Rory Sutherland: The Reason 'Smart People' Got Trump So Wrong — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The story I love about the the 2016
- 0:02election. Uh so um
- 0:04Was it that Yeah, it might have been.
- 0:05Hold on.
- 0:06Um
- 0:07Yeah. Uh was that um
- 0:10uh I had a friend who was an academic.
- 0:11He said, "Every single person in
- 0:13academia thought that Hillary Clinton
- 0:15would win
- 0:16except the primatologists."
- 0:19The primatologists who study apes,
- 0:21gorillas, chimpanzees, etc., they all
- 0:23knew Trump was going to win.
- 0:25And it does come down to weird like body
- 0:27language-y stuff.
- 0:28>> Yeah.
- 0:29>> Um it comes down to weird There is an
- 0:32interesting thing, okay,
- 0:36which is
- 0:37There are a few interesting things. One
- 0:39of the things I found hysterical about
- 0:41the US election, where you realize how
- 0:44what you might call elite opinion has
- 0:46become completely out of touch, was when
- 0:49someone at a Madison uh Was it Madison
- 0:52Square Garden's Trump rally? There was a
- 0:54comedian who made a joke about Puerto
- 0:56Rico, okay?
- 0:58>> And it was universally believed among
- 1:00the chatterati that, "Oh, he's
- 1:01completely lost the Latino So, the
- 1:03Latinx." How do you pronounce that? Is
- 1:05it Latinx, okay? "He's completely lost
- 1:08the Latinx vote, okay?"
- 1:11Have you actually met any Latin
- 1:12Americans ever? Because
- 1:15the idea That's as absurd as saying, "If
- 1:17someone had told an anti-Trump
- 1:19anti-French joke, it would offend the
- 1:22British because we identify as European,
- 1:24okay?" Latin Americans, okay, are
- 1:27They're much more nationalistic than
- 1:29they have a sense of Latino solidarity.
- 1:31Cubans, for example, and Mexicans would
- 1:34have found that joke hysterically funny.
- 1:35>> Yeah.
- 1:36>> And it was just this idea of how these
- 1:38people are seeing the world through
- 1:40these bizarre and arbitrary kind of
- 1:42ethnic lenses.
- 1:44>> Yeah, it's really
- 1:45>> That's kind of crazy. You you you know,
- 1:46cuz if you actually, you know, if you
- 1:48watch Narcos, okay?
- 1:50Mexicans and Colombians, it's partly, by
- 1:53the way, just a culture of rudeness.
- 1:55It's not that they necessarily hate each
- 1:56other, but it's just a it's a much much
- 1:59more forthright culture in terms of
- 2:01banter.
- 2:02In any case.
- 2:03>> Yeah, yeah.
- 2:04>> It was American English is is more
- 2:06sensitive to banter than British English
- 2:08is. We're pretty familiar with the what
- 2:10you might call friendly abuse.
- 2:12>> Yeah.
- 2:12>> Okay. And with Americans,
- 2:15particularly places like the Midwest,
- 2:17they can you know, they can kind of miss
- 2:19the cues and think you're being
- 2:21massively rude.
- 2:22Um
- 2:24But I mean
- 2:25uh
- 2:25a large part of that, I mean, people
- 2:28thought that Taylor Swift's endorsement
- 2:30would be absolutely decisive and one has
- 2:31to admit that celebrity endorsement
- 2:34seems to be spectacularly
- 2:36ineffectual.
- 2:37>> Mm. Always has been, but it's
- 2:39counterintuitive.
- 2:40>> And
- 2:40and actually
- 2:42what was weird is the Democrats were
- 2:44paying for people to endorse.
- 2:46>> I know that.
- 2:47>> Okay. So I'm not getting Hold on.
- 2:50How much sincerity do you have about
- 2:53your political beliefs? If you go,
- 2:54"Yeah, yeah, I'll support your campaign,
- 2:56but there'll be 10 million."
