Po 20 latach rozwiodłam się z PASTOREM. Doświadczałam PRZEMOCY psychicznej i religijnej – Sielatycka — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00For 20 years, you were a pastor's wife. And I thought there was no
- 0:03safer person than someone who was held so close to God.
- 0:06No. Before the wedding, the senior pastor at the time told me that
- 0:11if I still had any kind of doubt in my head, it meant I wasn't
- 0:14submissive enough. I didn't know that you actually didn't want to.
- 0:18Even though, for example, I was screaming, shouting, 'Leave me alone,' crying, it still
- 0:23wasn't clear. It broke my heart when my son was afraid to
- 0:25leave his room and waited until he left the house, or asked me to bring
- 0:29him something from the fridge because he was afraid to go into the kitchen, because Dad would
- 0:33either yell at him or make fun of him. There were situations
- 0:37where, for example, I was pushed out of the house and wandered around the neighborhood.
- 0:42Friends came to pick me up because I'd happened to take my phone with me. It was
- 0:46winter, I didn't have a coat. I felt I couldn't get out, that here
- 0:48I couldn't stay in touch with those people, because we had to go together,
- 0:52I couldn't do something because those people weren't good enough
- 0:56and he, for example, didn't like those people, and that was difficult for me.
- 0:59But okay, I thought, this is a new relationship,
- 1:02we're married, we're building a family, and so on. Someone wrote that if you don't
- 1:09feel Jesus strongly enough, you can't go to a psychologist.
- 1:13Hi. A very warm welcome to everyone to another episode of the Duszno
- 1:17podcast. My guest today is Magda Sielatycka. Hi, Magda.
- 1:20Hi. Listen, Magda is, however strange this may
- 1:25sound, a former pastor's wife, a psychology student and the founder
- 1:30of the Sztuka Wyjścia foundation, which focuses on helping people
- 1:35who have experienced religious and domestic abuse. Is everything
- 1:37okay, darling? Yeah.
- 1:41Oh, okay. [laughter] I can see you're looking at that. Focused
- 1:46on helping victims of religious and domestic abuse, and that's something
- 1:51we're going to talk about a little. [snort] You told me
- 1:55that you're afraid to speak publicly about experiences like these,
- 2:01that there will be an uproar in the Protestant community, but you
- 2:08have such a strong drive to help that you still want to talk about it. So I
- 2:13first wanted to ask: who would you like to help by telling
- 2:17your story? That's a good question. I especially
- 2:20liked that word, 'drive.'
- 2:23Yes, maybe I do have some kind of [laughter] drive,
- 2:29right? Great, great. When it comes to the people I have in mind,
- 2:34people I ultimately want to help, it is definitely those
- 2:40who have had some kind of experience with abuse,
- 2:46whether domestic, within the family, or in the context of communities
- 2:53or organizations that used certain methods, or where
- 2:57people found themselves in situations where they were experiencing abuse
- 3:01in some way. And I realize that sometimes this can be subjective,
- 3:05but it still matters, because if someone feels they are experiencing
- 3:08abuse or that they were treated inappropriately, it needs to be
- 3:12addressed. So it isn't only a question of whether we can objectively
- 3:16verify it. That's what courts are for. But we can also
- 3:24support someone who needs that help. Another group
- 3:28is people who have someone among their loved ones or friends
- 3:33who says they are experiencing this kind of abuse, who is in a situation
- 3:36that is deeply uncomfortable for them and affects them very
- 3:40deeply, and you can see that person fading, behaving
- 3:45differently, that their life is no longer moving in a positive
- 3:49direction, but that they are genuinely being oppressed or
- 3:53manipulated in some way. We want to help that person, but we don't know how. And
- 3:58this is also something I'd like to address, because there are many
- 4:02people who simply want to help but don't know how. Mm-hmm. And now
- 4:07let's go back to the beginning. Maybe we should explain it, because we want
- 4:12this whole story to be based very strongly on your own story and your
- 4:15experiences. You were a pastor's wife for 20 years.
- 4:21Well, almost. Almost, almost 20 years. It would have been 20
- 4:24this year. And maybe for those who are outside
- 4:26the Protestant community and don't really know what a pastor's wife is, because
- 4:31that role is perceived in many different ways, and you've had different experiences
- 4:34connected with being a pastor's wife, so maybe you could explain
- 4:39who a pastor's wife is, what role she can have in the church, because it's a Protestant church,
- 4:43I'm saying that correctly, right? In a Protestant church,
- 4:46what role does a pastor's wife actually have? [laughter] Okay, that's a great topic. We could
- 4:52talk about it for a long time, but I'll try to... A long time?
- 4:55No, you know, [laughter] let's not overdo it. So maybe I'll start with a story,
- 5:00that happened to me once, because this particular story really stuck
- 5:04in my mind. I don't know why, but it somehow stayed with me. And
- 5:08it was a long, long time ago. I think definitely more than 10 years ago. Once
- 5:12there was some kind of organized event, I don't know, maybe an election event or something,
- 5:17and various leaders, that's the word people use,
- 5:22or church leaders, yes, yes, from different Protestant communities
- 5:28were invited. And it doesn't really matter which political party
- 5:34it was, and so on. I don't want to get into that at all.
- 5:37At the end of that meeting, there was a moment when the politician hosting it
- 5:42was, I don't know, personally greeting people, shaking hands, and somehow
- 5:49we were standing there. I was with my husband, and he greeted
- 5:55the men one by one, because most of them were men, and I was standing beside him.
- 5:59So he held out his hand to me too and said, 'Oh, so you're Pastor.'
- 6:06And I said, 'Well, not exactly.' And he said, 'I know women are also
- 6:13pastors in some places. I don't understand it, but I know it happens.' And
- 6:18that was another kind of misunderstanding, because I myself was never actually a pastor,
- 6:22although in these communities it varies a lot, because in some
- 6:26organizations it's possible and in others it isn't, for various reasons: social,
- 6:30cultural, beliefs,
- 6:34interpretation. There are lots of factors. You could have
- 6:39a whole debate about it, but I wasn't in that role. I really was
- 6:43there as the pastor's wife. And so, to give you some context,
- 6:48there are many different Protestant communities in Poland.
- 6:56Sometimes we don't even realize how many. They're very different,
- 7:01because unlike the Catholic Church, which is fairly
- 7:05unified in terms of the format in which it functions in our
- 7:09society and generally around the world, there are a great many Protestant churches,
- 7:14ranging from more traditional ones to more liberal ones,
- 7:19really all sorts. Most of those cultural models probably came to us
- 7:24from the West, mainly from the United States, because
- 7:28there were a lot of missions from the United States at one time,
- 7:32and they particularly reached our part of the former Eastern Bloc. But I also
- 7:36know people whose organization began with some relative of the Tsar
- 7:42of Russia. That's what I heard, so that's an interesting subject too.
- 7:50So we have all these different communities. The role of women in them
- 7:56is also very different. Women as a whole, as
- 8:03a group, but also pastors' wives, let's say. So,
- 8:09actually... Oh, and I should add that there are churches where
- 8:14the pastor's wife is basically just there for appearances, simply sitting
- 8:19in the front pew, with the children nicely dressed with bows
- 8:24and dresses, and they're all sitting there representing the family. Yes. She represents it.
- 8:28At home, of course, she takes care of things, she's the exemplary wife, looks after
- 8:32the children and everything else, and in the church her role sometimes
- 8:38ends there. Sometimes there are situations where, for example,
- 8:43churches are more traditional, and, for example, there are still ones where
- 8:48women wear headscarves or are only allowed to wear dresses. I've heard of those, although
- 8:52I've never personally been to one, but I've heard of them. In any case,
- 8:59there are also churches where women have some role, for example they can teach
- 9:03children, run classes for children, but beyond that,
- 9:08for women, for example, that's where it ends.
- 9:12And there are other churches too, perhaps newer movements that
- 9:16have come in, where women, pastors' wives,
- 9:20actually take on a role within the structure, and not only in the structure, but
- 9:24also, for example, actually do something specific, right?
- 9:27In the organization I was part of,
- 9:31it was like this: women could basically take part in everything and could
- 9:35do anything, including becoming a pastor.
- 9:40If you like our content, I warmly encourage you to
- 9:43subscribe to the channel and boost our video, because that way
- 9:47you really help us grow. And if you'd like more, if
- 9:51you'd like the aftertalk, newsletter and other extras, I really
- 9:55encourage you to subscribe to us on Hero Hero for just three euros
- 10:00a month. That's roughly the price of a coffee. So first, you can
- 10:04support us, and second, get a whole bunch of really cool bonus content.
- 10:10Though I don't know what the feminine form would be now. Exactly, I don't know. Now it would be
- 10:13'pastora,' because now you're supposed to... now you have to change it. Let's invent a new word here.
- 10:18I propose 'pastorzyca.' 'Pastorzyca.' [laughter]
- 10:22There were also forms like 'pastorałka' or something, but that sounds unserious. Well,
- 10:27'pastorzyca.' You think that sounds serious? No, it sounds a bit like some
- 10:31witch from a fairy tale. I don't know, it makes me think of 'komarzyca.'
- 10:34Oh damn. Okay, then: a woman performing a pastoral role. Nice and impersonal. Well,
- 10:40maybe that's it. Yes, yes. So she can preach sermons and
- 10:44basically do all of it, right?
- 10:46And what was your role? Well, my role was that
- 10:51I was responsible for music in the church, so
- 10:54I wanted to mention this on camera and say thank you, because one of the
- 10:57microphones we work with was lent to us by Magda, [laughter] so
- 11:02thank you very much. I mean, I'm glad it's useful.
- 11:05It's being used. Yes, very much so.
- 11:07So you were responsible for the music section. Yes,
- 11:10because for those who don't know: I happened to have some experience in my life with
- 11:14Protestant churches, so I can say a little about this. In
- 11:17Protestant churches, the music section is incredibly important
- 11:21and it makes up a huge part of the service. There's a lot of playing,
- 11:25singing, many instruments, multiple vocal parts, and it
- 11:30looks completely different from Catholic churches, right?
- 11:33There it's the organist, or maybe someone on guitar, and people sing, whereas
- 11:36here it's a whole event, honestly, very often.
- 11:39Yes, yes. Although in the Catholic Church too, for example, gospel has become very
- 11:42popular, or at least it was. But generally, when we imagine
- 11:45going to Mass, it's more likely an organist singing, I don't know those
- 11:49songs, but singing those songs. Here, though, you have a developed
- 11:54music-and-vocal section. A band, basically a band.
- 11:57It's a band. Yes. Sometimes there are even several, because it's every
- 12:01Sunday, right? It's a little different from running
- 12:05a normal band, because then the band functions with one lineup, whereas here
- 12:09the dynamic is different because every Sunday you need something prepared, so
- 12:13the lineup changes. You're working with volunteers.
- 12:16And there is also a developmental aspect, because people can grow through
- 12:21it. It's something... you know, people like Whitney
- 12:26Houston started in church, and she wasn't
- 12:30the only one. Yes, yes, in the US a lot of people in music
- 12:35come from church backgrounds. So here you were responsible for the
- 12:41music section, and I assume you found it fulfilling.
- 12:45Yes. Yes. I love music. [laughter] So: pastor's wife. Pastor's wife. Listen,
- 12:48generally, long story short, a pastor's wife in the various
- 12:53Protestant denominations can perform all kinds of functions, from being decorative all the way to
- 12:57preaching sermons or being responsible for other
- 13:02things like the music section. And now I'd like to ask you about your
- 13:07path to becoming a pastor's wife, because that path too... well, I'll tell you,
- 13:14you said something like this. Attention,
- 13:19quote: 'I entered into marriage with him, meaning my former husband,
- 13:24because I was convinced that this was, quote, God's will, which was confirmed by church leaders,
- 13:30and despite my, meaning your, doubts, they emphasized submission
- 13:35to authority.' And I'm sorry, but that gives me chills.
- 13:38Yes. And when you add that you were told you had to learn submissiveness
- 13:43in order to get married, while you dreamed of getting married, it is
- 13:46so... sorry for saying this, but to me it is abusive and manipulative to the point that
- 13:50it genuinely gives me chills, because it reminds me of, you know,
- 13:54almost arranging a marriage, where you have some intuition, you feel something
- 13:58inside, but you have this authority telling you:
- 14:01'God chose you. God chose you.' Mm-hmm. And
- 14:06yes, and it wasn't one isolated situation. It's just that here I phrased it
- 14:10in that way, quite specifically, because I wanted to emphasize some part
- 14:16of it. Because of course it wasn't that it happened against my will,
- 14:20or that I didn't want it. No. It was my decision, and
- 14:25there was also, to some extent, emotional involvement in the relationship
- 14:30with my former husband. So it wasn't that someone
- 14:34forced me into it in some concrete way. However, what
- 14:38I would like to draw attention to is this, and I think there may be people who
- 14:43have experienced something similar, especially in more
- 14:48religious circles, but I think outside them as well, because the influence of society and the
- 14:53whole environment around relationships also matters, right? We aren't...
- 14:57especially now, looking back, you know, this was 20
- 15:01years ago, from today's perspective I can say, okay, this and this was
- 15:05abusive, but back then I had absolutely no idea. How was I supposed to
- 15:09know? Nobody told me, right? So I wasn't able to...
- 15:12I grew up in that. That was how it was presented to me, so it
- 15:18was what it was. But to give this perhaps a little more depth,
- 15:22there really was a situation where
- 15:27the story of our relationship was that
- 15:31we met in church. I had already been in that church for some time,
- 15:36because it was a church founded by American missionaries. I had previously
- 15:40had experience with a similar type of community, and also,
- 15:46here in Kraków, I got to know some other churches. In
- 15:49the meantime I came here to study.
