QBism: The New Theory That Shatters Our View of Reality — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00the shock is so great in quantum
- 0:01mechanics that we still have not figured
- 0:03out how to really process it how does
- 0:07quantum mechanics confront our view of
- 0:09reality even shattering it Amanda gter
- 0:13science writer and author of trespassing
- 0:16on Einstein's lawn dismantles long-held
- 0:19Notions about quantum mechanics
- 0:21proposing a revolutionary perspective
- 0:24where observers don't just perceive
- 0:26reality they actively participate in its
- 0:30Creation in this episode we'll delve
- 0:33into how our beliefs shape the quantum
- 0:35World why decart's subject object split
- 0:38is fundamentally flawed and how
- 0:40emergence could redefine our scientific
- 0:43understanding prepare to have your
- 0:45concept of reality transformed as we
- 0:47venture into the quantum realm where
- 0:50nothing is quite as it
- 0:52[Music]
- 0:54seems probably the most formative
- 0:58conversation that I had even though it
- 0:59was a very very brief
- 1:02conversation was one with the physicist
- 1:04John Wheeler so wheeler was this
- 1:08legendary American physicist who you
- 1:10know this is who came up with the terms
- 1:12black hole and Wormhole and he did
- 1:14revolutionary work in in uh everything
- 1:17general relativity Nuclear Physics
- 1:19quantum mechanics and had a very sort of
- 1:22profound philosophical mind but also
- 1:25spoke in this very enigmatic Yoda like
- 1:29way
- 1:30and um I had the chance to meet
- 1:34him well this is a whole long story but
- 1:36I my father and I snuck into a physics
- 1:39conference that was being held in in
- 1:41Wheeler's honor it was in honor of his
- 1:4390th birthday at Princeton and this is
- 1:47in 2002 I believe and it was this
- 1:51amazing conference and all the you know
- 1:53best physicists were up there giving
- 1:55talks and everything and Wheeler was
- 1:56just sort of sitting at the front and
- 1:58you know he was n at this point he was a
- 2:00bit hard of hearing but he was still
- 2:03deeply obsessed with all of these big
- 2:05questions about you know how come
- 2:07existence and why the quantum and all of
- 2:09the questions that I think you Kurt are
- 2:11interested in and so you know at some
- 2:14point after the talks we kind of waited
- 2:17our turn and we got to go up and talk to
- 2:19him and and Wheeler had had this idea
- 2:23that somehow observers are implicated in
- 2:26reality in the nature of reality and the
- 2:30question that I really wanted to ask him
- 2:32was if observers create reality where do
- 2:35The Observers come from so I asked him
- 2:38this we had to repeat it a few times
- 2:39because he was a bit hard of hearing and
- 2:42then he said the universe is a
- 2:44self-excited
- 2:45circuit okay and then we said okay and
- 2:50then my dad and I were very obsessed
- 2:52with this question about what is
- 2:53nothingness and Wheeler had talked a lot
- 2:54about nothingness and so our second
- 2:57question was you know does everything
- 2:58come from nothing
- 3:00and he said the boundary of a boundary
- 3:03is
- 3:04zero and we said okay thanks and we
- 3:07walked away and then we were sort of
- 3:09what the hell just
- 3:10happened so he wheeler had
- 3:13basically presented us with these kind
- 3:15of riddles and um I in a certain way
- 3:19have spent like much of my career trying
- 3:21to figure out what he meant by those
- 3:24phrases so I think that was definitely
- 3:27the shortest strangest but most influen
- 3:30conversation that I had so what's meant
- 3:33by it's a self- excited circuit and the
- 3:35boundary of a boundary is zero how's
- 3:37that at all connected to your question
- 3:39so wheeler passed away in in 2008 um but
- 3:43he throughout his whole career had kept
- 3:45journals these very very detailed
- 3:48journals every conversation he ever had
- 3:51every thought he ever had are in these
- 3:52notebooks um and he donated them all to
- 3:55the American philosophical Society
- 3:57library in Philadelphia so you can go
- 3:59there and read through all the journals
- 4:01so I spent a very very long time combing
- 4:05through these journals trying to figure
- 4:06out what was he really getting at and
- 4:09yeah so the idea of a a self- excited
- 4:11Universe I mean in a nutshell he had
- 4:15this notion that well first of all he
- 4:18saw quantum mechanics as as giving us a
- 4:21kind of participatory reality as he
- 4:23would put it where you don't have some
- 4:25reality that's just sitting out there
- 4:26some particular way independent of
- 4:28observers but Observers
- 4:30and the universe sort of come together
- 4:31and participate in the creation of
- 4:33reality and reality is sort of ever on
- 4:36the make in this story and so he wanted
- 4:40to give a story there's a famous diagram
- 4:42he drew that was a u the letter U with a
- 4:45an eyeball at the top and this is
- 4:47supposed to to capture this idea of a
- 4:49self- excited universe so the U is for
- 4:53universe and the idea is kind of the
- 4:55universe comes into being and gives rise
- 4:57to an observer and then the Observer
- 5:00looks back in time this is related to
- 5:03Wheeler's delayed Choice experiment so
- 5:05the the observer looks back in time and
- 5:07through the act of a Quantum measurement
- 5:08participates in creating the very
- 5:10universe that created The Observer so
- 5:12it's this kind of strange Loop and this
- 5:14was his idea of a a self- excited
- 5:17Universe which he never fully was able
- 5:20to flesh out but that was the he called
- 5:23it like an idea for an idea and then the
- 5:25boundary of boundary is zero this is a a
- 5:27trickier one there's a sense in which
- 5:29it's a it's a very basic um Concept in I
- 5:33guess topology that once you bound a
- 5:36space you you don't have to put a
- 5:39boundary on the boundary the boundary of
- 5:40the boundary is always equal to zero
- 5:42which apparently you can actually derive
- 5:44a lot of physics out of this very sort
- 5:46of tological statement but he wanted to
- 5:49say something a little deeper with it
- 5:50like that there are ways he called it a
- 5:54principle of austerity that there are
- 5:56ways that you can get so much out of so
- 5:59little so he he he was trying to reduce
- 6:02physics essentially to something like
- 6:05the identity of like Z equals z and then
- 6:07be able to say that you could derive all
- 6:08of physics from the I mean this was just
- 6:10one program that he worked on that again
- 6:12it was an idea for an idea yeah I mean
- 6:15it's not that I don't think these were
- 6:16the answers but but they were um very
- 6:19inspiring to me in my thinking and also
- 6:22just sort of presenting physics as this
- 6:26great mystery that needs to be solved
- 6:30John Wheeler one of the most influential
- 6:32physicists of the 20th century proposed
- 6:35a controversial idea that physicists are
- 6:38still debating to this day the idea that
- 6:41we live in a participatory Universe
- 6:44wheeler said to imagine a cosmic version
- 6:47of the double slit experiment where
- 6:49light from a distant quazar passes by a
- 6:51gravitationally lensing Galaxy it can go
- 6:54either to the left or to the right of
- 6:56the Galaxy now here's the twist we could
- 6:59choose to measure which path the light
- 7:01took or we could choose to observe an
- 7:03interference pattern after the light has
- 7:06already passed the Galaxy but this
- 7:08choice where we determine if a photon is
- 7:11a so-called particle or so-called wave
- 7:13is made billions of years later after
- 7:16the light began its Journey this idea is
- 7:19captured in his self- excited diagram
- 7:21where the universe creates Observer
- 7:23participan which in turn creates
- 7:26information which creates the universe
- 7:28are we pass passive observers of a
- 7:30predetermined universe or active
- 7:33participants in an Ever evolving
- 7:35interdependent web that we call
- 7:40reality so the participatory universe is
- 7:43just one of several interpretations of
- 7:45quantum mechanics can you explain what
- 7:47are these so-called interpretations of
- 7:49quantum mechanics and then what is the
- 7:52participatory universe and transition
- 7:54into
- 7:56cubism yeah so quantum mechanics
- 7:59it's funny I just watched there's a a
- 8:01mathematical physicist Marcus applebe
- 8:04who gave this talk at Dartmouth College
- 8:07last week this past week who he was
- 8:10comparing our understanding of quantum
- 8:12mechanics to long covid so he was sort
- 8:14of saying that you know there's been all
- 8:16these Revolutions in science over the
- 8:18centuries and normally it's you know
- 8:21cernus comes along and you know it says
- 8:22oh my God everything you thought was
- 8:23wrong and and there's this initial deep
- 8:26deep shock which is sort of a disease
- 8:27that you have to get over eventually you
- 8:30just get over it and you you move on and
- 8:32he said quantum mechanics is is unlike
- 8:34that because you know it's been well
- 8:37over a hundred years and you know and
- 8:40and we're still suffering from from the
- 8:42disease he called it long classicality
- 8:45interesting so it's the just the shock
- 8:48is is so great in quantum mechanics that
- 8:50we still have not figured out how to
- 8:52really process it and and because of
- 8:54that we have all these different
- 8:56interpretations that try to give
- 8:59almost a narrative account of what the
- 9:03mathematical formalism of quantum
- 9:04mechanics is trying to tell us about
- 9:06reality um and so you have you know the
- 9:11many worlds interpretation you have
- 9:13objective collapse you have relational
- 9:17quantum mechanics you have Boman
- 9:19mechanics you have cubism so there's all
- 9:22these different interpretations that
- 9:23that try
- 9:26to say what it is that quantum mechanics
- 9:29is really really telling us and they
- 9:32defin they they differ substantially I
- 9:34mean it's sort of remarkable that you
- 9:36can give such radically different
- 9:38interpretations of the same Theory um
- 9:42and in a sense
- 9:43it's philosophical temperament it's what
- 9:46what do you want your reality to be and
- 9:48then you try to construct a a story
- 9:51that's consistent with quantum mechanics
- 9:52and the thing about quantum mechanics is
- 9:54it makes it very very hard to give a
- 9:56consistent story you have to
- 10:00I mean I think the the central lesson is
- 10:04whatever the story is it can't be
- 10:05classical physics it we can't go back so
- 10:08something has to give and so for
- 10:10instance people who like you know bowan
- 10:13mechanics or something they I would say
- 10:16I I imagine they would agree really want
- 10:19something as close to a classical
- 10:21reality as possible so they they really
- 10:24want there to be a a freestanding
- 10:26reality that just is some particular way
- 10:28and if we have any uncertainty it's just
- 10:31because we don't know what the truth is
- 10:33but there is a truth out there with a
- 10:34capital T and but you know when you look
- 10:37at what you have to do the kind of
- 10:40contortions you have to twist yourself
- 10:42into to say anything that I mean they're
- 10:45so extreme you have to give up on
- 10:46relativity you have to allow for you
- 10:50know crazy non-local effects you have to
- 10:53allow for what they call
- 10:55non-contextuality you have to or sorry
- 10:57you have to allow for contextuality um
- 10:59what you end up with is still not a
- 11:01classical reality it's something
- 11:02incredibly incredibly strange the same
- 11:04with many worlds many worlds also kind
- 11:06of has a
- 11:07classical impulse there um but the price
- 11:12that you pay is this you know infinite
- 11:14number of of universes where everything
- 11:17that can happen is happening and an
- 11:19infinite number of you in all these
- 11:21universes so so the point is these
- 11:24interpretations make it very clear that
- 11:28whatever Quantum reality is it's not
- 11:31it's not your grandfather's
- 11:33reality what's interesting is he called
- 11:35it long classicality so he sees
- 11:37classical well our adherence to thinking
- 11:40classically as the disease yes he
- 11:43doesn't think of quantum mechanics as
- 11:44the disease that needs to be tamed no no
- 11:47I mean I think and that's that's the
- 11:49real Spirit of of cubism which we can
- 11:51talk about is cubism is sort of saying
- 11:54okay let's let's Embrace what quantum
- 11:57theory is saying and and and just get
- 12:00over these kind of classical impulses
- 12:03that we have so there's someone named
