YouTube2Text

Rich Mass Killer Realizes She's Been Caught 8 Years Later — Transcript

by Dr Insanity · 8,206 words · 1,415 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01You doing okay this morning?
  2. 0:03>> Yeah.
  3. 0:04>> Sorry to wake you up. Well, so my name's
  4. 0:06Tyler and this is Steve.
  5. 0:08>> This is 42-year-old Amy Velardi and for
  6. 0:11the last 8 years, she's been living with
  7. 0:14a terrifying secret [music] that these
  8. 0:17detectives are about to expose.
  9. 0:19>> I got assigned the case by the homicide
  10. 0:22that happened in Pendleton in 2015. So,
  11. 0:24we we'd like to talk to you.
  12. 0:27>> Oh my god.
  13. 0:28>> In 2015, Amy's parents and grandparents
  14. 0:31were found brutally murdered inside
  15. 0:33their family home and with no witnesses
  16. 0:36and no physical evidence connecting
  17. 0:38anyone to the murders, the case slowly
  18. 0:42goes cold.
  19. 0:45>> Say hi, Amy.
  20. 0:46>> Years after the homicides, Amy and her
  21. 0:49husband Ross had moved on spending their
  22. 0:51new found fortune on cars, a new house,
  23. 0:54and expensive exotic animals. But,
  24. 0:56unbeknownst to everyone, the killers had
  25. 0:58been closer to home all along.
  26. 1:01>> Amy's done what she promised she was
  27. 1:03going to do.
  28. 1:04>> And what had killed her?
  29. 1:06Deputies and stuff screwed up all the
  30. 1:07evidence.
  31. 1:08>> You're dead smack in the middle of this
  32. 1:10thing.
  33. 1:11>> But, we're not here because we think you
  34. 1:13did it or you might have did it, we know
  35. 1:15you did it. It's piling up, Ross. We
  36. 1:17don't want to roll the dice on this, I'm
  37. 1:19telling you.
  38. 1:24>> We have been following this case closely
  39. 1:26for several years working alongside
  40. 1:29police departments and legal experts to
  41. 1:30uncover every detail and bring you
  42. 1:33never-before-seen footage investigating
  43. 1:35South Carolina's most disturbing
  44. 1:37quadruple homicide.
  45. 1:40It's approximately 10:30 a.m. on a
  46. 1:42Monday morning just after Halloween when
  47. 1:45the Anderson County Sheriff's Office
  48. 1:47receives a frantic 911 call from what
  49. 1:49sounds like a house of horrors.
  50. 1:52>> Anderson County 911, what's the location
  51. 1:54of the emergency?
  52. 1:55>> Oh my god. I need somebody
  53. 1:58>> Ma'am, I can't understand you. What
  54. 1:59What's your address?
  55. 2:00>> 22717 Redbud Road.
  56. 2:03>> Ma'am, ma'am, tell me what's going on.
  57. 2:05>> Oh my god.
  58. 2:06Oh my god.
  59. 2:07>> Is somebody hurt? Ma'am, I can't
  60. 2:10>> And my mom is home and they're they're
  61. 2:12dead. Like, there's blood everywhere.
  62. 2:15>> Who are these people that are in the
  63. 2:16house?
  64. 2:17>> It's my mom and my grandpa and my granny
  65. 2:20and my stepdad.
  66. 2:22>> On the line is 32-year-old Amy Willard
  67. 2:25reporting that her entire family has
  68. 2:27been murdered. Within minutes, deputies
  69. 2:30rush to the home where the scene
  70. 2:32awaiting them would be even more brutal
  71. 2:34than Amy had led them to believe.
  72. 2:40Once officers step inside, they discover
  73. 2:44three victims. Mike Scott, Barbara
  74. 2:47Scott, and Violet Taylor lying deceased
  75. 2:51on the living room floor.
  76. 2:53Several feet away, inside a bedroom,
  77. 2:56lies the fourth and final victim, Kathy
  78. 2:59Scott. Each family member appears to
  79. 3:01have suffered multiple stab wounds and a
  80. 3:04single gunshot wound to the head. As
  81. 3:06crime scene investigators begin
  82. 3:08processing the home, they discover a
  83. 3:10trail of shoe prints, a Clorox bleach
  84. 3:13bottle sitting in the kitchen sink, and
  85. 3:15two cell phones discarded outside. The
  86. 3:17only significant clues left behind by
  87. 3:20whoever carried out this brutal attack.
  88. 3:22Back outside, deputies speak with the
  89. 3:25911 caller, Amy. She tells officers that
  90. 3:28she and her husband, Ross, live next
  91. 3:30door and became concerned after her
  92. 3:33mother, Kathy, failed to take her dog
  93. 3:35outside this morning. When Amy went to
  94. 3:37check on her, she says that's when she
  95. 3:39discovered the bodies of her parents and
  96. 3:42grandparents.
  97. 3:44After clearing the entire house and
  98. 3:46finding no murder weapon and very little
  99. 3:48physical evidence left behind,
  100. 3:50investigators grow increasingly
  101. 3:52concerned they're dealing with a
  102. 3:54ruthless and calculated killer, and that
  103. 3:57these may not be his first victims. At
  104. 4:00this stage, the only people on the
  105. 4:02investigators' radar are Amy and Ross,
  106. 4:05seemingly grieving relatives of the
  107. 4:07victims. However, later that evening, as
  108. 4:10news of the Scott family murders spreads
  109. 4:12across Anderson County, Amy's
  110. 4:15ex-husband, Neil, contacts police with
  111. 4:18some interesting information.
  112. 4:21>> Said you were married to Amy previously?
  113. 4:24>> I was her first husband.
  114. 4:26I believe she's capable of this. I say
  115. 4:28that because while we were married, she
  116. 4:30tried to stab me.
  117. 4:31>> What brought on y'all's separation? The
  118. 4:33fight or
  119. 4:34>> Oh, actually that was one of three
  120. 4:36fights. One, she just tried to charge
  121. 4:38me, tripped her and laid her down on the
  122. 4:39ground, then when I went back after me.
  123. 4:41The other time was a knockdown, drag-out
  124. 4:43where I was told she hit me in one of my
  125. 4:45fans with a ball bat. I don't remember
  126. 4:47that. So, the separation was on adultery
  127. 4:49charges.
  128. 4:50>> Did you get knocked out or something?
  129. 4:51>> I blacked out.
  130. 4:53>> Listen, Neil, I appreciate you calling
  131. 4:54in, and I'll keep your information
  132. 4:56handy.
  133. 4:57>> Amy's violent history places her under
  134. 4:59suspicion, but that soon becomes the
  135. 5:02least of detectives' concerns, as she
  136. 5:04and Ross begin behaving in ways no
  137. 5:06genuinely grieving couple ever should.
  138. 5:13On Wednesday morning, acting on
  139. 5:15information from Amy's ex-husband,
  140. 5:17investigators quickly secure a search
  141. 5:19warrant for Amy's trailer and rush over.
  142. 5:22The moment they step inside, they're
  143. 5:25struck by a peculiar smell, one eerily
  144. 5:28similar to what they encountered at the
  145. 5:30murder scene. As the search continues,
  146. 5:33detectives uncover an unusual amount of
  147. 5:36cash, $68,000
  148. 5:39bundled inside a bedroom safe, along
  149. 5:41with 18 firearms, all of which are
  150. 5:44seized [music] as potential evidence.
  151. 5:47Considering Amy and Ross's modest
  152. 5:49lifestyle, this discovery immediately
  153. 5:52raises questions. After clearing the
  154. 5:54trailer, investigators ask Amy and Ross
  155. 5:57to come to the station for an
  156. 5:58opportunity to clear their names. And
  157. 6:00interestingly, both agree, almost as if
  158. 6:03they've been expecting this very moment.
  159. 6:06Once Amy and Ross arrive at the station,
  160. 6:08they're immediately asked if they're
  161. 6:10willing to undergo a polygraph test,
  162. 6:12something rarely requested of witnesses.
  163. 6:15Ross agrees and is the first to take a
  164. 6:17seat. But before asking about the
  165. 6:19murders, the examiner would begin by
  166. 6:22trying to better understand the man
  167. 6:23sitting across from him. And Ross is
  168. 6:26about to reveal something from his past
  169. 6:28that makes him almost impossible to
  170. 6:31break.
