Rules Committee Hearing H.R. 7008, H.R. 6959, H.R. 8884, H.R. 8800, H.R. 9770 , H. Con. Res. 113 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 1:59Mhm.
- 3:54>> Mhm.
- 5:47>> Good afternoon. The committee will come
- 5:49to order.
- 5:50Without objection, the chair is
- 5:51authorized to declare recess at any
- 5:53time.
- 5:55Before we begin, I want to take a moment
- 5:56to recognize Ashley Anderson.
- 6:00Um a member of the majority staff on the
- 6:02committee who'll be leaving at the end
- 6:04of this month.
- 6:06Ashley started in Congress in 2017 with
- 6:09Martha McSally, then went on to work for
- 6:12Mr. Reschenthaler, Ms. Miller-Meeks, and
- 6:15then came to the Rules Committee as
- 6:17policy director for Chairman Burgess in
- 6:202024.
- 6:21Ashley, it's been a pleasure to work
- 6:24alongside you, and we'll certainly miss
- 6:26you here at the Rules Committee. All of
- 6:28us are rooting for you in this new and
- 6:31exciting chapter of your career.
- 6:39You're looking entirely too happy.
- 6:46Uh, now we turn to the business before
- 6:49us.
- 6:50Today, the Rules Committee is convening
- 6:52to consider four measures, H.R. 6955,
- 6:56H.R. 7008,
- 6:59H.Con.Res. 113, and H.R. 9770.
- 7:03H.R. 6955,
- 7:06the Main Street Capital Access Act,
- 7:09would tailor bank regulations based on
- 7:11the size of the financial institution to
- 7:15spur local bank formation and to empower
- 7:18community lenders.
- 7:20When the Dodd-Frank Act was signed into
- 7:22law, community and mid-size banks were
- 7:25unnecessarily subjected to a regulatory
- 7:29structure designed for large, complex
- 7:32financial institutions.
- 7:34This caused a ripple effect throughout
- 7:36communities across the nation. Local
- 7:39lending was suffocated, and the American
- 7:41people were the ones most affected. HR
- 7:446955
- 7:46ensures community lenders can focus on
- 7:49serving families, small businesses, and
- 7:51local economies, making life more
- 7:54affordable for Americans, and empowering
- 7:56Main Street.
- 7:58HR 7008,
- 8:00the Stop Insider Trading Act, would
- 8:03prohibit members of Congress, their
- 8:05spouses, or dependent children from
- 8:08purchasing stocks that are publicly
- 8:10traded.
- 8:11Additionally, this legislation would
- 8:13require members of Congress
- 8:16to disclose publicly each intended sale
- 8:20of stocks with the clerk of the House
- 8:23prior to its sale.
- 8:25Further, should any infractions occur,
- 8:28the House Ethics Committee would issue a
- 8:31fee
- 8:33a fine
- 8:34to the offending member equal to $2,000
- 8:40or 10%
- 8:41of the value of the covered investment,
- 8:44whichever is greater, plus the net gain
- 8:48realized from the sale.
- 8:53In addition, this legislation aims to
- 8:55restore trust in our election systems by
- 8:59implementing a common sense requirement
- 9:01of showing a valid photo ID to vote in
- 9:04federal elections.
- 9:0624 states already require photo ID to be
- 9:10presented prior to voting.
- 9:12Heck, you even need to present a photo
- 9:14ID to utilize the Olive Garden's
- 9:17never-ending pasta pass.
- 9:1980% of the American people believe
- 9:23showing photo ID at the polls makes
- 9:25sense.
- 9:26It's beyond time to make this simple
- 9:28first step to securing our election
- 9:30system.
- 9:32H. Con. Res. 113, the concurrent
- 9:34resolution on the budget for fiscal year
- 9:372027
- 9:39unlocks the very first step in advancing
- 9:42our third reconciliation package under
- 9:45the House Republican majority.
- 9:47This concurrent resolution covers three
- 9:50issues of paramount importance.
- 9:53Providing additional resources for
- 9:55baseline readiness
- 9:57so that the men and women of the armed
- 9:59forces
- 10:00are given the tools they need to carry
- 10:03out their mission successfully.
- 10:06Securing American elections, an issue
- 10:09that the American people remain very
- 10:12attuned to
- 10:13and support through and through.
- 10:16And supporting our nation's farmers and
- 10:19ensuring that our nation's food supply
- 10:21and food security remain as strong as
- 10:24they can possibly be.
- 10:26I look forward to the forthcoming
- 10:28testimony of our colleagues on why
- 10:30advancing this first step of our third
- 10:33reconciliation measure is so important.
- 10:37Finally, we turn to HR 9770,
- 10:40the continuing resolution that would
- 10:42fully fund the federal government
- 10:44through December 4th of this year.
- 10:47The House has been working diligently to
- 10:49pass standalone appropriations bills
- 10:52consistent with regular order.
- 10:54While we remain optimistic about the
- 10:56work of Chairman Cole and our colleagues
- 10:59in this process, that does not mean we
- 11:02should blind ourselves to the reality of
- 11:05the timeline ahead of us.
- 11:07We will likely need some kind of
- 11:10short-term extension to keep some, if
- 11:13not all, of our government open past the
- 11:15end of the fiscal year.
- 11:18Providing a buffer to continue our
- 11:19Article 1 duties of funding the
- 11:21government is prudent, responsible, and
- 11:25necessary.
- 11:27I know that Democrats supported
- 11:30virtually all of the current funding
- 11:32levels for agencies.
- 11:34They should do so again to responsibly
- 11:37ensure that an unnecessary collapse in
- 11:41government functions will not occur this
- 11:44fall.
- 11:45Unfortunately, if past is prologue,
- 11:48our Democrat colleagues may very well
- 11:50once again
- 11:52prove themselves incapable of supporting
- 11:54the continuity of government given their
- 11:57previous shutdown antics.
- 11:59I hope that is not the case today.
- 12:02We have the obligation to advance
- 12:04funding immediately
- 12:06so that the government does not bear the
- 12:08brunt once more of political
- 12:10gamesmanship
- 12:12and obstruction spurred by our
- 12:14colleagues across the aisle.
- 12:16With that, I now yield to the ranking
- 12:18member for any comments he wishes to
- 12:20make.
- 12:22>> Well, thank you, Madam Chair, and let me
- 12:23begin by saying that I want to associate
- 12:25myself with your kind words about
- 12:27Ashley's uh service to this committee.
- 12:30Um and we wish her nothing but the best
- 12:32in her next chapter. Um and um
- 12:36you know, the people who serve on the
- 12:37staff here in the Rules Committee work
- 12:39awfully long hours. Um
- 12:41Um probably more than any other
- 12:43committee. Uh and we don't thank them
- 12:44enough, but I wish you all the best,
- 12:46Ashley.
- 12:47And now, uh Madam Chair, there's a lot
- 12:49uh before us today,
- 12:51including two bills that we already
- 12:53considered 3 weeks ago.
- 12:55Uh they are back on the agenda because
- 12:57Republican leaders sent everyone home
- 12:59before bringing these bills to the floor
- 13:01since they didn't have the votes to pass
- 13:03their own rule.
- 13:04So, now we're doing it all over again.
- 13:08And then there are a few new things
- 13:09before us today. First, a a budget
- 13:11proposal that in that includes 73 3
- 13:15billion dollars for Donald Trump's new
- 13:17never-ending war in Iran that Congress
- 13:20already voted to end.
- 13:22A 12 billion dollar band-aid for farmers
- 13:24who are hurting, which I would say is a
- 13:26pretty big admission that Trump's tariff
- 13:28policies have devastated American
- 13:30farmers.
- 13:31And of course $10 billion to indulge the
- 13:34president's insane election conspiracy
- 13:37theories.
- 13:38I don't know how many of you watched his
- 13:39speech last Thursday, but it was both
- 13:41wacky and scary. You wacky because it
- 13:44was one conspiracy theory after another.
- 13:46Scary because this guy's actually
- 13:47sitting in the Oval Office.
- 13:50Together this budget framework outlines
- 13:52nearly $100 billion. That's billion with
- 13:56a B in funding with zero pay fors.
- 14:01Even Republicans know this thing is a
- 14:03dud. One Republican said and I quote,
- 14:05"$95 billion
- 14:07in new deficit spending, no offsets, and
- 14:10not one provision to lower the cost of
- 14:12living." end quote. Other Republican
- 14:14members have called it quote dead on
- 14:16arrival.
- 14:17There's also a continuing resolution to
- 14:18keep the government open.
- 14:20The funding deadline is months away and
- 14:22Republicans are already admitting they
- 14:23cannot finish their work.
- 14:25Instead they're trying to punt our work
- 14:27until December 4th.
- 14:29We also have before us the Stop Insider
- 14:32Trading Act.
- 14:33I absolutely support a ban on
- 14:35congressional stock trading. You
- 14:37shouldn't be able to use public power
- 14:38for private profit. I agree with that
- 14:41100%.
- 14:43But the idea that this Republican
- 14:44Congress has suddenly seen the light is
- 14:47a joke.
- 14:49The net worth of Donald Trump and his
- 14:50family have grown on a scale without
- 14:53precedent. We just found out his own
- 14:55teleprompter operator has been illegally
- 14:58cashing in on Cal-Maine Foods. I mean
- 15:01the corruption is staggering.
- 15:03And now the president wants to sell
- 15:06early access to his market-moving social
- 15:08media posts to those who can afford it.
- 15:11This president and this Republican party
- 15:14are rotten to the core and corrupt
- 15:16through and through.
- 15:17This is a nice little game they're
- 15:19playing bringing the stock trading ban
- 15:21to the floor and attaching it to get
- 15:23this, an unrelated partisan bill to make
- 15:26it harder for American citizens to vote
- 15:28in elections.
- 15:29But, that's what they're doing, and it's
- 15:30a game to them. It's all a game. If they
- 15:33cared about corruption, they could have
- 15:35banned stock trading 18 months ago.
- 15:38Uh and they could have brought a bill to
- 15:39the floor to address the blatant,
- 15:41brazen, shocking corruption at the White
- 15:43House.
- 15:44Instead, we get this totally inadequate
- 15:47and insufficient bill, which they know
- 15:49is dead on arrival in the Senate.
- 15:51And finally, there's Republican's
- 15:53so-called Main Street Capital Access
- 15:55Act.
- 15:57Lovely name. Wall Street must have focus
- 15:59grouped it.
- 16:00This bill makes bank mergers easier,
- 16:03regulators weaker, and oversight looser.
- 16:06What could possibly go wrong?
- 16:09Republicans run the House, they run the
- 16:11Senate, and the White House. What they
- 16:13lack is any idea on how to use it to
- 16:15make people's lives better.
- 16:16Power
- 16:18is supposed to be about helping people.
- 16:20And instead, this majority uses uses it
- 16:23to protect the president, to pay off the
- 16:25powerful, and to funnel more money into
- 16:28yet another endless war. The American
- 16:31people deserve a hell of a lot better,
- 16:34and I yield back my time.
- 16:36>> Thank you very much, Mr. McGovern.
- 16:39Without objection, any prepared
- 16:41statements that our witnesses may have
- 16:43will be included in the record.
- 16:45I now welcome our panel, Chairman
- 16:47Arrington, and Representative McCarthy
- 16:51from the House Budget Committee.
- 16:53Your full statements will be submitted
- 16:55for the record, and we ask that you
- 16:57summarize your statement in 5 minutes.
- 17:00Chairman Arrington, I welcome your
- 17:01testimony.
- 17:02>> Thank you, Madam Chair, Ranking Member.
- 17:05Uh
- 17:06I agree with Mr. McGovern, the American
- 17:08people deserve better than what they've
- 17:10gotten for the last year and a half.
- 17:13But, what they've gotten is a Democrat
- 17:16Party that I don't recognize in my 10
- 17:19years of service.
- 17:21Persistent, habitual
- 17:24um
- 17:26never-ending obstruction
- 17:30to stop the president from succeeding
- 17:33and advancing the policies and the
- 17:35agenda the American people
- 17:37overwhelmingly supported
- 17:40and voted for unilateral
- 17:44uh or Republican leadership in Congress
- 17:47alongside of this president.
- 17:49Um that has made it difficult to govern.
- 17:53What was unprecedented from my Democrat
- 17:56colleagues
- 17:57is now par for the course.
- 18:01Exhibit A, the first shutdown of the
- 18:05entire federal government
- 18:07over a clean CR. It's the first time
- 18:09it's ever happened from my Democrat
- 18:11colleagues. Both parties have
- 18:12participated in these uh shutdowns. I
- 18:16will readily concede that. But the first
- 18:18time a clean CR
- 18:20was rejected
- 18:22just to keep the the government funding
- 18:24at the last year's funding levels until
- 18:27we could meet out a compromise solution.
- 18:31What was their reasoning? What was their
- 18:34counter offer? To repeal the the program
- 18:38integrity measures that we put in place
- 18:40in the big beautiful bill to stop waste,
- 18:43fraud, and abuse. To prevent people not
- 18:45eligible, illegal, or people who are
- 18:47able to work and not working siphoning
- 18:49money off of the safety net programs
- 18:52that are there for our most vulnerable
- 18:53Americans. It was the longest shutdown
- 18:56in history
- 18:57before the next Democrat shutdown.
- 19:00This time it was shutting down the
- 19:02Department of Homeland Security after we
- 19:04had agreed four corners on funding the
- 19:08government.
- 19:09They shut down Homeland. They handcuffed
- 19:12our border patrol agents from protecting
- 19:14our borders. They
- 19:17They basically shut down our Coast
- 19:18Guardsman from defending our ports.
- 19:21CISA agents from defending our critical
- 19:24infrastructure against being hacked.
- 19:27For over 70 days,
- 19:29they held the American people's security
- 19:32hostage until we used a reconciliation
- 19:35bill to break the obstruction
- 19:38and fund ICE and CBP because they
- 19:41defunded it. To be clear, they shut
- 19:44Homeland Security down
- 19:46and then they defunded ICE and CBP.
- 19:48We had to turn it on unilaterally
- 19:51through reconciliation. We didn't get a
- 19:52single vote from Democrats on that.
- 19:55But here we are
- 19:57in the long train of obstruction abuses
- 20:01to do something
- 20:04before November as the window closes
- 20:07that is not just meaningful, it is
- 20:09important, it is critical, it is urgent.
- 20:12Support our troops,
- 20:15strengthen our
- 20:16our food supply,
- 20:18and safeguard the integrity of our
- 20:21elections. Madam Chair, um
- 20:25the obstruction and resistance at all
- 20:28cost
- 20:29and on all fronts goes beyond shutdowns.
- 20:34For the first time in 65 years or what
- 20:36is at least 65 years of a tradition of
- 20:39bipartisan support for the NDAA,
- 20:41National Defense Authorization Act, that
- 20:44are the policies that undergird our
- 20:46entire United States national defense,
- 20:48have been held up in the Senate
- 20:51by the Democrats.
- 20:52Prior to that,
- 20:54based on a temporary personnel decision
- 20:56of the president, they held up FISA 702,
- 21:00a critical security tool for our
- 21:03intelligence community
- 21:05to stop Chinese espionage,
- 21:07to stop terrorism, to stop drug
- 21:10trafficking.
- 21:11This is
- 21:14this new shameful era of obstruction and
- 21:18I presume
- 21:20that the motivation is to placate the
- 21:23left-wing Mandami socialist base of the
- 21:25party. I have no other answers.
- 21:28So Madam Chair
- 21:30and members of the
- 21:32distinguished Rules Committee,
- 21:35I present to you
- 21:37uh
- 21:39a reconciliation bill that will provide
- 21:41emergency funding for our sons and
- 21:43daughters
- 21:44so they have baseline battlefield
- 21:46readiness.
- 21:48Emergency funding to
- 21:50provide resilience
- 21:52and strength to our food supply that we
- 21:55all benefit from and lastly
- 21:58uh again
- 21:59uh the consent of the governed
- 22:02and a functioning democracy requires
- 22:05integrity and confidence in elections.
- 22:08And I will quote
- 22:11former Speaker Nancy Pelosi in 2017
- 22:14after the 2016 election
- 22:16based on
- 22:18the
- 22:20phony Russia collusion that was debunked
- 22:23later by an independent counsel.
- 22:25And I quote, "Our election was hijacked.
- 22:29There is no question.
- 22:31Congress has a duty to protect our
- 22:34democracy." Well, here's where I agree
- 22:36with her. We have a duty to protect our
- 22:38democracy and when half the country has
- 22:41little to no confidence in the outcome
- 22:44of our elections because we don't have
- 22:45basic safeguards like a photo ID,
- 22:48I think it is incumbent upon us to act
- 22:50and act
- 22:52with purpose and with urgency. With
- 22:54that, I yield.
- 22:57>> Thank you very much, Mr. Arrington. Mr.
- 23:00McGarvey, you're recognized. Thank you.
- 23:03Welcome to the Rules Committee.
- 23:05>> Thank you, Chairman Fox. Thank you,
- 23:06Ranking Member McGovern. Ashley, thank
- 23:08you for your service. Best of luck in
- 23:10your next chapter.
- 23:11Um I'm here on behalf of Ranking Member
- 23:13Boyle and House Budget Committee
- 23:15Democrats to talk about what is actually
- 23:17in this bill and I think importantly
- 23:19what is not. But first I want to start
- 23:21off with something that my colleague
- 23:22Chairman Arrington addressed. He
- 23:24addressed the need for people to work
- 23:26together. Let me talk about that for
- 23:28just a second.
- 23:29You know, as a candidate, Donald Trump
- 23:31promised the American people two things
- 23:33I actually agreed with.
- 23:35He said no more foreign wars
- 23:37and that he would lower costs on day
- 23:40one.
- 23:41Here's the thing.
- 23:43Those weren't just empty worthless
- 23:45campaign promises.
- 23:47They've become actual and dangerous
- 23:50lies.
- 23:51More than 18 months since he took
- 23:53office, we are fighting a foreign war in
- 23:54Iran. 17 American service members are
- 23:58dead.
- 24:00Three were killed just this past
- 24:01weekend. One was 19 years old.
- 24:04Three more Americans dead after Donald
- 24:07Trump declared a total and complete
- 24:09victory in the war that he started.
- 24:14This war has cost us American lives.
- 24:16This war has cost us tens upon tens of
- 24:19billions of dollars and we are getting
- 24:21nothing in return. It is the president's
- 24:23incompetence that has made our world
- 24:25less safe and stable than the day that
- 24:27he started this war. And because of
- 24:29Trump's war, because of Trump's tariffs,
- 24:32and because of this lapdog Republican
- 24:34Congress, families in Louisville,
- 24:35Kentucky and across this country are
- 24:38paying more than ever for groceries, for
- 24:40rent, utilities, for health care, and
- 24:42just about everything else. But here's
- 24:44the thing, it's not happening by
- 24:46accident. These aren't just broken
- 24:48promises. These are deliberate policy
- 24:51choices by the House Republicans.
- 24:54Let's look at the first Republican
- 24:55reconciliation bill. We're on the third
- 24:57one right now. The first Republican
- 24:58reconciliation bill, the one big
- 25:00beautiful bill as everyone called it. It
- 25:01gave massive tax cuts to billionaires
- 25:04and the wealthiest corporations while
- 25:06taking trillions of dollars away from
- 25:09American families health insurance.
- 25:11It took money away from kids and
- 25:13seniors, moms who were just trying to
- 25:15put food on the table.
- 25:17So, they did a second reconciliation
- 25:19bill. And the second reconciliation
- 25:20bill, what did it do? It gifted ICE $70
- 25:23billion.
- 25:24That was on top of the already $140
- 25:27billion that they gave them the year
- 25:29before. And what is this money going
- 25:31toward? 55 deaths in ICE custody since
- 25:34Donald Trump took office.
- 25:36Kids used as bait, families ripped
- 25:38apart, people killed on American
- 25:40streets. Just this past week, we saw two
- 25:42Americans killed by unfit and untrained
- 25:46ICE agents.
- 25:48So, you think that the third
- 25:49reconciliation bill, this would be the
- 25:51one
- 25:52where they finally do something about
- 25:54affordability for American families.
- 25:57Spoiler alert.
- 25:58It's not.
- 26:00The bill's 47 pages long. It doesn't
- 26:03include one single word about lowering
- 26:05costs for the American people. There is
- 26:07not one word in here about
- 26:09affordability. Instead, Republicans used
- 26:12this to add nearly a hundred billion
- 26:14dollars to the debt and deficit of this
- 26:16country to fund the most unpopular war
- 26:18in American history.
- 26:21But back to the original comments by the
- 26:22chairman about working together, we do
- 26:24want to work on things that I think are
- 26:25broadly popular. During the budget
- 26:27committee markup, Democrats offered 14
- 26:29common sense amendments to try to make
- 26:31this into a bill that does anything to
- 26:35help families.
- 26:36We tried to reverse cuts to Medicaid and
- 26:38SNAP. We tried to lower health insurance
- 26:40premiums, repeal Trump's tariff taxes,
- 26:43stop taxpayer dollars from funding an
- 26:45unauthorized war on more ICE brutality.
- 26:49I offered an amendment to make sure that
- 26:50the taxpayers would not be forced to pay
- 26:52for Donald Trump's ballroom.
- 26:54What happened?
- 26:56Republicans rejected every single
- 26:57amendment. They said no to healthcare.
- 27:00They said no to food assistance. They
- 27:01said no to lower gas prices. They said
- 27:03no to ending the president's corruption.
- 27:06But for Donald Trump's foreign war,
- 27:08here we are.
- 27:09And House Republicans are happy to open
- 27:11the checkbook.
- 27:13This is a budget of broken promises. It
- 27:15puts American people last.
- 27:18As we sit here, we sit in this fancy
- 27:20room, and we're talking about rules and
- 27:22process and budgets and reconciliation.
- 27:26We may think that the American people
- 27:28are sitting here watching. They're not.
- 27:30They're not talking about
- 27:31reconciliation. They are at home right
- 27:33now talking about their bills. They're
- 27:35talking about rent. They're talking
- 27:36about healthcare. They're talking about
- 27:37groceries. They're talking about gas
- 27:39prices. They are sitting here wondering
- 27:42what they're going to do about utilities
- 27:44and prescription drugs and why their
- 27:46paychecks don't go as far as they used
- 27:48to.
- 27:49And they're asking a fair question.
- 27:53This is a question we should ask
- 27:54ourselves. The American people are
- 27:55asking this question.
- 27:56Why can Republicans always find money
- 27:59for billionaires and wars,
- 28:02but never for the rest of us?
- 28:05Because that's who they serve.
- 28:07The Budget Committee Democrats are ready
- 28:09to work with anyone who is serious about
- 28:11lowering costs and making life easier
- 28:13for the American people.
- 28:14This bill does neither.
- 28:17I urge my colleagues to reject this
- 28:18bill, and thank you, and I yield back.
- 28:22>> Thank you, uh, Mr. McGarvey.
- 28:25Uh, Ms. Fischbach, do you have any
- 28:26questions?
- 28:28Mr. McGovern.
- 28:29>> Yeah, thank you, Madam Chair. Uh, first
- 28:31of all, let me just say I got I I love
- 28:33you Republicans. You don't take
- 28:34responsibility for anything. I mean, you
- 28:36control the House, you control the
- 28:38Senate, you control the White House. I
- 28:40think you control the Supreme Court, and
- 28:42nothing is your responsibility.
- 28:44Boy, it must be nice to live that way.
- 28:46Um, and I I'll just say, um, one thing,
- 28:48when you guys want to get things done,
- 28:50I mean, you do.
- 28:52When you wanted to tax cuts for
- 28:53millionaires and billionaires, I mean,
- 28:54you shoved that through, added 4.7
- 28:57trillion dollars to the debt, you got
- 28:58that through.
- 28:59I wish we could have stopped it, but you
- 29:01got it through.
- 29:02When you wanted to cut Medicaid by a
- 29:04trillion dollars, you did it in a
- 29:05nanosecond.
- 29:07SNAP by 200 billion dollars, you're
- 29:09going to increase hunger in this
- 29:10country.
- 29:11I mean, I mean, so the idea that you
- 29:14know,
- 29:15this idea that somehow you can't get
- 29:16anything done, yeah, you do the stuff
- 29:18you get done, unfortunately, is bad for
- 29:20the American people. But but everything
- 29:23is somebody else's fault, it's never
- 29:24your fault.
- 29:25And don't even get me going on
- 29:27corruption or on fraud or waste or
- 29:28abuse. I'm looking at what's happening
- 29:30in the White House right now and the
- 29:32silence of the entire Republican
- 29:34conference,
- 29:35I mean, that that that is complicity.
- 29:37That is complicity. And history will
- 29:39record that you were silent as this
- 29:41president ripped off the American
- 29:43people. I've never seen anything like
- 29:45it. It makes Richard Nixon look like a
- 29:46boy scout. But Chairman Arrington, in
- 29:482024, you came before this committee and
- 29:51you said, quote, "At a time when our
- 29:53national debt is approaching 35
- 29:55trillion, we are adding almost 8 billion
- 29:57dollars to the debt every day and we pay
- 29:5962 cents on every dollar just to service
- 30:02the debt. We must lead Congress toward a
- 30:04path of fiscal responsibility. The
- 30:06trajectory is unsustainable and is
- 30:09arguably the biggest threat facing our
- 30:11nation." End quote. You ended your
- 30:13remarks by saying, and I quote, "Not
- 30:15paying for our spending is not only
- 30:17irresponsible, it is irrational. We
- 30:19cannot continue to thrust the cost of
- 30:21things we think are important onto the
- 30:23backs of our kids and grandkids." End
- 30:25quote.
- 30:26Chairman Arrington, do you still believe
- 30:29that our debt is one of the biggest
- 30:30threats facing our nation?
- 30:32>> I do.
- 30:33>> So, Chairman Arrington, can you affirm
- 30:36the basic fact that since January 20th,
- 30:382025, since President Trump and the
- 30:41Republicans assumed full control of
- 30:43government, the national debt has
- 30:45increased by $3.3 trillion
- 30:47from 36 to 36.2 trillion to 39.5
- 30:51trillion.
- 30:53>> It's a misleading stat because the
- 30:56economy has grown
- 30:58with the cuts that we made on waste,
- 31:00fraud, and abuse. In total, for the
- 31:02first time in a decade, the deficit to
- 31:05GDP has gone down under Republican
- 31:08leadership and this president's watch.
- 31:09>> You disagree with the figure?
- 31:11>> the CBO's That's a direct quote from the
- 31:13CBO.
- 31:14>> with the that our that our our debt went
- 31:16from
- 31:17uh went from 36.2 to 39.5? Cuz I think
- 31:20that's that's
- 31:21>> We have We have We have We have
- 31:24liabilities
- 31:25in Social Security, Medicare. We have
- 31:28liabilities across the board that are
- 31:30outpacing our
- 31:32>> Mr. McGarvey, would
- 31:33those are accurate numbers?
- 31:35>> Yes. In fact, another stat we can look
- 31:37at, um the debt of this country from
- 31:40George Washington through Bill Clinton
- 31:42was about $5.7 trillion.
- 31:44The debt from George W. Bush and Donald
- 31:47Trump alone is nearly double that.
- 31:49>> Chairman Arrington, isn't it true that
- 31:50you um and everybody on the Republican
- 31:52side here voted in favor of a Republican
- 31:54reconciliation bill that is projected to
- 31:57add $4.7 trillion to our nation's debt
- 31:59over the next decade?
- 32:01>> Not true.
- 32:01>> Another $70 billion
- 32:03uh
- 32:03that
- 32:04that provided funding for ICE and CBP?
- 32:07>> The ICE and CBP was simply a replacement
- 32:11of what would have been discretionary
- 32:12funding for ICE and CBP when every
- 32:15Democrat voted to defund it.
- 32:17>> for that?
- 32:19>> Of course, I wouldn't defund ICE and
- 32:21CBP. That's Yes, sir.
- 32:23>> can you confirm that the plain text of
- 32:25the budget resolution before us right
- 32:27now instructs committees to propose
- 32:30legislation that would increase the
- 32:32deficit by as much as $95 billion
- 32:35dollars with no requirement that it be
- 32:37paid for.
- 32:39>> Mr. McGovern,
- 32:42ever since I've been here and probably
- 32:43for a hundred years,
- 32:45when we are in conflict and our military
- 32:48needs supplemental resourcing to keep
- 32:50our troops safe, we we we have never
- 32:53offset it. And the 200 billion dollars
- 32:56that you and your colleagues gave to
- 32:57Ukraine,
- 32:58that was not offset. So, I don't expect
- 33:00we should do this any differently.
- 33:02>> Yeah, but you but you said I go back to
- 33:04you not paying for our spending is not
- 33:06only irresponsible, it's irrational.
- 33:07>> That's
- 33:08>> We can continue
- 33:09>> to thrust the cost of things that we
- 33:11think are important onto the backs of
- 33:12our kids and our grandkids.
- 33:13>> That's correct.
- 33:14>> is, how come how can you come before the
- 33:16committee
- 33:17and advocate for spending tens of
- 33:19billions more taxpayer dollars on top of
- 33:22the trillions that you've already added
- 33:23to the deficit while not requiring any
- 33:25of this money
- 33:26>> It's a fair question.
- 33:27>> I I just the military stuff, other
- 33:28stuff. Why then none of it is is paid
- 33:30for?
- 33:30>> It It's a fair question. And I think we
- 33:32have to ask ourselves as a Congress
- 33:36why we provide emergency funding,
- 33:38supplemental appropriations for
- 33:39emergencies,
- 33:41because those emergencies require
- 33:43expeditious action, A, and B, if we
- 33:45don't act, we'll spend a lot more money.
- 33:48Now, that doesn't mean we shouldn't
- 33:49budget for emergencies. We need to do a
- 33:51better job of that across the board.
- 33:53>> it an emergency to give tax breaks to
- 33:55billionaires and millionaires? Cuz that
- 33:57was not paid for, either.
- 33:58>> It It was, in fact. In fact.
- 34:02>> You think an emergency it is a is making
- 34:06sure that millionaires and billionaires
- 34:07get tax cuts and big corporations. I
- 34:10just disagree with that. That's a
- 34:11fundamental values question.
- 34:13>> I didn't say that, just for the record.
- 34:15Although some, after a 21% inflation
- 34:18tax, would have said a 22% tax hike
- 34:20would be an emergency for their
- 34:22families.
- 34:22>> Yeah, your budget resolution instructs
- 34:24the Armed Services Committee to increase
- 34:25the deficit by as much as 60 billion
- 34:27dollars in order to use taxpayer dollars
- 34:29to cover more of the cost of the
- 34:30president's war in Iran.
- 34:32Are you aware that Republicans gave the
- 34:34Department of Defense an extra $150
- 34:36billion last July?
- 34:38>> Yes.
- 34:38>> And according to the Trump
- 34:39administration's own numbers, more than
- 34:41half of that money, $75.7 billion, has
- 34:44yet to be spent or even obligated?
- 34:47>> I know that we gave $150 billion to the
- 34:50defense of our country.
- 34:52>> So, given that you've said that our
- 34:53nation's debt is such an exi-
- 34:55existential crisis,
- 34:56>> Yes.
- 34:56>> wouldn't you agree that it is
- 34:57irresponsible to spend another $60
- 35:00billion in taxpayer dollars on Trump's
- 35:02war when you already have $75 billion
- 35:05available?
- 35:06>> No, sir, because we were so in the hole
- 35:08after 4 years of of a president that
- 35:11didn't have not just regard for our
- 35:14readiness, but for what our troops were
- 35:16focused on in in terms of war-fighting.
- 35:19That first hundred billion was to make
- 35:21up for 4 years. Thank God we put that
- 35:23additional money is to prepare for
- 35:25>> $75 billion that hasn't even been
- 35:27obligated yet. I've also submitted an
- 35:28amendment that I hope to offer in the
- 35:30Rules Committee later tonight to use $13
- 35:33billion out of that $60 billion to add
- 35:36the Major Richard Star Act to the
- 35:38reconciliation bill. This would help
- 35:40combat combat wounded veterans get the
- 35:42full support that they're entitled to.
- 35:44Chairman Arentou, would you support
- 35:46making my amendment in order to help
- 35:47these veterans?
- 35:49>> We simply unlocked the reconciliation
- 35:52process, Mr. McGovern, and you know the
- 35:54process as well as I do. The policies
- 35:57will be meted out by the authorizing
- 35:59committee chairs, not myself.
- 36:00>> But you would have no objection for me
- 36:02offering an amendment and and hopefully
- 36:04maybe getting a bipartisan
- 36:05>> I I would simply Our our focus
- 36:07>> Cuz if we're not going to pay for this
- 36:08other stuff,
- 36:09the whole issue over the over the
- 36:11veterans bill that we that we
- 36:13Republicans pulled last week was a lot
- 36:15of the veterans organizations were upset
- 36:17that you were robbing Peter to pay Paul.
- 36:18You were actually taking cutting
- 36:20veterans benefits
- 36:21on one hand to increase veterans
- 36:23benefits for other groups on the other
- 36:25hand. So, this would this would
- 36:27alleviate that. So that's what we try to
- 36:28do. Mr. McGovern, would you be okay with
- 36:30us trying to do that?
- 36:32>> No, in fact I sit on the Veterans
- 36:34Committee ranking member of government I
- 36:35think this is this is something where we
- 36:37actually all agree we should be taking
- 36:39care of our veterans. Instead they are
- 36:41looking to actually
- 36:42take things away from veterans who are
- 36:44suffering from tinnitus veterans who are
- 36:46suffering and and they're not willing to
- 36:47pay to help them.
- 36:48>> So we'll we'll see what happens later
- 36:49today. Um I think you'd all agree that
- 36:51affordability and the cost of living
- 36:53whether it's gas prices or child care
- 36:54costs are some of the top concerns of
- 36:56the American people. The question is why
- 36:58does why does this budget resolution not
- 37:00include anything to bring down costs? I
- 37:03mean you don't have to just take my word
- 37:05for it. On July 15th a Republican
- 37:07Congressman from South Carolina
- 37:08described your budget as quote $95
- 37:10billion
- 37:12in new deficit spending no offsets and
- 37:14not one provision to lower the cost of
- 37:16living end quote. So the question is why
- 37:18does your resolution why doesn't your
- 37:20resolution instruct any committee to
- 37:22propose legislation that would for
- 37:24example lower health care costs or help
- 37:27people who have lost their health care
- 37:29coverage regain it.
- 37:31>> Uh I would say that the first step in
- 37:34unwinding the cost of living crisis
- 37:37that was created by the failed policies
- 37:39of your party was to stop the wild
- 37:42reckless unbridled spending. This
- 37:44administration continues by the way a
- 37:46whole of government assault on fraud not
- 37:49on domestic energy producers but on
- 37:51fraud and we cut like I said a hundred
- 37:55I'm sorry 1.6 trillion dollars in waste.
- 37:58We put pro-growth policies that gave us
- 38:00a 3.8 and a 4.3 growth rates before you
- 38:04shut the government down.
- 38:05>> it sounds like we're back to the old
- 38:07let's blame Joe Biden. Well why doesn't
- 38:09your resolution instruct any of the
- 38:12any committee to propose legislation
- 38:14that would lower Americans child care
- 38:15costs? Or why doesn't the resolution
- 38:18instruct any committee to propose
- 38:19legislation that would lower Americans
- 38:21housing or rent costs. Or why doesn't
- 38:23your resolution instruct any committee
- 38:25to propose legislation that would lower
- 38:27gas prices for Americans' energy bills?
- 38:29I mean
- 38:30I mean, this is kind of the problem in a
- 38:32nutshell. And I'll close with this. You
- 38:34know, when it comes to war and tax cuts
- 38:36for wealthy
- 38:37and big corporations, you guys trip over
- 38:39yourselves to spend tax dollars with no
- 38:41offsets. This is your MO. But when it
- 38:44comes to helping American families,
- 38:46Republicans think it would be waste it
- 38:48would be wasteful spending. I got to
- 38:50tell you, I still do in-person town
- 38:52halls. I don't know about you, but I do.
- 38:54And all people want to talk about is the
- 38:56high cost of living. They can't afford
- 38:58their rents, can't afford to buy homes,
- 39:00child care costs are out of control,
- 39:01health care costs are out of control.
- 39:03They want to know why the hell aren't we
- 39:04focused in on that? And instead we're
- 39:06focused in on, you know, giving with the
- 39:09well-off and the well-connected even
- 39:10more.
- 39:11I think people have had it. And I think
- 39:14I think I think that's one of the
- 39:15reasons why you're going to see every
- 39:17Democrat oppose this. And I hope some
- 39:19Republicans who care about fiscal
- 39:20responsibilities will fiscal
- 39:22responsibility will oppose it as well.
- 39:24I I yield back.
- 39:26>> Thank you, Mr. McGovern. Mr. Scott,
- 39:28you're recognized.
- 39:30>> Thank you,
- 39:31Madam Chair.
- 39:33Mr. Arrington, uh
- 39:36you know,
- 39:37I personally believe that we won the
- 39:38last election
- 39:41because Americans wanted us to secure
- 39:43the border and stop the tax increase.
- 39:45I mean, the millions upon millions of
- 39:48people
- 39:49that were allowed to come into
- 39:52uh
- 39:54this country unchecked and intentionally
- 39:56unchecked by the Biden administration at
- 39:59at the behest of the Democrat Socialist
- 40:01movement,
- 40:03um
- 40:04has had a tremendous cost to us. But we
- 40:06we were secure. We we were elected to
- 40:08secure the border and stop the tax
- 40:09increase of the Democratic Party.
- 40:11>> That's right.
- 40:12>> And the Democratic Party
- 40:14we we stopped their tax increase. We
- 40:16didn't actually reduce the rate for
- 40:17millionaires, am I correct? Like no
- 40:19millionaires tax rate went down. They
- 40:22just didn't get the tax increase that
- 40:24the that the Democrats wanted them to
- 40:25get. Is that correct?
- 40:26>> 92% of the American people who are
- 40:28working people, I would suggest, 92%
- 40:31that take a standard deduction, actually
- 40:33got a another tax break as did working
- 40:37people who work overtime, work for tips,
- 40:39etc.
- 40:40>> You know, if you're working for tips, uh
- 40:42I eat at Waffle House on a regular
- 40:43basis, not as fancy as some of the
- 40:44places most members eat at, but I enjoy
- 40:46Waffle House with my family.
- 40:48Um you know, you're working overtime,
- 40:50you got you got a nice tax cut. Our
- 40:52senior citizens are getting a tax credit
- 40:55for
- 40:56on on the Social Security side because
- 40:58of some budget rules that we have to
- 41:00comply with.
- 41:02Uh that's the way that was done. But we
- 41:04were elected to share the border and
- 41:05stop the tax increase that the Democrats
- 41:07wanted. And the end result of stopping
- 41:08the tax increase is and this doesn't get
- 41:10talked about enough, I don't believe,
- 41:12but my understanding, according to CBO,
- 41:15tax revenue in the United States is
- 41:17higher than it's ever been in the
- 41:18history of the country. Is that correct?
- 41:20>> That's correct.
- 41:22>> And and actually, and you may not
- 41:24exactly know this number, but I looked
- 41:25it up. Revenue for 2026 is 17.5%
- 41:30of GDP.
- 41:32The 50-year average is 17.3%.
- 41:35>> Yeah.
- 41:36>> So just factually speaking, if you want
- 41:39more money,
- 41:40you have to grow the GDP of the country.
- 41:43You don't grow the GDP of the country
- 41:45taking all of the capital out of the
- 41:47private sector and depositing it in
- 41:49accounts where, you know, fraudsters are
- 41:52able to go get get it and uh
- 41:55and nobody at the state level in certain
- 41:57states, Democratic states like
- 41:58Minnesota, want to do anything about it.
- 42:00>> That's right.
- 42:01>> And so the one thing that I would tell
- 42:02you that I I wish we had done. I think
- 42:04the other thing people want us to do was
- 42:05to cut spending and it's pretty clear to
- 42:07me that if you look at the fraud that is
- 42:09occurring throughout the United States,
- 42:12that simply stopping the people that
- 42:15should not be getting assistance from
- 42:18stealing assistance or dollars I should
- 42:20say from the US government. I mean, my
- 42:23understanding is CBO came out the other
- 42:25Was it CBO or Congressional Research
- 42:28people came out and said for every
- 42:30dollar you put into fraud prevention,
- 42:32it would generate generate a $7
- 42:35return on the on the investment. That's
- 42:37correct.
- 42:38>> That's correct. Because we have $500
- 42:40billion according to GAO on the high
- 42:43side, but hundreds of billions for sure
- 42:46in fraud leaking out every year of this
- 42:49this government.
- 42:50>> And and of course the Democrats are
- 42:52defending the fraudsters. I mean, that's
- 42:54what that's what's happening. They don't
- 42:55want us to cut spending. We we could get
- 42:58all of the cuts that we wanted simply by
- 43:00getting rid of the fraud in this
- 43:01country, I believe. At least the vast
- 43:02majority of them.
- 43:04>> The enhanced COVID tax credits for
- 43:06Obamacare that they wanted to accept the
- 43:08government down over?
- 43:10Uh that there were tens of billions
- 43:12according to GAO and CBO in fraud and
- 43:15some of that was tens of thousands of
- 43:17social security numbers from dead
- 43:19people.
- 43:19>> Yep.
- 43:20Yep.
- 43:22You know, all of that money was going to
- 43:24the insurance carriers.
- 43:25>> That's correct.
- 43:26>> Not to the hospitals, correct?
- 43:27>> That's correct.
- 43:28>> And so and so they blame, you know, the
- 43:30challenge of the local hot that the
- 43:31local hospitals are having and I'm I'm
- 43:33I'm getting some reports together on on
- 43:36on what is actually happening at local
- 43:37hospitals. But the fact of the matter is
- 43:39Medicare Advantage plans aren't paying
- 43:40their claims and and other things and
- 43:42and because of the way the Democrats
- 43:43have done things, there's no mechanism
- 43:46to force these gargantuan insurance
- 43:48carriers actually pay the claims that
- 43:50they owe the local hospitals. I'm
- 43:51getting together some reports on that.
- 43:52But I
- 43:53I just want to get back to some some
- 43:55basics. I mean, the fact of the matter
- 43:56is we were elected to secure the border
- 43:58and stop the tax increase. We did that.
- 44:00They can scream
- 44:01that that billionaires got a lower tax
- 44:04rate and all of that. It's just
- 44:05nonsense.
- 44:06Um
- 44:07but the the main thing is
- 44:11with regard to the economy and the
- 44:12taxpayers need to understand, tax
- 44:14revenues are higher than they've ever
- 44:15been in the history of the country.
- 44:17>> Yes, sir.
- 44:19Yes, sir. And if you're going to bend
- 44:21the curve on the debt to GDP, which is
- 44:24the measure of our fiscal health, which
- 44:26we have lowered, the deficit is the
- 44:28input to the debt and that's gone down
- 44:30for the first time in a decade, you have
- 44:32to do two things. What we did to root
- 44:34out waste and fraud and save money and
- 44:36pro-growth policies that ignite the
- 44:38growth that we've seen, as I've said, 1%
- 44:42over CBO's projections gives us $3
- 44:45trillion in deficit reduction.
- 44:46>> The The final thing I want to say is is
- 44:48about uh the war with Iran.
- 44:51Every president, whether they be
- 44:52Democrat or Republican, has recognized
- 44:55the threat of Iran obtaining a nuclear
- 44:58weapon.
- 44:59There is no civilian purpose for uranium
- 45:03enrichment beyond 20%.
- 45:06You could say five, but we'll stretch it
- 45:08and say 20. No civilian use beyond 20.
- 45:12It's widely accepted
- 45:14in the international community that you
- 45:16that that Iran was far beyond
- 45:20the 20% of enrichment
- 45:22and was continuing
- 45:24to enrich beyond those levels.
- 45:27Had President Trump not done what he
- 45:29did, Iran would have had a nuclear
- 45:32weapon within a short period of time.
- 45:35And they already had the ability to
- 45:36make, you know, dirty bomb They had
- 45:39enough enrichment to do to do
- 45:41um
- 45:43to create a tremendous amount of damage
- 45:45throughout the world. And the fact of
- 45:46the matter is the majority of terrorism
- 45:47throughout the world, Iran has something
- 45:49to do with, whether it be sponsoring
- 45:51with intelligence or with weapons.
- 45:53Uh Iran uh it's a country run by
- 45:56jihadists. And I'm glad our president
- 45:58has the balls to do something about it.
- 46:00With that, Madam Chair, I yield.
- 46:02>> Thank you, Mr. Scott.
- 46:04Ms. Scanlon, you're recognized.
- 46:07>> Thank you. I yield first to the ranking
- 46:09member.
- 46:10>> Well, thank you. I I just want to say
- 46:12that um I listening to my colleague, Mr.
- 46:14Scott, um
- 46:16you know, I I I think maybe this is
- 46:18the biggest difference between Democrats
- 46:20and Republicans. You think that people
- 46:23in this country should be happy, that
- 46:25they should be grateful for all that
- 46:26they received under Republican
- 46:28leadership and under the leadership of
- 46:29Donald Trump. I will say to you, go to
- 46:32any coffee shop in this country, go to
- 46:34any VFW hall, go to any union hall, you
- 46:36know, go to any workplace and talk to
- 46:38regular people about what's on their
- 46:40mind and they will tell you the issue of
- 46:41affordability is front and center.
