Plática con el Prof. Emilio Tenti Fanfani con el tema Desigualdades sociales y escolares. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04Well, my name is Emilio Tenti Fanfani,
- 0:06I am a sociologist, professor, and
- 0:08researcher at the National Pedagogical
- 0:10University of the Argentine Republic.
- 0:12How are you? Good afternoon. Could you
- 0:13tell us a bit about the relationship
- 0:15that exists between inequality and
- 0:17education? Well, the relationship is
- 0:21very close because I usually say that
- 0:24everything that happens in society, in
- 0:26the field of the economy, politics,
- 0:28income distribution, changes in the
- 0:30family, everything is felt in school.
- 0:33Obviously, the problems of exclusion,
- 0:35the problems of inequality between
- 0:37those who have more, those who have
- 0:39less, those with higher income, those
- 0:41who have or have no income at all,
- 0:43between those who own property and
- 0:45those who do not. Owning property, not
- 0:48owning property, being rich, being poor
- 0:50, has an impact on one’s school
- 0:51trajectory. All these phenomena are
- 0:54felt within the school. One tends to
- 0:56believe, in an optimistic view, that
- 0:58school is precisely one of the great
- 1:00institutions, one of the great
- 1:02resources that modern societies have to
- 1:05build less unequal or more egalitarian
- 1:07societies, however we might say it; I
- 1:09think it is more correct to say less
- 1:11unequal. However, many of these
- 1:14expectations are not realized in
- 1:16reality, because we have increasingly
- 1:19educated societies, more and more boys
- 1:22and girls in schools, at the initial
- 1:25stage, middle school, and upper
- 1:27secondary; and yet, society remains
- 1:30unequal in terms of wealth distribution
- 1:33, in terms of property distribution. So
- 1:36, we must ask ourselves to what extent
- 1:37the school is fulfilling this role of
- 1:39building a more egalitarian or less
- 1:41unequal society. That is the question
- 1:42we have to ask. I think it is important
- 1:44. The school can play an equalizing
- 1:48role, but then we must ask: what are
- 1:50the social conditions, pedagogical
- 1:52conditions, and school conditions
- 1:54required for the school to fulfill this
- 1:56role?
- 1:58And what factors are those that
- 2:00influence and contribute to more
- 2:01inequality? Of course, because note
- 2:04that there is social inequality, no one
- 2:05disputes that. Latin America is the
- 2:07most unequal continent in the world.
- 2:10One says, "Well, on one hand, there is
- 2:12good news: the school is becoming more
- 2:14massive, there are more and more boys
- 2:15and girls in school." But when one
- 2:18looks at the knowledge, the learning
- 2:20that children actually develop in
- 2:22schools, the hard knowledge—and when
- 2:24I say hard knowledge, I mean the
- 2:26ability to read, write, and calculate
- 2:27—it remains concentrated in few hands
- 2:29. In other words, you can go to school,
- 2:33get certificates, diplomas, degrees,
- 2:35and not develop powerful knowledge.
- 2:38This is what the famous quality of
- 2:40education assessments show, both the
- 2:41national evaluations that countries
- 2:43carry out and these famous
- 2:45international assessments like PISA,
- 2:46which show that under equal schooling
- 2:48conditions, there are kids who know and
- 2:50others who don't. Just today I was
- 2:52reading in a newspaper, or rather on
- 2:54the internet yesterday, that six out of
- 2:56every ten Mexican children don't know
- 2:57how to divide or multiply. Stunning.
- 2:59They are in school. I mean, for
- 3:02Mexicans, we can say Latin Americans;
- 3:04almost half of the 15-year-olds
- 3:06surveyed by PISA, who take the PISA
- 3:08test, almost half lack reading skills,
- 3:10cannot read for comprehension, or lack
- 3:12basic calculation skills. So, the
- 3:15question we have to ask ourselves is,
- 3:17why is schooling not synonymous with
- 3:19learning? And then the question is, who
- 3:21are the ones who learn? Who has a
- 3:22greater probability of learning and
- 3:24taking something valuable away from
- 3:25school? And that is where the result
- 3:29that all research shows appears: that
- 3:31children who come from privileged homes
- 3:34, not just in economic terms—that is,
- 3:36money, income, property—but also in
- 3:39cultural terms, the children of those
- 3:41who have university-educated parents,
- 3:44have a greater probability of learning
- 3:46this important knowledge than those who
- 3:49come from homes that have scarce
- 3:51cultural capital, meaning at home, the
- 3:55level of schooling of their parents,
- 3:57and they also have material poverty.
