YouTube2Text

Raoul Pal: Crypto Won’t Stop. The Next Print Skips the Fed — Transcript

by Kyle Chasse crypto · 10,104 words · 1,469 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00We're sitting there watching an AI boom
  2. 0:02going on and the NASDAQ going up every
  3. 0:04day and we're like, why can't we have
  4. 0:05nice things in crypto?
  5. 0:07So, I think it's more midcycle, much
  6. 0:09like 2020 was.
  7. 0:12Then what's going to stop this? They
  8. 0:14can't allow this AI buildout to go bust.
  9. 0:17Simply can't. And so, if we bring enough
  10. 0:19liquidity back, we will then see both
  11. 0:22the NASDAQ and crypto perform. We had a
  12. 0:27clear run for liquidity and then we had
  13. 0:28the Iran war. If they get anything close
  14. 0:31to any agreement in those, you know, the
  15. 0:33oil price over time is 30 bucks.
  16. 0:36I think the lows in my expectation is
  17. 0:39that over the next 12 months,
  18. 0:41everything's significantly higher. We're
  19. 0:43at $2 half trillion today. If you just
  20. 0:46extrapolate the log trend, you get to
  21. 0:48about 100 trillion by 2035, let's say.
  22. 0:51Looks reasonable. And have that to
  23. 0:53assume I'm an idiot. Okay, fine. So
  24. 0:56that's a 20x at 50 trillion. Right.
  25. 1:00>> Coming up, Ral Pal names the three
  26. 1:03chains that held up through the crash
  27. 1:06where billionaires keep 10 times what
  28. 1:10their homes are worth and why AI agents
  29. 1:14already outnumber us online. And again,
  30. 1:18remember, nothing in this video is
  31. 1:19financial advice. It's for educational
  32. 1:21purposes only. But first, I had to ask
  33. 1:24him, can this cycle really run all the
  34. 1:28way to 2030? [music]
  35. 1:30Ralph, welcome to the channel. It's
  36. 1:32really good to have you here. Thanks for
  37. 1:33coming on. Uh, first question is, I've
  38. 1:36heard you talk about the cycle
  39. 1:37potentially extending all the way to
  40. 1:392030, which would be absolutely
  41. 1:41fantastic. Can you walk us through what
  42. 1:43would be required and kind of your
  43. 1:44thesis behind that?
  44. 1:46>> Yeah, it depends what what we're even
  45. 1:47calling the cycle anymore, right? So,
  46. 1:49you know, everybody in crypto thinks the
  47. 1:52cycle ended, but when I look at
  48. 1:53liquidity, which is the main driver of
  49. 1:54all of this, we didn't have a liquidity
  50. 1:56cycle. We just had
  51. 1:57>> a period of lower liquidity. We did not
  52. 2:01have a liquidity withdrawal cycle or
  53. 2:03anything of that sort. So, I think it's
  54. 2:05more midcycle, much like 2020 was. Um,
  55. 2:09you remember 2019, 2020, crypto was just
  56. 2:11drifting off, drifting off because there
  57. 2:12wasn't a lot of liquidity around. Um,
  58. 2:14and that was more of a midcycle
  59. 2:16phenomena. Um, so that's where I think
  60. 2:18we are, which it doesn't really matter.
  61. 2:20It's like kind of where are we going
  62. 2:21from here?
  63. 2:22>> Yeah.
  64. 2:22>> So, we think about the cycle and what
  65. 2:25drives it. So, it's driven by the debt
  66. 2:26refinancing and the debt reinancing is
  67. 2:30is has been extended to about 5.6 years.
  68. 2:32So, it's longer than it was a few years
  69. 2:34ago. Um, but we're also seeing the
  70. 2:37Treasury now adding liquidity at the
  71. 2:39front end almost only. In fact, they're
  72. 2:41buying back the long end. So what we've
  73. 2:44got is ongoing liquidity by that
  74. 2:47measure. Um then we think about okay
  75. 2:50well what else is driven by this cycle
  76. 2:53the financing cycle is obviously the AI
  77. 2:55buildout which is the biggest capex
  78. 2:59buildout in history.
  79. 3:01And the race to do the buildout is so
  80. 3:04big and so important. In fact, it's the
  81. 3:06single most important endeavor
  82. 3:08humanity's probably ever done is build
  83. 3:10this race for intelligence
  84. 3:13that they can't stop. And if you think
  85. 3:16about capex, we've got the biggest capex
  86. 3:18cycle funded because people talk a lot
  87. 3:21of [ __ ] about these these um neo
  88. 3:24clouds and who's going to go bust.
  89. 3:25Nobody cares. It's funded by the biggest
  90. 3:29most cash generating companies that have
  91. 3:31ever existed with the highest profit
  92. 3:34margins and they've got no debt really
  93. 3:36on their balance sheet. So they're
  94. 3:37building some debts now to build this
  95. 3:40gigantic buildout. So normally if you
  96. 3:43get a buildout of this type that is
  97. 3:46going to be funded by everybody both
  98. 3:49from government liquidity but a lot of
  99. 3:51it from the banking sector which has to
  100. 3:54expand its balance sheets which the the
  101. 3:56the Fed and the Treasury have both said
  102. 3:59that they want to do. Um
  103. 4:02then what's going to stop this? So let's
  104. 4:05say they tried to remove the liquidity
  105. 4:07from the market because the CPI was a
  106. 4:09bit hot. Okay, fine. That's possible.
  107. 4:13But they can't allow this AI buildout to
  108. 4:16go bust. Simply can't. Why? Because
  109. 4:19China will then build it out. And output
  110. 4:22of intelligence per unit of energy,
  111. 4:23which is how I measure this whole thing,
  112. 4:26is doubling every 4.6 months.
  113. 4:29So if you slow down for a year, let's
  114. 4:31say the US doesn't build out any data
  115. 4:33centers, well, China's going to be ahead
  116. 4:35by 3 years in intelligence. Now, the US
  117. 4:38holds the frontier right now, but that's
  118. 4:40not always going to be the case. Yes,
  119. 4:42uh, the US got access to better chips
  120. 4:44than China does right now, but the world
  121. 4:46changes fast. So, if that would be the
  122. 4:49case, then the US can never catch up.
  123. 4:51And if the US never catches up, then
  124. 4:53China would get to ASI faster than
  125. 4:56anybody else. And ASI is an event that
  126. 4:58maybe happens in 10 years, something,
  127. 5:00whatever it is, of which you've got an
  128. 5:03intelligence so superior that it
  129. 5:05basically dominates everything and
  130. 5:07everyone. and every political system,
  131. 5:08economic system, and everything. So,
  132. 5:11I've always said that this race is the
  133. 5:12only race that can never be won and
  134. 5:14should never be won, but nobody can
  135. 5:16afford to lose it either.
  136. 5:17>> Yeah.
  137. 5:17>> Because if not, you get one system
  138. 5:19dominating the world. And regardless of
  139. 5:21your or my viewpoint, people don't want
  140. 5:24one system, and one system makes it
  141. 5:26fragile and open to abuse. So, so that's
  142. 5:29why I don't think we're going to get um
  143. 5:32a slowdown in the cycle for for a period
  144. 5:35of time. And that was very similar to
  145. 5:372000. That period leading up to it from
  146. 5:39like 96 to 2001 we saw an extended
  147. 5:42cycle. So we saw you know the ISM slow
  148. 5:44down and then pick up again. We had the
  149. 5:47market have a big correction over the
  150. 5:48Asian crisis. But really productivity
  151. 5:51picked up and if productivity picks up
  152. 5:54then the Fed don't need to raise rates
  153. 5:55because it's disinflationary because
  154. 5:58you're getting more output per manh
  155. 6:00hour. Um and we're seeing that all over
  156. 6:02the place. We're seeing it in fact like
  157. 6:04Facebook, Nvidia, all of these
  158. 6:06companies, their profits per employee
  159. 6:10are just going vertical which is
  160. 6:12productivity because they're the biggest
  161. 6:14adopters of AI to start with. So we can
  162. 6:16see the evidence everywhere that this is
  163. 6:18not likely to be a normal cycle.
  164. 6:20>> Okay. So that was a really clear case of
  165. 6:24the continued spending and AI buildout.
  166. 6:26But now can you bring that back and
  167. 6:28relate it like for the viewers? How does
  168. 6:30that actually affect us in the crypto
  169. 6:33market and why will it drive liquidity
  170. 6:35and higher prices?
  171. 6:37>> Yeah. So why does it affect us? It's
  172. 6:40becoming so okay I'm going to go back a
  173. 6:42bit. We have jumped substrate of
  174. 6:46intelligence from carbon life forms. Us
  175. 6:49animals nature all of that stuff is all
  176. 6:51carbon. And we jumped substrate to
  177. 6:54silicon.
  178. 6:56We're now putting [ __ ] electricity
  179. 6:58through sand and producing super
  180. 7:00intelligence. It's bananas, right? But
  181. 7:02that's where we are. And it's a million
  182. 7:04times faster.
