PSIR-Class-139-International Relations (Paper-2) (Part-A and B Integrated) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00a very important new question which is
- 0:02the next question in your workbook on
- 0:03page number 11 that is who is Mr. X in
- 0:06international relations and how is he
- 0:07relevant in the debate. So Mr. X is
- 0:11nothing but basically he's a American
- 0:13diplomat
- 0:15and uh this name of the person this
- 0:18American diplomat who is basically Mr. X
- 0:21is George Kennan
- 0:24K E N Kenan.
- 0:27So his name is George Kennan and uh why
- 0:31is he called Mr. X? Let's first try to
- 0:34understand that in America there is a
- 0:36magazine which is called foreign policy.
- 0:39Okay, it's a very prominent American
- 0:42magazine on global affairs
- 0:45and uh it's a very old magazine foreign
- 0:49policy. In that magazine in the year of
- 0:521947,
- 0:56George Kennan basically wrote an article
- 1:00and this article was 8,000 words long.
- 1:068,000 words longing.
- 1:16So, he wrote basically an 8,000word long
- 1:20essay,
- 1:22but he used the title called Mr. X. He
- 1:25did not use his name.
- 1:28Why he did not use his name is because
- 1:30he was at that time one of the founding
- 1:34members of the America's Central
- 1:36Intelligence Agency.
- 1:38So he wanted to prevent his identity
- 1:41disclosure
- 1:43and as a result of which he wanted to
- 1:46write also and yet ensure that
- 1:49you know that he does not disclose
- 1:51anything through his own identity. So
- 1:55therefore he chose the word Mr. X number
- 1:57one. Number two
- 1:59what did he write in the essay which was
- 2:01such a long 8,000word article that he
- 2:04wrote. So he talked about
- 2:07how should US basically look at the
- 2:09Soviet Union during the cold war.
- 2:12And in that entire article he says key a
- 2:15very important thing
- 2:17that you have to understand
- 2:20a very important feature of the Soviet
- 2:22psyche that how do the Soviets think.
- 2:26And he said that one of the ways in
- 2:28which we see that how Soviets think is
- 2:31that these people who are in the Soviet
- 2:33Union
- 2:35they are trained people for prolonged
- 2:37warfare.
- 2:40trained people for prolonged warfare.
- 2:43He made this observation by analyzing
- 2:48the Soviet behavior
- 2:51since 13th century.
- 2:5513th century Soviet Union it was Russia
- 2:57only at that time. So he analyzed the
- 3:01psyche of the Russian leaders,
- 3:03studied the profiles of the Russian
- 3:05people and came out with a very
- 3:08important observation that the Russian
- 3:10people basically have
- 3:13a tendency to fight for a particular
- 3:16cause for a very prolonged period of
- 3:18time
- 3:20which is a very unique thing sir
- 3:23that they can fight for a particular
- 3:25thing for a very prolonged period of
- 3:27time
- 3:28And therefore he advised US number one
- 3:31to have a huge amount of strategic
- 3:33patience
- 3:35in dealing with Soviet Union.
- 3:38He says if USA is going to display
- 3:42immature behavior
- 3:45where it is going to have certain
- 3:48strategies and then expect that those
- 3:49strategies will give the Americans
- 3:51instant result. It will not work that
- 3:53way.
- 3:55So he said very clearly that
- 3:58that the Americans need to have what is
- 4:01called as strategic patience.
- 4:04They have to endure
- 4:07endure an adversary who has this habit
- 4:11of fighting for a prolonged period of
- 4:14time.
- 4:16So endure.
- 4:18And second thing he said is that when
- 4:20you endure what you have to
- 4:22simultaneously do is you have to ensure
- 4:24another important thing that you contain
- 4:27Soviet Union.
- 4:30For the first time he utilized a word
- 4:32called contain
- 4:35the containment doctrine
- 4:38that strategies have to be built for the
- 4:41purpose of containment of the Soviet
- 4:43Union. He did not use the word counter.
- 4:47He used the word contained. Contained
- 4:49means that wherever Soviet Union exists
- 4:52today,
- 4:53don't let it enlarge its territory
- 4:55further.
- 4:58There is a difference beta between
- 5:00containment and counter. Today we know
- 5:02that America wants to counter China
- 5:05because it knows there is only one
- 5:06China.
- 5:08China is not doing today what Soviets
- 5:11were planning at that time. Now try to
- 5:13recollect yesterday I told you one
- 5:14important point.
- 5:17that Soviets had realized that those
- 5:20socialist republics which are there
- 5:23which are part of the Soviet Union.
- 5:25These socialist republics basically have
- 5:28what? They have access to all nuclear
- 5:31material which will eventually become a
- 5:33part of the supply chain
- 5:36which they will give to the Soviet Union
- 5:38so that the Soviet can maintain parity.
- 5:41And yesterday we also said the second
- 5:43point that in order to achieve that
- 5:45parity the Soviets also wanted to spread
- 5:48communism to other states.
- 5:51And it is in this context that George
- 5:53Kennan went on to say that the Soviets
- 5:56have to be contained.
