Overcome Addictions and Obsessions of All Kinds | Dr. Anna Lembke — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00In the severest cases of addiction,
- 0:03people are not actually addicted to that
- 0:06substance or that behavior. What they're
- 0:10addicted to is control. Through my
- 0:14addictive behaviors, I can create this
- 0:17world within a world where my focus
- 0:20narrows. I everything else falls away.
- 0:22I've simplified things. I just have this
- 0:24one lever like a rat in a cage. And as
- 0:27long as I can press that lever, I know I
- 0:30can change the way that I feel.
- 0:33>> Welcome to the Huberman Lab podcast,
- 0:35where we discuss science and
- 0:36science-based [music] tools for everyday
- 0:38life.
- 0:42I'm Andrew Huberman and I'm a professor
- 0:44of neurobiology and opthalmology at
- 0:46Stanford School of Medicine. My guest
- 0:48today is Dr. Anna LMK. Dr. Dr. Anna LMK
- 0:51is the director of the dual diagnosis
- 0:53addiction clinic at Stanford University
- 0:55School of Medicine and one of the
- 0:56world's leading experts in addiction,
- 0:58dopamine dynamics in the human brain,
- 1:00and how dopamine and other
- 1:02neurochemicals in the brain govern
- 1:03risk-taking, reward, and healthy versus
- 1:06unhealthy pursuits. Today, we discuss
- 1:08the latest science of addiction and
- 1:10dopamine dynamics, and what Dr. Lumpky
- 1:12herself has observed clinically in terms
- 1:14of the different kinds of addictions out
- 1:16in the world and how people can
- 1:17successfully overcome each of them. We
- 1:20also discussed her new book, Radical
- 1:21Surrender, which I can tell you because
- 1:23I've read it, is an absolutely
- 1:25fascinating and actionable exploration
- 1:27into how giving up our attempt to
- 1:29control certain things actually allows
- 1:31our brain to access new strategies to
- 1:33overcome major challenges, including
- 1:35addiction, as well as codependency, and
- 1:38altogether live healthier, better lives.
- 1:40Most people are aware of what dopamine
- 1:42is and how it can work for better or for
- 1:44worse, as well as what addiction is and
- 1:46the various ways that people strive to
- 1:48overcome addiction. Dr. Anna LMK's
- 1:50perspective on these topics is uniquely
- 1:52different, actionable, and today you're
- 1:54going to learn about all of it. Before
- 1:56we begin, I'd like to emphasize that
- 1:58this podcast is separate from my
- 1:59teaching and research roles at Stanford.
- 2:01It is, however, part of my desire and
- 2:03effort to bring zero cost to consumer
- 2:04information about science and science
- 2:06related tools to the general public. In
- 2:08keeping with that theme, today's episode
- 2:10does include sponsors. And now for my
- 2:13conversation with Dr. Anna LMK. Dr. Anna
- 2:16LMK, welcome.
- 2:17>> Good to see you again, Andrew.
- 2:19>> Great to have you back. Your book,
- 2:20Dopamine Nation, and many things that
- 2:23you were saying in and around that book
- 2:26have become true. So, I want to start
- 2:28off by saying thank you. You were right.
- 2:32Most of the world is addicted to the
- 2:35internet in some form, social media. you
- 2:37were calling this and I think now
- 2:41roughly 8 years out from heavy use of
- 2:44social media I think almost everybody
- 2:46can say they have to do some sort of
- 2:49active distancing from screens from
- 2:53phones in order to recapture some
- 2:57semblance of a healthy life so you saw
- 3:00that train coming next
- 3:03>> yeah yeah I mean I think there has been
- 3:06a big change just in terms of awareness,
- 3:09not not unfortunately in terms of our
- 3:10behaviors. If if anything, the medium
- 3:13has become even more compulsively
- 3:15reinforcing. We're all struggling, but
- 3:18certainly in terms of the conversation,
- 3:21the awareness of potential harms, the
- 3:23addictive nature of the devices and the
- 3:26medium itself, I think there is a lot
- 3:28more awareness now, and that's good.
- 3:29>> Are you seeing this clinically? Are are
- 3:31people coming in specifically with the
- 3:34issue I can't unplug from whatever it
- 3:38is, Instagram, X, Reddit, YouTube, media
- 3:42more generally.
- 3:43>> Yep. So, they're bringing themselves in
- 3:45or um very often parents are bringing
- 3:48adolescents in. Our adolescent clinic
- 3:51now about 50% of the referrals are for
- 3:54digital media addiction in some form.
- 3:5750% of the referrals at this point for
- 3:59our adolescent clinic. Huge problem.
- 4:02>> Does it look like classic addiction? And
- 4:05maybe we could define or if you would
- 4:07define that again for us.
- 4:09>> Yes. So, so addiction broadly defined is
- 4:11the continued compulsive use of a
- 4:13substance or a behavior despite harm to
- 4:17self and or others. Sometimes that's a
- 4:19harm that we can see. Sometimes it's a
- 4:21harm that we don't see but others see.
- 4:23Um we look for the four C's. out of
- 4:25control use, compulsive use, craving,
- 4:27and continued use despite consequences.
- 4:30We also look for tolerance, needing more
- 4:32of the drug over time to get the same
- 4:33effect, and also withdrawal, finding
- 4:35that we're experiencing a painful
- 4:37physiologic response to stopping or
- 4:40cutting back.
- 4:41>> What's so unique about social media and
- 4:45online addiction is that it's often
- 4:48woven into vocation, social connection.
- 4:52Yes,
- 4:53>> we could draw some parallels like
- 4:55alcohol when I was growing up. There
- 4:57were like there was like happy hour,
- 4:59people with social lubricant. So, you
- 5:01could go to a party and not drink and
- 5:04get some of the experience but not all
- 5:05the experience. Now, that's different
- 5:07with fewer people drinking. Yes. But
- 5:09with digital addictions, it's almost
- 5:12like the opt out can seem or perhaps
- 5:14it's pretty bleak to people like who
- 5:16else who are you going to talk to and
- 5:18how?
- 5:18>> Yeah. And I think this is a a central
- 5:21part of the problem that it's not just
- 5:23an individual problem. It is a
- 5:25collective problem. It's one thing to
- 5:27tell your kid to get off of their device
- 5:28and go outside and play hide-and-seek,
- 5:30but if there's no other kids out there,
- 5:32it's hard to get a game together. So, I
- 5:34think looking at it as something akin
- 5:37to, let's say, pollution, right? We
- 5:40can't we're not going to solve the
- 5:41pollution problem by just having
- 5:43everybody try to use cloth rather than
- 5:45plastic bags. Although we could try to
- 5:47do that and that would be a good thing.
- 5:49We also need top-down guard rails like
- 5:52controlling the amount of waste that
- 5:53people can dump into rivers and oceans
- 5:55and into the air and and all of that
- 5:57stuff. And I think we're going to have
- 5:59to conceptualize digital media
- 6:01similarly. Like we as individuals have
- 6:03agency and need to exercise that agency,
- 6:06but we also need governments, schools,
- 6:08corporations that make and profit from
- 6:10these digital devices to really come to
- 6:12the table and help us help ourselves as
- 6:14we recognize the initification. You've
- 6:17probably heard that term of technology
- 6:20where first the product adds value, but
- 6:23as time goes on, it's engineered to
- 6:25actually exploit value from the user as
- 6:29the corporations get richer and richer.
- 6:31This is a a process called
- 6:32inshitification of technology. I can't
- 6:34remember the the name of the guy. Maybe
- 6:35someone can look it up and I can sound
- 6:37like I remember his name, but it's it's
- 6:39a great term because it is sort of the
- 6:40progression that you see in a lot of
- 6:42digital media products.
