Pentagon Papers at 50: Daniel Ellsberg on Risking Life in Jail to Expose U.S. Lies About Vietnam War — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00this is democracy now democracynow.org
- 0:02the quarantine report
- 0:04i'm amy goodman 50 years ago this week
- 0:07the new york times began publishing
- 0:09excerpts of the pentagon papers
- 0:127 000 pages of top secret documents
- 0:15outlining the secret history of the u.s
- 0:17war in vietnam the leak would end up
- 0:20helping take down
- 0:21president nixon help end the war in
- 0:24vietnam
- 0:25and lead to a major victory for press
- 0:28freedom
- 0:28the times expose was based on documents
- 0:31secretly photocopied
- 0:33by daniel ellsberg and anthony russo
- 0:36while they worked as pentagon
- 0:37consultants at the rand corporation
- 0:40ellsberg had been deeply involved in the
- 0:43vietnam war
- 0:44first traveling to vietnam as a pentagon
- 0:46analyst in 1964.
- 0:49but after turning against the war
- 0:51ellsberg decided to risk his life in
- 0:54prison to reveal the truth about vietnam
- 0:57the two men were charged with violating
- 0:59the espionage act of 1917
- 1:02as well as theft and conspiracy
- 1:05this is an excerpt from the 2009
- 1:08documentary
- 1:08the most dangerous man in america it
- 1:11begins
- 1:12with dan ellsberg it was the evening of
- 1:15october 1st
- 1:161969 when i first smuggled several
- 1:19hundred pages of top secret documents
- 1:22out of my safe at the rammed corporation
- 1:27the study contained 47 volumes 7
- 1:30000 pages
- 1:34my plan was to xerox the study and
- 1:36reveal the secret history of the vietnam
- 1:38war to the american people
- 1:41the fbi was trying to find out who gave
- 1:44the new york times a copy of the
- 1:46pentagon's
- 1:47secret study powell like like a
- 1:49thunderclap
- 1:50you get the new york times publishing
- 1:52the pentagon papers
- 1:53and the country is panicking
- 1:56this is an attack on the whole integrity
- 1:58of government if whole
- 2:00file cabinets can be stolen and then
- 2:02made available to the press you can't
- 2:04have orderly government anymore
- 2:06a name has now come out as the possible
- 2:08source of the times pentagon documents
- 2:11it is that of daniel ellsberg the top
- 2:13policy analyst for the defense and state
- 2:15department
- 2:16i think it is time in this country to
- 2:18quit
- 2:19making national heroes out of those
- 2:22who steal secrets and publish them in
- 2:24the newspaper
- 2:27in the first year of marriage we're
- 2:29talking about him going to prison for
- 2:30the rest of his life
- 2:39we felt so strongly that we were dealing
- 2:41with a national security crisis
- 2:43henry kissinger said that dr daniel
- 2:46ellsberg was the most dangerous man in
- 2:47america
- 2:48and he had to be stopped an excerpt from
- 2:51the most dangerous man
- 2:52in america daniel ellsberg and the
- 2:54pentagon papers
- 2:56the documentary was co-directed by
- 2:58judith erlick and rick goldsmith
- 3:00the nixon administration would go on to
- 3:02take extraordinary
- 3:04measures to silence and punish ellsberg
- 3:07including breaking into his
- 3:08psychiatrist's office
- 3:10but the government's misconduct led to
- 3:12charges
- 3:13against him and anthony russo being
- 3:16dismissed
- 3:17to mark the 50th anniversary of the
- 3:19publication of the pentagon papers
- 3:21we're joined now by daniel ellsberg who
- 3:23turned 90 years
- 3:25old in april over the past five
- 3:28decades ellsberg has been a leading
- 3:30critic of u.s militarism
- 3:32and u.s nuclear weapons policy as well
- 3:35as a
- 3:36prominent advocate for other
- 3:37whistleblowers
- 3:39oh and he hasn't stopped sharing
- 3:41government secrets
- 3:42we're going to talk about one of those
- 3:44secrets that he said
- 3:46he's willing to be prosecuted for that
- 3:48he just
- 3:49leaked but right now we go to berkeley
- 3:52california
- 3:53to the home of daniel ellsberg dan
- 3:55welcome back to democracy now this is
- 3:58such a
- 3:58significant milestone it was half a
- 4:01century ago
- 4:01sunday that the new york times started
- 4:05publishing
- 4:06the pentagon papers talk about how they
- 4:10got a hold of those papers
- 4:12and the decision you made especially for
- 4:14young people
