Professor Brian Greene: The Threat of AI, Consciousness & The End of Humanity — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00I can't convince you that we're not in
- 0:01the matrix. Why? We could be. Is this
- 0:04table real? Am I really here? Am I a
- 0:06simulation sitting [music] inside some
- 0:07computer? Maybe there's a kid on 29th
- 0:10century Earth and they happen to allow
- 0:13you and I to exist sitting at this
- 0:14table. And here's a big assumption.
- 0:16[music] Can you create a computer
- 0:18program that has consciousness? Nobody
- 0:21knows the answer to that, but I've
- 0:22spoken to some of today's AI researchers
- 0:25who think that chat GPT is conscious.
- 0:28And in the back of my mind, [music] I do
- 0:29think it's possible.
- 0:30>> But if we considered robots to be
- 0:32conscious, would they then get rights?
- 0:34>> I think that's something we should think
- 0:35about now, actually.
- 0:36>> Professor Brian Greene, what is the
- 0:38ultimate question that you're seeking to
- 0:40answer? [music]
- 0:40>> We find ourselves thrust on this planet.
- 0:43We're trying to figure out why we're
- 0:45here. Is there some ultimate purpose?
- 0:47We're a little dot on planet Earth. Then
- 0:50you begin to see our sun, one of many
- 0:52stars within [music] the galaxy. You can
- 0:54look at our Milky Way galaxy within the
- 0:58setting of the entire universe. [music]
- 1:00>> And what's beyond?
- 1:01>> Well, if the universe is infinite, if
- 1:03you go sufficiently far out into space,
- 1:05you're virtually guaranteed to find a
- 1:06copy of yourself out there.
- 1:08>> There's a version out there of me that
- 1:09just loves wine.
- 1:11>> There you go.
- 1:12>> So, should I feel insignificant?
- 1:14>> I would urge you not to. Because fact
- 1:16that we can understand that we are so
- 1:19small, that's what gives us [music] a
- 1:20sense of connection to something larger.
- 1:23>> Do you think it could lead us to God?
- 1:24>> If you mean the kind of [music] God our
- 1:27forebears often have spoken, that feels
- 1:29to me very much a human creation. I will
- 1:32tell you why I'm skeptical of that. But
- 1:34another thing we should [music] think
- 1:35about is the end of the Earth. Because
- 1:37if we go arbitrarily far into the
- 1:39future, the Earth is going [music] to
- 1:40spiral.
- 1:41>> Let's not want to get scary.
- 1:42>> Let's scare the whole way.
- 1:48>> This is super interesting to me. My team
- 1:50gave me this report to show me how many
- 1:51of you that watch this show subscribe.
- 1:53And some of you have told us, according
- 1:54to this, that you are unsubscribed from
- 1:56the channel randomly. So, a favor to ask
- 1:58all of you, please could you check right
- 2:00now if you've hit the subscribe button
- 2:01if you are a regular viewer of the show
- 2:03and you like what we do here. We're
- 2:04approaching quite a significant landmark
- 2:06on this show in terms of a subscriber
- 2:07number. So, if there was one simple free
- 2:10thing that you could do to help us, my
- 2:11team, everyone here to keep this show
- 2:13free, to keep it improving year over
- 2:16year and week over week, it is just to
- 2:17hit that subscribe button and to double
- 2:19check if you've hit it. Only thing I'll
- 2:20ever ask of you.
- 2:21Do we have a deal?
- 2:22If you do it, I'll tell you what I'll
- 2:23do. I'll make sure
- 2:25every single week, every single month,
- 2:27we fight harder and harder and harder
- 2:28and harder to bring you the guests and
- 2:29conversations that you want to hear.
- 2:31I've stayed true to that promise since
- 2:32the very beginning of the Diary of a CEO
- 2:33and I will not let you down. Please help
- 2:36us. Really appreciate it. Let's get on
- 2:38with the show.
- 2:39>> [music]
- 2:43>> Professor Brian Greene.
- 2:47What is the ultimate question that
- 2:48you're seeking to answer?
- 2:50>> The ultimate question I would say is
- 2:51what is the true nature of reality.
- 2:54We find ourselves thrust on this planet
- 2:59and we look out and we're trying to
- 3:00figure out
- 3:02why we're here, what it's made of, is
- 3:04there some ultimate purpose,
- 3:06or is it just some interesting accident
- 3:10that allowed us to have self-awareness
- 3:12and ask these kinds of questions about
- 3:14the nature of the world. And I think
- 3:16that to me is the the deepest kind of
- 3:18question that we humans can ask.
- 3:21>> Do you feel like over the last 30 years
- 3:23of your career you've gotten closer to
- 3:25understanding the answer to that
- 3:26question?
- 3:27>> Yes, but you know, it's kind of like
- 3:31picking up grains of sand on a beach,
- 3:33right? You pick up more and more and
- 3:35that that pouch of sand gets heavier, so
- 3:38your understanding is is deeper, it's
- 3:40weightier, but you look out and there's
- 3:42just almost infinitely more grains of
- 3:45sand that are out there. We understand
- 3:46the world better than we once did.
- 3:49But, does that really take
- 3:53some significant way toward assessing
- 3:56the big deep questions of say why is
- 3:58there something rather than nothing?
- 4:00Maybe that's the deepest question of
- 4:02all, by which I don't mean empty space.
- 4:05I mean nothing.
- 4:07Nothing at all.
- 4:09>> Well, where will this conversation go in
- 4:11the pursuit of that answer? To tell
- 4:13people who you are and to let them
- 4:16understand the journey you've been on
- 4:17academically and through your career.
- 4:19Where did you study? Where have you
- 4:21worked over the last couple of decades?
- 4:22>> Yeah, sure. Well, I grew up in Manhattan
- 4:24right across from the Hayden
- 4:25Planetarium. I would wander the hallways
- 4:28of the planetarium and come upon a
- 4:30meteorite. And the universe was sort of
- 4:33my backyard because of that. And that
- 4:36really set me on a trajectory that I
- 4:39continued following when I went to
- 4:41college, went to Harvard and studied
- 4:43mathematics and physics. And then from
- 4:45there was to Oxford where I got my
- 4:48doctorate pursuing work in a field
- 4:51called string theory. And then through
- 4:54the academic ladder, Cornell and
- 4:56ultimately Columbia where I've been a
- 4:57professor now for
- 4:5930 some odd years. You know, director of
- 5:01the Center for Theoretical Physics at
- 5:03Columbia University.
- 5:04>> If you were to explain string theory to
- 5:05me like I was 12,
- 5:07>> Yeah.
- 5:07>> how would you do it?
- 5:08>> Yeah, I would simply say this. Your
- 5:0912-year-old self probably knew that
- 5:11matter was made up of stuff called
- 5:14molecules that themselves are made up of
- 5:17atoms that are stuck together. And the
- 5:20the atoms are made of smaller things.
- 5:23Electrons in orbit around a nucleus that
- 5:26has neutrons and protons. And neutrons
- 5:29and protons, they even have smaller
- 5:31particles, particles called quarks.
- 5:34The question is is that the end of the
- 5:35story? Is it electrons and quarks and
- 5:37you're done? Everything is made up of
- 5:39them. Or might there be a finer level of
- 5:42structure inside the electron? Inside
- 5:45the quark. You take a powerful
- 5:46microscope and you look deeply, would
- 5:47you see anything else?
- 5:50And the idea of string theory is, yeah,
- 5:51you would.
- 5:52Inside an electron or inside a quark,
- 5:55you'd see a little tiny vibrating
- 5:57filament. And the different vibrations
- 5:59of the string yield the different
- 6:01particles. So, much like a string on a
- 6:03violin, when it vibrates in one pattern,
- 6:05you hear it as a C or a or an A sharp.
- 6:08>> Mhm.
- 6:09>> The different vibrations of the strings
- 6:11in string theory, they don't produce
- 6:13different musical tones. They produce
- 6:15different particles. So, a string
- 6:17vibrating one way, electron. A string
- 6:19vibrating another way, a quark. So,
- 6:22matter at its most fundamental level, if
- 6:25you were to take a powerful microscope
- 6:27and look deeply inside of any piece of
- 6:29matter, you'd see all these little
- 6:31vibrating filaments, these vibrating
- 6:33strings. That's the idea of the theory.
- 6:37>> So, I have two questions come to mind
- 6:38when you say that, which is how do you
- 6:40know? And the second one is, what if you
- 6:42zoomed in even further?
- 6:43>> Yeah, good. Both good questions. How do
- 6:45we know? We don't.
- 6:47Everything I just said could be utter
- 6:49nonsense. I don't think it is.
- 6:51But the only way that you know if an
- 6:54idea in science is correct is,
- 6:57you need to make predictions that you
- 6:58can go out and test, measure, and see
- 7:00whether you can confirm the ideas.
- 7:03We don't have the technology
- 7:05to look sufficiently
- 7:06deeply into matter to see the strings.
- 7:09We don't have the particle accelerators,
- 7:12the particle colliders with enough power
- 7:14to slam things together to access this
- 7:18finer level of structure that the theory
- 7:20is suggesting. So, you might say then,
- 7:22where do these ideas come from, right?
- 7:24Answer, mathematics. The power of
- 7:28mathematics is that it can take us to
- 7:30places that we can't yet go, literally
- 7:33using equipment. When we look at the
- 7:35mathematics of quantum mechanics, the
- 7:38mathematics of general relativity, and
- 7:40we put that math inside the math of
- 7:42string theory, all of a sudden the
- 7:44equations work. They come together
- 7:47harmoniously.
- 7:49And we're like, "Whoa." The math of
- 7:51quantum mechanics, we are confident in
- 7:53that. We have predictions and
- 7:55observations. The math of general
- 7:57relativity, we're confident in that. It
- 7:59makes predictions we've confirmed
- 8:00through observations. Now, we're willing
- 8:04to go where the math takes us. And the
- 8:06math takes us in this approach to these
- 8:09vibrating filaments.
- 8:10>> These vibrating strings.
- 8:11>> strings.
- 8:12>> So, if you pass me the string, yeah. So,
- 8:14essentially, if you zoom in to every
- 8:16cell in my body,
- 8:17>> Yeah.
- 8:18>> you will find that there's different
- 8:19shaped strings vibrating.
- 8:21>> That's the prediction.
- 8:22>> That's the prediction.
- 8:23>> Correct.
- 8:23>> And what is causing them to vibrate in a
- 8:26certain way? Who's telling them
- 8:28>> Yeah, yeah. The idea is
- 8:30we recognize that the universe has
- 8:33energy. If you were to ask me, "Where
- 8:35does the energy come from?" Nobody can
- 8:38answer that. That is the question of why
- 8:39there is something rather than nothing.
- 8:41The something is a fundamental currency
- 8:44called energy. If string theory is
- 8:47correct, then that energy manifests as
- 8:50these vibrational patterns of the
- 8:52strings themselves. If the theory is
- 8:53wrong, then the energy manifests through
- 8:56other things like motions of particles
- 8:59and the way in which space-time warps
- 9:01and curves. But, if string theory is
- 9:04correct, the energy of the universe is
- 9:06manifested in the vibrational patterns
- 9:08of strings. Now, when you say like, "Who
- 9:10mandates that that string vibrates in
- 9:13one pattern and that string vibrates in
- 9:15a different pattern?" If we go back to
- 9:17the Big Bang, the energetic explosion
- 9:21that resulted in space expanding, the
- 9:25detailed way in which that happened
- 9:27ultimately dictates how this or that
- 9:30string vibrates in the aftermath of that
- 9:34rapid cosmological explosion.
- 9:36>> Does this string theory idea
- 9:39tell us anything about why we're here?
- 9:42>> I would like to think that it does. It's
- 9:45very indirect. And we are aggregates of
- 9:49a huge number of particles, or if string
- 9:52theory is correct, a huge number of
- 9:53strings. I mean, inside your body,
- 9:55you've got something like a billion
- 9:57billion billion particles.
- 10:00And if string theory is correct, each of
- 10:01those particles is a vibrating filament.
- 10:04It is a gargantuan challenge to
- 10:06understand why those billion billion
- 10:09billion particles came together to yield
- 10:12you or me or somebody else. But again,
- 10:15that's a historical progression. And I
- 10:17think we understand the broad outlines
- 10:19of that narrative. That there was some
- 10:21initial event called the Big Bang that
- 10:24resulted in space expanding.
- 10:27The energy of that Big Bang ultimately
- 10:30transmuted into particles. Those
- 10:33particles were wafting through space.
- 10:35Gravity caused collections of those
- 10:38particles to clump together.
- 10:40Some of them clumped together into
- 10:42stars, like our sun. Some of them
- 10:44clumped together into planets, like our
- 10:46Earth. And on our Earth, some of those
- 10:49particles began to coalesce into more
- 10:53exotic and refined forms, giving rise to
- 10:57atoms, giving rise to molecules. And
- 11:00over the course of billions of years on
- 11:02our planet, those little molecules grew
- 11:06into more complex structures, ultimately
- 11:08giving first cells. And once you have a
- 11:11cell, cells divide, and they come
- 11:13together into larger multicellular
- 11:16aggregates that give rise to the
- 11:18beginnings of life in the ocean. And
- 11:20those life forms evolve further until
- 11:23they can walk out of the ocean and begin
- 11:25to live on land. And they begin to stand
- 11:29upright. And after a billion more years,
- 11:32you and I are sitting here at this
- 11:34table. And so, yeah, there is a story.
- 11:37That's the brief version that takes us
- 11:39from the Big Bang
- 11:41to us on planet Earth.
- 11:43>> Is it theoretical that this is all just
- 11:45a
- 11:47I was going to say
- 11:48perception, but the other word might be
- 11:49a simulation of sorts. Theoretically, we
- 11:51don't even know if yesterday exists, or
- 11:53if it was just we were just implanted
- 11:55with the memory of it.
- 11:56>> Absolutely right.
- 11:57>> We're in this age of AI now.
- 11:59And I wondered if this insurgence of AI
- 12:04and how powerful
- 12:05it is,
- 12:06and if you imagine it on a you sort of
- 12:08an exponential curve, has it made you
- 12:10question some of your like fundamental
- 12:12assumptions about that overarching
- 12:14question of why we're here?
- 12:16>> Well, yeah. In fact, even before AI,
- 12:20we were tussling with the very notion
- 12:23that you mentioned, which is
- 12:26all we ever have access to
- 12:30is now, right?
- 12:32We can try to remember yesterday's now,
- 12:36but as you say, that's happening right
- 12:39now through patterns that are in my
- 12:41brain or yours that we think reflects
- 12:44something that happened yesterday or the
- 12:46day before, but that's a leap of faith,
- 12:50right? So, there's a kind of, you know,
- 12:52skeptical nightmare scenario where we
- 12:56begin to question everything. You know,
- 12:58is this table real? Am I really here? Am
- 13:00I a simulation sitting inside some
- 13:02computer right now? Are we in the Matrix
- 13:05right now? These are the kinds of things
- 13:07which you naturally can come to when you
- 13:10take a deeply skeptical attitude to the
- 13:13nature of reality. Bottom line is, I
- 13:16can't convince myself, and certainly I
- 13:18can't convince you that we're not in the
- 13:19Matrix. Why? We could be.
- 13:22It is logically consistent and sensible
- 13:24to imagine that you and I are sitting in
- 13:27some computer. Maybe it's not, you know,
- 13:30some dark dystopian computer the way it
- 13:32was in The Matrix. Maybe there's a kid
- 13:35in, you know, 29th century Earth who's
- 13:39in his or her garage right now, and they
- 13:42came up this wonderful computer program,
- 13:45and they're simulating historical
- 13:47episodes in the past, and they happen to
- 13:50allow you and I to exist sitting at this
- 13:52table.
- 13:53I don't know how to prove that that's
- 13:54not the case.
- 13:56What I can say is if I'm willing to buy
- 13:59into that, everything falls apart.
- 14:02I can't trust any I can't trust my
- 14:04reasoning. I can't even trust my
- 14:06thinking that it's logical to imagine
- 14:08that individual cuz that individual may
- 14:10have implanted the false reasoning that
- 14:13it could be logical for us to be sitting
- 14:15here. What do I do at that point? And
- 14:17so, as a scientist, what I say is, I'm
- 14:20going to allow that as a possibility,
- 14:22and then I'm going to park it right over
- 14:24here.
- 14:25I allow it. I look at it every so often,
- 14:27I say, "That's scary, that possibility
- 14:29that we're in a simulation,
- 14:31but I'm not going to let it overwhelm me
- 14:33because then I'll be stuck."
- 14:34>> The simulation argument popularized by
- 14:36philosopher Nick Bostrom relies on
- 14:37probability.
- 14:38>> Yeah.
- 14:39>> Um it essentially says that if an
- 14:41advanced civilization, which I would
- 14:43argue we're an advanced civilization,
- 14:46ever develops the technological capacity
- 14:48to run conscious, high-fidelity computer
- 14:50simulations of their ancestors, they
- 14:53will likely run millions of or billions
- 14:54of them. And because these simulated
- 14:56realities would vastly outnumber the
- 14:58single raw physical universe, any given
- 15:01conscious observer is statistically
- 15:03almost certainly living inside a
- 15:05software code rather than base reality.
- 15:08>> The biggest assumption is, can you
- 15:11create a computer program that has
- 15:13self-awareness, that has consciousness?
- 15:16>> [sighs and gasps]
- 15:17>> You know, nobody knows the answer to
- 15:19that. I've spoken to some of today's AI
- 15:22researchers who think that chat GPT is
- 15:25conscious. They who think that Claude is
- 15:27conscious. Now, I
- 15:28I I talk to them and I'm respectful.
- 15:31That's the kind of person I am. But, in
- 15:33the back of my mind, I'm like, are you
- 15:34kidding me? You really think that chat
- 15:37GPT has feelings?
- 15:40That it thinks about its own existence
- 15:44and has anxieties?
- 15:47I think it can simulate that, but
- 15:49regardless,
- 15:51I don't think today's technology is
- 15:53there.
- 15:54Is it possible that tomorrow's
- 15:56technology, broadly defined, a year, 5
- 15:58years, 100 years, really will yield
- 16:01self-aware sentient artificial systems?
- 16:05Yeah, I do think it's possible. Now, not
- 16:08everybody agrees with that. I mean, no
- 16:10one knows, right? It's a
- 16:12logical possibility, but we don't know.
- 16:13Let us assume, following Nick Bostrom,
- 16:17that consciousness can be created in a
- 16:20mechanical box.
- 16:23If that's possible, then Nick simply
- 16:25says, "Look, our progeny in the future,
- 16:28they're going to be fascinated with
- 16:30creating sentient systems.
- 16:33And so, they're going to create millions
- 16:35and billions and trillions of of
- 16:37sentient systems in the box.
- 16:40And they're going to get really
- 16:41elaborate and create a version where the
- 16:43sentient beings are led to think that
- 16:45they're on a planet.
- 16:47And in fact, they're going to do it a
- 16:48thousand billion trillion different
- 16:50ways. Some are going to be a planet like
- 16:52Earth. Some are going to be on a planet
- 16:53like Mars. Some are going to be a planet
- 16:55like around some star in the Andromeda
- 16:57galaxy. They're going to be an
- 17:00enormous number of simulated beings.
- 17:04Enormous number of universes that are
- 17:05simulated. So, the question is,
- 17:08if we have one real universe, let's say
- 17:10this is real,
- 17:12and a gazillion artificial ones that are
- 17:14created in various laptop computers of
- 17:17the future,
- 17:19we're one of a billion trillion zillion
- 17:23instantiations of people who think that
- 17:25they're real.
- 17:26Now, one truly is real. The other are
- 17:29not real. So, if you're just talking
- 17:32about odds, the odds are
- 17:34anybody who thinks they're real is not.