- 15:52And for some time we were, so to speak,
- 15:56involved in creating, within that church,
- 15:59a student association, and we organized various
- 16:04meetings, trips to the mountains, sort of
- 16:10within the church, though people from outside also took part in various
- 16:14events, so overall it was quite a nice experience. And then
- 16:19at some point my former husband came to Kraków and he
- 16:27became involved in that ministry, but it was also framed as
- 16:31him having a calling to serve here, that God had called him, and so
- 16:37on. So he arrived already as someone
- 16:41who was, to some degree, important or key, and you could feel that
- 16:46despite everything. I don't know if it was because this was
- 16:49Christianity from the United States, from the Bible Belt, with some
- 16:54more traditional understanding of roles, where it was palpable that if you're a man,
- 16:59you have more to say, [laughter] so people should listen to you.
- 17:04And so we were working together a little
- 17:09within that student association, and we had various conflicts and it was
- 17:13unpleasant, because before that we'd been some kind of group and it hadn't been like
- 17:17that, whereas here we'd clash on different occasions. And then there was
- 17:24a situation, and without going on too long, there was a
- 17:27situation where the pastor who led that church decided that he
- 17:31would leave the country. And somehow it became a matter of us
- 17:37staying. Oh, and in the meantime I had graduated. And
- 17:40I made the decision that I'd like to work here for a while with
- 17:44that association for two or three years, just to see whether it might be
- 17:47something I'd like to do. I [clears throat] graduated in management,
- 17:50marketing and human resources management, so for me it was also
- 17:53a way to test myself, you know, to work somewhere among
- 17:58people in that association, with those students and
- 18:01everything. So I kind of got into it, and it was called, well, it is
- 18:09called [clears throat] full-time ministry, right? So
- 18:14when that pastor left, in a way we were...
- 18:19Oh. And my former husband was appointed pastor, to be a pastor, that it
- 18:23was a calling and so on. God wanted it, so
- 18:28we had an opportunity to work a little more closely together. And I also
- 18:32had the impression that he became much warmer toward me compared with
- 18:35how things had been before, right? Because earlier we'd fight about various things, and
- 18:38here suddenly it was like, oh, great. I took it as maybe some
- 18:44greater interest, I don't know. But I also wanted to work together,
- 18:48I wanted the organization to grow, for what
- 18:51we were doing to go well, so I cared about that too. So there were opportunities
- 18:55when we'd meet together. And at some point, well, it was quite
- 19:00[laughter] quite spectacular, because
- 19:04he invited me out to lunch, then actually dinner, and
- 19:09told me that he'd like to date me and everything, and then
- 19:18he pulled out a ring, [laughter] an engagement ring.
- 19:21Did I understand that correctly? He proposed to you on the same day he asked if
- 19:25he could date you? Well, yes, yes. I mean, date me, as in
- 19:29be his girlfriend. I know, but before that you hadn't had any
- 19:33romantic relationship at all. Romantic? No, no, no, no, no.
- 19:36Wow.
- 19:37It had only been, so to speak, within the context of work, right?
- 19:41So you weren't expecting anything at all. Okay. Wait. And
- 19:44he puts you in that situation. And what happened? I wasn't expecting it. Well, that's
- 19:49[laughter] a bit embarrassing for me to talk about now.
- 19:52Because looking back I also think, 'Oh God.'
- 19:54Okay, and a little aside here for everyone who, for example,
- 19:59grows up in or spends many years within a certain structure: things that to
- 20:04us on the outside may seem absurd can at that moment feel
- 20:07completely normal to those people. You know what I mean? And in that context
- 20:12it's hard to judge. I can be surprised by it
- 20:15and think, how is that possible, but none of us knows how we'd behave if we were
- 20:21somehow, damn it, indoctrinated, right?
- 20:26Yes. Yes. And that's exactly it, because again, with hindsight I'm
- 20:30able to assess how many of the things I learned back then,
- 20:34not about the Bible or God and so on, but how many of those things were actually
- 20:40reasonably solid, and how much of it
- 20:45was the whole surrounding layer because someone made something up, because it happened to be a phase, because
- 20:49it happened to be a trend, because someone thought it was right. And this was still the time, you know,
- 20:55before Facebook, when there weren't all these... what
- 21:02do you call them, goodness, conspiracy theories, right? They
- 21:09were simply passed around in a different way, [laughter]
- 21:12because they're always there. [inhales]
- 21:14So in the circles I was in at the time, when it came
- 21:19to relationships and romance and so on,
- 21:22there was this trend where people, [clears throat]
- 21:28I don't know, people entering relationships were supposed to hear
- 21:32from God that this was it, that this was the person, and so on, and enter into it
- 21:37seriously. So: God's will. God's will for everything. And this
- 21:43partner, pastor, your former husband, proposes to you.
- 21:46What do you say? At that moment I was very
- 21:51confused, but on the other hand I liked him, because we had actually spent
- 21:54some time together before, and we'd talked. And
- 21:58above all there was, so to speak, this calling. I wanted to continue doing
- 22:01something in that church. I had ideas about what the church should look like,
- 22:06how it could genuinely be a good
- 22:09place for people to be and to be part of, because I'd also had
- 22:13experiences like that abroad, so I simply liked it,
- 22:16so I saw meaning in all of it, right? As in, I thought church itself
- 22:21made sense, right? So I wanted to invest in it and get involved. And
- 22:25here was this pastor. So it somehow seemed natural that
- 22:29it could be great because together we could do more, right? But from the
- 22:35relationship side of things, all of it was very new to me.
- 22:40Because earlier too, partly due to how I'd been raised, I'd had
- 22:43some relationships with men, but
- 22:49they didn't have this whole church framework around them, right? That it was so important,
- 22:53that it was destiny, that God was calling you to it and everything. And
- 22:57so okay, at the time I said yes, but with the thought
- 23:04that there would still be time to try this out,
- 23:08because okay, engagement means yes, I'm interested, but there would be room
- 23:15to verify whether it actually worked. Because I had it in
- 23:17my head that we'd argued, so I was a little like... Yes, because from
- 23:23your story I understand that you had this thought, but now
- 23:28another quote. Mm-hmm. Before the wedding, the senior pastor at the time
- 23:31told me that if I still had any kind of doubt in my head,
- 23:35it meant that I wasn't submissive enough and didn't have enough trust
- 23:40in the authority of my future husband.
- 23:44Yes, that was actually in the context of his authority as a pastor, not yet
- 23:48as a husband, because I don't know whether it was... I mean, the name is in there, and
- 23:51I don't want to use it, so I wrote 'your future husband.'
- 23:54Yes, yes, yes. And I was regularly given prophetic words and
- 24:00interpretations of dreams, and I'm wondering who received those prophetic words and who
- 24:04had those dreams, [laughter] saying that this is what God says and that you're too
- 24:08rebellious and that you simply need to submit, that you need to be submissive.
- 24:13Oh gosh, I'd already forgotten that I told you this, because you know
- 24:18what, I wrote it to you because there was also this thing where I'd gone through
- 24:22a phase, actually this spring, of searching for some
- 24:26traces. I thought I might find some trace from that year, just so I'd know
- 24:30how I was thinking then, what was in my head, that I made those
- 24:34particular decisions rather than different ones, right? Mm-hmm. And I simply found... oh wow, it
- 24:39was quite a discovery, because on my computer I found a few files where
- 24:43I'd written down some notes, and they were from that very year,
- 24:47sort of leading into it... the following year we'd already
- 24:51started... This wasn't before the wedding; it was even before
- 24:56we were together. Okay.
- 24:58Before the engagement. What I wrote to you. [snort]
- 25:02So now I remember. I found those notes, and
- 25:07that is literally a quote from them. I wrote down what that pastor
- 25:10told me. And you know, he's not a bad person. He's genuinely a lovely
- 25:14person. I'm still in touch with those people to this day. They're lovely
- 25:18people, they live in the States. But they also had this kind of framework,
- 25:23and now I look at it from a bit of a distance. And you know, prophetic words
- 25:29and interpretations of dreams. Yes, yes, there were
- 25:32things like that. First of all, you can interpret dreams
- 25:33in five million different ways. And
- 25:37it's difficult for me even to imagine something like a pastor coming up
- 25:42and saying, 'Hey, I had a dream, and I interpret it to mean that you're too
- 25:45rebellious.' Yes. Yes. But actually it wasn't that pastor;
- 25:49other people said those things. He was drawing conclusions about me
- 25:54being rebellious. And I don't know how much of that is also American culture, because
- 25:58later, when I went to the States and spent some time there and
- 26:01was involved in that church and so on, there really is this thing where
- 26:05if the pastor says something needs to be done, then it needs to be done, and they genuinely
- 26:08do that, but it isn't a very
- 26:10power structure and a mechanism that allows for very serious abuse. You know
- 26:14what, yes. The problem is that in that culture there are other mechanisms
- 26:18that protect against it a little more, which doesn't mean there is no
- 26:21abuse there, but the level of independence and
- 26:25respect for the individual as an individual is structured differently than it is
- 26:30here, so those abuses... and again, that doesn't mean they don't exist, but
- 26:35there are different ways of defending against them. Here, in our context, unfortunately,
- 26:41it translates into simply turning it into
- 26:46a master [clears throat] and ruler, with everyone else as servants.
- 26:49Exactly. Sorry, I'm simply interpreting what you gave me,
- 26:54and to me, as someone from the outside, that's kind of how it sounds: they
- 26:59were drilling into you even before the engagement that you were too
- 27:02rebellious, meaning: you had your own opinion, right? That you had to be
- 27:06submissive and that there was some plan for you, and that plan was for you to become
- 27:11the pastor's wife. I suspect that's a huge
- 27:15simplification, and I'm sure your former husband had a lot of feelings for you and you
- 27:19for him, but you still had that 'but' in your head, you had doubts,
- 27:23you argued, and I think neither of you got time to test
- 27:29each other and see whether it worked or didn't work, because you kept hearing
- 27:35words about God's will. Yes, yes. For me, looking at it now
- 27:38again with hindsight, even the fact that, okay, the relationship
- 27:43started and so on, that's normal, these things happen.
- 27:46The problem appeared, and I see it as a major problem, when,
- 27:51at the moment I raised doubts about whether it was worth
- 27:55continuing, because during that engagement period,
- 27:58which in a healthy relationship should normally be wonderful, right?
- 28:01Here it was just clash after clash, and they were genuinely unpleasant
- 28:05situations, so I started thinking, I don't know, maybe I'd rather
- 28:09get out of this. Then we had one conversation, because there was some kind of
- 28:13premarital preparation, then another conversation. And it was like, no, no, iron
- 28:16sharpens iron, so that's character, because there's a verse in the Bible:
- 28:20one person's character shapes another's, right? And that's true,
- 28:23all of that is true, there's nothing wrong with that, just not in this context,
- 28:27right? It can't be used as an argument to persuade someone to remain in
- 28:31a situation that is really very unpleasant, right? Especially
- 28:35since we weren't married yet, but it was treated a little
- 28:38as though we already were. Another thing I heard was basically:
- 28:42'Oh, if you break off the engagement now and everything, what kind of
- 28:45image will that create for the church, for this pastor and everything? That wouldn't be
- 28:50right.' So all those statements about
- 28:55God's will, that God had brought you together, that it was obvious you belonged together, that
- 28:59here in ministry you have potential, he has potential, and so on, that together
- 29:02you can accomplish so much, played a major role in my case, right?
- 29:07So somewhere along the way I trusted that and thought, 'Okay, these people see it
- 29:12this way, those people see it that way,' and I didn't have enough confidence in that
- 29:15inner 'no.' I'd like to come back to that later, but
- 29:19I didn't have enough conviction to stand my ground then and say:
- 29:25'This isn't going to happen.' And on the other hand I also
- 29:28cared, because I wanted to get married. This guy seemed okay enough. Well,
- 29:33everyone has... it seems to me that in your head it might even feel prestigious,
- 29:37that this is, after all, a future pastor,
- 29:41that it's an important position in the church, that he'll be
- 29:45a shepherd, a shepherd to a fairly large group of people whom he'll lead. And
- 29:51in that context your doubts are very understandable, because I can also imagine
- 29:55you starting to wonder whether something is wrong
- 29:58with you, that you have these doubts, right?
- 30:03And you question yourself, your perceptions and your feelings, because after all he's
- 30:09a future pastor. Yes, yes. A lot of mechanisms
- 30:12were at work here, but I'll just clarify one thing: perhaps the fact
- 30:18that someone has such a prominent role, because it is
- 30:23seen as somewhat prominent in those churches,
- 30:26even if it's only a small group of people, it still matters. But the fact that someone had
- 30:31that prominent role wasn't particularly important to me. I
- 30:35saw it more as a lot of work [laughter]
- 30:39and responsibility than some 'wow, the pastor chose me.' But he was
- 30:48important to me as a person, not as a function
- 30:51at that time. However, there were many mechanisms on my
- 30:56side that influenced me, because I also had my own
- 30:59experiences. I grew up partly, not all the time,
- 31:03but within a family affected by alcohol problems, where there was also violence.
- 31:06So again, years later I know what those mechanisms are. Back then I had absolutely
- 31:10no idea they even existed. I thought that my life
- 31:14was fairly normal, right? Because somehow I managed. And years later
- 31:19I also know that these mechanisms revolve around the fact that
- 31:23experiences which, for someone coming from a healthy family, would be
- 31:27like, 'Oh wow, I don't want this,' and would automatically trigger a boundary—
- 31:32'I don't want someone treating me like this, I won't allow it at all'—for
- 31:36me it was normal. So for me, someone telling me that I
- 31:39was perceiving things wrong, feeling things wrong, or that I was too much this or that, or, I don't know,
- 31:44as I said [clears throat] earlier, as you quoted,
- 31:49that I wasn't submissive enough—well, okay, I was too rebellious,
- 31:53indeed, I thought I had quite a strong personality, although maybe I didn't
- 31:56except in some things, but I thought, okay,
- 32:01they're right. Maybe I really am focusing too much on myself and my needs,
- 32:05while here you're supposed to serve, help, listen to
- 32:10God. And through whom would God's voice come more than through a man
- 32:14of God, right? And I'll add one more aspect: the issue of safety.
