REFUTAÇÃO A ANDRE LUIZ SOBRE O CULTO ÀS RELÍQUIAS — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello, friends, peace of Christ be with
- 0:02you all. So, today's video is a
- 0:04response to Professor André Luiz
- 0:06regarding the topic of relics, right?
- 0:09On this same subject, this is the third
- 0:11video we've been producing in light of
- 0:14the apologetic controversies that have
- 0:16arisen over the last few weeks.
- 0:19Professor André made a response video
- 0:21to me and my historiographical research
- 0:23using Iswinsky, and he brings up some
- 0:24points here that I would like to answer
- 0:26in this video. As usual, I will leave
- 0:28many citations on the screen. Do not
- 0:31forget to pause the video and verify
- 0:32them. I won't read them all out, you
- 0:35know? I won't perform a literal
- 0:37narration because the video would
- 0:39become way too long, and I want to keep
- 0:42this as organic as possible. Well,
- 0:46Professor André tries to respond to my
- 0:48challenge regarding the apostolicity of
- 0:51the veneration of relics, and he claims
- 0:53it is something apostolic, right?
- 0:57Supposedly, some apostle left the
- 1:00church the practice of venerating the
- 1:03mortal remains of Christian martyrs and
- 1:06godly Christian men of the past.
- 1:10The Martyrdom of Polycarp is from the
- 1:122nd century, as most historians say;
- 1:14that is the state of the question in
- 1:17academia, so to speak, the dominant
- 1:19thesis. If the Martyrdom of Polycarp is
- 1:23from the end of the 2nd century, we
- 1:25have a source speaking of relic
- 1:27veneration from a Christian bishop of
- 1:30Asia Minor, who lived in the first half
- 1:33of the century and was a direct
- 1:35disciple of Saint John the Theologian.
- 1:39And the document shows that this
- 1:40veneration was already taking place in
- 1:42some way during his lifetime, right?
- 1:44The faithful of Smyrna, the followers
- 1:47of this church in Asia Minor, the
- 1:49followers of Saint Polycarp, insisted
- 1:51on touching his body while he was still
- 1:53alive. Touching his body because they
- 1:57believed he was already permeated with
- 1:59all virtue and goodness, adorned with
- 2:02all gifts due to his virtuous life, his
- 2:04life in contact with God. If that isn't
- 2:08a sufficient criterion of apostolicity,
- 2:10a Christian bishop from the first half
- 2:12of the 2nd century? A man who grew up
- 2:15at the feet of an apostle, Saint John
- 2:17the Theologian, a man of immense
- 2:19prestige throughout the early church
- 2:21precisely for his great holiness in
- 2:23life, a hero of the faith, a Christian
- 2:26martyr. If that is not enough for an
- 2:28evangelical to attest to the
- 2:30apostolicity of a Christian belief and
- 2:32practice, then what would be? And he
- 2:35brings up some authors who, albeit in a
- 2:37laudatory way, discuss the work of
- 2:39Iswinsky. This is an important question
- 2:41. Professor André himself acknowledges
- 2:45that Svineski is a top-tier scholar,
- 2:47but they mainly attack Svineski's work
- 2:50on a conceptual level. In other words,
- 2:54they argue that the definition of the
- 2:56cult of relics provided by the author I
- 2:58brought up is too restrictive. And
- 3:02because it is so restrictive, this
- 3:03definition ends up pushing this cult
- 3:05into the [later] century, and they
- 3:07suggest we should adopt a broader
- 3:09definition of what the cult of relics
- 3:11entails. That is where we hit the first
- 3:15problem, as the main point of
- 3:17divergence here is precisely what we
- 3:19call the thaumaturgic power of relics.
- 3:21What is that? It is the miraculous
- 3:23power, right? We know that these
- 3:25manifestations, which are very common
- 3:28today in both Roman Catholicism and
- 3:30Eastern Orthodoxy—exhuming mortal
- 3:32remains, kissing and venerating skulls
- 3:35or the bones of the dead—all emerged
- 3:37in Christianity in the [later] century,
- 3:40especially linked to the idea of the
- 3:42intercession of the saints; that is,
- 3:45the idea that saints can hear our
- 3:47prayers and answer them, and primarily
- 3:49the idea that these relics, these
- 3:52mortal remains, retain some miraculous
- 3:55power, that contact with them could
- 3:57bring about healing, the expulsion of a
- 3:59demon, for example, the protection of a
- 4:01city, and all of that. So, this
- 4:04thaumaturgic power is, in Svineski's
- 4:06definition, a constitutive element of
- 4:09the cult of relics. And the authors
- 4:12that Professor André brings up seem,
- 4:14in some way, not to consider
- 4:16thaumaturgic power a constitutive
- 4:18element. And so we find ourselves in
- 4:20this stalemate regarding the definition
- 4:22. The question is whether or not it is
- 4:25an essential identifier, that is, a
- 4:26necessary element for us to say that we
- 4:28truly have a cult of relics at a given
- 4:30moment in history. It strikes me that
- 4:34Professor André did not offer any
- 4:36definition of his own in his video,
- 4:38right? What does he personally consider
- 4:41? He brought up the opinions of these
- 4:44authors who tend to see other elements,
- 4:46such as the special honor that was paid
- 4:49to the mortal remains of martyrs, or
- 4:51even a special burial, or, for instance
- 4:53, the idea of commemorating the
- 4:55anniversary of martyrdom with the
- 4:57celebration of the Eucharist. All of
- 5:01this is presented by these authors as
- 5:02antecedents that could already indicate
- 5:04that the cult of relics dates back to
- 5:06the 2nd or 1st century. And here, I
- 5:08would like to draw attention to a very
- 5:09important factor. None of the authors
- 5:11cited by Professor André respond to my
- 5:14challenge. None of these scholars claim
- 5:16, for example, that the cult of relics
- 5:18is something apostolic or a practice
- 5:20bequeathed by the apostles. Quite the
- 5:22contrary, some of the authors brought
- 5:24up by him actually state that the cult
- 5:27of relics emerged in the 2nd century,
- 5:29not the apostolic era. So, it is
- 5:32interesting that, faced with so many
- 5:34responses produced so far by Roman
- 5:36Catholics and Eastern Orthodox, none of
- 5:39them have managed to bring even a
- 5:41single scholar, a single scholar with
- 5:43minimal respectability, to defend the
- 5:45thesis they hold. Because they argue
- 5:48that this practice dates back to the
- 5:50apostles, even citing the Bible
- 5:52incorrectly, yet they cannot bring
- 5:54absolutely any scholar, right? This is
- 5:56interesting. I think it is noteworthy.
