YouTube2Text

Ramsete il Grande e Priamo di Troia - Fondazione Claudio Venanzi — Transcript

by Fonclaven - la fondazione Claudio Venanzi · 12,119 words · 1,805 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01Good evening. Please, occasions to
  2. 0:08engage with culture are so rare that I
  3. 0:12believe it is partly a duty for all of
  4. 0:17us to be involved in promoting it.
  5. 0:22Because culture, unfortunately, is not
  6. 0:24promoted institutionally speaking, it
  7. 0:27is worth us promoting it ourselves
  8. 0:29somehow, especially considering that in
  9. 0:32most cases the contributions are truly
  10. 0:34symbolic. In return, you get an offer
  11. 0:38of culture that, in some way, claims
  12. 0:41and hopes to be qualitatively quite
  13. 0:44valid. In short, then, tonight we begin
  14. 0:48our series of meetings, "Parallel Lives
  15. 0:51." Plutarch, you know, actually wrote
  16. 0:56biographies of famous figures,
  17. 0:58comparing individuals from different
  18. 1:00eras, seeing how in some cases the
  19. 1:02biographies of different characters
  20. 1:04ended up being almost overlapping. Hm.
  21. 1:09And so his intent was to demonstrate
  22. 1:12that there existed human archetypes
  23. 1:15that are somehow conditioned by the
  24. 1:18experiences they faced, certain
  25. 1:20discourses, certain political issues,
  26. 1:23and the particular history they had
  27. 1:26within their lives. We, on the other
  28. 1:30hand, will do something different this
  29. 1:31evening. I do not want to give you a
  30. 1:33sequence of biographical data; that is
  31. 1:36not my intention, nor do I find it to
  32. 1:39be particularly useful. Hm, I want to
  33. 1:42do other things instead. It occurred to
  34. 1:46me to take some figures and, through
  35. 1:49these characters, talk about a
  36. 1:51phenomenon, a period, or an issue that
  37. 1:54characterized their era. Not by
  38. 1:59deepening the character himself, but by
  39. 2:02seeing how that character is a product
  40. 2:05of an issue, a product of a historical
  41. 2:08phenomenon that was occurring at that
  42. 2:11moment. So let's say the characters we
  43. 2:14will talk about will be the means, the
  44. 2:17tools that will help us understand what
  45. 2:20are actually very, very important
  46. 2:22phenomena, alright? I mean, between us,
  47. 2:27some biographical data about Ramesses
  48. 2:30II only interests us up to a certain
  49. 2:33point, but what he actually did, the
  50. 2:36influence he had on his history, and
  51. 2:39how he faced certain moments and
  52. 2:41turning points in the history of his
  53. 2:44era have, in some way, reached us today
  54. 2:47. So, this is what we will do this
  55. 2:51evening. Obviously, the comparison is
  56. 2:54between two figures who might seem
  57. 2:56absolutely distant from each other. The
  58. 3:00first, an extremely well-known figure,
  59. 3:03right? Ramesses. Ramesses II. Ramesses
  60. 3:06the Great, his real name wasn't
  61. 3:09Ramesses, you know? His name was
  62. 3:12Usermaatre Setepenre Ramesses the Great
  63. 3:15, a pharaoh whose greatness, between us
  64. 3:19, corresponds and coincides in many
  65. 3:22cases with the fact that he reigned for
  66. 3:2570 years. It is easy to be great, to
  67. 3:30leave a mark on history when you rule
  68. 3:33for 70 years. Mh, he was certainly not
  69. 3:36the greatest pharaoh of Egypt. Without
  70. 3:38a doubt he is the most famous pharaoh
  71. 3:40of Egypt, but not the greatest. The
  72. 3:43greatest pharaoh of Egypt was
  73. 3:44undoubtedly Thutmose, no doubt about it
  74. 3:47. Be that as it may, the first figure
  75. 3:50is a well-known character, a figure
  76. 3:53about whom there is vast literature and
  77. 3:55who built a huge quantity of monuments.
  78. 3:58Mh, some of the greatest monuments that
  79. 4:00Egyptian civilization has passed down
  80. 4:02to us were built by him. The second
  81. 4:05figure is a literary character, in some
  82. 4:07way he is the product of epic
  83. 4:09production. Priam, Priam of Troy. The
  84. 4:15last king of Troy mentioned in Homer's
  85. 4:18Iliad, partly mentioned also in the
  86. 4:21Odyssey and even in Virgil's Aeneid, so
  87. 4:24a character about whom we can even give
  88. 4:27the benefit of the doubt regarding
  89. 4:30Priam's possible existence. Mh, it
  90. 4:33hardly matters to us whether he was
  91. 4:35called Priam or perhaps John in his
  92. 4:38time. Certainly Troy had a final
  93. 4:40sovereign and we are obviously talking
  94. 4:42about him in this case. So, two
  95. 4:45characters who in some way are
  96. 4:48enormously distant, even geographically
  97. 4:51it seems mh, because Ramses in Egypt,
  98. 4:53Priam in Asia Minor, in the Troad, or
  99. 4:56to be precise in Mysia, which is a
  100. 4:59northeastern, northwestern, excuse me,
  101. 5:02region of Asia Minor, modern-day Turkey
  102. 5:05. The only thing that seems to unite
  103. 5:11them is the era, because Ramses, based
  104. 5:14on the dating currently followed by us
  105. 5:18Italians, Ramses lived between 1305 and
  106. 5:251212 B.C. I say our Italian dating
  107. 5:30because every archaeological school,
  108. 5:33regarding Egypt, provides different
  109. 5:35dates; because for ancient Egypt we do
  110. 5:38not have, as we do for ancient Rome, an
  111. 5:41absolute text, a sequence, an absolute
  112. 5:44chronology of reference. Therefore, we
  113. 5:48Italians together with the French use
  114. 5:51one dating, the English and Americans
  115. 5:54use another dating, and the Germans use
  116. 5:57yet another. Certainly these dates
  117. 6:00differ from one another by at most a
  118. 6:03decade, that is, we say from 1303 to
  119. 6:061212 B.C., while for example the
  120. 6:09English say from 1310 to 1220 B.C. Well
  121. 6:14, more or less, we are in the same
  122. 6:17ballpark. This is regarding Ramses.
  123. 6:20Regarding Priam, on the other hand, we
  124. 6:22are obviously in the realm of the
  125. 6:24Trojan epic, we are in the context of
  126. 6:26the Trojan War, therefore in the
  127. 6:28context of the Late Bronze Age. Late
  128. 6:31Bronze Age means for the Eastern
  129. 6:33Mediterranean, always be wary of those
  130. 6:36who talk to you about the Iron Age just
  131. 6:39like that, because the Iron Age here in
  132. 6:42Italy was in the 10th century. In Asia
  133. 6:47Minor, the Iron Age was in the 20th
  134. 6:49century B.C. In the Americas, the Iron
  135. 6:51Age arrived in the 10th century AD. So,
  136. 6:55in reality, you have to provide a
  137. 6:57dating, but also contextualize it
  138. 6:58geographically. For the Eastern
  139. 7:02Mediterranean, the end of the Bronze
  140. 7:04Age is exactly within the scope of the
  141. 7:06Trojan War, between 1250 and 1200 BC,
  142. 7:12approximately. So those are the years,
  143. 7:15it is the 13th century BC. Time seems
  144. 7:19to be the only thing they have in
  145. 7:20common. Hm. Otherwise, the geographical
  146. 7:24contexts are different, the cultural
  147. 7:26contexts are different; we might even
  148. 7:28think they didn't know each other at
  149. 7:30all. Hm, in some way. This is because,
  150. 7:33unfortunately, we study history in
  151. 7:35watertight compartments; we don't study
  152. 7:37it through contacts, let's say, along a
  153. 7:40synchronic line, but along a diachronic
  154. 7:42one. Let's start right from Priam, in a
  155. 7:46way. What do we really know about Priam
  156. 7:48? Actually, all things considered, we
  157. 7:52know very little about Priam because we
  158. 7:55all say, well, we have already
  159. 7:56discussed this here. Ah well, yes, we
  160. 8:01all know the Trojan War, we all know
  161. 8:03the Iliad, but if we then go to see how
  162. 8:05many of us have really read the entire
  163. 8:08Iliad from beginning to end, hmm,
  164. 8:10better not conduct that pathetic
  165. 8:12examination, if we want. Let's try to
  166. 8:16be kind and gloss over that. If we go
  167. 8:20and read the Iliad, we realize that, in
  168. 8:22reality, very little is said about
  169. 8:24Priam. Not only is very little said,
  170. 8:28but in the Iliad, Priam is an elderly
  171. 8:31character, very elderly; he can't even
  172. 8:34walk easily, so he is old, and thus
  173. 8:37quite different from the image of Priam
  174. 8:40that myth transmits to us. Why? Because
  175. 8:45we know Priam's story from other
  176. 8:47authors; we know it from Apollodorus,
  177. 8:49and in reality, we even know it from
  178. 8:51some Byzantine authors. Just think that
  179. 8:55even Priam's death—that is, how Priam
  180. 8:58died, having been killed during the
  181. 9:00Trojan War, during the destruction, the
  182. 9:03last night, we could say, of Troy—we
  183. 9:05don't even know from the Homeric poems;
  184. 9:08neither the Iliad nor the Odyssey tells
  185. 9:11us how Priam died. Just think, the only
  186. 9:15one who tells us about Priam's death is
  187. 9:18Virgil in the Aeneid, so perhaps who
  188. 9:20knows, maybe Virgil invented Priam's
  189. 9:23death during the destruction of Troy.
  190. 9:26So the data we have is truly scarce.
  191. 9:30Think, even about Priam's youth, we
  192. 9:33know very little. However, legends say
  193. 9:36he was a character who had a presence
  194. 9:39in many myths. He was a character who
  195. 9:42recurred in several different myths. Hm
  196. 9:44. And it is very strange because, all
  197. 9:46things considered, Priam is not Greek.
  198. 9:49Priam is actually a character from Asia
  199. 9:52Minor. A large part of the myths take
  200. 9:54place in the Hellenic environment, at
  201. 9:56least the most ancient myths. He,
  202. 9:58however, lives in the region of Asia
  203. 10:00Minor. And what are the few facts that
  204. 10:03we know, transmitted by some authors? A
  205. 10:05legend says that his true original name
  206. 10:07was Podarces. He is called Podarces.
  207. 10:10Podarces. This, too, is another
  208. 10:13interesting thing. Unfortunately, every
  209. 10:16time we study the Homeric poems, we
  210. 10:18study them in the various translations
  211. 10:21that have reached us, and in doing so,
  212. 10:24we lose many of the meanings conveyed
  213. 10:26by the names. That is, Agamemnon is
  214. 10:31called Agamemnon in Greek, Agamemnon in
  215. 10:35Latin, and Agamennone in Italian. And
  216. 10:39so, when we study the Homeric poems, we
  217. 10:41say Agamennone, but in reality,
  218. 10:43Agamemnon is a name that has, let's say
  219. 10:45, a meaning. Agamemnon means the one
  220. 10:48who commands. Now, a Greek who read
  221. 10:52Agamemnon, that name actually
  222. 10:54immediately conveyed the framing of the
  223. 10:56character to him. Well, Podarces, which
  224. 11:01was Priam's original name, means "first
  225. 11:05among feet," in the sense of the one
  226. 11:09who arrives first when running, all
  227. 11:16right? Therefore, he who runs fast. Now
  228. 11:20, if I, reading the Iliad, knowing that
  229. 11:23this gentleman here was named Podarces,
  230. 11:26that is, he who runs fast, well, once I
  231. 11:29have told you this, you understand that
  232. 11:32the fact that he ends up kneeling
  233. 11:34before Achilles, who is swift, has a
  234. 11:37very different meaning; that is, a
  235. 11:39hierarchy is created between this one
  236. 11:42who ran fast and Achilles, who is
  237. 11:45swifter; in other words, names have a
  238. 11:48meaning. Until tonight, this meaning
  239. 11:50did not exist for you because you did
  240. 11:52not know that his name was Podarces and
  241. 11:54that Podarces means "first among feet."
