Restorative Justice and the Maori Tradition — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03[Music]
- 0:09with the homie broadly you know but it's
- 0:12it y'all cool place but we call home be
- 0:16more stand up let's go this is the city
- 0:21way rock cities free wet psy
- 0:32no it's just after sunrise in Baltimore
- 0:39and the city's juvenile warrant task
- 0:41force is out on the streets rounding up
- 0:44teenage lawbreakers
- 0:46[Music]
- 0:49he's got prior armed robbery charges per
- 0:52hand gun charges prior carjacking
- 0:53charges definitely not on the right path
- 0:56they gave him the chance by sending him
- 0:58home on some sort of community or home
- 1:01detention apparently he violated that so
- 1:03they gave him a chance not to sit in
- 1:05jail and he obviously blew that so he's
- 1:09gonna go down or juvenile booking
- 1:10facility and it'll be up to a judge or a
- 1:12master there to decide whether or not
- 1:14they do want to incarcerate in which I
- 1:15think probably will happen
- 1:20six days a week city county and state
- 1:23agencies chase down juvenile offenders
- 1:25with outstanding warrants
- 1:29we're gonna be going to the courthouse
- 1:31down here we've got a gentleman that's
- 1:33got an open juvenile escape warrant that
- 1:35also has a pending adult charge an adult
- 1:37court 2004 was his first entry in our
- 1:40system that was for trespassing and then
- 1:43immediately thereafter a CD s possession
- 1:45with intent so that's I mean that's a
- 1:47lot of charges for a juvenile and it
- 1:49seems like from his records here he's
- 1:50been locked up at least twice a year for
- 1:52a distribution so these definitely a
- 1:55narcotic seller and say
- 1:58this is what they call the deep end of
- 2:01the juvenile justice system
- 2:03this young man has been selling drugs on
- 2:05the streets of Baltimore since he was
- 2:07about 10
- 2:10some of these kids get adult charges
- 2:12they're still in the juvenile system
- 2:13down here on probation until they're
- 2:16officially waved into the adult system
- 2:20so this will probably be the last time
- 2:22we deal with this gentleman but
- 2:24apparently he's got close to ten
- 2:27distribution charges as a juvenile and
- 2:29then at least one as an adult for many
- 2:35of these young people the criminal
- 2:37justice system has become a way of life
- 2:40once they've entered juvenile detention
- 2:42the chances of being arrested again are
- 2:45around 70%
- 2:47[Music]
- 2:50kids that go into the system
- 2:52one it's like a revolving door they find
- 2:55themselves in and out of jail but then
- 2:59two kids that go into the system they go
- 3:02into name network they make friends they
- 3:05get smarter they get stronger they could
- 3:07become battle daughter criminals when
- 3:09they go into the system and obviously
- 3:12that makes makes our life as police and
- 3:14detectives more difficult the costs are
- 3:19staggering
- 3:21to lock up one young person for a year
- 3:24costs more than $60,000 the
- 3:28psychological toll and long-term social
- 3:30costs are even higher
- 3:34and along with the serious lawbreakers
- 3:36the system also sweeps up kids who have
- 3:39committed only minor infractions
- 3:43many of those involved with the youth
- 3:45justice system from cops to judges to
- 3:48families are urgently seeking
- 3:50alternatives
- 3:53the system is horribly broken it being
- 3:57focused on punishment and focused on
- 4:00incarceration politicians on both sides
- 4:03of the aisle realize this I mean it's
- 4:06not any longer a liberal or conservative
- 4:08issue when I go to our legislature they
- 4:12all are not happy with the outcomes but
- 4:16there's a strange lack of will to do it
- 4:20any differently dr. Lauren Abramson is a
- 4:23psychologist and an assistant professor
- 4:26at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
- 4:28in Baltimore her interest in youth
- 4:31justice started years ago when she
- 4:33worked for Head Start a preschool
- 4:35program for low-income families there
- 4:39she had first-hand experience with kids
- 4:42whose worlds were rocked by violence and
- 4:44poverty
- 4:46that the headstart center there's always
- 4:48a part of the classroom that has
- 4:50dramatic play and the three and
- 4:54four-year-olds were playing out funerals
- 4:56and we're playing out you know somebody
- 5:00getting stabbed so you see in the
- 5:04classrooms what their lives are like and
- 5:06that was a lot of what was going on it's
- 5:08just something it's not but everybody
- 5:12got you're just nits and Rockwall is the
- 5:14buff man Scotia
- 5:18once they slip into the system I'm not