- 4:15at what point you went from you know
- 4:18working for the pentagon going to
- 4:20vietnam being a part of the war machine
- 4:23and then turning around and saying i
- 4:25will spend the rest of my life in jail i
- 4:28have to
- 4:29to stop this
- 4:32well the first trip i made to vietnam
- 4:34amy was actually in 1961
- 4:37on a research project looking at limited
- 4:39war
- 4:40research and development it was clear in
- 4:42one week they're talking
- 4:44to counterpart military officers who
- 4:47were advising
- 4:48vietnamese and who were looking at the
- 4:49war closely and reading their reports
- 4:51that it became very clear that the war
- 4:54under a corrupt tyrannical dictator
- 4:58no denziem who had a pretense
- 5:02of elections in which he tended to win
- 5:04102 percent of the voters in
- 5:06some districts was failing
- 5:10uh against a group that was led by
- 5:13communists who had evicted the french
- 5:15from the northern part of the country
- 5:17some years earlier and had that cachet
- 5:19of liberators of the country
- 5:21from occupation and we had the us had
- 5:24artificially carved out
- 5:26a part of that country as an
- 5:28anti-communist country which we
- 5:29supported very lavishly
- 5:31uh as if for example britain had
- 5:34supported the confederacy very lavishly
- 5:37in our civil war and in fact in surprise
- 5:39supplied
- 5:40all of their uniforms their bullets
- 5:43their rations
- 5:43for everything which is what we did for
- 5:45the puppet army in south vietnam
- 5:47it was very clear then that that was an
- 5:49extremely unpromising
- 5:51place to plant the flag against
- 5:54communism or
- 5:55for imperialism in that country as in
- 5:58as uh imprudent as it had been for the
- 6:00french
- 6:01to try to reconquer that country and we
- 6:04had supported the french from 45
- 6:06on until 54 and then took over the
- 6:08burden
- 6:09of suppressing that country and
- 6:11effectively occupying it ourselves
- 6:13so i was very surprised in 61 when i
- 6:16learned that president
- 6:18uh kennedy had taken the alleged advice
- 6:22of the chairman of the joint chiefs of
- 6:24staff maxwell taylor and walt rostau a
- 6:27major policy figure that all that was
- 6:29needed
- 6:30was uh advisers that he didn't need to
- 6:32send combat troops uh and that
- 6:34progress would be made if we simply went
- 6:36through the geneva conference
- 6:38of 1954 ceiling of advisors to about 600
- 6:42went up to a thousand and maybe several
- 6:45thousand in the end there were twelve
- 6:46thousand advisors there
- 6:48but that that was enough to keep that
- 6:50country
- 6:51in our control essentially that turned
- 6:54out to be a lie
- 6:55when i read the pentagon papers years
- 6:57later that was in 61
- 7:00i was reading those documents in 67 and
- 7:02i was particularly interested to
- 7:04see what their advice had actually been
- 7:07and what it turned out was that the
- 7:08president
- 7:09had been lying and that there and they
- 7:12backed him up in lying
- 7:13and that their advice actually was that
- 7:15advisers would not
- 7:17be enough to stem the nationalist forces
- 7:20we were fighting
- 7:21and that the only possibility was to
- 7:23send troops
- 7:24immediately and indeed that those didn't
- 7:27have a lot of promise that we would do
- 7:28better than the french
- 7:29but nothing less would do the job in
- 7:32other words
- 7:33i'd been lied to the whole country had
- 7:35been lied to the congress had been lied
- 7:36to
- 7:37as to what the situation was well that
- 7:39was arc typical
- 7:41of the entire 30-year conflict which was
- 7:43really from 1945 to 75
- 7:46the recent burns novik
- 7:49piece series about the war starts with
- 7:52the statement
- 7:53that was begun by decent men with honest
- 7:56motives
- 7:57that was not true for a single day of
- 7:59that war
- 8:00however decent they may have been in
- 8:02other contexts these uh
- 8:04smart men generally as smart as we have
- 8:06today
- 8:07managed to lie to the public every day
- 8:09of the war and
- 8:10in bad faith actually pursue a war that
- 8:13they saw had very little likelihood
- 8:15of helping anyone but leading just to an
- 8:18escalating stalemate which is what
- 8:20actually happened
- 8:21for the next 20 years of the war or so