  171. 6:32>> This is This is Mr. Lark.
  172. 6:33>> I'm polygraphing them. I'm not law
  173. 6:36enforcement in any way, shape, or form,
  174. 6:38or fashion.
  175. 6:38>> I do a lot of tests for law enforcement,
  176. 6:40but I don't have a gun or a badge.
  177. 6:42>> Any medical problems you know about?
  178. 6:45>> Uh physical or
  179. 6:47um nothing physically wrong. Um
  180. 6:49>> Any medical problem?
  181. 6:51>> I am rated for 30% uh for PTSD.
  182. 6:54>> Were you actually in combat or
  183. 6:56I know you had embassy duty. Some
  184. 6:58combat?
  185. 6:58>> Yeah, that that was my last 3 years. My
  186. 7:00first 2 and 1/2 I was infantry unit.
  187. 7:03>> So you was in combat first 2 and 1/2
  188. 7:04years you were there?
  189. 7:05>> Yeah, like it I only did one deployment,
  190. 7:08so it's not like I did like back-to-back
  191. 7:09deployments.
  192. 7:09>> So that you did one deployment in
  193. 7:11combat?
  194. 7:12>> Yes, sir.
  195. 7:12>> Were you in Iraq?
  196. 7:13>> Correct, Iraq.
  197. 7:15>> Now you you've been in the range, you
  198. 7:16know what a gunshot sounds like. Now you
  199. 7:18know what you know what screaming and
  200. 7:20everything sounds like.
  201. 7:22>> Oh, yeah.
  202. 7:22>> Uh you hear anything that was out of the
  203. 7:25ordinary?
  204. 7:25>> Not out of the ordinary.
  205. 7:27Amy sleeps with our television on.
  206. 7:29>> Uh-huh.
  207. 7:30>> I I hate to think that that would be the
  208. 7:32reason why I wasn't able to go save
  209. 7:33someone.
  210. 7:34>> Like Amy hadn't done do this?
  211. 7:36>> No, I don't think she had anything to do
  212. 7:38with this.
  213. 7:39>> Although Ross steers detectives away
  214. 7:42from Amy, his own background has started
  215. 7:45to draw attention to himself. Ross spent
  216. 7:485 years in the Marine Corps. During that
  217. 7:50time, he received extensive hand-to-hand
  218. 7:52combat training with knives, along with
  219. 7:54specialized instruction on how to resist
  220. 7:56interrogation if ever captured by the
  221. 7:59enemy. Realizing this, the examiner
  222. 8:01would allow Ross to share his thoughts
  223. 8:03on who could be responsible. And his
  224. 8:05answer would be unexpected, to say the
  225. 8:08least.
  226. 8:09>> Who do you say did this?
  227. 8:13>> I'm just I have no freaking clue.
  228. 8:15>> Do you know it?
  229. 8:16>> Did I know it? No.
  230. 8:18>> And what you got to tell them?
  231. 8:20>> There's three possible scenarios that
  232. 8:23>> Okay.
  233. 8:23>> Um
  234. 8:23>> Hold on.
  235. 8:25>> One, Mike deals in a lot of gold. Um
  236. 8:29he buys and sells gold. Um he buys and
  237. 8:32sells guns. And he buys and sells video
  238. 8:34games and stuff like that. And maybe
  239. 8:36maybe someone was [music] disgruntled
  240. 8:38with a sale.
  241. 8:40Um or maybe someone noticed that
  242. 8:43you know, he dealt in a lot of this
  243. 8:45stuff and
  244. 8:46figured they'd cash in. I You know,
  245. 8:48that's
  246. 8:49>> Okay.
  247. 8:49>> You know, that's one scenario that could
  248. 8:51be a Yeah, slight possibility. Uh the
  249. 8:54other one, um
  250. 8:56>> [music]
  251. 8:56>> I think it was Tuesday or Wednesday of
  252. 8:58this past week.
  253. 9:00Um
  254. 9:01>> Okay.
  255. 9:01>> He had mentioned to me that he had seen
  256. 9:05um Amy's ex.
  257. 9:06>> Huh?
  258. 9:07>> Amy's ex-husband
  259. 9:09kind of skulking around. Um and then the
  260. 9:11third [music] thing that I've um kind of
  261. 9:14been thinking over the last um
  262. 9:16couple of hour Well, not couple hours,
  263. 9:18but the last 24 is
  264. 9:21the last couple of weeks, Mike has an
  265. 9:24Mike kind of has like a weird habit
  266. 9:26where he'll just kind of walk up to the
  267. 9:27end of the driveway and he'll just make
  268. 9:29you know, kind of make a couple of
  269. 9:31circles and kind of
  270. 9:33look back and forth. And then he'll go
  271. 9:35go and walk up the road. So, don't know
  272. 9:37if that's something that is real
  273. 9:39suspect. I don't know if that's
  274. 9:40something that's relevant, but at this
  275. 9:42point, you know, the detectives are
  276. 9:44telling me, "Hey,
  277. 9:46Yeah, think of anything that might be
  278. 9:48out of the ordinary."
  279. 9:49>> Unsurprisingly, none of Ross's theories
  280. 9:52involve himself or Amy, but now it's
  281. 9:55time for the polygraph, and detectives
  282. 9:57are about to find out whether years of
  283. 9:59Marine training are enough to help Ross
  284. 10:01beat it.
  285. 10:02>> In any of your Marine training, you
  286. 10:03you've all been taught about Have you
  287. 10:05got captured or anything about the
  288. 10:07polygraph or anything?
  289. 10:08>> If you get caught, captured, or
  290. 10:09whatever, you give your name, your rank,
  291. 10:11social security number, blah, blah,
  292. 10:12blah. Don't give any other information,
  293. 10:14so on and so forth.
  294. 10:16>> Did you live in South Carolina?
  295. 10:18>> Yes.
  296. 10:19>> Regarding physically harming any of
  297. 10:20those people, do you intend to answer
  298. 10:22truthfully each question?
  299. 10:23>> Yes, sir.
  300. 10:24>> Before last year, did you ever
  301. 10:25intentionally harm anyone?
  302. 10:27>> No, sir.
  303. 10:28>> Did you physically harm anyone in that
  304. 10:30house?
  305. 10:31>> No, sir.
  306. 10:32>> Is there something else you're afraid of
  307. 10:33last year's question about?
  308. 10:35>> No, sir.
  309. 10:36So, you kept calling it a test. Did I
  310. 10:38pass my test?
  311. 10:40I was just joking. I said, "You keep
  312. 10:41calling it a test, you know, did I pass
  313. 10:43my test?"
  314. 10:48>> The examiner gives nothing away, leaving
  315. 10:50Ross in the dark about whether he passed
  316. 10:52or failed his polygraph. Meanwhile, Amy
  317. 10:55is brought into another room for her own
  318. 10:57test. Like Ross, she's about to be asked
  319. 11:00who she believes is responsible for her
  320. 11:02family's murders, and her answer would
  321. 11:05shift suspicion to someone already
  322. 11:07familiar to investigators.
  323. 11:09>> This is probably going through your head
  324. 11:11a million times since then. Tell me Tell
  325. 11:13me what your theory is.
  326. 11:15>> A lot of different scenarios have went
  327. 11:17through my head.
  328. 11:18>> Mhm.
  329. 11:19>> My uh my ex-husband
  330. 11:23and did not have a good relationship
  331. 11:24with my parents.
  332. 11:26>> Mhm. Can you think of a motive why he
  333. 11:28would be involved in something like
  334. 11:30that?
  335. 11:31>> My mom and stepdad were pushing him for
  336. 11:34child support. We're pushing him to take
  337. 11:36care of his son and
  338. 11:38>> Okay.
  339. 11:39>> And was not doing that.
  340. 11:41>> Okay.
  341. 11:42Tell me why you would not be involved in
  342. 11:44something like this.
  343. 11:46>> I love my family.
  344. 11:49I love them.
  345. 11:50There's no way that I can and especially
  346. 11:53the scene that was in there, I could
  347. 11:55never do that kind of thing.
  348. 11:57>> Okay.
