
  627. 19:51actually carry cancer-causing genes. I
  628. 19:55have it, you have it, everyone from
  629. 19:57children to adults has it. But why
  630. 19:59doesn't cancer develop? It's because we
  631. 20:00have methyl groups attached to
  632. 20:02cancer-causing genes. When we're young,
  633. 20:04we attach these methyl groups to switch
  634. 20:05off those cancer-causing genes. That's
  635. 20:07why cancer doesn't develop, but as we
  636. 20:08age, these methyl groups gradually
  637. 20:10decrease. That's why cancer occurs. As
  638. 20:11we get older. So, we sometimes use this
  639. 20:13to measure biological age. How many
  640. 20:14methyl groups are attached. Also, SAM
  641. 20:16is a bag that holds methyl groups, and
  642. 20:18once it releases the methyl group, it
  643. 20:20becomes an empty bag, which then turns
  644. 20:21homocysteine into an inflammatory
  645. 20:23substance. This inflammatory substance,
  646. 20:25homocysteine, then causes
  647. 20:26cardiovascular disease. So, as we age
  648. 20:27and methyl groups run low, we end up
  649. 20:29with cardiovascular disease. Ultimately
  650. 20:31, when methyl groups are scarce, they
  651. 20:32cause both cancer and cardiovascular
  652. 20:34disease. That's why we take folic acid
  653. 20:36to replenish our methyl groups. We eat
  654. 20:38spinach, broccoli, and things like that
  655. 20:40. To live a long life. This is a truly
  656. 20:41genuine anti-aging substance, but
  657. 20:43regardless, methyl groups are that
  658. 20:44precious. But what’s funny is that I
  659. 20:46mentioned earlier that our body
  660. 20:48produces 1 to 2 grams of creatine every
  661. 20:50single day. To produce that, it uses up
  662. 20:5340 to 50%of our methyl groups. It's
  663. 20:56using up half of those precious methyl
  664. 20:57groups—the ones that block cancer and
  665. 20:59cardiovascular disease—just to make a
  666. 21:01measly 1 or 2 grams of creatine. Inside
  667. 21:02our bodies. What does that mean? It
  668. 21:04means that just by taking this, we can
  669. 21:06mathematically save half of our methyl
  670. 21:08groups. While it doesn't mean this will
  671. 21:10definitely happen just by taking it,
  672. 21:12theoretically, in terms of mechanism,
  673. 21:13it could be the case. That's the claim
  674. 21:15being made. In fact, when people took
  675. 21:17creatine, homocysteine levels dropped.
  676. 21:19SAM was restored. There are studies
  677. 21:22like that. So, it seems that this is
  678. 21:24correct. This mechanism also stabilizes
  679. 21:26DNA. Then what is antioxidant effect?
  680. 21:28Antioxidant effect is about getting rid
  681. 21:29of active oxygen, right? If you think
  682. 21:30about it, this is also obvious. Since
  683. 21:31mitochondria are like nuclear power
  684. 21:33plants, they emit radiation. The name
  685. 21:35of that radiation is active oxygen. So,
  686. 21:37mitochondria ultimately produce active
  687. 21:38oxygen. In our bodies. But what is it?
  688. 21:40Creatine is what preserves ATP. So,
  689. 21:43naturally, less active oxygen is
  690. 21:44produced. Then it becomes anti-aging as
  691. 21:45well. It makes an indirect contribution
  692. 21:47to reducing active oxygen, and there's
  693. 21:49another indirect principle, as well as
  694. 21:50a direct principle being suggested
  695. 21:52where creatine eliminates active oxygen
  696. 21:53itself. It means these mechanisms exist
  697. 21:54as well. So, it seems correct that it
  698. 21:56also has antioxidant effects. Creatine
  699. 21:58provides energy. It acts as an
  700. 21:59antioxidant. It preserves muscle. It
  701. 22:00also protects brain nerves. It even
  702. 22:01boosts cognitive function. DNA
  703. 22:02stabilization is definitely correct.
  704. 22:04Regardless of how you look at it,
  705. 22:05studies on creatine intake and hair
  706. 22:07loss are still limited to just one, and
  707. 22:09it’s not even an observational study.
