Raoul Pal: My Final Warning To Crypto Investors in 2027 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Look, there's many things that can go
- 0:01wrong in markets and many things that
- 0:03can go wrong in economies.
- 0:04>> Today, I sit down with global macro
- 0:06investor Raul Pal. You've been in
- 0:08markets for decades. I think close to 30
- 0:11years.
- 0:12>> 30 something years. Yeah.
- 0:13>> As he sounds the alarm for crypto, AI,
- 0:17and markets in 2027.
- 0:18>> I'm not sure how it ends, but I don't
- 0:22think it ends in a speculative frenzy,
- 0:24per se.
- 0:24>> We talk the future of AI. There are now
- 0:27more agents on the internet than there
- 0:28are humans.
- 0:30So we've gone to I don't know 10 billion
- 0:33agents from zero in less than [music] a
- 0:36year.
- 0:36>> Raul's outlook on crypto total uh total
- 0:40market cap of crypto. [music]
- 0:41>> Yes. Goes to 100 trillion.
- 0:43>> Same thing. It's the same thing. It's
- 0:44going to 100 trillion.
- 0:46>> Watch today's whole video.
- 0:47>> So I I doubt we have the same collapse.
- 0:50And the reason being is
- 0:52>> so you understand everything. So I think
- 0:55well what is going to last
- 0:58what is going to last is investment and
- 1:00one of the simple things is is crypto
- 1:03layer ones.
- 1:03>> Click subscribe so you never miss
- 1:05conversations like this and let's start.
- 1:07Oh man, great to have you back. I want
- 1:08to start with the big question looking
- 1:11as a crypto investor in 2027. What
- 1:14matters? What do I look at or should I
- 1:16look for?
- 1:19Well, what matters is as ever liquidity
- 1:22matters the most for us. In fact, for
- 1:24all assets. So, we're looking for
- 1:26liquidity to rise. And a simple way for
- 1:28people to understand this is financial
- 1:30conditions are quite tight because the
- 1:33um
- 1:35because of the Iran war, what happened?
- 1:37It pushed up the dollar. We need a
- 1:38weaker dollar. It pushed up rates. We
- 1:41need rates to come down a bit. Um, and
- 1:44those two things are basically going to
- 1:46guide you as to what's going to happen
- 1:47in the future. It gives you a 3 to six
- 1:50month lead on what happens to markets.
- 1:53And right now there's not enough
- 1:54liquidity to fund the AI trade and the
- 1:57crypto trade and half of the stock
- 1:58market, which is why half the stock
- 2:00market's going down and only a few are
- 2:02going up. Just not enough enough money
- 2:04around. So, we need that to change. So,
- 2:06that's thing number one. Okay. So, let's
- 2:09assume that changes in 2027 at some
- 2:12point cuz it's been sideways for a while
- 2:14since the the Iran situation, which is
- 2:16why the NASDAQ's gone sideways and
- 2:19crypto's been sloppy and everything's
- 2:21been not great. And then it's like,
- 2:23okay, what is going to matter in 2027?
- 2:26Well, I think the rise of stable coins
- 2:28matters.
- 2:30It's being pushed by the US
- 2:31administration. The banking systems
- 2:33involved. Everybody's involved. Now, we
- 2:35need to see it scale bigger. you know,
- 2:37we want to see hundreds of billions of
- 2:40dollars um as stable coins and then we
- 2:42want to see volumes explode. So, that's
- 2:45not really happened yet. The growth is
- 2:46there, but we've not seen the explosion
- 2:49yet, but everybody's building. So,
- 2:51that's a massive use case for crypto.
- 2:54[snorts] The other thing is is the rise
- 2:56of agents. So, we've all got a gazillion
- 2:59agents that are working and doing stuff,
- 3:02but how many of ours are actually
- 3:03transacting? Very few. But this is the
- 3:06new population. This is the new users of
- 3:08the internet and the new users of
- 3:10payment systems.
- 3:12That's not really happening yet. So X um
- 3:17um what's it called? 402 and the uh you
- 3:20know Salana versions everything else
- 3:22it's barely started. So agents aren't
- 3:24making payments yet. So those are two of
- 3:26the big things that I'd really like to
- 3:29see which would give us a much stronger
- 3:33firmer footing for a longerl lasting
- 3:36bull market because now we're not
- 3:38talking about just speculation now we're
- 3:40talking about the infrastructure layer
- 3:41of the internet which is where these
- 3:44layer ones were always going to go.
- 3:46>> So that's the highle macro outlook. What
- 3:49is the investor's thesis for 2027 and
- 3:52how to take advantage of that? So the
- 3:54investment thesis is the rise of the
- 3:56agents for me and the rise of stable
- 3:58coins. I that we are going to see the
- 4:03layer ones being used as the
- 4:05infrastructure layer for the internet. I
- 4:06think we'll find it for identity as well
- 4:08whether it's for agent identity, payment
- 4:11identity, all of this kind of stuff. So
- 4:13these are the big signals that I'm
- 4:15looking for. This the trade for me
- 4:17remains the layer ones because it's the
- 4:19dummies trade. It's the one that they
- 4:22have to use. Everybody has to use layer
- 4:231 to do something. You can use layer two
- 4:27to be faster, but it all settles on the
- 4:29layer one. [snorts] So the layer 1 is
- 4:31the thing. People get it wrong and say,
- 4:33"Yeah, but they don't generate cash."
- 4:36And that's [ __ ] Doesn't matter.
- 4:38It's an infrastructure network. It's how
- 4:40much use does it have and how much value
- 4:42transacts on it. So I'm always looking
- 4:44for that. So we'll see, you know,
- 4:47speculation will bring new users back,
- 4:48but I want to see these fundamental
- 4:50structural use cases for crypto really
- 4:53start to scale. So the layer ones become
- 4:55the bet. And then it's like, well, how
- 4:57far out on the risk curve do you want to
- 4:59go? Because the layer ones are pretty
- 5:00straightforward. You could own Ethereum,
- 5:02Salana, and capture most of it. You can
- 5:04add whatever one you think if you think
- 5:06about like cloud or any of these big
- 5:08kind of open systems. There's normally
- 5:11about four or five that take up 90% of
- 5:13the market share. Right now we've got
- 5:15two so of the of the kind of open
- 5:19networks the layer ones we got Ethereum
- 5:21and and um Salana so there's probably
- 5:24two slots
- 5:27that will get rerated what are they you
- 5:29know my bet on that on one of those is
- 5:32others may [snorts] choose near others
- 5:34may choose something else whatever it is
- 5:36could be avalanche I don't know that's
- 5:38the job we have to see what the market
- 5:40decides where the activity goes that
- 5:42kind of stuff uh and then you got the
- 5:44applications layer, you know, the
- 5:46specific businesses built on top of
- 5:48these layer ones. Now, Hyperlquid is an
- 5:50example of that, even though it's its
- 5:51own layer 1, but it's a very it's a
- 5:53business, right? Those need to have cash
- 5:55flow generation because it's a business,
- 5:57unlike an infrastructure. And so, you
- 6:00know, Hyperlquid's a great example of
- 6:02something that does produce that. Now,
- 6:04we're going to produce others. Uh, what
- 6:06are those going to be? You know, some
- 6:07people think it's going to be the other
- 6:08trading style platforms, uh, you know,
- 6:11the FOMO or the pump.f fun or it could
- 6:14be
- 6:15I don't know another application on top
- 6:18and again we haven't really got there
- 6:19because it's been so thin on liquidity
- 6:21that most trades haven't worked um and
- 6:24it's been difficult the other one is
- 6:26privacy so privacy is a big deal uh you
- 6:30know the market's taken the bet with
- 6:32Zcash a bit of Monero is you know where
- 6:36is privacy going to fit into the
- 6:37equation of private money and I think
- 6:39that's a big deal as well and we'll see
- 6:41a blend of these one is like the store
- 6:42of value private which is Zcash and the
- 6:45other is how do you make Ethereum,
- 6:48Salana, SU and others private um for
- 6:52certain use cases because the financial
- 6:53system doesn't want you to see
- 6:56everything they're doing you don't get
- 6:58to see everybody's bank account why
- 6:59should you see every transaction now
- 7:01sure there needs to be uh legalities
- 7:04behind it you know I authorities need to
- 7:06see it like they want to see your bank
- 7:07account your credit card details if so
- 7:09required they're going to want that
- 7:11anyway The point being is you shouldn't
- 7:13see what I've transferred out of my
- 7:15crypto wallet or what's in it.
