YouTube2Text

RENAN SANTOS, CANDIDATO À PRESIDÊNCIA PELO MISSÃO, PARTICIPA DE SABATINA DO CORREIO — Transcript

by Correio Braziliense · 9,566 words · 1,529 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hello, and welcome to another edition
  2. 0:03of the Correio Brasiliense and TV
  3. 0:05Brasília 2026 Elections interview
  4. 0:07series. I’m Denise Rotemburg, a
  5. 0:10columnist for Correio. Joining me is
  6. 0:14Ana Maria Campos, a columnist for
  7. 0:16Correio Brasiliense and editor of the
  8. 0:18Law and Justice section. Folks, today
  9. 0:23we are hosting candidate Renan Santos
  10. 0:26from the Missão party, and I’d like
  11. 0:29to remind you that this program is
  12. 0:32produced in partnership with Febrafite,
  13. 0:35Fenat, UNAFISO Nacional, and ANFIP.
  14. 0:40Candidate, welcome. It is a pleasure
  15. 0:43and an honor to have you here. I’ll
  16. 0:46start with the first question regarding
  17. 0:48the topic that has captured so much of
  18. 0:50the public's attention this week: the
  19. 0:52current proceedings at the Supreme
  20. 0:54Federal Court. What would be the main
  21. 0:59judicial reform you intend to present
  22. 1:01if elected? Especially considering
  23. 1:04everything we have been witnessing at
  24. 1:06the STF these days?
  25. 1:08Let’s get into it. That could take an
  26. 1:10entire program to cover. Let’s start
  27. 1:11with the basics, let's start with the
  28. 1:13essentials. We must begin by removing
  29. 1:16Supreme Court justices, regardless of
  30. 1:18any reform, simply because we cannot
  31. 1:20maintain a Supreme Court with figures
  32. 1:22whose decisions are driven by a desire
  33. 1:24for impunity and the interests of
  34. 1:26criminals like Daniel Vorcaro. Second,
  35. 1:29the Supreme Court should only handle
  36. 1:31abstract cases, as is the case in most
  37. 1:33Constitutional Courts around the world,
  38. 1:34especially in Europe—abstract issues
  39. 1:36linked to constitutionality, not
  40. 1:38concrete cases involving specific
  41. 1:40individuals. Concrete cases involving
  42. 1:42individuals, especially politicians,
  43. 1:43must go to a separate court. Some legal
  44. 1:46experts already advocate for this; I
  45. 1:47propose it be handled by judges chosen
  46. 1:49by lot with two-year terms to oversee
  47. 1:51cases involving politicians, senators,
  48. 1:53and representatives, provided they are
  49. 1:55not from their own states to avoid
  50. 1:56political persecution. This way, we
  51. 2:00strip the Supreme Court of the power
  52. 2:01they currently have to interfere with
  53. 2:03Parliament. And then, if Parliament
  54. 2:05needs to impeach a justice, they can do
  55. 2:06so without fear of retaliation, which
  56. 2:08is what happens today. We must ban
  57. 2:10monocratic decisions, treat the court
  58. 2:12like a law firm—and we need to
  59. 2:13establish a maximum term of eight years
  60. 2:15for a justice. I don’t see an issue
  61. 2:18regarding age. I think a justice could
  62. 2:21be over 40 or under 50. The point is
  63. 2:25that they must serve a specific term,
  64. 2:26and that term should not coincide with
  65. 2:28the start of a President's term. We
  66. 2:32need an entry filter, meaning a
  67. 2:34political party, NGO, or union
  68. 2:36shouldn't be able to take every
  69. 2:38decision or topic that passes through
  70. 2:40Congress to the Supreme Court all the
  71. 2:43time, as if it were a final legislative
  72. 2:45instance. That must also be prohibited.
  73. 2:48The American Supreme Court handles very
  74. 2:50few cases. In Brazil, there are
  75. 2:51thousands. If I’m not mistaken, the
  76. 2:53American court handles maybe 150 cases
  77. 2:55a year at most. In Brazil, I think
  78. 2:57it’s something like 5,000 to 10,000
  79. 2:59cases. So, we are living in a sick
  80. 3:01model here. Therefore, a reform of this
  81. 3:04nature that I am proposing is one that
  82. 3:05changes the entire dynamic of the
  83. 3:07Supreme Court,
  84. 3:08meaning everything would go to the STJ.
  85. 3:10So, other lawsuits would go to the
  86. 3:12Superior Court of Justice and would not
  87. 3:14reach the STF. The STJ would be the
  88. 3:17final instance. As for concrete cases
  89. 3:21at the STJ, for cases involving
  90. 3:23politicians with special standing, a
  91. 3:25special court—the one I mentioned—
  92. 3:27with state appellate judges drawn by
  93. 3:29lot for 2-year terms, would take on
  94. 3:31cases of politicians who have
  95. 3:33privileged standing, leaving the STF
  96. 3:35with no cases, handling only abstract
  97. 3:38themes linked to constitutional issues,
  98. 3:40as it should be: a Supreme Court
  99. 3:42justice must handle abstract themes. It
  100. 3:45is a court linked to the Constitution.
  101. 3:47So, if a certain topic harms a basic
  102. 3:49principle of the Constitution, can that
  103. 3:51topic move forward in parliament or not
  104. 3:53? That is the discussion, and only that
  105. 3:55.
  106. 3:56These proposals are important, but they
  107. 3:58depend on Congress. The President of
  108. 4:01the Republic cannot carry them out
  109. 4:04alone. And we see that Congress today
  110. 4:07doesn't even approve impeachment
  111. 4:09proceedings, no matter how serious the
  112. 4:11allegations involving magistrates may
  113. 4:14be. And even today, this whole
  114. 4:17discussion in the Supreme Court,
  115. 4:19opening a process also causes a lot of
  116. 4:22controversy. How can we engage the
  117. 4:25country for a reform like this? Either
  118. 4:29a true President of the Republic, who
  119. 4:31is not involved in corruption scandals
  120. 4:33and who proposes, very honestly, to do
  121. 4:35this, he will have the powers after
  122. 4:37being elected for it. Not being,
  123. 4:41therefore, Flávio Bolsonaro or Lula,
  124. 4:43who are involved in scandals, anyone
  125. 4:44who has this willingness can make a big
  126. 4:47difference, especially since parliament
  127. 4:49will also be elected within this spirit
  128. 4:50, within this climate of change.
  129. 4:53Therefore, if the Brazilian population
  130. 4:55wants me to win the elections, they
  131. 4:57will also want my proposals, and they
  132. 4:59will help me pressure the lawmakers for
  133. 5:01this. I know there will be lobbying
  134. 5:03from senators, especially senators
  135. 5:04involved in corruption scandals. I know
  136. 5:06there will be lobbying from party
  137. 5:08presidents involved in the same
  138. 5:09corruption scandals, but they won't be
  139. 5:10a majority against what's coming. I
  140. 5:12think it's such a huge crisis that
  141. 5:14we've started to see the top of the
  142. 5:15Brazilian political hierarchy beginning
  143. 5:17to fall. Actually, if they open the
  144. 5:20data from Vorcaro's cell phone and if
  145. 5:22they actually punish those involved in
  146. 5:24the NSS scandal, everyone falls. So, as
  147. 5:28president of the Republic, I will
  148. 5:30appoint an attorney general who is
  149. 5:32absolutely upright and completely
  150. 5:33distant from political interests to
  151. 5:35carry out investigations and charges
  152. 5:37when they are involved. And the Federal
  153. 5:40Police must have a superintendent, a
  154. 5:42chief who is absolutely independent,
  155. 5:44which seems not to have been the case,
  156. 5:47neither for the PGR nor for the Federal
  157. 5:49Police. With these appointments, in
  158. 5:51plain English, if they don't cooperate
  159. 5:54willingly, they will cooperate by force
  160. 5:56. They will cooperate out of fear,
  161. 5:58because it's not exactly out of free
  162. 5:59will. If the PGR sees a crime, it will
  163. 6:01go after a party president, it will go
  164. 6:03after a congressman, and then things
  165. 6:04will get ugly. That point.
  166. 6:07Now, to do all of this, you need to
  167. 6:09have a majority in the National
  168. 6:10Congress, as Ana Maria rightly pointed
  169. 6:12out, right? It depends, a lot of things
  170. 6:15depend on Congress today. How do you
  171. 6:18intend to do this if you are elected,
  172. 6:20since your party is small today, it has
  173. 6:22Deputy Kim Kataguiri and perhaps, if my
  174. 6:25memory serves me right, it might have
  175. 6:27one or two more, if it has that many.
  176. 6:30How do you intend to have a majority in
  177. 6:33the National Congress, since your party
  178. 6:35is small today and we know that
  179. 6:38Congress is addicted to positions and
  180. 6:40parliamentary amendments. Would you
  181. 6:43engage in the "give and take" of public
  182. 6:45offices?
  183. 6:46I have one of the biggest caucuses in
  184. 6:47the National Congress today, which is
  185. 6:49the caucus that only has one Kim
  186. 6:50Kataguiri, because one Kim Kataguiri is
  187. 6:52worth more than 30 deputies from the
  188. 6:54centrão.