- 8:23from 60 15 years
- 8:25from 61 to 75. so when i became aware
- 8:29that that was repeating itself that
- 8:30history
- 8:31which in the pentagon papers ends in 68
- 8:35with president johnson's departure
- 8:39and now we were in 69 and i was made
- 8:41aware that president nixon was following
- 8:43exactly in the footsteps of his
- 8:45predecessors
- 8:46while telling the public in his election
- 8:48campaign and otherwise
- 8:49he was getting out and in fact he
- 8:52planned to get the us
- 8:53troops out u.s troops out slowly
- 8:57throughout his first term uh hopefully
- 9:00sooner but if necessary as it turned out
- 9:03to be
- 9:04over a matter of years and to pursue the
- 9:06war indefinitely through his
- 9:08second term in the air backing up
- 9:11president tu the
- 9:12puppet leader former general in vietnam
- 9:16and his army the army that we supported
- 9:19and managed
- 9:20with u.s air power and he virtually
- 9:22achieved that
- 9:23he almost did actually by 73
- 9:26he did get the american troops out
- 9:28people thought the war is over
- 9:30but from the point of view of bombing
- 9:32generating refugees
- 9:34torture uh deaths in vietnam
- 9:37it was going on as before and would have
- 9:39done so
- 9:40right through 1977 and later
- 9:43had not the president been forced to
- 9:45resign for acts he took
- 9:48in the process of assuring his policy
- 9:51and ensuring his staying in office
- 9:53namely he kept his own policy of
- 9:56threatening
- 9:56nuclear war even and threatening major
- 10:00escalations such as mining iphone and
- 10:02mining hanoi and bombing hanoi which he
- 10:05did do
- 10:06and going into the so-called sanctuaries
- 10:08other countries
- 10:09other sovereign countries like like laos
- 10:12and cambodia all of which
- 10:14he did do he did everything but the
- 10:15actual carrying out of nuclear weapons
- 10:17which he discussed
- 10:18at the highest levels and uh telling the
- 10:21people that he was getting out of the
- 10:22war
- 10:23all this time another big lie as we
- 10:25started with
- 10:26and i put out in 1969 to the senate
- 10:31uh and then to the newspapers in 71
- 10:34evidence that five
- 10:35previous four previous presidents had
- 10:38made similar
- 10:39lies and escalations and threats and had
- 10:42the war had gone on they preferred a
- 10:45bloody
- 10:46escalating stalemate to the humiliation
- 10:49of ending the war the only way it could
- 10:51be ended which was
- 10:53granting the southern communist-led
- 10:55forces
- 10:56a role in the government and stopping
- 10:58the bombing of the north
- 10:59but two nixon was so beholden
- 11:03to president tune win von tube that he
- 11:06had to keep him in there
- 11:07even when that was the only thing
- 11:08dividing us in keeping the war going
- 11:11in 1971 and 72. we learned much later
- 11:15the two regarded himself as having
- 11:17elected
- 11:18nixon and he was right in doing so
- 11:22uh in the last days of 1968 nixon's
- 11:25people
- 11:25at his orders which we learned many
- 11:27years later
- 11:29was telling to hold on don't negotiate
- 11:32we will give you better terms and indeed
- 11:34he had in mind giving him better terms
- 11:36and he did
- 11:37we'll keep you in power even though this
- 11:40communists are demanding as a part of
- 11:41the negotiations
- 11:43the two personally not be part of the
- 11:45elevator and that's what we were
- 11:47fighting for
- 11:48and that's what tens of thousands of
- 11:50americans
- 11:51and millions of vietnamese died to keep
- 11:54two in power as long as nixon was which
- 11:57did happen
- 11:58nixon left before two did and two left
- 12:01in 75
- 12:02it would not have happened had not nixon
- 12:06been faced
- 12:07with impeachment for the crimes he took
- 12:09to keep
- 12:10the war going and keep it hidden crimes
- 12:13mainly against me
- 12:14to keep me from putting out new
- 12:16documents that would incriminate him
- 12:18like the nuclear threats the other city
- 12:20was making and in process of that he
- 12:23burglarized my former psychoanalyst
- 12:24office
- 12:25he sent 12 cuban assets of the bay of
- 12:28pigs
- 12:28up to incapacitate me totally on the
- 12:31steps of the capital
- 12:32on may 3rd he overheard me on legal on
- 12:36illegal warrantless wiretaps when all