  183. 7:06So the world we're moving into operates
  184. 7:08at machine speed, not human speed.
  185. 7:11And our system of money, of system of
  186. 7:15record, all of these things,
  187. 7:17identification,
  188. 7:19it all works at human speed.
  189. 7:22But the agents are the new population.
  190. 7:26So GDP growth equals population growth
  191. 7:30plus productivity growth plus debt
  192. 7:31growth. And that's been slowing for a
  193. 7:34while now as the aging population has
  194. 7:36been occurring everywhere. And
  195. 7:38productivity of old people is less than
  196. 7:40young people. But now we're about to
  197. 7:42replace those workers with new workers.
  198. 7:45And those new workers work 24 hours a
  199. 7:47day, 7 days a week, and cost virtually
  200. 7:48nothing to run. That's AI. And then
  201. 7:50we're going to put that AI in a physical
  202. 7:52form in robots and they're going to do
  203. 7:55manual labor stuff. So we're going to
  204. 7:57see a huge change.
  205. 8:00The first part of this is agents. So
  206. 8:02agents went from almost zero at the
  207. 8:05beginning of the year. People have
  208. 8:06forgotten this to now more agents on the
  209. 8:09internet than humans
  210. 8:11by next year because these are all
  211. 8:13double exponentials. Met castle law
  212. 8:14squared. We don't know the number. Is it
  213. 8:18a hundred billion agents? Is it 500
  214. 8:20billion? I have no [ __ ] clue. But the
  215. 8:23next step to this, and it started
  216. 8:25originally in January 2026,
  217. 8:28was people connected their wallets to
  218. 8:30agents. So agents can become economic
  219. 8:33participants.
  220. 8:35Now, right now, we haven't seen a
  221. 8:38massive rise yet in the amount of
  222. 8:40payments, but it's it's going up.
  223. 8:43So we've got that going on where agents
  224. 8:46can connect wallets and make payments.
  225. 8:48So that's new economic actors coming in,
  226. 8:50but they're spending very little.
  227. 8:53In the same time, we've now used this
  228. 8:55digital infrastructure of blockchain to
  229. 8:58start tokenizing stuff like equities
  230. 9:01and people are already hooking up their
  231. 9:03agents to be able to trade equities,
  232. 9:05build portfolios, do all of that stuff.
  233. 9:07And that's a more interesting part. So
  234. 9:09we got the payments part, but the
  235. 9:11investment part is huge.
  236. 9:13If you look at the tokenized equities,
  237. 9:15it's one of the purest, cleanest
  238. 9:16uptrends I've ever seen, right? And it's
  239. 9:19not going to stop. We're told by
  240. 9:20everybody everything's going to get
  241. 9:22tokenized. And all of that makes it
  242. 9:24machine readable.
  243. 9:26So, what we're building out in this AI
  244. 9:29thing for the blockchain world is new
  245. 9:32participants and new ways of using
  246. 9:33blockchain, not in the ways that we just
  247. 9:35thought. We all kind of the markets kind
  248. 9:38of thought the token was the product,
  249. 9:40you know, is my token better than yours
  250. 9:41going to and it's not. The actual layer
  251. 9:44one is the product here and the layer
  252. 9:46one is the infrastructure layer for this
  253. 9:49whole digital age for all of what's
  254. 9:51coming. So, if you're about to explode
  255. 9:53the use case of blockchain and we're not
  256. 9:56going to have a
  257. 9:59an end to this cycle soon, the
  258. 10:01likelihood is that we see vast amounts
  259. 10:04of use coming to blockchains and vast
  260. 10:06amounts of use means number go up.
  261. 10:08>> Okay. And the last question on this
  262. 10:10particular topic is how does the or does
  263. 10:14the AI capex expenditure kind of
  264. 10:17buildout affect global liquidity or
  265. 10:19liquidity that matters to our markets?
  266. 10:22Well, the government and particularly
  267. 10:25the treasuries are very aware of this.
  268. 10:27Scott Besson, somebody I've known for a
  269. 10:28very long time. He's a macro guy. So,
  270. 10:30it's very useful having a macro guy as
  271. 10:32the treasury secretary because you kind
  272. 10:34of speak the same language. And
  273. 10:35basically what he's saying is he wants
  274. 10:37productivity growth to increase so GDP
  275. 10:40debt to GDP falls because GDP should
  276. 10:42grow faster than debt growth. And that's
  277. 10:44what they did in the 1950s.
  278. 10:47And he knows the only way to do that is
  279. 10:49to create more intelligence, right?
  280. 10:52Output of intelligence per unit of
  281. 10:53energy is kind of what everything is
  282. 10:56about. And so therefore, he understands
  283. 10:59it needs to be financed. Somebody's got
  284. 11:02to have the money to pay for all the
  285. 11:04equity and all of the debt. And it can't
  286. 11:06just be Abu Dhabi and, you know, Saudi
  287. 11:09and a bunch of other big pools of
  288. 11:11capital. You need broaderbased
  289. 11:14participation. So where's this
  290. 11:16broaderbased participation? Well, it's
  291. 11:18meaning the banking sector needs to
  292. 11:20start lending because they stopped banks
  293. 11:22lending really in any meaningful way
  294. 11:24after 2008. But their bank balance
  295. 11:26sheets are repaired now. So you need
  296. 11:28them to lever up. So they changed the
  297. 11:30economic rule book on what banks should
  298. 11:32do and can do with a change called the
  299. 11:34ESLR, which means that basically banks
  300. 11:37can hold more US bonds. Great. So Scott
  301. 11:39Besson can sell more bonds to the banks.
  302. 11:41But the magic is the banks take those
  303. 11:43bonds and turn them into leverage and
  304. 11:45create money. So money can only be
  305. 11:47created by the central bank or by the
  306. 11:49banking system.
  307. 11:51>> Mhm.
  308. 11:51>> So they are going to be creating a lot
  309. 11:54more money. Now that hasn't happened yet
  310. 11:55which is why we've had this problem with
  311. 11:57liquidity. So the rules changed but the
  312. 12:00banks didn't do a lot. And the reason is
  313. 12:02why it's because the yield curve is not
  314. 12:04steep enough. So the yield curve is the
  315. 12:05difference between money you can borrow
  316. 12:08at the short end and lend at the long
  317. 12:10end. And it's been quite flat and the
  318. 12:12reason it's been flat is because of
  319. 12:14Iran. So the Iran situation forced up
  320. 12:17rates. The yield curve flattening means
  321. 12:20yeah this economic times are not great
  322. 12:22because of it. And then the dollar went
  323. 12:25up a lot as well. So those things are
  324. 12:26financial conditions. Financial
  325. 12:28conditions tighten. The banks don't want
  326. 12:29to lend massive amounts. But the moment
  327. 12:32that that situation gets resolved, what
  328. 12:35you get is a dollar that weakens, a
  329. 12:37yield curve that steepens, and then the
  330. 12:39banks start really extending money. And
  331. 12:41we've seen that again back in in the
  332. 12:43late '9s. So that's what that is what
  333. 12:48they want to happen. Kevin Walsh
  334. 12:50understands that process, too.
  335. 12:52What they've basically done is split up
  336. 12:54the yield curve and said right you
  337. 12:56hyperscalers you issue at the long end
  338. 12:59and we the treasury will issue at the
  339. 13:00short end. So that's basically how the
  340. 13:03world is structured and that is how you
  341. 13:05add liquidity into markets to fund the
  342. 13:08capex boon via the banking system.
  343. 13:10They're not going to use their own
  344. 13:11balance sheet if they can avoid it.
  345. 13:13Yeah, they're buying back some bonds and
  346. 13:14adding a bit but they're not going to do
  347. 13:15the mega, you know, 2020 thing because
  348. 13:17there's no reason to. What they're going
  349. 13:19to do is make sure that the system has a
  350. 13:22higher velocity of money and the banking
  351. 13:24system expands and that flows through to
  352. 13:27what's known as excess liquidity. So
  353. 13:29that's liquidity growth in excess of
  354. 13:31GDP, i.e. there's liquidity spare. You
  355. 13:34don't need it for general economic
  356. 13:36growth. That's when you can see
  357. 13:38liquidity then go further out the risk
  358. 13:40curve into things like crypto because
  359. 13:42right now if you give them one choice,
  360. 13:44everybody will take intelligence over
  361. 13:46crypto.
  362. 13:48So there's a hor higher ROI right now.
  363. 13:51Doesn't mean it performs better in price
  364. 13:52when you get liquidity. Crypto has that
  365. 13:54convexity to it. But if you've got
  366. 13:56enough liquidity, it then seeps out to
  367. 13:58the other things. So it's not just in
  368. 13:59AI. So we've seen this, you know, we're
  369. 14:01sitting there watching an AI boom going
  370. 14:03on and the NASDAQ going up every day and
  371. 14:05we're like, why can't we have nice
  372. 14:06things in crypto? Um that's a function
  373. 14:09of not enough liquidity in the system.