- 46:43>> I do that. I see them at Waffle I see
- 46:45them at Waffle House, Walmart, and other
- 46:47places, Mr. Governor. Most of the
- 46:48Americans I know recognize how blessed
- 46:50they are to live in this country and do
- 46:52not want a socialist takeover like the
- 46:55Democratic Party has allowed.
- 46:57>> Well, they don't want a fascist takeover
- 46:58by the Republican Party, either. You
- 47:00want to go down that road, I'll go down
- 47:01that road. All right. We as we inch
- 47:03toward authoritarianism, you know what?
- 47:05Our people are sick of that, too.
- 47:06They're frightened of a president who
- 47:08whose ego is so fragile, he can't admit
- 47:11he lost an election and and promotes all
- 47:13this wacky propaganda that scares the
- 47:15hell out of the average voter, including
- 47:18a lot of Republicans. And I would also
- 47:19just say one thing on Iran. The Strait
- 47:21of Hormuz was open.
- 47:23Um and oil prices were coming down
- 47:26before this president launched this war
- 47:28and now Strait is closed, gas prices are
- 47:31going up, which is also an affordability
- 47:34issue. So, I'm sorry. You think people
- 47:36>> Yeah, gas prices are still lower than
- 47:38they would be if Kamala Harris had been
- 47:39elected.
- 47:40>> No, I That's That's just but but that's
- 47:42ridiculous. But anyway, but uh but the
- 47:44bottom line is you go you go down this
- 47:45road of You're going to keep thinking
- 47:47that people are happy and they should be
- 47:49grateful. I will tell you uh you know,
- 47:51you you will find out in November.
- 47:53People are sick of this. There's And by
- 47:55the way, I you know, when you say that
- 47:57the tax cuts didn't help people who are
- 47:58rich, I mean Donald Trump was up there
- 48:00bragging about the fact that one of his
- 48:02closest friends was able was able to buy
- 48:04a new private jet with the money he
- 48:06saved on the tax cuts. I don't know I
- 48:08don't know anybody who owns a private
- 48:10jet. Uh I don't hang around with those
- 48:12people like maybe you guys do, but the
- 48:14bottom line is that average working
- 48:17people in this country feel they're
- 48:18getting screwed, and they've had it, and
- 48:20they want to know why we're not focused
- 48:21more like a laser beam on the issues of
- 48:23affordability.
- 48:24>> I yield back I work in this country,
- 48:26love this country.
- 48:27>> I'm reclaiming my time. Thank you, Mr.
- 48:29Scott. Um
- 48:31I do have to agree with the ranking
- 48:32member. I mean, at a time when the price
- 48:34of gas and groceries and health care
- 48:36keeps climbing, uh you might think
- 48:39Republicans would come to Congress with
- 48:41a plan to help working families.
- 48:42Instead, they're back with a third a
- 48:45third partisan budget bill. And once
- 48:47again, it's completely missing the
- 48:50missing the moment for my constituents,
- 48:52I think for most Americans. This budget
- 48:54resolution paves the way for nearly 95
- 48:58billion dollars to be added to the
- 49:00deficit. That's on top of the trillions
- 49:02that have already been added by this
- 49:04administration through its misguided tax
- 49:06cuts and the prior reconciliation bills.
- 49:09Look, more than 70 billion would
- 49:12bankroll the president's ill-conceived
- 49:14senseless war. I mean, that's the
- 49:16monetary damage on top of the deaths
- 49:18that we're already seeing. It is the
- 49:20most unpopular war in American history,
- 49:23and presumably some portion of that to
- 49:25fund Pete Hegseth's obsession with the
- 49:27testosterone levels of members of our
- 49:30military. Another 10 billion dollars is
- 49:32going to fund Republicans' wild goose
- 49:34chase of a voter suppression bill, the
- 49:37SAVE Act, that would restrict access to
- 49:39the ballot for millions of Americans
- 49:42with provisions that even Republicans
- 49:44acknowledge are unlikely to survive
- 49:47Senate reconciliation rules.
- 49:50It's interesting to hear our Republican
- 49:51colleagues try to justify that bill.
- 49:54They don't say that it's necessary to
- 49:56actually prevent election fraud or even
- 49:58voting by non-citizens because that's
- 50:01not true. Those things aren't happening
- 50:02at the levels they claim. No, what they
- 50:04say is that the bill is necessary
- 50:06because Americans are concerned about
- 50:08the security of our elections. Well, of
- 50:11course they are. The president's been
- 50:12lying to them about that for nearly a
- 50:14decade.
- 50:16But back to the main point on this, not
- 50:18$1 is devoted to lowering the cost of
- 50:20groceries, reducing health care costs,
- 50:23or slashing skyrocketing energy prices.
- 50:26Republicans keep promising to lower
- 50:28costs, but instead they keep shifting
- 50:30the economic burdens to consumers
- 50:33through tariffs, through giveaways to
- 50:35billionaires and big business.
- 50:37Um, the only kind of welfare they seem
- 50:39interested in is corporate welfare, and
- 50:42boy are we seeing a lot of that. So,
- 50:45apparently there's always more money for
- 50:46war or to clean up some of the economic
- 50:49damage caused by this administration. If
- 50:51Republicans were serious about helping
- 50:53American families, they would be working
- 50:55to actually lower costs, strengthen
- 50:57health care, invest in our communities
- 50:59through housing, through child care,
- 51:01through all the things that Americans
- 51:03actually need rather than golden
- 51:06ballrooms and ripped up reflecting pools
- 51:09and golden arches and all the other crap
- 51:11that keeps getting proposed by this
- 51:13administration. So, uh, Mr. McGarvey, I
- 51:16I
- 51:17sense that you have some remarks you'd
- 51:19like to add in response to some of the
- 51:21nonsense we've been hearing.
- 51:23>> Thank you, Ms. Gillibrand. I I
- 51:24appreciate your remarks. Uh, I wanted to
- 51:26go to some of the things that Mr. Scott
- 51:28addressed specifically about fraud and
- 51:31about the actual budget and the tax cuts
- 51:34themselves. Um,
- 51:36we all agree, right? Let's get rid of
- 51:38the fraud.
- 51:39Let's get rid of fraud. Let's get rid of
- 51:40fraud. Let's get rid of waste. Let's get
- 51:41rid of abuse. Let's also remember what
- 51:44this administration is labeling as fraud
- 51:47or labeling as abuse. Director Vote came
- 51:50in front of our committee, Mr. Chairman,
- 51:52and he answered our questions because
- 51:55the thing about a budget is you can talk
- 51:57about things all you want in a budget.
- 51:58It's actually written down what you what
- 52:00you like and what you value. So, he said
- 52:03there was fraud in the LIHEAP program.
- 52:06LIHEAP, low income home energy
- 52:08assistance program. Right?
- 52:11But, he didn't find the fraud in the
- 52:14program. He zeroed it out completely.
- 52:18Over 100,000 seniors in Kentucky who
- 52:22rely on this program to keep their homes
- 52:25warm in the winter and right now when it
- 52:27is blazing hot in Kentucky to keep it
- 52:30cool in summer. This can be life or
- 52:32death. He
- 52:33He couldn't answer whether it's fraud
- 52:35for every single senior in Kentucky who
- 52:38uses this program. It is not a serious
- 52:40attempt. What they're trying to do is
- 52:43find little offsets that impact the
- 52:45people who are our neighbors, who live
- 52:47in our areas every single day, and
- 52:49they're trying to cut those so that they
- 52:51can pave the way for the wealthy tax
- 52:54cuts that they have put in place. Now,
- 52:55Mr. Scott, I'm from Kentucky.
- 52:58I love Waffle House. In fact, if they
- 53:00serve bourbon, I don't think I'd ever
- 53:01leave.
- 53:03But, what do you need to do is explain
- 53:05the tax cuts to the people at Waffle
- 53:06House the next time you're there because
- 53:08in this budget there were $4.7 trillion
- 53:11in tax cuts. The wealthiest Americans
- 53:13got over 50% of that. If you make a
- 53:16million dollars in America under these
- 53:19tax cuts by 2027, you will have $100,000
- 53:24more in your pocket. But, let's look at
- 53:26what we did for the people who work at
- 53:27Waffle House. There is no tax on
- 53:29overtime. There is no tax on tips. What
- 53:31does that actually mean?
- 53:34Because these tax cuts for the
- 53:35wealthiest Americans, they are
- 53:36permanent. They are not going anywhere
- 53:38unless we can change it. The no No on
- 53:40overtime, no tax on tips.
- 53:42It sunsets. They expire after 3 years.
- 53:45And what are they actually?
- 53:47The person at Waffle House doesn't want
- 53:48to have a tax on their tips, what do
- 53:50they now have to do? Under this bill,
- 53:51they have to itemize their deductions.
- 53:54They itemize their deductions. It
- 53:55sunsets after 3 years. There's also a
- 53:57$25,000 cap in this. When you itemize
- 54:01your deductions on tips, you actually
- 54:03lose the $15,000 standard deduction you
- 54:06get right now. This is no tax on $9,900
- 54:10worth of tips for 3 years. But if you
- 54:11make a million bucks, you get $100,000.
- 54:14Or if you're a low-income senior,
- 54:16they're zeroing out your programs.
- 54:17They're taking food off the table.
- 54:19They're making health insurance less and
- 54:21less affordable for every single
- 54:23American. And that's the numbers and the
- 54:26impact that are in this bill.
- 54:29>> Thank you. I I appreciate that. And and
- 54:32it just galls me every time our
- 54:34colleagues start talking about fraud
- 54:37when the actions of this administration
- 54:40show that that is not the focus, or at
- 54:42least not the focus with respect to the
- 54:45people who are committing massive fraud.
- 54:47I mean, if you just look at the fact
- 54:48that the administration has canned most
- 54:51of the inspectors general, whose job it
- 54:52is to actually investigate and find and
- 54:56prosecute fraud, waste, and have been
- 54:58doing a really good job at that up till
- 55:01now. When you look at the pardons that
- 55:03this administration has made for
- 55:05corporate tycoons who have defrauded
- 55:08Americans out of billions of dollars,
- 55:11and then they get a get-out-of-jail-free
- 55:13pass, which also removes their
- 55:15obligation to repay the seniors and the
- 55:18veterans and the folks who were
- 55:20defrauded. And and finally, um I guess
- 55:24in addition to that, you see the folks
- 55:25who've had their charges dropped when
- 55:27they've made sizable donations to either
- 55:29the president's campaign funds or his
- 55:30library or one of his golden ballrooms
- 55:33or something like that. And then
- 55:35finally, you just look at the front page
- 55:37of the Wall Street Journal today which
- 55:39says Justice Department pulls back on
- 55:41pursuing corporate crime. They've sent
- 55:44all their folks out to track down
- 55:47day workers at Home Depot and they are
- 55:50not going after corporate crime, they're
- 55:52not going after drug traffickers,
- 55:54they're not going after human
- 55:55traffickers and they're sure as heck not
- 55:57going after folks in our government who
- 56:00are defrauding the American people. So I
- 56:02thank you for your work on this and I
- 56:03yield back.
- 56:05>> Thank you Miss Scanlon. Mr. Griffith,
- 56:07you're recognized.
- 56:08>> I have questions Madam Chair.
- 56:10>> Thank you. Miss Leger Fernandez, you're
- 56:13recognized.
- 56:14>> Hello. Hello.
- 56:16Thank you very much. Good to see you
- 56:19Chairman and good to see you ranking
- 56:23you're the ranking member here today
- 56:25Mr. McGarvey and thank you for the
- 56:27explanation
- 56:29about the fact that uh
- 56:32it's not really working people. It's not
- 56:35seniors. It's not people who have paid
- 56:36taxes who have benefited from the
- 56:39deficit spending
- 56:41that we have seen the Republicans engage
- 56:44in and the last 18 months and that's
- 56:48really what's key here is this is
- 56:50deficit spending deficit spending. And
- 56:55Chairman Arrington you've seen uh uh
- 56:59this chart I think you and I have
- 57:02discussed this chart before because it
- 57:04shows that
- 57:06Republicans like talking about the
- 57:08deficit
- 57:10but really what Republicans like doing
- 57:12is increasing the deficit and every year
- 57:16every presidency under Reagan H. W. Bush
- 57:20the deficit went up not by a lot under
- 57:22those two
- 57:23it went down during Clinton
- 57:25uh during
- 57:26W. Bush it went up went down during
- 57:30Obama and then boy, under Trump, it just
- 57:34soared. Came down a bit under Biden.
- 57:38And uh now, you actually are have the
- 57:42distinction of being able to serve as
- 57:44chairman of the Budget Committee,
- 57:46uh
- 57:47and will be able to retire
- 57:49and claim as one of I think your
- 57:51accomplishments that you have added to
- 57:54that deficit spending.
- 57:57And this bill before us
- 58:01is going to add to that legacy of
- 58:05deficit spending by Republican
- 58:07presidencies if it ever
- 58:09got passed into law.
- 58:11And what we're hearing is that we're
- 58:13finally maybe some of the uh they call
- 58:16them hardliners, I don't know what the
- 58:17right name for it is, but people who say
- 58:19it's not good to do deficit spending are
- 58:21saying, "Wait a minute, there's no pay
- 58:23fors in here." There were no pay fors in
- 58:26the $7270
- 58:27billion that uh we passed last month,
- 58:30either. Uh do you remember by how much
- 58:32Trump raised the debt in his first term,
- 58:35Chairman Arrington?
- 58:36>> Uh the debt has gone up by too much
- 58:39under uh presidents in recent times,
- 58:43mainly because of the unfunded liability
- 58:46in entitlements that are on automatic
- 58:48spending. And and just just to be clear,
- 58:52we have a crisis of a balance sheet that
- 58:55has a $140 trillion that that will be um
- 59:01brought to bear on that balance sheet
- 59:03without the funding to deliver on the
- 59:05promises in those entitlements. That's
- 59:08the biggest reason it's increasing on
- 59:10everyone's watch, but no one in 10
- 59:13years, to my colleague and friend from
- 59:15New Mexico,
- 59:16in 10 years,
- 59:19no party, no budget chairman,
- 59:22no president has worked to reduce the
- 59:26deficit to GDP like
- 59:29like the House Republicans and this
- 59:31president and CBO has uh confirmed that.
- 59:35It's over 10% and it's because we
- 59:38reduced wasteful spending by 2.5
- 59:41trillion dollars. It's because of the
- 59:43Fiscal Responsibility Act that we forced
- 59:46Democrats to the table to negotiate and
- 59:49have saved to date a half a trillion
- 59:51dollars just keeping discretionary
- 59:53spending flat. And it's because we had
- 59:56paltry growth at a 1.8 in the last
- 59:59quarter of President Biden. We had a 3.8
- 1:00:02and 4.3 growth rate. That is tremendous.
- 1:00:05That is until Democrats shut the
- 1:00:07government down to expand a fraud-ridden
- 1:00:09COVID era program that they said was
- 1:00:11temporary that would cost $130 billion
- 1:00:13with no pay for it.
- 1:00:15>> the question was the question was a
- 1:00:17simple question which was how much has
- 1:00:20how much did President Trump increase
- 1:00:22the deficit?
- 1:00:22>> Less less than Joe Biden did and the
- 1:00:25under Democrat control.
- 1:00:26>> actually not true at all. It was by 8.4
- 1:00:30trillion dollars and Joe Biden actually
- 1:00:32brought the uh it he brought it down. So
- 1:00:36actually when you look at the numbers
- 1:00:38and this is the issue is that when you
- 1:00:40look at the rhetoric
- 1:00:40>> What's the source of that chart?
- 1:00:42>> When when you look at the rhetoric will
- 1:00:44actually
- 1:00:46What?
- 1:00:47United States Treasury. I don't know if
- 1:00:48you
- 1:00:49>> Yeah. I've heard of them.
- 1:00:51Yeah, you can
- 1:00:54If I may just to just to just a fact
- 1:00:56check
- 1:00:57the the interest on the debt which
- 1:00:59tripled okay from 350 billion to a
- 1:01:02trillion dollars under President Biden
- 1:01:03because the spending created record
- 1:01:0740-year inflation, interest rate soared
- 1:01:09and so if you add the extra cost and
- 1:01:11interest it's 12 trillion dollars
- 1:01:13magically.
- 1:01:14>> That's the issue that the rhetoric of
- 1:01:17Republicans
- 1:01:18>> It's the facts.
- 1:01:18>> deficit does not match the numbers.
- 1:01:21And I think that that's the issue that
- 1:01:24we keep bringing up and what
- 1:01:26are you doing it for, right?
- 1:01:29Uh the $4.7 trillion price tag that the
- 1:01:32CBO has told us the last
- 1:01:35uh the first reconciliation cost is the
- 1:01:38first reconciliation.
- 1:01:40Uh
- 1:01:41who are the big beneficiaries? And we
- 1:01:43heard Representative uh
- 1:01:45McGarvey point that out.
- 1:01:46They were the millionaires. They were
- 1:01:48the billionaires. And we brought
- 1:01:50amendments in this Rules Committee to
- 1:01:52say, "Hey,
- 1:01:53uh how about if we let the middle-income
- 1:01:56tax cuts stay? We extend those. And
- 1:01:59instead say, 'No tax cuts if you're
- 1:02:01earning over a billion dollars.'" They
- 1:02:03said, "No. How about over 500 million?"
- 1:02:05They said, "No."
- 1:02:06Republicans continuously
- 1:02:09tell us where their priorities are.
- 1:02:12And the last $70 billion was for
- 1:02:16ICE.
- 1:02:18And what's happened in the last 2 weeks?
- 1:02:21More shootings in the streets.
- 1:02:24Murders.
- 1:02:25Killings in the streets cuz Republicans
- 1:02:27refuse to put any guardrails on.
- 1:02:30And and I think that that's what we're
- 1:02:32facing here is there is
- 1:02:34uh
- 1:02:36You celebrate what came out of the one
- 1:02:39big beautiful bill. You don't like the
- 1:02:40name anymore cuz you changed the name.
- 1:02:43But what really came out of there is uh
- 1:02:45how many people lost access to medical
- 1:02:49coverage? Uh do you Do you know that,
- 1:02:51Representative McGarvey?
- 1:02:53>> How many people lost access to
- 1:02:55>> coverage after passage of the one big
- 1:02:57beautiful bill?
- 1:02:58>> It is thousands upon thousands upon
- 1:03:01thousands of people.
- 1:03:01>> 5 million people. 5 million people. And
- 1:03:05if we actually took what they intend to
- 1:03:08spend on war, we could extend the
- 1:03:10Affordable Care Act tax credits for I
- 1:03:15think it's 3 years.
- 1:03:17So, the people who are losing
- 1:03:21access to health care, they're all
- 1:03:23working families.
- 1:03:25Right? And instead we want they want
- 1:03:27more war. And I think that that's the
- 1:03:29issue that we're concerned about. And I
- 1:03:32don't know if you want to talk a little
- 1:03:33bit more about why these priorities,
- 1:03:36these budget priorities of the
- 1:03:38Republicans are hurting Americans access
- 1:03:41to lower to access to health care, and
- 1:03:43they're doing nothing to lower the cost
- 1:03:45for everyday Americans.
- 1:03:47>> Yeah, I mean
- 1:03:49the stories that are coming into our
- 1:03:50offices, they're real and they're
- 1:03:52heart-wrenching.
- 1:03:53I had a woman from Louisville, Kentucky,
- 1:03:55her name's Ann.
- 1:03:56Uh she called my office and
- 1:04:00she is she works two jobs.
- 1:04:02One of them she owns her own business.
- 1:04:03Her husband also is an independent
- 1:04:05contractor. They have a 19-year-old son
- 1:04:08who lives at their home while trying to
- 1:04:10go to the University of Louisville
- 1:04:11because he's disabled.
- 1:04:13Her health insurance premiums cost $325
- 1:04:17a month under the silver plan
- 1:04:20of the Affordable Care Act.
- 1:04:22Because of the Republicans' actions in
- 1:04:24these budget bills, her premiums are
- 1:04:26going up to $1,275
- 1:04:29a month.
- 1:04:30She talked about the fact that she can't
- 1:04:32sleep at night, that she gets short of
- 1:04:34breath when she thinks about it, that
- 1:04:36her son is still required to go to
- 1:04:38specialists multiple times per year,
- 1:04:41doesn't know if she's going to be able
- 1:04:42to pay for it. She's doing everything
- 1:04:45right.
- 1:04:47She's playing by the rules.
- 1:04:50But the policy decisions
- 1:04:52coming out of the House Republicans and
- 1:04:54coming out of the Trump administration,
- 1:04:56they are giving millions of dollars to
- 1:04:59the richest corporations and people in
- 1:05:00this country, and they are yanking
- 1:05:02health care away from people who are
- 1:05:05trying to make their way every single
- 1:05:07day doing it the right way.
- 1:05:10There are so many stories about this. I
- 1:05:11had a guy call me just a couple of weeks
- 1:05:13ago. His health insurance premiums gone
- 1:05:15up by a thousand dollars. This doesn't
- 1:05:17mention the fact that already in
- 1:05:18Louisville a birthing center has
- 1:05:19announced it's going to close, that the
- 1:05:21Lee Specialty Clinic was at the verge of
- 1:05:23closure because of the Medicaid cuts
- 1:05:26that are going into effect. This is
- 1:05:28going to impact the Kentucky Hospital
- 1:05:30Association. This is not some flaming
- 1:05:32liberal group by the way. They have
- 1:05:34projected that 35 rural hospitals in
- 1:05:37Kentucky could close because of these
- 1:05:40Medicaid cuts.
- 1:05:41>> And there is nothing in today's proposed
- 1:05:44budget
- 1:05:46reconciliation that addresses any of
- 1:05:49these issues that you're talking about,
- 1:05:50correct?
- 1:05:50>> None of this whatsoever. In fact, you
- 1:05:52know, I was listening to the chairman.
- 1:05:54He can argue all he wants to about
- 1:05:56whether it's a good thing
- 1:05:58to increase the debt or deficit of this
- 1:05:59country. What he can't argue about is
- 1:06:01whether or not it's happening.
- 1:06:03Reconciliation one increased the debt
- 1:06:05and deficit of this country.
- 1:06:06Reconciliation two increased the debt
- 1:06:08and and deficit of this country. This is
- 1:06:10reconciliation three and guess what?
- 1:06:11Third time's a charm. They are
- 1:06:13increasing the debt and deficit of this
- 1:06:14country once again. And just look at the
- 1:06:16numbers. It's right here because it's a
- 1:06:18budget. $60 billion deficit increase for
- 1:06:21Armed Services. $13 billion deficit
- 1:06:23increase for Intelligence. $12 billion
- 1:06:25deficit increase for Agriculture. A $10
- 1:06:27billion deficit increase for House
- 1:06:29Administration. And again, just look at
- 1:06:31the language. Don't believe me. Look at
- 1:06:33the language in the bill. They waived
- 1:06:35the Cutgo provision. The Cutgo provision
- 1:06:38is the fancy Republican rules from that
- 1:06:40they used where you got to pay for what
- 1:06:41you do. They waive it.
- 1:06:43Why waive it if you don't unless you're
- 1:06:47going to increase the debt or deficit?
- 1:06:49Um so, it's very clear what they're
- 1:06:50doing.
- 1:06:51>> Uh and I think that the other thing is
- 1:06:53we were here last week and they were
- 1:06:56they they they're they're allocating
- 1:06:58they're going to send more money for
- 1:07:00war.
- 1:07:01But last week they were unwilling
- 1:07:04they were unwilling to pay for veterans
- 1:07:07services, for the the benefits that
- 1:07:10veterans need without a pay for.
- 1:07:13But they're going to spend this money
- 1:07:15without a pay for. I think we should
- 1:07:17prioritize our veterans. And there is no
- 1:07:20instruction to the Veterans Services
- 1:07:23Committee, is there?
- 1:07:23>> Our veterans get nothing in this bill.
- 1:07:25>> So our veterans get nothing out of this
- 1:07:27bill. Shows you where their priorities
- 1:07:29are. And with that, Madam Chair, I yield
- 1:07:30back.
- 1:07:32>> Thank you, Ms. Leger Fernandez.
- 1:07:35Chairman Arrington,
- 1:07:37this resolution
- 1:07:39is about security, funding our armed
- 1:07:41services to protect our national
- 1:07:43security, funding our nation's farmers
- 1:07:46to protect food security, and funding
- 1:07:49measures to protect election security.
- 1:07:52What would be the cost if we fail in our
- 1:07:56constitutional duty
- 1:07:58to protect America's security?
- 1:08:02>> Madam Chair, I can't imagine if our
- 1:08:05troops could hear the conversation about
- 1:08:08pay fors that every Democrat on this
- 1:08:10committee
- 1:08:12has supported supplemental funding for
- 1:08:14Ukraine, for Taiwan, for Israel, and now
- 1:08:19they're they're taking exception with
- 1:08:21emergency funding for our troops in
- 1:08:24conflict right now
- 1:08:26on the front lines, risking their lives.
- 1:08:29So let me tell you the cost. The cost is
- 1:08:33our sons and daughters can't be safe in
- 1:08:36saluting the commander-in-chief and
- 1:08:39doing their duty. This is bombs,
- 1:08:41bullets, and battlefield readiness. This
- 1:08:43is not modernization
- 1:08:45of the military. The $350 billion
- 1:08:48request that the president submitted for
- 1:08:50modernization, that's not what this is.
- 1:08:52It's emergency supplemental. And if I
- 1:08:54thought we could work that out on a
- 1:08:56bipartisan basis,
- 1:08:59we would do it.
- 1:09:00>> And the number one duty of the federal
- 1:09:03government
- 1:09:03>> Provide for the common defense.
- 1:09:05>> Provide for the common defense.
- 1:09:06>> Yes, ma'am.
- 1:09:06>> Thank you very much.
- 1:09:09>> Any further questions of our witnesses
- 1:09:13on this panel?
- 1:09:15Seeing none,
- 1:09:17we thank you both for coming.
- 1:09:18>> They get shorter every reconciliation,
- 1:09:20Madam Chair.
- 1:09:23I think we may be wearing Mr. McGovern
- 1:09:25down.
- 1:09:26>> You're not.
- 1:09:27>> Don't count on it. Do not
- 1:09:30Do not count on wearing Mr. McGovern
- 1:09:32down.
- 1:09:33>> No, I know that about this guy. Thank
- 1:09:35you for the time and opportunity.
- 1:09:37>> you both for your good work. We
- 1:09:39appreciate you coming. Thank you, Mr.
- 1:09:40McGovern.
- 1:11:11>> I now welcome our second panel.
- 1:11:15Chairman Cole, former chairman of this
- 1:11:18committee, so he's chairman squared.
- 1:11:22Uh and I understand that ranking member
- 1:11:26DeLauro is on her way.
- 1:11:29Um
- 1:11:30the two of you represent the
- 1:11:32Appropriations Committee.
- 1:11:34Your full statement will be submitted
- 1:11:37for the record.
- 1:11:38We ask that you summarize your statement
- 1:11:41in 5 minutes, and there is
- 1:11:44ranking member DeLauro
- 1:11:47in all her glory.
- 1:11:49Chairman Cole, I welcome your testimony.
- 1:11:54>> Thank you very much, Madam Chair.
- 1:11:56Uh Chairwoman Fox, ranking member
- 1:11:59McGovern, members of the Rules
- 1:12:00Committee, I appreciate very much the
- 1:12:02opportunity to testify today.
- 1:12:04I come before you today on H.R. 9770,
- 1:12:08the Continuing Appropriations Act of
- 1:12:102027.
- 1:12:12Over the past year, the House
- 1:12:13Appropriations Committee has worked
- 1:12:15diligently to fulfill our Article 1
- 1:12:17duties. Last month, we completed our
- 1:12:20markup process for fiscal year 2027,
- 1:12:23reporting all 12 bills out of the full
- 1:12:26committee by June 24th. It's the
- 1:12:28earliest date this feat has been
- 1:12:30accomplished since fiscal year 2020.
- 1:12:33As of today, the full House um of
- 1:12:36Representatives has also passed three of
- 1:12:38these bills across the floor, including
- 1:12:40the Military Construction and Veterans
- 1:12:42Affairs bill, the Agriculture Rural
- 1:12:45Development Food and Drug Administration
- 1:12:47bill, and the and related agencies bill,
- 1:12:50uh and the National Security, Department
- 1:12:52of State, and related programs bill. I'm
- 1:12:55deeply proud of the work that the
- 1:12:56committee's done thus far, and I'm
- 1:12:58appreciative of the support we've
- 1:13:01received from the rest of our colleagues
- 1:13:03in this chamber. Unfortunately, current
- 1:13:05circumstances in the Senate make clear
- 1:13:08that Congress as a whole is unlikely to
- 1:13:10complete the full appropriations process
- 1:13:13by the start of the fiscal year. The
- 1:13:15fact remains that our friends and
- 1:13:17colleagues across the rotunda have yet
- 1:13:19to report any appropriations bills out
- 1:13:21of the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- 1:13:24Despite good faith efforts and
- 1:13:25reasonable negotiations, political
- 1:13:28gamesmanship from the left has kept
- 1:13:30their process at a standstill.
- 1:13:33While I've not given up hope that we can
- 1:13:35enact at least some appropriations bills
- 1:13:37before the start of the fiscal year, I'm
- 1:13:40also realistic, and I acknowledge the
- 1:13:42reality on the ground. Congress will
- 1:13:44need to enact a continuing resolution of
- 1:13:47some sort prior to September 30th to
- 1:13:50avoid a government shutdown at the start
- 1:13:52of the fiscal year 2027.
- 1:13:55Every member in this room is only too
- 1:13:57aware of what transpired over the last
- 1:14:00year. The threat of a shutdown is not
- 1:14:02only real, it's happened twice in the
- 1:14:05last 12 months. First, Senator Schumer
- 1:14:08and Senate Democrats plunged the nation
- 1:14:10into the longest government shutdown in
- 1:14:12history last October. Not to be outdone,
- 1:14:16they then later pushed the Department of
- 1:14:18Homeland Security into the longest
- 1:14:20partial shutdown in American history.
- 1:14:23Both of these shutdowns were
- 1:14:24unnecessary, reckless, and
- 1:14:26irresponsible. It would be equally
- 1:14:28reckless and irresponsible to repeat the
- 1:14:31same mistake at the end of this fiscal
- 1:14:33year. Stability is necessary, which is
- 1:14:37why the House is moving early and taking
- 1:14:39the step of putting today's bill
- 1:14:41forward. H.R. 9770, the Continuing
- 1:14:45Appropriations Act 2027,
- 1:14:48will put in place a continuing
- 1:14:50resolution keeping the government open
- 1:14:52and operating through December 4th of
- 1:14:542026.
- 1:14:56This will not only allow Congress time
- 1:14:58to continue our work on full appropriate
- 1:15:00full year appropriations bills through
- 1:15:03regular order, but will also ensure that
- 1:15:05the government remains open through the
- 1:15:07November election and into early
- 1:15:09December.
- 1:15:10Some may ask why it is necessary that we
- 1:15:13take this bill up in July. I would
- 1:15:15simply state that it's never too early
- 1:15:18to do the right thing. The right thing
- 1:15:20for this body and for the American
- 1:15:21people is to make sure that the
- 1:15:23government remains funded and remains
- 1:15:26open. Passing this bill now ensures that
- 1:15:29we, the House, have taken this important
- 1:15:32step prior to the August district work
- 1:15:34period. There will be no question about
- 1:15:36where the House stands. We stand
- 1:15:38squarely with our constituents who
- 1:15:40overwhelmingly want to keep the
- 1:15:42government open and providing services
- 1:15:45to them. Importantly, today's bill also
- 1:15:48does not contain a single poison pill
- 1:15:50rider. It's a clean CR fully funding our
- 1:15:53government. This includes our military
- 1:15:56and defense needs, support for our
- 1:15:58veterans, and critical services for our
- 1:16:00constituents like roads, parks, child
- 1:16:03care, water projects, infrastructure
- 1:16:06improvements, scientific research, job
- 1:16:09training, and countless others. I look
- 1:16:11forward to continuing the FY 2027
- 1:16:15appropriations process in the coming
- 1:16:17months. I thank each of you for your
- 1:16:19time, and I look forward to your
- 1:16:20questions.
- 1:16:22>> Thank you, Chairman Cole. Ranking Member
- 1:16:24DeLauro, thank you. You're recognized.
- 1:16:27>> Thank you, Chairwoman Fox and Ranking
- 1:16:28Member McGovern, members members of the
- 1:16:30committee. Uh good afternoon to all of
- 1:16:33you. It's great to be here alongside my
- 1:16:35friend, Chairman Cole, to discuss the
- 1:16:37stopgap funding measure released on
- 1:16:40Friday afternoon.
- 1:16:42I want to begin by stating clearly and
- 1:16:44plainly Democrats do not want a
- 1:16:47government shutdown. In a perfect world,
- 1:16:50the months remaining between now and
- 1:16:52September 30th would be ample time to
- 1:16:55fund the government um on a bipartisan
- 1:16:58basis through the appropriations process
- 1:17:01one bill at a time.
- 1:17:04However, given Republicans' refusal to
- 1:17:06write bipartisan bills in either the
- 1:17:08House or Senate, a continuing resolution
- 1:17:11is necessary.
- 1:17:13If I am going to support a continuing
- 1:17:15resolution, it needs to continue
- 1:17:17government operations, exclude any
- 1:17:19poison pills, and it must maintain
- 1:17:22Congress's constitutional authority over
- 1:17:25spending decisions.
- 1:17:27At this time, the continuing resolution
- 1:17:30released on Friday does not meet that
- 1:17:33standard.
- 1:17:34The final Homeland Security bill passed
- 1:17:37unopposed in April. Unopposed it was by
- 1:17:40a voice vote. By including a provision
- 1:17:43to remove all funding for the Border
- 1:17:47Patrol.
- 1:17:48Chairman Cole's bill does not continue
- 1:17:51that agreement, giving the Trump
- 1:17:54administration permission to use
- 1:17:56billions provided by this bill to fund
- 1:18:00Border Patrol without any substantial
- 1:18:03reforms to how that agency operates.
- 1:18:06It's a clear line in the sand that
- 1:18:09Democrats have drawn for months.
- 1:18:12In recent weeks, immigration agents have
- 1:18:14shot and killed residents in Maine and
- 1:18:18Texas.
- 1:18:20Neither of whom were the target of
- 1:18:22enforcement operations, highlighting the
- 1:18:25urgent need for dramatic reforms to
- 1:18:28protect our communities from further
- 1:18:31violence.
- 1:18:32We have also been presented this measure
- 1:18:35hastily put together with little more
- 1:18:37than a couple of days of thought. That
- 1:18:39is not the way to govern.
- 1:18:42The majority has not made time to gather
- 1:18:44information from our colleagues in the
- 1:18:47executive branch to identify any
- 1:18:49potentially critical anticipated needs.
- 1:18:53Let alone anything that may come to
- 1:18:54light over the next couple of months.
- 1:18:57Especially as we head into the heart of
- 1:18:59wildfire season and approach hurricane
- 1:19:03season. We are putting the cart before
- 1:19:05the horse by considering this
- 1:19:06legislation without understanding the
- 1:19:09full scope of what is needed to continue
- 1:19:12operations through December 4th. As a
- 1:19:15matter of fact, we have just received a
- 1:19:18lengthy proposed list of anomalies from
- 1:19:23the White House.
- 1:19:24But the process has made no time for us
- 1:19:29to evaluate these proposals. And this
- 1:19:32bill does not account for anything that
- 1:19:35is in these these proposals. And the
- 1:19:37chairman and I both know we go through
- 1:19:39these with a fine-tooth comb to see what
- 1:19:42is flexible and what isn't flexible.
- 1:19:45What are the needs that have to be met.
- 1:19:48Border patrol problems aside, Chairman
- 1:19:51Cole has put forward a plain bill absent
- 1:19:54controversial riders
- 1:19:56and containing most of the standard
- 1:19:58authorities we enact in these stopgap
- 1:20:01measures. That's a welcome change from
- 1:20:03most of the regular bills that have come
- 1:20:05to the floor this summer. But we still
- 1:20:08do not have all of the information that
- 1:20:11we need.
- 1:20:12We still have 2 months before the end of
- 1:20:15the fiscal year and should not rush
- 1:20:17through an incomplete funding extension.
- 1:20:19We ought to wait for the information
- 1:20:21that we need to get it right the first
- 1:20:24time.
- 1:20:25This resolution was dropped on us on
- 1:20:27Friday afternoon without any bipartisan
- 1:20:31negotiation.
- 1:20:33Had we been consulted, there are several
- 1:20:34provisions we would have pushed for to
- 1:20:36strengthen the measure and to
- 1:20:38and to protect congressional
- 1:20:40prerogatives, including the reversal of
- 1:20:42a proposed federal rule from the Office
- 1:20:45of Management and Budget that allows
- 1:20:47political appointees in the Trump
- 1:20:49administration to unilaterally block or
- 1:20:52terminate grant funding if they deem it
- 1:20:55not sufficiently in line with the
- 1:20:57president's policy priorities.
- 1:21:00If we had been brought in before the
- 1:21:02bill was released, we could be here
- 1:21:04touting a bipartisan agreement with a
- 1:21:06plan to fully fund the government for
- 1:21:08the next fiscal year before the end of
- 1:21:11this Congress. Instead, we are
- 1:21:13scrambling to jam through a one-sided
- 1:21:16stopgap measure 3 days before everyone
- 1:21:19leaves for the August recess.
- 1:21:23I'm deeply concerned about what may be
- 1:21:25attached to this funding measure through
- 1:21:27the rule that is passed out of this
- 1:21:29committee.
- 1:21:30There are some Republicans who have
- 1:21:32decided that they will not allow any
- 1:21:35legislation to be considered under a
- 1:21:37rule unless it includes an extremely
- 1:21:40partisan measure to restrict voting
- 1:21:43access for millions of American
- 1:21:45citizens. Under no circumstances will
- 1:21:48Democrats support that measure.
- 1:21:51If the position of my friends across the
- 1:21:53aisle is that they will shut down the
- 1:21:55government unless we severely restrict
- 1:21:57American citizens voting access, I
- 1:21:59invite them to make that case to the
- 1:22:02public and see how the public responds
- 1:22:04in November. At minimum, I cannot
- 1:22:07support this bill without the inclusion
- 1:22:10of the technical language regarding the
- 1:22:12Border Patrol that was agreed on. It was
- 1:22:16agreed on. It was a bipartisan,
- 1:22:18overwhelming voice vote in April. Until
- 1:22:22we are certain that the Republicans will
- 1:22:24not use this legislation to advance
- 1:22:27their voter suppression measure.
- 1:22:29Beyond that, the decision to pursue this
- 1:22:32path without any bipartisan negotiations
- 1:22:35gives me serious reservations in moving
- 1:22:38forward. I'm happy to answer the
- 1:22:40committee's questions. I thank you and I
- 1:22:42yield back.
- 1:22:43>> Thank you, Ms. DeLauro. Ms. Fischbach,
- 1:22:45you're recognized.
- 1:22:47>> Thank you, Madam Chair. And
- 1:22:48Chairman Cole, I think it's I think you
- 1:22:50mentioned it in your in your opening
- 1:22:52remarks, but I just wanted to
- 1:22:55check again and make it make a point of
- 1:22:57it. How many of the 12 appropriations
- 1:22:59bills have passed out of your committee?
- 1:23:01>> 12, all 12.
- 1:23:03>> And how many have passed the House?
- 1:23:04>> Three.
- 1:23:06>> And how many have passed the Senate?
- 1:23:07>> Zero.
- 1:23:09And that includes obviously out of
- 1:23:10committee, not just out of the Senate
- 1:23:12itself, but as the Senate Appropriations
- 1:23:15Committee hasn't gotten a single bill
- 1:23:16done yet. And I think it's pretty
- 1:23:18unlikely they're going to get them done
- 1:23:20between now and September 30th.
- 1:23:22>> And and thank you for pointing it out. I
- 1:23:23wouldn't have asked you question that
- 1:23:25out of committee, that out of the House,
- 1:23:27or excuse me, out of the Senate. And
- 1:23:30I mean, the Senate's not obviously not
- 1:23:32taking their duty seriously if if they
- 1:23:34are not even
- 1:23:36taking up the ones we've sent and doing
- 1:23:39anything. And so, I think this is the
- 1:23:40only responsible thing to do. It's like
- 1:23:42you said, they're probably not going to
- 1:23:44do anything before September 30th. It's
- 1:23:46unlikely that they will. And I think
- 1:23:48that to avoid a shutdown
- 1:23:50and let allow them more opportunity to
- 1:23:53get their work done and take it
- 1:23:54seriously, I think this is a necessary
- 1:23:57thing that we need to do. And so, I
- 1:23:59appreciate you bringing it forward and I
- 1:24:02you know, it's a pretty simple
- 1:24:05resolution, pretty simple piece of
- 1:24:07legislation. And so, I think that you
- 1:24:09know, it it's easy to understand what's
- 1:24:11going on in it. And so, I don't think we
- 1:24:13need to have
- 1:24:15you know, 3 months to to
- 1:24:18to digest what's going on in this. I
- 1:24:19understand it and I think that everybody
- 1:24:22else does, too. And so I appreciate you
- 1:24:23bringing it forward and I appreciate the
- 1:24:25fact that you're taking the responsible
- 1:24:27approach and making sure that we are
- 1:24:29able to um
- 1:24:31insist Senate get their work done.
- 1:24:33Thank you very much and I
- 1:24:34>> Thank you.
- 1:24:35Thank you, Ms. Fischbach. Mr. McGovern,
- 1:24:37you're recognized.
- 1:24:37>> Yeah, let me just first of all say that
- 1:24:39I want to remind my colleagues that the
- 1:24:41Senate is controlled by the Republican
- 1:24:43Party and Susan Collins is the chair of
- 1:24:45the
- 1:24:46>> Mhm.
- 1:24:46>> Appropriations Committee over there. So
- 1:24:48maybe there's a need for some change. Um
- 1:24:51and I would you know, I don't want to
- 1:24:52prolong this. I would just I have
- 1:24:54respect for
- 1:24:55uh both the chairman and the ranking
- 1:24:56member. Um
- 1:24:58it just seems to me based on what Mr.
- 1:24:59DeLauro just said that uh
- 1:25:02maybe we could have reached a bipartisan
- 1:25:04agreement if there was a bipartisan back
- 1:25:06and forth before this uh
- 1:25:09this was announced and um maybe we can
- 1:25:11still get to that at some point, but uh
- 1:25:13um I don't really have any questions. I
- 1:25:15just I just wish that this was more of a
- 1:25:16bipartisan process and maybe we would be
- 1:25:19maybe everything would be a little bit
- 1:25:20different right now, but it is what it
- 1:25:22is and I thank you both for being here
- 1:25:24and I yield back.
- 1:25:25>> Thank you, Mr.
- 1:25:26Mr. Scott, you're recognized.
- 1:25:29>> Thank you, Madam Chair. Uh I will tell
- 1:25:31you it seems to me that the Senate's
- 1:25:33actually controlled by the
- 1:25:34parliamentarian.
- 1:25:36Uh
- 1:25:37not
- 1:25:38uh the Republicans over there. But I I
- 1:25:40just Mr. Cole, I'm looking through the
- 1:25:42things. I mean
- 1:25:43>> How's that going so
- 1:25:45>> I don't see
- 1:25:48any reason for anybody to necessarily be
- 1:25:51to object to this. I like you don't have
- 1:25:54confidence that
- 1:25:55bills are going to make it through the
- 1:25:57House and the Senate prior to
- 1:26:00uh the end of the fiscal year.
- 1:26:03We only have
- 1:26:05we don't have that many work days until
- 1:26:07then to be honest with you. But but I
- 1:26:08haven't seen the Senate take much action
- 1:26:10on on anything yet. And so
- 1:26:12I've
- 1:26:14I think it's kind of smart to go ahead
- 1:26:15and take the potential chaos of a
- 1:26:17shutdown off of the table because of the
- 1:26:19amount of damage it does to the American
- 1:26:21citizens. And while I think it, you
- 1:26:23know, a shutdown probably works to the
- 1:26:24advantage of the Democrats politically
- 1:26:26because of the way the press operates
- 1:26:27and their messaging
- 1:26:29apparatus is is very damaging to the
- 1:26:32American citizens and our country. And
- 1:26:34so, I intend to vote for it. If you have
- 1:26:36any other comments that you'd like to to
- 1:26:38make as the chair, you're welcome to it.
- 1:26:40Other than that, Madam Chair, I'm I'm
- 1:26:42prepared to vote in favor of the
- 1:26:43continuing
- 1:26:44resolution.
- 1:26:45>> Mr. Cole.
- 1:26:46>> Uh
- 1:26:47all I'd point out is that
- 1:26:50Look, there's nothing in the bill to be
- 1:26:51against.
- 1:26:53It It just simply is a clean CR. And
- 1:26:56I've always had the philosophy I don't
- 1:26:57vote on bills because of what's not in
- 1:27:00them.
- 1:27:01I vote against them
- 1:27:03or for them on the basis of what is in
- 1:27:05them. There's nothing in here that's
- 1:27:06remotely controversial. And look, we've
- 1:27:09been through the two longest shutdowns
- 1:27:12in American history. The longest
- 1:27:13shutdown full government which Senator
- 1:27:16Schumer and Senate Democrats sprung on
- 1:27:18us. And to say they control by the
- 1:27:20Republicans simply not true because of
- 1:27:23the filibuster. And that's just the
- 1:27:25reality.