- 5:59I would pose this challenge to
- 6:00Professor André Luiz. What respected
- 6:03scholar who has produced a work that
- 6:05has undergone peer review, that has
- 6:07recognition from peers, would claim,
- 6:09for example, that we have evidence of
- 6:12the apostolicity of the cult of relics?
- 6:15Absolutely none, my friends. There is
- 6:17no such scholar. What these scholars,
- 6:21at best—that is, if we accept all the
- 6:23premises put forth in Professor
- 6:25André's video—at best, we could say
- 6:27that you have an antecedent to the cult
- 6:29of relics in the 2nd century, right?
- 6:32Which you would have there, in the
- 6:33second half of the 2nd century, which
- 6:35would be the case of the martyrdom of
- 6:36Polycarp. But even so, that would still
- 6:39be insufficient to demonstrate this
- 6:41apostolicity. So that is where this
- 6:48question comes in, and the great
- 6:50divergence lies precisely in the issue
- 6:51of thaumaturgical power. However, my
- 6:53friends, our work is an apologetic one.
- 6:56We are responding to other Christian
- 6:58traditions. And these Christian
- 7:00traditions define the cult of relics by
- 7:02encapsulating miraculous power as a
- 7:05constituent element. For example, if
- 7:08you take the case of the Roman
- 7:09Catholics, the Council of Trent itself
- 7:11states—it condemns those who denied
- 7:13in the 16th century that relics
- 7:15retained any miraculous power. When we
- 7:18look at sources that Eastern Orthodox
- 7:21accept as authoritative, they also
- 7:23state very clearly that miraculous
- 7:25power is a constituent element of this
- 7:28cult. What does that mean? You cannot
- 7:31say, you cannot place the emergence of
- 7:33this cult in a specific period of
- 7:35history if you do not have this element
- 7:37of thaumaturgical power. You take, for
- 7:40example, the Second Council of Nicaea,
- 7:42a council that took place in 787,
- 7:44although it does not deal directly with
- 7:46the question of the cult of relics, it
- 7:48ends up bringing in its minutes some
- 7:50confessions of faith. And a profession
- 7:53of faith by a bishop named Theodosius
- 7:55is extremely interesting. He was a
- 7:57bishop who was likely an iconoclast.
- 7:59And in order to be received back into
- 8:01the communion of the church, he needed
- 8:03to make a profession of faith. Look at
- 8:05the elements of the profession of faith
- 8:07he had to make. Likewise, I venerate,
- 8:11honor, and greet the relics of the
- 8:13saints, as those who fought for Christ
- 8:15and received from Him the grace for
- 8:17healing diseases, curing infirmities,
- 8:19and casting out demons, just as the
- 8:21Christian Church has received from the
- 8:23holy apostles and fathers down to us
- 8:25today. In other words, we have a bishop
- 8:28. And here, although this is not part
- 8:32of the council's dogmatic definition,
- 8:34we clearly have evidence that this was
- 8:36a profession considered orthodox for
- 8:38the bishops participating in that
- 8:39council. We have the affirmation of the
- 8:42veneration of mortal remains and also
- 8:44the attribution of miraculous power to
- 8:46those remains. And note, this is
- 8:49affirmed as a practice received by the
- 8:51Christian church from the apostles and
- 8:53the church fathers down to the present
- 8:55day. So, when we look at sources like
- 8:59this, and they are repeated ad nauseam
- 9:01in other sources that Eastern Orthodox
- 9:03consider authoritative, for example,
- 9:05you have the case of Saint John of
- 9:07Damascus. John of Damascus was a great
- 9:10defender of the cult, that is, the
- 9:12veneration of images. And he likewise
- 9:14defended the cult of relics as an
- 9:16apostolic tradition. He says the
- 9:18following in his Exact Exposition of
- 9:20the Orthodox Faith: "The Lord Christ
- 9:22has made for us the relics of the
- 9:23saints sources of salvation." Here it
- 9:25is not even talking about a blessing,
- 9:27right? It is already speaking of a
- 9:29source of salvation, from which
- 9:30multiple benefits flow and which exude
- 9:32oil of sweet fragrance. And let no one
- 9:35fail to believe this, right? And then
- 9:37he explains later in the same work what
- 9:39those benefits would be. For how could
- 9:42a dead body perform miracles? How,
- 9:44therefore, are demons cast out through
- 9:46them? Diseases dispelled, the sick
- 9:49healed, the blind restored to sight,
- 9:51the lepers cleansed, temptations and
- 9:53difficulties overcome? And how does
- 9:56every good gift descend through them
- 9:58upon those who pray with firm faith? So
- 10:01, for John of Damascus, who is
- 10:02considered a father of the church and a
- 10:04saint by Eastern Orthodoxy, this
- 10:06miraculous power to perform healings of
- 10:09diseases, the casting out of demons,
- 10:11and so much more was clearly an
- 10:12essential element of this cult, this
- 10:14veneration of relics. When you look at
- 10:18other texts, right, from the Eastern
- 10:19Orthodox tradition, such as the
- 10:21Catechism of Philaret of Moscow, we
- 10:23have the same thing, right, the clear
- 10:24affirmation also of this miraculous
- 10:26power. You have other documents as well
- 10:28that I will leave on the screen, such
- 10:30as, for example, the contemporary
- 10:31Catechism of the Orthodox Church in
- 10:32America, right? You also have, ah,
- 10:35documents from the Greek Orthodox
- 10:37Church as well, meaning all these
- 10:39documents, and other liturgical
- 10:40documents from Greek Orthodoxy, clearly
- 10:42affirm this element. So, since we are
- 10:46here in an apologetic dispute and I am
- 10:48trying to demonstrate that what Eastern
- 10:51Orthodox and Roman Catholics practice
- 10:53lacks, right, lacks apostolicity, lacks
- 10:55ancient historicity, in my view, it is
- 10:58very difficult here to claim that this
- 11:00thaumaturgic element cannot be
- 11:02considered. Another point I also bring
- 11:04to the discussion is that there is an
- 11:06inconsistency in Professor André's
- 11:08argument. Why? At the same time that he
- 11:11brings these academics who dismiss
- 11:13miraculous power as necessary to
- 11:15demonstrate the antiquity of this cult,
- 11:17when Professor André and other
- 11:18defenders of this cult appeal to the
- 11:20scriptures, what do they do? They
- 11:23appeal to examples that bring exactly
- 11:26which element? The thaumaturgic element
- 11:28. For example, when they use the texts
- 11:30of Elisha, or when they use the New
- 11:32Testament texts of Paul, right, of
- 11:34Peter, of Jesus. What do you have in
- 11:36these texts? What is the element that
- 11:38is being, that could, right, supposedly
- 11:40be demonstrated there? It is precisely
- 11:43the mortal remains or belongings of
- 11:46worthy and pious men of the past being
- 11:48used by God to perform miracles. So, if
- 11:52the thaumaturgic element is not an
- 11:53essential element, if it is not a
- 11:55necessary element to demonstrate the
- 11:57historical antiquity of this cult, why
- 11:59then would these passages that are used
- 12:01be precisely the passages that
- 12:02demonstrate this thaumaturgic element?