  374. 14:11And we've seen that in the stock market
  375. 14:12itself. it's only um the hyperscalers
  376. 14:16and anybody in the crypto tra in the um
  377. 14:19AI trade that's done well. Every other
  378. 14:21company is like five year four year lows
  379. 14:23or something in comparison. So they've
  380. 14:25seen a very similar situation
  381. 14:27everywhere. And that's that's a
  382. 14:29liquidity situation. So if we bring
  383. 14:31enough liquidity back and excess
  384. 14:32liquidity picks up, we will then see
  385. 14:35both the NASDAQ and crypto perform.
  386. 14:40the things that you described before
  387. 14:42like the Iran war get kind of getting in
  388. 14:43the way affecting yields uh making a
  389. 14:46stronger dollar, increasing the price of
  390. 14:48oil. This was all done already under a
  391. 14:52full uh red or Republican Congress and
  392. 14:56president. Now we have a full Democratic
  393. 15:00Democrat Congress
  394. 15:02with Trump still in the White House. Do
  395. 15:04you think how do you think this might
  396. 15:06change things and do you think it will
  397. 15:07affect liquidity at all, spending or
  398. 15:09anything like that?
  399. 15:12>> I don't think so. I mean, Texas made it
  400. 15:14pretty clear. They campaigned on strong
  401. 15:17rhetoric and then backed off the
  402. 15:18rhetoric almost immediately. Right? So,
  403. 15:21they've said, "Look, look, we won't do
  404. 15:22anything with all the data centers we've
  405. 15:24agreed. Just keep building, guys." And
  406. 15:25then it's like, "Actually, Elon's really
  407. 15:27good and we want him here and all of
  408. 15:29this stuff. There's no way they can stop
  409. 15:31this buildout because you're going to
  410. 15:33hand it to the Chinese." It's not people
  411. 15:34aren't stupid. So, they might campaign
  412. 15:37on it, but what they do is a different
  413. 15:39matter. But let's assume it's the power
  414. 15:41grid that's the issue um that they don't
  415. 15:44want electricity prices to go up. Good.
  416. 15:46They shouldn't and they need to solve
  417. 15:48it. So, how do you solve it? You force
  418. 15:50the hyperscalers and everybody else to
  419. 15:52build their own electricity. So, that
  420. 15:54means solar, that means gas turbines.
  421. 15:57Now there's issues in the supply chain
  422. 15:59with all of that but um they will just
  423. 16:02change the routting of electricity. Um
  424. 16:05yeah so it's done it's built on site
  425. 16:09that's fine. Now if any state wants to
  426. 16:11stop it another state will take it cuz
  427. 16:12it's a lot of jobs you know plumbers
  428. 16:14electricians you know everybody there's
  429. 16:17a lot of jobs in this and I can't
  430. 16:20imagine they want to shoot themselves in
  431. 16:21the foot.
  432. 16:23We had Michael Howell on here a few
  433. 16:25weeks ago and he was saying there was a
  434. 16:26coidsized debt uh wave of debt coming
  435. 16:31four years in a row and he thinks
  436. 16:34Bitcoin may take one or more hits in
  437. 16:382027 cuz he thinks that this comes the
  438. 16:40tail end of 2027 and then he thinks it
  439. 16:43goes way up from there. Do you agree
  440. 16:45with Michael or where do you see that?
  441. 16:47Look, it's it's almost impossible to
  442. 16:49tell because we had a clear run for
  443. 16:50liquidity and then we had the Iran war.
  444. 16:53>> Yeah.
  445. 16:53>> And at the end of last year, end of
  446. 16:552025,
  447. 16:58we thought there was a clear run and
  448. 17:00then you have a government shutdown
  449. 17:01twice. So, you don't you never actually
  450. 17:04know. You know what it should be and um
  451. 17:07it depends what they do with liquidity
  452. 17:10in the interim, what happens to the
  453. 17:12dollar, what happens to rates. uh and
  454. 17:15then you know how easy it is or how hard
  455. 17:16it is to finance the debt. So, I don't
  456. 17:19necessarily agree with Mike, but not
  457. 17:21saying he's wrong either. I'm like, we
  458. 17:23don't really know. We know that they
  459. 17:25need more liquidity and it's not come
  460. 17:28through yet and we know what the
  461. 17:29preconditions are for that. Let's wait
  462. 17:31and see. And basically, for anybody at
  463. 17:33home, just look at the dollar. You know,
  464. 17:35is the dollar going lower or higher? And
  465. 17:38it's been in this kind of corrective up
  466. 17:40channel for a while. It got to the top
  467. 17:42of the channel. It's dropped down a bit,
  468. 17:44but it's not made a decisive move yet.
  469. 17:46If it starts going up from here, yeah,
  470. 17:48we're pretty [ __ ] Um, you know, we're
  471. 17:50going to have a bigger slowdown than we
  472. 17:51expected. The economy will slow down.
  473. 17:54Um, but that normally would mean then we
  474. 17:56got rate cuts in 2027. But yes, we'd
  475. 17:58then go through a bad period. So, the
  476. 17:59economy for sure slows down somewhat in
  477. 18:03early 207 just based on the financial
  478. 18:06conditions that tightened earlier this
  479. 18:08year. Guys, real quick. As you can see,
  480. 18:11as we get more support from you guys,
  481. 18:13the viewers, more comments, more
  482. 18:15subscribers, more likes, the channel
  483. 18:17grows and we are able to get bigger and
  484. 18:19bigger guests on the channel. Ral Pal is
  485. 18:23here. This is [music] a long time in the
  486. 18:25works. So, I know that a lot of you guys
  487. 18:28who watch this channel are still not
  488. 18:30subscribed, [music] and if you could do
  489. 18:33me a small favor and please hit that
  490. 18:35subscribe button, it would mean the
  491. 18:36world to me. It really does help the
  492. 18:39channel oh so much and the more access
  493. 18:42we get, the more knowledge we get, the
  494. 18:44more I can bring to you guys. So, thank
  495. 18:47you for being here and let's get back to
  496. 18:49the interview. I I know it's really hard
  497. 18:51to predict, but how do you expect the
  498. 18:54kind of the next 6 months to play out
  499. 18:56for crypto? Do you think do you do you
  500. 18:58think the four-year cyclers have any any
  501. 19:00validity in this? meaning that we have
  502. 19:02seen a the bottom kind of in July or
  503. 19:04maybe maybe it comes this quarter and
  504. 19:06then that you know if it kind of follows
  505. 19:08historical patterns we would see things
  506. 19:09moving back up around the end of the
  507. 19:11year January February something like
  508. 19:13that look I think crypto bottomed in in
  509. 19:16July that was the last time I added um I
  510. 19:19think it bottomed um and I think it's
  511. 19:21basing and you know as I said there's a
  512. 19:24couple of prerequisites for this to
  513. 19:25start moving from here if not it's not
  514. 19:27going to move for a while um you know if
  515. 19:30they start tightening liquidity, which I
  516. 19:32don't see a reason why they should, then
  517. 19:34we've got more problems. But if it stays
  518. 19:36kind of sanguin like this, it's going to
  519. 19:37slop around for a bit, which is
  520. 19:39frustrating for everybody. It's a
  521. 19:40miserable market, but it is what it what
  522. 19:42it is. Um, but I just don't think that
  523. 19:45persists for particularly long. I really
  524. 19:47don't. You know, I think we've got, you
  525. 19:48know, it's very interesting to see
  526. 19:50negotiations on Ukraine, Russia going on
  527. 19:53just about right now. And they're still
  528. 19:56trying to figure out what's the out for
  529. 19:58the Iran situation. If they get anything
  530. 20:00close to any agreement in those, you
  531. 20:03know, the oil price over time is 30
  532. 20:04bucks. It solves a lot of problems and
  533. 20:07you know, the dollar weakens in that
  534. 20:08environment and um rates come down a
  535. 20:10lot. So the prize is very big to get
  536. 20:12this right for everybody involved a in
  537. 20:14the AI trade because energy is one of
  538. 20:17the inputs. You're you're turning that
  539. 20:19into intelligence. So, you know, there's
  540. 20:23a lot of ways this can play out, but we
  541. 20:25it's just not 100% clear yet. But I'm
  542. 20:28yeah I think the I think the lows in my
  543. 20:30expectation is that you know over the
  544. 20:33next 12 months everything's
  545. 20:35significantly higher.
  546. 20:37>> So let's [clears throat] talk about
  547. 20:39positioning then. And uh yeah, we won't
  548. 20:42try to call it top or bottom right now,
  549. 20:44but um you I heard you say earlier that
  550. 20:46you think L1's capture I don't know if
  551. 20:48it's I don't know if the right word is
  552. 20:49capture the value or or what you said,
  553. 20:51but I I do believe that your thesis is
  554. 20:52that L1's will outperform Bitcoin and
  555. 20:54and I guess most other things in the
  556. 20:57next run. Can you extrapolate on that a
  557. 20:59little bit?
