RICHARD DAWKINS RIPS RELIGION APART AGAINST BRIAN GREENE!? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00you would like to rid the world of
- 0:02religion is that is that too strong uh
- 0:04that's not too strong okay good all
- 0:06right good all right all right
- 0:08[Applause]
- 0:12good and and so when you say that here's
- 0:15my question um uh are you saying that
- 0:19the structure and the history of
- 0:22religion is something that you just want
- 0:23to get rid of or are you saying that you
- 0:27want to get rid of what some people do
- 0:29in the name of religion do you make that
- 0:31distinction is that one that's relevant
- 0:33I certainly want to get rid of well um I
- 0:37I I see virtue in the effect that
- 0:40religion has had on human culture I mean
- 0:42I see virtue in music and and art and
- 0:45things like that um I but if we think of
- 0:50religion as providing an alternative
- 0:54idea for How the Universe came into
- 0:56existence how life came into existence
- 0:58that kind of thing then um as a
- 1:00scientist I want to get rid of it um so
- 1:04um I mean which I agree with okay well
- 1:08what part do you not want to get rid of
- 1:10yeah
- 1:11good so so um well let me just give you
- 1:15a an example and you tell me where you
- 1:18come down on maybe that's the most
- 1:19straight far way of doing it so um you
- 1:22know in in Jewish so I'm Jewish um uh
- 1:25maybe a few others in the audience um uh
- 1:28thank you uh and and um so so not all of
- 1:32course but but many
- 1:34Jews here in New York view their
- 1:39religion in the following way they're
- 1:41willing to cherry-pick it for the parts
- 1:44that enriched their lives they're
- 1:47willing to throw away the parts that are
- 1:49archaic and just have no place you know
- 1:52in in in in the modern world um they're
- 1:55willing to view it as um almost poetry
- 1:58almost as as fiction literature with the
- 2:02one difference being that it connects
- 2:06them to a long lineage that makes them
- 2:08feel part of a larger narrative is there
- 2:11something that you don't like about what
- 2:13I said I get that totally I no problem
- 2:16with that no problem with that no no
- 2:18because um I mean you you you have a
- 2:21Heritage you have ancestors you have you
- 2:23have literature you have I mean that it
- 2:25it's the same as I feel you no doubt you
- 2:28feel too um a connection with
- 2:31Shakespeare I mean you know it I I don't
- 2:33have any problem with with with saying
- 2:37um I have a Christian Heritage Jewish
- 2:40Heritage in the case of a Jewish
- 2:42Heritage you have an even stronger
- 2:43reason which is the persecution of Jews
- 2:45right um which has happened through the
- 2:47centuries and perhaps most notably in
- 2:50the 20th century but earli centuries too
- 2:54um this is a very powerful reason for a
- 2:57kind of loyalty to a
- 3:00um a
- 3:01tradition um where I part company with
- 3:04it as you do is in
- 3:07in where it makes claims about the
- 3:10universe and and um the the the nature
- 3:14of life and yeah that kind of so when
- 3:16you when you say just for my own Clarity
- 3:18when you say that you when you greed and
- 3:21everyone sort of cheered which is sort
- 3:22of fun uh that you wanted to rid the
- 3:24world of
- 3:25religion I wouldn't have thought that
- 3:28this would then be your reaction to my
- 3:30description well I I suppose by religion
- 3:32I meant the
- 3:35scientific um falsehood of of um of of
- 3:40religion I did not I did not mean
- 3:42tradition because because um there are
- 3:45the Jewish tradition and all sorts of
- 3:46other Traditions tradition in literature
- 3:48tradition in art right um I don't want
- 3:51to get rid of that so then I wonder
- 3:53about about the following so religion as
- 3:56um you know as a word you know few
- 3:59hundred 500 years old or so it's not one
- 4:02that really goes back to uh archaic
- 4:05times so um and and there are some
- 4:09who have thought through the history of
- 4:14religious development and have indicated
- 4:17that the use of religion in the ways
- 4:20that you find utterly unacceptable is
- 4:23relatively recent a relatively recent
- 4:26development so if you take this stru Str
- 4:30that you know go back a handful of
- 4:32Thousand Years wherever you sort of want
- 4:34to you know uh view its Origins you know
- 4:38uh 1500 2,000 BC something of that sort
- 4:41let's just say um uh does it not feel
- 4:45that you're focusing um um so intently
- 4:50on the last part of the development of
- 4:53that structure in a way that at least as
- 4:58I've heard it and it's different from
- 4:59I'm hearing it tonight which is very
- 5:00interesting for me wipes it all out by
- 5:03virtue of what's Happening Now I'm
- 5:04skeptical of the suggestion that uh the
- 5:09scientific falsehood part of religion is
- 5:10recent sorry that the that the
- 5:12scientific falsehood part of religion is
- 5:14recent um I I I've I'm aware that there
- 5:18are people who say that yeah um and I I
- 5:21think they're wrong I mean I I just
- 5:22think if you if you go back to uh the
- 5:26Old Testament it's just it would just be
- 5:29nonsense to say say that the that the
- 5:30characters in that Abraham and and and
- 5:34um David and and um Moses and people um
- 5:38were not interested in the um scientific
- 5:44quasi scientific aspects of it of course
- 5:45they were I mean they were they were
- 5:46obsessed with it they were they were um
- 5:49um they believed that there was a and a
- 5:53a person called Yahweh um who made the
- 5:57world and who actually interv the whole
- 5:59time um who who um wrot Miracles and
- 6:03things like that um I think it's Karen
- 6:06Armstrong who's who's made the made the
- 6:09case that that that that the scientific
- 6:11part is recent I I just just think
- 6:14that's not historically accurate so but
- 6:18if one takes this metaphorical approach
- 6:21as I was sort of describing it in that
- 6:23particular case um
- 6:27um let me actually frame it some it
- 6:30so so um to what extent are uh are are
- 6:35you okay with I don't know how to say it
- 6:38but irrational ideas can I just give you
- 6:40an example again you know um uh I don't
- 6:44know about three weeks ago you know I I
- 6:46live uptown and uh you know my my mother
- 6:49lives over here 81st Street uh she's you
- 6:52know in her 90s and I and I and I called
- 6:55she's always home she doesn't really go
- 6:56out without me I called you know the