- 4:01Those children are more likely to not
- 4:04develop powerful knowledge. So, the
- 4:06question here is really a problem. The
- 4:10question is, shouldn't a good school
- 4:12precisely be able to counteract these
- 4:13inequalities, be able to combat these
- 4:15inequalities? So, the question is, why
- 4:17doesn't it do so? What conditions are
- 4:19required? Because if one explains why
- 4:22things are as they are, perhaps one can
- 4:24have a clue to develop policies
- 4:25effectively aimed at having the school
- 4:27fulfill this expectation, right?,of
- 4:29being an equalizer.
- 4:31And how does the school contribute to
- 4:33doing that? Yes. Well, we first have to
- 4:36ask the school about educational policy
- 4:37. In Latin America, another observation
- 4:40that all those who conduct research
- 4:42make is that schools, school
- 4:44institutions, are not equal; that,
- 4:46unfortunately, the poorest schools are
- 4:48the schools where the poor go, and that
- 4:50the richest schools—I mean rich even
- 4:52in physical infrastructure, didactic
- 4:54and technological resources, and the
- 4:57quality of the teachers. In other words
- 5:00, the rich—notice how curious—the
- 5:02rich have greater learning
- 5:03opportunities. They go to wealthy
- 5:04institutions, to powerful institutions,
- 5:06and the poor go to poor institutions.
- 5:08The question is, what is this a result
- 5:09of? Of a policy. That can be changed.
- 5:12Nothing is inevitable; there is no such
- 5:14determinism. There is a fatalism, but
- 5:15it can be changed. And if one truly has
- 5:18the intention for school to fulfill
- 5:20this equalizing role, we would have to
- 5:22modify the allocation of resources. We
- 5:24would need to have more and better
- 5:26schools for those who need them most.
- 5:28That is to break this vicious cycle of
- 5:30poverty. If poor children go to poor
- 5:32schools, it shouldn't surprise us that
- 5:34they have poor learning outcomes. But
- 5:36this can be turned around through
- 5:38resource allocation policies that are
- 5:40more equitable, giving the best
- 5:41learning opportunities to those who
- 5:43need them most.
- 5:45Why do you think governments don't
- 5:47focus their efforts on more egalitarian
- 5:49policies? Well, I get the impression
- 5:53that the excluded, the poor, the
- 5:54non-owners, let's say, don't have the
- 5:56same political weight as people like us
- 5:58; the educated, the inhabitants of
- 6:00large cities, have a greater capacity
- 6:02to make themselves heard. The question
- 6:07we have to ask ourselves is: who in
- 6:08society has an interest in developing a
- 6:10strong, powerful public school system?
- 6:13Who generally attends public schools?
- 6:15Precisely the most disadvantaged
- 6:16sectors throughout Latin America. The
- 6:18upper-middle and upper classes have
- 6:20their own school subsystem; they pay
- 6:23for it, they are expensive. They, I
- 6:26mean, the sectors that have their
- 6:27private schools, aren't interested in
- 6:29public school because they have their
- 6:30problem solved. Who should be
- 6:32interested in public school? The
- 6:33excluded. But the excluded have less
- 6:35capacity to make their voices heard in
- 6:38the political arena. Everything depends
- 6:40on a problem of power, let's say. There
- 6:42are moments when the excluded make
- 6:43themselves heard, they have their
- 6:45organizations, they demand. Well, then,
- 6:48in those stages of history where the
- 6:50excluded make themselves felt because
- 6:52they have organized and demand quality
- 6:54education, it is likely that one can
- 6:57manage to move the needle a little in
- 6:59favor of the most disadvantaged sectors
- 7:01; but this is a problem of power
- 7:03dynamics and, let's say, nobody is
- 7:05going to give you knowledge for free.
- 7:08You have to fight for knowledge.
- 7:09Capital never, ever belongs to those
- 7:12who give it away for free to those who
- 7:14don't have it. Agrarian reform, for
- 7:17example, it's not that the landowners
- 7:19gave away the land. It was the landless
- 7:21who had to fight, they organized
- 7:23themselves to achieve the agrarian
- 7:24reforms. The society of those excluded
- 7:26from knowledge, those excluded from
- 7:30knowledge will also have to demand
- 7:32knowledge, which is not happening yet.