  189. 6:54But that’s not a majority, is it? To
  190. 6:57pass a constitutional amendment, to
  191. 6:59pass any bill.
  192. 7:01No, it's just that I couldn't miss the
  193. 7:02chance to pay tribute to Kim here. And
  194. 7:04I always pay tribute, because his
  195. 7:05standard of quality is very high, and
  196. 7:07we need to elect many deputies. The
  197. 7:09provocation in your question is very
  198. 7:10good, because I do need to build a very
  199. 7:12large caucus. Now, regardless of the
  200. 7:14size of the caucus, due to the very
  201. 7:15nature of Brazilian elections, it will
  202. 7:17never be enough to form a majority.
  203. 7:19Therefore, I will have to form a
  204. 7:20coalition government. In parliamentary
  205. 7:24regimes around the world, it is normal,
  206. 7:26acceptable, and desirable that party
  207. 7:28coalitions be built within a program
  208. 7:30and republican proposals, as in Germany
  209. 7:32, as in Spain, and in any parliamentary
  210. 7:34regime, unlike Brazil. And in this
  211. 7:38sense, your question is very fitting,
  212. 7:40because only in Brazil, among
  213. 7:41presidential republics, is the issue of
  214. 7:43governability discussed so much,
  215. 7:44because you have two elections. You win
  216. 7:47the presidential election, and then you
  217. 7:49have an indirect election in parliament
  218. 7:50to form your majority. Therefore,
  219. 7:52parliamentarism would solve this. But I
  220. 7:54will have to hold this second election
  221. 7:55and I will form a simple majority or a
  222. 7:56majority for constitutional amendments
  223. 7:58with parties. This simple majority will
  224. 8:01be formed with participation in the
  225. 8:02government, through the signing by the
  226. 8:04parties of resolutions that bind their
  227. 8:06caucus to my program that won at the
  228. 8:07polls. In other words, if you want to
  229. 8:10participate in my government with
  230. 8:11ministries in a republican manner,
  231. 8:13there will be a resolution obliging
  232. 8:14your caucus to vote with me.
  233. 8:16That is, each party will have a
  234. 8:18ministry. So, the parties that choose
  235. 8:20to support you,
  236. 8:20not necessarily, but also, meaning, it
  237. 8:23may be that a party wants to join
  238. 8:25without needing that. And
  239. 8:27congratulations, you will be linked to
  240. 8:29my government, let's work together. Now
  241. 8:32, a party may propose to act in the
  242. 8:34security area of my government with an
  243. 8:35interesting nomination and doing it in
  244. 8:37a republican manner, with total
  245. 8:38scrutiny from oversight bodies and the
  246. 8:40press, I will do so, because I believe
  247. 8:42in coalition building. I am a political
  248. 8:45figure. I understand that I will not be
  249. 8:47able to govern without a majority. What
  250. 8:49I will not allow, however, is to
  251. 8:50destroy my government and destroy the
  252. 8:52dream of the people who voted for me
  253. 8:53with criminal behavior. I will not, I
  254. 8:56will not allow that. I would rather not
  255. 8:57have a majority and I would rather face
  256. 8:59the dispute, face the crisis than yield
  257. 9:01to that, because it would be destroying
  258. 9:03the entire dream of a generation that
  259. 9:05built my party. I cannot be seen as
  260. 9:07someone who gave in to that. So people
  261. 9:09know that I will have this difficulty.
  262. 9:12Now, there is one element: today, in
  263. 9:13the hands of Flávio Dino, there are at
  264. 9:15least 60 cases involving embezzlement
  265. 9:17of secret budget amendments involving
  266. 9:18the so-called "centrão." With an
  267. 9:21upright, independent Prosecutor General
  268. 9:23, as I mentioned, it will be very
  269. 9:24difficult for parliamentarians to keep
  270. 9:26up this climate of chicanery and
  271. 9:28blackmail against the federal
  272. 9:29government, because they will be
  273. 9:30worried about not getting arrested. I
  274. 9:33think the climate will be quite
  275. 9:34different. That is why we need to elect
  276. 9:36a righteous President of the Republic,
  277. 9:38who makes honest appointments and
  278. 9:39starts naming proper figures to the
  279. 9:41Supreme Court, because by investigating
  280. 9:43properly, the idea of a parliament that
  281. 9:45doesn't cooperate for un-republican
  282. 9:46reasons will start to change. They have
  283. 9:49overindulged themselves. It’s not
  284. 9:50that I’ve found a magic key to solve
  285. 9:52this; it’s that they’ve indulged so
  286. 9:54much in thievery that if you nudge
  287. 9:55things just a little, the whole house
  288. 9:57of cards collapses for everyone. I’m
  289. 9:59talking about the house collapsing for
  290. 10:01members of the PP, União Brasil, MDB,
  291. 10:03and PSD—the largest parties in the
  292. 10:04Republic today.
  293. 10:06But, um, they—parliamentarians today
  294. 10:08—have a lot of power because of
  295. 10:10mandatory amendments, and often they
  296. 10:13don't even need the government, the
  297. 10:15executive branch, to release funds,
  298. 10:17anyway. For their bases and even for
  299. 10:20the schemes you yourself mentioned. Do
  300. 10:22you think this should be changed, and
  301. 10:25how would you change it? I will alter
  302. 10:28the amendment model in two ways. First,
  303. 10:32for parliamentary amendments to work,
  304. 10:34they will be linked to the amount of
  305. 10:36discretionary budget that is opened up.
  306. 10:39In other words, to translate this for
  307. 10:40those watching us, you have a budget,
  308. 10:42and a part of the Brazilian budget is
  309. 10:44rigid, it is mandatory; meaning the
  310. 10:45president doesn't choose, it is
  311. 10:47determined by law. We are going to make
  312. 10:50parliament work to reduce that, because
  313. 10:51the more space for investment it
  314. 10:52generates, the more space I will give
  315. 10:54for amendments. Uh-huh.
  316. 10:56So, I have difficulty getting votes in
  317. 10:58parliament—any president does—on
  318. 11:00fiscal topics, which are the famous
  319. 11:01reforms; that is where they create
  320. 11:03difficulties, whereas for most topics,
  321. 11:04for example, those related to public
  322. 11:06security, it's easy to build a majority
  323. 11:08. In fact, under the Lula
  324. 11:09administration, some constitutional
  325. 11:11amendments related to public security
  326. 11:13were passed, so it’s not difficult.
  327. 11:14The problem is these fiscal themes. By
  328. 11:17changing the dynamics of the amendments
  329. 11:18so they are linked to the amount of
  330. 11:20discretionary budget, the
  331. 11:21parliamentarian's function—that
  332. 11:22parliamentarian you described—will be
  333. 11:24to decrease mandatory spending so that
  334. 11:26more space remains for amendments.
  335. 11:28That’s what it will be now.
  336. 11:29But on the other side, I have to
  337. 11:30discipline the use of the amendments,
  338. 11:31and that’s where our project comes in
  339. 11:33, which is the Law of Managerial
  340. 11:34Responsibility.
  341. 11:34What people say is the following:
  342. 11:36regarding this issue of amendments, we
  343. 11:38have already reached this point. First,
  344. 11:40the toothpaste is already out of the
  345. 11:41tube; it doesn’t go back in.
  346. 11:43Parliamentarians have mandatory
  347. 11:45amendments that they currently allocate
  348. 11:47wherever they want. And the government
  349. 11:50is forced to release them, because if
  350. 11:51it doesn't, it commits what is called a
  351. 11:53crime of responsibility. How do you
  352. 11:57intend to change something that
  353. 11:59Congress is already addicted to and
  354. 12:01nobody can fix? The Lula administration
  355. 12:04tried this countless times and failed.
  356. 12:06The most they managed was to negotiate
  357. 12:08for them to put at least half of these
  358. 12:10amendments into the health sector. How
  359. 12:14can this negotiation be done in a
  360. 12:16republican way with a corrupt Congress
  361. 12:18where most parliamentarians are
  362. 12:20expected to be reelected? Clearly, as I
  363. 12:24mentioned, these parliamentarians don't
  364. 12:25just use amendments because they want
  365. 12:27to deliver results; they want to steal
  366. 12:28through the amendments. And especially
  367. 12:31the secret budget amendments that most
  368. 12:33of the "Centrão" parliamentarians have
  369. 12:35access to, they were targets of
  370. 12:37embezzlement. I reiterate, Justice
  371. 12:39Flávio Dino is the most powerful
  372. 12:40justice on the Supreme Court today,
  373. 12:42because he holds the key leaders of
  374. 12:44parliament in his hands. In fact, this
  375. 12:45is part of Lula's reelection plan. Lula
  376. 12:47will appoint his own Prosecutor General
  377. 12:49this time, not someone appointed by
  378. 12:50Gilmar's group, like Gonet. And based
  379. 12:53on that, using Flávio Dino's cases, he
  380. 12:55will force Congress to fall in line.
  381. 12:57This
  382. 12:58No, Flávio Dino is already conducting
  383. 13:00several Federal Police operations
  384. 13:01against parliamentarians who embezzled
  385. 13:03funds.