- 6:59answering machine picked up she didn't
- 7:01answer I called again she didn't answer
- 7:02starting to like really freak out so I I
- 7:04get in the taxi cab and I'm racing down
- 7:07to 81 Street and I'm telling you in that
- 7:09taxi cab I was praying to God that you
- 7:12would be okay and I'm praying to God and
- 7:14I know that there I do not think there
- 7:16is a God okay this is a totally
- 7:18irrational thing that I'm doing let me
- 7:19just quickly say if you're there I'm
- 7:21sorry all right if you're you I just got
- 7:22to hedge my bets you know it's a
- 7:24conversation here I'm just sort of
- 7:25saying how I feel uh so so but I'm like
- 7:28really uh uh praying and and and and
- 7:31when I got there and everything
- 7:32ultimately was fine um it it it it felt
- 7:36like you know A Small Miracle to me now
- 7:39I don't believe in miracles I believe
- 7:42that were all bags of particles governed
- 7:44by the laws of physics and there's
- 7:45nothing else besides that but at the
- 7:47same time I find it useful to hold these
- 7:50irrational ideas in mind at certain
- 7:53moments and I don't give a that I
- 7:58do yeah
- 8:00um I get that I mean I I think I I I
- 8:03I'll make a similar confession um I
- 8:06would I would hesitate to spend the
- 8:09night in a notoriously haunted
- 8:11house the
- 8:13[Applause]
- 8:17faintest oh this is a good night man uh
- 8:22that is so but but I mean we are both
- 8:23being irrational and and um uh and and
- 8:30and that is a
- 8:32sin I
- 8:37agree all right I'm being waved at to
- 8:39open the discussion for audience
- 8:42questions I can't see who's out there I
- 8:44don't know who has a microphone but
- 8:45whoever need the lights up can we have
- 8:47the lights up please in in the
- 8:51auditorium that's not in not so much on
- 8:53us yeah good perfect that's not perfect
- 8:56it's it in your
- 8:57eyes yeah and can we just about dimly
- 9:00see people
- 9:03now yeah Whoever has a mic just Just
- 9:06Jump Right
- 9:08In good evening and thank you for a
- 9:10wonderful wonderful night I guess my
- 9:13question is how do you
- 9:15dovetail rationality into the social and
- 9:18political dialogue that's going on in
- 9:20the not just the United States but in
- 9:22the world today how do
- 9:25you how do you combat irrationality with
- 9:28rational ity at an emotional
- 9:31level such that it's kind so the
- 9:34question is did you hear it I did I did
- 9:36hear it I was hoping You' answer it yeah
- 9:39I can take a crack and then you can sort
- 9:41of you know back clean up and and finish
- 9:42it up for me I I mean we we we we live
- 9:45in a time when rationality and Truth are
- 9:49not respected in in in corridors of
- 9:52power um and um how do you reconcile you
- 9:56don't reconcile them what you do is you
- 9:58get out and vote the bugger
- 10:07out but I would add one one one quick
- 10:10thing on that um it's it's it's it's
- 10:12virtually impossible I found to have a
- 10:15conversation with somebody who is not
- 10:18going to play by the same rules and and
- 10:22so it's virs impossible to use
- 10:24rationality to convince someone who's
- 10:26looking at the world and describing
- 10:27things in an irrational Manner and I you
- 10:29know I think we once discussed this I'm
- 10:30not mistaken but I saw a video of yours
- 10:32once when you had a long conversation
- 10:35with with a woman and trying to convince
- 10:38her about the um the you know
- 10:41archaeological record right and and I
- 10:44sat there and I and I felt for you
- 10:47because I have had those conversations
- 10:49with people about you know the big bang
- 10:51and things of that sort but it was clear
- 10:53that you were never going to make
- 10:55Headway in that conver so so you stayed
- 10:58with it which is great
- 11:00but that approach probably is
- 11:02ineffective right yeah she was she was a
- 11:04hopeless case um I know I know who you
- 11:07mean her her name is Wendy Wright uh and
- 11:11um she she was she clearly was not
- 11:14listening and and you're right there it
- 11:16was totally lost calls but remember this
- 11:18was a television program so although I
- 11:21was talking to her right it's irrelevant
- 11:24whether I could convince her I clearly
- 11:26couldn't but there would have been lots
- 11:28of people watching that television
- 11:30program true who who would have been um
- 11:33influenced by it and recognizing um that
- 11:37that she was being completely irrational
- 11:39and so um I I I I don't buy the argument
- 11:43of which I've heard often that because
- 11:45you cannot convince the idiot you're
- 11:47talking to um that means that you should
- 11:51should simply um give up I mean um right
- 11:57yeah I guess a quick question but we
- 11:58have others uh would there be another
- 12:00strategy and I don't know what the
- 12:01answer to that question is uh and there
- 12:03are one or two questions uh from the
- 12:05audience still so I think you're you're
- 12:07you're s sure so uh going back to the
- 12:10idea of strength Theory when you guys
- 12:11were talking about how to actually
- 12:13combine the two uh formats of math I
- 12:17guess yes when we since we we are the
- 12:19ones that actually created math to begin
- 12:22with is it possible that what we use is
- 12:25fundamentally flawed to describe what
- 12:27you're attempting to do totally it's
- 12:29totally possible I mean I have i' I've
- 12:31I've had you know thoughts I don't know
- 12:33nightmares that when we have these
- 12:35conversations with the alien
- 12:37intelligence that we ultimately talk to
- 12:39you know they'll come down and say show
- 12:41us guys what have you done and figuring
- 12:44out the universe we pull out general
- 12:45relativity quantum mechanics we open it
- 12:47up and they just sort of look
- 12:50math we tried that you know it takes you
- 12:53part of the way but no no you'll never
- 12:56get anywhere with mathematics you know
- 12:58um and and and the problem is when I
- 13:00then try to imagine what it is that they
- 13:02would substitute for mathematics I don't
- 13:04have the creative imagination to think
- 13:06of anything that isn't ultimately
- 13:08isomorphic to math math just with some
- 13:11different formulation that we could map
- 13:13on to mathematics that we currently use
- 13:16so yes it could be that we have a
- 13:17limited set of tools based on the
- 13:19limited thing inside of our head has
- 13:21taken us so far but maybe it will not