  349. 11:58>> Although Amy attempts to steer
  350. 12:00detectives towards her ex-husband
  351. 12:02Daniel, they have no evidence linking
  352. 12:05him to the murders and are not
  353. 12:06considering him a suspect. But now it's
  354. 12:09time for the test. Unlike Ross, she's
  355. 12:11never been trained to withstand the
  356. 12:13pressure of a high stakes interrogation
  357. 12:14[music]
  358. 12:15and as far as she knows, both her future
  359. 12:18and Ross's depend entirely [music]
  360. 12:21on her results.
  361. 12:23>> Okay, please sit still. The test is
  362. 12:25about to begin.
  363. 12:27Are the lights on in this room?
  364. 12:29>> Yes.
  365. 12:31>> Regarding whether you were involved in
  366. 12:33the deaths of any of those people in
  367. 12:35that double-wide, are you going to tell
  368. 12:36me the [music] truth today?
  369. 12:38>> Yes.
  370. 12:39>> Were you present when any of those
  371. 12:41people in that double-wide were shot?
  372. 12:44>> No.
  373. 12:46>> Did you cause any of those injuries to
  374. 12:48any of those people in that double-wide?
  375. 12:50>> No.
  376. 12:51>> Do you know the name of the person who
  377. 12:53caused any of those injuries to any of
  378. 12:55those people in that double-wide?
  379. 12:58>> No.
  380. 12:59>> You may not be entirely satisfied with
  381. 13:03the way things are going.
  382. 13:05>> No.
  383. 13:05>> Right now.
  384. 13:06>> No, I do not.
  385. 13:07>> Well, I'm just going to tell you right
  386. 13:09up front, you failed the crap out of
  387. 13:10this polygraph.
  388. 13:11>> No.
  389. 13:11>> Okay. There's no doubt in my mind that
  390. 13:14you are involved in some way, shape or
  391. 13:18form in this. Okay.
  392. 13:19>> Great.
  393. 13:20>> And it wasn't even close. It wasn't even
  394. 13:23close. I mean, you failed the cowboy dog
  395. 13:26[ __ ] out of this test. You could not
  396. 13:28have done any worse. Their theory is
  397. 13:31that you're dead smack in the middle of
  398. 13:33this thing and Ross is dead smack in the
  399. 13:35middle of it.
  400. 13:36>> Well, didn't Ross pass it is?
  401. 13:38>> No.
  402. 13:39Hell no. No, he didn't pass it.
  403. 13:43>> If you go smoke and come back and talk
  404. 13:45to us.
  405. 13:46>> Um, I would like to go talk to my lawyer
  406. 13:49in their office next.
  407. 13:51Take your time.
  408. 13:52>> Let me ask you this.
  409. 13:55My goal every time I do this is to be
  410. 13:58fair.
  411. 13:59Do you think I was fair to you today?
  412. 14:02Okay.
  413. 14:03Thank you. I appreciate that.
  414. 14:05>> In reality, from this moment on, Amy
  415. 14:08would hold a grudge against the
  416. 14:09examiner. One that would stay with her
  417. 14:12for years. Despite failing the
  418. 14:14polygraph, the results alone aren't
  419. 14:16enough to prove guilt. Without a
  420. 14:18confession or physical evidence,
  421. 14:20detectives have no choice but to let the
  422. 14:22couple go. And before long, the
  423. 14:25investigation comes to a halt.
  424. 14:30As weeks turn into months, leads begin
  425. 14:33to dry up and the case eventually goes
  426. 14:36cold. For a time, Amy continues giving
  427. 14:40public interviews pleading for the
  428. 14:41killer to be found. But behind closed
  429. 14:44doors, life goes on for Amy and Ross and
  430. 14:47it appears they've put the tragedy
  431. 14:50behind them.
  432. 14:52After inheriting the family's home, the
  433. 14:55couple begins renovating the very place
  434. 14:57where the murders took place. Once the
  435. 14:59work is complete, they move in and
  436. 15:01settle into a comfortable new life
  437. 15:03benefiting from the money left behind by
  438. 15:06[music] the victims. During this time,
  439. 15:09Ross would spend nearly $40,000 on a
  440. 15:11Dodge Ram, a Mustang, [music]
  441. 15:13two Harley-Davidson motorcycles, and a
  442. 15:16Yamaha personal watercraft. Eventually,
  443. 15:19the couple would sell the home and move
  444. 15:21to West Columbia, South Carolina. All
  445. 15:24the while, they would keep the truth
  446. 15:25hidden not only [music] from
  447. 15:27investigators, but also from their own
  448. 15:29children, who were still too young to
  449. 15:31understand where all this new found
  450. 15:33fortune [music] had come from.
  451. 15:35>> Hey, I'm a little nervous.
  452. 15:36>> Honey, I'll show you some.
  453. 15:37>> Yeah, see you. Hope you
  454. 15:39>> little nervous.
  455. 15:45>> It's now 2023, and in an unexpected
  456. 15:48twist, the television series Cold
  457. 15:51[music] Justice approaches the Anderson
  458. 15:53County Sheriff's Office with the hope of
  459. 15:55finally solving the case. And 8 years
  460. 15:57later, the investigation is officially
  461. 15:59reopened.
  462. 16:00>> [music]
  463. 16:01>> Detective Tyler Duncan is assigned
  464. 16:03alongside veteran investigator Steve
  465. 16:05Spingola, and together, they're tasked
  466. 16:08with re-examining every piece of
  467. 16:09evidence collected [music] back in 2015.
  468. 16:12And as he scrolls through years of
  469. 16:14Facebook posts, [music] he comes across
  470. 16:16something unexpected, a video the couple
  471. 16:20would soon regret not deleting. Without
  472. 16:23this recording, detectives might have
  473. 16:25hit yet another frustrating dead end,
  474. 16:28especially since Amy's parents had no
  475. 16:30CCTV cameras surrounding their home. And
  476. 16:32it shows just how important reliable
  477. 16:34security can be, because when something
  478. 16:36happens, every second matters. That's
  479. 16:39why this video is sponsored by
  480. 16:40SimpliSafe home security to provide you
  481. 16:43with a trusted way to secure your own
  482. 16:45home. After I installed SimpliSafe, I
  483. 16:47felt much safer at home knowing that if
  484. 16:50anything moves where it shouldn't, I'll
  485. 16:51be alerted immediately, along with
  486. 16:53real-life security pros who can quickly
  487. 16:55step in help. SimpliSafe's [music]
  488. 16:57brand-new Active Guard outdoor
  489. 16:59protection means those pros can see a
  490. 17:01suspicious person in my driveway and
  491. 17:04speak to them, flash the spotlights,
  492. 17:06even call police before a break-in ever
  493. 17:08happens. Old alarm systems wait until
  494. 17:10the door is kicked in. Active Guard
  495. 17:12tells the intruder, "Hands up, police
  496. 17:14are on the way." while they're still
  497. 17:16outside. The tech is smart enough to
  498. 17:18tell friends from foes, so your partner
  499. 17:20or the dog walker won't trigger a 3:00
  500. 17:22a.m. panic. What I find myself using the
  501. 17:25most is their video doorbell, which
  502. 17:27sends me a notification whenever there's
  503. 17:28motion at my door, and even allows me to
  504. 17:31communicate with anyone at my door
  505. 17:33through its built-in speakers, saving me
  506. 17:35from porch pirates and keeping my
  507. 17:37packages safe. Their app even lets me
  508. 17:39arm or disarm the system, lock the front
  509. 17:41door, check every camera, and see that
  510. 17:43my studio is safe even when I'm not
  511. 17:45home. There are no long-term contracts.
  512. 17:47Plans start at about a dollar a day, and
  513. 17:49there's a 60-day money-back guarantee.
  514. 17:51And today, SimpliSafe has a deal just
  515. 17:54for the Dr. Insanity crew. Save 50% on
  516. 17:57your SimpliSafe security system when you
  517. 17:59sign up for a professional monitoring
  518. 18:00plan and get your first month free.
  519. 18:03Visit simplisafe.com/drinsanity
  520. 18:05to customize yours. There's no safe like
  521. 18:08SimpliSafe. With that said, let's return
  522. 18:11to the video that's about to spell
  523. 18:13serious trouble for Amy and Ross.
