YouTube2Text

Reading on Paper Rewires Your Brain — Transcript

by The Upgrade with Makai Elías Calles · 2,341 words · 415 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Your brain treats a physical book and a
  2. 0:02screen like they're two completely
  3. 0:04different objects. Not just a little
  4. 0:06different, but neurologically
  5. 0:08fundamentally different. Even though
  6. 0:09they may have the exact same words,
  7. 0:11information, and technically the same
  8. 0:13meaning, your brain works in a
  9. 0:15completely different way. And the scary
  10. 0:17part is that you can't feel it
  11. 0:19happening. [music]
  12. 0:20When using digital, you may think you
  13. 0:22can read more, faster,
  14. 0:24>> [music]
  15. 0:24>> and understand just as much, but you
  16. 0:26can't. So, let me show you what happens
  17. 0:28[music] when you replace paper with
  18. 0:30pixels.
  19. 0:34>> [music]
  20. 0:41>> Think about the home you grew up in.
  21. 0:43Were there [music] bookshelves, books
  22. 0:45lying around? Maybe a lot, maybe just a
  23. 0:47few. Now, here's a question you wouldn't
  24. 0:49expect to have a clear answer.
  25. 0:52Does it actually matter for how well
  26. 0:53kids do in school? Because researchers
  27. 0:56wanted to know the same thing. So, they
  28. 0:58started looking at academic performance
  29. 1:00across thousands [music] of children
  30. 1:01from different countries, different
  31. 1:03income levels, and different educational
  32. 1:05backgrounds. Basically, searching for
  33. 1:07patterns. And what they found was
  34. 1:09honestly pretty shocking.
  35. 1:11>> [music]
  36. 1:11>> Kids with just one book, literally one
  37. 1:14physical book in their home, were nearly
  38. 1:16twice as likely to meet basic literacy
  39. 1:19and math standards compared to kids with
  40. 1:21zero books. This was true whether the
  41. 1:24family was rich or poor, whether the
  42. 1:26parents went to college or not,
  43. 1:28regardless of what country they lived
  44. 1:30in. That is one book doubling the odds
  45. 1:33of academic success. And when they
  46. 1:35looked at kids with more than one book,
  47. 1:37who grew up surrounded by books, those
  48. 1:40children [music] completed an average of
  49. 1:41three additional years of education
  50. 1:44compared to kids who didn't. We're
  51. 1:46talking about the difference [music]
  52. 1:47between a university degree and a high
  53. 1:49school diploma. So, naturally,
  54. 1:51researchers thought, "Okay, but we live
  55. 1:53in the digital age now.
  56. 1:55What about e-books? Surely, a home full
  57. 1:58of e-books would show the same benefit,
  58. 2:00right?
  59. 2:01So, they checked and the correlation
  60. 2:03[music] vanished.
  61. 2:04Homes with e-books showed no positive
  62. 2:07relationship to academic [music]
  63. 2:08achievement or socioeconomic status. So,
  64. 2:11even if the kids had the same [music]
  65. 2:13access to the reading material,
  66. 2:14something about the physical books
  67. 2:16themselves was creating this massive
  68. 2:18difference. This forces [music] us to
  69. 2:21ask a more critical question. What if
  70. 2:23reading isn't just reading?
  71. 2:25Does how we read matter as much as what
  72. 2:28[music] we read? Because for the longest
  73. 2:29time, the assumption was that reading is
  74. 2:31reading. Words are words. The container
  75. 2:34doesn't matter. A story on Kindle is the
  76. 2:37same story [music] in paperback. Maybe
  77. 2:39just more convenient, right? But, that
  78. 2:41assumption is entirely wrong. The data
  79. 2:44presents a very different picture.
  80. 2:47>> [music]
  81. 2:51>> That finding about physical books versus
  82. 2:52[music] e-books, that was just the
  83. 2:54beginning.
  84. 2:55Once researchers began looking for this
  85. 2:57pattern, [music] they found it
  86. 2:59everywhere. Study after study shows that
  87. 3:01across different age groups and types of
  88. 3:03reading, people who read on screens
  89. 3:06understand [music]
  90. 3:07and remember less than those who read
  91. 3:09the same material on paper. At first, it
  92. 3:12seemed like maybe it was just a fluke.
  93. 3:14Maybe one study had the weird methods or
  94. 3:16the participants weren't representative.
  95. 3:19>> [music]
  96. 3:19>> But, then it kept showing up again and
  97. 3:21again. So, in 2024, researchers pulled
  98. 3:24together 49 [music] separate studies and
  99. 3:27conducted one of the largest and most
  100. 3:29comprehensive meta-analyses.
