Prof. Richard Johnson // Evolution, Nature and Diet: Insights into the Cause of the Obesity Epidemic — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00together, these three substances are all
- 0:03involved in the obesity epidemic. Now, I
- 0:06know we think of fruit as healthy,
- 0:09and it is,
- 0:10but not when you eat 10,000 grapes in a
- 0:1324-hour period.
- 0:16[music]
- 0:23Wow.
- 0:24[applause]
- 0:26I I think coming to the home of Sherlock
- 0:28Holmes,
- 0:30it's really was quite an entertaining
- 0:33story there.
- 0:34The You know, the sugar industry really
- 0:36isn't happy with me. That there's some
- 0:38truth to that.
- 0:40Um and but I'm here today to first off,
- 0:43I want to thank you for inviting me to
- 0:45come and speak.
- 0:47And it's really nice to see such a nice
- 0:48crowd.
- 0:50Um in the next 45 minutes, I'm going to
- 0:52tell talk to you about um a metabolite
- 0:55or well, a an a nutrient fruit fructose.
- 0:58I call it fructose. It's also fructose.
- 1:02A metabolite which is uric acid and a
- 1:04hormone, vasopressin.
- 1:06And together, these three substances are
- 1:10all involved in the obesity epidemic as
- 1:13I'll try to show you.
- 1:18This slide, I'm sure all of you have
- 1:20seen before, but there's been a dramatic
- 1:22increase in obesity and diabetes in the
- 1:24last century.
- 1:26Uh you can actually trace it the the
- 1:29rise back to the early 1900s.
- 1:32And uh the cause of it has been a big
- 1:35challenge for a lot of people
- 1:37because it because we're recognizing too
- 1:40that not only is this these two
- 1:43epidemics linked with each other, but
- 1:45they are associated with this this
- 1:47syndrome called the metabolic syndrome.
- 1:50And the metabolic syndrome is now
- 1:51associated with many many conditions
- 1:54including obesity, diabetes, high blood
- 1:56pressure, fatty liver,
- 1:58the classics.
- 2:00But it's also associated with
- 2:03Alzheimer's disease and vascular
- 2:06dementias, and behavioral disorders, and
- 2:10uh cancer,
- 2:12and uh and muscle wasting, and even
- 2:15aging. So the associations keep
- 2:17increasing, and with that the importance
- 2:20of understanding
- 2:22the cause of this syndrome is
- 2:24very uh key.
- 2:27Now superficially,
- 2:30it seems like uh it's bad habits. We're
- 2:33eating too much. We're exercising too
- 2:35little. And you can show in studies that
- 2:38people are eating more calories
- 2:40and they are more inactive.
- 2:43And so it has made it easy for the
- 2:45industry to say, well, it's this is a
- 2:48behavioral problem. You just you you
- 2:49just uh you know we have
- 2:51excess food and we have
- 2:54grocery stores open 24 hours a day and
- 2:57and we have all these things that allow
- 3:00us not to exercise. And it's that
- 3:03simple. But we know, everyone in this
- 3:05room knows
- 3:06that it's more complicated than that.
- 3:09And so today I'm going to talk to you
- 3:11about the biology of obesity and see if
- 3:14we can tease out
- 3:17how it actually is occurring, what's
- 3:19driving it.
- 3:21And uh we're going to begin by looking
- 3:23at where obesity occurs naturally.
- 3:26And that is in nature
- 3:28among certain species
- 3:30that will
- 3:32purposely gain weight
- 3:34to prepare themselves for a time when
- 3:36there's a food shortage.
- 3:38The classic are animals that prepare for
- 3:41hibernation.
- 3:42During the summer
- 3:44uh they they actually maintain a very
- 3:46stable weight.
- 3:47But beginning about eight weeks before
- 3:50winter or sometimes 12 weeks, there's
- 3:53like a biologic switch that happens in
- 3:56which they suddenly start uh
- 3:58uh gaining weight rapidly. They they
- 4:00become very hungry. They start foraging
- 4:03for food.
- 4:05And they become insulin resistant.
- 4:08They get elevated fats not just in their
- 4:11adipose tissue,
- 4:13but also in their liver and blood.
- 4:16And fact, they develop the metabolic
- 4:18syndrome, but it's not a
- 4:20pathophysiologic
- 4:22disease. It's a condition they purposely
- 4:25want to do to help them be ready for
- 4:29when there's no food around.
- 4:32Now, the question is, you know, what
- 4:34drives that biologic switch? And
- 4:38uh
- 4:39we were very interested in this, and we
- 4:41we actually have done studies in
- 4:43hibernating bears
- 4:45and other animals, hibernating animals.
- 4:48And what what we found with the bear in
- 4:50particular was that
- 4:52uh a key trigger seems to be a massive
- 4:55ingestion of fruit.
- 4:57And these guys can eat huge amounts of
- 5:00fruit.
- 5:01And the fruit uh contains a a
- 5:03carbohydrate, a sugar called fructose or
- 5:06fructose.
- 5:08Now, we were very interested in fructose
- 5:11uh because,
- 5:12you know, it seemed like it might uh
- 5:14it's also a major component of table
- 5:16sugar. And there's a sweetener called
- 5:19high fructose corn syrup, which is
- 5:21particularly used
- 5:22uh in soft drinks in the US and Mexico
- 5:25and other places.
- 5:27And we were um
- 5:29you know, thinking that that perhaps
- 5:30that might be involved in this metabolic
- 5:33response.