- 5:58That means he says a very important
- 6:00point that while there is a Soviet
- 6:03Union, while there are socialist
- 6:05republics, while we cannot do anything
- 6:07there, we must prevent the Soviet to
- 6:11spread the communist ideology elsewhere.
- 6:15Containment.
- 6:17See today USA very carefully uses the
- 6:20word counter China because Chinese have
- 6:23not been able today till now to create
- 6:27an ideology which they propagate which
- 6:30is antithesis of capitalism.
- 6:34So Chinese have not done that.
- 6:36In fact Chinese are hardcore
- 6:38capitalists.
- 6:53So idea is very clear sir
- 6:56that the Chinese today do not have any
- 6:59kind of ideology which is antidote or
- 7:03anti-thesis of capitalism.
- 7:06China today does not seek a destruction
- 7:08of capitalism.
- 7:12Soviet Union wanted to do that.
- 7:15So as a result of which he chose the
- 7:18word that while you have strategic
- 7:21patience
- 7:23contain Soviet Union.
- 7:26And then he went on to say that the best
- 7:28way to contain Soviet Union is
- 7:32create buffers.
- 7:35Create buffers
- 7:38around the Soviet socialist republics
- 7:40which are there.
- 7:42Create buffers.
- 7:45This is such an important point. He says
- 7:48create buffers around all those
- 7:51territories
- 7:53which are basically
- 7:56along the Soviet Union.
- 8:01along with the Soviet Union.
- 8:04So that you ensure what?
- 8:08So that you ensure one very important
- 8:11thing that Soviets are not able to
- 8:18Soviets are not able to do what? Not
- 8:21able to expand their Soviet communist
- 8:24influence beyond their national national
- 8:26boundaries.
- 8:30beyond their national boundaries.
- 8:33So now did you get clarity of the word
- 8:36containment versus counter
- 8:39and now please be very careful when you
- 8:42observe the language used in the
- 8:44newspapers.
- 8:46You will understand that they use the
- 8:47word counter and not contain China.
- 8:54Now coming to the next question, what is
- 8:57Mr. doctrine and examine the scheme
- 8:59through the scholarly point of view.
- 9:02So the scholar here is named as Paul
- 9:05Nids.
- 9:07Paul Nidz nit z
- 9:11Paul Nids. He's an important scholar. He
- 9:14has studied the doctrine propounded by
- 9:18Mr. X George Kennan. And he went on to
- 9:22say that what George Kennan actually
- 9:24advocated in that article
- 9:28eventually became the official policy of
- 9:31Harry Truman.
- 9:34Paul Nid went on to say that Truman
- 9:37doctrine is actually the reflection of
- 9:39the doctrine of Mr. X
- 9:42and what Truman did was precisely what
- 9:45was advocated by Mr. X.
- 9:48He went on to further say that
- 9:52when Harry Truman used language like we
- 9:55must protect and safeguard democracies.
- 10:00He says when
- 10:03Harry Truman went on to use words like
- 10:05we must counter the Soviet aggression.
- 10:10His idea was very clear
- 10:13that he was looking at a situation where
- 10:18Soviets had to be contained.
- 10:21And when Harry Truman went on to say
- 10:24that we will provide economic assistance
- 10:26and military aid
- 10:29to any country
- 10:31where Soviet aggression is visible,
- 10:35then this attempt to provide economic
- 10:37and military aid was nothing but
- 10:40an attempt at that time by
- 10:44Harry Truman to actually contain Soviet
- 10:46mil.
- 10:48So sir one thing is very clear beta that
- 10:51entire idea was
- 10:56to fuse democracy with capitalism
- 11:00and sell the two products
- 11:04as if they are meant for the welfare of
- 11:06people
- 11:09and see the beauty
- 11:13that capitalists will always use the
- 11:15term of democracy.
- 11:18to say that capitalism works best in a
- 11:20democracy
- 11:22because the beauty is that in a
- 11:24democracy what will happen is that as
- 11:25power is not concentrated in the hands
- 11:27of one but many
- 11:30the capitalists can support anyone and
- 11:33everyone who supports their interest
- 11:38and in order to counter this narrative
- 11:42that capitalism is beneficial for the
- 11:44people the Soviets deliberately used the
- 11:46word
- 11:48people in their own dictionary also
- 11:52by people's republic of China PRC was
- 11:56born in 1949 what is people for people's
- 11:59republic of China sir it's an
- 12:01authoritarian totalitarian regime
- 12:05but see the beauty sir the facade of
- 12:07using the word people's
- 12:10republic of China
- 12:14people's republic of India People's
- 12:24Republic of China
- 12:27they go up beauty
- 12:31sir what was there a challenge to Mr.
- 12:34Examine the argument sir. So there is
- 12:35one scholar sir his name is Walter
- 12:38Lipman.
- 12:39Walter W A L T E R Lipman. L Ip M
- 12:44Lipman.
- 12:45So Walter Lipman said that basically
- 12:48what was advocated by George Kennan is
- 12:51all moral talk
- 12:53and it's a very defensive doctrine
- 12:57by merely saying that we will contain
- 13:00Soviet Union. These are all moral
- 13:03discussions which are there.