- 5:20gonna say that it's impossible for them
- 5:22to break out of that lifestyle but what
- 5:24I will say is it definitely becomes far
- 5:27more difficult for them to turn their
- 5:29lives around
- 5:30I got educated you know my parents were
- 5:33strong they were tough for me I know
- 5:36that there's a different way to life but
- 5:38these kids when they get in trouble they
- 5:41don't have strong parents here in 2012
- 5:44where of course everybody is in the
- 5:46financial crisis recreation centers have
- 5:49been cut programs have been cut they
- 5:51have nothing to do these kids today are
- 5:56angry they don't have money so instead
- 5:59of playing like normal kids used to
- 6:01these kids are more focused on how to
- 6:03make money so they can have some of the
- 6:05things that they see much of what they
- 6:07need it's a downhill downhill battle at
- 6:11this point there they're about two
- 6:14million juvenile arrests annually and a
- 6:17relatively small percentage of those
- 6:20children actually end up behind bars
- 6:23that having been said the United States
- 6:26locks up children at rates far in excess
- 6:29of similarly situated countries we lock
- 6:32up kids at a rate of about 17 times
- 6:35greater than France for example now
- 6:38there's nothing in our rates of
- 6:40delinquency to account for that huge
- 6:42disparity and we think the pathway to
- 6:45public safety is paved through the
- 6:47penitentiary and we happen to rely on
- 6:50incarceration far more than similarly
- 6:53governed countries
- 6:55the best research we have about
- 6:58delinquency in the United States
- 7:00indicates that 9 out of 10 teenagers
- 7:04engage in delinquent acts so delinquency
- 7:07in America is a normative phenomenon
- 7:09very common to adolescence of that 90
- 7:13percent about 36% of the kids suffer an
- 7:19arrest the other kids they're like me
- 7:22they were lucky they didn't get arrested
- 7:27only about 25% of these kids are locked
- 7:30up for violent acts but the way the
- 7:34system works instead of changing
- 7:35behavior upon release more than half of
- 7:38these kids will go on to commit another
- 7:41crime in fact a 2011 study showed that
- 7:47involvement with the juvenile justice
- 7:48system at a young age is a strong
- 7:51predictor of adult criminality
- 7:56that leads some to argue that the system
- 7:59itself perpetuates the cycle
- 8:03[Music]
- 8:06if you take a kid a 16 year old and you
- 8:10expel them from school under
- 8:12zero-tolerance for a fight in the school
- 8:15yard and you prosecute him or her in the
- 8:18juvenile justice system and sends them
- 8:21to a year in a Youth Corrections
- 8:22facility that 300 miles from their home
- 8:25you are doing exactly the opposite of
- 8:29what the research would imply you ought
- 8:31to do if what your ambition is is to
- 8:34maximize the odds that these kids can
- 8:37succeed is adults it will turn a rather
- 8:43docile type person into a hardened
- 8:46criminal I've seen kids who've been shot
- 8:49and stabbed on the streets and actually
- 8:50survived and as a result of surviving
- 8:53they get a sense of invincible miss if
- 8:58you will the system definitely hardens
- 9:02people
- 9:09- Lauren Abramson and others the
- 9:12challenge was to figure out a way to
- 9:14push the system to produce better
- 9:16outcomes for young people based on her
- 9:24work in the community and her own
- 9:25research this is one of the best ladies
- 9:28in the world that I know Lauren
- 9:29suspected that the answer might be found
- 9:32in a powerful but controversial approach
- 9:34one that relied on emotions Lauren had
- 9:41studied with a revolutionary
- 9:42psychologist named sylvan tompkins who
- 9:45contended that one of the key motivators
- 9:48of human behavior was emotion
- 9:52Tompkins drew on Charles Darwin's work
- 9:55on evolution particularly his focus on
- 9:58the importance of emotions for human
- 10:00survival Darwin collected photographs of
- 10:05different types of people from around
- 10:06the world showing consistent emotional
- 10:09reactions proof that the same emotional
- 10:12response was universal
- 10:16Tompkins believed that humans were born
- 10:18with nine basic effects hardwired
- 10:21responses to stimuli that evolved to
- 10:24help us survive these effects include
- 10:28anger shame interest joy disgust fear
- 10:33sadness surprise and a repulsion to foul
- 10:37odors for which he coined the term
- 10:39dismount
- 10:42five of these were considered negative
- 10:44effects two of them positive and one
- 10:49neutral
- 10:52[Music]
- 10:54Lauren had worked enough in the juvenile