- 32:18I thought there could be no safer person than someone
- 32:21who stays so closely attached to God, right? So that's also
- 32:25[laughter] [inhales]
- 32:26This comes from my ignorance, so I'm asking you honestly now:
- 32:31who, I don't know if I'll even know how to phrase this,
- 32:33anoints a future pastor as a pastor? What determines that this
- 32:38particular man, who later became your husband, is regarded as the person who
- 32:44will be God's voice in that specific congregation?
- 32:50Okay, I'll explain it in this case, because generally it varies, but usually
- 32:55there are some superiors if it's an organized structure, right?
- 32:58Although there are also self-proclaimed apostles and so on who do various strange things,
- 33:03but call themselves 'apostle' on Facebook, so that happens too. There's
- 33:07one [laughter] very loud one who casts demons out of people in a very
- 33:10spectacular way and livestreams it on TikTok.
- 33:13I don't remember his name, but it's... I'm not going to say it.
- 33:17You know who? Well, I had this... I know, I know. [laughter]
- 33:21Wow. But it's funny that you happened to come across him.
- 33:26Listen, he's popped up for me more than once.
- 33:28Oh, well...
- 33:29it's interesting. He's done other things too, climbing on crosses somewhere and...
- 33:33So as for the pastor, in this organization
- 33:36there is always some... if these are larger organizations,
- 33:41there's a structure, so there are always some superiors, right? Here
- 33:45it happened to be an international organization,
- 33:49quite a large one, actually, so there were people who
- 33:54approved it and who ultimately appointed him to that position. And also
- 34:00because this overlaps somewhat with a Polish organization here,
- 34:05locally, it was also accepted there, right? Is it the case
- 34:09that people like that aren't vetted? Because this is also a quote:
- 34:17that what your husband said from the pulpit—sorry,
- 34:20my phone. How do I turn this off, darling? Okay, never mind—that what your husband said
- 34:26from the pulpit and what he did behind closed doors were two distant galaxies. And
- 34:33in that kind of... is there simply no vetting of such a person, or
- 34:37if, because you also said there were signs that he was abusive too, and it wasn't
- 34:40only you saying it, other people were saying it too, and that it had already
- 34:44gone too far and we couldn't undermine his authority because the whole
- 34:48congregation or church would lose authority, and whether they
- 34:53verify in any way a person who is later anointed to such
- 34:57a high position. Yes, but you see, these are things
- 35:01you said that have been compressed somewhere on the timeline into
- 35:06one ball, right? Whereas for us it was stretched across many, many years.
- 35:10Okay. So it intensified over time.
- 35:13Some things perhaps became more visible over time, so it's also like
- 35:18what usually happens in these configurations, that certain
- 35:22things only become visible after some time, right? The whole community... well, the whole... that most of the
- 35:27community knew about it, that quite a lot of people knew,
- 35:31that there were problems, yes, but those are two different things, because my
- 35:34experience is one thing, and the question of how
- 35:38it functioned within the community is another. So now maybe
- 35:43I'll try to move somewhere between the two, because it went on for some time. Regarding
- 35:50your question about vetting: yes, there is vetting, but it depends on
- 35:54the organization and on how a given organization
- 35:58functions and operates. In some
- 36:01organizations there are stronger systems of oversight and in others weaker ones. And here,
- 36:05for example, that organization also developed over the years because they had
- 36:08various challenges, but it was a fairly young organization that
- 36:13formed and developed quite broadly, so they
- 36:18didn't really have many systems at the beginning. They had some
- 36:21training for new pastors. At that time they didn't have a seminary, for example,
- 36:26something that in many organizations is a step toward becoming
- 36:29a pastor. They didn't have that then, so they had
- 36:33some training and some methods of vetting, but they were also largely
- 36:37based on subjective opinion, for example in this case the opinion of that
- 36:40missionary, that missionary family who came here,
- 36:44right? So they decided, okay, yes. And I think a major factor here
- 36:49was also that it was a subjective opinion, but at least
- 36:53at that time it was communicated as: well, this is God's will, right?
- 36:57So simply that this is how God is leading. And okay, if
- 37:01someone perceives it as God leading that way, it's hard to argue with it,
- 37:04right? I always wonder who decides that, who communicates the information
- 37:10that God is leading. Like, does someone have visions, or
- 37:14[laughter] where does that come from? You know what, that's a good question.
- 37:17That's exactly the kind of question a layperson asks, because in my head the wires just don't
- 37:20connect, so
- 37:24where does this leader get the information that this is God's will,
- 37:30that this person is anointed as pastor, that this is God's will and you should be
- 37:36submissive. And I understand that in this context perhaps also accept that he
- 37:40is imperfect, but he is your anointed pastor here. Yes, that
- 37:45is... goodness, that's a really great question, Kaja, honestly.
- 37:50A really, really deep question, right? Like, okay, how do you know?
- 37:55And because I don't want to address here
- 38:00the issue of spiritual experiences and who perceives what and from whom and so on,
- 38:07because I'm personally in a place where it's not like I completely
- 38:09cut myself off from such things, so that's not it. But looking at it from a
- 38:15human perspective, so to speak, I'll just say
- 38:19that again there are different movements and denominations. Some churches are more
- 38:23traditional, where it's basically like: okay, this is God's voice in
- 38:30the sense that they establish that they collectively made a decision, right? And that they
- 38:35agreed on something, so that's what we do, right? Okay, each of us has
- 38:40some conviction that this is the right thing, so it seems to us
- 38:45that this is where God is leading us at this moment. So, I don't know, we make
- 38:49a decision about, say, filling some position in the church,
- 38:54or getting a new building, or some other things, introducing a new program,
- 38:59changes, I don't know, in the way
- 39:03the service is run, or something. So there are organizations like that, and
- 39:08there are also organizations that operate very much on the principle that
- 39:13the Holy Spirit is said to show it, right? To give it. And then, okay, maybe it
- 39:19can be several people who have a similar conviction that
- 39:23this is what needs to be done, that the Holy Spirit was speaking to those
- 39:27several people. But there are also those who believe that
- 39:31there is one key person, one leader, and that is the one who hears
- 39:36from the Lord, so we have to follow him, right? So these are different
- 39:40approaches. In this case, honestly, looking back historically, I don't even
- 39:44know who made that decision. Your experience in marriage
- 39:50Mm-hmm. versus the experiences and problems
- 39:54that the congregation also raised regarding your husband and his behavior, and then
- 40:00the decision to leave that relationship because it was very harmful to you.
- 40:05And what does leaving a relationship with a pastor look like within
- 40:08church structures?
- 40:11Well, that's a lot too, [laughter] but that's good. Let's start with my
- 40:16experience. Maybe with that, because it seems to me that
- 40:21the rest is partly a curiosity, whereas here, in the context of
- 40:26what we're talking about, this experience can apply to many other
- 40:33people and situations. You don't have to be in a congregation to
- 40:37experience and go through such a process. So maybe I'll focus a little
- 40:42more on that here. And this experience, sort of...
- 40:48we stopped at the point where, okay, we got married and problems appeared,
- 40:54right? Or maybe they didn't even appear, because they were already
- 40:58there before, they just started becoming more painful,
- 41:03I'd say. Or I simply didn't expect it, because I thought: 'Okay,
- 41:07now we'll be together, so it'll be easier to solve some things.' Because
- 41:11then we moved in together, there was a plan for life,
- 41:15the church, all those other things, so I thought this was also
- 41:20a moment when, okay, certain things need to settle in, and they should
- 41:25settle in, right? But there is another important aspect, because throughout
- 41:31this whole process I was deeply convinced that something was
- 41:36seriously wrong with me. Because I had had a difficult childhood, and I was
- 41:41constantly told that I had a problem trusting men and that
- 41:45in this marital relationship, because of that childhood,
- 41:50that also... for some period of time I had also
- 41:56experienced violence in childhood from my mother's husband,
- 42:03who wasn't my father. So that stays with you, and
- 42:09again, I didn't grow up with my father, so it was also framed as if
- 42:14there was something in me: a lack of trust, a lack of
- 42:20submissiveness, or some other things that were supposedly necessary to have
- 42:26a good relationship. At least that was the state of knowledge
- 42:32at that time. [laughter] And again, I'll just mention that I
- 42:37really did have... so it doesn't sound like I'd only ever had experience with some
- 42:42pathological men, no, no. I really like men.
- 42:46I even went to a technical school where I had 33
- 42:50male classmates and I was the only girl, and honestly most of them were really
- 42:54great. [laughter] [inhales]
- 42:57And we had good relationships. But coming back to the issue of
- 43:05the marriage, the first ideas about doing something
- 43:09were mainly about fixing me, right? So they appeared very
- 43:14early. I remember we went to some people who
- 43:17did something resembling therapy, some pastors somewhere in another
- 43:21part of Poland. Later we went to someone else who
- 43:27supposedly knew something. Various kinds of prayers were organized. Again,
- 43:33mainly about me, so that somehow, I don't know, something in me would change.
- 43:39It's incredible how often the problem is seen in the victim.
- 43:45Well, that's basically... I mean, that is classic behavior,
- 43:50right? Yes, generally, yes. And now I am
- 43:54in a different place now, I'm examining the subject from another angle, so
- 43:57it's all okay, all okay. Right. So now I have greater
- 44:04awareness of how these mechanisms work. Back then I
- 44:06didn't know, of course. So that's one aspect: that
- 44:11something was wrong all the time. And for me, looking back again,
- 44:15what I remember is this feeling of being trapped. I think: I had so many friends, relationships,
- 44:19I did all kinds of things and so on, and now I feel as though
- 44:22someone has simply shut me in a cage, that I can't get out, that here I can't
- 44:25stay in touch with those people because we have to go together, I can't do something because those people are
- 44:28not good enough. And he, for example, doesn't like those people or
- 44:33something, and that was difficult for me. But okay, I thought, this
- 44:38is a new relationship, a marriage, we're creating a family and so on. So fine,
- 44:41you have to sacrifice some things, right? I can't live the way I used to
- 44:45anymore, because now this is serious. There's the church, there are all these
- 44:48serious people around, so I have to somehow find my place in it. So
- 44:52it was difficult, but again I thought, okay, maybe I'm
- 44:57immature, maybe I don't know how, maybe something, right? So it dragged on. At some
- 45:00point I made—or really we made—a decision, because
- 45:05I had worked in that church for, I don't remember now, maybe
- 45:11four years after we got married,
- 45:14and then an opportunity came up
- 45:17to work outside the church. So eventually I made that
- 45:23decision—we talked about it together—to do that. Because our
- 45:28working together in the church was difficult, and it was difficult for me, and I thought
- 45:31okay, maybe I'm the reason for the problem because I constantly have
- 45:34doubts about things, I dislike something, and so fine, I'll
- 45:37step away and do something else. So I got involved
- 45:41in that work. But at the same time I remained involved here in various
- 45:45things too, right? So it was kind of on two fronts.
- 45:49Then I became pregnant, my son was born, and
- 45:53things got more complicated because there were suddenly a lot of responsibilities. My son
- 46:02turned out to be quite distinctive, he had a lot of needs,
- 46:06[laughter] so that absorbed me to some
- 46:11extent too. Then I had to go back to work, so there was
- 46:14work, the church and my son, and the burden on me kept growing, and
- 46:17again I didn't realize what was happening to me, why I simply felt
- 46:25so bad in all of it. I thought, okay, when
- 46:30we have a child we'll take care of him together. It turned out that
- 46:34most of the responsibilities nevertheless landed on me. And my son
- 46:40was somewhat difficult, presented challenges,
- 46:44but it was also just an overwhelming amount, and there were more conflicts too.
- 46:49There was this constant dissatisfaction with various things.
- 46:57And here you referred to the fact that certain things really did happen.
- 47:00Again, this is a debatable issue.
- 47:04Of course everyone has their own opinion on what is abuse and what isn't
- 47:07abuse, but there were situations where, for example, I was pushed out of
- 47:10the house, and then
- 47:14I walked around the neighborhood. Friends came and picked me up because luckily
- 47:20I'd taken my phone. It was winter, I didn't have a coat. Not great, right?
- 47:23Apparently he came out after me right away and started looking for me, but well, and that it was
- 47:27an accident. Seriously, again, at the time I believed that, okay,
- 47:34he simply got so angry that he pushed me out, and fine, right? But
- 47:38now, looking back, damn, when would I ever push any member of my household
- 47:42out of the house? I can't imagine it. It's striking that you
- 47:48still seem afraid to call it what it was. You know what, I'm afraid to name it
- 47:52because for years I was accused—or rather I was told—that it was
- 47:57not true, that it couldn't be true, that I was exaggerating, that I was
- 48:02oversensitive, right? So there's that too. I don't want to enter into
- 48:07confrontation, I simply don't want to, especially because from
- 48:11the legal side I decided that we would divorce
- 48:15without assigning blame, right? I didn't pursue whether it was
- 48:20abusive or not abusive. In the court documents, of course,
- 48:23certain things had to be written and said, so I simply said
- 48:27what I had experienced, right? It wasn't a lie, it was the truth,
- 48:30but I didn't want to fight over it in any
- 48:36way, because the Polish justice system works the way it works and
- 48:39there was no point. There was absolutely no point dragging it out. But
- 48:43the situation is what it is. And you wrote this to me:
- 48:47'At home, constant stress, constant tension, one or two peaceful days, and then something
- 48:50was wrong again. Shouting, endless attempts to explain who knows what,
- 48:55forcing apologies for everything.' It happened that he pushed me out the door.
- 48:59Supposedly for my own good. Yes. Right, you did write that.
- 49:02Well, but that's my experience. That's what happened.
- 49:07And then, you know, on top of all that,
- 49:09a child, children, because later a second one appeared too, right?
- 49:16And it seems to me that then the thought must also appear that it no longer
- 49:22concerns only you, but also the children and their wellbeing, because if
- 49:26I may, I have another quote here. Well,
- 49:30'It broke my heart when my son was afraid to leave his room and waited until he left
- 49:33the house, or asked me to bring him something from the fridge because he was afraid to go to
- 49:37the kitchen because Dad would immediately either yell at him or make fun of him.'