- 13:06Walter Lipman went on to say sir that
- 13:08the only way to contain the Soviet Union
- 13:11is to use force
- 13:14and America must be ready to display
- 13:16force.
- 13:19Display that hard military power that it
- 13:21has achieved.
- 13:23So that with that hard military power it
- 13:25can try to ensure one thing
- 13:29that it is in a position to basically
- 13:31check
- 13:35any forceful expansion of the Soviet
- 13:37Union. See this is the different
- 13:41Walter Lipman is not saying that America
- 13:43must use force to destroy Soviet Union.
- 13:47He says that the best way to check the
- 13:49further expansion of the Soviet Union is
- 13:52not through containment by moral talk
- 13:56but check their containment
- 14:00through the use of force. And Walter
- 14:03Lipman became happy when Harry Truman
- 14:05went on to say that in the Truman
- 14:07doctrine we are going to provide
- 14:08military support to countries
- 14:11who might face Soviet aggression.
- 14:15So he went on to say that Truman
- 14:17doctrine is not a reflection of Mr. X.
- 14:21Truman doctrine rather he said that is a
- 14:23reflection of
- 14:27his idea of military containment.
- 14:31And in fact he goes on to argue that
- 14:33Americans never believed in that high
- 14:35moral standards
- 14:37that morality will compel somebody to
- 14:39display certain specific behaviors that
- 14:41you want them to display.
- 14:49World does not work like this sir. World
- 14:51is not Gandhi. Gandhi himself was so
- 14:54frail that he knew he cannot do
- 14:55violence. So better is talk nonviolence.
- 15:00Gandhi
- 15:15So he went on to say this. Walter lippen
- 15:18said very clearly.
- 15:20He said the idea is moral talk cannot
- 15:23contain Soviet Union
- 15:28this point of Walter Lipman has some
- 15:30very great significance for India
- 15:31Pakistan relations.
- 15:39terrorism
- 15:46is
- 15:48what prevents India today to become like
- 15:50Israel, go inside Pakistan
- 15:53and destroy their terrorism
- 15:54infrastructure.
- 16:15Gagari
- 16:26moral talk.
- 16:29Imagine now if Isra would have done the
- 16:31same for Hamas.
- 16:55doesn't give a damn about it.
- 17:08What is the hype about the
- 17:16sir Walter Lipman's idea and George
- 17:18Kennan's idea were pulled apart and in
- 17:21reality we will say that Harry Truman's
- 17:24approach was a blend of the two. It was
- 17:27not George Kennan's idea altogether. It
- 17:29was not Walter Lipman's idea altogether
- 17:32but a blend of two because Harry Truman
- 17:36at least as a statement understood sir
- 17:38that we cannot afford to be Israel at
- 17:39that time. World War II had just got
- 17:42over it.
- 17:44So fighting outright war was not
- 17:46advisable
- 17:48but if there is a situation where war is
- 17:50the only way out then America would not
- 17:52shy.
- 17:53That was the idea.
- 17:56Sir who built upon the challenged
- 17:58argument and how
- 18:01so argument of George Kennan was
- 18:03challenged by Walter Lipman
- 18:06and Walter Lipman's argument was built
- 18:09at the official level in America by a
- 18:11person named John Foster Duels
- 18:16John Foster F O S P E R D Ul
- 18:24John Foster Duels and his brother Alan
- 18:26Foster Duels.
- 18:30Alan Foster Dules.
- 18:33And you know who was Alan Foster Duels?
- 18:36Alan Foster Duels was the director of
- 18:38CIA.
- 18:41And you know who was John Foster Duels?
- 18:43He was his real brother
- 18:46who was secretary of state.
- 18:56And he built upon what is called as the
- 18:58idea of Walter Lipman sir because one
- 19:00thing became very clear that
- 19:02John Foster duels very clearly advocated
- 19:05sir
- 19:07America must ensure a roll back of the
- 19:09Soviet Union. He gave this point called
- 19:11roll back of the Soviet Union. Sir
- 19:15roll back
- 19:16word containment
- 19:19word roll back.
- 19:22What is the meaning of the word roll
- 19:23back sir? roll back simple
- 19:28come what may
- 19:31it has to be ensured that
- 19:36those countries in Eastern Europe which
- 19:38are part of the Soviet Union have to be
- 19:40liberated from the control of Soviet
- 19:42Union.
- 19:46They understand the difference. Abi when
- 19:48I was saying that the idea largely was
- 19:51to contain Soviet Union in containment,
- 19:54you were not doing anything to the
- 19:55Soviet socialist republics which were
- 19:57there. You said let them exist but we
- 20:00will not let them spread beyond where
- 20:02they are.
- 20:05But you know John Foster Duels was of
- 20:06the opinion that we have to roll them
- 20:10back.
- 20:11We can't allow them to even have those
- 20:13socialist republics. Now this is a point
- 20:16to understand and this is a place where
- 20:17I will introduce a word for you all
- 20:20where we say that John Foster duels
- 20:23basically favored a revisionist American
- 20:26policy.