- 12:39this began to come out
- 12:40as a result of truth-telling by john
- 12:43dean to the prosecutors
- 12:45alex butterfield telling the truth about
- 12:48the paping of the oval office which is
- 12:49essential
- 12:51elliot richardson and ruckel's house
- 12:53refusing the president's orders to fire
- 12:55the special prosecutor
- 12:57filed president special prosecutor
- 13:00demanding the tapes
- 13:01the supreme court including three nixon
- 13:03appointees
- 13:04ruling unanimously they had to give them
- 13:06over all these steps were individually
- 13:09essential to facing the president with
- 13:12resignation or impeachment and when he
- 13:15chose resignation
- 13:16the war became endable that's why that's
- 13:19why president uh
- 13:20rather henry kissinger called me the
- 13:23most dangerous man in america because he
- 13:25feared
- 13:26i had documents documents that would
- 13:29tell the truth
- 13:30about the lies he and his boss were
- 13:32telling now
- 13:33this was even after you'd released
- 13:37the pentagon papers i want to go back to
- 13:38that documentary the most dangerous man
- 13:40in america daniellesberg and the
- 13:42pentagon papers this excerpt focusing on
- 13:44how the nixon white house
- 13:46responded to your leak it begins with
- 13:49john dean who served as white house
- 13:51counsel to president nixon
- 13:53i think that there is probably some good
- 13:55justification
- 13:57for the strong feelings nixon had he
- 13:59would make a decision
- 14:00in the national security council and the
- 14:02next day read it on the front page of
- 14:04the new york times or some other
- 14:05newspaper
- 14:06this makes it virtually impossible to
- 14:09govern
- 14:10just because some guy is going to be a
- 14:12martyr we can't be in a position
- 14:14of allowing the fellow to get away with
- 14:16this kind of wholesale thievery or
- 14:17otherwise it's going to happen all over
- 14:18the government
- 14:19i just say that we've got to keep our
- 14:21eye on the main ball the main balls
- 14:22ellsberg
- 14:23we got to get this son of a [ __ ] the
- 14:26leak of the pentagon papers changed the
- 14:29nixon white house
- 14:30it really is what some of us have called
- 14:32the beginning of the dark period
- 14:34i mean it was rough and tumble before
- 14:36but it got down and dirty
- 14:38so it's really a defining event for the
- 14:41nixon presidency
- 14:42and this is when eagle krogue bud kroge
- 14:45was selected to head up
- 14:47the so-called plumbers unit i was
- 14:50summoned to the oval office
- 14:52by the president john ehrlichman and i
- 14:54met with him
- 14:56there was some suspicion that dr
- 14:58ellsberg had
- 14:59access to the more recent war plans
- 15:02that had been developed by the nixon
- 15:04administration and would be able to
- 15:06release those documents
- 15:08i came from that meeting feeling very
- 15:10strongly that
- 15:11i was dealing with a national security
- 15:13crisis and i was to take any means
- 15:15necessary to respond to it
- 15:29the president had decided to set up a
- 15:31special investigations unit
- 15:34in the white house staff
- 15:42[Applause]
- 15:48did daniel ellsberg work alone was he
- 15:51working with some other people was it
- 15:52part of a conspiracy
- 15:54and it was in that context that a
- 15:56proposal
- 15:57was made by e howard hunt to get
- 15:59information that could be used to
- 16:01discredit dr ellsberg
- 16:03a covert operation ought to be
- 16:05undertaken to examine
- 16:07all of the files still held by dr
- 16:09ellsberg's psychiatrist
- 16:10dr lewis fielding this went to john
- 16:13ehrlichman
- 16:15underneath that proposal were two lines
- 16:17approved for the line disapprove of the
- 16:19line
- 16:20he wrote his large e after approve
- 16:23and then put in under your assurance it
- 16:25is not traceable
- 16:31and that's an excerpt from the most
- 16:33dangerous man
- 16:34in america daniel ellsberg and the
- 16:36pentagon papers the documentary
- 16:38co-directed by judith ehrlich and
- 16:41rick goldsmith also dan the new york
- 16:44times had a special
- 16:45section uh called uncovering the secret
- 16:48history of the vietnam war
- 16:50on the publication of the papers you
- 16:53leaked to them they had it yesterday