  101. 3:31We're talking [music] about thousands
  102. 3:32and thousands of readers from elementary
  103. 3:34school kids all the way to college
  104. 3:36students. [music]
  105. 3:37This was a robust investigation to
  106. 3:40answer the question, who wins in a game
  107. 3:42of rock, paper, and pixels? And the
  108. 3:45results, across the board, print readers
  109. 3:48outperformed their digital counterparts.
  110. 3:50But, here's the thing, just knowing that
  111. 3:52this happens doesn't tell us why it
  112. 3:55happens. So, scientists, [music] being
  113. 3:57scientists,
  114. 3:59wanted to get specific and find out why.
  115. 4:02And this is where the research gets
  116. 4:03[music] really interesting.
  117. 4:10Researchers took 50 university students
  118. 4:12and equipped them with eye-tracking
  119. 4:14devices. Basically, [music] cameras that
  120. 4:16follow exactly where your eyes are
  121. 4:18looking and how they're moving. Then,
  122. 4:21they had half the students read a
  123. 4:23science article on paper and the other
  124. 4:25half read the exact [music] same article
  125. 4:27on tablets. Now, both students spent the
  126. 4:29same amount of time reading.
  127. 4:32This is important. [music]
  128. 4:33It's not that one group rushed or gave
  129. 4:35up early. They all put in the same
  130. 4:37amount of time. But, of course, the
  131. 4:39question here [music] was, were their
  132. 4:40eyes doing the same thing? Not even
  133. 4:43close. Think of reading from paper like
  134. 4:45exploring a landscape. You're a hiker
  135. 4:47who climbs up a mountain to get a view
  136. 4:49of the whole terrain. Then, you come
  137. 4:51back down and explore interesting
  138. 4:53trails, maybe looping back to check out
  139. 4:55something you passed. You're building a
  140. 4:57mental map. You know where you are,
  141. 4:59where you've been, and where you're
  142. 5:01going. This is exactly what print
  143. 5:03[music] readers did. They first skimmed
  144. 5:05to get the lay of the land, then circled
  145. 5:07back to reread important [music] or
  146. 5:09tricky sections. Now, digital reading is
  147. 5:12more like standing in a line at the
  148. 5:14airport. You're [music] facing forward,
  149. 5:16moving in one direction, and there's
  150. 5:18this subtle pressure to just keep going.
  151. 5:21You don't really loop back because,
  152. 5:22well,
  153. 5:23>> [music]
  154. 5:23>> you would have to go against the flow.
  155. 5:25So, in the study, digital readers moved
  156. 5:27through the text linearly in one
  157. 5:30direction, rarely returning, even when
  158. 5:33the material got more [music] difficult.
  159. 5:35And the eye-tracking data just makes
  160. 5:37sense. A physical book has what you
  161. 5:39might call dimensionality, [music]
  162. 5:41which allows you to engage in so-called
  163. 5:43embodied reading. You can see how thick
  164. 5:45the section you've read is [music]
  165. 5:46versus what's left, you can feel the
  166. 5:48pages shift in your hands, your brain
  167. 5:51[music] gets spatial anchors. You might
  168. 5:53remember, "Oh yeah, that concept was
  169. 5:54about a third of the way through,
  170. 5:56left-hand [music] page near the top,
  171. 5:58next to the coffee stain."
  172. 6:00On the screen,
  173. 6:01>> [music]
  174. 6:01>> everything exists in this infinite
  175. 6:03undifferentiated scroll.
  176. 6:05You can't see where you are, you can't
  177. 6:08feel your progress. Every moment looks
  178. 6:10basically the same as every other
  179. 6:12moment.
  180. 6:12>> [music]
  181. 6:13>> There's no embodied anchoring. And your
  182. 6:15eyes respond to that. Without the
  183. 6:17spatial landmarks, you're less likely to
  184. 6:19go back and review because you don't
  185. 6:21really have a clear sense [music] of
  186. 6:22where back even is. And the thing is,
  187. 6:25there are real consequences to this.
  188. 6:27[music]
  189. 6:27In the same study, after reading the
  190. 6:29article,
  191. 6:30both groups were tested on
  192. 6:32comprehension. Again, they spent
  193. 6:34>> [music]
  194. 6:34>> equal time on the same material, but one
  195. 6:37group read the traditional way, [music]
  196. 6:39on paper, and the other group had a
  197. 6:41screen. And the outcome was clear. Print
  198. 6:44readers scored 24% higher on
  199. 6:47comprehension. That's not a small
  200. 6:49difference. 24% [music]
  201. 6:50can make the difference between an A-
  202. 6:52minus and a C+ on an exam. But again,
  203. 6:56this still doesn't fully explain why
  204. 6:58different reading mediums or different
  205. 7:01eye movements would lead to such
  206. 7:03different outcomes. So, let's be
  207. 7:05scientists and ask,
  208. 7:07"Why is this happening?" And more
  209. 7:09specifically,
  210. 7:10"What's happening [music] inside our
  211. 7:11brains?"