  524. 18:16>> You guys keep calling the police.
  525. 18:18>> Okay.
  526. 18:18>> And you guys keep making calls.
  527. 18:20>> I did not call no police. I don't know
  528. 18:22anything.
  529. 18:22>> Yes, you might call the police on us
  530. 18:24last today.
  531. 18:25>> I don't know what day it is. That's all
  532. 18:27right.
  533. 18:28>> He's making calls for Amy and I, not
  534. 18:30only for us personally,
  535. 18:31>> Amy and me, not Amy and I.
  536. 18:34Amy and me.
  537. 18:35If you don't know English, stay in it.
  538. 18:38>> Wow.
  539. 18:39>> Wow.
  540. 18:40Hold on. Let me go get my grandmother,
  541. 18:42who's actually an English teacher, and
  542. 18:44we'll find out who's correct.
  543. 18:45>> Okay.
  544. 18:46>> Why don't you have Grandma come on out
  545. 18:47here real quick?
  546. 18:48>> I don't think your grandma wants to deal
  547. 18:49with this [music] trash. No. This is
  548. 18:52ridiculous at this point.
  549. 18:54>> Dad, you don't know do-do from diapers?
  550. 18:57>> Yeah, that's right, Jamie. I'm a little
  551. 18:59slow.
  552. 18:59>> I'll show you some.
  553. 19:00>> Yep. See you. Hopefully you got
  554. 19:03>> This footage completely contradicts the
  555. 19:05story Amy and Ross had been telling
  556. 19:07police for years, becoming the first
  557. 19:09major lead Detective Duncan believes
  558. 19:12could finally crack the case. [music]
  559. 19:13And so, after 8 years with virtually no
  560. 19:17progress, detective Duncan prepares to
  561. 19:19pay Amy and Ross a visit. A couple who
  562. 19:22have spent nearly a decade believing
  563. 19:24they got away with murder. But what
  564. 19:26detective Duncan is about to do is not
  565. 19:29without risks. Knowing the couple had
  566. 19:31already lawyered up in the past,
  567. 19:33detectives know they have only one
  568. 19:35chance to get this right or risk the
  569. 19:37case going cold for good.
  570. 19:41On December 11th at 8:00 a.m., detective
  571. 19:43Duncan and Spingola head to Amy and
  572. 19:45Ross's new home in West Columbia, South
  573. 19:47Carolina, more than 100 miles from where
  574. 19:50the murders took place. Once they
  575. 19:52arrive, the people inside the house have
  576. 19:54no idea their lives are about to be
  577. 19:57turned upside down forever.
  578. 20:00>> You ready?
  579. 20:00>> Let's go.
  580. 20:12>> There we
  581. 20:13There we go.
  582. 20:14>> Hey.
  583. 20:15>> Hey, let's go.
  584. 20:15>> Hey, Ross.
  585. 20:17I'm Tyler Duncan. I'm with Anderson
  586. 20:18County Sheriff's Office. This is Steve.
  587. 20:20>> Hi, guys.
  588. 20:21>> Let's go.
  589. 20:21>> Um so, we're I got assigned the case
  590. 20:24about the homicide that happened in
  591. 20:25Pendleton in 2015.
  592. 20:27>> Okay.
  593. 20:27>> And uh so, I'm trying to go around
  594. 20:30basically start from the beginning and
  595. 20:32since Amy Is Amy here?
  596. 20:33>> She is. Yeah, she is.
  597. 20:34>> So, since she's the one that called 911,
  598. 20:36I think you were there also. Um
  599. 20:37>> Yeah, well, I mean, I should have just
  600. 20:39after she called 911.
  601. 20:40>> Okay.
  602. 20:40>> Yeah.
  603. 20:41>> So, we we'd like to talk to you. Um
  604. 20:43we're kind of starting from the
  605. 20:44beginning of the case and going back
  606. 20:45through.
  607. 20:46>> Yeah, I mean, my house is a mess right
  608. 20:48now.
  609. 20:48>> Well, that's what we can actually go
  610. 20:49>> I just get We're sitting in
  611. 20:50>> We can get to sit in the car here and uh
  612. 20:52talk to you.
  613. 20:52>> minutes in there.
  614. 20:53>> All right. Do you want to talk to us
  615. 20:55both at the same time?
  616. 20:56>> We'll talk to you separately and we'll
  617. 20:58talk If you want to come on out, we'll
  618. 20:59talk to you and then we can talk to her.
  619. 21:01>> Okay.
  620. 21:04>> After Ross steps out of the house and
  621. 21:06walks towards the detectives vehicle.
  622. 21:08All three men know this could very well
  623. 21:11be their final standoff. The detectives
  624. 21:14have the element of surprise and the
  625. 21:16couple's unsettling digital footprint,
  626. 21:18while Ross relies on a rock-solid story
  627. 21:21backed by years of Marine training. The
  628. 21:23stakes have never been higher as the
  629. 21:25couple's future now rests entirely in
  630. 21:29Ross's hands.
  631. 21:31>> Did we wake you up?
  632. 21:33Oh, I'm sorry.
  633. 21:37So, if you just want to start from the
  634. 21:38kind of the beginning of what you
  635. 21:40remember and and we'll go from there.
  636. 21:42>> All right.
  637. 21:43>> Um
  638. 21:45>> Well, listen, I'm cuz that was quite a
  639. 21:48while ago. Um
  640. 21:49>> I went out to run my errands. I didn't
  641. 21:51really notice anything um
  642. 21:54out of the ordinary
  643. 21:56that I could see or you know, that
  644. 21:58morning. When Amy got up, she noticed
  645. 22:01that her mom's dogs had not been taken
  646. 22:04out yet.
  647. 22:05Which was weird cuz her mom takes her
  648. 22:07dogs out every morning.
  649. 22:09So, so she went out there to
  650. 22:11see why her mom's dogs hadn't been taken
  651. 22:14out.
  652. 22:14Um
  653. 22:16She let her mom's dogs out into the dog
  654. 22:18run
  655. 22:20and
  656. 22:21she went up to the
  657. 22:23house to
  658. 22:24you know, knock on the door, see if her
  659. 22:26mom maybe wasn't feeling well, see if
  660. 22:28something was going on that she didn't
  661. 22:30you know, didn't [clears throat] tell me
  662. 22:31about. So, she opened it up, walks in
  663. 22:36and
  664. 22:37that's when she apparently
  665. 22:38[clears throat]
  666. 22:39found the scene that she found.
  667. 22:42Um
  668. 22:43she went bolting back out of the house.
  669. 22:46Uh
  670. 22:48I believe that's when she made the call.
  671. 22:49I think she called 911 before she called
  672. 22:51me, if I
  673. 22:52remember correctly.
  674. 22:54>> From the start, detectives immediately
  675. 22:56notice a few things. Ross struggles to
  676. 22:59maintain eye contact and the story he's
  677. 23:01telling is one they've already partially
  678. 23:04verified. On the day of the murders,
  679. 23:06surveillance footage captured Ross at a
  680. 23:08nearby QuickTrip, seemingly supporting
  681. 23:10his account. But what appeared to clear
  682. 23:12Ross of suspicion 8 years earlier would
  683. 23:15eventually become one of the strongest
  684. 23:17pieces of [music] evidence against him.
  685. 23:21For now, Ross's story matches his
  686. 23:24original account. But as he continues
  687. 23:25[music] talking, small changes would
  688. 23:28begin to emerge, giving detectives an
  689. 23:31unexpected lead.
  690. 23:32>> Can you describe, I guess, your kind of
  691. 23:34your relationship with with Mike and
  692. 23:36Kathy?
  693. 23:36>> Yeah, so um at first when uh
  694. 23:40uh when Amy and I first started dating,
  695. 23:42um
  696. 23:43uh my relationship with Mike was really
  697. 23:45great, actually. Kathy is one of those
  698. 23:48people that
  699. 23:50if you don't understand her, she's hard
  700. 23:52to swallow. But I mean, overall, I'm I
  701. 23:56mean, she was a really good person, I
  702. 23:58think. Um it's like just some of her
  703. 24:00mannerisms were a little bit
  704. 24:03we'll say fun.
  705. 24:05There was a couple things that kind of
  706. 24:06were red flags, but I don't know if they
  707. 24:08have anything to do with this or not.