- 10:57justice system
- 10:58to know that the majority of experiences
- 11:00both offenders and victims had were
- 11:03overwhelmingly negative and then kids
- 11:09are stuck angry they're really angry and
- 11:15then there's just a lack of
- 11:16opportunities that go along with that I
- 11:18mean once you've been in prison you you
- 11:21know felon you can't vote anymore many
- 11:25places you can't get a job and it just
- 11:27sets this spiral of on lack of
- 11:29opportunity and it's devastated our
- 11:32country it's marginalized two whole
- 11:34groups of people
- 11:38Lorin ordinary thinking wasn't going to
- 11:41change the situation did needed
- 11:44something radical I had studied the
- 11:47effects of emotions on health and
- 11:49illness in a very kind of neuroscience
- 11:52kind of way and then I had community
- 11:54work that I was doing and I always
- 11:57thought that they would sort of be
- 11:58parallel interests but I I could not
- 12:03always figure out how to that they would
- 12:05intersect
- 12:07a moment of Revelation came for Lauren
- 12:10when she realized that someone had
- 12:12already combined these ideas and that
- 12:16they lived halfway around the world for
- 12:24nearly a thousand years the Maori people
- 12:27have called the islands of New Zealand
- 12:29home today
- 12:31the Maori make up about 14% of New
- 12:34Zealand's population where they are
- 12:36members of several dozen distinct Kiwi
- 12:38or tribes the Maori are best known for
- 12:46spectacular cultural traditions like the
- 12:48haka an aggressive ritual challenge that
- 12:51incorporates dramatic facial expressions
- 12:54to intimidate opponents they are less
- 13:02well known for an effective approach to
- 13:04justice that gives Lauren hope for
- 13:07Baltimore
- 13:11in Auckland New Zealand teenage
- 13:15offenders their victims and those
- 13:17involved in their case are called on to
- 13:20the sacred Maori meeting grounds called
- 13:22a Mirai
- 13:26[Music]
- 13:31once the call has been made by one of
- 13:34the women of the malai then the guests
- 13:38start to move forward on to the malai so
- 13:41they walking with this assurance that
- 13:44there is a warmth of welcome being
- 13:47extended to them notwithstanding who
- 13:49they are notwithstanding what crime they
- 13:51have performed when they come on these
- 13:55young people they are equals you never
- 13:58get that in a quarterly New Zealand law
- 14:02prohibits revealing the identity of
- 14:04juvenile offenders so their faces have
- 14:07been intentionally blurred it's
- 14:11fascinating watching them coming onto
- 14:13the Menai with the police who arrested
- 14:15them as part of the Polly they're all
- 14:16standing together after they are
- 14:20welcomed in a ritual called PO weary
- 14:22they enter the house and greet one
- 14:24another with an embrace and the
- 14:26traditional Maori greeting called a Hong
- 14:28e touching both nose and forehead
- 14:32represents the exchange of the ha or
- 14:35breath of life
- 14:38this is one of the strengths that our
- 14:42Maori environment can provide it is
- 14:46therapeutic in that sense the therapy
- 14:49begins even before the judgement is made
- 14:54then the people who would say the
- 14:58auditor thought that we are now one so
- 15:01your status now becomes merged with the
- 15:05rest of your hosts
- 15:08this is one of the final steps of the
- 15:11juvenile court procedure but the process
- 15:14is based on a centuries-old Maori
- 15:16tradition called a Hui the tradition
- 15:21required offenders and victims to meet
- 15:24with tribal elders and key family
- 15:26members to talk out the problem and
- 15:28settle it themselves with an agreement
- 15:32the modern version of this process is
- 15:35called a family group conference
- 15:38aspects of our culture like karakia
- 15:41prayer me me acknowledgement we're
- 15:44singing they all play their role in the
- 15:47process if anybody comes in like with an
- 15:52appropriate attitudes angry or
- 15:54frustrated you know the use of kuraki as
- 15:57a way of defusing all those types of
- 15:59things and it puts everyone on the same
- 16:01playing field and once everybody is down
- 16:07on the same level then we're ready to
- 16:09communicate with one another effectively
- 16:10and most importantly we want to see no
- 16:14more burglaries in particular and in
- 16:17this session the presiding judge and a
- 16:19group of tribal elders are evaluating
- 16:22how the offender is complying with the
- 16:24terms of his conference agreement
- 16:27welcome to you the elders intentionally
- 16:31put the proceedings in cultural terms