- 7:36Many people, many, um, in Latin
- 7:37American societies, what they demand is
- 7:40schooling, and they want diplomas, and
- 7:42they want degrees, and they haven't
- 7:44realized, it still hasn't been duly
- 7:46noted that today, under current
- 7:47conditions, having a diploma, even a
- 7:49bachelor's degree or a high school
- 7:51diploma, does not guarantee knowledge.
- 7:55So societies have to start demanding
- 7:57knowledge, just as the landless
- 7:58demanded land. Now, those excluded from
- 8:01mathematics, from language, from
- 8:02English, should mobilize for
- 8:04mathematics. not just for schooling,
- 8:06but for the learning of mathematics,
- 8:07for the learning of language, and other
- 8:09powerful forms of knowledge.
- 8:13In the case of teachers, how do their
- 8:15inequalities in terms of resources,
- 8:17training, and salaries affect their
- 8:19performance in the classroom? When one
- 8:22says they want a school, a good school,
- 8:24right? A good school: it is important
- 8:25to keep in mind that it doesn't just
- 8:27depend on the teachers. A good school
- 8:29is a school where there are material
- 8:31and physical resources, um,
- 8:33infrastructure, didactic resources, a
- 8:35strong, solid organization, and at the
- 8:37same time, we need qualified teachers;
- 8:39teachers who possess the knowledge
- 8:42resources to be able to deal with the
- 8:44variety of problems that teachers have
- 8:46to encounter in the classrooms.
- 8:49Teaching work is one of the most
- 8:51complex jobs that exists in
- 8:52contemporary societies, because for us
- 8:54teachers, for Latin American basic
- 8:56education teachers, the problems they
- 8:58have to solve are permanently changing.
- 9:02A cardiologist's problems do not change
- 9:03. Cardiological problems have been more
- 9:05or less the same for the last 50 years.
- 9:08The problem remains static, and they
- 9:09therefore have the advantage of having
- 9:11more and more resources to diagnose the
- 9:13problems. Now they have computed
- 9:15tomography, which didn't exist before,
- 9:16meaning they understand the problems
- 9:17better. and they have new technologies
- 9:20to solve the problems, new medications,
- 9:22new surgical techniques. On the other
- 9:24hand, for the teacher in school, the
- 9:26problems change, the kids change; for
- 9:28example, today a child, an adolescent
- 9:29today is not like an adolescent from 50
- 9:31years ago. Adolescents didn't even
- 9:33exist 50 years ago. The family is not
- 9:35the same family as before. The media,
- 9:37the cell phone, the kid with the cell
- 9:39phone in the classroom, and many
- 9:40teachers say, "What do I do with the
- 9:42cell phone?""It's a recent phenomenon,
- 9:43that is a new problem." Not even
- 9:46educational science has yet managed to
- 9:48investigate what the impacts and
- 9:50effects are, how to deal with cell
- 9:52phones, and how children's habits are
- 9:53permanently changing. Teachers
- 9:56encounter totally new problems every
- 9:58week, every month, or every year, and
- 10:00they are often disarmed when facing
- 10:02these issues, not even knowing how to
- 10:04define them, right? So, that is why
- 10:06today there is a need to strongly
- 10:08emphasize the professionalization of
- 10:10teachers. Today, we need highly
- 10:12qualified teachers with the capacity to
- 10:15collectively define these new problems
- 10:17and define strategies to address them.
- 10:20This implies a strong, strong
- 10:22enrichment, I would say, of the
- 10:23cultural capital of teachers in Latin
- 10:25America and in the world in general.
- 10:31What roles do teachers 'organizations
- 10:34play in this fight against inequality?
- 10:38I always say that the main defenders of
- 10:42public education in Latin America are
- 10:44the public sector teachers, because
- 10:45they also make their living from this.
