Post Office DID NOT Give Subpostmaster Alan Bates Contract — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00So we're jumping back into Alan Bates'
- 0:01his testimony to the Post Office Horizon
- 0:03IT inquiry and he details
- 0:06um what was sounds like quite a nice
- 0:07lovely post office that him and his wife
- 0:09had big plans for. Um and there's some
- 0:12mysteries relating to the sub
- 0:14postmaster's contract where he didn't
- 0:17receive the sub postmaster's contract
- 0:19and the Post Office tried to say well
- 0:21that he tried to disagree with that
- 0:23statement um when they took the
- 0:25litigation to court in 2019.
- 0:29However, the judge in that case, Mr.
- 0:31Justice Fraser, did actually decide that
- 0:34as a credible witness what he was saying
- 0:36in regards to not receiving it was true.
- 0:39Let's jump into the inquiry.
- 0:40Talking of which, um you ran a post
- 0:42office in North Wales.
- 0:45I did.
- 0:45Um what was the name of the post office
- 0:47and in which town was it?
- 0:49It's Craig-y-Don Post Office in
- 0:50Llandudno.
- 0:51Just say that again.
- 0:54Craig-y-Don Post Office in Llandudno.
- 0:57Yeah, I'm glad I don't have to say that.
- 0:59Don't ask me to repeat that.
- 1:00Um what kind of post office?
- 1:02It's like me teasing him about those
- 1:03names.
- 1:03I see. Okay.
- 1:05Uh what kind of post office was it?
- 1:07It was well it
- 1:09it was a three-position counter in uh it
- 1:12was uh when we first
- 1:14bought the property it was very much at
- 1:16the back of the the property in there
- 1:18and it was a bit run down. Um it also
- 1:20had another side and a
- 1:22um a retail side to the business which
- 1:25was a whole variety of things.
- 1:28Crafts, knitting, um
- 1:30haberdashery, a whole range of of
- 1:33things. So, for the first year or two we
- 1:36just ran the business as it was and
- 1:39slowly developed it from there putting
- 1:41on a
- 1:42big extension, up- updating the um
- 1:46updating a lot of the stock, but more
- 1:48importantly, we actually saw it as a a a
- 1:52big potential to to grow the Post Office
- 1:54business and we brought it right to the
- 1:56front of the building and with a
- 2:00a large queuing area for for people.
- 2:03Unfortunately, it seems what post
- 2:04offices need. And um
- 2:08so we we invested quite heavily in
- 2:11developing the post office and that was
- 2:12at the time Horizon came in.
- 2:15And imagine doing that, doing your best
- 2:17to make a business work, building up a
- 2:18small business to have security for
- 2:20yourself and your own family, to have an
- 2:23income, to provide a service to the
- 2:25community, and to have a massive
- 2:27organization come and decide to crush it
- 2:30for a completely invalid reason.
- 2:34Thank you. And I think you and your wife
- 2:36Suzanne were
- 2:3744 years old when you took it over, is
- 2:39that right?
- 2:40About that, yes, it would have been.
- 2:42You tell us in your witness statements
- 2:44that there's no need to turn it up. It's
- 2:45paragraphs 9 to 13 in summary terms
- 2:49about your decision to become a sub
- 2:51postmaster,
- 2:52your decision to pick this post office,
- 2:55uh your hopes and aspirations, and the
- 2:58process by which you applied, and by
- 3:00which your application was approved. I
- 3:04just want to look at an account you've
- 3:06given in the past in more detail about
- 3:08that, if we may.
- 3:09Um can we look, please, on the screen at
- 3:11poll 302
- 3:134194. Uh this is a witness statement you
- 3:16made in the course of the um group
- 3:19litigation proceedings in the High
- 3:20Court. Um we'll deal more about that
- 3:23later today. Uh is that right?
- 3:26Yes, it is, yes.
- 3:27And we can see the date on it in the top
- 3:29right, um 9th of August, 2018.
- 3:33Right, you did on in the conduct now.
- 3:35Hopefully, I did that quite well.
- 3:37And so this witness statement was made
- 3:40for the purposes of what came to be
- 3:42known as the common issues trial, is
- 3:43that right?
- 3:44That's correct.
- 3:45And so the process by which you applied
- 3:48to become a sub postmaster,
- 3:50the documents that were or in fact were
- 3:53not given to you,
- 3:55were important issues and addressed in
- 3:58this witness statement in very great
- 4:00great detail. Is that right?
- 4:02That is right, yeah.
- 4:03Can we look, please, at page three and
- 4:06pick up at paragraph 11, please? You say
- 4:09a key attraction to working with Post
- 4:11Office was that it would provide secure
- 4:14employment based upon the fact it
- 4:16provides a community service and has an
- 4:19established brand in the community. From
- 4:22among the various small business options
- 4:24available, a Post Office branch would,
- 4:26in my mind, be a safe option.
- 4:28I was also encouraged by the fact I
- 4:30could run a secondary business
- 4:32such as a retail shop alongside the Post
- 4:34Office branch.
- 4:36That sets out in summary your reasons
- 4:38for picking Post Office as a
- 4:41a future enterprise with your wife. Is
- 4:44that right?
- 4:45That's correct.
- 4:46So, big plans there. You know, seems
- 4:49like they knew what they wanted to do.