- 12:06So, in my view, I think the thesis of
- 12:08Svinevski, the conceptual dispute...
- 12:10Svinevski is right in the following
- 12:12sense: if you cannot demonstrate this
- 12:15miraculous power and all the practices
- 12:17that ended up being associated with
- 12:19miraculous power, that is, exhuming
- 12:21mortal remains, placing them in
- 12:23reliquaries, holding processions,
- 12:25consecrating, consecrating churches
- 12:27with these relics, if this cannot be
- 12:29demonstrated, at best, what you have is
- 12:31an antecedent. You could even say that
- 12:36you have a prior necessary condition
- 12:38for this cult to develop, but you
- 12:40cannot claim that you have the cult
- 12:42itself. Also remembering that Professor
- 12:47André, he seems to presuppose that the
- 12:49thesis of Svinevski was a thesis
- 12:51confronted by most academics, but that
- 12:53is not true. Another critique also made
- 13:12regarding Isvinsk's work is precisely
- 13:14the claim that he is using a weak
- 13:16argument from silence. However, I
- 13:20believe this does not do justice to our
- 13:22author. Why? What he demonstrates is
- 13:25not simply the fact that the martyrdom
- 13:27of Polycarp does not attribute any
- 13:28miraculous power. Even one of the
- 13:30authors brought up by Professor André
- 13:32acknowledges this, right? He
- 13:34acknowledges that there is indeed no
- 13:35attribution of miraculous power to the
- 13:37mortal remains. The problem is that we
- 13:40have dozens of martyrdom accounts from
- 13:42the first centuries, that is, from the
- 13:44second and third centuries. In none of
- 13:47these accounts do we have this element.
- 13:49He even brings, for example—I will
- 13:51leave the quote on the screen—the
- 13:52testimony of Eusebius of Caesarea.
- 13:54Eusebius of Caesarea, the church
- 13:56historian who wrote at the beginning of
- 13:58the century, presents a series of
- 14:00martyrdom accounts, and in none of
- 14:02these reports do we have the
- 14:04thaumaturgical element, right? So it is
- 14:06not simply one piece of evidence. It is
- 14:08a body of evidence. We have here a
- 14:11confluence of evidence where an
- 14:13expected piece of evidence does not
- 14:16appear. Therefore, a methodological
- 14:19caution is also appropriate here.
- 14:21Arguments from silence can be
- 14:22fallacious or not. In modern
- 14:24historiography, historians often use
- 14:26arguments from silence. Everything
- 14:29depends on the expectation of that
- 14:31evidence appearing in that context. So,
- 14:33what determines if the argument is
- 14:35non-fallacious is precisely the context
- 14:37. If we are talking about a context in
- 14:40which evidence would be expected, in
- 14:42which the presentation of that practice
- 14:43, fact, or idea would be expected, then
- 14:45we can affirm that there is indeed a
- 14:47plausibility to claim that the practice
- 14:49does not exist. When we observe, for
- 14:53example, the accounts of the second and
- 14:55third centuries, although you do have
- 14:57—and this is one of the elements
- 14:59Professor André brings up in his video
- 15:01—a special practice, a special honor
- 15:03being paid to the bodies of these
- 15:05martyrs, we find no evidence,
- 15:07conversely, in these various reports of
- 15:09any attribution of miraculous power.
- 15:12When you go to the second half of the
- 15:14fourth century, the logic is reversed.