- 1:27:26Uh and I don't want to go through that
- 1:27:28again. I don't want the
- 1:27:30final part of the campaign this year to
- 1:27:34be fought over government shutdown.
- 1:27:35Frankly, I don't think people on either
- 1:27:37side of the the partisan divide should
- 1:27:40want that. They should want to be
- 1:27:42fighting on the issues. I promise you
- 1:27:44this, if we shut down the government
- 1:27:45come September 30th, that will be the
- 1:27:48issue that dominates politics in the
- 1:27:50next few years. We're just trying to
- 1:27:52take that off the table for both sides,
- 1:27:55make sure that there's certainty in
- 1:27:57funding the government, that we don't
- 1:27:59have another one of these situations
- 1:28:01where we have lines at airports because
- 1:28:03two
- 1:28:04TSA agents aren't being paid for or any
- 1:28:07of those sorts of things. Just fund the
- 1:28:08essential things. We'll have the
- 1:28:11election. Things can be sorted out, we
- 1:28:13come back after that. If the Senate were
- 1:28:15moving, if they'd made as much progress
- 1:28:17as we have, uh then again, I would uh
- 1:28:21I'd be happy to to hope that that would
- 1:28:23happen, but I just don't see the time
- 1:28:25for it. So, let's remove the possibility
- 1:28:28of a government shutdown now through the
- 1:28:31election, have enough time when we
- 1:28:33finish that election to come back and
- 1:28:35make some appropriate decisions. In the
- 1:28:37meantime, we want to keep working on
- 1:28:39appropriations bills. I hope we keep
- 1:28:40bringing them to the floor. I know the
- 1:28:43House has lots of things to consider,
- 1:28:45uh but uh we're going to continue to try
- 1:28:47and move the regular process along. We
- 1:28:49want to take away the possibility of a
- 1:28:53shutdown between now and the election
- 1:28:54because again, we've seen that happen
- 1:28:56twice in this Congress already, uh
- 1:28:59generated by the Senate, and I'm not
- 1:29:01willing to risk a third time if we can
- 1:29:03avoid that.
- 1:29:06>> There's a difference between having a
- 1:29:07majority and being in control. You You
- 1:29:10yield back, Mr. Chairman.
- 1:29:11>> Yes, ma'am.
- 1:29:12>> Miss Kaptur, you're recognized.
- 1:29:15>> Thank you.
- 1:29:17Um
- 1:29:18I hate to say it, but it feels like this
- 1:29:20continuing resolution is an admission of
- 1:29:22failure, not by our brilliant
- 1:29:25appropriators, but by House Republican
- 1:29:27leadership. Um they're willing to give
- 1:29:31up one of Congress's most fundamental
- 1:29:33powers and duties in order to avoid
- 1:29:37another potential political loss um just
- 1:29:40before the election. Uh you know,
- 1:29:42they're asking us to give a blank check
- 1:29:44to this administration because they
- 1:29:46can't manage either their Republican
- 1:29:48caucus or to negotiate
- 1:29:52um actual bipartisan funding bills. So,
- 1:29:54I think it's an insult to the
- 1:29:56Appropriations Committee because I know
- 1:29:57they continue to do good work on even
- 1:29:59under duress, but it's a failure of
- 1:30:02Congress to be doing this months before
- 1:30:05um the end of the year. Um and it also
- 1:30:08robs the house of the ability to direct
- 1:30:11funding to our districts where we know
- 1:30:13we need it. It it robs every member of
- 1:30:15the ability to highlight, you know,
- 1:30:17whether community health centers or
- 1:30:20local infrastructure or uh
- 1:30:23we've been able to um get additional
- 1:30:25resources for schools and libraries. All
- 1:30:27that goes out the window with a
- 1:30:29continuing resolution. Um so so I'm not
- 1:30:33in favor of this. I think it is an
- 1:30:35admission of of failure by the the
- 1:30:37Republican leadership. Um I was struck,
- 1:30:40Ranking Member DeLauro, about something
- 1:30:42you said about the continuation of
- 1:30:43funding without guardrails for ICE
- 1:30:48at a time when in the last week to 10
- 1:30:51days we've seen two more killings of
- 1:30:53people on American streets under very
- 1:30:56very questionable circumstances.
- 1:30:59When we're still seeing a failure to
- 1:31:01have clear rules about use of force.
- 1:31:04Um all the money that has been sent to
- 1:31:06ICE uh amidst promises that they would
- 1:31:08be deploying
- 1:31:10um body cams for people to wear to
- 1:31:12remove some of these questions. We're
- 1:31:14not seeing that but now we're supposed
- 1:31:15to give them more money. Is that what
- 1:31:17this bill would do?
- 1:31:18>> Let let let let me be clear. First of
- 1:31:20all, I I just want to say there is there
- 1:31:22would have been no need to go down a
- 1:31:24road where there were difficulties here.
- 1:31:26As I said, you know you know of the um
- 1:31:30the some of the provisions that are in
- 1:31:31the bill are fine, which we could all
- 1:31:33agree to. But the issue is that the
- 1:31:37Republican continuing resolution, it
- 1:31:39does not include
- 1:31:42all of the sections of the fiscal year
- 1:31:452026 Homeland Security Appropriations
- 1:31:49Act. What it lacks, you not with regard
- 1:31:51to ICE, because what they've said is
- 1:31:53that there was no money that goes to
- 1:31:55ICE, but they have failed to put in what
- 1:31:59the agreement was, the funding
- 1:32:01agreement, PL 119-86,
- 1:32:04zeroed out funding for Border Patrol.
- 1:32:07They did it in two ways. This Republican
- 1:32:10CR carries
- 1:32:13omits
- 1:32:14that prohibition that guaranteed zero
- 1:32:18for Border Patrol. And so that gives the
- 1:32:22administration the flexibility to fund
- 1:32:24Border Patrol with the money that has
- 1:32:27been provided to CBP because we did
- 1:32:29provide money to CBP to carry out
- 1:32:33its its its its functions
- 1:32:36in a
- 1:32:36in a strong way.
- 1:32:39So, and no one has said, and and by the
- 1:32:41way, so that you understand, the
- 1:32:46we discovered that, we being the
- 1:32:48Democrats, discovered this technical
- 1:32:50error, and it was an error. I I I I I
- 1:32:54believe that that was an error. But
- 1:32:57nevertheless, we then
- 1:32:59formulated language in the way to fix it
- 1:33:03so we could move forward. That was
- 1:33:06denied because when the bill came
- 1:33:08forward,
- 1:33:11it
- 1:33:12we noticed that problem, we drafted the
- 1:33:14correction, when it came forward on on
- 1:33:17on Saturday, Republicans did not make
- 1:33:19the technical corrections in the bill
- 1:33:21that was introduced on Saturday. So,
- 1:33:24they made a choice
- 1:33:26to allow the CR to potentially fund
- 1:33:29Border Patrol no reforms as we have
- 1:33:34fought for over the last several months.
- 1:33:37And quite frankly, as I say, this piece
- 1:33:42was passed on the floor of the House
- 1:33:46bipartisan in April by virtue of a voice
- 1:33:50vote. So, why not fix it? So, that this
- 1:33:53would allow them to potentially fund
- 1:33:55Border Patrol on top of the $90.7
- 1:34:00billion
- 1:34:01that CBP has already received through
- 1:34:04reconciliation. And that's largely for
- 1:34:07border patrol operations. This could be
- 1:34:10This could have been corrected. Uh and
- 1:34:13and and so I'm
- 1:34:15That's That That is it. And I got all
- 1:34:17the citations and what bill it is, etc.
- 1:34:20etc. etc. So, in the midst this
- 1:34:23language, uh and I don't think that we
- 1:34:26can um What is it? It was it Ronald
- 1:34:30Reagan who said trust but verify?
- 1:34:32Uh we have no way of verifying that this
- 1:34:35money would not be used.
- 1:34:37>> when this bill was produced
- 1:34:38>> Yes.
- 1:34:39>> you checked it over
- 1:34:41>> We drafted the language.
- 1:34:42>> verifying that it didn't have anything
- 1:34:45that was different than what had been
- 1:34:46previously agreed to, you found that
- 1:34:48there were things that were different.
- 1:34:49And when you asked for corrections, they
- 1:34:51didn't
- 1:34:51>> We drafted the language.
- 1:34:53>> That's not good faith negotiation.
- 1:34:55>> So.
- 1:34:56>> Thank you. I yield back.
- 1:34:58>> Thank you, Ms. Kelly. And Mr. Griffith,
- 1:35:00you're recognized.
- 1:35:03>> Mr. Chairman,
- 1:35:05if
- 1:35:07the Senate doesn't act, if we don't get
- 1:35:09these appropriations bills
- 1:35:12passed,
- 1:35:15um
- 1:35:17these sections that uh
- 1:35:20the ranking member has just mentioned
- 1:35:22would not be in the government shutdown
- 1:35:24period, either.
- 1:35:25>> Would they?
- 1:35:25>> Correct.
- 1:35:27And
- 1:35:29if we do the CR
- 1:35:31now, which I will tell you I think is
- 1:35:33the responsible thing to do based on
- 1:35:35past actions on the Senate side, it's
- 1:35:37it's not just the filibuster. It's the
- 1:35:39modern filibuster that's been changed uh
- 1:35:42you know, if you went to the filibuster
- 1:35:44before the '70s, you wouldn't have these
- 1:35:45issues. But nonetheless,
- 1:35:47um
- 1:35:49but if the if the if we take these
- 1:35:51actions, and then
- 1:35:54through negotiations with the House and
- 1:35:56the Senate and and these
- 1:35:59uh things that the ranking member wants,
- 1:36:01which have been agreed to by the by the
- 1:36:03House previously, that would all be in
- 1:36:05the appropriations bill uh most likely,
- 1:36:08would it not?
- 1:36:08>> Correct.
- 1:36:10>> So, and if there and there's no reason
- 1:36:12why if we pass a a CR to take effect,
- 1:36:15should we not get appropriations bills,
- 1:36:17and we do pass appropriations bills,
- 1:36:18then the CR would not go into effect. Is
- 1:36:20that also correct?
- 1:36:21>> That's also correct.
- 1:36:22>> Now, let me ask you this cuz I I don't
- 1:36:24know the answer. If we approve if we
- 1:36:26approve, let's say the House and the
- 1:36:28Senate get together and we approve six
- 1:36:30of the 12 or so appropriations bills,
- 1:36:33does the CR only go into effect for the
- 1:36:35remaining areas that weren't approved?
- 1:36:38>> That's also correct. If we actually
- 1:36:40passed bills and they were signed into
- 1:36:42law, those would supersede a CR.
- 1:36:45>> So, this is kind of like
- 1:36:48buying that life insurance policy. When
- 1:36:50you have children, you hope you aren't
- 1:36:51going to die,
- 1:36:53but if you do, you want them taken care
- 1:36:54of.
- 1:36:56Am I correct that this is kind of like
- 1:36:58saying, "Okay, we're going to have this
- 1:36:59policy here. We hope we get it all done
- 1:37:02by September 30th, but if we don't,
- 1:37:05while members are distracted in October
- 1:37:07and we're going off campaigning or
- 1:37:09trying to campaign for both the House
- 1:37:11and the Senate,
- 1:37:13then we don't have to worry about the
- 1:37:14government shutting down and not doing
- 1:37:16the things that the American people
- 1:37:18wanted to do." Is that my understanding?
- 1:37:20>> That is correct.
- 1:37:21>> And and has it been your experience in
- 1:37:23your district as it has been in mine
- 1:37:25that of all the issues we fight about up
- 1:37:27here, having the government shut down
- 1:37:29and having people worrying about whether
- 1:37:31or not
- 1:37:32there's going to be, you know, this,
- 1:37:34that, or the other, whether the money
- 1:37:36for disaster relief is going to actually
- 1:37:39get get to where it needs to be, whether
- 1:37:41or not the Blue Ridge Parkway is going
- 1:37:42to be open in your district. May not be
- 1:37:43asking about the Blue Ridge Parkway, but
- 1:37:45similar functions like that, these are
- 1:37:47the things that people care about the
- 1:37:49most. Isn't that true?
- 1:37:50>> In my view, it is.
- 1:37:52>> And so, what we're doing here is we're
- 1:37:54trying to do the responsible thing,
- 1:37:56recognizing that in the past there have
- 1:37:58been issues and problems.
- 1:38:01We're just trying to make sure that that
- 1:38:03government moves smoothly as we move
- 1:38:05forward, and then we can negotiate all
- 1:38:07those things. If we can get these
- 1:38:08appropriations bills passed, that's
- 1:38:09fabulous, is it not?
- 1:38:11>> I think it's the prudent thing to do
- 1:38:13given what's happened literally within
- 1:38:15the last year. I mean, the longest
- 1:38:17government shutdown in history followed
- 1:38:20by the longest partial government
- 1:38:22shutdown history. There's nothing in
- 1:38:24this bill that's remotely offensive to
- 1:38:27anyone. It just simply continues things
- 1:38:30and makes sure we can have an election,
- 1:38:32sort these things out, but not shut down
- 1:38:34the government with all the risk to
- 1:38:36public safety,
- 1:38:38to the functioning of the economy. But
- 1:38:40those things done. And again, we've
- 1:38:42watched the Democratic
- 1:38:44you know, contingent in the Senate do
- 1:38:46that twice already. So, making sure it
- 1:38:49doesn't happen a third time,
- 1:38:51we think it's the prudent thing to do.
- 1:38:53>> Well, and it's prudent notwithstanding I
- 1:38:55mean, doesn't matter
- 1:38:57who does what, it just makes sure that
- 1:38:59if we're if we're negotiating points and
- 1:39:01we're arguing for our points
- 1:39:03uh
- 1:39:05vehemently and respectfully, but we
- 1:39:07can't get an agreement by September
- 1:39:0830th, the American people don't have to
- 1:39:10pay the price.
- 1:39:11>> That's that's exactly the effort here.
- 1:39:14>> Appreciated. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
- 1:39:16Appreciate your work. I yield back.
- 1:39:19>> Thank you, Mr. Griffith for always
- 1:39:20getting to the heart of the matter. Ms.
- 1:39:22Leger Fernandez, you're recognized.
- 1:39:25>> Thank you, Madam Chair, and hello Mr.
- 1:39:27Chairman and ranking member. I would
- 1:39:29note that in the short hearing that
- 1:39:31we've had so far, we've had Republicans
- 1:39:34mention repeatedly over and over and
- 1:39:37over again, "Shutdown, shutdown,
- 1:39:38shutdown."
- 1:39:39>> We're not talking about that.
- 1:39:40>> And I've heard the ranking member talk
- 1:39:42about can we have a conversation about a
- 1:39:44CR so that we can work out matters
- 1:39:48because a CR is best like an
- 1:39:51appropriation. I always like it when the
- 1:39:54two of you come before us and say well
- 1:39:55we worked things out, right? We didn't
- 1:39:58each get what we wanted but we worked
- 1:39:59things out and what I'm here
- 1:40:02what I'm hearing today is
- 1:40:04we were given this bill
- 1:40:06we had very time to very little time to
- 1:40:09look at them and we haven't been able to
- 1:40:10work things out.
- 1:40:11Uh, and is is that a good summary of
- 1:40:14kind of what we're seeing here?
- 1:40:15>> Yeah.
- 1:40:16I I I mean the fact is is I I said at
- 1:40:18the outset
- 1:40:20you know I'm not I'm I'm not going to
- 1:40:21get into
- 1:40:23you know everybody's view is about the
- 1:40:25government shutdown. All I can do is say
- 1:40:26it took you 79 days to come to a
- 1:40:28conclusion I made the very first day is
- 1:40:30to say let's separate out
- 1:40:33border security and and and ICE and fund
- 1:40:36everybody else. Took you 79 days to want
- 1:40:39to do that to pay these people. You know
- 1:40:41you kept talking about it but you
- 1:40:42didn't. That aside we could come to an
- 1:40:45agreement here. Why are we not following
- 1:40:49what we said we would do
- 1:40:52in April of 2026
- 1:40:55with regard to the funding of
- 1:40:59ICE which is there and the technical
- 1:41:02error?
- 1:41:03I don't believe anybody did this with
- 1:41:06malice of forethought. I think it was a
- 1:41:08technical error but what is contemplated
- 1:41:11is not providing that fix and saying
- 1:41:15zero as is in the
- 1:41:18in the bill for this effort. That that
- 1:41:20is not a problem. By the way I I might
- 1:41:22just add look
- 1:41:25I've talked about the Senate a lot and
- 1:41:27you know what what they do or what they
- 1:41:29don't do but I do know that
- 1:41:32the chair and the ranking member there
- 1:41:36uh a chair Collins and ranking member
- 1:41:38Murray have talked about coming to a
- 1:41:40bipartisan conclusion on where we go to
- 1:41:43a CR, which is not the case on the
- 1:41:47on the on the on the house side. And
- 1:41:49again, look, we received this moments
- 1:41:52ago. How many pages is this? Some
- 1:41:56you know, 20 pages of anomalies from the
- 1:42:00White House,
- 1:42:02which have not been reviewed or gone
- 1:42:04through about what that means. For
- 1:42:07instance, the OMB proposal for section
- 1:42:098, you need language
- 1:42:12to address funding shortfalls and to
- 1:42:15maintain the current services for public
- 1:42:18housing agencies. Without the anomaly,
- 1:42:22public housing authorities would have
- 1:42:23insufficient funds to maintain
- 1:42:26assistance for tens of thousands of
- 1:42:29households. Shouldn't we take the time
- 1:42:32to find out whether or not we can get
- 1:42:34this right on the first go-round? All
- 1:42:37we're simply asking for is to take a
- 1:42:40look at the technical fix that's needed.
- 1:42:43Let's make sure that the appropriations
- 1:42:46bill is not going to be loaded down with
- 1:42:49the Save Act,
- 1:42:51as we saw with the State and Foreign
- 1:42:53Operations bill.
- 1:42:55Uh that and talk about not a clean CR.
- 1:42:58That certainly wouldn't be a clean CR.
- 1:43:00We have no guarantees there what comes
- 1:43:03out of the the the the the committee
- 1:43:05here, and we could get to a bipartisan
- 1:43:09resolve of this uh if we were to to move
- 1:43:12forward uh in uh in in in in in good
- 1:43:16faith. Uh
- 1:43:18It defies imagination that we have now
- 1:43:22uh
- 1:43:222 months to go. We're going with half
- 1:43:25ideas and not full knowledge and
- 1:43:27understanding of what needs to go into a
- 1:43:30continuing uh resolution. And uh so, I'm
- 1:43:35happy to continuing to talk about it. I
- 1:43:38will say one last word. You know, people
- 1:43:40talk about, well, let's wait and see.
- 1:43:42You know,
- 1:43:43very clearly, there hasn't been any
- 1:43:46level of trust
- 1:43:50built up by this administration. Let's
- 1:43:53take a look at rescissions. Let's take a
- 1:43:56look at impoundments. Let's take a look
- 1:43:58at reconciliation.
- 1:43:59Let's take a look at a rule now at OMB
- 1:44:02says no longer are we going to provide
- 1:44:04grants across all agencies. Not only
- 1:44:08they're not going to be based on merit
- 1:44:10or peer reviewed with regard to science,
- 1:44:12but they're going to go through a
- 1:44:13a filter, a political filter with
- 1:44:16political appointees who know jack about
- 1:44:20what is in some of these bills. And they
- 1:44:22will make the decision as to where
- 1:44:24federal dollars are going to go. Both
- 1:44:27sides of the aisle should be so offended
- 1:44:30by that we come to a conclusion.
- 1:44:33We win some, we lose some, but we come
- 1:44:35to a conclusion on a bipartisan basis of
- 1:44:38what our constituents have said that
- 1:44:40they want these dollars for. And we pass
- 1:44:43the bills bicameral, bipartisan,
- 1:44:46president signs the bill, and then it
- 1:44:48gets reversed. Hell no. That cannot be
- 1:44:52the case on both sides of the aisle. We
- 1:44:54cannot go forward. And as I said, we
- 1:44:56need some assurances here. We need the
- 1:44:58fix, and we need to be guaranteed that
- 1:45:00the Save Act is not going to be part of
- 1:45:02this part of this effort. Thank you. I
- 1:45:05yield back.
- 1:45:05>> Thank you. I look forward to having a
- 1:45:07conclusion that has more bipartisan. I
- 1:45:09look forward to your bipartisan
- 1:45:11conversations moving forward. And with
- 1:45:13that, I yield back.
- 1:45:14>> Thank you, Ms. Salazar Fernandez.
- 1:45:17I don't see anyone else here
- 1:45:21available to ask any questions of our
- 1:45:23witnesses. I
- 1:45:26thank you all very much for coming and
- 1:45:29making your positions
- 1:45:31perfectly clear.
- 1:45:34Thank you very much and you're excused.
- 1:46:12I now welcome our next panel, Chairman
- 1:46:15Style and Ranking Member Morelle
- 1:46:18from the House Administration Committee.
- 1:46:40Well, I'm still looking for Chairman
- 1:46:43Style.
- 1:46:44>> I'm sure Mr. Morelle could represent
- 1:46:46both sides.
- 1:48:34>> I now welcome our next panel, Chairman
- 1:48:37Steil and Ranking Member Morelle from
- 1:48:39the House Administration Committee. Your
- 1:48:42full statements will be submitted for
- 1:48:43the record and we ask you summarize your
- 1:48:45statement in 5 minutes. Chairman Steil,
- 1:48:49I welcome your testimony.
- 1:48:51>> Chair Fox, thanks for having me and
- 1:48:54Ranking Ranking Member McGovern.
- 1:48:56Members of the Committee, thanks for
- 1:48:57inviting me to testify today in support
- 1:49:00of H.R. 7008, the Stop Insider Trading
- 1:49:04Act. I also want to thank Speaker
- 1:49:07Johnson, Leader Scalise, Whip Hoyer and
- 1:49:09their teams
- 1:49:10for their commitment to getting this
- 1:49:11common-sense bill to the floor. I also
- 1:49:14want to thank a handful of our
- 1:49:16colleagues who were at the front and
- 1:49:17center of this debate, including
- 1:49:20your colleague on this committee, Chip
- 1:49:21Roy, as well as Brian Fitzpatrick, Tim
- 1:49:24Burchett, Anna Paulina Luna, and others
- 1:49:26for their feedback and support
- 1:49:29throughout the process. Before the
- 1:49:31committee today is a Rules Committee
- 1:49:34print which combines the Stop Insider
- 1:49:37Trading Act with another common-sense
- 1:49:38measure the committee has advanced, the
- 1:49:41Voter ID Act. Together, these bills will
- 1:49:43clean up Congress and strengthen
- 1:49:45election integrity.
- 1:49:47I'll begin by discussing the second
- 1:49:49section first, which addresses lawmaker
- 1:49:52stock trading.
- 1:49:53This section ensures that lawmakers
- 1:49:56cannot use their position to profit off
- 1:49:59insider information they may garner
- 1:50:01while serving in Congress. Under the
- 1:50:03bill, members of Congress, their
- 1:50:04spouses, their dependent children are
- 1:50:06prohibited from purchasing securities
- 1:50:09issued by publicly traded companies. To
- 1:50:12sell a stock, members are required to
- 1:50:14provide advanced public disclosure at
- 1:50:16least 7 days in advance to the clerk of
- 1:50:18the house or the secretary of the
- 1:50:20Senate. The penalties associated with
- 1:50:23violations are steep. Members will be
- 1:50:25assessed a fine equal to $2,000 or 10%
- 1:50:28of the value of the transaction,
- 1:50:30whichever's greater. In addition,
- 1:50:32violators must forfeit any realized
- 1:50:34gains from a profitable sale.
- 1:50:37Legislation I believe is critical to
- 1:50:38restoring public trust in this
- 1:50:39institution.
- 1:50:41Nearly 15 years ago, Congress passed the
- 1:50:43STOCK Act, which required lawmakers to
- 1:50:45publicly disclose
- 1:50:46stock trades.
- 1:50:48However, the disclosure rules lack
- 1:50:49detail and can be fill filed a month
- 1:50:53after the transaction. This, coupled
- 1:50:56with increased attention to members'
- 1:50:58trades and particular by social media
- 1:50:59accounts, has fueled public frustration.
- 1:51:03I believe it's time we just stop
- 1:51:04allowing members to buy new stock. Doing
- 1:51:06so removes the appearance of impropriety
- 1:51:09altogether. Americans should be
- 1:51:10confident that lawmakers are working for
- 1:51:12them, not for their stock portfolios.
- 1:51:15Someone wants to go trade stocks for a
- 1:51:16living, there's a place to do that, it's
- 1:51:17called Wall Street. If you're here in
- 1:51:18Washington, you should be working on
- 1:51:19behalf of the American people. The
- 1:51:21reforms in the Stop Insider Trading Act
- 1:51:23are common sense, and I think that's
- 1:51:25actually why they're so overwhelmingly
- 1:51:26popular. Now, let me turn to the third
- 1:51:28section of the bill, uh the voter ID
- 1:51:30section. Uh Madam Chair, you may have
- 1:51:32seen uh the big news over the weekend.
- 1:51:34Uh the never-ending pasta bowl is back
- 1:51:37at Olive Garden. I used to work at Olive
- 1:51:39Garden, so this hit close to home. Uh
- 1:51:42but to safeguard the integrity of their
- 1:51:43pasta program, Olive Garden, as you may
- 1:51:45have seen, implemented photo ID
- 1:51:48requirements. However, in jurisdictions
- 1:51:50across the country, from Illinois and
- 1:51:52California and Minnesota, an individual
- 1:51:54can go to the polls on election day and
- 1:51:56cast a ballot without providing
- 1:51:57confirmation
- 1:51:59without providing confirmation of their
- 1:52:00identity. In other words, Madam Chair,
- 1:52:03we're protecting our breadsticks more
- 1:52:04than our ballots in jurisdictions across
- 1:52:06this country. Our voter ID Act
- 1:52:08implements common sense election
- 1:52:10integrity measures to require voters to
- 1:52:13show photo ID when casting a ballot in
- 1:52:16federal elections. This is another
- 1:52:18common sense policy, and again, I think
- 1:52:20that's why it's so popular with American
- 1:52:21people. 24 states require photo ID to
- 1:52:25vote. This bill makes the same that
- 1:52:27standard and takes it nationwide. Today,
- 1:52:30we have a real opportunity to clean up
- 1:52:32Washington and increase Americans'
- 1:52:34confidence in our election. I encourage
- 1:52:37all committee members to support this
- 1:52:38legislation. I look forward to your
- 1:52:40questions. I yield back.
- 1:52:41>> Thank you, Chairman Steil. Ranking
- 1:52:44Member McGovern, you're recognized.
- 1:52:46>> Thank you very much, uh Madam Chair, to
- 1:52:49you and to Ranking Member McGovern and
- 1:52:51to all my
- 1:52:53uh esteemed colleagues. It's always nice
- 1:52:54to be back in the Rules Committee, so
- 1:52:55thanks for the opportunity to uh to be
- 1:52:58here and address
- 1:52:59>> And former member of the committee.
- 1:53:01>> Yes, I Yes, I'm sorry. Yes, of course,
- 1:53:03and most importantly. Um
- 1:53:06Madam Chair, as I've said repeatedly,
- 1:53:07House Democrats strongly support a stock
- 1:53:10trading ban for members of Congress.
- 1:53:12We also support a ban on the president,
- 1:53:15the vice president, and federal judicial
- 1:53:17officers from trading individual stock
- 1:53:20as well. But none of that is before us
- 1:53:23today. Rather, this bill is a crude
- 1:53:25combination of two completely unrelated
- 1:53:27bills. The so-called Stop Insider
- 1:53:29Trading Act and the Voter ID Act, the
- 1:53:32latter of which is already a crude
- 1:53:35reformulation of at least three other
- 1:53:38failed Republican voter suppression
- 1:53:40proposals.
- 1:53:41If Republicans were serious about ending
- 1:53:43stock trading by government officials,
- 1:53:46they would not have attached a
- 1:53:47subsection of the Save America Act as a
- 1:53:50poison pill.
- 1:53:52And if Republicans were serious about
- 1:53:53protecting elections, they would not
- 1:53:55have gutted CISA's election security
- 1:53:58unit. They would actually fund the work
- 1:54:01of election workers across the country
- 1:54:03instead of indulging the president's
- 1:54:06almost childlike obsession with the 2020
- 1:54:09election.
- 1:54:10Instead, they echo his criticisms of
- 1:54:12state and local election administrators,
- 1:54:14both Republicans and Democrats, who
- 1:54:16patriotically and without favor
- 1:54:18do the unglamorous work of securing our
- 1:54:20democracy.
- 1:54:22Turning to the bill before us, I'll
- 1:54:23address both measures individually.
- 1:54:25Neither of them deserves passage.
- 1:54:28First, the so-called Stop Insider
- 1:54:29Trading Act. This bill would, in fact,
- 1:54:32allow members of Congress to continue to
- 1:54:34own and trade individual stocks.
- 1:54:37The bill will let members of Congress
- 1:54:38keep every single share of stock they
- 1:54:40currently own.
- 1:54:41The bill would allow members to
- 1:54:43liquidate their holdings at any time,
- 1:54:45profiting off years of ballooning
- 1:54:47investment portfolios. There is no
- 1:54:49divestiture required under this bill.
- 1:54:51And crucially, the bill does nothing to
- 1:54:54rein in the unprecedented, absurd, and
- 1:54:57deeply offensive corruption currently
- 1:54:59taking place in the White House. Donald
- 1:55:01Trump promised a booming economy and no
- 1:55:04new wars. Instead, he's enriched himself
- 1:55:06by billions and billions of dollars
- 1:55:08picking winners and losers in the stock
- 1:55:10market while pocketing the profits.
- 1:55:13I welcome any chance for us to consider
- 1:55:15legislation to end insider trading in
- 1:55:18Washington, including at the White
- 1:55:20House. But again, that is not what this
- 1:55:22bill does. So, we'll have to wait even
- 1:55:24longer for real progress. And when House
- 1:55:26Democrats regain gavels in November
- 1:55:28after this bill inevitably and
- 1:55:30justifiably fails to become law, and we
- 1:55:33finally ban stock trading by Congress,
- 1:55:35by the president, and by the Supreme
- 1:55:37Court. Now, to address the second, fully
- 1:55:39distinct part of this bill, the Voter ID
- 1:55:41Act.
- 1:55:43I have to have to say, in the words
- 1:55:45supposedly of Yogi Berra, this feels
- 1:55:47like déjà vu all over again. We will all
- 1:55:50remember the long list of failures.
- 1:55:52Republicans attempted to pass the SAVE
- 1:55:54Act. Then the SAVE Act part two once
- 1:55:57again. Then the SAVE America Act. And
- 1:55:59now the Voter ID Act. All these bills
- 1:56:02have the same purposes and the same
- 1:56:03origins. They aim to eviscerate mail
- 1:56:06voting, needlessly burden millions of
- 1:56:09eligible American voters, and further
- 1:56:11President Trump's obsession with
- 1:56:13undermining our elections in aid of
- 1:56:15Republican Party priorities and
- 1:56:18Republican politicians. Not to further
- 1:56:20the aims of this republic, not to assist
- 1:56:23our democracy, but to do this in a
- 1:56:24partisan way.
- 1:56:26The show-your-papers regimen and regime
- 1:56:29passed and proposed in this latest
- 1:56:31iteration would be more restrictive than
- 1:56:34any in the country
- 1:56:36currently in use anywhere, including
- 1:56:38states like Texas and Florida, those
- 1:56:41liberal bastions of voting rights. In
- 1:56:43fact, several Republican officials have
- 1:56:45appropriately criticized provisions of
- 1:56:47this bill as burdensome and potentially
- 1:56:49illegal.
- 1:56:50Republican Ohio Governor DeWine
- 1:56:53recently vetoed an anti-vote-by-mail
- 1:56:56bill almost identical to this one noting
- 1:57:00its restrictions would quote would not
- 1:57:02discourage fraud would not add any real
- 1:57:04security and would create an additional
- 1:57:07and significant burden for Ohioans to
- 1:57:09vote by mail. As I've said before, I
- 1:57:12support voter identification but despite
- 1:57:15its name the voter ID act is not a voter
- 1:57:17identification bill. It's a voter
- 1:57:19suppression act and I might just say and
- 1:57:23my dear friend and colleague who I often
- 1:57:25agree with
- 1:57:27chairman style but equating an endless
- 1:57:29pasta bowl at a chain Italian restaurant
- 1:57:32with the fundamental constitutional
- 1:57:34right to vote I think indicates how
- 1:57:36seriously we're taking this matter. In
- 1:57:38our markup committee Democrats offered a
- 1:57:40reasonable voter identification
- 1:57:42provision as an amendment to this bill
- 1:57:45and to show good faith we even retained
- 1:57:47a grant making provision in the original
- 1:57:50text. Not only did Republicans reject
- 1:57:52our amendment but they stripped out the
- 1:57:54grant making provision in advance of
- 1:57:55today's rule. That's right. Republicans
- 1:57:58remove the only slightly redeemable
- 1:58:01quality of this otherwise very bad bill.
- 1:58:05Simultaneously in a different vehicle
- 1:58:07Republicans would instruct the committee
- 1:58:09on House Administration to increase the
- 1:58:11deficit by 10 billion dollars to impose
- 1:58:14save act restrictions that have died in
- 1:58:16the Senate. So I'll tell you this much.
- 1:58:18It's notable the majority has agreed to
- 1:58:2010 billion as a new baseline for federal
- 1:58:23support for election administrators. I'm
- 1:58:25going to remind people of that and I
- 1:58:27look forward to a more effective more
- 1:58:29secure secure use for that level of
- 1:58:31funding over the next year but in the
- 1:58:33face of these two destructive bills I
- 1:58:35would ask my colleagues to show some
- 1:58:36courage oppose these foolish measures
- 1:58:39and with that I thank you for the time
- 1:58:41and I'll yield back.
- 1:58:44>> Um
- 1:58:45thank you both
- 1:58:46for your comments. Um
- 1:58:50Chairman style
- 1:58:52um I did mention that the Olive Garden
- 1:58:56um, has now instituted a requirement um,
- 1:59:00for a vote for uh, ID in my opening
- 1:59:03remarks.
- 1:59:05Um,
- 1:59:06we our friends across the aisle
- 1:59:10want to sow division by claiming that
- 1:59:13voter ID requirements for voters
- 1:59:16suppress voting.
- 1:59:19The largest study on this question
- 1:59:21conducted by the non-partisan National
- 1:59:25Bureau of Economic Research which
- 1:59:27tracked 1.6
- 1:59:29billion data points over an 8-year
- 1:59:33period confirmed that voter ID laws have
- 1:59:37no statistically measurable negative
- 1:59:40impact on voter participation.
- 1:59:44>> Yeah, that that's correct. I think
- 1:59:45that's a really important point. Um,
- 1:59:49you need an ID to board an airplane,
- 1:59:52open a bank account. I I obviously make
- 1:59:55light heart of the uh, the Olive Garden
- 1:59:57uh, requiring photo ID. There's uh,
- 2:00:00events that our colleagues on the other
- 2:00:02side of the aisle host that require a
- 2:00:03photo
- 2:00:04ID to get in. Um, and so the notion that
- 2:00:09somehow photo identification uh, for
- 2:00:13voting
- 2:00:14uh, is a uh, is a barrier, it's actually
- 2:00:17the statist- the statistics just don't
- 2:00:20support that. If you look at my home
- 2:00:21state of Wisconsin, we have a recently
- 2:00:22robust uh, photo ID bill. I think
- 2:00:25there's room for improvement. This law
- 2:00:26does that. Uh, but we what we see is
- 2:00:29continued high voter participation and I
- 2:00:31encourage high voter participation. I
- 2:00:32think that's a good thing. Uh, I think
- 2:00:34actually what we will see by requiring
- 2:00:36photo identification
- 2:00:38uh, is people's confidence in our
- 2:00:39elections to increase. Uh, and this the
- 2:00:42statistics really show us when people
- 2:00:43have confidence in their elections are
- 2:00:44actually more likely to participate.
- 2:00:46There's a lot of data that came out of
- 2:00:47the state of Georgia after Georgia
- 2:00:48passed their state uh election integrity
- 2:00:50legislation.
- 2:00:52Um and so I'm actually of the belief
- 2:00:53that we will see uh voter participation
- 2:00:55increase.
- 2:00:57>> May I
- 2:01:00>> Mr. Morelli?
- 2:01:01>> Yeah, just respond to it. I
- 2:01:03I don't think that we face
- 2:01:06such profound differences in belief
- 2:01:08around voter
- 2:01:09ID requirements. My state doesn't have a
- 2:01:13photo ID. We do signature analysis as is
- 2:01:15done in many states. But let's just
- 2:01:17assume for a moment that we could get
- 2:01:19together and decide that we have a
- 2:01:21national standard. I I would say that
- 2:01:24for instance in North Carolina, I know
- 2:01:25you're well uh
- 2:01:27acquainted with it, you can uh register
- 2:01:30to vote and vote with a driver's license
- 2:01:33even if it's expired for a year or less,
- 2:01:35a public assistance program ID card, a
- 2:01:38student ID or staff ID from a list of
- 2:01:40over 7,000 institutions. Um
- 2:01:44that would not be the case under this.
- 2:01:45This would be a much more restrictive
- 2:01:48voter ID law that you attempt to pass
- 2:01:50than is in the state of North Carolina,
- 2:01:52in the state of South Carolina, in the
- 2:01:54state of Florida, in the state of Texas.
- 2:01:56As I said, places that have placed a
- 2:01:58premium on voter ID and support this,
- 2:02:00but you the bill before the House that
- 2:02:03you're considering today is far more
- 2:02:05restrictive and many of those IDs, those
- 2:02:07forms of ID, would no longer be allowed
- 2:02:09under federal law. I would urge you to
- 2:02:12take a look at that.
- 2:02:14>> I wasn't going to bring up North
- 2:02:15Carolina, but since you have brought up
- 2:02:17North Carolina, I would say to you
- 2:02:20that we passed the cons- we we passed a
- 2:02:23law in the state that Republicans passed
- 2:02:25a law in the state of North Carolina
- 2:02:27with no Democrat support to have um
- 2:02:31voter ID.
- 2:02:33That was challenged in court by a
- 2:02:35Democrat member of our
- 2:02:38our Supreme Court.
- 2:02:41Stopped that from going through till it
- 2:02:44was approved.
- 2:02:46We passed a constitutional amendment
- 2:02:49supported by 61%
- 2:02:51of the people in the state. That was
- 2:02:54challenged by Democrats.
- 2:02:56We then passed another law. We finally,
- 2:02:59after about 10 years of Democrats
- 2:03:03fighting us tooth and nail in North
- 2:03:07Carolina to keep from having a voter ID.
- 2:03:12All the people say to me all the time
- 2:03:14is, "Why do the Democrats
- 2:03:17fight voter ID?"
- 2:03:20Could it be that they want to cheat?
- 2:03:22People do not understand why. It's an
- 2:03:2580%
- 2:03:27I believe 82%
- 2:03:29approval rating that we have ID to vote.
- 2:03:33It is an extraordinarily popular idea.
- 2:03:37It took us over 10 years in North
- 2:03:39Carolina to get it back over the
- 2:03:42objections of Democrats who who
- 2:03:45constantly didn't want it.
- 2:03:48>> I I think the I'm
- 2:03:50I'm sorry.
- 2:03:50>> I yield back. Mr. McGovern, you're
- 2:03:52recognized.
- 2:03:53>> Well, thank you. Uh
- 2:03:55Let me I I'll let the gentleman answer
- 2:03:57if he
- 2:03:59Well, yeah. The only thing I would say
- 2:04:00uh and I appreciate is that the question
- 2:04:03is
- 2:04:04first of all,
- 2:04:05voting is not a privilege. It's a right
- 2:04:07in America. And I know the president
- 2:04:09always refers to it as a privilege. It's
- 2:04:10not. Maybe drinking beer is a privilege.
- 2:04:13Maybe getting a bottomless bowl of pasta
- 2:04:15is a privilege. They're not rights. This
- 2:04:17is a right. All of the other rights flow
- 2:04:20from it. So, you want to make sure, I
- 2:04:23think, and I think many people would
- 2:04:24agree
- 2:04:25that as long as you're in a position to
- 2:04:27provide ID that proves who you are, why
- 2:04:30is it such a restrictive list? Why are
- 2:04:31student IDs no longer allowed? Virtually
- 2:04:34every state that has some form of photo
- 2:04:36ID that
- 2:04:37the state university to issue a student
- 2:04:38ID. This bill wouldn't allow it.
- 2:04:40>> Right, which is
- 2:04:42Well, let me let me just I again
- 2:04:44say for the record that voting is a
- 2:04:46constitutional right. It's not a lunch
- 2:04:48special.
- 2:04:49Uh you have a constitutional right to
- 2:04:51vote. You don't have a constitutional
- 2:04:53right to a breadstick or a bowl of
- 2:04:55pasta. Um and if your right to vote is
- 2:04:59denied, you have lost your voice in our
- 2:05:01government. So, I mean these these
- 2:05:03analogies are are just
- 2:05:04>> Are we done with
- 2:05:06>> Happy happy to yield to the gentleman.
- 2:05:08>> Thank you.
- 2:05:09Um we also have a right to bear arms,
- 2:05:11but we have to show
- 2:05:13>> an ID
- 2:05:14to buy a gun.
- 2:05:15>> Yeah. Well, I mean I again I
- 2:05:18we can argue that's a whole separate
- 2:05:20topic. Uh
- 2:05:21Well, Madam Madam Chair, it is a whole
- 2:05:23separate topic. No, have you have you
- 2:05:25said it? But I just want to say on the
- 2:05:26issue of voting rights and voting
- 2:05:28integrity, my Republican colleagues and
- 2:05:31this administration have absolutely no
- 2:05:33standing.
- 2:05:34I mean I I listened to this president's
- 2:05:36speech last week. It's 40 minutes of my
- 2:05:38life I'll never get back. It was crazy.
- 2:05:41It was insane. Um conspiracy theory
- 2:05:44after conspiracy theory and all of my
- 2:05:47Republican colleagues here just kind of
- 2:05:49went along to get along. Oh, whatever
- 2:05:50the president says, you know, I I get
- 2:05:53it. He can't stand the fact that he lost
- 2:05:55the 2020 election. I know his ego is
- 2:05:57fragile, but we're just going to let him
- 2:05:58say whatever he wants and let him create
- 2:06:01doubt
- 2:06:03um in the minds of the American people
- 2:06:05that somehow our elections are not safe.
- 2:06:07I actually read the garbage that he said
- 2:06:09he released. Uh the the the all the
- 2:06:12intelligence basically is saying that
- 2:06:15there's no evidence that there's been
- 2:06:17any kind of foreign interference or uh
- 2:06:19in our in our elections that the kind of
- 2:06:20the the the tool that foreign
- 2:06:22governments have is to try to create the
- 2:06:24impression that they may have um
- 2:06:26influenced our election as a way to
- 2:06:28discourage people from voting. Well, we
- 2:06:30don't have to worry about Russia or
- 2:06:32China or anybody else. Donald Trump's
- 2:06:34doing it all by himself. All because his
- 2:06:36ego can't stand the fact that he lost an
- 2:06:39election. And all my Republican friends
- 2:06:41are bending over backwards trying to do
- 2:06:43whatever they can to make it more
- 2:06:44difficult for people to vote. Chairman
- 2:06:46Steil, the introduced version of your
- 2:06:48voter ID bill included a grant program
- 2:06:51to help states provide eligible voters
- 2:06:54with free voter ID cards. Your committee
- 2:06:57reported a version of your bill that
- 2:06:59also included this grant program.
- 2:07:02The bill published on the Rules
- 2:07:04Committee website also included this
- 2:07:07grant program. Then, for some reason, a
- 2:07:10new version was published that deleted
- 2:07:12this grant program. Why?
- 2:07:14>> So, there's different ways that we want
- 2:07:16to make sure all individuals can receive
- 2:07:19a an ID under Supreme Court
- 2:07:21>> want to know why why why the grant
- 2:07:23program was deleted.
- 2:07:24>> I I was I was getting there if you'll
- 2:07:25give me the
- 2:07:26opportunity to to respond. Um
- 2:07:29there there are multiple ways we want to
- 2:07:31make sure that everyone can receive an
- 2:07:33ID. We're also going through a
- 2:07:35reconciliation process as you know this
- 2:07:36committee had a conversation I believe
- 2:07:38on that earlier
- 2:07:40today. There are funds now available in
- 2:07:42the committee on House Administration,
- 2:07:44something that we're looking at. But
- 2:07:46under the Supreme Court, everyone is
- 2:07:48allowed to get an ID if it is so
- 2:07:50determined that it's needed as it will
- 2:07:52be under this legislation
- 2:07:53>> But but you could have done it in this
- 2:07:54bill today.
- 2:07:55>> Yeah, there's different avenues of how
- 2:07:56we're looking at it.
- 2:07:57>> I guess I mean so without this grant
- 2:07:59program, if a state does not provide IDs
- 2:08:01for free, people without the specific
- 2:08:03forms of ID required by your bill will
- 2:08:06have to pay in order to simply vote.