- 49:41Well, that's a fact. That's something my son told me. Yes.
- 49:45So in a way,
- 49:48from this story it follows that you had to save not only yourself and that
- 49:50part of you that remained, but also the children.
- 49:57And I think that especially because
- 50:00divorce is viewed very negatively in churches—and I spent some time in a
- 50:04Protestant church and I know stories of couples who tried to divorce, and
- 50:09I know stories of couples where there was very
- 50:12clear information about physical abuse, very severe physical abuse of
- 50:18the wife, and that wife decided to divorce and the whole church tried to
- 50:23talk her out of it, saying that he was sorry,
- 50:27that he would change, that now this, now that, now something else, and they didn't
- 50:30stand on the victim's side and strengthen her in her decision to leave
- 50:35the abuser who was simply beating her,
- 50:39but instead sided with the man. Of course the abusive person could also have been a woman,
- 50:42obviously, but the priority was simply that there must not be a divorce.
- 50:46Yes, and that's where my next question comes from: about colliding with this
- 50:50church system, and divorce itself, and divorce from the church,
- 50:55because those are, you know, two separate issues that laypeople like
- 51:01us can't even imagine, right? What you have to go through there.
- 51:04And I think, again, I'm not alone in this subject. As you yourself mentioned,
- 51:08you had at least some picture of the fact that something
- 51:12like that happened somewhere, right? So it isn't isolated,
- 51:17I think. I remember historically, from years
- 51:21ago, situations where, I don't know, a husband
- 51:24would hold his wife under water in the bathtub, and the church would say that despite
- 51:30everything she had to forgive him, right? And continue the marriage.
- 51:35I heard a story where a husband ultimately ended up in prison because
- 51:41he raped the woman's daughter from a previous marriage, and she still went
- 51:46to visit him and bring him things and so on. Because no, you have to preserve it, right?
- 51:51The marriage has to be preserved. These are extreme situations,
- 51:54but I'll also tell you something I'll never forget: I was at the wedding
- 51:56of someone in my family in a Catholic church, and the priest from the pulpit said that you
- 52:01have to stay by that husband, really regardless of whether he becomes bedridden
- 52:06and you have to haul his wheelchair up the stairs—which is understandable, to
- 52:11stay with a partner through illness—or whether he's drunk or
- 52:14whatever, and the whole sermon was about the fact that it wouldn't always be rosy, and
- 52:19he listed a number of abusive behaviors on the part of a partner and said that you still
- 52:22had to stay anyway.
- 52:27simply have to stay in that marriage. And I'm thinking, what kind of world are we
- 52:32living in, you know, where our wellbeing, including our mental wellbeing, and
- 52:37especially if you have children, is simply paramount, right?
- 52:41And especially in these times, right?
- 52:48It's just that we live in times when things don't have to be
- 52:51that way, and you can say no. And you could also say
- 52:54that this image of you emerges: you're an adult child of an alcoholic, you come
- 52:58from the kind of [clears throat] home you come from, and also
- 53:03people from ACA backgrounds are vulnerable to entering abusive relationships, to not knowing how
- 53:07to set boundaries, to simply not knowing how to say no, taking the blame
- 53:11onto themselves, so it was also kind of a perfect match.
- 53:14Yes, yes. Those are patterns, right? Now, again, with hindsight
- 53:17and with what I'm learning, and then you also don't have a supportive
- 53:21environment, so it's incredibly difficult.
- 53:25And here, regarding the environment, you also did receive support.
- 53:31No, I did receive support, so it's not that—goodness, I'm incredibly grateful for that—
- 53:35but maybe I'd like to add a few thoughts here. First of all, this
- 53:40process, right, because I stopped at the point where we were,
- 53:45the children appeared, and this crisis in my mental health
- 53:49became very... or rather, I experienced a crisis.
- 53:55It was clearly getting worse, and I didn't know why, because I
- 53:59tried changing different things. I thought, okay, maybe I'm too involved in the
- 54:02church, so I'll pull back a little. Eventually I got to the
- 54:07point where I quit that job, which was important to me,
- 54:10because it gave me some sense of fulfillment, and it was a good
- 54:14job, because I also had some income that
- 54:19helped me with life in some way, so that was nice. But I gave it up,
- 54:23because I thought: 'Okay, there are two children here, there's this, it simply
- 54:26gets in the way, so I won't do it, maybe that will help the family,
- 54:32right? Things are bad, so we have to save it.' At some
- 54:39point I had a friend who years earlier had already been
- 54:43my friend before I got married, and she came to me and
- 54:47said, 'Listen, Magda, you're not doing well. Just go
- 54:51to an appointment. I've given you the numbers for a therapist, a psychologist. Just
- 54:56go and see.' And honestly, I was afraid, because first of all,
- 55:00okay, what if it somehow undermines my faith? But you know,
- 55:06what I was most afraid of, when I think back now—that was
- 55:10one thing, right? Because it was considered controversial. You go to someone who
- 55:12will tell you how to live. But you're supposed to have this relationship with Jesus
- 55:16and he is the one who tells you. [laughter]
- 55:18You're supposed to get it from him. Seriously, even today I read some post
- 55:23on Facebook where someone said exactly that: no, no, no, because you know,
- 55:27I'm studying psychology now, [laughter] [inhales] so I'm
- 55:31interested in the subject. I'm in various groups, and there
- 55:34I read someone writing that if it's not from Jesus, you can't
- 55:38go to a psychologist. So [laughter] you know, that still exists, right? So
- 55:43for me at that time, overcoming the barrier and going to a psychologist was enormous.
- 55:50I felt like everyone would say I'd become godless or something.
- 55:53That was one aspect. But the second thing I was most afraid of
- 55:57was that I would have to tell someone what I was experiencing in
- 56:01my marriage and how much it hurt me. I was afraid because I thought it
- 56:05would be chaos, what would happen. Because my
- 56:13husband didn't like it when I said something
- 56:18about him or about our marriage when he wasn't there and [snort]
- 56:22couldn't verify it, right? So that would later be
- 56:26addressed somehow. He didn't do it in a very
- 56:31direct way, but you could always feel the displeasure. So I was very
- 56:35afraid to say anything about anything in our marriage. And
- 56:38the situation was that whenever we talked with other people and
- 56:41we were together, if I said I had a problem with something,
- 56:45or something bothered me, it would always somehow get turned around until
- 56:49it came out that I was the problem. So at some point
- 56:53there stopped being any point in saying anything, right? Because nothing
- 56:56would get resolved anyway, and later it would come back in some conversation: 'You yourself
- 57:01said that...' Okay. In any case,
- 57:06that moment when I actually decided to go to
- 57:09a psychologist—it was a Christian psychologist, because of course I wouldn't have gone
- 57:13anywhere else, right? But he was really, really good. And he genuinely
- 57:18helped me see a few things from a different angle
- 57:24and notice things. At the very first meeting, goodness,
- 57:29it hurt so much, it was awful. At the first meeting with him, he
- 57:33said... we'd talked, I'd told him what I was struggling with,
- 57:38what my problems were. Of course I didn't say
- 57:43too much about the marriage, it was more about my son and the burden and so
- 57:46on. And he said to me: 'You know what? What I see is that you are
- 57:53terribly neglected.' And I was like,
- 57:58what does that mean? Neglected how? Damn, I dressed up a bit for this
- 58:03and everything. But he meant emotionally, right? That I was simply
- 58:09completely left on my own, that nobody cared what was happening to me
- 58:13and so on, that I didn't even have anyone I could go to and open my mouth to. So his
- 58:17first suggestion was—he also asked whether I had any friendships. And
- 58:21I said, well, yes, but in the church context it's a bit difficult because there's
- 58:24ministry, because this, because that. And he encouraged me and said, 'You know,
- 58:27it would be good for you, it would do you good to go out somewhere with someone,
- 58:31with a female friend, and just spend some time together.' So I think that
- 58:36was when it reached me that I genuinely needed contact with
- 58:40friends, because everything had become... by then it was probably just
- 58:45church, church and family all the time, right? So I also felt
- 58:50cut off, and that helped me. And then the whole process began, because
- 58:55one therapy, another therapy, then couples therapy came in, and these
- 58:59were honestly great experiences because I learned so, so much, a lot
- 59:03about myself, pain like you wouldn't believe in different places, because it's work on yourself,
- 59:07on those patterns where you thought everything was fine,
- 59:12right? And then it turns out it doesn't work. It turns out I was wrong, that
- 59:16when I thought I was giving so much of myself, I was actually doing it wrong, [laughter] because
- 59:20eventually I'd run myself into the ground and wouldn't be able to give anything anymore. Not to anyone,
- 59:23not to the children, not to anybody. So confronting that was difficult for me. And
- 59:28maybe I'll talk about one moment, because if someone is listening and
- 59:33going through a similar process, or I don't know, hitting a wall somewhere,
- 59:36I had one moment in therapy that I remember because it
- 59:40really affected me. Maybe it's a small thing, but later, after
- 59:46that psychologist I was seeing, I started
- 59:48seeing a female therapist, and at one session
- 59:53she pushed me in a healthy way. She asked me, well, how did you
- 59:58feel—I'm not sure which situation it concerned—how did you feel about it?
- 1:00:00Can you describe your feelings? And I tried to say something. But
- 1:00:06she kept asking, how did you feel? What did it do to you? What effect
- 1:00:14did it have? What were you thinking then? What were you feeling? More specifically: what did I feel? Because
- 1:00:17I was very analytical, I thought about things a lot, so she was trying to pull
- 1:00:21some feelings out of me, right? So, what did you feel? And I tried to
- 1:00:26name it somehow. I said, 'But I don't know how to name it. I don't know, it seems
- 1:00:30like maybe I felt nothing.' And she kept pressing. Damn, what else am I supposed to
- 1:00:35say? Finally, completely resigned, I said, 'You know
- 1:00:41what? I don't know what else to tell you. I think I've told you everything.
- 1:00:45I really don't have anything more for you here today.' And she
- 1:00:49looked at me and said: 'Oh, okay. That's fine. Then I
- 1:00:54accept you exactly as you are here with me.' And I looked at
- 1:00:59her like: that's it, that's okay?
- 1:01:03Yes, that's okay. There's still some topic here that
- 1:01:06we could talk about. And it simply hit me so hard that I
- 1:01:11am okay even when I don't have anything to give someone.
- 1:01:15I don't know, maybe for some people this means absolutely
- 1:01:17nothing, but for me it meant a huge amount, because I had always
- 1:01:21felt—and I want to emphasize this, because in relationships like that—that I was
- 1:01:25obligated to something, that I owed someone something, that I had to do something for someone,
- 1:01:28that I had to take care of his emotions, how he felt, whether he felt okay, whether
- 1:01:33I had to watch every little thing. It's a bit ACA, right? Adult child of
- 1:01:38an alcoholic. Yes, adult child of an alcoholic. Thanks, all these abbreviations.
- 1:01:43And you pay attention to every movement, every tiny twitch of an eyebrow, right?
- 1:01:49Because someone's already unhappy, so I have to do something
- 1:01:52to make it better, a million times more intensely,
- 1:01:55and just that reflex, right, to take care of someone. And here this woman tells me:
- 1:01:59'No, this is okay.' And the fact that she
- 1:02:05simply accepted that I had nothing more for her
- 1:02:09... I don't know. It broke me then. I remember I completely burst into tears,
- 1:02:12because I simply didn't know what to do with that.
- 1:02:15Because you'd been living in something completely different all along. It was like someone
- 1:02:19showed you another world, because there had always been some
- 1:02:21expectation of you: something more, still not enough of this, not enough of that, this was wrong, that was
- 1:02:25wrong, something else. Constantly walking on, as they say,
- 1:02:30shards of glass or something like that.
- 1:02:34I used to describe it as there always being a cloud in the room,
- 1:02:39a black storm cloud of some emotion that made you feel
- 1:02:44terribly bad. Yes. Yes.
- 1:02:46And I don't know how much you want to say about this, but it was in practically every
- 1:02:51area of your life: that you weren't enough.
- 1:02:55Yes. Yes. Because it carries over, right? It simply becomes your
- 1:02:58everyday reality. It's always not enough. So
- 1:03:04again, for me that experience was so
- 1:03:09significant because it was the first moment when it really
- 1:03:14hit me that I can say, 'No, I have nothing,' and that's okay,
- 1:03:21that it doesn't make me a worse person, that I have the right simply to
- 1:03:28have nothing more to give. And that began
- 1:03:32to carry over. It genuinely caused a kind of revolution inside me, and
- 1:03:36it started translating into small things. A seemingly small thing,
- 1:03:40but that moment of realizing that it's okay that I have nothing more,
- 1:03:47that I don't have to, and that this other person is okay with it.
- 1:03:50Because again, we're talking about a fairly close relationship. I had already been
- 1:03:53working with that therapist for some time, right? And she had gotten to know me from different
- 1:03:57angles, my thoughts, feelings and so on. So it's not
- 1:04:00that I generally have a problem where I feel I have to give something to everyone. No.
- 1:04:06Everyday relationships are different, and it's different when
- 1:04:10someone knows you much more deeply, when it's a closer, more intimate relationship, right?
- 1:04:15So I remember comparing it a little like this: that
- 1:04:21this therapist, through that behavior of hers, filled in
- 1:04:28a kind of hole
- 1:04:32that I'd felt for such a long time because
- 1:04:40my relationship with my husband had been so difficult.
- 1:04:45I constantly felt inadequate there, right? And suddenly, in
- 1:04:49this relationship, someone tells me no, that it's okay. That also
- 1:04:54must be incredibly difficult, living in something like that. I imagine it a bit
- 1:04:59like a split reality: you have a pastor husband who from the pulpit talks about
- 1:05:06all these wonderful things, mercy.
- 1:05:09If you like our content, I warmly encourage you to
- 1:05:12subscribe to the channel and boost our video, because that way
- 1:05:16you really help us grow. And if you'd like more, if
- 1:05:20you'd like the aftertalk, newsletter and other extras, I really
- 1:05:24encourage you to subscribe to us on Hero Hero for just three euros
- 1:05:29a month. That's roughly the price of a coffee. First, you can
- 1:05:33support us, and second, get a whole bunch of really cool bonus content. Well,
- 1:05:39I attended one of your husband's sermons once. Very charismatic. I was, [laughter]
- 1:05:42I was there, yes, very charismatic. It was a long time ago.