  708. 24:11Um one of them was
  709. 24:14at really weird times and weird hours of
  710. 24:16the day and night,
  711. 24:19I would see Mike
  712. 24:21walking around the perimeter of the
  713. 24:23property talking to himself. And
  714. 24:25something like this,
  715. 24:27what do [clears throat]
  716. 24:28where does your investigation normally
  717. 24:30What do you guys normally follow in
  718. 24:32cases?
  719. 24:33>> [music]
  720. 24:34>> TV shows that I watch
  721. 24:36always say, "Follow the money."
  722. 24:38>> [music]
  723. 24:38>> Right?
  724. 24:40That That's one of the biggest things.
  725. 24:41Follow the money
  726. 24:43and you find out where the real motives
  727. 24:46are.
  728. 24:47>> Interestingly, this follow the money
  729. 24:50approach will prove to be the key to
  730. 24:52solving the case, but not in the way
  731. 24:54Ross thinks. After a few more minutes,
  732. 24:57Ross's interview comes to an end and
  733. 25:00he's asked to let Amy know it's her
  734. 25:02turn. As detectives wait for her, they
  735. 25:05know the last time Amy spoke to law
  736. 25:06enforcement, she sat silently as they
  737. 25:09angrily confronted her over failing a
  738. 25:11polygraph test. But now, Amy's attitude
  739. 25:14would be very different and detectives
  740. 25:16are about to see how eight years of
  741. 25:18carrying a terrifying secret had changed
  742. 25:21her.
  743. 25:23>> Who's the victim?
  744. 25:24>> I got that very quickly.
  745. 25:26>> Yep.
  746. 25:26>> Very quickly and
  747. 25:28and he goes on and on and on. Benefits
  748. 25:30from this one.
  749. 25:31>> Excellent.
  750. 25:32>> But follow the money.
  751. 25:33>> Follow the money.
  752. 25:35>> You could tell that he's
  753. 25:36>> Yeah, I saw him.
  754. 25:37>> [music]
  755. 25:37>> Yeah.
  756. 25:37>> And crying and you know
  757. 25:38>> And every time he's talking
  758. 25:41he would look and then when he would go
  759. 25:42to answer and and again I don't I don't
  760. 25:44but but he can't look at you in the in
  761. 25:46the face.
  762. 25:47>> His timeline is extremely off.
  763. 25:51>> You can just hop in the passenger seat.
  764. 25:55Okay. Well, we can
  765. 25:57we can stand outside.
  766. 25:59You doing okay this morning?
  767. 26:00>> Yeah.
  768. 26:01>> Sorry to wake you up. Well, so my name's
  769. 26:03Tyler, this is Steve.
  770. 26:04>> you?
  771. 26:05>> But when we start with a case, you know,
  772. 26:07we're considered a cold case, we want to
  773. 26:09start from the beginning. That's how I
  774. 26:11operate. I hope you have no bad feelings
  775. 26:13with me. Um
  776. 26:14I'm sorry that the maybe the county or
  777. 26:16somebody has has irritated you. I can
  778. 26:18only imagine.
  779. 26:19>> Irritation, you know, you get pretty
  780. 26:21irritated about
  781. 26:23lies
  782. 26:24>> I understand.
  783. 26:25>> and stuff going around
  784. 26:26>> everything else and how that affects
  785. 26:27your children.
  786. 26:29>> Certainly.
  787. 26:29>> And
  788. 26:30>> But we're we're trying to do right by
  789. 26:31your mother, your grand your grandmother
  790. 26:34and then obviously Mr. Scott and and his
  791. 26:36mom. So
  792. 26:37>> I don't know if y'all are
  793. 26:42redoing it and y'all going to do it
  794. 26:43justice and that would be wonderful.
  795. 26:46>> Despite Amy claiming she's okay with the
  796. 26:49case being reopened, her defensive
  797. 26:52demeanor tells detectives otherwise.
  798. 26:54After reviewing the original case file,
  799. 26:56Detective Duncan knows that confronting
  800. 26:59Amy directly has never worked. So,
  801. 27:02learning from their previous experience,
  802. 27:03he decides to take an opposite approach
  803. 27:05to get to the bottom of what Amy truly
  804. 27:08feels about the victims.
  805. 27:10>> What do you remember? What can you help
  806. 27:12us with? Where should we look?
  807. 27:14>> I mean
  808. 27:16I
  809. 27:17I mean, obviously you got to know
  810. 27:18finding
  811. 27:20dead people doesn't really leave you in
  812. 27:22the right state of mind.
  813. 27:24It can do things to you.
  814. 27:25>> Yes, ma'am.
  815. 27:26>> Um
  816. 27:27but [music] and then everything that
  817. 27:29ensued, I mean, honestly, I can't even
  818. 27:30tell you. I can barely remember the
  819. 27:32funerals.
  820. 27:33I don't really remember much about being
  821. 27:35inside the house anymore. I I think I
  822. 27:37blocked that out. That's just and that's
  823. 27:39just how it's going to have to be at
  824. 27:40this point because I've got children.
  825. 27:42I've got to be here for them and I can't
  826. 27:44be in a loon bin.
  827. 27:46We had another girl that I was working
  828. 27:47for. She was around at the time here and
  829. 27:49there. Roxy.
  830. 27:52>> You said her name was Roxy?
  831. 27:53>> Yeah, Roxy Ford.
  832. 27:55>> How about letting So, he Roxy tell us a
  833. 27:57little bit about like the relationship
  834. 28:00between like I guess y'all and the
  835. 28:02family. Uh and I guess it was good and
  836. 28:05then something happened.
  837. 28:06>> Uh yeah, I mean, what happened?
  838. 28:09Um every I mean, a lot of people
  839. 28:11remember what happened.
  840. 28:12We got into it around 4th of July or
  841. 28:14something with Mike. It didn't have much
  842. 28:17to do with with my mom and my
  843. 28:19grandmother, of course. My father died
  844. 28:21when I was 18, so I didn't need another
  845. 28:23father cuz I was 23 and had my own kid.
  846. 28:26And there had always been issues there
  847. 28:28for years.
  848. 28:30>> [clears throat]
  849. 28:30>> But way before this. So,
  850. 28:33he had issues with a couple of my
  851. 28:35ex-husbands. He had issues with a couple
  852. 28:37of my friends.
  853. 28:38>> Now, who who This is Mike?
  854. 28:40>> Yeah.
  855. 28:40>> Okay.
  856. 28:41>> Um
  857. 28:42I really hate to tell y'all this. It
  858. 28:44probably sounds horrible coming from me,
  859. 28:45but he wasn't a nice person.
  860. 28:48>> For the first time in 8 years, Amy
  861. 28:51admits she never had a good relationship
  862. 28:54with her stepfather, but detectives
  863. 28:56would later learn her resentment towards
  864. 28:58him went far deeper. She also points
  865. 29:01Duncan and Spingola towards her friend
  866. 29:04and former employee, Roxy, someone
  867. 29:06detectives now need to interview as soon
  868. 29:08as possible. Before wrapping up,
  869. 29:11detective Spingola has one more question
  870. 29:13for Amy, one they would return to again
  871. 29:16and again throughout the investigation.
  872. 29:19>> How were things going financially at
  873. 29:20that time, okay?
  874. 29:21>> Yeah, it was fine.
  875. 29:23>> No problems?
  876. 29:24>> Nothing abnormal for me.
  877. 29:26>> And you tried to cooperate, and you
  878. 29:28answered questions before?
  879. 29:29>> Yeah.
  880. 29:29>> You took a polygraph?
  881. 29:31>> Yeah.
  882. 29:31>> How'd that go?
  883. 29:32>> Uh, they were like they I don't they
  884. 29:35wouldn't even tell me. They acted like I
  885. 29:37did something horrible on it, you know,
  886. 29:39and it's not that I haven't wanted
  887. 29:42to cooperate. It's just you get to a
  888. 29:45certain point and you see where things
  889. 29:46are going and you're like, you know
  890. 29:47what? This isn't good.
  891. 29:49>> Okay. You're not lost, ma'am.
  892. 29:50Thank you for talking to us.
  893. 29:52>> Thank you. Take care.