- 12:05Richard Hamming I'm not sure if you know
- 12:06who that person is he's a physicist
- 12:09engineer has a fantastic series on
- 12:11YouTube about learning it's from the 80s
- 12:13I believe it's just a fantastic watch he
- 12:16said that people form their
- 12:19interpretations of quantum mechanics
- 12:20based on their prior metaphysical
- 12:22beliefs so he said this is true of
- 12:24Einstein and this is true of bore
- 12:26Christopher had this lecture on
- 12:28cubism he said that what was different
- 12:30about cubism is that it started with
- 12:32let's take Quantum mechanic seriously
- 12:34and then let's see what occurs from
- 12:35there let's let that dictate our
- 12:37interpretation rather than our prior
- 12:40beliefs dictating it at least that's
- 12:42what he said but that's how most
- 12:44scientists to view their work is they're
- 12:46the rational person who goes in without
- 12:48preconception then and then I let the
- 12:49data tell me and I am so disjoint from
- 12:52my eego that I'll follow the data
- 12:54wherever it goes okay so I I take that
- 12:57with a grain of salt when he says that
- 12:59you know the history much more so please
- 13:01outline what cubism is and if my
- 13:04reiterating of Christopher's story is AP
- 13:08yeah well it's funny I mean to defend
- 13:10him a little I would just say I mean I
- 13:13think he does he does sort of freely
- 13:15admit a certain philosophical
- 13:17temperament so you know he talks about
- 13:20really wanting Free Will for instance
- 13:23and and really in that sense not wanting
- 13:28a block un Universe story you know where
- 13:30the world just is sitting there
- 13:32deterministically and and just sort of
- 13:35is some particular way and and our
- 13:37actions have no no real Hold On The
- 13:40World um so I think I think he would
- 13:43acknowledge some of his sort of
- 13:45philosophical you know biases in that in
- 13:47that sense and he also you know to
- 13:50connect back to what we were talking
- 13:51about earlier he studied a bit with
- 13:53wheeler when wheeler was at the
- 13:55University of Texas at Austin so this is
- 13:58Leon wheeler career um Chris fooks was
- 14:01was there in Texas and so I think he was
- 14:05very deeply influenced by wheeler and
- 14:09then also he read a lot of William James
- 14:12and early American pragmatist philosophy
- 14:14and is very influenced by that too so I
- 14:16think that's sort of wonderful wonderful
- 14:17where that's coming from yeah so cubism
- 14:20yeah I mean
- 14:22cubism so so yeah what what Chris to say
- 14:25is
- 14:26that the name is similar to to KFC where
- 14:30it originally stood for Kentucky Fried
- 14:33Chicken but at some point they just
- 14:34decided to it's just KFC it doesn't
- 14:37stand for anything so cubism is like
- 14:39that it originally stood for Quantum
- 14:40basanis but now it's just cubism okay
- 14:43well why don't you start with it
- 14:44historically because why was it called
- 14:46Quantum basanis and why did it
- 14:49change yeah so quantum mechanics is very
- 14:52much about probabilities right classical
- 14:55mechanics just gave us values for things
- 14:59you know this is the position this is
- 15:01the momentum and quantum mechanics gives
- 15:03us probabilities for what we might
- 15:05measure and that's part of why it's so
- 15:08strange as a as a theory because
- 15:11probabilities sort of normally are
- 15:15thought of as reflections of some kind
- 15:17of ignorance on the part of the Observer
- 15:19but these probabilities seem to sort of
- 15:21be fundamental to the world in some way
- 15:23and so then the question is are we
- 15:25talking about the Observer are we
- 15:26talking about the world and then you get
- 15:28into all these deep questions and so how
- 15:30to understand probabilities you know the
- 15:34the there's a something called the wave
- 15:36function and in quantum mechanics which
- 15:38is the most you can say about the state
- 15:40of some Quantum system is encoded in
- 15:42this wave function but the wave function
- 15:45just gives
- 15:46you probability or gives you a way of
- 15:49getting probabilities out of it and so
- 15:52so how to understand probability becomes
- 15:54really essential to how to think about
- 15:57quantum mechanics and so there are
- 16:00different philosophies of probability
- 16:02and so you could say you know I think
- 16:04probably the intuitive one that most
- 16:06people have is what's known as the
- 16:07frequentist interpretation of
- 16:09probability so if I say you know the
- 16:12odds of a coin flip Landing heads is 50%
- 16:16what do I really mean by that well I
- 16:18mean if I flipped the coin an infinite
- 16:21number of times it would come out to
- 16:235050 right um and that's like
- 16:27philosophically a really
- 16:29complicated story to defend because
- 16:32first of all nobody can do anything an
- 16:34infinite number of times second of all
- 16:36like why does that tell you anything
- 16:37about what's going to happen the one
- 16:39time that you do it and then also what's
- 16:41the causal story you're giving about why
- 16:45that probability has any hold on what
- 16:47the coin actually does and so then
- 16:49people talk about like the coin has a
- 16:51propensity you know because it's a an
- 16:53unbiased coin it has a propensity to do
- 16:56a certain thing and then it's like now
- 16:59you're like imbuing the world with
- 17:01propensity like it's just like a whole
- 17:02complicated thing as we're talking about
- 17:05probability and wave functions later
- 17:08Amanda will discuss the born rule but a
- 17:11preview is warranted
- 17:13now the born rule is something you'll
- 17:16hear plenty about in quantum mechanics
- 17:18and what it is is a method from
- 17:20translating from the wave function to
- 17:23probabilities also the topological
- 17:25principle of the boundary of a boundary
- 17:27is zero has deep-seated Connections in
- 17:30physics and we'll explore that later
- 17:32Bourne proposed that the probability of
- 17:35finding a particle is the absolute
- 17:37square of its wave function this forms a
- 17:40bridge between these abstract so-called
- 17:42wave functions and measurable
- 17:44probabilities though the rigorous
- 17:46treatment of this involves fancy
- 17:48machinery called projection valued
- 17:50measures and density functions that's
- 17:52for another episode though now the
- 17:54boundary principle where the boundary of
- 17:56a boundary is zero stems from
- 17:58combinatorics so counting principles in
- 18:01something called homology in
- 18:03differential geometry which is the
- 18:05language of Einstein this becomes the
- 18:08statement that the differential of a
- 18:10differential is zero also known as the
- 18:13poer Lemma when applied to General
- 18:16relativity's remon curvature tensor it
- 18:18leads to energy and momentum
- 18:20conservation in SpaceTime in
- 18:23electromagnetism it gives us Maxwell's
- 18:25equations these principles demonstrate
- 18:27how the cosmos speaks an obscure yet
- 18:30simple
- 18:34language it's just like a whole
- 18:35complicated thing and so a very
- 18:37different way of looking at probability
- 18:39is is basian probability where you just
- 18:42say I have some prior expectations based
- 18:45on my prior experiences flipping coins
- 18:48and then I'm going to you know assign a
- 18:51probability and I'm going to flip the
- 18:53coin and then based on the outcome I'm
- 18:55going to update my prior
- 18:59probabilities for the next round and
- 19:02that and so then now you can talk about
- 19:04like
- 19:05well if I take that story objectively
- 19:08then I would say the more I learn the
- 19:12more I act on the world and get
- 19:13consequences of my actions and update my
- 19:15beliefs I like inch closer and closer to
- 19:18some truth about what the coin really is
- 19:22right um and then that's problematic too
- 19:25and so then there's a a variant of
- 19:28basanis called personalist basanis okay
- 19:32which says I'm never really trying to
- 19:36get to the truth of the capital T I'm
- 19:38just trying to make my own beliefs
- 19:41consistent with one
- 19:43another um and and I'm doing that
- 19:46through acting on the world and then
- 19:48updating and but I'm not claiming that
- 19:51my beliefs have some antic hold on how
- 19:56what the world has to do um as a result
- 19:59and aticle just means it's corresponding
- 20:01to some capital T truth out there yeah
- 20:04either corresponding to or compelling
- 20:06the world to do something um a law of
- 20:09physics would compel the world to act a
- 20:11certain way or something um so cubism
- 20:15came from a personalist basian
- 20:18interpretation of probability so the
- 20:20idea was let's treat probabilities in
- 20:23quantum mechanics in this way and and
- 20:26that way you don't run a foul of things
- 20:29the noo the like a you know a bell
- 20:31inequality or something like that where
- 20:34if you really think that like basically
- 20:36like if you really want to say my the
- 20:39probabilities I
- 20:41assign or the uncertainties that I have
- 20:44come from my own ignorance about the
- 20:47actual state but the actual state is
- 20:49something I just may not know what it is
- 20:52um you know we can do these experiment
- 20:55these Bell experiments that show you you
- 20:57get into trouble if you think about it
- 20:58it that way um so just a moment are you
- 21:02suggesting that Quantum that cubism I'm
- 21:04not sure if we're at the point where
- 21:05we've transitioned but let's just say
- 21:08it's cubism does cubism get over
- 21:10so-called get over Bell's theorem or
- 21:14Bell's in equality does it get over it
- 21:15somehow does it bypass it does it give
- 21:17it a different interpretation like what
- 21:19does cubism have to say about Bell's
- 21:21theorem yeah so so the idea of bell
- 21:24Serum is like you have multiple
- 21:29assumptions that you put in and those
- 21:32assumptions are like locality and
- 21:35realism okay in in Belle's
- 21:38version and so you say I'm going to
- 21:42assume the world is local so things
- 21:44there's no spooky action in a distance
- 21:46and I'm going to assume realism meaning
- 21:48like things have some state in and of
- 21:52themselves regardless of
- 21:54measurement I'm going to assume those
- 21:56things and then I'm going
- 22:00to calculate like an upper limit on how
- 22:05distant um events might be correlated
- 22:09this is how Belle like worked it out
- 22:10right so then he says given those
- 22:13assumptions there's some upper limit for
- 22:16those correlations and then you run the
- 22:17experiment and you see it violates that
- 22:20upper limit the it's much more strongly
- 22:22correlated than that and
- 22:25so the world and Quantum the Theory
- 22:29violate Bell inequality and with that it
- 22:33it's such a complicated way of talking
- 22:35about it this is how physicists talk
- 22:36about it but it's like this weird double
- 22:37negative it's like hard to think about
- 22:39but the point is just that the
- 22:43world and quantum theory can't be both
- 22:47local and
- 22:49realist yeah at least one of those
- 22:51assumptions have to be false one of
- 22:53those assumptions has to be false but it
- 22:54doesn't tell you which one you like it's
- 22:56up to you to pick pick which one you're
- 22:59willing to give up
- 23:01and this by the way gets like is said
- 23:07wrong all the time and it makes me
- 23:10crazy it's like one of my like Pet
- 23:12Peeves in science journalism because
- 23:14people say like oh it proves that the
- 23:16the quantum mechanics is non-local but
- 23:18like that's absolutely not true it's
- 23:20like you could have locality or you
- 23:22could have realism it just proves you
- 23:24can't have both um
- 23:26so so one thing that many people do is
- 23:30say okay I'll give up
- 23:31locality um but then you have a real
- 23:35like problem I mean you have to give a
- 23:37story of that you know you end up viol
- 23:40like you don't have relativity anymore
- 23:41because you don't have lorenza Marius
- 23:43anymore and you have a preferred frame
- 23:44and it's this whole complicated thing
- 23:46where that
- 23:47nobody's given like a convincing account
- 23:50of what what you do if you give up
- 23:52locality in that way and then it's like
- 23:53so weird that
- 23:55like the world's non-local but only a
- 23:57little and only in these rare circum I
- 24:00don't know that to me that's like not
- 24:02not a convincing story so the other
- 24:04option is you say I'm going to give up
- 24:07realism I'm going to give up this idea
- 24:09that there are outcomes that are just
