¿Qué ha pasado con las guerras en Ucrania y en el Medio Oriente? - Es la Hora de Opinar — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:09During the holiday season, various
- 0:11events occurred on the international
- 0:13stage, and today we’re going to get
- 0:15up to speed, we’re going to provide
- 0:17an update, and catch up on these
- 0:19international issues with our
- 0:21international affairs expert, eh,
- 0:23Mauricio Mehulán. Mauricio, how are
- 0:26you? Good evening.
- 0:27Hello, Leo. Good evening.
- 0:29Well, let's start with the wars. The
- 0:31war in Ukraine, the war in Iran. What
- 0:33has happened?
- 0:35What happened during this month that we
- 0:36didn't see you while you were on
- 0:37vacation? Look, regarding the war in
- 0:42Ukraine, what has happened is that
- 0:44Ukraine has shown enormous efficiency
- 0:46in its drone warfare, especially drones
- 0:49, in its ability to penetrate deep into
- 0:51Russian territory. It has been bombing
- 0:57energy facilities, refineries, and has
- 1:00greatly damaged Russia's ability to
- 1:03produce and export oil. It has also
- 1:08been attacking civilian facilities; for
- 1:11example, commercial ones, such as
- 1:13warehouses, uh, storage facilities
- 1:15similar to Amazon. For instance, in
- 1:20Russia, they have been carrying out
- 1:22these attacks, and this has created a
- 1:24feeling among the Russian population
- 1:26that the war is now reaching us, it's
- 1:28affecting us, and of course, that
- 1:30generates political pressure, but
- 1:31Putin's response, in parallel, has been
- 1:34an escalation. He has been launching a
- 1:39huge number of missiles and drones
- 1:41against Ukrainian cities, causing a
- 1:43great number of deaths and, above all,
- 1:46exploiting the shortage that exists in
- 1:48the world today. One of the central
- 1:53issues is that there is a shortage of
- 1:55missiles to defend against ballistic
- 1:57missiles, the Patriots. And given this
- 2:02shortage, and those who are in Ukraine
- 2:05will tell you, they learn to
- 2:06distinguish, for example, between the
- 2:08explosions of a Russian ballistic
- 2:10missile and the explosions of the
- 2:12interceptors, and they tell you: "We
- 2:14counted 15 missiles and we didn't count
- 2:16a single interceptor.""We counted one
- 2:20interceptor or only two," which means
- 2:22that 13 or 14 managed to get through,
- 2:23and this is what we are seeing in the
- 2:25great missiles that are only made in
- 2:27the United States,
- 2:29they aren't, they are starting to be
- 2:31made in other European countries, and
- 2:33right now Trump had said he was going
- 2:35to give Ukraine the license to be able
- 2:37to manufacture them in Ukraine, but the
- 2:39logistical issue, first of all, remains
- 2:41to be seen if it truly holds up because
- 2:43then Trump already backed out as well.
- 2:47But if the logistical task of
- 2:48manufacturing these missiles and making
- 2:51them work is carried out, it takes
- 2:52quite a long time; we are not talking
- 2:54about overnight. And this also connects
- 2:59with the other war, because one of the
- 3:00topics that has been emerging the most,
- 3:02today I received for example a report
- 3:03from the Council of Foreign Relations
- 3:05of the United States,
- 3:09about the shortage of the U.S. arsenal,
- 3:12the shortage of ammunition, shortage of
- 3:14missiles, because the war in Iran has
- 3:17produced this shortage in the United
- 3:19States, also in Israel and other actors
- 3:22and the capacity size, Yes, no, of that
- 3:24size. And the capacity to produce to
- 3:30resupply these arsenals is limited. We
- 3:33have to put a lot of money into it,
- 3:34says the Council of Foreign Relations.
- 3:37We have to add a lot of speed, we have
- 3:39to clear obstacles and we don't have to
- 3:41produce, look how they say it, we don't
- 3:43necessarily have to produce the highest
- 3:45quality weaponry, but the greatest
- 3:47amount of good enough weaponry, because
- 3:49right now it's a matter of quantity.
- 3:53The United States is very undersupplied
- 3:55and therefore Ukraine is very
- 3:56undersupplied. European countries are
- 4:00saving the missiles they have, they are
- 4:02not giving them to Ukraine and this is
- 4:04being felt with the Russian response in
- 4:06Ukraine and it is also being felt with
- 4:08the decision-making that the United
- 4:10States is carrying out regarding Iran.