  558. 20:59>> Do they necessarily outperform some
  559. 21:01applications layer? Because what we're
  560. 21:03seeing is the rise of the applications
  561. 21:04layer where these are businesses that
  562. 21:07have cash flows and they've done well
  563. 21:09and some of them are persistent and will
  564. 21:11last a long time. Others fail after a
  565. 21:15while but they they capture attention
  566. 21:16but we're seeing the rise of businesses
  567. 21:18built on blockchain. Hyperlquid is a
  568. 21:20great example. Yes, it's a layer one but
  569. 21:21really it's a specific domain. Okay,
  570. 21:25great. So, how do you capture the
  571. 21:27[clears throat] bulk of economic
  572. 21:28activity that's about to happen? Well,
  573. 21:30stable coins, um, real world asset
  574. 21:33tokenization, equity tokenization, all
  575. 21:36of this agent ID, all of this is
  576. 21:38blockchain stuff and it's all layer 1
  577. 21:40stuff. Now, some of them may be built on
  578. 21:43layer 2, base, Robin Hood, etc. But the
  579. 21:46whole of a layer 2 is secured by the
  580. 21:49layer 1. So, how I think about this is
  581. 21:52ETH is the best example. Let's say you
  582. 21:54could magically turn off ETH today.
  583. 21:58How much is E ETH worth? Is it the
  584. 22:00whatever the number is 300 billion today
  585. 22:03or is it more? Well, you'd shut down
  586. 22:05every layer 2,
  587. 22:0870% of all um stable coins,
  588. 22:1270% of all of DeFi, the digital art
  589. 22:16market, most of the real world asset
  590. 22:17tokeniz. I mean, the whole [ __ ] lot,
  591. 22:20right? And if you just give it like
  592. 22:21let's say threeyear forward um valuation
  593. 22:25on what that lot's worth, I don't know,
  594. 22:28call it a trillion, call it one and a
  595. 22:29half trillion. It's certainly not 300
  596. 22:32billion, right? That's the value of ETH.
  597. 22:35And so it's the infrastructure layer.
  598. 22:37The agents will use the layer ones
  599. 22:39because they're programmable, they're
  600. 22:40fast, they're smart to be able to do the
  601. 22:43things that they need to do. Now whether
  602. 22:44that's payments or whether it's the
  603. 22:47equities that get tokenized that they
  604. 22:49will do the investing in um all of that
  605. 22:52stuff that's all being built out right
  606. 22:54now. It's layer one stuff is where the
  607. 22:56value occurs cuz it's the infrastructure
  608. 22:58layer and that's why it's an easier bet.
  609. 23:01you know, if not, you're picking small
  610. 23:02caps. Um, and you need to know what
  611. 23:05you're doing. Is, you know, XYZ
  612. 23:07application layer built on a layer 2
  613. 23:10going to get enough customers and enough
  614. 23:12revenue to win over the long term or
  615. 23:14not? I don't know. That's pretty hard.
  616. 23:15Single stock picking to outperform an
  617. 23:18index, pretty hard. Um, but the layer
  618. 23:20one basket of layer ones, you're going
  619. 23:23to get it right. Simple as that.
  620. 23:28I know that you're uh I don't know if
  621. 23:30you're on the what I don't know what
  622. 23:32your role is at SU exactly. I don't know
  623. 23:33if you're chairman on the board.
  624. 23:34>> No, I'm just I'm on the board of the
  625. 23:36foundation.
  626. 23:37>> Okay. Um so you're biased. I am too
  627. 23:39because I is no other foundation I've
  628. 23:42had a chance to get closer with. So
  629. 23:44everyone watching, take that with a
  630. 23:45grain of salt.
  631. 23:46curious to get your thoughts on Suie and
  632. 23:49um I'm just going to paraphrase a
  633. 23:52criticism that I heard recently and try
  634. 23:54to get your take on it because another
  635. 23:55thing I had made I just recorded another
  636. 23:57show right before I got on with you and
  637. 24:00uh one of the things I brought to
  638. 24:01people's attention was I think that
  639. 24:03we're still very early because I've
  640. 24:04heard a lot of people say that the
  641. 24:05pretty the layer one race is pretty much
  642. 24:07done that you've got like ETH and maybe
  643. 24:08Salana um but in fact if you ask people
  644. 24:12like what real world application is is
  645. 24:14built that as the mass adopted today and
  646. 24:17I think the answer is like zero besides
  647. 24:19maybe maybe a store of value for bitcoin
  648. 24:21and even then
  649. 24:22>> maybe stable coins still very early it's
  650. 24:24still small
  651. 24:25>> yeah so it's so it's not it's nothing
  652. 24:27and then I use this example too of like
  653. 24:28okay imagine you know huge platform like
  654. 24:31I don't know let's say a a tinder or
  655. 24:33something like that that 70 80 million
  656. 24:34users were adopt one of these uh infra
  657. 24:37uh ones and use it for all the
  658. 24:38transactions for everything like that
  659. 24:40chain would instantly become one of the
  660. 24:42most used chains in the world just by
  661. 24:43transaction volume um So I think it's
  662. 24:45still really early, but when it comes
  663. 24:47down to SU specifically, uh what keeps
  664. 24:49you super bullish despite so far the
  665. 24:53lack at least that we know publicly kind
  666. 24:55of lack of use cases and apps on it.
  667. 25:00>> Um for the same reason I'm bullish on
  668. 25:02the whole space.
  669. 25:04The TAM the total addressable market of
  670. 25:06crypto used to be humans,
  671. 25:10right? Number of humans. So if you look
  672. 25:12at the internet, crypto and internet
  673. 25:13adoption are pretty much the same speed.
  674. 25:16So play out and you get to about 5
  675. 25:18billion, six billion and then you kind
  676. 25:20of tap out because the rest are people
  677. 25:23who don't have internet access, etc. Um
  678. 25:27but now with agents and where we're
  679. 25:29going, we've got an infinite tan and
  680. 25:32these these new inhabitants of
  681. 25:35cryptoland are operate at machine speed
  682. 25:38as I said before. So you're going to
  683. 25:40need infrastructure layer that can do
  684. 25:43that
  685. 25:45and SU is almost purposely built for
  686. 25:48this because it is incredibly fast,
  687. 25:51incredibly cheap um and it is highly
  688. 25:55programmable, more so than pretty much
  689. 25:56any other chain. So that gives you
  690. 26:02a likelihood that they will get um agent
  691. 26:05activity at scale over time if they do
  692. 26:08the right things and build out the
  693. 26:09ecosystem and if you know there's a lot
  694. 26:11of ifs there because it's it's new and
  695. 26:13it's young. Salana's been doing a
  696. 26:16fantastic job same way and they're
  697. 26:18saying to says the same thing all the
  698. 26:20time faster cheaper you know that's the
  699. 26:23way to go and even Vitalik's been saying
  700. 26:25the same thing. So we do have a two-
  701. 26:27horse race right now, but the game is
  702. 26:30look at every cloud provider, every
  703. 26:33email provider, I mean pretty much any
  704. 26:35infrastructure product that we all use.
  705. 26:39Um it comes down to there's usually
  706. 26:42five, four or five that dominate 85% of
  707. 26:46everything and then there's a tail and
  708. 26:49so we only have two.
  709. 26:52So there's a good bet there to be had.
  710. 26:54Okay. What are the what are the other
  711. 26:56three going to be? Could it be Suie on
  712. 26:59paper? Yeah, very much looks like it
  713. 27:01should be. Um, could it be could Near
  714. 27:05have a place within that? Yeah,
  715. 27:06possibly. Could it be Avalanche? Poss. I
  716. 27:09don't know. I don't know. But you know
  717. 27:12my focus is on this intelligence
  718. 27:14buildout and SUI has more intelligence
  719. 27:19um built within its blockchain than than
  720. 27:22in a slot of his blockchain than anybody
  721. 27:24else. So it has a much higher chance to
  722. 27:26me. Um and also when I look at I look at
  723. 27:29a measure called economic density is how
  724. 27:31much economic activity or TVL per user
  725. 27:34is there um per chain and how consistent
  726. 27:38is that? Now, ETH dwarfs everybody.
  727. 27:42>> Yeah.
  728. 27:43>> Um, and because, you know, it's been so
  729. 27:45good at what it's done. It was the first
  730. 27:48uh and
  731. 27:50SW held up its economic density when the
  732. 27:52price fell 80%. Others didn't. Stuff
  733. 27:54like Avalanche didn't. They collapsed,
  734. 27:56but Su held up. In fact, only really
  735. 27:58three chains held up, which was um
  736. 28:02Salana, ETH, and SUI. So, there there's
  737. 28:05economic signal there that it's very
  738. 28:07sticky. there 70% staking, you know,
  739. 28:10there's a stickiness around to this that
  740. 28:13that is interesting. Uh, and let's see
  741. 28:15when Hashi comes online and stuff like
  742. 28:17that. It should build a lot of TVL and
  743. 28:20ignite the system. So, we'll have to
  744. 28:21wait and see. Um, you know, it's a
  745. 28:24riskier bet, so people have to realize
  746. 28:26that, but you know, Ethan Salana is very
  747. 28:29straightforward.