  386. 13:03Exactly. And that will be the tone of
  387. 13:05the parliamentarians 'next term. So, at
  388. 13:08the same time that they have a lot of
  389. 13:09power, they have also never had so many
  390. 13:11problems and they are afraid. And there
  391. 13:12is a desire, speaking from behind the
  392. 13:14scenes in Brasília, to reach a
  393. 13:16compromise with the executive branch.
  394. 13:17So, what kind of pacification can we
  395. 13:19reach? The pacification model, in my
  396. 13:21view, is this: a new fiscal anchor
  397. 13:22where amendments are determined by the
  398. 13:24available discretionary space. And on
  399. 13:26the other hand, the following logic:
  400. 13:28the government formulates public policy
  401. 13:30and the congressman delivers it, but
  402. 13:32the public policy must come from the
  403. 13:33federal government. Why? The money for
  404. 13:37amendments today is in the range of 65
  405. 13:38billion reais. It is money that does
  406. 13:41not follow a rational logic. I don't
  407. 13:43know if I can go on, but this is
  408. 13:44actually a fascinating discussion. In
  409. 13:462011, Brazil passed legislation on
  410. 13:48health regions, determining that states
  411. 13:50would be divided into regions that
  412. 13:52would be autonomous in the complexity
  413. 13:54of public health services offered by
  414. 13:56the SUS. Therefore, investments must
  415. 13:59meet criteria where a given region will
  416. 14:01have everything from the most complex
  417. 14:02hospital to basic health units. Today,
  418. 14:04this has not been implemented yet,
  419. 14:06because the parliamentarians just
  420. 14:07choose: "Oh, I'll build a hospital in
  421. 14:09my region." No, no, that polyclinic is
  422. 14:10going to be in the region where I have
  423. 14:11the most votes. And that is irrational.
  424. 14:14So, policy has to be determined by the
  425. 14:15federal government, by the central
  426. 14:17planning of the federal government,
  427. 14:18investments in infrastructure, health
  428. 14:19investments. And the congressman has to
  429. 14:22make the delivery, which is basically a
  430. 14:24purely electoral act, it’s an act of
  431. 14:26vanity for the congressman, it's the
  432. 14:28inauguration, which is the truth. The
  433. 14:30truth is what the congressman wants.
  434. 14:31This, this is a very old thing. The
  435. 14:33amendment comes from the old logic that
  436. 14:35Brazil is not, Brazil doesn’t have a
  437. 14:37republican characteristic like the
  438. 14:38American one. So the congressman has to
  439. 14:41show people that he is serving the
  440. 14:42public, and then he has to keep
  441. 14:44inaugurating works, even though it’s
  442. 14:45not parliament that inaugurates works.
  443. 14:47So we created this distortion. So,
  444. 14:50since the voter thinks that the
  445. 14:51congressman's job is to inaugurate
  446. 14:53works, which is crazy, let him
  447. 14:55inaugurate the work. It's, it's
  448. 14:57ridiculous. Hey, go ahead, inaugurate
  449. 14:58the work, say it was you who brought it
  450. 15:00, but you are not the one who will
  451. 15:01determine the policy. We have to reach
  452. 15:03this agreement. This has to be the
  453. 15:04agreement we have to reach. So,
  454. 15:06inaugurate the work, pretend you did
  455. 15:07that work, but don't determine the work
  456. 15:09, because them determining the work is
  457. 15:10chaos. These are irrational investments
  458. 15:13, with embezzlement, with corruption,
  459. 15:15and with a lack of planning and
  460. 15:17priority.
  461. 15:18Candidate, eh, I saw a statement of
  462. 15:20yours regarding the pension reform as a
  463. 15:23very necessary measure, because
  464. 15:25otherwise, in a few years, retirees
  465. 15:28will not receive their pensions. I
  466. 15:31wanted to know what model of reform you
  467. 15:34think is necessary, if this reform will
  468. 15:38affect the retirees who are already
  469. 15:40receiving their pensions, if it will
  470. 15:43lower the age eh for for retiring, how
  471. 15:47is this model that you think about?
  472. 15:51Uh-huh. First, in the reform that
  473. 15:54Deputy Kim Kataguiri presented,
  474. 15:55currently collecting signatures, we are
  475. 15:57going to make a parametric reform, that
  476. 15:59is, within the parameters of the
  477. 16:00current model for the public servant
  478. 16:02regime, especially federal ones, it
  479. 16:03will affect the military and the
  480. 16:05judiciary a lot. Eh, these parameters
  481. 16:08involve especially age, age and
  482. 16:10contribution. Second, then comes a
  483. 16:13general pension reform that has to
  484. 16:14establish an automatic trigger that
  485. 16:16does not demand new reforms for the
  486. 16:17establishment of the age. What is the
  487. 16:20automatic trigger? Determined by the
  488. 16:21IBGE, the life expectancy of the
  489. 16:25Brazilian, it automatically changes the
  490. 16:27date for retirement. Period. Two, end
  491. 16:30the major exceptions that exist. Three:
  492. 16:33implement a reform based on my labor
  493. 16:35reform, which is the new employment
  494. 16:37record or a new model of Brazilian
  495. 16:39labor legislation that combines the
  496. 16:41FGTS with the INSS, transforming it
  497. 16:42into a new pension plan that will yield
  498. 16:44returns. The person will even be able
  499. 16:48to choose where part of this pension
  500. 16:50will yield returns, so it no longer
  501. 16:51yields like the FGTS, which yields less
  502. 16:53than the SELIC—the craziness we have
  503. 16:55here—and which will therefore allow
  504. 16:57the person to build their own capital.
  505. 17:01As they earn higher income, they will
  506. 17:02have more discretion over their
  507. 17:04earnings, with a portion remaining in
  508. 17:05the general system, since the general
  509. 17:07system is a pay-as-you-go scheme, where
  510. 17:09, ultimately, the young are paying for
  511. 17:10the old. I believe that with this new
  512. 17:14model, we will be able to achieve a
  513. 17:15reduction in informality, and therefore
  514. 17:17an increase in the contribution base to
  515. 17:18reduce the social security crisis and
  516. 17:20be less unfair to everyone. So this
  517. 17:22reform is planned for our government.
  518. 17:25Now, speaking of reforms, a very
  519. 17:28important law that is practically
  520. 17:30shelved in Congress, is paralyzed, and
  521. 17:33has to do with tax collection is the
  522. 17:36Organic Law of Tax Administration (LOAT
  523. 17:38), which empowers oversight and creates
  524. 17:41the entire system for auditing public
  525. 17:44accounts that is so necessary,
  526. 17:47including a career plan for tax
  527. 17:50auditors in all areas and for all
  528. 17:52federal entities. How do you intend to
  529. 17:56handle this issue of tax administration
  530. 17:59and also oversight? Something that is
  531. 18:03so important for the country—knowing
  532. 18:05where its taxes go, and how to oversee
  533. 18:07the collection of its taxes?
  534. 18:10I have little knowledge about this
  535. 18:11specific project, but in terms of
  536. 18:13principles, the proper functioning of
  537. 18:15the State and effective accountability
  538. 18:17for the execution of public policies at
  539. 18:19the municipal, state, and federal
  540. 18:20levels require the maximum possible
  541. 18:22transparency. So much so that the
  542. 18:25foundation of my government program is
  543. 18:26the managerial responsibility law,
  544. 18:28which involves helping and assisting
  545. 18:29public management in Brazilian
  546. 18:30municipalities and federal entities,
  547. 18:32which is currently cryptic; we barely
  548. 18:33know how money is spent, generally on
  549. 18:35inefficient public policies. I had an
  550. 18:38informal meeting with the Federal Court
  551. 18:40of Accounts (TCU) to define and
  552. 18:42understand if they have a dashboard of
  553. 18:44indicators that is good enough to help
  554. 18:46us do this. And they do, so it all adds
  555. 18:49up. One, increased transparency; two,
  556. 18:52the ability to understand; three,
  557. 18:54indicators. It’s good, it’s good
  558. 18:56not only for oversight, but for
  559. 18:57formulating policies. I think that is a
  560. 18:59problem we have in Brazil, which is the
  561. 19:01problem of flying blind. Like you're a
  562. 19:02plane, you're piloting a plane, you
  563. 19:04can't see anything and you don't have
  564. 19:05the indicators. And in Brazil, there is
  565. 19:07little culture of working based on
  566. 19:09indicators. It's a problem that we
  567. 19:12perhaps inherited from a patrimonialist
  568. 19:13culture. I quite like, principially
  569. 19:16speaking,
  570. 19:18candidate, you are the main leader of
  571. 19:21the MBL, which was very important in
  572. 19:24the impeachment process of former
  573. 19:27president Dilma Rousseff and was very,
  574. 19:31very motivated by the Lava-Jato
  575. 19:34allegations, which at that time were
  576. 19:37very strong. And today, what happened
  577. 19:41with Lava-Jato is that it became
  578. 19:42discredited. I—my—my question is
  579. 19:45actually two-fold. If you think Brazil
  580. 19:48became better after the impeachment and
  581. 19:51what is your opinion regarding the
  582. 19:53criticisms made of Lava-Jato? It is a
  583. 19:58very, very complicated reflection,
  584. 19:59because I don't think Brazil is better
  585. 20:01today, but I don't think it was because
  586. 20:03of the impeachment. I think the
  587. 20:05impeachment was necessary. If we look
  588. 20:08objectively, that government needed to
  589. 20:09fall. Uh, but
  590. 20:12due to the corruption,
  591. 20:13due to the corruption, due to the
  592. 20:14project of—because it wasn't just
  593. 20:16because the government was corrupt. The
  594. 20:18PT's corruption was based on buying the
  595. 20:20parliament. The whole Petrolão, as the
  596. 20:23heir to Mensalão, was based on sharing
  597. 20:25money so that government partners, who
  598. 20:27generate majorities in Congress, could
  599. 20:29earn money and also fund campaigns.