  242. 11:57That is, the humiliation that Priam
  243. 11:59undergoes at the feet of Achilles
  244. 12:01acquires an even greater significance.
  245. 12:04So he was named Podarces and was the
  246. 12:07son of Laomedon. Laomedon was a king of
  247. 12:10Troy. The king had ordered, we could
  248. 12:14say, commissioned the gods, Apollo and
  249. 12:17Poseidon, to build the walls of Troy.
  250. 12:21Then he refused to pay them. And so the
  251. 12:24gods sent a monster. To save himself
  252. 12:27from this monster, Laomedon calls
  253. 12:29Hercules. Hercules goes there, defeats
  254. 12:31the monster, but then Laomedon does not
  255. 12:33pay Hercules either. And so Hercules
  256. 12:36gets angry. And I know, Hercules gets
  257. 12:40angry and destroys Troy. It is the
  258. 12:43famous first Trojan War when Troy is
  259. 12:45destroyed by Hercules. Hercules kills
  260. 12:50Laomedon, kills all of Laomedon's
  261. 12:52children, except for the two youngest,
  262. 12:56a girl named Hesione and a 4-year-old
  263. 12:59boy named Podarces, indeed, him.
  264. 13:04Hercules, who goes there and destroys
  265. 13:07Troy, has a friend named Telamon, who
  266. 13:09will be the father of the famous Ajax,
  267. 13:12who will then take part in the Trojan
  268. 13:14War, and Telamon obtains Hesione as
  269. 13:17spoils of war, this girl, the Trojan
  270. 13:19princess, and decides to marry her.
  271. 13:22Hesione was 13 years old; that's how
  272. 13:25marriages were back then. Since the
  273. 13:29gods wanted everyone to give a gift at
  274. 13:33weddings, when Hesione was to marry
  275. 13:37Telamon, she asked Hercules, demanded a
  276. 13:40gift from Hercules. Hercules had to
  277. 13:45give it to her; he was forced to
  278. 13:46provide it. He says, "Very well, what
  279. 13:49do you want?" And Hesione asks for her
  280. 13:524-year-old brother, but her brother is
  281. 13:55part of the war booty. So Hesione has
  282. 13:58to buy him. Hercules tells her, "Yes,
  283. 14:02but officially you must redeem your
  284. 14:04brother." Hesione is a prisoner; the
  285. 14:07only thing she has is the veil on her
  286. 14:10head. So she takes this veil, unwraps
  287. 14:12the veil, and gives it to Hercules. She
  288. 14:14says, "With this, I buy my brother, you
  289. 14:16can give him to me." From that moment
  290. 14:20on, that boy would be called Priam,
  291. 14:22because in Greek, the verb "priamai"
  292. 14:25means to redeem. So Priam means "the
  293. 14:29redeemed one." Agreed? What does Priam
  294. 14:34do? And here a very big gap opens up in
  295. 14:37our knowledge. The myths don't tell us
  296. 14:39about certain things because the myths
  297. 14:41don't care about talking about Priam
  298. 14:43when he was 15 or 20 years old. We only
  299. 14:46know that, being the only male of the
  300. 14:48Trojan family left, he eventually
  301. 14:50becomes King of Troy. Mh. He becomes
  302. 14:53King of Troy, but in reality, Troy is a
  303. 14:55very small city. And what does he do?
  304. 14:57He allies himself with his most
  305. 14:59powerful friends nearby, who are the
  306. 15:00Phrygians. And in this alliance with
  307. 15:04the Phrygians, he fights the Amazons,
  308. 15:07who were, let's say, the creatures of
  309. 15:11chaos that existed closest to Troy. For
  310. 15:16the Greeks, chaos, for the Greek
  311. 15:19mentality, was the failure to respect a
  312. 15:23series of rules made by the gods, and
  313. 15:26this could also be a physical failure
  314. 15:29to respect them, so a normal being is
  315. 15:32actually a divine creature. A centaur,
  316. 15:37who is half man and half horse, is a
  317. 15:39creature of chaos. A faun, who is half
  318. 15:44man and half goat, is a creature of
  319. 15:46chaos. The Amazons, who are women with
  320. 15:50masculine attitudes, are creatures of
  321. 15:53chaos. That is, it's as if the Amazons
  322. 15:55were half woman and half man. In their
  323. 15:58own way, they are also hybrids,
  324. 16:00understood? And so in this war against
  325. 16:03the Amazons, Priam wins over the
  326. 16:06Amazons and gains the alliance of
  327. 16:08Phrygia. This sculpture that you see
  328. 16:12here is located in Munich, Germany. It
  329. 16:15is the so-called pediment of Aegina. It
  330. 16:18is a large pediment from the Temple of
  331. 16:20Aphaia on the island of Aegina in
  332. 16:22Greece. The pediment was, however,
  333. 16:25brought to Munich in the 1800s, where
  334. 16:27it is currently exhibited, in the
  335. 16:30Glyptothek of Munich. And in this image
  336. 16:34, the war between the Phrygians and the
  337. 16:36Amazons is represented, and in this
  338. 16:39representation, Priam is also present.
  339. 16:42This right here is actually the oldest
  340. 16:45image we have of Priam. Mm. Consider,
  341. 16:48you see here he is represented as young
  342. 16:49. We always imagine Priam as an old man
  343. 16:51, right? But in reality, this is one of
  344. 16:54the few references we have to Priam's
  345. 16:57history in its earliest phase. For
  346. 17:01example, the myth tells us that as a
  347. 17:03boy, he married a princess named Arisbe
  348. 17:06, and from this Arisbe, he had a son
  349. 17:09whose name was Aesacus. When he
  350. 17:13participates, let's say, as a boy in
  351. 17:16this war, to forge an alliance with the
  352. 17:19King of Phrygia, he marries the
  353. 17:21daughter of the King of Phrygia, named
  354. 17:23Hecuba, and repudiates his previous
  355. 17:26wife, Arisbe. We don't know why, given
  356. 17:30that in reality, polygamy was permitted
  357. 17:32at the time; that is, at the time,
  358. 17:34these peoples were polygamous. Priam
  359. 17:37himself would marry another woman after
  360. 17:39Hecuba and would have several
  361. 17:41concubines. So, for example, the myth
  362. 17:44is deficient here; we don't know why he
  363. 17:46repudiates his first wife. Agreed? But
  364. 17:52obviously, most of the information we
  365. 17:54have about Priam relates to the Trojan
  366. 17:56War. We know that he, in fact, marries
  367. 17:58Hecuba and has 19 children with her. Of
  368. 18:03these 19 children, 11 are boys and
  369. 18:06eight are girls. Some of his children
  370. 18:10we don't even know the names of; they
  371. 18:11aren't even mentioned in the Homeric
  372. 18:13poems. The ones that are most important
  373. 18:16to us, however, are the first two sons:
  374. 18:18Hector, who was the firstborn, and
  375. 18:20Paris, whose real name was actually
  376. 18:23Alexander, who was the second-born. Mm.
  377. 18:27This vase depicts the arming of Hector
  378. 18:29before, precisely, Priam there and his
  379. 18:32mother Hecuba. You see that this vase,
  380. 18:36which is set in and describes an
  381. 18:38episode of the Trojan War, already
  382. 18:40shows Priam as an old man, see? He is
  383. 18:42already leaning on a staff, isn't he?
  384. 18:46So the figure of Priam enters the great
  385. 18:49epic, the great mythological tradition,
  386. 18:52already as a mature character. Mm.
  387. 18:56During the war—I mean, the Homeric
  388. 18:59poems are very long, yet Priam is
  389. 19:00spoken of very little. Damn it, he is
  390. 19:04the King of Troy, but curiously, it
  391. 19:07seems that the role of king throughout
  392. 19:09all the Homeric poems is filled more by
  393. 19:12his son Hector than by him. Priam is
  394. 19:15almost never in the narrative. When he
  395. 19:19is, it is mostly, for example, to
  396. 19:21welcome envoys, perform religious rites
  397. 19:24, or comfort Helen. Helen is always
  398. 19:29comforted by Priam; Helen almost never
  399. 19:31appears alone, she always appears with
  400. 19:33her father-in-law, that is, with Priam.
  401. 19:36So, he is a character who is actually
  402. 19:38present very little in the epic form.
  403. 19:40Mm. I mean, however, as a looming
  404. 19:43presence with his 50 children, his two
  405. 19:46wives, Hecuba and Laothoe, is the
  406. 19:49second wife, plus an unspecified number
  407. 19:52of concubines, in fact. By the way, the
  408. 19:56number of 50 children isn't even
  409. 19:57certain, because Homer doesn't mention
  410. 19:59it. Hyginus, who is a Byzantine writer,
  411. 20:02says there were 48 children. Eutropius,
  412. 20:05another much later writer, says instead
  413. 20:07there were 115. So, in reality, the
  414. 20:11matter was a bit complex, you know,
  415. 20:15like that. Well, excuse me, in a little
  416. 20:19while we will talk about Ramesses II,
  417. 20:21who is not a mythical figure. Well, for
  418. 20:26Ramesses II we have confirmed,
  419. 20:29confirmed 127 children, but it is also
  420. 20:32true that Ramesses II had 12 wives and
  421. 20:36about fifty concubines, so, however,
  422. 20:43everyone, excuse me, everyone has their
  423. 20:47own problems, okay? There, everyone has
  424. 20:50their own problems. Obviously, the
  425. 20:55figure of Priam becomes central to the
  426. 20:58story when, the day after the killing
  427. 21:01of Hector, um, of the Trojan prince
  428. 21:03Hector, Priam must indeed ransom his
  429. 21:06body from Achilles. This is a beautiful
  430. 21:09silver vase from the Roman treasure of
  431. 21:12Boscoreale. This vase is currently in
  432. 21:16America and it depicts Achilles sitting
  433. 21:19and Priam, as you can see, kneeling
  434. 21:22before Achilles to ask for the return
  435. 21:25of Hector's body to give him a proper
  436. 21:28burial. With this episode, indeed,
  437. 21:32Achilles in some way, how could we say,
  438. 21:35lays down his arms and the Iliad ends,
  439. 21:37because the Iliad ends with this. The
  440. 21:40Iliad, you know, does not end with the
  441. 21:42destruction of Troy. After all, the
  442. 21:44Iliad, we’ve talked about it here, is
  443. 21:46a book that concerns the wrath of
  444. 21:48Achilles. It begins when the wrath of
  445. 21:50Achilles begins, it ends when the wrath
  446. 21:52of Achilles ends. And who is it that
  447. 21:53brings the wrath of Achilles to an end?
  448. 21:56Priam, therefore Priam, who is a
  449. 21:58character that in the poem actually
  450. 22:00intervenes little, is however the one
  451. 22:02whose intervention resolves the wrath
  452. 22:04of Achilles. So the Iliad ends thanks
  453. 22:08to Priam in some way. This vase, same
  454. 22:16thing, represents the body of Hector
  455. 22:18laid out below, Achilles above who is
  456. 22:19feasting, and Priam who is asking for
  457. 22:21the return. Therefore, a very important
  458. 22:25character who speaks directly with
  459. 22:28Achilles. Do you remember this detail?
  460. 22:31Priam, despite the attempts to dissuade
  461. 22:34him that his wife and children had made
  462. 22:38, telling him not to go, leaves the
  463. 22:41city alone, sneaks into the Achaean
  464. 22:45camp at night, and goes to beg Achilles
  465. 22:48directly to have the return of his
  466. 22:52son's body. Also this other vase. This
  467. 22:55is a beautiful vase, it is located in
  468. 22:57Berlin and it depicts the same thing.
  469. 23:00You always see Hector's body on the
  470. 23:03ground, Priam always depicted as an
  471. 23:05elderly old man with a beard, in this
  472. 23:08case white, with a cane as he goes to
  473. 23:10kneel before Achilles, and Priam even
  474. 23:13makes Achilles cry. Mm. Achilles is
  475. 23:17moved by the request that Priam makes.