- 4:13Now we jump arenas
- 4:15to the Middle East
- 4:16and what is happening with Iran? The
- 4:19issue is basically stalled. That is to
- 4:23say, we have raised a number of
- 4:25scenarios regarding whether the war
- 4:27will escalate or if an agreement will
- 4:29be reached and what the agreement will
- 4:32consist of, but we have not talked
- 4:34enough about what happens if the war
- 4:36does not end, if it stays in the
- 4:38situation in the
- 4:40We are left in a very unstable
- 4:43ceasefire. Eh, in fact we are left with
- 4:46the breakdown of the ceasefire. Two
- 4:51months ago, on June 17, a 60-day
- 4:54ceasefire was agreed upon that really
- 4:56didn't last. It had certain conditions
- 5:00and was very favorable for Iran, some
- 5:03of them, but at the end of the road the
- 5:06ceasefire didn't last because Iran
- 5:08interprets the conditions of the
- 5:11ceasefire as its freedom to control the
- 5:14strait. Let's remember that everything
- 5:17here has revolved around this strait,
- 5:19through which before the war 20%of
- 5:20global energy circulated. So, Iran,
- 5:24perceiving that there were different
- 5:27interpretations regarding the future of
- 5:29the Strait of Hormuz and the United
- 5:32States was interpreting it as there
- 5:34being total freedom of navigation, the
- 5:37hardest sectors of Iran decide to take
- 5:39a step even defying the ceasefire and
- 5:42begin to attack vessels. The United
- 5:46States responds, Iran responds to the
- 5:48U.S. retaliation. The matter escalates
- 5:51for several days and the ceasefire is
- 5:53materially broken. But after some time,
- 5:56about 10 or 12 days later, the United
- 5:58States simply ceases hostilities, it's
- 6:00not that it signs a ceasefire,
- 6:04it maintains its blockade on Iranian
- 6:06ports. Iran keeps the Strait of Hormuz
- 6:09closed. And so, today, rather than
- 6:13betting on an escalation—I'm not
- 6:15saying the escalation can't resume, it
- 6:17could happen—but rather than betting
- 6:20on an escalation, the United States is
- 6:22betting on an economic war of greater
- 6:24dimensions. That is how Trump just
- 6:27announced it. He just announced it on
- 6:28the day of
- 6:29the day of
- 6:30the day that is the famous D-Day, right
- 6:32?
- 6:33Exactly. The economic D-Day, he says.
- 6:37That is to say, the quantity of
- 6:39sanctions and the scale of the
- 6:40sanctions will be something never
- 6:42before seen against Iran. And through
- 6:46that gamble, the United States is
- 6:48thinking that eventually—and
- 6:50eventually means probably within a few
- 6:53months or even more—Iran will have to
- 6:56give in because internal pressure will
- 6:58build up. I mean, to try to understand
- 7:02the U.S. logic, it's that we are going
- 7:05back to where we were in
- 7:06December-January. Let's remember that
- 7:09in December-January we saw the largest
- 7:12demonstrations in Iran. that we have
- 7:16heard of since the founding of the
- 7:18Islamic Republic, and these
- 7:20demonstrations put the regime in check,
- 7:22although the regime finally ended up
- 7:24controlling them very repressively with
- 7:26many deaths.
- 7:30But this is what led actors within the
- 7:32United States, Israel, and elsewhere to
- 7:34think that the regime was very unstable
- 7:36and that it was possible to attack and
- 7:39cause the collapse of the regime. Let
- 7:43me, because I have a minute left in
- 7:45this segment and I also want us to move
- 7:47to the other part of this war, which is
- 7:49Lebanon, and apparently Gaza is
- 7:50reappearing too.
- 7:52Gaza is also reappearing these days. I
- 7:54think we have to talk about that right
- 7:56now, if you want me to comment a little
- 7:57more on Gaza. The issue of Lebanon is
- 8:01relatively calmer than when we left it,
- 8:03because Trump forces
- 8:07Israel and Hezbollah, through the
- 8:09Lebanese government, into a ceasefire
- 8:11that has been maintained—I wouldn't
- 8:13tell you at 100%, but the situation in
- 8:15Lebanon has de-escalated compared to
- 8:17how we left it previously. at least
- 8:21there is a good
- 8:22Well, that front is relatively calm
- 8:25there.