- 24:12determinately sitting out there and um
- 24:16so that's what cubism does so cubism
- 24:17it's not getting around you know Belle
- 24:20it it's just the choice that cubism
- 24:23makes is to give up the realism not not
- 24:26the locality so cubism is still local
- 24:28in your book just to bring it to
- 24:31something that the viewers may want to
- 24:33look up there's a book that you have
- 24:35called trespassing on Einstein's lawn
- 24:36and we covered it in the introduction
- 24:38but please outline for us in the book
- 24:42it's a personal Quest that you embark on
- 24:44with your father and I want you to tell
- 24:47us about this fatherdaughter Dynamic and
- 24:50how that influenced the writing
- 24:52especially the writing of
- 24:55physics yeah so the book
- 24:59tells this story it's sort of this weird
- 25:01mashup of like a physics book and a
- 25:02memoir and um it tells this story of
- 25:07like when I was um it starts when I'm
- 25:10like 15 years old and um my father who
- 25:14was this very like had a very Zen Guru I
- 25:19mean still does has a very Zen Guru kind
- 25:21of vibe about him um you know took me
- 25:24out to to dinner at a Chinese restaurant
- 25:27and and says how how would you define
- 25:29nothing and we end up having this like
- 25:32whole deep conversation I mean I was
- 25:35like this really rebellious kid I was
- 25:37not taking physics I was like in like
- 25:39remedial science like I was like failing
- 25:42math like you know I was like not the
- 25:44person you would like talk about physics
- 25:47with for sure um but I think I I think I
- 25:51always kind of had
- 25:53like philosophical leanings and I think
- 25:56he sensed that and he did as well and so
- 25:58um so he asked me this question about
- 26:01nothing and we ended up having this
- 26:02whole long conversation he had had this
- 26:04idea that he was very excited about
- 26:07about how to define
- 26:09nothing it's usually defined in the
- 26:11negative so you would say like nothing
- 26:13is the absence of everything um and then
- 26:17if you try to ask a question like how do
- 26:19you get something from nothing you're
- 26:21sort of like foiled from the beginning
- 26:23because you've defined nothing as
- 26:25like know something and so like how
- 26:27could you have something so he wanted to
- 26:30Define nothing in the positive and say
- 26:32what it is not what it isn't and so he
- 26:34had had this idea that like nothingness
- 26:37is a state of complete sameness that
- 26:40extends without bound infinitely that
- 26:44that would be nothing um and so I mean
- 26:47this is not physics this was just like a
- 26:49an idea um but
- 26:52we started talking about it and it just
- 26:55triggered this like insane thing where
- 26:57it was like well
- 26:58you know if the universe came from
- 27:01nothing like how do how do scientists
- 27:03think that that happened and like I
- 27:04don't know let's do a little research
- 27:06and like you know yes cut to like many
- 27:09many years later I'm like still doing
- 27:11the research but basically we like just
- 27:14went on this like insane Journey that we
- 27:18really like doubled down on of like
- 27:20trying to understand teaching ourselves
- 27:22physics and trying to understand you
- 27:25know cosmology and and and physicists
- 27:29think about all of these ideas and then
- 27:30crashing conferences like I was telling
- 27:32you and then I I had always wanted to be
- 27:35a writer but at some point I sort of
- 27:37realized you know we I snuck us into
- 27:39these conferences by claiming to be a
- 27:41journalist and then I was like oh
- 27:44there's actually this field called like
- 27:45science journalism where you can do this
- 27:48and then you know like when when we have
- 27:50a question like we can just ask the
- 27:52physicist like we don't have to
- 27:54read popular books to try to find this
- 27:57one little thing just like ask somebody
- 27:59so basically like little by little this
- 28:02like fake career that I had invented for
- 28:04myself like morphed into an actual
- 28:06career in science journalism and then um
- 28:10and then I it it was the dream I mean I
- 28:13got to interview all of these amazing
- 28:15people and and so the book just like
- 28:18tells this whole story but the physics
- 28:21part of it is basically we realized
- 28:24early on that
- 28:25um that physicists have way of defining
- 28:29what's real in like a pretty rigorous
- 28:32way so I always thought this question of
- 28:33like what's real seemed kind of vague
- 28:35and philosophical but um you can define
- 28:39something as real in physics if it's
- 28:41invariant in any reference frame um and
- 28:46so with that definition in mind we were
- 28:49able to sort of like you know we made
- 28:51this list of like here are all the
- 28:53things that you that could be the
- 28:54ingredients of reality so like particles
- 28:57fields forces space time um the universe
- 29:01whatever and the Wii is your father in
- 29:02you yeah um and so we were like in a
- 29:07restaurant we wrote this on a napkin and
- 29:09then we were like okay we're going to
- 29:10just figure out like each one of these
- 29:12things is it real or not and then we
- 29:14start going through it you know and that
- 29:16took us through these Amazing Ideas in
- 29:19at The Cutting Edge of physics and
- 29:21little by little it was like Crossing
- 29:23one after the next office list and
- 29:24realizing like none of these things are
- 29:27invariant but what is invariant is this
- 29:30state of nothingness that my dad had
- 29:32like started with like that by
- 29:34definition is kind of like the ultimate
- 29:35invariant and so anyway so it became it
- 29:39became this whole uh this whole wild
- 29:43Journey but through it like I got to
- 29:45really learn some like deep physics and
- 29:47so I wanted to take the
- 29:50reader you know I didn't feel like I was
- 29:52in this position most like popular
- 29:54science books are like written in this
- 29:56like Professor model you know you know
- 29:58where it's like let me tell you how the
- 30:00world Works um like the reader the
- 30:02student and the the writer the professor
- 30:05but it was like you know I had come into
- 30:07this as like this kid who was just like
- 30:09messing around and like sneaking into
- 30:11conferences and like I I was in no
- 30:13position to tell anyone you know here's
- 30:16how the world is so instead I was like
- 30:18let me just tell you the story of what I
- 30:20did and like you can learn the stuff
- 30:22that I learned with me um so that's how
- 30:25I wrote it I remember watching a of
- 30:28yours and saying that there are these
- 30:29unconnected facts when you first learned
- 30:31physics plenty of new terminology it's
- 30:34difficult to make them into a coherent
- 30:35framework and then the Insight dawned on
- 30:38you or was given to you about what is
- 30:40real is what's invariant in any
- 30:42reference frame and then that helped you
- 30:44crystallize and connect different facts
- 30:46yes were there any other insights that
- 30:48helped you see almost all of physics or
- 30:51almost all of philosophy perhaps because
- 30:53you have a degree in philosophy almost
- 30:56all of a certain field was made much
- 30:58more simple and more easy to be digested
- 31:01because of a single Insight I mean
- 31:04that's the one like that that
- 31:07Insight it sounds so simple but there's
- 31:10no way I would have learned the physics
- 31:12I learned without it because it just it
- 31:14cuts right through like I mean if that's
- 31:16what you're obviously if what you're
- 31:18interested in is like engineering
- 31:19something this is not this is not the
- 31:21insight for you but but if what you're
- 31:23interested in is like what's real um you
- 31:26know this idea of like what's real is
- 31:29what's invariant it just it's exactly
- 31:33what you said it like cuts through all
- 31:34the complication and lets you see what's
- 31:37important so like for instance um I
- 31:41remember coming across like Stephen
- 31:43Hawkings work great and like obviously
- 31:46Stephen Hawkings was like the most
- 31:47famous physicist since Einstein and and
- 31:50everyone's heard of Hawking if you ask
- 31:52them like what did he do that was so
- 31:54important like people kind of know like
- 31:58it might be like something with black
- 31:59holes and then it's like even if you
- 32:02know like okay he discovered the black
- 32:04holes like
- 32:05radiate it's like it's not obvious why
- 32:08that's such a big deal all right black
- 32:10holes radiate like we thought they were
- 32:12black they're not really black like yeah
- 32:14and even if they're not black they're
- 32:15still mostly black even if they do
- 32:17radiate yeah exactly like for you know a
- 32:21long long millions of years they're
- 32:22going to be pretty much you know dark
- 32:24dark dark brown um but yes exactly and
- 32:28it pales in comparison to thetion disc
- 32:30which is around it anyhow right right
- 32:32which exactly so like you could imagine
- 32:34being like all right that's cool but
- 32:37like with this idea in mind of like
- 32:40things are real if they're invariant
- 32:42when you look at what's really happening
- 32:44in the situation with like Hawking
- 32:45radiation these are particles that are
- 32:47being created at the Horizon of a black
- 32:48hole The Horizon of a black hole is not
- 32:51invariant so if you're outside the black
- 32:55hole which means you're in like an
- 32:57accelerated state of motion from a
- 32:59relativity perspective because you have
- 33:00to like keep yourself out um then
- 33:04there's a horizon it's very real to you
- 33:07if you fall in you're an inertial
- 33:10observer in like a uniform motion you
- 33:12just sail right through there's no
- 33:14Horizon it doesn't exist so the Horizon
- 33:17is not
- 33:18invariant
- 33:19and what that means is these particles
- 33:22of Hawking radiation which are created
- 33:25by the Horizon are also not invariant so
- 33:27so if you're an accelerated Observer
- 33:31outside these particles exist if you're
- 33:33falling in these particles don't exist
- 33:37and so all of a sudden you have this
- 33:38scenario which has never happened before
- 33:40Hawking where particles which is
- 33:43supposed to be like if you had to pick
- 33:46one ingredient of like what's everything
- 33:47made of what is stuff like what am I
- 33:50what is this what right it's
- 33:52particles they're not invariant so
- 33:55they're not ultimately real and we were
- 33:57able to like cross that off the list and
- 33:59that is a huge deal it's just an example
- 34:03of like being able to look at something
- 34:05that's like this really complicated
- 34:06physics that you might just be like oh I
- 34:09all right that's weird um and be like oh
- 34:12I see what's happening here and this is
- 34:14a big deal yes so this Insight is it
- 34:16what you would say allowed you as
- 34:18someone who doesn't have a background in
- 34:21math or physics when ordinarily you need
- 34:23one of those to understand High LEL
- 34:25physics or ideally both is it this
- 34:28Insight that which is real is invariant
- 34:30in any reference frame that helped you
- 34:33yes 100% so that was a serendipitous
- 34:36Insight if you were to engineer such an
- 34:39insight to someone who's listening maybe
- 34:41that Insight resonates with them maybe
- 34:43it doesn't but they're looking for such
- 34:44a level of insight yeah how should they
- 34:47go about getting this piece of
- 34:50information or this different
- 34:52perspective that would align different
- 34:53views and align different pieces of
- 34:55terminology help them grasp it yeah
- 34:58that's really interesting I mean you
- 35:00have to figure out what question you're
- 35:02trying to answer um because the question
- 35:05we were trying to answer is
- 35:07like what is something right we had come
- 35:10up with like this idea of what is
- 35:12nothing and now we needed to know what
- 35:13is something um which is another way of
- 35:15saying like what is real what's the
- 35:17stuff of the world and so by giving this
- 35:20definition oh something is real if it's
- 35:22invariant then we had this way of
- 35:24cutting through all the complicated
- 35:27stuff and was seeing what we needed to
- 35:29see to answer our question so I think if
- 35:31you just have maybe you have a totally
- 35:33different question but whatever the
- 35:35question is is going to define the thing
- 35:38that you need to look for and then
- 35:41that's going to let you cut through