  476. 23:22So much so that Achilles then returns
  477. 23:24Hector's body, which will be given a
  478. 23:26proper burial. How does Priam die?
  479. 23:30Priam is not killed by Achilles.
  480. 23:32Achilles dies before the end of Troy.
  481. 23:34Achilles is killed by Paris, right? By
  482. 23:36an arrow shot that strikes him in the
  483. 23:39heel. The death of Achilles was
  484. 23:42supposed to mark the end of the Trojan
  485. 23:44War. Troy would no longer have fallen
  486. 23:48because the oracle had said that for
  487. 23:50Troy to fall, it was necessary for a
  488. 23:53descendant of the only mortal who
  489. 23:55helped the gods build the walls of Troy
  490. 23:58to participate in the Trojan War. The
  491. 24:02walls of Troy had been built by the
  492. 24:04gods with the collaboration of a mortal
  493. 24:06named Aeacus. This Aeacus had only one
  494. 24:10son, Peleus, who had only one son,
  495. 24:12Achilles. That is why Achilles must
  496. 24:15participate in the Trojan War, because
  497. 24:17it is as if he had the password to
  498. 24:19breach Troy, but the moment Achilles is
  499. 24:22killed, who does it? So what do the
  500. 24:24Greeks do? They leave from there, they
  501. 24:28go to Thessaly to get the only male
  502. 24:30child that Achilles had, who was indeed
  503. 24:33named Pyrrhus, a young boy who knew
  504. 24:37nothing about the Trojan War. This
  505. 24:40Pyrrhus is taken from his mother, he
  506. 24:43was a young lad, since the myth takes
  507. 24:46some liberties. From when they take him
  508. 24:49as a boy from his mother to when he
  509. 24:51arrives in Troy, he has become an adult
  510. 24:53. It is true that it takes a long time
  511. 24:56to make that journey at that time, but
  512. 24:57still. And he arrives there, he is no
  513. 25:00longer called Pyrrhus, he is called
  514. 25:02Neoptolemus, which means the new the
  515. 25:04new fighter. And this Neoptolemus,
  516. 25:07angry, is a descendant of Achilles; it
  517. 25:10is as if he felt the resentment of his
  518. 25:13father Achilles, who had been moved
  519. 25:16before Priam. So what does he do?
  520. 25:18Neoptolemus is the meanest of them all.
  521. 25:22He kills children, for example, he
  522. 25:24kills Astyanax, he kills Polites, who
  523. 25:26is another of the Trojan princes, and
  524. 25:28then he kills Priam there. But, as I
  525. 25:32repeat, this story is told by Virgil,
  526. 25:35it is not told by Homer. So Priam meets
  527. 25:39a rather sad end. Obviously, we will
  528. 25:42return to Priam. Now let's talk about
  529. 25:45this gentleman. Here, instead, we are
  530. 25:46in a completely different context.
  531. 25:50Egypt, the Egypt of the 19th Dynasty.
  532. 25:55The 19th Dynasty is a completely
  533. 25:56different dynasty from all the
  534. 25:57dynasties that had been there before.
  535. 25:59It was a dynasty of soldiers. The first
  536. 26:03pharaoh of the 19th dynasty was named
  537. 26:06Ramessu, Ramses I, his grandfather, was
  538. 26:09a general, he wasn't even of royal
  539. 26:12blood. Mm. And obviously, we are the
  540. 26:16ones who divide the history of Egypt
  541. 26:18into dynasties precisely based on
  542. 26:20family relationships. Mm. The 19th
  543. 26:23dynasty is a dynasty where the pharaohs
  544. 26:25are all generals. There is Ramses,
  545. 26:28there is Seti, son of Ramses I, and
  546. 26:31then the son of Seti. One of the sons
  547. 26:35is precisely Usermaatre, he went down
  548. 26:39in history later as Ramses II, a figure
  549. 26:43who was a soldier, mm, of Berber
  550. 26:48descent, he had red hair, we know, but
  551. 26:51the Egyptians shaved themselves
  552. 26:53completely, so we know he had red hair
  553. 26:56because he still has it on his mummy.
  554. 27:01Um, he becomes, uh, let's say, an
  555. 27:03important figure in his grandfather's
  556. 27:06court already, he shows his worth so
  557. 27:08much that then his father Seti, at a
  558. 27:11certain point, brings him on as regent.
  559. 27:14But mind you, he had a lot of brothers,
  560. 27:16uh, I mean, he would have more than 100
  561. 27:19children, it's not like his father had
  562. 27:21taken it easy. Mm. But you know, in
  563. 27:25ancient Egypt, to become pharaoh,
  564. 27:27family relationships were important,
  565. 27:30that is, you became pharaoh by marrying
  566. 27:32a royal princess, which royal princess
  567. 27:35had to be the direct daughter of
  568. 27:37pharaohs. I mean, in what sense? I am
  569. 27:42the pharaoh. I have a son and a
  570. 27:44daughter. My son does not become
  571. 27:47pharaoh. He only becomes pharaoh if he
  572. 27:49marries his sister or if he marries my
  573. 27:52sister, so the aunt who is perhaps also
  574. 27:54the daughter of another pharaoh. So you
  575. 27:58could be the son of a pharaoh, but if
  576. 28:00you didn't marry a royal princess, you
  577. 28:02remained nothing. Conversely, a slave
  578. 28:06who married a royal princess became
  579. 28:08pharaoh. In ancient Egypt, it was like
  580. 28:11that. Power was transmitted through the
  581. 28:15female line and he, after several
  582. 28:18marriages without children with royal
  583. 28:20princesses, marries Nefertari who was
  584. 28:23the granddaughter of Pharaoh Ay and
  585. 28:26great-granddaughter of Pharaoh
  586. 28:28Amenhotep and therefore this would be
  587. 28:31decisive for him becoming pharaoh. He
  588. 28:35becomes pharaoh very young, his father
  589. 28:37dies quite early. He becomes pharaoh
  590. 28:42practically at 16 years old, even
  591. 28:44though he had brothers much older than
  592. 28:47him, but the dynastic sequence was
  593. 28:49fierce. This is him. Uh, consider that
  594. 28:55he died at about 93 years old, now 93
  595. 29:00years in ancient Egypt. That's a lot,
  596. 29:0593 years is truly a lot, but besides,
  597. 29:07consider that the anthropometric
  598. 29:09measurements, the study of the mummies
  599. 29:11is extraordinary because we study
  600. 29:13historical figures in books, but in
  601. 29:15reality, with the mummies, you are
  602. 29:17standing right in front of them, so you
  603. 29:19know everything. Anthropometric study
  604. 29:22shows that at 93 years old, he was 1.78
  605. 29:25meters tall. Anthropometric studies
  606. 29:31show that when he was between 20 and 30
  607. 29:34years old, he was likely nearly 1.90 m
  608. 29:37tall. Mm. For the populations of Egypt.
  609. 29:48Unfortunately, here—well, 93 years
  610. 29:50old, he actually had spinal bone
  611. 29:52disease, so at 93 he practically
  612. 29:54couldn't walk anymore. Mm. Well, lucky
  613. 29:58him, I mean, he made it that far back
  614. 30:00then. True, he lived the life of a
  615. 30:03pharaoh. Of course, he wasn't taking
  616. 30:04the subway at 7 in the morning,
  617. 30:05that’s for sure. He had red hair, a
  618. 30:09slightly aquiline nose like this, but
  619. 30:11you can see very, very sharp features.
  620. 30:15He was an extraordinary character,
  621. 30:17however, a man of great culture and
  622. 30:19intelligence. This is his name, one of
  623. 30:23his many names that. Obviously, he
  624. 30:27reigned for more than 70 years, even
  625. 30:29nearly 80 years, as a sole ruler, since
  626. 30:32he had already been partially assisted
  627. 30:35by his father; consider that Egypt is
  628. 30:38full of his monuments. This is part of
  629. 30:42the royal titulary and it repeats twice
  630. 30:45. He is the king of Upper and Lower
  631. 30:52Egypt, which means he who lives for the
  632. 30:54sedge and the bee, and this is his name
  633. 30:57, which means "the power, the justice,
  634. 30:59and the splendor belong to the sun."
  635. 31:03The name is precisely Usermaatra, and
  636. 31:07following that, "endowed with life."
  637. 31:09The complete name is here, it repeats.
  638. 31:12This was the name given to the males.
  639. 31:16All the males in a family had the same
  640. 31:18name. All the males in his family were
  641. 31:20named Ramses. And the name, here it is,
  642. 31:24Ra. This is the god Ra. Sessu, mer-Amon
  643. 31:30. Ramesessu-mer-Amon, which means "
  644. 31:33Ramses, beloved of the god Amon." While
  645. 31:37over there, again, Usermaatra, and this
  646. 31:39is indeed his name, the royal titulary.
  647. 31:43As a boy, one of the first things he
  648. 31:45did was to consecrate the dynastic
  649. 31:47temple in the city of Abydos. This is
  650. 31:51him at about 17 years old, in the city
  651. 31:53of Abydos, with an incense burner in
  652. 31:55his hand, consecrating the temple.
  653. 31:58Interestingly, Ramses almost always has
  654. 32:02himself depicted with that particular
  655. 32:05cap you see there. That cap was called
  656. 32:09"khepresh." It means blue because it
  657. 32:14was a cap made of metal covered in
  658. 32:17lapis lazuli, but it wasn't really a
  659. 32:20cap; it was a helmet, a battle helmet.
  660. 32:24Ramses has himself depicted with the
  661. 32:26helmet during the first phase of his
  662. 32:28life, the first half of his life. It's
  663. 32:32a bit like some political head of state
  664. 32:35, some politician we still see today
  665. 32:37who always appears in public in uniform
  666. 32:40, or think of Arafat who always
  667. 32:42appeared with his keffiyeh; it was a
  668. 32:44very specific message, meaning he
  669. 32:46identifies himself as a military
  670. 32:48commander in a war situation. He always
  671. 32:53appears, in fact, with his crown, or
  672. 32:55rather, with his battle helmet on. Mh.
  673. 32:59And we said he married Nefertari. And
  674. 33:03here we find something interesting.
  675. 33:04Look at this statue. This is Nefertari.
  676. 33:08This one, oops, sorry, this one you see
  677. 33:11here, mh, one of Ramses 'queens, a
  678. 33:14descendant of a royal family. The one
  679. 33:18next to it is called the Hecuba of
  680. 33:20Berlin. It is a statue that actually
  681. 33:23comes from Asia Minor; it probably
  682. 33:25doesn't represent Hecuba. I put it here
  683. 33:27to indicate Hecuba because that is how
  684. 33:29it is identified. Because Hecuba is the
  685. 33:32same thing. Hecuba, the wife of Priam,
  686. 33:35whom he marries when he gains the
  687. 33:37alliance of the Phrygians and becomes
  688. 33:39king. So for him, the marriage to
  689. 33:42Hecuba serves to confirm his royalty
  690. 33:45over the city of Troy. So look, the
  691. 33:49Egyptians and the inhabitants of the
  692. 33:52Troad had their power transmitted
  693. 33:55through marriage. In reality, the
  694. 33:59entire ancient Mediterranean was
  695. 34:00characterized by this. There was a
  696. 34:02matriarchy in protohistoric times where
  697. 34:06power was transmitted through the
  698. 34:08female line. You see, to be king of
  699. 34:10Ithaca you have to marry Penelope, to
  700. 34:12be king of Mycenae you have to marry
  701. 34:15Clytemnestra, to be king of Sparta you
  702. 34:17have to marry Helen, and so on. That is
  703. 34:20, marriage granted royalty over a
  704. 34:23specific area, and this is something
  705. 34:25that unites them both. We also know a
  706. 34:29great many things about Ramses. We know
  707. 34:31, for example, that he was a great
  708. 34:32builder, right? This here is the famous
  709. 34:34temple of Abu Simbel where he is
  710. 34:36depicted. It is a temple dedicated to
  711. 34:40the majesty of the pharaoh, not a tomb.