- 7:18>> Some people get on Ethereum negatively
- 7:22that oh value is not acrewing to the the
- 7:24main coin. The network is growing but
- 7:26the value is not growing. I look at it
- 7:28I've heard it explained like the Uber
- 7:30model. They're going for world network
- 7:32domination and they can crank up those
- 7:34fees any time.
- 7:35>> The the entire job of technology is to
- 7:38lower fees. There is no fees going to go
- 7:40up. Tony makes this really clear. Uh the
- 7:43guys at SUI make this really clear and
- 7:46um and um Vitalix made this clear. Fees
- 7:49go towards zero. Oh, but how is it
- 7:52valuable then? Okay, let me turn off the
- 7:54switch of Ethereum today. How much value
- 7:57do you destroy? You destroy everything
- 8:00that uses the layer 1.
- 8:03So that's right, you know, the things
- 8:05that are based on the layer 1 is half
- 8:07the financial system are trying to use
- 8:08the layer one. The RWA market is the
- 8:11layer one. Uh the entire digital art
- 8:13market is the layer one. Oh, but it's
- 8:15also the entire layer twos because they
- 8:17all settle on Ethereum. So you've
- 8:19destroyed every single layer two as
- 8:20well. Oh, and that's also the entire
- 8:22DeFi market because it's 75% of the DeFi
- 8:26market. So what you've basically
- 8:29destroyed is
- 8:31expected future value of the next three
- 8:33years is I don't know a trillion, one
- 8:36half trillion dollars.
- 8:38That's how much Ethereum is worth. Now,
- 8:40currently, it's not trading at those
- 8:42valuations because, you know, it's
- 8:44depressed because of um liquidity and
- 8:47stuff like that, but generally speaking,
- 8:50that's how you value Ethereum. How much
- 8:52would the market pay you not to shut it
- 8:54off? How much value is accured in
- 8:55everything built on top of Ethereum?
- 8:58Uh, and so that yeah, that's how I think
- 9:00about this. So it's the easiest way to
- 9:02describe the value of a network.
- 9:04>> To back up or big picture big picture it
- 9:07a little. You've been in markets for
- 9:09decades. I think close to 30 years.
- 9:12>> 30 something years. Yeah.
- 9:13>> You used to be at Goldman Sachs, right?
- 9:16>> Yep. And running a hedge fund and all of
- 9:18that stuff.
- 9:18>> Have you ever seen a market like this
- 9:21macro wise? Macro.
- 9:22>> Like which? Like which?
- 9:24>> Like the macro conditions. And anybody
- 9:26trading or investing, check out exchange
- 9:28partner BTCC and get a 15% first deposit
- 9:33bonus. So, literally an extra 15% on
- 9:36your first deposit that's greater than
- 9:39$500,
- 9:40as well as earn up to $30,000 in signup
- 9:43bonuses, all for new users. I'm sure
- 9:46you've seen BTCC before. They are
- 9:48global. They have some of the biggest
- 9:50names with them. Sign up now and only
- 9:52with referral code altcoin grab your 15%
- 9:55firsttime bonus. Link down below. Check
- 9:57it out.
- 9:58>> Like which
- 9:59>> like the macro conditions?
- 10:01>> Uh yeah. No, I've seen it many times. It
- 10:05reminds me a lot of the uh the late 2000
- 10:09late 90s. So the late ' 90s we had a
- 10:13technological re revolution the
- 10:14internet.
- 10:16And what we saw was
- 10:19the central bank deciding not to raise
- 10:21rates because they thought productivity
- 10:23would pick up and speed up the economy
- 10:26and would lower inflation which proved
- 10:28correct.
- 10:29They then sort of ignited the banking
- 10:32system to add liquidity. They didn't use
- 10:34a central bank balance sheet then and
- 10:35they won't do it this time. So what you
- 10:37want is the banks to lend as much money
- 10:39as possible because they create money.
- 10:40The only two sources of money creation
- 10:43is the central bank or the banking
- 10:45system.
- 10:46And that's what they did back then. That
- 10:48allowed for massive amounts of capital
- 10:50to flow into what was at the time one of
- 10:52the largest capex booms of all time,
- 10:55which was the internet.
- 10:57And out of that, in the end, obviously,
- 11:00some of it went bust. And we can come on
- 11:01to a bit of that later,
- 11:04but they allowed for liquidity to flow
- 11:08to funds this thing. And we're in very
- 11:11similar conditions now. Inflation wasn't
- 11:13super low, but it was contained. They
- 11:16just left rates as they were. They
- 11:18didn't raise them at all. In fact, they
- 11:20cut them once. Uh Greenspan raised rates
- 11:22in 97 and then cut them in 98. That was
- 11:25all that happened. And they let
- 11:26productivity run. So, we're in a very
- 11:29similar situation where we see old
- 11:32economy names. Remember it back then it
- 11:33was called bricks and mortar versus, you
- 11:35know, Amazon and stuff. And people will
- 11:37be selling those and buying that. It's
- 11:38the same bifocation you're seeing in
- 11:40markets. Uh it's sort of exact same
- 11:43setup. Um we had in the middle of it we
- 11:47had the Asian crisis in 97 and 98 which
- 11:50blew up a bunch of hedge funds all that
- 11:51kind of stuff. You know do we have some
- 11:53sort of crisis around now? It doesn't
- 11:55feel like it's going to be that big but
- 11:56we definitely don't have the liquidity
- 11:58required to to to keep the market
- 12:01running right now which is fine because
- 12:03it it should pause. The other thing we
- 12:05see outside of um back in back in the
- 12:08late 90s we saw rotations, big
- 12:10rotations. It always starts with the
- 12:12semiconductors
- 12:13because that's [clears throat] the first
- 12:14thing you have to order if you want to
- 12:16build something and then it moves down
- 12:18the pipe and it moves to the
- 12:19applications layer like um like this
- 12:22time around it's moved to healthcare
- 12:24because we're starting to see drug
- 12:25breakthroughs all of that. So you'll get
- 12:27this rotation, you'll get another round
- 12:29of semis being ordered, stuff like that.
- 12:32And crypto fits within this. It's just
- 12:34part of the technology stack of the
- 12:36exponential age. So you know, crypto is
- 12:39the settlement layer for all of where
- 12:41the the settlement and storage layer for
- 12:45where all this goes. So it needs capital
- 12:49too to continue its build build out. If
- 12:51not, it's going to be too slow versus
- 12:53what required. So you see these weird
- 12:55capital rotations, but they actually
- 12:56make sense in the end. They kind of push
- 12:58the whole thing as we start, you know,
- 13:01funneling everything into this new world
- 13:03of of AI and the new digital age.
- 13:06>> If 2001 was the end of the party for the
- 13:09internet era bubble, um what year do you
- 13:12think we are in now?
- 13:15>> So I I doubt we have the same collapse.
- 13:18And the reason being is everyone looks
- 13:20at this and says there's all this debt
- 13:22and we've got um yeah everyone's
- 13:25building too many data centers blah blah
- 13:27blah. It's utter horseshit because this
- 13:30is the most in demand product we have
- 13:34ever created.
- 13:36The issue with the data centers is there
- 13:38are people borrowing money to build data
- 13:40centers and then can't plug in the
- 13:42electricity. So they don't have any cash
- 13:43flows and they go bust. It's being
- 13:45funded by the cash the most cash
- 13:48generative businesses in all of history
- 13:50and they've got barely any debt on their
- 13:52balance sheets. So this is going to go
- 13:55and the more intelligence you create,
- 13:58the more demand for intelligence you
- 14:00create because now the agents are the
- 14:02largest users of AI themselves.