- 2:08:08>> I don't know that
- 2:08:08>> And I guess the question is who who
- 2:08:10asked you I want to know like who asked
- 2:08:12you to delete this grant program?
- 2:08:14>> I I actually if I can comment, I don't
- 2:08:16think your previous statements actually
- 2:08:17accurate. I think if you as we look at
- 2:08:19the Supreme Court jurisprudence,
- 2:08:22if it is required, states will be
- 2:08:23required to provide the ID.
- 2:08:26The second question that you asked is
- 2:08:28we're looking at ways to make sure that
- 2:08:30the
- 2:08:32I've had broad conversations.
- 2:08:47There are broad conversations about how
- 2:08:49we how we ultimately have all of these
- 2:08:52pieces of the puzzle work. We're also
- 2:08:53working in real time on the
- 2:08:54reconciliation piece.
- 2:08:55>> But why?
- 2:08:57Why was it taken out? I'm just trying to
- 2:08:58understand why it was taken out. You had
- 2:09:00it in your original bill. It was in the
- 2:09:02bill that you reported out of your
- 2:09:03committee. It was in the
- 2:09:05bill published on the rules website. So
- 2:09:07like now it's not there and so I'm just
- 2:09:10trying to understand like why. There's
- 2:09:12got to be a reason why. Somebody asked
- 2:09:14you to do it. So I want I just want to
- 2:09:16know who asked you to take it out and I
- 2:09:18want to know why.
- 2:09:19>> We're always looking at ways to improve
- 2:09:20and finesse bills and this is a part of
- 2:09:21the part of a broader conversation.
- 2:09:24>> Can you give us like a name so we can
- 2:09:26follow up with somebody to find out like
- 2:09:28what what you know like why was it I
- 2:09:30mean
- 2:09:31Yeah, who's having this broader
- 2:09:33conversation?
- 2:09:34>> Republicans in the House of
- 2:09:35Representatives.
- 2:09:36>> Okay, so all right. So so you asked the
- 2:09:40I'm reading the your your letter that
- 2:09:42you sent to the Rules Committee.
- 2:09:44>> Mhm.
- 2:09:44>> And you're asking the Rules Committee
- 2:09:47for a closed rule on this bill. Meaning
- 2:09:49that you don't want any amendments to be
- 2:09:51even considered.
- 2:09:52Yet you got a chance to amend this bill
- 2:09:55at the last minute by taking out the
- 2:09:56grant program. Why do you think your
- 2:09:58colleagues don't deserve the same
- 2:09:59opportunity?
- 2:09:59>> Obviously that'll be a decision for you
- 2:10:01here at the Rules Committee as to
- 2:10:02whether or not amendments are allowed.
- 2:10:04>> Usually usually when we get a letter
- 2:10:06like this from a chair it it says that
- 2:10:08they asked the Rules Committee for an
- 2:10:09appropriate rule. You actually very a
- 2:10:12very specific saying that you request
- 2:10:15the committee grant a closed rule.
- 2:10:17>> I'm of the belief that the bill is ready
- 2:10:18to be brought to the floor and will
- 2:10:19pass.
- 2:10:20>> But I so but you again
- 2:10:22This
- 2:10:24was in the bill that you introduced that
- 2:10:27was reported out of your committee that
- 2:10:29was you know published on the Rules
- 2:10:31Committee website. You
- 2:10:34mysteriously gets taken out. You can't
- 2:10:36tell us who asked you to take it out or
- 2:10:38why it's taken out.
- 2:10:40And yet you asked you and you kind of
- 2:10:43do something that most chairs don't do.
- 2:10:45You know, who usually ask for an
- 2:10:46appropriate rule, you ask for a closed
- 2:10:47rule. I guess so that nobody could try
- 2:10:50to put it back in or to amend this in
- 2:10:52any other way. I would just I just don't
- 2:10:54understand why your colleagues don't
- 2:10:56deserve the same opportunity that you
- 2:10:58had to be able to remove something that
- 2:10:59again what made it through your
- 2:11:00committee.
- 2:11:02And and and I I got to tell you it just
- 2:11:04seems to me that this is just
- 2:11:06another example of all of you guys
- 2:11:08playing
- 2:11:09politics. And you know, and the reason
- 2:11:12why this matters is that these grants
- 2:11:15could have made it so that people
- 2:11:16without these ideas could get them. I
- 2:11:18mean that that was the whole point of
- 2:11:20this. And
- 2:11:22and I and and it's gone. And I and and I
- 2:11:25I so I again I
- 2:11:28I don't even know what the hell you guys
- 2:11:29are trying to do, but it's certainly not
- 2:11:31trying to preserve the integrity of
- 2:11:32elections or to get more people to vote.
- 2:11:35You're trying to make it so that people
- 2:11:37will be frustrated and can't vote.
- 2:11:39And again, I think that goes against
- 2:11:41what this country is about.
- 2:11:43Mr. Morelle, you've submitted a
- 2:11:44substitute amendment to this
- 2:11:45legislation. Can you explain your
- 2:11:47amendment to us and what
- 2:11:49advantages it has over Mr. Styles' bill?
- 2:11:52>> Yes, so there's actually because there's
- 2:11:54multiple pieces of
- 2:11:56uh
- 2:11:58of the bill that we would make better,
- 2:12:00but I I also just to your earlier point
- 2:12:04about amendments, we would make
- 2:12:07amendments and I would like to see an
- 2:12:08amendment that um
- 2:12:10the previous the the that we revert to
- 2:12:12at least the portion of the bill that
- 2:12:14had the grant making. So, my amendment
- 2:12:15would restore the grants. I think it was
- 2:12:17the only redeemable part of this bill
- 2:12:21would be to give resources to local
- 2:12:23uh election administrators. They're
- 2:12:25doing hard work. They're doing it
- 2:12:26without uh support from the federal
- 2:12:28government. And now this bill takes away
- 2:12:31what I consider the only redeemable part
- 2:12:34of the bill. They need support. Uh they
- 2:12:37need support whether or not we add all
- 2:12:38these additional uh requirements on them
- 2:12:40or not. Um
- 2:12:43but at least it uh it would uh make the
- 2:12:46bill better. I mean, it's a bad bill,
- 2:12:48but it would make it better to be able
- 2:12:49to provide some resources. And you know,
- 2:12:53the other the the thing that we should
- 2:12:55note is that would be they would be
- 2:12:56administered by the elections
- 2:12:59um
- 2:12:59um advisory commission and the EAC or
- 2:13:02the Elections Assistance Commission
- 2:13:04Commission. And the EAC provides
- 2:13:07resources and support for local
- 2:13:10state and local election administrators.
- 2:13:12The whole point and the president is now
- 2:13:14fired. So there are no members of the
- 2:13:16commission at all. Fired all the
- 2:13:18remaining ones. So the the commissioners
- 2:13:21don't exist. The professional staff
- 2:13:22does. They can continue to do grant
- 2:13:24making, but I think it says
- 2:13:26um worlds about how the president views
- 2:13:29this. He continues to try to take
- 2:13:31guardrails off of the election system so
- 2:13:34that people will lose confidence. And I
- 2:13:36appreciate your comments about the
- 2:13:37president's speech the other night. I
- 2:13:39mean, the president's the one who took
- 2:13:41apart and and eliminated the election
- 2:13:44security unit of CISA. And then he talks
- 2:13:46about the challenges uh facing uh our
- 2:13:49local administrators and
- 2:13:50vulnerabilities. Well, you're the one
- 2:13:52who's making it worse, not better. So
- 2:13:54the grants would be one. Uh and then we
- 2:13:57have additional amendments as it relates
- 2:13:59to
- 2:14:00um the um
- 2:14:01uh the the um
- 2:14:03the um
- 2:14:04program that relates to the
- 2:14:06the um other part of the bill that
- 2:14:08that's entirely which as it relates to
- 2:14:10stock trading.
- 2:14:11>> I'm just surprised that you know, his
- 2:14:13request were totally closed rule, not an
- 2:14:15appropriate rule. So, clearly some
- 2:14:18>> Well, it may also have to do, if I
- 2:14:19might, it also may have to do with
- 2:14:20amendments that could come from forward
- 2:14:22by other members that mirror the voter
- 2:14:24ID requirements in the various states.
- 2:14:26In some states, you can use concealed
- 2:14:28weapons permits. You can almost always
- 2:14:30use student IDs. If you're trying to
- 2:14:32control who can vote, you have to make
- 2:14:34sure that there's no amendments because
- 2:14:35they might actually pass.
- 2:14:37>> And just going back to the Olive Garden
- 2:14:38possible example, uh my understanding
- 2:14:41that that's you got to put down, in
- 2:14:42addition to an ID, $100.
- 2:14:45Um so, I I I hope what we're not trying
- 2:14:47to do here is kind of institute another
- 2:14:49poll tax.
- 2:14:50Um yeah, actually make it uh
- 2:14:53costly for people to vote. And again, I
- 2:14:55I I you know, I asked the question about
- 2:14:57the grant program. Again, it was in the
- 2:14:59bill that you introduced, it was in the
- 2:15:00bill that you reported out of committee,
- 2:15:02it was in the it was the bill published
- 2:15:03in the in the rules website. And can't
- 2:15:06get an answer why it was removed. Can't
- 2:15:07get an answer who actually
- 2:15:09asked you to remove but I I guess with
- 2:15:11there's some backroom deal going on in
- 2:15:12some backroom in the capital here trying
- 2:15:15to figure out how to how to make it more
- 2:15:16difficult for people to vote.
- 2:15:18You know, but I mean cuz because I we we
- 2:15:21have not yet to hear a good reason why
- 2:15:23it was taken out of this bill. Uh but I
- 2:15:26mean, this is not the way you should be
- 2:15:29legislating, you know, on elections or
- 2:15:32protecting people's right to vote or on
- 2:15:34any of this stuff. I mean, this is just
- 2:15:36not the way you should do it.
- 2:15:37>> Ma'am, if I might just make one other
- 2:15:39additional point, I this bill is not
- 2:15:41going to pass the Senate. I think
- 2:15:43everyone in this room, anybody who's in
- 2:15:45the capital knows that. But you could
- 2:15:47have you could find yourself in a
- 2:15:48position, let's say this did pass,
- 2:15:50president signed it, but the
- 2:15:51reconciliation didn't happen, which is
- 2:15:53also highly dubious. You could end up
- 2:15:55having this bill with no money in it.
- 2:15:58So, efforts to provide people with free
- 2:16:00voter ID, any of that would be without
- 2:16:02any resources to be able to carry out.
- 2:16:04>> how that money in the reconciliation
- 2:16:05bill, if it would ever pass would be
- 2:16:07used.
- 2:16:08I mean, yeah, I mean
- 2:16:10this is scary.
- 2:16:12Um and and this should not be a partisan
- 2:16:13issue.
- 2:16:14Um and not just Democrats, but
- 2:16:16Republicans in this chamber who give a
- 2:16:18damn about integrity in elections ought
- 2:16:21to be outraged by what's going on. With
- 2:16:23that, I yield back.
- 2:16:25>> Chairman yields back. Now recognize the
- 2:16:27gentleman from Georgia, Mr.
- 2:16:29>> Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm just
- 2:16:30listening to how ridiculous their
- 2:16:31argument is ever not
- 2:16:33showing a photo ID. Yeah, I literally
- 2:16:35showed a photo ID to buy Sudafed over
- 2:16:37the last couple of weeks and they
- 2:16:38actually scanned the back of the ID to
- 2:16:40make sure that you can buy it. I also
- 2:16:42showed an ID to pick up uh some
- 2:16:44prescriptions for another family of mine
- 2:16:47member of mine the other day. And you
- 2:16:48know what?
- 2:16:49The people who were working behind the
- 2:16:51counter knew exactly who I was because
- 2:16:53we've
- 2:16:54been doing business there for a long
- 2:16:56long time.
- 2:16:57Although with PBMs conducting themselves
- 2:16:59the way that they do, not sure how much
- 2:17:01longer those independent pharmacies are
- 2:17:02able to survive. That's a different
- 2:17:03issue though.
- 2:17:05Um but I want to get to uh the stock
- 2:17:09issue.
- 2:17:10You know,
- 2:17:11Chairman Sarbanes, you and I have had
- 2:17:12this discussion before. As you know, I
- 2:17:16uh
- 2:17:18I had my Series 7 before I got here. I I
- 2:17:21I look at the bill. I I'm going to vote
- 2:17:23for the bill. I want to I want to bring
- 2:17:26up a couple of things though that I I
- 2:17:28wish we could just do that I think would
- 2:17:30solve a lot of the problems. And you and
- 2:17:34I have had this discussion. I appreciate
- 2:17:35your time with that. I think I think the
- 2:17:37issue that leads to the confusion
- 2:17:40is the range
- 2:17:43on the trade.
- 2:17:45So, when you go and we fill out our
- 2:17:46disclosures, you have a range of 1,001
- 2:17:48to 15,000, 15,001 to 50,000, 50,001 to
- 2:17:52100,000, 100,001 to 250, 250 to 500. And
- 2:17:56it goes all the way up 5 million to 25
- 2:17:59million.
- 2:18:00Um and you know, sometimes when things
- 2:18:03get reported in blogs, if you will,
- 2:18:07just say you paid $14,000 for a stock
- 2:18:10that falls in the 1 to 15,000 range, and
- 2:18:13if you sold it for 16,000, it falls in
- 2:18:15the 15 to 50. And so, sometimes when
- 2:18:18they do their calculation, they'll say
- 2:18:19paid as little as $1,000 and sold it for
- 2:18:22as much as $50,000, and it certainly uh
- 2:18:26gives the perception,
- 2:18:28if that's happening on a regular basis,
- 2:18:30that there is tremendous amounts of
- 2:18:31insider trading going on
- 2:18:33uh in the halls of Congress. Now, let me
- 2:18:35be clear about this. There There is at
- 2:18:36least one member of Congress that has
- 2:18:37been prosecuted for insider trading. Is
- 2:18:39that correct?
- 2:18:41>> Yes.
- 2:18:42>> And uh
- 2:18:43but if you if you if you look at this
- 2:18:45form, you can also go down, and you can
- 2:18:47click other exact amount.
- 2:18:50And I just really think if members, and
- 2:18:53I I don't have much stock. I have less
- 2:18:56than 10,000 left, I think. Uh
- 2:18:59but
- 2:19:00you know,
- 2:19:01I really think if we simply put
- 2:19:05the number of shares that were purchased
- 2:19:07and the price that it was purchased at,
- 2:19:10or the number of shares that were sold
- 2:19:11and the price that was sold at, it would
- 2:19:13eliminate
- 2:19:15a lot of the
- 2:19:17accusations.
- 2:19:19And just wondering if that was
- 2:19:20discussed. That's not a part of the
- 2:19:22bill, but
- 2:19:24um
- 2:19:25I've actually started doing that. When I
- 2:19:26do sell something, sold X at this
- 2:19:28particular share value.
- 2:19:30Um
- 2:19:31any thoughts on that?
- 2:19:33>> You You bring up a great point. When
- 2:19:35Congress passed the STOCK Act 15 years
- 2:19:37ago,
- 2:19:38uh it was largely a disclosure regime,
- 2:19:40and you correctly note that it gave
- 2:19:42large bands in which
- 2:19:45um those reports would be made
- 2:19:46available.
- 2:19:47Um
- 2:19:48if an individual wants to try to make a
- 2:19:50persuasion off of returns on any of
- 2:19:52those given reports, especially
- 2:19:54uh under the uh the the rules of social
- 2:19:56media, if you will, uh one can one can
- 2:19:59sometimes tell a story that's
- 2:20:00inaccurate. I think that's a broader
- 2:20:02challenge with how the reporting regime
- 2:20:04under the STOCK Act operates. This bill
- 2:20:07before us today
- 2:20:09uh is a little bit more laser-focused in
- 2:20:10the aspect of insider trading. As you
- 2:20:13correctly noted, a member of Congress
- 2:20:14will was held accountable for insider
- 2:20:16trading. Insider trading is already
- 2:20:18illegal uh and should be prosecuted to
- 2:20:20the fullest extent of the law. I think
- 2:20:22one of the challenges we see is
- 2:20:23prosecuting insider trading is actually
- 2:20:25really difficult. Uh and so, due to the
- 2:20:29scrutiny that's been placed on buying
- 2:20:32and selling individual shares of stock,
- 2:20:34um I think there's an opportunity to
- 2:20:35simply put in place a bright-line rule
- 2:20:37that prevents members of Congress from
- 2:20:38doing that. And in so doing, uh removing
- 2:20:42even the appearance of impropriety that
- 2:20:44an individual uh was engaged in a trade
- 2:20:46based on insider information.
- 2:20:47>> So, we're saying that you can't buy
- 2:20:49stock.
- 2:20:50>> Individual shares of stock upon upon
- 2:20:53being elected to Congress. That's
- 2:20:54accurate.
- 2:20:55>> So, I want to you know, a lot of us have
- 2:20:56spouses that work. And I want to you
- 2:20:59know,
- 2:20:59if you work for
- 2:21:01uh
- 2:21:02companies a lot of times the company
- 2:21:04401K
- 2:21:05match may be done in stock in that
- 2:21:08company. This bill doesn't prohibit
- 2:21:11the working spouse from
- 2:21:13401K matches or other things along those
- 2:21:16lines
- 2:21:18from from
- 2:21:20continuing to work at that employer.
- 2:21:22Does it?
- 2:21:23>> Great question. So, the the spouse of a
- 2:21:26member as well as dependent children are
- 2:21:28restricted under this as relates to
- 2:21:30buying and selling shares. The exception
- 2:21:32that you correctly note is what we call
- 2:21:34the spousal exception. So, if that
- 2:21:36income is earned in the ordinary course,
- 2:21:38um that is allowed. So, if your if your
- 2:21:41spouse works uh for Coca-Cola
- 2:21:44uh and they give 1,000 shares of stock
- 2:21:45to every every employee at that pay
- 2:21:47grade, um your spouse would be able to
- 2:21:49earn that. And again, that goes back to
- 2:21:51the core concept here. The The focus on
- 2:21:53this uh is not to prevent ownership of
- 2:21:56private assets.
- 2:21:57>> Sure.
- 2:21:58>> on this is to prevent an individual
- 2:22:00member from profiting off of inside
- 2:22:01information. So, if it's through the
- 2:22:03ordinary course of their business,
- 2:22:04almost by definition, your spouse is not
- 2:22:06engaged in
- 2:22:08a a trade based on inside information
- 2:22:10garnered from the the member's inside
- 2:22:14information.
- 2:22:15>> And if your If your grandparent started
- 2:22:17a company that then got bought and
- 2:22:19bought again and ended up
- 2:22:21with shares of a company, you're not
- 2:22:23forced to liquidate them. You just can't
- 2:22:25buy more shares, correct?
- 2:22:26>> That would be accurate.
- 2:22:27>> Okay. And those shares are also
- 2:22:29disclosed on your financial disclosure,
- 2:22:31so people could see if you
- 2:22:32>> They would be.
- 2:22:33>> Um
- 2:22:34Okay. So,
- 2:22:36one
- 2:22:38one of the other areas that I do have
- 2:22:40concerns about and I have
- 2:22:43I'd like to submit for the record
- 2:22:44actually a Wall Street Journal article
- 2:22:46and if it wasn't the Wall Street
- 2:22:47Journal, I wouldn't um
- 2:22:50pay much attention to it.
- 2:22:53Um I shouldn't say that, I guess.
- 2:22:55But it's probably true. There's not much
- 2:22:57journalism anymore
- 2:22:58uh out there. But the new Washington
- 2:23:01temptation, inside information
- 2:23:04and a prediction market account.
- 2:23:06Do Are we doing anything to and Mr.
- 2:23:09Chairman, I'd like to submit for the
- 2:23:10record that Wall Street Journal article.
- 2:23:12Just as we're having this discussion,
- 2:23:14are we doing anything
- 2:23:15>> the date on that again?
- 2:23:18>> I'll have to expand it with my eyes like
- 2:23:21they are.
- 2:23:22July the 16th.
- 2:23:23>> All right. Without objection, so
- 2:23:25ordered.
- 2:23:26>> Are we addressing the polymarket issue?
- 2:23:29>> Uh in the Committee on House
- 2:23:30Administration, uh which um
- 2:23:35Member Morgan Griffith, your your the
- 2:23:37the name tag is is off right now. So, I
- 2:23:38as I looked right up there, you're not
- 2:23:40Miss
- 2:23:41Chairwoman Fox.
- 2:23:42Uh Morgan Griffith
- 2:23:43joins us on the Committee on House
- 2:23:45Administration. We have a separate piece
- 2:23:47of legislation
- 2:23:48addressing that, not included in this
- 2:23:50bill before us today, but I think it's
- 2:23:52one absolutely worthy of our efforts.
- 2:23:54>> I absolutely believe that there's
- 2:23:55probably more potential for abuse there
- 2:23:57than there is even even in this with
- 2:23:58proper disclosure. We had we had a
- 2:24:00member a couple of years ago
- 2:24:02um
- 2:24:03that
- 2:24:06when their spouse was going before
- 2:24:08Senate confirmation
- 2:24:10it was revealed that uh there had been a
- 2:24:14a fairly significant trade that had not
- 2:24:16been reported. Do you remember what I'm
- 2:24:18talking about? I'm not going to call the
- 2:24:19member, but
- 2:24:20>> I I don't know that I I recall that, but
- 2:24:22I could envision that occurring.
- 2:24:24>> So, there was there was a member of the
- 2:24:25House who was going through the
- 2:24:27confirmation process and
- 2:24:29then they went through an audit
- 2:24:32because of the Senate confirmation
- 2:24:33process and in that comparison they
- 2:24:35found
- 2:24:36a trade that had not been disclosed.
- 2:24:39Um
- 2:24:42I I I guess one of my frustrations with
- 2:24:44this and I and again, I support the
- 2:24:45legislation. I think the ban on buying
- 2:24:47is is the is the right way to go with
- 2:24:49the solution.
- 2:24:50But I guess one of my frustrations with
- 2:24:52this and I had another member and they
- 2:24:53were being very critical of a Republican
- 2:24:55who had bought a bunch of stocks. I'm
- 2:24:56like, well, how do you know they bought
- 2:24:57the stocks?
- 2:25:00Because they filled out the disclosure.
- 2:25:03You know, the ones who don't fill out
- 2:25:04the disclosure are actually the ones
- 2:25:06that you probably
- 2:25:07if if if they're out there
- 2:25:09the ones that you need to be more
- 2:25:10worried about. Is that a
- 2:25:12would that be a reasonable statement?
- 2:25:15>> It It's It's a great question cuz in a
- 2:25:17lot of these broader ethics regimes it's
- 2:25:19either a disclosure regime or a
- 2:25:21prohibition regime and the Stock Act
- 2:25:24passed 15 years ago was broadly a
- 2:25:26disclosure regime, which then brings to
- 2:25:28light the concern.
- 2:25:30This bill before us today, the Stop
- 2:25:32Insider Trading Act, has a specific
- 2:25:34prohibition, which simply removes the
- 2:25:37the
- 2:25:39even the appearance of inappropriate
- 2:25:40action.
- 2:25:41>> This this bill is is I believe it's well
- 2:25:43thought and a big step in the right
- 2:25:45direction. Uh
- 2:25:47it the ban is limited purchasing
- 2:25:49individual stocks from publicly traded
- 2:25:51companies. I do worry about private
- 2:25:53placements and um the potential
- 2:25:57with private placements and think that's
- 2:25:58something we probably need to address in
- 2:26:00the future, but I I appreciate your work
- 2:26:02on this. I look forward to supporting it
- 2:26:03and I think it's a broad broad step in
- 2:26:05the right direction.
- 2:26:08>> Gentlemen, your time is back now. I
- 2:26:09recognize the gentle lady from
- 2:26:11Pennsylvania, Ms. Scanlon, for her time.
- 2:26:13>> Thank you. Um I I think we are way past
- 2:26:17the time where we need to be dealing
- 2:26:19with the fact that
- 2:26:21uh the public is broadly mistrustful of
- 2:26:24members of Congress or the president or
- 2:26:27the vice president dealing in the stock
- 2:26:29market because it has not just provided
- 2:26:32the appearance of impropriety or the
- 2:26:35appearance of using
- 2:26:37um
- 2:26:38government information for personal
- 2:26:40profit, but we've seen it actually
- 2:26:43occurring in real time and on an
- 2:26:45increasing basis, particularly with the
- 2:26:47White House. I mean, it's interesting
- 2:26:49that our colleagues mentioned that there
- 2:26:51actually was a member of Congress who
- 2:26:53was prosecuted for insider trading, uh
- 2:26:56Republican member, but even after the
- 2:26:59courts held him accountable, he was
- 2:27:00pardoned by this president. So, we're
- 2:27:03not seeing the kind of
- 2:27:05um serious attention to preventing this
- 2:27:09kind of essentially insider trading from
- 2:27:12from occurring, and the American people
- 2:27:14have had it. They are fed up with it.
- 2:27:16Congress needs to enact a comprehensive
- 2:27:19ban on members of Congress as well as
- 2:27:22the president, the vice president, and
- 2:27:25members of their families from owning or
- 2:27:27trading individual stocks or having
- 2:27:29other financial dealings, and I agree
- 2:27:31with Mr. Scott. I know he's leaving now,
- 2:27:33but I agree that we should also be
- 2:27:35dealing with this with the prediction
- 2:27:37markets. But unfortunately, the bill
- 2:27:40that our colleagues are putting on the
- 2:27:42floor uh this week doesn't do any of
- 2:27:44that. The bill only
- 2:27:47prohibits members of Congress from
- 2:27:48purchasing additional stocks. Now, I
- 2:27:52have never traded stocks myself, but
- 2:27:54it's my understanding that the way you
- 2:27:55make money is when you sell the stocks.
- 2:27:58And this bill does not uh
- 2:28:01prohibit them from selling the stocks,
- 2:28:03and that's where the profit is made. Um
- 2:28:05and the public notice requirement in
- 2:28:07this bill is so weak, it wouldn't
- 2:28:10prevent the kinds of transactions that
- 2:28:11have already eroded public trust. Things
- 2:28:14like a lawmaker unloading healthcare
- 2:28:17stocks that then promptly lost value
- 2:28:21after he voted in the big ugly bill last
- 2:28:23summer to uh
- 2:28:25to cut Medicare funding by billions and
- 2:28:28billions of dollars. If our Republican
- 2:28:30colleagues are serious about government
- 2:28:32accountability, we would have on the
- 2:28:34floor this week Ranking Member Morelle's
- 2:28:36Resolve Restore Trust in Government Act,
- 2:28:40which establishes a comprehensive ban on
- 2:28:42stock ownership and trading for members
- 2:28:45of Congress, the president, and the vice
- 2:28:47president. Or as a backup, have the
- 2:28:50Restore Trust in Congress Act co-led by
- 2:28:53our Rules colleague uh Congressman Chip
- 2:28:56Roy, which at least would
- 2:28:57comprehensively prohibit members of
- 2:29:00Congress, if not the president and vice
- 2:29:03president, from owning and trading
- 2:29:05individual stocks. Uh instead, after 18
- 2:29:08months of unprecedented self-dealing and
- 2:29:12personal enrichment by members of the
- 2:29:14Trump administration, Republicans are
- 2:29:16choosing to ignore the most significant
- 2:29:18conflicts of interest in government
- 2:29:20while advancing legislation that barely
- 2:29:23scratches the surface. And if that
- 2:29:25weren't enough, they've combined this
- 2:29:27with this completely unrelated voter ID
- 2:29:31bill, which doesn't actually deal with
- 2:29:34any actual voter fraud but instead
- 2:29:37suppresses votes. So, we got to get this
- 2:29:38straight. Republicans are refusing to
- 2:29:41address this problem that actually
- 2:29:43exists. The president, his family, and
- 2:29:45some members of Congress getting rich
- 2:29:48off stocks whose value changes based on
- 2:29:50official government action but instead
- 2:29:53they're pushing the Save Act. A bill
- 2:29:55that would prevent hundreds of thousands
- 2:29:58of American citizens from voting in
- 2:30:00order to satisfy the president's
- 2:30:02obsession about fictitious non-citizen
- 2:30:06voting. So, the corruption is coming
- 2:30:09from inside the house but it's the White
- 2:30:10House and that's where our attention
- 2:30:12should be.
- 2:30:14Rep. Morelle, can you talk about why the
- 2:30:17requirements in the STOCK bill that
- 2:30:19Republicans have put forward um is so
- 2:30:22inadequate particularly
- 2:30:25um when it allows them to continue to
- 2:30:26own and sell stocks?
- 2:30:30>> Yeah, thanks and I think you did a great
- 2:30:31job of summarizing. I mean, there's
- 2:30:33several problems with this bill. First
- 2:30:35of all, it does not require divestiture.
- 2:30:37You can still own stocks. You can sell
- 2:30:39them. You're not required to sell them
- 2:30:40at a particular time. So, you can wait
- 2:30:42until the appropriate time when it
- 2:30:44benefits you to sell the stock and it
- 2:30:46also allows you to buy additional stock
- 2:30:49of those companies that provide you with
- 2:30:50a dividend. So, if you get a dividend
- 2:30:52from SpaceX, you can buy more SpaceX
- 2:30:55stock. So, that's publicly traded.
- 2:30:58Second problem is it doesn't do anything
- 2:31:00with private sales or private stock. In
- 2:31:02fact, this isn't a hypothetical. Members
- 2:31:04of the House are trading in private
- 2:31:06stock making massive profits from stocks
- 2:31:09in privately traded companies with
- 2:31:11federal contracts. It's happened. It's
- 2:31:14been highlighted. It's been It's been
- 2:31:16detailed. Um
- 2:31:17and in those cases some cases, they've
- 2:31:19done it with a company that was then
- 2:31:21purchased by SpaceX, a publicly traded
- 2:31:24company. So, you can make a lot of money
- 2:31:26still. So, you don't have to divest
- 2:31:27public stocks. You can own private
- 2:31:29stocks and continue to trade in those.
- 2:31:31Does nothing to rein in the crypto
- 2:31:33market whatsoever. And we know the
- 2:31:34president and his family have made
- 2:31:36billions of dollars in the crypto space.
- 2:31:39The president also purchased Warner
- 2:31:41Brothers corporate bonds at a time when
- 2:31:44Warner Brothers in the middle of merger
- 2:31:46talks right now over which the
- 2:31:49president's FCC will ultimately be able
- 2:31:52to make decisions. The president also
- 2:31:53failed on thousands
- 2:31:56of of trades to acknowledge and disclose
- 2:31:59them within the time required under the
- 2:32:01law. In fact, the president trades stock
- 2:32:03more than all of the members of the
- 2:32:05house combined. The president of the
- 2:32:07United States, yet he's not even covered
- 2:32:08in this bill for reasons
- 2:32:10well, I don't even know for what
- 2:32:12reasons. I
- 2:32:13It is without realistic explanation why
- 2:32:16that would happen. And the other thing
- 2:32:18which I agree with Mr.
- 2:32:19Mr. Scott is
- 2:32:21the exclusion of the prediction markets
- 2:32:24is shocking. I mean, we see the abuses
- 2:32:28being reported every single day. You
- 2:32:31know, whether it's things about
- 2:32:33contracts or military strikes or some
- 2:32:36foolish things like when the White House
- 2:32:39press secretary is going to stop her
- 2:32:40press conferences to the minute and find
- 2:32:43that some people can trade on that. We
- 2:32:46we we know that it was reported over the
- 2:32:49weekend that Representative Luna shared
- 2:32:52with someone that J.D. Vance was going
- 2:32:54to be chosen as vice president cuz she
- 2:32:56had inside information and she passed it
- 2:32:58along to someone with the express
- 2:33:00purpose of putting down a
- 2:33:03a contract in the prediction markets
- 2:33:05over whether or not it would be J.D.
- 2:33:07Vance and that person profited
- 2:33:09handsomely from this. This is to to the
- 2:33:11point you made, if we have any hope of
- 2:33:15restoring trust in American people in
- 2:33:17our government, we have to stop doing
- 2:33:19the things the president, the vice
- 2:33:20president, members of Congress, and the
- 2:33:23judiciary have to stop doing things
- 2:33:25where the public feels there's inside
- 2:33:28information that we have access to, in
- 2:33:30many cases that we do, and are profiting
- 2:33:32from it. And this is this is not that
- 2:33:35hard to do.
- 2:33:37There are bills, there's a number that
- 2:33:38you've referenced. We could do it in
- 2:33:40this bill. We'd need to take out the
- 2:33:43Save America Act provisions, which don't
- 2:33:45deserve to be in this bill, but we could
- 2:33:47change this but require divestiture and
- 2:33:50private stock trades
- 2:33:52and the crypto market participation and
- 2:33:55prediction markets. Let's give the
- 2:33:56American people the kind of government
- 2:33:58they deserve and that they want.
- 2:34:00>> Yeah, I
- 2:34:02It is just unbelievably concerning and
- 2:34:06and offensive
- 2:34:08that
- 2:34:09folks are supposed to be public
- 2:34:10servants, supposed to be serving the
- 2:34:13people, not themselves, um continue to
- 2:34:16be able to
- 2:34:18use information that they obtain as a
- 2:34:20result of government service in order to
- 2:34:23profit. Although we did see a new twist
- 2:34:26on that this week when the president
- 2:34:28announced that he will sell access to
- 2:34:30his Truth Social posts.
- 2:34:33If you can pay $100,000 or so, you will
- 2:34:37get early access to government action
- 2:34:41that will then move the market. So it is
- 2:34:43literally paid to play. If you pay off
- 2:34:46the president's social media media
- 2:34:48company, you're going to be able to make
- 2:34:50more money cuz you'll have advanced
- 2:34:51notice. I mean, it is a culture of
- 2:34:54corruption that is truly mind-boggling
- 2:34:58and we need to put a an end to it. You
- 2:34:59had something else?
- 2:35:00>> Well, just that
- 2:35:01the president is somehow under the idea
- 2:35:05that if you do things openly, publicly,
- 2:35:08it makes them okay. So if he told you he
- 2:35:10was going to rob your bank in the middle
- 2:35:12of the day
- 2:35:13and
- 2:35:15you know, filmed it while he was robbing
- 2:35:16your bank, that somehow that's no longer
- 2:35:18a crime because he told you he was going
- 2:35:20to do it. So, developing for Truth
- 2:35:22Social where he's going to give inside
- 2:35:24information to people who will pay
- 2:35:26significant amount of money. So, you're
- 2:35:28only doing it for economic advantages.
- 2:35:30There's no other reason to have the app.
- 2:35:32But, think about this. In the 21st
- 2:35:35century, the United States Congress is
- 2:35:37going to sit and allow the president of
- 2:35:38the United States, who makes
- 2:35:40market-making decisions every single
- 2:35:43hour, is going to allow that person to
- 2:35:45sell that information to private
- 2:35:48investors who will pay him for it, and
- 2:35:50we're just going to sit here and go,
- 2:35:52"Okay.
- 2:35:53That's okay." I mean, is anybody in
- 2:35:55America think that's okay other than the
- 2:35:58members of Congress who are unwilling to
- 2:35:59stand up to him?
- 2:36:01>> Well, I'd suggest that this Congress
- 2:36:02will say it's okay, but hopefully the
- 2:36:04next one won't. Thank you. I yield back.
- 2:36:08>> The gentlewoman yields back. Now,
- 2:36:09recognize the gent- the other gentleman
- 2:36:11from from uh Georgia, Mr. Jack.
- 2:36:14>> Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I want to
- 2:36:16congratulate my friend Chairman Steil on
- 2:36:19bringing this legislation before us and
- 2:36:21the work that you put into this topic to
- 2:36:23deliver a really impressive piece of
- 2:36:25legislation. I'm curious, could you
- 2:36:26explain to this committee, from your
- 2:36:27perspective, what are people voting
- 2:36:29against when they vote against this
- 2:36:31legislation this week?
- 2:36:32>> Well, I I think that's that's important
- 2:36:34to know. We hear a lot from our friends
- 2:36:36uh across the aisle what they would do
- 2:36:38if they were in charge. They were in
- 2:36:39charge, and they didn't bring any of
- 2:36:41this. So,
- 2:36:42you you got a pretty good idea what
- 2:36:44they're going to do. Absolutely nothing.
- 2:36:46This bill in front of us is an
- 2:36:48opportunity to ban members of Congress
- 2:36:50from buying individual shares of stock.
- 2:36:53And when this comes to this committee
- 2:36:55for a vote to give us a rule,
- 2:36:57if we're successful, I think we will be,
- 2:36:59we'll be on the floor, and if members
- 2:37:00vote against it, they're allowing
- 2:37:01members to to buy and trade uh
- 2:37:04individual shares of stock as they are
- 2:37:06today. I think this is our opportunity
- 2:37:08actually for the most uh comprehensive
- 2:37:11uh and important um
- 2:37:13piece of ethics reform in the house that
- 2:37:15we've seen probably over 10 years. This
- 2:37:18bill before us is substantive, it works,
- 2:37:21it has broad support,
- 2:37:24and I think we got an opportunity to
- 2:37:25make a huge change. And And folks that
- 2:37:27choose to vote against it can go home
- 2:37:28and explain to their constituents why
- 2:37:30they think members of Congress should be
- 2:37:32able to buy
- 2:37:33individual shares of stock.
- 2:37:35And two, on the other side with photo
- 2:37:38identification,
- 2:37:39this is our opportunity to make sure
- 2:37:41that all 50 states have photo ID when
- 2:37:44individuals go to the polls. It's pretty
- 2:37:46straightforward, easy concept. It's
- 2:37:49popular because it's common sense.
- 2:37:51American people understand that we need
- 2:37:52to have basic common sense election
- 2:37:55integrity. And you either support
- 2:37:57election integrity or you think that you
- 2:37:59should just be able to walk in as they
- 2:38:00do in the state of Minnesota and vouch
- 2:38:03for up to eight people to cast their
- 2:38:05ballot. Thank you very much, Mr.
- 2:38:07Chairman. I just submit
- 2:38:08not only is is banning stock trading for
- 2:38:11members of Congress wildly, wildly
- 2:38:12popular if you poll Americans, so too
- 2:38:14are some of these common sense
- 2:38:16requirements with respect to voting. So,
- 2:38:18this is this should be a wildly popular
- 2:38:20bill. I hope the vote later this week
- 2:38:23reflects that and
- 2:38:26I will yield back to our distinguished
- 2:38:28chairman, Mr. Griffith. Thank you.
- 2:38:29>> Gentleman yields back. Now recognize the
- 2:38:31gentleman from Colorado, Mr. Neguse, for
- 2:38:33his time of questioning.
- 2:38:35>> Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
- 2:38:37Thank you, Chairman Steil,
- 2:38:39and Ranking Member Morelle for being
- 2:38:41here and for your testimony.
- 2:38:43Chairman Steil,
- 2:38:44so, the name of your bill
- 2:38:47is the Stop Insider Trading Act,
- 2:38:50correct?
- 2:38:50>> That's correct.
- 2:38:51>> Okay.
- 2:38:53You think that's an accurate description
- 2:38:54of the bill?
- 2:38:55>> Yeah.
- 2:38:56>> Okay.
- 2:38:57What does trading mean to you?
- 2:38:59>> The buying and selling for profit.
- 2:39:01>> The buying and selling for profit. I
- 2:39:04couldn't agree with you more. I look
- 2:39:05Webster's dictionary defines it as the
- 2:39:08business of buying and selling.
- 2:39:11This bill,
- 2:39:12as you said, bans the buying of
- 2:39:15individual shares of stock, right?
- 2:39:17>> That's correct.
- 2:39:18>> It does not ban the selling.
- 2:39:19>> It it reforms the selling, of course. It
- 2:39:21makes changes.
- 2:39:22>> the selling, right?
- 2:39:24You're allowed to sell as much stock as
- 2:39:27you would like as a member of Congress
- 2:39:29under this bill. Is that wrong?
- 2:39:31>> I think it's insufficient to describe it
- 2:39:33that way, but that what you said is
- 2:39:34accurate but misleading.
- 2:39:35>> accurate, yes.
- 2:39:36>> Correct. Yes, it is accurate. So, let's
- 2:39:38say there's a Republican senator
- 2:39:41who decides that they're going to sell
- 2:39:42millions of dollars of stock
- 2:39:45the week before the COVID-19 pandemic
- 2:39:47begins in earnest. That's legal under
- 2:39:51your bill, right?
- 2:39:52>> Of course, they would have provided a
- 2:39:53minimum of 7 days advance notice. I'm
- 2:39:55not sure that you could do that in the
- 2:39:57timeline you just proposed.
- 2:39:58>> would be legal under this I I'm This
- 2:40:01isn't a hypothetical. A Republican
- 2:40:02senator
- 2:40:047 8 days before, 9 days before the
- 2:40:07COVID-19 pandemic began in earnest, sold
- 2:40:11millions millions of dollars of stock.
- 2:40:13Under this bill, that would not be
- 2:40:15legal, right?
- 2:40:16>> But of course, they would provide
- 2:40:17notice. That's That's the part that you
- 2:40:19don't want to discuss.
- 2:40:20>> the notice, but here's what I don't
- 2:40:22understand why you Hold on. I'll I'll
- 2:40:23give you a chance to explain this. You
- 2:40:25could defend it on the merits. You've
- 2:40:26clearly decided that the buying of
- 2:40:28stock,
- 2:40:30right? Is a practice that you don't
- 2:40:32believe should be permitted by members
- 2:40:33of Congress. I agree.
- 2:40:35>> Okay.
- 2:40:36>> But for some reason, you've decided that
- 2:40:38the sale of stocks, individual stocks,
- 2:40:42is completely fine but for the notice
- 2:40:44requirements that you've now imposed in
- 2:40:45this bill. And I don't quite understand
- 2:40:48that disconnect because there are many
- 2:40:50bills,
- 2:40:51many bills that have been introduced,
- 2:40:52including a bill I introduced
- 2:40:557 years ago
- 2:40:57with Chip Roy and other members of this
- 2:40:59body that It 140 cosponsors on it
- 2:41:02That would ensure that the sale and the
- 2:41:05purchase of stocks
- 2:41:07is banned.
- 2:41:08And this bill does not do that. So, I'm
- 2:41:11just I'm trying to understand why you've
- 2:41:13decided that it's permissible on one end
- 2:41:15but not the other.
- 2:41:17>> I appreciate your response. Great.
- 2:41:19So, the focus of the bill is to stop an
- 2:41:21individual from being able to profit off
- 2:41:23of insider information.
- 2:41:26So, that that that core concept of What
- 2:41:28is the bill's goal? I think it's really
- 2:41:31important. So, let's go back to your
- 2:41:32example of an individual
- 2:41:33>> There you go. Go ahead. Sorry. Go ahead.
- 2:41:35Yeah, go please. I want
- 2:41:36>> So, so let's go back let's go back to
- 2:41:37the example of an individual that made a
- 2:41:39significant sale prior to the pandemic
- 2:41:41cuz I think that's actually a very
- 2:41:42relevant discussion point
- 2:41:43>> Sure.
- 2:41:44>> inside of this. The point of the the
- 2:41:46pre-disclosure is that you it prevents
- 2:41:50the individual from being able to profit
- 2:41:52off of that sale because the inside the
- 2:41:54information is now publicly available.
- 2:41:56So, if an individual was in a leadership
- 2:41:57role, say they're the chair of the
- 2:41:59intelligence committee of the House or
- 2:42:00the Senate. That individual may have
- 2:42:03information leading up to a pandemic.
- 2:42:05>> Sure.
- 2:42:05>> Now, proving that information was
- 2:42:07inside, that's very difficult. I noted
- 2:42:09that earlier. Proving insider illegal
- 2:42:11inside trades is actually very difficult
- 2:42:13for the Department of Justice. So, my
- 2:42:15bill would require that you would
- 2:42:18provide an advance disclosure of that.
- 2:42:20That would be of course market moving.
- 2:42:22It mirrors the sale.
- 2:42:24>> Just of the of the notion of that you
- 2:42:25intend to sell the stock.
- 2:42:27>> Right. That's an actual
- 2:42:28>> no So,
- 2:42:29>> So, so walk you through the economics
- 2:42:31maybe. So, in
- 2:42:32>> understand the example. I What I'm going
- 2:42:34to clear my time here cuz I I wanted to
- 2:42:35give you ample opportunity here. If
- 2:42:37you're the chairman of the Intel
- 2:42:38Committee
- 2:42:39and today you uh come across information
- 2:42:44that
- 2:42:45compels you to sell $500,000 worth of
- 2:42:49stock in a particular company that you
- 2:42:52own.
- 2:42:53>> Mhm.
- 2:42:53>> You make that disclosure under the STYLE
- 2:42:55Act,
- 2:42:56right? 7 days I think or what what's the
- 2:42:58notice requirement?
- 2:42:59>> Minimum 7.
- 2:42:59>> Minimum 7 days. Okay.
- 2:43:02I don't know that that's necessarily
- 2:43:04going to draw the scrutiny of anybody in
- 2:43:06the public domain and then if a week
- 2:43:08from now or two weeks from now, well,
- 2:43:10stock trades are made every day by
- 2:43:12members of the
- 2:43:12>> you know, public disclosure would be
- 2:43:14prima facie evidence of insider trading
- 2:43:16subject to the jurisdiction of
- 2:43:18>> Department of Justice.