  600. 20:33They could also get rich in the process
  601. 20:34, but in general, it was with members
  602. 20:35of parties. That's why there was the PP
  603. 20:37, they even had their own directorates,
  604. 20:39or the MDB had them, the PT also had
  605. 20:41them. So they set up a kind of
  606. 20:42consortium that generated these
  607. 20:44majorities. It even triggered the
  608. 20:46rebellion of the low clergy, from
  609. 20:47Eduardo Cunha himself, who thought he
  610. 20:48didn't have enough space in that game.
  611. 20:51The problem is that Brazil, which was
  612. 20:54bubbling in that period with Operation
  613. 20:56Lava-Jato, became confused. And what
  614. 21:00was the confusion? Since the streets in
  615. 21:02that process—I called for
  616. 21:04demonstrations, I and Kim, we brought
  617. 21:07down the PT—the streets didn't
  618. 21:09naturally materialize into an electoral
  619. 21:11phenomenon of their own. Because if it
  620. 21:15had been an electoral phenomenon of its
  621. 21:16own, if Kim had the age back then, if
  622. 21:18Janaína Paschoal had a more powerful
  623. 21:20verve, if Sergio Moro had wanted to be
  624. 21:22a candidate for president, the three of
  625. 21:24them would have won the election
  626. 21:25because they represented the moment.
  627. 21:29Since no one there was fit to be a
  628. 21:30candidate for various reasons, a person
  629. 21:32named Jair Bolsonaro appeared in
  630. 21:34parallel, who is a career politician
  631. 21:35involved in corruption scandals, with
  632. 21:37children involved in corruption
  633. 21:38scandals. And this individual was
  634. 21:41identified by the people behind that
  635. 21:43phenomenon as a leader. He was not
  636. 21:45responsible for the impeachment. He has
  637. 21:46nothing to do with Operation Car Wash.
  638. 21:48What was changing Brazil was the
  639. 21:50streets, the impeachment, and Car Wash.
  640. 21:52For better or worse, how can I put it,
  641. 21:54there was also a creation of confusing
  642. 21:55social networks, there was a lot of
  643. 21:56hysteria. Car Wash crossed the line at
  644. 21:59several moments. Bretas, for example,
  645. 22:01Bretas is a
  646. 22:02Uh-huh. Can I
  647. 22:03judge from Rio de Janeiro,
  648. 22:04a lunatic. Bretas is a lunatic, Bretas
  649. 22:07is a person, right, uh, who crossed
  650. 22:09many lines. Bretas uh was also there
  651. 22:12within the scope of Car Wash. The Car
  652. 22:15Wash did cross the lines at times, but
  653. 22:18the voter discovered Bolsonarism and
  654. 22:21then the voter became attached and
  655. 22:23formed such a powerful bond with him
  656. 22:26that it not only destroyed the
  657. 22:28revolution happening at that moment,
  658. 22:31but created their own pet bandit. And
  659. 22:35then we have the regrettable Brazil we
  660. 22:37have today, where the voter who went to
  661. 22:39the streets against PT's corruption
  662. 22:41defends Flávio's corruption. They
  663. 22:44defend it, saying: "Oh, the PT is
  664. 22:45corrupt, right? Flávio..." No, no,
  665. 22:48he's allowed. So much so that if you
  666. 22:51ask a Flávio voter, a Flávio voter,
  667. 22:52uh, do you think it's wrong that
  668. 22:54Alexandre de Moraes received 130
  669. 22:55million in a contract there with his
  670. 22:57wife? Absurd. And Flávio with 130
  671. 23:00million from Dark Horse? Normal. Normal
  672. 23:04. No, normal. They
  673. 23:05answer that it's private money, right?
  674. 23:08But considering that the polls today
  675. 23:10place Lula and Flávio Bolsonaro in a
  676. 23:12runoff, if it's the two of them, who
  677. 23:14would you support?
  678. 23:17I support Renan Santos.
  679. 23:20In other words, if you are not in the
  680. 23:22runoff, will you go home, tend to your
  681. 23:24life, or will you oppose whoever wins,
  682. 23:26but not campaign for either of them?
  683. 23:29That's it.
  684. 23:30I know that journalistically speaking,
  685. 23:31it's not the coolest answer I can give
  686. 23:33you.
  687. 23:33Hmm. I can only imagine a scenario in
  688. 23:35which I will be working in the runoff
  689. 23:37to win the election. Eh, no, I cannot
  690. 23:39imagine anything else, otherwise it
  691. 23:40would even be disrespectful to those
  692. 23:42betting on me. So, even though
  693. 23:43journalistically speaking it would be a
  694. 23:45cool answer to give you, I wouldn't
  695. 23:47give that answer.
  696. 23:48Why is it that the youth, why do many
  697. 23:51young people identify with Renan Santos
  698. 23:54?
  699. 23:55Well, I’m not even that young, I’m
  700. 23:5742 years old. I think it’s many
  701. 23:59things. Even though I’m 42, I have a
  702. 24:03very frank language on social media,
  703. 24:07that captivates younger generations. So
  704. 24:12much so that there is no, when we look
  705. 24:14at income brackets, for example, it’s
  706. 24:16not rich or poor, the kids follow us.
  707. 24:19Two. These people don’t have that
  708. 24:23emotional bond with Lula or Bolsonaro.
  709. 24:25This person today, for example, who is
  710. 24:2720 years old and follows me and will
  711. 24:28vote for me, they lived through the
  712. 24:29Bolsonaro administration, they didn’t
  713. 24:31idealize Bolsonaro. They are living
  714. 24:32through the Lula administration now and
  715. 24:34lived through the Dilma administration
  716. 24:35before when they were a child and saw
  717. 24:36it was bad. This person, therefore,
  718. 24:39doesn’t have the bond that older
  719. 24:40people have with Lula or Bolsonaro. And
  720. 24:42they are, therefore, capable of making
  721. 24:44new constructions. And we are proposing
  722. 24:46a very simple pact with them. Look, we
  723. 24:48are not going to get rich from politics
  724. 24:50. You will see our journeys in a very
  725. 24:52open way. Our proposals, we discuss
  726. 24:55openly with you. I do daily livestreams
  727. 24:57. I don’t know another politician in
  728. 24:59Brazil, a party leader, who is
  729. 25:00practically every day live, for 2 hours
  730. 25:02, saying what they think and explaining
  731. 25:04their positions. Sometimes Kim, now we
  732. 25:07have a party, MBL, and Kim is a leader
  733. 25:09of his own bench, which is him,
  734. 25:11but we decide the position to be taken
  735. 25:13live on a live broadcast. And people
  736. 25:16see a lot of truth in that. So young
  737. 25:18people feel part of a construction that
  738. 25:20doesn’t necessarily happen right now.
  739. 25:23Of course I want to win the elections,
  740. 25:24I am working to win the election, but
  741. 25:25they feel part of the project which is
  742. 25:27their generation’s project.
  743. 25:28Now, what is the project for the youth?
  744. 25:31What do you offer to this young
  745. 25:33audience? What is, for example, a
  746. 25:36reform that moves in the direction of
  747. 25:39entrepreneurship, job creation? How to
  748. 25:43serve this young audience that today
  749. 25:45arrives so without perspective in the
  750. 25:47face of, even the lack of debate
  751. 25:48between the presidential candidates?
  752. 25:51The messages have to be short. In other
  753. 25:54words, the impression you have is that
  754. 25:55people nowadays don’t like to think
  755. 25:56much. How exactly what are you going to
  756. 25:59offer to this young audience?
  757. 26:00First of all, I have to be careful, the
  758. 26:02young crowd will come after me if my
  759. 26:03ankles are showing, okay? Because
  760. 26:05it’s a tradition of ours too,
  761. 26:07they’ll understand. Oh, this one’s
  762. 26:08still okay. The other one’s okay.
  763. 26:10Well, that's fine. I apologize here
  764. 26:11during the interview. I promise I’m
  765. 26:13not corrupt.
  766. 26:13Explain now to
  767. 26:14explain. I have a theory, and our
  768. 26:16voters know it, that if a politician
  769. 26:18wears pants generally in a lighter blue
  770. 26:20than this, with loafers usually, like
  771. 26:22this, with no socks, the politician who
  772. 26:24exposes his ankles is involved in a
  773. 26:26corruption scandal, no matter which one
  774. 26:28. Uh, and it has, I have 100%accuracy
  775. 26:32on this. Every politician I saw was
  776. 26:34involved in some corruption scandal.