- 16:34reminding the offender that he's part of
- 16:36something bigger cuter and cuter - oh hi
- 16:41Mary Kay McKie and now take total
- 16:44holistic approaches in addition to the
- 16:47official authority of the court this
- 16:49location has symbolic power the Mirai is
- 16:53the figurative home of all Maori and yet
- 16:56each Maori ewwy or sub tribe has its own
- 17:00unique Mirai the elaborate carvings
- 17:03tells stories of their particular
- 17:05ancestors and history
- 17:09by bringing them to the marae it's not a
- 17:12soft option because all of those
- 17:15protocols that are observed when you
- 17:18come to the marae have been observed
- 17:20ever since Maori arrived here in this
- 17:23country in Maori villages in the past a
- 17:27crime would throw the community out of
- 17:29balance
- 17:31[Music]
- 17:33traditional Maori justice turns on the
- 17:36idea of restoring that balance
- 17:39[Music]
- 17:42to achieve that families of both parties
- 17:45involved with the crime would gather
- 17:47with tribal elders at the Mirai to
- 17:49discuss the incident and it was also an
- 17:55opportunity for the person who committed
- 17:58the crime to understand the effect by
- 18:01being there and feeling the the pain
- 18:04that they've caused
- 18:08the Maori understood the power of
- 18:11emotions like shame to motivate us just
- 18:14as sylvan tompkins research would later
- 18:16show in the 1960s
- 18:18[Music]
- 18:20the group decided together what the
- 18:22consequences would be for the crime a
- 18:24decision based on the Maori concept of
- 18:27o2 or reciprocity the perpetrator and
- 18:32his family had to compensate for loss or
- 18:35damage with a payment of food or
- 18:38property
- 18:39[Music]
- 18:42in serious cases like murder this might
- 18:45require extreme measures for example the
- 18:49offender might have to give up a child
- 18:51to compensate for the lost life there
- 18:58was the idea that by coming up with a
- 19:00plan of making a means that that would
- 19:05achieve reconciliation and it would
- 19:08achieve a restoration of the balance
- 19:11that had been upset by the crime in New
- 19:16Zealand's youth justice system the focus
- 19:18has shifted away from an adversarial
- 19:21approach towards restoration and
- 19:23rehabilitation the punishment focus has
- 19:28not been particularly successful for the
- 19:31young people we're dealing with so
- 19:36instead to bring the young offender into
- 19:38balance not just with his victim but
- 19:40with his tribe and community judge tao
- 19:43manu suggested a cultural immersion and
- 19:48one way of doing that was to return them
- 19:50to the mariah and to return them to
- 19:52their roots their original identity as
- 19:56marvin and work on that strengths work
- 19:59on all of the issues within this context
- 20:02of being here exposed to the spirit of
- 20:05the ancestors and to really give them as
- 20:08much assistance as we possibly can to
- 20:10find a new direction in life that
- 20:13doesn't lead to prison
- 20:16the Maori tradition has helped transform
- 20:19New Zealand's youth justice system it's
- 20:22been so successful that it's been
- 20:24adopted in Australia and is making
- 20:26inroads in US cities like Baltimore you
- 20:29are very lucky those who come here are
- 20:31very lucky because people here they want
- 20:34you to succeed we want you to succeed
- 20:37it's important to remember
- 20:40come here courting you've been given a
- 20:43chance at the end of the paper it's all
- 20:49in the reads okay so come toward the end
- 20:59of the proceedings the offender receives
- 21:01final admonishment and encouragement
- 21:04from his elders you have the potential
- 21:24to be in a final flourish the young
- 21:38offender who has been learning more
- 21:40about his cultural roots Rises and
- 21:42performs a traditional haka with a group
- 21:45of supporters
- 21:49[Music]
- 22:02but Baltimore doesn't have the haka or
- 22:05any of the other traditions that help
- 22:07Maori youth offenders get back on the
- 22:10right path it's just a completely
- 22:12different atmosphere the kids today have
- 22:15no conflict resolution skills everything
- 22:19is fine people lose their lives over
- 22:21simple simple disputes still Lauren
- 22:27Abramson believed that the same
- 22:29principles driving the success of New
- 22:31Zealand conferences could happen in
- 22:33Baltimore that the essential elements of
- 22:36the group conference telling stories
- 22:39using the power of shame and empowering
- 22:41the community to come up with a solution
- 22:43were Universal but she wouldn't know if