- 2:43:19>> Then why not do that on the purchase?
- 2:43:21Why have you decided to do it on the
- 2:43:22purchase?
- 2:43:23>> That That's actually a great question,
- 2:43:25Mr. Neguse. So, what we're looking at is
- 2:43:27real-world situations where individuals
- 2:43:29enter Congress. So, upon entering
- 2:43:31Congress, easy for all of us to agree
- 2:43:32there should be no additional purchase
- 2:43:34of an individual share of stock. I mean,
- 2:43:35that's actually reasonably
- 2:43:37straightforward. You have made the
- 2:43:38choice to become a member of Congress.
- 2:43:40That's an obligation that we're placing
- 2:43:41upon you. An individual who is leaving
- 2:43:44their private life, who is making
- 2:43:46reasonable savings for themselves and
- 2:43:48their family. Maybe they bought 100
- 2:43:50shares of use Coca-Cola earlier cuz we
- 2:43:52had the gentleman from Georgia here. 100
- 2:43:54100 shares of Coca-Cola stock or any
- 2:43:55other good American company that's
- 2:43:58working hard. They're using that to
- 2:43:59maybe save up for down payment on a
- 2:44:01home, their wedding, their child's
- 2:44:03wedding. Now they arrive in Congress.
- 2:44:05The question then became, what do we do?
- 2:44:07How do we think through this and how do
- 2:44:08we address this? We share the goal of
- 2:44:10preventing that individual from
- 2:44:11benefiting off of any insider
- 2:44:12information. Of course, if an individual
- 2:44:15was it leading up to a major global
- 2:44:17event and that individual's trade was
- 2:44:20noticed in advance rather than after,
- 2:44:22one, there would most likely be market
- 2:44:24moving such that the profit would be
- 2:44:26removed, thus preventing the individual
- 2:44:28from
- 2:44:29>> I don't I would just simply say cuz I've
- 2:44:30got limited time, I would say that I
- 2:44:34while I understand
- 2:44:36that there are members of your caucus
- 2:44:37and and frankly
- 2:44:39members of the Democratic caucus as well
- 2:44:41who have concerns about divestment of
- 2:44:44stocks that they already own. Okay? I
- 2:44:46understand that that's a concern that's
- 2:44:49been expressed by some members and so in
- 2:44:51so far as you're trying to address that
- 2:44:52concern, you've adopted this, you know,
- 2:44:56para- new paradigm that you've
- 2:44:57constructed. I would just say that
- 2:44:59that's the reason, and that it's not
- 2:45:01this argument. I just don't think that
- 2:45:03it's intellectually consistent. So, I I
- 2:45:05hear you. I You've You've made the
- 2:45:06argument. You've made the argument, and
- 2:45:08so, yeah, I'm sure my gentleman's my
- 2:45:10colleagues on the other side of the
- 2:45:10aisle will give you more time if you'd
- 2:45:12like, but I just don't think that that's
- 2:45:15an accurate argument. In my view, 140
- 2:45:17members of this body, Republicans and
- 2:45:20Democrats, have clearly, unambiguously
- 2:45:24said, "We should ban the sale or
- 2:45:26purchase of stocks."
- 2:45:28Period. Full stop. And there's a bill
- 2:45:32by one of the members of this committee,
- 2:45:34this august committee, the Rules
- 2:45:35Committee, and I look forward to making
- 2:45:37an amendment to this bill that you
- 2:45:39proposed to perhaps consider
- 2:45:41substituting Mr. Roy's bill, which would
- 2:45:43accomplish what I've described. I want
- 2:45:45to make sure I'm understanding, as a
- 2:45:47technical matter, the ambit of this
- 2:45:49bill.
- 2:45:51Under this bill, can you purchase crypto
- 2:45:54holdings?
- 2:45:55>> It makes no changes to the House rules
- 2:45:56in that regard.
- 2:45:57>> So, you can't or you can?
- 2:45:59>> It makes no changes in this regard.
- 2:46:00>> I don't Is it allowed
- 2:46:01>> House rules still apply. You were You
- 2:46:02today are allowed to buy crypto
- 2:46:04>> what I'm asking. It's not a trick
- 2:46:05question. You're allowed to.
- 2:46:07>> That's That's what I was saying.
- 2:46:08>> Individual placements. Can someone else
- 2:46:10reference this previously that they're
- 2:46:12Can you do individual
- 2:46:14purchase of individual placements of
- 2:46:15stock under
- 2:46:17>> shares of stock, no.
- 2:46:19>> Individual shares, no. Private
- 2:46:21placements, yes.
- 2:46:23>> The Right, the current House rules would
- 2:46:25apply.
- 2:46:26>> Correct. Okay. So, if it's easier, I'll
- 2:46:29frame it that way. I'll I'll use
- 2:46:30>> House rules apply.
- 2:46:31>> Okay, fine.
- 2:46:32>> But there I What I want to make clear to
- 2:46:34people who are listening is there are
- 2:46:35significant restrictions in place under
- 2:46:37House rules. I wouldn't want somebody to
- 2:46:38walk away and think
- 2:46:39>> Fine.
- 2:46:39>> that no other rules apply. I want to
- 2:46:41make sure that they're clear that
- 2:46:42current House rules would apply.
- 2:46:43>> Let's use your language.
- 2:46:44>> Yeah, I think it's more accurate.
- 2:46:45>> Under current House rules, members of
- 2:46:47Congress can buy crypto holdings, and
- 2:46:49under your bill, that does not change,
- 2:46:51right?
- 2:46:51>> There's no change
- 2:46:52>> Okay, and under current House rules,
- 2:46:53members of Congress can buy stocks
- 2:46:55through private placements, and under
- 2:46:57your bill, that does not change, right?
- 2:46:59>> No change.
- 2:46:59>> Okay, and under current House rules,
- 2:47:01members of Congress can buy stocks or
- 2:47:04excuse me, can buy industry-specific
- 2:47:06mutual funds, right?
- 2:47:07>> That's accurate.
- 2:47:07>> And that does not change under your
- 2:47:09bill.
- 2:47:09>> not change
- 2:47:09>> Okay, and under current House rules,
- 2:47:11members of Congress can buy uh bonds,
- 2:47:14right?
- 2:47:15>> Mhm.
- 2:47:15>> And under your bill, that does not
- 2:47:17change.
- 2:47:17>> They can still buy bonds.
- 2:47:18>> And there are countless other pieces of
- 2:47:20legislation that members of Congress
- 2:47:22have introduced, myself included, that
- 2:47:25would ban all of what I just described.
- 2:47:28That is the point. I would say with
- 2:47:31respect to Mr. Morelle's comment about
- 2:47:33the prediction markets, I do not
- 2:47:35understand, and perhaps you can
- 2:47:37illuminate this for me.
- 2:47:40The House Administration Committee has
- 2:47:41jurisdiction over member participation
- 2:47:44in prediction markets,
- 2:47:45right?
- 2:47:46>> That's accurate.
- 2:47:46>> Okay, you're the chair.
- 2:47:48>> Along with others, but yes.
- 2:47:49>> But you you've got principal
- 2:47:50jurisdiction.
- 2:47:50>> Yes, yes.
- 2:47:51>> You're in charge. Okay.
- 2:47:544 months ago, the United States Senate,
- 2:47:56on a bipartisan basis, on a voice vote,
- 2:48:00took action and said, "You know what?
- 2:48:03No senator in this body is allowed to
- 2:48:06make bets on prediction markets." Every
- 2:48:08Republican, every Democrat agreed to it.
- 2:48:11Why can't we?
- 2:48:12>> I I we have moved forward legislation,
- 2:48:14the Committee on House Administration on
- 2:48:16this topic. I look forward to
- 2:48:18I I'd be
- 2:48:19>> we I I'm saying this happened in April.
- 2:48:21We could do a one-page resolution. We
- 2:48:23could just literally cut and paste the
- 2:48:25Senate resolution, and we could pass it
- 2:48:27tomorrow.
- 2:48:28Will you help us with that?
- 2:48:30>> Yes, I been supportive of making
- 2:48:32restrictions
- 2:48:33in the prediction markets space.
- 2:48:34>> Why isn't it in this bill?
- 2:48:36>> I We have two different pieces of
- 2:48:37legislation we moved through.
- 2:48:40Obviously, prediction markets are
- 2:48:41reasonably new and novel technology
- 2:48:42available to American people.
- 2:48:43>> It took the Senate a day. It's a
- 2:48:45one-page resolution. It literally is a
- 2:48:47paragraph. It just says, "Members of the
- 2:48:49Senate are banned from participating in
- 2:48:51prediction
- 2:48:51>> fully supportive of my legislation
- 2:48:52moving forward, if that's the question.
- 2:48:54>> No, the question is can Well, I guess
- 2:48:57I'll follow with Mr. Morelli, and maybe
- 2:48:59Mr. Morelli, I would encourage I I know
- 2:49:00you've been pushing on this, but maybe
- 2:49:01we can just
- 2:49:03write a one-page resolution. We'll just
- 2:49:05take the Senate resolution, go to the
- 2:49:07floor this week, and apparently,
- 2:49:09according to Mr. Style, that that would
- 2:49:10meet with his approval. All right? Am I
- 2:49:12Am I wrong? Is that not something that
- 2:49:14you all have been able to debate in the
- 2:49:15committee? Mr. Morelli.
- 2:49:17>> Well, no, you're absolutely right. We
- 2:49:19can do by resolution
- 2:49:21and have it apply to House members and
- 2:49:23House family member members of families
- 2:49:25of House members, dependents, and do
- 2:49:28just exactly what the Senate did. The
- 2:49:30alternative is to do it in a bill, which
- 2:49:31isn't even in front of us for reasons
- 2:49:33that completely escape my
- 2:49:36understanding. There should be a
- 2:49:37provision in this bill as as bad as this
- 2:49:39bill is, how would you not include the
- 2:49:41prediction markets? But yes, to your
- 2:49:43point, we could do a resolution. Doesn't
- 2:49:44have to pass the Senate. Doesn't have to
- 2:49:46have the president sign it. We could do
- 2:49:47a resolution pertaining simply to the
- 2:49:49House. We should do that today.
- 2:49:51>> I couldn't agree more, and I would just
- 2:49:53I would hope that the majority
- 2:49:56Republican House
- 2:49:58would perhaps emulate what your
- 2:50:01colleagues in the upper chamber did
- 2:50:03under John Thune, and simply say,
- 2:50:05instead of the delay and the dilatory
- 2:50:07tactics and everything else, we're just
- 2:50:08going to ban it. And you'll certainly
- 2:50:10have my support, and I suspect you have
- 2:50:11a lot of Democrats who would agree with
- 2:50:12you. I do want to talk about very
- 2:50:14briefly, cuz the chair has
- 2:50:16indulged me, so
- 2:50:18here on the vote the
- 2:50:20What's the the Save Vote Act, or
- 2:50:22>> Normally, you say y'all get to go on
- 2:50:24forever and ever because you have less
- 2:50:26people, but today, you have more.
- 2:50:28>> Well,
- 2:50:29you don't want to tempt me here.
- 2:50:32I very quick question on the
- 2:50:35Save America What I don't know if we're
- 2:50:37calling it the reduced version or what
- 2:50:38What's the
- 2:50:39What's this new version called that
- 2:50:44What is it? Isn't there a title of it?
- 2:50:45Voter ID or what
- 2:50:48or section three of the bill?
- 2:50:50Okay.
- 2:50:51So,
- 2:50:52my understanding
- 2:50:55is that in Wisconsin, the voters
- 2:50:58approved
- 2:51:00by
- 2:51:01constitutional amendment, essentially a
- 2:51:04codification of the voter ID law that
- 2:51:07had already been on the books in
- 2:51:08Wisconsin, right?
- 2:51:09Okay.
- 2:51:10>> that's accurate.
- 2:51:11>> And
- 2:51:12National Conference of State
- 2:51:13Legislatures has described Wisconsin's
- 2:51:16constitutional measure, which is the
- 2:51:17same as the statutory measure, as the
- 2:51:20most restrictive in the country.
- 2:51:22I don't know if you've seen that, but
- 2:51:23>> I I don't know if it's the I didn't I've
- 2:51:25not seen the that term, but it's a it's
- 2:51:27a good a reasonably good photo ID law.
- 2:51:29>> Reasonably good photo ID law.
- 2:51:32Under that law,
- 2:51:33you can use a college ID.
- 2:51:35>> Mhm.
- 2:51:36>> And under your bill, you can't.
- 2:51:37>> Correct.
- 2:51:39>> And I'm trying to understand why
- 2:51:43if that, as you said, reasonably good
- 2:51:45standard
- 2:51:47is good enough for your constituents and
- 2:51:49the people that you represent in
- 2:51:49Wisconsin,
- 2:51:51there are plenty of constituents of
- 2:51:53yours
- 2:51:54at a variety of different colleges and
- 2:51:56universities that you represent that
- 2:51:59right now comply with what has been
- 2:52:02described by others as the most strict
- 2:52:04voter ID law in the country by using
- 2:52:07their college ID, but their congressman
- 2:52:10is championing a bill that would tell
- 2:52:13them that they no longer can do that. I
- 2:52:14don't understand that.
- 2:52:15>> Sure, great question.
- 2:52:17Universities across the country,
- 2:52:19including in my home state,
- 2:52:20issue IDs to non-citizens, issue IDs to
- 2:52:24illegal immigrants, as many states do,
- 2:52:26many of them blue states. The state next
- 2:52:28to me, the state of Illinois, issues
- 2:52:30driver's licenses, for example,
- 2:52:32to non-citizens and including illegal
- 2:52:34immigrants.
- 2:52:35And so this is a standard to say, how do
- 2:52:38we make sure
- 2:52:39that we're
- 2:52:40protecting the integrity of our
- 2:52:42elections? And we believe the best way
- 2:52:44to do that is through the forms of IDs
- 2:52:47listed in the bill.
- 2:52:47>> So the Wisconsin standard really isn't
- 2:52:49the reasonable, I think the word you
- 2:52:50used was reasonably good standard. That
- 2:52:52doesn't sound like you're I mean it
- 2:52:54sounds like it's
- 2:52:54>> think it's I don't Yeah, I don't think
- 2:52:55the standard to get a student ID is
- 2:52:57nearly as sufficient
- 2:52:58>> I didn't ask you that. I said the
- 2:53:00Wisconsin law
- 2:53:02that 62% of the voters of Wisconsin a
- 2:53:05year and a half ago
- 2:53:07decided they'd put in the state
- 2:53:09constitution that you 5 minutes ago
- 2:53:12described as a reasonably fair standard
- 2:53:14apparently did not meet
- 2:53:15>> What's definitely
- 2:53:16>> the muster here at the federal level.
- 2:53:17>> Well, sure. It is The Wisconsin standard
- 2:53:20is way better than a lot of other
- 2:53:21states. I mean a lot of states have
- 2:53:22nothing. In the state of Minnesota, next
- 2:53:24to my home state, you can vouch for
- 2:53:26eight people. I think that's disastrous.
- 2:53:27So compared Well, cuz I don't want to
- 2:53:29look anything like Minnesota.
- 2:53:31>> I'm saying why didn't you You're the
- 2:53:32Wisconsin
- 2:53:33>> Because I don't I actually think we can
- 2:53:34do better. Yeah, so I think Wisconsin
- 2:53:35beats most states, no doubt. I'm not
- 2:53:37uniquely familiar with your home state's
- 2:53:40photo or voter laws, but I can tell you
- 2:53:43in my the neighboring states next to
- 2:53:44Wisconsin, we got some disasters on our
- 2:53:46hands.
- 2:53:46>> How much time do you have under this law
- 2:53:49if you vote provisionally, if you don't
- 2:53:50have photo ID, to be able to then ensure
- 2:53:53that your vote still counts? Um what's
- 2:53:56the time span?
- 2:53:56>> You'd reference back You'd reference
- 2:53:58back to your state law on
- 2:54:00on that.
- 2:54:01>> I thought the federal standard I thought
- 2:54:02the standard here was 3 days, or is that
- 2:54:04wrong?
- 2:54:04>> Is it It is 3 days. I apologize. I
- 2:54:06apologize. I apologize. 3 days.
- 2:54:08>> 72 hours.
- 2:54:08>> So right. So if you forget your ID
- 2:54:10>> You forget your ID, you got 72 hours.
- 2:54:13>> That'd be accurate.
- 2:54:14>> And if you don't do that, then your vote
- 2:54:15doesn't count.
- 2:54:17Right?
- 2:54:17>> Right. You would not have cured your
- 2:54:19ballot. That's right.
- 2:54:20>> Do you know what that time period is in
- 2:54:22Wisconsin?
- 2:54:24>> Go ahead.
- 2:54:25>> It's a lot longer.
- 2:54:26>> Yeah. We also have We also have many
- 2:54:28weeks of early voting. So, an individual
- 2:54:31could could go in and do their early
- 2:54:33in-person vote safely in the state of
- 2:54:36Wisconsin. And if you forgot it, you
- 2:54:37could show up day after day after day.
- 2:54:39>> I would just simply say
- 2:54:41obviously I'm I believe Colorado has the
- 2:54:43gold standard, but if it's good enough
- 2:54:46for the people of Wisconsin, I'm just
- 2:54:47again don't really understand why
- 2:54:50you would champion on the one hand the
- 2:54:52Wisconsin standard and then
- 2:54:54simultaneously propose a far more
- 2:54:56exacting in my view than the general
- 2:54:58assembly has proposed.
- 2:55:00We've probably beaten this this horse to
- 2:55:03death here. So, in any event, I thank
- 2:55:04you both. Gentlemen, yields back. I will
- 2:55:06yield back. And I recognize myself and I
- 2:55:09will beat that horse.
- 2:55:14Mr. Stahle, is it not true that the
- 2:55:16individual states, while they have
- 2:55:19sovereignty under the United States of
- 2:55:21America, do not represent everybody in
- 2:55:24the nation?
- 2:55:26>> That's right.
- 2:55:27>> So, Wisconsin has a great standard for
- 2:55:29Wisconsin,
- 2:55:32but that doesn't necessarily mean that
- 2:55:34we want Wisconsin student IDs changing
- 2:55:38federal policy. Isn't that accurate?
- 2:55:40>> That's accurate. I wouldn't say that
- 2:55:43Wisconsin is flawless. I just say it's
- 2:55:44better than other states.
- 2:55:45>> The state legislature says it's the best
- 2:55:47of the states, that doesn't mean it's
- 2:55:48the best that the United States can do
- 2:55:50for its federal elections. Am I not
- 2:55:52correct?
- 2:55:52>> That's accurate.
- 2:55:53>> There you go.
- 2:55:54Now, I got a couple of other things cuz
- 2:55:55y'all got into talking about some
- 2:55:57financial stuff that, you know, I'm just
- 2:55:59a poor boy from Southwest Virginia and I
- 2:56:02don't understand it all. I got to tell
- 2:56:03you, and I'm sure there's some people
- 2:56:05back home don't know what this is. Now,
- 2:56:06y'all that have money and are big-time
- 2:56:09in the financial world, maybe you do.
- 2:56:11What in the heck is a private placement?
- 2:56:13He said you you can still do private
- 2:56:15placements. I don't even know what y'all
- 2:56:16talking about.
- 2:56:17>> That's not not something I engage in,
- 2:56:19but under the House rules individuals
- 2:56:21can own
- 2:56:22a host of different private assets.
- 2:56:25>> All right, I don't know what a What is a
- 2:56:26private placement? He said you can buy
- 2:56:29>> You could ask your colleague to describe
- 2:56:31private placement for his question if he
- 2:56:32would like.
- 2:56:33>> Maybe Mr. Morelle can answer. He seems
- 2:56:36>> I think they're just private offerings
- 2:56:38from companies that are not publicly
- 2:56:40traded, but are privately issued private
- 2:56:42stock.
- 2:56:44>> All right, and so as as both of you
- 2:56:46know, cuz that's what I was That's what
- 2:56:47I was worried about. Cuz he He It
- 2:56:50implied
- 2:56:52gentleman implied he wanted to get rid
- 2:56:53of that, but as as you all know, having
- 2:56:55heard me talk about it, I got rid of all
- 2:56:57my $6,000 worth of stocks when
- 2:57:00the previous act was enacted. And
- 2:57:04the only thing I have is a
- 2:57:07small swimming pool entity that I have a
- 2:57:10ownership interest in. And if that's a
- 2:57:12private placement, we suddenly want to
- 2:57:13ban that, I'm like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa,
- 2:57:15wait a minute."
- 2:57:16Because that that community pool might
- 2:57:19not exist if
- 2:57:21if I hadn't bought a fair number of
- 2:57:23shares in it
- 2:57:24back in 1991. And
- 2:57:28And I will confess I sold a share this
- 2:57:30year.
- 2:57:32Uh
- 2:57:33I sold is a is a loose term. Gave one to
- 2:57:37my youngest son when he turned 18.
- 2:57:39One of the shares that I
- 2:57:42So, I understand there may be people
- 2:57:45doing big-time stuff, but there's also a
- 2:57:46lot of people if that's a private
- 2:57:48placement, there's a lot of people who
- 2:57:49are doing things in their community
- 2:57:51where they've got a little community
- 2:57:53pool or some other thing that's more I
- 2:57:55mean, it makes money some years.
- 2:57:58We might even make money this year, but
- 2:57:59we didn't make money in the in a number
- 2:58:01of years as well. And the idea is to
- 2:58:03make sure that people have a place to
- 2:58:07go swimming, be on the swim team, play
- 2:58:09water polo,
- 2:58:11pick up Stonegate rules water polo on
- 2:58:13Sunday nights, that kind of stuff.
- 2:58:15So, let's make sure we're not throwing
- 2:58:16the baby out
- 2:58:18with the swimming pool water, so to
- 2:58:20speak. Uh that would be my concern, but
- 2:58:22I didn't know what exactly what you're
- 2:58:23talking about. Now I do, and I
- 2:58:24appreciate that. The other thing on the
- 2:58:26sales, and I think the 7 days, Mr.
- 2:58:28Chairman, is probably a pretty good
- 2:58:30idea. I mean, somebody want to argue
- 2:58:31about being 10 days, okay, maybe the 10
- 2:58:34days is a little bit better, but
- 2:58:35but, you know, if you own if you own
- 2:58:38some stock and you're not a wealthy
- 2:58:40person, and we
- 2:58:41we've been going through some of this,
- 2:58:43not with stock, but with other assets,
- 2:58:46trying to figure out how are we going to
- 2:58:47pay for that college education
- 2:58:49uh
- 2:58:50this year, and I mean, that was the
- 2:58:51discussion my wife and I had this
- 2:58:53morning before I left town is what are
- 2:58:55we going to to make sure we get
- 2:58:56tuition paid and the room and board
- 2:58:58paid, and
- 2:58:59you know, what's it going to look like
- 2:59:00in September when we get through paying
- 2:59:02all the big fees,
- 2:59:03and what's the monthly outgoing to be?
- 2:59:05And And so, to say that a member who
- 2:59:07comes to Congress, gets elected, and
- 2:59:09comes to Congress, and has a portfolio
- 2:59:13can't make a decision to sell that stock
- 2:59:17and and for whatever reasons, but most
- 2:59:18of the time most members of Congress are
- 2:59:21not as wealthy as the public thinks we
- 2:59:23are.
- 2:59:24And
- 2:59:25uh
- 2:59:26you got to figure out how you're going
- 2:59:27to pay for things like college
- 2:59:28education. I've got two in coming up on
- 2:59:31August 18th, I'll have two in college at
- 2:59:33the same time,
- 2:59:35and we're trying to figure out how to
- 2:59:36juggle all that. Now,
- 2:59:38as I said, we don't have the publicly
- 2:59:40traded stocks, and this bill just deals
- 2:59:42with those publicly straight traded
- 2:59:44stocks. Isn't that
- 2:59:45>> Correct, Mr. Chairman.
- 2:59:46>> That's accurate.
- 2:59:46>> Yeah.
- 2:59:47And uh I I think that's appropriate, and
- 2:59:49I think it's a pretty good
- 2:59:51uh idea.
- 2:59:52Uh the mutual funds is pretty innocuous,
- 2:59:55too. You can still own the mutual funds,
- 2:59:57and
- 2:59:58uh
- 2:59:58my other son, who's more financially
- 3:00:00adept perhaps than I am, my older one
- 3:00:02who's now 20, uh apparently, and we've
- 3:00:05got to change our financial forms, cuz
- 3:00:07apparently I
- 3:00:09he got a statement the other day in the
- 3:00:10mail, and I saw it, and I said, "What is
- 3:00:11this?" She goes, "Oh, I bought a couple
- 3:00:13thousand dollars out of my summer
- 3:00:15earnings last year in in a mutual fund."
- 3:00:17And I'm like, "Oh, great. I got to got
- 3:00:18to amend my
- 3:00:20public disclosure form
- 3:00:22uh to reflect that. It's not big money,
- 3:00:24but uh and I think the disclosure's
- 3:00:25fine. But saying that they can't own or
- 3:00:28they can't sell
- 3:00:29uh
- 3:00:30is uh
- 3:00:32I think a little onerous and would
- 3:00:33discourage good people from running for
- 3:00:35Congress. Is there anything else you
- 3:00:37wanted to add as we've had these
- 3:00:38discussions going on now for a good
- 3:00:40while?
- 3:00:40>> I appreciate it. Maybe just uh a couple
- 3:00:43things to note. And so, going back to
- 3:00:46the the 7-day disclosure and how do you
- 3:00:48get there? Looking at securities law,
- 3:00:5110b5-1 plans are how publicly traded
- 3:00:53companies uh manage their senior
- 3:00:55leaders, who by definition have inside
- 3:00:57information on their company.
- 3:00:58And so, as I noted earlier, actually
- 3:01:01enforcing insider trading violations
- 3:01:04actually pretty difficult for the DOJ.
- 3:01:06That's already illegal for all members
- 3:01:07and all Americans. They it's illegal,
- 3:01:09they should be held accountable, the DOJ
- 3:01:10should prosecute it. It's difficult to
- 3:01:12prosecute. The 10b5-1 plan on the
- 3:01:14publicly traded company side, what in
- 3:01:16large part they're doing is these
- 3:01:18pre-disclosures. And what it does is it
- 3:01:20sets up the evidence to prosecute an
- 3:01:24insider trading case. So, our my my our
- 3:01:27colleague uh from Colorado was
- 3:01:28referencing this.
- 3:01:30Uh and so, if an individual made that
- 3:01:32public announcement 7 days in advance,
- 3:01:35it would be pretty easy to show the
- 3:01:36timeline. Now now let's let's leave that
- 3:01:39one given person so I don't make an
- 3:01:40accusation on that given person. But
- 3:01:42let's let's say an individual member,
- 3:01:45could you could document, had inside
- 3:01:47information on a given topic. They
- 3:01:48provide a 7-day notice that they're
- 3:01:51going to make this sale. They then go
- 3:01:53and make the sale, and then the evidence
- 3:01:54is pretty clear.
- 3:01:56That individual engaged in insider
- 3:01:58trading. That disclosure in that point
- 3:02:01in time actually gives great leverage to
- 3:02:04the Department of Justice to hold an
- 3:02:05individual accountable. It's more
- 3:02:08difficult under the current scenario
- 3:02:10because you don't see where that
- 3:02:11timeline is. And so the reason publicly
- 3:02:13traded companies put these plans in
- 3:02:15place for their executives is to root
- 3:02:18out and prevent individuals from making
- 3:02:22insider information trades, which are
- 3:02:24illegal and should be prevented. And so
- 3:02:27what we tried to do is strike the
- 3:02:28balance to make sure that individuals
- 3:02:30who have successful private sector
- 3:02:32careers, and whatever that word is,
- 3:02:34whether or not it's it's successful that
- 3:02:36you own a local pool and are able to
- 3:02:37help people swim or maybe you or your
- 3:02:40spouse worked at a publicly traded
- 3:02:43company and that publicly traded company
- 3:02:45gave stock as part of the compensation.
- 3:02:48Or you used it to save up for either
- 3:02:51your retirement or
- 3:02:53for the education of your child.
- 3:02:56Is it the belief that we want to make
- 3:02:57sure that those individuals are
- 3:02:59encouraged and able to come to Congress
- 3:03:00in the same way we can have farmers and
- 3:03:01veterans
- 3:03:03come to this institution and serve. Once
- 3:03:06you're here, you can't acquire new and
- 3:03:08additional individual shares of stock. I
- 3:03:10think that's a reasonable restriction to
- 3:03:11put in place. But the core of this bill
- 3:03:14is that prevents members of Congress
- 3:03:15from being able to profit off of insider
- 3:03:17information by putting in place a
- 3:03:20bright-line rule. That is really
- 3:03:22important. If I can just quickly go back
- 3:03:24on the photo ID in my home state of
- 3:03:26Wisconsin cuz I think it's relevant.
- 3:03:28Wisconsin, as I noted, has a reasonably
- 3:03:29good photo ID bill. I don't think it's
- 3:03:32perfect. I think it's reasonably good.
- 3:03:34Now, I think it's reasonably good in
- 3:03:36specifically in comparison to what I
- 3:03:39view as disastrous states. And in
- 3:03:40Wisconsin, we can look across a river
- 3:03:43and across a state line and see a pair
- 3:03:46of really bad examples. Illinois to our
- 3:03:48south, Minnesota to our west. And the
- 3:03:50state of Minnesota has been noted in our
- 3:03:52committee, you were there at the
- 3:03:52hearing,
- 3:03:54Mr. Griffith,
- 3:03:56about how in Minnesota, not only do you
- 3:03:58not need a photo ID, an individual can
- 3:04:01come to the polls and vouch for up to
- 3:04:03eight other people to vote. We were
- 3:04:06making light-hearted comments earlier
- 3:04:08about the never-ending possible. Imagine
- 3:04:11rolling in to your local Olive Garden
- 3:04:13and vouching for eight other people at
- 3:04:15your table that they too are who they
- 3:04:17say they are. Nobody thinks that's
- 3:04:19rational. So, I think Wisconsin has a
- 3:04:21pretty good idea.
- 3:04:22We have a Supreme Court that's become
- 3:04:24hyper-partisan and hyper-liberal. And
- 3:04:26so, thoughtfully our state assembly and
- 3:04:28state senate uh moved through and moved
- 3:04:31the Wisconsin
- 3:04:33uh legislation on photo ID into the
- 3:04:36constitution as a mechanism to prevent
- 3:04:40our Supreme Court from driving forward a
- 3:04:42partisan liberal agenda. Smart move uh
- 3:04:45by our colleagues in the state assembly
- 3:04:47and state senate. And so, we enshrine
- 3:04:49that in the constitution. That's good.
- 3:04:50We don't We don't I don't want our state
- 3:04:52to look like Minnesota or Illinois, Mr.
- 3:04:54Chairman. And so, that said, I think
- 3:04:57there's room for improvement. And I I
- 3:04:59flagged my concern specifically uh as it
- 3:05:02relates to the standards some of our
- 3:05:05universities are using when issuing a
- 3:05:08photo ID. It's a very different
- 3:05:09standard, for example, than the state of
- 3:05:11Wisconsin's Department of Transportation
- 3:05:13has when issuing a a driver's license or
- 3:05:16a state-issued ID. Uh I think we are
- 3:05:18best served we move to that higher
- 3:05:20standard uh rather than uh the lower
- 3:05:23standard allowing uh universities to
- 3:05:26issue uh photo IDs with either limited
- 3:05:29uh documentation or uh giving those IDs
- 3:05:33uh to non-citizens or to illegal
- 3:05:35immigrants. So, I appreciate you giving
- 3:05:36me the time, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.
- 3:05:38>> Yeah, and I will I will say this on the
- 3:05:40going back on the the doc issue.
- 3:05:43I think one of the nice things about the
- 3:05:447-day rule and and everything you said
- 3:05:47was accurate, but one of the things I
- 3:05:48like about it is if a if a wealthy
- 3:05:50member of Congress,
- 3:05:52more likely to be a senator, but still,
- 3:05:54a wealthy member of Congress
- 3:05:56suddenly said, "I'm going to sell a
- 3:05:57million or two million or five million
- 3:05:59dollars of the share in the XYZ
- 3:06:01Corporation.
- 3:06:03That gives the public notice that
- 3:06:04they're selling, maybe I will too, too.
- 3:06:06Or that they'll take a look at it, or
- 3:06:08people will take a look Roll Call will
- 3:06:09certainly report it if there's a 7-day
- 3:06:11notice. And now that's not happening and
- 3:06:13it just happens and then people say,
- 3:06:14"Well, I wish I'd known he was going to
- 3:06:15sell. I'd have sold, too."
- 3:06:17Anyway.
- 3:06:18I I yield back and now recognize the
- 3:06:20gentle lady from New Mexico, Ms. Leger
- 3:06:22Fernandez, for her time.
- 3:06:23>> Uh thank you so very much. And I want to
- 3:06:25go back to this idea that this is the
- 3:06:27Stop Insider Trading Act. Uh and we went
- 3:06:31over earlier that trading involves
- 3:06:34both the purchase and the sale. You
- 3:06:37cannot have trading without the sale.
- 3:06:40And uh Chairman, you said that the
- 3:06:42purpose of this was to make sure that
- 3:06:45Congress people don't make a profit off
- 3:06:48of information we get here from serving.
- 3:06:50Is that Did I recall you saying that
- 3:06:52correctly?
- 3:06:53>> Yeah, as it relates to publicly traded
- 3:06:55company stock.
- 3:06:55>> Let's Let's go back to the question of
- 3:06:57Do you make a profit when you buy a
- 3:06:59stock?
- 3:07:01>> No.
- 3:07:02>> You make a profit when you do what?
- 3:07:04>> You may.
- 3:07:05>> You sell the stock.
- 3:07:07>> No, only if you sell for a profit.
- 3:07:09>> So So
- 3:07:10to clarify, you could lose, but that's
- 3:07:12your chance for making a profit. It's
- 3:07:13the sale of the stock, right?
- 3:07:15>> That's your chance.
- 3:07:16>> Stock Stop Insider Trading Act does not
- 3:07:20prohibit the sale of stocks.
- 3:07:23>> Right, but it prevents you from
- 3:07:24profiting off of the sale.
- 3:07:25>> doesn't. You can profit as much as you
- 3:07:27want. You can profit as much as you
- 3:07:28want.
- 3:07:29As much as you want. As long as you own
- 3:07:30that stock, you can profit. And that's
- 3:07:33where Democrats are going.
- 3:07:34Is that we should not Congress people,
- 3:07:38if you make the choice to come here,
- 3:07:40there should be a vehicle for you to be
- 3:07:42able to divest of individual stocks.
- 3:07:45That's what the bill that Joe Neguse and
- 3:07:48Chip Roy introduced. That's what the
- 3:07:49bill that we have presented. That's what
- 3:07:52the bill
- 3:07:53that Democrats offered as an alternative
- 3:07:56does. Is that correct, ranking member?
- 3:08:00>> Absolutely requires divestiture. And may
- 3:08:02I just add the notion that a 7-day
- 3:08:05waiting period, and I appreciate
- 3:08:07Mr. Griffith's comments, but honestly, I
- 3:08:10don't think of a member of Congress who
- 3:08:13learned that, you know, it's likely
- 3:08:15maybe Boeing instead of Northrop Grumman
- 3:08:17was going to get a military contract and
- 3:08:19they owned Northrop Grumman and wanted
- 3:08:21to get rid of their stock before that
- 3:08:23was acknowledged saying I sold
- 3:08:26$10,000 worth of stock
- 3:08:28a month before anybody knows about it,
- 3:08:30and I acknowledge it's 7 days. That that
- 3:08:33that does virtually nothing. There's
- 3:08:35nobody sitting around watching in real
- 3:08:37time what members of Congress are doing,
- 3:08:39respectfully, and there's no way to
- 3:08:42track
- 3:08:43and and to your point, you only make the
- 3:08:45money if you sell at a price that's
- 3:08:47higher than what you bought it at. So,
- 3:08:49you can only make the money, and it's
- 3:08:50true you can lose money, too, but you
- 3:08:53get to control the timing of when that
- 3:08:56happens if you're not required to
- 3:08:57divest, right? I mean, so that's And by
- 3:09:00the way,
- 3:09:01if you already own stock and there's a
- 3:09:05dividend, you can buy more of that. So,
- 3:09:07the notion that you can't buy is not
- 3:09:09true. Now, it is more narrow, but the
- 3:09:11buying, holding, and selling of stock is
- 3:09:14still allowed under this on the public
- 3:09:17side. On the private side, there's no
- 3:09:19you know,
- 3:09:19>> anything here at all.
- 3:09:21>> Wait, and I think the concern is
- 3:09:23my my colleague from Pennsylvania
- 3:09:26referenced it earlier that maybe what
- 3:09:28you wanted to do is maybe lose less,
- 3:09:30right? And and, you know, here's the
- 3:09:32article that said that when you're going
- 3:09:36to be making these big decisions about
- 3:09:38what happens, we had a colleague that a
- 3:09:41week before he voted to significantly
- 3:09:43cut Medicaid, and I'm quoting from our
- 3:09:45article here dated 11/20/25.
- 3:09:49Uh um um the first on NBC met Mr. Mr.
- 3:09:52Chairman, which I'd seek to enter into
- 3:09:54the record. A week before he voted to
- 3:09:56significantly cut Medicaid by a trillion
- 3:09:59dollars,
- 3:10:01this representative dumped six figures
- 3:10:04worth of stock in a quartet of companies
- 3:10:07that managed nearly half of all Medicaid
- 3:10:10enrollees in the country. Now, Chairman,
- 3:10:12>> Without objection.
- 3:10:14>> This your bill would do nothing to have
- 3:10:16prevented this sale, correct?
- 3:10:19>> I would actually disagree with that.
- 3:10:20>> You disagree with that.
- 3:10:22You
- 3:10:22>> It would do nothing? I think that's an
- 3:10:23inaccurate statement of the bill.
- 3:10:25>> Uh okay, so would it have uh he would be
- 3:10:28able to have sold this stock. You would
- 3:10:30have had to give notice.
- 3:10:31>> would have provided You would have
- 3:10:32provided public notice of the sale.
- 3:10:35>> But he would have been able to sell it.
- 3:10:37It would have not have prevented it.
- 3:10:38Might have Might have allowed the world
- 3:10:40to know before a a newspaper article
- 3:10:43came out, but it would have still
- 3:10:44allowed it.
- 3:10:45>> Well, it depends it depends on the the
- 3:10:47timeline of that sale, of course. 7 days
- 3:10:49notice would require 7 days to elapse.
- 3:10:51>> All your All your bill does is fill out
- 3:10:54a form. And this is the thing what what
- 3:10:57the American public is mad and they are
- 3:11:00mad as hell about is the idea that
- 3:11:04elected officials, both in Congress, in
- 3:11:07the Senate, in the White House are
- 3:11:09making big bucks and they
- 3:11:13are the ones
- 3:11:14>> That's actually why this bill is so
- 3:11:15important. It it's it's about ending the
- 3:11:17profiting off of inside information. So
- 3:11:19you exactly You exactly nailed what
- 3:11:20they're upset about and this is what the
- 3:11:22bill actually accomplishes.
- 3:11:24>> It does not end the profit. It does not
- 3:11:24end the profit cuz the profit is at the
- 3:11:26sale and and this does not prevent the
- 3:11:28sale. You continued You are allowed to
- 3:11:30continue
- 3:11:31>> you don't believe in market forces.
- 3:11:32>> on. Ranking member
- 3:11:33>> Well, may I just May I just make one
- 3:11:35additional point? Even if you had 7 days
- 3:11:37notice, let's say the press did know.
- 3:11:39They came and said, "Hey, we realize
- 3:11:41that you sold all your stock in some
- 3:11:43company.
- 3:11:45You're going to say it's because I was
- 3:11:46diversified or I It's not likely you're
- 3:11:49going to say it's because I learned that
- 3:11:51the United States government is going to
- 3:11:53be buying I mean, it doesn't disclose
- 3:11:55anything. Yeah, it gives I guess the
- 3:11:56press a couple of days if they happen to
- 3:11:58be following your specific trades and
- 3:12:01gives them a little bit of a head start
- 3:12:02on trying to figure out what you were
- 3:12:04doing, but let's be clear. No one is
- 3:12:06going to say because I had information
- 3:12:09which led me to sell. But, the good news
- 3:12:11is I did it for 7 days, so it gives you
- 3:12:13some advanced time to figure out what
- 3:12:15was motivating me. I mean, it's a silly
- 3:12:18>> All it does is give you cover. And I
- 3:12:20think the bigger the bigger bigger huge
- 3:12:23like gaping hole of this bill
- 3:12:26is that we might have information or we
- 3:12:28might be In In this instance, going to
- 3:12:31be one of hundreds of votes.
- 3:12:34The reality is there is a man.
- 3:12:37And there will always be a man and
- 3:12:38hopefully someday a woman who can move
- 3:12:40markets much bigger than any one of us.
- 3:12:43And that is the President of the United
- 3:12:45States.
- 3:12:46And this bill does not cover that at
- 3:12:48all. And And we know that this is
- 3:12:50happening.
- 3:12:53Just uh Truth Social. Uh President Trump
- 3:12:56said with regards to Nvidia, "I've
- 3:12:58gotten all necessary permits. Uh I am
- 3:13:00going This This company's going to go
- 3:13:03through. It's great." He never told
- 3:13:05everybody on Truth Social that he had
- 3:13:06bought 200,000 to 500,000 dollars of
- 3:13:10that company's stock.
- 3:13:12Uh
- 3:13:12And a CNN investigation found that
- 3:13:15President Trump is marketing stocks
- 3:13:19on Truth Social after he's purchased
- 3:13:24shares.
- 3:13:25Now, Chairman Steel,
- 3:13:27your bill doesn't cover the President or
- 3:13:29the Vice President.
- 3:13:32Does it?
- 3:13:33>> Is that a question? No, it it is focused
- 3:13:35on Congress per the jurisdiction of the
- 3:13:37Committee on House Administration.
- 3:13:39>> Oh, okay, but we have jurisdiction.
- 3:13:41Congress has jurisdiction.
- 3:13:44And we are the only ones who can say the
- 3:13:47president should not be purchasing or
- 3:13:50selling stock because he controls the
- 3:13:53market.
- 3:13:54Congress is the one and we don't tell
- 3:13:56him, nobody else is going to do it. Is
- 3:13:58that correct, Ranking Member?
- 3:14:02>> Absolutely.
- 3:14:03>> And and earlier we had a conversation
- 3:14:06about the fact that President Trump has
- 3:14:09now said that he's going to sell early
- 3:14:11access
- 3:14:13to Wall Street on so Truth Social. I
- 3:14:17don't know what you thought about that.
- 3:14:19There was a conversation about it, but I
- 3:14:21think in in the end Chairman Steel,
- 3:14:24you never told us what you thought about
- 3:14:27having a president give access to Wall
- 3:14:30Street early on, paid access for
- 3:14:33information that could move the market.
- 3:14:35Do you think that that should be
- 3:14:36allowed?
- 3:14:37>> I haven't read those reports.
- 3:14:39>> Okay, well, I'm going to just tell you
- 3:14:40now. President the President Trump has
- 3:14:43said that he would provide early access
- 3:14:46to Wall Street to Truth Social so that
- 3:14:49they would be able to make decisions
- 3:14:51about what's happening. Do you think
- 3:14:53that that is appropriate behavior for a
- 3:14:54president?
- 3:14:55>> I I haven't read the reports. I'll read
- 3:14:56it following the meeting here.
- 3:14:59>> Okay.
- 3:15:00It's interesting, you know, I will say
- 3:15:02that Josh Hawley Josh Hawley actually
- 3:15:05said that what he thought that the idea
- 3:15:07that having a president buy and sell
- 3:15:10stock and market stock, that there
- 3:15:13should be a bill that applied to him.
- 3:15:16And what happened to Josh Hawley was
- 3:15:19that President Trump came after him.
- 3:15:21I'm just wondering if
- 3:15:23Republicans on the
- 3:15:25House side are equally afraid
- 3:15:28of this president coming after them for
- 3:15:31actually holding him to a high standard
- 3:15:35uh to any kind of standard with regards
- 3:15:37to owning and selling stock.
- 3:15:41But I want to go to another matter. And
- 3:15:44that's this
- 3:15:47section three of the bill, which is like
- 3:15:50save light, I guess. Uh
- 3:15:52and what strikes me is that there are
- 3:15:55three forms of ID now allowed.
- 3:15:57And there is no tribal ID allowed.
- 3:16:00Did Did I miss that? I saw three forms
- 3:16:02that says state ID,
- 3:16:04uh military ID uh and
- 3:16:08Now there's there's a passport.
- 3:16:10>> There's five forms allowed. Uh the fifth
- 3:16:13one being tribal IDs um issued.
- 3:16:17I I can It'll take me a second to find
- 3:16:18you the the legislative text, but it
- 3:16:20It's five forms.
- 3:16:21>> I'm reading uh Okay, thank you. I'm
- 3:16:23sorry. I'm glad I asked that because I I
- 3:16:25had
- 3:16:26that section. It does cover tribal ID.
- 3:16:29>> Yep.
- 3:16:29>> But but the the other piece of this bill
- 3:16:32is that right now, right, you have taken
- 3:16:35away
- 3:16:36you have taken away the money that would
- 3:16:38allow states that would help states. And
- 3:16:41you keep shaking your head, but it's not
- 3:16:42in this bill.