- 1:05:46And exactly, he is this role model, this example, and he leads
- 1:05:52his community, while there's this other version of your husband who is
- 1:05:57at home, and who I suspect doesn't fully match what
- 1:06:01he presents from the pulpit in church.
- 1:06:05Yes. You know what, it took me such a long time for that to sink in, that it
- 1:06:09didn't match, right? Because it was also like
- 1:06:13I kept thinking that what he was doing was so
- 1:06:17important that I had to help him and create space for him to do it. So things had to be
- 1:06:24handled. Okay, the house had to be handled, so I handled it, right? Various things in
- 1:06:28the church too. I wasn't only doing the music side; I also did
- 1:06:32many other things in the church that had to be taken care of, and
- 1:06:36I thought, okay, I'll handle it. It wasn't important to me to
- 1:06:40be out front or anything. Sometimes there were situations like that,
- 1:06:44but what mattered to me was that things functioned, right? So that he had
- 1:06:47space to do his thing, because that was so important,
- 1:06:51right? So I didn't think of it in terms of me missing something. But
- 1:06:57again, those conflicts were very difficult for me, and the fact that...
- 1:07:06I want to focus on some...
- 1:07:10pull out one specific thing, right? Because
- 1:07:15in relationships like this, what
- 1:07:21was extremely difficult for me—let's
- 1:07:26stick with the word difficult—was that
- 1:07:32conflicts between people are of course
- 1:07:36normal, you can resolve them, [clears throat] but when the same pattern happens
- 1:07:40every single time, that you say something and it gets
- 1:07:47turned around against you, and [clears throat]
- 1:07:55I'll call it this now: used as a weapon against you, right? To give
- 1:08:00an example, imagine a situation like
- 1:08:04this, a dialogue, right?
- 1:08:09Let's say, in this case, the husband says he cannot understand what's
- 1:08:17wrong when his wife doesn't want to touch
- 1:08:23her husband, what's wrong with her.
- 1:08:27Maybe she simply doesn't feel like it.
- 1:08:31And she says in that situation: 'Hey, you've been yelling at me for the last
- 1:08:37month several times a week. I was left alone having to
- 1:08:46take care of the child because you got offended and did nothing except
- 1:08:49watch movies and deal with your own things.'
- 1:08:55Second thing. Third thing: constant tension in the house. Because
- 1:08:58you got offended, and not only do you yell, you also sulk, you don't want to
- 1:09:02talk, the situation can't be resolved. So yes, I really don't
- 1:09:08feel like touching someone like that.' And the husband says: 'You know what, whatever I
- 1:09:14do, it's wrong for you. Nothing ever suits you.'
- 1:09:21And okay, maybe there's one such
- 1:09:26situation, maybe several. God, people are different, right? These things
- 1:09:29happen, people say things sometimes. But those are also
- 1:09:33things you later apologize for. But when there are no
- 1:09:36apologies at all, no reflection that something is wrong,
- 1:09:39and instead the same pattern repeats and repeats and repeats and repeats—those
- 1:09:44are, for example, the kinds of things that, for me, can simply
- 1:09:48wear a person down, because it's one situation after another after another after another.
- 1:09:53It's not once in a while. Sometimes it can happen several times a day.
- 1:09:56Sometimes there's a break, some sweet period, what I call
- 1:10:01the honeymoon, right? When things are nice. Leaving aside some of the
- 1:10:05bigger explosions and bigger
- 1:10:09scenes for various reasons—goodness, someone may feel unwell, have a bad
- 1:10:14day and so on, different situations happen—but
- 1:10:18you know, when for example you only get an apology when someone
- 1:10:23is really backed into a corner, like, 'Hey, damn, that wasn't okay, that
- 1:10:28was wrong, and someone else also confirmed it was wrong and
- 1:10:31inappropriate. Fine, I'm sorry. And a week later it's: you know, I still
- 1:10:36feel pain from that situation. But I apologized.
- 1:10:41And then there's no room for that anymore, right? It's like, I don't know,
- 1:10:47I'm giving a hypothetical example now, but to compare it to a
- 1:10:50physical experience, right? Someone, I don't know, beat someone up
- 1:10:55and apologized, but a week later the other person still hurts, right? They still
- 1:10:59haven't healed, the bruises haven't gone away, it still hurts, so you can't
- 1:11:03expect someone to immediately stand back up and for everything to be fine.
- 1:11:07Because the word 'sorry' was said once every five years, or three
- 1:11:12or two, I don't know, it varies. I'm talking partly about my own situation and
- 1:11:16partly about others I've encountered, because not
- 1:11:20everything... But yes, almost 20 years of marriage.
- 1:11:26Yes. I want to come back to the church you mentioned, because that's another
- 1:11:29thread, because I know you asked me, and
- 1:11:31here I pulled the personal thread along a bit. I don't know whether this
- 1:11:35should be now or whenever you want. Yes, you can, you can. Yes,
- 1:11:38Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Go on, go on. You can. Okay, okay. So here
- 1:11:42we have this personal context, but we also have
- 1:11:46the church context, and they overlap, because
- 1:11:52as you already mentioned earlier, all kinds of things can happen, but apparently not
- 1:11:56divorce, as if divorce were the greatest sin of all.
- 1:12:00And throughout this whole process, that's something I still don't
- 1:12:04understand. I cannot get my head around the fact that
- 1:12:10for people—and it seems to me this goes even
- 1:12:15broader than that—it's not only people who
- 1:12:19identify as believers, but also
- 1:12:26a broad part of society,
- 1:12:30as if separation or divorce were something
- 1:12:35much, much worse than, for example, abuse,
- 1:12:40that someone left someone, right? As though they had violated some huge sacred thing. And here
- 1:12:45you're also leaving a pastor, so it's even more. So
- 1:12:52it's...
- 1:12:57I'll tell you again from my personal experience, and I'll tell a story too,
- 1:13:01which is still quite moving for me.
- 1:13:08Because my situation was that we tried
- 1:13:13therapy and other things. We were also in the States for some time,
- 1:13:19using some help there as well. Truly wonderful people, by the way. Everyone
- 1:13:24wants to help. In those circles, and again, I know there's a lot of
- 1:13:28criticism too, because [inhales]
- 1:13:32I have my own theory about it. I intend, [laughter]
- 1:13:35if possible, maybe to conduct some research in that direction for my master's thesis,
- 1:13:40if I even get that far, [snort]
- 1:13:42but I have my own theory, which
- 1:13:47isn't only my theory; it's based on various
- 1:13:50indications and knowledge I've been gathering, that specific kinds of people
- 1:13:55also gather in Protestant circles. Not because they're
- 1:14:00Protestant circles, but because it's a niche, a small group. First of all,
- 1:14:04you need a certain amount of courage, for example, to admit that you're
- 1:14:07Protestant. For years that was problematic.
- 1:14:11Now maybe less so, because social acceptance
- 1:14:15has changed somewhat and difference has become a little more
- 1:14:18accepted, but for years it was a problem. That's one thing, so it
- 1:14:22requires people to step out a little and say, 'Okay, I'm
- 1:14:26different,' right? So that's one kind of person, because many people simply
- 1:14:30are conformists and they'll preserve the status quo
- 1:14:36if only to avoid standing out from everyone else, right? So that's
- 1:14:40one group. But there is also a group of people who gather in
- 1:14:46these circles who are looking for a place where there is
- 1:14:48acceptance, because these environments are often genuinely
- 1:14:52very, very accepting and welcoming, and that's good, that's
- 1:14:58a real treasure. I think that's a major advantage, that so many people
- 1:15:03gather there, but because of that character, there also come
- 1:15:07people who are a bit, to use a biblical expression if I may,
- 1:15:13[laughter] wolves in sheep's clothing,
- 1:15:16right? And they may not even realize it themselves. I'm not saying they're all
- 1:15:21predators and psychopaths and so on, but they're people with various
- 1:15:27disorders, and they may not even realize how much harm they
- 1:15:32cause others, but they enter and act according to their patterns. And
- 1:15:36unfortunately, because there aren't enough safeguards there, because
- 1:15:41people don't know what to do with it, they accept it to some degree and don't know how to
- 1:15:45confront inappropriate behavior, the environment can become somewhat
- 1:15:51[laughter] toxic.
- 1:15:55So for all the good that is there, unfortunately there is also toxicity, and
- 1:16:02that's something I'd ultimately like to
- 1:16:07research somewhere down the line, right? To what extent, for example, in this group
- 1:16:12of people these dynamics appear more than elsewhere. But I don't
- 1:16:18know; at the moment these are only my thoughts. I'm searching,
- 1:16:21checking, because it interests me from a sociological and
- 1:16:25psychological perspective too, right? But returning to
- 1:16:31this whole process,
- 1:16:36well, saying in a Protestant environment that [laughter]
- 1:16:42I'm getting divorced—and from a pastor who at that time
- 1:16:47was functioning as a pastor of one of those
- 1:16:51I don't know, maybe medium-sized churches, not the tiniest one,
- 1:16:54[clears throat] somewhere in Poland—and we'd been in this for so many years,
- 1:16:58so the surname was recognized to some extent and everything, so it
- 1:17:04caused a certain wave. Especially because before that I had not publicly
- 1:17:11said in any way that there were problems. People knew, leaders knew that
- 1:17:15we had problems, those abroad knew, coworkers knew what was
- 1:17:20going on, right? But obviously I wasn't going around telling everyone,
- 1:17:24'Hey, I feel awful in this setup.' It was being processed,
- 1:17:30worked on, worked on, worked on, worked on. I reached a point where
- 1:17:34I simply decided, especially when I saw what was happening mainly with
- 1:17:39one of our children, that no, I simply couldn't...
- 1:17:43it couldn't be like this. It couldn't be like this. I couldn't live this
- 1:17:47way. There was no improvement. So much time and money had been invested
- 1:17:52in therapy, in all of it, in attempts to repair it, and I was in
- 1:17:56worse and worse condition, right? I was also using
- 1:18:01therapeutic help and so on. So there came a moment—sometimes
- 1:18:04there's simply one last straw.
- 1:18:06Yes. And I'll add here, because you said you were in worse and worse
- 1:18:08condition, but I have here what condition you were in:
- 1:18:12insomnia, psychosomatic pain, panic attacks, severe anxiety disorders,
- 1:18:16just so you all know, because you're telling it so gently, I'll read what
- 1:18:20you wrote to me. Well, I eventually ended up in a very
- 1:18:24serious condition, especially when I remember those panic attacks and
- 1:18:28psychosomatic pains. And again, when you're in it, I didn't fully know they were
- 1:18:32psychosomatic pains. I went from doctor to doctor: this hurts, that hurts.
- 1:18:35Eventually it turned out that with appropriate medication
- 1:18:39treatment, they really were psychosomatic pains. Full stop.
- 1:18:43You were in a very serious condition.
- 1:18:46Your children were in it. You decide to take that step and go with it
- 1:18:54to people in your congregation. I don't know how
- 1:18:59that happened exactly or what the community's reaction
- 1:19:02was. Exactly, because
- 1:19:06I also have this little quote from you: you said that, thank God, current
- 1:19:10Polish law is more merciful to victims [inhales] of what
- 1:19:15we're talking about than the law they follow. And you said you'd do it
- 1:19:19regardless of what anyone thinks, whether they say you're allowed or not, but that Polish
- 1:19:23law is more merciful. Yes, that was such a moment, because
- 1:19:28[clears throat] at one point I went to get
- 1:19:31legal help, when I had already reached a place where, okay, this simply
- 1:19:36wasn't going to work and I needed some kind of help here. And I was terrified because
- 1:19:39I was afraid of confrontation, afraid of manipulation again, that someone would tell me I
- 1:19:42wasn't allowed, that you're not allowed, not allowed, not allowed, no, you're not allowed to
- 1:19:46leave this, you have to work on it, you have to keep going, because I also understand that
- 1:19:49there's this narrative that you'll ruin your husband's life.
- 1:19:54I understand, right? Because it did have consequences for him,
- 1:19:57that—am I understanding correctly?—he could no longer serve, I mean, he can't anymore, not in
- 1:20:01that congregation and so on. I didn't even know to what
- 1:20:05extent those things... because by that point I was already at a place where
- 1:20:09I simply wanted to save myself, not weigh all those things, right? So
- 1:20:15when I finally reached that place where
- 1:20:19I made the decision—and it happened during one of those therapy sessions—
- 1:20:22something simply clicked and I thought, no, this is the end.
- 1:20:26Of course I'd thought about it before. It wasn't some decision made under the influence of
- 1:20:29emotion. It had been building for some time, because things weren't improving.
- 1:20:33You knew for six years. Actually, yes, six years. Yes.
- 1:20:37Yes. There was all that work and so on, and it just never
- 1:20:42produced results, until the decision came.