- 6:43>> Take us back to the circuitry, the brain
- 6:46circuitry that underlies uh these and
- 6:48all forms of addiction. If you could
- 6:50tell us about dopamine and the circuitry
- 6:52and what's involved in resetting the
- 6:55circuitry.
- 6:56>> So, dopamine is a neurotransmitter.
- 6:58Neurotransmitters are molecules that we
- 7:01make in our brains that allow for
- 7:02fine-tuned control of the electrical
- 7:04circuits. Our brain is basically a
- 7:06bundle of wires. Those are the neurons,
- 7:08but they don't actually connect end to
- 7:09end. There's a spa a gap or a space
- 7:11between them. That gap is called the
- 7:13syninnapse. And dopamine is a
- 7:15neurotransmitter that bridges that gap
- 7:18being released from the presinaptic
- 7:19neuron binding to a receptor on the
- 7:21outside of the post synaptic neuron and
- 7:23then controlling those electrical
- 7:25circuits. Dopamine has many different
- 7:27functions in the brain, but one of its
- 7:29primary functions is in reward and
- 7:31reinforcement.
- 7:33Very broadly speaking, the more dopamine
- 7:35that's released in the dedicated part of
- 7:37the reward pathway in the brain. And the
- 7:39faster that dopamine is released, the
- 7:41more likely we are to experience that
- 7:43substance or behavior as reinforcing and
- 7:46usually pleasurable when it's, you know,
- 7:48in concert with the other symphony of
- 7:51neurom modulators like indogenous
- 7:52opioids, indogenous canabonoids, etc.
- 7:55For example, in mice and rats, chocolate
- 7:59increases, dopamine firing 55% above
- 8:02baseline. Sex is 100%, nicotine is 150%
- 8:06all the way up until methamphetamines,
- 8:07which is a th000%. Which is why I like
- 8:09to say that's why we first have dinner,
- 8:11then have sex, then have a cigarette.
- 8:14>> [laughter]
- 8:15>> Um, and [clears throat and snorts]
- 8:17even though the data you just uh cited
- 8:19are from rodents, can we assume that
- 8:22parallel kind of scaling of dopamine
- 8:24with different um behaviors and and
- 8:26substances is also occurring in humans?
- 8:28>> Yes, we can. I mean, it's not an exact
- 8:31one to one and it's much harder to me
- 8:32measure absolute dopamine levels in
- 8:34humans than it is in rats. In rats, you
- 8:36can put a probe right in the nucleus
- 8:37cumbent, measure dopamine levels um
- 8:39directly. You know, we're not doing that
- 8:41in humans. It's usually relative
- 8:43comparisons, but there are there are
- 8:45ways to to measure dopamine levels, but
- 8:47the idea is the same that the more
- 8:49dopamine that's released, the faster
- 8:50that it's released in that dedicated
- 8:52reward pathway, the more likely that
- 8:54substance or behavior is to be
- 8:55reinforcing. And we know that things
- 8:58like social media, gambling, sex
- 9:00activate the same reward pathway as
- 9:02drugs and alcohol.
- 9:04>> I'd like to take a quick break to
- 9:05acknowledge our sponsor, Lingo by
- 9:07Abbott. I recently learned that more
- 9:10than one in three US adults have
- 9:11pre-diabetes. Yet, most of them don't
- 9:13realize this. One reason for that is
- 9:15that it's easy to assume that we're
- 9:17doing the right things, eating the right
- 9:18foods, getting movement throughout the
- 9:20day, but it's very difficult to know how
- 9:22that translates to better glucose
- 9:24regulation. That's one of the many
- 9:26reasons why I love Lingo, which captures
- 9:28and interprets your glucose data,
- 9:29helping you to make more informed,
- 9:31personalized decisions about your
- 9:33health. Lingo is an everyday wearable
- 9:35that tracks your glucose 247 so you can
- 9:37see what works for you. Lingo shows you
- 9:40how factors like specific foods,
- 9:42activity, sleep, and stress affect your
- 9:44glucose. Understanding your unique
- 9:46responses to these can help you to build
- 9:48habits that work to improve your health.
- 9:50I personally have used Lingo, and for
- 9:52me, it's an invaluable tool for
- 9:54improving my metabolic health. If you'd
- 9:56like to try Lingo, Huberman Lab
- 9:58listeners in the US and UK can save 10%
- 10:00on a four-week plan. Just visit
- 10:03hellolingo.com/huberman
- 10:05for more information. Terms and
- 10:07conditions apply. Again, that's
- 10:09hellingo.com/huberman.
- 10:12Today's episode is also brought to us by
- 10:14Helix Sleep. Helix Sleep makes
- 10:16mattresses and pillows that are
- 10:18customized to your unique sleep needs.
- 10:20Now, I've spoken many times before on
- 10:22this and on other podcasts about the
- 10:24fact that getting a great night's sleep
- 10:26is the foundation of mental health,
- 10:28physical health, and performance. Now,
- 10:30the mattress you sleep on makes a huge
- 10:32difference in the quality of sleep that
- 10:33you get each night. How soft it is or
- 10:36how firm it is all play into your
- 10:37comfort and need to be tailored to your
- 10:40unique sleep needs. If you go to the
- 10:42Helix website, you can take a brief
- 10:43two-minute quiz and it will ask you
- 10:45questions such as, "Do you sleep on your
- 10:47back, your side, or your stomach, maybe
- 10:48you know, maybe you don't. Do you tend
- 10:50to run hot or cold during the night?"
- 10:51Things of that sort. You answer those
- 10:53questions and Helix will match you to
- 10:55the ideal mattress for you. For me, that
- 10:57turned out to be the Dusk Dusk mattress.
- 11:00I've been sleeping on a Dusk mattress
- 11:02for more than four years now, and it's
- 11:04been far and away the best sleep that
- 11:06I've ever had. If you'd like to try
- 11:08Helix, you can go to
- 11:09helixleep.com/huberman.
- 11:12Take that 2-minute sleep quiz, and Helix
- 11:14will match you to a mattress that's
- 11:15customized for you. Right now, Helix is
- 11:18giving up to 27% off their entire site.
- 11:21Again, that's helixleep.com/huberman
- 11:24to get up to 27% off.
- 11:27So, if somebody engages in a behavior or
- 11:31takes a substance and is like, I love
- 11:34this,
- 11:36you've talked before about there being a
- 11:38a a sort of um inverse of that um that
- 11:41takes place as that experience wears
- 11:43off. It doesn't necessarily, you know,
- 11:46cast them forward just feeling much
- 11:48better about everything in life. What do
- 11:50we know about the circuitry underlying
- 11:51that? One of the most important
- 11:53processes to understand in order to
- 11:55appreciate what happens in the brain as
- 11:57we go from recreational use of an
- 11:59intoxicant to maladaptive addictive use
- 12:02is to understand this concept of
- 12:03homeostasis. Homeostasis is a limited
- 12:06number of conditions that the organism
- 12:08needs to remain within in order to
- 12:11survive. And the metaphor that I like to
- 12:13use for that is to imagine that in your
- 12:15reward pathway there's a scale or
- 12:18something like a balance um a beam on a
- 12:20central fulcrum. And when it's at rest,
- 12:23that's baseline homeostasis.
- 12:25Pleasure and pain very simply work uh at
- 12:29like opposite sides of a balance. When
- 12:31we experience pleasure, it tips one way,
- 12:33pain, it tips the other. And the rules
- 12:36governing that that this balance begin
- 12:38with the primary rule that the the
- 12:40balance wants to restore homeostasis
- 12:43such that with any deviation from
- 12:45neutrality, our brains will work very
- 12:47hard to get back to that level balance.