- 8:25Yes, yes. And the one in Gaza,
- 8:27the one in Gaza. Uh, the issue here is
- 8:30that Hamas announces, between when we
- 8:32left and came back,
- 8:34Hamas announces that it is willing to
- 8:37disarm. And so, given that announcement
- 8:41, the conditions would apparently be
- 8:44set to implement what was phase two,
- 8:46that deal from Trump. However, when you
- 8:52look deeper, you will find that Hamas
- 8:54has actually restocked its weaponry and
- 8:57has replenished its personnel, the
- 9:00number of its members. It is estimated
- 9:04that Hamas has about 30,000 members
- 9:06again and has rebuilt its tunnels. So
- 9:09one says: "Well, honestly, announcing
- 9:12disarmament from an analytical
- 9:13perspective, what Hamas apparently does
- 9:16is say: 'Look, I will disarm,' and they
- 9:19declare it as such, 'I will disarm as
- 9:21long as Israel completely withdraws
- 9:23from Gaza,' knowing that Netanyahu will
- 9:26not completely withdraw from Gaza." In
- 9:29fact, what the Israeli government
- 9:32announces first is, "I will withdraw
- 9:34from Gaza once Hamas completely disarms
- 9:37," and then Netanyahu openly says, "I
- 9:40do not accept Trump's announced plan
- 9:43for this disarmament because the
- 9:46conditions simply are not there for
- 9:48Israel to be able to withdraw." We must
- 9:51remember that there are elections,
- 9:53there are elections in Israel.
- 9:55Netanyahu is appealing to his base, and
- 9:58it is very unlikely that before the
- 10:00elections take place and we know which
- 10:02government will control Israel, we will
- 10:05actually see this plan start to move
- 10:07forward.
- 10:07Well, let me, uh, let's take a break. I
- 10:11want to return with you to, uh,
- 10:12something happening in the Middle East,
- 10:14this incredible agreement between
- 10:16Turkey and Arabia and Asia,
- 10:18and Asia, right? Yes, exactly. And
- 10:20Saudi Arabia and Pakistan.
- 10:22Anyway. And I also want to talk about
- 10:24what happened in Ceuta, in Spain, right
- 10:26?
- 10:26Let's talk about that too.
- 10:27We will be back in a moment.
- 10:44Well, we continue catching up on
- 10:45international matters with our expert
- 10:47Mauricio Mulam. Mauricio, an agreement
- 10:51between Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and
- 10:53Pakistan that would have been
- 10:55unthinkable a few years ago.
- 10:58Yes, and it is also a defense pact
- 11:01between the three,
- 11:03yes?
- 11:03Which is basically a declaration that
- 11:05an attack on one would be equivalent to
- 11:08an attack against all,
- 11:09like NATO. In theory, Article 5 of NATO
- 11:13,
- 11:15uh, this is similar to Article 5. I
- 11:17think we need to make some distinctions
- 11:19here. In practical reality, it is
- 11:22difficult to think that a mini-NATO is
- 11:24being established between the Middle
- 11:26East and Asia.
- 11:29Uh, one example is, for instance, the
- 11:31intervention of Pakistan and Saudi
- 11:33Arabia already had a mutual defense
- 11:35pact. When, when did they establish it?
- 11:39We have to remind the audience a bit
- 11:41about when Israel bombed Doha, the
- 11:43capital of Qatar, in September 2025.
- 11:47Yes,
- 11:48a few days later a mutual defense pact
- 11:51is announced between Saudi Arabia and
- 11:53Pakistan, somewhat sending the signal
- 11:55of "careful, Israel, don't mess with me
- 11:57."
- 11:58By the way, a reminder that Pakistan
- 12:00has nuclear weapons. It is the only
- 12:02Muslim country
- 12:03that has nuclear weapons.
- 12:05Yes, indeed. So, uh, in theory, there
- 12:08is this defense pact. However, when
- 12:12Iran has attacked Saudi Arabia in this
- 12:15war we are talking about, it's not like
- 12:17Pakistan has come in and joined the war
- 12:19in total defense of Saudi Arabia. They
- 12:24have sent thousands of troops, 8,000
- 12:26troops to Saudi Arabia, and have sent
- 12:29uh defense systems and sent
- 12:31collaboration. We are talking more
- 12:35about military collaboration than a
- 12:37defense pact where Pakistan would have
- 12:39gone to war with Iran; that is not the
- 12:41case. And that is sort of how we have
- 12:43to think about it. In reality, these
- 12:45are military collaboration pacts that
- 12:48are political statements, very firm and
- 12:50very strong political declarations, but
- 12:53in practice, it is the complementarity
- 12:56between Saudi resources, which are very
- 12:58abundant, Turkish military technology,
- 13:01especially in drones and missiles,
- 13:03which is truly state-of-the-art, with,
- 13:06uh, well, everything that can be
- 13:08contributed.
- 13:10Pakistan in nuclear matters. Nuclear,
- 13:12the defense umbrella, and everything
- 13:14that can mean. Turkey and Saudi Arabia
- 13:16didn't like each other, right?