- 35:43because if you're not trying to like do
- 35:47science as as a working scientist every
- 35:50day in the lab is trying to like just do
- 35:52something if you just like are trying to
- 35:53ask some kind of philosophical question
- 35:55about like what does this all mean then
- 35:57the question should steer how you make
- 36:01your way through all the science right
- 36:03right so there's this word that keeps
- 36:04coming up philosophy or philosophers so
- 36:07many people see philosophy and physics
- 36:09as distinct some people see them as
- 36:11overlapping and those people tend to be
- 36:14philosophers of physics surprise
- 36:15surprise so help me understand this
- 36:19amorphous perimeter between physics and
- 36:22philosophy how do you see
- 36:24it yeah so I don't think there's any
- 36:27real difference between the two and I
- 36:29think the reason it seems like there's a
- 36:33difference between the
- 36:34two is
- 36:37because okay so for the most part we're
- 36:40all operating with a philosophy if you
- 36:42think you're not using philosophy is
- 36:45you're just wrong I mean like so Neil
- 36:47wrong Amanda gter said it yeah that's a
- 36:50point if you think you're not using
- 36:52philosophy you're probably using bad
- 36:54philosophy I don't think I'm the first
- 36:55person that said that but um but I but I
- 36:58buy it um so like for the most part the
- 37:01philosophy that we inherited from like
- 37:0317th century thinkers like Alo dekart
- 37:06like the start of that was the start of
- 37:08modern science it came out of a
- 37:11philosophy like very specific
- 37:13philosophical
- 37:14ideas that philosophy
- 37:17underlies most of everyday science um
- 37:24and in most of our everyday lives which
- 37:27is like where we can use classical
- 37:29physics that philosophy works well
- 37:33enough and so we think it makes it seem
- 37:37like you don't need philosophy you could
- 37:39do science like independent of
- 37:41philosophy but it's just because your
- 37:42philosophy is like good enough that you
- 37:45don't that you can like keep it in the
- 37:46background and not think about it and
- 37:49what happens when you get to like
- 37:51starting with relativity but then like
- 37:53even more so in quantum mechanics you
- 37:55you find yourself in these places that
- 37:56are very far from our everyday
- 37:58experience so like you know extreme
- 38:01gravitational situations speeds very
- 38:04close to the speed of light or scales
- 38:06that are like you know getting
- 38:08comparable to like a plank length um
- 38:10right at those in those
- 38:13regimes it's not just the physics that
- 38:15breaks down it's our philosophy that
- 38:17breaks down that 17th century philosophy
- 38:19doesn't work anymore and so all of a
- 38:22sudden you feel like you oh my God I
- 38:24have to confront not only my
- 38:26understanding of phys but also my
- 38:28philosophical assumptions and it's the
- 38:30reason you have to confront both is
- 38:31because they're all mixed up from the
- 38:33beginning it's just that like you were
- 38:35able to pretend that they were separate
- 38:37so I think you know and Bell's theorem
- 38:40which we were talking about is like a
- 38:41perfect example like that's like a key
- 38:44result in quantum mechanics right and
- 38:46that led to like it's not just
- 38:48philosophical it's like it led to
- 38:51Quantum Computing Quantum cryptography
- 38:54teleportation like all these um Quantum
- 38:56Technologies that we have that came out
- 38:58of out of work from from Bell's theorem
- 39:02but Bell's theorem is a theorem about
- 39:05realism and locality which are
- 39:06metaphysical philosophical assumptions
- 39:09that you're making about so you're
- 39:10testing your philosophy and finding this
- 39:13philosophical world view can't hold and
- 39:17then like where do we go from there um
- 39:20so like is that physics well yeah
- 39:23because you have to run a physics
- 39:24experiment but is it philosophy yeah
- 39:25you're testing metaphysical assumptions
- 39:27like there's no way to distinguish the
- 39:29two at that level so I really think that
- 39:33the big takeaway is like they're always
- 39:38in combination with one another and and
- 39:41honestly like all the best deepest
- 39:44thinking physicists like Einstein and
- 39:48bore and Wheeler they they that's how
- 39:51they were thinking they were thinking
- 39:52about the philosophy and the physics
- 39:54together because you can't separate the
- 39:56two and and if you do then you're just
- 39:59you're just working under all these
- 40:00assumptions that you're not
- 40:01acknowledging basically okay so you're
- 40:03just philosophizing with physics it's
- 40:04just that you're unaware of it yes I see
- 40:07okay so let's continue philosophizing
- 40:10there's there's a phrase Quantum state
- 40:13which most people think of as the wave
- 40:14function so that's an embedded question
- 40:16to this you can distinguish the two if
- 40:18you like but some people say the quantum
- 40:20state is
- 40:21informational some people say the
- 40:23quantum state is knowledge based or
- 40:25epistemic is the fancy word
- 40:27or that it's belief based or doxastic is
- 40:30the fancy word or they'll say that it's
- 40:32metaphysical like there's something real
- 40:34that it corresponds to so information
- 40:36knowledge metaphysical and and doxastic
- 40:40so belief based yeah what would be the
- 40:43difference between these for Quantum
- 40:46States like different interpretation how
- 40:48different interpretations see that yeah
- 40:50what is meant when someone says the
- 40:51quantum state is just informational or
- 40:54someone else says no you're wrong the
- 40:55quantum state is episte
- 40:58no you're wrong Quantum state is
- 40:59doxastic no you're wrong it's actually
- 41:02metaphysical yeah yeah I mean this is
- 41:04this is like the the thing that all
- 41:07these different interpretations like
- 41:08disagree on is exactly like that's the
- 41:11heart of it is like how would you
- 41:13understand the quantum state or a wave
- 41:14function um so like if I if I take it to
- 41:17be a metaphysical thing like there's
- 41:20actually a wave fun like that is that is
- 41:23you know reality is this wave function
- 41:26well then you're like ever already in
- 41:28many worlds person so the idea is like
- 41:30the universe just is this Quantum State
- 41:33that's like evolving in this Hilbert
- 41:36space which is you know this
- 41:38mathematical space and it's just this
- 41:41you know Vector in Hilbert space and
- 41:42that's all there is uhhuh so it's a
- 41:44realist view it's a realist view yes
- 41:47yeah is that what you said realist view
- 41:48yes yeah yes yeah so paradoxically
- 41:51enough even though it sounds the most
- 41:52anti-realist of almost any of the
- 41:54interpretations the ever writing the
- 41:56Multiverse from quantum mechanics is a
- 41:58realist interpretations interpretation
- 42:00of quantum mechanics yeah it's a funny
- 42:04like yes that that's definitely correct
- 42:07I mean it's taking the wave fun this
- 42:09mathematical object to be the real thing
- 42:13um like sort of ironically that ends up
- 42:16making like all the stuff that we would
- 42:19normally sort of think of as real in our
- 42:21everyday lives not real yes like
- 42:23interestingly enough in the evering case
- 42:25unicorns are real so it's just there
- 42:28would have to be some other Universe
- 42:29where un yeah right sure but unicorns
- 42:32are actually real and so it's quite
- 42:35unintuitive to to call it real but in
- 42:38the technical sense it's a realist
- 42:40interpretation yes yes um yeah if I
- 42:44think it
- 42:46is I mean so objective collapse would be
- 42:50another theory that's realist in that
- 42:53way where you would say the quantum
- 42:54state is a real thing or at least is a
- 42:58representation of a real thing um no I
- 43:02think they would say the quantum state
- 43:03is a real thing the wave function is a
- 43:04real
- 43:05thing
- 43:07um but at certain scales like for
- 43:11whatever reason either like gravity
- 43:12comes into play this what Penrose would
- 43:14say or
- 43:16um I don't know if there's a certain
- 43:18amount of Deco I don't know these
- 43:19theories well enough to say but like at
- 43:21some for some reason at some scale this
- 43:25thing which is actually real actually
- 43:28collapses um and then you get some some
- 43:32classical outcome in some sense um so
- 43:35that's another way of taking it to be
- 43:36real without being like ever readying
- 43:38about it so if you're ever ready and you
- 43:39say it never collapses it's just like
- 43:42the way function is eternal reality
- 43:45great now the information people would
- 43:47be who some people say the quantum state
- 43:49is just about information maybe it's a
- 43:52subset of knowledge or a subset of
- 43:54belief I mean I think probably carll's
- 43:57interpretation of um like relational
- 44:00quantum mechanics would be that sort of
- 44:01a thing where you say I mean he would
- 44:05say this is also a little related to to
- 44:08Everett where Quantum states are
- 44:11relative States um so in Everett like
- 44:14the big wave function the the ultimate
- 44:17one is is real and absolute and
- 44:20invariant um so that's the real thing um
- 44:24but then there's all these like relative
- 44:27wave functions within that and so then
- 44:29relli does away with the big real
- 44:31absolute thing but just deals in
- 44:33relative so so the idea being like you
- 44:36and I don't have to have the same wave
- 44:39function for the same object so I can
- 44:41describe an electron with a wave
- 44:43function you could describe an electron
- 44:44with a wave function but based on the
- 44:46information that we have about the
- 44:48electron if we have different
- 44:49information we can give different
- 44:51Quantum States for that thing um so so I
- 44:56think that would be a very
- 44:57information based approach and this
- 45:00becomes really relevant because there
- 45:03are these paradoxes like the viger's
- 45:05friend Paradox if you don't mind can you
- 45:08outline viger's friend yeah so it's this
- 45:12very
- 45:13mind-bending Paradox where let's say
- 45:16okay you're my friend Kurt and you go
- 45:19into a lab and you're going to measure
- 45:22you have a cubit so like you know a a
- 45:25Quantum system that can be in one state
- 45:26or other and it's an electron that can
- 45:29be spin up or spin down along some axis
- 45:33and um and you're going to make a
- 45:35measurement and and say you know the
- 45:38electron spin up or it's spin down
- 45:41but I'm vigner and I'm standing outside
- 45:44the lab and the lab is like a completely
- 45:48isolated
- 45:50system
- 45:51so from my
- 45:54perspective quantum mechanics should
- 45:56tell me that you as a physical system
- 46:00and the electron as a physical system if
- 46:03you interact you just become Tangled
- 46:04with each other and you just end up in
- 46:08this big superposition
- 46:10of uh Kurt has seen the electron spin up
- 46:14and the electron is spin up plus Kurt
- 46:16has seen the electron has spin down and
- 46:18the electron is spin down and then I can
- 46:20make a measurement and then I'll find
- 46:23like one of those or the other um so
- 46:26it's a scaled up version of shinger cat
- 46:28it's just instead of the cat it's you
- 46:31and then you have another friend who's
- 46:32wondering well what's going to happen
- 46:33with the super position like the cat's
- 46:35in the box but then shinger is in a box
- 46:39too so yeah it's like these nested
- 46:41measurements and like you you what you
- 46:43realize is like the friend can assign
- 46:47one state to the thing like the friend
- 46:49says the electron is spin up that's the
- 46:51state um whereas like vigner is like no
- 46:54the electron's still in a super position
- 46:56of up and down and so is the friend um
- 46:59and so then you're like well if the
- 47:01quantum state is supposed to like say
- 47:04what the state of the electron is whose
- 47:07Quantum state is right because I have
- 47:09one and you have one and they're
- 47:10different um so it sort of points to
- 47:14this fact that you probably can't treat
- 47:16Quantum States as as not relative in
- 47:19some sense um as being absolute like
- 47:22this is the Quantum state of the
- 47:24electron and so different
- 47:26interpretations have to get around this
- 47:27in different ways
- 47:29um and so like many worlds like Everett
- 47:32would just say well no worries like in
- 47:35one
- 47:37Universe uh you know one outcome happens