- 20:28What is the meaning of the word
- 20:29revisionism? Revisionism,
- 20:32a country which is not satisfied with
- 20:34existing territorial borders
- 20:37and revisionism means that a country
- 20:39which is dissatisfied with the existing
- 20:41territorial borders wants to
- 20:46seek altering of those borders and if
- 20:48necessary through the use of force
- 20:52if necessary through the use of force.
- 20:55Sir, one such country which is a
- 20:57revisionist country in our Asia is none
- 21:00other but our neighbor Pakistan.
- 21:03Another one is China.
- 21:06Both of them today are revisionist
- 21:07powers.
- 21:09So be careful in the newspaper you might
- 21:11hear this word that China is a
- 21:13revisionist country.
- 21:16Pakistan is a revisionist country
- 21:19because revisionism means that these
- 21:21countries want today to change and alter
- 21:25the status quo.
- 21:28Alter the status quo. [clears throat]
- 21:32India for that matter is a status quo
- 21:34country.
- 21:36In the dictionary here we call India as
- 21:38status coast
- 21:41because India does not want to forcibly
- 21:43alter the border.
- 21:45Had we wanted to do that then we would
- 21:47have transformed the ceasefire line into
- 21:50not a line of control but we would have
- 21:52crossed the ceasefire line of control to
- 21:54create a new border.
- 22:13Salad
- 22:30status.
- 22:34dissatisfied.
- 22:57secretaries
- 23:04research and analysis secretary [snorts]
- 23:16countrys.
- 23:43after that particular point when I spoke
- 23:45to the RSS head.
- 23:48He never got back to me.
- 23:51Imagine sir that means these chhatty
- 23:54wearers could not even gather 300 people
- 23:58who had the courage today to settle in
- 24:00the P on behalf of the RAW
- 24:04to get the P liberated
- 24:08but the fact is this I probably only the
- 24:13RSS chief can tell us that nobody else
- 24:15can know today
- 24:18but somewhere this reflects our
- 24:22point of morality, the moral talk.
- 24:26When it comes to taking those hard
- 24:27decisions,
- 24:29we run away.
- 24:33We run away. Sir,
- 24:38so one thing therefore becomes very
- 24:40clear. Sir
- 24:43John Foster duel talking about the roll
- 24:46back doctrine. Roll back here means a
- 24:48revision. But now the question that
- 24:51arises is
- 24:53with the John Foster duel's approach of
- 24:55revisionism do we make an inference that
- 24:58America itself is a revisionist country
- 25:02or America is a status quoist.
- 25:08So how do we look at America?
- 25:13Is America a status quoist or is America
- 25:15a revisionist? And why?
- 25:19of
- 25:31answer
- 25:45sir. The beauty is
- 25:48that when we look at these two words of
- 25:50status quo and revisionism,
- 25:53unfortunately, America does not fall
- 25:55under either of the category.
- 25:58America falls under a unique category
- 26:00called perpetual irritant in the
- 26:03international relations.
- 26:05That's how scholars define America.
- 26:08Perpetual irritant
- 26:11which changes its behavior from status
- 26:14quo to revisionism and revisionism to
- 26:16status quo based upon whatever suits
- 26:19their need.
- 26:34But America being an international
- 26:35irritant,
- 26:39it does not have what we call as
- 26:54Geopolitics
- 27:19College of Commerce. True embodiment.
- 27:42This is nothing. What has happened here
- 27:44today? What we call as sangi karan of
- 27:46our education system is basically a
- 27:49counter response to the leftist
- 27:51ecosystem which was there. Unfortunate
- 27:54problem is our education system was
- 27:56never neutral in nature. Congress
- 28:06beauty.
- 28:27America remains as I said a perpetual
- 28:30irritant. Please use this word in the
- 28:32exam. There is no problem. It's a
- 28:33scholarly defined word.
- 28:37And when we say that America is a
- 28:39perpetual irritant, don't forget the
- 28:41fact that what we are trying to say is
- 28:42that why it is a perpetual irritant is
- 28:44because its behavior changes between
- 28:47status quoism to that of what is known
- 28:51as
- 28:52revisionism and revisionism to status
- 28:54quoism.
- 29:00So because of this rapidly changing
- 29:02behavior under every presidency
- 29:05and no particular political foreign
- 29:07policy thought of Republicans or
- 29:10Democrats till today
- 29:12we cannot assertain how America will
- 29:15display a standardized behavior like
- 29:18Pakistan for example we know is sir it's
- 29:20a perpetual revisionist state
- 29:25Pakistan will one day give up
- 29:26revisionism and say that I will not have
- 29:29any claims over Kashmir. That day
- 29:31probably will be the last day in the
- 29:32history of Pakistan as a state then
- 29:35because the state will collapse. The
- 29:37idea of Pakistan today is basically this
- 29:39only.
- 29:42So expecting some country which has
- 29:45taken a stand to alter the stand is not
- 29:48possible sir.
- 29:50That is what I'm trying to say.
- 29:53So the larger debate is very clear. Ba
- 29:55George Kennan advocated for what we can
- 29:59now say status quoism.
- 30:02Walter Lipman was of the opinion of
- 30:05status quoism with aggression.