- 12:49And the way our brains do that is what
- 12:52happens that makes us vulnerable to
- 12:54addiction. So for example, if uh if I do
- 12:57something pleasurable, which for me is
- 12:59like I don't know, watching celebrity
- 13:02gossip videos and eating chocolate that
- 13:04releases dopamine in my reward pathway,
- 13:06my pleasure pain balance tilts to the
- 13:08side of pleasure. No sooner has that
- 13:10happened than my brain's going to work
- 13:11to restore level balance. I like to
- 13:13imagine that as these neuro adaptation
- 13:15gremlins hopping on the pain side of the
- 13:17balance to bring it level again. But the
- 13:19gremlins like it on the balance. So they
- 13:21don't get off as soon as it's level.
- 13:22They stay on until I'm tilted an equal
- 13:24and opposite amount to the side of pain.
- 13:26That's the come down, the hangover, or
- 13:29just that moment of craving, right?
- 13:30Wanting to watch one more video even
- 13:32though I told myself that I wouldn't.
- 13:34Now, if I manage to resist the urge uh
- 13:37and I stop watching videos, then the
- 13:39gremlins get the message that their job
- 13:41is done. They hop off and homeostasis is
- 13:44restored.
- 13:45But if I continue to consume my drug of
- 13:47choice over days to weeks to months to
- 13:49years, those gremlins multiply. They get
- 13:51bigger. They get stronger. They're
- 13:53lifting weights. And eventually they end
- 13:55up camped out on the pain side of the
- 13:58balance. And now I've changed my
- 14:00hideonic or joy set point. I need more
- 14:04of my drug in more potent forms, not to
- 14:06get high and feel good, but just to
- 14:09level the balance and feel normal. And
- 14:11when I'm not using, I'm walking around
- 14:13with a pleasure pain balance tilted to
- 14:15the side of pain, experiencing the
- 14:18universal symptoms of withdrawal from
- 14:20any addictive substance or behavior,
- 14:21which are anxiety, irritability,
- 14:24insomnia, depression, and craving. And
- 14:28this is why so many people will relapse
- 14:30even though they can see that their
- 14:32lives are better when they're not using.
- 14:33It's because their brains aren't
- 14:34necessarily better. They're in a chronic
- 14:37reward deficit state. It's also why many
- 14:40people think that the reason they use
- 14:43their drug of choice is to self-medicate
- 14:45anxiety or depression because withdrawal
- 14:48mediated symptoms include anxiety and
- 14:50depression. And when they use their drug
- 14:52of choice, they do feel better
- 14:54temporarily because it restores
- 14:56homeostasis.
- 14:58But in the end game, all they're doing
- 15:00is adding more gremlins to the pain side
- 15:01of the balance and digging themselves
- 15:03deeper into that reward deficit hole.
- 15:06And that really is important to
- 15:08understand because it informs how we
- 15:10treat addiction. What we need to do to
- 15:13treat addiction first and foremost is to
- 15:16restore a level balance or get folks
- 15:18back to homeostasis. We can do that in
- 15:21in one of two ways. They can abstain for
- 15:23long enough for those gremlins to get
- 15:26the message they need to hop off and for
- 15:27homeostasis to be restored. And for most
- 15:31substances and most people, that means
- 15:3310 to 14 days of acute withdrawal where
- 15:35you feel like it's never going to get
- 15:37any better. There's no light at the end
- 15:38of the tunnel. But usually by weeks
- 15:40three or weeks four, about 80% of folks
- 15:42will report starting to feel
- 15:44significantly better. The other way to
- 15:46restore homeostasis is to give folks a
- 15:48medication that we can actually put on
- 15:50the pleasure side of the balance that
- 15:52has a long enough half-life that it
- 15:54doesn't induce this sort of uh cycle of
- 15:57accumulating these gremlins. And that's
- 15:59things like buprenorphine or methadone
- 16:01to treat opioid addiction.
- 16:03>> I realize the answer to the question I'm
- 16:04about to ask doesn't really exist in the
- 16:07mechanistic neurobiological literature,
- 16:09but clinically speaking, I'm curious how
- 16:11the following scenario might work.
- 16:13>> So, somebody is addicted to cocaine or
- 16:16to gambling or to sex or to online
- 16:20behavior and they come into your clinic
- 16:22and they say, "My life is really
- 16:25challenged because of this." and you
- 16:27say, "Okay, you're going to need to
- 16:28abstain and we're going to need to give
- 16:31you some other supports in that time.
- 16:33Social connection, you know, somebody
- 16:36else in the sobriety community, maybe
- 16:38you think about what led you to this,
- 16:40etc., etc." Right?
- 16:41>> That all seems great, but it also seems
- 16:44problematic based on the model you
- 16:46described because some of those things
- 16:48are also going to give some dopamine
- 16:49reward. Maybe the person also says,
- 16:51"Listen, I can abstain from high potency
- 16:53THC edibles and online behavior, but I
- 16:56need nicotine. I need the nicotine or
- 16:59I'm going to start the nicotine to kind
- 17:00of get me over the bump."
- 17:01>> Right. Right.
- 17:02>> Nicotine tickles this dopamine pathway.
- 17:04It puts, you know, some some weight on
- 17:06that side of the scale, so to speak. So
- 17:09the question is, if somebody's trying to
- 17:11get away from a certain unhealthy
- 17:13addictive behavior, do they need to
- 17:15abstain from other dopamine-inducing
- 17:17behaviors, even if they aren't
- 17:19life-threatening, career-threatening,
- 17:21even if they aren't currently addicted
- 17:22to them?
- 17:23>> Right? So great, great question. Let me
- 17:25back up a little bit and just say, so if
- 17:26somebody comes in and they says they
- 17:28say, "I'm addicted to X, Y, or Z." The
- 17:30first thing out of the gate is not,
- 17:31"Okay, you need to abstain from that."
- 17:32So, so just to make it very clear, we we
- 17:35establish a therapeutic alliance. We
- 17:38discuss, you know, their use, the impact
- 17:40that it's had on their lives. We talk
- 17:42about uh, you know, some of the basic
- 17:44neurobiology and then we sort of find
- 17:47out where they are and what their
- 17:49motivation and their degree of
- 17:50confidence. So, just want to say that
- 17:51and and in our outpatient setting, if
- 17:53someone had repeatedly tried to quit on
- 17:55their own and been unable to, we we
- 17:56wouldn't just say, "Well, try again." we
- 17:59would say, "Hey, maybe you need a higher
- 18:00level of care, something like an
- 18:01intensive outpatient treatment or maybe
- 18:03a residential treatment." So, just to,
- 18:06you know, make sure that your listeners
- 18:07know, like these are nuanced
- 18:09conversations, but to get to your point,
- 18:12all reinforcing substances and behaviors
- 18:15do work on the same final common
- 18:17pathway. And dopamine has become a kind
- 18:19of common currency for measuring the
- 18:21addictive potential of many different
- 18:23substances and behaviors. They all have
- 18:25their own unique chemical cascade, but
- 18:27they all ultimately will release
- 18:28dopamine in the nucleiocumbent. Now,
- 18:31clinically speaking,
- 18:33you would think that if somebody was
- 18:35using nicotine, alcohol, and cannabis
- 18:38and was just willing to give up one of
- 18:40those that it wouldn't have like a
- 18:43restorative impact because you've got
- 18:45the other things going on. But it turns
- 18:46out clinically what we see is even if
- 18:50they're only willing to give up let's
- 18:51say nicotine which is a common scenario
- 18:53like you know I'm not going to give up
- 18:54my cannabis but I want to stop nicotine
- 18:56products as long as they don't replace
- 18:58it with something else or escalate their
- 19:00cannabis use or escalate their alcohol
- 19:02use or start you know uh compulsively
- 19:05watching pornography or what have you.
- 19:07As long as they really just remove that
- 19:10thing we see improvements.