- 13:19No. And what we have seen is a
- 13:20rapprochement in recent years; that is,
- 13:22after the tensions that existed
- 13:24basically in the previous decade
- 13:26between Saudi Arabia and Turkey, we see
- 13:28a rapprochement in recent years, but
- 13:30one that culminates in this defense
- 13:32pact, and it is a bit about starting to
- 13:34look for alternatives to the United
- 13:36States. Meaning, the United States is
- 13:38not, is not going to defend us, right?
- 13:40The United States.
- 13:42By the way, in Korea, they are also
- 13:43asking themselves that now. We have to
- 13:45talk about Korea, uh, for another time,
- 13:47for another time.
- 13:49This, the, uh, United States is viewed
- 13:51with great mistrust, first because of
- 13:54its volatility, its erratic nature, its
- 13:56lack of strategic planning, and its
- 13:59back-and-forth. I mean, one day Trump
- 14:01says, "I'm going to escalate," the next
- 14:02day he says, "I'm not going to escalate
- 14:03." That produces an uncertainty that
- 14:08obviously isn't liked when it comes to
- 14:10defense matters, and second, uh, also
- 14:12an inability; I mean, the United States
- 14:15isn't necessarily protecting me the way
- 14:17I would like to be protected, and now
- 14:19they are telling us they have exhausted
- 14:22arsenals, and what are we supposed to
- 14:24do? So
- 14:26we are going to form up.
- 14:27From this perspective, they form a
- 14:29defense pact that has implications for
- 14:30the Middle East and that has
- 14:32implications for Asia. Let's not forget
- 14:35that, for example, Pakistan entered an
- 14:37active armed conflict in 2025 against
- 14:39India, which was escalating and could
- 14:42have escalated much further. So, what
- 14:45we have to understand here is that also
- 14:47from Pakistan's side, having Turkey and
- 14:49Saudi Arabia, for what those countries
- 14:51can contribute, represents an important
- 14:53factor in the face of everything
- 14:55happening in that other region. Well, I
- 14:58don't want to—I want to move on to
- 15:01the other topic, but to Ceuta, though I
- 15:04must say that as Iran has been
- 15:06weakening its presence in Syria as well
- 15:08, and now the Turks have taken it over,
- 15:11that has the Israelis worried. I mean,
- 15:14my God, the Middle East, no. Truly,
- 15:17Israel carried out a bombing on an
- 15:19airbase that, according to Israeli
- 15:21intelligence, was going to start being
- 15:23occupied by Turkish military, sending
- 15:26—sending a message from Israel
- 15:28against Turkey. Turkey is a member of
- 15:31NATO and is a strategic ally of the
- 15:33United States. Israel is too. And so
- 15:35the United States today, right now as
- 15:38we are speaking, is implementing
- 15:40mechanisms to de-escalate and
- 15:42deconflict—that's what it's called—
- 15:44and establish lines of communication so
- 15:47that a clash event doesn't happen
- 15:49between Israel and Turkey, which would
- 15:51be enormously complicated.
- 15:53The Middle East is—is fascinating,
- 15:55without a doubt. But I want to go to
- 15:58Ceuta. Ceuta, just so you know, is a
- 16:01territory that is in Africa, it's a
- 16:03Spanish enclave in Africa, right? Uh,
- 16:07in Moroc—well, it's not Morocco, it's
- 16:09Spain.
- 16:10Morocco, well, in territory
- 16:11in African territory
- 16:12next to—
- 16:14next to—it has a land border with—
- 16:16with Morocco.
- 16:18Morocco, by the way, does not
- 16:19officially recognize Spanish
- 16:21sovereignty over Ceuta. But anyway,
- 16:22that's how it is. But anyway, uh, what
- 16:24we saw is that suddenly hordes of
- 16:27Moroccans came pouring in,
- 16:29thousands and thousands,
- 16:30it is calculated at 80,000 if I'm not
- 16:32—
- 16:33there are figures, I mean, depending on
- 16:34the numbers you want to use,
- 16:36but in one day it suddenly opened, they
- 16:38crossed the border
- 16:39from July 30th to August 1st
- 16:42it is estimated that
- 16:45depending on the figures, between 50,
- 16:4860, 70,000 people,
- 16:50mostly young people,
- 16:51mostly young people entering, crossing
- 16:58—crossing the fences and then
- 17:00swimming toward the Spanish side,
- 17:02toward Spanish territory.
- 17:05And neither the Moroccans nor the
- 17:07Spaniards could stop it.
- 17:08No, no.