- 16:55and among the quotes they highlight
- 16:57which is
- 16:58so important is
- 17:02the contrast of what was being said
- 17:04publicly
- 17:05and what was being said privately so you
- 17:08have the war grows in secret
- 17:10in 1963 defense secretary robert
- 17:13mcnamara at a white house news
- 17:14conference says
- 17:15we were viewed in great detail the plans
- 17:18of the south vietnamese and the plans of
- 17:19our own military advisors for
- 17:21operations during 1964 we have every
- 17:24reason to believe
- 17:26they will be successful but on the same
- 17:29day december 21
- 17:311963 mcnamara said in a memo
- 17:34to president lyndon johnson the
- 17:36situation is very disturbing
- 17:38current trends unless reversed in the
- 17:40next two to three months
- 17:42will lead to a neutralization at best
- 17:44more likely a communist controlled state
- 17:46in 1964 you have johnson saying in a
- 17:49televised address we still
- 17:51seek no wider war but in the pentagon
- 17:54papers
- 17:55it says on february 1st 1964 the united
- 17:59states embarked
- 18:00on a new course of action on that date
- 18:02under direction of the american military
- 18:04establishment an elaborate program of
- 18:06covert military operations against the
- 18:08state of north vietnam
- 18:10was set in motion now i want to focus on
- 18:13your getting the pentagon papers dan
- 18:15explain what this was this is before
- 18:18kissinger and nixon were afraid you were
- 18:20going to have another leak around
- 18:22nuclear issues about the report
- 18:25in your safe that only a few people had
- 18:29and your decision to xerox them
- 18:32to include your children i think robert
- 18:35ellsberg your 13 year old child at the
- 18:37time helped you do this
- 18:39and why you decided to do this and
- 18:41include your kids
- 18:44well the great journalist i f stone
- 18:47once said all government's official
- 18:50lie and nothing they say is to be
- 18:53believed
- 18:54that doesn't mean that everything they
- 18:56say is a lie it means that anything they
- 18:58say
- 18:59may be a lie and it's never the last
- 19:02word they are always misleading
- 19:04one audience or another and you have to
- 19:07back that up use your common sense back
- 19:09it up with other sources
- 19:11nothing illustrates that better in
- 19:13writing than the pentagon papers but of
- 19:15course it's still
- 19:16true today what you're quoting uh
- 19:19could have been written about
- 19:20afghanistan and in fact it was when the
- 19:23washington post got the afghan papers a
- 19:25couple of years ago
- 19:27somewhat lower levels they illustrated
- 19:29that uh the
- 19:30act almost identical quotes have been
- 19:32saying about afghans
- 19:33during the 20-year war that we have so
- 19:36far
- 19:37experienced there and it could be
- 19:39another 20 wars
- 19:41years even with u.s troops out of the
- 19:43country as nixon got u.s troops out of
- 19:45the country
- 19:46in 73 but planned to continue the war
- 19:49with air power
- 19:50and i think also there's a plan right
- 19:52now to continue the war in afghan
- 19:54killing afghans creating refugees
- 19:58indefinitely from bases outside
- 20:00afghanistan
- 20:02but again in both cases you have people
- 20:04speaking quite reasonably and
- 20:05realistically
- 20:06inside about the lack of progress while
- 20:09outside the public is reassured
- 20:11that tax money can still be given to
- 20:13congress to be buy
- 20:14uh beans and bones and boots and troops
- 20:18for our puppet allies over there
- 20:20indefinitely
- 20:21now when i'd learned that uh year by
- 20:24year in the pentagon 64-65 and i was in
- 20:27vietnam
- 20:28from 65 to 67 it was very clear
- 20:32that these lies were persisting in the
- 20:34interests
- 20:35of keeping a war going there was always
- 20:37an alternative
- 20:38to getting higher as the joint chiefs
- 20:40tended to want
- 20:42with no real prospect of success or
- 20:44getting out
- 20:45somehow lowering the cost and the
- 20:47president chose each time not to do
- 20:50the latter not to be subject to charges
- 20:52of losing the war
- 20:53or ending it but of uh keeping it going
- 20:56with some promise of winning
- 20:58a totally illusory promise on the
- 21:01outside
- 21:02not confirmed on the inside i saw that