- 30:09But when it came to John Foster duels,
- 30:11he outrightly said no status quoism and
- 30:13nothing but outright revisions.
- 30:16And this confusion between these three
- 30:18scholars itself is a reflection of the
- 30:20point that I just made that America is a
- 30:22perpetual irritant.
- 30:46Who is Mr. in international relations.
- 31:01Scholar Scholar James Patterson.
- 31:08James Patterson. P A T E R S O N.
- 31:11Patterson.
- 31:14He says a very important thing. He says
- 31:16circuit
- 31:18doctrine is a reflection of free will
- 31:22and this free will of the nations
- 31:24eventually became the core principle of
- 31:26globalization.
- 31:30So Truman doctrine was a reflection of
- 31:32free will
- 31:34and this free will later on transformed
- 31:36itself into what is called as
- 31:38globalization.
- 31:40James Ba
- 31:50When you say Truman doctrine is an
- 31:52embodiment of free will,
- 31:56you are trying to say sir, America is a
- 31:58country that stands for free will.
- 32:01Agreed. But sir, what does Truman
- 32:04doctrine say? Roman doctrine says that
- 32:08wherever we see aggressive communist
- 32:11behavior
- 32:13we will use military force.
- 32:17This is completely repentant with
- 32:21what Aristotle would say that man is a
- 32:23social animal.
- 32:26But if man is a social animal why will
- 32:28man enter into a conflict?
- 32:33If man is a social animal, according to
- 32:36Aristotle, man will try to live in
- 32:38synthesis and harmony with each other.
- 32:41He will try to create rules, regulation,
- 32:44laws that will promote such synthesis,
- 32:47promote such harmony.
- 32:49And when you say that Truman doctrine is
- 32:52basically an embodiment of free will,
- 32:56we agree to that proposition, what you
- 32:59say. But sir when you say that free will
- 33:01means that it is my will only and I will
- 33:05not have the respect for somebody's
- 33:06else's will then that free will is not
- 33:09free will sir.
- 33:12If today America goes on to say that
- 33:14under Truman doctrine if there is Soviet
- 33:16spreading their ideology I will not
- 33:18tolerate that. I will contain it by
- 33:20using military force if required because
- 33:23free will means the will that I decide
- 33:25what it is.
- 33:28Then as I said sir this entire thought
- 33:30process is repentant to
- 33:33not only very importantly what Aristotle
- 33:36would say that man is a social animal
- 33:40but also to the larger theory of social
- 33:42contract
- 33:45because sir if there is a state where
- 33:47the people of the state have consented
- 33:49that we want communist ideology
- 33:52then who is USA there to say that no you
- 33:55will not have communist ideology sir.
- 33:58But this is at the heart of the problem
- 34:00today between America and Afghanistan
- 34:05America and Afghanistan. Root cause of
- 34:07the problem today is this only. No.
- 34:11Taliban today says there is a social
- 34:14contract in our society and that social
- 34:16contract is where the Afghan people are
- 34:19willing to follow the Punwali code
- 34:22through which we will govern ourselves.
- 34:24America says no sirwali
- 34:28code is not acceptable to me.
- 34:31Your Sharia is not acceptable to me
- 34:34which is an Islamic law.
- 34:36You must be a democracy sir.
- 34:40Sir when you impose a democracy then the
- 34:42question is where is free will
- 34:45in Truman doctrine? If Harry Truman is
- 34:48going to use military force and then
- 34:50ensure that a country becomes a
- 34:51democratic sir it's not through social
- 34:53contract. its imposition
- 34:56point because this is the place where
- 34:59through the Truman doctrine we see this
- 35:01origin of America's behavior of
- 35:04imposition of democracy future
- 35:19could have done this very beautifully
- 35:20you know where in the entire central and
- 35:23south America
- 35:26Because when you study American
- 35:27Revolution as part of world history, we
- 35:30will see that that America deliberately
- 35:33chose to have, you know, dictators in
- 35:38Central and South America when the
- 35:40Spanish and the Portuguese left.
- 35:43Rather than promoting democracy, they
- 35:45chose to have dictators there.
- 35:48What Soviet Union should have done was
- 35:50they should have engaged with those
- 35:51dictators. They tried. One example,
- 35:53Cuba. Fidel Castro.
- 35:58Fiddle Castro was a communist Americaf.
- 36:38but the fact is very clear sir
- 36:43that how do you call it as an embodiment
- 36:45of free will they are things on which
- 36:48questions can come in the exam
- 36:52He was Truman Doctrine a true reflection
- 36:54of free will
- 36:57and this is where you have to counter
- 36:59James Batterson who coined the idea that
- 37:02it is a embodiment of free will because
- 37:05it was not
- 37:08when we look at it in the larger
- 37:09philosophical sense
- 37:13scholar Eric Foner Eric E R I C Fner F O
- 37:17N R
- 37:22He gave a very simple observation. He
- 37:24said Truman doctrine created the
- 37:26foundation of cold war
- 37:32and helped sustain the cold war.
- 37:37Helped sustain the cold war.