- 22:48it could work here until she tried it
- 22:52I was still on the faculty at Johns
- 22:54Hopkins so in my spare time I would
- 22:56contact Department of Juvenile Services
- 23:00schools neighborhoods and it took three
- 23:04years to get it going
- 23:05I was nervous then and I still get
- 23:10nervous when I facilitate which i think
- 23:12is a good thing I mean you never really
- 23:15know what's gonna happen in that circle
- 23:20all the security officer who's by the
- 23:23end of her first five years of running
- 23:25the conferencing program twenty-four
- 23:27hundred people had gone through the
- 23:29process that meant 290 cases had been
- 23:33diverted from overburdened courts
- 23:39most importantly the preliminary
- 23:41indicators were that kids who had gone
- 23:43through conferencing were far less
- 23:46likely to commit crimes again we try to
- 23:50identify appropriate cases for community
- 23:53conference at arraignment stage the
- 23:56arraignment stage is when the case first
- 23:57comes in and the youth is arraigned told
- 24:01what the charges are against him that's
- 24:03an early stage it's a pre-trial stage
- 24:05and it helps keep the case out of the
- 24:08system actually and I should tell you
- 24:10something about the respondents also is
- 24:13that they're young the cases we most
- 24:15refer to community conferencing are
- 24:17assaults thefts and malicious
- 24:21destruction there are cases that involve
- 24:24a victim this is Miss Bartlett the
- 24:25manager because it's low tech and low
- 24:28admin a single conference cost 90
- 24:31percent less than a court case
- 24:37and conferences usually take place
- 24:39within weeks of the incident while cases
- 24:42that go to court are often delayed for
- 24:44months
- 24:4795% of conferences are successful this
- 24:52is partly due to intensive training of
- 24:54facilitators who follow a very specific
- 24:57simple script
- 25:01misty Faye has been facilitating
- 25:04conferences for 12 years I'm gonna go
- 25:06around and say who everybody is just so
- 25:08you all know each other and then you're
- 25:11gonna talk about what happened
- 25:12conferencing can be especially effective
- 25:15at handling cases that clog up the
- 25:17system
- 25:19these boys broke into a neighbor's house
- 25:22and stole a roll of toilet paper they've
- 25:25been charged with first degree burglary
- 25:27petty theft and destruction of property
- 25:31it may seem trivial but first-degree
- 25:34burglary is a felony charge it's the
- 25:36money we were outside playing football
- 25:42football at least lady came out and told
- 25:45us they'd do it too loud
- 25:48it becomes play football there cuz she
- 25:49was trying to sleep so we had moved over
- 25:52to this little area and Tricia had noise
- 25:54there was a whole little window it was
- 25:56cream oh yeah no I was like and I seen
- 26:00that old baby right there and that's all
- 26:02I seen the holes like and that's why I
- 26:03was laughing and stuff he had told you
- 26:06money like you could reach through there
- 26:07grab it it does we kept old know that
- 26:10don't do that
- 26:11but the money took it anyway he threw it
- 26:14I was just standing looking and that's
- 26:16when mr. Epps and his wife at came and
- 26:19he said since nobody wanted to get
- 26:21parents they were gonna call the police
- 26:23and that's when police officer was out
- 26:25there he was asking this question just
- 26:28to him like felony I'm like 10 years old
- 26:31and if I don't do anything about this
- 26:33you have a felony on you
- 26:35it's just was like it went from innocent
- 26:38to delinquent and so fast in my eyes and
- 26:41I was just like I really didn't know
- 26:43what to do so I was just kind of like
- 26:46sad
- 26:49yeah it helped us when we convene a
- 26:52conference basically we're widening the
- 26:55circle of who's there
- 26:56it's each of those young people and
- 26:59their family members and the people in
- 27:02their life who they care about and who
- 27:03care about them when they decide what
- 27:06can be done to make this better there's
- 27:0815 people that are part of the solutions
- 27:11as opposed to two people you know you
- 27:15don't go messin with people's stuff you
- 27:17don't go touching things that don't
- 27:19belong to you
- 27:20you don't go and touch even if it is
- 27:23just for fun just to do something
- 27:25because like this gentleman say here the
- 27:28consequences are done you get your ass
- 27:30that's your ass I don't need to be using
- 27:34vulgar language I apologize but I'm
- 27:36telling you the severity of it is you