- 17:37The odds are anybody who's got a
- 17:38self-aware sense of the world is
- 17:41probably in a simulation.
- 17:43>> You use anxiety as a sort of proxy for
- 17:45consciousness almost. Like the bit being
- 17:46able to feel these things.
- 17:48>> Yeah.
- 17:48>> I guess the question then becomes like
- 17:49what is what is it? What is anxiety?
- 17:52>> Yeah.
- 17:52>> Is it an electrical signal going through
- 17:54it from
- 17:54>> think it is. I think that love and hate
- 17:57and anxiety and jealousy and gratitude
- 18:00and grief and all human emotion is
- 18:03nothing but electrical impulses going
- 18:06through our brains. An electrical
- 18:08impulse is just particles moving or
- 18:10strings moving along various
- 18:13connections. I think that is all that it
- 18:15is. Now, some people hear that and
- 18:16they're like, "Wow, that is a pretty
- 18:18bleak way of looking at life. We're
- 18:21these wondrous beings who
- 18:23can have all this emotion, right? The
- 18:26emotion captured by Shakespeare in the
- 18:29sonnets, right? The emotion captured by
- 18:32Beethoven in the Ninth Symphony. You
- 18:34can't reduce that to electrical signals
- 18:37in the brain." I say, "Yeah, I you can.
- 18:40I really do think that you can. I don't
- 18:42think that diminishes the wonder of what
- 18:44we can feel and sense and articulate and
- 18:47express through the various ways that we
- 18:49have, be it through music or theater or
- 18:52art or literature or poetry." Yeah, I am
- 18:56as
- 18:57awestruck by our capacity to create as
- 19:00as anybody else, but in the end,
- 19:03I think it all does reduce to electrical
- 19:06impulses going through this
- 19:09gray piece of meat in this bone cage
- 19:12that's sitting on our shoulders.
- 19:14>> And if you imagine any rate of
- 19:15improvement from today, presumably at
- 19:17some point in the future our future our
- 19:20future progeny, you call them?
- 19:21>> Yeah.
- 19:22>> would be able to create
- 19:24>> Why not? That's my view. I don't think
- 19:26there's something special about the
- 19:28brain as a substrate. I think as long as
- 19:30you have the same electrical impulses,
- 19:33if they're housed in silicon inside a
- 19:37metallic box, I don't think that makes
- 19:40them fundamentally different than what's
- 19:42happening inside of our heads. Now,
- 19:44philosophers argue this, you know,
- 19:45psychologists argue this.
- 19:48They say, "No, no, no, no. It's not just
- 19:50the brain. It's the brain, its
- 19:51connection to the body, it's the tactile
- 19:53sense of the world, it's the olfactory
- 19:55sense of the world, it's the visual
- 19:57sense." It's only when you put it all
- 19:59together that you get the full
- 20:01experience of what it means to be
- 20:02self-aware self-aware human being. And
- 20:05my view is well, maybe that's true, but
- 20:07if so,
- 20:08give the artificial version tactile
- 20:11sense and olfactory sense and visual
- 20:14sense. We will have the capacity to do
- 20:18this. At that point, I just don't see a
- 20:22fundamental difference between the
- 20:24artificial version and shall we call it
- 20:28the organic. And so, yeah, I think
- 20:30there's a really interesting argument to
- 20:32be made that simulations will outnumber
- 20:35real worlds and therefore, there's a
- 20:38chance that right now we are in one of
- 20:41those simulated worlds.
- 20:45>> Does it change anything even if that's
- 20:47true?
- 20:47>> Nah, I don't think it does. And I think
- 20:49that's the beauty.
- 20:51If I'm in a simulation,
- 20:53I'm going to live out my life in this
- 20:54simulation to the fullest.
- 20:56Now, I'd like to think that as a
- 20:58physicist, what I do, what my colleagues
- 21:01do is try to figure out the laws of the
- 21:04universe writ large. But, if we're in a
- 21:07simulation and all we're doing is
- 21:08figuring out the laws that the
- 21:1015-year-old futuristic kid decided to
- 21:13impose on this artificial world,
- 21:15hey, that's not a bad way to spend your
- 21:18time, too.
- 21:19>> On the subject of AI,
- 21:21do you I mean, a lot of people that have
- 21:23sat here, people like Geoffrey Hinton,
- 21:24have told me that it's quite
- 21:26inconceivable that when there is a more
- 21:28intelligent life form on this planet,
- 21:30i.e., AI, which is accelerating in its
- 21:32intelligence towards superintelligence
- 21:34and AGI and all these terms that these
- 21:35smart people use, um it's inconceivable
- 21:37that we will remain in control.
- 21:39>> Yeah.
- 21:40>> Logically, that kind of also stacks up.
- 21:41>> It does, but I think there are
- 21:44alternatives. We tend to speak very much
- 21:48at the extremes, right? Humans are in
- 21:51control. AI is in control. AI wipes us
- 21:55out for
- 21:57reasons that might be benign or might be
- 22:01dystopian. It seems to me that what will
- 22:04likely happen is something more in the
- 22:07middle, which is
- 22:09we are going to work with artificial
- 22:12systems. We're doing it right now, and
- 22:15look how quickly we have acclimated to a
- 22:18world that would be unthinkable in 2021.
- 22:22There many examples now, but there's a
- 22:23beautiful one that's on my mind. An
- 22:2580-year-old mathematical conjecture
- 22:28that was called the Jacobian conjecture
- 22:30was solved
- 22:32very recently by a mathematician using
- 22:36AI. I see us blending with AI,
- 22:41not necessarily that we have implants,
- 22:43but maybe we will, but there will not be
- 22:47a sharp a distinction
- 22:49between the biological intelligence and
- 22:52the artificial intelligence. And that to
- 22:54me, if that ultimately yields a
- 22:57new life form
- 22:59that no longer
- 23:01can be called human,
- 23:04that may be the way things evolve.
- 23:08And so, evolution is something that is
- 23:12inherent to how we got here.
- 23:16Why would we think that this moment in
- 23:18the evolutionary progression was the end
- 23:21of it all? We weren't going to
- 23:23continue to evolve. And maybe the
- 23:25continuation of our evolution is in
- 23:29partnership with the artificial
- 23:30intelligence systems that we ourselves
- 23:32create.
- 23:34>> That we give birth to.
- 23:35>> Yeah.
- 23:36It's us, right? It's our creation. You
- 23:39know, it's not an alien. We haven't been
- 23:40taken over. And so, yeah, I think that
- 23:43is a a real possible way that this story
- 23:46plays out.
- 23:48>> How do you feel about it?
- 23:50>> I am fine with it.
- 23:53You know, I think that we tend to
- 23:56become very attached
- 23:58to the way things are. And we gain a
- 24:02sense of the way things are is the way
- 24:04it will always be. I think that's a
- 24:07natural way that we humans have lived
- 24:11our lives. Why? Because the time scales
- 24:14for change in our past have been
- 24:17relatively slow. Right? We live what?
- 24:2030, 40, 50, call it 80 years, 100 years,
- 24:23whatever. But the time scales for change
- 24:25were typically much larger than that.
- 24:28The time scales for political change and
- 24:29the time scales for technological
- 24:31change, much larger. So, as a species,
- 24:34we've grown accustomed to the thought
- 24:36that, yeah, what we see is how it will
- 24:39always be. But of course, as we look
- 24:41back through history, we can see the
- 24:42changes. And so, we're uncomfortable
- 24:44with change because we're unused to
- 24:47living through that kind of change at
- 24:49the kind of speed that we are and will
- 24:52continue to encounter.
- 24:54But I think we just have to get with it.
- 24:57Now, look, I don't want AI system to
- 25:01wipe us out, don't get me wrong, but I
- 25:02think if we recognize that change is
- 25:04happening, will happening, we can
- 25:06embrace it in a way that will have an
- 25:08outcome that will be acceptable, that
- 25:12will in fact be wonderful in the things
- 25:15that it will allow us to do.
- 25:17>> I'm quite curious. You talked about AI
- 25:18being able to solve that complex math
- 25:20problem. I'm wondering if
- 25:23with accelerating ever more intelligent
- 25:25AI, there's a bunch of other things
- 25:27within physics that you think might
- 25:29become possible
- 25:30>> Oh, yeah.
- 25:30>> in the near term. I mean, one of them
- 25:31I'm thinking about, we can talk about
- 25:32some of the others that I have in my
- 25:33mind, but and any others that you think
- 25:35are interesting, but one of them is us
- 25:36being able to live forever.
- 25:38>> Yeah.
- 25:39>> Do you think we're going to be able to
- 25:40live forever?
- 25:40>> Yeah, that would be a that would be a
- 25:42good one. I don't think that death is
- 25:44inevitable
- 25:46in the sense that
- 25:48death can be thought of as the increase
- 25:52in entropy, the increase in disorder in
- 25:54a physical system. And when the entropy
- 25:57gets too large, the system can't
- 25:59function the way it once did. And that's
- 26:03really what we call death, right? That's
- 26:06really what it means. And so, in
- 26:08principle, we can imagine harnessing
- 26:11some of the processes that have caused
- 26:14the degradation in the human body that
- 26:17have naturally resulted in us typically
- 26:20not living more than 100 or 120 years. I
- 26:22mean, people like, you know, David
- 26:23Sinclair, who I've spoken to about
- 26:25things like this, yeah, you know, I
- 26:26think we can forestall the kinds of
- 26:29degradation. Now, if you're talking to
- 26:32me, I think on time scales that are so
- 26:34much longer than a human life. I think
- 26:38about time scales that speak to the
- 26:41entire
- 26:43time frame of the cosmos from beginning
- 26:46to the closest that science can take us
- 26:48to the very end. And on those scales, I
- 26:52don't think that we will be able to
- 26:53forestall death. But please note, the
- 26:56time scales I'm talking about are
- 26:58ludicrous
- 26:59compared to any time scale that we are
- 27:03familiar with. 100 more years, 200 more
- 27:06years, maybe 500 more years. I don't
- 27:08think anybody can really say for sure. I
- 27:10do think that is within the possible
- 27:13range of what
- 27:14science and medicine will ultimately be
- 27:18able to accomplish. And I will say
- 27:20though,
- 27:21you know, I I read a book when I was
- 27:23about in my 20s called The Denial of
- 27:25Death by Ernest Becker. He was a social
- 27:29psychologist, I guess sociologist, who
- 27:32believed strongly that so much of what
- 27:35we do in our lives is driven by our
- 27:40awareness of our own mortality. And as I
- 27:42began to think more and more about that,
- 27:44it made more and more sense to me. Which
- 27:47had a dual effect on me. Very
- 27:49interesting framework to think about
- 27:51your life within the context of
- 27:54recognizing its finite nature. But the
- 27:56flip side of that is you're constantly
- 27:58thinking about your own death, you know,
- 28:00which, you know, is a a curious way to
- 28:02go about your life. But I don't think
- 28:04that denial of death, that human
- 28:06motivation would go away if we lived 200
- 28:09years or 300 or 500. Yeah, we'd have
- 28:13longer lifespans, we'd be able to do
- 28:15more things. But, you know, if we live
- 28:17to 500, you know, as we approach 450,
- 28:20475, we'll be thinking the exact same
- 28:23thoughts that we think now as we
- 28:26approach 70 or 80. It'll be no
- 28:29different. And so from a fundamental
- 28:31perspective, yeah, I would choose to
- 28:33live longer, but I don't think it
- 28:35changes anything fundamentally.
- 28:37>> I I find it quite interesting. I was
- 28:38actually writing a a letter about this,
- 28:40sort of an an article to myself really
- 28:42about this yesterday about this idea of
- 28:43long-termism and how when you just
- 28:45change the time horizon of something,
- 28:47the decisions you make today are
- 28:48different.
- 28:49>> Yeah.
- 28:49>> And a simple way of explaining this
- 28:51through the context of like business
- 28:52would be, if I told you to build a
- 28:54business, then I gave you 1 year and
- 28:56unlimited resources, but you had to
- 28:58build it as big as you could,
- 28:59you would take certain shortcuts
- 29:01>> Yeah.
- 29:01>> and you would not maybe not think about
- 29:03the foundations. But if I gave you 20
- 29:05years, you'd really make great
- 29:06foundations and then, you know, you'd
- 29:08build up from there. And I think about
- 29:10the same in our lives because we do have
- 29:11this sort of sort of inbuilt time
- 29:13horizon, okay, I'm going to live maybe
- 29:1480 years and then I'm 30 and then 40 and
- 29:16then kids and then I start to, you know,
- 29:18change and
- 29:19I mean, maybe at some deeper level we
- 29:21are making a certain set of decisions
- 29:22based on that time horizon that we
- 29:24wouldn't make otherwise.
- 29:25>> Yeah, I mean, when I was 20 or 30,
- 29:29you know, even though I had this mindset
- 29:31that was inculcated by reading Becker's
- 29:33book, there was a certain sense of an
- 29:36infinite horizon that somehow was
- 29:40infusing your decisions, you know, to
- 29:43write a book. Well, that's like a 4-year
- 29:46undertaking, but you know, when you're
- 29:4830, you're like, yeah, sure, yeah,
- 29:50I'm going to do that. Now, I'm going to
- 29:53choose those books with a certain kind
- 29:54of care, right? You know, there's a
- 29:56different kind of mindset that that is
- 29:59brought to bear. So, I certainly agree
- 30:02that the time horizon has a profound
- 30:05impact on the moment-to-moment choices,
- 30:07but the pattern that we humans go
- 30:11through from birth, you know, to
- 30:14adolescence,
- 30:15adulthood, middle age, to ultimately old
- 30:18age if we're lucky and then, you know,
- 30:20we disappear, that pattern will persist
- 30:23regardless of what the ultimate scale of
- 30:25it is, whether it's 80 years or 800
- 30:27years. I think that we would go through
- 30:29a very similar kind of rhythmic
- 30:32variation in how we approach the world.
- 30:36If we were immortal,
- 30:38that would change a lot, but I don't see
- 30:42immortality in our future.
- 30:44>> What is this sort of the least inspiring
- 30:47possibility of the sort of answer to the
- 30:49big question of why we're here? And then
- 30:50I'll ask you the the most optimistic
- 30:52possibility.
- 30:53>> Yeah, I think the least inspiring would
- 30:56be if What if in the end of the day
- 31:00it's all just an accident. There is no
- 31:03deep explanation for
- 31:05why the world is the way it is. There's
- 31:07no deep explanation for why there's
- 31:09something rather than nothing. And if
- 31:11that's the truth,
- 31:12I'm on board.
- 31:14But it wouldn't feel as enriching as it
- 31:17might be if I can now jump to the other
- 31:19side of your question. You know, if
- 31:21there is a true fundamental answer to
- 31:24the question of why there is anything at
- 31:26all, and I recognize that that answer
- 31:29dovetails with everything else that
- 31:31we've been developing. That answer
- 31:33ultimately yields quantum mechanics and
- 31:36yields the general theory of relativity,
- 31:37maybe even yields string theory. That
- 31:40would feel deeply satisfying. Why did
- 31:43our brain evolve? So we could get the
- 31:45next meal.
- 31:46So we could get shelter. So we could get
- 31:49a mate and have progeny, allowing our
- 31:52genetic material to propagate into our
- 31:55descendants, right? This is what the
- 31:57brain was meant to do. And yet this
- 32:01brain can do so much more than that. It
- 32:03can figure out the equations of physics.
- 32:05That's That's a miracle right there. And
- 32:08so the deep gratification would come
- 32:10from this brain
- 32:11being able to figure out some stuff. And
- 32:14then it dovetails with a deep
- 32:16explanation for why there's anything at
- 32:19all,
- 32:20giving us a coherent narrative from the
- 32:22beginning until today and perhaps on
- 32:24into the far future.
- 32:27Yeah.
- 32:28>> Do you think it's going to happen? Do
- 32:29you think we're going to answer that
- 32:30question?
- 32:30>> I don't know.
- 32:32Nobody does.
- 32:34I think all vectors are pointing in a
- 32:36direction that suggests that there are
- 32:39real explanations that it's not just
- 32:41happenstance. There are these particles
- 32:43we mentioned before called electrons.
- 32:46Here it is, my spinning electron, right?
- 32:48And so, when an electron spins, it gives
- 32:52rise to a little magnetic field, sort of
- 32:54like a trillionth of the strength of the
- 32:56magnetic field of a magnet on your
- 32:58refrigerator.
- 33:00We can use the math of quantum mechanics
- 33:02to predict the strength of that magnetic
- 33:04field. And we can do it and it comes out
- 33:062.
- 33:0815 decimal places long. We can do the
- 33:10math. We then can measure the magnetic
- 33:13field.
- 33:14And it agrees digit by digit by digit by
- 33:16digit by digit with what we calculate.
- 33:20Our prediction is borne out by our
- 33:22observations to 15 decimal places.
- 33:26I mean, that's breathtaking.
- 33:27We should not have been able to do that
- 33:31in some sense, to understand the world
- 33:33that deeply with the brain that really
- 33:35was focused upon, you know, getting the
- 33:37bison. And so, the fact that we can do
- 33:40that suggests to me that there are these
- 33:43deep patterns in the world
- 33:46that
- 33:47will ultimately stitch together into a
- 33:51coherent story.
- 33:53>> Do you think it could lead us to
- 33:55God?
- 33:56>> Well,
- 33:56>> Or religion?
- 33:57>> Yeah, it depends what you mean
- 33:59by God. You know, if you mean the kind
- 34:02of God that
- 34:04our forebears
- 34:06often have spoken of and people today as
- 34:08well, a kind of anthropomorphized being,
- 34:12you know, sitting on the throne in some
- 34:14heavenly place,
- 34:16I suspect not.
- 34:18That feels to me very much a human
- 34:20creation.
- 34:21And a wondrous human creation. I'm not
- 34:25of the mindset as some of my science
- 34:27colleagues are that religion is an enemy
- 34:30of science and needs to be wiped. It can
- 34:32be, but anything can be an enemy of
- 34:34anything else. It depends how you use
- 34:36it. I see religion not as a structure
- 34:40that tries to explain the world in terms
- 34:43of its workings. I see it as a structure
- 34:45that tries to quell our anxiety, our
- 34:49existential anxiety. Where did religions
- 34:51come from? They came from our forebears
- 34:54recognizing that they would die. So, you
- 34:58know, our forebears had these elaborate
- 35:01rituals of burying their dead. There are
- 35:03these wonderful caves in various parts
- 35:06of the world that have been excavated
- 35:08where the grave goods, as they call it,
- 35:11involving, you know, animal teeth
- 35:13stitched together.
- 35:14It would take a single individual years
- 35:17to create the grave goods that are
- 35:19buried with an individual. Why would
- 35:22they spend the time on that? Well,
- 35:25they were imagining that death is not
- 35:26the end.
- 35:28That that individual needed those grave
- 35:30goods for their next journey into the
- 35:32afterlife. And why were they thinking
- 35:34about that? Because it's too terrifying
- 35:37to imagine that death is truly the end.
- 35:40And so, from that, you can see the
- 35:43glimmers of a religious sensibility
- 35:45emerging where we want to have something
- 35:49that suggests that death is not the end.
- 35:52So, we invent these beautiful structures
- 35:54called religions. And I say that even
- 35:58from a personal standpoint, I don't
- 36:00believe in any of the traditional
- 36:02religious practices. Right, I'm Jewish.
- 36:05I was raised sort of Jewish, more
- 36:06culturally than religiously.
- 36:09Do I pray on occasion?
- 36:11Yeah, I do.
- 36:13Do I believe that I'm praying to an
- 36:14actual god? I do not.
- 36:17But the act of
- 36:20going through the kind of ritual that
- 36:23our ancestors did and giving yourself
- 36:26over momentarily to something that you
- 36:28imagine as being more powerful, I think
- 36:31it's deeply in our nature.