- 5:35And when we put animals on fructose, we
- 5:39found, especially if we put it in the
- 5:40drinking water,
- 5:42that the animals would drink liked
- 5:44fructose a lot, and they would drink a
- 5:45lot of it.
- 5:47And they would uh become fat and insulin
- 5:50resistant and develop fatty liver and
- 5:52all the characteristics of metabolic
- 5:54syndrome fairly rapidly compared to uh
- 5:58control mice.
- 5:59These two are brothers, by the way.
- 6:04When we try to understand
- 6:07how this happened, we found that
- 6:09initially when you give an animals
- 6:12fructose or in the drinking water like a
- 6:15soft drink,
- 6:16that they get the calories from the
- 6:18drinking water so they eat less chow.
- 6:21So they try to stay in energy balance
- 6:24and this idea of staying in energy
- 6:26balance has been shown in multiple
- 6:27animals and also in humans
- 6:31that you know it's
- 6:33there studies showing that there is this
- 6:35desire to try to maintain
- 6:37your weight so that if you eat more one
- 6:39day
- 6:40you'll eat less the other the next and
- 6:42so forth or that you'll burn more
- 6:44calories.
- 6:45But and we could show that for the first
- 6:47few weeks
- 6:49that there was no change in body weight
- 6:51because they they kept an energy
- 6:53balance. But after around four weeks,
- 6:57five weeks
- 6:58they lost that
- 7:00that ability to maintain energy balance
- 7:03and they not only did they drink a lot
- 7:05of calories, but they started eating
- 7:08more calories. They became hungry. They
- 7:10became
- 7:12they they lost their satiety response
- 7:14and we could show that they were
- 7:16developing leptin resistance. Leptin is
- 7:19a hormone
- 7:20that's released by fat that acts on the
- 7:23brain to say that you're full.
- 7:25And if you give inject an animal with
- 7:28leptin,
- 7:29they'll reduce their food intake for the
- 7:31next 24 hours. They don't quit eating.
- 7:34They just reduce their food intake and
- 7:36you can show that by injecting leptin in
- 7:38normal animals, control animals over a
- 7:4124-hour period, they will reduce
- 7:44their their their food intake.
- 7:48But if they
- 7:51have fructose for like four to five
- 7:52weeks, they become leptin resistance and
- 7:55we could show that leptin resistance in
- 7:58the brain as well. We could show that it
- 8:00was happening.
- 8:05So in the beginning we said this looks
- 8:08like uh sugar just makes you hungry
- 8:12by causing a biologic response called
- 8:14leptin resistance
- 8:16and then you eat more. And so maybe
- 8:18really it is that simple that you're
- 8:20eating more
- 8:22and uh and and we found also that they
- 8:25became lethargic. The animals will will
- 8:28actually
- 8:29uh reduce their resting energy. Uh they
- 8:32they they huddle and kind of when they
- 8:35sleep they they they reduce their their
- 8:37movement.
- 8:39And uh and so we thought could it just
- 8:41be that? But then we did some
- 8:42experiments
- 8:44where we uh
- 8:45paired fed animals so that all the
- 8:47animals are eating the same amount of
- 8:49food.
- 8:50And we found that fructose
- 8:53had an effect
- 8:54on inducing metabolic syndrome even
- 8:58when
- 8:59we restricted the
- 9:00we we prevented them from eating more
- 9:02cuz they were hungrier, but we prevented
- 9:04them from being able to eat more. So
- 9:06they were eating the same amount of
- 9:07calories.
- 9:08And so there was a slight increase in
- 9:10weight
- 9:12when we did this because their resting
- 9:13energy metabolism decreased. But what we
- 9:16really saw was that they became
- 9:19diabetic. They became insulin resistant
- 9:21and diabetic. They developed fatty
- 9:23liver. They developed hypertension.
- 9:26And and we could show this even if we
- 9:28did caloric restriction. So we did a
- 9:31study where we restricted the calories
- 9:34to the to the rats. So they were eating
- 9:36less than uh you know they were eating
- 9:39only 90% of what they normally eat,
- 9:4185-90% of what they normally eat.
- 9:44And they still became diabetic and they
- 9:46still developed visceral fat. Um
- 9:49and so there was a mechanism that was
- 9:52occurring independently
- 9:54of of food of excess food intake. And we
- 9:58found that there were two paths and this
- 10:00is kind of important.
- 10:02Um there is this path where you they
- 10:04become leptin resistant
- 10:06and this makes them hungry.
- 10:09And interestingly when you make an
- 10:10animal leptin resistance, they seek fat.
- 10:14They really want to eat more calories.
- 10:16They know that they somehow sense that
- 10:18fat is got more calories.
- 10:20Um, and so they actually
- 10:23start craving fat.
- 10:25They drop their resting energy
- 10:26metabolism.
- 10:28And that combination of leptin
- 10:30resistance with fat
- 10:32makes them rapidly develop obesity. You
- 10:34can still make them get obese without
- 10:36giving them fat or giving them small
- 10:39amounts of fat.
- 10:40But um but they the fat really
- 10:43accelerates weight gain.
- 10:45So
- 10:47interesting though if if you know if in
- 10:49a keto diet you're eating a high fat
- 10:51diet, but you don't gain weight.
- 10:53But that's because
- 10:54keto diet prevents the leptin
- 10:56resistance.
- 10:58So it turns out that fat is important in
- 11:01driving obesity.
- 11:03But you have to be get leptin resistance
- 11:06from carbs
- 11:08first.
- 11:09And actually we found that we could stop
- 11:11the sugar and they would stay leptin
- 11:14resistant for weeks and that they remain
- 11:17susceptible
- 11:18to getting fat with a high fat diet
- 11:22while they're leptin resistance even
- 11:23when the sugar stopped.