- 27:40know we all know how we was how we was
- 27:44all raised to come up we would have got
- 27:45seriously in trouble
- 27:47mm-hmm then had to work to pay it off
- 27:50kids can end up in the system for the
- 27:53most ridiculous
- 27:55I kinda mean just kind of really minor
- 27:56things and then they're stuck in this
- 27:58system or it could have gotten dismissed
- 28:01at court at which point nobody really
- 28:04learned anything from it and they're
- 28:06back out in the street doing the same
- 28:07thing within the next day or the next
- 28:10week instead this case was referred from
- 28:14the Juvenile Services Division of the
- 28:16state's attorney's office if it had gone
- 28:19to court each one of these boys and
- 28:21their families would have faced a
- 28:22lengthy legal process you got to hire
- 28:27lawyers so it puts a stress on finances
- 28:32to begin with and then the offender
- 28:37oftentimes will get punished by the
- 28:40judge will have a sentence the victim
- 28:44really has no role in court so you know
- 28:48you're making shorter eggs for the
- 28:50normal process often results in
- 28:52frustration misunderstood if they go to
- 28:55court and victims are kept quiet and
- 28:59have to sit there and listen to lawyers
- 29:01arguing and trying to distort things so
- 29:04that they'll win the case that's just
- 29:08gonna make them more angry and offenders
- 29:11don't get a chance to learn how to do
- 29:13things any differently and and they get
- 29:16punished and sent away and that makes
- 29:17them angry what what part did my son
- 29:20play in it we need to be able to express
- 29:23our effect it's part of our biology you
- 29:25know the positive and the negative we
- 29:28need to be able to to give voice to it
- 29:30and to not put a lid on it
- 29:32and so what conferences really do very
- 29:38powerfully is create a space for people
- 29:40to do that and when they can give voice
- 29:43to that then it can shift into something
- 29:46else as a conference unfolds everyone
- 29:50gets a chance to tell their story in
- 29:53doing that the key emotions or effects
- 29:57present in the Maori process come out
- 29:59like shame it was kind of stupid cuz it
- 30:08was just twelve people stupid I almost
- 30:1110 at one time so I do understand the
- 30:14boys get bored and rambunctious but they
- 30:17violated you violated this man's home
- 30:19you violated him and his wife I don't
- 30:23want something like that and something
- 30:25that small can actually alter your whole
- 30:27life because it was just a kid joke but
- 30:31that's not a joke you don't do that the
- 30:35important thing is for the kids to
- 30:38understand that number one I mean as
- 30:42adults it happens all the time you have
- 30:43guilt by association if there is
- 30:45something going on that you know
- 30:46shouldn't be going on and you stick
- 30:48around whether you're a part of it or
- 30:49not
- 30:49you're going down just like you were the
- 30:52one that did it this is this right we
- 30:55could sit here and go around around and
- 30:57rail you want to give them every chance
- 30:59to say what they need to say so that it
- 31:02can be transformed into something else
- 31:04and that's the power of it when that
- 31:07happens a change takes place in the
- 31:09conference what the facilitators refer
- 31:12to as the shift the first thing I would
- 31:15say is mr. Epps I'm sorry that happened
- 31:17I wish none of this happened I was to me
- 31:20that once I was told that I committed a
- 31:24felony I got scared I was mad because I
- 31:29didn't understand anyway I thought it
- 31:31was just customer totally people so she
- 31:34was gonna talk to our parents I might
- 31:37have to go to bed early or something
- 31:38like that but no we all got in trouble
- 31:41for breaking and entering
- 31:48I try to be a goody two-shoes obviously
- 31:52crime victims who participate in
- 31:55conferences are more likely to get
- 31:57restitution someplace to play perhaps
- 32:00even more importantly they help come up
- 32:02with acceptable solutions what do you
- 32:07guys think should be done to make this
- 32:09better
- 32:20[Music]
- 32:22the shift happens for different people
- 32:25at different times but it's the point at
- 32:27which an individual and/or the group
- 32:31change from being feeling all the
- 32:36negative effects or the negative
- 32:38emotions into seeing something from
- 32:42someone else's perspective and starting
- 32:44to just slide down the hill into the
- 32:47more positive effects you can see it in
- 32:51the circle you can feel it you know like
- 32:54sometimes it's a laughter like a shared