- 19:13>> We see improvements. So there there is
- 19:15this sort of fine-tuning that goes on
- 19:17and we will totally meet patients where
- 19:19they are and say hey what are you
- 19:20motivated to tackle what's the most
- 19:23problematic in your life. Now where we
- 19:26will make exceptions to this is number
- 19:28one if a patient just wants to give them
- 19:30all up at once which we sometimes see
- 19:32and there's data to support doing that.
- 19:34So for example, there are studies
- 19:36showing that for people who are addicted
- 19:38to alcohol and nicotine products who
- 19:41give up both at the same time compared
- 19:43to people who just give up alcohol but
- 19:46keep smoking. If you follow them
- 19:48prospectively, the people who gave up
- 19:50both at the same time tend to have
- 19:52better outcomes, which is, you know,
- 19:55makes sense from like the neuroscience
- 19:57perspective, right? because you're now
- 19:59not constantly pinging your reward
- 20:01pathway with any really potent
- 20:03intoxicant. So, we will ask people to
- 20:07give up more than one substance if
- 20:09they're obviously paired. So, for
- 20:11example, if drinking coffee is almost
- 20:14always followed by craving for a
- 20:16cigarette, then we might ask them to
- 20:17give up caffeine and the cigarettes, you
- 20:21know, for this period of time. The other
- 20:22thing is that we introduce it really as
- 20:24an experiment. We invite them to be the
- 20:26scientists in their own lives and to
- 20:28give it up for 30 days, not a lifetime.
- 20:31Why 30 days? Because on average, that is
- 20:34the amount of time it takes to begin to
- 20:36reset reward pathways.
- 20:37>> Yeah. What I'm trying to understand, I
- 20:39think many people ask me about this, is
- 20:42if I'm trying to move away from a
- 20:45particular compulsive or addictive
- 20:46behavior, what do I need to be mindful
- 20:49about in other areas of my life? Now,
- 20:52some of that's obvious, right? work,
- 20:54social connection, sleep, exercise, all
- 20:56of these things we know are healthy. We
- 20:57should continue to do those as much as
- 20:59possible, but replacement behaviors in
- 21:02my completely naive uh clinical
- 21:05expertise because I have none truly
- 21:07[laughter]
- 21:08um is very common. Like you go to a
- 21:1012step meeting, uh let's just say used
- 21:12to see a lot of smoking, now you see a
- 21:14lot of uh oral nicotine use. You see a
- 21:16lot of tattoos. You see a lot. Now,
- 21:18there's some other things going on
- 21:19there, but there's this idea that
- 21:22everybody is going to be addicted to
- 21:23something, and you just need to
- 21:25carefully pick your something.
- 21:26>> Recovery is going to be something
- 21:28different for everybody.
- 21:30>> The philosophy in 12step recovery is
- 21:34that even if you abstain from all the
- 21:36intoxicants, you're not really in
- 21:38recovery if you're not practicing a
- 21:41values-based life, if you're not
- 21:43following the 12 steps. There's this
- 21:45whole notion of the dry drunk where you
- 21:48may not be using any intoxicants at all
- 21:50and be completely abstinent and yet if
- 21:53you are still enacting your sort of
- 21:56narcissistic pathology then you're not
- 21:59in recovery. So that's a very let's say
- 22:02like philosophical and spiritual
- 22:04definition of addiction. And so yes, I
- 22:07mean the dopamine nation is all about
- 22:09the that we live in a drug world that
- 22:12almost everything has become more
- 22:14accessible, more reinforcing, more more
- 22:16plentiful, you know, making us all more
- 22:18vulnerable to the problem of addiction.
- 22:19But I still think the aspiration is not
- 22:22just to move from, you know, one
- 22:23addiction to another, although that's
- 22:25very common, this whack-a-ole problem,
- 22:27but really to kind of get at those core
- 22:31behaviors that drive compulsive reuse
- 22:34and try to get ourselves out of that
- 22:38addiction vortex. So, you know, the the
- 22:40dopamine fast or the 30 days of
- 22:42abstinence, you know, or the stopping
- 22:45using substances is really just the
- 22:47first step. I mean recovery is
- 22:49ultimately about so much more than that
- 22:52and it really is a biocschyosocial
- 22:55spiritual disease and so we have to
- 22:57intervene at all those levels if our
- 23:01circuitry is primed for this like we we
- 23:04we're in a world that's filled uh with
- 23:06things that can easily tap into these
- 23:09dopamine reward and motivation
- 23:11circuitries that we really are all
- 23:14walking around sort of lured to this or
- 23:17to that and that people find their
- 23:19thing. It's just a question whether or
- 23:20not you can find something that's not
- 23:21detrimental to self or others. Like now
- 23:23you can gamble online so easily.
- 23:26Pornography is readily accessible. Um
- 23:29social media is socially acceptable and
- 23:31it's become the main frame for um
- 23:34interaction among humans at least a
- 23:36certain generation of humans. So how are
- 23:39we supposed to navigate in this world?
- 23:41Uh given that the circuitry is within
- 23:44us, there's no escaping that. the lures
- 23:46are everywhere and in some sense the
- 23:49algorithms and just our our deficits in
- 23:52life as as well as what we're drawn to
- 23:55um basically set us up to engage in
- 23:57things until they become too much. I
- 23:59mean is is [snorts] this part of
- 24:00everybody's life arc to figure out what
- 24:01your trip wire is and then get over it
- 24:03and then that's the is this part of the
- 24:05hero's journey?
- 24:06>> I think we are all struggling with some
- 24:08form of compuls over overconumption in
- 24:10the modern age because everything has
- 24:12been drugified. I mean, I've called it
- 24:15the the modern plague. I've called
- 24:16addiction the modern plague. And I think
- 24:18that's accurate. I think if you look in
- 24:20the foreseeable future, you know, 50,
- 24:23100, 500 years, we're living in a world
- 24:27of plenty. Um, more and more machines
- 24:30will be doing our work. People will
- 24:32progressively have more leisure time,
- 24:34more disposable income, more access to
- 24:36luxury goods, even for the poorest of
- 24:38the poor. And so, the question then
- 24:40becomes, what do we do with ourselves?
- 24:42And the hope had always been that we
- 24:44would sit around and have deep
- 24:45philosophical discussions and clean up,
- 24:48you know, the garbage in the planet and
- 24:50help each other, but it looks like we're
- 24:51mostly just um, you know, masturbating
- 24:54to images online. Um, some version of
- 24:57that. So, it it's a it's a very
- 25:00important question, you know, beyond the
- 25:02question of just the mechanics of early
- 25:05recovery and abstaining sort of what
- 25:07what then? What then? And it is why I
- 25:11think this spiritual element in
- 25:12particular is so important. First of
- 25:15all, there are many people with severe
- 25:17addiction for whom the spiritual
- 25:20transformation was the only way that
- 25:23they were able to get into recovery.
- 25:25Without that piece, it would have been
- 25:26impossible for them. And I think many
- 25:29humans are dealing with uh the problems
- 25:32that people with addiction are are
- 25:34dealing with. you know, um, as my friend
- 25:36Kent Stunnington has said that people
- 25:39with addiction are are modern-day
- 25:41prophets because they show us who we
- 25:43really are. And I would add to that that
- 25:45people with addiction who can get into
- 25:47recovery in this world really do have a
- 25:50wisdom that we could all learn from
- 25:51because we are living in a drug world.
- 25:53And this is again where I think this the
- 25:55spiritual piece. However we define that
- 25:58pathway, you know, in 12 steps, it's the
- 26:01the essence of it really is
- 26:03acknowledging that we don't have control
- 26:06uh over our addictive behaviors and many
- 26:09other things. Conceiving of a power
- 26:12greater than ourselves, however you
- 26:14define it, as long as it's not you. And
- 26:17then finally, you know, being willing to
- 26:19give our will over to that power in the
- 26:21hopes of uh being restored to sanity.