- 13:23take us to the end thank
- 13:25you so when I end up having discussions
- 13:28about science and religion to a
- 13:30surprisingly frequent uh extent I end up
- 13:33encountering the Viewpoint that science
- 13:35and religion are actually one and the
- 13:37same thought process that science is a
- 13:39form of religion uh in one way or
- 13:41another and I try to debate that in a
- 13:43number of ways but I would be interested
- 13:45to hear what you would have to say to
- 13:46someone who says well science really
- 13:47isn't any different from religion in the
- 13:49first place I'll give it real quick one
- 13:50and maybe follow up you know uh there
- 13:53are similarities there are radical
- 13:55differences and the most radical of all
- 13:57is uh show me how to use any religious
- 14:01text I don't care pick anyone that you
- 14:03want show me how to use that to
- 14:05calculate the spectrum of
- 14:09helium right so so there are qualities
- 14:11of the world that we understand
- 14:14rigorously by virtue of the scientific
- 14:17structure it is mathematics that makes
- 14:20predictions that we can go out and test
- 14:22and moreover if we test a prediction and
- 14:24it's wrong we throw the thing away
- 14:27because we are incrementally moving
- 14:30toward truth and that that that's quite
- 14:32different and and let me just quickly
- 14:34also add to that just so you know that
- 14:35I'm not just spouting hot air I really
- 14:38will put you know my money where my
- 14:40mouth is I would be thrilled if tomorrow
- 14:44string theory was ruled out I've worked
- 14:47on it since
- 14:491985 okay I had I had black hair when I
- 14:52started okay um but um I'm not invested
- 14:56in it I'm invested in truth or getting
- 15:00closer to truth and this is the way that
- 15:03we can move toward
- 15:07truth I I have nothing to add to that I
- 15:10mean I I think it's absolutely right and
- 15:12and um there's a huge difference this
- 15:14and the difference is evidence in
- 15:16massive massive massive quantities of
- 15:19evidence and in the case of religion
- 15:22there is absolutely none whatsoever
- 15:26[Applause]
- 15:31uh given the um the singularity at the
- 15:34beginning of the universe the big bang
- 15:37and the uh the evidence that qu that
- 15:40particles are entangled yes that uh if
- 15:44that implies that all particles are
- 15:46thereby entangled with each
- 15:49other does that intuitively have any
- 15:53implications for Consciousness Theory um
- 15:57it's a good question uh since we don't
- 15:59really understand Consciousness as we
- 16:01were describing here it's a little hard
- 16:03for me to give you a complete answer to
- 16:06that but I will say the following it is
- 16:08the case that when particles interact
- 16:11with each other they do acquire this
- 16:13very strange quantum mechanical quality
- 16:16called entanglement Einstein again was a
- 16:19key figure in figuring out entanglement
- 16:21as you no doubt know but just so that
- 16:23we're all clear if two particles are
- 16:25entangled one could be over here one
- 16:26could be over here they could be on
- 16:27opposite sides of the country opposite
- 16:29sides of the universe you measure this
- 16:31particle and somehow it instantaneously
- 16:32affects the particle over there that's
- 16:35weird right Einstein called it spooky
- 16:37spooky action at a distance right now
- 16:40when you have all these particles
- 16:42interacting near the Big Bang they do
- 16:44all become entangled but the thing is
- 16:46the greater the number of particles the
- 16:48more dilute the entanglement becomes and
- 16:52it can be diluted to such a degree that
- 16:54to some extent it doesn't really play
- 16:57the kind of fundamental role that it
- 16:58would with just two particles in a
- 17:00pristine environment that you set up to
- 17:03be maximally entangled so while in some
- 17:07sense everything is connected to
- 17:08everything else and maybe you want to
- 17:10think that Consciousness therefore sort
- 17:11of connected to the world through some
- 17:13quantum entanglement with our brains the
- 17:16degree of entanglement is just so
- 17:17fantastically tiny that it's hard to
- 17:20imagine that that's how things will turn
- 17:23out Richard
- 17:25anything obviously not
- 17:29thank you I'm just
- 17:34fascinated thank you very much for both
- 17:36coming out um and the Lively
- 17:39discussion I had I grew up in New York
- 17:41City and I had a Jewish earth science
- 17:43teacher but you know and so I didn't
- 17:45have the conflict between religion and
- 17:46science that Mr Dawkins grows up with
- 17:49and he just pointed out if you believe
- 17:51the world was created in six days how do
- 17:53we how long would a day have been by
- 17:55that metaphorical understanding um so I
- 17:58was very grateful f for my public school
- 17:59education but my
- 18:02question but uh hey I went to ps87 I 44
- 18:06right down the street so I'm with
- 18:09you my question is entangled with the
- 18:11previous one uh the double slit
- 18:14experiment in quantum physics implies
- 18:16that an electron will behave as a wave
- 18:18when it is not being observed but
- 18:20returns to acting like an particle when
- 18:23we try to observe it judging by the
- 18:25interference pattern it produces this
- 18:27implies that the Universe we live in is
- 18:28conscious without personifying this
- 18:31intelligence would you agree Mr Dawkins
- 18:33that quantum physics implies that our
- 18:35universe is conscious no I me um thank
- 18:40you of course it doesn't imply that it's
- 18:43nothing to nothing to do with it it's
- 18:45it's deeply mysterious but there are
- 18:47there are different ways of being
- 18:49mysterious just because but they're both
- 18:51mysterious it doesn't mean the same
- 18:53thing yeah there can be a um an error in
- 18:58thinking that often tries to imagine
- 19:02that Consciousness plays a critical role
- 19:05in causing the fuzziness of the quantum
- 19:08world to resolve into definite reality
- 19:10such as in the experiment that that you
- 19:12uh describe so well but there's no
- 19:15evidence that Consciousness is a vital
- 19:17part of that story We believe I mean
- 19:20there were people in the 30s and 40s who
- 19:22who put this idea forward and it's very
- 19:25hard to rule it out just like it's hard
- 19:26to rule out many things in the world
- 19:27because we always bring Consciousness to