  712. 34:43Eh, the temple is dedicated to the
  713. 34:45pharaoh as a god in the far south of
  714. 34:48Egypt to indicate that, in fact, Ramses
  715. 34:50' sovereignty must extend to the
  716. 34:53extreme south. But above all, Ramses,
  717. 34:57to tell the truth, for the first 20
  718. 34:59years of his life, was primarily a
  719. 35:01soldier; he led two great military
  720. 35:03campaigns, the most famous one, and
  721. 35:05sorry, that is why his monuments are
  722. 35:07full of triumphalistic images, like in
  723. 35:09this case, no? All these prisoners
  724. 35:12chained under his feet, in fact, these
  725. 35:14are the feet of the statues, these that
  726. 35:17you see here above, right? The feet of
  727. 35:20the Abu Simbel statues and all these
  728. 35:22prisoners represented underneath. This
  729. 35:25is again, do you see the king's titles?
  730. 35:28You see them up there like that. Heb
  731. 35:40useramon, That is, long live Horus, the
  732. 35:47mighty bull loved by Maat, he of the
  733. 35:49two lands of Upper and Lower Egypt,
  734. 35:51lord of the western lands and the far
  735. 35:54south and the lands of Nubia, he of the
  736. 35:56bee and he of the sedge.
  737. 35:59He-who-is-of-truth, son of Ra, son of
  738. 36:02Ra, Ramesses is the general title,
  739. 36:04indeed, of the pharaoh. Now, but the
  740. 36:11pharaoh, Priam, these figures, who were
  741. 36:15they within the scope of Egypt, indeed
  742. 36:17within the scope of the ancient world.
  743. 36:20Now we must take a brief digression. In
  744. 36:26prehistory and protohistory, you know,
  745. 36:29we speak of a sort of primitive
  746. 36:31communism, meaning the concept of king
  747. 36:34or the concept of government, the
  748. 36:37concept of a leader, did not exist in
  749. 36:40social hierarchies; it wasn't there.
  750. 36:45But the moment states become more
  751. 36:47elaborate, obviously communities need
  752. 36:52greater organization, therefore a
  753. 36:54hierarchy capable of managing all this.
  754. 36:59Now there is a Sumerian tale that says
  755. 37:02something very interesting. The tale
  756. 37:05says 1,000 years after the flood—you
  757. 37:10know that the universal flood was also
  758. 37:13in Sumerian mythology. Mh. 1,000 years
  759. 37:18after the flood, power descended from
  760. 37:23heaven and chose men to rule over the
  761. 37:27people. This legend, in other words
  762. 37:32this Sumerian phrasing, is to say that
  763. 37:35all the peoples who characterized—in
  764. 37:38this case, reference is made to the
  765. 37:40Eastern Mediterranean—were governed
  766. 37:43by figures who were not kings because
  767. 37:46they were stronger than the others or
  768. 37:49had been elected: they were a sort of
  769. 37:52selected race placed to govern the
  770. 37:54peoples. Therefore, all the populations
  771. 37:59that were, in fact, occupying the area
  772. 38:02of the Eastern Mediterranean had
  773. 38:05sovereigns governing them who
  774. 38:08considered themselves all relatives of
  775. 38:11one another, a bit like the Europe of
  776. 38:14the Habsburgs in the 1700s, agreed?
  777. 38:17They were all relatives among
  778. 38:19themselves and were the so-called great
  779. 38:22kings. The term great king is present
  780. 38:26in all the populations of the ancient
  781. 38:28Near East. The great kings were the
  782. 38:32king of Egypt, the king of Kish, the
  783. 38:34king of Elam, that is of Susa, that of
  784. 38:36Akkad, of the Sumerian territory, of
  785. 38:38Assur, of Mari, of Ebla, of Hatti, of
  786. 38:40Crete, and of Mycenae. These were the
  787. 38:43great kings. Only a great king could
  788. 38:48address another great king. Only a
  789. 38:54great king could give his daughter in
  790. 38:57marriage to another great king. Any
  791. 39:00woman who was not linked to a great
  792. 39:02king, if she entered the family of a
  793. 39:04great king, became a concubine, she did
  794. 39:07not become a wife. The great kings were
  795. 39:10all relatives among themselves. Now the
  796. 39:13pharaoh of Egypt was a god for the
  797. 39:16Egyptians. Agreed? Actually, this is a
  798. 39:19discussion that needs to be had; a very
  799. 39:21, very complex and long discussion,
  800. 39:23that of the concept of the great kings,
  801. 39:25especially concerning Egypt, about
  802. 39:27which we are better informed than
  803. 39:29elsewhere. But these great kings were
  804. 39:32figures who, in some way, were the
  805. 39:34guardians of the people; they weren't
  806. 39:37politicians who are just placed there
  807. 39:40and do whatever they feel like. The
  808. 39:44great kings were, in reality, figures
  809. 39:46who were the guarantors of the people
  810. 39:48and they had to prove they were great
  811. 39:51kings. They had to demonstrate it in
  812. 39:55certain ways, in certain circumstances,
  813. 39:58in certain situations throughout their
  814. 40:01lives; they had to have the bearing of
  815. 40:03great kings, is that clear? And they
  816. 40:07talked to each other, they wrote to
  817. 40:09each other; meaning the pharaoh, who
  818. 40:12was a god, wrote letters—even
  819. 40:14friendly ones—to the king of Kish, or
  820. 40:16to the king of Mari, or to the king of
  821. 40:19Kush, understood? He was a great king.
  822. 40:22Now, the number of great kings was
  823. 40:25fixed because it had been established
  824. 40:29from the beginning. Every now and then,
  825. 40:34someone would be added who, in some way
  826. 40:37, established themselves as a great
  827. 40:39king alongside the others. Hmm. In the
  828. 40:461700s, England, Prussia, and Austria
  829. 40:49didn't go to war with each other
  830. 40:51because they were all relatives.
  831. 40:55Napoleon arrives, who is related to no
  832. 40:57one, and wages war. It's an example
  833. 41:00that serves only to help you understand
  834. 41:02the concept, is that clear? Good. In
  835. 41:05this civilization of great kings, these
  836. 41:07are the places where we know there were
  837. 41:10great kings. At a certain point, in the
  838. 41:1310th century BC, another great king
  839. 41:16appears: Troy. At Troy, there hadn't
  840. 41:20been a great king; it wasn't a city
  841. 41:21linked to the great kings. From the
  842. 41:2510th century, a city whose name was
  843. 41:28Wilusa, which was located there, begins
  844. 41:30to be counted in the list of great
  845. 41:33kings, and the sovereign of Wilusa
  846. 41:35demands his place on the political
  847. 41:38chessboard of the entire Ancient Near
  848. 41:40East. The great kings were extremely
  849. 41:44different from one another; in every
  850. 41:47civilization, they were different.
  851. 41:49Every population had its own great
  852. 41:51kings. The great king of Egypt, of
  853. 41:54Akkad, of Sumer, of Assur, of Gudea,
  854. 41:56the great king of the Hittites. Mycenae
  855. 42:02; Agamemnon was a great king, he was
  856. 42:04the king of Mycenae. Menelaus, his
  857. 42:08brother, was not a great king. Indeed,
  858. 42:12we speak of the Mycenaean people and we
  859. 42:15also include Sparta, Tiryns, and so on,
  860. 42:18because Mycenae was the reference city,
  861. 42:21so he was the king of Mycenae,
  862. 42:23Agamemnon—or rather, saying it the
  863. 42:25Greek way, Agamemnon—which indeed
  864. 42:28means the one who commands everything,
  865. 42:30the king of kings, precisely. These
  866. 42:35were the great kings on the list we had
  867. 42:37, and these figures were in agreement
  868. 42:39with one another; they helped each
  869. 42:41other, they helped each other
  870. 42:43militarily. When one of them got into
  871. 42:46trouble, the others would intervene.
  872. 42:49When one faced a famine, the others
  873. 42:51helped, provided they didn't conspire
  874. 42:53to feast upon the remains of the one
  875. 42:55who had perished. I mean, in a way,
  876. 42:58they were the only ones capable of
  877. 43:00communicating with each other. There
  878. 43:04was a sort of balance in the Eastern
  879. 43:07Mediterranean and the Ancient Near East
  880. 43:10: very diverse peoples linked by a
  881. 43:13series of fake family relationships.
  882. 43:18Because it’s not true that they were
  883. 43:19related; obviously, they had nothing to
  884. 43:21do with each other. Yet, there were
  885. 43:23these trade ties, these family bonds
  886. 43:25through which they respected one
  887. 43:27another. Hm. The Great King was the
  888. 43:30protector of everything, the one who
  889. 43:32guaranteed peace. To violate that peace
  890. 43:35was, in a way, to defy the Great King
  891. 43:37and, therefore, all those who were
  892. 43:39Great Kings like him. Agreed? This was
  893. 43:43the very complex situation of that era.
  894. 43:47Obviously, the relations between some
  895. 43:50of these Great Kings were often strange
  896. 43:53, and in this particular case, two of
  897. 43:56them—the Great King of Egypt and the
  898. 43:59Great King of Hatti (the part you see
  899. 44:02in red)—were in close contact, and it
  900. 44:05was close contact over a zone that was
  901. 44:08the Near East here, the part of the
  902. 44:11land of Canaan, here like this, which
  903. 44:14was a point of contact, but an
  904. 44:17important point of contact. Hm, because
  905. 44:20it was an area where certain trade
  906. 44:23routes ended and where there were
  907. 44:27extraordinary materials, materials that
  908. 44:30everyone coveted at the time: the
  909. 44:31cedars of Lebanon. Today Today we
  910. 44:37sometimes struggle to understand why
  911. 44:40that area is so important. It's true, I
  912. 44:43mean, they talk about the Golan Heights
  913. 44:46. Personally, the first time I went to
  914. 44:50the Golan Heights, I said: "My goodness
  915. 44:53, it would be like going to war for 50
  916. 44:55years over the little hills located, I
  917. 44:58don't know, between Fabriano and Albac.
  918. 45:01" I mean, and there it’s actually
  919. 45:03cultivated, there's...I mean, there, on
  920. 45:05the Golan Heights, there's nothing:
  921. 45:07they’re scorched, ugly, and these
  922. 45:08people have been killing each other for
  923. 45:10decades over the Golan Heights. Back
  924. 45:13then, this was much more understandable
  925. 45:14because there were the cedars of
  926. 45:16Lebanon. The cedar of Lebanon was the
  927. 45:20only tall tree usable for certain
  928. 45:23things. In Egypt, there were palm trees
  929. 45:26. The palm tree cannot be used to build
  930. 45:28houses. The palm tree cannot be used
  931. 45:31for pulling, for making sleds, for
  932. 45:33moving blocks. The palm tree cannot be
  933. 45:36used to carve sarcophagi. So in Egypt,
  934. 45:39there are palm trees, and that’s it.