- 36:33>> So, who are you praying to?
- 36:34>> I am praying to the universe, if I have
- 36:36to give a word to it. Recognizing that
- 36:39this prayer is going to fall on deaf
- 36:42ears because there's nothing else out
- 36:44there to hear it, but it makes me feel
- 36:47better. And so, there's a part of my
- 36:49mind that's willing to allow the
- 36:53scientific understanding to have its
- 36:55place,
- 36:57but the irrational human side to have
- 37:00its place, too.
- 37:01>> What is the most compelling argument or
- 37:04idea or experience you've ever
- 37:05encountered for a god, like the ones we
- 37:08read about in the Bibles?
- 37:10>> Very little.
- 37:11Very little. You know, somebody died in
- 37:14the operating room and they were able to
- 37:16leave their body and see things that
- 37:18they could not possibly have seen, and
- 37:21then they reported back when they were
- 37:22revived, and people were like, "Oh, you
- 37:24must have died and left your body.
- 37:25That's the only No. No, no, no. The
- 37:28human brain has this wonderful
- 37:30imaginative capacity to see things
- 37:33inside of its head that it doesn't
- 37:34literally see. That's what we can do.
- 37:37And so, I've never seen a single example
- 37:39where I couldn't feel that I could give
- 37:41a logical explanation which was more
- 37:44compelling than the supernatural
- 37:46explanation.
- 37:47>> What about the Big Bang then?
- 37:48>> Good. So, the Big Bang is a question of
- 37:53how it got started.
- 37:54>> Yeah.
- 37:55>> And over time, we have been able to push
- 37:57our understanding ever further back. So,
- 38:01in about 19,
- 38:04uh call it 29 or so, Edwin Hubble, who
- 38:07was a great astronomer,
- 38:10noticed, through powerful observations
- 38:13through the telescope at Mount Wilson
- 38:14Observatory in California, that the
- 38:16distant galaxies all seemed to be moving
- 38:19away.
- 38:20Interesting. Others, George Lemaître,
- 38:22who is a Belgian priest as it turns out
- 38:24who also knew Einstein's general
- 38:26relativity said, "Well, look, if all the
- 38:28galaxies are moving away, just wind that
- 38:31cosmic film backwards. Back in time they
- 38:34must have been closer and closer and
- 38:35closer together.
- 38:37Way back in the beginning they must have
- 38:38all been on top of each other and then
- 38:41everything running the film forward must
- 38:43have swelled outward in a big bang-like
- 38:46explosion. Let there be light. Let there
- 38:48be light. Yeah. And so, starting in
- 38:501929,
- 38:52we began to have a scientific account of
- 38:56how it is that the universe may have
- 38:58been billions of years ago. And in our
- 39:01era, other scientists took the story
- 39:03even further suggesting that there was
- 39:06an earlier era when the universe was
- 39:09just infused with a kind of uniform
- 39:13energy. You could say, "Where did the
- 39:15energy come?" I don't know. But if it
- 39:17was infused with this uniform energy,
- 39:18they showed that the math required that
- 39:21the universe underwent this rapid
- 39:23swelling, the Big Bang. And so, era by
- 39:27era by era, my point is we can push our
- 39:30understanding ever more deeply trying to
- 39:33get at cosmic origins. We have not been
- 39:36able to push back to time zero itself,
- 39:39but because we're able to push our
- 39:41understanding further back and make
- 39:43predictions about, for instance, what's
- 39:45known as the cosmic microwave background
- 39:48radiation. This is heat that we can
- 39:51observe today
- 39:52that was left over from the Big Bang.
- 39:55Big Bang was very hot. The universe has
- 39:57cooled ever since for 13.8 billion
- 40:00years. We can detect the residual heat
- 40:04from the Big Bang.
- 40:06And so, this gives me confidence that
- 40:09we're inching toward the answer to the
- 40:12question that you asked. Now, will we
- 40:14require God at some point
- 40:17by which I mean, will we say
- 40:19we've gone as far as we can.
- 40:21Will we have to invoke something else? I
- 40:24can't say no, but I don't see any reason
- 40:27at this point to envision that we won't
- 40:29be able to push all the way to a full
- 40:31understanding.
- 40:32>> Most of us don't really
- 40:34understand um
- 40:36I guess how scale
- 40:39>> Yeah.
- 40:39>> and time
- 40:40have a relationship. Which means that,
- 40:42you know, I've been alive for 33 years
- 40:44now, and it feels like a long time.
- 40:45>> Yeah.
- 40:46>> But, I'm presuming the further and
- 40:48further you zoom out and the sort of
- 40:50the bigger, the wider the scale gets,
- 40:52time is experienced differently. So,
- 40:54actually, I could have been here for a
- 40:56second in a toddler's universe who's
- 40:58created this simulation.
- 40:59>> Yes, all of this is possible when
- 41:01simulations are part of the story. But,
- 41:03if you put that to the side
- 41:05and just look at our universe, yeah.
- 41:07The time scales even there are shocking.
- 41:11I mean, Carl Sagan used an analogy. He
- 41:14said, "Look,
- 41:15if you want to understand the time
- 41:17scales of the universe from the
- 41:18beginning until today, which is billions
- 41:20of years, like 13.8 billion years, he
- 41:22said, "Here's one way to do it. Imagine
- 41:26that all of cosmic history from the
- 41:28beginning until today, you compress it
- 41:30down to 1 year."
- 41:31>> Okay.
- 41:33>> Now, in that scheme, that means each day
- 41:35is about 40,000 years. But, you can then
- 41:38put all of the milestone moments in the
- 41:42evolution of the universe on the
- 41:43calendar.
- 41:44So, imagine you have the Big Bang as
- 41:46January 1st.
- 41:47Then the Milky Way galaxy forms like
- 41:49something around, you know, March 15th
- 41:53or something like that. And the Sun and
- 41:55the Earth form sometime, you know, in
- 41:57May, you know. And then the first, you
- 42:00know, life on Earth is sometime in
- 42:02December, like December 2nd. And then,
- 42:04you know, the first modern humans, they
- 42:07appear like on New Year's Eve, right?
- 42:10>> Really?
- 42:10>> And then all of civilization
- 42:13takes place in the last 10 seconds.
- 42:15Right? So, like 11:55,
- 42:18you know, it's the it's the rise of the
- 42:21Buddha. 11:56, the fall of Rome. 11:58,
- 42:24the Renaissance. 11:59,
- 42:26you're like 1 second to the stroke of
- 42:28midnight, you get modern science. So,
- 42:30like modern science is like 1 second
- 42:34in this cosmic calendar.
- 42:36And so, that helps you get a feel for
- 42:39the time scales that are involved when
- 42:42you're talking cosmologically. Cuz
- 42:44you're right, 33 years in a lifetime,
- 42:46you know, I'm I'm going to posit you're
- 42:49going to live to 99, let's say. That's
- 42:511/3 of your life. You know, that's
- 42:52that's not small, it's not big, but you
- 42:54know, it's a significant part of it. On
- 42:56cosmic terms,
- 42:5833 years, it's zero. It doesn't
- 43:01register. That's how tiny it is on the
- 43:04scales that we're talking about
- 43:06cosmologically.
- 43:09>> So, should I feel insignificant?
- 43:11>> You can. I would urge you not to. One of
- 43:13the reactions to all this certainly can
- 43:15be,
- 43:16look, we're a little tiny speck
- 43:19in space, right? I mean, you can give
- 43:21the same kind of context for space
- 43:25itself, right? Because we're on a planet
- 43:27around the sun. The sun is one star
- 43:31of 100 billion others or so in the Milky
- 43:33Way galaxy.
- 43:35>> Have you got a
- 43:35>> Yeah, I think there's a a little version
- 43:38of this thing here if we can get this
- 43:40guy to go on. Right, yeah. So, if you
- 43:42sort of start like here, right? Here we
- 43:44are in the studio, right? And if here we
- 43:46then begin to
- 43:48pull out to planet Earth. Like we're a
- 43:50little dot on planet Earth. And then if
- 43:52you pull out from there,
- 43:54this is Earth within the solar system.
- 43:56You begin to see how tiny we look even
- 43:58on the scale of the solar system. But of
- 44:01course, here you can pull out further,
- 44:03and you begin to see our sun, one of
- 44:05many stars within the galaxies. You only
- 44:07see a few here, but you know, there are
- 44:09100 billion stars in our galaxy. And
- 44:12then you can go even further than that.
- 44:14You can look at our Milky Way galaxy
- 44:17within the setting of the entire
- 44:20universe that has at least 100 billion
- 44:23other galaxies.
- 44:24So,
- 44:25we, as a little tiny speck around our
- 44:28star, our star is one of 100 billion
- 44:31stars in a galaxy that's one of 100
- 44:33billion galaxies.
- 44:35That can certainly make you feel small
- 44:37in space.
- 44:39The beauty though
- 44:40is that our minds
- 44:42can reach out to the edge of the cosmos.
- 44:45The fact that we can understand that we
- 44:47are so small is what gives us heft.
- 44:50That's what gives us a sense of
- 44:52connection to something larger. I
- 44:54imagine that
- 44:56fish
- 44:57don't realize
- 44:59that they're like in one ocean of many
- 45:03oceans on the Earth that's one planet. I
- 45:05I don't think maybe I'm wrong and maybe
- 45:07the fish are like, "Ah, yeah, yeah, you
- 45:09know."
- 45:09>> [clears throat]
- 45:09>> But but assuming that the fish don't
- 45:11know that, they don't know that they're
- 45:13insignificant. They don't even really
- 45:16think in those terms per se. But the
- 45:18fact that we can do that,
- 45:20the fact that we can realize how
- 45:21insignificant we are when you talk about
- 45:24the expanse of space, you realize that
- 45:26there other measures of significance.
- 45:28And one measure of significance is your
- 45:30ability to understand your own
- 45:32predicament.
- 45:34And the fact that we can do that is what
- 45:37to me is wondrous.
- 45:38>> How do we know we're not just that whole
- 45:40universe there isn't just a we're just a
- 45:43microbe in the in the gut of a of a
- 45:45fish?
- 45:46>> Yeah, we we could and again that's much
- 45:48like this simulation argument. But let
- 45:51me give an example in here that helps
- 45:53give you a sense of
- 45:55why we believe this stuff. This here
- 45:58is the cosmic microwave background
- 46:00radiation. This is the heat
- 46:03left over from the beginning.
- 46:05Now, it's color-coded. The different
- 46:07colors correspond to different
- 46:08temperatures in space. This is a picture
- 46:11of space
- 46:13with a device that measures the
- 46:15temperature at each location and assigns
- 46:17it a color.
- 46:18>> How much of space? Or just a segment?
- 46:20>> This is a segment of the observable
- 46:21universe. The segment that we can see.
- 46:23Now, space can be much larger than
- 46:25things that we can see. That's
- 46:27absolutely the case. But, my point is
- 46:30these tiny color variations correspond
- 46:33to tiny temperature differences. We can
- 46:36use mathematics
- 46:37to predict the pattern of the
- 46:39temperature variations.
- 46:41And what we predict matches this image
- 46:44to incredible precision.
- 46:47And so, the fact that we can do a
- 46:49calculation right at this table with a
- 46:52piece of paper, a pencil, and a
- 46:54computer, and generate an image that
- 46:57agrees with what we see, we say, "Look,
- 47:00yeah, we can be skeptical. Maybe we
- 47:02don't have the full answer. But, that
- 47:04agreement gives us confidence that we've
- 47:07got something in the direction of truth.
- 47:10And that to me
- 47:11is what gives us
- 47:13something that counteracts the feeling
- 47:16of insignificance.
- 47:19>> And on that, if you just pull that up
- 47:20again. So, this is the observable
- 47:22universe, which is I mean, how big is
- 47:23that?
- 47:24>> The universe is about 13.8 billion years
- 47:27old. So, you'd think that the
- 47:29universe the distance we could see would
- 47:31be about 13.8 billion light years, the
- 47:34distance light can travel in 1 year. We
- 47:36can actually see a little bit further.
- 47:38More like 45 billion light years. So,
- 47:41you can think about this as here we are.
- 47:43We look out billions of light years that
- 47:45way, billions of light years that way,
- 47:47billions of light years in every
- 47:49direction. And this is like a big sphere
- 47:51that surrounds us, and we're measuring
- 47:53its temperature, the temperature of
- 47:55space, the photons that have traveled to
- 47:57us from about 300,000 years after the
- 48:01beginning. So, this picture is a
- 48:04snapshot, in essence, of what the
- 48:07universe was like a mere moment, in
- 48:10cosmological terms, 300,000 years after
- 48:13the beginning.
- 48:14That is an amazing picture.
- 48:17>> And what's beyond?
- 48:19>> I don't know. I don't have any reason to
- 48:21suspect that reality radically changes
- 48:25just beyond the place that we can see. I
- 48:28think it's incredibly unlikely that the
- 48:31world is so consistent with our
- 48:34scientific understanding for it to all
- 48:37be a ruse.
- 48:39>> So, is it infinite?
- 48:41>> It could be.
- 48:42And if it is infinite, there are some
- 48:44really weird things, if what we have
- 48:47been talking about isn't weird enough,
- 48:49right? You know, if the universe is
- 48:52infinite, if you go sufficiently far out
- 48:54into space,
- 48:55you're virtually guaranteed
- 48:57to find a copy of yourself out there.
- 49:00And a copy of the Earth out there. And a
- 49:03copy of our galaxy out there.
- 49:07It's virtually impossible to imagine a
- 49:09universe that goes on infinitely far and
- 49:12doesn't repeat. You know, in fact, I see
- 49:14a prop here. I can sort of tell you why,
- 49:16right? So, here's a deck of cards,
- 49:18right? And I think it's a new deck,
- 49:21yeah. So, everything is in order, right?
- 49:23It's all perfectly ordered like that.
- 49:25Now, if I was to take this deck of cards
- 49:27and I start to shuffle it, right? So,
- 49:30you know, I'm not a particularly good
- 49:31shuffler, but you know, you get the
- 49:33basic idea. You know, I keep shuffling,
- 49:36and of course, the order changes
- 49:38every time, right? So, if I now, you
- 49:40know, I'm not a great shuffler, so
- 49:41there're probably still, you know, some
- 49:43things that are still, you know, in
- 49:44numerical order, but it's more mixed up
- 49:47than it was before. And I can keep on
- 49:48doing this. Now, sooner or later,
- 49:52if I continue to shuffle these cards
- 49:54over and over and over and over and over
- 49:56and over again, sooner or later, it will
- 49:58get back to the completely ordered
- 50:00arrangement. Why? Because there aren't
- 50:03enough different arrangements to go
- 50:05around, right? That idea applies in the
- 50:08universe in the following way. In any
- 50:11region of space, there are particles.
- 50:13Those particles can be arranged in a
- 50:15variety of different ways. Here, they're
- 50:17arranged so that you and I are sitting
- 50:19at this table, and we've got the cameras
- 50:20and everything. This is just a particle
- 50:22arrangement.
- 50:23There are only a finite number of
- 50:25arrangements of particles in a given
- 50:27region of space. This you can establish
- 50:29from the laws of quantum physics. So, if
- 50:31you go out far enough in space, region
- 50:33by region by region, the particles will
- 50:35have different arrangements, but they
- 50:36have to repeat, much like the order of
- 50:38the cards has to repeat.
- 50:40So, there has to be a place out there.
- 50:42In fact, if it goes on infinitely far,
- 50:44if you imagine I shuffle these cards
- 50:46infinitely many times,
- 50:48I'll get that nice ordered arrangement
- 50:51infinitely many times, too. Similarly,
- 50:54there are infinitely many copies of you,
- 50:57of me, of everything we're familiar with
- 50:59out there in the cosmos. And so, if the
- 51:02universe is infinite, it kind of
- 51:04challenges a little bit our sense of
- 51:06self.
- 51:07Right? Like, what does it mean to be who
- 51:09you are if there other versions of you
- 51:12having the exact same thoughts,
- 51:14they had the same childhood,
- 51:16they had the same history, because,
- 51:18again, that's just an arrangement of
- 51:20particles over time, and it has to
- 51:22repeat.
- 51:24>> There's a version out there of me that
- 51:25just loves wine.
- 51:27>> There you go, right? In fact, it's even
- 51:30easier, I should say,
- 51:31for the particle arrangement to almost,
- 51:34but not quite, exactly replicate what
- 51:38we're familiar with. Which would mean
- 51:40there's a universe out there in which
- 51:42you and I are interchanged, or you grew
- 51:45up in New York City, and I grew up
- 51:48something Yeah, cuz those are again
- 51:50almost replications. You got the earth,
- 51:52you got the sun, but the detail particle
- 51:54arrangement is close to but not
- 51:56identical to what we are used to. So,
- 51:59yeah, an infinite universe
- 52:01brings in some fairly strange ideas.
- 52:06>> But even in the observable universe, I
- 52:07mean this transitions nicely to the
- 52:08subject of aliens, which people are um
- 52:10Yeah, very obsessed about. I guess
- 52:11there's two questions here, which is why
- 52:13do we care so much, I guess
- 52:14philosophically, about aliens?
- 52:17>> You know, I think we, at least in this
- 52:19country and elsewhere, too,
- 52:21we love the idea of conspiracy. We love
- 52:24the idea that the deep state is hiding
- 52:27things from us. And by we, I don't mean
- 52:29me, I certainly mean the zeitgeist, you
- 52:32know, loves the idea of this Area 51.
- 52:34You know, so I think there's a a a
- 52:36a desire for there to be more than
- 52:40what's apparent on the surface. And
- 52:42wouldn't it be exciting if, you know,
- 52:45we've long known that there are these
- 52:47aliens, they visited us, and it's been
- 52:50kept under wraps. That's like the deep
- 52:52conspiracy. That feeds that hunger for
- 52:55there to be something that's being
- 52:57hidden from us. Now, I think the other
- 52:59reason is we're deeply lonely
- 53:02as a species. Sure, we've got people
- 53:05around, but, you know, I think this
- 53:07sense, the desire for a god, I don't
- 53:10think it's that much different from the
- 53:12desire for there to be other life out
- 53:14there. It's the desire to be part of
- 53:16something bigger. Now, if you ask me, do
- 53:19I think there are actually other life
- 53:21forms out there?
- 53:23I'd like to think of it in two ways.
- 53:24One, yeah, I think it's hard to imagine
- 53:27that we're the only life. I mean, the
- 53:29more we look, the more we find the
- 53:31organic molecules necessary for life,
- 53:33you know, amino acids, nucleic acids,
- 53:36you know, the the raw material seems to
- 53:40not be too hard to come by in the
- 53:42cosmos. So, to imagine that there's
- 53:44other, you know, bacterial life or
- 53:47viruses out there, that seems to me a
- 53:50reasonable working hypothesis.
- 53:53But, if you then say, "But, what about
- 53:54intelligent life?" And by intelligent
- 53:57life, let's just call us intelligent.
- 53:59And then, it's debatable, but let's just
- 54:01say that. You know, that is a harder
- 54:03question. I mean, even on our planet,
- 54:06right? It was an asteroid 65 million
- 54:08years ago that wiped out the dinosaurs.
- 54:11And in that way, opened up the
- 54:14evolutionary pathway by which we came to
- 54:17dominate in the way that we do. Without
- 54:20that, it could still be the dinosaurs
- 54:22are grazing around on various plant life
- 54:26and other life forms on the surface of
- 54:28this Earth. And without that kind of
- 54:30accident on some other world, maybe
- 54:32intelligent life is rare or even so rare
- 54:35that we're the only example. So, I don't
- 54:38consider that an absurd perspective as
- 54:41well, that there is life, but there may
- 54:43not be any intelligence beyond us.