  708. 22:11Since it's a cross-sectional study, it
  709. 22:12obviously can't determine causality,
  710. 22:14though a link is possible. So, we
  711. 22:16can’t tell if the creatine caused the
  712. 22:18hair loss, or if people experiencing
  713. 22:19hair loss just happen to eat more
  714. 22:21creatine-rich foods. Ultimately, since
  715. 22:24the supplement data is still limited, I
  716. 22:26can't definitively tell you today that
  717. 22:28taking creatine will make you go bald.
  718. 22:29Or that it makes you live longer. Or
  719. 22:30that it helps with longevity. I
  720. 22:31obviously can’t make such bold claims
  721. 22:34; that wouldn't make sense, but this
  722. 22:36paper does have some merit. That much I
  723. 22:39can say for sure. I looked into various
  724. 22:41studies, and there are animal studies.
  725. 22:43Some animal studies show that creatine
  726. 22:45increased lifespan, while others show
  727. 22:47no effect. So, it’s basically a
  728. 22:48toss-up. It’s ambiguous. But the
  729. 22:50problem is, there are no studies
  730. 22:51showing that creatine increases human
  731. 22:53lifespan. If such research existed, we
  732. 22:55would certainly know about it by now.
  733. 22:57However, there is an abundance of
  734. 22:59research on creatine preventing
  735. 23:01sarcopenia in the elderly or improving
  736. 23:03physical function and preventing
  737. 23:05frailty. So, putting aside all these
  738. 23:08mechanistic claims, isn't simply
  739. 23:10preventing muscle loss a form of
  740. 23:12longevity in itself? I personally
  741. 23:15believe that elderly people should
  742. 23:17absolutely take creatine. I’m certain
  743. 23:19of this. Of course, provided they
  744. 23:21include strength training. So, I looked
  745. 23:22into whether there’s any downside for
  746. 23:24a healthy, average person who doesn't
  747. 23:26strength train to take 3 to 5g of
  748. 23:27creatine. I did some digging. It seems
  749. 23:29there are no downsides. No matter how
  750. 23:31much I think about it. I think Dr.
  751. 23:32Decken is right. It saves energy,
  752. 23:34doesn't it? As we confirmed earlier, it
  753. 23:36also slightly reduces homocysteine. It
  754. 23:38also helps a bit with cognitive
  755. 23:39function. It can be helpful when
  756. 23:40working overnight or similar tasks. And
  757. 23:42it clearly has no nephrotoxicity or
  758. 23:43hepatotoxicity. You know that common
  759. 23:44concern? People say that if you just
  760. 23:46consume tons of whey protein without
  761. 23:48exercising, it stimulates mTOR and
  762. 23:49accelerates aging. Creatine doesn't
  763. 23:50have that effect. While there’s a
  764. 23:52claim that cell swelling might slightly
  765. 23:54stimulate mTOR, nothing has been proven
  766. 23:56yet regarding creatine doing so. I'm
  767. 23:58not saying you shouldn't exercise, just
  768. 24:00like with protein. You absolutely must
  769. 24:01exercise. Everyone, while doing this
  770. 24:04PPT presentation, I had a realization;
  771. 24:05today's discussion is about whether
  772. 24:07there's any harm in healthy people
  773. 24:08taking creatine. It's even more so for
  774. 24:10exercise. Is there any reason for a
  775. 24:12healthy person not to exercise? There
  776. 24:13isn't. Even less so. You should
  777. 24:15definitely exercise and take it, but
  778. 24:16the conclusion is that you can take it
  779. 24:18even if you don't. Today. So, here is
  780. 24:20the conclusion. Who benefits from
  781. 24:21taking creatine? Almost everyone.
  782. 24:23Vegetarians, especially those who can't
  783. 24:24get creatine from their diet. These
  784. 24:26people will see even greater effects
  785. 24:28from taking creatine. Next, the elderly
  786. 24:29, whether they have sarcopenia or not,
  787. 24:30or do strength training or not—you
  788. 24:32should definitely take it. Just take it
  789. 24:33. But definitely do strength training
  790. 24:34too. Those who are sleep-deprived,
  791. 24:36high-intensity cognitive workers, and
  792. 24:37adults who work overnight—I don't
  793. 24:39think there's any harm in taking it.