- 19:29bear on any data that we look at that we
- 19:32become aware of that we can speak of
- 19:34Consciousness is part of it you can say
- 19:36therefore Consciousness was part of
- 19:38ensuring that that reality arose but as
- 19:40far as we know it doesn't need to be
- 19:43Consciousness that brings a definite
- 19:45reality doesn't need a physicist with a
- 19:47PhD it could doesn't could be a mouse
- 19:50could do it it could be a dust Mo that
- 19:52could do it it's any kind of interaction
- 19:55it could be a photon in the microwave
- 19:56background radiation that bangs into the
- 19:58elect on and that forces it to snap to
- 20:00attention so I I don't see any direct
- 20:03role for Consciousness but who knows we
- 20:06could be
- 20:07wrong good evening gentlemen thank you
- 20:10uh one of the tangents we went down
- 20:12tonight was exploring the concept of
- 20:16extraterrestrial life or life outside
- 20:18the Galaxy so from Richard's point of
- 20:20view you said we're sample size of one
- 20:24so all our concepts of what one may be
- 20:28is what we see before us regardless of
- 20:30our imagination and when you look at
- 20:32Hollywood and you look at aliens they're
- 20:34sort of
- 20:36humanoid and I kind of my thinking is
- 20:39any Superior race has to be sort of like
- 20:42us because we got to be able to make it
- 20:43I can't see something with tenacles
- 20:45making a watch so are we limited to what
- 20:50are you limited to what you
- 20:52believe a race may be outside of our
- 20:57existence because we're human and you
- 21:00you we have no other concept to measure
- 21:03against science fiction writers are
- 21:05often criticized for lack of imagination
- 21:07and and uh making them sort of humanoid
- 21:10but with three eyes or you know some
- 21:11minor difference like that there are
- 21:14biologists uh Simon Conway Morris at
- 21:16Cambridge University is one who actually
- 21:18thinks that um the likelihood is that
- 21:23life would produce humanoids uh and and
- 21:27um he goes I think too far but he does
- 21:30make the point that convergent evolution
- 21:33is very powerful and we have spectacular
- 21:37examples in the animal kingdom of
- 21:39different radically unrelated animals
- 21:43converging on the same design because
- 21:47that's a very good way to be uh and uh
- 21:51um you're probably familiar with well
- 21:52for example Australian uh mammals the
- 21:55marsupial forer of Australia produced a
- 21:58range of mammals which
- 22:01were um Niche for Niche convergent upon
- 22:05the mammals in in Asia and independently
- 22:08in South America um so he he
- 22:13deploys the the power of convergent
- 22:16evolution to suggest that if there is
- 22:19life elsewhere in the universe quite
- 22:21probably it will look pretty much like
- 22:23us um I don't think I go along with that
- 22:26quite but but the point has been made
- 22:29um we talked a bit earlier about uh
- 22:32different kinds of life whether it has
- 22:34to be carbon based that kind of thing
- 22:37and um I think it's an open question and
- 22:39I think we can get a sort of handle on
- 22:41the question by looking at the animal
- 22:44kingdom and looking at the the different
- 22:46things that have evolved in the animal
- 22:48kingdom both Divergent and
- 22:52convergent um but I think it's an open
- 22:54question and I would as I said before I
- 22:56would love that I would love to come
- 22:58across
- 22:59a second sample of of of Life I'll look
- 23:02around outside the parking
- 23:04lot I didn't hear that I didn't hear it
- 23:06either but it was definitely
- 23:09funny thank you hi uh you guys have
- 23:12talked a lot about t0 what happened
- 23:14after that I don't think there's been a
- 23:15lot of talk about what happened or not
- 23:17what happened at at d0 what what
- 23:20happened at d0 what created it isn't
- 23:22that and the universe happened 4 and a
- 23:25half well 14 billion years later we have
- 23:27life so everything was so size does that
- 23:30imply some kind of God watchmaker
- 23:32something I mean could you delve into
- 23:33more what you think about what happened
- 23:35before that incident at the Big Bang not
- 23:36everything after well I'll start with a
- 23:38big bang then Rich maybe take it in into
- 23:40the biological domain but uh the the the
- 23:44question you're asking is why is there
- 23:45something rather than nothing and it is
- 23:48the key question and it's one that we
- 23:51really have absolutely no idea how to
- 23:55answer and I think we're all upfront
- 23:58about about that but once we allow for
- 24:01stuff to exist space time matter in some
- 24:05sense the laws of physics with that
- 24:08minimal architecture we can then run
- 24:11things forward and as far as we know we
- 24:13don't need anybody from the outside
- 24:15tinkering with things in order to get
- 24:17things where they currently are so could
- 24:19you say that some God created it and
- 24:21then stood back of course and this has
- 24:23long been said and there's very little
- 24:25that we can ever say to refute that the
- 24:28point of the matter though is it's not
- 24:30very interesting it may be true it ain't
- 24:32interesting why because you're just
- 24:35replacing one mysterious collection of
- 24:37words with another word which to me
- 24:40holds as much mystery so from the
- 24:43standpoint of explaining science I don't
- 24:46find that it takes us anywhere forward
- 24:49from the standpoint of understanding the
- 24:50rich structure of of human Heritage and
- 24:54our ongoing attempt to figure out who we
- 24:57are and how we fit into the cosmos I do
- 25:00find there's a lot of value in that way
- 25:02of thinking about the world but I don't
- 25:04find any value in terms of trying to
- 25:07find scientific explanatory power I
- 25:09think it's worse than that I think it's
- 25:11worse than than um just not interesting
- 25:16um because
- 25:18the the point is that um although it's
- 25:23very difficult to know what happened at
- 25:25in at the at the beginning uh and where
- 25:28the laws of physics come from where the
- 25:30physical constants come from what we can
- 25:32say is that it is relatively easier to
- 25:36understand how simple things came into
- 25:38existence than complex things and um a
- 25:44God who thought it all up and created it
- 25:46even a deistic God who didn't uh
- 25:49subsequently
- 25:51intervene whatever else he she or it was
- 25:56was like they could not be simple I mean