- 26:24And I really like that phrasing because
- 26:26it suggests that we were once sane and
- 26:28that we can be restored to being sane
- 26:31and that that's part of the journey. So
- 26:33I do think that that sort of deeper
- 26:35meaning and purpose and the spiritual
- 26:37pivot is is really essential.
- 26:40>> Want to talk about your new book, A
- 26:42Radical Surrender, and I want to talk
- 26:44about the spirituality piece. But before
- 26:46I do that, I I want to just um ask your
- 26:49opinion about two areas uh related to
- 26:52addiction that we see a lot of uh
- 26:54online. One is there's a clip out there
- 26:58now and I entirely believe that this was
- 27:00his experience because he's
- 27:02self-reporting it. Ben Affleck is was
- 27:03talking about getting over I think it
- 27:05was alcohol addiction. He's been asked
- 27:07several times, you know, what allowed
- 27:08you to finally do that. And he just
- 27:10said, well, the consequences just
- 27:12finally became intense enough, scary
- 27:15enough that you just won't stand for it
- 27:17anymore. So, it's perhaps an interesting
- 27:19window into this process and the
- 27:21dopamine circuitry and and and what's
- 27:23required to exit the addictive cycle
- 27:25once and for all. The other thing that
- 27:28we hear is that childhood trauma and
- 27:30early events and family structures and
- 27:33um and their deficits are at the root of
- 27:36all of it. And I realize none of this is
- 27:39mutually exclusive with the model that
- 27:41>> right
- 27:42>> you presented. But there does seem to be
- 27:44a sort of divide in the public
- 27:48understanding and belief about addiction
- 27:50>> where many people feel like, oh no, you
- 27:53know, it's this is all the the um
- 27:55playing out of an unhealthy narrative
- 27:57that occurred early. If we can
- 27:59understand that early set of dynamics,
- 28:02then we can escape the addictive cycle.
- 28:04So I'd like to know if that's true or
- 28:06not, sometimes, often times, always,
- 28:10never. And I also think that Ben's
- 28:12description is really important because
- 28:15at the end of the day, even if one
- 28:17incorporates a higher power in order to
- 28:20move through addiction, there's this
- 28:22piece of like enough. Enough is enough.
- 28:24And that can come from the outside many
- 28:26many times, but ultimately the person
- 28:28has to do it for themselves. So just
- 28:30like any thoughts on that or reflections
- 28:32about what could be going on with enough
- 28:35is enough and with trauma and in
- 28:39particular early childhood trauma as it
- 28:41relates to addiction.
- 28:42>> Yeah. So there's lots of evidence
- 28:45showing that childhood trauma is a
- 28:47significant risk factor for addiction.
- 28:49It's very clear that if you are raised
- 28:52in a home where you experience physical,
- 28:54sexual, emotional abuse, neglect, chaos,
- 28:58you are at increased risk for all kinds
- 29:00of mental and physical health
- 29:02consequences, including addiction. I
- 29:05also really appreciate a rat experiment
- 29:07where a rat is trained to know that if
- 29:11it presses a lever, it will get cocaine.
- 29:14Most rats will then press that lever
- 29:16till exhaustion or death. But if the
- 29:18cocaine is taken away, eventually that
- 29:20behavior will extinguish. The rat will
- 29:22stop pressing the lever, will go off and
- 29:24do other things. If you then expose that
- 29:26rat to a very painful foot shock, the
- 29:29first thing the rat will do is run back
- 29:30and start pressing the lever again. In
- 29:32other words, not only can stress and
- 29:35childhood stress in particular be the
- 29:38progenitor of developing addiction later
- 29:41in life, but in the midst of trying to
- 29:44recover or of recovery itself, if you're
- 29:46exposed to a very extreme stressor,
- 29:48those neural networks are highly
- 29:51sensitive. They may die down, but the
- 29:54embers are still there and they can
- 29:55easily get reactivated by stress and
- 29:57trauma. So, super important to
- 29:59acknowledge that risk factor. But there
- 30:01are also other risk factors. There are
- 30:03genetic risk factors, right? So if you
- 30:05have a biological parent or grandparent
- 30:07with an alcohol use disorder, you are at
- 30:09increased risk to develop an alcohol use
- 30:11disorder even if you're not raised in an
- 30:13alcoholusing home. There are access risk
- 30:16factors. So and then that's one of the
- 30:18main focuses of dopamine. Like simply
- 30:20having access to a drug means you're
- 30:22more likely to use it, more likely to
- 30:24change your brain in the process and
- 30:26more likely to get addicted. Which is
- 30:27also why addiction doesn't discriminate.
- 30:30Like you can have the perfect family,
- 30:32the nearperfect childhood, you can have
- 30:34a great job, you can have great friends,
- 30:36and you can still get addicted because
- 30:38you're surrounded by addictive
- 30:40substances and behaviors which once you
- 30:42use them will change your brain into
- 30:44this very specific physiologic uh you
- 30:47know phenomenon. So you know these these
- 30:50two things exist simultaneously.
- 30:52I think the danger that can happen and
- 30:55and and in my career span was very
- 30:58common is that you have psychiatrists
- 31:01and psychologists and many many
- 31:03different types of mental health
- 31:04providers who aren't very well trained
- 31:06in addiction. So don't know much about
- 31:08it, don't want to ask about it because
- 31:11they haven't learned much about it and
- 31:12don't have the tools to intervene. And
- 31:15so when a patient presents with a
- 31:18substance use disorder or behavioral
- 31:20addiction, we'll spend a a lot of time
- 31:24trying to find the reason behind the
- 31:27addiction. And that is not productive,
- 31:31especially not initially when that
- 31:34person is deep in their addiction. For
- 31:36people to really be able to process the
- 31:38trauma that might be contributing to the
- 31:40addiction, they first need to get into
- 31:43at least early recovery, get back to
- 31:45homeostasis, get their prefrontal cortex
- 31:48back online, not be constantly craving
- 31:50and disregulated, and then they can ga
- 31:52engage in in the trauma work. The other
- 31:55thing too that I think is is happens
- 31:57with the narrative of addiction and this
- 31:59is just very common because I've been
- 32:01listening to many narratives you know
- 32:04over many years when people are in their
- 32:07addiction they are very quick to blame
- 32:10others for their problems and not take
- 32:12responsibility themselves and which is
- 32:14why the 12 steps can be so effective
- 32:17especially you know your own uh sort of
- 32:19character inventory what did what did I
- 32:21contribute to the problem right forcing
- 32:23people to look at what they contributed
- 32:26as part of the 12 steps. Even if the
- 32:27only thing they contributed was just
- 32:29showing up or maybe repeating the same
- 32:31patterns and not changing them from
- 32:33patterns, maladaptive patterns from
- 32:34childhood. It's really important to
- 32:37acknowledge that that kind of victim
- 32:38narrative is just not productive for
- 32:41getting into recovery. It's important to
- 32:42process the trauma. It's important to
- 32:44know, you know, when you've been
- 32:46wronged, where and how, but it's equally
- 32:48important to know what you've
- 32:49contributed, how you are perpetuating
- 32:51the problem, and and to move on from
- 32:53there. Now, getting to uh the idea of
- 32:56consequences. I don't know if you've
- 32:57seen there's a great Key and Peel sketch
- 32:59where [laughter]
- 33:02I don't remember the details exactly,
- 33:04but Key or Peel or one of them, you
- 33:06know, he's getting up there and he's
- 33:07talking to a he's like in re I guess
- 33:09he's in recovery and he's talking to a
- 33:10bunch of high school students and he's
- 33:12talking about, yeah, the only way to get
- 33:13into recovery is consequences. And then
- 33:15at one point a big wrecking ball comes
- 33:17in and like hits him and he's see I told
- 33:19you consequences. Anyway, I'm probably
- 33:20butchering the scene, but I just found
- 33:22it hilarious. Practically speaking, in
- 33:26the reality of treating addiction, many
- 33:29people with severe addiction do not get
- 33:32into recovery until they have serious
- 33:35consequences.