- 14:05So you're creating this loop of infinite
- 14:08demand. There is no excess supply of
- 14:12intelligence and never can be. the more
- 14:14we make of it, the more we'll take of
- 14:16it. So, you've got a vastly different
- 14:18product funded by vastly different
- 14:20people. Back then, you had
- 14:23fiber optic, let's say that was the big
- 14:25builder and the telos. Well, fiber optic
- 14:28went bust because none of them were
- 14:30generating cash when they built it. This
- 14:32is the opposite. These are the most cash
- 14:33flow generating companies on earth
- 14:35building out this. So, we don't have any
- 14:37of these worries. Will a bunch of data
- 14:39centers, a bunch of peripheral
- 14:41businesses go bust? Yes, and it should
- 14:42do. That's capitalism at play. The
- 14:44weaker hands go. But what you saw
- 14:46immediately one goes bust is one of the
- 14:48bigger players buys it because everybody
- 14:50needs the compute.
- 14:52So I'm not sure how it ends, but I don't
- 14:57think it ends in a speculative frenzy
- 14:59per se because I think this is a real
- 15:01demand product.
- 15:03It either creates societal disruption
- 15:07which we're already seeing or
- 15:11as we go into a world where intelligence
- 15:13I mean by 2032 the total intelligence
- 15:16output of AI will exceed all of that of
- 15:19humanity
- 15:22because you can measure roughly how much
- 15:23intelligence a human brain has. How much
- 15:26um
- 15:28um how much electricity costs to run a
- 15:29brain 20 watts a day. you can compute
- 15:32that basically AI overtakes us all by
- 15:342032, 2034, whatever it is. So now
- 15:38you've got super intelligence that's
- 15:40more intelligent than all humans in
- 15:42existence,
- 15:44you know, then you start to worry about,
- 15:45okay, what is a company when an AI
- 15:48agents can build? You think you form a
- 15:50company, you have to go and file and
- 15:51register something and pay something,
- 15:52you have to hire people and payroll
- 15:54systems. Agents don't need any of that.
- 15:57So, so why would they not be building
- 15:59businesses whether we control them or
- 16:01another AI creates a business? So, it
- 16:04becomes a different economic actor.
- 16:07Markets aren't necessarily the same
- 16:08thing. If you think about how agents
- 16:11raise cash, that's a very
- 16:14obvious use case for what meanoins have
- 16:16done. Memecoins have been able to
- 16:18capture the attention of a market, go up
- 16:20to 10 billion dollars in value, and then
- 16:22destroy that value overnight. Now, if an
- 16:25agent if if your AI which you've given
- 16:28money to sees another agent that's
- 16:30developed an idea that says, "Hey,
- 16:32listen. There's a three-week opportunity
- 16:34to do this.
- 16:36You give it five grand of your money.
- 16:38Everybody gives it money. It raises a
- 16:40billion bucks. It does that thing and
- 16:42collapses it after 3 weeks. You will
- 16:44take your money out."
- 16:46Well, how the hell stock markets work in
- 16:48that?
- 16:50You know, time cycles compress in ways
- 16:52we don't understand because everything's
- 16:54built for human time. You know, five
- 16:56days a week trading all of this. But
- 16:58this is all this is all machine time.
- 17:02And when you put electricity through
- 17:05silicon, which is the new substrate of
- 17:07intelligence, we've jumped substrate
- 17:09from carbon, which is what we are. It's
- 17:11a million times faster. We have no way
- 17:14of dealing with this. So the issue is is
- 17:17who are the investors? What are the
- 17:19strategies? Do do you honestly think you
- 17:21and I are going to be outsmarting
- 17:23super AI? No, of course we're not. So in
- 17:27which case it's going to be making the
- 17:29investment decisions. That's a different
- 17:30market on a different time horizon
- 17:32operated at a different speed. So that's
- 17:34why I give this idea about you've kind
- 17:36of got four years left to unf your
- 17:38future and I'm serious about it because
- 17:40beyond then I don't know what the world
- 17:42looks like. What does an economy look
- 17:44like when productivity explodes and
- 17:47therefore and we've added new population
- 17:50into an economy of AI and robots? If you
- 17:53think population growth equals GDP
- 17:56growth plus productivity growth plus
- 17:58debt growth, well, if you're going to
- 18:00add infinite people into an economy,
- 18:04well, it grows because they all have
- 18:06economic demands and they increase
- 18:08productivity massively. Well, you could
- 18:10have GDP growth at 20%.
- 18:12Who does it acrue to?
- 18:15Who owns the agent? Who owns this? And
- 18:18it starts becoming a really screwy
- 18:19world, which is one of the reasons I I
- 18:21can I get to the idea is okay, we don't
- 18:25know so much past 2030 and nobody does.
- 18:30The rate of change is Reed's law, which
- 18:32is a double exponential, which is why
- 18:34it's so hard to keep up with this [ __ ]
- 18:37You know, we're used to crypto which was
- 18:38a, you know, metaf's law, single
- 18:40exponential, and we thought we were cool
- 18:41kids because we could deal with change.
- 18:43We can't, none of us can deal with this,
- 18:45right? Humans can't comprehend this. So,
- 18:48I think, well, what is going to last?
- 18:52What is going to last as investment? And
- 18:53one of the simple things is is crypto
- 18:56layer ones. Why? Because they're an
- 18:59infrastructure layer that everybody can
- 19:01own. Anybody in the world can own it.
- 19:04and all of this economic activity has to
- 19:06take place on it. So in which case that
- 19:09feels like it's going to last. Um it's
- 19:11like a you know I I think of it like a
- 19:13universal basic equity. We all have an
- 19:16ability whichever country you're in to
- 19:17own this infrastructure layer. That's
- 19:19pretty good to me.
- 19:22Um and the other layer that I own for
- 19:24the long term is is digital art on
- 19:26blockchain. Reason being is art is
- 19:29upstream of all wealth. Always has been.
- 19:33And culture is the single most important
- 19:35thing that makes us humans. And we're
- 19:36living through the most important time
- 19:38humanity's ever gone through. We've just
- 19:41invented, no, not invented, we've
- 19:42discovered the greatest technology we
- 19:45will ever discover and the last
- 19:47technology we will ever discover because
- 19:49AI discovers everything after us.
- 19:52So, we're going to live through these
- 19:53times and it's all being cataloged on
- 19:55the internet and arts is upstream of all
- 19:56of that. Because if you think about
- 19:59times that are cultural, whether it was
- 20:01like the the late 90s for you, whatever
- 20:03period it was or the mid 2000s,
- 20:06your concert tickets are worth nothing.
- 20:08The music you've bought on streaming is
- 20:10worth nothing. All of those memories are
- 20:11worth nothing. They're valuable to you,
- 20:14but art is the actual thing that
- 20:16compresses all of the value of that
- 20:18cultural moment. Whether it's Warhol of
- 20:20the 60s and 70s, whether it's um Basat
- 20:24for the 80s, whether it's Damian Hurst
- 20:27and Banksy for the '9s and 2000, they
- 20:30compress all of the culture
- 20:32and it becomes immensely valuable
- 20:33because they're scarce. And I think
- 20:36that's, you know, for me digital art,
- 20:38the art of the internet will become
- 20:40incredibly valuable. So that's a simple
- 20:42bet that I've had layer ones plus
- 20:44digital art. And then the flip side of
- 20:46that is anything that makes us human.
- 20:49human experiences.
- 20:51You know, why do people watch your show?
- 20:53Well, because you're a human talking to
- 20:54other humans. They relate to it. It
- 20:57feels something. And and when you do
- 20:58something live and in person, it becomes
- 21:00even more so. And then we look at the
- 21:02things like the rise of the value of
- 21:04sports teams. It's like this.
- 21:07Concert tours like this. Stuff like
- 21:09chess. Bizarre, right? Chess. No human's
- 21:12beaten a computer at chess in 35 years.
- 21:15Yet the chess industry is the biggest
- 21:17it's ever been because we like to watch
- 21:19humans compete with other flawed humans.
- 21:23Travel just like this. These are all
- 21:26experience layers and the experience
- 21:28layer becomes incredibly valuable too.
- 21:31It is hard for me to imagine exponential
- 21:34like this whether it happens by 2032
- 21:362030 you know some I can imagine linear
- 21:39but exponential is harder.