- 2:59I mean, that that actually is actually a
- 3:01self-effacing
- 3:02>> Yeah.
- 3:03>> endorsement. You know, it's it's a it's
- 3:05a self-canceling endorsement.
- 3:07>> Yeah.
- 3:08>> Um but it it was interesting because in
- 3:11fairness, okay, I'm going to defend
- 3:12nearly all the pollsters got it wrong,
- 3:14but a colleague of mine in the United
- 3:16States within WPP had what you might
- 3:18call the marketing data on Trump uh
- 3:22versus Harris.
- 3:24And the marketing level data just showed
- 3:26that Trump's uh voltage, which is the
- 3:28technical term used by the brand asset
- 3:30valuator, okay? Trump's voltage was was
- 3:33way way higher and that he said to me,
- 3:36he was in Canada about 5 days before the
- 3:38election. He said, "No, Trump's going to
- 3:39win. Forget all the other stuff."
- 3:41>> Yeah.
- 3:41>> So so there were other modes of market
- 3:43research which were much much closer.
- 3:45One of the cleverest ones was not asking
- 3:48people what they were going to vote. It
- 3:49was asking people what they thought who
- 3:51they thought their neighbors would vote
- 3:52for.
- 3:53>> Yeah, it's interesting. was an ingenious
- 3:55little lateral hack because no one's
- 3:58When we're asked the question about
- 3:59ourselves,
- 4:01our question is what does it say about
- 4:03me to answer this question, not what's
- 4:05the honest answer to this question.
- 4:06Yeah, okay. You know, would you prefer
- 4:08this evening to have um canapés with
- 4:11caviar or KFC? Okay?
- 4:14Your first thought is I better not say
- 4:16KFC cuz it makes me look a bit
- 4:18unsophisticated. But deep down, when
- 4:20you're walking past the bargain bucket
- 4:22repository, you're going to turn left,
- 4:24okay? And so, that was an ingenious That
- 4:27was an ingenious kind of approach to
- 4:29research, which I thought was very, very
- 4:31clever indeed because it's a brilliant
- 4:33way of just taking taking one component,
- 4:37one distorting component out of the
- 4:38information.
- 4:39>> Yeah, that's really uh is it really
- 4:41interesting. And it would But it would
- 4:43be interesting to see whether that still
- 4:44works in 4 years' time cuz as with
- 4:46anything, there is now a bit of a herd
- 4:47mentality of like, "Okay, well, that
- 4:50that will be the golden like a sort of
- 4:52lateral hack to
- 4:53>> It By the way, the for the Democrats,
- 4:56um
- 4:58there's something there, okay? I always
- 5:01describe the difference between ITV and
- 5:03Channel 4 and the BBC.
- 5:06Um
- 5:08somehow, okay, when you watch Channel 4,
- 5:11if you watch Gogglebox, okay, or you
- 5:13watch ITV,
- 5:15you kind of get the impression that the
- 5:17people who make these programs kind of
- 5:19like their audience. They have a kind of
- 5:21affection for the people. In Okay, the
- 5:23person who you really felt liked his
- 5:25audience was Shakespeare, all right? Cuz
- 5:28you have a whole panoply of different
- 5:30characters, some of whom are fat and
- 5:31drunk and ridiculous, but you feel that
- 5:34Shakespeare actually loved humanity in
- 5:37all its kind of
- 5:39variety. Yeah.
- 5:41>> And you have that slight feeling the
- 5:44Democrats have lost that. You don't
- 5:47actually feel that they like the public.
- 5:49>> Mhm. And little phrases like trash or,
- 5:52you know,
- 5:53it was unspeakable as it was
- 5:55etc.
- 5:56Those kind of things you actually get
- 5:58the feeling and it's it's a feeling it's
- 6:00not really about what people say. It's
- 6:02about the body language and the whole
- 6:04way in which things are presented.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Rory Sutherland: The Reason 'Smart People' Got Trump So Wrong by Jimmy's Jobs Clips, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,054 words across 186 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.