- 32:57joke sometimes it's when somebody cries
- 33:01it's it's just the change that signifies
- 33:06that everybody's on their way toward
- 33:08resolution part of the resolution is an
- 33:12agreement for restitution of some kind
- 33:14similar to the Maori concept of uh - or
- 33:18restoring balance in this case the
- 33:21conference members determined that the
- 33:23boy should pay for repair of the screen
- 33:25and also wash mr. Epps truck I really do
- 33:29believe it has to do with a collective
- 33:30vulnerability like that we can all feel
- 33:33each other we can all see each other
- 33:35everybody's focused in my grandmother
- 33:39always used to say two heads are better
- 33:40than one even if one is a cabbage head
- 33:43that's kind of how it makes sense to me
- 33:47so you know all of us know things
- 33:50together that we don't know separately
- 33:53we all have an innate wisdom that's
- 33:56built by the innate wisdom of others and
- 34:00I think that's what this picks up on
- 34:03youth offenders whose cases are resolved
- 34:06in conferences are far less likely to
- 34:10less than 10% go on to commit new crimes
- 34:14compared to cases dealt with by courts
- 34:16and juvenile services where nearly a
- 34:19quarter of the kids are likely to
- 34:24reoffended umbers are consistent even
- 34:27when the crimes are more serious it
- 34:31isn't it absolutely isn't just about
- 34:34minor cases a lady's house was broken
- 34:37into in the middle of the night her car
- 34:39was taken from the front of her house we
- 34:41are handling felony a lot of felony
- 34:44offenses and we're getting the same
- 34:46kinds of outcomes 60% lower reoffending
- 34:5095 percent of the time they come up with
- 34:52an agreement that they can abide by
- 34:54we had a secretary of Juvenile Services
- 34:57once who said well you can use this but
- 35:00no cases where there's physical harm I
- 35:02mean we set up things in our head about
- 35:06what this shouldn't be used for because
- 35:08we need to have the serious justice
- 35:10intervention for those serious cases I
- 35:12would say you know absolutely this is a
- 35:16serious justice intervention I think the
- 35:19hard part for people is to acknowledge
- 35:22that we have a lot of capability to
- 35:25resolve these things ourselves
- 35:27I believe in large parts the system
- 35:33actually hinders the growth by taking a
- 35:38kid and just throwing them in jail and
- 35:40basically forgetting about them at that
- 35:42point what are you doing what yields
- 35:46results is people really working
- 35:49together and really engaged in it and it
- 35:52can't be the government it's got to be
- 35:55the people who live there
- 35:57people can facilitate this process they
- 36:00can help the community conferencing
- 36:02center can facilitate it but they're not
- 36:04the answer they build a bridge between
- 36:07people to get that done that's where the
- 36:11work comes from we're talking about very
- 36:15basic human relationships and a way of
- 36:19dealing with them which is why I think
- 36:22it successfully you know would it be
- 36:24copied and followed in other countries
- 36:27it's not something that's owned by Maori
- 36:30even though the idea is based very
- 36:33firmly and traditional ideas of how
- 36:36Maori
- 36:37resolve disputes to resolve conflicts so
- 36:40I really think of the conferences that
- 36:43we do as a ritual that lets people be
- 36:49very human and that lets them take this
- 36:53incident that has harmed people and that
- 36:55has caused harm and to be human about it
- 36:58but to also be able to move that into a
- 37:01different place
- 37:03together in a way that's good for
- 37:06everybody and I like the analogy of in
- 37:10medicine in the 70s when they discovered
- 37:14you know the clicker that you get to
- 37:15manage your pain medicine well they
- 37:18found out that if people manage their
- 37:20own pain medicine administration that
- 37:23they used less medicine and got more
- 37:26pain relief because they're doing it
- 37:30themselves and I think that's what
- 37:34conferencing is like you have to put in
- 37:37less effort but you're letting people
- 37:39resolve it themselves and they come up
- 37:42with incredibly lasting and creative
- 37:45solutions because they get to decide
- 37:59for more on fixing juvie justice or to
- 38:02watch this program again visit pbs.org
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Restorative Justice and the Maori Tradition by Ken Laundra, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,940 words across 756 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.