- 21:41>> Well no you imagine exponential because
- 21:43you know crypto. So when you look back,
- 21:45you go, "Bitcoin's gone from a hundred
- 21:47bucks to
- 21:50120,000." You've kind of been part of
- 21:52it. You've seen it. You sort of
- 21:53understand it. And even the ups and
- 21:56downs that we have to live through, when
- 21:58you zoom out and put it on a log chart,
- 21:59it's like, "Yeah, it's not really that
- 22:01exciting."
- 22:02But the double exponential, not a
- 22:04chance. So if you put the double
- 22:06exponential in perspective, agents only
- 22:11started in December last year.
- 22:15There are now more agents on the
- 22:17internet than there are humans.
- 22:19So we've gone to I don't know 10 billion
- 22:22agents from zero in less than a year.
- 22:27Anthropics revenues are the fastest
- 22:29scaling of revenues of any company in
- 22:31recorded history. Chat GPT's users are
- 22:34the fastest scaling of users of any
- 22:36company in history.
- 22:38So if you ask me how many agents are
- 22:40there going to be next year, how many
- 22:41transactions are they going to make? I
- 22:43can make you a guess, but I never would
- 22:46have said at the beginning of the year
- 22:48of this year to the end of this year,
- 22:50we'd have 10 billion agents and we'd all
- 22:52be using them already.
- 22:55That's because we don't understand
- 22:56double exponentials.
- 22:58>> Raul, in your book, which you just
- 23:00wrote, the everything code, bought it
- 23:01myself. You talk about the magic
- 23:04formula. What is Maybe we covered it
- 23:06already, but what is that?
- 23:07>> We did, but it's really important. It's
- 23:09the it's the formula of what drives
- 23:12economic growth and it's the number of
- 23:14people in your population
- 23:17particularly if they're growing then
- 23:20your economy grows. Why? Because more
- 23:22people consume more goods and are
- 23:24economic actors and work in the
- 23:26population. All of the western world has
- 23:29got a aging population. Many in Europe
- 23:32are shrinking. Japan shrinking, China
- 23:34shrinking, South Korea shrinking,
- 23:36Singapore shrinking. Everybody's
- 23:38shrinking. The US is about flat. So we
- 23:40have no economic growth brought by by
- 23:44people. So the other way we tried to
- 23:46solve it 3 years ago was immigration.
- 23:49Society said no, we can't deal with it.
- 23:52So that stopped. So right, you've got no
- 23:54engine of growth from that. The next
- 23:56thing is productivity. How do you get
- 23:58more output per person?
- 24:01Now the problem is is aging populations
- 24:04are less productive. Why? Because they
- 24:06don't work. the labor force
- 24:07participation rate keeps falling. The
- 24:10answer to that has been for the last 20
- 24:13or 30 years is add more debt.
- 24:17Debt creates false growth because you
- 24:21can borrow money and now you can spend
- 24:22more. So that's what happens and then
- 24:25you have to service the debt and it
- 24:26becomes a problem.
- 24:28So stuck with that, the only answer is
- 24:30issue more debt and then the government
- 24:32funds it via liquidity, debasement of
- 24:34currency, which is the game we've all
- 24:36lived in crypto for our whole lives is
- 24:38right, they're printing money to service
- 24:41the debt. We get the game, therefore we
- 24:43own these assets. Fab.
- 24:47But at some point, something needs to
- 24:50change
- 24:52because then you debase everything away.
- 24:54And the change is we're about to change
- 24:57the population.
- 24:59We go from 9 billion people
- 25:03to infinite.
- 25:05Now, right now, they're not really
- 25:06economic actors as we talked about. So,
- 25:09these agents and robots don't spend
- 25:10money much. There's only a few hundred
- 25:13thousand transactions.
- 25:15But soon as they do, they become
- 25:17economic actors. They consume
- 25:18electricity. They consume compute. and
- 25:21they spend on stuff whether it's on our
- 25:22behalf or their own behalf. Okay, now
- 25:25you're creating an economy and then the
- 25:27robots will come in in physical form and
- 25:29you'll put AGI brains into [ __ ] humanoid
- 25:33robots and you've created a new species.
- 25:34People aren't ready for that at all at
- 25:37all. Something smarter, stronger,
- 25:39faster, cheaper than you to run.
- 25:41Nobody's ready for that. But that's
- 25:43coming
- 25:45and that changes productivity because we
- 25:47all know these AIs can work 24/7. You
- 25:51can have an army of them working for
- 25:52you. So your productivity goes up at
- 25:55first. So that's the advantage you have
- 25:57by leaning into the technology. Your
- 25:59productivity explodes. You have more
- 26:01economic output. You get more money.
- 26:05Um and that's great because we've got
- 26:07this aging population of people leaving
- 26:08the workforce anyway. We need to replace
- 26:10them. But at some point it actually does
- 26:12this and goes vertical and then the
- 26:15world changes and the economy changes
- 26:16and that's the magic formula. And the
- 26:18magic formula Kevin Walsh is talking
- 26:21about it. Scott Besson's talking about
- 26:22it. Donald Trump's talking about it.
- 26:24Everybody's talking about it.
- 26:25Productivity is the game.
- 26:27Now they don't they're not telling you
- 26:29that they're replacing humans as well.
- 26:32But that's what it is. And then you've
- 26:34got somebody like Elon who ends up
- 26:35owning robots at scale and the ability
- 26:40to talk to them i.e. the network.
- 26:44I mean that's you've got your own
- 26:47population. You've got your own country
- 26:48essentially. Essentially you know he's
- 26:50building something of
- 26:53nation state size which people don't
- 26:56really understand.
- 26:58>> I want to encourage everybody down below
- 27:00before we get too far. Raul, you shared
- 27:01your time with me. So, I want to
- 27:02encourage the audience, check out the
- 27:04book. Um, one more thing on Arl, you
- 27:07know, what what's what got you to write
- 27:10it? What are you most proud of?
- 27:12>> I this whole thing has been like 35
- 27:14years of work. And back [clears throat]
- 27:16in about 2020, I started seeing
- 27:20the clarity of what the was going on.
- 27:25Why the world was why were why were our
- 27:28wages not going up as much as things
- 27:30like houses?
- 27:32Why could I afford less? Why all the
- 27:35kids who went and got the best college
- 27:36degrees, did their mast's degree, spend
- 27:38all that, why did that not give them the
- 27:40leg up that they thought it was going to
- 27:42give them? You know, why is this all
- 27:44this happening? And then I realized that
- 27:46about the debasement of currency and
- 27:48then I started figuring out okay how
- 27:49does the mechanism work
- 27:52what what can we understand about this
- 27:55thing like financial conditions and
- 27:57liquidity and how it drives asset how
- 27:59can we use it to our favor to invest and
- 28:02then I started thinking about what's the
- 28:04world we're going into so we're in the
- 28:07exponential age now where everything's
- 28:08going to exponential
- 28:10and I predicted that back from 2021 I
- 28:13said this is what's all going to happen
- 28:14people laughed at me, but it's
- 28:15happening. And the next phase is the
- 28:17economic singularity when we don't
- 28:19understand how how economies work. So
- 28:21the book is telling us about
- 28:24where we are today and why we're there,
- 28:29what we're going to have to deal with at
- 28:30this moment in time
- 28:33and how to then profit from this
- 28:36transition
- 28:37and how to survive in the other side.
- 28:39So, it's basically the everything I
- 28:41could I could do to get across
- 28:44everything that I'd learned to help
- 28:45people in all of this because it's a
- 28:47wild time. thinking about the everything
- 28:49code and not to oversimplify it, but if
- 28:52you had to oversimplify it, is it would
- 28:54it be a safe assumption that barring
- 28:56some uh black swan event, a meteor
- 28:58strike, a world war, whatever, it's like
- 29:00asset prices are going to keep going up
- 29:03because either they'll if the economy
- 29:05slows, they'll print a bunch or if we
- 29:07have huge productivity with AI, uh
- 29:09that's just huge growth.
- 29:11>> Yes. one is it but we don't know where
- 29:14that economic growth occurs to but asset
- 29:17prices go up now of course there's
- 29:19cycles there's liquidity cycles market
- 29:21you know we've just seen a big
- 29:22correction in half these markets so it's
- 29:24not saying that but what it's saying is
- 29:28look when it really struck home was co
- 29:32they shut the entire world for about a
- 29:36year the entireing planet shut down what
- 29:40did we get one quarter of recession
- 29:42recession and the market was back at
- 29:44all-time highs by the following quarter.