  748. 28:30>> Ashley is the native Bitcoin on Sui,
  749. 28:32right?
  750. 28:33>> That's right. And it allows Bitcoin to
  751. 28:36go in a very
  752. 28:39easy, safe manner um to be used as
  753. 28:43collateral. So you can do Bitcoin
  754. 28:45lending and borrowing without some of
  755. 28:46the clunkiness of how this is being
  756. 28:48sorted out right now.
  757. 28:49>> Yeah,
  758. 28:50>> that's an onchain solution.
  759. 28:51>> That is something I'm very much looking
  760. 28:53forward to. I've used a for a long time
  761. 28:54to sometimes borrow against my Bitcoin.
  762. 28:56And you know, you you had smart contract
  763. 28:59risk with a to start with, which is kind
  764. 29:01of scary in today's age of mythos and AI
  765. 29:04exploits, but then you add another layer
  766. 29:05of, you know, risk wrapping the Bitcoin
  767. 29:08and WBTC. So, um, yeah, something I'm
  768. 29:11looking forward to come out there for
  769. 29:12sure.
  770. 29:13Do you know when it comes out?
  771. 29:15>> It's very soon. It's very soon. Um,
  772. 29:19yeah, not sure the exact date, but it's
  773. 29:21very, very soon. Yeah. matter of weeks.
  774. 29:23I think
  775. 29:25>> one of the things that surprised me
  776. 29:26about you, Ral, is I think I believe uh
  777. 29:28let me know if I'm wrong on this, but I
  778. 29:29think that you're starting a digital
  779. 29:31digital art fund. Is that right?
  780. 29:33>> Yeah.
  781. 29:34>> All right. So, we got to talk about this
  782. 29:35because uh my the question I was going
  783. 29:38to ask and then this came to my mind too
  784. 29:40was first let's talk I want to know how
  785. 29:44your portfolio is diversified whether
  786. 29:46it's real estate, stocks, bonds, cash,
  787. 29:50crypto. Um just like how are you how do
  788. 29:53you diversify your your investment
  789. 29:54portfolio?
  790. 29:55>> So none of my real estate is an
  791. 29:57investment. That's my life.
  792. 29:59>> You live in it.
  793. 30:00>> Yeah.
  794. 30:00>> I live in it now live in it all the
  795. 30:02time. Um but those are my things. That's
  796. 30:05my lifestyle. So I don't think of real
  797. 30:07estate as an investment. And every time
  798. 30:09I've tried to make real estate
  799. 30:10investments, I've lost money. But every
  800. 30:12time I've bought a nice home, a place I
  801. 30:15want to use, it makes money. So I just,
  802. 30:17you know, so I don't think of it like
  803. 30:18that. So, you know, investments are
  804. 30:21mainly in crypto. Um, I have um, you
  805. 30:25know, tech equities as well. Um, and
  806. 30:28then I have a big digital art collection
  807. 30:30which is crypto in its own, but it's a
  808. 30:32it's a it's a different bet and a longer
  809. 30:34term bet. And that's basically my whole
  810. 30:36investment portfolio. I don't do VC
  811. 30:38investing really. Um, because I don't
  812. 30:40know what I'm doing. Everything that I
  813. 30:42think looks amazing generally is [ __ ]
  814. 30:44and everything I think is looks [ __ ] is
  815. 30:46amazing. So, I'm just not, you know, I'm
  816. 30:48a macro guy, so I just I keep it simple.
  817. 30:51>> Yeah. It's okay. So, now I just want to
  818. 30:53understand the digital art thesis a
  819. 30:54little bit more because most people
  820. 30:56watching this, myself included, when we
  821. 30:58think about digital art, we think about
  822. 30:59NFTTS and we think about how that boom
  823. 31:01and bust cycle happens. And I'm curious
  824. 31:03to get your thought on like how the
  825. 31:05future of digital art plays out and what
  826. 31:07kind of brings interest back uh into
  827. 31:10that realm. So, everybody thinks about
  828. 31:13the PFP craze and looks in their wallet
  829. 31:15from a bunch of [ __ ] that they bought
  830. 31:16that went to zero and they got really
  831. 31:18excited about and everyone was putting,
  832. 31:20you know, WGMI and, you know, all of
  833. 31:23that [ __ ] on the timeline. That was a
  834. 31:25moment in time. Um, and you know, crypto
  835. 31:28loves to speedrun and test technology
  836. 31:31like memecoins have done as well. And
  837. 31:33so, we did it with NFTs, which are
  838. 31:35digital contracts, amazing things that
  839. 31:37you can store stuff in. And um
  840. 31:41out of that came some artists, not just
  841. 31:45PFP stuff. Some PFP stuff has potential
  842. 31:49long-term value. Crypto Punks being
  843. 31:51obviously the main one. Um but that
  844. 31:55Mickey Mouse bought the IP rights to and
  845. 31:57has now built a whole digital arts um
  846. 32:00sort of foundation around this stuff.
  847. 32:04So what is art? Right?
  848. 32:06Art is cultural memory.
  849. 32:10It's the memory of the times, the
  850. 32:12observation of the times that we live
  851. 32:13in. So Warhol was the ' 60s and ' 70s.
  852. 32:17You had the the artists at the turn of
  853. 32:20the of the 1900s in Paris, you know,
  854. 32:23impressionists, all of that. That was
  855. 32:25the culture of the times represented
  856. 32:27into art. Then art jumped substrate.
  857. 32:31Yes, we've had, you know, digital
  858. 32:34digital stuff. Um but it didn't have it
  859. 32:38was hard to give it value because it
  860. 32:39didn't have blockchain which creates
  861. 32:41digital scarcity but really it jumps it
  862. 32:43jumped substrates to the streets with
  863. 32:46Basat and Banksy. So we've gone from
  864. 32:50canvas to the streets and then we jump
  865. 32:53to the digital streets. Why? It's
  866. 32:56because that's where our culture is.
  867. 32:58That's what's happening. And so what it
  868. 33:01does is if you think of
  869. 33:04culture, what what does that mean? So if
  870. 33:07I think about I was in London in the
  871. 33:09late '9s, right? That was an early
  872. 33:112000s. London was like the single place
  873. 33:13to be. And that's where Banksy comes
  874. 33:15from, Damen Hurst comes from famous
  875. 33:17artists. Blur, Oasis, the music was
  876. 33:20happening, the nightclubs were
  877. 33:21happening, the whole athera scene was,
  878. 33:22everything was happening in London. Now
  879. 33:25what of that has value? My memories? No.
  880. 33:28my concert tickets, my nightclub
  881. 33:30tickets, the the receipts I had from the
  882. 33:34you know buying bowls of champagne in
  883. 33:36some night has no value. Vinyl records
  884. 33:40well maybe a hundred bucks if you got a
  885. 33:42rare one. So all of that I want to
  886. 33:47remember and I want to say I was part of
  887. 33:50and I understood that where does it all
  888. 33:52flow through? It flows into the art. Art
  889. 33:55is upstream of all wealth and it's where
  890. 33:57culture gets canonized.
  891. 34:00Okay, great. And it becomes immensely
  892. 34:02valuable. So if we think about Warhol,
  893. 34:04why is Warhol so valuable? It's a
  894. 34:07compaction and compression of all of the
  895. 34:09times of the 60s and 70s. That's the
  896. 34:12Rolling Stones and David Bowie and Lou
  897. 34:14Reed and everything that happened and
  898. 34:15New York City and Studio 54 and all of
  899. 34:18that compresses into a piece of art
  900. 34:20which is Warhole and it's ultra scarce.
  901. 34:23And if you're a rich baby boomer, you
  902. 34:25really want to own that because that was
  903. 34:27that was your hero days. And it's the
  904. 34:30same with Damian Hurse. It's the same
  905. 34:31with Banksy. It's the same with all of
  906. 34:33this stuff. So, let's go to now. Now,
  907. 34:36we've got
  908. 34:38the largest, fastest pace of change in
  909. 34:40all of human history. We're about to
  910. 34:42replace ourselves as Apex intelligence
  911. 34:45with this new intelligence.
  912. 34:47This period of art coming onto
  913. 34:49blockchain which was what 2017
  914. 34:53to today is a very scarce moment in time
  915. 34:56where humans are creating the digital
  916. 34:58art
  917. 34:59after that becomes more AI than humans.
  918. 35:02But but anyway they are recording this
  919. 35:06moment and it matters to a lot of
  920. 35:08people. If you think about a big
  921. 35:10cultural moment was COVID, we all went
  922. 35:13from being in offices doing all this
  923. 35:14stuff to being at home and talking to
  924. 35:16each other online. It was like a massive
  925. 35:18change. In fact, the world was never the
  926. 35:20same again. Maybe went back to offices.