- 10:48Those of us who work in the public
- 10:49sector are the main defenders of the
- 10:51public sphere. I have great respect for
- 10:55the teachers' organizations in Latin
- 10:58America. I am not saying they are
- 11:00perfect, ideal, or democratic, but as a
- 11:02principle, let's say, wage earners in
- 11:05general—teachers, workers—would not
- 11:07exist, we would have no weight in
- 11:09society if we did not unite. A big
- 11:11businessman can pick up the phone, call
- 11:13the President of the Republic, and ask
- 11:15for an appointment. In Argentina, the
- 11:18manager of Renault, the manager of the
- 11:20factory, I don't know, General Motors,
- 11:22picks up the phone and the President
- 11:23will receive him. A worker at the
- 11:25General Motors factory wouldn't even
- 11:28think of it. Besides, if he called the
- 11:29President, he would never be given an
- 11:30appointment. Wage earners can only
- 11:33exist and make ourselves heard through
- 11:34collective action, which implies that
- 11:36we organize ourselves and elect our
- 11:37representatives. This is on one hand,
- 11:40that is, defending the collective
- 11:41action of teachers through their
- 11:43representative organizations, which
- 11:44will have to keep improving their
- 11:46mechanisms of representation. All these
- 11:48things, I understand that. We are never
- 11:50in ideal situations, but the sacred
- 11:52principle of the right to collective
- 11:54expression seems fundamental to me.
- 11:56Secondly, I believe that unions must
- 11:58simultaneously balance their struggles,
- 12:01on one hand, in improving their working
- 12:03conditions, salaries, et cetera, et
- 12:06cetera. But at the same time, they must
- 12:08keep in mind that the school system is
- 12:10not just a source of employment for
- 12:11teachers; it is a system whose function
- 12:13is to develop powerful knowledge in new
- 12:15generations. So it must influence, it
- 12:19must also think that education is a
- 12:21public good and must contribute to
- 12:23these equity policies, to ensure that
- 12:25the right to education is truly
- 12:27effective, so that all Latin American
- 12:29children develop certain basic
- 12:31knowledge. That must be a goal not only
- 12:34for society, but especially for the
- 12:36union as well. The union has to
- 12:38intervene politically in this regard.
- 12:40It is a major player in the field of
- 12:42educational policy. It should not be
- 12:43limited only, as some might wish, to
- 12:45the defense of its legitimate corporate
- 12:47interests, of salary improvements, of
- 12:49better working conditions. At the same
- 12:51time, they must keep in mind the
- 12:52general interest, not just corporate
- 12:54interest, but the general interest. The
- 12:56issue of education is a matter of
- 12:57general interest. Technologies, as you
- 13:02mentioned, can contribute to narrowing
- 13:04the inequality gap, or they can also
- 13:07increase it.
- 13:10Well, to the extent that technologies
- 13:12in their material form are concentrated
- 13:14in certain privileged classes,
- 13:16obviously it can continue to reproduce
- 13:19those inequalities. That is why these
- 13:21programs developed in Latin America to
- 13:23provide free computers to children from
- 13:24working-class sectors are important.
- 13:26Children of the middle class have
- 13:28internet access, they have this
- 13:30equipment, they even have some training
- 13:32. Children from lower-income sectors do
- 13:34not have the means to buy a computer or
- 13:36a smartphone. So, I believe that the
- 13:39state should have...there have been
- 13:40major programs in Uruguay, in Argentina
- 13:42, where millions of computers were
- 13:43distributed to all high school students
- 13:44so they had their own computer. So,
- 13:46well, it is not just about distributing
- 13:49the tool, you also have to develop the
- 13:51ability to make intelligent use of this
- 13:53tool. It is the same thing as with
- 13:55books. I can distribute books, but it
- 13:57is another thing to develop reading
- 13:59skills. What good is a book to someone
- 14:00who does not know how to read? What
- 14:02good is a PC to you if you do not know
- 14:04how to use that PC? In other words, you
- 14:06have to do both things at the same time
- 14:08. And obviously, if technology is
- 14:09concentrated in a few hands, it
- 14:11obviously tends to reproduce [
- 14:12inequality]. If the most sophisticated
- 14:14technologies are only within the reach
- 14:16of those who can buy them, obviously it
- 14:17will reproduce inequality. Therefore, a
- 14:19state, a democratic society, should
- 14:21also have policies to facilitate access
- 14:23to these technologies for those who,
- 14:25through their own family resources,
- 14:27will never be able to access them.
- 14:30Which countries are more egalitarian
- 14:33and why?
- 14:34Look, I think there is a relationship.
- 14:37Inequalities tend to interact.