- 33:37And I think part of the phenomenon there
- 33:39is because the brain is just very
- 33:42masterful at minimizing consequences
- 33:46related to addictive behaviors. So we
- 33:48just like like whatever happens, you
- 33:50know, a DUI, a car crash, a lost
- 33:53relationship, uh you know, pancreatitis,
- 33:58our brain just does this clickity
- 33:59clickity click, some weird, really weird
- 34:01mental madness like, well, it's it's
- 34:03actually okay or it's not really, you
- 34:06know, the substance or it wasn't really
- 34:08related to that behavior. We're just
- 34:11really really good at that. You know,
- 34:12it's called denial, as you know, and
- 34:14it's incredibly powerful. And at some
- 34:17point after a certain number of
- 34:20consequences, the denial just crumbles.
- 34:23And this is commonly referred to as, you
- 34:25know, hitting hitting rock bottom. It's
- 34:27just it's a moment where you get and
- 34:28you're just like, "Okay, I I can't
- 34:30pretend that this isn't happening
- 34:32anymore." And for some people, that
- 34:35place is just like the expression on
- 34:36their loved one's face when they're
- 34:38caught using late at night when they
- 34:41were pretending that they were, you
- 34:42know, sober and just the expression of
- 34:44the loved one. for other people they you
- 34:46know they they're home they got to end
- 34:47up homeless or in jail or bankrupt or
- 34:50much more significant consequences
- 34:52before so people are different you got
- 34:54your high bottoms your low bottoms but
- 34:56the bottom line is everybody sort of has
- 34:58that moment where it's like okay that
- 35:01like I I just can't do this anymore
- 35:03>> I don't know if there are any data on it
- 35:04but do interventions work
- 35:06>> there are wonderful intervention
- 35:08interventionists out there many of them
- 35:10are people who have um you know struggle
- 35:12with addiction themselves and they can
- 35:15be very helpful. Yeah. especially when
- 35:16they come into a home where parents are
- 35:19really struggling with a child, either
- 35:21an adult child or a minor and just at
- 35:24their wits end. Um to try to, you know,
- 35:27extract some kind of behavior change,
- 35:29especially since again with these
- 35:31computers and the digital medium, you
- 35:34know, people kids can just stay in their
- 35:36rooms and stay at home and sort of, you
- 35:38know, engage in this sort of constant
- 35:40looping sort of self-titillation and not
- 35:43emerge. and parents very often can be
- 35:46held hostage to that.
- 35:48>> I'd like to take a quick break and
- 35:49acknowledge our sponsor, AG1. I'm
- 35:52excited to share that AG1 has just
- 35:54launched their newest formulation, AG1
- 35:56Pro. AG1 Pro takes the clinically backed
- 35:58AG1 formula, which is a blend of
- 36:00vitamins, minerals, probiotics, and
- 36:02adaptogens, and adds three important new
- 36:04ingredients: creatine monohydrate,
- 36:06calcium HMBB, and zinc carnosine. Each
- 36:09serving has 5 g of creatine monohydrate
- 36:11to support muscle strength and
- 36:13performance. as well as brain health,
- 36:15calcium HMBB to support muscle recovery
- 36:17and reduce muscle breakdown, and zinc
- 36:19carnosine to support and improve the
- 36:20lining of your gut. All three of these
- 36:22ingredients have compelling science to
- 36:24support them, and therefore, I love
- 36:26seeing them added to the existing AG1
- 36:28formula. As most of you know, I've been
- 36:30taking AG1 every day for nearly 14 years
- 36:33now. I started taking it long before I
- 36:34even knew what a podcast was. It's a
- 36:36great product, and it's now made even
- 36:38better with the new AG1 Pro formula. If
- 36:40you would like to try AG1 Pro, you can
- 36:43go to drinkag1.com/huberman
- 36:46to get a special offer. AG1 is giving
- 36:48away a free bottle of omega-3 co-enzyme
- 36:50Q10 with your first subscription. Again,
- 36:53go to drinkag1.com/huberman
- 36:55to get a free bottle of omega-3
- 36:57co-enzyme Q10 with your first AG1
- 37:00subscription. Let's talk about surrender
- 37:03and spirituality and everything that
- 37:05goes with surrender. I can't remember if
- 37:09the story was at a particular stage or
- 37:12not the last time we spoke on this
- 37:14podcast, but I do recall sharing a
- 37:17story. It's true story about a friend
- 37:20who was badly addicted to drugs and
- 37:23alcohol and had gone through multiple
- 37:26relapses, gone to um various private
- 37:29clinics, uh like had tried so many
- 37:32different things. And I think I asked
- 37:34you like, "Do you just give up?" Right?
- 37:36Do you just give up? That story ended up
- 37:38in a pretty wild place. Um he uh he
- 37:42won't mind me sharing this. Um I checked
- 37:44with him. One of their kids had gotten
- 37:46into a stash. There was a whole mess.
- 37:48Like it was like it was like this is it
- 37:50or I'm taking the kids. I'm going.
- 37:52That's it. That's it.
- 37:53>> He ended up um going to a place where
- 37:57the entire treatment was uh faith-based.
- 38:01>> Mhm. And I remember when he told me he
- 38:05was headed off there, I was like, "Okay,
- 38:07this is like like [clears throat]
- 38:09no." He went there for a week or so. Um
- 38:13came out. Um that was something like 4
- 38:17and 1/2 years ago. He's actively in
- 38:1912step and that's keeping him going,
- 38:21>> right?
- 38:22>> Um never seen him or his family in
- 38:25better shape. It's super impressive.
- 38:28>> So I ate my words. [laughter]
- 38:31There's something there. Something
- 38:33happened. [clears throat] So the
- 38:34question is what happened?
- 38:36>> We know what would have needed to happen
- 38:37for the circuitry,
- 38:39>> right?
- 38:39>> But clearly something
- 38:41>> worked that hadn't worked
- 38:44>> anywhere else any way else.
- 38:46>> And it was really bad. It was like it
- 38:48was as bad as it could get. And that he
- 38:50had wrapped his truck around a pole at
- 38:527:00 a.m. after taking pills. That this
- 38:55was prior to that. I mean, he had had so
- 38:57many of these in the short time that I'd
- 38:59known him. and and now it's been a long
- 39:01time. So I'm like man that is awesome.
- 39:03When I ever [clears throat] say like so
- 39:05great and he's just like he will tell
- 39:07you like I mean this isn't propaganda
- 39:09for me. He'll tell you God Jesus got him
- 39:11sober.
- 39:12>> Mhm.
- 39:12>> And I'm like so what the heck's going
- 39:14on?
- 39:15>> Yeah. I mean it it is fascinating and in
- 39:17my career I have seen that many times
- 39:20over. Um you know either either through
- 39:2212step or many different types of
- 39:25religious practices. people who couldn't
- 39:27get into recovery in any other way and
- 39:30then this this spiritual pivot um just
- 39:32became key for them and I think
- 39:37the core of understanding this
- 39:39phenomenon is to appreciate that in the
- 39:43severest cases of addiction people are
- 39:46not actually addicted to that substance
- 39:50or that behavior what they're addicted
- 39:53to is control.
- 39:56So, we evolved over millions of years of
- 39:58evolution to reduce uncertainty and it's
- 40:01what's kept us alive in a chaotic and
- 40:04dangerous world full of famine, blood,
- 40:07fire. We are born with a mental model of
- 40:11the world, what I'll call a mind map.