- 15:17You have a series of abundant accounts
- 15:20that begin more or less around the year
- 15:22360 with reports from Hilary of
- 15:23Poitiers of people unearthing these
- 15:25mortal remains, attributing to them all
- 15:28sorts of miraculous power. So there is
- 15:31obviously a discontinuity here in the
- 15:33tradition, my friends, right? It is not
- 15:35just an isolated piece of evidence, but
- 15:37a body of evidence. Given the absence
- 15:40of evidence, we can indeed state that
- 15:42the most plausible position is that
- 15:44this practice, which began to gain
- 15:46popularity in the second half of the
- 15:484th century, is not a practice that
- 15:50dates back to the earliest eras of the
- 15:52church. It is also important to
- 15:54remember that even within that century
- 15:57—and Professor André alludes to this
- 15:59fact, noting that Christianity only
- 16:02became a tolerated religion at the
- 16:04beginning of the century—even in that
- 16:06first half, we have several decades
- 16:09where Christianity was already
- 16:11tolerated, and yet we still do not see
- 16:13these practices of exhumation, these
- 16:15massive exhumation practices, and the
- 16:18attribution of miraculous power. This
- 16:20is also difficult to explain if you
- 16:23already had an apostolic practice from
- 16:25the 1st century, if we already had
- 16:27practically 300 years of consistent and
- 16:30systematic practice, and we simply do
- 16:32not find any evidence of it. So, in my
- 16:36view, the weakest point of Professor
- 16:38André's argument—and it is an
- 16:39element for which he bears the burden
- 16:41of proof—is that even if all we had
- 16:43was a fragile argument from silence,
- 16:45which I do not believe is the case, the
- 16:47burden of proof still lies with the
- 16:49Roman Catholics and the Eastern
- 16:51Orthodox. They must, indeed,
- 16:54necessarily demonstrate this miraculous
- 16:56power in these older sources. And none
- 16:59of the texts that Professor André
- 17:00presented can simply carry that burden
- 17:03of proof. That is why, for example,
- 17:05when Roman Catholics and Orthodox bring
- 17:07up supposed biblical evidence, such as
- 17:09the account of Elisha, I believe this
- 17:11is a real shot in the foot. Because if
- 17:15the account of Elisha had indeed been
- 17:17the ignition point for a cult of relics
- 17:19—remembering that the Elisha account
- 17:21happens centuries before Christ—why
- 17:23do we have no archaeological evidence
- 17:26from Second Temple Judaism, from the
- 17:28Judaism of Jesus 'time, or from earlier
- 17:30Judaism? Any archaeological or
- 17:33uncontroversial textual evidence
- 17:35claiming, for example, that Elisha's
- 17:37remains began to be venerated, or
- 17:39claiming, for example, that people
- 17:41started seeking contact with those
- 17:43remains. We simply have no evidence of
- 17:46this, right? When we look at the Old
- 17:48Testament law, this was something very
- 17:51unlikely to appear. And the explanation
- 17:54is that there were laws of ritual
- 17:55impurity regarding human bodies and the
- 17:57remains of those people. The Jews would
- 18:00indeed have had a prejudice against
- 18:02having contact with such remains.
- 18:04Professor André also appeals to New
- 18:06Testament texts. He even says that
- 18:08these texts clearly demonstrate the
- 18:10practice of relic veneration, but I
- 18:12vehemently disagree. Look, in the video
- 18:15the professor is responding to, I could
- 18:17have indeed explored this argument
- 18:19better, which I only did in the second
- 18:20video in response to one of the
- 18:22brothers. But we don't have the
- 18:24veneration of relics in either the New
- 18:27or Old Testament, not even as a
- 18:28description. What we have in the New
- 18:32and Old Testaments is only the
- 18:33description of God extraordinarily
- 18:35using belongings or mortal remains, in
- 18:37Elisha's case, to perform miracles. But
- 18:41there are a series of leaps, right, a
- 18:43series of premises that Roman Catholics
- 18:44and Eastern Orthodox need to
- 18:46demonstrate to endorse the cult. Why?
- 18:49We do not have in the New Testament,
- 18:51for example, a description of people
- 18:53keeping these mortal remains or
- 18:54attributing miraculous power to them.
- 18:57If, in fact, it was what I said in the
- 18:58previous video, which I believe
- 19:00Professor André hadn't had access to
- 19:02when he made this response. If, in fact
- 19:05, we had a practice here of people, for
- 19:07example, keeping Paul's handkerchiefs
- 19:10and aprons and starting to venerate
- 19:12these items, and attributing any
- 19:14miraculous power to them, and this
- 19:16practice being described by a biblical
- 19:18author as positive, then I would say
- 19:21you have a descriptive argument that
- 19:23could indeed be used without being
- 19:25fallacious by the proponents of this
- 19:27cult. But we have nothing of the sort.
- 19:30We actually have a series of logical
- 19:31leaps, a series of logical leaps.
- 19:33Starting, for example, with the fact of
- 19:35these people's dignity. Elisha was a
- 19:37prophet. Paul, Peter, apostles. Jesus
- 19:40was God himself incarnate. Simply
- 19:43transferring to saints and martyrs what
- 19:45was attributed to these men who occupy
- 19:46a special dignity needs to be
- 19:48demonstrated, right? Furthermore, the
- 19:51description of the cult itself does not
- 19:53exist, right? Because the cult that was
- 19:55practiced, if you take, for example,
- 19:57even the most minimalist version, right
- 19:59? Even the most minimalist evidence
- 20:02brought forth in the work is the
- 20:04martyrdom of Polycarp; we have nothing
- 20:06similar to that being endorsed in
- 20:08biblical or apostolic texts. We do not
- 20:12have evidence, for example, of Jesus
- 20:14and the apostles normatizing any
- 20:15practice that resembles the martyrdom
- 20:17of Polycarp. And I wanted to draw
- 20:20attention to another fact here, when
- 20:22the martyrdom of Polycarp is used,
- 20:24right? An argument some commenters made
- 20:26on my last video, and also an argument
- 20:28Professor André makes, is that
- 20:30Polycarp was a disciple of John.