  777. 26:36Therefore, we created an internal rule
  778. 26:37where we prohibit our group members
  779. 26:39from showing their ankles on air. So,
  780. 26:41unfortunately, I was about to break it
  781. 26:43as party president. I’ll probably be
  782. 26:45reported to the ethics committee in the
  783. 26:46middle of an election, but I apologize,
  784. 26:48okay? Please, the younger ones,
  785. 26:51the younger ones, we will have—and
  786. 26:53this is the most interesting thing—we
  787. 26:55have countless open proposals on
  788. 26:57national issues. We didn't create a
  789. 27:00proposal like, "Oh, this is aimed at
  790. 27:02the youth," because they understand the
  791. 27:04beauty of our project is their
  792. 27:06participation in an eminently national
  793. 27:08project. So they will discuss rare
  794. 27:09earths with us, even if they don't see
  795. 27:11an immediate benefit. "Oh, I'm young,
  796. 27:13what do I gain from rare earths?" Uh,
  797. 27:15they look at our security policy, even
  798. 27:16if it's not necessarily a policy aimed
  799. 27:18at the youth. That's why when I'm asked
  800. 27:21, "Oh, but don't you have policies for
  801. 27:22women, or Black people, or Indigenous
  802. 27:23people?" I said, "Well, I'm making
  803. 27:26policies for Brazilians and all my
  804. 27:28policies are benefiting all Brazilians.
  805. 27:30" I was actually asked that in an
  806. 27:33interview, I said, I’ll give an
  807. 27:35example. Women in Brazil enter
  808. 27:36universities much more than men. I will
  809. 27:38reform and improve the university
  810. 27:40system, therefore I will benefit more
  811. 27:41women than men in that regard. Now, I
  812. 27:43haven't framed it that way. Like, "Look
  813. 27:45, a proposal: more universities for
  814. 27:47women." I should have done that,
  815. 27:48because it would be a marketing ploy to
  816. 27:50gain more votes. But I pay the price of
  817. 27:52wanting to be very clear, very honest,
  818. 27:55of not wanting to project a false image
  819. 27:57to people like, for example, who are
  820. 27:59the biggest victims of violence in
  821. 28:01Brazil? Generally, men, no, young black
  822. 28:05men. uh the of the daily homicides that
  823. 28:10happen in Brazil, let's say of
  824. 28:12homicides in general in Brazil, uh
  825. 28:13women account for 10%. Uh minors are 12
  826. 28:17%, men and women, but majorita, and the
  827. 28:20rest are men, what's the bracket? Poor
  828. 28:22men, generally mixed-race and black. So
  829. 28:25I could say: "My security policy to
  830. 28:26save black people." Even for women
  831. 28:29victims of femicide, 67%are mixed-race
  832. 28:31and black. So I could make a racial
  833. 28:33focus a security policy for black
  834. 28:35people. it's not a security policy for
  835. 28:38Brazilians and a person, a woman, a man
  836. 28:40, black, young or old, reading our
  837. 28:42program and watching our videos, will
  838. 28:44understand that it positively affects
  839. 28:47their lives. So that helps me with
  840. 28:50young people, because they realize it's
  841. 28:52authentic, they realize I'm telling the
  842. 28:54truth, I'm not trying to pander,
  843. 28:56because today there's a term on the
  844. 28:58internet, there's post-irony and
  845. 28:59there's also a perception in Gen Z of
  846. 29:01everything that is fake. Newer
  847. 29:05generations are really shying away from
  848. 29:07certain types on social media that are
  849. 29:09somewhat fake and a politician clearly
  850. 29:11trying to pander doesn't work. So I
  851. 29:13don't try to pander. So I won't do it.
  852. 29:15Ah, so what is your policy for the
  853. 29:16youth? If I did that, no young person
  854. 29:18would join.
  855. 29:18Is it because maybe young people don't,
  856. 29:21uh, don't like politics, right? They
  857. 29:25are distant from politics and so the
  858. 29:27political candidate who doesn't present
  859. 29:29themselves as a typical politician is
  860. 29:32liked. Worse, they don't.
  861. 29:35No,
  862. 29:35I don't think so. I think young people
  863. 29:37want to talk about politics. Now the
  864. 29:39political category, uh, the category of
  865. 29:41the politician, the pandering type,
  866. 29:43they still have some space among young
  867. 29:45people. You have, for example, like
  868. 29:47Tábata Amaral, who is all about women,
  869. 29:50women, women, women, women, women. She
  870. 29:52will capture a niche there, not a huge
  871. 29:54one, but she will capture a niche, uh,
  872. 29:56a category especially among
  873. 29:57identitarians or a Nikolas who talks to
  874. 29:59the young right-wing evangelical. Now,
  875. 30:02in general, young people are debating
  876. 30:04politics. What I am proposing is: "I
  877. 30:05will debate politics with you without
  878. 30:07treating you like an idiot." So, I
  879. 30:09won't pander to you, I will annoy you
  880. 30:11sometimes, but that's part of the game.
  881. 30:13An example where part of my electorate
  882. 30:15disagrees with me, but doesn't abandon
  883. 30:17me, right? a discussion about ending
  884. 30:20the 6-by-1 schedule, where our position
  885. 30:22is clearly one that is against what
  886. 30:24Lula is proposing, because what he is
  887. 30:26proposing is just a populist act. And
  888. 30:29we are proposing another reform model.
  889. 30:31And some is a reform model based on the
  890. 30:33sale of work hours, as happens in the
  891. 30:36best global experiences, with
  892. 30:38legislation that doesn't tax a person's
  893. 30:40salary as much, which is what I was
  894. 30:42explaining: you reduce the FGTS, add it
  895. 30:45to the INSS and that becomes the entire
  896. 30:47social security part; you reduce all
  897. 30:49the other bureaucracies and taxes, so
  898. 30:52that, basically, a larger part of the
  899. 30:54work, of the money from the work, stays
  900. 30:57with the worker and that's how you
  901. 30:59reduce informality. Because the policy
  902. 31:02has to be one of reducing informality
  903. 31:03with social security contributions,
  904. 31:04otherwise the system itself breaks. You
  905. 31:07have to create a middle ground that
  906. 31:09benefits this and that the person sells
  907. 31:11their work hour without, sorry, with a
  908. 31:13lot of flexibility. Today, if you go to
  909. 31:16Denmark, to give an example, a Denmark,
  910. 31:18any 18, 19-year-old is finding their
  911. 31:20first job at Burger King, at McDonald's
  912. 31:22, agreeing, look, I can do a schedule
  913. 31:23where I come in on Tuesday and Friday
  914. 31:25morning. Then they sold the hour, it's
  915. 31:28easy. Getting a first job for a young
  916. 31:30person happens faster. In the United
  917. 31:32States it's the exact same thing. Here
  918. 31:34in Brazil you have to have a discussion
  919. 31:35, there's no way to deal with the whole
  920. 31:37month. And what if the young person
  921. 31:38doesn't want to work the whole month?
  922. 31:39And if the young person wants to do a
  923. 31:41gig to raise some cash so he can pay
  924. 31:43his salary? If he wants, as many do in
  925. 31:46Europe, just the little money for him
  926. 31:48to finish studying, you are taking this
  927. 31:50possibility away from people. What you
  928. 31:53have to have is the minimum per hour,
  929. 31:55the minimum time for rest, and the
  930. 31:57maximum time worked.
  931. 31:59That's it, you have to define it by law
  932. 32:00. Aside from that, the person has to be
  933. 32:02free to set up their own work agreement
  934. 32:04. Are you in favor of the death penalty
  935. 32:06?
  936. 32:07In principle, logically, yes. But to
  937. 32:09pass that, I would need a new
  938. 32:10constitution. And I think we are not at
  939. 32:12the moment, with this congress that you
  940. 32:14wrote, we are not at the moment
  941. 32:16to mess with that. Now
  942. 32:17If a new constituent assembly is passed
  943. 32:19, basically the current
  944. 32:20parliamentarians would put Vorcaro as
  945. 32:21emperor of Brazil. Based on what you
  946. 32:26said regarding the labor issue,
  947. 32:28combining payroll taxes with social
  948. 32:31security contributions, can we infer
  949. 32:33that you would change, for example, the
  950. 32:36tax reform that was recently enacted?
  951. 32:42We had the tax reform on consumption;
  952. 32:44would you keep it or come up with
  953. 32:45something new? Scrap what's there and
  954. 32:48do it all over again?
  955. 32:50Brazil taxes consumption heavily
  956. 32:51because it doesn't know how to tax
  957. 32:52income, as many people work informally.
  958. 32:55That is the hard truth. And also
  959. 32:58because those at the top manage to
  960. 33:00escape taxation, they can maneuver
  961. 33:01around it. The whole world, everyone
  962. 33:03can maneuver around it. So it becomes
  963. 33:05difficult to implement that taxation.
  964. 33:07The United States, for example, they
  965. 33:09tax income more and tax consumption
  966. 33:11less. So they become a more consumerist
  967. 33:13nation because of that. We should
  968. 33:16naturally move toward increasing formal
  969. 33:18employment for Brazilians and reducing
  970. 33:19the tax on consumption. Things have to
  971. 33:22head in that direction. Now, the model
  972. 33:24...