- 25:58if they're going to be we're going to
- 25:59credit them with the brain power to
- 26:02devise the laws of physics and to Divi
- 26:04and to set the physical constants to
- 26:06some optimal value then they've got to
- 26:10be the kind of entity that requires
- 26:13explanation in its own right of exactly
- 26:15the same kind of explanation as we in
- 26:18biology are used to providing in the
- 26:21theory of evolution so it would have to
- 26:24be intelligent in other words and
- 26:26intelligence intelligence creativity
- 26:29uh inventiveness qualities like that
- 26:32come late in the universe we understand
- 26:35where they come from they come from
- 26:36evolutionary processes to suddenly
- 26:38smuggle in intelligence at the at the
- 26:40very beginning is to betray the entire
- 26:44scientific Enterprise so it's much worse
- 26:47than being uninteresting it's positively
- 26:50anti-scientific so so the one thing I
- 26:52would say is
- 26:55um uh well since you got Applause I I'll
- 26:58sort of agree with you but um you you
- 27:00know um you know my my my suspicion or
- 27:03at least I rais as a possibility the
- 27:06Judgment of the complexity and
- 27:09intelligence required to give rise to
- 27:12the universe as we know it I feel like
- 27:15you're coming at it from what we
- 27:18currently understand which could well be
- 27:21completely misleading there may be this
- 27:23incredibly simple starting point that a
- 27:27divine being could have invoked and all
- 27:31of this might by virtue of some deep
- 27:33symmetry in the structure that isn't
- 27:36even apparent it's all simple from the
- 27:39standpoint of the ingredients and and
- 27:41the laws and it may be the so so I guess
- 27:44I slightly worry even though I largely
- 27:46agree with you I slightly worry about
- 27:47saying what would be required because we
- 27:50don't know what would be required that's
- 27:52what I mean by us not being able to
- 27:54figure it out but if it's simple why
- 27:55call it God I mean I no no I agree
- 27:58that's exactly the point that I made it
- 27:59would be just replacing one word with
- 28:01another but I guess I worry about the
- 28:02argument of trying to uh delineate the
- 28:06degree of intelligence and complexity
- 28:07required uh I have no idea whether what
- 28:10you said is true in that
- 28:13regard but if it's just plain Simplicity
- 28:17just call it
- 28:18Simplicity what yeah so so so so that I
- 28:22that I agree with but it was the uh
- 28:24attributing a certain necessary level of
- 28:27complexity intelligence that uh I I find
- 28:29hard but but I agree with the the larger
- 28:31point that we're just replacing one word
- 28:33with another
- 28:34so you see I'm unsatisfied with
- 28:37that I should have stopped when I
- 28:39convinced him with string theory okay go
- 28:41ahead uh yeah if I was listening
- 28:43carefully enough earlier um I think it
- 28:45was said that uh the whole range of
- 28:47physics from quantum mechanics to
- 28:49general relativity you could understand
- 28:51the machine of the brain but not
- 28:54Consciousness and two things occur to me
- 28:57about physics that aren't understood and
- 28:59I'm wondering if you have any comment as
- 29:01whether Consciousness might be fueled by
- 29:04dark energy or by the collapse of
- 29:07Schrodinger's multiplicity into the
- 29:09actual measurable singular so for Dark
- 29:12Energy I it's hard for me to see where
- 29:14there'd be any connection you know the
- 29:16amount of energy in dark energy is so
- 29:19feeble in any volume compatible with
- 29:23everyday experience that it's hard for
- 29:24you to imagine that energy making a
- 29:26significant difference
- 29:28but when you come to uh the collapse of
- 29:31the wave function the schroer equation
- 29:32that you describe there are some very
- 29:34smart people who do draw a connection to
- 29:36Consciousness right Roger Penrose is a
- 29:39very smart man he was my graduate
- 29:42adviser at Oxford for two weeks uh and
- 29:45um and and uh and he is convinced by
- 29:48virtue of analysis that he's done for a
- 29:51decade and experiments that he's done
- 29:53with neuroscientists that there is a
- 29:55connection between microtubules in the
- 29:57brain that can collapse the way function
- 29:59and he believes that that's the seat of
- 30:00Consciousness I've looked at it I'm not
- 30:04I don't I don't see it I'm not convinced
- 30:05of it but I can't say that I've studied
- 30:07it in great detail so so is that a
- 30:10possible link I I guess it it
- 30:13conceivably could be thank you I don't
- 30:15know if you I've tried to read Roger's
- 30:17book but but um I I must say I didn't I
- 30:20I I don't understand Quantum there
- 30:22enough right
- 30:24right hi so my question um it's a fun
- 30:28question that I thought of because we
- 30:30were talking about a little bit um how
- 30:33Lord Kelvin though a really brilliant
- 30:35scientist was astoundingly wrong about
- 30:37certain things about the universe and
- 30:39Earth and so I wonder if we took two
- 30:44well-known scientists from your
- 30:45respective Fields let's say Einstein and
- 30:48uh and uh Darwin and we brought them to
- 30:51our time what do you think that they
- 30:53would be the most astounded and Amazed
- 30:55by with our current scientific
- 30:57understanding and what do you think they
- 30:59would find the hardest to accept or be
- 31:01most skeptical
- 31:03about so I can do Einstein if you want
- 31:05or you want to with Darwin I I I once um
- 31:08had to do a television program in which
- 31:11a Japanese television company uh brought
- 31:15an actor dressed up as Darwin
- 31:19um to visit me and uh I was supposed to
- 31:25bring him up to date as to things that
- 31:27had happened
- 31:30since since his death um and uh it it
- 31:34was an interesting experience because he
- 31:36he he he was well made up he had plenty
- 31:39of slap on which kept on dropping off um
- 31:42and um I so I sort of bowed very low and
- 31:46said what an honor it was to to to meet
- 31:48him and things and then um I had to
- 31:52explain to him about modern
- 31:54genetics and uh he
- 31:58um this would have been very surprising
- 32:01to him very interesting not so much
- 32:02surprising as revelatory to him because
- 32:06in his own
- 32:07lifetime um not only did Lord kelvin's
- 32:11estimate of time worry him he was also
- 32:13worried by a man called Fleming Jenkin