- 29:47That was the wakeup call is oh all you
- 29:50do is just print as much money as
- 29:52possible debase the currency and the
- 29:54price of the collateral that could go
- 29:55bust goes up because the purchasing
- 29:58power's gone down. So you can't have a
- 30:00crisis.
- 30:02And anytime we get close to something
- 30:05happening, they print money
- 30:08because when you've got an aging
- 30:10population, it's everybody's pension.
- 30:13And so they kind of defend this
- 30:15collateral layer. So once you realize
- 30:17that, you realize that you're sort of
- 30:18protected from the worst case scenario
- 30:20events. Yeah, you can still have the
- 30:21wrong bets, take the wrong investments,
- 30:24you'll still have cycle risk, they go up
- 30:26and down. And in crypto, it's br brutal.
- 30:27and in the S&P it's less so because it's
- 30:29a more volatile asset. But once you
- 30:32realize that, you realize there's no
- 30:34point being a bear.
- 30:36And then once you understand the
- 30:38exponential age, you realize, well, I
- 30:40can either try and reject it and I'm
- 30:42just going to be angry and watch the
- 30:43world change around me or I can use it
- 30:46to my advantage.
- 30:50>> And so that's that's really, you know,
- 30:52the everything code is is that whole
- 30:54process is they will keep debasing
- 30:55currency until we find the solution. and
- 30:56the solutions just turned up.
- 30:59We'll probably have both regimes for a
- 31:01while because you have to fund this
- 31:03build out. So, what a great time to be
- 31:06an investor
- 31:07and and diving in into crypto. Obviously
- 31:10with tokenization and layer ones, the
- 31:12thesis is we're early thinking about
- 31:14Bitcoin. Am I too late to buy Bitcoin
- 31:18again? Grab a 15% firsttime deposit
- 31:21bonus only with exchange partner BTCC.
- 31:24So, literally an extra 15% on your first
- 31:27deposit that's greater than $500,
- 31:31as well as earn up to $30,000 in signup
- 31:34bonuses. All for new users. I'm sure
- 31:36you've seen BTCC before. They are
- 31:38global. They have some of the biggest
- 31:40names with them. Sign up now and only
- 31:42with referral code altcoin grab your 15%
- 31:46firsttime bonus. Am I too late to buy
- 31:48Bitcoin?
- 31:50>> I don't think so. Because in a digital
- 31:52world, digital stores of value become
- 31:55more transportable, more usable. We know
- 31:58that
- 32:00the banking system has now accepted
- 32:02Bitcoin as a collateral, which was a big
- 32:05hurdle. Back in 2020 and 2021, I was
- 32:07talking about this. It has to be
- 32:08collateral layer. We're seeing that.
- 32:10It's still too volatile to be great
- 32:12collateral, but we're seeing sovereign
- 32:13nation states, um, sovereign wealth
- 32:15funds, all of these people owning this
- 32:17stuff. We're seeing households now have
- 32:19access to it. So it's easier to use.
- 32:22It's more transportable than gold. It's
- 32:25secure. So we will just see it take a
- 32:28larger and larger share of world
- 32:30savings.
- 32:32But that's very different to the layer
- 32:34ones. And the reason being is there is
- 32:38world savings and Bitcoin can only be
- 32:40100% world savings, which obviously it
- 32:42won't be, but right. So it it has
- 32:45diminishing returns baked into the cake
- 32:49while layer ones don't. Why? Because
- 32:51they're infrastructure.
- 32:53If you have a trillion dollar a trillion
- 32:55agents all creating vast economic
- 32:58activity,
- 33:00well, it's going to happen on blockchain
- 33:01rails and therefore these the
- 33:02infrastructure layer is even more
- 33:04valuable. So they're very different
- 33:05beasts. You know, one is a pure
- 33:07technology play and the other is a
- 33:09technological solution to um
- 33:15a very big need in savings which is how
- 33:17to avoid the basement and how to make it
- 33:19transportable, safe, secure, all of
- 33:21those things.
- 33:22>> Kathy Wood, Michael Sailor, Bitwise
- 33:26Investment Research all say Bitcoin to a
- 33:29million in the next 5 to 10 years. Does
- 33:31that
- 33:32>> look I'm I'm a total [ __ ] So I like to
- 33:34do the moronic way is just take the
- 33:36trend the log trend channel of Bitcoin
- 33:41and just extrapolate it out and you get
- 33:44to about 20 36 it's about a million
- 33:46bucks. It's like yeah seems about right.
- 33:49It sounds like a big number now because
- 33:51it we're thinking exponentials again.
- 33:53But when you put on a log regression
- 33:55channel, just get that lovely little
- 33:56channel up. It's like, yeah, obviously
- 33:59if it continues to grow, is it a too
- 34:02large a part of world savings to stop
- 34:04growing? No. You know, where's it versus
- 34:07gold? You know, very simple things. So,
- 34:09yeah. No, I don't have an issue with
- 34:11that whatsoever. What's the exact date?
- 34:13Who knows? So, i.e., can it 10x from
- 34:15here over time? Sure, no problem.
- 34:19I am going to share my screen for this
- 34:21next question. Let's see if
- 34:24see if I can do it.
- 34:27Um
- 34:29I can't do it. Okay, [laughter]
- 34:31never mind. But for this next question,
- 34:33I was going to show you the coin gecko
- 34:35total uh total market cap of crypto.
- 34:38>> Yes. Goes to 100 trillion.
- 34:40>> Same thing. It's the same thing. It's
- 34:41going to 100 trillion, which I've said
- 34:43for a long time. How do I make these
- 34:46crystal ball? I just get the log
- 34:48regression channel, drag it out and go,
- 34:51well, of course it's going to go to 100
- 34:52trillion. So, right now it's what, two
- 34:54and a half trillion. Okay, there's
- 34:56plenty of money to be made here. Just
- 34:59patience. People just cannot understand
- 35:01patience. They want to get rich quick.
- 35:03When the answer's in front of you,
- 35:06anybody if you say, "Oh, this asset's
- 35:07$25 and it's going to $100.
- 35:11Is that a good bet?" You go, "Yeah,
- 35:13amazing."
- 35:15But when you say, well, it's over 10
- 35:16years and it's crypto and it's, you
- 35:18know, two and a half trillion now. It's
- 35:19going to 100. Everyone goes, no, that
- 35:21can't happen. It's just it's bizarre. Or
- 35:24I want it now. So, yeah. No, to me, it's
- 35:27pretty obvious it'll get there.
- 35:29>> Yeah. Do you do say you we have four
- 35:31years left to make as much money as we
- 35:33can before? We don't really know. It's
- 35:34harder to tell.
- 35:35>> Yeah. Yeah,
- 35:36>> in in the next four years, just crypto
- 35:38market cap, how much money, you know, do
- 35:41you foresee coming into the total,
- 35:43>> you know,
- 35:45who the [ __ ] knows? Extrapolate the log
- 35:47trend out. Um, you know, where is it? If
- 35:50it's two trillion today, does it get to
- 35:5620 trillion?
- 35:58Yeah, that's reasonable. I know nobody
- 36:00thinks we can have nice things because
- 36:01we've had 18 months of [ __ ] but you
- 36:05know, we've all lived in crypto markets.
- 36:07I mean, I remember when it 10xed
- 36:116 months in the end of 2017.
- 36:14So, yes, there were smaller markets,
- 36:16etc. back then. But yeah, I don't see
- 36:18any reason why, you know, 10 trillion to
- 36:2120 trillion is not an easy ask
- 36:24economic conditions allow it to happen.
- 36:27And the only thing the audience has to
- 36:28remember is if it goes to 20 maybe
- 36:30corrects back down to 12. It's like
- 36:31there'll be nasty corrections along the
- 36:33way.