- 1:20:45Yes. And then what? [inhales]
- 1:20:47Well, yes. I think the first thing
- 1:20:52I did was write the information down, because I decided it was
- 1:20:56better in writing. But first I went to a lawyer,
- 1:21:05and when I explained the situation to the lawyer,
- 1:21:09the lawyer told me what the legal situation looked like. And that was the moment when
- 1:21:13I sort of... because the people in that organization, the leaders, they
- 1:21:17already knew what was going on, right? So they were aware
- 1:21:22to some extent, but
- 1:21:27this was the first time I came to them with a decision. I
- 1:21:32told them, basically, hey, at this stage,
- 1:21:37regardless of what you think is right or wrong, whether I have
- 1:21:42grounds to end this marriage or not, it turns out
- 1:21:48the law is more merciful to me and gives me those grounds, and
- 1:21:53regardless of what you say, I simply want to do it because I
- 1:21:57cannot live like this. It was a difficult moment. But they
- 1:22:01actually... I expected them to exclude me completely from
- 1:22:04everything, to say, 'Oh, you fallen woman, you don't want
- 1:22:07to stay with your husband,' and so on. And I remember that there was this enormous
- 1:22:12fear that I would simply be excluded. I thought, okay, at least my
- 1:22:14family—even though they didn't really like the idea either—
- 1:22:20is accepting enough that I knew I would always find
- 1:22:23shelter there, that if everything here completely collapsed and nobody
- 1:22:27wanted anything to do with me, nobody wanted to know me in this
- 1:22:31environment, then at least I had my loving family, who
- 1:22:35regardless of my views would always take me in, right? So that was a
- 1:22:38safety cushion that genuinely played a huge role
- 1:22:42at that moment. But I'd also like to tell one more
- 1:22:47story connected with this,
- 1:22:51and it also relates to a story titled 'I Believe You,' because in
- 1:22:56situations like this, I'll tell you how enormously important social support is—
- 1:23:01from loved ones, family, even in the context of the church. Because
- 1:23:06as for my own situation, my own, generally speaking...
- 1:23:12our local situation here was known to very few people, right?
- 1:23:18although people in the States knew, where we'd had all those conversations,
- 1:23:23but here locally, including in the community where
- 1:23:26I was, only a few people knew, basically those
- 1:23:31we worked with, and even then only to a limited
- 1:23:36extent. But they could see we were in a process, that we were in therapy
- 1:23:40and so on. And there was this moment
- 1:23:45when
- 1:23:48again, in hindsight it looks different, but at that time
- 1:23:53I was afraid—or maybe not exactly afraid—
- 1:23:58that my version of reality,
- 1:24:05the way I perceived that reality, how I saw it, and
- 1:24:09my feelings were one thing,
- 1:24:13but there were also certain facts, right? This happened, that happened, this was
- 1:24:17said, the situation looked like this, and I was afraid that when I talked
- 1:24:26about those things, they would once again be treated as some kind of
- 1:24:29whim of mine, something I'd invented, that I had some
- 1:24:37hypersensitivity, that I was oversensitive, that I lacked some ability, that I couldn't
- 1:24:41do this or that. And I think something that always echoed in my head was when
- 1:24:47my husband told me that because I'd had such a difficult
- 1:24:51family situation, I didn't know what it meant to be in a relationship with a real man,
- 1:24:56and that was why all these problems existed, right? So
- 1:25:01that got lodged very deeply in me, and I was genuinely very afraid of it. I
- 1:25:07thought, now everyone will simply decide that I'm
- 1:25:10crazy. But okay, fine, let it be. I just want to survive.
- 1:25:16[laughter] [inhales] And I thought, okay. So the positive thing was
- 1:25:21that when I finally came forward clearly and said
- 1:25:25that this was [sigh] [inhales]
- 1:25:27the end of the marriage from my side to those leaders,
- 1:25:33the ones abroad, they actually showed me a lot of support in that whole
- 1:25:37situation and genuinely helped me a great deal, which I hadn't expected. So that
- 1:25:41was really good. Very much so. [clears throat]
- 1:25:45And I think what also helped was that it turned out there were other problems too,
- 1:25:49that I wasn't the only one who had a problem and I wasn't the only person
- 1:25:54who had been affected, who was raising the fact that these problems existed and that they
- 1:25:58were serious, right? So the timing overlapped somewhat, and
- 1:26:05there really was support and cooperation
- 1:26:09from that side. But locally too, I'll tell one story that
- 1:26:15really affected me at the time, because
- 1:26:21I had a friend from the band, and there was a period when he'd sometimes
- 1:26:28drop by for coffee and we'd talk.
- 1:26:31And I decided to tell him, apart from my closest
- 1:26:37people, my closest female friends who already knew about my
- 1:26:41situation and where I was, and I think by then I'd already told a few
- 1:26:45people that I'd made the decision that I wanted to separate. One
- 1:26:49friend of mine—I went to her and said:
- 1:26:53'Listen, [clears throat]
- 1:26:55everyone was praying for a miracle. There won't be a miracle.'
- 1:26:58[laughter] Because I simply can't keep waiting for it
- 1:27:01anymore, waiting for something to change, right? And she said to me, when I told her I'd
- 1:27:08decided to get divorced, she looked at me and said,
- 1:27:12'Magda, this is the greatest miracle I could have imagined.'
- 1:27:19[laughter] That I had even reached that point at all,
- 1:27:21right? I remember how strongly that hit me.
- 1:27:24But going back to that story with this friend from the band, because
- 1:27:29he visited us from time to time, I decided I'd also
- 1:27:33tell him that I was at this point, right? And I
- 1:27:38thought, okay, this will probably be the moment when I lose this friend, because he
- 1:27:43will probably side with all those religious
- 1:27:48people who say you can't divorce and that I have no grounds or
- 1:27:54anything for it. So I arranged to meet him for coffee at a mall or
- 1:27:59something and said, 'Listen, this is the situation. I want you to know because
- 1:28:02we're in touch, whether you come over to our place or something,
- 1:28:07that this is the end of the relationship. At this moment
- 1:28:13it's not public yet, because we still have to process
- 1:28:17various things, but for me it's over.
- 1:28:21And I expected him to immediately say, 'What are you doing,
- 1:28:26Magda?' and so on. He asked why, and said that
- 1:28:33he had noticed—although I'd never talked to him about it—that there were some
- 1:28:37problems, but he hadn't expected them to be that serious.
- 1:28:43I told him a few stories and said this to him. I said,
- 1:28:48'You know what, I understand that when you hear other people, or
- 1:28:52whoever, you'll probably simply
- 1:28:56believe what they say. I understand, that's just
- 1:29:00life, right? You'll probably think I'm exaggerating too, or something.' And he
- 1:29:07looked at me carefully and said, 'No, no. Magda, I'm glad you
- 1:29:11told me. I believe you.' And those words, 'I believe you,' from someone
- 1:29:16who hadn't been involved, hadn't known before, someone I'd never spoken to
- 1:29:20about this, I remember they simply
- 1:29:26moved me so much then—that someone believed me, someone who wasn't
- 1:29:32somehow involved in it. And this is where I'd like to
- 1:29:39raise the issue of social support, because sometimes
- 1:29:45we wonder how to help someone who is experiencing something like this.
- 1:29:50And the words 'I believe you' can work miracles. Really, it's
- 1:29:56that kind of validation, right? That
- 1:30:02you know what, maybe I'm not making it up, maybe
- 1:30:05it gives courage to other women, women and men in such a situation. Because you also
- 1:30:13mentioned yourself that recently there were several major scandals in Protestant
- 1:30:16circles involving affairs or other abusive behavior by
- 1:30:22pastors, husbands who cheated on them, or things like that, and that
- 1:30:26you said you later saw
- 1:30:30a flood of Facebook posts titled 'I forgive you, husband,' and that those pastors' wives
- 1:30:36didn't decide to actually fight for
- 1:30:40themselves, their lives, their comfort, or
- 1:30:44their children's comfort. And you said you're probably
- 1:30:47the only pastor's wife with that much seniority and reach who did not
- 1:30:51forgive it, who said no and drew that boundary—with emphasis
- 1:30:55on probably, because you can never know 100 percent, just to be clear.
- 1:30:59And in that context you're an example that it can be done, that it's worth
- 1:31:04fighting, that there are all kinds of problems, but there's also a chance of receiving support from
- 1:31:10the community and other people, and that you said that today,
- 1:31:16two years after the decision, you're very happy, even though it's hard.
- 1:31:20Yes, yes. Both things, but maybe I'll address the first one—the issue
- 1:31:25of forgiveness—because that is [laughter] a huge topic. Again, I
- 1:31:30don't know what guides people, because every situation is different, right? And
- 1:31:35there are people where, from the outside, it seems to us,
- 1:31:38okay, damn, why is she still with him? But
- 1:31:44everyone has their own perspective, right? Whether it's
- 1:31:47for religious reasons or any other reasons, or maybe the guy really
- 1:31:51is great enough that despite being abusive or cheating... well,
- 1:31:55no, abuse is different. At this moment [inhales]
- 1:31:58I'm putting abuse aside, but other things. I don't know. Everyone
- 1:32:02has to approach it individually; again, I don't know those situations well enough. But
- 1:32:07what I do want to say is that I'm not the first, because
- 1:32:11I myself was told the story of another
- 1:32:15[clears throat] woman who was also married to a pastor and left him, and
- 1:32:19he was extremely abusive. That story was also important to me here, mainly
- 1:32:25because of the children. She described what situation her children were in,
- 1:32:29what condition they were in, and that really mobilized me. I thought,
- 1:32:32no, my children are much younger right now and I simply don't want to be
- 1:32:36in that place in a few years. Yes, exactly. Because I saw the same
- 1:32:40signals, the same symptoms in them that she described experiencing with
- 1:32:45her own children. And I thought, 'No, I don't want to be in that place.'
- 1:32:49I care too much about my children to simply allow this
- 1:32:52to happen. And I know that if we stay in this arrangement, that's where we're heading, right?
- 1:32:59So that mattered. But you also mentioned
- 1:33:05others. Yes, yes, there are a lot of them. Abroad too.
- 1:33:12And what does your situation look like now,
- 1:33:17at this moment, within that specific organization, and how did it
- 1:33:22end for your former husband? Were the issues
- 1:33:29addressed with him? Did he face any consequences for what he
- 1:33:32did? Because I understand it wasn't only toward you, but also toward
- 1:33:35some people in the congregation, because there were complaints and problems being raised
- 1:33:41about his behavior, abuses or whatever.
- 1:33:45Did he face any consequences for what he did? Well, yes, in that
- 1:33:51congregation, in that church, he is no longer a pastor.
- 1:33:54And I don't want to go further into how the story continues
- 1:34:02or what is happening there, because some of the information I
- 1:34:06receive I can only treat as circumstantial, so I don't want to
- 1:34:11comment on it. In that church he is not a pastor.
- 1:34:15And as for those other situations, I didn't process them in any way,
- 1:34:19I didn't participate in them, although I know they happened,
- 1:34:24because it was also said publicly at a meeting, but I myself didn't
- 1:34:27at a meeting, but I myself didn't look into it. Of course over
- 1:34:34the years I heard various things, but again I didn't process them, so
- 1:34:39at least at the stage when decisions were being made, I had absolutely
- 1:34:42nothing to do with them. And do you personally feel any consequences of what
- 1:34:48happened? Has anything changed in
- 1:34:52how people treat you? Oh, that's a very good question.
- 1:34:55Of course I do. You know, there are several things. I
- 1:35:00started being involved in church when I was, I don't know, 17 or 18.
- 1:35:07And I was always connected with church somehow, always
- 1:35:11involved in various things. For me one of the
- 1:35:14priorities—and it genuinely mattered, and even now
- 1:35:19after all these years and personal therapy, because I don't know how much of
- 1:35:22it came from my mechanism of rescuing other people, right? As they say,
- 1:35:26I want to save everyone, and in churches everyone gets saved
- 1:35:29maybe even more than Jesus saves them. [laughter] People somehow
- 1:35:34want to save others even more, be better than, I don't know, God or something, but
- 1:35:40I don't even want to get into that. Sometimes we try to compete over
- 1:35:46who is the better rescuer. But I definitely had those mechanisms.
- 1:35:51Still, even after this whole process, I genuinely care deeply
- 1:35:55about people. I also liked being involved, because a large part of my
- 1:36:00work—or rather my involvement, because
- 1:36:04people call it ministry, like healthcare service or some other religious service—
- 1:36:09was working with people. And across 20 years there were all kinds of cases and
- 1:36:16situations you end up processing:
- 1:36:22illnesses, deaths, cancer, losing children. There is truly so much. And
- 1:36:29despite everything, as someone who is, let's use
- 1:36:37the word, on the board of an organization, or in this case
- 1:36:41of a church—some churches call it a council—
- 1:36:46those things reach you, right? They affect you. There were many projects where
- 1:36:51we helped, for example, solve people's housing problems,
- 1:36:55families, single mothers raising children in various
- 1:37:01life situations. Not to mention the entire Ukrainian crisis, which I had the chance
- 1:37:04to participate in. I later counted it up and realized I had the chance
- 1:37:08to process roughly 10,000 people during those first months,
- 1:37:13helping them with transport and accommodation. Those are the kinds of
- 1:37:17things you're dealing with all the time. Of course also processing
- 1:37:21different scammers, because people take advantage, right? And you have to
- 1:37:26handle that too. So throughout all those years I was involved in it, and
- 1:37:32I still care about it deeply. That's also why I
- 1:37:35decided to move toward helping people psychologically,
- 1:37:40through the foundation too, because I simply care about people. I always
- 1:37:44have and I still do. But again, in the church context, I was involved for 20
- 1:37:49years. And this situation meant that suddenly
- 1:37:56I could no longer be there. And again, I don't know how
- 1:38:01things were processed there, who made which decisions or whatever,
- 1:38:05but at some point I was told, no, you have your own
- 1:38:11things to process and so on, so you won't be here anymore, right? And that
- 1:38:15was also my livelihood, my job, right? So suddenly I lost my job, so
- 1:38:20I ended up with my marriage over—and okay, that was my decision,
- 1:38:29because again I was trying to save myself—but also suddenly without an income, without
- 1:38:37a job, after basically almost, I don't know, seven or ten
- 1:38:42years away from working in finance, where I had worked
- 1:38:46in a very narrow field called derivatives.
- 1:38:51And after that ten-year break,
- 1:38:57it's very hard to get back into that market, right?
- 1:39:02Because you have this gap,
- 1:39:04and it's a very narrow field. First of all, finding a position—the company
- 1:39:10had moved out of Kraków, so going back there wasn't possible either—and
- 1:39:16I was left in this situation of: what am I supposed to do with myself now?
- 1:39:19But what was the reason they removed you?