- 21:05no one
- 21:06i saw from reading the pentagon papers
- 21:08that the president
- 21:09had president after president had gotten
- 21:12quite realistic reports
- 21:14from people inside not from everybody
- 21:16many liars
- 21:17but a lot that were realistic enough to
- 21:19let him know that he did have the choice
- 21:22of getting out in fact he would have had
- 21:23a lot of support for doing it
- 21:25but he would have been the one who will
- 21:27born the brunt of charges that he had
- 21:29lost the war had he done what the joint
- 21:30chiefs wanted
- 21:32which was he knew correctly i think was
- 21:35very foolish which would have led to
- 21:37nuclear war with the chinese
- 21:38in the case of the vietnamese um he
- 21:41chose not to do that
- 21:42and chose instead to stalemate keep the
- 21:45war going
- 21:46so
- 21:49i saw then that it no longer paid to be
- 21:52a president's man giving him the truth
- 21:54about realities
- 21:55he had that he knew it's not a matter of
- 21:58treatment
- 21:59speaking truth to power power was
- 22:01getting the truth
- 22:02and choosing not to be the fall guy for
- 22:06hojimen city becoming saigon
- 22:09as eventually didn't happen that wasn't
- 22:11going to happen under his term
- 22:13so the only way i could see was having
- 22:15congress
- 22:16take steps in the end by the way they
- 22:18did under the extraordinary
- 22:20circumstances of
- 22:21watergate but for years that didn't seem
- 22:23very promising either
- 22:25congressman after congressman whom i
- 22:27showed these realities
- 22:29chose again to let me put it out
- 22:31eventually and not to take the risks of
- 22:33going to prison or
- 22:34condemnation of putting on i couldn't
- 22:36get anybody to put them out
- 22:38finally i mean this is a critical point
- 22:41dan uh
- 22:42talk i mean the senators who were known
- 22:44as the anti-war senators you went to
- 22:47one after another and while some
- 22:50apologetic
- 22:52just said they couldn't do it on their
- 22:53own well
- 22:55yes as frequently said just yesterday as
- 22:58i keep reading these things
- 23:00i read every other time they didn't
- 23:02accept the papers
- 23:04one of them mcgovern even said he
- 23:06couldn't accept them because they were
- 23:07illegal
- 23:09senator mcgovern who ran for president
- 23:11then that was the opposite of the truth
- 23:13of what he had actually said to me
- 23:15each one of the presidents and and
- 23:17congress persons
- 23:19fulbright mcgovern later representative
- 23:22pete mccoskey in the house
- 23:24senator matthias in the state each of
- 23:26them anti-war
- 23:28effective anti-war people within the
- 23:29congress each
- 23:31enthusiastically said they would use the
- 23:33papers
- 23:34and then and assured me that my name
- 23:36didn't have to come out and they would
- 23:38pull the constitution off the wall and
- 23:40say the speech and
- 23:41clause here i can't be questioned about
- 23:44anything i give here we won't have to
- 23:45give your name
- 23:46to each i said i prefer not to be named
- 23:49but that's not a consideration i'm
- 23:51preferred
- 23:52ready to go to jail on these things if
- 23:53there's any reason you have to call me
- 23:56uh to authenticate how you got the
- 23:57papers and so forth
- 23:59each one eventually after thinking about
- 24:02it
- 24:02turned back and looking back at it when
- 24:05neil sheehan from the times told me
- 24:07you shouldn't put it out in congress the
- 24:09way i wanted to it should only come out
- 24:11in the times and he knew we had
- 24:12some conflict about that i thought it
- 24:15should come out
- 24:16in the congress so it could get subpoena
- 24:17witnesses get people under oath
- 24:19bring witnesses against documents i
- 24:21thought it was very much preferable
- 24:23to it coming out in the newspapers first
- 24:26he on the other hand kept saying no dan
- 24:27it's got to come out in the newspapers
- 24:29and i frankly thought well he's a little
- 24:31influenced there by getting a pulitzer
- 24:33prize and so forth i wasn't
- 24:34i wasn't convinced and he was right
- 24:37actually
- 24:39later when the papers did come out both
- 24:42senator mansfield the majority leader
- 24:44senator fulbright the foreign affairs