- 37:46scholy
- 38:09Answer
- 38:18steps but the way the knowledge has to
- 38:20be put there. The points have to be put
- 38:22there is very different.
- 38:36There is no other way.
- 38:39Scholar Dennis Merrill Dennis B I S
- 38:43Merryill M E R
- 38:46I L M E R I L M Dennis Merryill.
- 38:52He gives a very interesting observation
- 38:54sir. He says that Truman doctrine was
- 38:57basically a shield for America to
- 38:59promote their global economic interest
- 39:02and it was basically managed by the
- 39:05business lobby in America. So he gives a
- 39:07very fresh perspective or Dennis March
- 39:11recent research.
- 39:14He says a very important point. He says
- 39:16see the problem was that America wanted
- 39:18to create a scenario where they
- 39:21deliberately wanted to intervene in
- 39:23those countries which were even having a
- 39:25free will to decide their own future
- 39:28and in those countries they wanted to
- 39:30promote their business interest. Case in
- 39:32point for example non-aligned countries
- 39:35India
- 39:38because we were non-aligned at that time
- 39:39one thing is very clear sir
- 39:42as a non-aligned country America at that
- 39:45time wanted to promote their own
- 39:47interest
- 39:49in India they understood one thing by
- 39:53being a non-aligned country India will
- 39:55not directly accept
- 39:57so they used various measures to try to
- 40:00tell
- 40:03You see
- 40:05Soviet Union is bad for you.
- 40:09Soviet Union is harmful for you. Your
- 40:11economy will not work under planned
- 40:12economy.
- 40:16They created academic literature.
- 40:21How planned economy is bad?
- 40:24How planned economy will not help? Sir,
- 40:26let's understand one thing. At a time
- 40:27when India became independent
- 40:30had India not gone for a planned
- 40:31economy. One thing is very clear sir
- 40:33India as a country would have collapsed
- 40:36because at that time there was neither
- 40:38any purchasing power nor there was a
- 40:40demand nor there was a supply and
- 40:42leaving the country to to the
- 40:44capitalists would have caused absolute
- 40:46plunder
- 40:48as it happened when the country was
- 40:49colonized.
- 40:52So planned economy in that sense was a
- 40:54buffer preventing that blunder
- 41:03in order to promote economic interest.
- 41:05Multiple strategies were used of which
- 41:08one important strategy to pursue
- 41:10economic interest was academics.
- 41:13[snorts]
- 41:14academics may he say is sir they
- 41:16promoted so much of research to counter
- 41:19Soviet Union to portray their models as
- 41:22false
- 41:24unscientific
- 41:25but the beauty is that they never
- 41:27invested any academic interest to
- 41:29portray how capitalism can
- 41:30scientifically elevate the problem
- 41:41can you see the title
- 41:47What if there is no Congress?
- 42:02beauty.
- 42:05This is an example sample
- 42:08academics.
- 42:24At one point of time, it was a very
- 42:26prominent name.
- 42:34narrative building.
- 42:54Leftist versus rightist.
- 43:00But the beauty is what sir? The beauty
- 43:02is very important here that in order to
- 43:06promote economic interest, don't show
- 43:08that the your system is good. Only show
- 43:13one thing that the other system is bad.
- 43:20Only show other system is bad.
- 43:24Congress
- 43:34fake.
- 43:55Who killed Justice Lawyer? Judge lawyer.
- 43:57Sorry. Who killed judge lawyer?
- 44:04Gujarat IPS officers conversation with
- 44:06the then chief minister and the home
- 44:08minister
- 44:15it's called the polyester prince
- 44:18Polyester.
- 44:43This is called a narrative building.
- 44:46Americans
- 44:50never ever tried to create a scenario.
- 44:54Soviet Union
- 45:00America throughout the cold war was busy
- 45:03in doing one thing. They wanted to seek
- 45:05the collapse of Soviet Union. Soviet
- 45:07Union collapsed. When America achieved
- 45:10that global hgemony,
- 45:12why was America not able to maintain
- 45:14that global hedgemony? by 1990s
- 45:18discussion America was a uniolar power.
- 45:21My question to you is why was America
- 45:23unable to sustain as a uniolar power
- 45:25three decades now?
- 45:27This is the reason sir
- 45:30that had America invested
- 45:33in portraying that how capitalism is
- 45:36beneficial for the globe
- 45:38than only portraying that how communism
- 45:40is bad for the globe
- 45:43probably America's global hedgemony
- 45:44would have been there
- 45:47sir had the BJP tried to portray more
- 45:50about their own points that this is what
- 45:53we ought to do than merely criticizing
- 45:56Congress they have come down to 240.
- 45:59Reality was not even 240. That is EVM
- 46:01fudging. Reality is 166
- 46:20from prosecution even after they retire.
- 46:25Chief Election Commissioner and Election
- 46:26Commissioners have complete immunity
- 46:29even after retirement from prosecution
- 46:31by the courts.
- 46:46elections
- 46:59UPSC was a headless body for some
- 47:01months.