- 47:40in the other Universe the other outcome
- 47:41happens and we're always going to end up
- 47:43in the universes where we agree on our
- 47:45things and so like you just sort of
- 47:47sweep all the disagreements into
- 47:49different universes and then it's fine
- 47:52um but you know or you could have
- 47:55objective collaps people would say
- 47:57well a friend is a big macroscopic
- 47:59system and when they make the
- 48:00measurement the thing actually collapses
- 48:02and so vigner can't really describe it
- 48:05as being a big superposition because
- 48:06that would just be wrong um do you have
- 48:10yeah okay let's get well basically what
- 48:12I was going to ask is do you have a
- 48:14favorite interpretation but maybe you're
- 48:15about to answer that I'm sympathetic to
- 48:18to rll's relational quantum mechanics
- 48:21um but U but cubism I think would be my
- 48:25like preferred um
- 48:27I don't you know as a journalist like
- 48:28I'm I'm supposed to be like neutral
- 48:30trying to give this classical third
- 48:32person story of like what's really H
- 48:35what's the real state of the electron I
- 48:37think it's just the wrong question um
- 48:39and again it just goes back to these
- 48:41like 17th century philosophical ideas
- 48:43that we have about what how reality
- 48:45Works um and so I would prefer to you
- 48:49know not suffer from long classicality
- 48:52and just say you know the world is is
- 48:55quantum and um and so I can write down
- 48:59one Quantum State and you can write down
- 49:01another quantum state so so what what
- 49:04cubism says is my my Quantum state is
- 49:09not a description of the thing so if
- 49:11we're talking about shirting or cat and
- 49:14I say I'm going to write down a Quantum
- 49:16state that has the cat in a superp
- 49:17position of dead and alive that is not a
- 49:20description in cubism of the cat that
- 49:23tells me nothing about the state of the
- 49:25cat hm what it tells me is about the
- 49:28state of my various degrees of belief
- 49:31about what might happen when I interact
- 49:34with the
- 49:35cat okay so it's a very different story
- 49:38um it's not describing the cat it's
- 49:40describing my beliefs and
- 49:43then but the but the sort of interesting
- 49:46content comes from the fact
- 49:49that while I can have whatever beliefs I
- 49:52want
- 49:54um my beliefs have to be related to each
- 49:58other in a consistent way so it's not
- 50:01completely unconstrained it's not like
- 50:03well I believe anything I want you know
- 50:05what happens in cubism is the born rule
- 50:07which is this like sort of fundamental
- 50:10rule in in Quantum Mechanics for how
- 50:12normally the born Ru is taken to be like
- 50:14how you get probabilities out of the the
- 50:17wave function so like you square the
- 50:19amplitude of the wave function and that
- 50:20gives you the probability that's the
- 50:21born rule
- 50:23cubism sort of mathematically rewrites
- 50:26the born rule in terms of just how
- 50:29different probabilities for different
- 50:31measurements you can make on the same
- 50:32system relate to each
- 50:34other and this is a really really
- 50:37interesting move
- 50:39because what it says is like the
- 50:41difference between quantum mechanics and
- 50:43classical mechanics is in classical
- 50:44mechanics I can make I can measure
- 50:46anything of a system I can measure its
- 50:49position and its momentum no big deal in
- 50:52quantum mechanics you can't do that
- 50:54there's certain measurements you can
- 50:55make that clude you from making other
- 50:58measurements at the same time and and
- 51:02that ends up being like really
- 51:03fundamental that that's how you get the
- 51:05uncertainty principle and all this stuff
- 51:06so so that's the like Central difference
- 51:09and and so because I can make you know
- 51:12if I'm vigner I can
- 51:14measure I can open the lab and then say
- 51:17hey Kurt what did you get when you
- 51:19measured your electron that's one
- 51:20measurement I can make or I can measure
- 51:23the whole U and the electron in like a
- 51:26superposition basis and get an
- 51:29interference pattern and I and so I can
- 51:31do these different types of measurements
- 51:33but I can't do them both um and so my
- 51:36beliefs about what I think I'm going to
- 51:40see when I do one type of measurement is
- 51:43constrained by how it's related to the
- 51:45beliefs about what I could do if I take
- 51:47these other
- 51:48measurements and and that constraint
- 51:51ends up being in cubism like sort of the
- 51:53the real content of quantum mechanics so
- 51:57it's just really interesting because
- 51:58it's a totally different way of looking
- 52:00at at the physics well the word belief
- 52:03here must be used in some abstract sense
- 52:06because if I was to ask my mom mom look
- 52:07I have a quantum mechanical experiment
- 52:09it's either going to be spin up or spin
- 52:11down what are your beliefs about this
- 52:13what are the probabilities you're
- 52:15signing to this she's going to cook me
- 52:16food and she's going to think that I've
- 52:18lost my mind it's a good mom yes exactly
- 52:22she'll have no idea what I mean I said
- 52:23the word quantum mechanics I I she has
- 52:25no beliefs about that I said spin up
- 52:26spin now she doesn't know maybe she
- 52:28would say 50/50 but that may just happen
- 52:30to be actually what the probabilities
- 52:32are but it could be 75 25 or what have
- 52:35you could be 99 whatever so what is
- 52:38meant when we say look the way function
- 52:41represents our beliefs we didn't have
- 52:43any beliefs about wave functions prior
- 52:45to wave functions being invented in the
- 52:461900s and presumably the world was still
- 52:49operating prior to then so what is meant
- 52:52by the word belief yeah so what's sort
- 52:55of remarkable is really just means
- 52:57belief um it does it means like a numer
- 53:00it's a belief that you can put a number
- 53:02on so so I mean that's like the bare
- 53:05minimum I guess um but it really is your
- 53:09belief so it you it could be it could be
- 53:11your mom coming to if she's willing to
- 53:13put some numbers on it the thing is is
- 53:16that the born
- 53:17rule what she has to do is
- 53:20say okay I believe you know I 90% that
- 53:24this would happen if I did this I
- 53:26believe 10% that this happen if I did
- 53:28this and I believe 20% this would but
- 53:30then if she plugs all those beliefs in
- 53:33the BN R is going to
- 53:35either say you know proceed or like stop
- 53:38and rethink so if it doesn't fit this
- 53:43equation it's the born Ru is going to
- 53:45say hang on your beliefs are not
- 53:47self-consistent so you're not just
- 53:49referring to that they don't add up to
- 53:50one you're referring to something else
- 53:53it's related to the fact that they don't
- 53:54add up to one but it's
- 53:57yeah they've Rewritten it in this way
- 53:58that they they have to yeah okay so the
- 54:02fact that they have to add up to one is
- 54:03like the law of total probability right
- 54:06if the world were
- 54:07classical that's all that's that would
- 54:10be the the the the whole constraint you
- 54:12would just need the law of probability
- 54:14total
- 54:15probability the born rule is an addition
- 54:18a slight addition to the to the law of
- 54:21total probability so it's classical
- 54:23probability Theory plus this one EXT
- 54:26constraint which is like an empirical
- 54:29fact that comes from the fact
- 54:30essentially that like Plank's constant
- 54:31is not zero
- 54:34so again it comes from the fact that our
- 54:37probabilities don't add in the way that
- 54:40they did classically like that's what we
- 54:42see in the double slit experiment it's
- 54:43like your probabilities right there's
- 54:46interference with the probabilities yeah
- 54:48they interfere and so Richard fan was
- 54:49like this is the whole mystery of
- 54:50quantum mechanics is like why do
- 54:52probabilities not add in a classical way
- 54:55it's it's similar to like the whole
- 54:56mystery of Relativity is like why do
- 54:58veloc velocities not add in a classical
- 55:00way so you
- 55:03say okay what I have to do to make my
- 55:06beliefs consistent is it has to conform
- 55:09to the law of total probability plus the
- 55:12born R yes now Amanda I still don't see
- 55:15how this helps my mom because my mom
- 55:18will say okay okay Kurt okay son 65 25
- 55:23I'm like Mom that doesn't add to one
- 55:24we'll normalize it mom she's okay okay I
- 55:26don't know what that means and then
- 55:28she'll just throw out some other numbers
- 55:29how is she supposed to know if it adds
- 55:31up to the born rule how am I supposed to
- 55:33know it can't be belief means belief in
- 55:36it does though it does help me through
- 55:38this the amazing thing about cubism is
- 55:41like they mean what they say it really
- 55:43is um so so the idea is the Boral is
- 55:47going to
- 55:48say look if you were if you were
- 55:50betting if you were placing bets like
- 55:53think about it like you're betting on
- 55:55like that outcomes of all the different
- 55:58types of measurements you can make on
- 55:59this system you're saying like if I
- 56:01choose to measure position I'm going to
- 56:03get this if I choose to measure momentum
- 56:04I'm going to get this and then you're
- 56:05putting like a dollar amount sure on
- 56:08like each thing that you could do if you
- 56:11violate the born roll it means you've
- 56:13you've subjected yourself to a sure loss
- 56:16no matter what you do you're going to
- 56:17lose money so your only goal here is to
- 56:22just not have a sure loss you want to
- 56:24just like adjust your bets so that
- 56:27you're not you're not open to to just
- 56:30losing no matter what happens um so so
- 56:34if your mom like comes up with some
- 56:35numbers and you're like hold on this
- 56:37doesn't fit you have to one of these has
- 56:40to be a little lower let's say and then
- 56:43she can search her soul this is how
- 56:45Chris always says it she can search her
- 56:47soul and make a decision you know what
- 56:50I'm going to put more on this one A
- 56:51Little Less on this she she tweaks it
- 56:54that's it nothing compels her to believe
- 56:58any particular thing but quantum
- 57:01mechanics compels her to make her
- 57:04beliefs coherent with one
- 57:07another
- 57:09and and this is a you know they
- 57:11emphasize this in cubism this is a
- 57:13normative rule so this is not an
- 57:15ontological rule this is not saying like
- 57:17this is how the world is it's saying
- 57:18this is what you should
- 57:20do as an agent in the world who is
- 57:24trying to bet on the outcomes of your m
- 57:26measurements and that is the whole story
- 57:28yes Chris says throwing some holy
- 57:30water like quantum mechanics compels you
- 57:32quantum mechanics compels
- 57:34you okay so let's imagine he's doing
- 57:36that to my mom but it would take two
- 57:38years before she was to articulate by
- 57:40chance some set of probabilities that
- 57:43would happen to align with the born rule
- 57:45yet the universe is still moving and
- 57:48trucking along and presumably at any
- 57:51given instant we're making billions of
- 57:54quantum mechanical measurements and
- 57:55observ ations and so on so this is
- 57:57happening under the hood it's not just
- 57:59physicist in a lab writing it down when
- 58:01I'm looking at you there are many
- 58:02quantum mechanical effects occurring and
- 58:04this desk here and same with you and
- 58:07same with the people listening so at no
- 58:09point are the people who are listening
- 58:12making beliefs about quantum mechanics
- 58:14consciously in fact some of them are
- 58:16finding out about quantum mechanics
- 58:18right now yeah so help me understand how
- 58:22does belief conscious belief or what we
- 58:24ordinarily colloquially think of his
- 58:26belief yeah have anything to do with a
- 58:29Quantum system so I think the the
- 58:33question comes
- 58:34from usually seeing Quantum States as
- 58:37being like reality or a description of
- 58:40reality and then you're saying well like
- 58:42how could reality be my beliefs right
- 58:45but here in cubism it's not that's not
- 58:48what reality your Quantum states are
- 58:51just tools that agents use to make
- 58:54better gambling decisions
- 58:56um about the measurements that they're
- 58:58going to make and that's it and I mean
- 59:01there's a sense in which um cubism they
- 59:03they say like it's a small Theory
- 59:05it's that nobody's saying that's what
- 59:08reality is they're just saying quantum