- 40:14Um, our mind map is different from the
- 40:16mind map of a fish. So, we're not we're
- 40:18not born with tabular rasa. It's not
- 40:19just a blank slate. We already have an
- 40:22elaborated series of neural networks
- 40:26that prepare us to anticipate the world
- 40:29that we live in as human beings. And as
- 40:32we grow and develop and have human
- 40:34experiences, we're constantly predicting
- 40:38what will happen in the world. And when
- 40:40our predictions are right, that feels
- 40:42good and is reinforcing,
- 40:44releases dopamine, right? And when our
- 40:46predictions are wrong, we have really
- 40:48one of two choices. We can update the
- 40:51map or we can update the world. Now,
- 40:54updating the world takes an interesting
- 40:56form. It's a way of further foraging and
- 40:59seeing if maybe I need to collect more
- 41:00data. It's a way of redirecting our
- 41:02attention. Uh so that now we're
- 41:04attending to things that match with our
- 41:07mental model. But the bottom line is
- 41:10that we're constantly seeking to
- 41:14assert control and reduce uncertainty.
- 41:17And it's adaptive. And it's what's kept
- 41:19us alive.
- 41:21What has happened in the modern world is
- 41:25that we have developed so many levers to
- 41:29control our experience that we have
- 41:33become addicted to control itself. So we
- 41:36are constantly optimizing, right? We're
- 41:39relationship maxing. We're career
- 41:42maxing. We're looks maxing. We're
- 41:43counting our steps, our sleep, our
- 41:45accomplishments, our calories, other
- 41:47people. We're trying to engineer
- 41:51perfection and get the perfect mental
- 41:54model of the world to the point where
- 41:57our efforts to exert control are now
- 42:00quite divorced from what is actually
- 42:02happening in the world. And addiction is
- 42:04the quintessential example of that.
- 42:07through my addictive behaviors, I can
- 42:10create this world within a world where
- 42:13my focus narrows. I everything else
- 42:16falls away. I've simplified things. I
- 42:18just have this one lever like a rat in a
- 42:20cage. And as long as I can press that
- 42:23lever, I know I can change the way that
- 42:26I feel. Now, as the disease progresses,
- 42:29my drug stops working. And maybe I even
- 42:32feel worse when I use it. But it doesn't
- 42:34matter because I'm in control of
- 42:37changing the way that I feel in that
- 42:39moment. It's like with gambling
- 42:41addiction. People think that people who
- 42:44get addicted to gambling are addicted to
- 42:45money. They're not addicted to money.
- 42:48They're addicted to the game. Which is
- 42:50why loss chasing happens where
- 42:52pathological gamblers will tell you that
- 42:54a part of them actually wants to lose
- 42:57because they know when they lose they
- 42:59have a justification to stay in the game
- 43:02longer. The game is a world. It's a
- 43:04world within a world where I am God. I
- 43:08press the lever. I control on this
- 43:10minuscule level. And it's distorted and
- 43:14it's messed up and the rest of my life
- 43:16is going to hell. But right here and
- 43:18right now, everything's simple. I have
- 43:21that feeling of grip. I'm exercising
- 43:23control. This is all by way of saying
- 43:26that in my opinion it's not only people
- 43:29with you know classic addictions who are
- 43:31struggling with this addiction to
- 43:33control but it's all of us now again
- 43:35because we have so many levers for
- 43:38control we've made ourselves masters of
- 43:40the universe we we exert our will over
- 43:42material reality in every way and as a
- 43:46result we are much more miserable so for
- 43:50example what I see in clinical care
- 43:52especially among young people is
- 43:54incredibly anxious people who hate
- 43:56themselves. Why are they anxious?
- 43:58They're terrified they're going to
- 44:01choose wrong and end up missing out on
- 44:03their best life. It's a constant FOMO.
- 44:06It's like, oh, but but if I choose this
- 44:08career that I'm maybe that I maybe I
- 44:10should be going to this career. It's
- 44:12this idea if I am the only arbiter of my
- 44:14destiny, then like what if I mess it up?
- 44:18It's all on me. So, there's terror and
- 44:19anxiety. And that's also this illusion
- 44:22that well because we can control so much
- 44:25we should be able to get it perfectly
- 44:26right such that any fall from perfection
- 44:32people are just filled with
- 44:33self-loathing shame. There's no sacred
- 44:35ballast of sort of forgiveness or grace.
- 44:37It's like I messed up. I messed up my
- 44:40life. And of course with the internet
- 44:41our shame has legs. It ricochets all
- 44:44around the world. And you know, very
- 44:45sadly, you know, working at a at a
- 44:48prestigious university,
- 44:50I see, you know, young people with all
- 44:53the promise, all the gifts, who end
- 44:56their own lives in the wake of what a
- 44:59generation ago would have been a
- 45:01disappointment, but not a
- 45:02life-threatening one, right? A a a grant
- 45:05not received, a social rejection, an an
- 45:08academic reprimand.
- 45:11young people taking their own lives
- 45:14because the shame and the self-loathing
- 45:16in a world in which we're expected to
- 45:19manipulate our experience to achieve
- 45:21perfection. It's too much. We we've lost
- 45:24our tolerance for imperfection. We've
- 45:26lost our tolerance for uncertainty. Now
- 45:29just not getting the right, you know,
- 45:30soy mocha latte in the morning sends us
- 45:33for a tail spin. And that all leads to
- 45:36ultimately what is what is the answer to
- 45:38that? What is the antidote? It's the
- 45:40spiritual pivot. It is radical
- 45:42surrender. It's acknowledging the limits
- 45:45of what we can control. Giving that will
- 45:47over however we define it and merging
- 45:51with our lives unfolding rather than
- 45:54trying to engineer some future
- 45:56perfection.
- 45:58>> Incredible. I've never thought about
- 45:59this uh addiction to control. Some years
- 46:02ago, you told me something that really
- 46:04stuck in my mind and made me kind of
- 46:07take a look at myself for a moment
- 46:08[laughter] where you said that addicts
- 46:10like to like line up their pills or kind
- 46:14of count their their uh bags. I've never
- 46:17been a powder taker uh except creatine.
- 46:20Um I I confess. [laughter] I confess
- 46:22it's bettered my life. You do you, but
- 46:24it's bettered my life. And this need to
- 46:26quantify. M
- 46:28>> and I was just thinking about that for a
- 46:29moment in light of what you just said
- 46:31because that behavior could be viewed as
- 46:34you're you're establishing some
- 46:35certainties about the future. I know
- 46:38I've got this I can get into a certain
- 46:40feeling state if I need to. I can do
- 46:43that you know x many days apart if I
- 46:45need to extend it. You know the the fear
- 46:47of
- 46:48>> you know basically not being able to
- 46:50control one's future state
- 46:51>> right? you know, for many years, uh,
- 46:53before it became essentially legal or
- 46:55decriminalized. I had friends that, uh,
- 46:57were pretty chronic, uh, cannabis users,
- 47:00>> and they didn't re really meet the, you
- 47:03know, classic definition of addiction.
- 47:05But then I would always just say, well,
- 47:07how do you do when you travel? And like,
- 47:10not well, but I, you know, like take put
- 47:12in my shoe. This is before edibles
- 47:13became really common, right? You know,
- 47:15so like they were basically telling me
- 47:17that they they could do fine without it,
- 47:18but they just don't do without it. Yes.
- 47:20>> And and I found them
- 47:21>> they could do fine without it until they
- 47:22actually had to go without it.
- 47:23>> Exactly. Exactly. So, you know, and they
- 47:26were pretty irritable if they
- 47:28>> hadn't had it or if they weren't certain
- 47:31when they could.
- 47:32>> Right.