  935. 45:42In Syria there was the Aleppo pine, but
  936. 45:44the Aleppo pine isn't much, I mean, the
  937. 45:47Aleppo pine is a small pine, so it
  938. 45:48produces little timber. The only
  939. 45:52effective timber that existed was, in
  940. 45:54fact, the cedar of Lebanon. There are
  941. 45:57many legends that refer to the journeys
  942. 45:59and exploits to obtain the cedars of
  943. 46:02Lebanon; the story of Wenamun, the
  944. 46:04lamentations of Nippur, they are all
  945. 46:06ancient literary texts that speak
  946. 46:08precisely of the importance of this
  947. 46:11place. And then here is Canaan, and at
  948. 46:16this point, there is an incredible
  949. 46:19place called Nahr el-Kalb. I don't know
  950. 46:24if any of you have ever been to Lebanon
  951. 46:26, to Nahr el-Kalb. It's an incredible
  952. 46:30place, truly, because it's a river
  953. 46:34gorge. But the gorge of this river,
  954. 46:37believe me, is as long as this room, so
  955. 46:40it really is a ridiculous thing, but
  956. 46:42this river gorge, which is found
  957. 46:44exactly here at this point, has a
  958. 46:45peculiarity. It is the only point where
  959. 46:50, in a radius from here, heading inland
  960. 46:53for more than 100 km, the only point
  961. 46:56where anyone moving from north to south
  962. 46:59is forced to pass, and it's as wide as
  963. 47:02this room. And so what happens? Why is
  964. 47:06it an incredible place? Because anyone
  965. 47:10from antiquity who passed through that
  966. 47:13gorge felt the need to leave an
  967. 47:15inscription on the wall, on the cliff
  968. 47:18face of this gorge. And it's incredible
  969. 47:24because you go there and you find the
  970. 47:27signature of the great Sumerian king
  971. 47:31Sargon. You find the signature of the
  972. 47:35Assyrian emperor Tiglath-Pileser, you
  973. 47:37find the inscription in hieroglyphs—
  974. 47:39everyone obviously signs with their own
  975. 47:42script. You find the signature of
  976. 47:45Ramesses II, but you also find the
  977. 47:47signature of Emperor Hadrian, the
  978. 47:49signature of Octavian Augustus, and the
  979. 47:51signature of Vespasian. Right up to the
  980. 47:54last one, who put his name up this big,
  981. 47:56which was Moshe Dayan. The description
  982. 48:01of Moshe Dayan—and it's a place as
  983. 48:03big as this room, so strategically
  984. 48:05speaking, it was incredibly important;
  985. 48:07it's called Nahr el-Kalb, which in
  986. 48:09Arabic means the Dog River. Mh, it's
  987. 48:12located right here, and the center, the
  988. 48:15city that lies just behind it—
  989. 48:16currently in Syrian territory, just
  990. 48:19behind is a figure of speech, it's 100
  991. 48:21km away—is the city of Kadesh. Today,
  992. 48:24Kadesh is a village in Syria, it is not
  993. 48:26the city that is here. Now, the prince
  994. 48:30of Kadesh, who was allied with the
  995. 48:33Egyptians, at a certain point sided
  996. 48:35with the Hittites, and this caused this
  997. 48:38war, the war between Ramesses and the
  998. 48:41Hittites. Ramesses was young, you know,
  999. 48:45this is the most beautiful statue of
  1000. 48:48Ramesses that exists, and it is found
  1001. 48:50today in Turin. Mm, you see, he always
  1002. 48:53has the crown on his head. And this is
  1003. 48:58the Hittite emperor, Muwatalli.
  1004. 49:02Muwatalli, who obviously carries on
  1005. 49:04this war, even if in reality he isn't
  1006. 49:06the one fighting it; his brother, who
  1007. 49:07was named Hattusili, is fighting
  1008. 49:09against Ramses. You know that the war
  1009. 49:13of Kadesh, we are around 1278 BC, was
  1010. 49:15actually a battle where no one knows
  1011. 49:17who won because the Egyptians say, "We
  1012. 49:20won." The Hittites said, "We won." In
  1013. 49:25fact, the border actually remained at
  1014. 49:26Kadesh, since Kadesh was razed to the
  1015. 49:28ground, there was nothing left to
  1016. 49:30divide, and consequently, each of the
  1017. 49:32two could say, "We won." However,
  1018. 49:35consider that the war of Kadesh was
  1019. 49:37indeed an extraordinary thing. This
  1020. 49:40that you see here, you see, is an
  1021. 49:42engraving that is found at Abu Simbel,
  1022. 49:44which is the famous poem of Kadesh, the
  1023. 49:46whole story of the war. Mm. An Iliad,
  1024. 49:50that is, the whole course of this
  1025. 49:52battle for the city of Kadesh is
  1026. 49:54recounted. This watercourse you see
  1027. 49:58here is the Orontes River, which is the
  1028. 50:00river that marked the border between
  1029. 50:02Egyptian and Hittite territory. And on
  1030. 50:06the Orontes was this very city. So,
  1031. 50:09whoever controlled the city had a
  1032. 50:11bridgehead against the opposing empire.
  1033. 50:14Mm. And you know that in reality Ramses
  1034. 50:17II took a real beating at the battle of
  1035. 50:19Kadesh, because he was just a boy, he
  1036. 50:21was 24 years old, and he got caught by
  1037. 50:24the Hittite army while he was crossing
  1038. 50:26the river, so he was in the river with
  1039. 50:28his chariot. Mm. And his division, the
  1040. 50:31Amun division, was totally wiped out,
  1041. 50:33right? But Ramses says that during the
  1042. 50:37battle he at a certain point alone, all
  1043. 50:40alone, manages to win because his
  1044. 50:43entire division is massacred, the other
  1045. 50:46divisions are still across the river,
  1046. 50:49so they hadn't managed to cross, and he
  1047. 50:52finds himself surrounded by enemies and
  1048. 50:55believes he is lost. So what does he do
  1049. 50:59? He puts it in his mouth. It is
  1050. 51:02written here, this thing, he puts the
  1051. 51:04collar he had around his neck into his
  1052. 51:06mouth, which was the collar of the god
  1053. 51:09Amun. All pharaohs believed they were
  1054. 51:11children of Amun. Like this. And he
  1055. 51:14begins to pray to the god Amun to help
  1056. 51:17him. And at a certain point here the
  1057. 51:21inscription starts from here, words
  1058. 51:23spoken by the great king. It reaches
  1059. 51:26here, the lord of the western pieces,
  1060. 51:28it goes on, and then there is an
  1061. 51:30interesting point. Here it says that he
  1062. 51:33decides to sacrifice himself alone,
  1063. 51:35alone on the chariot; he even says "I
  1064. 51:38am alone with my two horses" and gives
  1065. 51:40the names of the two horses, one called
  1066. 51:43Victory in Thebes and the other called
  1067. 51:46Rising Sun in Memphis are the names of
  1068. 51:48the two horses. And he says he takes
  1069. 51:52off and charges against the enemies to
  1070. 51:54kill, to die. And there is a beautiful
  1071. 51:57sentence here that starts from this
  1072. 51:59point that says: "Here you are, Father,
  1073. 52:05and I see that you are for me more than
  1074. 52:08a million men." Why? What happens? And
  1075. 52:13the image says it: the soul of the god
  1076. 52:16Amun enters inside the pharaoh. And in
  1077. 52:20fact look, the pharaoh has four arms,
  1078. 52:22do you see? Two arms are red in color
  1079. 52:25and they are the God who has entered
  1080. 52:27inside him. So he begins to shoot such
  1081. 52:31a quantity of arrows that the
  1082. 52:33inscription, which is not seen here but
  1083. 52:36is reported further back, says that the
  1084. 52:39enemies fall by the tens of thousands
  1085. 52:42under the hooves, precisely, of Victory
  1086. 52:45in Thebes and Rising Sun in Memphis. Eh
  1087. 52:48, however, it's interesting, you see
  1088. 52:51this heroic image, right, of the
  1089. 52:53pharaoh who has four arms, precisely to
  1090. 52:55indicate the speed of the God who is
  1091. 52:58with him inside the same body and
  1092. 53:00therefore shoots the enemies. And then
  1093. 53:05obviously the pharaoh who won, it's not
  1094. 53:08true that he won, he won, but, let's
  1095. 53:11say, the surrender of the spies he
  1096. 53:14captured. Mh, here below you can see
  1097. 53:17the spies down there being beaten and
  1098. 53:20they reveal, precisely, what the
  1099. 53:22betrayal had been, they had been told
  1100. 53:24in reality to cross the river while
  1101. 53:27instead it was not true and so on.
  1102. 53:30Anyway, this is another part of the
  1103. 53:31story and this is the drawing. Just to
  1104. 53:34show better the image that otherwise is
  1105. 53:36very damaged. You can see, you see the
  1106. 53:39city of Kadesh, which is this part that
  1107. 53:41you see here with the walls and the
  1108. 53:43pharaoh, you see that with the horse he
  1109. 53:45is overwhelming the enemies. Here are
  1110. 53:48the military divisions, Hittites,
  1111. 53:50defending the city and the city is
  1112. 53:53besieged. So the siege, the attack on
  1113. 53:55Kadesh was this incredible siege in
  1114. 53:58contact between the Egyptian people and
  1115. 54:00the Hittites, but in reality, it is not
  1116. 54:02known who won. Eh, this is the detail,
  1117. 54:05you see, of the bas-relief that
  1118. 54:06represents, precisely, the city with
  1119. 54:08the inhabitants placed inside it. The
  1120. 54:12name of the city, here it is, Nesuten
  1121. 54:14Kadesh, it is written, that is, the
  1122. 54:16city of Kadesh. In the end, a
  1123. 54:21non-aggression treaty was made, which
  1124. 54:24is this one written in cuneiform. Today
  1125. 54:27it is kept at the Istanbul Archaeology
  1126. 54:30Museums, and it is precisely the peace
  1127. 54:32treaty between the Hittites and the
  1128. 54:35Egyptians. Careful, though. We talked
  1129. 54:43about, we saw the legendary tradition
  1130. 54:45of Priam, and now I have given you some
  1131. 54:48military indications regarding Ramses.
  1132. 54:52This map is a particular map because we
  1133. 54:55are in the 10th century BC. We are in
  1134. 55:00the transition between the so-called
  1135. 55:03Late Bronze Age and the Final Bronze
  1136. 55:06Age. The Final Bronze Age in some parts
  1137. 55:10corresponds to the Iron Age, because
  1138. 55:13this era is marked by a series of
  1139. 55:15migrations of peoples. These migrations
  1140. 55:19, which took place over centuries and
  1141. 55:22in completely different ways, are
  1142. 55:24migrations that characterized the
  1143. 55:26entire Eurasian area. Practically, what
  1144. 55:30happened? That some peoples who were
  1145. 55:34settled in territories, partly
  1146. 55:36Ukrainian, partly Russian, and partly
  1147. 55:39Uzbek—so these peoples you see here
  1148. 55:43in purple—move. Those peoples who
  1149. 55:48were there were the stock that we
  1150. 55:50define as the Aryan or Indo-European
  1151. 55:52stock. These peoples, you see, move
  1152. 55:57into various areas, but the problem is
  1153. 56:00not that they are moving, but that they
  1154. 56:03trigger a series of displacement waves
  1155. 56:07that reach all the surrounding
  1156. 56:09territories. That is, this is the
  1157. 56:13important thing to understand. There is
  1158. 56:16no poor fellow with his wife and
  1159. 56:18children and a cart who starts from
  1160. 56:21here, starts from Crimea, and arrives
  1161. 56:24in Denmark or arrives in India. That
  1162. 56:27did not happen. He, with his wife and
  1163. 56:31children, actually moves 200 km, that
  1164. 56:33is, he arrives perhaps in the territory
  1165. 56:35of Moldova. The Moldavians, who had
  1166. 56:39lived there peacefully for thousands of
  1167. 56:41years, have these people arrive who are
  1168. 56:43instead bellicose, they are warmongers.
  1169. 56:46The Moldavians flee, and what do they
  1170. 56:48do? They flee and crash into Thrace.
  1171. 56:51They arrive as invaders, so what do the
  1172. 56:52Thracians do? They flee as well. This
  1173. 56:55triggers a process that eventually
  1174. 56:57involves the areas of the Mediterranean
  1175. 57:01too. In short, around the 10th century
  1176. 57:05BC. Many populations of the
  1177. 57:08Mediterranean saw themselves attacked
  1178. 57:11by people who, until a few years
  1179. 57:13earlier, lived peacefully in front of
  1180. 57:15them without any problems. At a certain
  1181. 57:18point, these people invade them, is
  1182. 57:20that clear? Due to ethnic pressures
  1183. 57:23from behind. Therefore, the peoples who
  1184. 57:28come into contact with each other are
  1185. 57:30often brotherly peoples, they are the
  1186. 57:32famous great kings who were often even
  1187. 57:35related to each other, but who suffer
  1188. 57:37the attack of those behind them.