- 59:11theory the everyone is confused by
- 59:14quantum theory because they think
- 59:15quantum theory is describing reality and
- 59:18quantum theory is not describing reality
- 59:20it's describing how we ought to bet on
- 59:24our measurement outcomes and if you're
- 59:25not not doing a complicated like double
- 59:29sit experiment or something you probably
- 59:31don't need to write down a Quantum State
- 59:32and you probably don't need to make
- 59:33these bets and that doesn't mean the
- 59:35universe is going to fall apart it just
- 59:37means you're not doing Quantum mechan
- 59:40like you're not an agent who's gambling
- 59:42on these things so okay then you could
- 59:45say well hold on now we've just made
- 59:48this so small that like who
- 59:51cares but the deeper point is the fact
- 59:55that your beliefs have to be consistent
- 59:58with one another in this way something
- 1:00:01about that mathematical structure tells
- 1:00:03you about the character of the world so
- 1:00:07you're not learning about reality from
- 1:00:10the wave function that's not what the
- 1:00:12wave function is doing if you want to
- 1:00:15learn about reality you
- 1:00:16say why should I bet this w why am I why
- 1:00:20am my bets constrained in this way
- 1:00:24that's weird what kind of work world is
- 1:00:26this such that that would be the best
- 1:00:28way to gamble on measurement outcomes
- 1:00:30and then that's the road in to asking
- 1:00:32these kind of like deep ontological
- 1:00:34questions about reality but the road in
- 1:00:36is not to say like what does the wave
- 1:00:39function what does it
- 1:00:40represent nothing it represents our
- 1:00:43degrees of belief about measurement
- 1:00:44outcomes so
- 1:00:47cubism it's the wave function is not
- 1:00:50describing reality but that doesn't mean
- 1:00:52that it doesn't tell us something very
- 1:00:54deep about the nature of real it so um
- 1:00:58when we look at the fact that we have to
- 1:01:01organize our bets in this particular
- 1:01:04way um that's telling
- 1:01:08us something about the character of the
- 1:01:10world so it's it's very similar to um
- 1:01:13like Chris books likes to use this
- 1:01:16example of the ugina which I think is
- 1:01:19some kind of microscopic organism the
- 1:01:21ugena tail um so you can look look at
- 1:01:26the ug's tale and it's just it's just a
- 1:01:31a feature of the ugina it's not about
- 1:01:33the world but the fact that this is a
- 1:01:35useful tool for the ugina to navigate
- 1:01:37its World tells you something about the
- 1:01:40world like indirectly and so the idea is
- 1:01:42supposed to be the same in cubism that
- 1:01:44the fact that the born rule constrains
- 1:01:46our beliefs in this particular way tells
- 1:01:49us something about the character of the
- 1:01:51world that we're that we're having
- 1:01:53beliefs about and so what does it tell
- 1:01:55us well this is something cubism still
- 1:01:58trying to figure out um but the the Deep
- 1:02:02Point seems to be that it tells us that
- 1:02:05the world is not divisible into subject
- 1:02:07and object in the way that we have
- 1:02:09thought and Sak heart so it tells us
- 1:02:12that reality is participatory in this
- 1:02:16really deep sense um it tells us that
- 1:02:19there's not just some way that things
- 1:02:21are sitting out there independent of us
- 1:02:24but that we and the world together
- 1:02:26through these like concrete interactions
- 1:02:28these measurement interactions are
- 1:02:29creating something genuinely novel um
- 1:02:33sometimes the cubus describe it as like
- 1:02:35there's a spark you know there's this
- 1:02:36novel little bit of creation almost like
- 1:02:39a little big bang every time there's a
- 1:02:41measurement and um and so it's not that
- 1:02:46you know like Kurt when you asked you
- 1:02:48know wasn't the universe just going on
- 1:02:50you know before we were making bets and
- 1:02:53and writing down these wave functions
- 1:02:56um so the wave functions are not the
- 1:02:58reality and and that the cubus would say
- 1:03:01like that's the mistake these other
- 1:03:02interpretations are making it's not the
- 1:03:05reality but the fact that we should
- 1:03:06structure our beliefs in this way does
- 1:03:09tell us that the reality has this
- 1:03:11character of subject and object not
- 1:03:14being like neatly neatly and
- 1:03:17unambiguously divisible um so that does
- 1:03:20tell us something very deep and then you
- 1:03:23know cubism is hoping to go on with this
- 1:03:27this kind of ontological project of
- 1:03:28trying to say more about the nature of
- 1:03:31that reality but it it gives this um
- 1:03:33participatory story because you can't
- 1:03:36say you know when you make a measurement
- 1:03:38you can't say that you're
- 1:03:40revealing something that was already
- 1:03:42there you're not finding out what was
- 1:03:43already there you're participating in
- 1:03:45the creation of that thing but the key
- 1:03:48is also it's not in you right it's in
- 1:03:52the interaction between you and the
- 1:03:53world that's where the novelty is
- 1:03:55happening it's in the subject because
- 1:03:57again the subject and object can't be
- 1:03:58like neatly divided in this way and so
- 1:04:01some people hear about cubism they say
- 1:04:03oh it's it's solipsistic because it's
- 1:04:05all about beliefs and and it's not just
- 1:04:08anyone's beliefs it's my beliefs right
- 1:04:10so if I write down a wave function it's
- 1:04:12my beliefs and they don't have to be the
- 1:04:14same as yours and so people think that
- 1:04:17they hear that and they think like
- 1:04:19because they're so used to thinking of
- 1:04:20the way function is like representing
- 1:04:21reality it's like well then it's only my
- 1:04:24universe and only your universe un and
- 1:04:26like no that's not what's happening it's
- 1:04:28my beliefs and your beliefs it's my way
- 1:04:30function and your way function but what
- 1:04:34arises through measurement is something
- 1:04:37shared between me and the world when I
- 1:04:39make a measurement um and what arises
- 1:04:41through measurement is something shared
- 1:04:43between you and the world when you make
- 1:04:45a measurement and then if you and I are
- 1:04:47interacting with each other we're
- 1:04:48creating something shared together so um
- 1:04:52so there's this participatory story
- 1:04:55and sometimes I like to think about
- 1:04:58wheeler used to tell this anecdote that
- 1:05:00I
- 1:05:01love um just going back to John Wheeler
- 1:05:03for a second so wheeler liked to tell
- 1:05:07this story about playing a game of 20
- 1:05:09questions so he would he he tells the
- 1:05:13story that he was at a a dinner party
- 1:05:16and they're playing 20 questions they
- 1:05:17would send someone out of the room and
- 1:05:19they would decide on like a word and the
- 1:05:22person would come back in and start
- 1:05:23asking yes or no questions and they
- 1:05:25would have to have 20 Questions spell to
- 1:05:27guess the word so then it was Wheeler's
- 1:05:29turn to leave the
- 1:05:30room and he leaves and when he comes
- 1:05:34back in he
- 1:05:36starts he said okay he leaves he leaves
- 1:05:39her room and it takes very long time it
- 1:05:42seems for them to decide on the word and
- 1:05:44so then he goes back into the room and
- 1:05:46he starts guessing he says you
- 1:05:48know is it an animal and they say no and
- 1:05:53then he says okay is it
- 1:05:57green and the next person thinks for a
- 1:05:59second says no you know he says is it
- 1:06:02white and the next person thinks they
- 1:06:03say yes and this goes on and he's
- 1:06:07noticing that the answers are taking
- 1:06:10longer and longer each time and finally
- 1:06:14he says is it a
- 1:06:17cloud and the person you know thinks for
- 1:06:20a long time and then everyone bursts out
- 1:06:21laughing they say yes and it turns out
- 1:06:24that what the game was was when he left
- 1:06:26the room they decided that they weren't
- 1:06:28going to pick a word they were just
- 1:06:31going to answer questions on the
- 1:06:34fly but the rule was that whenever they
- 1:06:37answered a question it had they had to
- 1:06:39have something in mind that was
- 1:06:41consistent with all the previous answers
- 1:06:42so that if he like challenged them they
- 1:06:44would be able to like come up with a
- 1:06:45word that this thing could be so for
- 1:06:49wheeler this like was the like a perfect
- 1:06:54example of what happens in Quantum
- 1:06:55mechanic because the point is the word
- 1:06:58cloud didn't exist before he started
- 1:07:01asking
- 1:07:02questions but he didn't come up with the
- 1:07:05idea that it was a cloud because he was
- 1:07:08asking questions in response to the
- 1:07:09answers he was getting from the people
- 1:07:11but they didn't come up with it either
- 1:07:12because they would have given different
- 1:07:15answers if he had asked different
- 1:07:16questions and so the word
- 1:07:19cloud was this sort of participatory
- 1:07:22creation that came about between you
- 1:07:24know the person making the measurement
- 1:07:26the person asking questions of the world
- 1:07:27and the world responding in turn and so
- 1:07:30it's like in the end shared between all
- 1:07:33of them
- 1:07:35that's right so this is Wheeler's idea
- 1:07:38of like a participatory universe and
- 1:07:40this is really the kind of ontology or
- 1:07:43the kind of reality that cubism gives
- 1:07:46you because you're asking questions
- 1:07:49about the world and yes you're
- 1:07:50structuring your wave function in terms
- 1:07:52of your beliefs and all of that but
- 1:07:55that's not what's happening in the
- 1:07:58actual measurement in the actual
- 1:08:00measurement you're asking a question of
- 1:08:01the world the world's responding back
- 1:08:03and the two of you together are like
- 1:08:04creating something new um so that's the
- 1:08:08real story that like cubism is trying to
- 1:08:10tell and the whole thing about beliefs
- 1:08:12is just a way of telling that story
- 1:08:15really really
- 1:08:17consistently um and and I guess the
- 1:08:19other thing I should
- 1:08:21add is you know in terms of the basian
- 1:08:24part of the story
- 1:08:27you know you yes it's true that like
- 1:08:30your beliefs can be anything you want as
- 1:08:32long as they're consistent in according
- 1:08:35to the born rule but they're they're
- 1:08:38informed by all your prior experiences
- 1:08:40so the whole idea of basian probability
- 1:08:42is that you make a measurement you get
- 1:08:45an outcome and then you update your
- 1:08:49probabilities that you're going to
- 1:08:50assign so you update your beliefs in
- 1:08:52reaction to what the world has given you
- 1:08:55um um so so the interesting thing here
- 1:08:58is like in terms of solving Like the
- 1:08:59quote unquote measurement problem is
- 1:09:01that like other interpretations what
- 1:09:04they would call the collapse of the wave
- 1:09:06function in cubism it's just an agent
- 1:09:09updating her beliefs right so she gets
- 1:09:12an outcome changes her probabilities
- 1:09:14that's that's it that's the whole story
- 1:09:16of like the the collapse of the wave
- 1:09:18function um it's not a big deal because
- 1:09:20the wave function doesn't refer to
- 1:09:21reality but that means that like your
- 1:09:24beliefs even though like you are free to
- 1:09:26believe whatever you want as long as
- 1:09:28they fit together in this way prescribed
- 1:09:30by the Bor R your beliefs are not
- 1:09:33subjective in the sense of being like
- 1:09:35just you know made up in your head
- 1:09:38because they arise from your whole
- 1:09:40history of like prior concrete
- 1:09:42interactions with the world and so in
- 1:09:44some
- 1:09:45sense the beliefs already straddle that
- 1:09:48subject object divide because they
- 1:09:51already
- 1:09:52incorporate these interactions that that
- 1:09:55straddle that divide themselves and so
- 1:09:58so I think you know it's personalist and
- 1:10:01it's important to say that but it's also
- 1:10:03important to realize that like those
- 1:10:05beliefs you know you're not just like
- 1:10:07coming up with them in your head you're
- 1:10:09interacting with the world and updating
- 1:10:11in response to that and then like the
- 1:10:13last thing I should say about about
- 1:10:16cubism is
- 1:10:17um it's not just the quantum State
- 1:10:21assignment that you give to a system
- 1:10:22that's
- 1:10:23personalist but the out come is personal
- 1:10:26too so again this like is what helps us
- 1:10:30get out of like a vor's friend Paradox
- 1:10:32is like you can make a measurement and