- 24:47leader chairman
- 24:48said we now have to have hearings and i
- 24:50braced for these
- 24:52didn't happen in fact it was nixon who
- 24:55wanted hearings
- 24:56and tried to get congressman a bear to
- 24:58hold hearing because
- 25:00for the reason in both sides they did
- 25:03incriminate mainly democrats nixon
- 25:05wanted it
- 25:06even though it also made participants
- 25:08look bad
- 25:09the senators didn't want it because we
- 25:12have so much to talk about in so
- 25:14little time but i want to get to that
- 25:15point where you and
- 25:17tony rousseau your co-conspirator who
- 25:19was working at the rand corporation
- 25:21uh said let's do it and you decided to
- 25:24xerox that
- 25:267 000 page report how did you do it
- 25:29um how did you get the papers out and
- 25:32then
- 25:32the story of going underground the story
- 25:35many times but
- 25:37it involved i asked tony if he knew
- 25:39someone with a xerox machine
- 25:40his then woman friend linda sinai now
- 25:43linda resnick
- 25:44in california uh played the crucial role
- 25:47of immediately saying
- 25:48yes you can use my xerox machine i
- 25:51charged 10 cents a page
- 25:53used up all my savings at that time but
- 25:56i kept that going tony helped me for a
- 25:58number of nights and i kept on by myself
- 26:02and at first taking a suitcase or a
- 26:04briefcase rather
- 26:05out of this pentagon papers past the
- 26:07guards
- 26:08was very nerve-wracking uh all they had
- 26:11to do was ask to open that briefcase and
- 26:13i'd be
- 26:14in the soup uh but eventually god used
- 26:17to be they're not asking they they then
- 26:19didn't ask
- 26:19briefcases very much the current people
- 26:22i think don't thank me for the fact that
- 26:24they now do have to open their
- 26:26briefcases but uh we did get them out
- 26:29uh xerox all night collate stuff make
- 26:32several copies of each
- 26:34bring them back in the morning so that
- 26:36the jury couldn't be convinced in the
- 26:38end that wasn't why i did it but
- 26:40it was no significant uh deprivation of
- 26:43any
- 26:44uh owner of such information by our
- 26:47taking it was only
- 26:48overnight and i was the only person
- 26:50authorized to read it at that point
- 26:52though i was charged with conversion and
- 26:54theft actually
- 26:55so that went on for really tony
- 26:58stayed for seven or eight times then he
- 27:01was doing other things
- 27:03and i did it by myself for much of the
- 27:05next year on and off
- 27:07because i would always think there's
- 27:09very little chance this will have any
- 27:10effect
- 27:11on the war the uh it ends in 1968
- 27:14the war uh under nixon has started under
- 27:1769. i mean the report ended in 68.
- 27:21at the end of 68 and then under under
- 27:24johnson
- 27:25and then nixon was not incriminated
- 27:27directly at all in fact he's
- 27:29not mentioned in the eisenhower years a
- 27:30little oddly
- 27:32but uh so he was happy to have those out
- 27:35what he was worried about
- 27:36was what else i might put out and he had
- 27:38reason to worry about that
- 27:40that wasn't just paranoid so that he had
- 27:42to try to stop me to do it and that took
- 27:44illegal means in those days so i want to
- 27:48jump forward to 1973 because then we
- 27:50have to i want to talk about the new
- 27:52release
- 27:53uh that showed that we almost went to
- 27:55nuclear war in 1958
- 27:57but um and that was taiwan china
- 27:59particularly relevant now
- 28:01as uh biden makes his nato summit
- 28:05appearance and then goes on to meet with
- 28:07um putin
- 28:08but i just wanted to end with the trial
- 28:11in 1973 of you and tony russo
- 28:14and how it ended up in a mistrial the
- 28:16trial that could
- 28:17lead to you being in prison for life for
- 28:20treason
- 28:20as a you know just like if julian
- 28:22assange came to the united states and
- 28:24faced a trial
- 28:25but in the end talk about what happened
- 28:28what scuttled this
- 28:29well i was facing a possible 115 years
- 28:32in prison
- 28:33assange by the way faces 175
- 28:36but it comes to about the same thing
- 28:38less for me now
- 28:39at this point as i face similar charges
- 28:42because what i've done in the last month
- 28:44is exactly as indictable as anything the