  973. 33:24Would you keep this tax reform?
  974. 33:26I would keep it because its model is
  975. 33:27good.
  976. 33:27The model is good. Now, privileges for
  977. 33:29certain sectors must be struck down,
  978. 33:31because then we can lower the tax rate.
  979. 33:33And we have to create an automatic
  980. 33:35trigger involving state governments and
  981. 33:37the federal government for spending
  982. 33:39cuts in order to have a reduction in
  983. 33:41the VAT rate. Because as it stands,
  984. 33:44it’s that situation: they establish
  985. 33:46the VAT, a super high rate will appear
  986. 33:47there, and people will just survive and
  987. 33:49adapt, and the tax remains high. If
  988. 33:52spending remains high, they will need
  989. 33:53to increase the VAT rate. And there is
  990. 33:54still another problem that impacts this
  991. 33:55. Brazilian states are wasteful. They
  992. 33:59keep renegotiating their debt and they
  993. 34:00live off the tax that is currently the
  994. 34:02state one, which is the ICMS, which is
  995. 34:03what will be replaced by the VAT and to
  996. 34:04a large extent, it will remain with the
  997. 34:06states as well. So, how will this be
  998. 34:08done? If the state doesn't do its
  999. 34:10homework, the VAT will become expensive
  1000. 34:11for everyone, including those in other
  1001. 34:13states. So, a wasteful state that
  1002. 34:15doesn't pay its own debts will generate
  1003. 34:17a higher VAT for people in states that
  1004. 34:20do pay the bill. So there will need to
  1005. 34:22be a fiscal framework for the states so
  1006. 34:25that we can pull our VAT down.
  1007. 34:28What is your opinion on the
  1008. 34:30Constitutional Fund of the Federal
  1009. 34:32District, which is the fund that
  1010. 34:34maintains public security, health, and
  1011. 34:36education in the Federal District
  1012. 34:38because it is the capital? There’s a
  1013. 34:42lot of talk; the Lula administration
  1014. 34:45has even started discussing the
  1015. 34:47possibility of changing how this fund
  1016. 34:49is updated to reduce it, because it’s
  1017. 34:52a 30-billion-real fund per month—per
  1018. 34:54year, sorry.
  1019. 34:56Uh, I don't know what its increase
  1020. 34:58trigger is.
  1021. 34:59It’s the current revenue, the
  1022. 35:00variation of the Union's net current
  1023. 35:02revenue. Hm.
  1024. 35:03From June of one year to July of the
  1025. 35:05next,
  1026. 35:06okay? I would lock it and set it by the
  1027. 35:09IPCA, as most triggers should be.
  1028. 35:12But don't you think the Federal
  1029. 35:14District, as the capital of Brazil,
  1030. 35:16should have special treatment? I think
  1031. 35:18the Federal District—with all due
  1032. 35:20respect to its population, I'm already
  1033. 35:22...here I go losing votes again, but I
  1034. 35:24have no problem saying it—the HDI of
  1035. 35:25the Federal District is way above the
  1036. 35:27national average, even though there’s
  1037. 35:29a distortion involving people in the
  1038. 35:30Pilot Plan; and those who live in...
  1039. 35:32some of Brazil's largest favelas are
  1040. 35:34there. That said, uh, there are places
  1041. 35:36in much, much worse situations than the
  1042. 35:38Federal District. If we go to Pará, if
  1043. 35:41we go to Piauí, if we go to Maranhão,
  1044. 35:43if we go to Amazonas, if we go to
  1045. 35:45Amapá, a significant part of
  1046. 35:46Pernambuco, a significant part of Bahia
  1047. 35:48: the situations are such that
  1048. 35:49sub-Saharan Africa outperforms the HDI
  1049. 35:51in some parts of these regions. So the
  1050. 35:53state will have to focus heavily on
  1051. 35:55serving these regions. Uh, but I always
  1052. 35:57say, you need to have a floor and a
  1053. 35:59trigger. Uh, if the president, in a
  1054. 36:01discretionary manner, wants to increase
  1055. 36:02it in that year's budget to make
  1056. 36:04investments, they should do it, and I
  1057. 36:05think that has to be the criterion. We
  1058. 36:07keep discussing the issues of health
  1059. 36:09floors, education floors. Uh, deep down
  1060. 36:11, it’s a floor. The president, they
  1061. 36:14have to have the freedom, the
  1062. 36:15discretionary liberality to say: "Now
  1063. 36:17I’m going to invest more in health,
  1064. 36:18no, now I’m going to help the Federal
  1065. 36:19District more." It’s a discretionary
  1066. 36:23choice of the president in that budget.
  1067. 36:25And then the politicians of the Federal
  1068. 36:27District and the population should do
  1069. 36:28their representative work so that this
  1070. 36:30agenda is carried forward.
  1071. 36:32But doesn't that create a political
  1072. 36:34relationship where, if the president is
  1073. 36:37an enemy of the governor, they could
  1074. 36:40hinder these transfers that benefit the
  1075. 36:43population?
  1076. 36:44Unfortunately, that already happens
  1077. 36:45with all states on several other issues
  1078. 36:47, such as, for example, the release of
  1079. 36:48funds for public works. So, in practice
  1080. 36:50, this problem is a problem shared by
  1081. 36:52all the states of the federation. I
  1082. 36:55think that having an automatic trigger
  1083. 36:57based on inflation variance is a fair
  1084. 37:00trigger, which is the trigger I want to
  1085. 37:02set for health and education. The rest
  1086. 37:05must be discretionary. We have to trust
  1087. 37:07the capacity of the Executive Branch
  1088. 37:09and understand that there will be a
  1089. 37:11need for investments, and also in a
  1090. 37:13state government's ability to, let's
  1091. 37:15say, raise its funds, and understand
  1092. 37:17that there will be, let's say,
  1093. 37:19resources from private activity, the
  1094. 37:21normal taxation on that activity.
  1095. 37:23Let me speak, please, Ana Maria. It's
  1096. 37:27just that, as he speaks about this
  1097. 37:29issue of trusting the discretion of the
  1098. 37:32president of the executive branch, one
  1099. 37:34of your proposals came to mind, which
  1100. 37:37is the atomic bomb, is the arsenal,
  1101. 37:39Brazil starting to invest in a nuclear
  1102. 37:42arsenal. Imagine an intemperate, crazy
  1103. 37:47president in possession of a bomb like
  1104. 37:49that. Trump already has one, there's
  1105. 37:54already an intemperate crazy president,
  1106. 37:56Trump already has it, the North Korean
  1107. 37:58dictator has it, Pakistan has an atomic
  1108. 38:00bomb. So yes, in practice, I already
  1109. 38:03have crazy presidents with...
  1110. 38:05But wouldn't it be much better to
  1111. 38:07invest, for example, in social programs
  1112. 38:09, education, health, rather than
  1113. 38:11specifically in an atomic bomb, dealing
  1114. 38:13with a country that has as many
  1115. 38:14difficulties as Brazil?
  1116. 38:17India built its nuclear weapons,
  1117. 38:18Pakistan too, with social problems
  1118. 38:20greater than Brazil's, and today they
  1119. 38:22are also solving their social problems.
  1120. 38:25India, in basic sanitation and the
  1121. 38:27provision of bathrooms with sewage
  1122. 38:29connections, has surpassed Brazil.
  1123. 38:33So you can do both things because a
  1124. 38:34government is complex. What I think is
  1125. 38:37that social policies will not solve a
  1126. 38:39geopolitical problem. If someone wants
  1127. 38:41to invade you, are you going to say: "
  1128. 38:42Oh, take a public health clinic, I
  1129. 38:43won't be able to respond. Take a
  1130. 38:44welfare check." No, I will need to
  1131. 38:47respond with force. It's not even about
  1132. 38:49force, as if you're going to throw an
  1133. 38:50atomic bomb at someone. Which is even
  1134. 38:52proven
  1135. 38:52Respect, sir, do you think? Respect,
  1136. 38:53powers of deterrence. And I still say,
  1137. 38:56naturally, today the main geopolitical
  1138. 38:59instrument of deterrence is the atomic
  1139. 39:01bomb. Now, if there is another type of
  1140. 39:04weaponry or an investment that has this
  1141. 39:06same power of deterrence, it is solved.
  1142. 39:09How would your relationship be with
  1143. 39:11these great powers of the planet, the
  1144. 39:14United States, China, the European
  1145. 39:17Union, how to deal with economic
  1146. 39:19interests and maintain sovereignty?
  1147. 39:23national. Ah, that is a point that we
  1148. 39:25discuss a lot in our book of proposals.