- 1:10:34get an
- 1:10:36outcome and it doesn't mean that outcome
- 1:10:39is true for me when I'm over here and
- 1:10:42I'm vigner um so outcomes are personal
- 1:10:46just like Quantum State assignments are
- 1:10:48personal and so um in cubism like to be
- 1:10:51consistent you you end up with all these
- 1:10:53levels of like personalism
- 1:10:56um but again you don't want to think of
- 1:10:58it as being in some agent's head it's
- 1:11:01not like the world's in your head it's
- 1:11:03you're interacting with the world in a
- 1:11:04very real way and the outcome is
- 1:11:07something shared
- 1:11:09between the people participa
- 1:11:12participating in that interaction which
- 1:11:13is like you and the world or you and
- 1:11:15another agent if you're acting on each
- 1:11:17other um but anyone who's not in that
- 1:11:19interaction like bner standing outside
- 1:11:22this is not you know
- 1:11:25an outcome for vigner so it's it's
- 1:11:28personal in that
- 1:11:30sense okay let's go through a side door
- 1:11:33with all these different interpretations
- 1:11:34of quantum mechanics there are other
- 1:11:37foundational issues at the heart of
- 1:11:39quantum field Theory which is said to be
- 1:11:41the deeper Theory have you heard of some
- 1:11:45interpretation of quantum mechanics
- 1:11:46solving any of the foundational problems
- 1:11:48in qft any of the interpretations yeah
- 1:11:52any of them I haven't seen any
- 1:11:54personally but I don't know about the
- 1:11:56relationship between interpretations of
- 1:11:58quantum mechanics and the foundational
- 1:12:00issues of quantum field theory in qft
- 1:12:02it's almost like you're already telling
- 1:12:06a kind of real story about like what's
- 1:12:08happening in the world cubism wants to
- 1:12:12just be like measurement we're talking
- 1:12:13about measurement that has to be the
- 1:12:15foundation of of of anything you're
- 1:12:17talking about so I would think like well
- 1:12:20I don't know tell tell me what you have
- 1:12:21in mind well actually one of the
- 1:12:22interpretations so Penrose makes some
- 1:12:25claims about quantum gravity so then
- 1:12:27that has to say something about Quantum
- 1:12:28field Theory but then there are other
- 1:12:30issues like how do we rigorously Define
- 1:12:33the findan path integral or what about
- 1:12:36existence of mass gaps or problems with
- 1:12:39renormalization and it doesn't seem to
- 1:12:42me like interpretations of quantum
- 1:12:44mechanics have any bearing here but it
- 1:12:46seems like they should to me because
- 1:12:49quantum mechanics is at the higher level
- 1:12:51than Quantum field Theory Quantum field
- 1:12:53theory is more foundational so we're
- 1:12:56stuck up here trying to interpret when
- 1:12:58we should be over here
- 1:13:00interpreting it's like the the
- 1:13:02interpretation is going to set the terms
- 1:13:04for what you're counting as real what
- 1:13:07you're counting as it's going to sort of
- 1:13:11set like the the really really
- 1:13:13fundamental terms in which like any
- 1:13:16theory that you talk about in physics
- 1:13:17then has to apply like so for example
- 1:13:21people talk about in quantum gravity or
- 1:13:24something like MH or not even quantum
- 1:13:27gravity like talking about like like
- 1:13:28vacuum fluctuations let's say yes okay
- 1:13:31so you have like because of uncertainty
- 1:13:33you have vacuum fluctuations you have
- 1:13:35pair production of particles and like so
- 1:13:37you can tell this whole story but
- 1:13:41really if you're thinking in like terms
- 1:13:44of like Quantum foundations and
- 1:13:45interpretations like what are those
- 1:13:47fluctuations fluctuations of right
- 1:13:50because it's coming out of uncertainty
- 1:13:51so it's is it fluctuations in your
- 1:13:53beliefs is it fluctuations
- 1:13:55in your knowledge and information is it
- 1:13:59like cuz if you're saying it's
- 1:14:01fluctuations of a thing that's just
- 1:14:03sitting out there fluctuating like
- 1:14:06you're already either like a Boman
- 1:14:08you've already picked an interpretation
- 1:14:09at that point do you know what I mean
- 1:14:11yes so the cubis would say cubis would
- 1:14:14say you got to talk about where's your a
- 1:14:17the agent has to be in the story from
- 1:14:19the beginning and what are they
- 1:14:21measuring and how are they betting on
- 1:14:23the outcomes of those measurements
- 1:14:25so would the cubis say that your beliefs
- 1:14:27are actually fluctuating no um I realize
- 1:14:30I said that but no
- 1:14:33um they would say the the fluctuations
- 1:14:37come from uncertainty Quantum
- 1:14:39uncertainty and in a Cuba Story the
- 1:14:44uncertainty comes in with the fact that
- 1:14:47you can't make certain measurements
- 1:14:50simultaneously and I mean that's what's
- 1:14:51happening right like when you get like a
- 1:14:53vacuum fluctuation in the standard like
- 1:14:55story it's um coming about because of
- 1:14:59this non-commuting nature of like time
- 1:15:02and energy right so you say oh on really
- 1:15:04really really short time scales you can
- 1:15:06get these like huge fluctuations of
- 1:15:09energy um and
- 1:15:12so but what you're really saying that's
- 1:15:14like again it's like you're just trying
- 1:15:16to tell a very realist story at that
- 1:15:18point because what's you're really
- 1:15:19saying is if I were to measure the time
- 1:15:22I could get this thing if I were to
- 1:15:24measure energy I could get this thing
- 1:15:26and then those are related in this
- 1:15:28strange Quantum non-classical way but
- 1:15:31like the whole story has to be like what
- 1:15:33are you actually going to measure and
- 1:15:35and you can't talk about like what some
- 1:15:38field out there is doing independent of
- 1:15:40what you're
- 1:15:42measuring Amanda to get into some less
- 1:15:48well we'll see it could be less hairy or
- 1:15:49more hairy ground what is your view of
- 1:15:53Consciousness oh boy that's yeah that's
- 1:15:56more hairy
- 1:15:58um my view of Consciousness is is
- 1:16:02related to all of this great and let me
- 1:16:05try to think of the least painful way of
- 1:16:07explaining it um to put a name to it
- 1:16:11like the The View that I I find
- 1:16:14compelling is um usually called the
- 1:16:18inactive view or an activism um and this
- 1:16:22is in the world of like what's sometimes
- 1:16:23called like 4E cognition so this is like
- 1:16:26embodied embedded extended and active um
- 1:16:30it's related to ecological psychology as
- 1:16:32well so anything that starts with an e
- 1:16:34um tends to fall in this camp and
- 1:16:38um and
- 1:16:40so yeah I would I of of the ease I would
- 1:16:43I would choose anactive
- 1:16:46um but can I give a historical aside for
- 1:16:50please please because I find that this
- 1:16:53really really helps explain where I'm
- 1:16:55coming from um this idea that we have of
- 1:16:59Consciousness was invented in the 17th
- 1:17:02century oh okay it does not it was not
- 1:17:05always with us and I think that's like a
- 1:17:08really key thing for us to remember
- 1:17:10because it seems like oh that's just so
- 1:17:13intuitive but it's not um this was like
- 1:17:16an this was an invention um and it was
- 1:17:20invented mostly B by
- 1:17:22dekart um even though were like
- 1:17:25predecessors in like going back to Plato
- 1:17:28and and Augustine and stuff but
- 1:17:30deart is the one I think we can blame
- 1:17:33most significantly and
- 1:17:37um what you have to remember and what
- 1:17:39people seem to have forgotten is when
- 1:17:42dekart came up at this
- 1:17:44idea that the mind is in the head and
- 1:17:48that there's this sort of firstperson
- 1:17:49story cojito osum this whole thing he
- 1:17:53was not coming up with this to explain
- 1:17:55the mind which was not yet a
- 1:17:58problem he was trying to invent a new
- 1:18:00Theory of
- 1:18:01physics so the physics that existed at
- 1:18:04the time was Aristotle's physics and
- 1:18:08when you look at that there was no real
- 1:18:12subject object
- 1:18:14distinction um so for instance
- 1:18:18like you
- 1:18:19know we now thanks to Dart make this
- 1:18:22distinction like primary qualities and
- 1:18:24secondary qualities right and um like
- 1:18:27subjective objective so um in Aristotle
- 1:18:31you know redness or sweetness or all
- 1:18:33these things were not like in our heads
- 1:18:36they were just like part of the world
- 1:18:38but also like objects did things because
- 1:18:41they had like internal motivation like
- 1:18:44things fell because they like yearned to
- 1:18:46be close to the Earth like so there was
- 1:18:48objects weren't really objects and
- 1:18:50subjects weren't really subject it was
- 1:18:51all mixed up and
- 1:18:55and decart came along and he had come up
- 1:18:57with cartisian geometry and cartisian
- 1:19:01coordinates and he thought to himself
- 1:19:03like if everything were just size shape
- 1:19:06and motion if that's all that existed
- 1:19:09then I could describe the whole universe
- 1:19:11just using my coordinate system and I
- 1:19:16would have this new physics um but like
- 1:19:20unfortunately there's all this other
- 1:19:22stuff like thoughts and ideas and colors
- 1:19:25and sounds and like and none of that
- 1:19:27fits that story so I need somewhere else
- 1:19:30to put them and then he has this
- 1:19:33realization of like oh you know
- 1:19:37I I can doubt everything that I see but
- 1:19:40I can't doubt my doubting so there's
- 1:19:42this difference between the things that
- 1:19:45are like self- knowing and then the
- 1:19:47things that are only known and so so he
- 1:19:49creates this distinction between like
- 1:19:51the cojito which is like the self-
- 1:19:53knowing self-referential thing
- 1:19:55the I the capital i i and and the
- 1:19:58objects in the world and so then he
- 1:20:00takes all this subjective stuff that
- 1:20:01doesn't fit in his coordinate system and
- 1:20:03he sticks it in the head and then he
- 1:20:05takes everything else that's left is
- 1:20:07just objective and so he write like the
- 1:20:11words coo osum like this first appeared
- 1:20:14in A Treatise on physics this was a a
- 1:20:16move for physics and so and his physics
- 1:20:20wasn't great but it it did displ
- 1:20:24aristotles very quickly and then Newton
- 1:20:27came along and Newton fixed it basically
- 1:20:29and it became Newtonian physics but new
- 1:20:32Newton's physics would not have existed
- 1:20:33without dick hearts and and so it set
- 1:20:36the stage for classical physics and at
- 1:20:38the same time and in the same move it
- 1:20:41invented this idea of Consciousness as
- 1:20:43being something self- knowing that we
- 1:20:46experience directly but the world we
- 1:20:48only experience indirectly and that
- 1:20:50there's qualia and that there's objects
- 1:20:53and those are different this whole story
- 1:20:55that we tell about Consciousness came
- 1:20:58from this one move which was to say I'm
- 1:21:01going to make a split between subject
- 1:21:02and
- 1:21:03object and so you get from this one
- 1:21:06single move subject object split you get
- 1:21:09Consciousness and you get classical
- 1:21:11physics and so when quantum physics
- 1:21:14comes along and goes wait a minute
- 1:21:17classical physics is wrong this story
- 1:21:18doesn't work and if you look at like
- 1:21:21bore and you look at like the origins of
- 1:21:23quantum mechanics like what they're
- 1:21:24realizing is the issue is that subject
- 1:21:28object distinction the world cannot be
- 1:21:30divided up that way you can get away
- 1:21:32with it for so long but when you look
- 1:21:34really really
- 1:21:35closely you get this little H bar uh
- 1:21:40planks constant which tells you this is
- 1:21:43measuring like a a subject object
- 1:21:45overlap that you can't get rid of and
- 1:21:49and so all of a sudden that story was
- 1:21:52wrong and you need to remove that
- 1:21:55subject object split but where We've
- 1:21:58Ended up is in this really confused
- 1:22:00place where we kind of see that on the
- 1:22:02quantum mechanic side but we're doubling
- 1:22:05down on the Consciousness side so we're
- 1:22:07walking around with this very incoherent
- 1:22:09metaphysics where we're
- 1:22:12saying okay yeah like in quantum
- 1:22:14mechanics like objects aren't really
- 1:22:16just objects but subjects are still
- 1:22:18really subject like it just doesn't make
- 1:22:21sense like if you we need to be like
- 1:22:23that split was the wrong move you can't
- 1:22:26carve the world up that way it doesn't
- 1:22:28work and so you have to fix the story