  927. 35:21All of this stuff changed. And that was
  928. 35:24all recorded
  929. 35:26and it was recorded by artists like Bele
  930. 35:29who shows up every single day and
  931. 35:31creates a piece of art. Doesn't sell all
  932. 35:33of them. He doesn't purposely sell them.
  933. 35:35He sells few. So, it's scarce. But he
  934. 35:37recorded that and there's no coincidence
  935. 35:39that over that period the people
  936. 35:41everyday piece with the 5,000 everydays
  937. 35:43sold for $69 million. Now he's sold
  938. 35:46several pieces of art over 5 million
  939. 35:48bucks even recently [snorts] because
  940. 35:50he's there recording this change and he
  941. 35:53does it in interesting ways like he's
  942. 35:55even built robots with the heads of the
  943. 35:58you know whether it's people from the
  944. 35:59art industry or from technology industry
  945. 36:01and I've got one of those robots. Um, so
  946. 36:04it's all about an observation of what is
  947. 36:06happening. Then you got XCopy. XCOP is
  948. 36:09an anonymous British artist much like
  949. 36:12Banksy that started
  950. 36:16on the digital streets early with Tumblr
  951. 36:18until it became um until he saw
  952. 36:21blockchain and he was very early and he
  953. 36:24was commenting on digital culture UK
  954. 36:27life all of this stuff very banksy yes
  955. 36:29but with this glitch art become
  956. 36:31immensely valuable you know one of ones
  957. 36:33of his trade for from $600,000 to I
  958. 36:37don't know 5 million us
  959. 36:40and then you've got a bunch of other
  960. 36:41artists
  961. 36:42and they're all acrewing value. So
  962. 36:44outside of all the noise that people
  963. 36:46think about about these PFPs, we're
  964. 36:48seeing multi-billionaires coming into
  965. 36:51the space. We're seeing a new rise of
  966. 36:54collectors coming into the space. People
  967. 36:55who just buy the art and hoard it. So
  968. 36:58it's gone from the marketplace. So the
  969. 37:01scarce art that's highly sought after
  970. 37:04that has social consensus that is the
  971. 37:06measure of the culture of our times.
  972. 37:09Now as we and there's two sides of it
  973. 37:13for me. One is this cultural side. The
  974. 37:16other is commenting on where the
  975. 37:17technology is. So there's a bunch of
  976. 37:18artists using cutting edge technology to
  977. 37:20make art. That's amazing too. That's a
  978. 37:23record of what's happening, the changes
  979. 37:24we go through. So when blockchain goes
  980. 37:28up in value over time, we're at $2 half
  981. 37:30trillion today. If you just extrapolate
  982. 37:33the log trend, you get to about 100
  983. 37:35trillion by 2035, let's say, you're
  984. 37:37going to generate $97 trillion of
  985. 37:39wealth. Let's have that because I'm an
  986. 37:41idiot. You get to $50 trillion of new
  987. 37:44wealth. Well, upstream of all wealth is
  988. 37:48art. It always is. So the average
  989. 37:51multi-billionaire has no more than five
  990. 37:53houses because they're paying the ass to
  991. 37:54manage.
  992. 37:55>> Yeah.
  993. 37:56>> But they have more than 10 times the
  994. 37:58value of their houses in art.
  995. 37:59>> Wow.
  996. 38:00>> Because it's a great store of wealth.
  997. 38:02Always has been, always will be because
  998. 38:04humans cover this stuff. Um and it has
  999. 38:07prestige and it's a store of value and
  1000. 38:09it's transportable and all of the things
  1001. 38:11that make it very special and it acts as
  1002. 38:13collateral. You can borrow against it
  1003. 38:14which you can in digital art too.
  1004. 38:18So the probability of this art going up
  1005. 38:20a lot in value is very high. As wealth
  1006. 38:23comes in, it flows into owning the art
  1007. 38:26to flex, to store value, all of this
  1008. 38:28stuff. And art is really interesting in
  1009. 38:31um crypto.
  1010. 38:33If you go back to why did all the
  1011. 38:36Chinese, the Indians, the Kazakhstan,
  1012. 38:39all of these guys buy so much
  1013. 38:40contemporary art,
  1014. 38:42they bought it because they're weak
  1015. 38:44currencies. So, you buy something in
  1016. 38:46dollars first. You buy the dollars and
  1017. 38:48then you think, where do I park my
  1018. 38:49dollars? Do I put it in tea bills? Do I
  1019. 38:52buy real estate? Yeah, they all did,
  1020. 38:55tons of it. And do I buy art and they
  1021. 38:58all bought a ton of art. And then what
  1022. 39:01happened is the art and the real estate
  1023. 39:02went up in dollar terms and their
  1024. 39:05currencies and the dollar went up versus
  1025. 39:07their currencies. They made a double
  1026. 39:08kicker. Great investment. So here we are
  1027. 39:12living in dollar world and we get to put
  1028. 39:15it into ETH world and ETH world over
  1029. 39:18time has outperformed dollar and then
  1030. 39:20we're looking for the scarcest thing to
  1031. 39:22own in ETH world like the real estate on
  1032. 39:26Central Park right that's what we're
  1033. 39:27looking for or the warhole so we got
  1034. 39:30digital art the most valuable piece of
  1035. 39:32block space ever sold was the people
  1036. 39:35it's the scarcest most valuable real
  1037. 39:37estate in the whole of ETH world if if
  1038. 39:39you choose the right pieces. Now, that's
  1039. 39:41a you know, you got to figure that bit
  1040. 39:43out as well. It's not easy. Um, and so
  1041. 39:46therefore, you get art going up from,
  1042. 39:49let's say, something's valued at 10, it
  1043. 39:50goes up to 50 E. You get the 5x
  1044. 39:52multiplier. And ETH goes from $25,000
  1045. 39:57to $10,000. That's a 4x multiplier.
  1046. 40:01That's a [ __ ] amount [ __ ] ton amount of
  1047. 40:03returns. People don't get the convexity
  1048. 40:05of this.
  1049. 40:06>> That's true.
  1050. 40:08for those who cuz like I'm one of them
  1051. 40:11who would have no idea. I I
  1052. 40:12>> it's a lot of fun. It's full of nice
  1053. 40:14people. It's really interesting. You get
  1054. 40:15to meet amazing artists, uh people from
  1055. 40:18around the world. It's it's it's an
  1056. 40:20extraordinary community. So just real
  1057. 40:23quick for those who are watching who
  1058. 40:24might be interested in in kind of
  1059. 40:26exploring that for the first time you I
  1060. 40:28don't think there's I don't know are
  1061. 40:29there art tools like uh like DeFi Llama
  1062. 40:31and things that you know GMGN that you
  1063. 40:33might look for for new tokens launching
  1064. 40:35and we know how to analyze that pretty
  1065. 40:36good and look for startups there but
  1066. 40:39>> I wouldn't I would not try and look for
  1067. 40:42speculation. You want to look for social
  1068. 40:44consensus. It's the same idea that we
  1069. 40:46had with ETH and Salana. It's like the
  1070. 40:49social consensus. It has use.
  1071. 40:52>> Find artists that have use people like
  1072. 40:55that that have demand from the right
  1073. 40:58people that are held away. So XCOPY has
  1074. 41:00a great structure where you can get
  1075. 41:01these one of ones that are super rare,
  1076. 41:03but he's also got larger series. So it's
  1077. 41:05a nice rabbit hole to go down. Then you
  1078. 41:08there's a on Twitter there's 24 hours of
  1079. 41:10art written by a friend of mine, Roger
  1080. 41:12Dickman. That's a way for people to just
  1081. 41:14learn about what's happening in the art
  1082. 41:15world. Don't treat it like a speculation
  1083. 41:17thing. treat of it like this is an asset
  1084. 41:21I should own going into the economic
  1085. 41:23singularity when we don't know how the
  1086. 41:24world works and it's going to remain
  1087. 41:27valuable. So what we're looking here is
  1088. 41:28a long-term store of wealth. Um we're
  1089. 41:32not looking for how do I flip this? It
  1090. 41:34doesn't it's that's not it's not the
  1091. 41:36market for that. It doesn't work.
  1092. 41:37There's not enough participants in it to
  1093. 41:40do that 2020 2021 all over again and
  1094. 41:42nobody actually wants that.
  1095. 41:44>> Yeah. Okay. So [clears throat] assuming
  1096. 41:47that
  1097. 41:50things don't go horribly wrong with this
  1098. 41:52Iran war and and throwing things off
  1099. 41:53track, I I know that you guys do a lot
  1100. 41:55of research at Global Macro Investor and
  1101. 41:57you've probably
  1102. 41:59made some assumptions on total crypto
  1103. 42:02market cap and kind of how high things
  1104. 42:04go by 2030 because that's your kind of
  1105. 42:06timeline. Where do we get by 2030? How
  1106. 42:09high is Bitcoin? How high is ETH? What's
  1107. 42:11the total crypto market cap? Every time
  1108. 42:12you make a prediction online, somebody
  1109. 42:14throws it in your face. So, it's not
  1110. 42:15worth doing. But what what you know is
  1111. 42:18like I've said, listen, 100 trillion by
  1112. 42:202035
  1113. 42:22looks reasonable.