- 11:25So this actually could explain a lot of
- 11:27the clinical studies that came from the
- 11:29NIH where they had no
- 11:31there was an immediate switch of diet.
- 11:35But the other point
- 11:37is that fructose was having a very
- 11:39strong effect on the mitochondria.
- 11:42And it was through the mitochondria
- 11:44effect as well as other enzymatic
- 11:46effects. It's not strictly
- 11:48mitochondrial, but it's it's heavily
- 11:50mitochondrial.
- 11:52And they could develop all the features
- 11:54of metabolic syndrome. And this can
- 11:55occur even with caloric restriction.
- 11:59So it's a little complicated, but
- 12:00hopefully
- 12:01you'll see.
- 12:03And then we realized that the metabolic
- 12:05syndrome was not just
- 12:08uh you know insulin resistance and
- 12:10elevated triglycerides and all this kind
- 12:12of stuff that we've learned,
- 12:14that it's actually a syndrome
- 12:17in which the animal becomes hungry
- 12:20and thirsty by the way,
- 12:22and seeks food. They actually start
- 12:24seeking food,
- 12:25a foraging response.
- 12:28And they develop they increase their
- 12:30food intake to increase their fat
- 12:32stores.
- 12:34They develop insulin resistance,
- 12:36which actually maintains a high blood
- 12:38glucose cuz when there's no food around,
- 12:40you want to have
- 12:42elevated glucose in your blood because
- 12:43the brain likes glucose and if there's
- 12:45not food around and you don't get enough
- 12:48fuel to the brain, you're going to be in
- 12:50trouble.
- 12:52It induced a systemic inflammatory
- 12:54response, a low-grade one, which
- 12:56probably helped it fight infection. It
- 12:58raises blood pressure to help maintain
- 13:00the circulation. It raises pressure in
- 13:02the kidney to help facilitate excretion
- 13:05and it reduces oxygen needs by
- 13:07suppressing the mitochondria, which
- 13:09allows it to live in a hypoxic
- 13:12environment. In fact, some animals use
- 13:15fructose to like the naked mole rat will
- 13:18actually make fructose when it's in the
- 13:20burrow it's in the in its burrows
- 13:22because it uses that to switch
- 13:25to a glycolytic pathway that allows it
- 13:28to to not have as much oxygen around. So
- 13:31it's all about survival. This is a
- 13:34pathway that animals use to survive
- 13:38is and to protect themselves from a time
- 13:41when there's no food around, food
- 13:43shortage
- 13:45and water shortage.
- 13:49So the question was, you know, why would
- 13:51this particular nutrient do that?
- 13:53Because we couldn't show it with other
- 13:55nutrients. It's really seems to be very
- 13:57specific to fructose.
- 14:00And what we found is that there is is
- 14:02it's all about chemistry and the
- 14:04metabolism of fructose. And fructose is
- 14:07you different from glucose
- 14:10in how it's metabolized. We just had a
- 14:12little review on this in Nature
- 14:14Metabolism that came out a few weeks
- 14:16ago.
- 14:17But basically, there's an enzyme called
- 14:19fructokinase that specific for fructose
- 14:22and it
- 14:23makes this substance called fructose 1
- 14:25phosphate, which actually is a signaling
- 14:27molecule and actually can signal a fat
- 14:31synthesis and uh a shift from
- 14:34mitochondrial metabolism to glycolysis.
- 14:37There's also ATP depletion that occurs
- 14:40acutely when fructose is phosphorylated
- 14:43that's not seen with glucose because of
- 14:46the feedback systems that glucose has.
- 14:49But with fructose, there's no feedback
- 14:51system and the ATP levels fall
- 14:53generating uric acid and the uric acid
- 14:57causes oxidative stress to the
- 14:59mitochondria that over time suppresses
- 15:01mitochondrial function.
- 15:03So it's like this perfect thing. It
- 15:05drops the energy level in a cell.
- 15:09And the way it kind of works, it's
- 15:11really
- 15:12cool
- 15:13is normally we I always thought that the
- 15:16way it worked was, you know, you eat
- 15:18food as a calorie or as an energy source
- 15:22and, you know, it's there to replace the
- 15:25active energy in the cell. And the
- 15:26active energy is called ATP.
- 15:29So you eat
- 15:31food to make energy, ATP, which we use
- 15:34to do everything we do.
- 15:36And if there's if the ATP levels are
- 15:38full, if you have enough ATP, that extra
- 15:42calories would go into fat.
- 15:45And that's a form of stored energy. So
- 15:47cuz when you burn fat, you can produce
- 15:49ATP.
- 15:51So it's like there's active energy, ATP,
- 15:53there's stored energy, it's fat.
- 15:55And the way it should work is you fill
- 15:57up the ATP, you fill the gas tank and
- 16:00then the extra energy gets stored as
- 16:03fat. But that's not how it works.
- 16:07That's not how it works.
- 16:09What we found is that the way it works
- 16:11is to trick the system into thinking
- 16:14that there's
- 16:15that you're starving.
- 16:17And the way fructose does that is it
- 16:19causes an acute drop in ATP. It's like,
- 16:23oh my gosh, there's not enough energy.
- 16:26And when it reduces the ATP,
- 16:30there's a signal
- 16:32to um to eat more.
- 16:36And so that then drives in more caloric
- 16:39intake, but there's also a block
- 16:42to prevent fat from being broken down.