- 1:39:22I have no idea. I mean, probably the divorce situation, right? That it was
- 1:39:26controversial and all that, that there are some guidelines that someone who
- 1:39:31doesn't have their family situation, their marriage, properly settled
- 1:39:36also can't be a leader, can't lead other people
- 1:39:39or something, right? So you can be a leader when
- 1:39:44you're in a marriage that is effectively a ruin, but on paper you're still
- 1:39:49husband and wife and you're an exemplary married couple. Even though there are signals,
- 1:39:54some people know, they see it, different things are being reported,
- 1:39:58and you want to resolve the situation for your own good and your children's good,
- 1:40:03but then that becomes inconvenient. And probably some kind of, in quotation marks, systemic
- 1:40:08change has to happen so divorce isn't viewed as... because I understand divorce
- 1:40:12is seen this way, rather than the fact that you were in
- 1:40:16a difficult relationship, a very difficult one.
- 1:40:22You could say a toxic one. Let's put it that way, right?
- 1:40:25Mm-hmm. Instead it's just the fact that you're getting divorced.
- 1:40:27Mm-hmm. And you know, I think your testimony is extremely important,
- 1:40:32important because maybe you are that little light at the end of the tunnel
- 1:40:36for women or men—because women can also be abusive—in
- 1:40:40similar situations, who, for example, because
- 1:40:44they belong to some community, church or whatever, know that divorce is frowned upon,
- 1:40:47and maybe it is still worth daring to do it, you know.
- 1:40:53Well, that's exactly what I'm daring to do. All right then. [laughter]
- 1:40:56[inhales] But you've touched on a subject here that
- 1:41:00really eats at me. [laughter] [inhales] It's probably
- 1:41:04one of the most painful things I'm still going through. It
- 1:41:08still hurts. I ended my, how should I call it,
- 1:41:15ministry, whatever, a year ago, and honestly
- 1:41:21it's something that's hard to heal from. So are you
- 1:41:27still affiliated somehow, and where is your faith in all of this?
- 1:41:33Faith is another podcast, you know? Oh, [laughter] okay. But maybe briefly.
- 1:41:39You know what, I'm glad you asked that. Because, goodness,
- 1:41:45a situation like this can do something to your mind. I had
- 1:41:50years when I genuinely wondered what was true and what
- 1:41:53I was supposed to hold on to, because I had been looking for
- 1:41:57some kind of stability for my faith in the church, right? And then suddenly
- 1:42:03everything fell apart. You're in a relationship with a pastor that
- 1:42:07is just completely surreal. It's so painful and none of it
- 1:42:12adds up, right? How is that even possible?
- 1:42:16That someone can say one thing and do another. They're like two completely different
- 1:42:20worlds, right? Here he says he loves you, and here he's suddenly doing something to you,
- 1:42:24and I mean something serious. I'm not talking about a little argument, it's
- 1:42:28suddenly some total outburst, right? And [snort] it just
- 1:42:34doesn't add up. I thought, what is even happening here? So it honestly took me years
- 1:42:37to sort it out in my head. What helped me a little
- 1:42:41was that at one point I was completely frustrated with church,
- 1:42:44hugely, but then when I went to the States and was in a slightly different environment, I thought,
- 1:42:48'No, this really isn't about church. It's about our specific
- 1:42:51situation. It isn't that something is wrong with church itself,
- 1:42:55it's that there are situations that are wrong and they need to be addressed within
- 1:42:59the church.' But as for faith itself, as you asked, I
- 1:43:06separate it a little, because on one hand it's connected, but on
- 1:43:09the other hand faith is something personal, right? And for me,
- 1:43:14faith from a personal point of view is still something that
- 1:43:20can really be summed up in one sentence: it revolves around the person of
- 1:43:23Jesus Christ. You can't get around that in any way if someone
- 1:43:27associates themselves with Christianity at all. And of course
- 1:43:31Christianity also has cultural aspects, historical aspects, traditions,
- 1:43:35there's a lot of it. For example, Polish culture is deeply connected
- 1:43:40with some form of Christianity, so there are social values
- 1:43:44and so on, and you can debate each of those things endlessly.
- 1:43:47But what I would call personal
- 1:43:51faith—the term you used—from my perspective is connected with the person of Jesus
- 1:43:55the term you used, from my perspective it is connected with the person of Jesus
- 1:44:00Christ, and you cannot get around that in any way.
- 1:44:02So it isn't entirely tied to the institution, right? And I understand that your
- 1:44:07marital experiences with a pastor and your experiences in that institution
- 1:44:15didn't affect what is, I assume, deep in your heart and your
- 1:44:20relationship, let's say—let's say—with Jesus. Put it that way.
- 1:44:25That sounds a little strange when you say it. I know, but a relationship with God. Maybe
- 1:44:32I used it because I don't want to avoid it,
- 1:44:34it's just that sometimes it's used in a strange way. I can't think of another word.
- 1:44:38I know. But it's a great word, right? It's a good word, except
- 1:44:41that fundamentally, you know,
- 1:44:46what always amazes me is that the basic
- 1:44:50commandment is the commandment to love. Yes. And that's also such a dissonance,
- 1:44:55yes, an enormous dissonance. When you think that it was said
- 1:44:59about loving God and another person, right? That another
- 1:45:03person has value, and then suddenly what starts having value are, I don't know, some
- 1:45:07programs, or who is right. I mean both in the church context and then
- 1:45:11it spills into society and the various right wings and left wings fighting each other,
- 1:45:15conservatives or whoever, and it simply turns into
- 1:45:19conservatives or whoever, and it simply turns into
- 1:45:26a point of conflict about who is right. What really stands out to me
- 1:45:29in your story is this instrument of power,
- 1:45:31yes, because throughout your story there is this strong imperative of power over you,
- 1:45:37over your life, over aspects connected with the congregation and so
- 1:45:43on, over the way they, in quotation marks, programmed you to
- 1:45:48be submissive, obedient, and not have those doubts, or to suppress
- 1:45:51the doubts that, if you'd stood up for yourself back then,
- 1:45:56probably none of all this would exist today. Although on the other hand it probably
- 1:45:58made you the person you are today, so it's hard to
- 1:46:01assign a value to it. Yes, yes, it's hard to assign a value to it.
- 1:46:05That's what we're given, right? These things simply happen, and
- 1:46:09that's what we have, this reality, right?
- 1:46:12I'd also like you to address the issue of sexual abuse
- 1:46:17and
- 1:46:22how functioning within a particular community, in this case a
- 1:46:26Protestant one, affected how it was addressed or not addressed there.
- 1:46:33Okay. This is also a topic where
- 1:46:38I feel that, of course, in religious circles it can be
- 1:46:43a little...
- 1:46:47I don't know, often a shameful subject, or one that simply isn't
- 1:46:51addressed, at least from what I can see from my own
- 1:46:57experience, it isn't really a topic that gets addressed. Mostly it is
- 1:47:01addressed in the sense that you absolutely must not have sex before marriage,
- 1:47:05right? And again, partly from my own experience of
- 1:47:13let's call it working in the church for so many years,
- 1:47:17I know that basically this is what gets said, people do what they do, and
- 1:47:24then it gets skipped over and everyone moves on, right? Practice and theory
- 1:47:30are two different things, and God forbid someone admits they did it, because
- 1:47:35then it becomes a scandal, right? So there are things
- 1:47:41someone says, someone doesn't say. But in
- 1:47:48the context of our conversation, and
- 1:47:53again coming back to the foundation work that I
- 1:47:58want to use to help people in situations like this, this is
- 1:48:05a very serious problem: sexual abuse in relationships. And again,
- 1:48:13if the marriage has to survive because the assumption is that it can't be
- 1:48:19broken up, then someone sometimes has to pay a price, and
- 1:48:24sometimes that price is being sexually exploited and
- 1:48:30even being aware of it, but not wanting to—or having no way to
- 1:48:37address it, because there's nobody to talk to, nobody to
- 1:48:40turn to, no idea what to do, and you end up in a situation where
- 1:48:45you simply participate in it for the sake of peace. So technically there is consent, but
- 1:48:50in reality it would be better if there wasn't. And there's also this narrative of submission to
- 1:48:54the husband. Yes, that narrative is there. And on top of that,
- 1:48:56when the husband tells you that he can't imagine it
- 1:49:02any other way, that first of all he's entitled to it because it's your duty
- 1:49:06after all, right? And that still exists. It's not that we
- 1:49:09say, oh, there is freedom, of course consent matters,
- 1:49:14right? First it was the legal side, that you have to give consent, but no,
- 1:49:19in marriages like these there is often a completely different narrative. Because
- 1:49:22once you've already consented by saying you're a wife, then
- 1:49:25theoretically why can't you function in that role,
- 1:49:32as, I don't know how to say it,
- 1:49:36the object that serves that purpose, right? Because that's often how it looks in
- 1:49:40such relationships. And I think [clears throat] the worst thing is
- 1:49:44that when—and I know what I'm talking about here—
- 1:49:49and at the moment when, somewhere along the way...
- 1:49:53when you're struggling with it and, for example, you say,
- 1:49:55'I feel uncomfortable with this, I feel like an object,' then
- 1:49:59the other side may tell you, or if you say, 'I feel forced,
- 1:50:05I feel used,' the other side tells you, 'Then you're manipulating me
- 1:50:09with sex,'
- 1:50:14because if you're doing it even though you don't want to, then that means you're
- 1:50:19manipulating me. But on the other hand, you're supposedly
- 1:50:21obliged to do it, because you're supposed to be submissive and it's your marital
- 1:50:25duty. Well, supposedly not. And I mention this
- 1:50:28because I know there are people who
- 1:50:31are in that place and do it for the sake of peace and so on, and in the
- 1:50:36long term it is a complete
- 1:50:43devastation of the psyche. I don't even know what to call it. I don't know
- 1:50:49whether there is a worse form of humiliation than being
- 1:50:56sexually exploited, feeling
- 1:51:00sexually exploited in a relationship as close as marriage.
- 1:51:05And the statistics on rape—I don't remember the exact numbers right now—but
- 1:51:10they show this. We have an interview on our channel with Ania Sieczka. She
- 1:51:15co-created a campaign, God, I think it was called 'Ona temu winna,'
- 1:51:20I don't remember exactly what the campaign was called, but it was a campaign
- 1:51:22about awareness of what sexual
- 1:51:27violence is. And those statistics show that some devastating majority of rapes
- 1:51:34are rapes within marriage. Marital rape. Except that women who are
- 1:51:39being exploited often don't even know that what is happening is rape.
- 1:51:44Yes, people sometimes know, but they don't know what to do about it. What
- 1:51:48to do, because it's marriage, so how could you not have consented if you're
- 1:51:51a wife? As if you couldn't refuse consent.
- 1:51:53Or, I don't know, speaking from my own experience,
- 1:51:59that
- 1:52:03'I didn't know you actually didn't want to,' even though I, for example,
- 1:52:08am screaming, shouting, 'Leave me alone,' crying. But apparently it wasn't clear.
- 1:52:14What are you saying? Tears are running down your face, but apparently that's just
- 1:52:18foreplay. Foreplay. Yes.
- 1:52:19Yes. So this is something where
- 1:52:24again I don't know what the scale is, because generally, as you say,
- 1:52:27I'm aware that it's a major issue in marriages. But
- 1:52:32in churches specifically I have no idea, because it's a topic I had barely
- 1:52:37heard discussed at all, and when I raised it myself, it was also
- 1:52:42a challenge, because there's no awareness, nobody really knows what it means,
- 1:52:45nobody knows what to do about it. So because there are no tools and nobody knows
- 1:52:48what to do, it becomes, goodness, 'I'm sorry,' right? Because what
- 1:52:53else do you do? And again, I now [clears throat] know what kind of
- 1:52:58tools need to be used in that kind of situation,
- 1:53:01but that's something you learn.
- 1:53:03But you were in that situation years ago. I was, but
- 1:53:07I also want to add that there are different forms beyond
- 1:53:11physical coercion. Maybe, okay, that can happen once, say,
- 1:53:15in that form and then it becomes clear it's a problem. So the other person
- 1:53:19may switch to other methods, and most often those are
- 1:53:23forms of manipulation, and something that's repeatedly quoted in religious
- 1:53:28circles is a passage from the Bible about
- 1:53:34marriage, saying that the wife no longer owns her body,
- 1:53:40her husband does, and the husband doesn't own his body, his
- 1:53:44wife does, right? So a husband may say,
- 1:53:50'Listen, whenever you want,
- 1:53:55I'm always ready, so you can always tell me.'
- 1:53:58And supposedly it's meant to work the other way around
- 1:54:01too, right? So if I tell you, you're supposed to be ready too. Except, you know,
- 1:54:06the situation may be completely different. If she is, I don't know,
- 1:54:10overloaded with all sorts of things and genuinely doesn't want to, and he then
- 1:54:14insults her—or even if it isn't insults, but some
- 1:54:18other kind of pressure—or completely ignores whatever needs
- 1:54:22she has, right? And she doesn't feel like she wants to participate, but he says:
- 1:54:27'No, no, you know, I'm always ready. Whenever you need it,
- 1:54:30I'm there for you, so you should be there for me too.' And is that really an equal
- 1:54:34arrangement—is it really equal? So here you have to
- 1:54:38remember there are different situations, but this passage is genuinely often
- 1:54:41is genuinely used often. I heard it I don't know how many times: 'It's written that way in
- 1:54:44the Bible, so that's what you have to do,' right? But it doesn't work like that, and
- 1:54:48the context of that passage is different too, right? But who would
- 1:54:51care? Who would care what the context is, if
- 1:54:55this interpretation happens to fit? It fits. Just like there are a few other
- 1:54:58things that also always fit when convenient.
