PHILOSOPHY - Metaphysics: The Grandfather Paradox [HD] — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Intro music]
- 0:06- I'm Agustín Rayo,
- 0:07I'm philosophy professor at MIT,
- 0:09and today I wanna tell you about
- 0:11the grandfather paradox,
- 0:12which is a famous paradox of time travel.
- 0:16Imagine
- 0:18Bruno.
- 0:19Bruno has a grudge
- 0:20against his grandfather,
- 0:22and rightly so,
- 0:23his grandfather was a horrible man.
- 0:25Amongst many other things,
- 0:27he perpetrated this fraud
- 0:29that left millions of people in poverty.
- 0:32So there's nothing Bruno would want more
- 0:35than to kill grandfather.
- 0:38Unfortunately,
- 0:40grandfather's already dead.
- 0:42Grandfather died
- 0:43many years before Bruno was born,
- 0:47but
- 0:49that needn't stop Bruno,
- 0:51because Bruno has constructed
- 0:53a time machine
- 0:55and intends to travel to the past
- 0:57to kill grandfather
- 0:59when he was still a young man.
- 1:01In fact,
- 1:02he wants to travel back enough in time
- 1:05that he can kill grandfather
- 1:08before grandfather had any children.
- 1:11So
- 1:13picture Bruno.
- 1:14He's traveled back in time.
- 1:17He's brought a sniper's rifle with him,
- 1:20and he's trained himself to use it.
- 1:23He's been tracking grandfather's movements
- 1:26and knows exactly
- 1:28where he goes for his morning walk.
- 1:30He's found a perfect spot
- 1:32in a nearby building,
- 1:33and he has a clear shot.
- 1:35Grandfather is walking.
- 1:37He stops to tie his shoelaces.
- 1:40Bruno caresses the trigger.
- 1:42And
- 1:43what happens?
- 1:45We know
- 1:47that Bruno
- 1:48will not succeed in killing grandfather.
- 1:51Why?
- 1:52Well, I already told you
- 1:54the grandfather is Bruno's grandfather.
- 1:56And from that, it follows
- 1:59that grandfather must have lived
- 2:01long enough to have children.
- 2:03But on this story,
- 2:05Bruno has traveled to a time
- 2:07before
- 2:09the time when grandfather had children.
- 2:10So
- 2:11if Bruno were to succeed,
- 2:13grandfather would never
- 2:15have any children,
- 2:16which would contradict
- 2:18what I already told you about.
- 2:20Maybe you think that the story
- 2:21could be interpreted differently.
- 2:23Maybe you think
- 2:25that
- 2:26we can imagine a situation in which
- 2:29Bruno kills grandfather.
- 2:31As a result, the fraud never takes place.
- 2:34So Bruno travels back to the present
- 2:37and finds that everyone is much happier.
- 2:40I claim that that doesn't make any sense.
- 2:44But I think it's easy to think otherwise.
- 2:46Because there are lots of movies that tell
- 2:48stories which are kind of like that one.
- 2:49One good example of this is
- 2:52one of my favorite films, Back to the Future.
- 2:54Now, I don't know if you've seen
- 2:56Back to the Future.
- 2:57But it's very easy to give you
- 2:58a quick summary.
- 2:59So according to the film, there's this guy,
- 3:02Marty McFly,
- 3:03who has a father, George.
- 3:06And nobody respects
- 3:08George.
- 3:09But
- 3:10Marty gains access to a time machine,
- 3:13which is a specially modified DeLorean.
- 3:15He gets into the DeLorean,
- 3:18reaches a certain speed,
- 3:19there's a flash of bright light.
- 3:22And
- 3:23that allows him to travel
- 3:25to the past,
- 3:27to a time when his father was a young man.
- 3:29He interacts with his father,
- 3:30hechanges his father's character.
- 3:34And when Marty comes back
- 3:36to the future,
- 3:37he finds his father a changed man.
- 3:40He finds that now
- 3:41everybody respects his father.
- 3:43And his father
- 3:45is very, very happy.
- 3:46My colleague Brad Scow once
- 3:48taught me a wonderful way
- 3:50of seeing just why this story
- 3:52is inconsistent.
- 3:53Because look, at the beginning of the film,
- 3:56we're told that ata certain time,
- 3:581985,
- 4:00George is respected by nobody.
- 4:03And at the end of the film,
- 4:04we're told that at that very time,
- 4:07in 1985, everyone respects George.
- 4:11But look, it doesn't matter whether we're
- 4:13told one thing at the beginning of the film
- 4:16and a different thing at the end of the film,
- 4:18it's still inconsistent.
- 4:19One way to see this
- 4:20is to imagine that you're sitting on a jury.