- 36:33>> And the simple way of dealing with that
- 36:35is not fearing the CL. If you've got a
- 36:37long enough time horizon, all you want
- 36:40to do is save money for when it does
- 36:42that fall back down to 12 and you pile
- 36:45another bunch in. And what you end up
- 36:47doing is compounding. You get back to
- 36:49the all-time highs in your P&L much
- 36:51earlier than the market. That's all you
- 36:52have to do. The compounding effect is so
- 36:54good, but people can't do it because
- 36:57emotion, emotion, fear, social
- 37:00signaling, you know, oh, those crypto
- 37:02people, they're idiots, they're bubble
- 37:03b, you know, people just don't get any
- 37:05of this. It's just a technology. You
- 37:07could have done the same with Amazon
- 37:08stock does exactly the same. Um, you
- 37:11could have done it with Microsoft,
- 37:12Google, they're all the same just to
- 37:14have slightly lower volatility levels,
- 37:16but some of them are pretty high. I mean
- 37:18uh Amazon what fell 97 and a half 98% in
- 37:22its first kind of downturn and it's had
- 37:24many over 50%. But people don't remember
- 37:27that they think oh Amazon yeah what you
- 37:29know all you have to do is own Amazon.
- 37:31Yeah great you have to deal with the
- 37:32draw downs and with crypto you know
- 37:34we're kind of used to it but new
- 37:36entrance find it really hard. So
- 37:38particularly people who enter and have
- 37:40only been in one cycle
- 37:43you know they get angry and upset
- 37:45because they've lost money. I'm like,
- 37:47"No, it's just time horizon." Unless you
- 37:50think that crypto is not going to be
- 37:52used for any of this, that everybody's
- 37:54wrong. The banking industry is wrong,
- 37:55the asset management industry is wrong,
- 37:57the US government's wrong, the Chinese
- 37:58government's wrong, all of the European
- 38:00regulations were pointless, and all of
- 38:02the single investors who've done all of
- 38:04the homework over the thousands of
- 38:05hours, they're all wrong as well. Okay,
- 38:08you can take that bet,
- 38:10but that's stupid.
- 38:13You know, it's not like this is a dumb
- 38:15group of people in crypto. some of the
- 38:16smartest people in the world. Plus, you
- 38:19know, you, you know, people worship
- 38:21people like Stan Duck Miller. Stan
- 38:22Stan's been in crypto for a long time.
- 38:25So, of all of the main main hedge fund
- 38:27managers, they're all big believers.
- 38:28They all own it. They all trade it. And
- 38:31so does Black Rockck, the largest
- 38:32financial institution on Earth. Oh, and
- 38:34Goldman Sachs. Oh, and JP Morgan.
- 38:38They're building their own blockchains.
- 38:40I mean, this is insane. It's everything
- 38:42we've ever wanted. And then people are
- 38:44still like, "Well, it's never going to
- 38:46happen." I'm like, "Just wait."
- 38:49>> Raul, you gave me, we did an interview
- 38:52years ago, I think in 2022 at bottom of
- 38:55the market in retrospect. Um, but you
- 38:57gave me some great advice back then,
- 38:59which was, oh, if you're betting on the
- 39:01industry getting bigger, which is
- 39:03crypto, have a basket of five or six
- 39:06coins. Maybe two will fail, two will be
- 39:08middling, and hopefully one or two
- 39:09really hit. What is your basket of six
- 39:13today?
- 39:14>> My basket hasn't chang.
- 39:16I'm going to have Bitcoin, Ethereum,
- 39:19Salana, Sui, Zcash.
- 39:24That's mainly it. And I don't
- 39:27>> don't have any hyperlquid. Why? Because
- 39:28I don't use per. So why would I own a
- 39:31product that I don't use?
- 39:32>> How about AI coins?
- 39:35>> No.
- 39:37No, because that's too speculative for
- 39:40me. I just want to be able to not worry.
- 39:44You know, it's hard enough to deal with
- 39:45the volatility. And I've gone through
- 39:48many, many 80% draw downs. Um, I don't
- 39:51want to figure out is this thing going
- 39:53to survive? Is it just hot air? Is it
- 39:55being pumped up by a bunch of
- 39:56influencer? I don't want to do any of
- 39:58that.
- 40:00um you know I'll do more in the art
- 40:01market but even then you can you can go
- 40:04to okay what's got social consensus
- 40:07what's proven to last over time you can
- 40:09see the network effects of these artists
- 40:11so yeah so I don't I don't really I'm
- 40:14much more boring than people imagine I
- 40:15don't trade I don't do anything I've
- 40:17never sold any crypto I've never single
- 40:18I've never sold a single token since
- 40:242018 maybe
- 40:27that's when I sold some Bitcoin 2,000
- 40:30and it went up to 20,000 and I bought it
- 40:32at 200 and it went up to 2,000. I sold
- 40:35it, then it went up to 20,000. Um, and
- 40:38that was the last time I ever sold
- 40:40crypto.
- 40:41>> You mentioned Zcash as one of your bets.
- 40:44Obviously, the play is privacy, which is
- 40:46a huge trend. I'm all for the the the
- 40:48trade of privacy, but let me give you my
- 40:51um so I'm saying like obviously I think
- 40:53it's going to keep going up because the
- 40:54momentum is there in the crypto market
- 40:55and and it's a very easy narrative to
- 40:57hit, but this is my fear that uh privacy
- 41:02if you want it for transactions can just
- 41:04be added to a stable coin. It's like if
- 41:07yeah, okay, it's a store of value that's
- 41:08private, but
- 41:11it's not going to be used for
- 41:12transactions because stable coins will
- 41:14just add that. It's not it's it's just a
- 41:16private version of Bitcoin. Just think
- 41:18of it as that. And that's the simple
- 41:20narrative. You know, what percentage of
- 41:22Bitcoin's market cap should it be?
- 41:24Should it be 1%, 10%, 20%, I don't know,
- 41:28somewhere amongst that mix. And that's
- 41:31the bet really. It's pretty
- 41:33straightforward. It's pretty clear. It's
- 41:34a very obvious thing. Now, what I also
- 41:39know is I do not have the stomach for
- 41:41fighting every government, every
- 41:43regulator all over again. I mean, I've
- 41:45done that for since 2012 in crypto. It's
- 41:49been hard. Um, and you know, Zcash will
- 41:52have that issue. You have to take on the
- 41:54fight again cuz they're going to stop
- 41:56privacy and they're going to ban you
- 41:57from owning it in a wallet and
- 41:59eventually it'll come around to it. Um,
- 42:02so therefore it's a smaller proportion
- 42:03of my portfolio
- 42:05because I don't I just not that I don't
- 42:07think it's a uh it's a very good
- 42:11opportunity. I just think I don't want
- 42:14my whole net worth to be on a fight with
- 42:17governments again. We won that fight.
- 42:21>> I sort of already asked you this, but
- 42:23how do I take advantage? Not you
- 42:25personally because you're not going to
- 42:26take the risk, but decentralized AI. The
- 42:28blue chips are VVV towo and near. I
- 42:32would say it's how do I think about it
- 42:34if I want to take advantage of something
- 42:36like that.
- 42:37>> Well, again I would think about the
- 42:38settlement layer. So I think near suite
- 42:41and Salana the speed the efficiency of
- 42:44all of that that's much more where I
- 42:47would gear towards
- 42:49um you know with um [clears throat]
- 42:52Venice AI it's great you know do you
- 42:55want to own that business? Is it going
- 42:56to generate money for you? I don't know.
- 42:59But, you know, it's a great project and
- 43:01I love it. I don't own any of it. Is TA
- 43:04going to get the Is Bitensor going to
- 43:07get the economic traction? Is it a good
- 43:10idea? Great. Do I fade Barry Silbert?
- 43:13Every time I do, I've got it wrong. So,
- 43:16I don't fade Barry. Um,
- 43:19but is it going to work? I I just don't
- 43:21know. I don't know. So, that that's hard
- 43:24for me to own. Now, if I was more
- 43:26speculative
- 43:28um and shorter term in nature, yeah, I'd
- 43:31choose a basket of some of these and
- 43:32hope it works. But I look back at the
- 43:34baskets of stuff that I thought was
- 43:35really smart back in 2020, 2021. There's
- 43:38baskets of metaverse stuff all went to
- 43:40zero. Baskets of other stuff all went to
- 43:43zero. So you it's really actually
- 43:45difficult to know what's going to get
- 43:46traction and when. And it might be not
- 43:48till the following cycle that it really
- 43:49gets traction. So it's difficult to
- 43:51tell.