- 1:55:01Although it also seems to me that arguments like that are used by
- 1:55:05abusive individuals, and the ones who are in church and know
- 1:55:10Scripture or the Bible use that knowledge as leverage and throw out that
- 1:55:13argument. Predators in other environments will do it differently, and
- 1:55:17it seems to me this isn't really tied entirely to
- 1:55:21church teaching itself, but to the fact that an abusive person knows how to
- 1:55:25use something to their own advantage. But the fact that in these church
- 1:55:29communities sex is taboo, sex isn't discussed openly,
- 1:55:33and there is no education about it—which I honestly can't
- 1:55:37get my head around—is a pathology of the system. And damn, new generations
- 1:55:42are already coming up. I hope this changes, because so many
- 1:55:47women in marriages, young people at the beginning of their journey who are looking for
- 1:55:52you know, and they don't know either, and different situations happen, so
- 1:55:58on Minecraft. On Minecraft. So sexual education
- 1:56:01is simply crucial. And likewise, if you experience
- 1:56:05sexual violence or abuse, regardless of what
- 1:56:09situation you're in, whether you belong to a church or whether your husband is some
- 1:56:14prominent, high-ranking person, regardless, you simply have to seek
- 1:56:18help. And even if not as publicly as you, then at least talk about your
- 1:56:22experiences and assert your rights, because nobody has the right to tell you that
- 1:56:27it's your duty, or God's will, or whatever else, that you have
- 1:56:31to be submissive. No. It's your body. You
- 1:56:35decide what happens to it, and any form of pressure is
- 1:56:40a form of violence. And here I'd add that legally
- 1:56:45some things are regulated, but in churches, again, it's like, well,
- 1:56:49we have the Bible, we have the Bible. But the Bible—okay, part of it is the law
- 1:56:54of a historical nation that lived several thousand years ago, and another
- 1:56:58part is from about 2,000 [clears throat] years ago and the law of another nation
- 1:57:03is also taken into account, Roman law in that case. So
- 1:57:09these things overlap somewhere, and as I wrote to you,
- 1:57:14church is an interesting construct where
- 1:57:17different systems get mixed together, and sometimes you simply don't know what
- 1:57:21to hold on to, right? In my own process, I reached
- 1:57:25a point where I realized Polish law is actually very similar
- 1:57:29when it comes to family matters, divorce and life. It is
- 1:57:33similar to something society has developed
- 1:57:37that in some way resembles that ancient law,
- 1:57:41only you have to read it carefully and search. And of course there are people who
- 1:57:45deal with this, historians who research it and so on, and you can learn
- 1:57:49a lot from them if you need to. But again, the tendency in
- 1:57:52churches is to skim everything and mix it all
- 1:57:56together. A little of this, a little of that, and I
- 1:58:00joke: a bit of archaic wisdom, a bit of the American Bible Belt,
- 1:58:05because so many missionaries and churches came from there and the culture
- 1:58:08soaked in, plus a bit of our Polish context, and depending on what
- 1:58:12suits someone, that's what they choose at the moment. And that is
- 1:58:15difficult, because in situations like these there are certain guidelines, and it would be good
- 1:58:18to use, for example, our Polish
- 1:58:23law, imperfect as it is, because it still protects
- 1:58:30the victim to some extent, and work is continuing, things are
- 1:58:34being improved and so on, but it does provide some protection, and
- 1:58:37we need to keep in mind that it is, despite everything,
- 1:58:41more, I'd say, consistent with love than the idea that
- 1:58:49your neighbor has to sacrifice their life for someone who simply
- 1:58:54uses them, right?
- 1:58:56Yes.
- 1:59:00Those are also your words: that it's important for this to come across,
- 1:59:05that to a large extent there are genuinely good people in these communities,
- 1:59:09people who offer support, help, warmth, who
- 1:59:13often save lives, who take people in—in quotation marks—
- 1:59:19in extreme, crisis situations where those people can seek rescue,
- 1:59:24and that these are also people who, as an organization and as
- 1:59:29individuals, suffer because of the abusive behavior of a few people,
- 1:59:33so we don't now paint the Protestant
- 1:59:39church as some Sodom and Gomorrah, to use the biblical
- 1:59:44nomenclature. It's just that unfortunately, as in other environments, we're only
- 1:59:49human, and situations like this happen. That doesn't change the fact that
- 1:59:54certain structures, as I see them from the outside while we talk, are
- 1:59:59archaic and outdated, and excessive importance is placed, for example, on
- 2:00:03staying married rather than looking at the wellbeing
- 2:00:06of the wife, the children, and so on.
- 2:00:09I want it to be clear that we are not just attacking
- 2:00:13church as such.
- 2:00:17You're telling your [laughter] individual story. And at the end I'd also like
- 2:00:21to talk a little about your foundation, which is being created,
- 2:00:26Sztuka Wyjścia, and I'd like you to say what you told me
- 2:00:31off camera: that if someone needs help, they can at any
- 2:00:34time... Yes, yes, yes. I'll add that,
- 2:00:38but if I could just refer for a moment to something you
- 2:00:41said earlier about the church, right? I spent another 20
- 2:00:46years in church. An interesting experience for me was that this year
- 2:00:51I had the chance to complete a course in one therapeutic method,
- 2:00:58to educate myself and develop in this field. And what struck me was how
- 2:01:03many of the things the course participants talked about—most of them were already
- 2:01:09therapists and psychologists, and they happened to all be women on that course—
- 2:01:16they talked about various situations and experiences with
- 2:01:21clients, patients they'd worked with, and I was shocked by how
- 2:01:26many similar situations I had had the chance to process. And over
- 2:01:31a long period too, because often these are relationships that last 10, 15,
- 2:01:3420 years, with people who pass through, appear, disappear and so
- 2:01:40on. And many of the situations they discussed, I had had the chance
- 2:01:45to process. So coming back to the question
- 2:01:50of church, it really can be a place that, as
- 2:01:55you said, on one hand genuinely offers some kind of help in
- 2:02:00crisis situations, but on the other hand there is even more
- 2:02:03potential there. There really could be more, because there are
- 2:02:07so many great people there who want to give, who are together enough,
- 2:02:12and also partly because of faith, right? That
- 2:02:17okay, I won't invest only in my earthly life and accumulate material
- 2:02:22goods and so on, but I'll think about something more, right? And somewhere
- 2:02:26that attention turns toward other people, toward helping, toward support, right?
- 2:02:30Someone organizes a meal, someone organizes a trip somewhere,
- 2:02:34someone pays for something for someone else, people gladly give to
- 2:02:37contribute to someone else's investment, I don't know, because they're struggling,
- 2:02:41right? We had situations like that too. Someone was in debt. I personally worked through
- 2:02:46several situations where someone was genuinely in enormous
- 2:02:49debt, trapped in a cycle, right? And we were able to support that person and
- 2:02:54get them out of it as a church, not as some external
- 2:02:58organization, but as a local community. And those are the kinds of things where you think,
- 2:03:01'Wow, that's great.' Looking back 15 years later, seeing that person
- 2:03:06went through it, got out of it and is in a completely different place—damn,
- 2:03:10that's genuinely great. So again, I stand a little
- 2:03:15in the middle, because I know there is a lot of criticism toward church, because there are various
- 2:03:17scams and I am aware of goodness, countless things we could talk about,
- 2:03:22[inhales] and if someone has been affected or hurt by those things,
- 2:03:25I'm even willing to talk about them, and again,
- 2:03:29as far as time allows, of course people can also write to me already
- 2:03:35through the foundation, which is still taking shape, but
- 2:03:38it will be operating soon. So we can address these things,
- 2:03:44and I can explain various issues to some extent, also
- 2:03:49separate what is about God from what is [laughter] other factors, because these are
- 2:03:54often very complex factors, right? But I think there is a lot of potential in church.
- 2:04:00What I'm doing now isn't within church, it's outside it,
- 2:04:04but again I think the potential there is
- 2:04:07large. And I'll keep saying this, because this will in a sense be very close to my heart:
- 2:04:13there needs to be health there. And where there are no systems
- 2:04:20that create safety for people and protect them from
- 2:04:24abuse, something has to be done to introduce them,
- 2:04:30for safety, so people aren't harmed so badly. And
- 2:04:34again, as you mentioned, by individuals,
- 2:04:38or by the lack of safeguards. Sometimes those individuals are willing to change,
- 2:04:43willing to improve something, and they may not even be aware that they are doing this kind of
- 2:04:47harm, but there are no safeguards, right? And that's the problem:
- 2:04:51there's no one to come in and say, 'This isn't
- 2:04:53okay.' People are afraid because, after all, it's the voice of the Lord,
- 2:04:56because he's a great speaker on stage and speaks beautifully. And we know that often people
- 2:05:00with that beautiful, wonderful charisma, as they say,
- 2:05:05say one thing and do another. It's no secret either
- 2:05:09that certain kinds of people are drawn to leadership roles. And that's
- 2:05:14a separate issue: these people often have a predisposition to
- 2:05:19charm others, climb the ladder, gain power, and
- 2:05:23well, that's a very long separate topic too. And we're deliberately not
- 2:05:28using certain words or diagnosing certain disorders here, but I think it's
- 2:05:32not really difficult to infer from this conversation what we're talking about,
- 2:05:37right? It's a classic pattern. The problem is that people don't realize
- 2:05:41how it works, because it's a classic pattern operating in societies.
- 2:05:44We have it on a large scale, with dictators who
- 2:05:50cause destruction. Kapuściński once wrote something like that there
- 2:05:55would be no dictator without his entourage. He was referring to one of the
- 2:05:58countries in Africa. And that entourage, right? Where does it come from?
- 2:06:03Mm-hmm. How does that entourage form? That's the large scale,
- 2:06:09right? And we see it, because we see dictators, we see Putin
- 2:06:12today, and historically countless others. But on a small scale
- 2:06:17it happens too, in organizations—goodness, especially
- 2:06:21universities, healthcare. Someone often finds their own little territory and becomes
- 2:06:26king there, right? We have all sorts of
- 2:06:30organizations, and unfortunately the same thing happens in church. We experience it, and
- 2:06:35often we have this problem where church becomes ugly and so on, even for
- 2:06:40someone who would actually like to have some kind of,
- 2:06:45as you put it earlier, relationship with Jesus. I'm not talking about
- 2:06:49people who don't want that, but those who do, and it becomes an obstacle for them,
- 2:06:53because they feel hurt by it, because these are abuses and nobody watches over it, nobody
- 2:06:58knows how to stop it, there are no tools for it, right? So this is another
- 2:07:02area where I'd like to see a process of
- 2:07:10building those kinds of tools. I think even addressing certain things openly
- 2:07:13is already a contribution to change, because people like you
- 2:07:18shake the structure a little and show that not everything can be
- 2:07:23swept under the rug, because there will be people who speak openly about certain
- 2:07:27pathologies in the system. Yes. And finally I wanted to ask about
- 2:07:32your foundation, so that you could encourage anyone who needs
- 2:07:35support or help—what should they do? Yes, we'll put something here [laughter]
- 2:07:40we already agreed there would be some contact. Yes,
- 2:07:43yes, there will. And don't [laughter] hesitate to write to Magda
- 2:07:48if you need to, because she expressed that willingness and openness.
- 2:07:52Yes, it's not a one-person foundation, because I also have—oh, great—[laughter] a great
- 2:07:56team, and we're putting everything together. It's taking us
- 2:08:00a little longer than expected, but that's usually how these things go,
- 2:08:03you know?
- 2:08:08Formally, I mean—because we're already doing various things, but
- 2:08:12formally we still have to legalize it, so to speak. But contact
- 2:08:16is available. Tell us at the end what forms
- 2:08:18of support there will be. That's a good question, because we already have
- 2:08:23some things partly planned, while others are still being developed.
- 2:08:27Definitely support groups and definitely individual help. And this is also
- 2:08:30more along the lines of—I'm not a therapist, so I won't be doing
- 2:08:35that kind of work. I hope to move in that direction someday,
- 2:08:37but it's a long road. Still, I can provide some form of support,
- 2:08:44taking [clears throat] into account my experience and the
- 2:08:48skills I've gained so far. At the very least I can provide guidance,
- 2:08:52help point someone onward depending on what they need.
- 2:08:56And definitely when it comes to all those church structures, because
- 2:09:01I've spent so much time there, and that's probably still where I have
- 2:09:07the most contacts. Quite a few people have already contacted me
- 2:09:10after hearing about my story somewhere and
- 2:09:13trying to get some advice about their own situation. And those have been really good,
- 2:09:19good meetings. Goodness, there are wonderful women who genuinely
- 2:09:23are searching and simply want to do the right thing. It's not only that they found themselves in
- 2:09:26a situation—mainly women, though one man has also appeared—
- 2:09:29they're looking for a solution. And in that context, I really
- 2:09:34can help, because I have my own experience and
- 2:09:38the knowledge I've gained over that time, so...
- 2:09:41Magda, thank you so much for sharing your story. I admire your
- 2:09:45courage. Will you stay with us a little longer for the
- 2:09:49aftertalk? It's another 10 or 15 minutes of conversation after the conversation for our
- 2:09:53supporting patrons and subscribers. Oh,
- 2:09:56behind the paywall. Of course. Great,
- 2:10:00great. So listen, because the work we do,
- 2:10:07we earn from you watching us or supporting us,
- 2:10:11so I warmly encourage you to support our podcast. You can become our
- 2:10:15subscriber on Hero Hero, which I strongly recommend, because there, after
- 2:10:19the conversation with a guest, I write a newsletter about my
- 2:10:24impressions and whatever came to mind. I share all the, I don't know,
- 2:10:28things that were mentioned, links, films, and lots of different
- 2:10:32extras and curiosities, so I warmly encourage you to join. And
- 2:10:36of course we post the aftertalks there too, so there's lots of bonus content on Hero Hero.
- 2:10:41You can subscribe to us for €3 a month, so I don't think that's
- 2:10:44a large amount. You can support us on Patronite or become a
- 2:10:48YouTube supporter, so there are plenty of options. Thank you all, and
- 2:10:53in particular I'd like to thank patron Krasulka, patron Julka,
- 2:10:56patron Mikuś, patron Tomek, patron Kuba, patron
- 2:11:00Maksymilian, and patron, patron, patron Wojtek. Thank you. Bye.
- 2:11:06[laughter]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Po 20 latach rozwiodłam się z PASTOREM. Doświadczałam PRZEMOCY psychicznej i religijnej – Sielatycka by dusznø podcast, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 19,938 words across 1,770 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.