- 17:09And it's that, that invasion
- 17:12shook Europe. Yes. it overwhelms a city
- 17:17that is inhabited by approximately
- 17:2085,000 people and suddenly, well, the
- 17:23unexpected, sudden arrival of between
- 17:2750 and 70,000 people obviously
- 17:30completely overwhelms it, right? And,
- 17:34of course, there are many factors for
- 17:36analysis. We don't know yet everything
- 17:39that could be behind this. There will
- 17:41be a lot of investigation into this.
- 17:43There are many hypotheses. Eh, the
- 17:45first thing we do know is that there
- 17:47was a whole movement on social media.
- 17:50What had happened before? That the
- 17:52Spanish Supreme Court in July, eh, if
- 17:55I'm not mistaken, on July 8th, had
- 17:59decreed a, uh, a law indicating that
- 18:02the arrival of migrants by sea into
- 18:07Spanish territory did not imply that
- 18:09they would be returned immediately, as
- 18:12they say, not automatically. A trial
- 18:15had to be held and their case had to be
- 18:18processed. And this was interpreted as
- 18:22meaning that it is now possible to
- 18:25arrive by swimming into Spanish
- 18:28territory in Ceuta.
- 18:30That, that, that crossing a small gulf
- 18:32there, right? Crossing a small gulf.
- 18:33Several sank, uh, because they drowned.
- 18:37Unfortunately, there was also a
- 18:39significant number of deaths, it must
- 18:41be said, but, uh, the rumor spread and
- 18:43a whole movement started to generate on
- 18:45social media. Now, there is undoubtedly
- 18:49exploitation by human trafficking
- 18:52networks of this, of this, of this
- 18:54series of events that they incentivize,
- 18:56and they obviously made a large amount
- 18:59of money from what was happening. And
- 19:03then there is the whole issue of to
- 19:05what extent Morocco had anything to do
- 19:07with it or not. We must mention a
- 19:10precedent because a situation on a
- 19:13smaller scale, but still a delicate
- 19:15situation, occurred in 2021 when 8,000
- 19:18Moroccans also entered Ceuta. At that
- 19:22time, there was indeed political
- 19:24tension between Morocco and Spain, even
- 19:26because Spain had hosted a leader of a
- 19:28separatist movement in the Spanish
- 19:30Sahara and this was protested by
- 19:32Morocco. Even the Moroccan ambassador
- 19:36to Spain in 2021 said that Spanish
- 19:38actions have consequences. So, in some
- 19:41way, Morocco did use migration as a
- 19:45tool of pressure at that time.
- 19:47Therefore, the hypothesis now arises as
- 19:49to whether they might not be using it
- 19:51again.
- 19:52I heard some Spanish news and analysis
- 19:54programs that claimed this, this is
- 19:57supported, provoked by the King of
- 20:00However, however, several things must
- 20:02be said. The relationship between
- 20:04Morocco and Spain has become much
- 20:06closer
- 20:06with the socialist government, right?
- 20:09In fact, of course, today Spain, uh,
- 20:11supports the Moroccan plan for the
- 20:13autonomy of the Spanish Sahara under
- 20:16Moroccan sovereignty. And so it is
- 20:20difficult to think that Rabat, that is
- 20:22to say, Morocco, has orchestrated this
- 20:25whole movement. It is also difficult to
- 20:28think that the movement could have
- 20:30occurred without some kind of
- 20:31relaxation or at least negligence from
- 20:33the Moroccan authorities. So, it is
- 20:36possible that there might be a
- 20:37political message there as well. But
- 20:39events like these could happen again.
- 20:42Social media movements are exerting
- 20:44huge influence, and human trafficking
- 20:46networks are taking advantage. It must
- 20:49be said,
- 20:49and it must be said immediately.
- 20:53Right-wing parties opposed to
- 20:54immigrants in Spain, even Republicans
- 20:56in the United States. The image
- 20:59connects with their narrative, it
- 21:00connects a lot. Hordes of migrants
- 21:04invading our borders and crossing the
- 21:06fences in the face of very relaxed
- 21:08migration control measures, and of
- 21:10course that strengthens the far-right
- 21:13all over Europe.
- 21:15Well, thanks. We left the topic of
- 21:18Korea on the back burner, but we will
- 21:19deal with it next week,
- 21:22because the world goes on, right? And
- 21:24there are certainly many topics to
- 21:25discuss with Mauricio Besulam. Thank
- 21:27you. Thank you, dear Leo.
- 21:29Thank you for joining us. Good night.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of ¿Qué ha pasado con las guerras en Ucrania y en el Medio Oriente? - Es la Hora de Opinar by NMás, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,178 words across 533 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.