- 32:17who um made the point that uh because of
- 32:22the prevailing genetics of Darwin and
- 32:25Jenkins time which was blending
- 32:28inheritance they were aware that of
- 32:31course that animals inherit from both
- 32:33parents but they thought of it as being
- 32:35a kind of mixture of the mother and
- 32:37father almost like mixing two
- 32:40liquids uh and Fleming Jenkin pointed
- 32:43out that if that were the case um uh
- 32:46Offspring should be intermediate between
- 32:49their two between the two parents and if
- 32:52that were the case then there would be a
- 32:55a rapidly natural selection would run
- 32:57out of variation on which to select um
- 33:01and this did worry Darwin he shouldn't
- 33:04really have worried because it was quite
- 33:06obviously not true that um variation
- 33:09disappears it's it's not it's not the
- 33:10case that as the generations go by
- 33:13animals become more and more gray and
- 33:16sort of uniform they do retain their
- 33:18their their their variation but nobody
- 33:22understood why and it wasn't well me
- 33:25mendle who was a contemporary of Darwin
- 33:27actually did discover why but Darwin
- 33:29never knew about it it wasn't
- 33:31rediscovered until after Darwin's death
- 33:35um so I had to explain melan genetics to
- 33:38this actor posing as Darwin and also um
- 33:42DNA and and um he did his part well he
- 33:45said yes that's
- 33:50it um so I don't know whether that I
- 33:53mean I I I think that is that is one
- 33:55thing that that that would have as I
- 33:58said not not quite surprised Darwin but
- 34:00but but he would have felt yes
- 34:01everything clicks into place now and and
- 34:04I I now that was the one thing that
- 34:06Darwin got wrong he he got precious
- 34:08little wrong I mean if you read the
- 34:09Origin of Species it is an amazingly
- 34:12preent book Michael gizan said he was
- 34:14working a hundred years ahead of his
- 34:17time astonishing man um but the but
- 34:20genetics he did get get wrong and and so
- 34:23that perhaps the answer yes so on the
- 34:25quickly on the Einstein one I I think
- 34:26Einstein would be surprised surprised
- 34:28that quantum mechanics is still with us
- 34:30effectively in the form that he detested
- 34:33um and he thought that advances would do
- 34:35an end run around quantum mechanics and
- 34:37somehow all the weirdness would
- 34:39disappear with a deeper understanding
- 34:41and it hasn't happened um I also think
- 34:43that you know as we describe advanc you
- 34:45know as we describe string theory and
- 34:47and and all the qualities of the theory
- 34:49and and I I think you just say you guys
- 34:50are
- 34:52geniuses utter geniuses
- 35:00[Applause]
- 35:02I have a question for Brian regarding
- 35:04Mass I understand from Einstein that a
- 35:07particle's mass increases with
- 35:09acceleration at CERN they take protons
- 35:12and accelerate them to very close to the
- 35:15speed of light over over
- 35:1699.99% of the speed of
- 35:19light my question is what is the change
- 35:21in the mass of that particle from rest
- 35:23to the point of collision multiply by 1
- 35:25over the < TK of 1 minus V over c squ v
- 35:28is a velocity C is the speed of life
- 35:30thank thank you thanks very
- 35:36much I didn't understand that answer at
- 35:41all so I have to write this but I'm
- 35:43going to ask hopefully for a non-
- 35:45pessimistic answer to this question
- 35:47which is um I'm a little puzzled by the
- 35:51disappointment in the search for
- 35:53extraterrestrial intelligent life
- 35:56because it seems challenging by or
- 35:59severely limited by two elements one is
- 36:01astrobiology which seems to suggest that
- 36:06the combustible energy sources that
- 36:09would be uh they they would they
- 36:12suffocate the species that create
- 36:14sufficient advancement to support radio
- 36:17wave broadcasting we're suffocating
- 36:19ourselves and the other element that I
- 36:22find challenging in terms of evidence
- 36:26for extraterrestrial life is the time
- 36:29synchronization needed to collect a
- 36:32radio signal the duration of a species
- 36:36that broadcasting is probably short yeah
- 36:39the universe when I was growing up we
- 36:41thought it was expanding now you guys
- 36:43have changed the rules again no no still
- 36:45expanding but it's accelerating it's
- 36:47accelerating so in some period of time
- 36:50we're only going to see our own Galaxy
- 36:52so you've got a dual parm problem of
- 36:56combustible energy suffocating us or
- 36:59others and getting the signals to
- 37:03synchronize so why would we see yeah
- 37:08you're pointing out how unlikely these
- 37:10programs are to succeed I mean look life
- 37:12on this planet us began very early on in
- 37:16the history of this planet but uh in
- 37:18that 4 billion year window as you're
- 37:21saying we've only been radio
- 37:22broadcasting what for less 50 75 years
- 37:25so even if an extraterrestrial
- 37:28Society civilization was trying to find
- 37:30us and they sort of knew where to look
- 37:33it wouldn't just be a matter of pointing
- 37:35their Scopes in the right direction
- 37:36they'd have to be waiting for just the
- 37:38right interval of time so so I I think
- 37:41you're pointing out how hard it is and
- 37:43therefore perhaps not surprising that we
- 37:46haven't found any if indeed life is
- 37:49commonplace throughout the Universe and
- 37:50the other thing is look you know we we
- 37:52we now know of so many planets right
- 37:54that's one of the major changes in the
- 37:56last de deade right there are so many
- 37:58planets out there and if a a fraction of
- 38:01them support life right there could be
- 38:04whatever there could be you know 100
- 38:06million civilizations scattered
- 38:09throughout the Galaxy okay but that's
- 38:13one per per enormous number of stars so
- 38:16it's still very sparse even with a 100
- 38:19million civilizations out there so it's
- 38:21hard to find and what about your take on
- 38:25astrobiology and the likelihood of a
- 38:27species suffocating itself I'm curious
- 38:29to hear what yes there a further source
- 38:32of of pessimism would be that the
- 38:35interval of time between a civilization
- 38:37working out how to you send radio waves
- 38:40and destroying Itself by Warfare of some
- 38:43sort it could be I there could be
- 38:46civilizations winking into existence
- 38:49here here and there and then winking out
- 38:50again um after a rather short time uh I