  1149. 39:28Brazil needs to understand that it is
  1150. 39:30entering a new world model. So, a
  1151. 39:33situational analysis we make is that
  1152. 39:34the world we lived in from post-World
  1153. 39:36War II until the fall of the Berlin
  1154. 39:38Wall was one thing. From the fall of
  1155. 39:40the Berlin Wall until the Twin Towers
  1156. 39:42was another. And from the Twin Towers
  1157. 39:43until now, it’s yet another. With the
  1158. 39:45rise of China, with a new cold war, and
  1159. 39:47with a slow decline of the United
  1160. 39:50States as the prominent power and the
  1161. 39:52rise of China. It is a different world;
  1162. 39:54how does Brazil position itself in this
  1163. 39:56world? It is a world where, therefore,
  1164. 39:58you are practically being forced to
  1165. 39:59have to choose a side. And we are
  1166. 40:01seeing it: the Iran-Israel war, you
  1167. 40:03have to choose a side. United States
  1168. 40:04and China, Russia, Ukraine, you have to
  1169. 40:06choose a side. There’s already China
  1170. 40:08and Taiwan. When the United States just
  1171. 40:10now encroached on Venezuela, deep down,
  1172. 40:12they were messing with a Chinese ally
  1173. 40:13here. So, we will have to look at this
  1174. 40:16crisis and we have to see how to
  1175. 40:17position ourselves in it. We can
  1176. 40:19position ourselves, choose one side,
  1177. 40:20choose the other side, be ambiguous,
  1178. 40:22choose no side, strengthen ourselves,
  1179. 40:24join a bloc of countries, and negotiate
  1180. 40:26with both. In other words, there are
  1181. 40:28many possibilities that we have.
  1182. 40:29And which possibility do you bet on the
  1183. 40:30most? The possibility is the following:
  1184. 40:33there is an American inevitability in
  1185. 40:35our continent, so we will not escape
  1186. 40:37having necessarily cordial relations
  1187. 40:39with the United States. These cordial
  1188. 40:41relations can be beneficial or not. So,
  1189. 40:43when I denounced the participation of
  1190. 40:45Rock Bridge in Flávio's campaign and
  1191. 40:47the submission of Flávio's campaign to
  1192. 40:49the Americans, I am denouncing a model
  1193. 40:51that is very bad for Brazil, which is:
  1194. 40:52Brazilian natural resources go to the
  1195. 40:54United States to be processed and
  1196. 40:56American businessmen help their
  1197. 40:57bootlickers here in Brazil get elected.
  1198. 40:59That is not good. Now, eventually, you
  1199. 41:01will need to have a long-term
  1200. 41:03geopolitical partnership with the
  1201. 41:04United States, with technology exchange
  1202. 41:06, where rare earths, processing power
  1203. 41:08for data centers, via clean energy,
  1204. 41:10underpin this relationship and it is
  1205. 41:11mutually beneficial. Now, what if it
  1206. 41:13isn't? What if it's a Trump all the
  1207. 41:15time? I have to look at the European
  1208. 41:17Union, I have to look at China, I have
  1209. 41:18to look at Latin America, form a bloc
  1210. 41:20with neighboring countries, build a
  1211. 41:22kind of federation, a sort of UNASUR.
  1212. 41:24Would you keep Mercosur and strengthen
  1213. 41:27UNASUR? I would recreate the NASU under
  1214. 41:30new terms,
  1215. 41:31for example,
  1216. 41:31with investment in infrastructure, a
  1217. 41:33policy for destroying organized crime
  1218. 41:36in our region. Countries have to act
  1219. 41:39together to destroy all organized crime
  1220. 41:40. Basically, I'm talking about the
  1221. 41:43factions that export drugs to the rest
  1222. 41:45of the world, which do what? We have
  1223. 41:47very troubled political regimes in
  1224. 41:49South America, so negotiating as a bloc
  1225. 41:51with other countries in the world. One
  1226. 41:54example, the Panama Canal, its
  1227. 41:55geopolitical power is giant; it makes a
  1228. 41:56connection between the Atlantic and
  1229. 41:58Pacific. Now there's going to be a
  1230. 41:59railway, Shangaius,
  1231. 42:01which interests China a lot and doesn't
  1232. 42:04interest the United States, because you
  1233. 42:06bypass the Panama Canal, precisely in a
  1234. 42:09region with grain production, ores,
  1235. 42:11rare earths that goes from Brazil to
  1236. 42:13Peru. So, geopolitically, it's a region
  1237. 42:16that will be increasingly important, so
  1238. 42:18being in a bloc with them will increase
  1239. 42:20our bargaining power. I wanted to ask
  1240. 42:24you about your proposal, your
  1241. 42:26commitment, if elected, within one year
  1242. 42:29, to free all favelas from the
  1243. 42:31occupation of organized crime and the
  1244. 42:34factions. Is that really possible?
  1245. 42:37It, it, it is, because militarily
  1246. 42:39speaking, organized crime is very
  1247. 42:42fragile. The leaders and the soldiers
  1248. 42:46are poorly trained, and they only
  1249. 42:48survive because of the very fragile
  1250. 42:50legislation we have, very weak
  1251. 42:51sentences, the control they have over
  1252. 42:54the prisons, and the lack of political
  1253. 42:56will from the federal government to
  1254. 42:58unify security policies, not the
  1255. 43:00day-to-day, routine policy that a
  1256. 43:02governor does. They should have freedom
  1257. 43:05to manage their police and carry out
  1258. 43:06their local policies, but the policy of
  1259. 43:08combating crime. Especially because the
  1260. 43:10Red Command operates in Ceará,
  1261. 43:12articulated by a strategy formed in Rio
  1262. 43:13. The PCC takes the drugs that come
  1263. 43:15through Mato Grosso do Sul and exports
  1264. 43:16them to São Paulo. So you will have to
  1265. 43:18coordinate this via the federal
  1266. 43:19government. So since that doesn't exist
  1267. 43:22today, you have this free-for-all. The
  1268. 43:24federal government must articulate a
  1269. 43:26destruction of organized crime. Because
  1270. 43:28if you ask any police officer, if you
  1271. 43:30have freedom and support from the
  1272. 43:33government and legal support to
  1273. 43:35confront a faction in a favela, in a
  1274. 43:38neighborhood, in a city, will you have
  1275. 43:40any difficulty? No BOPE officer or
  1276. 43:42Ceará police officer will say that no,
  1277. 43:45no, it's difficult. It's not difficult.
  1278. 43:47The problem is what comes after. We
  1279. 43:49will arrest these people, and once
  1280. 43:50arrested, they will remain isolated in
  1281. 43:52prison. We will destroy their entire
  1282. 43:53financing network. COAF will catch the
  1283. 43:55companies that launder their money. The
  1284. 43:58port of Santos will have an
  1285. 43:59intervention to prevent drugs from
  1286. 44:01going to Europe. I will have a
  1287. 44:03cooperation program with the
  1288. 44:04Netherlands to prevent them from
  1289. 44:05receiving drugs that left Brazil. I
  1290. 44:06will have a border policy with Bolivia
  1291. 44:08to prevent drugs from entering. I will
  1292. 44:10have a policy involving the police of
  1293. 44:12São Paulo and Mato Grosso do Sul to
  1294. 44:14prevent the drug routes, where trucks
  1295. 44:16pass with drugs hidden inside, from
  1296. 44:17operating. If I manage to build this
  1297. 44:20web, I will break them financially,
  1298. 44:22politically, and territorially. And
  1299. 44:24then we free them militarily speaking;
  1300. 44:26that is not difficult. The problem is
  1301. 44:27something else. The problem is that no
  1302. 44:29one ever said: "I am going to
  1303. 44:30coordinate this as if it were a war."
  1304. 44:32And I will give Brazilians and you
  1305. 44:33journalists a unique opportunity to
  1306. 44:35provide the kind of coverage you see in
  1307. 44:37the war in Ukraine, with a map of
  1308. 44:38Brazil. Look, this area that was red,
  1309. 44:41marked as red, has just been liberated.
  1310. 44:43Look, federal troops have entered such
  1311. 44:45and such a city. You will have very
  1312. 44:47beautiful, very graphic coverage.
  1313. 44:48Well, we saw this at the beginning of
  1314. 44:50Sérgio Cabral's government in Rio de
  1315. 44:52Janeiro. We saw where it ended up.
  1316. 44:55That's why it's not such an easy thing
  1317. 44:57to do, because he would go there, take
  1318. 44:59a favela, and say: "Oh, look, we have
  1319. 45:01arrived here with the pacification of
  1320. 45:02this region." And we saw where that led
  1321. 45:05. I wanted to ask you if you,
  1322. 45:07may I just reply to you on this? It is
  1323. 45:10quite important. It's because it was
  1324. 45:11poorly done for the reasons I raised,
  1325. 45:13because it wasn't a structure that
  1326. 45:15involved changes to criminal laws,
  1327. 45:16penal procedural laws, prison laws;
  1328. 45:18there was no project for
  1329. 45:19de-favela-ization.
  1330. 45:20Doesn't the public security amendment
  1331. 45:22already try to move in this direction
  1332. 45:24of unifying the service?