  1189. 57:41Obviously, the ones we are interested
  1190. 57:44in, or rather the ones we are
  1191. 57:46interested in under these circumstances
  1192. 57:49, are the populations you see down here
  1193. 57:51, which arrive in the area, hitting the
  1194. 57:54Mediterranean coast and pushing all
  1195. 57:57those peoples who previously lived on
  1196. 58:00the edge of the Mediterranean into the
  1197. 58:02sea. And what do these people, who find
  1198. 58:05themselves under attack from behind, do
  1199. 58:07? They jump onto ships and cross the
  1200. 58:09sea. Those who were here cross it, they
  1201. 58:13cross toward Asia Minor, they cross
  1202. 58:15toward Cyprus, they cross toward Egypt.
  1203. 58:19The populations that were in Asia Minor
  1204. 58:22, in Cyprus, and in Egypt, seeing these
  1205. 58:24people arriving—people they see are
  1206. 58:27different because they are all the
  1207. 58:30peoples who lived behind them—simply
  1208. 58:32call them the Sea Peoples. We have the
  1209. 58:37names of these Sea Peoples in Egyptian
  1210. 58:40sources; they are the Shardana, the
  1211. 58:42Tursenoi, these are the reported names.
  1212. 58:47Shardana means Sardinians. Some say
  1213. 58:51they were the Sardinians from Sardinia,
  1214. 58:52others, more likely, say they were the
  1215. 58:54Sardians from the city of Sardis.
  1216. 58:58Tursenoi means the inhabitants of Tyre.
  1217. 59:01Some say no, they were the Etruscans.
  1218. 59:04Akiawa are the Achaeans. So, around
  1219. 59:081250 BC, all the populations living on
  1220. 59:11the coast of Egypt, on the coast of
  1221. 59:14Asia Minor, and on the Syrian coast
  1222. 59:17suddenly saw this avalanche of people
  1223. 59:19arriving, people with whom, until a few
  1224. 59:22years earlier, they had actually traded
  1225. 59:25; they were face to face, right? They
  1226. 59:29arrive because they are being pushed
  1227. 59:31from behind. Now, Ramses is the one
  1228. 59:36most useful to us in these matters
  1229. 59:39because we have Egyptian literature
  1230. 59:42that tells us about these things in
  1231. 59:45detail, and it says that Ramses, in his
  1232. 59:49seventh year of reign, had to suddenly
  1233. 59:52repel the massive attack of the Akiawa.
  1234. 59:58Akiawa—on this we have certainty—
  1235. 1:00:01are the Achaeans, because the Achaeans
  1236. 1:00:04are also called Hiyawa in Hittite
  1237. 1:00:06sources; that is, the Achaeans, who are
  1238. 1:00:09actually people from Greece, are the
  1239. 1:00:12inhabitants of Bronze Age Greece,
  1240. 1:00:14pressed from behind by the Dorians, who
  1241. 1:00:17actually came from Macedonia, Moldova,
  1242. 1:00:20Romania, etc., and were in turn pushed
  1243. 1:00:23from behind by the Aryans. The Akiawa
  1244. 1:00:27find themselves forced to cross to the
  1245. 1:00:30other side and look for a passage, they
  1246. 1:00:33are looking for a gap, in fact. Ramses,
  1247. 1:00:37obviously, in this case, deploys all
  1248. 1:00:41his forces and tries to repel the
  1249. 1:00:44attack of the Akiawa. This relief you
  1250. 1:00:48see here represents Ramses, the same
  1251. 1:00:50name, right? You see, behind his back,
  1252. 1:00:53you can see that the Lord, the prince
  1253. 1:00:56of Upper Egypt—it’s written here,
  1254. 1:00:58the prince of Upper Egypt, descendant
  1255. 1:01:00of Amun, who is strong in heart, it’s
  1256. 1:01:03written behind—and look, he holds his
  1257. 1:01:05enemies by their hair, like this, and
  1258. 1:01:08you can see this bunch of enemies that,
  1259. 1:01:10precisely, he has defeated. If you look
  1260. 1:01:14at the features of the enemies, there
  1261. 1:01:16are Negroid types, dark-skinned
  1262. 1:01:18characters, but also white-skinned
  1263. 1:01:20characters. You can see one with a
  1264. 1:01:23black beard, right behind him. Well,
  1265. 1:01:28this map represents one of these waves
  1266. 1:01:31of the Sea Peoples. You see, there is a
  1267. 1:01:35yellow arrow, this one you see here,
  1268. 1:01:37which in reality are the Achaeans, who
  1269. 1:01:39pass through the Strait of Cyprus like
  1270. 1:01:42this and arrive to attack Egypt here.
  1271. 1:01:45Why don't they arrive here? Because
  1272. 1:01:47here there are the mountains, here are
  1273. 1:01:48the Lebanon Mountains. The Lebanon
  1274. 1:01:50Mountains are mountains over 3000
  1275. 1:01:52meters high. So the only way to get
  1276. 1:01:54through is to slide south and arrive in
  1277. 1:01:57a richer and more prosperous country,
  1278. 1:01:59which is, indeed, Egypt. So the Sea
  1279. 1:02:02Peoples attack Egypt, but they are
  1280. 1:02:04repelled by Egypt. We will see where
  1281. 1:02:07else they go. They don't enter Egypt,
  1282. 1:02:11but they try to attack the kingdom of
  1283. 1:02:13Hatti, which is this part here. The
  1284. 1:02:16kingdom of Hatti would be the Hittite
  1285. 1:02:18Empire, and in fact, the Sea Peoples
  1286. 1:02:20will lead to the collapse of the
  1287. 1:02:22Hittite Empire. The Hittite Empire dies
  1288. 1:02:24, it ends, completely overwhelmed by
  1289. 1:02:26the Sea Peoples. But look at this arrow
  1290. 1:02:28, it's interesting. To arrive and
  1291. 1:02:30attack the Hittite Empire, those who
  1292. 1:02:32come here, look at where they pass.
  1293. 1:02:35Here, here where I am pointing now,
  1294. 1:02:37there is Wilusa, that is, there is Troy
  1295. 1:02:39. Wilusa is not part of the Hittite
  1296. 1:02:43territory. Um, I have sometimes heard
  1297. 1:02:47on television in documentaries about
  1298. 1:02:49the Hittite city of Wilusa. Now, Wilusa
  1299. 1:02:53is not a Hittite city, it is not even
  1300. 1:02:57of Hittite culture; it is of Asianic
  1301. 1:03:00culture. Asianic means peoples of Asia
  1302. 1:03:03Minor who cannot be classified within
  1303. 1:03:05the Hittite civilization or the other
  1304. 1:03:07neighboring civilizations. Our problem
  1305. 1:03:10is that when we refer to ancient
  1306. 1:03:12peoples by the name of their government
  1307. 1:03:14, we categorize the whole population
  1308. 1:03:16that way. Like when we talk about the
  1309. 1:03:18Roman Empire. But if I went to Syria in
  1310. 1:03:21the Roman Empire, it was difficult to
  1311. 1:03:23find people who were born in Velletri,
  1312. 1:03:25in Frosinone, or in Ascoli Piceno, or
  1313. 1:03:27in Ancona. In Syria, I found Romans who
  1314. 1:03:31were actually born in Damascus, Aleppo,
  1315. 1:03:33etc., because the state is Roman, but
  1316. 1:03:35culturally they are not Roman. In the
  1317. 1:03:38Hittite Empire, it was like that. The
  1318. 1:03:41Hittites were the people of Hatti, and
  1319. 1:03:43the Hittites were here only in this
  1320. 1:03:45small central piece that you see here,
  1321. 1:03:47but their empire had extended across
  1322. 1:03:49the entire central Anatolian plateau.
  1323. 1:03:52Around, because the Hittites did not go
  1324. 1:03:54by sea. Along the coast here, there
  1325. 1:03:58were all vassal states, vassal
  1326. 1:04:01principalities, which were related to
  1327. 1:04:04the great Hittite king by sending him
  1328. 1:04:07wives, princes, hostages, and so on. At
  1329. 1:04:13a certain point, in the 13th century BC
  1330. 1:04:16, one of these vassal states, Wilusa,
  1331. 1:04:18that is Troy, felt important enough to
  1332. 1:04:21declare itself autonomous and to name
  1333. 1:04:24its king "Great King." Is that clear?
  1334. 1:04:29So it is clear that the Sea Peoples,
  1335. 1:04:31these famous Ahhiyawa, that is, the
  1336. 1:04:33Achaeans, who had to attack the Hittite
  1337. 1:04:35empire, passed through the Dardanelles
  1338. 1:04:38strait here and invaded Wilusa,
  1339. 1:04:40precisely invading the city of Troy. So
  1340. 1:04:45the same migratory wave of the Sea
  1341. 1:04:47Peoples that slammed into Egypt slammed
  1342. 1:04:50into the north, before arriving in the
  1343. 1:04:53Hittite empire, it slammed into the
  1344. 1:04:56Trojan principality. Here then is the
  1345. 1:05:01historical circumstance that connects
  1346. 1:05:04Ramesses down there, excuse me, with
  1347. 1:05:07Priam who is in the north at the same
  1348. 1:05:09time. You understand that, seen in this
  1349. 1:05:14light, the rape of Helen is a literary
  1350. 1:05:16creation. After all, Helen, that is,
  1351. 1:05:21Helena, who is the colleague who is
  1352. 1:05:24kidnapped, has the linguistic root in
  1353. 1:05:27her name "el" which means Greece.
  1354. 1:05:31Greece is called Hellas. Therefore,
  1355. 1:05:34Helen represents the government in the
  1356. 1:05:37Greek territory. The rape of Helen in
  1357. 1:05:40some way, and by the way, always
  1358. 1:05:42remember that power passed through the
  1359. 1:05:44female line, so the rape of Helen
  1360. 1:05:46represents the usurpation of the
  1361. 1:05:48government in the Aegean area. Hmm.
  1362. 1:05:52Obviously then, there is a Great King,
  1363. 1:05:55a Great King of Wilusa who wants to be
  1364. 1:05:57Great King, but no one wants him to be.
  1365. 1:06:00This is the casus belli that is
  1366. 1:06:02triggered throughout the entire Eastern
  1367. 1:06:04Mediterranean. How does Ramesses react?
  1368. 1:06:08This is a relief found at the temple of
  1369. 1:06:11Karnak, in the pylon of the temple of
  1370. 1:06:14Karnak. You can see Ramesses on his
  1371. 1:06:17chariot overwhelming the Sea Peoples.
  1372. 1:06:20The Sea Peoples arrive, they land in
  1373. 1:06:23Cyrenaica, so they land further away,
  1374. 1:06:26then by land they approach the Delta.
  1375. 1:06:29of the Nile, but there they are
  1376. 1:06:32overwhelmed by Ramesses who, in the
  1377. 1:06:34inscription you see there, boasts of
  1378. 1:06:36having had a great victory and of his
  1379. 1:06:39glory against the Sea Peoples
  1380. 1:06:41themselves. Unfortunately, the
  1381. 1:06:43inscription, many of the images are
  1382. 1:06:45unfortunately damaged, you can see it
  1383. 1:06:48well here, you can even see the horse,
  1384. 1:06:50because the temple of Karnak, this half
  1385. 1:06:53of the temple of Karnak, even if one
  1386. 1:06:55goes to Egypt, they practically never
  1387. 1:06:58tell you that. In the 6th century, the
  1388. 1:07:01temple of Karnak was transformed into
  1389. 1:07:03the cathedral of Luxor. It became a
  1390. 1:07:07church, and by becoming a church, they
  1391. 1:07:09destroyed, they deliberately erased all
  1392. 1:07:12the images. Agreed? Then in the 1700s,
  1393. 1:07:15wanting to restore its temple
  1394. 1:07:17appearance, everything related to the
  1395. 1:07:19church was removed. Is that clear? But
  1396. 1:07:22it was the cathedral, because Thebes
  1397. 1:07:24was the medieval, well, early medieval
  1398. 1:07:26name, and it became the cathedral.