- 38:54I guess that's another aspect of your
- 38:56suffocating
- 38:57so quickly we're at 10:00 but I think we
- 38:59start a little bit late are you guys
- 39:00okay to do another 5 10 minutes is that
- 39:03okay
- 39:06okay uh there seems to be a widespread
- 39:09idea in the culture that in order for
- 39:12life to be meaningful we all eventually
- 39:14have to die and I'm a little skeptical
- 39:18of that idea um it seems Merit
- 39:21trious
- 39:22like makes us feel better that there has
- 39:25to be some meaning um but if you imagine
- 39:28asking someone 50 years going by in
- 39:30their life is your life still meaningful
- 39:32are you involved in useful projects are
- 39:34you advancing things it seems like life
- 39:37could still be meaningful no matter how
- 39:39old you're getting so I wonder what your
- 39:42thoughts are about the necessity of
- 39:44death for the meaning of life I'll let
- 39:45Richard uh well I mean there there is a
- 39:49pretty sound darwinian reason why why
- 39:51why we die um which um I can perhaps
- 39:55briefly explain um
- 39:58genes uh mature at different I mean when
- 40:01I say mature have have their effect at
- 40:02various times during life and most of
- 40:04them have an effect during early
- 40:07embryology um but then they have effects
- 40:09later and later and later um and if you
- 40:12imagine a gene that makes
- 40:15you die of for example cancer at the age
- 40:20of 10 and then another Gene that makes
- 40:22you die at the age of 20 another Gene
- 40:24that makes you die at the age of 30 40
- 40:26Etc um the ones that make you die at the
- 40:30age of 10 are never going to get through
- 40:31into the Next Generation the ones that
- 40:34make you die at the age of 20 a few of
- 40:35them will get through ones that make you
- 40:37die at the age of 30 quite a lot will
- 40:39get through Etc and ones that make you
- 40:41die as you when you're when you're 100
- 40:44will certainly have got through by the
- 40:45time they kill you um so we are um a
- 40:50kind of dpin of late acting lethal genes
- 40:54or Sub sub sublethal genes which is why
- 40:57from a darwinian point of view we die of
- 41:00old age um and there's a more
- 41:03sophisticated versions of that theory
- 41:05but you seem to be
- 41:08um talking rather Less in a darwinian
- 41:11way than in a than in a sort of
- 41:13subjective way saying wouldn't it be
- 41:14nice if we wouldn't wouldn't life feel
- 41:17more meaningful I think with the way you
- 41:18put it um if we didn't die no I I was
- 41:23challenging the idea that people spread
- 41:25that in order for life to be meaningful
- 41:27we have to die like people say life
- 41:30wouldn't be meaningful if we live
- 41:32forever and that just well I don't know
- 41:34who says that I mean well like like
- 41:36Bernard Williams says that I mean there
- 41:37are philosophers who who've thought this
- 41:39issue through and have made cogun
- 41:42arguments that um all the things that
- 41:45give life meaning that we usually list
- 41:48um many of them would evaporate if we
- 41:51didn't die right I mean you know if um
- 41:54you know those of you who uh you know
- 41:56your abil ities could always uh improve
- 41:59over time well if you have infinite time
- 42:01you'll be able to achieve anything so
- 42:03there'll be no real challenge there'll
- 42:05be no sense of success those of you who
- 42:07your abilities will Plateau and hit a
- 42:08limit well for eternity you're going to
- 42:10be stuck right that's not going to feel
- 42:12too good either right so so you know uh
- 42:15but you know these are nice interesting
- 42:16thought experiments um it's hard to
- 42:18really know but I guess from a
- 42:19flat-footed straightforward perspective
- 42:21I just wonder if you had the opportunity
- 42:23hey professor Dawkins you've done so
- 42:25much for Humanity uh we're gonna let you
- 42:28live forever would you would you would
- 42:30you choose that no I I I maybe 200 years
- 42:33but but but um but at the end of the 200
- 42:36they came back to you at the end of the
- 42:37200 and said you know your 200's up uh
- 42:39hey you want a couple hundred more I
- 42:41tell you what I think the the the the
- 42:43the the the only frightening thing about
- 42:46death really is it is eternity and I'd
- 42:52rather spend eternity under a general
- 42:54anesthetic
- 42:59which is what's going to
- 43:01happen all right so we have time for we
- 43:03only have time for two more
- 43:07questions I have a question for both of
- 43:10you uh I'm curious if you think it's
- 43:12possible or even likely that the true
- 43:16nature of reality and physics could be
- 43:18something that's fundamentally just
- 43:21inaccessible to the human mind um
- 43:24because the way our brains are wired no
- 43:26I I you know I um I had a a Nova program
- 43:29years ago on a book I wrote and in one
- 43:31of the scenes I'm at a Blackboard
- 43:33lecturing to somebody who clearly is not
- 43:35getting because I'm getting frustrated
- 43:37and ultimately the C of pans and it's a
- 43:40Labrador Retriever that I was that I was
- 43:42you know and and it was misunderstood by
- 43:43many people they thought we were trying
- 43:45to say the audience is like the dog uh
- 43:47but that that's that's not what it is
- 43:48the point was uh there are intelligent
- 43:51species that walk this planet that seem
- 43:52to have a limit to what they can
- 43:54understand right dogs and cats are smart
- 43:56but they seem not to understand the
- 43:58general theory of relativity right every
- 44:00time I say that I always think the dogs
- 44:02going thinks we don't understand
- 44:03relativity stupid human you know uh but
- 44:06but barring that possibility the Earth
- 44:08is smart beings that have a limit why
- 44:10would we be any different from that
- 44:13that's the point so exactly like you're
- 44:14saying it could be the truth is right
- 44:16out here staring Us in the face but we
- 44:18just don't have the brain power to grab
- 44:20hold of it and maybe we never will now
- 44:22the optimistic way of saying it is even
- 44:25with this limited brain power look what
- 44:26we've been able to figure out right we
- 44:28can figure out laws that tell us how the
- 44:30universe evolved from a split second
- 44:32after the beginning we able to pry apart
- 44:34matter and understand its constituents
- 44:36we understand how time elapses how space
- 44:38expands why stars shine I mean that's