- 20:33Therefore, what was being practiced
- 20:34there at Polycarp's martyrdom would be
- 20:36an apostolic tradition, probably
- 20:38inherited from the apostle John. But we
- 20:40have a series of problems. To begin
- 20:43with, the Martyrdom of Polycarp, my
- 20:45friends, is not a work written by
- 20:47Polycarp himself. Actually, it is a
- 20:49work written by Polycarp's church, by
- 20:51the community of Smyrna. Furthermore,
- 20:55regarding the practice described in
- 20:56chapters 17 and 18 of this work, at no
- 20:58point does the author—whoever they
- 21:00may have been—claim it is. We do not
- 21:03know exactly—we do not have detailed
- 21:05biographical data about the author of
- 21:08this work. At no point does he claim it
- 21:10to be an apostolic tradition. So,
- 21:13notice that the argument that Catholics
- 21:16and Orthodox make here doesn't even
- 21:17find substance in the text they are
- 21:19using, right? You cannot assume that
- 21:22simply because a practice was described
- 21:25by a church in the second half of the
- 21:272nd century, it is necessarily
- 21:28apostolic. If the text said that by
- 21:31keeping Polycarp's remains, by
- 21:33commemorating the anniversary of his
- 21:36martyrdom, they were following a
- 21:38practice that was standardized, that
- 21:40was commanded by an apostle. Then you
- 21:43could even say you have an argument
- 21:44here from the Martyrdom of Polycarp,
- 21:46but we don't even have that. I would
- 21:49even like to draw attention to how
- 21:51Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholics
- 21:53are very arbitrary in the yardstick
- 21:56they set for evidence. For example, you
- 21:59have a text from Irenaeus of Lyons in
- 22:02which he attributes to an apostolic
- 22:04tradition—and here we do have an
- 22:06explicit attribution to apostolic
- 22:08tradition—the age of Jesus'
- 22:10crucifixion, right? Irenaeus of Lyons
- 22:12had that theology of recapitulation and
- 22:14he understood that Jesus was crucified
- 22:16already old, right? That when Jesus was
- 22:18crucified, he was already a man who was
- 22:21around 50 years old, somewhere between
- 22:2340 and 50. And he attributes this to an
- 22:26apostolic tradition. So, based on this
- 22:28criterion, Roman Catholics and Orthodox
- 22:31should believe that Jesus was crucified
- 22:33at an older age. However, we know from
- 22:36biblical evidence that this is
- 22:37impossible. When you take, for example,
- 22:39the chronology of the Gospel of Luke,
- 22:41there is no way Jesus could have been
- 22:43crucified, for instance, at an age
- 22:45close to 50. So we have an ancient
- 22:48author from the 2nd century claiming an
- 22:49apostolic tradition, and he was wrong,
- 22:51and the Orthodox and Catholics accept
- 22:53that he was wrong. Why then does the
- 22:56martyrdom of Polycarp, which does not
- 22:58claim that the practice is an apostolic
- 23:00tradition, which does not say that
- 23:02Polycarp normalized that practice,
- 23:04which does not say that Polycarp
- 23:05received that practice from John,
- 23:07suddenly become incontestable evidence
- 23:09that the practice was apostolic? See
- 23:12that even if I were to concede that the
- 23:14martyrdom of Polycarp is the veneration
- 23:16of relics, which I am not conceding due
- 23:19to the elements I have already argued,
- 23:21there is still no demonstration of
- 23:23apostolicity here. And then the
- 23:25professor asked some questions, right?
- 23:26How could we then demonstrate the
- 23:28apostolicity of the veneration of
- 23:30relics? Well, first from the evidence,
- 23:32the texts that were produced by the
- 23:34apostles or by people directly
- 23:36connected to the apostles. Even if we
- 23:39admit, for example, that Polycarp was a
- 23:41disciple of John, we have absolutely no
- 23:43text from Polycarp speaking about the
- 23:45veneration of relics. Or else a
- 23:47historiographical evidence that would
- 23:50be quite robust and would even be
- 23:52accepted by modern historians as a
- 23:54strong motive of credibility for an
- 23:57apostolic practice would be independent
- 23:59sources attesting to these practices.
- 24:02And here we have another methodological
- 24:04problem. The source that Catholics and
- 24:06Orthodox cite is an isolated source. We
- 24:10have, as I have already said, dozens of
- 24:12accounts of martyrdoms, and not all
- 24:13these accounts—in fact, in most of
- 24:15these martyrdom accounts, I will even
- 24:17leave a table here on our screen—
- 24:18attest to what is, for example,
- 24:20described in the martyrdom of Polycarp.
- 24:24So, if indeed Professor André or
- 24:25another Roman Catholic could present
- 24:27ancient sources, sources, for example,
- 24:29from the 1st century, from the
- 24:31beginning of the 2nd century, from
- 24:33independent traditions converging to
- 24:34the same practice, we could indeed say
- 24:36that there is a robust
- 24:37historiographical argument there. It is
- 24:41what we see, for example, in some
- 24:42authors who defend infant baptism,
- 24:44although I, personally, believe that
- 24:45the historiography of infant baptism
- 24:47has already been refuted a long time
- 24:48ago. But what do some authors claim?
- 24:52They will claim that you have
- 24:53convergent evidence, that is, you have
- 24:55independent traditions that go back to
- 24:57the 1st century of the church, to the
- 24:58first centuries of the church. We are
- 25:02basically talking about the 1st and 2nd
- 25:03centuries, archaeological and textual
- 25:05evidence that would already attest to
- 25:06the baptism of children, which I also
- 25:08contest. But assuming that such
- 25:10evidence really existed, then we would
- 25:13have a strong motive of credibility to
- 25:15affirm that there we have an apostolic
- 25:17practice. But my friends, in the case
- 25:20of the veneration of relics, this is
- 25:22not even close to being the reality.
- 25:26Still regarding the martyrdom of
- 25:28Polycarp, Professor André brings up
- 25:30chapter 13 of the work, in which it is
- 25:33claimed that the faithful of Polycarp's
- 25:35church insisted on touching Polycarp's
- 25:37body because a certain sacredness was
- 25:39already attributed to it. The problem
- 25:42is that when we analyze chapter 13, we
- 25:44once again do not have the
- 25:46thaumaturgical element. At no point is
- 25:48the attribution of any miraculous power
- 25:50described there in this type of
- 25:52touching of Polycarp's body, right? You
- 25:55could even argue that this is an
- 25:57antecedent to the cult, but you still
- 25:59cannot claim it is the cult itself.
- 26:03Another issue the professor also raises
- 26:05is that there would be a contradiction
- 26:07between Iswinievski and Candida Moss.
- 26:09Remembering that Candida is that author
- 26:11who places the martyrdom of Polycarp in
- 26:13the 1st century. She is also followed
- 26:16by other authors, such as, for example,
- 26:18Éric Rebillard, right? You also have
- 26:20another position from Hans von
- 26:22Campenhausen, who claims that some
- 26:24portions, chapters 17 and 18, would be
- 26:26more from the end of the 1st century.
- 26:30So you have a layered textual tradition
- 26:32, and, in short, the fact is that there
- 26:34is some academic controversy over the
- 26:36date of the martyrdom, right? Whether
- 26:39in the second half of the 1st century
- 26:40or the first half of the 2nd century.