- 47:04So one thing is very important sir
- 47:07America's biggest reason as we will see
- 47:10after some time that why they were
- 47:11unable to maintain their uniolarity was
- 47:15of never being in a position to portray
- 47:18how
- 47:20their capitalism would benefit the
- 47:22globe.
- 47:25That is why we also say at a social
- 47:27level that it is these capitalists who
- 47:29have brought in the society the theme of
- 47:31us versus them.
- 47:46clear Dennis economic motive.
- 47:52How did Marshall plan emerge in the
- 47:54international context? How did it lead
- 47:56to the rise of ideological bipolarity?
- 48:00So Marshall plan was basically born in
- 48:03the context of Truman doctrine only VA.
- 48:06Marshall plan idea was to help the
- 48:08Europe in their post-war recovery
- 48:12and
- 48:14Marshall plan was designed in such a way
- 48:16that it was so deceptive that it was
- 48:19open to everybody.
- 48:21It was even open to countries of Soviet
- 48:23Union
- 48:26because idea was what sir corrupt the
- 48:28Soviet Union. Marshall plan. This is
- 48:31where roll back point of the John Foster
- 48:33duels is visible. Can you understand
- 48:36sir? Create a program called the
- 48:39Marshall plan. Under the Marshall plan
- 48:41say that we are going to give economic
- 48:42aid. Give economic aid to every country
- 48:46which includes countries of the Soviet
- 48:47Union also
- 48:49creating insecurity amongst those
- 48:52countries that why should we not take
- 48:54the aid from the
- 48:56Marshall plan. Imagine if there is a
- 48:58socialist republic which is a part of
- 49:00the Soviet Union. If it decides to go
- 49:02for taking aid under Marshall plan what
- 49:05will happen sir? Through that economic
- 49:07aid the America will do subversive
- 49:08activities
- 49:10and try to disconnect and ruin that
- 49:13country and take it away from the
- 49:15control of the Soviet Republic.
- 49:18So design it in such a way
- 49:21package it in such a way.
- 49:27So one thing became very clear sir that
- 49:31Marshall plan was created in the context
- 49:32of Truman doctrine. And now the second
- 49:35part of the question that how did it
- 49:37lead to the rise of ideological
- 49:38bipolarity?
- 49:40It led to the rise of the ideological
- 49:42bipolarity because
- 49:44three important agencies were interested
- 49:46with implementation of the Marshall
- 49:48Plan. You know who were those three
- 49:49important agencies better? Number one,
- 49:52Department of Defense of US. Number two,
- 49:55the CIA. Number three, the National
- 49:58Security Advisor of US.
- 50:02Sir, how can a Marshall plan which is an
- 50:05economic aid plan be implemented by the
- 50:08Department of Defense?
- 50:10How can it be implemented by National
- 50:12Security Adviser of your country? How
- 50:14can it be implemented by the Central
- 50:17Intelligence Agency of your country?
- 50:21The fact that these three agencies were
- 50:23used for the purpose of implementing the
- 50:25Marshall plan speaks everything about
- 50:27it.
- 50:31How did Stellin in Russia react to the
- 50:33Marshall plan? Stellin came out with
- 50:35what is called as the inlet theory.
- 50:38Inlet in le inlet
- 50:46sir.
- 50:47Stellin sir Marshall plan was created
- 50:51with the larger agenda and objective of
- 50:55infusing
- 50:57democracy plus capitalism in the
- 51:00socialist republics of Soviet Union.
- 51:03Idea was to corrupt their minds.
- 51:08through propaganda plus narrative.
- 51:14Idea was to corrupt their minds
- 51:17through propaganda plus narrative.
- 51:21So one thing became very clear sir he
- 51:23had to close the inlet.
- 51:26So Stellin said a very clear thing sir
- 51:29any Soviet socialist republic
- 51:33even visualizing such kind of a thinking
- 51:38that they will try to go for what is
- 51:40known as any attempt of
- 51:44any attempt of engaging with the
- 51:47Americans
- 51:50they will be checked with an iron And
- 51:58they will be checked with an iron
- 51:59handle.
- 52:15Sir, what is the significance of brother
- 52:17plan? How it cemented the ideological
- 52:19bipolarity?
- 52:21Sir, brother plan was created by the
- 52:25foreign minister of the Soviet Union
- 52:28whose name was Molotov.
- 52:31Molotov M O L O T O V.
- 52:37He created a concept called a brother
- 52:39plan
- 52:41by
- 52:45he said all socialist republics are
- 52:48brothers of each other.
- 52:50Feminists
- 52:58wave feminism
- 53:08brother
- 53:13as a side he said all socialist
- 53:16republics are brothers of each other
- 53:21and these brothers of each other are
- 53:24going to be given all economic support
- 53:26for economic integration. See this is
- 53:28where the difference lies better.
- 53:31And this brother plan which supported
- 53:34economic integration was also called as
- 53:36Moltov plan.
- 53:38M O L O T O V Mto.
- 53:43His actual name was Velas Maltto.
- 53:47V Molto
- 53:49Vas Molto.
- 53:55Sir, how is Molto plan different
- 53:56basically from the Marshall plan?
- 54:00Marshall plan is a plan that only
- 54:02focuses on economic aid.