- 16:44And so you the ATP levels stay low,
- 16:48and the energy you eat gets
- 16:50put into stored energy,
- 16:53and you increase your fat stores.
- 16:55Eventually the ATP levels return to
- 16:57normal, but at the expense that you've
- 16:59eaten more and you've stored more energy
- 17:02as fat.
- 17:04The way that this can be shown, for
- 17:06example, is if you inject
- 17:08glucose or fructose into the brain of a
- 17:10mouse.
- 17:12If you inject glucose into the brain of
- 17:14a mouse, the ATP levels in the brain go
- 17:16up immediately. The animal quits eating.
- 17:20It it's a satiety response.
- 17:22But if you give fructose to an animal
- 17:25and inject in the brain, the ATP levels
- 17:27fall,
- 17:28and the animal immediately gets hungry
- 17:31and eats more.
- 17:33It's all about energy.
- 17:35If the energy's low,
- 17:37it tells the animal to eat.
- 17:39If the energy's high, it tells the
- 17:40animal to quit eating.
- 17:42But that energy is the active energy,
- 17:45and the wild card is the stored energy.
- 17:48If you can divert the energy to the
- 17:50stored energy, you have the solution for
- 17:52what drives obesity.
- 17:57So we realize that the nutrient fructose
- 18:00is is really a serious
- 18:03uh bad nutrient in terms of us.
- 18:08It might be good if we were going to
- 18:09hibernate, but since we're not, uh
- 18:13you know,
- 18:14it it's not not an ideal nutrient
- 18:18for us.
- 18:19But there is uh I want to go back to the
- 18:22uric acid because we found
- 18:24that the uric acid was involved in how
- 18:27fructose works.
- 18:30Uric acid is a breakdown product of DNA
- 18:33and RNA.
- 18:35And uh it's actually the
- 18:37uh in most animals
- 18:40there's an enzyme that helps degrade
- 18:41uric acid
- 18:43called uricase.
- 18:45But our species lost that enzyme
- 18:50in a mutation that occurred millions of
- 18:52years ago.
- 18:53So humans
- 18:56have higher uric acid levels and we have
- 18:59to get rid of the uric acid through
- 19:01other ways and we do it through the
- 19:02urine and through the gut. We we try to
- 19:05excrete it but we can't actually break
- 19:07it down very well.
- 19:10And so these mutations led it to a
- 19:13higher uric acid and I was wondering why
- 19:16would we have a higher uric acid?
- 19:20Uh and I when I started looking at this
- 19:23I saw that there were actually evidence
- 19:25of parallel mutations.
- 19:28One that affected the
- 19:30the great apes and and humans
- 19:33uh an ancestor, common ancestor, and
- 19:36another one that affected the gibbons
- 19:38and the the the lesser apes.
- 19:41And the mutations had been timed to
- 19:44about 12 million years ago.
- 19:47So I thought well maybe I can get some
- 19:50you know I can this this could might be
- 19:52important in obesity because if uric
- 19:55acid is key to how fructose works
- 19:59maybe I could learn something by
- 20:01studying this period of time.
- 20:03So um I called and I started reading
- 20:07about it and I um
- 20:10learned that
- 20:12uh
- 20:13around 20 million years ago the first
- 20:15apes appeared in East Africa.
- 20:19And they were uh a big
- 20:22pro uh
- 20:23advance in evolution they were larger,
- 20:25they had bigger brains, they were
- 20:27tailless, but they lived on fruit. They
- 20:30they were primarily fruit eaters and
- 20:32they they lived in the trees and by 17
- 20:35million years ago, there was like 30
- 20:38species of apes. It was really a a time
- 20:40of it was a Garden of Eden
- 20:43uh in Africa and uh and there was a lot
- 20:46of
- 20:47uh
- 20:48of evolution and a lot of
- 20:50ape species that that
- 20:53uh occurred.
- 20:54And then there was a global cooling, not
- 20:57global warming, but global cooling. And
- 21:00it occurred in the mid Miocene and this
- 21:03led to
- 21:04uh a fall in the sea level
- 21:07uh and the development of ice at the
- 21:09polar caps.
- 21:11Uh and uh suddenly Africa, which was
- 21:14separated from Asia and Europe at the
- 21:17time,
- 21:18suddenly there was a land bridge
- 21:20and apes were able to migrate into
- 21:22Europe.
- 21:23And the world expert on that was at the
- 21:26Museum of Natural History here in
- 21:28London.
- 21:29And I reached out to him and he he
- 21:31studied these apes and and had written
- 21:34about it and uh he invited me over and
- 21:36yesterday I went to visit him in Poole.
- 21:39He's uh like 85 years old now. He's been
- 21:42retired for some time.
- 21:44But uh this work really was led by him
- 21:47in terms of understanding what happened
- 21:50back then.
- 21:53And what he showed was that as global
- 21:55cooling advanced,
- 21:58the apes in Europe began to starve
- 22:01during the winters, during the seasonal
- 22:03winters. And you could show this as
- 22:05striations on the enamel of their teeth
- 22:08cuz during
- 22:09uh grow while they're growing the the
- 22:11enamel uh is critical for good nutrition
- 22:14and when during the cooler seasons
- 22:17when the there was less fruit available,
- 22:20they started starving.
- 22:22And uh and what what uh Peter Andrew
- 22:25showed
- 22:27was that
- 22:29by based on fossil evidence,
- 22:32it was a European ape that went on to
- 22:35become humans and the great apes in
- 22:37Africa and the orangutan
- 22:39in Southeast Asia and he called this the
- 22:43back to Africa
- 22:44hypothesis that as the weather got
- 22:47cooler the apes in Europe became extinct
- 22:51but some of them made it back and those
- 22:53that made it back evolved to become
- 22:56uh us as well as the great apes and so
- 22:59forth.