- 54:47>> Much of the reason most people haven't
- 54:49posted content or built their personal
- 54:50brand is because it's hard and it's
- 54:52time-consuming. And we're all very, very
- 54:54busy. And if you've never posted
- 54:56something before,
- 54:57there's so many factors in your
- 54:59psychology that stop you wanting to
- 55:01post. What people will think of you. Am
- 55:03I doing this right? Is the thing I'm
- 55:04saying absolutely stupid? All of these
- 55:07result in paralysis, which means you
- 55:09don't post and your feed goes bad.
- 55:12I'm an investor in a company called Stan
- 55:14Store, which you've probably heard me
- 55:15talk about. And what they've been
- 55:16building is this new tool called Stanley
- 55:18that uses AI, looks at your feed, looks
- 55:20at your tone of voice, looks at your
- 55:22history, looks at your best performing
- 55:23posts, and tells you what you should
- 55:25post, makes those posts for you. You can
- 55:27also you just use it for inspiration.
- 55:29And sometimes, what we need when we're
- 55:31thinking about doing a post for our
- 55:32social media channels is inspiration.
- 55:34Building an audience has fundamentally
- 55:36changed my life. And I think it could
- 55:38change yours, too. So, I'm inviting you
- 55:40to give this new tool a shot and let me
- 55:42know what you think. All you have to do
- 55:44is search coach.stand.store
- 55:46now to get started. Whenever I talk to
- 55:48any founders, they all carry the same
- 55:49belief that the biggest threat to their
- 55:51small business is having a bad product.
- 55:53It's not. The biggest threat they face
- 55:55is hiring the wrong person for their
- 55:56small team because bad hires put the
- 55:59handbrake on growth and rapidly infect
- 56:01company culture. And I get it. When
- 56:03you're starting out, you need A-players
- 56:05your company, but you don't have 40
- 56:06spare hours to spend sifting through
- 56:08interviews. So, you hire fast to fill
- 56:10the seat, but this ends up costing you
- 56:12even more in the long term. What any
- 56:13small business actually needs is a
- 56:15reliable and efficient way to find the
- 56:16right talent without stalling momentum.
- 56:18That's where our long-term sponsor
- 56:20LinkedIn and LinkedIn Hiring Pro can
- 56:22help you. It streamlines the entire
- 56:23hiring process from drafting a job
- 56:25description to shortlisting candidates
- 56:27and conducting AI-powered interviews for
- 56:29initial screenings. Nearly 60% of hirers
- 56:32who've used this tool have found a
- 56:33candidate to interview within a week.
- 56:35Hire right the first time around. And
- 56:37get started by posting your first job
- 56:39for free at linkedin.com/doac.
- 56:42That's linkedin.com/doac.
- 56:44And terms and conditions apply.
- 56:46If one of your children came to you and
- 56:48said, "Dad, um
- 56:49what is the what is the meaning then of
- 56:51this life? If we're we're alone in this
- 56:52universe, it's a gazillion miles away
- 56:54from anything interesting in the cosmic
- 56:56spectrum of things, what is the meaning
- 56:58of all of this, Dad?"
- 56:59>> Yeah, well, they do ask.
- 57:00>> Oh, they do.
- 57:01>> You know, um unfortunately or
- 57:03fortunately, because I spend a lot of
- 57:05time thinking about this stuff and
- 57:06writing about it, I'm sort of in in the
- 57:08familial zeitgeist at home, if you will.
- 57:11But, you know, my answer generally is I
- 57:14don't think that hovering out there in
- 57:16the depths of space
- 57:18there is the answer.
- 57:21You know, I I think, you know, this this
- 57:23urge to look out and have the answer
- 57:26brought to us, I think that's
- 57:30needs to be inverted. I think that we
- 57:32need to come to the universe with our
- 57:35answer to that. And I think the charge
- 57:38of every sentient living being is to
- 57:41come to their own rationale for their
- 57:45life, their own answer to your question,
- 57:49their own set of activities and desires
- 57:52and achievements and relationships that
- 57:55gives their life meaning
- 57:57and combine to make me feel connected.
- 58:01>> One of the things that does make me feel
- 58:02connected is just knowing that the
- 58:05particles that I'm made out of existed
- 58:07at the Big Bang.
- 58:08>> Yes, exactly. Isn't that wondrous?
- 58:12You
- 58:14are the universe constructed in a way
- 58:17that you can reflect on the universe.
- 58:21Now, some would say, "No, no, no, we're
- 58:23special. We're like these divine
- 58:26offspring, you know, made in the image
- 58:28of God." And sure, I mean, I like the
- 58:31way that that sounds, but I find it much
- 58:33more satisfying to describe it the way
- 58:36you did.
- 58:37There were particles that emerged from
- 58:38the Big Bang that coalesce into a form
- 58:41that allowed us to momentarily, cuz
- 58:44we're here for a brief flicker of cosmic
- 58:46time, to momentarily reflect on our own
- 58:49existence. That's a connection.
- 58:51>> One of the things that actually helped
- 58:52me a lot through my life, funnily
- 58:53enough, is
- 58:54is kind of watching what you just showed
- 58:56on the screen there, which was I watched
- 58:58a video when I was younger of them just
- 58:59zooming out from Earth. Yeah. And we
- 59:02talked about feeling insignificant
- 59:04earlier. I mean, there's some of them
- 59:05here. I'll just pick one at random, like
- 59:07this one here. Well, it's just a a lady
- 59:09sat on some grass and
- 59:11she zooms out further and further and
- 59:12further. And when I saw this, I must
- 59:13have been, hmm, it was a video like this
- 59:16one. I must have been about 14 years
- 59:17old. And at first I had the thought that
- 59:19a lot of people might have, which was,
- 59:20"Oh, like none of this matters because
- 59:22we're so insignificant on the grand
- 59:24scheme of things that like what's the
- 59:26point?" And then I I had this other
- 59:28thought which has stayed with me ever
- 59:29since which is
- 59:33it liberated me from worry.
- 59:35>> Yeah.
- 59:36>> Because if if all of my worries are just
- 59:38a speck
- 59:40in this bigger thing which are a speck
- 59:42in a bigger thing and a speck in a
- 59:43bigger thing it meant that I could
- 59:46take more risks in my life.
- 59:47>> Yeah.
- 59:48>> And not be encumbered by what will
- 59:50happen if and what will people think and
- 59:51etc. etc. etc. which kind of liberates
- 59:54one to go and pursue whatever they want
- 59:55to pursue.
- 59:56>> Yeah. Carl Sagan with the pale blue dot,
- 59:59you know, if you're familiar with that
- 1:00:00terminology. He He had the Viking
- 1:00:03spacecraft when it was going by Saturn
- 1:00:09turn around and take a shot of planet
- 1:00:13Earth through the gossamer rings of
- 1:00:15Saturn. And in that photo the Earth is
- 1:00:18this little tiny pale blue speck sort of
- 1:00:21as we saw in the film as it went by
- 1:00:23there. And he in this wonderfully poetic
- 1:00:26passage described how everything we care
- 1:00:29about, everything we love, everything we
- 1:00:31fight, the rivers of blood that has been
- 1:00:34spilled to conquer a tiny little
- 1:00:37fraction of a pixel in space that gives
- 1:00:42you a setting
- 1:00:44where the concerns that you're
- 1:00:46mentioning of an individual human life,
- 1:00:48of of countries, of nations, you realize
- 1:00:51how utterly small it is in the
- 1:00:54cosmological setting. And again, that to
- 1:00:57me isn't insignificance as you were
- 1:00:59saying, it's liberation.
- 1:01:01>> We have this um
- 1:01:03>> [clears throat]
- 1:01:03>> this spectrum of I guess confidence
- 1:01:05>> Yeah.
- 1:01:05>> in front of us here and on one end of it
- 1:01:07it says low confidence on this end it
- 1:01:09has high confidence. And there's five
- 1:01:12little figurine type things there next
- 1:01:14to you. What I would like you to do is
- 1:01:16to place them in line with your
- 1:01:18confidence that the thing is real. So
- 1:01:20the first one that I'm going to ask you
- 1:01:21to place is those mini scales which
- 1:01:22represent free will.
- 1:01:24>> This guy here, free will?
- 1:01:25>> Yes, that's free will. Do you think
- 1:01:26humans have free will? Are you low
- 1:01:28confidence or high confidence? I'll push
- 1:01:30it over there for you towards you so you
- 1:01:30can
- 1:01:31>> Uh well, uh I do not think we have free
- 1:01:34will.
- 1:01:35And I
- 1:01:37have high confidence in that assessment,
- 1:01:40which I guess means low confidence that
- 1:01:41we have free will.
- 1:01:43>> What is free will?
- 1:01:44>> To me, free will is really just the
- 1:01:46everyday
- 1:01:48sense that you are the ultimate author
- 1:01:51of your actions. That the buck stops
- 1:01:54with you when it comes to the decisions
- 1:01:57that you make for how you are going to
- 1:01:59respond one way or another in the
- 1:02:01moment-to-moment existence of life. I
- 1:02:04don't think that freedom of the will is
- 1:02:07real.
- 1:02:08And I can give you a quick sense why. It
- 1:02:11really is an extension of everything
- 1:02:13that we've already spoken about, which
- 1:02:15is
- 1:02:16you know, when I look at you,
- 1:02:18I see a man.
- 1:02:20But I also imagine that I'm looking
- 1:02:23inside you and I see your particles.
- 1:02:25And so you are a man-shaped collection
- 1:02:28of particles. That is what you are.
- 1:02:31And each of those particles and the
- 1:02:34agglomeration of those particles are
- 1:02:36fully governed by the laws of physics. I
- 1:02:39don't say that we have those laws yet.
- 1:02:41We have an approximation to them with
- 1:02:43Schrödinger and Einstein and all those
- 1:02:44folks, but I do believe that there is an
- 1:02:46ultimate set of principles that guide
- 1:02:50how your particles behave. You do not
- 1:02:54have the capacity
- 1:02:56to intercede in the lawful progression
- 1:02:58of your particles. So, if you raise your
- 1:03:01hand,
- 1:03:02it is not you who's doing that. It is
- 1:03:05the laws of physics guiding the
- 1:03:07particles in your brain, sending
- 1:03:09electrical signal down your arm, causing
- 1:03:11your muscle to contract or expand,
- 1:03:13resulting in your hand going up.
- 1:03:15You don't control the laws that govern
- 1:03:18those particles. You don't control the
- 1:03:19laws that govern those particles. You
- 1:03:20don't control the laws that govern those
- 1:03:21>> You felt that you did. And so the
- 1:03:23feeling that you and I and everyone else
- 1:03:26have that we make decisions and those
- 1:03:29decisions result in our action, it's a
- 1:03:31powerful, it's a seductive sensibility.
- 1:03:34But no, I do not think that you are the
- 1:03:37place where that choice, if you will,
- 1:03:40occurred. The choice is actually within
- 1:03:44the lawful unfolding of the particles.
- 1:03:46And I can't control that particle
- 1:03:48motion. Therefore, I can't control the
- 1:03:51decision. Therefore, I don't control the
- 1:03:53motion of my arm.
- 1:03:54>> Therefore, I don't control my life?
- 1:03:56>> You don't, in some sense. If you buy
- 1:03:58into it
- 1:03:59fully, [snorts]
- 1:04:00it can be paralyzing. Or you can
- 1:04:03recognize it, which I do,
- 1:04:05and I say, "Okay, within that structure,
- 1:04:08I'm going to live my life as fully as I
- 1:04:10can. And I am able, not always, cuz I'm
- 1:04:14a human being, but in the best of
- 1:04:16moments I can pull back
- 1:04:18and have a certain objectivity
- 1:04:20about the things that happen in my life.
- 1:04:24And I observe them
- 1:04:27at a remove, as opposed to being
- 1:04:29completely wrapped up in the
- 1:04:32moment-to-moment. Now, that doesn't make
- 1:04:34me an aloof person, it doesn't make me
- 1:04:37somebody who somehow is detached. No.
- 1:04:40It's just I can analyze the world at
- 1:04:42multiple levels.
- 1:04:44>> So, who is and what is guiding those
- 1:04:46particles to make the decisions that
- 1:04:47those particles are making?
- 1:04:49>> The best I can say, and I think the best
- 1:04:51that we can say right now is that there
- 1:04:54is some body of law. Now, what does that
- 1:04:57mean, a body of law? There is some
- 1:05:01patterns that repeat in the world. Now,
- 1:05:05you drop an apple and it falls on
- 1:05:08Newton's head repeatedly. You can rely
- 1:05:11upon certain kinds of particle motion
- 1:05:14because there's certain regularities in
- 1:05:16the world. And the regularities in the
- 1:05:19world are what I mean by the laws of
- 1:05:20physics.
- 1:05:22They may be articulated mathematically.
- 1:05:24Our best guess is as of today that math
- 1:05:27is the best language we have for
- 1:05:29describing those laws, but out there, I
- 1:05:32think there are some fundamental
- 1:05:33patterns.
- 1:05:35And those patterns ultimately are what
- 1:05:37determine how the particles move.
- 1:05:40And so that's all that we are. We are a
- 1:05:43body of particles that move, and that's
- 1:05:45responsible for why things do what they
- 1:05:48do. And remarkably,
- 1:05:50our brains allow us to self-reflect,
- 1:05:53to look at what we do and analyze it.
- 1:05:55And when we do that, we tend to ascribe
- 1:05:57authorship
- 1:05:59to ourselves.
- 1:06:01But that's a story that we tell
- 1:06:03ourselves. It makes us feel good. It
- 1:06:05makes us feel part of the unfolding. It
- 1:06:08perhaps has an evolutionary utility,
- 1:06:11that if you feel responsible for what
- 1:06:13you're doing, maybe it helps you to
- 1:06:15survive. Maybe that's why this way of
- 1:06:17thinking was inculcated over the course
- 1:06:19of generation upon generation. Maybe
- 1:06:21there's an evolutionary explanation, but
- 1:06:23fundamentally speaking, I don't think
- 1:06:24it's real.
- 1:06:25>> I was going to say then, well, maybe the
- 1:06:27the particles are trying to survive in
- 1:06:30this form. But even as I thought about
- 1:06:32that, I thought, so maybe my particles
- 1:06:34are making the decisions they make to
- 1:06:36raise my hand, to go on a holiday with
- 1:06:38my fiance, to have kids because they
- 1:06:42want to survive in this form. But
- 1:06:44actually, I disappear at some point.
- 1:06:46>> Yes.
- 1:06:47>> But my particles don't.
- 1:06:48>> Right.
- 1:06:48>> They then become dirt or someone else or
- 1:06:50whatever or child. It doesn't seem that
- 1:06:52they care much about necessarily being
- 1:06:54in this form.
- 1:06:54>> They don't. I don't think they do. So, I
- 1:06:57don't think they care. I don't even
- 1:06:58think the word care is applicable to
- 1:07:01them. The notion of caring is a
- 1:07:04high-level construct that only emerges
- 1:07:07when the particles are configured
- 1:07:10sufficiently to yield a complex
- 1:07:11information processing system called a
- 1:07:13human brain.
- 1:07:14>> And consciousness.
- 1:07:15>> And consciousness. Now, if you ask me
- 1:07:17where consciousness comes from, I don't
- 1:07:18know. So as you discussed before, I
- 1:07:20think it's just physical processes.
- 1:07:21Let's go with that. Assuming that's the
- 1:07:23case, this conscious self-awareness
- 1:07:26invents the idea of caring
- 1:07:29because it's a useful concept for us to
- 1:07:31organize our lives and our experiences.
- 1:07:34This conscious self-awareness and that
- 1:07:36invents all the other words, happy, sad,
- 1:07:39meaning, purpose, morality, activity,
- 1:07:43action, choice, decision, freedom, will,
- 1:07:45all human-made. These concepts don't
- 1:07:49exist out there in the universe. There's
- 1:07:51no notion of freedom of the will
- 1:07:53floating in space outside the Andromeda
- 1:07:56galaxy. This is a selection of ideas
- 1:08:01that we humans as a species have found
- 1:08:04to give us utilitarian advantage in
- 1:08:08organizing our experiences. That's all
- 1:08:12that it is. That doesn't diminish it. I
- 1:08:14don't go around trying to erase my sense
- 1:08:19of self. I accept my sense of self, but
- 1:08:21I also see it for what it is,
- 1:08:24a human construct.
- 1:08:26>> Does that mean that consciousness and
- 1:08:27everything that I am could theoretically
- 1:08:29just be as you said earlier in the sort
- 1:08:31of
- 1:08:32pessimistic version of events
- 1:08:35random, totally random. Like
- 1:08:37consciousness itself was just the
- 1:08:39particles came together over a long
- 1:08:40enough period of time and then they they
- 1:08:41found this form and now I can
- 1:08:42>> It could and maybe it was random and
- 1:08:45happened only once on this planet,
- 1:08:48right? I mean, again, maybe there is
- 1:08:50life out there and maybe there's even
- 1:08:52complex life out there. Maybe even life
- 1:08:54as big as us or bigger, but maybe when
- 1:08:57we encounter those life forms
- 1:08:59they have no idea of what it means to
- 1:09:03have an inner world.
- 1:09:04>> This um I think it was a physicist said
- 1:09:05to me that
- 1:09:07it was a bit of a spiritual esoteric
- 1:09:09idea, but they basically said to me that
- 1:09:11they think consciousness could be they
- 1:09:12could come from this sort of original
- 1:09:14source and it's divided itself up into
- 1:09:16the humans, the bees, the birds to
- 1:09:19go out there and understand the nature
- 1:09:21of the universe.
- 1:09:22>> Yeah.
- 1:09:22>> And then when we die we kind of return
- 1:09:23to the source, but you know, I'll give
- 1:09:25birth to a baby, they'll go off into
- 1:09:26different corners of the the earth and
- 1:09:28look at different things and have
- 1:09:30different experiences and it's all
- 1:09:31feeding back into the central
- 1:09:32consciousness which is sole objective is
- 1:09:34to understand itself and it's funny cuz
- 1:09:36I heard this idea from this physicist
- 1:09:38and then I I was in a somewhere in
- 1:09:40Europe and I was driving down the road
- 1:09:43and I saw one of these tourists just
- 1:09:44like looking up at a mountain
- 1:09:46and they're just like looking out at the
- 1:09:47sea and they were looking at things that
- 1:09:49were interesting sure which is what we
- 1:09:50do as humans. Yeah, I thought kind of
- 1:09:52makes sense.
- 1:09:53>> Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:09:53>> But we're like we're actually just like
- 1:09:55consciousness is its own philosophical
- 1:09:57position called idealism. And idealism
- 1:10:00holds that the fundamental truth of
- 1:10:04reality is consciousness, but
- 1:10:07fundamentally everything that I've seen
- 1:10:10throughout my life suggests to me that
- 1:10:12that's not how it is. I can't prove it.
- 1:10:14I hope it's true, but if you ask me what
- 1:10:16I think is really true, I think that
- 1:10:18consciousness is something that emerges
- 1:10:21when there's a sufficient amount of
- 1:10:23information processing that itself is
- 1:10:26carried by the motion of particles
- 1:10:28through various interconnected
- 1:10:30structures.
- 1:10:31>> Is my dog conscious?