- 14:43Societies that are more egalitarian in
- 14:45terms of income distribution, health,
- 14:47and housing distribution are, at the
- 14:48same time, more egalitarian in terms of
- 14:50learning, right? Because inequalities
- 14:53feed back into each other. So, there
- 14:56are societies that are more egalitarian
- 14:58in economic and social terms, where the
- 15:00gap between the income of the rich and
- 15:02the income of the poorest isn't as wide
- 15:04—the income of the richest 10%versus
- 15:05the income of the poorest 10 or 20%—
- 15:07which have, let's say, a more
- 15:09egalitarian distribution of income. At
- 15:12the same time, it’s likely they also
- 15:14have a more egalitarian distribution of
- 15:16knowledge, and one knows which ones
- 15:18those are. Actually, they are, uh,
- 15:20societies like, for example, the Nordic
- 15:22countries in Northern Europe. They are
- 15:26societies where extreme poverty doesn't
- 15:28exist, where the difference between the
- 15:29highest and lowest salaries is small,
- 15:31where there is a low unemployment rate,
- 15:33and at the same time, they also have
- 15:34this equity in the development of
- 15:36skills and, uh, knowledge. In other
- 15:38words, the most egalitarian societies
- 15:40are more egalitarian in every sense.
- 15:42They are more egalitarian in the
- 15:43economy, in social matters, and in
- 15:45educational matters.
- 15:47How can we, as citizens, work to become
- 15:50a fairer society?
- 15:52I think that, first of all, I am not
- 15:54convinced that all Argentines, for
- 15:57example, agree on having a more
- 15:59egalitarian society. It's a lie that we
- 16:01all want a more egalitarian society.
- 16:03There are even ideological groups that,
- 16:05on the contrary, say that inequalities
- 16:07are important, that they legitimize
- 16:09inequalities, because they say that if
- 16:11we were all equal, then there would be
- 16:13no incentive to, for example, innovate.
- 16:16So, inequality is a positive factor
- 16:18that has positive effects. In other
- 16:20words, I'm not convinced that everyone
- 16:22wants an egalitarian society beyond
- 16:23just words, let's say. So, obviously,
- 16:25it is a result of political struggle.
- 16:27Everything ends up in politics.
- 16:28Politics is the arena where all
- 16:30contradictions are concentrated. If one
- 16:33wants a society, those of us who want a
- 16:35more egalitarian society will have to
- 16:37fight to build this egalitarian society
- 16:39. Because not everyone agrees. Not
- 16:41everyone agrees. Some even believe that
- 16:44humans are naturally unequal or that
- 16:48equality, uh, equality threatens
- 16:51freedom. There is a tension between
- 16:54equality and freedom. They give you
- 16:56those classic examples. In Cuba, they
- 16:57are all very, the income distribution
- 16:59is very egalitarian, but freedom is
- 17:02lacking. In neoliberal capitalist
- 17:05societies there is a lot of freedom,
- 17:06where you have the freedom to travel
- 17:08wherever you want. Well, you have the
- 17:10freedom to go to Miami, to go to Abu
- 17:12Dhabi, or on vacation to Europe. That
- 17:15freedom is held by both the indigenous
- 17:17person and the wealthy Latin American
- 17:19citizen, but it is a totally...what is
- 17:22freedom if there are no material
- 17:24resources to be able to exercise that
- 17:26freedom? I also...we all have the
- 17:28freedom to go to Europe. Yes. Yes, but
- 17:30who actually goes to Europe? The
- 17:32exercise of freedom requires a certain
- 17:33level of equality. We must seek a
- 17:35balance between freedom and equality.
- 17:38So, there are some who speak out, who
- 17:40adhere more to the idea of freedom, and
- 17:42others of us—I say "us" because I am
- 17:44in the progressive camp, especially in
- 17:45Latin America where we live in such
- 17:47unequal societies. I am rather
- 17:50egalitarian, a proponent of justice; I
- 17:52emphasize the value of justice more
- 17:54than the value of freedom, without
- 17:56denying it. In other words, I believe
- 17:58that all wisdom would consist in being
- 18:00able to balance justice, equality, and
- 18:02freedom.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Plática con el Prof. Emilio Tenti Fanfani con el tema Desigualdades sociales y escolares. by SNTE Nacional, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,117 words across 511 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.