  1114. 42:24>> Um, and have that to assume I'm an
  1115. 42:27idiot. Okay, fine. So, that's a 20x
  1116. 42:3350 trillion, right? Okay. So, there's a
  1117. 42:3520x there. Then you need to work out
  1118. 42:38okay what is the what is the component
  1119. 42:41parts of the market how big is Bitcoin
  1120. 42:43where is it Bitcoin dominance versus
  1121. 42:44smart contracts I don't know but I
  1122. 42:48imagine that
  1123. 42:50Bitcoin dominance is lower rather than
  1124. 42:53higher because you're putting the
  1125. 42:55financial system on smart contracts and
  1126. 42:57that's a big [ __ ] beast.
  1127. 43:00>> Yeah.
  1128. 43:00>> Right. This is a multihundreds of
  1129. 43:02trillions of dollar beast that is coming
  1130. 43:04on chain slowly but surely.
  1131. 43:08But you know in the next 10 years, how
  1132. 43:09much of it will be on chain? Well, a lot
  1133. 43:12more than today. It won't be all of it.
  1134. 43:14Still not. Definitely not cuz there's
  1135. 43:15too many monopolies and incumbents and
  1136. 43:18all of that stuff. So, you know, it's
  1137. 43:20pretty easy math to get to high numbers.
  1138. 43:23And then the question is is, you know,
  1139. 43:25yeah, what's Bitcoin versus Ethereum
  1140. 43:27versus whatever? And the answer to that
  1141. 43:29is you don't know. And anybody who
  1142. 43:30thinks they know knows nothing. You
  1143. 43:32know, is it reasonable for Bitcoin to be
  1144. 43:34a million bucks over that period? Of
  1145. 43:35course it is. By what date? You don't
  1146. 43:37know. Um, you know, did you expect did
  1147. 43:40anybody expect ETH would still not have
  1148. 43:42broken a new high
  1149. 43:44considering how much activity is going
  1150. 43:46on 5 years later? No. This has been the
  1151. 43:50longest pause we've had for a new high
  1152. 43:51to break. So things don't always play
  1153. 43:54out as they have done in the past. But
  1154. 43:57people should worry less about this
  1155. 43:59stuff and think
  1156. 44:01where is this going?
  1157. 44:03And do I have the stomach for the
  1158. 44:06volatility to accept the time horizon?
  1159. 44:09Because as I keep saying, if you distill
  1160. 44:11it all down to the simplest term, it's
  1161. 44:14so [ __ ] obvious.
  1162. 44:17But the hard part is the wiggles on
  1163. 44:19route. If you'd asked Jess Bezos what
  1164. 44:22Amazon share price would be at any one
  1165. 44:24point or where it is in three or
  1166. 44:25something, he has no clue. What did he
  1167. 44:27not do? Sell it.
  1168. 44:29>> Mhm.
  1169. 44:29>> Cuz he knew where it was going. Elon the
  1170. 44:32same. Bill Gates the same. I mean, all
  1171. 44:34wealth is is really made by owning
  1172. 44:37assets and not selling them. But [ __ ]
  1173. 44:39our space thinks it's it's in fact more
  1174. 44:42important to pretend you're Stevie Cohen
  1175. 44:45and you can short-term trade your way to
  1176. 44:46wealth. It's just utter [ __ ]
  1177. 44:48There's very few rich traders.
  1178. 44:50>> Yeah,
  1179. 44:50>> there are some,
  1180. 44:52>> but there's very few. But we know, I
  1181. 44:56mean, half of, no, 90% of the wealth in
  1182. 44:58the world has been made from owning good
  1183. 45:00assets and not selling them, whether
  1184. 45:02they're houses, other real estate,
  1185. 45:06stocks, private companies, anything.
  1186. 45:08It's that's what makes money. But people
  1187. 45:11get confused because there's this
  1188. 45:13desperate need to make money this week,
  1189. 45:14next week, this month, this year, as
  1190. 45:17opposed to listen, my future self is
  1191. 45:19going to thank me if I just stop [ __ ]
  1192. 45:22around with all this stuff.
  1193. 45:23>> Yeah. Stop trading.
  1194. 45:25Uh [clears throat]
  1195. 45:28earlier you said that that you still
  1196. 45:31think that AI is a really good play.
  1197. 45:32People are going to keep their money in
  1198. 45:33AI and that in order for crypto to go
  1199. 45:36up, we kind of need more liquidity to
  1200. 45:37come into the system. A lot of other
  1201. 45:38people have argued that uh that people
  1202. 45:41are going to rotate from AI into crypto
  1203. 45:43and Bitcoin things like that because
  1204. 45:45there's not may their argument is that
  1205. 45:47there's like not a lot more places for
  1206. 45:49it to go and so therefore like people
  1207. 45:52are going to now look at the thing that
  1208. 45:53seems more obvious which is Bitcoin you
  1209. 45:54know kind of like halfway below its
  1210. 45:56all-time high and maybe rotate in there.
  1211. 45:58So, uh, [clears throat]
  1212. 46:01you you think that they're wrong on that
  1213. 46:03that people aren't going to rotate money
  1214. 46:04into
  1215. 46:04>> So, when you've got limited liquidity,
  1216. 46:06you now need to look for the best return
  1217. 46:08for your dollar. Um, because you got
  1218. 46:11limited amounts of capital to put it in
  1219. 46:13particular space. And so, Bitcoin versus
  1220. 46:16NASDAQ got to two standard deviations
  1221. 46:19oversold, uh, which is usually the
  1222. 46:21bottom of all of these kind of log
  1223. 46:23trends. And it started bouncing from
  1224. 46:25there. And I think it continues to
  1225. 46:27outperform because what we do know is
  1226. 46:31blockchain is undervalued versus the use
  1227. 46:33cases that are coming that are provable.
  1228. 46:35You know, equities on chain, all of this
  1229. 46:37kind of stuff. So I think that's so I
  1230. 46:40think the rotation is right. If you've
  1231. 46:41got limited capital, you should see
  1232. 46:43Bitcoin outperform and we saw a bit of
  1233. 46:46that. Yeah. NASDAQ stopped going up in
  1234. 46:48what June, something like that. Um and
  1235. 46:50Bitcoin bottomed in July.
  1236. 46:53>> Yeah. Now, so then the next phase is
  1237. 46:56just you're asking the question is is
  1238. 46:58there enough liquidity to drive both? If
  1239. 47:01there is, both will go up.
  1240. 47:04>> If there isn't, it's probably it's
  1241. 47:07probably crypto still for a while. Um
  1242. 47:11that that's kind of how I think about
  1243. 47:13it. Um because it needs to play catch-up
  1244. 47:16because it is part of the same trade,
  1245. 47:18right? It's just an infrastructure layer
  1246. 47:19for this for this whole trade. You need
  1247. 47:22both. So we're seeing that and so yes
  1248. 47:25over time they both via rotations go up
  1249. 47:28but really what we're likely to see is
  1250. 47:31the whole space get rerated.
  1251. 47:34>> All right. So we're going to go to the
  1252. 47:36rapid fire part of the show which is
  1253. 47:37just quick questions and answers. It's
  1254. 47:39more fun than anything. Uh no one will
  1255. 47:42keep you accountable for this because
  1256. 47:43you don't have too much time to think
  1257. 47:44about it. But uh first of all I did
  1258. 47:46order your book. It's on the way. I
  1259. 47:47haven't got it yet. Looking forward to
  1260. 47:49it. But the everything code, uh, which
  1261. 47:52part of the big thesis is the hardest
  1262. 47:53for people to understand,
  1263. 47:58>> that we're all going to be fine.
  1264. 48:01Everyone just assumes they're going to
  1265. 48:02be [ __ ] and the AI is going to take
  1266. 48:04our jobs and the robots are going to
  1267. 48:06kill us and the data centers are going
  1268. 48:08to do us and the liquidity, the
  1269. 48:10debasement of money is going to destroy
  1270. 48:12everything. It's like, just follow the
  1271. 48:14code. It's fine.
  1272. 48:17>> What does that mean? Follow the code.
  1273. 48:18It's fine.
  1274. 48:20It means yes, we know debasement. So we
  1275. 48:23then look for assets that outperform
  1276. 48:25debasement and there's only two over
  1277. 48:27time which has been crypto and tech. So
  1278. 48:29own those.
  1279. 48:30>> Yes, they're volatile and they're quite
  1280. 48:32hard to live with but that's what is
  1281. 48:33what it is. Um and then
  1282. 48:37you just basically own your own demise.
  1283. 48:39So if you're going to be replaced by
  1284. 48:41somebody better, you want to bet on
  1285. 48:42them. So you bet on the trade of the AI
  1286. 48:45trade, etc. Um, and then we know that
  1287. 48:47all of the agents in their new world,
  1288. 48:48which will be a hidden economy, machine
  1289. 48:50economy, we won't see, they have to use
  1290. 48:52blockchain.