- 43:53What is the probability would you give
- 43:55that not a recession happens? Obviously
- 43:58you think a lot of people think oh AI is
- 44:00going to be huge for 2027 2028 markets
- 44:02going to go up but probability wise
- 44:04would you say 5% up that you may be
- 44:07wrong or what probability do you give
- 44:09it?
- 44:10>> Look there's many things that can go
- 44:11wrong in markets and many things can go
- 44:13wrong in economies. I didn't imagine
- 44:15we'd be having to deal with an Iran war
- 44:17after we'd had a government shutdown
- 44:19right they killed liquidity. We got 10
- 44:2110 in the crypto market. Then we're just
- 44:23about to recover. We have another
- 44:24government shutdown in January. We're
- 44:26like, great, we can have our liquidity
- 44:28back. Iran war, dollar goes up, oil goes
- 44:31up, rates go up.
- 44:34So you you you you just don't know. So
- 44:37it's hard to assess the probability.
- 44:39Economically wise,
- 44:42unless the dollar weakens and rates
- 44:45um ease off somewhat, we're likely to
- 44:49have slower economic growth. Do we get a
- 44:52recession? I think they're almost
- 44:53impossible in this day and age, but that
- 44:55doesn't mean it can't hit your business,
- 44:57my business, your friends personally.
- 45:00You know, we've seen the K-shaped
- 45:01economy plenty of times. So, you know,
- 45:04we've also got the biggest capex
- 45:05buildout in economic history. It's like
- 45:0815% of GDP right now or something stupid
- 45:11and it's still growing. So, it's hard to
- 45:13have a recession unless that grinds to a
- 45:15halt. So, let's play that one through.
- 45:18So, all the hyper scalers start deciding
- 45:21not to spend.
- 45:23Okay. So, if you're the first one to
- 45:25stop spending,
- 45:28the rate of intelligence per unit of
- 45:30energy is doubling every 4.6 months by
- 45:32my measure. You are 3 years behind
- 45:35within one year. You'll never catch up.
- 45:38Double exponential.
- 45:40So nobody can slow. This is the most
- 45:44powerful technology the world has ever
- 45:46had.
- 45:48So nobody can afford to not play the
- 45:51game.
- 45:52And then when you go to nation states,
- 45:56neither China nor the US can stop. In
- 45:59fact, they have to put all the resources
- 46:01into this trade because if they don't,
- 46:04one country's intelligence doubles every
- 46:064.6 months and the other one doesn't.
- 46:09What happens? One can control the world.
- 46:12When you've got two, you got to
- 46:13counterbalance, which is how it should
- 46:15be. But you cannot have one cuz if not,
- 46:18you have one system that rules all and
- 46:20that's not a world anybody wants to live
- 46:21in. You choice.
- 46:24So therefore, the US government will not
- 46:26allow this trade to go bust. They will
- 46:29make sure all capital roots to it if it
- 46:30needs to whether it's the banking system
- 46:32whether it's a central bank balance
- 46:34sheet or any other mechanism possible
- 46:36even expropriating savings anything to
- 46:39fund this cuz it's too big and the
- 46:42Chinese are the same. So that's why I
- 46:45find it very difficult to get something
- 46:48really ugly.
- 46:50Yes, we will have slowdowns in
- 46:52liquidity. Yes, economic slowdowns will
- 46:54occur. It's not like it's all going to
- 46:55be off to the races. But I lived through
- 46:57the 90s. I was at Goldman and then
- 46:59running a hedge fund. And what we saw
- 47:02was no economic slowdown. We got a bit
- 47:05of a slowdown in in 1998 because the
- 47:08Asian crisis, but basically the economy
- 47:10just kept going strong. It didn't
- 47:12overheat because you had these slowdown
- 47:14periods in the middle of it. The markets
- 47:15rotated a lot like they are now. There
- 47:18was flat periods as well. And the flat
- 47:20periods were we used to call them, in
- 47:21fact, my boss used to call them the
- 47:23pause that refreshes. So the markets go
- 47:26sideways for a while and then they
- 47:27[ __ ] explode again. Why? Because the
- 47:29game was too big. Um, so I kind of think
- 47:32of it that way and then we get into 2030
- 47:35and then I don't know so much anymore.
- 47:37But I the for me the probability of
- 47:41having a
- 47:43a really nasty downside outcome in the
- 47:47next four years is low.
- 47:49But we will have sectors that suddenly
- 47:51fall out of favor and can fall 50% but
- 47:53they'll have gone up 5x. So you have to
- 47:56kind of put it in perspective of that.
- 47:58And there's sectors of the economy that
- 48:00will get entirely left behind and will
- 48:01go to zero because we're in a massive
- 48:04transition
- 48:06>> like anything AI can replace
- 48:08parallegals.
- 48:09>> Yeah.
- 48:09>> Delivery and one AI versus another.
- 48:13M don't forget you know somebody's
- 48:15building legal a you know AI Harvey and
- 48:18then the next minute chat GPT builds a
- 48:20legal you know this is a ruthless
- 48:23relentless
- 48:25hyper accelerating business of dog eat
- 48:27dog out there so it's very difficult to
- 48:30invest
- 48:31you know the NASDAQ is pretty easy
- 48:34because at least you get the survivors
- 48:37but it's kind of like crypto markets
- 48:38that we've understood it's like Jesus
- 48:40you can go from hero to zero overnight
- 48:42in this stuff. So, it's it's not easy.
- 48:46But again, being a crypto investor,
- 48:48you're kind of used to it a bit easier.
- 48:49Like you talked to me about the AI
- 48:51tokens, and we all know that none of
- 48:53those may work. They all may work. One
- 48:55of them may work. We're kind of used to
- 48:58that weird probabilistic odds.
- 49:01>> Well, speaking of conviction investing,
- 49:03you tweeted out a couple years ago or or
- 49:05a couple months ago or I don't know
- 49:07when, but that you're n that you're 90%
- 49:10in SUI. What gave you that conviction?
- 49:12>> No, I mean that was that was that I
- 49:14don't I found I can't even give
- 49:16percentages anymore because then people
- 49:19blame you for their P&L swings.
- 49:23Will I put 90% in sui? I'm like yeah
- 49:25I've run risk for 30 years. I know what
- 49:28I'm doing and I know I know what my
- 49:29income stream is and I know that I don't
- 49:32need access to the capital. Somebody
- 49:34else is like oh I put it in sui because
- 49:36I was going to buy a house and I needed
- 49:37a few extra grand and suddenly they're
- 49:39down 80%. It's like I can't I can't do
- 49:41that anymore. It's just, you know, it's
- 49:44you can't do it. So, I don't give my
- 49:45percentage allocations anymore. Like, I
- 49:47don't give price targets anymore because
- 49:49it's the same thing. And I get it.
- 49:51People's hopes and dreams are in a
- 49:52thing. So, they want somebody to follow
- 49:53and and then it doesn't go according to
- 49:56plan and then they get angry. It's like
- 49:58it's just it's not worth it. The best
- 49:59thing is to write a book and help people
- 50:01do it themselves.
- 50:02>> But what gave you what no matter what
- 50:04percentage you have, what gave you the
- 50:06convictions? Well, partly I'm on the
- 50:07foundation, so I got given some um but
- 50:10because I think that faster, cheaper
- 50:16um blockchains which can compress as
- 50:20much intelligence into the blockchain
- 50:21because it can do a,024 transactions
- 50:23within each block is made for the
- 50:29exponential age and for agents and where
- 50:32we're going. you know, the team is not
- 50:35like it's well, sometimes it's a great
- 50:37advantage to have a bunch of young kids
- 50:38doing it, but this it's a very
- 50:40experienced group of people and
- 50:44I think the probability of it being in
- 50:46that group of the top four layer ones
- 50:51is very high.
- 50:53Now, has it got a lot of traction right
- 50:55now? Not enough. Have they built amazing
- 50:58technology? Yes. Um and then you have to
- 51:01decide well what is the probability that
- 51:03the market is underpricing its potential
- 51:05future path versus now and I think very
- 51:07much so um you know will that bet be
- 51:10100% right will I stay 90% no because I
- 51:12convert income into crypto all the time
- 51:15and so you know I change allocations
- 51:17like I've got Zcash now I don't
- 51:19generally sell anything I just add to
- 51:21other stuff as you build your portfolio
- 51:23over time but you know I've got
- 51:24relatively high conviction in it um
- 51:27because I see the world in a certain
- 51:29Um, and it fits that world view for me.