  894. 29:54>> She can't remember anything, but because
  895. 29:56she doesn't remember her lies.
  896. 29:58Am I wrong?
  897. 30:01>> Despite Amy's best attempts, detectives
  898. 30:04know her account is full of lies, even
  899. 30:08more so than Ross's. Still, at this
  900. 30:11stage, they have nothing concrete tying
  901. 30:14either Amy or Ross to the murders, and
  902. 30:16the couple knows it. Once detectives
  903. 30:18return to the station, both sides
  904. 30:20realize they're at a pivotal point in
  905. 30:23the investigation, as the next 24 hours
  906. 30:26could determine whether Amy and Ross
  907. 30:28walk free or spend the rest of their
  908. 30:29lives behind bars.
  909. 30:33The following morning, detective Scotty
  910. 30:35Hill and prosecutor Kelly Siegler follow
  911. 30:38up on the previous day's leads and
  912. 30:40decide to pay a visit to Amy's former
  913. 30:42co-worker, Roxy. The detective's hunch
  914. 30:45is that Amy believes this interview will
  915. 30:48strengthen her alibi. But by introducing
  916. 30:50a new potential witness, whatever Roxy
  917. 30:53is about to say now has the power to
  918. 30:55shift the investigation in either the
  919. 30:57detective's or the couple's favor.
  920. 31:04>> Hey Roxy, how are you doing?
  921. 31:05>> I'm good, how are you?
  922. 31:06>> I'm fine.
  923. 31:09Basically, what we We've decided to do
  924. 31:11is start this case [music]
  925. 31:13from the beginning and work it like it's
  926. 31:15never been worked before.
  927. 31:16>> Okay.
  928. 31:17>> Do everything we can. So, obviously, you
  929. 31:19were kind of a big deal in the early
  930. 31:22early days of the case. You worked for a
  931. 31:24Ross named Amy, right?
  932. 31:26And how was she to work for?
  933. 31:27>> Um cool, laid back. Um
  934. 31:31we jumped around a lot, never took
  935. 31:32anything too serious.
  936. 31:34Um I think I seen
  937. 31:36>> [music]
  938. 31:37>> um
  939. 31:38Kathy and
  940. 31:40What was his name?
  941. 31:41>> Mike.
  942. 31:41>> Mike.
  943. 31:42>> Mhm.
  944. 31:42>> Um
  945. 31:43at [music] the the shop, the grooming
  946. 31:45shop, twice. And the first time
  947. 31:48everything was great, and then the
  948. 31:50second time they came, uh it wasn't
  949. 31:52[music] good.
  950. 31:53Um it was kind of I was in the back
  951. 31:55grooming, so I didn't hear everything
  952. 31:57that was going on,
  953. 31:58but
  954. 31:59just watching body language and hearing
  955. 32:01what they were saying
  956. 32:03>> [music]
  957. 32:03>> at the time,
  958. 32:04it wasn't it was something to do with
  959. 32:07money.
  960. 32:07>> Okay.
  961. 32:08>> Um because afterwards, Stacy I'm Stacy
  962. 32:11uh Amy had talked about um how she was
  963. 32:14going to keep her kids away from
  964. 32:17um
  965. 32:18Kathy and Mike.
  966. 32:20>> Mhm.
  967. 32:20>> And that's when they
  968. 32:22we just went kaputs from there. They
  969. 32:23never
  970. 32:24>> [music]
  971. 32:25>> got along after that.
  972. 32:26And then throughout working there, she'd
  973. 32:28always tell me about how [music] she was
  974. 32:30treated growing up and all that, so.
  975. 32:33>> What kind of stuff would she say about
  976. 32:34how she was treated?
  977. 32:35>> Um she told me that she was always a
  978. 32:38daddy's girl and when um,
  979. 32:42her dad passed away
  980. 32:44>> [music]
  981. 32:45>> I think she said her dad had a he was
  982. 32:47working on a car and it crushed him and
  983. 32:49he was
  984. 32:49>> [music]
  985. 32:49>> placed in the hospital
  986. 32:51um,
  987. 32:51and her mom decided to pull the plug on
  988. 32:54him and she said she was only 13 and so
  989. 32:57she didn't really have a say so
  990. 32:59>> [music]
  991. 32:59>> but
  992. 33:00she always uh, hated her mom for that.
  993. 33:03>> What Roxy has just [music] revealed
  994. 33:06could provide detectives with one of the
  995. 33:08strongest motives behind the murders as
  996. 33:11[music] Amy's hatred towards her mother
  997. 33:13over the decision to remove her father
  998. 33:15from life support had only deepened over
  999. 33:18the years and as detectives wrap up the
  1000. 33:20interview and relay their findings to
  1001. 33:22Duncan and Svingala, Amy and Ross are
  1002. 33:24completely unaware that their luxurious
  1003. 33:27life is about to come crashing down.
  1004. 33:31While Amy and Ross continue enjoying
  1005. 33:33their freedom, Duncan and Svingala drive
  1006. 33:35over to two people who knew the victims
  1007. 33:37better than almost [music] anyone else.
  1008. 33:39Their closest friends, Stan and Mary. To
  1009. 33:42see if their stories match, detectives
  1010. 33:44decide to interview them separately and
  1011. 33:46while they expect [music] to hear more
  1012. 33:48unsubstantiated claims, they're about to
  1013. 33:51uncover much more than that.
  1014. 33:54>> Do we just hop in the passenger seat so
  1015. 33:55we can sit down and and talk about what
  1016. 33:57happened back in 2015 real quick?
  1017. 34:00We're investigating the case again going
  1018. 34:02through going through everything.
  1019. 34:05>> Um, and
  1020. 34:07that's kind of why you know, we can kind
  1021. 34:09of talk in private a little bit and just
  1022. 34:11see. I know at some point in time I
  1023. 34:13think you had called and talked with
  1024. 34:14some detectives back back then and stuff
  1025. 34:17so
  1026. 34:17>> I did because I felt like I I needed to
  1027. 34:19tell them what I knew about what Barbara
  1028. 34:22had told me.
  1029. 34:23>> I kind of I kind of come on the case
  1030. 34:25earlier this year um, started reviewing
  1031. 34:27it and stuff um
  1032. 34:29>> I hope you catch them man. I tell you
  1033. 34:31what. We were with him, uh, Kathy was
  1034. 34:33here uh, that uh, Friday before we don't
  1035. 34:35know exactly when she died, either
  1036. 34:37Friday night or Saturday, whatever. But,
  1037. 34:39she and Kelly and and we told the first
  1038. 34:42people we were really good friends. She
  1039. 34:44cleaned her house, but Mike and I were
  1040. 34:46good friends and
  1041. 34:48we sent food home for them.
  1042. 34:50Our food was in their refrigerator when
  1043. 34:52they died.
  1044. 34:53>> I'd say at least 3 months before that
  1045. 34:56happened,
  1046. 34:57she was just a nervous wreck over what
  1047. 34:59was going on uh there in that
  1048. 35:01house. And then that last time I went,
  1049. 35:05that was just a few days before [music]
  1050. 35:07that happened.
  1051. 35:09Uh Barbara was just I mean, she was
  1052. 35:11beside herself crying and and going on
  1053. 35:14about how uh Amy
  1054. 35:17something bad was going to happen
  1055. 35:18because uh uh
  1056. 35:20Amy just
  1057. 35:22seemed like she just hated their guts.
  1058. 35:24>> I [music] think the week that he died or
  1059. 35:27the weekend that he died,
  1060. 35:30I think he told his boss that he knew he
  1061. 35:31was going to die.
  1062. 35:33>> Do you know why he would say that?
  1063. 35:34>> He would get killed.
  1064. 35:36>> He was that afraid?
  1065. 35:37>> Yeah, he just knew. I think they might
  1066. 35:39have I don't remember all of that stuff,
  1067. 35:41but uh
  1068. 35:42you know, but uh
  1069. 35:44>> To the detectives' surprise, neither
  1070. 35:47Stan nor Mary believe these murders came
  1071. 35:50out of nowhere. Their accounts suggest
  1072. 35:52this may have been a planned attack,
  1073. 35:54potentially [music] explaining why so
  1074. 35:56little evidence was left behind. But,
  1075. 35:58what stood out to Stan and Mary even
  1076. 36:00more was the couple's behavior in the
  1077. 36:02days after the murders, convincing them
  1078. 36:04that one of the Valorities is indeed the
  1079. 36:08killer.