- 23:00So
- 23:02he and I talked about this
- 23:04and we realized that the uric case
- 23:06mutation
- 23:07that the common ancestor for the
- 23:09orangutan the great apes was some ape in
- 23:12Europe
- 23:13during the time of seasonal starvation
- 23:15and
- 23:16we proposed
- 23:18that what happens is that as the season
- 23:23as uh global cooling occurred these apes
- 23:26could not survive the winter
- 23:29and we're starving but a mutation might
- 23:32have allowed a better
- 23:35fat response to
- 23:37to uh to the to the same amount of
- 23:40fructose or even to less fructose
- 23:42because it would drive a higher uric
- 23:44acid response if you didn't if you if
- 23:46you can't degrade the uric acid
- 23:49and that that might have allowed the
- 23:51animals to survive the winter.
- 23:54So to to look at that we actually
- 23:57resurrected the extinct gene
- 23:59and we're able to show in animals that
- 24:01when you extinguish this gene or
- 24:04actually was in cell culture but when
- 24:06you extinguish this gene that uh that
- 24:08the fat response to fructose
- 24:11is is amplified.
- 24:14And we also found
- 24:16that if we took
- 24:18like laboratory rats and we inhibited
- 24:21uric case that even small amounts of
- 24:24sugar
- 24:25could cause metabolic syndrome.
- 24:28So they we could enhance the effects
- 24:31of sugar
- 24:32or for soft of fructose
- 24:35by just inhibiting the uricase and then
- 24:39the soft drinks cause that greater uric
- 24:41acid response, more insulin resistance,
- 24:44higher blood pressures, more weight
- 24:45gain, higher triglycerides, higher
- 24:48liver fat. In other words,
- 24:50it seems like this was
- 24:53uh
- 24:54a survival mechanism that helped us
- 24:56survive, that we developed a a
- 24:58sensitivity to sugar
- 25:01that um that everyone has compared to
- 25:04other species, that we are particularly
- 25:06sensitive because we had this mutation.
- 25:10And that mutation
- 25:11uh allowed us to store fat easier
- 25:15in response to sugar.
- 25:18But that was fine back then, and
- 25:20actually we found that the mutation only
- 25:22raised uric acid
- 25:24to like three or four milligrams per
- 25:26deciliter, and in 1920 that was what was
- 25:29normal in in in the American population.
- 25:33But over the last 100 years as sugar
- 25:35intake has gone up, as well as other
- 25:38foods that drive up uric acid, the serum
- 25:41uric acid continues to increase along
- 25:44with sugar intake. So now we're in a
- 25:46high sugar
- 25:47environment with high uric acid.
- 25:51And if you look at uric acid levels, the
- 25:54higher your level,
- 25:56the higher the frequency of obesity, the
- 25:59higher the frequency of diabetes,
- 26:02the higher the frequency of
- 26:03hypertension, the higher the frequency
- 26:05of kidney disease.
- 26:08So this mutation
- 26:11was great
- 26:13back then,
- 26:15but it's not great now. It's like a
- 26:17thrifty gene. It's like something that
- 26:19was meant to help us during a time of
- 26:21food scarcity
- 26:23is now
- 26:25a boomerang back and hurting us during a
- 26:27time of food plenty.
- 26:31But most people when we talk about uric
- 26:33acid, we think of of the classic disease
- 26:36gout, which you know, most mammals do
- 26:39not get gout
- 26:40because they have uricase.
- 26:42But uh actually, you know,
- 26:45uh uh we we have lost this enzyme, so we
- 26:48get the disease gout. And it's
- 26:50interesting that birds
- 26:52uh and reptiles lost uric acid as well
- 26:55through separate mechanisms, and they
- 26:56get gout as well.
- 26:58So the Tyrannosaurus had gout.
- 27:01And uh so we're not alone.
- 27:04But uh but we get gout. Among mammals,
- 27:07we're we're the ones that really get
- 27:09this.
- 27:10And it's because of that mutation.
- 27:12And gout is this painful arthritis where
- 27:15uric acid, which is not very soluble,
- 27:18can crystallize. And when it
- 27:20crystallizes, it can those crystals can
- 27:23deposit in the joints. We now have ways
- 27:25to look for the crystals under using
- 27:28dual energy CT scans.
- 27:31And so um we know that these crystals
- 27:33are very pro-inflammatory.
- 27:35And about 9 million people in the US
- 27:37have gout, and it's particularly common
- 27:40among men, especially those who have
- 27:42metabolic syndrome.
- 27:45Surprise.
- 27:47What is uh been exciting and scary about
- 27:51this has been the discovery in the last
- 27:53few years
- 27:54that the crystals aren't just going to
- 27:56the joints.
- 27:58Now we're discovering with this new dual
- 28:00energy CT scan that crystals are also
- 28:03going to the coronary arteries
- 28:06and to the aorta and to blood vessels.
- 28:09And it's this very scary thing because
- 28:12uh some studies, like one recently in
- 28:14JAMA, found that 85% of people with gout
- 28:18have some crystals in their blood
- 28:19vessels.
- 28:21That's scary, okay? Because it's
- 28:23pro-inflammatory, it activates
- 28:25inflammasome, and it
- 28:27localizes to atherosclerotic plaque.
- 28:31And in fact,
- 28:33um
- 28:34its presence
- 28:35increases the risk for heart attacks and
- 28:39cardiac mortality.