  794. 24:40Just like drinking coffee. And for
  795. 24:42those doing high-intensity workouts,
  796. 24:43you obviously should be taking it. Also
  797. 24:45, for normal, average adults who just
  798. 24:46walk, there's no reason not to take it,
  799. 24:48even if it might not have much of an
  800. 24:50effect. You need to understand that
  801. 24:52very subtle nuance. There might be
  802. 24:54almost no effect. As mentioned earlier,
  803. 24:56things like muscle preservation haven't
  804. 24:57been fully proven, so there might not
  805. 24:58be any effect, but there's no harm in
  806. 25:00taking it. So, I will summarize the
  807. 25:02five conclusions from Dr. Daeryung’s
  808. 25:04fact check. Finally. First, the elderly
  809. 25:11and those doing muscle-strengthening
  810. 25:13exercises—definitely take it.
  811. 25:14Excluding those who shouldn't take it,
  812. 25:15which I'll mention later, the cognitive
  813. 25:17side seems almost certainly true. It
  814. 25:18seems good for almost everyone to take
  815. 25:20it; even if the effect is lower for
  816. 25:21healthy average people, there’s no
  817. 25:23harm in it. This is also mostly true,
  818. 25:24though anti-aging is ambiguous. There's
  819. 25:26nothing proven regarding human lifespan
  820. 25:27, but it makes sense. It seems like
  821. 25:29more research is needed, and I'll
  822. 25:30explain who should not take it from now
  823. 25:31on. There are two groups who should
  824. 25:33absolutely not take creatine: first,
  825. 25:35those with bipolar disorder. There are
  826. 25:36people who swing between mania and
  827. 25:37depression, right? There are reports
  828. 25:39that taking this can trigger a switch
  829. 25:40to mania. So, patients with bipolar
  830. 25:42disorder should not take it, and next,
  831. 25:43those with poor kidney function; I've
  832. 25:45said this repeatedly, it doesn't damage
  833. 25:47the kidneys. But it interferes with
  834. 25:48blood tests. Especially, it could
  835. 25:49increase the burden in cases of
  836. 25:50nephrotic syndrome. There is talk of
  837. 25:52this as well. So this part is quite
  838. 25:53clear. If you have bad kidneys and are
  839. 25:55seeing a nephrologist. It's better for
  840. 25:56these people to just not take it. Of
  841. 25:57course, if you consult your
  842. 25:58nephrologist and they say it's okay,
  843. 26:00you might take it, but generally, it's
  844. 26:01safer to avoid it; there's no data for
  845. 26:03pregnant or nursing women. It's not
  846. 26:04that it's definitely harmful, but we
  847. 26:05just don't know. Since it's ambiguous,
  848. 26:07just don't take it. If you have
  849. 26:08allergies, you definitely shouldn't
  850. 26:10take it, and those three or four groups
  851. 26:11simply don't need to take it. Now, I
  852. 26:14also looked into teenagers; my daughter
  853. 26:16is currently a high school student and
  854. 26:18a test-taker who studies late, so I
  855. 26:19wondered if I should give it to her,
  856. 26:21but the clinical data is the same.
  857. 26:24There’s no proof that it’s
  858. 26:26dangerous. But there’s also no proof
  859. 26:27that it’s safe. Dr. Darren Candow
  860. 26:29says teenagers should definitely take
  861. 26:31it, but while we let them drink coffee,
  862. 26:34it hasn't been clearly proven that
  863. 26:35creatine is on that same level, so
  864. 26:37personally, I wouldn't give it to my
  865. 26:39high school daughter. Dr. Candow says
  866. 26:42to give it to them, and he is a much
  867. 26:44higher authority, so I don't know who
  868. 26:45is right, but since I’m in a position
  869. 26:47where I have to be conservative and
  870. 26:48safe, it’s ambiguous. I recommend not
  871. 26:50taking it. That’s what I’d say. Now
  872. 26:52, the last point. How should you take
  873. 26:54it? Well, it’s very easy. Just take 3
  874. 26:56to 5 grams. You could split the dose
  875. 26:58like 10 to 20 grams as mentioned
  876. 27:00earlier, but just taking 3 to 5 grams
  877. 27:02daily should be fine. Back in my day,
  878. 27:03when I first started working out, they
  879. 27:05used to say you had to load 20 grams of
  880. 27:07creatine and then drop to 3 grams once
  881. 27:08your blood levels were up, but that’s
  882. 27:10not the case anymore. Loading isn't
  883. 27:11necessary. There’s nothing else to it
  884. 27:13. Just 3 to 5 grams, that’s it.
  885. 27:14Simple. What form should you take?