- 28:47obama or trump
- 28:49or biden administration has indicted for
- 28:52in the last several months i've put out
- 28:53information
- 28:54that was clearly held continually held
- 28:57from the american people
- 28:58wrongly at a top secret level or saying
- 29:01that i've done it i've said here it is
- 29:03let's test whether criminalizing the
- 29:06release
- 29:07of any or all top-secret material or
- 29:10secret or confidential material
- 29:12no matter when that's the way the law
- 29:14the plain law
- 29:15of the law uh law exists let's test
- 29:18whether that law is constitutional
- 29:20in the us of a uh with the first
- 29:23amendment other countries have the law
- 29:25including britain they don't have the
- 29:27first amendment
- 29:28and by strong means if the supreme court
- 29:31were the first time
- 29:33to address this issue it's very hard for
- 29:35them to find
- 29:36that broad sweeping word
- 29:40of the first amendment we're going to
- 29:42get to that but the trial
- 29:43how it ended up how it ended up in
- 29:46america well they ended up
- 29:47first of all because the
- 29:50[Music]
- 29:52gene john dean revealed to the
- 29:54prosecutors on april 17th
- 29:57almost the day that the president had
- 29:58returned to bombing of north vietnam it
- 30:01sent the order out
- 30:02he then gets the word that john dean has
- 30:04revealed to break into my former
- 30:06psychoanalyst's office and uh obviously
- 30:09illegal at that time although now after
- 30:129 11
- 30:13it might be illegal but then illegal
- 30:16then word of illegal wiretappings came
- 30:19out
- 30:20overhearing of me which they'd been
- 30:21denying for two years
- 30:23eventually the word that the president
- 30:27the judge himself judge matthew byrne
- 30:29had been offered
- 30:30during the trial by the president and
- 30:33then by
- 30:34john ehrlichman had been offered the
- 30:36post of the fbi directorship which was
- 30:38in a
- 30:39transition state at that point something
- 30:41he'd wanted all his life
- 30:43when we learned that afterwards it
- 30:44really meant i was going to lose
- 30:47he was not going to get that job if i
- 30:49was acquitted on 12
- 30:50felony counts so he would have given
- 30:52instructions that would have
- 30:53hung me up for some years to say the
- 30:55least when that came out we moved for a
- 30:57mistrial but he turned it down saying
- 30:59that hadn't influenced him at all
- 31:01rather foolishly
- 31:04but the trial went on and uh other
- 31:07things came out the
- 31:08illegal wiretapping they couldn't find
- 31:10the taps
- 31:12uh the triggers of the illegal
- 31:13wiretapping of me
- 31:15because the president had removed them
- 31:17from
- 31:18j edgar hoover's private files to white
- 31:21house files where they couldn't be
- 31:22gotten so they denied that there were
- 31:24such
- 31:24tapes they were afraid correctly that
- 31:27truman would
- 31:28hoover would use these illegal acts
- 31:30ordered by the white house
- 31:32to blackmail the white house and to let
- 31:34hoover stay
- 31:35so when the president when i'm sorry to
- 31:37keep saying that when the judge
- 31:39said okay overall pattern of events here
- 31:43offends
- 31:43a sense of justice bizarre circumstances
- 31:48and he dismissed all charges with
- 31:50prejudice meaning we couldn't be tried
- 31:52again
- 31:53that was the first time i think the
- 31:54federal trial had been
- 31:56dismissed just before it went to the
- 31:57jury on such grounds
- 32:01dan ellsberg pentagon papers
- 32:03whistleblower extraordinaire
- 32:05author of the doomsday machine
- 32:07confessions of nuclear war planner and
- 32:09secrets in memoir vietnam and the
- 32:10pentagon papers when we come back
- 32:12we look at the latest leak that's right
- 32:16a secret document he exposed showing the
- 32:18u.s considered attacking china with a
- 32:20nuclear weapon in 1958
- 32:22he's willing to go to jail for the
- 32:24latest leak stay with us
- 32:33you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Pentagon Papers at 50: Daniel Ellsberg on Risking Life in Jail to Expose U.S. Lies About Vietnam War by Democracy Now!, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,162 words across 931 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.