  1399. 1:07:28Curiously, it remained a church even
  1400. 1:07:31after the Arab conquest, because even
  1401. 1:07:33today Luxor in Egypt is a
  1402. 1:07:35majority-Christian city. Almost all the
  1403. 1:07:38inhabitants of Luxor are Copts. Agreed?
  1404. 1:07:41And so, unfortunately, the inscription
  1405. 1:07:43was damaged. This is an important
  1406. 1:07:46document. It is a terracotta letter
  1407. 1:07:50written by the Hittite emperor
  1408. 1:07:53Muwatalli, the one who waged war
  1409. 1:07:57against Ramses. It is a letter that is
  1410. 1:08:00currently in London. This bump you see
  1411. 1:08:03in the middle is actually an
  1412. 1:08:05indentation, a seal, and it is the
  1413. 1:08:08royal seal of King Muwatalli. And the
  1414. 1:08:12inscription, written in cuneiform even
  1415. 1:08:15though the language is Hittite, speaks
  1416. 1:08:18of the fact that Egypt and Hatti,
  1417. 1:08:21meaning the Hittite Empire, must
  1418. 1:08:23present a united front against the
  1419. 1:08:26arrival of the Sea Peoples. The letter
  1420. 1:08:30is currently in London. This is an even
  1421. 1:08:34more interesting document. It is a
  1422. 1:08:36document that, well, it is located in
  1423. 1:08:39Istanbul. It is also in cuneiform
  1424. 1:08:43script and is a letter sent to the king
  1425. 1:08:46of Wilusa, that is, the king of Troy.
  1426. 1:08:50Unfortunately, it does not mention the
  1427. 1:08:53name of the Hittite emperor who sent a
  1428. 1:08:55letter to all the surrounding kingdoms,
  1429. 1:08:58asking them to present a united front
  1430. 1:09:00against the attack of these Sea Peoples
  1431. 1:09:03. But the document that is even more
  1432. 1:09:06interesting for us is this one.
  1433. 1:09:09Unfortunately, it is a fragment, a
  1434. 1:09:11fragment with cuneiform writing, and it
  1435. 1:09:14is also currently in London; it is,
  1436. 1:09:17well, it's about this big, it's this
  1437. 1:09:20small. It is actually a letter that the
  1438. 1:09:24Hittite emperor, who is no longer
  1439. 1:09:26Muwatalli but has become his brother
  1440. 1:09:29Hattusili, writes to the great king of
  1441. 1:09:33the Ahhiyawa, that is, the king of the
  1442. 1:09:36Achaeans. Unfortunately, the name of
  1443. 1:09:41the king of the Ahhiyawa is not written
  1444. 1:09:44, and it says—well, he actually
  1445. 1:09:47writes to the king of the Sea Peoples
  1446. 1:09:50—asking for the help of the king of
  1447. 1:09:54the Ahhiyawa against the prince
  1448. 1:09:57Piyama-Radu of Wilusa. The prince
  1449. 1:10:02Piyama-Radu of Wilusa was, in quotes, "
  1450. 1:10:07boh," Hector, "boh." But curiously, in
  1451. 1:10:11other terms, the Sea Peoples are
  1452. 1:10:13arriving; the Hittite emperor is afraid
  1453. 1:10:15, and he has good reason to be, because
  1454. 1:10:17the Hittite Empire will be overwhelmed
  1455. 1:10:20by those very Sea Peoples. He asks for
  1456. 1:10:22help from all the neighboring peoples.
  1457. 1:10:24Some side with him, the Phrygians, the
  1458. 1:10:27Mysians, while others, let's say,
  1459. 1:10:30demand their autonomy. Among them is
  1460. 1:10:33the king of Wilusa, who even wants to
  1461. 1:10:36become a great king, that is, he wants
  1462. 1:10:38to become one of the figures who govern
  1463. 1:10:41the peoples on equal footing with the
  1464. 1:10:44others. So, the King of Hatti, given
  1465. 1:10:48the betrayal by the King of Wilusa,
  1466. 1:10:51asks, or rather tries to befriend the
  1467. 1:10:53King of the Ahhiyawa, and writes him
  1468. 1:10:56this letter, speaking ill of this
  1469. 1:10:58prince Piyama-Radu of Wilusa, sorry,
  1470. 1:11:01the Emperor of Hatti. So, in reality,
  1471. 1:11:06it's as if the Achaeans were encouraged
  1472. 1:11:08by the Hittite Emperor to attack Troy.
  1473. 1:11:12That is what this document tells us.
  1474. 1:11:15Then, obviously, it all remains to be
  1475. 1:11:17seen. It could very well be that
  1476. 1:11:18Piyama-Radu has nothing to do with it.
  1477. 1:11:20We accept the era is that one, that's
  1478. 1:11:23clear. But there is something
  1479. 1:11:25interesting here, Piyama-Radu, meaning
  1480. 1:11:28this Hittite prince—or rather this
  1481. 1:11:30prince of Wilusa—is referred to as a
  1482. 1:11:33troublemaker and a plunderer. Now, here
  1483. 1:11:37is something interesting. Priam,
  1484. 1:11:41throughout the description of the Iliad
  1485. 1:11:44, is indicated as an extremely peaceful
  1486. 1:11:48character, while his son Paris, after
  1487. 1:11:54being recognized by his father—
  1488. 1:11:56because you know Paris had been exposed
  1489. 1:11:58, right? returned to Troy having become
  1490. 1:12:01an adult. After he was recognized as a
  1491. 1:12:05Trojan prince, Paris took to plundering
  1492. 1:12:08all the cities of Asia Minor, Cyprus,
  1493. 1:12:11and Crete, so much so that Paris
  1494. 1:12:13destroyed many kingdoms that faced the
  1495. 1:12:16Aegean and the area of the eastern
  1496. 1:12:19Mediterranean. It is possible that in
  1497. 1:12:24reality, the Piyama-Radu indicated here
  1498. 1:12:26was not Priam, but perhaps Paris.
  1499. 1:12:29Except that, in the impossibility of
  1500. 1:12:31framing Paris, the head of the Hittite
  1501. 1:12:33Empire...Priam, to imply his son or
  1502. 1:12:37whoever it was? We cannot know this. We
  1503. 1:12:41are in the realm of hypotheses. Agreed?
  1504. 1:12:46Obviously, while Egypt managed to repel
  1505. 1:12:49the Sea Peoples (but Egypt has a
  1506. 1:12:52completely different military and
  1507. 1:12:54economic strength, that's normal), it
  1508. 1:12:57was not so for the small kingdom of
  1509. 1:13:00Wilusa, especially because all the
  1510. 1:13:03other neighboring states, given the
  1511. 1:13:06arrival of the Sea Peoples, defected
  1512. 1:13:09against Troy. First and foremost Mysia,
  1513. 1:13:13the famous Telephus, King of Mysia, who
  1514. 1:13:16was even Priam's brother-in-law, who
  1515. 1:13:18out of fear of the arrival of the
  1516. 1:13:20Achaeans sided with the Achaeans. Is
  1517. 1:13:23that clear? So the principality of
  1518. 1:13:26Wilusa, Priam or whoever it was, could
  1519. 1:13:28have reacted and responded to the
  1520. 1:13:31attack of the Ahhiyawa if he had the
  1521. 1:13:33support of all the petty kings around
  1522. 1:13:36him; a thing that, however, was not
  1523. 1:13:38done because, in reality, there was
  1524. 1:13:40this concept: that Wilusa was not
  1525. 1:13:43supposed to be a great kingdom. The
  1526. 1:13:46King of Wilusa could not be a great one
  1527. 1:13:48; he was not a descendant of the Priams
  1528. 1:13:50. Priam was a "ransomed one." The name
  1529. 1:13:53Priam, that is, the name "ransomed," is
  1530. 1:13:55shameful; it does not contain anything
  1531. 1:13:57divine within itself. Is that clear? So
  1532. 1:14:00it is normal that all the petty kings
  1533. 1:14:02around were saying, "He has done what
  1534. 1:14:04he wanted up until now." Now that these
  1535. 1:14:06others have arrived, he is afraid and
  1536. 1:14:08fears our help, so we abandon him. And
  1537. 1:14:11this is what happened. Obviously the
  1538. 1:14:15great Achaean wave overwhelms—here we
  1539. 1:14:18are talking about Priam's history and
  1540. 1:14:22so obviously we say it overwhelms Troy
  1541. 1:14:25—but there are truly infinite
  1542. 1:14:27kingdoms that the wave of the Sea
  1543. 1:14:30Peoples overwhelmed. Agreed? I mean,
  1544. 1:14:34the entire Mediterranean was devastated
  1545. 1:14:36by this wave of the Sea Peoples. To the
  1546. 1:14:38point. Just think that the Bronze Age
  1547. 1:14:41civilization, the Mediterranean
  1548. 1:14:42civilization that existed before, will
  1549. 1:14:44be totally wiped away by it. There are
  1550. 1:14:48very few relics, the cultural relics
  1551. 1:14:52that will remain in the Mediterranean
  1552. 1:14:55from this moment on. Just think that
  1553. 1:14:58the arrival of the Sea Peoples, or
  1554. 1:15:00rather this sort of ethnic displacement
  1555. 1:15:03, wipes away all the populations that
  1556. 1:15:06had previously been in Greece. Even the
  1557. 1:15:10light of the previous language is lost,
  1558. 1:15:12the language that had been Mycenaean,
  1559. 1:15:15the Cretan civilization disappears. The
  1560. 1:15:18Dorians arrive, these new populations.
  1561. 1:15:21The only city that will not be wiped
  1562. 1:15:24away and that will live off the glory
  1563. 1:15:26of this for the following centuries
  1564. 1:15:28will be Athens. Athens boasted of being
  1565. 1:15:32the only one that had survived. And
  1566. 1:15:34where do these famous Sea Peoples go?
  1567. 1:15:38Sea Peoples, we call them that because,
  1568. 1:15:41you know, to give the name "Sea Peoples
  1569. 1:15:44"—incidentally paraphrasing or rather
  1570. 1:15:47translating the term used by the
  1571. 1:15:50Egyptians, which is Naadu en pin, which
  1572. 1:15:53indeed means Sea Peoples—is a great
  1573. 1:15:5619 th-century archaeologist named
  1574. 1:15:58Gaston Maspero, a Frenchman. Gaston
  1575. 1:16:03Maspero is the one who says Sea Peoples
  1576. 1:16:05, but in reality, these Sea Peoples are
  1577. 1:16:07those who will later become the Greeks
  1578. 1:16:10of Magna Graecia or the Greeks of the
  1579. 1:16:12Ionian coast of Turkey. Is that clear?
  1580. 1:16:14They are the new inhabitants who will
  1581. 1:16:17completely change the ethnic landscape
  1582. 1:16:19of that area. Only Athens remains there
  1583. 1:16:21, and so much so that it claimed to be
  1584. 1:16:24the ancestor of all because it had
  1585. 1:16:26remained there, but the others will
  1586. 1:16:28wipe away everything. This, indeed, is
  1587. 1:16:33the citadel, the walls of Troy, but the
  1588. 1:16:35Sea Peoples caused far greater damage.