  212. 7:17The good news is we don't have to guess
  213. 7:19or hypothesize. We have the data to
  214. 7:22understand what's going [music] on. When
  215. 7:24researchers use EEG machines, basically
  216. 7:27electrode caps that [music] measure your
  217. 7:29brain's electrical activity, they can
  218. 7:31see that your brain operates differently
  219. 7:33depending on what you're reading from.
  220. 7:36When you read on paper, [music] your
  221. 7:37brain lights up with what are called
  222. 7:39beta and gamma frequency waves. These
  223. 7:42are the patterns you see when someone is
  224. 7:44deeply focused, [music]
  225. 7:45actively problem-solving, and just
  226. 7:47really locked in. Now, when you read
  227. 7:50from a screen, your brain shifts [music]
  228. 7:52to theta and alpha waves,
  229. 7:55and these are very different. These are
  230. 7:56the patterns associated with a lighter
  231. 7:59mental state, more mind-wandering, and
  232. 8:01less focus.
  233. 8:03It's almost like your brain is idling.
  234. 8:04[music]
  235. 8:05Other imaging studies show similar
  236. 8:07findings. When people learn from paper,
  237. 8:10their prefrontal cortex, which is
  238. 8:11responsible for decision-making and
  239. 8:13executive function, shows reduced
  240. 8:16activity during information processing.
  241. 8:18This suggests that paper-based reading
  242. 8:20allows the brain to process and absorb
  243. 8:23information more efficiently. And as a
  244. 8:25consequence, here's something that might
  245. 8:27surprise you. Print readers actually
  246. 8:29read [music] faster than digital
  247. 8:31readers, by about 10 to 30% depending on
  248. 8:34the [music] study. And you might think,
  249. 8:35well, maybe they're just skimming
  250. 8:37through, but the comprehension data
  251. 8:39shows the opposite. [music] They're not
  252. 8:40rushing or taking shortcuts. They're
  253. 8:43processing more efficiently. So, your
  254. 8:45brain is not only comfortable, but also
  255. 8:47optimized for paper [music] in a way
  256. 8:50it's not yet optimized for pixels.
  257. 8:52So, why is your brain doing this? Why
  258. 8:55would the exact same words [music]
  259. 8:56create different neural patterns? Well,
  260. 8:59researchers point to three
  261. 9:01interconnected explanations. First,
  262. 9:04there's a concept of cognitive load.
  263. 9:06Your brain's [music] working memory is
  264. 9:07like the RAM on your computer. You've
  265. 9:09only got so much. When you're reading on
  266. 9:11the screen,
  267. 9:12>> [music]
  268. 9:12>> you're not just processing words, you're
  269. 9:14also managing where you are since you
  270. 9:16can't really see [music] or feel,
  271. 9:18resisting the urge to check
  272. 9:19notifications, and deciding when to
  273. 9:22scroll. All of this overloads your
  274. 9:24cognitive load.
  275. 9:25So, your mental resources are divided,
  276. 9:28leaving less capacity for actually
  277. 9:30understanding what you're reading. And
  278. 9:32second, we return to embodied reading.
  279. 9:35This is what I talked about earlier. A
  280. 9:37physical book has weight, texture, the
  281. 9:40sound of pages, and a lovely smell. This
  282. 9:43multi-sensory experience gives your
  283. 9:45brain more opportunities [music] to hang
  284. 9:47memories on. And actually, Hollywood
  285. 9:49actors would say that when they're
  286. 9:50learning their lines, they
  287. 9:52overwhelmingly prefer physical scripts
  288. 9:54over tablets. They talk about how the
  289. 9:56physical experience helps [music] them
  290. 9:58absorb the text, not just mentally, but
  291. 10:01almost bodily. The tactile experience
  292. 10:03[music] becomes part of how the memory
  293. 10:06gets encoded. Third, there's a
  294. 10:08shallowing effect. The [music] entire
  295. 10:10digital environment with hyperlinks,
  296. 10:12notifications, and infinite feeds has
  297. 10:15trained us to scan and hunt for
  298. 10:17keywords, rather than read deeply. We've
  299. 10:21been conditioned to skim,
  300. 10:23and that habit persists when we're
  301. 10:24trying to read something seriously on
  302. 10:26the screen. The medium itself [music]
  303. 10:28encourages superficial processing, which
  304. 10:31leads to weaker memory formation. So,
  305. 10:34you've got the triple whammy that lowers
  306. 10:36your engagement [music] and
  307. 10:37comprehension.
  308. 10:43All of these effects are concerning for
  309. 10:45adults, but for children, the
  310. 10:47implications are much more serious.