- 1:22:31you've told on both sides yes and so
- 1:22:34what fixes it on both sides okay so from
- 1:22:37my perspective cubism fixes it on the
- 1:22:41physics side and an activism fixes it on
- 1:22:44and do they play well with one another
- 1:22:46is an activism somehow interpreted in
- 1:22:49cubism or vice
- 1:22:51versa so they're doing very different
- 1:22:54things
- 1:22:55but when you really look at what they're
- 1:22:57doing they're both
- 1:22:59just trying to like in activism is
- 1:23:02trying to understand mind without the
- 1:23:04subject object split and cubism is
- 1:23:06trying to understand the world without
- 1:23:07the subject object split yes I see I see
- 1:23:11so Carl fron has something called active
- 1:23:13inference is this
- 1:23:16related sort of um I think it depends
- 1:23:20how you interpret his stuff interesting
- 1:23:23their interpretations of Carl
- 1:23:25friston of another podcast yeah right I
- 1:23:29mean I think like the way it's usually
- 1:23:31talked about is
- 1:23:34um like he talks about right these marov
- 1:23:37blankets as being like these the split
- 1:23:39which I I think that's very cool um but
- 1:23:43then it's like you're sort of trying to
- 1:23:45infer like he usually refers to like
- 1:23:47hidden states on the other side um and I
- 1:23:51think in like these other stories you
- 1:23:53wouldn't want to talk about like hidden
- 1:23:55like the world's not hidden to you like
- 1:23:56I think that idea that that like I'm in
- 1:23:59my head and all I know is my own
- 1:24:01experiences and the actual reality out
- 1:24:03there is something hidden that I have to
- 1:24:05infer like I think that's already a
- 1:24:07problematic story um but I think
- 1:24:11probably you could talk about free
- 1:24:12energy without using that kind of
- 1:24:14language and then maybe it would be fine
- 1:24:17so the solution to not dichotomizing the
- 1:24:21world into subject and object yeah is
- 1:24:24what everything is object or everything
- 1:24:26is subject or something else something
- 1:24:29else so I think like I think that's the
- 1:24:33problem we've all gotten into is like
- 1:24:35jakkart was like here's the dinner menu
- 1:24:39you may have subjects and objects and
- 1:24:42then people like are like well wait a
- 1:24:44minute like this is dualism I don't want
- 1:24:46two things like that's crazy I will just
- 1:24:49take subjects or they're like I will
- 1:24:51just take objects but then there's like
- 1:24:54a few people that are like you know what
- 1:24:56maybe these aren't the options like why
- 1:24:58do I have to pick one of these things
- 1:25:00like yes interesting so I think that the
- 1:25:03issue is I don't think it's it there's a
- 1:25:07reason those are the options which are
- 1:25:08like in any perception you have to make
- 1:25:11a subject object distinction in any
- 1:25:14Quantum measurement you have to make a
- 1:25:16subject object distinction but the
- 1:25:18difference is you want to
- 1:25:21say in a participatory way I am enact in
- 1:25:24that distinction as my way of making a
- 1:25:27perception or as my way of making a
- 1:25:28measurement you don't want to say that
- 1:25:30distinction is given to me from the
- 1:25:32beginning in some like absolute sense I
- 1:25:35know I'm speaking very abstractly here
- 1:25:37but like I think that's like the issue
- 1:25:39is like you want to you you you don't
- 1:25:42want to take the subject object
- 1:25:43distinction as pregiven and absolute and
- 1:25:45fixed so you definitely don't want to
- 1:25:47say it's all subject and you definitely
- 1:25:49don't want to say it's all object
- 1:25:50because that's already assuming that
- 1:25:51distinction is fixed you want to say
- 1:25:53it's it's movable and in any given
- 1:25:57situation I can carve it up in different
- 1:25:59ways does that mean you can carve
- 1:26:01yourself out of the situation can you
- 1:26:04carve it up in any way in the sense that
- 1:26:07it's just assigning different weights to
- 1:26:10subject and object so I'm going to think
- 1:26:12of this situation as 99% subjective 1%
- 1:26:15objective or I can think of this
- 1:26:17situation as entire 99.9 and I thus I'm
- 1:26:20minimizing my own contribution to the
- 1:26:22point you could make it 100% objective
- 1:26:25I've never thought of it that way but I
- 1:26:27think that sounds right to me in some
- 1:26:29sense I mean you can't take if you take
- 1:26:32yourself out of it entirely you're
- 1:26:33you're dead in some sense right so like
- 1:26:36you can't do that bore loved to talk
- 1:26:39about like a blind man with a a cane
- 1:26:41like a stick um and he would say if the
- 1:26:45man holds the the cane very tightly he
- 1:26:50can use it to like touch the world and
- 1:26:53in that sense the the cane is part of
- 1:26:57the man and so it's on the subject side
- 1:27:00of the subject object of VI but he could
- 1:27:03also hold it very Loosely in his hand
- 1:27:05and like consider it as an object and
- 1:27:08then like he's not touching the world
- 1:27:09with it he's touching the cane and so
- 1:27:11now the cane is on like the object side
- 1:27:13of the subject object VI so it's the
- 1:27:15same cane but it could be on either side
- 1:27:17so that division is like movable and and
- 1:27:21bore thought that was really the essence
- 1:27:23of quantum mechanics was that that
- 1:27:24division is not fixed and in cubism this
- 1:27:28becomes important too because the cubis
- 1:27:31says the measuring device is an
- 1:27:33extension of the
- 1:27:34agent um so so the the the line can be
- 1:27:40drawn you know very differently in a
- 1:27:43given measurement scenario depending on
- 1:27:46like what how how I wanted to be up okay
- 1:27:49I'm much less
- 1:27:51confused good that's interesting in the
- 1:27:53same way that if you start writing you
- 1:27:55become accustomed to writing the pen is
- 1:27:57then an extension of you you don't even
- 1:27:58think of the pen you don't think of your
- 1:28:00individual fingers on the keyboard so
- 1:28:02the keyboard is akin to an extension of
- 1:28:04you yes so some people would say it's
- 1:28:06not just Akin it is so John Veri may say
- 1:28:09that that's a cognitive science
- 1:28:10scientist who is also an advocate for 4E
- 1:28:13cognitive science by the way ex yeah you
- 1:28:16have just outlined that the Cubist view
- 1:28:17is that in quantum mechanics we're
- 1:28:19making measurements the measurement
- 1:28:21device is at that point an extension of
- 1:28:23you actually I'm still confused so I'm
- 1:28:26gonna get some clarification on that
- 1:28:28afterward this is how I feel every day
- 1:28:31like I almost NOP yeah exactly okay well
- 1:28:34anyway Amanda thank you for spending so
- 1:28:37much time with me I appreciate you
- 1:28:39taking time out of your day for this and
- 1:28:41Amanda please tell me what is it that
- 1:28:43you're currently working
- 1:28:44on so I am working on a project that's
- 1:28:49been 10 years in the making um that is
- 1:28:52related to all of the things that we're
- 1:28:54talking about um
- 1:28:56because it's basically
- 1:29:00um I was telling you about Wheeler's
- 1:29:02journals in John Wheeler's journals I
- 1:29:05found reference to the student of his
- 1:29:07named Peter putam who I had never heard
- 1:29:08of and I sort of went down this Rabbit
- 1:29:12Hole of like who is this guy because
- 1:29:14wheeler students were all like you know
- 1:29:15richer fman and whoever and these like
- 1:29:17very famous people and it was like who's
- 1:29:19this Peter putam
- 1:29:21and long story short
- 1:29:24found that putam was you know the
- 1:29:27student of wheelers he did his PhD in
- 1:29:29physics but then he became very
- 1:29:31interested in how the mind works and
- 1:29:34came up with his own theory of mind um
- 1:29:39and then he and Wheeler throughout their
- 1:29:41lives had this like really intense
- 1:29:43correspondence because Wheeler's trying
- 1:29:44to understand like the
- 1:29:46nature of quantum mechanics and like
- 1:29:49what role The Observer plays and like
- 1:29:50what's an observer and then putam is
- 1:29:52like working on a theory of the Observer
- 1:29:55and they're trying to like put these
- 1:29:57pieces together um and in the meantime
- 1:30:01putam ends up um moving down south in
- 1:30:05like rural Louisiana and working as a
- 1:30:06janitor and living in like total poverty
- 1:30:09and writing all these papers but not
- 1:30:10publishing any of it and then he's
- 1:30:12killed by a drunk driver in the 1980s
- 1:30:15and when he dies he leaves $40 million
- 1:30:18to the nature nature conservancy which
- 1:30:21it turned out he had made in the stock
- 1:30:22market but never touched any of it
- 1:30:24and then his papers all his stuff ended
- 1:30:27up like tucked away in this like storage
- 1:30:30unit and so I found all of his
- 1:30:32unpublished stuff and I've been trying
- 1:30:34to reconstruct like what was his theory
- 1:30:36of mind which I think is very related to
- 1:30:38these inactive embodied ideas that we
- 1:30:41were talking about and um and trying to
- 1:30:45relate that to Wheeler's
- 1:30:47participatory uh understanding of
- 1:30:50reality which is very related to qism
- 1:30:51which we were talking about and how to
- 1:30:53piece those stories together Amanda
- 1:30:56thank you for spending so much time with
- 1:30:58me you're very welcome I hope I didn't
- 1:31:01just add to confusion beautiful it's
- 1:31:04beautiful thank you I appreciate it
- 1:31:07firstly thank you for watching thank you
- 1:31:09for listening there's now a website Kurt
- 1:31:12jungle. org and that has a mailing list
- 1:31:15the reason being that large platforms
- 1:31:17like YouTube like patreon they can
- 1:31:19disable you for whatever reason whenever
- 1:31:22they like that's just part of the terms
- 1:31:24of service now a direct mailing list
- 1:31:26ensures that I have an untrammeled
- 1:31:28communication with you plus soon I'll be
- 1:31:30releasing a one-page PDF of my top 10
- 1:31:33toes it's not as Quinton Tarantino as it
- 1:31:35sounds like secondly if you haven't
- 1:31:37subscribed or clicked that like button
- 1:31:40now is the time to do so why because
- 1:31:43each subscribe each like helps YouTube
- 1:31:46push this content to more people like
- 1:31:48yourself plus it helps out Kurt directly
- 1:31:51aka me I also found out last year that
- 1:31:53external links count plenty toward the
- 1:31:55algorithm which means that whenever you
- 1:31:57share on Twitter say on Facebook or even
- 1:32:00on Reddit Etc it shows YouTube hey
- 1:32:03people are talking about this content
- 1:32:05outside of YouTube which in turn greatly
- 1:32:08AIDS the Distribution on YouTube thirdly
- 1:32:10there's a remarkably active Discord and
- 1:32:12subreddit for theories of everything
- 1:32:14where people explicate toes they
- 1:32:16disagree respectfully about theories and
- 1:32:18build as a community our own toe links
- 1:32:21to both are in the description fourthly
- 1:32:23you should know this podcast is on
- 1:32:25iTunes it's on Spotify it's on all of
- 1:32:28the audio platforms all you have to do
- 1:32:30is type in theories of everything and
- 1:32:31you'll find it personally I gain from
- 1:32:33rewatching lectures and podcasts I also
- 1:32:36read in the comments that hey tow
- 1:32:37listeners also gain from replaying so
- 1:32:40how about instead you relisten on those
- 1:32:42platforms like iTunes Spotify Google
- 1:32:44podcast whichever podcast catcher you
- 1:32:46use and finally if you'd like to support
- 1:32:49more conversations like this more
- 1:32:51content like this then do consider
- 1:32:52visiting patreon /k jongle and donating
- 1:32:56with whatever you like there's also
- 1:32:58PayPal there's also crypto there's also
- 1:33:00just joining on YouTube again keep in
- 1:33:02mind it's support from the sponsors and
- 1:33:05you that allow me to work on tow
- 1:33:07fulltime you also get early access to
- 1:33:09adree episodes whether it's audio or
- 1:33:11video it's audio in the case of patreon
- 1:33:13video in the case of YouTube for
- 1:33:15instance this episode that you're
- 1:33:16listening to right now was released a
- 1:33:17few days earlier every dollar helps far
- 1:33:20more than you think either way your
- 1:33:22viewership is generosity enough thank
- 1:33:25you so much
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of QBism: The New Theory That Shatters Our View of Reality by Curt Jaimungal, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,767 words across 2,302 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.