  1589. 1:16:39They caused the Hittite Empire to
  1590. 1:16:40collapse. I mean Troy, for heaven's
  1591. 1:16:43sake, was ultimately a small kingdom,
  1592. 1:16:45it was the epic that made it great, but
  1593. 1:16:48the Hittite Empire, which encompassed
  1594. 1:16:50all of Asia Minor, will be wiped away
  1595. 1:16:52by them. Obviously, therefore, the
  1596. 1:16:57Trojan War: this is a page of the
  1597. 1:16:59so-called Ambrosian Iliad, one of the
  1598. 1:17:01oldest complete texts of the Iliad from
  1599. 1:17:03the Roman era that we have today. It is
  1600. 1:17:08kept in Milan, at the Ambrosian Library
  1601. 1:17:10, and this, you see, is a parchment
  1602. 1:17:13page showing soldiers fighting before
  1603. 1:17:15the eyes of those, you see, who are the
  1604. 1:17:18gods above. These little faces you see
  1605. 1:17:21here are the gods. Hmm. Unfortunately,
  1606. 1:17:26of the Iliad of the Ambrosiana, we
  1607. 1:17:28mostly preserve the images because some
  1608. 1:17:30wise guy in the 1600s decided to cut
  1609. 1:17:32out the figures, threw away all the
  1610. 1:17:35text, so we only have the figures, okay
  1611. 1:17:37? Some parts of the text remained stuck
  1612. 1:17:41to the back of the figures in the 1600s
  1613. 1:17:43. Eh, but let's say that at least we
  1614. 1:17:47have the whole comic strip of the Iliad
  1615. 1:17:50. The fall of Wilusa is even depicted
  1616. 1:17:56on a Hittite bas-relief that is now in
  1617. 1:17:59the museum of Boğazkale, which is a
  1618. 1:18:02small village in central Turkey near
  1619. 1:18:04Hattusa, the capital of the Hittites,
  1620. 1:18:07where you can see various cities
  1621. 1:18:09overwhelmed by the arrival of the Sea
  1622. 1:18:12Peoples. I like to think, this is the
  1623. 1:18:15drawing, because the original is all
  1624. 1:18:17black basalt and you can't see anything
  1625. 1:18:18. I like to think that these represent
  1626. 1:18:22the city of Troy, Wilusa, with the
  1627. 1:18:24defenders and the arrival of the people
  1628. 1:18:27here, but actually, between us, this
  1629. 1:18:30represents a city with soldiers around
  1630. 1:18:33it. It is hard to imagine that it is
  1631. 1:18:35truly the fall of Wilusa. In Egypt, how
  1632. 1:18:38do they deal with the arrival of the
  1633. 1:18:40Sea Peoples? Ramses II does not manage
  1634. 1:18:42to do it. Ramses II actually has other
  1635. 1:18:47problems. Incidentally, within the
  1636. 1:18:51scope of the ethnic movements connected
  1637. 1:18:53to the Sea Peoples, we must also
  1638. 1:18:55include other ethnic migrations that
  1639. 1:18:58characterized those lands at that time.
  1640. 1:19:01For example, the passage of the Hebrews
  1641. 1:19:04from Egypt to the land of Canaan. It is
  1642. 1:19:07all one great ethnic wave that involves
  1643. 1:19:10the entire Ancient Near East. Hmm. Or
  1644. 1:19:14the movement of the Gutians into
  1645. 1:19:16Mesopotamian territory, or the descent
  1646. 1:19:18of the Chaldean populations, or the
  1647. 1:19:20descent of the Assyrians from the north
  1648. 1:19:22, or the advance of the Phrygians
  1649. 1:19:24towards the west. I mean, we are
  1650. 1:19:28talking about this event, but in
  1651. 1:19:30reality, it is a huge ethnic
  1652. 1:19:31displacement that marks the end of
  1653. 1:19:33protohistory, the end of the Bronze Age
  1654. 1:19:36, and the arrival of the Iron Age.
  1655. 1:19:40These newcomers, the Indo-Europeans,
  1656. 1:19:45what do they bring? They bring a whole
  1657. 1:19:47series of things that were not in the
  1658. 1:19:49Mediterranean at that time. They bring
  1659. 1:19:51iron, they bring an economy based on
  1660. 1:19:54war, they bring patriarchy, they bring
  1661. 1:19:56the military use of the horse and
  1662. 1:19:58certain breeds of horses, okay? They
  1663. 1:20:01bring the use of the war chariot, the
  1664. 1:20:03use of certain types of weapons. So the
  1665. 1:20:05cultural landscape of the entire
  1666. 1:20:07Mediterranean changes completely; not
  1667. 1:20:10just the Eastern Mediterranean, but the
  1668. 1:20:12Central and Western Mediterranean will
  1669. 1:20:15follow later. Does Egypt resist all of
  1670. 1:20:19this? Egypt resists at first, but only
  1671. 1:20:22for a little while, because remember
  1672. 1:20:25that we are in the 19th Dynasty here.
  1673. 1:20:28Starting from the 20th dynasty, Egypt's
  1674. 1:20:31crisis begins. Invasions will arrive,
  1675. 1:20:34first the invasions of the Phrygians,
  1676. 1:20:36then the Libyan invasion, then the
  1677. 1:20:38Persian invasion later on. So it is
  1678. 1:20:41somewhat Egypt's swan song, yet Egypt
  1679. 1:20:44defends itself and claims to have
  1680. 1:20:47resisted this wave. This one you see
  1681. 1:20:50here is uh one of the most famous
  1682. 1:20:52reliefs in all of Egypt. Unfortunately,
  1683. 1:20:56uh only if you specifically ask the
  1684. 1:20:58guides who are there in Egypt do they
  1685. 1:21:00show it to you; otherwise, they don't
  1686. 1:21:02care. It is located at Medinet Habu.
  1687. 1:21:07Medinet Habu is a temple that is
  1688. 1:21:08practically near the Valley of the
  1689. 1:21:10Kings, just before the Valley of the
  1690. 1:21:12Kings, okay? where on the back wall of
  1691. 1:21:15the Medinet Habu temple, which is the
  1692. 1:21:18temple built by the son of Ramesses II,
  1693. 1:21:20that is, Ramesses III, who was not,
  1694. 1:21:23however, the immediate successor of
  1695. 1:21:25Ramesses II. Ramesses II had as a
  1696. 1:21:28successor first his son named Merneptah
  1697. 1:21:30, then another son who is precisely
  1698. 1:21:32Ramesses III. Well, in this temple on
  1699. 1:21:36the side you see this scene which would
  1700. 1:21:38represent precisely the victory of
  1701. 1:21:40Ramesses himself over the Akaiwasha,
  1702. 1:21:42that is, over the Achaeans, the people
  1703. 1:21:44of the sea. Peoples of the sea, in fact
  1704. 1:21:47, it is seen a bit poorly here. If we
  1705. 1:21:49look at the drawing that clarifies it
  1706. 1:21:50better for us, here it is. You can see
  1707. 1:21:53the shore of Egypt, uh, like this the
  1708. 1:21:58arrival of the Achaeans with their
  1709. 1:22:00ships. Do you see? Like this, ready to
  1710. 1:22:03attack Egypt, all the Egyptian soldiers
  1711. 1:22:06lined up along the coast and the
  1712. 1:22:08gigantic pharaoh alone, who with
  1713. 1:22:10volleys of arrows strikes down the
  1714. 1:22:13Achaean fleet, obviously driving it
  1715. 1:22:15back into the sea. Hmm. So a missed
  1716. 1:22:19Trojan War. In this case, what will the
  1717. 1:22:27result of this affair be? This, that is
  1718. 1:22:31: with the end of the Hittite Empire,
  1719. 1:22:37Egypt first has an expansion towards
  1720. 1:22:39the east, but a very ephemeral
  1721. 1:22:42expansion. That is, this color you see
  1722. 1:22:45here is a color that must not mislead
  1723. 1:22:47you, because in reality this expansion
  1724. 1:22:50is extremely...Oops, no, excuse me, it
  1725. 1:22:53is extremely ephemeral, very large, but
  1726. 1:22:56there is a lot of desert here. Then
  1727. 1:22:58this area will soon be conquered by the
  1728. 1:23:00Persians and so on. The Hittite kingdom
  1729. 1:23:03no longer exists. Here in its place is
  1730. 1:23:06the kingdom of Phrygia, as is the
  1731. 1:23:08kingdom of Lydia on this other side.
  1732. 1:23:12Then the kingdom of Lydia, it too will
  1733. 1:23:14shortly be conquered by the Persians
  1734. 1:23:16and the kingdom of Phrygia will take
  1735. 1:23:18the place of what had been the kingdom
  1736. 1:23:20of Priam, therefore the city of Troy.
  1737. 1:23:24The kingdom of Phrygia will create a
  1738. 1:23:26new era, a completely different epoch,
  1739. 1:23:29founded on completely different
  1740. 1:23:31economic foundations. The ruler, the
  1741. 1:23:34king, the first king of Phrygia,
  1742. 1:23:37coincidentally, who was he? he was the
  1743. 1:23:41son of one, uh, one of Priam's
  1744. 1:23:42daughters, because there was this
  1745. 1:23:44connection, right? All related to each
  1746. 1:23:47other. So it was said that the son of
  1747. 1:23:50this, uh, daughter of Priam, who, uh,
  1748. 1:23:52according to one version of the myth
  1749. 1:23:55was called Deiphobe, according to
  1750. 1:23:57another version, however, was Melanippe
  1751. 1:24:00, and so on. In short, this daughter of
  1752. 1:24:03Priam would marry the prince of Phrygia
  1753. 1:24:05, and she would have this son who would
  1754. 1:24:07then be the first king of Phrygia. Who
  1755. 1:24:11was this little boy who had this, um,
  1756. 1:24:14this, uh, this importance? His name was
  1757. 1:24:19Gordius. Gordius was indeed the first
  1758. 1:24:22king of Phrygia. Gordius would be the
  1759. 1:24:24one who ties the knot, like that. And
  1760. 1:24:27the son of Gordius will be even more
  1761. 1:24:29famous than his father because his name
  1762. 1:24:31will be Midas. And the son of Midas is
  1763. 1:24:35Croesus. The son of Croesus then dies
  1764. 1:24:37because he will be defeated by the
  1765. 1:24:39arrival of Cyrus the Great. So, the end
  1766. 1:24:41of the empire of the kingdom of Troy
  1767. 1:24:45then merges into what will be the
  1768. 1:24:48kingdom of Phrygia. In short, what is
  1769. 1:24:52the story that unites Ramses and Priam?
  1770. 1:24:57The end of all the balances, the end of
  1771. 1:25:00the world of the great kings, the great
  1772. 1:25:03international balances that had kept
  1773. 1:25:06the entire Eastern Mediterranean in
  1774. 1:25:09equilibrium, exactly like in Hapsburg
  1775. 1:25:12Europe before Napoleon. What does
  1776. 1:25:16Napoleon do? He disrupts all of this,
  1777. 1:25:18and so that balance will no longer
  1778. 1:25:19exist, and even peoples who had
  1779. 1:25:21previously been allies will begin to
  1780. 1:25:23make war on each other. The same thing
  1781. 1:25:26happened here in the Bronze Age; there
  1782. 1:25:28was the great matriarchal civilization
  1783. 1:25:30of the Bronze Age, the Mediterranean
  1784. 1:25:32civilization. These balances of the
  1785. 1:25:35great kings had lasted as long as
  1786. 1:25:37someone who had no right to it wanted
  1787. 1:25:38to become a "great king." Priam, or
  1788. 1:25:42those acting for him, earns the
  1789. 1:25:44hostility of the others, onto which is
  1790. 1:25:46superimposed the arrival of this ethnic
  1791. 1:25:49variation of the peoples—the Aryans,
  1792. 1:25:51or the peoples pushing the Sea Peoples
  1793. 1:25:53—who then end up crashing into the
  1794. 1:25:55city of Troy. Everyone reacts in their
  1795. 1:25:57own way. Egypt manages, at least at
  1796. 1:25:59first, to resist. Troy will be wiped
  1797. 1:26:02out, and after it, the Hittite Empire
  1798. 1:26:04will also be wiped out. These two
  1799. 1:26:08figures, very distant from each other,
  1800. 1:26:11lived through this same tragedy: the
  1801. 1:26:13end of an era, protohistory, and the
  1802. 1:26:16beginning of a new course of events,
  1803. 1:26:18that is, official history from the Iron
  1804. 1:26:21Age onwards. Thank you for your
  1805. 1:26:24attention. Have a good evening.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Ramsete il Grande e Priamo di Troia - Fondazione Claudio Venanzi by Fonclaven - la fondazione Claudio Venanzi, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,119 words across 1,805 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.