- 44:41pretty great stuff so maybe we have the
- 44:44brain power and it's just a matter of
- 44:46time but nobody can say for sure one of
- 44:49my favorite science fiction stories is
- 44:51Fred H's the black cloud uh despite its
- 44:53obnoxious hero it's probably model of to
- 44:57the author I should imagine um but at
- 45:00the end of the of the book um the the
- 45:03the humans are in touch with a
- 45:04superhuman intelligence and the human
- 45:07superhuman intelligence the black cloud
- 45:09communicates to them its knowledge of
- 45:12physics and they can't take it the human
- 45:14brain just burns up and and
- 45:17two really smart physicists die as a
- 45:20result of overheating of the brain um
- 45:24and and so that that I think is
- 45:25perfectly possible that we are not
- 45:26capable of it on the other hand I agree
- 45:28with Brian um I'm amazed at the fact
- 45:32that a brain which was naturally
- 45:34selected on the African Savannah to hunt
- 45:38and
- 45:40gather is capable of devising special
- 45:44General and general relativity quantum
- 45:46theory and it's it's astonishing what
- 45:48the human brain can do given the much
- 45:52more limited tasks which it was required
- 45:55to do when it was being naturally
- 45:57selected these are emergent properties
- 46:00it's a a
- 46:01wonderful Testament to the power of
- 46:04emergence uh and so there there maybe
- 46:08there isn't a limit but um I don't know
- 46:11one way or the other
- 46:18thanks hello uh do you think that modern
- 46:21physicists are worried enough or
- 46:23spending enough time on uh realism and
- 46:25ontology and specifically what do you
- 46:27think of ban
- 46:29pyo that is exactly the question I'd
- 46:31hoping we'd end
- 46:32on uh so so um yeah so uh we just had a
- 46:37a conference for instance at Columbia
- 46:39last week where the focus was uh uh
- 46:42philosophers were involved and some
- 46:44physicists have sort of described
- 46:47philosophers having no role in physics
- 46:48that's utterly ridiculous these are
- 46:51folks who've thought hard about quantum
- 46:53physics forcing us to really try to link
- 46:56up the mathematical symbols with real
- 46:58things in the world and to shake those
- 47:01dictionaries and make sure that they
- 47:02really work and we're uncertain at the
- 47:04moment so uh on the ontology side people
- 47:08do think about it but it's typically
- 47:10more in the philosophy side of things
- 47:11and I do think that physicist could do
- 47:14more to advance that uh that project in
- 47:17terms of this Boman approach that you
- 47:20mentioned this is a very interesting
- 47:22story that I'll just tell in 30 seconds
- 47:25the approach to Quantum mechanics that
- 47:27Richard was describing you know the
- 47:29Copenhagen approach that was really in
- 47:32some sense promulgated by some very
- 47:35convincing physicists in the 1920s 1930s
- 47:38and so forth Neil's bore being sort of
- 47:40the famous father of quantum mechanics
- 47:42um if the bowan approach had a champion
- 47:46of that magnitude and that level of uh
- 47:49respect I think it would likely have
- 47:52been the dominant way that we would have
- 47:54thought about quantum mechanics why in
- 47:57the Copenhagen approach you have to give
- 47:59up making definite predictions you can
- 48:01only make probabilistic predictions
- 48:03that's hard to swallow okay but you also
- 48:06have to give up particles having
- 48:07definite trajectories particles no
- 48:10longer go along trajectories as in the
- 48:12Newtonian picture in the Boman approach
- 48:15yes you also have to deal with
- 48:17probabilities but particles do have
- 48:19definite trajectories so you only have
- 48:22to sort of give up one thing in the
- 48:24buium framework and you have to give up
- 48:25two in the copen hanging one so I think
- 48:28people would have had an easier time and
- 48:30would have latched on to this way of
- 48:32thinking about things people still push
- 48:34this Theory forward whether or not it's
- 48:36actually right in the sense of it's the
- 48:39real description of the world nobody
- 48:40knows but it's a worthy contender in an
- 48:43arena where many are still competing to
- 48:46win out with the right way of thinking
- 48:48about quantum
- 48:49mechanics end with that thank you very
- 48:53much let's give a big round of applause
- 48:56for Brian green and Richard
- 49:02Dawkins thank you so terrific well done
- 49:05than you
- 49:07wonderful all right you guys thank you
- 49:10so much please join us in the lobby for
- 49:11a book signing uh I think there's a few
- 49:13left to grab sorry can I just say
- 49:15Richard has something to say is my mic
- 49:17still on okay on the book signing um
- 49:21it's a very large audience and uh out of
- 49:24courtesy to people at the end of the the
- 49:26signing queue we don't want to take too
- 49:29long at the beginning of the signing
- 49:31queue and
- 49:32therefore uh we will we cannot
- 49:35personalize actually dedicate books to
- 49:38particular people and also please know
- 49:44selfies all right thank you guys so much
- 49:46uh remember to go to pangman
- 49:47philosophy.com check out our events that
- 49:49are coming up this month and let Art and
- 49:52Science Inspire good night
- 50:02[Music]
- 50:20[Music]
- 50:22many years ago in the coast of the
- 50:24Pacific a young man clawed at his eyes
- 50:27for the vision he prostrate on the
- 50:28ground on the ground in this Village
- 50:30told of a monstrosity called capitalism
- 50:34said the food they crew would be shipped
- 50:36from the country and they barely get by
- 50:38well someone else got the money said the
- 50:40government help these people out with
- 50:42the Army problems that were never big
- 50:44would inflate alarmingly fast but the
- 50:47people walk past he thrashed on the
- 50:50grass nobody paid attention except the
- 50:52few who had a laugh no mind could
- 50:54imagine such a change of scenery the
- 50:56culture was strong and inct like the
- 51:00[Applause]
- 51:02green but not for
- 51:12[Applause]
- 51:15long could we yeah
- 51:24yeah but the change was coming to the
- 51:27planet At Last Man Revolution made it
- 51:30happen really fast
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of RICHARD DAWKINS RIPS RELIGION APART AGAINST BRIAN GREENE!? by Pangburn, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,406 words across 1,191 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.