  1333. 45:27It does, but it unifies the routine
  1334. 45:29activity of the police. The routine
  1335. 45:31activity of the police must belong to
  1336. 45:33the governor. Now, the formulation of a
  1337. 45:36police force to confront organized
  1338. 45:38crime, which is an activity—let's use
  1339. 45:40a nice term here—interstate, that has
  1340. 45:42to be done by the federal government,
  1341. 45:43which is the war,
  1342. 45:45international connection,
  1343. 45:46clearly, not the United States one,
  1344. 45:48okay? Like, oh,
  1345. 45:50the United States is saying, it's a
  1346. 45:51terrorist, no, I don't want any
  1347. 45:52American setting foot on Brazilian soil
  1348. 45:54. Now it will have it with Bolivia, it
  1349. 45:55will have it with all the countries
  1350. 45:56bordering Brazil and with the countries
  1351. 45:57that receive the drugs that Brazil
  1352. 45:58exports. Now, regarding this connection
  1353. 46:03between organized crime and the
  1354. 46:06financial market, because we've seen
  1355. 46:08some channels of communication between
  1356. 46:11organized crime and Faria Lima,
  1357. 46:14specifically in that case involving gas
  1358. 46:16stations, right, with some fintechs, uh
  1359. 46:19, laundering money for the PCC,
  1360. 46:22including. How do you intend to handle
  1361. 46:26this issue regarding the financial
  1362. 46:28market?
  1363. 46:30Ah, with crime, you mean, or the
  1364. 46:31financial market as a whole?
  1365. 46:32The financial market. And this
  1366. 46:35relationship between the financial
  1367. 46:37market and organized crime, for which
  1368. 46:40some signs have already been caught
  1369. 46:42that this contact exists.
  1370. 46:44Yeah, let's go. About fintechs, I am
  1371. 46:48very much in favor of fintech policy
  1372. 46:50because they are bringing people into
  1373. 46:51the banking system and even a
  1374. 46:53microcredit market that is reaching
  1375. 46:54people who didn't have credit with big
  1376. 46:56banks and now are able to have it, and
  1377. 46:58this was good for Brazil in general, it
  1378. 46:59generated an increase in banking supply
  1379. 47:01for people. Therefore, it's not that
  1380. 47:04the link between organized crime and
  1381. 47:06the use of fintechs, or even the use of
  1382. 47:08crypto that some do, will make me
  1383. 47:09destroy the crypto market or the
  1384. 47:11fintech market. So, one thing is one
  1385. 47:12thing, another thing is another thing.
  1386. 47:14I have to use the instruments we have
  1387. 47:16at our disposal, especially COAF, to
  1388. 47:17catch the companies involved, carry out
  1389. 47:19operations, and put them in jail, just
  1390. 47:21like the military leader of organized
  1391. 47:23crime who is in the favela. In other
  1392. 47:26words, a crime boss operating in Faria
  1393. 47:28Lima must receive a sentence similar to
  1394. 47:31the crime boss in Rocinha, because they
  1395. 47:34are part of the same organization. So,
  1396. 47:37the sentences must be very high, 30, 40
  1397. 47:39, 50 years without parole progression,
  1398. 47:41because the man who launders PCC money
  1399. 47:43in Faria Lima is participating in an
  1400. 47:45operation that kills people every day.
  1401. 47:49And this understanding you need to have
  1402. 47:51, it's not because the guy is in a suit
  1403. 47:53, all dressed up, going to dinner in a
  1404. 47:54nice place, that he is not responsible
  1405. 47:56for someone's death. He is; he is
  1406. 47:59laundering the money that ultimately
  1407. 48:01came from a murder. So we have to catch
  1408. 48:03him too.
  1409. 48:04OK. Our time is almost up. I would like
  1410. 48:06you to talk a little more about your
  1411. 48:08education proposal so we can finish our
  1412. 48:10interview.
  1413. 48:12There are so many. Uh, but I will try.
  1414. 48:14Let's go. Basic education, my
  1415. 48:16priorities. One, uh, institution as
  1416. 48:19mandatory of the phonics method for
  1417. 48:21literacy in Brazil. It's absurd to
  1418. 48:24adopt any method other than one that is
  1419. 48:26assertive and proven by international
  1420. 48:28studies to be efficient for teaching
  1421. 48:30children to read and write. Two, a
  1422. 48:33goal-based policy, like the one Ceará
  1423. 48:35started for all schools with bonuses
  1424. 48:37and payments for teachers and
  1425. 48:39principals based on their performance.
  1426. 48:42There is a lot of demand. Oh, the
  1427. 48:44teachers' union wants a raise. I'll
  1428. 48:45give it. That's how it will be. The
  1429. 48:47school performed well. I'll give the
  1430. 48:48principal a nice raise. I'll give the
  1431. 48:50principal a nice bonus, a nice bonus
  1432. 48:52that is handled by the state
  1433. 48:54governments, right? The schools would
  1434. 48:56be federalized.
  1435. 48:58The policy. They implement the policy,
  1436. 49:00but the policy must be federalized. Why
  1437. 49:03? Because there are states that don't
  1438. 49:04apply it. It's very easy for a governor
  1439. 49:07, like the one in Maranhão, who
  1440. 49:08performs poorly in national tests, to
  1441. 49:10say: "I'm giving a flat raise to
  1442. 49:11teachers, everyone gets it." And then
  1443. 49:14he doesn't do well, he's not worried
  1444. 49:15about the indicator because his money
  1445. 49:16isn't even collected in Maranhão, he
  1446. 49:18collects it here in São Paulo through
  1447. 49:19the federal pact. It's very easy,
  1448. 49:21everyone must have a performance goal,
  1449. 49:23from the school principal to the
  1450. 49:26teacher and the family. The family is
  1451. 49:28not involved in the activity. So, how
  1452. 49:30are we going to do it? The school
  1453. 49:31performed well. The best students in
  1454. 49:33that school, their families will
  1455. 49:35receive a cash prize. The family to be
  1456. 49:37rewarded. Because lower-income families
  1457. 49:39, especially the ones we track with
  1458. 49:41single mothers, the mother supports the
  1459. 49:42house, she's providing for the home,
  1460. 49:44she doesn't have time to be with the
  1461. 49:46child helping with homework. So, if the
  1462. 49:48mother knew, hey, I received a prize
  1463. 49:50because my child is doing well, the
  1464. 49:52mother will stay on top of it, she will
  1465. 49:54guide the entire ecosystem of people
  1466. 49:56around her to ensure that the child
  1467. 49:58feels secure to produce better
  1468. 50:00academically at school. The children
  1469. 50:03who are the outliers, the top 1%that
  1470. 50:05you find in any school, we will enroll
  1471. 50:07them in the best schools in the
  1472. 50:08municipality or state, according to the
  1473. 50:10mother's and father's wishes, so they
  1474. 50:12can compete in the best entrance exams.
  1475. 50:15It doesn't matter the gender, race, or
  1476. 50:17color, but public school children are
  1477. 50:18getting good grades in any municipality
  1478. 50:20in Brazil. The state will invest in
  1479. 50:22them as early as the third or fourth
  1480. 50:24grade through standardized tests that
  1481. 50:26will track their performance and say, "
  1482. 50:27This child is exceptional, they will
  1483. 50:29get into USP, Unicamp, or ITA, so I
  1484. 50:31will invest in them right now." And
  1485. 50:33then I no longer need the quota system
  1486. 50:35because I am solving the problem
  1487. 50:37beforehand. For the children who don't
  1488. 50:40want to go to university or who won't
  1489. 50:41join this program, there's technical
  1490. 50:43training in high school, just like in
  1491. 50:44Germany, where 50%of the workforce goes
  1492. 50:45through this technical education. We
  1493. 50:48have to do this right away with SESC,
  1494. 50:50SENAT, SENAI, and SENAR, with everyone
  1495. 50:51bringing in jobs and training, geared
  1496. 50:53toward the specific vocation of each
  1497. 50:54municipality. This already links the
  1498. 50:57student to their first job. And for the
  1499. 51:00university, I don't know if I'm
  1500. 51:01rambling, but for the university,
  1501. 51:03is that okay? Let's wrap it up, but the
  1502. 51:04rest can happen like that. Uh, we are
  1503. 51:06going to end university autonomy so
  1504. 51:08that the state can provide direction
  1505. 51:10for investments in teaching, research,
  1506. 51:12and outreach in public universities. In
  1507. 51:14other words, we will focus on the
  1508. 51:16humanities, exact sciences, and
  1509. 51:18biological sciences, especially
  1510. 51:19research in engineering, biotechnology,
  1511. 51:21artificial intelligence, geology, rare
  1512. 51:23earths, and oceanography (given the
  1513. 51:25Brazilian coastline), to train people
  1514. 51:27capable of building companies that will
  1515. 51:29increase Brazilian productivity through
  1516. 51:31the generation of knowledge. And this
  1517. 51:34meets Brazil's ambition to be a growing
  1518. 51:36country. Singapore does this, Israel
  1519. 51:39does this, China does this, Japan is
  1520. 51:40doing this, and Brazil needs to do it.
  1521. 51:43Okay, candidate, thank you very much
  1522. 51:45for your presence and see you next time
  1523. 51:47. Thank you very much for your presence
  1524. 51:50.
  1525. 51:50Thank you.
  1526. 51:51The Sabatina, Correio Brasiliense, 2026
  1527. 51:54Elections ends here. We truly
  1528. 51:56appreciate your company and see you
  1529. 51:58next time. Bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of RENAN SANTOS, CANDIDATO À PRESIDÊNCIA PELO MISSÃO, PARTICIPA DE SABATINA DO CORREIO by Correio Braziliense, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,566 words across 1,529 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.