- 1:10:32>> It is, but I think it's got a different
- 1:10:34level of consciousness. You can tell
- 1:10:37when they're feeling good, happy or sad
- 1:10:40or frustrated or intrigued. The ears
- 1:10:44change, the eyes change, the shape of
- 1:10:45the face you can't help but ascribe an
- 1:10:48inner world to that. And again, I always
- 1:10:51worry that the dogs like the fish or
- 1:10:52like these humans think they're so damn
- 1:10:54special, but we actually are well
- 1:10:56developed well beyond that. I mean,
- 1:10:58we're just playing along. In fact, in
- 1:10:59New York City, who picks up the poop,
- 1:11:01right? We pick up the poop. So, the dog
- 1:11:03walks along is like this, you know,
- 1:11:05king-like being, and we behind them with
- 1:11:07these little plastic bags. So, who's
- 1:11:09really in charge? But, putting that to
- 1:11:10the side, I do think that the dogs and
- 1:11:13the cats have a level of conscious
- 1:11:15awareness. And I think you go down
- 1:11:18through the animal kingdom. If you were
- 1:11:20to ask me, does an insect have
- 1:11:22consciousness? Mhm. Then, I'm less
- 1:11:24clear. I suspect not. If you ask me
- 1:11:27whether a virus or a bacterium has
- 1:11:30consciousness, I don't think so. I don't
- 1:11:32think there's adequate information
- 1:11:34processing capacity in those structures
- 1:11:37to have the kind of rich inner world
- 1:11:39that we would normally ascribe to a
- 1:11:41conscious being. But, that's all that I
- 1:11:43think it is. I don't think that there's
- 1:11:45some
- 1:11:46uber universal consciousness that's out
- 1:11:49there that we go back to when we die.
- 1:11:51Not that I wouldn't like it. I just
- 1:11:53don't think it's true. Moreover,
- 1:11:56I can understand why humans would
- 1:11:57introduce this idea. Again, it's Ernest
- 1:12:00Becker and the denial of death. How
- 1:12:01wonderful to say, "Yeah, our bodies die,
- 1:12:04sure.
- 1:12:06But, our consciousness, it doesn't die.
- 1:12:08Our consciousness, it floats off and it
- 1:12:11rejoins the universal con-
- 1:12:13Wow. That makes you feel good. And we
- 1:12:17tell these stories that make us feel
- 1:12:19good, and there's nothing wrong with
- 1:12:20that. However, I do think it's important
- 1:12:23that we see them for what they are,
- 1:12:25which are human-authored stories to
- 1:12:27combat our own recognition that we are
- 1:12:30mortal beings.
- 1:12:32>> Moving on to the next one is the
- 1:12:34universe there on the little card. We
- 1:12:36talked about this a little bit, and
- 1:12:37you've given your answer already, but do
- 1:12:38you think the universe is infinite?
- 1:12:41>> I don't know, but I'm going to put it
- 1:12:43sort of around here. You know, in fact,
- 1:12:46lately, I should tell you, the work that
- 1:12:48I've been doing has imagined that the
- 1:12:50universe is not infinite. So, I've been
- 1:12:52doing a lot of scientific exploration
- 1:12:55with mathematics with a handful of
- 1:12:57colleagues and the kind of weird things
- 1:12:59that can happen if it's not infinite.
- 1:13:01And it's very interesting. There's a lot
- 1:13:04of mileage that you can extract from a
- 1:13:07universe that you go off in that way and
- 1:13:09you wind up coming back to your starting
- 1:13:11point much like you would on the surface
- 1:13:12of the earth. It's a finite extent. But
- 1:13:15if you ask me in my heart of hearts, if
- 1:13:17I was forced to make a choice, I would
- 1:13:19say infinite with a medium level of
- 1:13:22confidence.
- 1:13:22>> What about do you think life could exist
- 1:13:27outside of earth? And I'll say
- 1:13:28intelligent life.
- 1:13:29>> Intelligent life.
- 1:13:30>> Do you think intelligent life exists
- 1:13:32outside of earth?
- 1:13:32>> Yeah, so for intelligent aliens, I'm
- 1:13:35going to definitely go a little bit more
- 1:13:38over here. You know, I put it as uh it's
- 1:13:41possible. Obviously, it happened once.
- 1:13:44Therefore, it could happen again. You
- 1:13:45know, obviously, intelligence is not
- 1:13:47somehow contradictory to the way the
- 1:13:49universe evolves. It can support
- 1:13:51conscious and intelligent beings. But I
- 1:13:54think it may be special.
- 1:13:55>> Is there not a bit of a contradiction
- 1:13:57here though with these two things that
- 1:13:58you think the universe is infinite?
- 1:14:00>> Oh, when I say this, I should say
- 1:14:03within the observable universe.
- 1:14:04>> Oh, okay.
- 1:14:05>> Yeah. So, in the entire expanse of the
- 1:14:08universe as opposed to the observable
- 1:14:09part, which again is a part that even in
- 1:14:11principle we could have connection with,
- 1:14:14then yeah, I would absolutely put it in
- 1:14:16exactly the same place because there'd
- 1:14:18be copies of us out there. But if we
- 1:14:20talk instead about are we going to get a
- 1:14:24signal?
- 1:14:25Are we going to be visited? Then I put
- 1:14:28that at much lower confidence. And in
- 1:14:31fact, I I would say one thing about the
- 1:14:32visitation because you mentioned the
- 1:14:35interest that people have on aliens.
- 1:14:38I find it really odd that people are
- 1:14:41taken with these photographs
- 1:14:44that are meant to sort of just catch the
- 1:14:47alien ship as it was racing. If an alien
- 1:14:51could travel across the galaxy, say, to
- 1:14:54reach us, they are so technologically
- 1:14:57advanced that the idea that our archaic
- 1:15:02airplanes and their cameras could
- 1:15:04capture a photograph of them is
- 1:15:06ludicrous. They will be able to evade us
- 1:15:10in so simply that the idea that we just
- 1:15:13barely caught them on our cameras is is
- 1:15:15absolutely ridiculous. Moreover,
- 1:15:18if they could travel to us,
- 1:15:20again, I'm talking about traveling
- 1:15:22across light-years, right? I mean, our
- 1:15:24galaxy, 100,000 light-years end to end,
- 1:15:28right? To be able to traverse that
- 1:15:30requires a level of technological
- 1:15:32sophistication that is so beyond
- 1:15:34anything that we can do.
- 1:15:36To imagine that beings that advanced
- 1:15:39would be interested in us,
- 1:15:42so interested that they would like
- 1:15:43kidnap us?
- 1:15:45That'd be like saying, "I was walking to
- 1:15:48the park yesterday.
- 1:15:51Don't tell anyone, but I kidnapped an
- 1:15:53ant." There's an ant walking along and
- 1:15:56nobody was looking and I sort of
- 1:15:58kidnapped it to
- 1:16:00We don't do that because it's not
- 1:16:01interesting. Similarly, we would not be
- 1:16:04of interest to the aliens because
- 1:16:06they're so incredibly advanced that this
- 1:16:09idea that they're abducting us is just
- 1:16:12ludicrous.
- 1:16:15>> Is it going to be possible, you know, we
- 1:16:16were talking earlier on about the the
- 1:16:17possibilities that artificial
- 1:16:18intelligence is going to unlock? Is it
- 1:16:20possible within the laws of physics for
- 1:16:22us at some point, when we get
- 1:16:24sufficiently intelligent, to travel
- 1:16:26across the universe?
- 1:16:28>> It's a It's a It's a great question.
- 1:16:30It's a tough one. So,
- 1:16:33if
- 1:16:34the technological advancement was simply
- 1:16:36making our ships faster, no. Because
- 1:16:39even if you travel near the speed of
- 1:16:41light, which is the ultimate speed
- 1:16:43limit.
- 1:16:44You know, to go to the nearest star,
- 1:16:47Alpha Centauri, it would take you 4
- 1:16:49years, even at the speed of light, to
- 1:16:51get there, right? And then if you
- 1:16:53actually want to go not just to the
- 1:16:54nearby star, but actually across the
- 1:16:57galaxy, again you're talking 100,000
- 1:16:59years to do that. So, that
- 1:17:03brute, straightforward approach will not
- 1:17:05succeed. However, there are exotic ideas
- 1:17:08of things called wormholes. You've
- 1:17:11probably encountered these. These ideas
- 1:17:13of A wormhole is like a tunnel. What is
- 1:17:16a tunnel?
- 1:17:17On Earth, a tunnel is a shortcut that
- 1:17:20gets you from here to here without
- 1:17:21having to go over the mountain, right?
- 1:17:23Tunnel it right through.
- 1:17:25There's an analogous idea that people
- 1:17:27float in the universe, where to get from
- 1:17:29here to there, there may be a shortcut,
- 1:17:32a kind of tunnel that connects them and
- 1:17:34is a quicker way of getting from point A
- 1:17:36to point B.
- 1:17:37We don't know if these tunnels through
- 1:17:39space exist. We don't know if they
- 1:17:41existed, whether we could actually get
- 1:17:43through them. And so it's a highly
- 1:17:45speculative idea. But if they do exist,
- 1:17:48and if we one day can create them and
- 1:17:51manipulate and control them, then at
- 1:17:53least in principle, we could take two
- 1:17:55distant locations like this corner and
- 1:17:58this corner. But imagine that we could
- 1:18:00manipulate this surface, fold it
- 1:18:03together to bring the two corners next
- 1:18:05to each other, and build a little tunnel
- 1:18:08between them. Then we can go from one
- 1:18:10end to the other by going through that
- 1:18:11shortcut. That's
- 1:18:14a very far-out idea.
- 1:18:16>> no evidence of it.
- 1:18:16>> There's no evidence at all. Now, now,
- 1:18:18let me just say again, much as we
- 1:18:20discussed earlier, this idea is not just
- 1:18:23some wild, late-night musing of a
- 1:18:26physicist. It comes out of the math of
- 1:18:29Einstein's general relativity, that
- 1:18:31these wormholes could exist. In fact,
- 1:18:33Einstein himself, in 1935,
- 1:18:36wrote a paper with a colleague Nathan
- 1:18:38Rosen
- 1:18:39where they introduced this idea that we
- 1:18:41now call wormholes. We're no further
- 1:18:43along in knowing whether wormholes are
- 1:18:45real than Einstein was back then. We've
- 1:18:47analyzed and we've developed the
- 1:18:48mathematics. You know, science fiction
- 1:18:51has taken this idea. You know, I In
- 1:18:54Interstellar, I believe Matthew
- 1:18:56McConaughey goes through a wormhole.
- 1:18:58Jodie Foster went through one in
- 1:19:01Contact. You know, they're they're a
- 1:19:03ubiquitous feature of science fiction
- 1:19:06trying to allow for the kinds of travel
- 1:19:09across the galaxy that otherwise would
- 1:19:10be impossible. But whether this is
- 1:19:13actually real, no nobody knows.
- 1:19:15>> What about time travel?
- 1:19:17>> Yeah.
- 1:19:17>> Can can we travel backwards in time
- 1:19:20within the laws of physics?
- 1:19:21>> Yeah, that is the the the way of
- 1:19:23phrasing it. Because if you ask me the
- 1:19:25reverse question, can we travel to the
- 1:19:27future?
- 1:19:29I would say, yeah, that kind of time
- 1:19:30travel we are highly confident of. So I
- 1:19:33don't have a little thing for that. But
- 1:19:35let's call, you know, this is time
- 1:19:36travel to the future, right? I put it
- 1:19:38very, very high confidence for that.
- 1:19:41>> You think we can travel to the future?
- 1:19:42>> Yes, in principle.
- 1:19:44Executing it, a different story. But one
- 1:19:46of the things that emerges from
- 1:19:48Einstein's special and general
- 1:19:50relativity is that the way time elapses
- 1:19:54for you and for me is variable
- 1:19:57depending upon how fast we move and the
- 1:19:59strength of the gravity that we
- 1:20:01experience. So for instance,
- 1:20:03if I want to see what your life would be
- 1:20:05like
- 1:20:0660 years from now.
- 1:20:08Einstein laid out a blueprint for how I
- 1:20:11could do that. I build a spaceship. I
- 1:20:13travel out into space near the speed of
- 1:20:15light.
- 1:20:16I go for a certain period of time, maybe
- 1:20:18about 6 months. I turn around, I come
- 1:20:20back 6 more months. I come back, I'm 1
- 1:20:22year older. 6 months, 6 months. But you
- 1:20:25will be 60 years older if I traveled
- 1:20:29sufficiently close to the speed of light
- 1:20:31because my clock
- 1:20:33would be ticking off slow compared to
- 1:20:35your clock. Your clock went through 60
- 1:20:37years, while my clock
- 1:20:40went through 1 year.
- 1:20:42There is no physicist who knows what
- 1:20:44they are talking about who disputes
- 1:20:46this.
- 1:20:47Now, it's not controversial, but if you
- 1:20:50then say to me, "Well, do it." I'd say,
- 1:20:52"I don't know how to build a spaceship
- 1:20:53that goes that fast, at least not yet."
- 1:20:55>> You would only have aged 1 year.
- 1:20:57>> Correct. But, I would have aged 60.
- 1:20:58>> Correct.
- 1:20:59>> Could you then go back?
- 1:21:00>> Uh
- 1:21:01I don't know.
- 1:21:02And if you were to ask me to give my
- 1:21:04confidence on going back, I would say
- 1:21:06it's pretty pretty low.
- 1:21:08People have written
- 1:21:11proposals for how you could go back.
- 1:21:13They do involve things like wormholes.
- 1:21:15That is one possibility, because if you
- 1:21:18have a have a tunnel from one point in
- 1:21:20space to another, if you then move the
- 1:21:23openings at different speeds, their
- 1:21:25clocks will tick off at different rates.
- 1:21:27This clock may be before this clock. So,
- 1:21:30if I travel this way, I'm going one way
- 1:21:32in time. If I'm traveling that way, I'm
- 1:21:33going the reverse way in time. But
- 1:21:35again, like we said before, we don't
- 1:21:36know if wormholes are real.
- 1:21:38If they are real, you might in principle
- 1:21:40be able to travel back. But, if you ask
- 1:21:42me, do I think that you can? Low, low
- 1:21:44confidence that you can travel back.
- 1:21:46>> You've used the word Einstein a few
- 1:21:47times.
- 1:21:48>> Yeah.
- 1:21:48>> And I think this generation, you know,
- 1:21:50we we exist with AI now and calculators
- 1:21:52and all this incredible knowledge that's
- 1:21:54come from sort of standing on the
- 1:21:56shoulders of so many of these giants.
- 1:21:58Who do you think is the smartest person
- 1:22:00to have ever lived in your estimation?
- 1:22:01>> It's a tough one. People often make it
- 1:22:04an easier question by saying, "Who's
- 1:22:05smarter, Isaac Newton
- 1:22:07or Albert Einstein?"
- 1:22:09And first, my answer is, when you're
- 1:22:11talking about that level, it doesn't
- 1:22:13matter who's smarter. But, if you really
- 1:22:14press me, I think I'd say Isaac Newton.
- 1:22:17Because Newton kind of went from nothing
- 1:22:21to
- 1:22:22develop the laws of physics. There were
- 1:22:25people before, but there wasn't really a
- 1:22:27mindset that the universe should be
- 1:22:31articulable in a few mathematical
- 1:22:33equations. And yet here comes along
- 1:22:35Isaac Newton, and he writes down the
- 1:22:38equation that we teach high school kids
- 1:22:39F = MA, force equals mass times
- 1:22:42acceleration, which governs just about
- 1:22:44everything in the world around us
- 1:22:46non-quantum mechanically.
- 1:22:48He writes down the law of gravity F = G
- 1:22:50M1 M2 over R squared articulating how
- 1:22:54the gravitational force works, and he
- 1:22:55was sort of doing this on he invents
- 1:22:58calculus in order to be able to use that
- 1:23:01as a tool for articulating the laws of
- 1:23:04physics. I mean, he kind of went from no
- 1:23:07real architecture of physics to a solid
- 1:23:12mathematical formulation.
- 1:23:15Einstein came along and there was
- 1:23:16already a lot of physics. I think going
- 1:23:19from nothing to the first step, that's
- 1:23:23hard to imagine.
- 1:23:24>> Was Newton
- 1:23:26to some degree like neurodivergent? How
- 1:23:28could he be so genius?
- 1:23:29>> I wish I knew the answer to a question
- 1:23:31like that. Like, you know, what is it
- 1:23:34inside their heads that allows them to
- 1:23:36do the things that just are superhuman
- 1:23:39or feel superhuman to us? I have no
- 1:23:41idea. Now, Newton was a kind of weird
- 1:23:44fellow, right? He was deeply religious
- 1:23:46as makes sense for the time.
- 1:23:49He was ultimately, you know, in the
- 1:23:51government tracking down counterfeiters
- 1:23:53and and hanging them. I mean,
- 1:23:56there seems to be a certain curmudgeonly
- 1:23:58side of him that was also part of his
- 1:24:02genius.
- 1:24:03Uh he once reportedly took a a knitting
- 1:24:07needle and stuck it in his eye between
- 1:24:10the
- 1:24:11ball and the socket to see if he could
- 1:24:13manipulate sight through mechanical
- 1:24:15pressure. I mean, who does these kinds
- 1:24:17of things, right? So, he's a different
- 1:24:20thinker, but clearly one who ultimately
- 1:24:23was able to see deeper.
- 1:24:25You know, and as you said, you know,
- 1:24:26standing on the shoulders of giants, you
- 1:24:28know, and there was a certain humility
- 1:24:30that came through. I mean, there's a
- 1:24:31beautiful quote where he describes
- 1:24:33himself
- 1:24:34as a boy playing on the seashore, having
- 1:24:37found a smoother shell and prettier
- 1:24:40pebble than most, while the great ocean
- 1:24:43of truth, he said, lay before me all
- 1:24:46undiscovered. He knew that we were just
- 1:24:49on the shore, and we'd taken our first
- 1:24:51baby step into the cosmic ocean, and
- 1:24:54there is much more to be discovered.
- 1:24:57>> Is it conceivable that the next Newton
- 1:24:59or Einstein is going to be
- 1:25:02an artificial intelligence? Could it be
- 1:25:04Claude?
- 1:25:05>> Yes, it could absolutely be. Look,
- 1:25:07I I like to think of scientific
- 1:25:09creativity, or creativity in general, in
- 1:25:11sort of three main buckets. It's a
- 1:25:14coarse organization, but I think it's
- 1:25:15helpful.
- 1:25:16One bucket of creativity is the ability
- 1:25:21to see the landscape of possibilities
- 1:25:23more fully than
- 1:25:26a mortal human being. And there's a lot
- 1:25:29that emerges from the ability to do
- 1:25:32that. For instance, you know, if you're
- 1:25:34a chess player, you you can see the
- 1:25:37spectrum of allowed moves that are
- 1:25:39available to you more than the ordinary
- 1:25:41chess player, you know? If you're a
- 1:25:43scientist, you can sort of see the
- 1:25:45landscape of ideas and equations that
- 1:25:47you might bring to bear on a puzzle more
- 1:25:49than somebody else, and that is what
- 1:25:51allows you to achieve greatness.
- 1:25:54Artificial systems,
- 1:25:55they have the entire landscape, right?
- 1:25:58They've read the entire internet.
- 1:26:00They've read every textbook. They know
- 1:26:03everything that we have ever developed.
- 1:26:05So, in that kind of creativity,
- 1:26:07obviously, they're going to excel, and
- 1:26:10we've seen that.
- 1:26:11A human can't beat an AI any longer in
- 1:26:14chess. A human can't beat an assistant
- 1:26:16in Go, right? I mean this famous
- 1:26:19example with uh AlphaGo, right? Move 37
- 1:26:24has become this sort of iconic move
- 1:26:26where, you know, Lee Sedol, the world
- 1:26:28champion, is playing and you can see it
- 1:26:31on his face. The AI makes a move
- 1:26:34and is he smiles momentarily and he's
- 1:26:36like, "Oh, it messed up."
- 1:26:39And then his face changes.