  1080. 36:09>> Did you go to the funeral, ma'am?
  1081. 36:10Anything unusual at the funeral?
  1082. 36:12>> Weird.
  1083. 36:13>> Weird why?
  1084. 36:15>> For them just to come in like they were
  1085. 36:17all upset and and concerned about what
  1086. 36:19had happened. That just didn't seem
  1087. 36:21normal to me. I don't know.
  1088. 36:23>> Do you remember anything anything
  1089. 36:24unusual happening at the funeral,
  1090. 36:25anything that stuck out in your mind?
  1091. 36:27>> Do I have to say that?
  1092. 36:28>> Yeah.
  1093. 36:30>> I don't want to say it.
  1094. 36:32>> You know, we we're trying to put this
  1095. 36:34together.
  1096. 36:35>> She was dressed like a
  1097. 36:38>> Red?
  1098. 36:38>> Huh?
  1099. 36:39>> Red dress?
  1100. 36:40>> Uh I don't remember the color dress, but
  1101. 36:42short dress, boots and all that kind of
  1102. 36:44stuff.
  1103. 36:45Kelly will be able to tell you more than
  1104. 36:47I can on that.
  1105. 36:48>> If she wasn't speaking to him or having
  1106. 36:50anything to do with him, I don't know
  1107. 36:52why she decided she'd come in and check
  1108. 36:54on.
  1109. 36:55>> What do you think happened?
  1110. 36:57>> Minute I heard it, I
  1111. 36:59I I thought
  1112. 37:00Amy's doing what she promised she was
  1113. 37:02going to do. I never even considered it
  1114. 37:04being anybody else.
  1115. 37:06>> When you heard they were
  1116. 37:07they were murdered, what was your first
  1117. 37:09thought?
  1118. 37:11>> They killed her.
  1119. 37:13>> What makes you say that?
  1120. 37:14>> They did. They're the ones who killed
  1121. 37:15her.
  1122. 37:16Uh and y'all know that, too. So, several
  1123. 37:19people have told me, you know, just
  1124. 37:20don't have the proof. And what I was
  1125. 37:22told, and I don't know, maybe your
  1126. 37:23sheriff told me that, but uh they went
  1127. 37:26in over there, the
  1128. 37:27uh deputies and stuff thought it was a
  1129. 37:30uh
  1130. 37:31murder, and screwed up all the evidence.
  1131. 37:34>> After speaking with Stan and Mary,
  1132. 37:36detectives Duncan and Spingola know
  1133. 37:38they're closing in on a breakthrough.
  1134. 37:40They just hope it comes fast enough
  1135. 37:42before the couple disappears. Over the
  1136. 37:44following weeks, Duncan and Spingola
  1137. 37:46conduct dozens more interviews with
  1138. 37:48family members and friends, re-examining
  1139. 37:50every piece of evidence to see whether
  1140. 37:52anything had been overlooked over the
  1141. 37:53years. And that's when they come across
  1142. 37:55something peculiar. Amy had insisted
  1143. 37:58from the beginning the $60,000 recovered
  1144. 38:01from her home was her savings. But as
  1145. 38:04investigator Duncan digs deeper, he
  1146. 38:06discovers Amy and Ross's dog grooming
  1147. 38:09business had been earning far less than
  1148. 38:11they originally claimed. That's when
  1149. 38:13Spingola uncovers something critical.
  1150. 38:16While reviewing the victim's phone
  1151. 38:17records, he finds that just days before
  1152. 38:20his death, Mike had photographed stacks
  1153. 38:22of cash to prove to a seller that he had
  1154. 38:25enough money for an upcoming purchase.
  1155. 38:27But upon closer inspection, the serial
  1156. 38:30numbers in this photograph exactly match
  1157. 38:33the cash seized from Amy and Ross's
  1158. 38:35home. Then comes their biggest
  1159. 38:38breakthrough yet. Duncan and Spingola
  1160. 38:40revisit the CCTV footage from the
  1161. 38:42morning of November 1st and identify the
  1162. 38:45shoes Ross was wearing, red Asics
  1163. 38:47Speedstar sneakers. When they compare
  1164. 38:49[music] them to the bloody footprint
  1165. 38:51left at the scene, the match is
  1166. 38:53undeniable. Nearly a decade later,
  1167. 38:55Detective Duncan finally has the
  1168. 38:57concrete physical evidence he's been
  1169. 39:00searching for.
  1170. 39:01On the morning of December 20th,
  1171. 39:03detectives return to the couple's home
  1172. 39:05for what they believe will be their
  1173. 39:07final visit. Once they arrive, they spot
  1174. 39:09Ross's brand new Ford Mustang,
  1175. 39:12confirming the couple hadn't
  1176. 39:13disappeared. While Amy refuses to speak
  1177. 39:15with them this time, Ross agrees to
  1178. 39:18another interview. After eight years
  1179. 39:20without an arrest, Ross is convinced any
  1180. 39:23evidence against him simply doesn't
  1181. 39:24exist. But he's about to get a reality
  1182. 39:26check and his final chance to explain
  1183. 39:29away the damning evidence stacked
  1184. 39:31against him.
  1185. 39:34>> Hey, so we just want to ask you a couple
  1186. 39:36more things and we're going to get out
  1187. 39:37of here, okay?
  1188. 39:40So, there was something that had come up
  1189. 39:43>> [clears throat]
  1190. 39:43>> um while we was looking through the
  1191. 39:45file. Do you remember owning a
  1192. 39:47like a red pair of shoes?
  1193. 39:50>> Red pair of shoes?
  1194. 39:51>> Asics uh Speedstar shoes.
  1195. 39:54>> Don't recall.
  1196. 39:56>> So, there was a video on your phone
  1197. 39:59of you wearing these Asics Speedstar
  1198. 40:01shoes.
  1199. 40:02>> I yeah, I remember those shoes.
  1200. 40:03>> What What happened to the shoes?
  1201. 40:06Cuz I don't think they ever found They
  1202. 40:08never found the shoes.
  1203. 40:10>> That's a good question cuz I have no
  1204. 40:12idea.
  1205. 40:14>> Possibly thrown away?
  1206. 40:17The reason that I ask is we found
  1207. 40:21This is from crime scene photos, and
  1208. 40:23these are confirmed to be ASICS
  1209. 40:25Speedstar shoes.
  1210. 40:26>> Okay.
  1211. 40:27>> Um inside and they have blood droplets
  1212. 40:30on them.
  1213. 40:30And interestingly enough, you're at the
  1214. 40:32QuickTrip wearing those shoes the night
  1215. 40:35of the murders.
  1216. 40:37>> I have no idea how those shoes would
  1217. 40:39have any kind of blood on them. I mean,
  1218. 40:41obviously I was wearing them at the at a
  1219. 40:43QuickTrip on the 31st.
  1220. 40:45>> Well, and they never found the clothes
  1221. 40:47either that you were wearing.
  1222. 40:49>> I mean, I I can understand where that
  1223. 40:50would look like to be a problem, but
  1224. 40:52again, I don't
  1225. 40:55know where the shoes are at the moment,
  1226. 40:57and I don't remember whatever happened
  1227. 40:58to those particular shoes. If something
  1228. 41:01were to have happened that I had done,
  1229. 41:03it would be stupid for me to wear them
  1230. 41:05in the house and then wear them after
  1231. 41:07that.
  1232. 41:08>> Well, that's what I'm saying. They were
  1233. 41:09never found. So, it's almost like you
  1234. 41:11got rid of them. And y'all did benefit
  1235. 41:13from the murders, okay, because you got
  1236. 41:14a lot of money. We've been through your
  1237. 41:15financials, okay?
  1238. 41:17>> Didn't get a lot
  1239. 41:17>> Y'all Y'all Y'all were struggling all up
  1240. 41:21until the murders. The money found in
  1241. 41:22your safe,
  1242. 41:24there's money photos from Mike's
  1243. 41:25computer that match the same serial
  1244. 41:27numbers as the money that was found in
  1245. 41:29the safe. So, it's not savings. That's
  1246. 41:31money that was found inside of Mike and
  1247. 41:33Kathy's house that Mike was saving, and
  1248. 41:36y'all took it after you killed him,
  1249. 41:38okay? And I'm telling you right now,
  1250. 41:39we're going to prove it.