- 28:42And so, uh,
- 28:44gout is not
- 28:46just a
- 28:48nuisance, uh, arthritis that people get
- 28:52from, uh,
- 28:53associated with obesity.
- 28:55It's the crystals are actually playing a
- 28:58role
- 28:59in cardiovascular events.
- 29:02And in fact,
- 29:04the epidemiology suggests that gout
- 29:06increases the risk
- 29:08for
- 29:09uh, cardiac mortality
- 29:11including in uh,
- 29:14large meta-analyses and
- 29:17epidemiologic studies.
- 29:19And it also increases the risk for total
- 29:21mortality.
- 29:23But you can also see this with
- 29:24hyperuricemia itself.
- 29:26And now there are Mendelian
- 29:28randomization studies which kind of look
- 29:30at genetically elevations, genetically
- 29:33driven elevations in uric acid also
- 29:36predict cardiovascular death.
- 29:42Well, uric crystals can also form in the
- 29:44kidneys and in the back and in the eye
- 29:47and other sites, but particularly
- 29:50uh, crystals can form in the urine and
- 29:52then they can activate inflammasomes
- 29:55on the in the tubular lining and then
- 29:57the crystals get taken up into the
- 29:59kidney tissue and
- 30:01there's a very strong relationship of
- 30:03gout with kidney disease and it's been a
- 30:05area of of intense study and I'm I'm a
- 30:08kidney specialist
- 30:10um, among other things and um, and it's
- 30:13been an area that we've been studying a
- 30:15lot.
- 30:16And we we uh, definitely have
- 30:19experimental and other supporting
- 30:21evidence that
- 30:23gout is is involved in kidney disease.
- 30:31So, we think that uric acid is involved
- 30:34not just in um,
- 30:36gout,
- 30:37in cardiovascular and kidney disease.
- 30:39And we also found, as you saw, that uric
- 30:43acid is involved in the metabolic
- 30:44response of fructose.
- 30:47But I'm going to kind of move away from
- 30:49that just for a little bit now
- 30:52and talk about uh,
- 30:54if if the fructose we get is primarily
- 30:57dietary.
- 30:58And um,
- 31:00for sure the overwhelming
- 31:03intake of fructose is from sugar
- 31:07and sweet foods.
- 31:09But it turns out that sugar is not just
- 31:12is not the only source of fructose
- 31:15that we get.
- 31:16And this was a very surprising thing
- 31:19when we found this.
- 31:21But basically the body can make
- 31:24fructose. And it's been known for a long
- 31:25time that there's this pathway called
- 31:27the polyol pathway
- 31:29that can convert glucose to fructose.
- 31:32Fructose can also be converted to
- 31:34glucose, believe it or not, but so but
- 31:37there's there is a two-way street where
- 31:38some glucose can be converted to
- 31:41fructose and there's a specific enzyme
- 31:43called aldose reductase that seems to be
- 31:46the controlling enzyme for this
- 31:48reaction.
- 31:51And when you eat a high-carb diet,
- 31:53you're basically increasing the
- 31:55substrate for an enzyme reaction
- 31:58that that shifts glucose to fructose. So
- 32:01a high-carb diet, diabetes in which you
- 32:04have high glucose in your blood and so
- 32:06forth
- 32:07can can drive this reaction.
- 32:10And we found that if we gave carbs to
- 32:14animals
- 32:15that they could convert the carbs to
- 32:18fructose if it was high-glycemic carbs.
- 32:20And we could
- 32:21induce metabolic syndrome. But if we
- 32:24blocked fructose metabolism,
- 32:26the carbs were much less effective at
- 32:29causing metabolic syndrome. And in fact,
- 32:31this is a study we did with soft drinks.
- 32:33So soft drinks
- 32:35we give them to mice, they develop
- 32:37full-blown metabolic syndrome.
- 32:39And the soft drinks had glucose and
- 32:41fructose in them. They're made with high
- 32:43fructose corn syrup.
- 32:45But what we found was that if we blocked
- 32:47fructose metabolism,
- 32:50we could block the development of
- 32:52metabolic syndrome
- 32:53from soft drinks.
- 32:55So it turns out that the glucose in the
- 32:57soft drinks
- 32:59is working heavily through its ability
- 33:01to to generate fructose.
- 33:04And that And when you block fructose
- 33:06metabolism, you block the effects of a
- 33:09high glycemic meal to cause metabolic
- 33:12syndrome.
- 33:13There's still a glucose insulin pathway
- 33:15that's important,
- 33:17um but it's much less uh significant
- 33:20compared to the fructose pathway, at
- 33:23least in the animal.
- 33:26We also knew that
- 33:28aldose reductase is activated by salt,
- 33:31and there's a whole literature on on
- 33:33salt activating this enzyme.
- 33:36And so we became interested, you know,
- 33:38could salt actually
- 33:40be involved in metabolic syndrome?
- 33:44And uh I started talking to my obesity
- 33:46doctor friends and
- 33:48And there's like a large literature that
- 33:50people who are overweight eat a high
- 33:51salt diet. It's like classic and
- 33:54ultra-processed foods that are rich in
- 33:56sugar and salt
- 33:58that there's salt is is uh is a big
- 34:00component, and you can show that they
- 34:02have high salt concentrations in the
- 34:04urine, and they have increased
- 34:07osmolarity, which is when you eat salt,
- 34:09the salt concentration goes up in your
- 34:11blood.
- 34:12And you can show that in people who are
- 34:14overweight.