  886. 27:16There are so many types of creatine out
  887. 27:17there, but you don't need any of them.
  888. 27:18This is also very straightforward. Just
  889. 27:20take Creatine Monohydrate. That’s the
  890. 27:23standard form. Just search for Creatine
  891. 27:24Monohydrate and take whatever comes up.
  892. 27:26This part is important. I was surprised
  893. 27:27too, but apparently, the raw materials
  894. 27:28come from either Germany or China.
  895. 27:30German-made is the way to go. It has a
  896. 27:3299.9%purity level, while Chinese-made
  897. 27:34products aren't quite at 99.9%and
  898. 27:36reportedly have some impurities. And
  899. 27:38those impurities could potentially
  900. 27:40contain toxic substances. It doesn't
  901. 27:42mean they definitely contain toxic
  902. 27:43substances. It’s not for sure, but
  903. 27:44there’s a possibility. So, obviously,
  904. 27:46it’s better to choose the higher
  905. 27:47purity, and you can find it by
  906. 27:49searching for "Creapure." This is not
  907. 27:51an advertisement, and it’s not a
  908. 27:52brand name. It’s more like a
  909. 27:53certification mark. I’ll show you.
  910. 27:55See, if you search for "Creapure" on
  911. 27:56the internet, a bunch of products will
  912. 27:58pop up like this. I just searched for
  913. 28:00it exactly like that to show you what
  914. 28:02comes up. The company doesn't matter. I
  915. 28:04have no affiliation with any of them.
  916. 28:05Look here. Just look for this mark. You
  917. 28:07see this Creapure label here? It's
  918. 28:09right here, right? Here it is. Right
  919. 28:11here. It's right here. It doesn't
  920. 28:12matter which one it is. Now, let me
  921. 28:13explain how to search on Coupang. If
  922. 28:15you type "creatine" in English on
  923. 28:16Coupang, it shows up. Right there. The
  924. 28:18mark. It’s on all of these, right
  925. 28:20here. It’s right here. The companies
  926. 28:22are all different now. It doesn't
  927. 28:23matter which one. This one, or this one
  928. 28:25. Things like this. So, I looked it up,
  929. 28:28and thought "Ah, I see," then checked
  930. 28:30the creatine I was taking. And it
  931. 28:32wasn't there. So, I put the brand
  932. 28:35I’ve been taking into ChatGPT. It
  933. 28:37said, "Bip, bip, warning! That product
  934. 28:39uses ingredients from China." That’s
  935. 28:40what it told me. Oh, it made me so
  936. 28:42frustrated. Anyway, it’s a waste to
  937. 28:43throw it away, so I’ll finish it, but
  938. 28:45you guys should look for the
  939. 28:46German-made ones that say "Creapure."
  940. 28:48I'm going to buy the German one once
  941. 28:49I'm done with this, so when is the best
  942. 28:51time to take it? It doesn't really
  943. 28:52matter, but the best timing is right
  944. 28:54after a workout with carbohydrates and
  945. 28:55protein. They say that's the most
  946. 28:57efficient way. 3 to 5 grams, and since
  947. 28:59it’s flavorless, you can mix it into
  948. 29:01rice or anything else. After
  949. 29:03fact-checking Dr. Attia’s podcast
  950. 29:04extensively, the conclusion I’ve
  951. 29:06reached is that, while it’s not
  952. 29:08exactly a magical fountain-of-youth
  953. 29:09elixir for immortality based on current
  954. 29:11evidence, it certainly helps with
  955. 29:13functional health and the
  956. 29:14musculoskeletal system. That much is
  957. 29:16certain. So, the conclusion so far is
  958. 29:18that it’s a conditionally essential
  959. 29:20nutrient for maintaining functional
  960. 29:22health span. Alright, so today I’ve
  961. 29:27covered everything from the new effects
  962. 29:29of creatine, its impact on cognition
  963. 29:31and women’s health, to how to take it
  964. 29:33. Let’s wrap up with our three-line
  965. 29:36summary. Did you find today's video
  966. 29:53helpful? If it was helpful, subscribe
  967. 29:55here and check out the related videos
  968. 29:56over here.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 최신 과학이 밝힌 크레아틴의 항노화, 뇌인지 기능, 뼈 건강 추가 효과ㅣ닥터딩요 by 닥터딩요, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,025 words across 968 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.