- 3:16:43And
- 3:16:44it is I'm going back to that awful
- 3:16:47analogy you all kept turning to of that
- 3:16:51this is like a bowl of pasta, that you
- 3:16:53need an ID to get a bowl of pasta in.
- 3:16:55And ranking member still you I'm ranking
- 3:16:56member Morella, you spoke so eloquently
- 3:16:59about voting is not pasta. Voting is not
- 3:17:03a privilege. It's not a privilege. It's
- 3:17:05not something you do when you have
- 3:17:07enough money.
- 3:17:08When you have enough money to be able to
- 3:17:10go to a restaurant and eat as much pasta
- 3:17:13as you want.
- 3:17:15It is a right. It's a constitutional
- 3:17:17right. And our problem
- 3:17:19is that a lot of people do not have
- 3:17:21enough money to be able to own a
- 3:17:24passport. They do not have enough money
- 3:17:27to be able to own a car and have a
- 3:17:29driver's license. They do not have the
- 3:17:31kinds of money
- 3:17:33that allows them to easily access some
- 3:17:36of a passport, a
- 3:17:40a driver's license, or these other
- 3:17:41things. And that's why a pot of money
- 3:17:44that would help people get the photo IDs
- 3:17:47they need would be so essential.
- 3:17:50And ranking member Morelli, you seem to
- 3:17:52want to add to that.
- 3:17:53>> Well, I'd just say this, that I thought
- 3:17:56I think there's a little bit of a
- 3:17:57conflation of two different things.
- 3:17:59Voter ID,
- 3:18:00as I understand it, is to prove to a
- 3:18:04poll watcher that you are who you say
- 3:18:06you are.
- 3:18:07That's all. So, why would student ID not
- 3:18:10be acceptable? The chairman said it's
- 3:18:12because it doesn't prove citizenship,
- 3:18:14but that's not the point of voter ID at
- 3:18:16the polls. The vote The point of voter
- 3:18:18ID, as I understand it, photo ID, is to
- 3:18:21simply prove who you are. You are
- 3:18:23already registered to vote. That's
- 3:18:25already done. And so, this makes it
- 3:18:28harder, and I think it's because,
- 3:18:30honestly,
- 3:18:32they'd prefer that college students not
- 3:18:34vote. So, let's put a number of barriers
- 3:18:37in front of them, and the idea, which
- 3:18:38clearly proves who they are, I am Joe
- 3:18:41Morelli, here's my ID. It says it right
- 3:18:43here. I go to the University of
- 3:18:44Wisconsin. I go to the State University
- 3:18:46of New York. I go to the University of
- 3:18:48New Mexico. That's all. I am who I am.
- 3:18:50And by the way, if you look, even in in
- 3:18:54in places like every state literally
- 3:18:56allows student ID, because it's a way of
- 3:18:59proving who you are. Universities issue
- 3:19:01them. That's a pretty basic thing. Most
- 3:19:03states allow hunter's license, or gun
- 3:19:07permits, or
- 3:19:08in some cases, your utility bills.
- 3:19:11Um
- 3:19:12all you need to do when you go to vote,
- 3:19:14if you if you're not willing to accept
- 3:19:15the system that a number of states have
- 3:19:17where you have signature analysis, and
- 3:19:20And feel the need to have photo photo
- 3:19:21ID, why would you limit the number of
- 3:19:25photo ID possibilities which simply
- 3:19:28allow you to prove
- 3:19:30who you say you are. And by the way,
- 3:19:32I don't know. We've had I don't know how
- 3:19:34many hearings. I haven't heard anybody
- 3:19:35bring to us people who showed ID and
- 3:19:39vouched for to vote when it wasn't them.
- 3:19:41I mean, it simply never happens. This is
- 3:19:43the other thing that's fascinating about
- 3:19:45this. In the reconciliation bill, they
- 3:19:47would give $10 billion which I'm glad
- 3:19:48for. I mean, we which I'm glad for. I
- 3:19:50mean, we should be giving money to local
- 3:19:52administrators, but a portion of that is
- 3:19:54intended to help facilitate this. But,
- 3:19:58we'd spend billions of dollars on
- 3:19:59something that isn't even a problem. We
- 3:20:01have plenty of problems in this country
- 3:20:03that actually could use some resources
- 3:20:05to help go to address them. This is not
- 3:20:07one of them.
- 3:20:09>> One of our problems is corruption and
- 3:20:11the what we're seeing in this bill is it
- 3:20:13doesn't address corruption. It just
- 3:20:14makes a voting a little harder and that
- 3:20:16seems par for the course for
- 3:20:18Republicans. And with that, Mr. Mr.
- 3:20:20Chair, I yield back.
- 3:20:24>> Gentleman yields back.
- 3:20:26And now recognize the gentlewoman lady
- 3:20:29from Indiana.
- 3:20:30>> Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Before I get
- 3:20:32into my questions about the Stop Insider
- 3:20:35Trading Act, I want to give Chairman
- 3:20:37Style an opportunity to respond to some
- 3:20:40of the
- 3:20:41um
- 3:20:42concerns that were raised about voter
- 3:20:44identification.
- 3:20:46Um Chairman Style, is there not also an
- 3:20:49affidavit option for those that may or
- 3:20:51may not have IDs? And what else uh
- 3:20:54can you tell us about the ability that
- 3:20:57this provides to give opportunities to
- 3:21:00vote while also safeguarding our
- 3:21:01elections?
- 3:21:04>> You bring up a couple good points. We
- 3:21:07lay out in this bill in particular
- 3:21:09for situations where individuals are
- 3:21:11voting by mail.
- 3:21:13The one can go through the process of
- 3:21:15including your last four digits of your
- 3:21:16social security number as well
- 3:21:18as uh an affidavit. What we want to make
- 3:21:22sure is that everybody is able and
- 3:21:23eligible to vote which builds on the
- 3:21:25previous point which I think is
- 3:21:27important to go back to which is about
- 3:21:29the need for some individuals who may
- 3:21:31not have resources to obtain a free ID.
- 3:21:34In my home state of Wisconsin
- 3:21:36the Department of Transportation
- 3:21:37estimates that the cost of issuing an ID
- 3:21:42knowing that the employees and equipment
- 3:21:43is already there the the cost of issuing
- 3:21:46an ID for an individual who can't afford
- 3:21:48one is a little less than $5 in the
- 3:21:50neighborhood of $4.50.
- 3:21:52Last year in the state of Wisconsin was
- 3:21:54it 2 years ago if my memory serves me
- 3:21:56correctly roughly 100,000 people in the
- 3:21:59state of Wisconsin obtained an ID
- 3:22:01without payment costing the state less
- 3:22:04than half a million dollars. So the
- 3:22:07state of Wisconsin provides that to
- 3:22:08individuals that can't afford it
- 3:22:10recognizing that it's required to vote
- 3:22:13in the state of Wisconsin. Then the
- 3:22:15question becomes how do we pay for that?
- 3:22:16The total cost in a in a federal concept
- 3:22:19is reasonably de minimus half a million
- 3:22:20dollars in the state of Wisconsin about
- 3:22:222% of the United States of America you'd
- 3:22:24run that out nationally and get a pretty
- 3:22:25good idea.
- 3:22:27A few million dollars to make sure
- 3:22:28everybody has it. If an individual
- 3:22:30doesn't have an ID in the United States
- 3:22:31a state issued ID it's really important
- 3:22:34to help that individual get that. So I'm
- 3:22:35I'm a big supporter of making sure that
- 3:22:38states are doing that. Under Supreme
- 3:22:40Court jurisprudence states would be
- 3:22:42required to do that. Whether or not the
- 3:22:44funds come through the expansion of Hava
- 3:22:46grants, whether or not it comes through
- 3:22:49reconciliation,
- 3:22:50whether or not it comes through
- 3:22:51appropriations,
- 3:22:53we can we can work that piece out.
- 3:22:56But I think ultimately to make sure that
- 3:22:57individuals who if there are individuals
- 3:22:59who can't afford a state ID we should
- 3:23:00help them get that. I think that's
- 3:23:02important. As it relates to student IDs
- 3:23:04I think there's a lot of challenges on
- 3:23:05how some again not all but how some
- 3:23:08universities issue their IDs that there
- 3:23:10are is not strict protocols
- 3:23:13as it relates to that in comparison to
- 3:23:16the five ways that we allow for IDs. We
- 3:23:19all recognize that every state issues
- 3:23:21their state ID or state driver's license
- 3:23:24differently. We respect that difference,
- 3:23:26but we all respect that it's a robust
- 3:23:28and secure process.
- 3:23:30And so relying on that, obviously
- 3:23:32somebody has a passport federally issued
- 3:23:35ID, if you will, that's allowed in a
- 3:23:36tribal ID.
- 3:23:38That being the core concept, I think
- 3:23:39strengthens the integrity of our photo
- 3:23:42ID requirement. But again, these are
- 3:23:44common sense and I know some of our
- 3:23:46colleagues on the left struggle when we
- 3:23:49slightly make fun of all the different
- 3:23:51reasons and ways that you need an ID.
- 3:23:54The point is you need it for almost
- 3:23:56everything. So goodness gracious, if you
- 3:23:59need an ID for everything, let's just
- 3:24:00put the standard in place. You need a
- 3:24:02photo ID to vote, so we don't have folks
- 3:24:04going to the polls, voting in federal
- 3:24:06elections in the state of Minnesota this
- 3:24:08November where one person walks in and
- 3:24:11vouches for eight other people. The
- 3:24:13standard needs to be set. You need to
- 3:24:14show photo identification to vote. Now
- 3:24:16ultimately, I'd love to see the whole
- 3:24:18broader package go through
- 3:24:20with other election reforms, but this is
- 3:24:22the most basic, common sense principle
- 3:24:26you can imagine. You need photo
- 3:24:27identification to vote.
- 3:24:29And separate, of course, is legislation
- 3:24:32that prevents members of Congress from
- 3:24:33profiting off of insider information,
- 3:24:35the Stop Insider Trading Act.
- 3:24:37>> Thank you.
- 3:24:38We often hear the Democrats say voter
- 3:24:40fraud is not widespread. And it we look
- 3:24:43only to Bush v. Gore and the closeness
- 3:24:46of that presidential election and and to
- 3:24:49understand and we see it every day in
- 3:24:51our elections. In my own hometown, we
- 3:24:53had a city council race that came down
- 3:24:55to three votes.
- 3:24:57And so it doesn't have to be widespread
- 3:25:00to disenfranchise
- 3:25:02voters across the country. So voter ID
- 3:25:05is a critical component of preventing
- 3:25:07voter fraud
- 3:25:09Um because it doesn't have to be
- 3:25:10widespread to to threaten the integrity
- 3:25:13of our elections in the United States.
- 3:25:16How concerned are you with the
- 3:25:18president's most recent report of
- 3:25:20China's influence in our elections and
- 3:25:23the urgent need to pass not just the
- 3:25:26voter identification provisions in the
- 3:25:28Stop Insider Trading Act, but also
- 3:25:31in Save America.
- 3:25:33>> Well, we we unquestionably know that
- 3:25:34there are actors that want to
- 3:25:36destabilize the US election system.
- 3:25:40And so we should be cognizant of that
- 3:25:41and always working to enhance the
- 3:25:43integrity inside of our elections. To
- 3:25:46your earlier point,
- 3:25:48how many illegal votes or inappropriate
- 3:25:51votes
- 3:25:53should we accept?
- 3:25:54>> Right.
- 3:25:54>> And the obvious answer is zero. And so
- 3:25:56you you referenced Bush v. Gore because
- 3:25:59for all Americans over a certain age,
- 3:26:02they remember that election.
- 3:26:05But for you and I, not too far from our
- 3:26:08home state, Mariannette Miller-Meeks in
- 3:26:10the state of Iowa won her congressional
- 3:26:12seat by six votes. The Democrat who lost
- 3:26:16that race challenged that. Challenges
- 3:26:19come before the Committee on House
- 3:26:20Administration. And so this is when
- 3:26:22Democrats were in control. And they were
- 3:26:24driving forward trying to take
- 3:26:27Mariannette Miller-Meeks out of her duly
- 3:26:30elected position at that time to try to
- 3:26:33expand their majority in the House. And
- 3:26:37so when we know House races because we
- 3:26:40have 435 House races here, there's more
- 3:26:42data points, we know how close some of
- 3:26:46these races are. Many aren't called and
- 3:26:48decided for weeks after the election.
- 3:26:51That is when you recognize how important
- 3:26:54election integrity is
- 3:26:56in nearly divided House and nearly
- 3:26:58divided Senate. Any movement can
- 3:27:01actually swing elections. And so making
- 3:27:03sure that we have this standard
- 3:27:05nationwide
- 3:27:07that we know individuals are showing
- 3:27:08photo identification when they go to the
- 3:27:10polls matters that we know that the
- 3:27:13members that come from for example the
- 3:27:14state of Minnesota are the duly elected
- 3:27:17members that there wasn't shenanigans in
- 3:27:19those elections and I think that's
- 3:27:20really important to do in all 50 states
- 3:27:23and this bill sets the standard and says
- 3:27:25no you need to have photo identification
- 3:27:26when you go to the go to the polls and
- 3:27:28vote in federal elections it matters
- 3:27:31it's important it's common sense and
- 3:27:32it's easy to do.
- 3:27:33>> The House and Senate majorities and the
- 3:27:35presidential election will depend on the
- 3:27:38integrity of these elections so I
- 3:27:39appreciate your work on that and then
- 3:27:41turning to the Stop Insider Trading Act
- 3:27:43members of Congress are elected to serve
- 3:27:45their constituents and the American
- 3:27:47people not profit from non-public
- 3:27:49information
- 3:27:51um
- 3:27:52however
- 3:27:54Americans rightly fear that some members
- 3:27:56of Congress may be using sensitive
- 3:27:58information to benefit their stock
- 3:28:01portfolios.
- 3:28:02Congress passed the Stop Trading on
- 3:28:05Congressional Knowledge the Stock Act in
- 3:28:072012
- 3:28:09so lawmakers are already prohibited from
- 3:28:11using non-public information for their
- 3:28:14own
- 3:28:15financial benefit but many Americans
- 3:28:17including me remain concerned that the
- 3:28:20Stock Act is insufficient and that we
- 3:28:23must implement stronger measures which
- 3:28:25brings me to the Stop Insider Trading
- 3:28:27Act which I appreciate your leadership
- 3:28:29on I'm a proud co-sponsor of this bill
- 3:28:32to to help ensure that members of
- 3:28:33Congress are not able to use their
- 3:28:35public office for private financial gain
- 3:28:38though we did take an important step
- 3:28:40Congress did with the Stock Act more
- 3:28:42than a decade ago it's clear members of
- 3:28:44Congress
- 3:28:46though we are subject to the same
- 3:28:48insider trading laws as every other
- 3:28:50American under the Stock Act
- 3:28:53more needs to be done on this front
- 3:28:55despite the existing safeguards that we
- 3:28:58have, uh the American people remain
- 3:29:00concerned. It's one of the the most um
- 3:29:03I would say responses I've received in
- 3:29:06in uh
- 3:29:07input to the office asking to support
- 3:29:10the Stop Insider Trading Act. So, this
- 3:29:12will build on existing ethics laws,
- 3:29:15strengthening the framework with clear
- 3:29:17common sense guardrails to increase
- 3:29:19transparency and accountability.
- 3:29:21Chairman Style, um from your
- 3:29:23perspective, what shortcomings have
- 3:29:25become apparent since the enactment of
- 3:29:28the STOCK Act more than a decade ago? Uh
- 3:29:30why are additional safeguards necessary?
- 3:29:33And what new restrictions in this bill
- 3:29:37will close those loopholes?
- 3:29:39>> Uh thank thank you very much. Uh you
- 3:29:41note uh the STOCK Act passed about 15
- 3:29:44years ago and what it does and does not
- 3:29:47uh require. One of the challenges that
- 3:29:49we see with the STOCK Act is because the
- 3:29:52reporting is 30 days after the fact uh
- 3:29:55and the reporting is within bands. Uh
- 3:29:58that was noted earlier
- 3:30:00uh by our colleague uh Mr. Scott. Uh
- 3:30:03that that coupled uh with attention in
- 3:30:05particular in the social media space uh
- 3:30:08raises a lot of concerns. The question
- 3:30:10then began, how do you prevent members
- 3:30:12of Congress from profiting off of this
- 3:30:15in the first place? What's What's the
- 3:30:17solution uh recognizing this concern?
- 3:30:20Well, let's let's prevent members from
- 3:30:21profiting off of any inside information
- 3:30:23they gain. And let's make a bright-line
- 3:30:25rule uh that you can't trade. You can't
- 3:30:27continue to buy and sell uh individual
- 3:30:30shares of stock. The bill accomplishes
- 3:30:32that goal. It puts in place a blanket
- 3:30:35rule on the acquisition of individual
- 3:30:36shares of stock. It provides 7 days
- 3:30:39minimum 7 days advance notice uh for the
- 3:30:41sale. That provides the public uh notice
- 3:30:43of any sale. It would gut the ability to
- 3:30:45profit from that. Uh and it would set up
- 3:30:48an individual's uh uh case in the event
- 3:30:51uh that somebody was still trying to
- 3:30:53profit off of insider information, uh,
- 3:30:55to actually be prosecuted and held
- 3:30:56accountable to the law. I think this
- 3:30:58makes meaningful and substantive
- 3:30:59reforms, uh, and it's the types of
- 3:31:01reforms I think we need to pass here in
- 3:31:03the house.
- 3:31:04>> It also, uh, will, uh, ban members of
- 3:31:07Congress and their families from
- 3:31:09purchasing individual stocks. I think
- 3:31:11that's critically important, um, because
- 3:31:14just because members of Congress might
- 3:31:16be banned, uh, their family members may
- 3:31:18also yet currently be able to trade on
- 3:31:22information that may be accessible to
- 3:31:24members of Congress,
- 3:31:26um, and the advanced notice on selling
- 3:31:28those investments I think is a is an
- 3:31:30important step to increase transparency
- 3:31:33and restore public trust. I think this
- 3:31:35is a must-do. I hope we'll get this bill
- 3:31:38through, uh, across the finish line.
- 3:31:40Again, Mr. Chairman, I want to thank you
- 3:31:42for your tremendous leadership on this
- 3:31:44issue. Uh, the American people deserve
- 3:31:46confidence that the decisions, uh, that
- 3:31:48we make are guided by what's best for
- 3:31:50them, not what benefits personal
- 3:31:52investment portfolios. I hope my
- 3:31:54colleagues will support this
- 3:31:56legislation, uh, in this committee and
- 3:31:58on the floor. Thank you.
- 3:32:03>> Mr. Norman, do you have any questions?
- 3:32:07>> Uh, thank thank both of you for
- 3:32:10testifying. You know, there was a lot of
- 3:32:11questions about this before, Brian. You
- 3:32:13heard it in caucus meeting and I think
- 3:32:15others. Has most of this been resolved,
- 3:32:17in your opinion?
- 3:32:19>> Yeah, I actually think that we have a
- 3:32:20product, um, that, uh, should be able to
- 3:32:23garner the support of the overwhelming
- 3:32:24majority of the house.
- 3:32:27>> Joe, do you have any comments?
- 3:32:29>> Well, I do have quite a few, but I'll,
- 3:32:32uh, I'll simply say this, that I think
- 3:32:34at the end of the day, if we want
- 3:32:35Americans to trust us,
- 3:32:37if they want to have faith that the
- 3:32:38decisions we're making are in their
- 3:32:39interest, then we need to get to a point
- 3:32:42where we ban the ownership of individual
- 3:32:46stock by members of Congress, by the
- 3:32:48president, by the vice president. Um
- 3:32:50and until that time that we do and this
- 3:32:52bill doesn't do it,
- 3:32:53uh doesn't really even come close to
- 3:32:55doing it, then I think we're going to
- 3:32:56continue to disappoint the American
- 3:32:58people.
- 3:32:59>> Well, we know things that the ordinary
- 3:33:01public doesn't. We have access to things
- 3:33:04that people don't. And um
- 3:33:06hopefully this safeguards. You know, if
- 3:33:07you're a crook, you can beat any system.
- 3:33:09It doesn't matter what. But there ought
- 3:33:11to be rules on it and uh
- 3:33:13but I didn't get to hear much of your
- 3:33:14testimony, if any, but I heard some of
- 3:33:16the background on it. But thank you for
- 3:33:18each of you for taking the time.
- 3:33:19>> I think you can watch it later tonight
- 3:33:20when you're back in your uh apartment if
- 3:33:23you have a few hours.
- 3:33:24>> Okay.
- 3:33:29Uh Yoder.
- 3:33:30>> Thank you, Mr. Norman. Um seeing no
- 3:33:33further members here to ask any
- 3:33:36questions, I thank our witnesses for
- 3:33:39being here and
- 3:33:41you are excused.
- 3:34:07I now welcome our next panel, Chairman
- 3:34:10Hill, Ranking Member Waters from the
- 3:34:13House Financial Services Committee.
- 3:34:32Your full statements will be submitted
- 3:34:34for the record and we ask that you
- 3:34:37summarize your statement in 5 minutes.
- 3:34:47>> Chairman Hill,
- 3:34:49I welcome your testimony.
- 3:35:06>> Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure
- 3:35:07to be with the Rules Committee today to
- 3:35:10talk about HR 6955,
- 3:35:13which is the Main Street Capital Access
- 3:35:15Act. It was introduced by myself along
- 3:35:17with the
- 3:35:19chair of our subcommittee, Andy Barr of
- 3:35:21Kentucky.
- 3:35:25Since becoming chairman of the
- 3:35:26committee, I've made it a priority to
- 3:35:27restore, strengthen, and vitality to
- 3:35:29America's community banks. These
- 3:35:31institutions are foundational to our
- 3:35:33financial system,
- 3:35:34indispensable to our economy, and a
- 3:35:36unique strength of our country.
- 3:35:40The legislation before you is about one
- 3:35:41simple idea. Let's help community
- 3:35:44lenders make it easier for small
- 3:35:46businesses and entrepreneurs to access
- 3:35:48the capital they need to grow, hire
- 3:35:50workers, and strengthen Main Street
- 3:35:52America.
- 3:35:54For many small businesses, the greatest
- 3:35:56obstacle to expansion is not a lack of
- 3:35:58good ideas or hardworking employees, but
- 3:36:00it's access to financing.
- 3:36:03Community banks and credit unions remain
- 3:36:05the backbone of small business lending
- 3:36:07across the country, particularly in
- 3:36:09rural communities and in smaller cities.
- 3:36:12Recently, during our debates about
- 3:36:14comprehensive housing policy that the
- 3:36:16ranking member and I were engaged in,
- 3:36:19you heard me say
- 3:36:21time and time again that six out of 10
- 3:36:23home construction loans come from our
- 3:36:25community banks under $10 billion.
- 3:36:29Our community banks and their credit
- 3:36:30unions, they know their customers, they
- 3:36:32understand local markets, and they're
- 3:36:34often willing to finance businesses that
- 3:36:36larger institutions overlook.
- 3:36:39Unfortunately, over time outdated
- 3:36:41regulatory requirements have made it
- 3:36:43increasingly difficult for those
- 3:36:44community-focused institutions
- 3:36:47to deploy their capital efficiently.
- 3:36:50Compliance costs have risen dramatically
- 3:36:52and resources that could otherwise be
- 3:36:53used to make loans instead have been
- 3:36:56uh devoted to navigating unnecessary
- 3:36:59regulatory burdens.
- 3:37:02The Main Street Capital Access Act takes
- 3:37:04meaningful steps to modernize these
- 3:37:06requirements while preserving the safety
- 3:37:08and soundness of our financial system.
- 3:37:11It removes barriers that unnecessarily
- 3:37:12restrict the flow of capital to local
- 3:37:14businesses without compromising our
- 3:37:17strong supervisory framework that
- 3:37:19protects consumers and maintains
- 3:37:21confidence in our banking system.
- 3:37:24This legislation recognizes an important
- 3:37:26reality
- 3:37:28that regulation should be tailored to
- 3:37:30risk.
- 3:37:32Requirements designed for the nation's
- 3:37:34largest and most complex financial
- 3:37:36institutions should not automatically
- 3:37:38apply in the same manner to
- 3:37:39community-based lenders whose business
- 3:37:42model is centered on relationship
- 3:37:43banking and serving local communities.
- 3:37:46By improving the regulatory environment
- 3:37:48for these smaller institutions, we
- 3:37:50expand opportunities for small
- 3:37:51businesses that depend on them.
- 3:37:54Several times this year uh Congress has
- 3:37:58uh taken on a strong bipartisan basis
- 3:38:00votes and passed this kind of concept of
- 3:38:03tailored regulatory compliance based on
- 3:38:06business size and complexity.
- 3:38:08This approach means that greater access
- 3:38:10to financing for manufacturers looking
- 3:38:12to purchase new equipment, family-owned
- 3:38:14restaurants seeking to open a second
- 3:38:16location, farmers investing in new
- 3:38:18technology and entrepreneurs starting
- 3:38:20businesses
- 3:38:21right along all of our main streets.
- 3:38:24This is not about weakening oversight.
- 3:38:26It's about making sure that our
- 3:38:28regulatory framework is efficient,
- 3:38:30effective, and appropriately calibrated.
- 3:38:32Strong financial institutions and
- 3:38:34vibrant local economies are
- 3:38:36complementary goals, not competing ones.
- 3:38:39And the benefits of increased access to
- 3:38:41capital extend well beyond individual
- 3:38:42businesses.
- 3:38:44When small businesses can obtain
- 3:38:45financing, they hire employees, increase
- 3:38:47wages, invest in their communities, and
- 3:38:49generate greater economic growth.
- 3:38:52These investments ripple outwards,
- 3:38:54supporting suppliers, creating new
- 3:38:55opportunities, and strengthening local
- 3:38:57tax bases that fund schools,
- 3:38:59infrastructure, and essential public
- 3:39:01services.
- 3:39:03In a time when many many small
- 3:39:04businesses continue to face inflationary
- 3:39:06pressures, higher borrowing costs, and
- 3:39:08economic uncertainty, Congress should be
- 3:39:10looking for practical bipartisan ways to
- 3:39:13remove unneces- unnecessary barriers to
- 3:39:16growth.
- 3:39:17This legislation does precisely that.
- 3:39:19The Main Street Act spurs new bank
- 3:39:21formation, tackles banking deserts, and
- 3:39:24lowers significant barriers for new
- 3:39:27banks.
- 3:39:28It reforms the bank supervisory process
- 3:39:30to make it more transparent.
- 3:39:32The bill brings common sense tailoring
- 3:39:34back to bank regulation based on an
- 3:39:37institution's size, business model, and
- 3:39:39risk profile.
- 3:39:41And it provides certainty around
- 3:39:43regulatory approval of bank mergers and
- 3:39:45acquisitions. The bill improves bank
- 3:39:47resolution framework in a way that
- 3:39:49protects depositors, promotes greater
- 3:39:51competition, and allows smaller banks to
- 3:39:54meaningfully participate in the bidding
- 3:39:56process for the assets of a bank that
- 3:39:58has failed. It helps banks attract,
- 3:40:01retain, and enhance their funding
- 3:40:02sources to better serve American
- 3:40:04families and business.
- 3:40:06All in all, in my view, the Main Street
- 3:40:08Capital Access Act reflects the
- 3:40:10principle that federal policy should
- 3:40:12encourage responsible lending, promote
- 3:40:14economic opportunity, and ensure that
- 3:40:17our community financial institutions can
- 3:40:18continue to serve the businesses and
- 3:40:20families that rely on them every day. I
- 3:40:23urge my colleagues to support H.R. 6955,
- 3:40:26and I thank the chair, and I yield back
- 3:40:28the balance of my time.
- 3:40:30>> Thank you, Chairman Hill.
- 3:40:32Ranking Member Waters, you're
- 3:40:33recognized.
- 3:40:34>> Thank you very much.
- 3:40:36Thank you, Chair Powell.
- 3:40:38We all care about community banks and
- 3:40:40credit unions. For that reason, I was
- 3:40:42pleased to work with Chair Hill on a
- 3:40:44package of community bank provisions
- 3:40:47included in our landmark housing bill,
- 3:40:51the 21st Century Road to Housing Act.
- 3:40:54Oh, there it is.
- 3:40:56Now, even though Trump refused to sign
- 3:40:58it, that legislation has become the law
- 3:41:00of the land. And those provisions help
- 3:41:04community lenders and not mega banks,
- 3:41:08big tech,
- 3:41:09payment apps, or even payday lenders,
- 3:41:13debt collectors, and credit bureaus.
- 3:41:16Unfortunately, that is not the case for
- 3:41:18the bill before you today.
- 3:41:21HR 6955
- 3:41:23is a Wall Street deregulation hiding as
- 3:41:27a community bank bill. This package is
- 3:41:29made up of 24 Republican bills with just
- 3:41:33two Democratic bills. Tomorrow, Madam
- 3:41:36Chair, we mark the 16th anniversary of
- 3:41:39the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
- 3:41:42Community Protection Act becoming a law.
- 3:41:46That law was passed in response to the
- 3:41:492008 financial crisis when, in case my
- 3:41:53Republican colleagues have forgotten,
- 3:41:57millions of Americans lost their jobs,
- 3:41:59their homes, and their life savings. But
- 3:42:02this package ignores those lessons and
- 3:42:05rolls back a long list of safeguards and
- 3:42:08oversight of the largest banks.
- 3:42:10Importantly,
- 3:42:11the nation is grappling with an
- 3:42:14affordable affordability crisis and
- 3:42:17surge in financial scams and fraud
- 3:42:20costing consumers tens of billions of
- 3:42:23dollars. This is all made worse because
- 3:42:27Trump has shut down the Consumer
- 3:42:30Financial Protection Bureau. Voting for
- 3:42:32HR 6955
- 3:42:34would add insult to injury by hampering
- 3:42:38a future CFPB from issuing new rules
- 3:42:42such as reigning in debt collectors or
- 3:42:44abusive medical debt practices. But
- 3:42:47maybe that is the point. Furthermore,
- 3:42:51Madam Chair, this bill ignores the
- 3:42:53lessons from the failure of Silicon
- 3:42:55Valley Bank and other regional banks
- 3:42:58just 3 years ago.
- 3:43:00These large regional banks failed
- 3:43:04after Congress rolled back capital,
- 3:43:07liquidity, and other rules specifically
- 3:43:09for those banks.
- 3:43:11Nevertheless, this bill lets even
- 3:43:14more
- 3:43:15of these large banks escape critical
- 3:43:18safeguards, risking more failures. In
- 3:43:21fact, the sponsors of this bill were so
- 3:43:24zealous to raise thresholds they
- 3:43:27increased one threshold that will add
- 3:43:30bad actors who commit fraud against a
- 3:43:33bank. Yes, you can't make this up.
- 3:43:35There's a provision that will increase
- 3:43:37the amount individuals can defraud
- 3:43:41absolutely
- 3:43:44at a bank by then
- 3:43:47turn around and obtain subsidized
- 3:43:50financing from the government for those
- 3:43:52assets from the failed bank. HR 6955
- 3:43:56also falls well short of what we know
- 3:43:59can be done on a bipartisan basis to
- 3:44:02promote, preserve, and enhance access to
- 3:44:05banking services for Main Street
- 3:44:07communities. I have a letter led by the
- 3:44:10National Community Reinvestment
- 3:44:13Coalition and signed by organizations
- 3:44:16all over the country, including Alabama,
- 3:44:20Kansas, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, and
- 3:44:23Utah.
- 3:44:25They are opposed because the bill would,
- 3:44:28quote, sharply
- 3:44:31limit monopoly and competition review
- 3:44:34for mergers involving roughly 96%
- 3:44:38of all banks.
- 3:44:42Compress merger review
- 3:44:45and sideline community evidence and
- 3:44:49weaken fair lending accountability.
- 3:44:52Americans for Financial Reform and other
- 3:44:55leading consumer group organization
- 3:44:57wrote a letter saying, and I quote,
- 3:45:01"This radical legislation would compound
- 3:45:04an already aggressive deregulatory
- 3:45:08spree. Taken together, these changes
- 3:45:11would be more damaging than the
- 3:45:15sum of their parts, leaving the
- 3:45:17financial system dramatically weaker and
- 3:45:20more vulnerable to instability and
- 3:45:22crisis, quote, unquote." Now,
- 3:45:25Republicans made a few technical changes
- 3:45:27at the request of Trump regulators, but
- 3:45:30let me give you another example what
- 3:45:32they didn't change. Wells Fargo, which
- 3:45:35many of you may remember, created
- 3:45:37millions of fake consumer accounts and
- 3:45:40has been the subject of countless
- 3:45:42enforcement actions for consumer harm,
- 3:45:45like discrimination and anti-money
- 3:45:49laundering deficiencies, would have a
- 3:45:51new tool to delay future enforcement
- 3:45:55actions even when consumers have been
- 3:45:57harmed. Madam Chair, instead of letting
- 3:46:01Wall Street put Americans and our
- 3:46:03economy at risk again, we should be
- 3:46:06working together to address the
- 3:46:07affordability crisis caused by Trump's
- 3:46:10failed economic policies
- 3:46:13and endless war with Iran. So,
- 3:46:17I urge members to oppose this bill and I
- 3:46:19yield back the balance of my time.
- 3:46:23>> Um thank you both. I'm going to defer my
- 3:46:27questions for
- 3:46:28um a little bit. Mr. Norman, do you have
- 3:46:31any questions? I'm sorry, Mr. Griffith.
- 3:46:33I should ask Mr. Griffith first. No.
- 3:46:35>> I have no questions.
- 3:46:36>> No questions.
- 3:46:38Ms. Scanlon.
- 3:46:40>> Thank you. I think we agree America
- 3:46:42needs a strong financial system that
- 3:46:45supports community banks and credit
- 3:46:47unions and small businesses because
- 3:46:49they're the backbones of our our local
- 3:46:52economies, but
- 3:46:53we're concerned because of it instead of
- 3:46:55advancing targeted reforms to support
- 3:46:58those institutions, what we have here is
- 3:47:01bundling together of the largest package
- 3:47:03of banking and Wall Street deregulations
- 3:47:06since the 2008 financial crisis and
- 3:47:10it's just pretending to say that this is
- 3:47:12going to help Main Street instead of
- 3:47:14mega banks.
- 3:47:16Meanwhile, President Trump has spent the
- 3:47:18last year and a half dismantling the
- 3:47:20Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,
- 3:47:23the agency that actually does protect
- 3:47:26families from predatory financial
- 3:47:27practices. So, we know the president's
- 3:47:30actions have already cost American
- 3:47:32consumers an estimated
- 3:47:36in dismissed enforcement cases, pardoned
- 3:47:39fraudsters,
- 3:47:41rescinded rules, and the gutting of the
- 3:47:43consumer complaint system. This bill
- 3:47:45would go even further by weakening the
- 3:47:47ability of banking regulators to protect
- 3:47:51consumers and preserve financial
- 3:47:53stability.
- 3:47:54I mean, if our Republican colleagues
- 3:47:56were serious about supporting Main
- 3:47:58Street, they would work across the aisle
- 3:48:00on targeted reforms that strengthen
- 3:48:02community banks without weakening the
- 3:48:04safeguards that protect consumers and
- 3:48:08taxpayers and the economy. Instead, once
- 3:48:11again, this bill asks the American
- 3:48:13people to take on more financial risk so
- 3:48:16the banking industry can make more money
- 3:48:18and face less accountability.
- 3:48:21So, you know, I'm not in favor of
- 3:48:23putting the thumb on the scale for
- 3:48:25billionaires and big businesses and and
- 3:48:27leaving the American people to shoulder
- 3:48:29the risk.
- 3:48:30Um Ranking Member Waters
- 3:48:33after the financial crisis in 2008, uh
- 3:48:36Congress established a number of
- 3:48:38regulatory thresholds and supervisory
- 3:48:41authorities that this bill would change
- 3:48:43or roll back.
- 3:48:45Um can you explain why those guardrails
- 3:48:47exist and what could happen if
- 3:48:49regulators lose the tools they need to
- 3:48:52identify problems before they become
- 3:48:54crises? And I think you mentioned some
- 3:48:56California banks.
- 3:48:57>> Well, thank you, uh Representative
- 3:48:59Scholten. I just want to say in the way
- 3:49:02that you have described uh your
- 3:49:04concerns, that's exactly what is
- 3:49:07happening with this bill. As a matter of
- 3:49:09fact, I do believe uh that we have to be
- 3:49:12concerned about members who say that
- 3:49:16they support community banks, uh but
- 3:49:19really uh they are
- 3:49:21using this as a way to hide uh the
- 3:49:25deregulatory efforts that have been made
- 3:49:28by uh some members on the opposite side
- 3:49:30of the aisle. And to tell you the truth,
- 3:49:33I think that with all of the good work
- 3:49:36that we have done uh with the big
- 3:49:38housing bill, Mr. Hill and I working
- 3:49:40together, uh bipartisan effort, this
- 3:49:43will hurt some of what we've
- 3:49:46accomplished in making sure uh that we
- 3:49:49get rid of deregulatory work uh by many
- 3:49:53of those who would like to see the big
- 3:49:55banks uh continue uh to have more power
- 3:49:59and more control than they should. I
- 3:50:01reference uh
- 3:50:03Wells Fargo uh when I spoke just a
- 3:50:06moment ago. Everybody remembers the fake
- 3:50:09accounts uh that were set up. Everybody
- 3:50:11knows we worked very hard. We worked so
- 3:50:14hard we were able to undo those who sat
- 3:50:18on the board and the CEO uh at one point
- 3:50:21so that we could try and clean up uh
- 3:50:24what was happening Wells Fargo. Well,
- 3:50:26Wells Fargo really doesn't mind. It is a
- 3:50:29cost of doing business. We don't want
- 3:50:32our banks uh to be able uh to undermine
- 3:50:36um this kind of work that we have done
- 3:50:39um in order to uh save face, you know,
- 3:50:43for the big banks. And so, this bill
- 3:50:46does not do uh what I think some will
- 3:50:49think it does in terms of support for
- 3:50:52community banks. In fact, I think will
- 3:50:55undermine much of the work that we have
- 3:50:57done.
- 3:50:59>> Well, I I do want to take the
- 3:51:00opportunity to thank Chairman Hill and
- 3:51:03yourself for the the incredible work you
- 3:51:05did in putting together the bipartisan
- 3:51:07housing bill and uh overcoming a number
- 3:51:09of obstacles, not the least of which is
- 3:51:11always the Senate, to get that get that
- 3:51:14passed and hopefully start
- 3:51:16providing more housing options for
- 3:51:18Americans cuz I'm sure you hear as I do
- 3:51:20all the time how much housing problems
- 3:51:22are just driving uh so much of what's
- 3:51:25going on in our communities. So, thank
- 3:51:27you for your work on that. I yield back.
- 3:51:30>> Thank you, Ms. Kelly. Mr. Norman.
- 3:51:33>> As As one of the I'll thank both of you
- 3:51:35for coming. This is one of the few times
- 3:51:36I've actually I think you're kind of
- 3:51:37happy with this bill, which is a good
- 3:51:39thing.
- 3:51:40Uh now, I appreciate your
- 3:51:42bipartisanship. Um Chairman Hill, the
- 3:51:46CAMELS rating has been a
- 3:51:48subject of a lot of discussion. I know
- 3:51:50in my banking days
- 3:51:51where they felt like it was too much was
- 3:51:53left up to the
- 3:51:55whoever was judging
- 3:51:57the sensitivity, the capital adequacy,
- 3:51:59the
- 3:52:00has the appeals process, is there a time
- 3:52:03limit? I noticed that's in there. If
- 3:52:05some if if a
- 3:52:07examiner's not
- 3:52:09fair and doesn't have the ratings that
- 3:52:11they feel is
- 3:52:13is there an adequate time for the appeal
- 3:52:15process and is there ending time to get
- 3:52:17an answer on it?
- 3:52:19>> I appreciate that, Mr. Norman, and let
- 3:52:20me start out by saying that I couldn't
- 3:52:23disagree more with uh the ranking
- 3:52:25member's opening statement on her
- 3:52:27positioning of this bill. This bill is
- 3:52:28aimed at the heart of America's consumer
- 3:52:31uh banking companies are community
- 3:52:34lenders. There's nothing in this bill
- 3:52:35that's going to
- 3:52:36benefit the biggest banks in the
- 3:52:38country. In fact, to the contrary, this
- 3:52:40bill makes our local community banks and
- 3:52:42our small regional banks
- 3:52:44much more competitive with those big
- 3:52:47global Wall Street banks. It's just a
- 3:52:49fact. In fact, this bill allows them to
- 3:52:51now compete dramatically for both
- 3:52:54deposits and for resolution of banks
- 3:52:57when they fail so that these failed
- 3:52:59banks don't automatically go in the
- 3:53:01hands of one of the biggest banks
- 3:53:03headquartered in uh
- 3:53:05in New York, for example.
- 3:53:07And I can walk through the more detail
- 3:53:09on that as we go through the the
- 3:53:10evening, but let me answer your
- 3:53:11question, Mr. Norman. Uh Don Riegle, a
- 3:53:14Democratic Senator from Michigan in the
- 3:53:161990s,
- 3:53:17said that one of the biggest
- 3:53:18frustrations he heard from his
- 3:53:20constituents
- 3:53:21in the Riegle-Neal bill that was signed
- 3:53:23into law in the 1990s by President
- 3:53:25Clinton,
- 3:53:27uh that bill said that banks ought to be
- 3:53:29able to question and examine output in
- 3:53:32some orderly way to have an ombudsman uh
- 3:53:36to allow them to assess with an
- 3:53:38independent view whether the bank had
- 3:53:40been treated fairly or not. And this was
- 3:53:42after uh really 10 tumultuous years in
- 3:53:46the economy in the 1980s where a lot of
- 3:53:48banks failed all across the country and
- 3:53:50a lot of savings and loans failed.
- 3:53:52But the government never really fully
- 3:53:54implemented that and so in this bill we
- 3:53:56have a provision that allows I think for
- 3:53:59a much more fair examination process
- 3:54:02that we got technical assistance from
- 3:54:04the regulators and from bankers. Is this
- 3:54:06a fair process by which people could
- 3:54:09question and examine? But I believe
- 3:54:11that's represented in the bill. And also
- 3:54:13we facilitated in the bill that if
- 3:54:15they're not satisfied through that
- 3:54:16process they can go to federal court, of
- 3:54:18course, which is every citizen's right.
- 3:54:21>> Okay, thank you. Maxine, you have any
- 3:54:23comment on that?
- 3:54:24>> Well, you know, I'm just looking
- 3:54:27at what
- 3:54:28is in this legislation. Voting for HR
- 3:54:326955
- 3:54:33would add insult to injury by hampering
- 3:54:37a future CFPB from issuing new rules
- 3:54:41such as reigning in debt collectors or
- 3:54:43abusive medical debt practices. But
- 3:54:46maybe that is the point. I guess all
- 3:54:49that I'm saying when I point to Consumer
- 3:54:52Financial Protection Bureau is
- 3:54:55there's still a lot of work to be done
- 3:54:58to help our constituents. I want to tell
- 3:55:01you something I just read
- 3:55:03on the plane coming out.
- 3:55:06Walmart
- 3:55:07is putting beef under lock and key
- 3:55:11because the thievery that is going on by
- 3:55:14people who can't afford the increased
- 3:55:17price of beef anymore is just running
- 3:55:22you know, their profit margins on beef.
- 3:55:24And so why is this happening? It is
- 3:55:27happening because we have an
- 3:55:29affordability crisis. We need to be
- 3:55:32paying attention to what we do to
- 3:55:34protect our consumers. The Consumer
- 3:55:37Financial Protection Bureau is there to
- 3:55:41make sure that our big agencies who have
- 3:55:44so much power are not working on behalf
- 3:55:47of just big banks, but on behalf of
- 3:55:50small banks. We can't excuse them or we
- 3:55:53can't let them off the hook. As a matter
- 3:55:55of fact, if you really want to do
- 3:55:57something for a community banks,
- 3:55:58separate
- 3:56:00big banks from community banks in a real
- 3:56:03way instead of hiding big banks hiding
- 3:56:06behind legislation supposedly for
- 3:56:09community banks.
- 3:56:10>> Well, thank thank both of you
- 3:56:12testifying. Appreciate it. I yield back.
- 3:56:15>> Thank you, Mr. Norman. Miss Leja
- 3:56:17Fernandez.
- 3:56:18>> Uh thank you so very much uh
- 3:56:22Madam Chair for recognizing me and and
- 3:56:24for the conversation today. Uh you know,
- 3:56:26one of uh
- 3:56:27I'm a big fan of
- 3:56:29uh
- 3:56:30the Consumer Financial Protection
- 3:56:31Bureau.
- 3:56:32Uh
- 3:56:33and I'm also very concerned that what
- 3:56:35we're seeing is President Trump is
- 3:56:37regularly pardoning
- 3:56:39fraudsters
- 3:56:41uh who provide
- 3:56:43tens of thousands, sometimes millions to
- 3:56:46his campaign or to his family's uh
- 3:56:50businesses and so forth. But who's
- 3:56:53standing up and fighting for consumers?
- 3:56:56Who's fighting for working families?