- 34:15And when we put salt, just salt in the
- 34:18water, we We add We added a little bit
- 34:21of sucralose to make it more
- 34:23uh
- 34:24So the animals like it, but we actually
- 34:26showed that sucralose alone did nothing.
- 34:29But we found that when we gave salt to
- 34:31animals that they did become obese, but
- 34:33it took a lot longer than with sugar. So
- 34:36sugar, the effect is like eight weeks.
- 34:38Salt, we had to go like
- 34:40three months, four months before we
- 34:42started seeing it, but they became fat
- 34:44and diabetic.
- 34:45And their blood pressures went up. And
- 34:47when we blocked fructose metabolism,
- 34:50even with them getting the same amount
- 34:52of salt, we could block the development
- 34:55of obesity.
- 34:57And the question is why would salt
- 35:00intake cause obesity?
- 35:02And
- 35:03as as I mentioned, salt raises serum
- 35:06osmolality
- 35:07and kind of mimics dehydration.
- 35:10Dehydrated animals need water to
- 35:12survive.
- 35:14And it turns out that when you burn fat,
- 35:16you also produce water.
- 35:19It's called metabolic water.
- 35:21So fat is not just a source of calories,
- 35:23it's a source of water. And when an
- 35:26animal hibernates and burns its fat,
- 35:28it's using the the water from the
- 35:30metabolic
- 35:32the metabolic water from the fat to
- 35:34survive. So animals use water, metabolic
- 35:38water. And in fact, some species like
- 35:41the whale
- 35:42that's very fat
- 35:44uses the fat to produce water, but 1/3
- 35:47of its water comes from
- 35:49from from the fat because they they
- 35:51don't drink salt water. They get their
- 35:53water from their food they eat
- 35:55and from the fat they metabolize.
- 35:58So
- 35:59as mentioned, obese people tend to be
- 36:01dehydrated. They tend to have
- 36:03be on high salt diets. And so it's sort
- 36:06of a secret that no one realizes, but
- 36:09people overweight tend not to drink
- 36:11enough water.
- 36:14And there is a hormone that drives water
- 36:18conservation.
- 36:19And it's called vasopressin. And animals
- 36:22in the desert and many animals have high
- 36:24vasopressin levels to help them conserve
- 36:26water. And most of the way we think of
- 36:28it is it it reduces the loss of water in
- 36:31the urine. So when your urine becomes
- 36:33dark yellow and concentrated, it's
- 36:36because you've turned on this hormone to
- 36:38help hold on to water.
- 36:41So we wondered, could vasopressin be
- 36:44also involved in how fructose works and
- 36:48how salt works to increase obesity?
- 36:51Because
- 36:52uh you know, vasopressin is the water
- 36:55preservation hormone.
- 36:57And what we found was that when we gave
- 36:59fructose to animals,
- 37:01that they started making vasopressin.
- 37:05And if you give glucose to animals
- 37:07acutely, they don't until the glucose
- 37:09converts to fructose. So a glucose won't
- 37:11stimulate vasopressin acutely,
- 37:14but fructose does.
- 37:16And when we started studying it more,
- 37:19we found that um that vasopressin
- 37:22levels, and this was actually done by a
- 37:24lot of other people,
- 37:26are inevitably high in people with
- 37:28obesity. It's like a great serum marker.
- 37:31That they call it copeptin, but it's
- 37:33kind of the uh
- 37:35stable derivative of vasopressin, but
- 37:37it's elevated and predicts obesity. It's
- 37:40very high in people with obesity. It
- 37:42predicts diabetes.
- 37:43Uh it's like a biomarker that's not used
- 37:46very often.
- 37:48So it turns out that vasopressin goes
- 37:51through the V2 receptor to concentrate
- 37:53urine,
- 37:54but there were these other receptors
- 37:57that no one really knew what they did.
- 37:58We know the V1A receptor helps drive
- 38:01blood pressure,
- 38:02which is a survival mechanism. But there
- 38:05was this receptor called the V1B
- 38:06receptor no one really knew what it did.
- 38:09We do know that
- 38:11it activates uh the adrenal gland to
- 38:14make a uh the brain to make ACTH and
- 38:16then the adrenal gland to make cortisol.
- 38:19And it also raises glucagon,
- 38:23which can raise blood glucose.
- 38:25But what we found is that
- 38:28fructose-induced metabolic syndrome
- 38:31is working through vasopressin.
- 38:34And that it's involving uric acid, yes,
- 38:37and it's involving vasopressin.
- 38:40And it's through this receptor that no
- 38:42one really knew about.
- 38:43When you knock out the V1B receptor, you
- 38:46can prevent animals from developing
- 38:49obesity even when they eat all the sugar
- 38:52they want. And in fact, they like sugar
- 38:54more
- 38:55than a normal mouse, but they don't get
- 38:57fat.
- 38:59They're completely protected.
- 39:01Now, vasopressin is a hormone that can
- 39:03be suppressed by hydration. It can be
- 39:05suppressed by water.
- 39:07And we did some studies cuz there was
- 39:09this belief that hydration might
- 39:12actually help reduce obesity.
- 39:16And so what we ended up doing was we did
- 39:19a hydration study
- 39:20where we hydrated animals
- 39:23uh with with gel food that has gel on it
- 39:26and so we could control how much water
- 39:29they were getting. We could suppress the
- 39:31development of obesity
- 39:34to sugar
- 39:35and also in general to western diet.
- 39:38So this idea that drinking water
- 39:41uh can help keep you skinny is true.
- 39:44Okay? It's true.