  1291. 48:54So, we might as well own the
  1292. 48:56infrastructure rails that they're going
  1293. 48:57to operate their new economy on
  1294. 48:59>> 100%.
  1295. 48:59>> So, it's pretty straightforward.
  1296. 49:02And then it's to lean into AI as much as
  1297. 49:04possible and use it because if not, you
  1298. 49:07are definitely going to be behind by a
  1299. 49:09massive amount. Don't forget that
  1300. 49:10intelligence is doubling every 4.6
  1301. 49:12months. So, you need to lean into the AI
  1302. 49:16and in the end remember that the only
  1303. 49:19thing that humans can do
  1304. 49:22is be human and the AI can't be that.
  1305. 49:26>> Okay, back to questions. Um, Ethereum
  1306. 49:27above 10K, what year? [snorts]
  1307. 49:31>> I don't know. I don't know. I'm always
  1308. 49:33scared of making predictions in
  1309. 49:34Ethereum. Um, I I have no idea. Um, I
  1310. 49:38would assume within the next year or
  1311. 49:40two, you know, 12 months, 18 months, but
  1312. 49:42[ __ ] yeah, I don't know.
  1313. 49:44>> Okay. Gold led Bitcoin last time. Does
  1314. 49:48it continue to lead it this time?
  1315. 49:50>> Uh, gold is mirroring financial
  1316. 49:51conditions.
  1317. 49:53Um, and therefore,
  1318. 49:56uh, as financial conditions tighten,
  1319. 49:58gold came lower. As it as it as it as
  1320. 50:02financial conditions went up in 2025,
  1321. 50:04gold went up. gold got rerated
  1322. 50:08because it had been going sideways for a
  1323. 50:10long period of time. So the rerating of
  1324. 50:13gold has been done and then it should be
  1325. 50:16more
  1326. 50:18normal in terms of its return
  1327. 50:19distribution. Um crypto has been
  1328. 50:23sideways for a long period of time. It's
  1329. 50:25likely to get rerated. So no, the next
  1330. 50:27leg the next leg of financial conditions
  1331. 50:29easing crypto massively outcomes gold.
  1332. 50:33You said it earlier, but just to get on
  1333. 50:35the record again, what year do you think
  1334. 50:36we have ASI?
  1335. 50:38>> ASI, look, AGI is like it's now. It's
  1336. 50:42like, you know, we can argue what that
  1337. 50:44is, but it's basically now between now
  1338. 50:46and 2027.
  1339. 50:48Everyone's going to know that we've
  1340. 50:50birthed an intelligence smarter than all
  1341. 50:52of us. And there'll be parts where
  1342. 50:54humans still are better than the AI
  1343. 50:57doing it. What super intelligence is is
  1344. 50:59something better than all of the
  1345. 51:01knowledge of all of humanity. sort of
  1346. 51:02combined. And if you just extrapolate it
  1347. 51:05all out, uh we get above the um
  1348. 51:10intelligence produced um gets above all
  1349. 51:13human intelligence by 2035.
  1350. 51:17>> Yeah.
  1351. 51:17>> Um so it's somewhere like call it 2035,
  1352. 51:202037,
  1353. 51:22you're going to have things that we do
  1354. 51:24not even understand.
  1355. 51:26>> Mhm.
  1356. 51:28To me, it just seems like it would be
  1357. 51:29faster than that with like recursive
  1358. 51:30self-improvement being almost here
  1359. 51:32fully.
  1360. 51:33>> We simply don't we simply don't have the
  1361. 51:35compute for this.
  1362. 51:37>> There's no [ __ ] way. I We probably
  1363. 51:39need quantum. I mean, we're talking
  1364. 51:41about god level intelligence now. We're
  1365. 51:43not we're not talking about
  1366. 51:45>> an AI that's in your computer. We're
  1367. 51:47talking about something so different
  1368. 51:48that nobody can comprehend what that is.
  1369. 51:51>> Yeah.
  1370. 51:51>> Um you need we we just simply couldn't
  1371. 51:54build out the infrastructure to build it
  1372. 51:55yet. that doesn't like so your every you
  1373. 51:59just follow the code everything will be
  1374. 52:00fine you don't worry about ASI as all at
  1375. 52:03all you don't think that it's a threat
  1376. 52:05to humanity
  1377. 52:07>> no and the reason being is if you
  1378. 52:10observe how the universe works it's all
  1379. 52:13computation at every level and if you
  1380. 52:16add valuable computation to the
  1381. 52:17universal structure
  1382. 52:20um you survive so if you think about the
  1383. 52:24layer of computation beneath us.
  1384. 52:26Intelligence, that's nature, right?
  1385. 52:28We've learned from it. We built medicine
  1386. 52:30from it. We've observed it. We've
  1387. 52:31learned physics from it and biology
  1388. 52:32from, right? That's nature. That's what
  1389. 52:34nature does. Um, you know, an apple
  1390. 52:36falling from a head, that was us
  1391. 52:38discovering gravity. This is nature. So,
  1392. 52:40we've discovered everything because of
  1393. 52:41that. So, mankind destroys nature cuz
  1394. 52:44we're the super apex. We're we're dead,
  1395. 52:48right? So, what does humans do? Humans
  1396. 52:52have this thing called qualia which is
  1397. 52:54this weird set of senses. What is how
  1398. 52:57does red feel? What is fear? What is
  1399. 53:02what is my observation? What are these
  1400. 53:04feelings? All of this stuff, right? It's
  1401. 53:05called it's called qualia. Some animals
  1402. 53:08are proven to have qualia. We don't
  1403. 53:10really know what qual is and I can't
  1404. 53:11prove I've got it to you. We have no
  1405. 53:13idea. So one of these weird things
  1406. 53:15that's what people confuse with
  1407. 53:16consciousness. And then so
  1408. 53:20we because of that we do really fringe
  1409. 53:23things, weird things. And that's where
  1410. 53:26we discover new things. So we're really
  1411. 53:30um broad-based compute and we're the
  1412. 53:32most efficient compute that we were the
  1413. 53:34most efficient compute that exists. 20
  1414. 53:37watts a day, you get human brain power
  1415. 53:39out of it. Um
  1416. 53:42and without it, don't forget AI is just
  1417. 53:44the compression of all human thought.
  1418. 53:46Yeah,
  1419. 53:47>> like we're a compression of all of
  1420. 53:48nature around us and what we learned and
  1421. 53:50then we move on and build new
  1422. 53:52intelligence on top. So AI is building
  1423. 53:55intelligence on top of what humans
  1424. 53:57learn. If you get rid of the layer
  1425. 53:59underneath us, AI has nothing. Like if
  1426. 54:03you get rid of the the layer beneath
  1427. 54:05nature,
  1428. 54:07it has nothing. If you go beneath
  1429. 54:08nature, you get it down to um geology
  1430. 54:12and soils and all of that. Nature can't
  1431. 54:14survive. If you go down another layer
  1432. 54:17further, it's molecular structures and
  1433. 54:20nothing can surv, you know. So, it's all
  1434. 54:22built on top of each other. People just
  1435. 54:23don't understand any of this stuff.
  1436. 54:25Everything is a network. Everything's
  1437. 54:26built on each other and each layer
  1438. 54:28compresses the layer above and turns
  1439. 54:30into something else. So, if you think
  1440. 54:32about all of the soil, that's a
  1441. 54:33compression of all of the rocks and all
  1442. 54:34the things that happened that allows
  1443. 54:36then plants to grow, which allowed us to
  1444. 54:39then be born because you can then have
  1445. 54:41animals that have food stuffs.
  1446. 54:43It's all one. It's It's all one process.
  1447. 54:46So, no, I don't fear it because it can't
  1448. 54:48kill us and it shouldn't kill us.
  1449. 54:50>> Well, Ralph, thank you so much for
  1450. 54:51coming on, man. For those who don't
  1451. 54:53know, most of most do know you, but uh
  1452. 54:55for those who don't, where do they
  1453. 54:56follow you? And uh also, why should they
  1454. 54:59buy your book?
  1455. 55:00>> Yeah. So, a couple of fun things. If you
  1456. 55:01want to carry on the conversation with
  1457. 55:02me, I've got an AI um um chatbot called
  1458. 55:06Ralpal.ai. And you can have all these
  1459. 55:09conversations with me about it's trained
  1460. 55:10on all of my stuff and it's free. So,
  1461. 55:12raal.ai AI ral.com r a o l p a l uh has
  1462. 55:17a lot more information about me. I'm
  1463. 55:18always hanging out on X as everybody
  1464. 55:19knows. So you can find me there and buy
  1465. 55:22the book because it'll help you unfuck
  1466. 55:23your future.
  1467. 55:25>> Thanks for coming on bro. Really
  1468. 55:26appreciate it.
  1469. 55:26>> Yeah, not at all. Good to see you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Raoul Pal: Crypto Won’t Stop. The Next Print Skips the Fed by Kyle Chasse crypto, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,104 words across 1,469 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.