- 3:56:58Who's fighting for the people who are
- 3:57:00holding those credit cards, who are
- 3:57:02seeing those big banks gouge them? And
- 3:57:06uh that has in the past been the
- 3:57:07Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's.
- 3:57:10And uh before President Trump took off
- 3:57:14uh office, uh the CFPB
- 3:57:17had returned $21 billion
- 3:57:21to Americans cheated by scammers. $21
- 3:57:23billion. Yes.
- 3:57:24Right? And that's their money.
- 3:57:27>> That's right.
- 3:57:27>> That's their money.
- 3:57:29Uh and but what we're seeing is that
- 3:57:31he's
- 3:57:32taken an axe to this great Consumer
- 3:57:35Protection Bureau. He's fired staff uh
- 3:57:39and uh this has cost consumers. And so,
- 3:57:42what does this bill do to protect the
- 3:57:45Consumer Financial Protection Bureau? I
- 3:57:47mean, it needs protecting now, too,
- 3:57:48doesn't it, uh, Ranking Member Waters?
- 3:57:51>> Well, um, you aptly mentioned the
- 3:57:54Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,
- 3:57:56which many of us have fought so hard uh,
- 3:57:59to have someplace for our consumers uh,
- 3:58:01to register their complaints. Prior to
- 3:58:04the Consumer Financial Protection
- 3:58:06Bureau, there was no place really in
- 3:58:08government uh, that uh, the average
- 3:58:11consumer uh, could lodge a complaint.
- 3:58:14Well, I want you to know that the
- 3:58:15Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- 3:58:17have to millions, and you just mentioned
- 3:58:20uh, the return of uh,
- 3:58:22of assets and money and whatever uh,
- 3:58:25that our consumers were able uh, to
- 3:58:27experience. And so, if we don't have a
- 3:58:29Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,
- 3:58:32those people who are being treated
- 3:58:34badly, who have been ripped off, uh, who
- 3:58:37have been taken advantage of, really uh,
- 3:58:40don't have anywhere to go. And so, we've
- 3:58:43got to look out really for the consumer
- 3:58:46banks. We all Everybody knows that I and
- 3:58:49many of you, we really support the small
- 3:58:52banks. We really support the community
- 3:58:55banks. We wouldn't do anything uh, to
- 3:58:58undermine the community banks, but this
- 3:59:00bill
- 3:59:01does that. It really undermines their
- 3:59:04ability to have a voice, uh, to have
- 3:59:07someone that's going to speak up for
- 3:59:10them when they have been defrauded,
- 3:59:12etc., etc. And so, we've got to fight
- 3:59:15against the bill. I know what some
- 3:59:16people will be tricked, and they'll
- 3:59:18think that they'll be helping community
- 3:59:20banks. Not true. And so, I'm hopeful
- 3:59:23that we're able to get the message out
- 3:59:25so that people will understand like you
- 3:59:27do exactly uh, what we have to be aware
- 3:59:30of.
- 3:59:32>> Uh, with that, Madam Chair, you're back.
- 3:59:35>> Thank you very much.
- 3:59:37Um Chairman Hill, I appreciated the
- 3:59:40comments that you made having grown up
- 3:59:43in an extremely rural area.
- 3:59:46I'm
- 3:59:47I'm very familiar with um
- 3:59:50how important rural banking is.
- 3:59:53Um
- 3:59:54and I have very strong feelings about
- 3:59:58how bad Dodd-Frank has been over the
- 4:00:01years.
- 4:00:02And I'm glad that to see your committee
- 4:00:05coming in
- 4:00:07to correct some some of the problems
- 4:00:11with Dodd-Frank.
- 4:00:13Um
- 4:00:15I I
- 4:00:17don't think that this hides the
- 4:00:20deregulatory effort on the part of
- 4:00:23Republicans. I think I'm we're very
- 4:00:25proud of the deregulatory efforts that
- 4:00:28we're putting out there.
- 4:00:30And um what I am cu-
- 4:00:33growing up again in a rural area, I'm
- 4:00:36quite familiar with how banks know how
- 4:00:38to make decisions because they know the
- 4:00:41people, they know the area. They can
- 4:00:44make a lot of great decisions based on
- 4:00:48on the area. And frankly,
- 4:00:50I get a little put out with the people
- 4:00:53who want to help us poor rural people
- 4:00:56whose institutions just can't get along
- 4:01:00without big regulations from Washington,
- 4:01:03D.C. when they do much better.
- 4:01:07The bank in my community was a very
- 4:01:09small bank
- 4:01:12forever and ever and ever,
- 4:01:14the most profitable small bank in the
- 4:01:17United States for a long time.
- 4:01:20And did a wonderful job.
- 4:01:23Um
- 4:01:24Uh Ms. Waters,
- 4:01:26you bring up the beef under lock and
- 4:01:28key.
- 4:01:30What about those flash mobs out in
- 4:01:32California who came into the drug stores
- 4:01:36and the jewelry stores and stole when
- 4:01:38our economy was at its best
- 4:01:41in this country.
- 4:01:43It isn't It isn't the economy. It isn't
- 4:01:46the affordability that makes people
- 4:01:48thieves.
- 4:01:51It's bad values on their part.
- 4:01:55Um so I thank you both for coming today
- 4:01:58and bringing this good bill to us.
- 4:02:02And I look forward to
- 4:02:03>> I'm sure my uh
- 4:02:04>> discussing it. You have something you'd
- 4:02:06like to add.
- 4:02:06>> I'd like to add just because uh
- 4:02:09a couple things. The this bill is
- 4:02:11completely tailored to small banks.
- 4:02:15Just a few weeks ago on the House floor
- 4:02:17on the suspension calendar
- 4:02:19uh we gave regulatory relief on the
- 4:02:23suspension calendar a 100% vote in this
- 4:02:26House
- 4:02:27by voice
- 4:02:28to tailor regulatory compliance for
- 4:02:31banks under $6 billion. Of
- 4:02:34Of the 5,000 banks in this country,
- 4:02:36probably 4,500 of them are under $6
- 4:02:39billion. And it's precisely that theme
- 4:02:42that is in this bill.
- 4:02:44So first of all, this bill is absolutely
- 4:02:47written and tailored to uh small
- 4:02:50community banks both rural and urban.
- 4:02:52And if it's not, then why did the
- 4:02:53Opportunity Finance Network
- 4:02:56uh all across the country representing
- 4:02:58500 community development lenders? What
- 4:03:00about the National Bankers Association
- 4:03:02of African American Banks? What about
- 4:03:05the CDFI Coalition of urban, rural, and
- 4:03:08native communities uh nationwide? And
- 4:03:11the Community Development Bankers
- 4:03:12Association all support this bill
- 4:03:16strongly because it has that balance in
- 4:03:18it.
- 4:03:19And then this assertion that
- 4:03:21this is weakening consumer protection or
- 4:03:23consumer laws, nothing think it further
- 4:03:25from the case.
- 4:03:26>> believe that at all. I I don't believe
- 4:03:28that is that assertion at all.
- 4:03:31I appreciate you speaking up. We
- 4:03:34we need to get Would you like to get
- 4:03:36those on the in the record?
- 4:03:37>> Well, I just would I would just simply
- 4:03:38say that there's this bill in no way
- 4:03:41weakens consumer protection. Uh
- 4:03:44the
- 4:03:45laws on safety and soundness, like if
- 4:03:48you want to stop a bank from unsafe or
- 4:03:50unsound activity, are fully uh able to
- 4:03:53be implemented in the statute. And the
- 4:03:55same for consumer compliance on fair
- 4:03:58housing, fair lending, equal
- 4:04:00opportunity, uh credit opportunity. All
- 4:04:02those laws are in place and fully
- 4:04:04implementable by our supervisors.
- 4:04:06>> Well, without objection, I can insert
- 4:04:09those letters
- 4:04:09>> Yeah, without objection, I'll I'll
- 4:04:10>> of support um for for this for this bill
- 4:04:14and for community banking. I know the
- 4:04:16community bankers in North Carolina, and
- 4:04:19I know how good they are.
- 4:04:20>> Madam Chair, may I
- 4:04:21>> Well, I'm going to I'm going to
- 4:04:23recognize Mr. Scott.
- 4:04:25>> Okay.
- 4:04:25>> Miss Waters.
- 4:04:28>> Madam Chair,
- 4:04:29uh
- 4:04:30I appreciate
- 4:04:31um
- 4:04:34the chair and the
- 4:04:35ranking member being here today. Um I
- 4:04:38Mr. Hill, do you have any further
- 4:04:40comments on the bill? I mean, I know I'm
- 4:04:42from a small town,
- 4:04:44and
- 4:04:45uh regulatory relief for small banks I
- 4:04:47think is important.
- 4:04:49>> Well, I ran one of those small banks
- 4:04:51before I was in Congress. I ran it
- 4:04:53successfully throughout the financial
- 4:04:54crisis. Our bank grew and was more
- 4:04:56profitable
- 4:04:57in the years of the financial crisis and
- 4:04:59following the financial crisis. And but
- 4:05:02we were operated in very small rural
- 4:05:04counties, like 10,000 people in the
- 4:05:06county in the Mississippi Delta.
- 4:05:08And I know that I spent more time
- 4:05:10worried about the next compliance exam
- 4:05:12or hiring the next compliance officer
- 4:05:14than I did than hiring the next loan
- 4:05:16officer
- 4:05:17because of
- 4:05:19the one-size-fits-all approach on
- 4:05:22consumer compliance and safety and
- 4:05:24soundness laws. And what we do here is
- 4:05:27without
- 4:05:28compromising compliance or compromising
- 4:05:31safety and soundness, we tailor it to
- 4:05:32the business mission, size, and
- 4:05:34complexity of the institution. And I
- 4:05:37think this will really help particularly
- 4:05:38small rural institutions. I was just in
- 4:05:41the chairwoman's state earlier today
- 4:05:44with a group of small
- 4:05:46banks from around North Carolina and and
- 4:05:48they explained to me how they thought
- 4:05:50this would benefit them specifically in
- 4:05:52that regard. And if they are better off,
- 4:05:54then their customers are better off.
- 4:05:56>> That's exactly right.
- 4:05:57>> You're You're back to the gentleman.
- 4:05:59>> I I don't I don't do much banking
- 4:06:00anymore, unfortunately. Uh but I look
- 4:06:03forward to the day when I'm
- 4:06:05back in business and banking again, and
- 4:06:07I look forward to walking into a small
- 4:06:09community bank where they know me and I
- 4:06:10know them, and I'm not just a number
- 4:06:12like you are with a Bank of America or
- 4:06:15one of those big boys.
- 4:06:16>> know, you raise a good point there
- 4:06:17because I mentioned at the top that six
- 4:06:20out of 10 home construction loans are
- 4:06:22made by banks under 10 billion.
- 4:06:25If you ask the biggest banks
- 4:06:27in the country, what is your home
- 4:06:29construction portfolio in Arkansas? And
- 4:06:31the answer will be, "None. We don't do
- 4:06:33that business."
- 4:06:34>> Ag is what?
- 4:06:35>> And the pandemic
- 4:06:36exposed that the biggest banks, like
- 4:06:39Bank of America or other I'm not picking
- 4:06:41on Bank of America's, but the largest
- 4:06:42five to 10 banks
- 4:06:44have a credit requirement and a credit
- 4:06:46box that doesn't facilitate reaching out
- 4:06:49to a lot of small, rural,
- 4:06:51entrepreneurial, or local farm or local
- 4:06:53businesses. And that's why small our
- 4:06:55Main Street banks are essential. We
- 4:06:57don't want to be Canada
- 4:06:59with four banks. We want to have a
- 4:07:01diverse in size and diverse in location
- 4:07:04financial system. This bank This bill,
- 4:07:06the Main Street bill, will aid Main
- 4:07:08Street, not Wall Street, and help
- 4:07:09achieve that.
- 4:07:10>> I know BB&T and SunTrust weren't
- 4:07:12necessarily your
- 4:07:14hometown community bank, but they
- 4:07:15originated that way and kind of kind of
- 4:07:17bought them and you know, kind of the
- 4:07:19the bigger they get
- 4:07:21the the less important you are to them
- 4:07:23and the less customer service you get
- 4:07:24out of them. And so I I'll just tell you
- 4:07:27the the small banks are the ones that
- 4:07:29that I very much want to make sure we're
- 4:07:30taking care of and I trust you
- 4:07:32uh Chairman Hill to do that. And so uh
- 4:07:35and and competition is good for the
- 4:07:37marketplace because that's where
- 4:07:39customer service will will will succeed.
- 4:07:41With that, Madam Chair, you
- 4:07:43>> Thank you very much. I thank our
- 4:07:45witnesses for being here.
- 4:07:47We have no other members here to ask
- 4:07:49questions. So, thank you all very much
- 4:07:51for patiently waiting.
- 4:07:54>> And uh
- 4:07:56appreciate your
- 4:07:57being here.
- 4:08:03I need a statement about
- 4:08:05and then
- 4:08:07No, okay.
- 4:08:24>> You want to remember this now?
- 4:08:25>> I now welcome Ms. Bartz, Mr. Magaziner,
- 4:08:29and Mr. Davidson.
- 4:08:41Um
- 4:08:43Ms. Bartz, you may submit your written
- 4:08:45testimony and we ask you to keep your
- 4:08:47remarks to 5 minutes.
- 4:08:51Yeah, pull it close to you, sir.
- 4:08:55>> Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair.
- 4:08:58Um I want to explain why I did this
- 4:09:00amendment. Actually, this is an issue
- 4:09:02that came to my attention last week. Uh
- 4:09:06it was on the floor when we had
- 4:09:08discussion about take care of America's
- 4:09:10Veterans Act and there was a lot of
- 4:09:13confusion so variety ways to look at how
- 4:09:16one to make sure that we going to fund
- 4:09:19the benefits for people when we go to
- 4:09:21send them to wars we're going to send
- 4:09:23them in the military and there was some
- 4:09:25concerns you know to be able to fund the
- 4:09:27Richard Star Act you know that
- 4:09:30you know we would
- 4:09:32you know codify some of the VA actions
- 4:09:35that could potentially could cut
- 4:09:37benefits for future veterans and current
- 4:09:39military. So I think you know to be fair
- 4:09:42I think we need to make sure that if we
- 4:09:44send people to war we're going to find
- 4:09:45the benefits for them so including the
- 4:09:48current military. So I think there is a
- 4:09:50better solution. I think it should be
- 4:09:51bipartisan issue. So and you know major
- 4:09:55Richard so I think most probably
- 4:09:56committee familiar what is this act is
- 4:09:58so it's kind of fixes in some way
- 4:10:00loophole if you are in the military and
- 4:10:03you're medically discharged
- 4:10:05and to your combat related military you
- 4:10:08are not there for 20 years so you cannot
- 4:10:10get fully full military retirement and
- 4:10:12full VA disability is offset but
- 4:10:15ultimately if you got injured in combat
- 4:10:18you probably couldn't stay you know for
- 4:10:2020 years. So I think it's fair for these
- 4:10:22people who actually get these injuries
- 4:10:24that they can get both and
- 4:10:27I think this act which is I think the
- 4:10:29fiscal of this act about 9.4 billion you
- 4:10:33know but this is germane to this
- 4:10:34reconciliation where we're going to be
- 4:10:36funding
- 4:10:38Department of War and that's who is
- 4:10:41actually going to provide for military
- 4:10:43retirement full military retirement
- 4:10:45pension.
- 4:10:47I think this is you know should be a
- 4:10:49partisan issue. Representative Jen Jeff
- 4:10:52Van Drew and Anna Paulina Luna
- 4:10:54co-sponsored this amendment. I really
- 4:10:56appreciate that and
- 4:10:58I know that we're going to be dealing
- 4:10:59with some offsets later which is fine
- 4:11:02you know but we Samson could
- 4:11:05be dealing with this situation And
- 4:11:07whatever VA does, really, they can do
- 4:11:10some efficiencies, they can change some
- 4:11:11things. You know, if they change
- 4:11:13something, there are some savings, it
- 4:11:14still goes to the bottom line to go to
- 4:11:16our national debt. So, ultimately, if VA
- 4:11:18is going to be saving something, 20
- 4:11:21billion, you know, 19 billion roughly,
- 4:11:23so we'll still be 10 billions of savings
- 4:11:25if we just fund this particular act
- 4:11:27because these people truly deserve to
- 4:11:30have, you know, full pay, full
- 4:11:32retirement pension and compensation. So,
- 4:11:34I think my man is very simple. It just
- 4:11:36increases that what CBO's score said. It
- 4:11:38costs us 9.4 billion to be able to, you
- 4:11:41know, treat our treat our veterans and
- 4:11:43military fairly. So, and this is just
- 4:11:46adds to the reconciliation as a separate
- 4:11:48amendment and you know, seems like it
- 4:11:51should be not even a partisan issue. I'd
- 4:11:53appreciate your support and in the long
- 4:11:56run, you know, I think it will also
- 4:11:58might even be able to save us money. But
- 4:12:00regardless what it is, if we send people
- 4:12:02to war, we should fund their benefits
- 4:12:04when they come back. We have a lot of
- 4:12:05heroic people serving in the military in
- 4:12:07tough situations and we as a country
- 4:12:09should appreciate that and I believe
- 4:12:11this is the best and brightest of our
- 4:12:13country that save our republic, fight
- 4:12:16for our republic. So, I would appreciate
- 4:12:18bipartisan support of this amendment and
- 4:12:20happy to answer any questions.
- 4:12:22Kilbuck.
- 4:12:24>> Mr. Magazine.
- 4:12:29>> Thank you, Madam Chair and members of
- 4:12:31the committee.
- 4:12:32I come before you tonight disappointed
- 4:12:34but not surprised.
- 4:12:37I came to Congress to fight corruption.
- 4:12:40To stop bribes, to get dark money out of
- 4:12:42our elections, to ban members of
- 4:12:44Congress from profiting off their
- 4:12:46positions by trading on inside
- 4:12:49information.
- 4:12:50And for a brief moment, I thought we
- 4:12:52might actually get it done this year.
- 4:12:54I worked with a bipartisan group of
- 4:12:56Republican and Democratic members
- 4:12:59including Mr. Roy, my my co-lead to
- 4:13:02write a strong bill to ban stock trading
- 4:13:05in Congress once and for all. We
- 4:13:08introduced our bipartisan bill, the
- 4:13:10Restore Trust in Congress Act, with
- 4:13:13strong support from both sides of the
- 4:13:15aisle and the support of the American
- 4:13:17people who are disgusted by the
- 4:13:19corruption in Washington.
- 4:13:22But instead of letting us vote on that
- 4:13:24bill,
- 4:13:25the Republican majority is playing
- 4:13:28political games because they don't want
- 4:13:30change, because they want politicians to
- 4:13:32continue to get rich off of their
- 4:13:34positions.
- 4:13:36So, let's get one thing straight. The
- 4:13:38so-called stock trading ban that the
- 4:13:41House Republicans are pushing today
- 4:13:43would still allow members of Congress to
- 4:13:45trade stocks,
- 4:13:47to sell unlimited amounts at any time
- 4:13:51with insider knowledge, just like some
- 4:13:54former members sold stocks before the
- 4:13:56COVID-19 pandemic because they knew what
- 4:13:59was coming before everybody else did.
- 4:14:01That would still be allowed under this
- 4:14:03bill that's being pushed to the floor
- 4:14:04today.
- 4:14:06And under this bill, members would still
- 4:14:08be allowed to vote on healthcare policy
- 4:14:10knowing that they own a bunch of
- 4:14:12healthcare stocks, would still be
- 4:14:13allowed to vote on defense policy
- 4:14:16knowing that they own defense company
- 4:14:17stocks, on AI policy knowing that they
- 4:14:20own the stocks of those same AI
- 4:14:22companies. This bill would do nothing to
- 4:14:24end the conflicts of interest
- 4:14:27in order to make Congress work for the
- 4:14:29American people and not just the
- 4:14:30insiders.
- 4:14:32In addition, the Republican leadership
- 4:14:34has combined their bad bill with a
- 4:14:37completely unrelated and controversial
- 4:14:41bill about election administration.
- 4:14:44So, whatever you think about that issue,
- 4:14:45whatever you think about voter ID, the
- 4:14:48decision to combine the two into one
- 4:14:51bill rather than allow separate votes
- 4:14:55shows that the Republican majority
- 4:14:57doesn't really want any of this to pass.
- 4:14:59It's just a political game to them.
- 4:15:02So, I have introduced an amendment that
- 4:15:05will strike the language of this
- 4:15:07unserious, fake reform bill that the
- 4:15:10Republican leadership has put in front
- 4:15:11of us and replace it with the language
- 4:15:15from the bipartisan Restore Trust in
- 4:15:17Congress Act, a real ban on members of
- 4:15:21Congress owning and trading stocks with
- 4:15:24no gimmicks and no exceptions. The same
- 4:15:27exact bipartisan language that Mr. Roy
- 4:15:29and a lot of other Republican members
- 4:15:32came together with us to introduce last
- 4:15:34year.
- 4:15:35That is the better bill because it
- 4:15:36actually bans stock trading
- 4:15:39as opposed to the one that the
- 4:15:40leadership is trying to jam through
- 4:15:41today, which does not, and everybody
- 4:15:43knows it.
- 4:15:44But, there's one other thing that we
- 4:15:46must do.
- 4:15:47When we
- 4:15:49got our bipartisan group together and we
- 4:15:51started working on
- 4:15:52the Restore Trust in Congress Act, there
- 4:15:55wasn't a lot of talk then about the
- 4:15:56president trading stocks because up
- 4:15:59until that point, President Trump, for
- 4:16:01all of his many faults, had not been an
- 4:16:04active stock trader while in office.
- 4:16:08But, over the past year, that has
- 4:16:09changed dramatically.
- 4:16:12So far in 2026, and listen to this, so
- 4:16:15far in 2026,
- 4:16:17President Trump has traded more stocks
- 4:16:20than every member of Congress combined
- 4:16:24based on the public filings. He bought
- 4:16:27Nvidia stock right before he lifted
- 4:16:29export controls on Nvidia chips.
- 4:16:32He bought and sold defense stocks when
- 4:16:35making decisions about the Iran war. He
- 4:16:37even bought stocks of the parent company
- 4:16:40of the UFC right before the UFC fights
- 4:16:43on the White House lawn.
- 4:16:45No stock trading ban is complete if it
- 4:16:47doesn't also include the President of
- 4:16:50the United States. So, in addition to
- 4:16:52fully banning stock trading in Congress,
- 4:16:55my amendment also will ban stock trading
- 4:16:57by the president, the vice president,
- 4:16:59and the Supreme Court. Let's root out
- 4:17:01corruption everywhere.
- 4:17:03That is what the American people want
- 4:17:05and deserve for us to do. And I'll yield
- 4:17:07back.
- 4:17:09>> Thank you very much.
- 4:17:11Ms. Spadorcia, you're recognized.
- 4:17:13>> Thank you, Chairwoman Fox and members of
- 4:17:15the committee.
- 4:17:16Uh I appreciate Chairman Steil's
- 4:17:18leadership on this legislation and I
- 4:17:21support all the goals of this
- 4:17:22legislation. I have amendment before you
- 4:17:26that deals specifically and narrowly
- 4:17:28with some of the voter ID provisions in
- 4:17:30this bill.
- 4:17:32I, like most Americans, believe that
- 4:17:34only uh
- 4:17:35eligible American citizens should vote
- 4:17:37in our elections.
- 4:17:39Requiring voters to present photo ID is
- 4:17:41a common sense way to do that. Americans
- 4:17:44deserve confidence that every legal vote
- 4:17:47is counted and only legal votes are
- 4:17:49counted. My amendment fully supports
- 4:17:52that objective.
- 4:17:54In fact, my amendment exists because
- 4:17:56North Dakota already meets and in many
- 4:17:58respects exceeds the legislation the
- 4:18:01election integrity standards this bill
- 4:18:04is designed to establish.
- 4:18:06North Dakota is the only state in the
- 4:18:08nation that does not require voter
- 4:18:10registration.
- 4:18:11Instead, for more than 70 years, we've
- 4:18:13relied on a different system
- 4:18:15that emphasizes continuous voter
- 4:18:17verification rather than voter
- 4:18:19registration.
- 4:18:21Because of that system, North Dakota is
- 4:18:23exempt from the National Voter
- 4:18:25Registration Act.
- 4:18:27Our system already requires voters to
- 4:18:29present photo ID before voting.
- 4:18:32It verifies citizenship and residency
- 4:18:34through official state records.
- 4:18:36Our Secretary of State continuously
- 4:18:38updates our voter eligibility using
- 4:18:41information on residency changes,
- 4:18:43deaths, and other eligibility records
- 4:18:45maintained by the state.
- 4:18:47North Dakota has strong safeguards for
- 4:18:50absentee and mail-in voting.
- 4:18:52Voters must verify their identity before
- 4:18:55receiving and casting a ballot, and our
- 4:18:57election administrators maintain secure
- 4:19:00chain of custody procedures throughout
- 4:19:02the absentee ballot voting process.
- 4:19:05Our election laws are also include
- 4:19:07accommodations that work well for tribal
- 4:19:09communities while maintaining election
- 4:19:11integrity. Simply put, North Dakota has
- 4:19:14developed a system that is tailored to
- 4:19:16our state, protects the integrity of our
- 4:19:19elections, and has worked successfully
- 4:19:22for decades.
- 4:19:23The concerns raised by our Secretary of
- 4:19:26State is not with the purpose of
- 4:19:28Chairman Styles' bill. We support its
- 4:19:30purpose. The concern is that the bill
- 4:19:32amends the Help America Vote Act in ways
- 4:19:35that assume every state has a voter
- 4:19:37registration system.
- 4:19:39As currently drafted, portions of this
- 4:19:41bill expand requirements that are common
- 4:19:44practices for voter registration. This
- 4:19:47includes collection of social security
- 4:19:49numbers, use of military IDs, and voter
- 4:19:53affidavits, and other procedures that
- 4:19:55simply don't exist in North Dakota.
- 4:19:59In the opinion of the Secretary of State
- 4:20:01of North Dakota, those changes would
- 4:20:03weaken North Dakota's election integrity
- 4:20:05by requiring us to move away from the
- 4:20:08system that already exceeds the
- 4:20:10objectives Congress is trying to achieve
- 4:20:12today.
- 4:20:13My amendment is narrow. It does not
- 4:20:15weaken voter ID requirements. It does
- 4:20:18not weaken election integrity. It does
- 4:20:21not create a loophole. It simply
- 4:20:23preserves North Dakota's long-standing
- 4:20:25election system. We should avoid
- 4:20:27unintentionally replacing one of the
- 4:20:29strongest election integrity systems in
- 4:20:31the country with requirements that were
- 4:20:33never designed for a state without voter
- 4:20:35registration. I respectfully ask the
- 4:20:38committee to make my amendment in order.
- 4:20:40Thank you. I yield back and look forward
- 4:20:42to your questions.
- 4:20:43>> Thank you, Ms. Fedorchak.
- 4:20:46Mr. Davidson, you're recognized.
- 4:20:49>> Uh thank you, Madam Chairwoman, and
- 4:20:50thanks to the Rules Committee for the
- 4:20:51work you do here. Um
- 4:20:53you know, we have a number of bills that
- 4:20:55comprise consideration as part of this
- 4:20:57rule. So, I will once again plead that
- 4:21:00we uh fix a problem, an unconstitutional
- 4:21:04and ineffective surveillance uh tool
- 4:21:07called the Corporate Transparency Act.
- 4:21:09Democrats installed it in the FY 2021
- 4:21:13National Defense Authorization Act, and
- 4:21:15for some reason Republicans want to
- 4:21:17unilaterally disarm and not include even
- 4:21:20the ability to consider this as an
- 4:21:21amendment. Uh whereas Democrats put it
- 4:21:24into the base text, wouldn't allow
- 4:21:25amendments, and forced it into law.
- 4:21:28They've done rulemaking that made the a
- 4:21:29bad law even worse in practice. But
- 4:21:32thankfully, the Trump administration uh
- 4:21:35has a rule in place that minimizes that
- 4:21:38impact.
- 4:21:40The bill I've got that relates to this
- 4:21:42has 193 cosponsors. This is broadly
- 4:21:45supported, and it locks in with the
- 4:21:47administration's doing. But it makes it
- 4:21:49law. So, I plead with the committee,
- 4:21:51please make this
- 4:21:53in order, and ideally just incorporate
- 4:21:55it into the base text. I think that
- 4:21:56would be a better way to do it.
- 4:21:58We're also uh talking about budget
- 4:21:59reconciliation again. And well, um
- 4:22:04you know, reconciliation's an important
- 4:22:05tool. We are in the House, I think,
- 4:22:07uniformly frustrated by the Senate at
- 4:22:09times.
- 4:22:10But uh
- 4:22:12we're requesting $95 billion
- 4:22:14on offset.
- 4:22:15One of the tools in budget
- 4:22:17reconciliation is to do just that. One
- 4:22:19of the points of the Budget
- 4:22:20Reconciliation Act is to pay for our
- 4:22:23spending.
- 4:22:24Sound money is essential to defending
- 4:22:26freedom. We don't currently have sound
- 4:22:28money. And since we don't have sound
- 4:22:30money, we must cut spending and grow
- 4:22:32revenue. Since we aren't cutting
- 4:22:34spending,
- 4:22:36uh we should at least prioritize our
- 4:22:37spending so that we avoid increases that
- 4:22:39outpace our revenue growth. And while
- 4:22:42our revenue growth is
- 4:22:43strong,
- 4:22:45um our spending is growing even faster.
- 4:22:49So,
- 4:22:50there there I'd ask unanimous consent to
- 4:22:52submit this for the record.
- 4:22:55This is just a summary of that, but
- 4:22:56>> Without objection.
- 4:22:57>> Thank you, Madam Chairwoman. But, look,
- 4:22:59there there are easy ways to save money.
- 4:23:03Uh conservative groups have provided
- 4:23:05them for us. Uh we debated them uh
- 4:23:08through reconciliation one,
- 4:23:10reconciliation two. The Republican Study
- 4:23:12Committees consolidated them, and
- 4:23:14various other uh colleagues have worked
- 4:23:16on this for years. So, I have four
- 4:23:20amendments. One would save $4 trillion
- 4:23:23on the 10-year budget scoring window,
- 4:23:25and I don't think that's incredibly hard
- 4:23:27to do. Uh
- 4:23:29and I think importantly, look, this is a
- 4:23:31budget window that because of our rules,
- 4:23:33we lay out a 10-year window. Well, what
- 4:23:35happens inside that 10-year window? In
- 4:23:372032,
- 4:23:39the Social Security Trust Fund quits
- 4:23:41working, which is the payroll taxes that
- 4:23:43are collected uh become insufficient to
- 4:23:47cover the payouts. And under current
- 4:23:49law, as scored in our budget and all of
- 4:23:51our CBO scores that go from 2032 and
- 4:23:54beyond,
- 4:23:55they assume under current law that we're
- 4:23:57going to cut spending on Social Security
- 4:23:58by 20%. Now, I don't believe a future
- 4:24:01Congress is going to do that, but I
- 4:24:02think it's irresponsible for us to put a
- 4:24:04budget out there that pretends that that
- 4:24:06would even happen.
- 4:24:07So, this first amendment creates a
- 4:24:10mandate that all savings, all of the
- 4:24:12savings that we get from budget
- 4:24:13reconciliation, would go into that
- 4:24:16Social Security Fund because it protects
- 4:24:17it. You know, bad news doesn't get
- 4:24:19better with time. Kicking the can down
- 4:24:21the road isn't going to make this easier
- 4:24:22to solve down the road. We should
- 4:24:24protect Social Security, and I think
- 4:24:25this would be a good way to do both
- 4:24:27things. I've got a related proposal,
- 4:24:29separate amendment, $2.6 trillion. I got
- 4:24:32a different one that's a little easier,
- 4:24:33that's 1.25 trillion dollars. And since
- 4:24:36we're only asking for 95 billion dollars
- 4:24:39worth of new debt, I got one that would
- 4:24:41save 95 billion dollars, but it would
- 4:24:43lock it in every stinking year.
- 4:24:45Look, we're bankrupting our country.
- 4:24:47It's not compassionate to bankrupt a
- 4:24:49country. $5 foot longs are $12. Houses
- 4:24:53have gone up 80% and payroll tax payroll
- 4:24:55wages have not gone up like that.
- 4:24:58And it's because we're spending too much
- 4:25:00money.
- 4:25:01So, regardless of how important it is,
- 4:25:02we paid for we we we fought last week
- 4:25:05over a veterans bill. Caring for our
- 4:25:07veterans is a first order priority. But
- 4:25:09because of the rules of the house and
- 4:25:10common sense, we found pay fors.
- 4:25:13Now, the pay fors created a debate here
- 4:25:16and people thought maybe we could find
- 4:25:17better pay fors, but the principle was
- 4:25:19we're going to pay for it. But you're
- 4:25:21telling me this new 95 billion dollar
- 4:25:23request, we don't have to pay for?
- 4:25:25I'm offended. Now, lastly, we're talking
- 4:25:28about uh
- 4:25:29you know, bill that deals with insider
- 4:25:31trading. And I I do object to calling it
- 4:25:34insider trading stop insider trading act
- 4:25:36because insider trading's already
- 4:25:37illegal. Um
- 4:25:39and so I think we're confusing people.
- 4:25:41Insider trading is already a crime. But
- 4:25:43you do get access to a lot of
- 4:25:44information in Congress. I think the
- 4:25:46ethics rules already steer people to do
- 4:25:47the right thing. Um but passing this law
- 4:25:50makes sense, but it should make sense
- 4:25:52for the executive branch and the
- 4:25:53judiciary branch, too. So, I have an
- 4:25:56amendment that would apply this equally
- 4:25:58to all SES employees and above in the
- 4:26:00executive branch, so that would include
- 4:26:02cabinet secretaries, all elected
- 4:26:03officials in the executive branch. And
- 4:26:05it would include uh the judiciary branch
- 4:26:08as well. So, I'd plead with you to make
- 4:26:10all of my amendments in order. Let's
- 4:26:11give us a chance to represent the people
- 4:26:13that sent us here to represent them. And
- 4:26:15I yield back.
- 4:26:17>> Thank you, Mr. Davidson.
- 4:26:20Um does any member on our side have any
- 4:26:23questions?
- 4:26:27Mr. McGovern.
- 4:26:28>> J- just briefly, Mr. Davidson, I you
- 4:26:29know,
- 4:26:30we objected to the your veterans bill
- 4:26:32cuz you cut veterans benefits to pay for
- 4:26:34other veterans benefits.
- 4:26:36But if you're going to pay for a
- 4:26:37veterans benefits, then you ought to pay
- 4:26:39for the war.
- 4:26:40And this doesn't do that. And Ms.
- 4:26:42Spartz, I asked Chairman Arrington here,
- 4:26:45I have an amendment similar to yours on
- 4:26:46the Richard Star Act, whether he'd be
- 4:26:48open to allowing us to make that an
- 4:26:50order. And I got a blank stare. So I
- 4:26:52don't know whether he was having a
- 4:26:54moment or whether he was just trying not
- 4:26:56to answer the question.
- 4:26:58But I would hope that if your amendment
- 4:27:00gets blocked,
- 4:27:01that
- 4:27:03that you will sign the discharge
- 4:27:05petition. Because otherwise, I don't see
- 4:27:06how we're going to ever get a vote on
- 4:27:08it. So I hope that you'll sign the
- 4:27:09discharge petition if they block your
- 4:27:11amendment. Otherwise, this is all talk.
- 4:27:13And Mr. Magaziner, Mr.
- 4:27:17Fedoracheck, I mean,
- 4:27:18I I just so you know, when Chairman
- 4:27:21Style came up to testify, he wrote a
- 4:27:24letter that's a little different than a
- 4:27:26lot of other chair
- 4:27:28request rules. They usually request an
- 4:27:30appropriate rule. But he was pretty
- 4:27:33clear.
- 4:27:34He wants a totally closed rule to govern
- 4:27:37this issue. And I understand why because
- 4:27:41they
- 4:27:42don't want to expand their and make more
- 4:27:46effective the the Stop Insider Trading
- 4:27:48Act. And I don't know what what the
- 4:27:50problem is um with North Dakota.
- 4:27:53But but the point of the matter is
- 4:27:56you know, we'll see what happens. But he
- 4:27:57specifically asked for totally closed
- 4:27:59rule. Yeah, you want
- 4:28:00>> Okay, to clarify, I just want to make
- 4:28:02sure that we know we can try to find a
- 4:28:04lot of things. And I think the version
- 4:28:07that you have on the discharge petition
- 4:28:08is roughly 90 billion dollars, you know.
- 4:28:10So let's just find 9 billion to fund it.
- 4:28:12It's 10 times more. Let's just find 9
- 4:28:14billion to fund You know, what I'm just
- 4:28:16saying
- 4:28:17No, I No, I'm just saying let's just
- 4:28:20find what I'm just saying. We can let's
- 4:28:22find 9 billion to truly deal with the
- 4:28:24nature of combat veterans, you know, not
- 4:28:27not expand on that. So,
- 4:28:29so would you would you do something with
- 4:28:31this a lower amount or not? Not 90
- 4:28:33billion. 90 billion is a lot.
- 4:28:36No, we do. No, I think we need to do it.
- 4:28:38We need to find something not more
- 4:28:39thanks, you know. So,
- 4:28:41so
- 4:28:41>> It sounds like the answer is no.
- 4:28:43>> Well, well, your bill is too broad, you
- 4:28:45know, we need to truly deal with an
- 4:28:47issue we need to deal not do more and
- 4:28:48more. So, I think this is a bill. So,
- 4:28:50will you support this on the floor that
- 4:28:51that this version?
- 4:28:54No, they were very disappointed because
- 4:28:56it seems like you don't want to support
- 4:28:57this amendment. You want to have more
- 4:28:59stuff. So, the would you support this
- 4:29:00amendment?
- 4:29:02Ranking member, would you support this
- 4:29:049.4 billion amendment?
- 4:29:06>> an amendment to make the Richard Star
- 4:29:07Act in order.
- 4:29:08>> So, you only support Democratic
- 4:29:09amendments. You don't support Republican
- 4:29:10amendments.
- 4:29:12Seems like we should be bipartisan on
- 4:29:14this issue.
- 4:29:14>> Excuse me.
- 4:29:15You are in charge your party is in
- 4:29:17charge of this Congress and in charge of
- 4:29:19this committee. If your amendment is not
- 4:29:21made in order, it is not because four
- 4:29:22Democrats and vote for it. It's because
- 4:29:24all of these Republicans voted against
- 4:29:26it. So, that's the issue. And all I'm
- 4:29:29saying to you is that they don't make
- 4:29:30your amendment in order, will you sign
- 4:29:32the discharge petition so we can have a
- 4:29:33vote? And I think your answer is no. And
- 4:29:36that's
- 4:29:36>> Well, you have a different you have a
- 4:29:37different legislation on that petition.
- 4:29:39Thank you, Mr. Ranking Member, but
- 4:29:41hopefully you can support if it's in
- 4:29:43order.
- 4:29:46>> Thank you. I do want to thank the
- 4:29:48representative from North Dakota from
- 4:29:50bringing forward the fact that our
- 4:29:52elections are
- 4:29:54constitutionally run by the states and
- 4:29:57and the fact that there's some issues
- 4:29:58with the legislation that's being
- 4:30:01pressed here
- 4:30:03and how it would be implemented in the
- 4:30:04states, I think is really telling. Mr.
- 4:30:07Magaziner, I I hope that your
- 4:30:09amendment's made in order. I certainly
- 4:30:11will be
- 4:30:13voting for it myself, but you seem to
- 4:30:15have a fair amount of you know, you
- 4:30:16mentioned there was a lot of bipartisan
- 4:30:18support and that's including among
- 4:30:20members of the Rules Committee. So,
- 4:30:22hopefully they will follow what they've
- 4:30:24already sponsored.
- 4:30:26>> Yeah, no, that's right. Thank you. And
- 4:30:28and again, when we introduced the
- 4:30:29Restore Trust in Congress Act last year,
- 4:30:31it was with broad bipartisan support
- 4:30:33including by at least one of the
- 4:30:34Republican members of the Rules
- 4:30:36Committee. And I think, you know, to
- 4:30:38Ranking Member McGovern's point, you
- 4:30:40know, the reason that Chairman Steil
- 4:30:41doesn't want an an open rule is because
- 4:30:43he knows that there is broad support in
- 4:30:45both parties for including the President
- 4:30:48and Vice President and Supreme Court for
- 4:30:50having a real stock trading ban that
- 4:30:51actually bans stock trading and doesn't
- 4:30:53just pretend to. And so, if we can open
- 4:30:56this up then I think you'll find broad
- 4:30:58support on both sides and of course the
- 4:31:00American people as well.
- 4:31:01>> Thank you. I yield back.
- 4:31:04>> Thank you, Ms. Leger Fernandez.
- 4:31:07>> Uh thank you for your amendments. Uh we
- 4:31:09made many of the same points you did, uh
- 4:31:10Representative Davidson, of where
- 4:31:12they're willing to uh
- 4:31:14rack up the debt again and we don't
- 4:31:16really see them willing to
- 4:31:19uh raise revenue. And so, we're going to
- 4:31:20have some amendments suggesting that
- 4:31:22there are ways to uh raise revenue to
- 4:31:24pay for what they want to
- 4:31:25uh do. And uh I I think it's like a half
- 4:31:28stock trading ban. It's not really a
- 4:31:30trading ban. It is uh you uh and earlier
- 4:31:32today Chairman Steil said, "No, it's
- 4:31:34enough to just require disclosure of
- 4:31:37sales." Uh but that's not a ban, is it?
- 4:31:40Uh Representative
- 4:31:40>> Well, we've had disclosure for over a
- 4:31:42decade and it hasn't fixed the problem.
- 4:31:44All it's done is shown that there is a
- 4:31:45big problem. And and again, under this
- 4:31:48so-called stock trading ban that's not a
- 4:31:50stock trading ban, members could still
- 4:31:52sell any amount at any time on any
- 4:31:54inside information and can still hold as
- 4:31:57much stock as they want while they're
- 4:31:58voting on the regulations and the laws
- 4:32:01for those same industries. So, there'll
- 4:32:03still be a tremendous conflict of
- 4:32:04interest. And of course, it does nothing
- 4:32:07to do address the the trader in chief
- 4:32:10right now who is the President who's
- 4:32:11traded more than every member of
- 4:32:12Congress combined this year.
- 4:32:14>> Outrageous and corruption action. And
- 4:32:17thank you for your amendments and with
- 4:32:19that Madam Chair, thank you all for you
- 4:32:21coming forward and explaining your
- 4:32:23amendment and I yield back.
- 4:32:26>> Thank you. Ms. Fettercheck, did you have
- 4:32:28some other comment you wish to make?
- 4:32:30>> Uh no, I just wanted to emphasize that
- 4:32:33the amendment I'm seeking is very narrow
- 4:32:36and it is recognizes that North Dakota
- 4:32:38already meets and exceeds the standards
- 4:32:41that we're trying to create for the rest
- 4:32:42of the country
- 4:32:44uh of which I strongly support.
- 4:32:47>> Thank you.
- 4:32:59>> Madam Chair.
- 4:33:01Mr. Mr. Schiff, may I ask you now for
- 4:33:03unanimous consent to insert in the
- 4:33:04record written testimony from
- 4:33:05Representative Courtney in support of
- 4:33:06his amendment number 878 to HR 8800
- 4:33:10which would authorize 610 million for
- 4:33:12the construction of up to two medium
- 4:33:14landing ships by reducing funds
- 4:33:16authorized for the one big battleship
- 4:33:18program by 610 million.
- 4:33:21>> Without objection. Is there anyone else
- 4:33:23seeking to testify on today's agenda?
- 4:33:27Seeing none, this closes the hearing
- 4:33:29portion of our meeting.
- 4:33:32The chair will be in receipt of a motion
- 4:33:35from the gentleman from Virginia, Mr.
- 4:33:37Griffith.
- 4:33:38>> Madam Chair, I move the committee grant
- 4:33:40HR 8800, the National Defense
- 4:33:43Authorization Act for fiscal year 2027
- 4:33:45as structured rule. The rule waives all
- 4:33:47points of order against consideration of
- 4:33:48the bill. The rule provides 1 hour of
- 4:33:50general debate equally divided and
- 4:33:52controlled by the chair and ranking
- 4:33:53minority member of the Committee on
- 4:33:54Armed Services or their respective
- 4:33:55designees. The rule provides that in
- 4:33:58lieu of the amendment in nature of
- 4:33:59substitute recommended by the Committee
- 4:34:00on Armed Services now printed in the
- 4:34:02bill, an amendment in nature of
- 4:34:03substitute consisting of the text of
- 4:34:05rules
- 4:34:06committee Print 119-33
- 4:34:09shall be considered as adopted in the
- 4:34:10bill as amended shall be considered as
- 4:34:12read. The rule waves all points of order
- 4:34:14against provisions in the bill as
- 4:34:16amended. The rule makes in order only
- 4:34:18those amendments printed in part A of
- 4:34:20the Rules Committee report.
- 4:34:22Amendments in block described in section
- 4:34:243 and pro forma amendments described in
- 4:34:26section 4.