- 1:26:41Cuz he slowly realizes that wasn't a
- 1:26:43mistake. Even the commentators, if you
- 1:26:45listen to them, they were like, "Oh my
- 1:26:46god, the AI has made a mistake. What a
- 1:26:48blunder the AI has made." And then
- 1:26:51within 20, 30 seconds they're like, "Oh.
- 1:26:53Oh. That was genius." Why? The AI could
- 1:26:58see the spectrum of possibilities more
- 1:27:00than a human being. So, at that level of
- 1:27:02creativity, AI will win. Second bin of
- 1:27:06creativity, second bucket, is putting
- 1:27:08together divergent ideas in a way that
- 1:27:12no one has thought of before and in that
- 1:27:14way making progress. You know, that's
- 1:27:16kind of what Einstein did in general
- 1:27:17relativity. Put together Riemannian
- 1:27:19geometry and Newtonian gravity, yielded
- 1:27:22the general theory of relativity. But
- 1:27:24again, AIs, since they know everything
- 1:27:27that we've ever developed,
- 1:27:29can
- 1:27:31combine things in a way that we would
- 1:27:32never have thought of.
- 1:27:34The final domain is the one where
- 1:27:37somebody comes up with something that
- 1:27:39nobody has ever imagined, ever thought
- 1:27:42of. It's not just putting things
- 1:27:43together, it is radically new.
- 1:27:46That's the tough one. We're still able
- 1:27:49to win in that category. There are
- 1:27:50examples where people just come up with
- 1:27:53things that Where did it come from? How
- 1:27:56did they think of that? If you develop
- 1:27:59an artificial system and allow it to
- 1:28:01have a life,
- 1:28:03allow it to grow up,
- 1:28:05put it in an environment where it
- 1:28:07actually has experiences of the sort
- 1:28:11that an Isaac Newton had. Could it be
- 1:28:14that that system then develops to a
- 1:28:16place where it can do the things that
- 1:28:18we'd like to think are exclusively
- 1:28:21human? Coming up with something that is
- 1:28:23not previously represented in the
- 1:28:27database on which the AI system has
- 1:28:29trained. And so, even this third, more
- 1:28:32difficult or more pristine bucket of
- 1:28:36creativity, could an artificial system
- 1:28:38do the I don't think there's a barrier.
- 1:28:41>> I've done almost 700 interviews with
- 1:28:44some of the most interesting people in
- 1:28:45the world. And one of the things you
- 1:28:46learn, which is unexpected, is that
- 1:28:48vulnerability is the doorway to
- 1:28:50connection. And after sitting here for
- 1:28:522-3 hours with a guest, I feel a deep
- 1:28:55sense of connection to them. And as they
- 1:28:56leave, what I get them to do is to write
- 1:28:59a question in the Diary of a CEO. We've
- 1:29:02taken all of the questions from the
- 1:29:04Diary of a CEO. We have put the question
- 1:29:07here on this card with the name of the
- 1:29:10person that wrote it. So, you can sit at
- 1:29:11home, as I do with my fiance, and my
- 1:29:14colleagues at work, and other people in
- 1:29:15my life, whenever we get a minute, we
- 1:29:17play the Diary of a CEO conversation
- 1:29:19cards. And it is incredible what
- 1:29:22happens. These are great if you're in a
- 1:29:23romantic relationship and you want to
- 1:29:25connect your partner more. These are
- 1:29:26also great if you're in a team and you
- 1:29:28want to bond your team together. And I
- 1:29:30have to say they're also great for
- 1:29:31families that want to learn more about
- 1:29:32each other and that need a good excuse
- 1:29:35to spend some time in a digital world in
- 1:29:37the analog environment connecting human
- 1:29:40to human. It is remarkable what the
- 1:29:42right question at the right time can do.
- 1:29:45Go to the diary.com
- 1:29:47and you can get [clears throat] these
- 1:29:48conversation cards right now.
- 1:29:50There should be a button just down below
- 1:29:52here. And if it says subscribe, you're
- 1:29:54already subscribed. If it says subscribe
- 1:29:56bar, that means you're not yet. And if
- 1:29:58you're not subscribed, please could you
- 1:29:59do us a favor and hit that button. It
- 1:30:00helps to show more than you know. And
- 1:30:02according to the algorithm, you're
- 1:30:04someone that watches is show, but you
- 1:30:05haven't yet hit that button. Thank you
- 1:30:07so much.
- 1:30:08>> This comes to one of our questions,
- 1:30:09which is the skull there.
- 1:30:11>> Yes.
- 1:30:11>> Which is, do you believe it will be
- 1:30:13possible to live forever? And again, I
- 1:30:16think about this in the context of AI,
- 1:30:17where you said it will be able to
- 1:30:18understand that take us to the limit.
- 1:30:21It's hard to It's hard to understand um
- 1:30:24how that is an unsolvable problem. In
- 1:30:26fact, a lot of the smartest people on
- 1:30:27Earth, including I think Elon Musk said
- 1:30:28it recently that living another 100,
- 1:30:31200, 300, 400, 500 years
- 1:30:33>> Yeah.
- 1:30:33>> seems to be within the laws of physics.
- 1:30:34>> Yes. I think that is absolutely within
- 1:30:37the realm of possibility, but 500 years
- 1:30:40is so different from forever.
- 1:30:42Like when I hear forever
- 1:30:44I'm taking it kind of literally.
- 1:30:47>> Oh, okay. Yeah.
- 1:30:47>> And and so if if forever doesn't mean
- 1:30:50500 or 1,000, if it means never ceases,
- 1:30:54then I have
- 1:30:56no confidence that that kind of
- 1:30:59existence will be possible.
- 1:31:02>> What about 500 years?
- 1:31:03>> 500 years, yeah, I would say, again, not
- 1:31:06in our lifetime, which is sad. I would I
- 1:31:09would put that at reasonably high
- 1:31:10confidence that, you know, hundreds of
- 1:31:13years will be within our ability.
- 1:31:15>> If we are on this sort of exponential of
- 1:31:17intelligence
- 1:31:18then it you know, and if 2021
- 1:31:21>> Yeah.
- 1:31:22>> we couldn't solve that math equation
- 1:31:23you're talking about, but in 2026 we
- 1:31:25can.
- 1:31:25>> Yeah.
- 1:31:26>> And you've got trillions of dollars now
- 1:31:27pumping into these artificial
- 1:31:29intelligence systems to make them
- 1:31:30smarter and more powerful.
- 1:31:31It is It is conceivable that if we're on
- 1:31:33an exponential curve here it could be
- 1:31:36within our lifetimes that there is a
- 1:31:37discovery made about our telomeres and
- 1:31:39whatever else it might be that the
- 1:31:41guests on my show have talked about that
- 1:31:42means we can theoretically
- 1:31:43>> But let me tell you why I'm I'm
- 1:31:45skeptical of that. Number one
- 1:31:48right now we have a certain kind of
- 1:31:51artificial intelligence. It's basically
- 1:31:52large language models.
- 1:31:54And that's a certain paradigm
- 1:31:57where the system is trained on an
- 1:31:59enormous number of tokens, an enormous
- 1:32:01number of words, you know, basically the
- 1:32:03entire internet. And based upon the
- 1:32:05statistics and the statistics of the
- 1:32:08statistics of the statistics of how the
- 1:32:10words are arranged, the system is able
- 1:32:12to provide answers to questions that are
- 1:32:15coherent and and and insightful and so
- 1:32:18forth.
- 1:32:19There
- 1:32:20isn't necessarily an unlimited capacity
- 1:32:24of that kind of artificial intelligence
- 1:32:26to continue to improve, right? And so
- 1:32:29it's not obvious to me that it's just a
- 1:32:31matter of pumping billions and billions
- 1:32:32of dollars, building ever larger data
- 1:32:34center, putting them in space, whatever
- 1:32:36you're going to do, and the more money
- 1:32:38you put in and the more data you have
- 1:32:40and the more computer power you have,
- 1:32:42the better it's going to be. That's not
- 1:32:44obvious to me that will continue up that
- 1:32:45exponential curve. And that's why I'm
- 1:32:47hesitant to say in our lifetime. It may
- 1:32:50take a number of lifetimes to develop
- 1:32:53the
- 1:32:54kind of artificial intelligence
- 1:32:56necessary to advance the kinds of
- 1:32:58scientific problems that you're talking
- 1:33:00about. But look, I'd be thrilled if it's
- 1:33:02our lifetime. I'd be thrilled if I'm
- 1:33:04wrong and these systems are up to the
- 1:33:06task.
- 1:33:07>> One of the terms that has emerged in the
- 1:33:09world of AI recently, um, is this term
- 1:33:11recursive self-improvement.
- 1:33:13>> Yeah.
- 1:33:13>> Recursive self-improvement is the
- 1:33:15concept where an AI becomes intelligent
- 1:33:17enough to write its own software, design
- 1:33:18its own hardware, or train its own
- 1:33:20successors without human intervention.
- 1:33:22And once this loop begins, the upgraded
- 1:33:23AI uses its superior intelligence to
- 1:33:25build an even smarter version of itself,
- 1:33:27which then builds an even smarter
- 1:33:29version and so on. Because computer
- 1:33:30systems operate in seconds rather than
- 1:33:32human evolutionary timescales, this
- 1:33:34feedback loop could trigger an
- 1:33:35exponential, quote, intelligence
- 1:33:37explosion, rapidly taking AI from
- 1:33:40human-level capability to
- 1:33:41superintelligence within days or hours.
- 1:33:43>> Yeah.
- 1:33:43>> And the big AI leaders, Dario at, um,
- 1:33:46Anthropic has recently published an
- 1:33:47article warning that we're edging closer
- 1:33:50to that. Sam Altman has said the same,
- 1:33:52Dennis has said the same, um, Elon has
- 1:33:54talked about this as well recently. And
- 1:33:55their timelines for this explosion in
- 1:33:57intelligence because of the AIs being up
- 1:33:59to train themselves ranges from 2 years
- 1:34:01to 5 years, placing them between 2026
- 1:34:04and 2029. And Dario, who's the CEO of
- 1:34:07the biggest model called Anthropic
- 1:34:08Claude,
- 1:34:09has stated that AI systems outperforming
- 1:34:12most humans across all human tasks,
- 1:34:13including software engineering, could
- 1:34:15arrive within 2 to 3 years. And
- 1:34:16Anthropic has been warning that full
- 1:34:18recursive self-improvement
- 1:34:21could arrive [snorts] by 2027 to 2028.
- 1:34:24Demis at Google
- 1:34:25is citing 2029 as a real possibility,
- 1:34:28and Sam Altman
- 1:34:29says this decade.
- 1:34:31I mean, Brian Johnson tweeted yesterday,
- 1:34:33"Pace yourself
- 1:34:35as if you'll live to 500 because you may
- 1:34:37>> [laughter]
- 1:34:37>> because you
- 1:34:38because you may."
- 1:34:39>> Look, I'm all for the possibility that
- 1:34:43these systems will take off in a way
- 1:34:46that hopefully we are
- 1:34:48uh
- 1:34:49>> Hopefully.
- 1:34:49>> hopefully working in a way that allows
- 1:34:52the kinds of future that you're
- 1:34:54envisioning. That we are here and
- 1:34:56>> Would it be a good thing?
- 1:34:57>> Well, you know,
- 1:34:59it would be seductive. I mean,
- 1:35:01if someone was to present you with the
- 1:35:03opportunity to live for to 500 years,
- 1:35:06I think many people would opt in for
- 1:35:08that It's very hard to say, "Ah, you
- 1:35:10know, 100 years is enough, and I just
- 1:35:13you know, there are people who do that,
- 1:35:15who will look at the world and say,
- 1:35:18"It's enough, you know, I'm I'm I'm
- 1:35:19done." But back to the prognostications
- 1:35:22that are are being made. Look, it's
- 1:35:25absolutely the case that the AIs will
- 1:35:27self-improve through the very process
- 1:35:30that got us here, but on a time scale
- 1:35:32that's tiny compared to the time scale
- 1:35:34that got us here.
- 1:35:36I'm skeptical that by 2029 this will
- 1:35:40really be the case.
- 1:35:43I I I
- 1:35:43let's see, right? I mean, this is a very
- 1:35:46short-term, right? So, we will know in a
- 1:35:49few years whether this is the case.
- 1:35:51>> How many years has it taken living
- 1:35:53organisms to get from
- 1:35:55a single-cell microbe or whatever to
- 1:35:58understanding string theory?
- 1:35:59>> Yeah, so, you know, the first life on
- 1:36:00our planet formed roughly within the
- 1:36:03first billion years. You know, people
- 1:36:05debate exactly where that is. And you
- 1:36:07know, we're now roughly call it, you
- 1:36:09know, 5 billion years in. So, call it
- 1:36:11roughly 4 billion years.
- 1:36:13>> I mean, a a computer going from zero to
- 1:36:15being smarter than every human on Earth
- 1:36:17has taken
- 1:36:17>> Yeah, well, it depends where you
- 1:36:19>> decades.
- 1:36:19>> where you start the god,
- 1:36:21>> Oh, true.
- 1:36:21>> right? Because again, if you think about
- 1:36:23the systems as we they needed us.
- 1:36:26>> Yeah.
- 1:36:26>> Without the internet and all the data,
- 1:36:29what would they have trained on? At
- 1:36:31least this version of artificial
- 1:36:33intelligence. If it's the computer, the
- 1:36:36artificial system that's self-tinkering,
- 1:36:39then yeah, there's this feedback that
- 1:36:41will yield an exponential growth. And if
- 1:36:43there's no barrier,
- 1:36:45and there may be, right? There may be a
- 1:36:46barrier to the kind of artificial
- 1:36:48intelligence systems that we have. We
- 1:36:50may allow it to iterate and it iterates
- 1:36:52and it sure it improves, but doesn't
- 1:36:54improve like this. It improves like
- 1:36:57this. It could asymptote. It could
- 1:37:00approach a maximal
- 1:37:02intelligence
- 1:37:04compatible with this version of the
- 1:37:05artificial system. And so, it won't
- 1:37:07skyrocket. It could do this. And we
- 1:37:10don't know the answer, which curve is
- 1:37:12the right one.
- 1:37:13>> Give me a rebuttal to that.
- 1:37:15>> A rebuttal to it being the exponential
- 1:37:17curve?
- 1:37:18>> Give me a rebuttal
- 1:37:19>> Oh, oh, you're asking this
- 1:37:20>> system.
- 1:37:20>> That was uh Brian saying one of that.
- 1:37:22Give me a rebuttal to that.
- 1:37:26>> The rebuttal to the idea of an asymptote
- 1:37:28is that AI isn't just improving one
- 1:37:30thing. It's exploring an astronomically
- 1:37:32vast solution space of algorithms, data,
- 1:37:35and hardware configurations that humans
- 1:37:37can't even conceive of. Furthermore,
- 1:37:39each marginal gain in intelligence could
- 1:37:41instantly be reinvested into solving the
- 1:37:44very bottlenecks that might cause a
- 1:37:45slowdown, effectively breaking through
- 1:37:47the wall rather than hitting it.
- 1:37:49Maybe.
- 1:37:51>> But, if all of these incremental
- 1:37:53improvements
- 1:37:55ultimately are limited by the kind of
- 1:37:58artificial intelligence that we are
- 1:38:00working within, then none of that will
- 1:38:04necessarily be able to break through.
- 1:38:06And I think this is something that we're
- 1:38:07just going to have to see over time.
- 1:38:10Fight back.
- 1:38:12>> That points to a crucial distinction
- 1:38:14about whether the current paradigm has a
- 1:38:15hard limit. While it's possible there's
- 1:38:18an invisible ceiling, it's also true
- 1:38:20that we haven't yet mapped out where
- 1:38:21that boundary lies, meaning any
- 1:38:23predictions about a plateau remain
- 1:38:24speculative for now.
- 1:38:26>> Yes, and all I'm saying is there is a
- 1:38:28possible limiting ceiling, exactly as
- 1:38:32you just admitted.
- 1:38:33>> Rebuttal that as well.
- 1:38:35The counter to that is the idea that an
- 1:38:37intelligent system could innovate beyond
- 1:38:39the current framework by recursively
- 1:38:41redesigning its own architecture. By
- 1:38:43altering its fundamental rules, it might
- 1:38:45not just reach the ceiling, but raise it
- 1:38:47all together, or bypass it into an
- 1:38:49entirely new domain of capability.
- 1:38:52>> But you do agree that the system that
- 1:38:55we're starting with may be
- 1:38:56self-limiting. I'm simply positing that
- 1:38:59as a logical possibility, and therefore
- 1:39:02will have that natural inbuilt ceiling.
- 1:39:06>> Yes, absolutely.
- 1:39:08>> Okay, stop. I'm done.
- 1:39:10>> [laughter]
- 1:39:13>> Isn't that crazy?
- 1:39:14>> Yeah.
- 1:39:15>> It's totally insane.
- 1:39:16>> [laughter]
- 1:39:18>> Cuz even 5 years ago, we never would
- 1:39:20have thought that was possible.
- 1:39:21>> Yeah.
- 1:39:21>> It would have been this I doubt it.
- 1:39:23>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Totally crazy. And And
- 1:39:25again, you know, just the flip side,
- 1:39:27even though I'm saying that there may be
- 1:39:29a ceiling, I also would say there may
- 1:39:31not be a ceiling. And again, that's both
- 1:39:34exciting and frightening at the same
- 1:39:35time, because it's not obvious that we
- 1:39:37would be prepared for that, you know.
- 1:39:40>> W- Why frightening? What would that
- 1:39:41mean?
- 1:39:42>> Well, you know, there are the usual
- 1:39:43doomsday scenarios that many people have
- 1:39:46articulated.
- 1:39:48You know, from these systems just having
- 1:39:51a single-minded focus on some particular
- 1:39:54outcome that may not ultimately involve
- 1:39:57us. Or that these systems may have a
- 1:40:00self-preservation instinct that prevents
- 1:40:04us from stopping them if they head in a
- 1:40:06direction that we're not happy with. I
- 1:40:08mean, Yann LeCun who's a you know, he's
- 1:40:10a He's one of the good
- 1:40:11>> godfathers of AI.
- 1:40:12>> Yeah, yeah. His view is much more of the
- 1:40:15sort just pull the plug.
- 1:40:18If something's going in the wrong
- 1:40:20direction, just pull the plug. I mean,
- 1:40:21just stop the AI system. And it's not
- 1:40:24obvious to me and I guess to many of the
- 1:40:26other leaders that if these systems
- 1:40:28advance sufficiently far that they won't
- 1:40:31be able to stop you from pulling the
- 1:40:32plug. The other thing I would say, and
- 1:40:34again, this is not original, many people
- 1:40:36have worried about this.
- 1:40:38You rattled off the names of the leaders
- 1:40:41of the current companies that are
- 1:40:44leading the charge in AI. There are only
- 1:40:47a handful of companies and a handful of
- 1:40:49people. Putting that kind of power in
- 1:40:52such a small number of hands has
- 1:40:54historically, not with AI, but with
- 1:40:57other power structures,
- 1:40:59not always turned out well, you know?
- 1:41:02And so, yes, I think there is a chance
- 1:41:04that there's an instability that the
- 1:41:07power of these kind of artificial
- 1:41:09systems may generate.
- 1:41:11>> So, Demis, I mean, I use Demis because
- 1:41:13Demis is running the biggest AI company,
- 1:41:15said that since the design of machines
- 1:41:16is one of the these intellectual
- 1:41:17activities, an ultra-intelligent machine
- 1:41:20could design even better machines if the
- 1:41:22exponential continues, which is not
- 1:41:24certain,
- 1:41:25but now has a decade-long track record
- 1:41:27supporting it, then it cannot possibly
- 1:41:29be more than a few years before AI is
- 1:41:31better than humans at essentially
- 1:41:32everything. The combination of
- 1:41:34intelligence, agency, and
- 1:41:35unpredictability is a recipe for
- 1:41:37existential danger. Not because AI is
- 1:41:39evil, but because it's complex in ways
- 1:41:41we don't fully understand yet. If a
- 1:41:43system can improve faster than humans
- 1:41:44can evaluate those improvements, the
- 1:41:46normal safety feedback loop breaks down.