  1251. 41:41>> Or you can roll the dice, and when that
  1252. 41:42jury comes back, I'm telling you, we
  1253. 41:44just said it's not going to be pretty.
  1254. 41:46We're not here because we think you did
  1255. 41:48it or you might have did it. We know you
  1256. 41:51did it. Okay, we're just here as a
  1257. 41:52courtesy. It's piling up, Ross.
  1258. 41:54>> So, you're telling me that And if you
  1259. 41:56guys said you went through my
  1260. 41:57financials, right, you saw where I had
  1261. 42:00made the money.
  1262. 42:02>> And we saw where you spent it.
  1263. 42:03>> No, you didn't.
  1264. 42:04>> Yes, we did.
  1265. 42:04>> Cuz I did not
  1266. 42:05>> cars. Your car was even repoed, buddy.
  1267. 42:08I'm telling I'm not trying to scare you
  1268. 42:09here, but
  1269. 42:10>> That's actually absolutely what you're
  1270. 42:11trying to do.
  1271. 42:12>> Well, I'm not.
  1272. 42:13>> You said it the best, follow the money.
  1273. 42:15We did that. It led right into your
  1274. 42:17single wide. Just telling you.
  1275. 42:19>> Using Ross's own words against him,
  1276. 42:22Detective Duncan and Spingola followed
  1277. 42:24the money and ironically it led
  1278. 42:26detectives straight back to him. For the
  1279. 42:29first time, Ross begins to realize he
  1280. 42:32and Amy may not be as untouchable as
  1281. 42:34they once believed. But even then, he's
  1282. 42:36convinced detectives still don't have
  1283. 42:38enough to secure a conviction and he's
  1284. 42:40about to show them just how confident he
  1285. 42:43really is.
  1286. 42:44>> Let's just play this out in a
  1287. 42:45hypothetical, right?
  1288. 42:47>> Right.
  1289. 42:48>> Let's say a deal
  1290. 42:50happens.
  1291. 42:50>> Right.
  1292. 42:52>> What kind of deal would that be?
  1293. 42:54>> I don't know, Ross. Here's Okay, but
  1294. 42:56here's the deal. With That's a very bad
  1295. 42:58analogy. Here's the thing, sir. Without
  1296. 43:00a deal,
  1297. 43:02there's no hope. Do you believe that? I
  1298. 43:03want you to go and you know, really
  1299. 43:04think about this.
  1300. 43:05>> I I understand that, but my my point
  1301. 43:07being is you guys just brought up my
  1302. 43:09kids.
  1303. 43:09>> Right.
  1304. 43:09>> My wife.
  1305. 43:10>> Right.
  1306. 43:10>> My family.
  1307. 43:11>> Right.
  1308. 43:11>> Mine is going to be
  1309. 43:13better than Amy's cuz I came to the
  1310. 43:15trough first, right?
  1311. 43:16>> Right.
  1312. 43:16>> So, prison time,
  1313. 43:18no matter what,
  1314. 43:20Amy, prison time, no matter what.
  1315. 43:24So, now you're talking about both of us
  1316. 43:25are going to prison.
  1317. 43:27Um
  1318. 43:29my my three kids in here,
  1319. 43:33they grew up without a father and a
  1320. 43:34mother. Granted, my mother would be more
  1321. 43:36than willing to take them. I understand
  1322. 43:38that.
  1323. 43:38>> We're not the ones who put y'all in this
  1324. 43:40predicament, okay? Y'all made a decision
  1325. 43:42for whatever reason, okay, to do what
  1326. 43:44y'all did.
  1327. 43:45>> we made a decision. You passed the law.
  1328. 43:47>> I understand it. We make decisions at
  1329. 43:50under stress.
  1330. 43:51>> now you have Now, I I you know, eight
  1331. 43:53years whatever,
  1332. 43:54now you're going to have to deal with
  1333. 43:55the consequences.
  1334. 43:56>> For
  1335. 43:58almost 10 years now, no one has found
  1336. 44:01anything
  1337. 44:03enough to come [snorts] down here and
  1338. 44:04bother me
  1339. 44:06or my wife or my family.
  1340. 44:09For 8 years, nothing's been enough to
  1341. 44:10come down here, but now all of a sudden,
  1342. 44:128 years later,
  1343. 44:14there's enough evidence to come bother
  1344. 44:15me.
  1345. 44:16Why or how?
  1346. 44:17>> And we found
  1347. 44:18the missing pieces.
  1348. 44:20>> Okay.
  1349. 44:20>> Okay, and I just showed you
  1350. 44:21>> Why Why is it Why is it 8 years later
  1351. 44:25the missing pieces have just finally
  1352. 44:27quote unquote fallen in their place?
  1353. 44:29>> I can't answer that because I wasn't I
  1354. 44:31wasn't the ones that was investigating
  1355. 44:32this case before I got it.
  1356. 44:34>> So, tell me where they fell for sure.
  1357. 44:36>> I don't know.
  1358. 44:37>> I can't plead guilty to something that
  1359. 44:39>> Ross, don't go there. Don't go there
  1360. 44:40anymore, please.
  1361. 44:41>> I have a lot of respect for you.
  1362. 44:43>> All right.
  1363. 44:43>> Don't go there anymore.
  1364. 44:45>> All right. I won't say anything.
  1365. 44:46>> and you did yours. You understand it?
  1366. 44:48>> Yep.
  1367. 44:48>> That's it. That's the bottom line. No
  1368. 44:50more bull
  1369. 44:52>> All right. I won't
  1370. 44:53>> Then if if if that is where we are,
  1371. 44:55then at this juncture, it is time for me
  1372. 44:58to hop out of the truck, and I probably
  1373. 44:59will be contacting an attorney.
  1374. 45:01>> All right. You're free to go. Okay.
  1375. 45:03>> Yep.
  1376. 45:03>> You guys have a
  1377. 45:05nice drive back to Anderson.
  1378. 45:08>> Despite Ross still refusing to admit to
  1379. 45:11the horrific crime he and Amy committed,
  1380. 45:13Duncan and Spingola no longer need his
  1381. 45:16confession. The evidence speaks for
  1382. 45:18itself. Later that day, both Amy and
  1383. 45:21Ross are arrested and transported to the
  1384. 45:23Anderson County Detention Center, where
  1385. 45:24they are charged with four counts of
  1386. 45:26murder. Based on eight years of
  1387. 45:28findings, this is what investigators
  1388. 45:30believe happened on the night of October
  1389. 45:3331st, 2015. Around 11:00 p.m. that
  1390. 45:37night, Amy and Ross walked the short
  1391. 45:39distance from their trailer to the Scott
  1392. 45:41family home. Because they were family,
  1393. 45:43detectives believe they were able to
  1394. 45:45enter the house without forcing their
  1395. 45:46way inside. Investigators believe Mike
  1396. 45:49Scott was attacked first before he had a
  1397. 45:51chance to defend himself. Kathy Scott,
  1398. 45:54Barbara Scott, and Violet Taylor all
  1399. 45:56suffered slash wounds, which
  1400. 45:58investigators concluded were the fatal
  1401. 46:00injuries. After they had already died,
  1402. 46:03each victim was then shot in the head.
  1403. 46:07Detectives believe Amy and [music] Ross
  1404. 46:09then took the cash Mike kept inside the
  1405. 46:11home before leaving the scene. Two days
  1406. 46:13after the murder, Amy returned to the
  1407. 46:15house and placed the 911 call reporting
  1408. 46:18she had discovered the bodies. In
  1409. 46:20February 2026, Amy is found guilty on
  1410. 46:24all four counts of murder and sentenced
  1411. 46:26to four life sentences. As of August
  1412. 46:292026, Ross remains behind bars awaiting
  1413. 46:32trial. If convicted, he too could
  1414. 46:35receive four life sentences, one for
  1415. 46:38each victim.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Rich Mass Killer Realizes She's Been Caught 8 Years Later by Dr Insanity, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,206 words across 1,415 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.