- 54:05Its objective is that use money as a
- 54:08muscle to
- 54:10break the Soviet Union. Its objective is
- 54:14use money as an instrument to achieve
- 54:17what John Foster Dules wanted to achieve
- 54:19which is called the roll back of the
- 54:22Soviet Union.
- 54:24But sir, this is the place where moltov
- 54:26plan differs. Molto of plan is a plan
- 54:29which went on to say that we are all
- 54:31brothers.
- 54:34So we will basically give money so that
- 54:37all of us economically integrate sir.
- 54:40Now why this is important is because it
- 54:42is the moltov plan that germinated the
- 54:45idea that economic integration can also
- 54:49lead to
- 54:51a better model of governance.
- 54:54And in fact,
- 54:57European Union
- 54:59contemporary global challenges
- 55:18Interconnection
- 55:22connection
- 55:41the spark for European Union as a
- 55:44economic integration project came from
- 55:46Maltto plan.
- 55:55What germinated the seed of economic
- 55:58integration that economic integration
- 56:00can also be a viable model of governance
- 56:03is the maltto of plan.
- 56:06So Mol basically played a very important
- 56:08role
- 56:11question using scholars argue what led
- 56:13to the birth of council for mutual
- 56:15economic assistance.
- 56:19Scholar here is Elina Draomir.
- 56:23Elena Eelina
- 56:27Dragomir. D R A G O M E I R
- 56:32D R A G O M E I R. Dragir.
- 56:35So what does Elena Dragumir say? Elena
- 56:37Dragomir says that idea of Molotov who
- 56:41was the foreign minister of Soviet Union
- 56:43was
- 56:45that let's focus on economic integration
- 56:48in such a manner that even if the
- 56:50Americans use Marshall plan economic aid
- 56:53they cannot break us
- 56:56a lighter note
- 56:58explanation
- 57:01rather than telling
- 57:04others that why Congress is had had the
- 57:07BJB focused on understanding that why
- 57:11they are good things would have been
- 57:12different. This is what Molotov and
- 57:14Soviet Union did they never said we will
- 57:17basically roll back capitalism. They
- 57:20never said we will counter capitalism.
- 57:22They never said we will contain
- 57:23capitalism.
- 57:25They simply said sir we will create such
- 57:27an economic integration
- 57:30which will manifest as council for
- 57:32mutual economic assistance eventually
- 57:34that this model of economic integration
- 57:37will be such that it can never break
- 57:39away. So sir council for mutual economic
- 57:42assistance is born as
- 57:47sir it is born as a template for
- 57:50international political economy
- 57:54international political economy
- 57:58political economic perspective of
- 58:00comparative politics political sociology
- 58:02and political economy perspective
- 58:09scholars
- 58:20CMEA was never created with the
- 58:22objective to counter what is called as
- 58:24Marshall plan.
- 58:26It was created with the objective of
- 58:28binding the socialist republics in such
- 58:30an economic integration model that there
- 58:32would be no scope to break away.
- 58:36Clear?
- 58:41Clear scholar. Scholar. Robert Ivy.
- 58:47Robert Ivy. I I V I E. I I E I B. I I E.
- 58:56Robert I sir.
- 59:02All important point.
- 59:05Key. Truman doctrine and Marshall plan
- 59:08deliberately used
- 59:13a disease metaphor for communism. They
- 59:17important point
- 59:19disease metaphor.
- 59:25He says the objective of Truman doctrine
- 59:28and Marshall plan was to actually show
- 59:30communism as an ideology of the diseased
- 59:34people.
- 59:36Because when you show it as an ideology
- 59:38of the diseased people, what will happen
- 59:40as a consequence is that it will create
- 59:42psychological hatred.
- 59:45It will create pathological
- 59:48impulse. The word he uses is
- 59:50psychological hatred and pathological
- 59:52impulse.
- 59:54Pathological impulse.
- 1:00:11Psychological pathological level neural
- 1:00:14impulses effect.
- 1:00:20The difference principle difference
- 1:00:21between Gandhian approach to cast versus
- 1:00:24theite approach to cast
- 1:00:28smash the cast.
- 1:00:31Anion of cast.
- 1:00:46Reason
- 1:00:50categorically said was an
- 1:01:03starting
- 1:01:09Truman Doctrine in Marshall Plan
- 1:01:11deliberately used this kind of disease
- 1:01:13metaphor.
- 1:01:15Communism is a disease.
- 1:01:19idea was communist people must
- 1:01:21psychologically develop hatred for
- 1:01:23communism
- 1:01:29because
- 1:01:31capitalists at that time and
- 1:01:32specifically America was behaving
- 1:01:34exactly like BJP was.
- 1:01:51almost
- 1:02:01America versus Soviet Union. Got the
- 1:02:03difference, sir? In how they were
- 1:02:05looking at cold war.
- 1:02:11Clear?
- 1:02:19Ch
- 1:02:24continue.
- 1:02:30Sure.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of PSIR-Class-139-International Relations (Paper-2) (Part-A and B Integrated) by Pavneet Singh - UPSC , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,774 words across 1,071 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.