- 4:23The witness takes the stand,
- 4:25and at the beginning of her testimony,
- 4:28she says that
- 4:29at the crucial time, she was
- 4:32buying cigarettes at the store.
- 4:34And towards the end of her testimony,
- 4:36she says that at that very same time,
- 4:40she was instead at home watching TV.
- 4:44You can tell right there that not
- 4:47everything in the witness's story is true.
- 4:51And that's because
- 4:52her story is inconsistent.
- 4:53And it doesn't help
- 4:55that part of the story was told
- 4:57at the beginning of her testimony,
- 4:58and the other part was
- 5:00told at the end of her testimony.
- 5:02The story is still inconsistent.
- 5:04I think the same
- 5:05thing happens with Back to the Future.
- 5:06Just because we're told one thing
- 5:08at the beginning of the story
- 5:09a different thing at the en of the story,
- 5:12that doesn't mean that the story
- 5:14is consistent.
- 5:16There is a different way of interpreting
- 5:18Back to the Future
- 5:19where it is a consistent story.
- 5:21It's just that on this different interpretation,
- 5:25it's not primarily a time travel story.
- 5:29It's really a story about travel
- 5:31between universes.
- 5:33On this interpretation, what happens is that
- 5:36when Marty McFly boards the DoLorean,
- 5:40what happens is not that he goes
- 5:42to the past of his own universe.
- 5:44What happens is that he
- 5:46travels to a different universe.
- 5:48In this different universe,
- 5:51he meets copies of his parents,
- 5:54interacts with them,
- 5:56and then he goes to the future of that universe
- 5:59and finds the older copies of his parents
- 6:04to be very happy and respected by all.
- 6:07Notice, however, that that's not
- 6:09the interpretation that is suggested by the movie
- 6:11because on that interpretation,
- 6:13the movie is a tragedy.
- 6:15Think of Marty's poor original
- 6:18father stuck in our universe.
- 6:21It's not only the case
- 6:22that nobody respects him.
- 6:24He was also abandoned by his son, Marty.
- 6:27In summary, I think that
- 6:29insofar as we interpret Back to the Future
- 6:32as an ordinary, bona fide time travel story,
- 6:36we have to concede that even though
- 6:38it's a great movie, it's logically inconsistent.
- 6:42Similarly, when we interpret the
- 6:44story of Bruno and his grandfather
- 6:47as an ordinary, bona fide time travel story,
- 6:50we cannot say consistently
- 6:52that grandfather is his grandfather
- 6:54and that Bruno succeeds in killing him
- 6:57at a time before he had children.
- 7:00This leaves us with a very
- 7:03tricky question.
- 7:04We know that Bruno will not succeed
- 7:07in killing grandfather
- 7:09but
- 7:11what stops him?
- 7:14Here are some different options
- 7:15for answering this question.
- 7:16One thing you could say is
- 7:20what stops him is that time travel is impossible
- 7:23so he could have never been in that position.
- 7:26Another thing you could say is that
- 7:28the universe contains a special
- 7:31anti-paradox force
- 7:33and that if Bruno
- 7:35was about to succeed in killing grandfather,
- 7:37somehow this force would
- 7:38come down and intervene.
- 7:40I think there is no need
- 7:43to go in for either of these options.
- 7:45If you ask me,
- 7:47what stops Bruno from killing grandfather,
- 7:49I say,
- 7:51I don't know,
- 7:52because you haven't finished telling the story.
- 7:54But probably what stops
- 7:55him is something quite mundane.
- 7:58In some ways of developing the story,
- 8:00it'll turn out that Bruno was
- 8:03pointing the rifle but lost his nerve
- 8:04at the very last minute.
- 8:06In other ways of spelling out
- 8:07of the story, he got distracted.
- 8:09Maybe there's a barking
- 8:10dog in the background.
- 8:11Another way of telling the story,
- 8:13he shoots but misses.
- 8:15We know that there are some
- 8:17inconsistent time travel stories.
- 8:19But that doesn't mean that
- 8:21every time travel story is inconsistent.
- 8:23There are perfectly consistent ways of
- 8:25telling the story of Bruno and his grandfather.
- 8:27And on some of these,
- 8:29there are perfectly mundane reasons
- 8:31for explaining why Bruno failed.
- 8:34It could be that time travel
- 8:37is technologically impossible.
- 8:40So it could be that it will remain
- 8:42forever beyond our reach.
- 8:44But that doesn't mean that
- 8:45time travel itself is logically inconsistent.
- 8:49In fact, I think the concept of
- 8:51time travel is perfectly consistent.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of PHILOSOPHY - Metaphysics: The Grandfather Paradox [HD] by Wireless Philosophy, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,262 words across 246 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.