- 26:42Although this divergence itself is not
- 26:45the center of our argument. As we have
- 26:48already said, the main challenge is
- 26:49precisely the question of apostolicity
- 26:51and especially when this cult begins.
- 26:55Ah, but the professor then brings up
- 26:58the fact that Candida Moss comments
- 27:00that the martyr becomes a kind of place
- 27:03of power. And he starts to argue that
- 27:06this would contradict Iswinievski,
- 27:08since our author understands that this
- 27:10attribution of thaumaturgical power is
- 27:13something later, something that will
- 27:15only arise in the second half of the
- 27:17century; the problem is that when
- 27:19Candida Moss says that the martyr is a
- 27:21place of power, she is not talking
- 27:23about miraculous power. She is not
- 27:26talking about the power to perform
- 27:28miracles through his mortal remains,
- 27:30but she is talking in a sociological or
- 27:33liturgical sense. Since that place
- 27:37where the martyr is buried becomes, for
- 27:39example, an object of an annual
- 27:41celebration of the Eucharist and also
- 27:44an object of a martyrdom anniversary.
- 27:48So this obviously ends up having
- 27:50liturgical consequences and
- 27:52sociological consequences for that
- 27:54community. That is what she calls a
- 27:57place of power and not some kind of
- 27:58miraculous power attributed to the
- 28:00martyr. So there is no really necessary
- 28:03logical contradiction between
- 28:05Iswinievski and Candida Moss. Even
- 28:08Candida Moss herself makes this
- 28:10distinction, right? In the work
- 28:13Professor André cites, she says the
- 28:15following: that one should not confuse
- 28:17interest in bodies with an interest in
- 28:19relics. In other words, at no point is
- 28:22Candida Moss, for example,
- 28:23contradicting Tsvirko, by claiming that
- 28:25we already have the cult of relics in
- 28:27the martyrdom of Polycarp. She is,
- 28:29however, affirming that we do have
- 28:31there what would be the cult of the
- 28:33saints, but not necessarily the cult of
- 28:35relics. Well, that is where the
- 28:38professor makes that analogy which is
- 28:40omnipresent in these debates, right,
- 28:41which is the analogy with the Trinity.
- 28:45Just as in the case of the Trinity, the
- 28:47technical definitions, the conceptual
- 28:49refinement of the definition of the
- 28:51Trinity, emerged in the 4th century,
- 28:52right? And yet we do not claim that the
- 28:55Trinity emerged as such in that century
- 28:57; we understand, we as Protestants
- 28:59understand, that the Trinity is
- 29:01biblical and that the patristic authors
- 29:03of the century were working
- 29:05conceptually within biblical data. That
- 29:07is even what they believed, right? If
- 29:08you take, for example, the works of
- 29:10Athanasius, this is stated with great
- 29:13clarity in the sense that the Trinity
- 29:15is a biblical doctrine. Yet we do not
- 29:17claim that the Trinity only emerged in
- 29:19the 4th century. The problem, my
- 29:21friends, is that this analogy is
- 29:22extremely poor for the case of relics.
- 29:25Why? For the Trinity, what we have is
- 29:27the development of concepts and
- 29:29language to explain something that was
- 29:32already materially contained in the
- 29:34apostolic writings. In the case of
- 29:37relics, you don't really have an idea,
- 29:38but a practice. Furthermore, there is a
- 29:41very large difference between the two
- 29:42things. In fact, the Trinity is clearly
- 29:44exposed in the scriptures, but the
- 29:46explanation of the mystery does require
- 29:48a technical, philosophical, and
- 29:50theological refinement that the cult of
- 29:52relics does not require. In truth, the
- 29:55practice, for example, of venerating
- 29:57mortal remains or attributing to them
- 29:59any type of miraculous power would
- 30:01already be something available to the
- 30:03oldest authors. So, on one side you
- 30:06have a philosophical and theological
- 30:08refinement, on the other you have a
- 30:09practice. The analogy simply is not
- 30:13applicable. Furthermore, the divergence
- 30:16, the difference in documentary
- 30:18evidence for the two is brutal. You
- 30:21already have, for example, in the 2nd
- 30:23century, church fathers developing the
- 30:25doctrine of the Trinity quite clearly.
- 30:29In the case of Origen, for example, you
- 30:30already have a quite explicit defense
- 30:32of the doctrine of the Trinity,
- 30:33although he did not have the same
- 30:34terminological refinement that would
- 30:36emerge in the 4th century. Now, in the
- 30:38case of the cult of relics, you have
- 30:40nothing of the sort. You literally have
- 30:42a practice that emerges, right, that
- 30:44explodes in the century and for which
- 30:46you find no evidence of the same
- 30:48elements of this practice at earlier
- 30:50dates. That is when another argument
- 30:53from Professor André arises that I
- 30:54consider particularly very poor, right?
- 30:57He makes another analogy in which he
- 30:59says the following: that no apostle
- 31:01said we should read the books of the
- 31:03New Testament, right, the 27 books of
- 31:05the New Testament. He himself explains
- 31:08why no apostle said that. Since when
- 31:10the apostles were writing, they did not
- 31:12yet have the collection of the 27 books
- 31:15finalized, right? There is no way, for
- 31:18example, for the apostle Paul to tell
- 31:19you to read the Apocalypse of John,
- 31:21since Paul actually died before the
- 31:22writing of the Apocalypse of John.
- 31:25However, my friends, the principle that
- 31:27guides the practice is already clearly
- 31:29contained in the scriptures. Professor
- 31:31André himself acknowledges that Jesus
- 31:34and the apostles, for example,
- 31:35recommended reading and verifying the
- 31:37Hebrew scriptures, right? We have Jesus
- 31:39himself stating there in his disputes
- 31:41with the Pharisees: "You are wrong
- 31:43because you do not know the scriptures.