- 51:33>> In our final five minutes, I want to do
- 51:34a bit of a speed round. Just a sentence
- 51:36or two on each question, starting with
- 51:38the best financial advice you ever
- 51:41heard.
- 51:42>> Best financial advice I ever heard was
- 51:45when I was looking for a job out of
- 51:47university and I spoke to a friend of my
- 51:50dad's and he says, "What do you want to
- 51:51do for a living?" And this was we just
- 51:54had the 80s, right?
- 51:56>> [snorts]
- 51:56>> And uh I'm like I either want to go into
- 51:58marketing because dad was in marketing
- 52:00and I kind of understood that or I said
- 52:02I want to go into finance into the city
- 52:05the city of London. And the guy looked
- 52:06at me he goes you know let me make this
- 52:08easy for you. You can go and work for a
- 52:12fantastic marketing company. Go and work
- 52:15for Mars. Amazing fastmoving consumer
- 52:17goods marketing. He goes you'll get free
- 52:20Mars bars. if you go and work for a
- 52:23bank, you get free money.
- 52:26Um, and that was the best piece of
- 52:28advice. He's like, it's basically the
- 52:29same job. Um, and so it's understanding
- 52:35to be closer to the money is easier to
- 52:37get money than being further away from
- 52:39the money. So go into finance that still
- 52:41holds.
- 52:42>> Go into finance, go into crypto, go into
- 52:43AI.
- 52:46>> Next question. the what is the greatest
- 52:50trade ever that most still don't see
- 52:55for me it's digital art and I'll explain
- 52:57it's really simple I've explained why
- 53:01art is upstream of all culture and all
- 53:04wealth right the richest people put more
- 53:07money into art than they do into their
- 53:08houses
- 53:12we've got this incredible cultural
- 53:14momentum this thing happening around us
- 53:16of which is being cataloged by artists,
- 53:19the rise of AI and and just how the
- 53:22world is dealing with all of this. So,
- 53:24this art is going to be valuable to me.
- 53:26Okay, great.
- 53:27But art is on Ethereum and it's priced
- 53:30in ETH.
- 53:32And if we're right about the layer ones
- 53:34and let's say ETH goes from 2 and a half
- 53:37thousand bucks to
- 53:39$25,000 in 10 years time.
- 53:42So you get the 10x multiplier, but then
- 53:47let's say I've bought art that's ends up
- 53:49being valuable. So the art goes up in
- 53:52ETH terms. So let's say I bought
- 53:53something for 10 ETH and it goes to 100
- 53:56ETH. I've made 10x. I bought the right
- 53:59artist. Great. But then ETH's gone up
- 54:0210x as well. And that becomes a 100x
- 54:05return.
- 54:07And that is what's people I don't know
- 54:10why we've got the thumbs up, but
- 54:12Zoom obviously likes it um as an idea.
- 54:15So that's it's the convexity of that
- 54:17trade is misunderstood
- 54:19>> and top three artists that you hold.
- 54:23>> Uh
- 54:25I mean
- 54:27everyone's got different taste in what
- 54:28they want as artists, but I'm massively
- 54:30attracted to XCopy because he was one of
- 54:34the first and he's the culture of the
- 54:35internet and he's anonymous and it's
- 54:37like Banksy. It's like the culture of
- 54:40the streets was Banksy. The culture of
- 54:41the internet is excopy people because
- 54:44every single day he basically comments
- 54:47on what we're going through as society
- 54:49and he's like a bow around the internet
- 54:50every evening you see people's piece of
- 54:52art come out one of his everydays um I
- 54:54like that and I also like see I split my
- 54:57art collection into two sides one is
- 54:58cultural one is um technologydriven
- 55:02so on the cultural side there's a guy
- 55:04called die with the most likes who's a
- 55:05good friend who's also very appreciated
- 55:08in the space unbelievable he writes But
- 55:10he he's basically got this he's
- 55:12basically cataloging and commenting on
- 55:15the decline of middle America
- 55:19with a fondness for middle America and
- 55:21all of its weirdness.
- 55:23And so he creates physical art, digital
- 55:25art books and pros
- 55:30and does characterization in person, you
- 55:32know, character around this whole thing.
- 55:34It's it's it's amazing. Um, and I love
- 55:37his art and it's some of it can be quite
- 55:39outrageous. And then on the other side
- 55:40there's people like Kim Asendorf are
- 55:42pushing technological limits with what
- 55:44you can do with with art, what can you
- 55:46do with a smart contract, how you can
- 55:48program it in smart ways. So that's the
- 55:50that's the AI being used for art and the
- 55:53other side is commenting on what
- 55:55societyy's going through. So that's kind
- 55:57of how I think about it.
- 55:58>> Next question. I know you don't make
- 56:00price predictions anymore, so I would
- 56:02never ask you, but I'm making a bet with
- 56:05my dad, which is basically prices right
- 56:07rules closest without going over about
- 56:10where Ethereum will be by top of this
- 56:13next cycle, 2029, 2030.
- 56:15>> I'm not doing it
- 56:17cuz you're going to clip it and then I'm
- 56:19going to get shhat on. There's zero
- 56:21upside. So, thank you. But no,
- 56:23>> that's fair. That's fair. But I feel
- 56:24everybody that reads your book, The
- 56:26Everything Code, they know which
- 56:28direction you think it's headed and they
- 56:29know which assets that you're most
- 56:30bullish on.
- 56:31>> Yeah, it's going up and I've given you
- 56:34the thesis on how to do it. It's all in
- 56:36the book and I've talked about it. I'm
- 56:38very open about all of this stuff, but I
- 56:40just have to be, you know, because price
- 56:41predictions are always wrong by
- 56:43definition. None of us know, right?
- 56:45>> Nobody got it right in crypto. Hardly
- 56:46anybody. A am I going to be 100% right
- 56:49to say the price of crypto will be
- 56:51higher in 5 years time than today?
- 56:54Maybe. In 10 years time, definitely. You
- 56:58know why five years? Well, maybe there's
- 56:59a bare market and you catch the timing.
- 57:01But you know what I mean? It's going up.
- 57:03It's not that it's not that complicated,
- 57:05but everybody wants to over complicate
- 57:07it. You know, I figured this out years
- 57:10ago. all this stupid [ __ ] that we've
- 57:11gone through with crypto and investing.
- 57:14All we had to do was just buy 50%
- 57:16NASDAQ, 50% Bitcoin and have never done
- 57:20anything again and it would work. And
- 57:22you wouldn't have any of the failures
- 57:23and any of the mess that's in your
- 57:25wallet of shame. You would have had to
- 57:27have done billions of hours of videos
- 57:29and watching stuff and reading all the
- 57:31you didn't need to do any of it. You
- 57:33just needed that simple trade which was
- 57:35like, well, techn is going up.
- 57:37>> Raul, thank you so much for coming on.
- 57:39link, Amazon link for your book down
- 57:40below. Final thoughts for the altcoin
- 57:42daily community.
- 57:45>> I'm trying to teach people
- 57:48that we do have only four years to
- 57:51unfuck our futures. I'm not saying the
- 57:52world ends in four years time. I'm like,
- 57:54I just don't know what it looks like.
- 57:56We've been gifted an opportunity set
- 57:58like AI and crypto which are parts of
- 58:02our own demise. You know, as humans get
- 58:04replaced,
- 58:05these are parts of the infrastructure
- 58:07layer to do it. and we can invest in it
- 58:09all. So, the best thing is just lean
- 58:12into it and then use the technologies
- 58:14yourself.
- 58:16You know, put your savings in Bitcoin,
- 58:18you know, think about how you can use um
- 58:22um smart contracts in what you do and
- 58:24then use AI in everything you do and
- 58:26you'll navigate it fine. And just
- 58:28remember to go and touch grass now and
- 58:30then cuz it's a intense world out
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Raoul Pal: My Final Warning To Crypto Investors in 2027 by Altcoin Daily, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,468 words across 1,546 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.