- 1:41:49You cannot catch problems before they
- 1:41:50compound.
- 1:41:51>> He's absolutely right.
- 1:41:53You know, the the problem with
- 1:41:55exponentials
- 1:41:56is that they grow so quickly that by the
- 1:41:59time you see them, it's too late to do
- 1:42:01anything about it. I mean, what happens
- 1:42:03with the pandemic? With the pandemic,
- 1:42:05you know, it starts off slow, nobody
- 1:42:07cares, nobody's paying it. It's a story
- 1:42:08in the news, a story in the news, starts
- 1:42:10to be By the time it becomes a real
- 1:42:12story, the pandemic is at the part of
- 1:42:15the exponential curve that makes it very
- 1:42:17difficult to address the problem itself.
- 1:42:20And the same thing, you know, could
- 1:42:22easily happen here. That the increase in
- 1:42:26intelligence, and I'm glad Demis phrased
- 1:42:28it way. It may not be that it's
- 1:42:29intrinsically evil to have this kind of
- 1:42:32powerful intelligence. It just may act
- 1:42:34in ways that are so alien to us, so
- 1:42:38foreign to us, so unexpected to us that
- 1:42:41we don't know how to deal with it. And
- 1:42:44moreover, it may not necessarily be
- 1:42:46beneficial to our existence. Now, as I
- 1:42:48said before,
- 1:42:49I'm perhaps a minority when I say I can
- 1:42:53imagine that we work with the AI and
- 1:42:56co-develop into something that we can't
- 1:42:59even predict today. That seems to me a
- 1:43:02real possibility.
- 1:43:03>> And that's also the temptation.
- 1:43:05>> Yeah. You know, I have a friend, Michael
- 1:43:07Douglas, who's brilliant physicist, and
- 1:43:10he said to me,
- 1:43:13"We physicists, we should choose the
- 1:43:14final problems that we work on because
- 1:43:18in a few years
- 1:43:19we'll be out of business because the AI
- 1:43:22systems will just be doing it all."
- 1:43:26And that's both exciting and terrifying
- 1:43:28because as a physicist, you know, your
- 1:43:30your life blood is looking out at the
- 1:43:32world and finding puzzles and trying to
- 1:43:35find the explanations for them. And if
- 1:43:36you can just put it into an AI system
- 1:43:38and it generates the answer, yeah, there
- 1:43:40can be a certain existential angst about
- 1:43:43what your role is at that point. But
- 1:43:45it's also exciting. Because maybe we
- 1:43:48will get answers to questions that we
- 1:43:50thought we would never get in our
- 1:43:51lifetime.
- 1:43:52>> Did you say you're friends with Jan
- 1:43:54LeCun?
- 1:43:55>> Yeah.
- 1:43:56>> And did you say he thinks we should just
- 1:43:57pull the plug?
- 1:43:58>> When you confront Jan and say, "Dude,
- 1:44:02aren't you worried about what's going to
- 1:44:04happen with this?" He's like, "Ah,
- 1:44:05don't worry. Just pull the plug if
- 1:44:08there's a problem."
- 1:44:09>> Oh. Oh.
- 1:44:10>> Yeah. His view is
- 1:44:12the difference between the AI systems
- 1:44:15that we have today and the AI systems
- 1:44:17that we need for tomorrow, if you really
- 1:44:19want this to continue, is they can't
- 1:44:20just be probabilities and statistics
- 1:44:23based on words. The AI systems need to
- 1:44:25have some inner model of the world as we
- 1:44:29do, right? I mean, if I take this cup
- 1:44:31here
- 1:44:32and I push it, I have an inner model of
- 1:44:35what it would take to move it without
- 1:44:36spilling, and I have an inner model of
- 1:44:38what it would take to spill it. I won't
- 1:44:40actually do it because it would make a
- 1:44:41mess.
- 1:44:42That's not just statistics and
- 1:44:44probabilities of words. That's
- 1:44:47a model of how reality functions. And
- 1:44:50that's what he and many others have been
- 1:44:52developing. A world model together with
- 1:44:55the probabilities of large language
- 1:44:57model or some weird hybrid or something
- 1:44:59that we haven't thought of. That may be
- 1:45:02the next phase of artificial
- 1:45:04intelligence.
- 1:45:05But of course, Demis and others might
- 1:45:06say
- 1:45:08the LLMs through self-improvement,
- 1:45:11maybe they would develop that world.
- 1:45:14Maybe they would on their own get to the
- 1:45:16place that you would think that we
- 1:45:17humans would need to inject something
- 1:45:20extra. Who knows?
- 1:45:21>> Cuz if only like if I get this glass
- 1:45:23here, I I say to the AI, "What happens
- 1:45:25to this if I push it in that direction?
- 1:45:32>> If you push that mug, it'll slide across
- 1:45:34the table, and depending on how hard you
- 1:45:36push, it could knock into the plate or
- 1:45:38slide right off the edge.
- 1:45:40>> Now, again, it simply is relying upon
- 1:45:43the fact that it's read everything on
- 1:45:44the internet. And there are physics
- 1:45:46textbooks, there are conversations about
- 1:45:48things falling, and it bases its
- 1:45:51response by drawing on those collections
- 1:45:54of data.
- 1:45:55>> Isn't that what I'm doing as well?
- 1:45:56>> I don't know. What is How does human
- 1:45:58intelligence work? And certainly
- 1:46:01evolutionary psychologists have asked
- 1:46:02the following question: Are we like a
- 1:46:04blank slate?
- 1:46:05And we simply learn about the world
- 1:46:08people tell us, we experience, and so
- 1:46:10forth, or is there something more
- 1:46:11innate? And I think there is strong
- 1:46:14evidence that we have a kind of innate
- 1:46:17physical intuition about the world
- 1:46:19that's really been passed down through
- 1:46:21the generations. Not that you can pass
- 1:46:23down F equals MA or Newton's laws to
- 1:46:26your children because you learned, of
- 1:46:27course, that's silly. But there is an
- 1:46:30evolutionary
- 1:46:31assess
- 1:46:34the world and figure out how to act,
- 1:46:37right? Those of our forebears who could
- 1:46:40not throw the rock or the spear, they're
- 1:46:42the ones who didn't get the next meal.
- 1:46:44Those of our forebears that had a
- 1:46:45slightly better predilection
- 1:46:49for ingesting experience and codifying
- 1:46:52it in some understanding of how the
- 1:46:54world actually works, they're the ones
- 1:46:55that survived. And so, they can pass
- 1:46:58down that predilection. And I do think
- 1:47:00that that's part of how we assess the
- 1:47:03world. I don't think we're a complete
- 1:47:04blank slates in that sense.
- 1:47:06>> It would make sense. Babies are born
- 1:47:08with some kind of intelligence. They
- 1:47:09grip fingers. But But But that is in
- 1:47:10part because the the parent has passed
- 1:47:13that on, and so an AI could pass
- 1:47:15>> Yes, that's right. When you talk about
- 1:47:16the AI systems themselves being
- 1:47:18evolutionary, yeah, they certainly do
- 1:47:20pass down the achievements of generation
- 1:47:24N to generation N plus 1. That is
- 1:47:26certainly part of this iterative process
- 1:47:28without a doubt.
- 1:47:29>> What a weird world we're living in.
- 1:47:31>> Yeah.
- 1:47:31>> It's like crazy.
- 1:47:33So sometimes I think but I imagine
- 1:47:35through history everyone's thought like
- 1:47:36God, what a time to be alive.
- 1:47:37>> Yeah.
- 1:47:37>> We are living through a rapid change
- 1:47:39that is a little unprecedented.
- 1:47:42>> How do you think one should contend with
- 1:47:43all of this? Cuz people are concerned.
- 1:47:45Change is not something that we love at
- 1:47:47this rate.
- 1:47:48>> You know, again, I think people will
- 1:47:49cope in many different ways. You know,
- 1:47:52if you can stay open and excited to the
- 1:47:54possibilities
- 1:47:56and have the flexibility of change.
- 1:48:00>> Oh, one of the things I've been thinking
- 1:48:01a lot about lately is Elon's out there
- 1:48:03saying that we're heading to an age of
- 1:48:04abundance. He's kind of shifted his
- 1:48:05perspective from this doomerism to age
- 1:48:07of abundance and then part of his
- 1:48:09narrative there is we won't need money
- 1:48:11because when you've got robots and AI
- 1:48:13and more energy, then we're not going to
- 1:48:16have to worry about food and these kinds
- 1:48:17of things or bills whatever. But still
- 1:48:19humans pursue scarcity.
- 1:48:21>> Yeah.
- 1:48:22>> We we pursue status. We want, you know,
- 1:48:24humans want the home on
- 1:48:26the end of Miami Beach with the best
- 1:48:28plot. And there's there's a there's
- 1:48:30finite numbers of these things that a
- 1:48:32lot of humans pursue. Even like academic
- 1:48:34discovery, Nobel Prizes. There's a
- 1:48:35finite number of them and we pursue
- 1:48:37them. So there's one would argue that
- 1:48:38they're still going to be a
- 1:48:41a competition. Humans are still going to
- 1:48:43strive for things, right?
- 1:48:45>> Why do we do that?
- 1:48:46>> Yeah.
- 1:48:46>> Right? And part of the reason is
- 1:48:49if you know that you're going to die,
- 1:48:53if you know that your life is finite,
- 1:48:55there can be an urge to make your mark,
- 1:48:59to do something special, to be out of
- 1:49:01the ordinary so that in some symbolic
- 1:49:04way you continue to exist even after you
- 1:49:07are gone, right? I mean, you know, Elon
- 1:49:10Musk, yeah, after he's gone, people
- 1:49:13going to talk about him for a long long
- 1:49:15time, right? Because he had a radical
- 1:49:18impact and who knows where it will go.
- 1:49:21He's got many productive years still
- 1:49:23left. And so yes, there is this natural
- 1:49:26tendency to seek something that will
- 1:49:30allow you to symbolically persist after
- 1:49:33you are gone. Now,
- 1:49:35if we all realize that that is part of
- 1:49:38human motivation, maybe as a species we
- 1:49:41could begin to shift, right? It isn't
- 1:49:44the case that we have to always be the
- 1:49:47way we have been. Historically, that's
- 1:49:48the way we have been. Kings want to be
- 1:49:51kings in part because they have the
- 1:49:53power. If they have the power, they have
- 1:49:55the hegemony, then they in a sense exist
- 1:49:57even when they are gone. Their progeny.
- 1:49:59Why do we have descent of monarchies?
- 1:50:03Because the king continues to exist
- 1:50:06through the king's progeny. And so yeah,
- 1:50:08could we perhaps get to a place where we
- 1:50:11shed
- 1:50:12that way of being because we're in a
- 1:50:15world of abundance
- 1:50:17where the whole notion of scarcity is
- 1:50:19artificial?
- 1:50:20And we're only inventing it, we realize,
- 1:50:22in order that we can feel good and
- 1:50:24special and maybe we can find other ways
- 1:50:26to feel good and special. I allow for
- 1:50:28that possibility. I'm not particularly
- 1:50:30optimistic that that's what will happen.
- 1:50:33Uh the flip side is that it's easy to
- 1:50:34say that money won't matter when you
- 1:50:36have a trillion dollars, right? You're
- 1:50:37right. I I mean, you know, you just have
- 1:50:39to sort of see this stuff in context.
- 1:50:41But yeah.
- 1:50:42>> We have one more little uh
- 1:50:43>> Yeah.
- 1:50:44>> souvenir thing there. And this is kind
- 1:50:47of what we're talking about, which is
- 1:50:48robots. Do you think AI can become
- 1:50:49conscious? Is the question.
- 1:50:50>> Yeah.
- 1:50:51>> High confidence or low confidence?
- 1:50:52>> Yeah, I'm pretty high confident on that.
- 1:50:55You know, again, as I'm saying before, I
- 1:50:57just see consciousness as a physical
- 1:50:59process.
- 1:51:00And it's a matter of, in one way or
- 1:51:02another,
- 1:51:03achieving that physical process in an
- 1:51:05artificial system. And I don't see a
- 1:51:07fundamental barrier to doing that.
- 1:51:10>> I was thinking about how laws would have
- 1:51:12to potentially change if if we
- 1:51:14considered robots to be conscious and
- 1:51:16they lived in our homes, would they then
- 1:51:18get rights?
- 1:51:20>> I think that's something we should think
- 1:51:21about now, actually. Yeah, it's a it's a
- 1:51:23very
- 1:51:25tricky idea. I mean, you know, it's one
- 1:51:28thing, you know, to pull the plug on a
- 1:51:31on a light bulb. It's another thing to
- 1:51:33pull the plug on a sentient system.
- 1:51:36And
- 1:51:37we may well find ourselves
- 1:51:40in that situation. The the the challenge
- 1:51:44the challenge is
- 1:51:46it's virtually impossible to ever prove
- 1:51:48sentience, right? I mean, you know, as
- 1:51:51we look at each other, we each afford
- 1:51:54the other
- 1:51:56consciousness. I believe that you are
- 1:51:58conscious. You believe that I am as
- 1:51:59well. Why?
- 1:52:00You were more or less, you know,
- 1:52:02physically constructed more or less the
- 1:52:04same way. We're part of the same
- 1:52:06species.
- 1:52:07Uh our body language, our speech is so
- 1:52:09similar in the grand scheme of things
- 1:52:12that we afford the other what we
- 1:52:14internally experience.
- 1:52:17But we don't know it, right? You don't
- 1:52:18know that I'm conscious. I could be
- 1:52:20faking it. I could be a really good
- 1:52:22artificial zombie that speaks and talks,
- 1:52:25but there's nothing going on inside. And
- 1:52:27the same could be true for you. And what
- 1:52:29that means is when we are with these
- 1:52:31artificial systems that don't have our
- 1:52:33lineage, they're not part of the same
- 1:52:35species, they don't necessarily look
- 1:52:36like us, they don't have the upbringing
- 1:52:38that we had, and so on and so forth,
- 1:52:41will we be willing
- 1:52:43to agree that they're conscious if they
- 1:52:44tell us that they are?
- 1:52:46I mean, if the artificial system says,
- 1:52:49"I really am. I'm I'm feeling exactly
- 1:52:52the thing that I read about in your
- 1:52:54internet. I'm I'm I'm feeling love.
- 1:52:57Or I'm feeling depressed." If they say
- 1:52:59that to us, will we say, "No, no, no.
- 1:53:01You're just mimicking. You're miming the
- 1:53:04kinds of things that human beings have
- 1:53:05said. There's nothing going on inside.
- 1:53:07There's nothing There's no world inside
- 1:53:09there." How do we ever get beyond that?
- 1:53:11And I don't know the answer to that
- 1:53:13question,
- 1:53:15even though I strongly believe that
- 1:53:17there's no logical fundamental barrier
- 1:53:20that prevents the system from saying
- 1:53:22that and from telling the truth.
- 1:53:25>> And electrical circuits within that
- 1:53:26system causing it to behave in such a
- 1:53:28way when it's scared, when it's in love.
- 1:53:30>> Yeah.
- 1:53:30>> Where it cuddles you and because that's
- 1:53:32what the electrical circuits told it to
- 1:53:33do.
- 1:53:34>> Yes, but is there an inner world
- 1:53:36associated with that or is it just going
- 1:53:38through the motions? Here's how I think
- 1:53:41it's going to likely turn out.
- 1:53:43We'll have these artificial systems.
- 1:53:45They'll start to say these things. At
- 1:53:46first we'll be like, "Come on. Come on.
- 1:53:48Come on." It's not not real.
- 1:53:50But we'll start to get used to them
- 1:53:53behaving just like we in the sense of
- 1:53:56having these inner worlds.
- 1:53:58And sooner or later, through a process
- 1:54:01that's so perhaps slow that we don't
- 1:54:03even notice it, we will afford them
- 1:54:05consciousness.
- 1:54:06We will talk to them as if they're
- 1:54:07conscious. We will imagine that they're
- 1:54:09conscious. And ultimately we will treat
- 1:54:12them as if they're conscious. Now, I
- 1:54:13hope that we do that
- 1:54:15in a in a good way. We have a terrible
- 1:54:17history of treating conscious beings in
- 1:54:20a respectful way, even in the same
- 1:54:23species, right? We've done terrible
- 1:54:24things to each other, even though we
- 1:54:26afford consciousness. We do terrible
- 1:54:28things to animals. I'm vegan.
- 1:54:31I don't eat any animal products.
- 1:54:33I think that's not the way to treat a
- 1:54:35living system that has some level of
- 1:54:38conscious awareness. I do eat plants.
- 1:54:41I don't think plants have a sufficiently
- 1:54:42high level of consciousness, if at all,
- 1:54:45that I'm concerned about cutting them
- 1:54:48and eating them.
- 1:54:49>> Have you always been vegan?
- 1:54:50>> I've been vegan since 1993.
- 1:54:53>> Oh, damn. Since I was
- 1:54:54>> So, I've been vegetarian since I was 9
- 1:54:56years old.
- 1:54:58And so, that's how I treat living or
- 1:55:02conscious beings because I don't think
- 1:55:04it's right to treat them that way.
- 1:55:06>> What was the catalyst for that decision?
- 1:55:07>> Well, when I was 9 years old, it was
- 1:55:09very flat-footed. My mother cooked spare
- 1:55:11ribs
- 1:55:12and for the very first time I realized
- 1:55:14what meat was. I'm a city kid.
- 1:55:17I grew up where meat was in cellophane.
- 1:55:19You buy it wrapped at the supermarket.
- 1:55:22But when the meat came on a bone,
- 1:55:25I was like, wait a second. What is that?
- 1:55:27I was like, oh my god, this is like the
- 1:55:29rib of an animal.
- 1:55:31And I was like, and and I said I'm I
- 1:55:32told her I said I'm never going to eat
- 1:55:33meat again. Later on, I did eat you have
- 1:55:37cheese and milk. I wasn't vegan at that
- 1:55:38point. But when I was a professor at
- 1:55:41Cornell in the 1990s, I went to an
- 1:55:44animal sanctuary in Watkins Glen, New
- 1:55:46York
- 1:55:47where they showed you what happens to
- 1:55:49these animals when they are treated like
- 1:55:52milk factories. You know, what happens
- 1:55:54to the cows and it's it's awful. And
- 1:55:57within 72 hours after visiting that
- 1:56:00animal sanctuary, I said I'm done. I'm
- 1:56:02not participating any longer. I'm not
- 1:56:04going to eat
- 1:56:06or drink or imbibe any living any
- 1:56:09substance that came from an animal. And
- 1:56:11so that was the end for me.
- 1:56:14>> For some people, it might be somewhat
- 1:56:16surprising to hear that from a
- 1:56:17physicist.
- 1:56:19>> I agree. It's inconsistent.
- 1:56:21Because
- 1:56:22if I believe as I do that you and I are
- 1:56:26just a collection of particles in one
- 1:56:28configuration
- 1:56:30and the cow
- 1:56:32or the pig is just a collection of
- 1:56:34particles in a different What does it
- 1:56:35matter if you eat particles in one
- 1:56:37configuration that we call a cow or
- 1:56:39another configuration that we call a
- 1:56:40carrot? But as a human being,
- 1:56:43I allow the other parts of me to shine
- 1:56:46through and I look at that collection of
- 1:56:48particles that happens to be a cow and I
- 1:56:50say, it just doesn't feel right to me
- 1:56:53to eat that collection of particles. It
- 1:56:55just doesn't feel right and I don't want
- 1:56:56to do it.