- 31:45" We also have, for example, the case
- 31:48of the Bereans, right, who are praised
- 31:50by the apostles there in Acts, because
- 31:52they verified in the Hebrew scriptures
- 31:54if the apostolic preaching aligned with
- 31:56what was there in the biblical text. So
- 31:59, in this way, you already have a
- 32:01principle that is clearly applicable to
- 32:03the books of the apostles. We already
- 32:05have, for example, Paul speaking of his
- 32:07authority, right, saying that what he
- 32:09taught was a commandment of God. We
- 32:11already have Peter, even referring in
- 32:14Second Peter, referring to Paul's
- 32:17writings as scripture, right? We even
- 32:20have Paul ordering that his letters be
- 32:22read in the churches. So, the practice
- 32:26of reading apostolic writings finds
- 32:28absolutely no equivalence with the cult
- 32:31of relics. We already have the apostles
- 32:34of the century themselves encouraging
- 32:36the reading of their own letters. And
- 32:39their own letters already serving as a
- 32:41normative standard for those churches.
- 32:44And the apostolic authority, obviously,
- 32:46not only through the epistles, but
- 32:48through their oral preaching, also
- 32:49being authoritative for those
- 32:51communities. Already in the second
- 32:54century, we clearly have the apostolic
- 32:56fathers, the apologetic fathers, for
- 32:58example, referring to and citing these
- 33:00apostolic texts as authoritative. With
- 33:03Irenaeus of Lyons, we already have what
- 33:05would be a proto-canon, right? We
- 33:06clearly have that Irenaeus considered
- 33:08the four gospels and the Pauline
- 33:10epistles to be canonical. And he claims
- 33:13that these sets of documents, of texts,
- 33:15he he he brings a description, right,
- 33:17an extremely high status, stating that
- 33:19they formed with the scriptures of the
- 33:21old covenant the pillar and foundation
- 33:23of our faith. So, we have here a
- 33:26context that is very different from the
- 33:28cult of relics. If this cult met the
- 33:31same criteria of apostolicity that we
- 33:33have for the writings of the New
- 33:35Testament, Professor André would
- 33:38indeed have a robust argument, but we
- 33:40definitely do not have that, right? And
- 33:44here I wanted to highlight something
- 33:46very important, because when you read,
- 33:48for example, the texts of Nicaea II or
- 33:51other texts, right, from catechisms of
- 33:53Eastern Orthodoxy or Roman Catholicism,
- 33:55they don't simply say that this is an
- 33:57apostolic practice that we can choose
- 33:59to perform or not. In the case of
- 34:03Nicaea II, the language for those
- 34:05people who refused to offer this
- 34:07worship is extremely harsh. These
- 34:10people were excommunicated from the
- 34:11church. So, see that we are not talking
- 34:14about a peripheral detail. If there is,
- 34:17in fact, an apostolic tradition that
- 34:20you tell us is normative, that we are
- 34:22even under the threat eternally, right,
- 34:29of losing our salvation for not
- 34:30observing this practice, then, my
- 34:32friends, you do have the burden of
- 34:34proof to clearly demonstrate this
- 34:36doctrine as apostolic; otherwise, we
- 34:38will simply echo that very clear
- 34:40Pauline principle. Even if an angel
- 34:44from heaven, even if an apostle
- 34:45presents another gospel than the one
- 34:47preached by the apostle Paul, let him
- 34:48be anathema. If you cannot bring robust
- 34:52evidence of the normativity of this
- 34:54practice, we are indeed justified in
- 34:56rejecting it, especially when you say
- 34:59that this practice is a condition for
- 35:01our salvation. Now I ask you, if
- 35:04something that is a condition for our
- 35:06salvation was not recorded in any
- 35:08apostolic writing, how can we give any
- 35:11credibility to it? If not even the
- 35:13oldest sources that we have already
- 35:15discussed here state that this practice
- 35:17is normative? In other words, if you
- 35:20take, for example, the martyrdom of
- 35:22Polycarp, no one there is saying that
- 35:23if you do not practice that special
- 35:25form of guarding the remains of
- 35:26Polycarp, you are subject to eternal
- 35:28damnation. So I ask you, if not even
- 35:31these ancient sources say this, how are
- 35:33we going to give credibility to the
- 35:35authority of your churches to demand
- 35:36such a thing from us? And that is when,
- 35:41at the end of the video, Professor
- 35:43André then attributes to me a kind of
- 35:45selectivity in the academics I use to
- 35:47endorse my practices. Well, but here it
- 35:50is important for us to remember an
- 35:52extremely relevant issue. First of all,
- 35:55you don't measure the academic strength
- 35:57of research by counting academics,
- 35:58right? You simply don't say: "There are
- 36:02seven supporting one position, ten
- 36:03supporting another, so the one with
- 36:05more supporters is simply the winning
- 36:07position." You need to analyze the
- 36:09merit and substance of the argument
- 36:11that each academic brings. In fact, a
- 36:14good portion of the academics cited by
- 36:15Catholics, for example, and by the
- 36:17professor, don't even have specialized
- 36:19literature on this subject. Isvinsky,
- 36:21for example, is considered, among
- 36:23modern academics, the most specialized
- 36:25literature on the origin of the cult of
- 36:27relics. The professor cited, for
- 36:29example, other academics who talk about
- 36:31the cult of the saints. But when it
- 36:33comes to such a specific work dealing
- 36:35with the origin of this cult, you can
- 36:37see in academic journals and reviews
- 36:39that Isvinsky's work is the most cited.
- 36:42So, first, I didn't bring in an
- 36:43academic who lacks respectability; on
- 36:45the contrary, he has a great deal of
- 36:47respectability. His is extremely
- 36:49specific literature on the topic and,
- 36:52unlike what the professor said, his
- 36:54theses do, in fact, have quite robust
- 36:56academic reception. I don't think the
- 36:59fact that the professor brought up
- 37:01these historians proved that his
- 37:03position is the minority one. He would
- 37:05need to bring, for example, some
- 37:07analysis, some more comprehensive
- 37:09academic review, bringing the range of
- 37:11authors who spoke on this subject to
- 37:13actually prove that. A second point I
- 37:17wanted to draw attention to is
- 37:19precisely the methodology we find in
- 37:21both Eastern Orthodox and Roman
- 37:23Catholics. They are generally very
- 37:26arbitrary, for example, in the strength
- 37:28, in the benchmark established to prove
- 37:30their doctrines. For example, the
- 37:34professor seems to somehow believe that
- 37:36my position is more fragile because it
- 37:38is not an academic consensus. But, my
- 37:41friends, if there is one thing Eastern
- 37:44Orthodox do, it is hold positions that
- 37:46are absolutely contrary to academic
- 37:48consensus. When you take, for example,
- 37:52the issue of the cult of images that
- 37:54was defined and defended at the Second
- 37:56Council of Nicaea in 787, what the
- 37:58bishops stated there is that the
- 38:00veneration of images is a practice that
- 38:02dates back to the apostles themselves.