- 4:34:28Each amendment shall be considered only
- 4:34:30in the order printed in the report may
- 4:34:32be offered only by a member designated
- 4:34:33in the report shall be considered as
- 4:34:35read shall be debatable for the time
- 4:34:37specified in the report equally divided
- 4:34:39and controlled by the proponent and
- 4:34:41and opponent shall not be subject to
- 4:34:44amendment except as provided by section
- 4:34:454 of the rule and shall not be subject
- 4:34:47to a demand for division of the
- 4:34:49question.
- 4:34:51The rules wave wave The rule waves all
- 4:34:53points of order against the amendments
- 4:34:54printed in part A of the Rules Committee
- 4:34:56report or amendments in block described
- 4:34:58in section 3 of the rule. The rule
- 4:35:00provides that the chair of the Committee
- 4:35:01on Armed Services or his designee may
- 4:35:03offer amendments in block consisting of
- 4:35:05further amendments printed in part A of
- 4:35:07the Rules Committee report not earlier
- 4:35:09disposed of. Amendments in block shall
- 4:35:11be considered as read shall be debatable
- 4:35:14for 40 minutes equally divided and
- 4:35:16controlled by the chair and ranking
- 4:35:17minority member of the Committee on
- 4:35:18Armed Services or their respective
- 4:35:21designees shall not be subject to
- 4:35:23amendment except as provided by section
- 4:35:254 of the rule and shall not be subject
- 4:35:27to demand for division of the question.
- 4:35:29The rule provides that the chair and
- 4:35:30ranking minority member of the Committee
- 4:35:32on Armed Services or their respective
- 4:35:33designees may offer up to 10 pro forma
- 4:35:35amendments each at any point for the
- 4:35:38purpose of debate. The rule provides one
- 4:35:40motion to recommit. The rule provides
- 4:35:42for consideration of H.R. 8884 the
- 4:35:45Removing Barriers to Work for Disabled
- 4:35:48Americans Act under a closed rule. The
- 4:35:50rule waves all points of order against
- 4:35:52consideration of the bill. The rule
- 4:35:53provides that in lieu of the amendment
- 4:35:54in the nature of substitute recommended
- 4:35:55by the Committee of Ways and Means now
- 4:35:57printed in the bill an amendment in the
- 4:35:58nature of substitute consisting of the
- 4:36:00text of Rules Committee Print 119-34
- 4:36:04shall be considered as adopted and the
- 4:36:05bill as amended shall be considered as
- 4:36:08read. The rule waives all points of
- 4:36:09order against provisions in the bill as
- 4:36:11amended. The rule provides 1 hour of
- 4:36:12general debate equally divided and
- 4:36:14controlled by the chair and ranking
- 4:36:15minority member of the Committee on Ways
- 4:36:16and Means or their respective designees.
- 4:36:19The rule provides one motion to
- 4:36:20recommit. The rule further provides for
- 4:36:22consideration of H. Con. Res. 113
- 4:36:24establishing the congressional budget
- 4:36:26for the United States government for
- 4:36:27fiscal year 2027 and setting forth the
- 4:36:30appropriate budgetary levels for fiscal
- 4:36:32years 2028 through 2036
- 4:36:35under a closed rule. The rule waives all
- 4:36:36points of order against consideration of
- 4:36:38the concurrent resolution. The rule
- 4:36:40provides 1 hour of general debate
- 4:36:42equally divided and controlled by the
- 4:36:43chair and ranking minority member of the
- 4:36:44Committee on the Budget or their
- 4:36:46respective designees.
- 4:36:48The rule provides that an amendment in
- 4:36:49the nature of a substitute consisting of
- 4:36:51the text of Rules Committee Print 119-37
- 4:36:55shall be considered as adopted and the
- 4:36:56con-
- 4:36:57and the concurrent resolution as amended
- 4:36:59shall be considered as read. The rule
- 4:37:01permits the chair of the Committee on
- 4:37:02the Budget to offer amendments in the
- 4:37:04House pur- pursuant to Section 305A5
- 4:37:08of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974
- 4:37:10to achieve mathematical consistency. The
- 4:37:13rule further provides for consideration
- 4:37:15of H.R. 70008
- 4:37:17the Stop Insider Trading Act under a
- 4:37:19closed rule. The rule waives all points
- 4:37:22of order against consideration of the
- 4:37:23bill. The rule provides that in lieu of
- 4:37:25the amendment in the nature of a
- 4:37:25substitute recommended by the Committee
- 4:37:27on House Administration now printed in
- 4:37:29the bill an amendment in the nature of a
- 4:37:30substitute consisting of the text of
- 4:37:32Rules Committee Print 119-38
- 4:37:35modified by the amendment printed in
- 4:37:37part B of the Rules Committee report
- 4:37:39shall be considered as adopted and the
- 4:37:40bill as amended shall be considered as
- 4:37:42read. The rule waives all points of
- 4:37:44order against provisions in the bill as
- 4:37:46amended. The rule provides 1 hour of
- 4:37:47general debate equally divided and
- 4:37:49controlled by the chair and ranking
- 4:37:51minority member of the Committee on the
- 4:37:52House on House Administration or their
- 4:37:54respective designees. The rule provides
- 4:37:56one motion to recommit. The rule further
- 4:37:58provides for consideration of H.R. 6955,
- 4:38:02the Main Street Capital Access Act,
- 4:38:03under a closed rule. The rule waves
- 4:38:06all points of order against
- 4:38:07consideration of the bill. The rule
- 4:38:09provides that in lieu of the amendment
- 4:38:10in the nature of a substitute
- 4:38:11recommended by the Committee on
- 4:38:12Financial Services now printed in the
- 4:38:13bill, an amendment in the nature of a
- 4:38:14substitute consisting of the text of
- 4:38:17Rules Committee Print 119-35 shall be
- 4:38:19considered as adopted and the bill as
- 4:38:21amended shall be considered as read. The
- 4:38:23rule waves all points of order against
- 4:38:24provisions in the bill as amended. The
- 4:38:26rule provides 1 hour of general debate
- 4:38:27equally divided and controlled by the
- 4:38:28chair and ranking minority member of the
- 4:38:31Committee on Financial Services or their
- 4:38:33respective designees.
- 4:38:35The rule provides for one motion to
- 4:38:37recommit. The rule further provides for
- 4:38:39consideration of H.R. 9770, the
- 4:38:42Continuing Appropriations Act, 2027,
- 4:38:45under a closed rule. The rule waves all
- 4:38:46points of order against consideration of
- 4:38:48the bill. The rule provides that the
- 4:38:49bill shall be considered as read. The
- 4:38:50rule waves all points of order against
- 4:38:51provisions in the bill. The rule
- 4:38:53provides 1 hour of general debate
- 4:38:54equally divided and controlled by the
- 4:38:56chair and ranking minority member of the
- 4:38:57Committee on Appropriations or their
- 4:38:58respective designees. The rule provides
- 4:39:01one motion to recommit. Finally, the
- 4:39:02rule provides that in the engrossment of
- 4:39:04H.R. 8800,
- 4:39:07the clerk shall add the text of Senate
- 4:39:101383 as passed by the House as new
- 4:39:13matter at the end of H.R. 8800,
- 4:39:16assign appropriate designations to
- 4:39:18provisions within the engrossment,
- 4:39:20conform cross-references and provisions
- 4:39:22for short titles within the engrossment,
- 4:39:25and be authorized to make technical
- 4:39:26corrections to include corrections in
- 4:39:28spelling, punctuation, page and line
- 4:39:29numbering, section numbering, and
- 4:39:31insertion of appropriate headings.
- 4:39:35And I so move.
- 4:39:40>> Thank you very much, Mr. Griffith.
- 4:39:43Um
- 4:39:44is there
- 4:39:46um
- 4:39:47>> Member, chair.
- 4:39:48>> Yeah. Sorry.
- 4:39:51Is there any discussion on the motion
- 4:39:53from the gentleman from Virginia?
- 4:39:55>> Chair, we have several amendments. We're
- 4:39:56going to try to be quick, but six bills
- 4:39:58and one rules an awful lot. But, uh I
- 4:40:00have an amendment to the rule. I move
- 4:40:01the committee make an order amendment
- 4:40:02number 19 to H. Con. Res. 113 offered by
- 4:40:05myself, which would add budget
- 4:40:07reconciliation instructions requiring
- 4:40:09the House Committee on Armed Services to
- 4:40:11submit changes in laws within its
- 4:40:12jurisdiction that increased direct
- 4:40:14spending by no less than $13 billion
- 4:40:17out of a 60 billion out of the $60
- 4:40:19billion that Republicans allocated for
- 4:40:21the Department of Defense for the
- 4:40:22purpose of adding the Major Richard Star
- 4:40:24Act to the reconciliation bill.
- 4:40:26Republicans gave DOD $150 billion last
- 4:40:28July. They haven't used half of it. Now,
- 4:40:30they want to send another $60 billion
- 4:40:33for the war again without paying for it.
- 4:40:35But, when it comes to helping combat
- 4:40:36wounded veterans, Republicans insist on
- 4:40:38cutting benefits to other disabled
- 4:40:40veterans and raising VA home loan fees.
- 4:40:42That's BS, and that's why your bill was
- 4:40:44pulled from the House floor last week. I
- 4:40:46urge a yes vote on my motion, and I
- 4:40:48yield back, and I'm going to ask for a
- 4:40:50recorded vote.
- 4:40:53>> You've heard the motion from Mr.
- 4:40:54McGovern. Is there any further
- 4:40:56discussion?
- 4:40:58Hearing none, the question is on the
- 4:41:00amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:41:02saying I.
- 4:41:03>> I.
- 4:41:04>> Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:41:07of the Chair, the no's have it.
- 4:41:08>> a recorded vote.
- 4:41:09>> The Clerk will call the roll.
- 4:41:11>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr.
- 4:41:13Norman. Mr. Norman, no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 4:41:15Houchin. Mr. Langworthy. Mr. Langworthy,
- 4:41:16no. Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott, no. Mr.
- 4:41:18Griffith. Mr. Griffith, no. Mr. Jack.
- 4:41:20Mr. Jack, no. Mr. McGovern.
- 4:41:22>> I.
- 4:41:23>> Mr. McGovern, I. Ms. Scanlon. Ms.
- 4:41:24Scanlon, I. Mr. Neguse. Mr. Neguse, I.
- 4:41:26Ms. Leger Fernandez. Ms. Leger
- 4:41:28Fernandez, I. Madam Chair.
- 4:41:29>> No.
- 4:41:29>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:41:31>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:41:32>> 4 A's, 7 A's.
- 4:41:34>> The no's have it. The amendment's not
- 4:41:35agreed to. Further discussion.
- 4:41:37>> I have an amendment to the rule. I move
- 4:41:39the committee make an order amendment
- 4:41:40number 17 to H. Con. Res. 113 offered by
- 4:41:42myself, which would add budget
- 4:41:44reconciliation instructions requiring
- 4:41:46the House Committee on Transportation
- 4:41:47and Infrastructure to submit changes in
- 4:41:49laws within its jurisdiction that
- 4:41:51provide $60 billion for natural disaster
- 4:41:53recovery efforts. Communities across the
- 4:41:55country have been devastated by natural
- 4:41:57natural disasters. This budget
- 4:41:59resolution includes no money to help
- 4:42:01them recover or rebuild. If we're going
- 4:42:03to spend $60 more for Trump's war, we
- 4:42:06should spend the same amount helping
- 4:42:07people across the US who have lost their
- 4:42:09loved ones, friends, and homes, farms,
- 4:42:12and businesses due to natural disasters.
- 4:42:14I urge you yes vote on my motion and I
- 4:42:15yield back.
- 4:42:17>> Is there further discussion on the
- 4:42:18amendment from Mr. McGovern?
- 4:42:21Hearing none, the question's on the
- 4:42:22amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:42:24saying aye.
- 4:42:24>> Aye.
- 4:42:25>> Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:42:28of the chair, the
- 4:42:29The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:42:31>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:42:33Norman. Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 4:42:35Houchin. Mr. Langworthy. Mr. Langworthy
- 4:42:37no. Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott no. Mr.
- 4:42:39Griffith. Mr. Griffith no. Mr. Jack. Mr.
- 4:42:41Jack no. Mr. McGovern.
- 4:42:42>> Aye.
- 4:42:43>> Mr. McGovern aye. Ms. Scanlon. Ms.
- 4:42:44Scanlon aye. Mr. Neguse. Mr. Neguse aye.
- 4:42:46Ms. Leger Fernandez. Ms. Leger Fernandez
- 4:42:48aye. Madam Chair.
- 4:42:49>> No.
- 4:42:49>> Madam Chair no.
- 4:42:50>> The clerk will report the total.
- 4:42:52>> 48 ayes, 7 noes.
- 4:42:53>> The noes have it. The amendment's not
- 4:42:55agreed to.
- 4:42:55>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:42:56rule. I move the committee make in order
- 4:42:58amendment number 20 to H. Con. Res. 113
- 4:43:00offered by myself, which would create a
- 4:43:02point of order requiring that any
- 4:43:03reconciliation bill resulting from the
- 4:43:05Republicans fiscal year 2027 budget
- 4:43:08resolution must be fully offset or paid
- 4:43:11for and must not increase the deficit.
- 4:43:13Um and I would urge a yes vote on this.
- 4:43:16>> Is there further discussion on the
- 4:43:18amendment? Hearing none, the question's
- 4:43:20on the amendment. All those in favor
- 4:43:22signify by saying aye.
- 4:43:23>> Aye.
- 4:43:24>> Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:43:27of the chair, the noes have it.
- 4:43:29The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:43:30>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:43:32Norman. Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 4:43:34Houchin. Mr. Langworthy. Mr. Langworthy
- 4:43:36no. Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott no. Mr.
- 4:43:38Griffith. Mr. Griffith no. Mr. Jack. Mr.
- 4:43:40Jack no. Mr. McGovern.
- 4:43:41>> Yes, McGovern. I'm Ms. Scanlon.
- 4:43:43>> Ms. Scanlon I'm Mr. Neguse.
- 4:43:45>> Mr. Neguse I'm Ms. Ledger Fernandez.
- 4:43:46>> Ms. Ledger Fernandez I am Madam Chair.
- 4:43:48>> No.
- 4:43:48>> Madam Chair no.
- 4:43:49>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:43:50>> Four yes, seven nos.
- 4:43:52>> The nos have it. The amendment's not
- 4:43:54agreed to.
- 4:43:54>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:43:55rule. I move the committee make an order
- 4:43:57amendment number one to H. Con. Res. 113
- 4:43:59offered by Representative Omar, which
- 4:44:01would reverse the cuts to SNAP that were
- 4:44:03imposed by Republicans in their big ugly
- 4:44:05bill. Uh because of the big ugly bill
- 4:44:07Republicans enacted last year, over 4
- 4:44:09million Americans have lost their food
- 4:44:10benefits, including 1 million kids, all
- 4:44:12to give massive tax breaks to Jeff Bezos
- 4:44:15and other billion other billionaires.
- 4:44:16And the bill and the cuts haven't even
- 4:44:18been fully implemented yet. So I would
- 4:44:19urge a yes vote on this to uh to reverse
- 4:44:22these terrible cuts.
- 4:44:24>> Any further discussion on the amendment
- 4:44:26from Mr. McGovern?
- 4:44:28>> Just a reminder that Madam Chair
- 4:44:30>> Mr.
- 4:44:31>> Just a reminder that uh anybody under
- 4:44:32the age of 18
- 4:44:34or over the age of 64, 65 and over, or
- 4:44:37anybody who is medically or
- 4:44:39psychologically disabled or unable to
- 4:44:41work was exempt from the work
- 4:44:42requirements in our bill.
- 4:44:43>> Yeah, but they're not not exempt from
- 4:44:44losing their benefits and many of them
- 4:44:45are as we speak.
- 4:44:48>> Uh
- 4:44:49there's Is there further discussion?
- 4:44:52Hearing none, the question is on the
- 4:44:54amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:44:56saying I.
- 4:44:57>> I.
- 4:44:58>> Those opposed no. No. In the opinion
- 4:45:00chair the nos have it.
- 4:45:02>> The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:45:03>> Mrs. Fischbach.
- 4:45:04>> No.
- 4:45:05>> Mrs. Fischbach no, Mr. Norman.
- 4:45:06>> No.
- 4:45:06>> Mr. Norman no, Mr. Roy. Mrs. Shalchi.
- 4:45:08Mr. Langworthy.
- 4:45:09>> No.
- 4:45:09>> Mr. Langworthy no, Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott
- 4:45:11no, Mr. Griffith.
- 4:45:12>> No.
- 4:45:12>> Mr. Griffith no, Mr. Jack. Mr. Jack no,
- 4:45:14Mr. McGovern.
- 4:45:15>> I.
- 4:45:15>> Mr. McGovern I, Ms. Scanlon. Ms. Scanlon
- 4:45:17I, Mr. Neguse.
- 4:45:19>> I.
- 4:45:19>> Mr. Neguse I, Ms. Ledger Fernandez. Ms.
- 4:45:21Ledger Fernandez I, Madam Chair.
- 4:45:22>> No.
- 4:45:23>> Madam Chair no.
- 4:45:24>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:45:25>> Four yes, seven nos.
- 4:45:26>> The nos have it.
- 4:45:27>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:45:29rule. I move the committee make an order
- 4:45:30amendment number nine to H. Con. Res.
- 4:45:32113 offered by Representative Tonko,
- 4:45:34which would add a section to the budget
- 4:45:36resolution requiring that no taxpayer
- 4:45:38funds could be given by the Trump
- 4:45:39administration to people who were
- 4:45:41convicted of of assaulting law
- 4:45:43enforcement officers on January 6th,
- 4:45:462021. Madam Chair, this fund is a
- 4:45:48disgrace. People who assaulted police
- 4:45:50officers should not be given
- 4:45:51compensation for doing so. Last week,
- 4:45:53Acting Attorney General Blanched
- 4:45:55testified that the fund was dead, but
- 4:45:57Senator Cornyn during his questioning
- 4:45:58raised continued concerns that the
- 4:46:00administration has yet to commit to that
- 4:46:02in writing. So, I ask that this
- 4:46:04amendment be made in order so we can
- 4:46:05debate and vote on it.
- 4:46:08>> Is there any further discussion on Mr.
- 4:46:10McGovern's amendment?
- 4:46:12Hearing none, the question is on the
- 4:46:14amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:46:16saying aye.
- 4:46:16>> Aye.
- 4:46:17>> Those opposed say no.
- 4:46:18>> No.
- 4:46:20>> The opinion share the nose have it.
- 4:46:21>> for a roll call.
- 4:46:22>> Clerk will call the roll.
- 4:46:23>> Mrs. Fischbach, Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:46:25Norman, Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy, Mrs.
- 4:46:27Houchin, Mr. Langworthy, Mr. Langworthy
- 4:46:29no. Mr. Scott, Mr. Scott no. Mr.
- 4:46:31Griffith, Mr. Griffith no. Mr. Jack, Mr.
- 4:46:34Jack no. Mr.
- 4:46:35>> Aye.
- 4:46:35>> Mr. McGovern aye. Mr. Scanlon, Mr.
- 4:46:37Scanlon aye. Mr. Neguse,
- 4:46:38Mr. Neguse aye. Ms. Leger Fernandez, Ms.
- 4:46:40Leger Fernandez aye. Madam Chair,
- 4:46:42>> No.
- 4:46:42>> Madam Chair no.
- 4:46:43>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:46:44>> Four ayes, seven nays.
- 4:46:46>> The nays have it.
- 4:46:47>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment.
- 4:46:48>> not in
- 4:46:48>> I have an amendment to the rule. I move
- 4:46:50the committee make an order amendment
- 4:46:51number 14 to H.R. 7008 offered by
- 4:46:53Representative Ocasio-Cortez,
- 4:46:55which restores grants to states that
- 4:46:57require
- 4:46:58photo IDs without charge to eligible
- 4:47:01voters.
- 4:47:04>> Is there any further discussion to the
- 4:47:06amendment from Mr. McGovern?
- 4:47:08Hearing none, the question is on the
- 4:47:10amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:47:12saying aye.
- 4:47:13>> Aye.
- 4:47:14>> Those opposed say no.
- 4:47:15>> No.
- 4:47:16>> The opinion share the nays have it. The
- 4:47:18amendment's
- 4:47:18>> I ask for a roll call, Madam Chair.
- 4:47:19>> Clerk will call the roll.
- 4:47:20>> Mrs. Fischbach, Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:47:22Norman, Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy, Mrs.
- 4:47:25Houchin, Mr. Langworthy, Mr. Langworthy
- 4:47:27no. Mr. Scott, Mr. Scott no. Mr.
- 4:47:29Griffith, Mr. Griffith no. Mr. Jack, Mr.
- 4:47:32Jack no. Mr. McGovern,
- 4:47:34>> Aye.
- 4:47:34>> Mr. McGovern, aye. Ms. Scanlon, Ms.
- 4:47:35Scanlon, aye. Mr. Neguse,
- 4:47:37>> Aye.
- 4:47:37>> Mr. Neguse, aye. Ms. Leger Fernandez,
- 4:47:39>> Aye.
- 4:47:39>> Ms. Leger Fernandez, aye. Madam Chair,
- 4:47:41>> No.
- 4:47:41>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:47:42>> The clerk will report the total.
- 4:47:44>> Four ayes, seven nays.
- 4:47:45>> The nays have it. The amendment's not
- 4:47:46agreed
- 4:47:47>> Mr. Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:47:48rule. I move the committee make an order
- 4:47:49amendment number 15 to HR 7008 offered
- 4:47:52by Representative Davidson, which
- 4:47:53extends the stock trading restrictions
- 4:47:55the bill creates to judicial officers as
- 4:47:57well as all senior executive service
- 4:47:59positions and above including the
- 4:48:02president, the vice president, and any
- 4:48:04cabinet secretary, and any political
- 4:48:06appointee. I just say if Republicans
- 4:48:08won't work with us to get a stock
- 4:48:09trading ban bill that is bipartisan and
- 4:48:12comprehensive, at least you can make an
- 4:48:13order an amendment from one of your own
- 4:48:15members to expand the restrictions in
- 4:48:17this bill to include senior
- 4:48:18administration officials and judicial
- 4:48:20officers.
- 4:48:22>> Is there any further discussion on the
- 4:48:24amendment?
- 4:48:25Hearing none, the question's on the
- 4:48:27amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:48:28saying aye.
- 4:48:29>> Aye.
- 4:48:30>> Those opposed say no.
- 4:48:32>> No.
- 4:48:32>> In the opinion of the chair, the nays
- 4:48:34have it.
- 4:48:34>> Ask for roll call, Mr. Chair.
- 4:48:36>> The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:48:37>> Mrs. Fischbach, Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr.
- 4:48:39Norman, Mr. Norman, no. Mr. Roy, Mrs.
- 4:48:41Houchin, Mrs. Houchin, no. Mr.
- 4:48:43Langworthy, Mr. Langworthy, no. Mr.
- 4:48:44Scott, Mr. Scott, no. Mr. Griffith,
- 4:48:47Mr. Griffith, no. Mr. Jack, Mr. Jack,
- 4:48:49no. Mr. McGovern,
- 4:48:50>> Aye.
- 4:48:50>> Mr. McGovern, aye. Ms. Scanlon, Ms.
- 4:48:52Scanlon, aye. Mr. Neguse,
- 4:48:53>> Aye.
- 4:48:53>> Mr. Neguse, aye. Ms. Leger Fernandez,
- 4:48:56Ms. Leger Fernandez, aye. Madam Chair,
- 4:48:57>> No.
- 4:48:58>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:48:59>> The clerk will report the total.
- 4:49:00>> Four ayes, eight nays.
- 4:49:02>> The nays have it. The amendment's not
- 4:49:04agreed to.
- 4:49:04>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:49:05rule. I move the committee make an order
- 4:49:06an amendment number 232 to HR 8800
- 4:49:10offered by Representative Barr,
- 4:49:12which repeals the 1957 AUMF.
- 4:49:17>> You You've heard the Is any further
- 4:49:19discussion on the amendment?
- 4:49:22Hearing none, the question is on the
- 4:49:23amendment. All All in favor signify by
- 4:49:26saying I.
- 4:49:27>> I.
- 4:49:28>> Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:49:30chair the no's have it.
- 4:49:32>> I'd ask for a roll call.
- 4:49:33>> The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:49:35>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:49:37Norman. Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 4:49:39Houchin. Mrs. Houchin no. Mr.
- 4:49:41Langworthy. Mr. Langworthy no. Mr.
- 4:49:42Scott.
- 4:49:43Mr. Scott no. Mr. Griffith.
- 4:49:49Mr. Griffith no. Mr. Jack.
- 4:49:51Mr. Jack no. Mr. McGovern.
- 4:49:53>> I.
- 4:49:53>> Mr. McGovern I. Ms. Scanlon. Ms. Scanlon
- 4:49:55I. Mr. Neguse.
- 4:49:56Mr. Neguse I. Ms. Leger Fernandez. Ms.
- 4:49:59Leger Fernandez I. Madam Chair.
- 4:50:00>> No.
- 4:50:00>> Madam Chair no.
- 4:50:02>> The clerk will report the total.
- 4:50:03>> 40 ayes, eight nays.
- 4:50:04>> The no's have it. The amendment's not
- 4:50:06agreed to. Ms. Scanlon.
- 4:50:07>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:50:09rule. I move the committee make in order
- 4:50:10amendment 10 to H. Con. Res. 113 offered
- 4:50:13by myself which would add budget budget
- 4:50:15reconciliation instructions requiring
- 4:50:17the House Committee on Education and
- 4:50:19Workforce to submit changes in laws
- 4:50:21within its jurisdiction to provide $10
- 4:50:24billion to lower Americans' child care
- 4:50:26costs by increasing funding for child
- 4:50:28care and development block grants. Uh
- 4:50:31Americans are struggling with the cost
- 4:50:33of living. This Republican budget
- 4:50:35resolution would add nearly a hundred
- 4:50:37billion in new spending, but without a
- 4:50:39dollar devoted to addressing the cost of
- 4:50:41living crisis. My amendment would help
- 4:50:43more families afford child care, allow
- 4:50:45parents to stay in the workforce, and
- 4:50:47strengthen our economy by allowing
- 4:50:50making it easier for Americans to raise
- 4:50:52a family.
- 4:50:53I yield back.
- 4:50:54>> Is there any further discussion on the
- 4:50:56amendment?
- 4:50:57Hearing none, the question's on the
- 4:50:58amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:51:00saying I.
- 4:51:01>> I.
- 4:51:02>> Those opposed say no. No.
- 4:51:04>> I'd ask for a roll call.
- 4:51:05>> In
- 4:51:07The amendment's not agreed to.
- 4:51:08>> I'd ask for a roll call.
- 4:51:09>> The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:51:11>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:51:13Norman. Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 4:51:15Houchin. Mrs. Houchin no. Mr.
- 4:51:17Langworthy. Mr. Langworthy no. Mr.
- 4:51:18Scott. Mr. Scott no. Mr. Griffith. Mr.
- 4:51:21Griffith no. Mr. Jack. Mr. Jack, no. Mr.
- 4:51:23McGovern.
- 4:51:23>> Hi.
- 4:51:24>> Mr. McGovern, no. Ms. Scanlon.
- 4:51:25>> Hi.
- 4:51:25>> Ms. Scanlon, no. Mr. Neguse.
- 4:51:27>> Hi.
- 4:51:27>> Mr. Neguse, no. Ms. Leger Fernandez. Ms.
- 4:51:29Leger Fernandez, no. Madam Chair.
- 4:51:30>> No.
- 4:51:30>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:51:32>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:51:33>> 40 yeas, eight nays.
- 4:51:35>> The nays have it. The amendment's not
- 4:51:36agreed to. Ms. Scanlon, you're
- 4:51:38recognized.
- 4:51:38>> Madam Chair, I have an amendment to the
- 4:51:40rule. I move the committee make in order
- 4:51:41amendment 11 to H. Con. Res. 113 offered
- 4:51:44by myself, which would add budget
- 4:51:46reconciliation instructions requiring
- 4:51:48the House Committee on Financial
- 4:51:50Services to submit changes in laws
- 4:51:52within its jurisdiction and provide $10
- 4:51:54billion for the purposes of lowering
- 4:51:56Americans' rent and housing costs by
- 4:51:58increasing funding for the Home
- 4:52:00Investment Partnership Program and
- 4:52:02Community Development Block Grants. I'm
- 4:52:05disappointed that our Republican
- 4:52:06colleagues voted against lowering costs
- 4:52:09and of child care for American families,
- 4:52:11but since you rejected that opportunity,
- 4:52:14uh let's try another approach and
- 4:52:15address the housing costs that are
- 4:52:17stretching family budgets to the
- 4:52:19breaking point. We've seen what
- 4:52:21bipartisan collaboration can do to bring
- 4:52:23about positive change in the housing
- 4:52:25space, so I propose an amendment to do
- 4:52:27the same here. I yield back.
- 4:52:30>> Thank you. Is there any further
- 4:52:31discussion on the amendment? Hearing
- 4:52:33none, the question's on the amendment.
- 4:52:35All those in favor signify by saying I.
- 4:52:37>> I.
- 4:52:38>> Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:52:41of the Chair, the nays have it. The
- 4:52:42amendment's not agreed to. Ms. Scanlon
- 4:52:44requests a roll call. The clerk will
- 4:52:45call the roll.
- 4:52:46>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr.
- 4:52:48Norman. Mr. Norman, no.
- 4:52:50>> No.
- 4:52:50>> Norman, no. Mr. Roy. Mrs. Houchin. Mrs.
- 4:52:52Houchin, no. Mr. Langworthy.
- 4:52:53>> No.
- 4:52:53>> Mr. Langworthy, no. Mr. Scott. Mr.
- 4:52:55Scott, no. Mr. Griffith. Mr. Griffith,
- 4:52:57no. Mr. Jack. Mr. Jack, no. Mr.
- 4:52:59McGovern.
- 4:52:59>> Hi.
- 4:52:59>> Mr. McGovern, no. Ms. Scanlon.
- 4:53:01>> Hi.
- 4:53:01>> Ms. Scanlon, no. Mr. Neguse. Mr. Neguse,
- 4:53:03no. Ms. Leger Fernandez. Ms. Leger
- 4:53:05Fernandez, no. Madam Chair.
- 4:53:06>> No.
- 4:53:06>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:53:08>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:53:10>> 40 yeas, eight nays.
- 4:53:11>> The nays have it. The amendment's not
- 4:53:12agreed to. Ms. Scanlon, you're
- 4:53:14recognized.
- 4:53:14>> I have have amendment to the rule. I
- 4:53:16move the committee making order
- 4:53:17amendment number 12 to H. Con. Res. 113
- 4:53:20offered by myself, which would add
- 4:53:22budget reconciliation instructions
- 4:53:24requiring the House Committee on Energy
- 4:53:25and Commerce to submit changes to
- 4:53:28provide $10 billion for purposes of
- 4:53:31lowering Americans energy bills by
- 4:53:33increasing funding for the low-income
- 4:53:35energy assistance program or LIHEAP.
- 4:53:38LIHEAP is incredibly important in my
- 4:53:41community and I know the communities of
- 4:53:43many of the members here. Um our
- 4:53:45Republican colleagues rejected an
- 4:53:47opportunity to lower costs for
- 4:53:48childcare, then they rejected uh the
- 4:53:51opportunity to help families afford
- 4:53:53housing. So, uh let's try to keep the
- 4:53:55lights on for Americans by providing
- 4:53:57additional LIHEAP funding. Um it's a
- 4:54:00lifeline for families and I would urge a
- 4:54:03yes vote on my amendment. I yield back.
- 4:54:06>> Any further discussion on the amendment?
- 4:54:09Hearing none, the question is on the
- 4:54:11amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:54:13saying I.
- 4:54:14>> I.
- 4:54:14>> Those opposed say no.
- 4:54:16>> No.
- 4:54:17>> Independent chair, the no's
- 4:54:18>> a roll call.
- 4:54:19>> Ms. Scanlon requests a roll call. The
- 4:54:21clerk will call the roll.
- 4:54:22>> Mrs. Fischbach.
- 4:54:23Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr. Norman. Mr.
- 4:54:25Norman, no. Mr. Roy. Mrs. Houchin. Mrs.
- 4:54:27Houchin, no. Mr. Langworthy. Mr.
- 4:54:28Langworthy, no. Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott,
- 4:54:31no. Mr. Griffith.
- 4:54:32Mr. Griffith, no. Mr. Jackson. Mr.
- 4:54:34Jackson, no. Mr. McGovern. Mr. McGovern,
- 4:54:36I. Ms. Scanlon. Ms. Scanlon, I. Mr.
- 4:54:38Neguse. Mr. Neguse, I. Ms. Leger
- 4:54:40Fernandez. Ms. Leger Fernandez, I. Madam
- 4:54:42Chair.
- 4:54:42>> No.
- 4:54:43>> Madam Chair, no. Clerk, what is the
- 4:54:44total?
- 4:54:45>> Four yeas, eight nays.
- 4:54:46>> The no's have it. The amendment's not
- 4:54:48agreed to. Ms. Scanlon, you're
- 4:54:49recognized.
- 4:54:50>> Have an amendment to the rule. I move
- 4:54:51the committee making order amendment two
- 4:54:53to H.R. 7008 offered by Representative
- 4:54:56Morelle. The amendment would strike the
- 4:54:58text and replace it with the text of
- 4:55:00H.R. 6731, the Restore Trust in
- 4:55:03Government Act, which bans congressional
- 4:55:05participation in prediction markets and
- 4:55:08provides that eligible voters are able
- 4:55:10to cast a ballot using any number of
- 4:55:12acceptable forms of identification.
- 4:55:15We've already discussed these bills
- 4:55:18um at length, but um if we're going to
- 4:55:20have an overwhelming majority of
- 4:55:22Americans believe members of Congress
- 4:55:24shouldn't trade individual stocks. They
- 4:55:26feel similarly about the president, the
- 4:55:28vice president, the Supreme Court. Um if
- 4:55:30we're going to be serious about fighting
- 4:55:33corruption, we should pass this bill.
- 4:55:37>> Is there any further discussion on the
- 4:55:38amendment?
- 4:55:40Hearing none, the question's on the
- 4:55:41amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 4:55:43saying I.
- 4:55:44>> I.
- 4:55:45>> Those opposed say no. No.
- 4:55:47In the opinion of the chair, the no's
- 4:55:48have it. Members may agree to call the
- 4:55:51The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:55:52>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach no. Mr.
- 4:55:55Norman. Mr. Norman no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 4:55:57Houchin. Mrs. Houchin no. Mr.
- 4:55:58Langworthy. Mr. Langworthy no. Mr.
- 4:56:00Scott. Mr. Scott no. Mr. Griffith. Mr.
- 4:56:02Griffith no. Mr. Jackson. Mr. Jackson
- 4:56:04no. Mr. McGovern. Mr. McGovern no. Ms.
- 4:56:06Scanlon. Ms. Scanlon I. Mr. Neguse.
- 4:56:08Mr. Neguse I. Ms. Leger Fernandez. I.
- 4:56:11Ms. Leger Fernandez I. Madam Chair. No.
- 4:56:13Madam Chair no. Clerk will report the
- 4:56:15total. Four yeas, eight nays.
- 4:56:17Ms. Scanlon, you're recognized.
- 4:56:19>> Thank you. I have one more amendment. I
- 4:56:20move the committee make in order
- 4:56:22amendment five to H.R. 7008 offered by
- 4:56:25Representative Magaziner, which strikes
- 4:56:27the text and replaces it with the text
- 4:56:29of H.R. 5106, the Restore Trust in
- 4:56:32Congress Act. And I have really high
- 4:56:34hopes for this one because it is
- 4:56:35co-sponsored by Representative Roy. Um
- 4:56:38several members of the committee here
- 4:56:40are co-sponsors of it, including
- 4:56:42Representatives Langworthy and Norman.
- 4:56:45Um you know,
- 4:56:46this would strike the underlying bill
- 4:56:48and uh
- 4:56:50well, it doesn't extend to the president
- 4:56:52and vice president, it does what the
- 4:56:53bill before us fails to do, which is
- 4:56:56establish a comprehensive ban on members
- 4:56:59of Congress and their families owning
- 4:57:01and trading individual stocks. It's a
- 4:57:03real standard.
- 4:57:04Um and and I think uh we definitely
- 4:57:07should be allowing Congress to vote on
- 4:57:09this and instead of the sham bill that
- 4:57:11we have before us. I yield back.
- 4:57:14>> Is there further discussion on the
- 4:57:16amendment?
- 4:57:17Hearing none,
- 4:57:18the question is on the amendment. All
- 4:57:20those in favor signify by saying I.
- 4:57:22>> I.
- 4:57:23>> Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:57:25of the chair, the no's have it.
- 4:57:26>> I'd ask for a roll call vote.
- 4:57:28>> The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:57:30>> Mrs. Fischbach.
- 4:57:31>> Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr. Norman.
- 4:57:33>> Mr. Norman, no. Mr. Roy.
- 4:57:34>> Mr. Sajjan.
- 4:57:35>> Mr. Sajjan, no. Mr. Langworthy.
- 4:57:37>> Mr. Langworthy, no. Mr. Scott.
- 4:57:38>> Mr. Scott, no. Mr. Griffith.
- 4:57:40>> Mr. Griffith, no. Mr. Jack.
- 4:57:42>> Mr. Jack, no. Mr. McGovern.
- 4:57:43>> Mr. McGovern, I. Ms. Scanlon.
- 4:57:45>> I.
- 4:57:45>> Ms. Scanlon, I. Mr. Neguse.
- 4:57:47>> Mr. Neguse, I. Ms. Leger Fernandez.
- 4:57:49>> Ms. Leger Fernandez, I. Madam Chair.
- 4:57:50>> No.
- 4:57:51>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:57:52>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:57:53>> Four yeas, eight nays.
- 4:57:55>> The no's have it. The amendment's not
- 4:57:56agreed to.
- 4:57:58>> Madam Chair.
- 4:57:59>> Ms. Leger Fernandez, you're recognized.
- 4:58:01>> I have an amendment to the rule. I move
- 4:58:02the committee make in order amendment
- 4:58:03number 13 to H. Con. Resolution 113
- 4:58:06offered by myself, which would add
- 4:58:08budget reconciliation instructions
- 4:58:10requiring Republicans to fully offset
- 4:58:14any deficit increase in the
- 4:58:16reconciliation bill by requiring wealthy
- 4:58:19individuals and large corporations to
- 4:58:21pay their fair share in taxes, which may
- 4:58:24include reversing or limiting some of
- 4:58:27the tax cuts for the wealthy and
- 4:58:29corporations passed as part of the
- 4:58:31Republicans big, beautifully ugly bill.
- 4:58:34Raising the corporate tax rate, imposing
- 4:58:36a minimum tax on billionaires, or
- 4:58:38closing loopholes used by the
- 4:58:40ultra-rich. You guys can work it out,
- 4:58:42but you should pay for what you want to
- 4:58:46spend, and with that, I yield back.
- 4:58:49>> Is there further discussion on the
- 4:58:51amendment? Hearing none, the question's
- 4:58:53on the amendment. All those in favor
- 4:58:54signify by saying I.
- 4:58:57Those opposed say no. No. In the opinion
- 4:58:59of the chair, the no's have it. The
- 4:59:01amendment's not agreed to.
- 4:59:03The clerk will call the roll.
- 4:59:05>> Mrs. Fischbach.
- 4:59:06Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr. Norman. Mr.
- 4:59:08Norman, no. Mr. Roy. Mrs. Houchin. Mrs.
- 4:59:10Houchin, no. Mr. Langworthy. Mr.
- 4:59:12Langworthy, no. Mr. Scott.
- 4:59:13Mr. Scott, no. Mr. Griffith. Mr.
- 4:59:15Griffith, no. Mr. Jack. Mr. Jack, no.
- 4:59:17Mr. McGovern. Mr. McGovern, I. Ms.
- 4:59:19Scanlon. Ms. Scanlon, I. Mr. Neguse. Mr.
- 4:59:22Neguse, I. Ms. Leger Fernandez. Ms.
- 4:59:24Leger Fernandez, I. Madam Chair.
- 4:59:25>> No.
- 4:59:26>> Madam Chair, no.
- 4:59:27>> Clerk will report the total.
- 4:59:28>> 40 ayes, eight nays.
- 4:59:30>> The nays have it, the amendment's not
- 4:59:31agreed to.
- 4:59:32>> Madam Chair.
- 4:59:33>> Fernandez.
- 4:59:34>> I have an amendment to the rule. I move
- 4:59:35the committee strike section 11 of the
- 4:59:37resolution, which provides that in the
- 4:59:39engrossment of HR8 800, 8800, the clerk
- 4:59:44shall add the text of the Save America
- 4:59:46Act as passed by the House. Uh this is
- 4:59:49the Save America Act that Republicans
- 4:59:51keep adding to every single bill, and
- 4:59:52now they want to put it on NDAA. Let's
- 4:59:56kill this zombie voter suppression
- 5:00:00effort once and for all. So, I suggest
- 5:00:02we strike uh that from the NDAA, allow
- 5:00:05the NDAA to move forward uh on its
- 5:00:09merits or not. And with that, Madam
- 5:00:11Chair, I yield back.
- 5:00:13>> Is there a further discussion on the
- 5:00:15amendment from Ms. Leger Fernandez?
- 5:00:17Hearing none, the question is on the
- 5:00:19amendment. All those in favor signify by
- 5:00:21saying I.
- 5:00:22>> I.
- 5:00:23>> Those opposed say no.
- 5:00:25In the no, in the opinion of the chair,
- 5:00:27the nays have it, the amendment's not
- 5:00:28agreed to.
- 5:00:30Okay, the clerk will call the roll.
- 5:00:32>> Mrs. Fischbach. Mrs. Fischbach, no. Mr.
- 5:00:33Norman. Mr. Norman, no. Mr. Roy. Mrs.
- 5:00:35Houchin.
- 5:00:38Mrs. Houchin, no. Mr. Langworthy. Mr.
- 5:00:40Langworthy, no. Mr. Scott. Mr. Scott,
- 5:00:42no. Mr. Griffith. Mr. Griffith, no. Mr.
- 5:00:44Jack.
- 5:00:47Mr. Jack, no. Mr. McGovern. Mr.
- 5:00:49McGovern, I. Ms. Scanlon. Ms. Scanlon,
- 5:00:50I. Mr. Neguse. Mr. Neguse, I. Ms. Leger
- 5:00:53Fernandez. Ms. Leger Fernandez, I. Madam
- 5:00:55Madam
- 5:00:55>> No.
- 5:00:55>> Madam Chair, no.
- 5:00:57>> Clerk will report the total.
- 5:00:58>> Four yeas, eight nays.
- 5:00:59>> The nays have it. The amendment is not
- 5:01:02agreed to.
- 5:01:03Further discussion or amendment?
- 5:01:07Hearing no further discussion, the
- 5:01:08question's on the motion from the
- 5:01:10gentleman from Virginia. All those in
- 5:01:12favor signify by saying aye.
- 5:01:14>> Aye.
- 5:01:15>> Those opposed say no.
- 5:01:16>> No.
- 5:01:17>> In the opinion of the chair, the ayes
- 5:01:18have it. The motion's agreed to.
- 5:01:20>> for a roll call.
- 5:01:21>> The clerk will call the roll.
- 5:01:22>> Mrs. Fischbach.
- 5:01:23>> Aye.
- 5:01:24>> Mrs. Fischbach, aye.
- 5:01:25>> Aye.
- 5:01:25>> Aye.
- 5:01:26>> aye. Mr. Roy.
- 5:01:27>> Aye.
- 5:01:27>> Houchin.
- 5:01:28>> Aye.
- 5:01:28>> Mrs. Houchin, aye. Mr. Langworthy.
- 5:01:30>> Aye.
- 5:01:30>> Mr. Langworthy, aye. Mr. Scott.
- 5:01:31>> Aye.
- 5:01:32>> Mr. Scott, aye. Mr. Griffith.
- 5:01:33>> Aye.
- 5:01:33>> Mr. Griffith, aye. Mr. Jackson.
- 5:01:35>> Aye.
- 5:01:35>> Mr. Jackson, aye. Mr. McGovern.
- 5:01:36>> No.
- 5:01:36>> Mr. McGovern, no. Miss Scanlon.
- 5:01:38>> No.
- 5:01:38>> Miss Scanlon, no. Mr. Neguse.
- 5:01:40>> No.
- 5:01:41>> Mr. Neguse, no. Ms. Leger Fernandez.
- 5:01:43>> No.
- 5:01:43>> Fernandez, no. Madam Chair.
- 5:01:45>> Aye.
- 5:01:45>> Madam Chair, aye.
- 5:01:47>> The clerk will report the total.
- 5:01:48>> Eight yeas, four nays.
- 5:01:50>> Ayes have it. The motion to report
- 5:01:51agreed to. I'll be managing the rule for
- 5:01:53the majority.
- 5:01:54>> And me.
- 5:01:55>> Yeah.
- 5:01:55>> Me for the majority.
- 5:01:58>> The dynamic duo again.
- 5:02:00The Without objection, the meeting is
- 5:02:02adjourned.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Rules Committee Hearing H.R. 7008, H.R. 6959, H.R. 8884, H.R. 8800, H.R. 9770 , H. Con. Res. 113 by HouseRules, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 49,425 words across 8,284 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.