  311. 10:50Researchers at Johns Hopkins used MRI
  312. 10:52scans to study kids ages [music] 8 to
  313. 10:5512, looking at the connectivity in the
  314. 10:57brain regions involving language [music]
  315. 10:59processing and cognitive control. They
  316. 11:02found that children who spent more time
  317. 11:04reading on books had stronger
  318. 11:06connections [music] between these
  319. 11:07crucial brain regions. Conversely,
  320. 11:09children who spent more time on screens
  321. 11:12showed fewer connections in those exact
  322. 11:14same areas. These are not merely
  323. 11:16temporary effects. They represent
  324. 11:18[music] fundamental differences in the
  325. 11:20way a child's brain develops, and
  326. 11:23[music] it starts remarkably early. In
  327. 11:25one study, scientists compared two
  328. 11:27groups of 5-year-old preschoolers during
  329. 11:30storytime. One group experienced
  330. 11:32traditional interactive storytime. They
  331. 11:35sat with an adult who read from physical
  332. 11:37books, responded to the children,
  333. 11:39>> [music]
  334. 11:39>> and encouraged participation. Now, the
  335. 11:41other group simply watched a video of
  336. 11:44the same stories [music] being read by
  337. 11:46the adult on a screen with no live
  338. 11:48interaction, social cues, or engagement.
  339. 11:51After just 6 weeks, the screen group
  340. 11:54performed significantly worse on
  341. 11:56attention [music] tests and showed brain
  342. 11:58patterns similar to those of children
  343. 12:00with ADHD. Think about that. These
  344. 12:03children had the same stories told to
  345. 12:05them by the same adult [music]
  346. 12:07for the same amount of time. The only
  347. 12:10difference was the medium, and it was
  348. 12:12enough to create attention deficits in
  349. 12:14developing brains.
  350. 12:16>> [music]
  351. 12:21>> Now, here's maybe the most troubling
  352. 12:22finding of all, especially for adults
  353. 12:25who think they've got this figured out.
  354. 12:27When researchers test comprehension and
  355. 12:29then ask people how well they think they
  356. 12:31understood [music]
  357. 12:31what they read, digital readers
  358. 12:33consistently report feeling more
  359. 12:35confident than print readers, but their
  360. 12:37actual test scores tell a different
  361. 12:39story. They understood less, but felt
  362. 12:42like they understood more.
  363. 12:45This is what is termed a metacognitive
  364. 12:47failure. Your brain's ability to
  365. 12:49accurately judge its own performance is
  366. 12:52broken. Digital reading creates an
  367. 12:54illusion of comprehension, and the
  368. 12:55research shows this gap gets bigger the
  369. 12:58more complex the material. With simple,
  370. 13:01straightforward content, the difference
  371. 13:03between print and digital is small, but
  372. 13:06with dense, challenging texts [music]
  373. 13:08that require real understanding,
  374. 13:10print has a massive advantage.
  375. 13:13>> [music]
  376. 13:18>> Now, here's [music] the thing. None of
  377. 13:19this means that screens are evil or that
  378. 13:21we should throw away the devices.
  379. 13:23For quick information gathering, for
  380. 13:25>> [music]
  381. 13:25>> reference material, for skimming news. I
  382. 13:28think screens are genuinely helpful, but
  383. 13:30we cannot ditch the books. When you
  384. 13:33really need to learn something specific,
  385. 13:34when you need it to stick, when it's
  386. 13:36complex, when it matters, reach for
  387. 13:39paper. And if you have kids, well, this
  388. 13:42matters even [music] more. Physical
  389. 13:43books aren't just nostalgic or quaint.
  390. 13:46Keep one or a few around the house.
  391. 13:48They're priceless tools that build
  392. 13:51better brains, better attention, and
  393. 13:53deeper understanding. The key is just
  394. 13:55being deliberate [music] about which
  395. 13:57tool you use for which task. Technology
  396. 14:00is cool, but books are historical and
  397. 14:02[music] cultural gifts.
  398. 14:05Your brain loves paper. Use that to your
  399. 14:07advantage. If this changed [music] how
  400. 14:09you think about reading, subscribe.
  401. 14:12We're exploring more neuroscience that
  402. 14:13actually changes [music] how you live
  403. 14:15your daily life.
  404. 14:17We also have a video about why you
  405. 14:18should stick to handwriting, so check
  406. 14:20that out. And drop a comment. Are you
  407. 14:22team print, team digital, or somewhere
  408. 14:25[music] in between? I was a Kindle fan
  409. 14:27for a long time, and I still carry it
  410. 14:29with me,
  411. 14:30but personally, I now buy most of my
  412. 14:32books [music] physically.
  413. 14:33They are heavy, but as we've learned,
  414. 14:36they are worth it.
  415. 14:39>> [music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Reading on Paper Rewires Your Brain by The Upgrade with Makai Elías Calles, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,341 words across 415 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.