- 39:45And uh we I believe that you we should
- 39:48be drinking like eight glasses of water
- 39:50a day
- 39:52if we can.
- 39:54And in fact, we did studies in humans
- 39:56where we gave sugar or salt
- 39:58and we could show evidence for
- 40:00activation of the vasopressin pathway.
- 40:02Vasopressin levels went up. ACTH went
- 40:05up. This is in people.
- 40:07Um and we could suppress it by just
- 40:09giving them extra water. So we gave
- 40:10salty soup
- 40:12and it activates the process and the
- 40:14blood pressure goes up and cortisol goes
- 40:16up and we can block that. Uric acid goes
- 40:19up. We can block that by simple
- 40:22hydration.
- 40:24Uh this is uric acid, glucose.
- 40:29So in conclusion,
- 40:31uh
- 40:32we think that
- 40:34this survival switch can turn can can
- 40:37accelerate
- 40:38and
- 40:39when it's overactivated, it can be
- 40:41driving disease.
- 40:42I'm going to just give a case example of
- 40:44Alzheimer's here in the last couple
- 40:46minutes.
- 40:47Um Alzheimer's disease is now being
- 40:49linked with metabolic syndrome.
- 40:52They call it insulin resistance in the
- 40:53brain.
- 40:55They get mitochondrial dysfunction in
- 40:56the brain. These are all things that
- 40:58fructose does.
- 40:59So we were wondering could fructose be
- 41:01involved
- 41:02because it's the same risk factors. Even
- 41:04a high salt diet has been linked with
- 41:06Alzheimer's
- 41:07and ultra processed foods.
- 41:10And people who eat sugar
- 41:12tend to have lower cognitive function.
- 41:15They have
- 41:16smaller brains by CT
- 41:19in studies from the NHANES.
- 41:22And if you give fructose to animals
- 41:25they develop trouble they have trouble
- 41:27over time getting through maze. They
- 41:29develop all these these findings
- 41:32insulin resistance to the brain, reduced
- 41:35mitochondrial energy, oxidative stress
- 41:38and even over time they develop amyloid
- 41:40plaques.
- 41:42And so it turns out that this is a study
- 41:45in humans
- 41:47where if you give person and you clamp
- 41:49their blood sugar to be a little bit
- 41:50high you can show an increase in
- 41:53fructose production in the brain of
- 41:55humans
- 41:56in this study that was published by a
- 41:58group at Yale.
- 42:01And when you look at the brain of
- 42:02patients with Alzheimer's they have five
- 42:05to six fold higher fructose levels.
- 42:07And we think that that foraging
- 42:12it's basically a foraging response gone
- 42:14wrong
- 42:15because what happens is they to forage
- 42:18you have to reduce the blood supply to
- 42:20the brain and this is what fructose
- 42:21does.
- 42:23And over time it causes
- 42:26dementia.
- 42:28And if you look at
- 42:29Mendelian studies uric acid's the only
- 42:32one that really lines up with
- 42:33Alzheimer's.
- 42:37So
- 42:38the final comment is
- 42:41fruits are healthy.
- 42:43Don't not eat fruit.
- 42:45If you eat like a bear you're getting
- 42:47trouble. If you drink fruit juice you're
- 42:48in trouble. But look at the the of
- 42:49fructose in a fruit compared to a soft
- 42:53drink is it astronomically different.
- 42:56And fruit has a lot of good things like
- 42:59vitamin C and so forth that actually
- 43:00counter some of the effects of fructose.
- 43:04Some people say, well, look, sugar
- 43:05intake is decreasing.
- 43:08How can you explain the rise in obesity?
- 43:10But they just need to look at history.
- 43:13There's a delay after sugar is reduced
- 43:16before you see a a drop
- 43:18in prevalence. But if you look at like
- 43:21diabetes incidence,
- 43:23uh this started falling just in concert
- 43:25with
- 43:26uh with the reduction in sugar intake.
- 43:30And but obesity plateaus, the prevalence
- 43:33plateaus, it takes a longer time.
- 43:36Although it's now decreasing, part of
- 43:38that could be from GLP-1s.
- 43:41And so I'm going to end by just saying
- 43:44evolution is continuing as we speak.
- 43:46I've written a book about this and uh
- 43:48thank you very much.
- 43:51>> [applause]
- 44:00[applause]
- 44:01>> And well, thank you so much for that,
- 44:03Professor. Um just the the the body of
- 44:06work that you've
- 44:08accumulated [laughter]
- 44:08over the decades is uh astounding.
- 44:11>> That's why I'm so old.
- 44:14>> Um and I kind of on that note, every
- 44:16year we um award somebody uh with the
- 44:21Bennett Foundation Lifetime Achievement
- 44:23Award. And this year we thought it very
- 44:25apt to be presented to you. So
- 44:28congratulations, Steve, if you want to
- 44:29come on out.
- 44:30>> [applause]
- 44:30>> Thank you.
- 44:36>> [applause]
- 44:38>> It's a pleasure to meet you.
- 44:43>> We uh
- 44:44didn't have to think too hard this year
- 44:45because Simon and I reckon between us we
- 44:47read about 20,000 of your papers. Uh now
- 44:50I don't know if you've done 20,000
- 44:51papers, that probably means we've read
- 44:53it more than once, but uh
- 44:58[applause]
- 45:03[music]
- 45:05thank you for everything. Brilliant.
- 45:06>> Thank you very much.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Prof. Richard Johnson // Evolution, Nature and Diet: Insights into the Cause of the Obesity Epidemic by Preventive Health Collaboration, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,307 words across 1,151 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.