- 38:06And this in academia today, this is not
- 38:08considered a minority thesis, it is
- 38:11considered a denialist thesis. We do
- 38:14not have, for example, any author of
- 38:16the stature of Isvinsky defending such
- 38:17a thing. Even respected Eastern
- 38:21Orthodox scholars like Andrew Louth,
- 38:24Kallistos Ware, or John McGuckin—
- 38:27specifically in the case of Louth and
- 38:29McGuckin, who publish with reputable
- 38:32academic presses—clearly state there
- 38:35is no evidence for an apostolicity of
- 38:38image veneration as defined at Nicaea
- 38:40II. When you look at Richard Price, for
- 38:45example, one of the greatest
- 38:47authorities today, if not the greatest,
- 38:49on the Council of Nicaea, he clearly
- 38:51states that what was defined at that
- 38:53council cannot even be traced back to
- 38:56the Church Fathers of the 4th and 5th
- 38:58centuries. If it can't be traced to the
- 39:014th and 5 th-century Fathers, let alone
- 39:04the apostles. The thesis of an
- 39:07apostolicity of image veneration is now
- 39:10defended only by confessional readings,
- 39:12usually Eastern Orthodox. When they do
- 39:17cite a study to that effect, it is
- 39:19usually by an author who does not
- 39:21publish with academic presses and has
- 39:23absolutely no academic or
- 39:25historiographical reception for their
- 39:27positions. But even so, that is not a
- 39:31problem for Roman Catholics and Eastern
- 39:33Orthodox like Professor André to
- 39:35passionately defend the veneration of
- 39:37images. What does this demonstrate? It
- 39:40demonstrates that the professor, in
- 39:41truth, does not give much credit to the
- 39:43issue of academic consensus. Academic
- 39:45consensus. Why? Both traditions operate
- 39:48on the principle of sola ecclesia. And
- 39:52sola ecclesia has a very clear effect.
- 39:57Doctrines are not adhered to or
- 39:59affirmed by the strength of their
- 40:00demonstration. It is not the strength
- 40:04of the exegetical or historical
- 40:06demonstration of these doctrines that
- 40:08causes apologists to defend them. It is
- 40:12simply because their respective
- 40:14churches have said so—it is the
- 40:15Eastern version of sola ecclesia and
- 40:17the Roman version, which in the final
- 40:20analysis is a sola papa. So
- 40:22historiographical evidence doesn't
- 40:24matter, and biblical evidence doesn't
- 40:26matter. What truly determines adherence
- 40:29to these doctrines is simply that the
- 40:31respective churches and traditions have
- 40:34said so. This, in my view, leads us to
- 40:37a quite undesirable situation. You
- 40:40literally often have to adhere to
- 40:42complete historical "flat-earthism," as
- 40:44is the case, for example, with the
- 40:46veneration of images. Defending today
- 40:49that image veneration is an apostolic
- 40:51tradition or an apostolic practice is
- 40:53absolute historical "flat-earthism" and
- 40:55also an ecclesiastical fideism.
- 40:58Ecclesiastical fideism is simply
- 41:00adhering to the authority of some
- 41:01institution or tradition, however
- 41:03fragile the demonstrations of authority
- 41:06and credibility of those traditions may
- 41:08be. That is basically what Roman
- 41:10Catholics and Eastern Orthodox do at
- 41:12the end of the day, isn't it? And here
- 41:15I am not saying this as a way to
- 41:17diminish the figure of Professor André
- 41:20, right? It is not a question of
- 41:22intellectual ineptitude, that is
- 41:23definitely not the case, especially
- 41:25since he seems to be a very intelligent
- 41:27person. But it is that the theological
- 41:30principle, the theological system that
- 41:32Professor André adheres to, demands
- 41:34this of him; that is, it ends up
- 41:36requiring that, for you to truly and
- 41:38coherently adhere to these traditions,
- 41:40you need to commit this, uh,
- 41:41intellectual suicide. It is an
- 41:44intellectual suicide based on "
- 41:45flat-earth" theories, on the acceptance
- 41:47of historical "flat-earth" theories, as
- 41:49is the case, for example, of affirming
- 41:51the apostolicity of the cult of relics,
- 41:53something that no academic Professor
- 41:54André brought up and no serious
- 41:56academic defends, and also
- 41:57ecclesiastical fideism. Remembering
- 41:59that faith is not fideism. Faith is not
- 42:01believing against reason or against
- 42:03evidence, right? But what,
- 42:06unfortunately, these traditions demand
- 42:07from their followers is precisely that:
- 42:09it is to believe against reason, it is
- 42:10to believe against evidence. And the
- 42:14only way for you to belong, for you to
- 42:16be in these communities consistently
- 42:17and coherently, is precisely to
- 42:19practice an intellectual suicide based
- 42:21on these two elements. So, my friends,
- 42:24that is it. I hope you share this
- 42:26response, comment here, because that
- 42:28helps with our engagement. Don't forget
- 42:31to subscribe to this channel, right?
- 42:33For those who are not yet subscribed,
- 42:35don't forget to leave a like on the
- 42:37video so the video gets engagement and
- 42:39as many people as possible have access
- 42:41to this material. See you next time.
- 42:43Stay in the peace of Christ.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of REFUTAÇÃO A ANDRE LUIZ SOBRE O CULTO ÀS RELÍQUIAS by Bruno Lima - Respostas Cristãs, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,092 words across 1,134 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.