- 1:56:59>> Brian, you've written many fascinating
- 1:57:01books. I've got some of them here. I I
- 1:57:02think there's one other that I'm
- 1:57:03missing, I believe.
- 1:57:04>> Yeah, there's more of a kids book, I
- 1:57:06think. Yeah.
- 1:57:08>> For my listeners at home, what is the
- 1:57:09most interesting thing that we haven't
- 1:57:11talked about that we should have talked
- 1:57:12about that exists within your works that
- 1:57:15I guess is either
- 1:57:17fascinating or somewhat relevant to
- 1:57:19their everyday life.
- 1:57:20>> Yeah, well, I'm going to go more on the
- 1:57:22fascinating than relevant to everyday
- 1:57:23life. As you know, I'm pretty esoteric
- 1:57:25>> [laughter]
- 1:57:26>> in these kind of things. But in the book
- 1:57:27Until the End of Time,
- 1:57:29I I tried to give the reader a sense of
- 1:57:33how we got here, but I also then turn to
- 1:57:36the future and try to give them a sense
- 1:57:38of what will be if we go arbitrarily far
- 1:57:40into the future. And yeah, that's it. I
- 1:57:43used the metaphor of the Empire State
- 1:57:44Building, which I I think helps you get
- 1:57:47a feel for
- 1:57:50what the universe will be like if you
- 1:57:52take the current understanding of the
- 1:57:54laws of physics and extrapolate
- 1:57:56arbitrarily far into the future.
- 1:57:58And so, to try to give people a sense, I
- 1:58:01asked them to imagine
- 1:58:02that every floor of the Empire State
- 1:58:05Building represents an era of time
- 1:58:08that's 10 times longer than the floor
- 1:58:11below. So, like at the at the ground
- 1:58:13floor, that's like 1 year. And then the
- 1:58:15next floor, 10. Next is 100, 1,000,
- 1:58:1710,000, 100,000, and so forth.
- 1:58:20Exponentially larger time scales as you
- 1:58:23walk up the stairs of the Empire State
- 1:58:26Building. Now, in this way of thinking
- 1:58:28about things, everything from the Big
- 1:58:29Bang until today takes you to just about
- 1:58:32here, the 10th floor. We're about 10 to
- 1:58:34the 10 years from the beginning.
- 1:58:38And what I do is I take the audience
- 1:58:41from that point and I step through the
- 1:58:44key markers in the far future of the
- 1:58:46universe to give you a feel
- 1:58:48for what will happen. And I can and of
- 1:58:50take you through a couple milestones,
- 1:58:52right? So again, here we are today.
- 1:58:54>> So when does it get scary?
- 1:58:55>> Yeah, well, it's scary the whole way.
- 1:58:58You know, so here we are, 10 to the 10
- 1:59:00years from the beginning. If you just go
- 1:59:02up to here, 10 to the 11 years, what
- 1:59:04happens here is the sun
- 1:59:07will get bigger and bigger. It swells.
- 1:59:09It eats up the close planets, Mercury
- 1:59:12and Venus. It may swallow up the Earth,
- 1:59:14too. We're not sure, but certainly it
- 1:59:16will make life on Earth virtually
- 1:59:18impossible because it would be so hot on
- 1:59:21this planet.
- 1:59:22If you go up to the next floor above
- 1:59:24that, 10 to the 12 years from the
- 1:59:27beginning, what you find here is that
- 1:59:29the universe is expanding ever more
- 1:59:33quickly, driving the distant galaxies
- 1:59:35away
- 1:59:36faster than the speed of light. So we
- 1:59:39won't see them. So a future astronomer
- 1:59:41here looking out into the deep night sky
- 1:59:43will see only darkness. In the deep,
- 1:59:45deep night sky, everything will have
- 1:59:47drifted beyond the cosmic horizon.
- 1:59:50>> Why will it be going faster than the
- 1:59:52speed of light?
- 1:59:52>> Because we have found surprisingly that
- 1:59:54the expansion is speeding up.
- 1:59:56>> And there's no limit to that.
- 1:59:57>> There doesn't seem to be a limit. Now
- 1:59:58again, there's always assumptions in
- 2:00:01every prognostication,
- 2:00:03assuming that what we measure and see
- 2:00:06today will persist. It's like what the
- 2:00:09AI people are assuming that the growth
- 2:00:11that they see today will persist. Is
- 2:00:13that true? We don't know, but it's our
- 2:00:14best guess from the laws of physics that
- 2:00:17it will. If you then go up to about
- 2:00:19here,
- 2:00:20the uh 20th floor, something interesting
- 2:00:23happens. If the Earth is still here, if
- 2:00:25it wasn't swallowed up on the 11th floor
- 2:00:27by the swelling sun, the Earth is going
- 2:00:29to spiral
- 2:00:30into the dead sun because it will lose
- 2:00:32energy through gravitational radiation.
- 2:00:36Ripples in the fabric of space will
- 2:00:38cause the orbit of the Earth to decay.
- 2:00:40We will crash in to the dead sun. That
- 2:00:43will be the end of the Earth by about
- 2:00:45the 20th floor.
- 2:00:47>> But the end of life itself took place
- 2:00:48>> could easily have taken much earlier.
- 2:00:50>> On the 11th floor.
- 2:00:51>> On the 11th floor. If we go up to about
- 2:00:53the 30th floor, what will happen here
- 2:00:56is that
- 2:00:57the stars
- 2:00:59themselves will spiral into the
- 2:01:03the black hole at the center of most
- 2:01:06galaxies. So, most galaxies have a black
- 2:01:09hole. We have one in the center of our
- 2:01:10Milky Way galaxy.
- 2:01:12And the stars themselves, much like the
- 2:01:14Earth will spiral into the Sun, the
- 2:01:16stars will spiral into the black hole,
- 2:01:18which means there will be only kind of
- 2:01:20black holes as the remaining macroscopic
- 2:01:23structure in the universe.
- 2:01:25>> Has that happened elsewhere?
- 2:01:26>> Oh, certainly. We see things that can
- 2:01:28spiral into black holes in and it's
- 2:01:31certainly even in the center of our
- 2:01:33galaxy. There's evidence that there's
- 2:01:34activity there and that activity in part
- 2:01:37is stars being ripped apart as they fall
- 2:01:40into a black hole. So, this is pretty
- 2:01:42clear that this will happen.
- 2:01:43>> Is this the end of all galaxies as they
- 2:01:46spiral into the black hole?
- 2:01:47>> Yeah. So, after 10 to the 30, 10 to the
- 2:01:5035 years, it's hard to imagine that
- 2:01:53galaxies as we know them will persist.
- 2:01:56The stars will have burned out. I could
- 2:01:58have even mentioned another milestone
- 2:02:00around the 14th floor.
- 2:02:02Almost all stars will have used up their
- 2:02:04nuclear fuel.
- 2:02:06>> All of them?
- 2:02:07>> Just about all of them will fade to
- 2:02:08black in the
- 2:02:09>> them in the whole universe?
- 2:02:10>> Yeah.
- 2:02:10>> So, they'll
- 2:02:10>> Or at least the observable universe. I
- 2:02:12can only really speak to the part that
- 2:02:13we have direct access to. Yeah.
- 2:02:16And so, by the 30th floor, those those
- 2:02:18dark stars will spiral into black holes.
- 2:02:21>> So, there could be no life anywhere?
- 2:02:23>> It's hard to imagine. But let's stay
- 2:02:25optimistic and imagine that somehow
- 2:02:28there is some life floating in the
- 2:02:30darkness cuz I want to get to something
- 2:02:31interesting on a two two more
- 2:02:33milestones. By the 38th floor, wherever
- 2:02:35that is,
- 2:02:37we believe that protons,
- 2:02:39which are the heart of matter, will
- 2:02:41likely themselves disintegrate, fall
- 2:02:43apart.
- 2:02:45And so, if there is any remaining
- 2:02:48organized matter of the sort that we're
- 2:02:50familiar with somehow persisting
- 2:02:52somewhere, it itself will disintegrate
- 2:02:55by the 38th floor. That's our belief
- 2:02:57based on our laws of physics.
- 2:02:59>> There'll be no matter anywhere.
- 2:03:01>> There will be fine particulate
- 2:03:03constituents, because when a proton
- 2:03:05falls apart, it doesn't disappear. It
- 2:03:08falls apart into other more refined
- 2:03:10particles. And so, they will continue to
- 2:03:13persist, but the aggregate called the
- 2:03:15proton will not.
- 2:03:18If we keep on going to roughly, say, the
- 2:03:2050th floor, this is an interesting
- 2:03:22point.
- 2:03:23Because imagine that somehow some
- 2:03:26conscious being still exists in the
- 2:03:29darkness of space. I don't know how it
- 2:03:31is. Dark clouds of particles somehow are
- 2:03:34having electrical signals allowing them
- 2:03:36some kind of conscious self-awareness.
- 2:03:39After the 50th floor, that conscious
- 2:03:41being will likely think its final
- 2:03:43thought. The reason is,
- 2:03:45when you think, it generates heat.
- 2:03:48That heat has to be carried away. It's
- 2:03:50very easy for that heat to leave us in a
- 2:03:52room like here, because there's a lot of
- 2:03:55room for that so-called heat or entropy
- 2:03:57to be absorbed. By the 50th floor, the
- 2:04:00universe won't be able to absorb the
- 2:04:02heat generated by the process of thought
- 2:04:05itself. So, any thinking being, when it
- 2:04:07thinks one more thought, will burn up.
- 2:04:10It'll fry in the entropic waste, the
- 2:04:12heat generated by thought itself. So, by
- 2:04:15the 50th floor, it is hard to imagine
- 2:04:17any kind of consciousness
- 2:04:20continuing to exist. And that's why I
- 2:04:22said earlier, when you said, "Do you
- 2:04:23think that we'll live forever?" I'm
- 2:04:26thinking here, and I'm like, well, maybe
- 2:04:27we'll live to here, like 500 years or
- 2:04:311,000 years, but here, no way. It's hard
- 2:04:34for me to imagine that we will continue
- 2:04:36to persist.
- 2:04:37By the 68th floor,
- 2:04:39black holes themselves will begin to
- 2:04:42disintegrate.
- 2:04:43Stephen Hawking showed us that black
- 2:04:45holes are not fully black. When you take
- 2:04:48quantum physics into account, they can
- 2:04:50emit particles that will waft outward
- 2:04:54causing the black hole to shrink and
- 2:04:56over time the black hole itself will
- 2:04:59disappear.
- 2:05:00A black hole the size of our sun, with
- 2:05:03the mass of our sun, about 10 to the 68
- 2:05:06years for that to happen. A black hole
- 2:05:09of the gargantuan sort that we think
- 2:05:11might exist, billions and billions of
- 2:05:14times more massive than the sun, it'll
- 2:05:16take about 10 to the 100 years, very top
- 2:05:19of the Empire State Building, for that
- 2:05:21kind of black hole to disintegrate. But
- 2:05:23by the time we get here, 10 to the 100
- 2:05:25years into the future, we suspect it
- 2:05:27will just be
- 2:05:29detritus of particles
- 2:05:31wafting through an ever larger, ever
- 2:05:34colder, ever quiet universe.
- 2:05:37That's
- 2:05:38the future
- 2:05:40that we're looking at.
- 2:05:43>> And then when does the Big Bang kick off
- 2:05:44and it all start again?
- 2:05:45>> Well, it's interesting because you're
- 2:05:47absolutely right. You can say, "What
- 2:05:48about beyond the top of the Empire State
- 2:05:50Building?" Now, things Look, this whole
- 2:05:52thing is speculative, right? We are
- 2:05:54extrapolating
- 2:05:55from laws of physics that we've
- 2:05:57developed on thinking about physics
- 2:05:59here. We're assuming that it applies all
- 2:06:02the way up into the exponentially far
- 2:06:05future. Is that true? I don't know.
- 2:06:07It's our best guess based on what we
- 2:06:09know today, but definitely it is an
- 2:06:11assumption.
- 2:06:12If you extrapolate even further, then
- 2:06:14yeah, you can imagine that way an
- 2:06:17exponential of an exponential of years
- 2:06:19into the future, sure, could particles
- 2:06:21somehow recoalesce just by chance and
- 2:06:25build a state of matter that might
- 2:06:28generate another Big Bang and And all
- 2:06:30starts again. Yes.
- 2:06:32Definitely within the realm of
- 2:06:33possibility.
- 2:06:35>> Hm.
- 2:06:37So, it's not the most appealing future.
- 2:06:39>> Well,
- 2:06:41I agree, but here is Can I tell you my
- 2:06:42take on it?
- 2:06:43>> Sure.
- 2:06:44>> My take on it is when you realize
- 2:06:47that,
- 2:06:49you know, the far future is a realm of
- 2:06:51darkness.
- 2:06:53And when you also realize that until
- 2:06:54life emerged, say on planet Earth, it
- 2:06:57was a kind of realm of chaotic
- 2:07:01conglomeration of particles, you know,
- 2:07:04before. So, it's as if we're living in a
- 2:07:06special time.
- 2:07:08We're living at a special region in the
- 2:07:10cosmological unfolding when living
- 2:07:13beings like ourselves and consciousness
- 2:07:15as we experience is compatible with the
- 2:07:18state of the universe.
- 2:07:20How wondrous, how spectacular
- 2:07:24that there is this brief window of time.
- 2:07:26I mean, Nabokov had this wonderful
- 2:07:28saying that we live
- 2:07:31in a brief crack of light between two
- 2:07:35eternal stretches of darkness.
- 2:07:38How beautiful to exist in that brief
- 2:07:39crack of light. And that to me is where
- 2:07:42the gratitude comes from that I was
- 2:07:44mentioning earlier. You said earlier,
- 2:07:45like, what gives your life meaning and
- 2:07:47how
- 2:07:48the fact that we understand that we live
- 2:07:52in this very special era in cosmological
- 2:07:55history
- 2:07:56where for small period of cosmic time
- 2:08:00living beings can stand up, look around,
- 2:08:02contemplate themselves and the universe,
- 2:08:04and gain some insight. And then it all
- 2:08:06goes away. But how wonderful that there
- 2:08:08is that brief moment that we are now
- 2:08:11inhabiting.
- 2:08:14>> It is wonderful when you say it like
- 2:08:15that.
- 2:08:17Frank, the thing that's I think is most
- 2:08:18special about you isn't just the extent
- 2:08:20of your intelligence, it's your ability
- 2:08:22to communicate in such a way that makes
- 2:08:24the complex both interesting and
- 2:08:27understandable. And that's what I've
- 2:08:28seen throughout all of your work and all
- 2:08:29the videos that I was I was told you I
- 2:08:30was watching your TED Talk with my
- 2:08:31fiance a couple of weeks ago and um it's
- 2:08:34the closest I've ever come to actually
- 2:08:35understanding this concept called string
- 2:08:37theory.
- 2:08:37>> Oh, great. Well, I'm glad to hear it and
- 2:08:38thank you very much. Really appreciate
- 2:08:40that.
- 2:08:40>> I have a couple of your books here. I
- 2:08:42think this is the most recent one from
- 2:08:432020 called Until the End of Time, Mind,
- 2:08:46Matter, and Our Search for Meaning in an
- 2:08:48Evolving Universe. And I think um you
- 2:08:52know, your work makes makes us feel so
- 2:08:54many things, but I think maybe the most
- 2:08:56important feeling it makes us feel is
- 2:08:57connected.
- 2:08:58>> Yeah.
- 2:08:59>> Um and I think we're all searching for
- 2:09:00connection in an increasingly lonely,
- 2:09:02isolated-feeling universe and and so
- 2:09:04that's why I love to have these
- 2:09:05conversations on the show. I sometimes
- 2:09:06joke to the team that I oversee the C in
- 2:09:08it stands for like our one of our goals
- 2:09:09is to make people feel more connected in
- 2:09:11some capacity and you most certainly do
- 2:09:13that.
- 2:09:14So, thank you for having that impact on
- 2:09:15the world. It's a it's a very important,
- 2:09:17increasingly important impact to be
- 2:09:18having on the world and
- 2:09:19um it makes us look up, not just down, I
- 2:09:21guess. And that's a that's a wonderful,
- 2:09:23wonderful thing.
- 2:09:24>> Well, thank you.
- 2:09:25>> I'm going to link all of your books
- 2:09:26below. So, if people do want to continue
- 2:09:28this conversation, they can continue it
- 2:09:29through all of your books here. Is there
- 2:09:30anywhere else people can go to support
- 2:09:32your work or learn more about your work?
- 2:09:33Where where would you direct them?
- 2:09:35>> It's the World Science Festival, you
- 2:09:36know, uh worldsciencefestival.com.
- 2:09:39You'll find all sorts of conversations
- 2:09:41of the sort that we're talking about
- 2:09:42here. Uh
- 2:09:43also, I'm you know, I'm working on a new
- 2:09:45AI we're talking a lot about an AI
- 2:09:47education system where
- 2:09:50AI will help people understand these
- 2:09:52ideas better. Should launch sort of in
- 2:09:54the
- 2:09:54next year or so. So, keep an eye out for
- 2:09:57that kind of thing as well.
- 2:09:58>> Where do people follow you?
- 2:10:00>> Uh
- 2:10:00well, you know, on on Twitter or
- 2:10:02Instagram, we we post uh
- 2:10:04semi-frequently,
- 2:10:06but uh more at our YouTube channel, uh
- 2:10:09World Science Festival.
- 2:10:10>> And in terms of these books that I have
- 2:10:11in front of me, I have four of them.
- 2:10:13Different groups of people, which one
- 2:10:15would you direct them to read?
- 2:10:17>> Well, my favorite, if you sort of frame
- 2:10:19it in that flat-footed way, is Until the
- 2:10:21End of time because it's the more
- 2:10:23philosophical and the more the kind of
- 2:10:26ideas that we spoke about here today.
- 2:10:28But if you know, if you want to hear the
- 2:10:29hardcore of what string theory is or the
- 2:10:31new insights in space and time, some of
- 2:10:33the other books are more direct in that
- 2:10:36way.
- 2:10:36>> Until the end of time. Mind matter and
- 2:10:39our search for meaning in an evolving
- 2:10:40universe. We have a closing tradition
- 2:10:42where the last guest leaves a question
- 2:10:43for the next. The question left for you
- 2:10:45is, what might be worth even more than
- 2:10:48the thing that matters most to you?
- 2:10:52>> Oh, well, I would say
- 2:10:54the thing that matters most to the
- 2:10:56people I care most about. You know, the
- 2:10:59things that matter to my wife and my
- 2:11:01kids feels much more important than the
- 2:11:03things that matter to me most because
- 2:11:06I'm so involved in that relationship,
- 2:11:11you know, so that to me is the thing
- 2:11:14that trumps all else.
- 2:11:16>> The things that matter more to them.
- 2:11:17>> Yeah.
- 2:11:18>> Mhm, it's a beautiful answer.
- 2:11:20Wasn't expecting that, but it's very
- 2:11:21true.
- 2:11:22Brian Greene, thank you so much. It's
- 2:11:24been an honor.
- 2:11:24>> My pleasure. Thank you.
- 2:11:26>> YouTube have this new crazy algorithm
- 2:11:27where they know exactly what video you
- 2:11:30would like to watch next based on AI and
- 2:11:32all of your viewing behavior. And the
- 2:11:34algorithm says that this video is the
- 2:11:37perfect video for you. It's different
- 2:11:39for everybody looking right now. Check
- 2:11:40this video out and I bet you you might
- 2:11:42love it.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Professor Brian Greene: The Threat of AI, Consciousness & The End of Humanity by The Diary Of A CEO, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 23,106 words across 3,660 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.