- 4:51Set up something to have some security
- 4:53for themselves and what was it, you
- 4:56know, turned out not to be the case
- 4:58because of a horrendous mistake relating
- 5:01to a computer system. It's absolutely
- 5:03shocking. Compounded then by the human
- 5:06failure, which I think is even worse
- 5:08than the fact that Horizon seemed to be
- 5:12completely unfit for purpose. I did just
- 5:14notice there in paragraph 10 it says
- 5:16August 1996 I left Eureka. I'm pretty
- 5:18sure that was a museum that I remember
- 5:20going to. That was pretty cool. Might
- 5:22have been around that time as well.
- 5:24Now, um, paragraph 12 on this page right
- 5:28through to, um, paragraph 23 on page
- 5:33five addresses the initial inquiries you
- 5:37made with the existing or the outgoing
- 5:40sub-postmaster, Peter Savage, I think
- 5:42his name was.
- 5:42That's correct.
- 5:43Um, and the planned visits that you made
- 5:47and indeed some unannounced visits that
- 5:48you made
- 5:50to the post office in question as part
- 5:52of your due diligence. Is that right?
- 5:54That's correct.
- 5:56Can we just look at paragraph 21 on page
- 5:58five, please?
- 6:00So, it wasn't something that they just
- 6:01jumped into. A lot of research. I mean,
- 6:03it probably won't surprise us that he
- 6:05was meticulous with this cuz he's as
- 6:07he's shown in having to battle the post
- 6:10office every way during the battle
- 6:12during the post office scandal. You
- 6:14know, you have to be meticulous,
- 6:15dedicated, and as Alan Bates puts it,
- 6:17stubborn.
- 6:18You say that you do remember that during
- 6:20one of my visits
- 6:22um to the branch, Mr. Savage explained
- 6:24that he had a practice of keeping unders
- 6:27and overs in a tin in the safe as a
- 6:30system to deal with any odd shorts or
- 6:33overs. I remember this cuz I thought it
- 6:35to be rather casual and unusual for a
- 6:37business. Nevertheless, I was not
- 6:39particularly concerned and considered it
- 6:41to be a matter for Mr. Savage and his
- 6:42staff, and I didn't understand it to
- 6:45involve large figures or to be um
- 6:48uh problematic. Is that
- 6:50And I can see where he's coming from
- 6:51there because, you know, as anybody who
- 6:54runs a business will tell you it's
- 6:55important to know literally where every
- 6:57penny is at every point to be accounted
- 6:59for.
- 7:00Right.
- 7:01That is right, and it was very odd and
- 7:03very strange, I thought, for a for a
- 7:05cash-based um system
- 7:08where you didn't actually record
- 7:10anywhere the amounts. Um and you didn't
- 7:14you didn't provide post office with
- 7:15returns of the position each week in
- 7:18there as well. But, you know, that
- 7:19seemed to be the way it operated.
- 7:21But, these were small sums of money, is
- 7:22that
- 7:23They were small sums of money, yeah.
- 7:25Uh on um
- 7:27from paragraph 24, if we scroll down,
- 7:29please, um right through to paragraph 33
- 7:32at the bottom of page seven,
- 7:34you deal with the agreement to purchase
- 7:36the post office.
- 7:38Yes?
- 7:38Yes.
- 7:39And then if we go forward to page eight,
- 7:40please,
- 7:42um from paragraph 34 on this page,
- 7:45uh, right through to, uh, paragraph 86
- 7:48on page 19,
- 7:50you deal with the following issues. I'm
- 7:53just going to summarize them without
- 7:55reading the text.
- 7:56Firstly, the application to the Post
- 7:58Office to be a sub-postmaster.
- 8:01Secondly, the interview at the regional
- 8:03office in Bangor that you and your, um,
- 8:06wife attended.
- 8:08Thirdly, um, the confirmation that your
- 8:12application had been successful.
- 8:15And the material that you were then
- 8:17given.
- 8:18Yes? And if we just go forward to page
- 8:2015, please, and look at paragraph 62,
- 8:23you say,
- 8:24"At no stage during the process of my
- 8:26application, appointment, and branch
- 8:28opening,
- 8:30uh, was I ever, um, sent a copy of the
- 8:32sub-postmaster contract. I first
- 8:34obtained a copy of the sub-postmaster
- 8:36contract much later in circumstances I
- 8:39explained below. At no point during my
- 8:42appointment process was it mentioned or
- 8:43explained to me that the sub-postmaster
- 8:46contract, which was a lengthy document
- 8:48of 114 pages, governed the terms of my,
- 8:52um, appointment." Now, we hear later
- 8:54that, uh, is this right, that the Post
- 8:56Office robustly challenged you on that
- 8:59issue alongside other issues at the
- 9:02trial, and then the trial judge, then
- 9:04Mr. Justice Fraser, held that you were
- 9:07an honest witness, that you were telling
- 9:09the truth, and that like many other
- 9:11sub-postmasters, you did not receive a
- 9:14copy of this document.
- 9:15It's correct.
- 9:17And this is probably surprisingly more
- 9:19common than you'd think these days.
- 9:21There's many people, private and public
- 9:23sector, who start jobs and aren't given
- 9:26a written contract. Uh, I think it's
- 9:28supposed to be provided,
- 9:31I may be wrong on this, but within so
- 9:33many weeks, I want to say 12 weeks of
- 9:34appointment to a post, but in many cases
- 9:37not, on them. Sure people will let us
- 9:38know their experience in the comments
- 9:40below.
- 9:40You address later in this section of
- 9:42your witness statement your initial
- 9:44classroom
- 9:45training and then lastly the transfer of
- 9:49the branch to you and the opening of it.
- 9:52Correct?
- 9:53Correct. Yes.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Post Office DID NOT Give Subpostmaster Alan Bates Contract by DPS Computing, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,665 words across 274 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.