- 47:32>> And these extreme levels of motivation
- 47:34to like ensure they could get high in
- 47:37the future came about. And I'm not
- 47:38trying to point fingers at them. I think
- 47:40we all have components of this. So,
- 47:42there are a number of things that you've
- 47:43said about addiction that that weave
- 47:44into this control piece.
- 47:46How is it though that we can separate
- 47:49out the healthy, mildly unhealthy and
- 47:52truly unhealthy versions of this? So for
- 47:54instance, many people enjoy exercise and
- 47:57it gives them some feeling about their
- 47:59body aesthetics, their future body
- 48:01aesthetics, their longevity and that
- 48:03could be semi unhealthy to really
- 48:06unhealthy. But we're all told we need to
- 48:08exercise. So at what point are we
- 48:09addicted to exercise? If you exercise
- 48:11and you fulfill your job and family
- 48:13obligations, you're not, you know,
- 48:16waking up to run in the middle of the
- 48:17night just because you're you're
- 48:19healthy.
- 48:19>> Are you addicted? I mean, are you
- 48:21addicted to control? I mean, where do
- 48:23you draw the line? It can become a very
- 48:24jagged line, too.
- 48:26>> Yes. Uh, and you know, I'm not sitting
- 48:28here in judgment of people who have
- 48:31highly controlled lives and are thriving
- 48:33and doing great. Again, we are wired to
- 48:37reduce uncertainty. it is completely
- 48:39adaptive to do that. Um what I am
- 48:42talking about is the mismatch and you
- 48:44know similar argument with dopamine
- 48:46nation. The mismatch in dopamine nation
- 48:48that I talked about is this plenty
- 48:49paradox where we reflexively approach
- 48:52pleasure and avoid pain. It works great
- 48:53in a world of scarcity. It's a disaster
- 48:55in a world of plenty. In radical
- 48:57surrender I'm I'm talking about a
- 48:59control paradox where we evolved to
- 49:01reduce uncertainty in a chaotic world.
- 49:04That was essentially our teologic
- 49:06mandate, right? or our reason for
- 49:08existence. If you look at active
- 49:10inference and the free energy principle,
- 49:11that is essentially the underlying
- 49:13theory of that neurocognitive branch of
- 49:16science that we all exist to reduce
- 49:19uncertainty to exert our will to predict
- 49:23and to control. The problem is again a
- 49:26mismatch between what is highly adaptive
- 49:29in an organically uncertain world and
- 49:33what now becomes maladaptive in a world
- 49:36that we've essentially paved over.
- 49:38Right? And now we control everything. In
- 49:42fact, one of the big dangers in addition
- 49:45to anxiety and self-loathing is
- 49:48nihilistic boredom because there's
- 49:51nothing that we're not in control of. So
- 49:54now we have nothing to exert our need to
- 49:57control on. Right? And so what do we do
- 49:59in response to that? We engineer
- 50:01uncertainty. And this is at the heart of
- 50:04social media, slot machines, um sports
- 50:07betting, right? I mean why do people
- 50:10love sports? And I love sports, too. So,
- 50:12I'm not saying it's unhealthy to love
- 50:14sports, but it may be the last bastion
- 50:16where we don't know the outcome. It's
- 50:19genuinely uncertain unless they're
- 50:20cheating and it's rigged. It's we don't
- 50:22know. And it's it's complex and it's
- 50:24many factors. People want to give
- 50:26themselves over to destiny with a
- 50:30capital D, right? To to something
- 50:32greater than themselves. At the same
- 50:33time that we have a strong evolutionary
- 50:37psychology to control, we also have a
- 50:40strong need to surrender to something
- 50:43greater than ourselves. And both of
- 50:44those things coexist and may even work
- 50:47physiologically in our brains through an
- 50:48opponent process mechanism. So a lot of
- 50:50the the science on this and it's
- 50:52emerging science on spirituality will
- 50:54tell you that our spirituality network
- 50:57can't actually get activated when our
- 50:59control network is online because the
- 51:01control network is inhibiting the
- 51:03spirituality network.
- 51:04>> So as long as we have a way to control a
- 51:07situation, we're going to inhibit for
- 51:09example the per perry aqueductal gray
- 51:11which is sort of like the hub of this
- 51:13spirituality network. And that aligns
- 51:15perfectly with what you see in the last
- 51:18200 to 500 years as we've been able to
- 51:20apply science and technology to exert
- 51:23more control over our day-to-day
- 51:24existence. People are moving away from
- 51:27spiritual practices. They're moving away
- 51:29from faith-based organizations. Churches
- 51:32and temples are being turned into
- 51:34nightclubs and community centers. People
- 51:37are becoming more and more secular. And
- 51:40and yet when some crisis occurs all of a
- 51:43sudden that sort of it reignites sort of
- 51:45this like people even atheists you know
- 51:47will we'll pray in a moment of absolute
- 51:49terror. It it's the circuitry is there
- 51:52but we don't access it on a regular
- 51:54basis because we're so busy trying to
- 51:57control our next move.
- 51:59>> You mentioned periqueductal gray. Uh you
- 52:01and I are familiar with that. Uh we
- 52:03should probably inform the listeners and
- 52:06viewers about PAG PhD. we first uh met
- 52:11uh because we were team teaching neuro
- 52:13anatomy, right? And in neuro anatomy, we
- 52:15teach that the pag it's it's a really
- 52:18cool structure, right? It's got these
- 52:19different kind of like wedges of like
- 52:21represents pain, pleasure, sensory
- 52:24input. It's a kind of an integrative hub
- 52:26as I understand, but but that's a very
- 52:28superficial understanding. you'll you'll
- 52:30tell us what is known about PAGE in the
- 52:32context of what you're talking about and
- 52:34are there any components of the
- 52:35circuitry that make it makes sense that
- 52:39Pag would be involved in the experience
- 52:41of of spirituality or letting go of
- 52:45control.
- 52:46>> Yeah. So the Pag is intimately
- 52:49associated with our threat response. So
- 52:52fight, flight and freeze. In fact,
- 52:54there's a wonderful experiment where
- 52:56human brains are neuroimed while playing
- 52:59Pac-Man. And as long as the, you know,
- 53:02Pac-Man enemy is far away, the
- 53:04prefrontal cortex, the control centers
- 53:06light up. But as soon as that Pac-Man is
- 53:09just about to die, you know, within the
- 53:11presence of the ghost, the pag just goes
- 53:13wild. It absolutely light lights up. So,
- 53:15it's very essential in the face of like
- 53:18imminent death in sort of coordinating
- 53:20like what am I doing now? And then
- 53:23there's a very fascinating experiment or
- 53:26or series of experiments that have come
- 53:27out looking at lesions in humans and
- 53:30lesions that either increase or decrease
- 53:32spirituality whether you know parts of
- 53:35the brain remove removed dur due to
- 53:37trauma or cancer or epilepsy. And what
- 53:40they found was that spirituality
- 53:44is a circuit and this circuit the hub of
- 53:47it is probably the pag. And it makes
- 53:51sense that a part of the brain that's
- 53:54intimately associated with imminent
- 53:56threat and death would also be
- 53:58associated with spiritual surrender or
- 54:01you know letting go of control and
- 54:04accessing uh this sort of network that
- 54:07essentially is going to function to
- 54:11allow us to come up with an entirely new
- 54:14approach because what we've been doing
- 54:16hasn't been working. So the PAG is rich
- 54:19in uh muopioid receptors which are our
- 54:22natural pain relievers. The PAG is rich
- 54:25in oxytocin receptors which is our
- 54:28connection or love hormone. And both of
- 54:31those being activated then also
- 54:33stimulates a vast array of serotonin
- 54:36receptors. And serotonin when it
- 54:39functions in this regard in the PGA is
- 54:42essential for increasing neuroplasticity
- 54:45or learning in the face of rapid change.
- 54:50And again getting back to addiction,
- 54:54what what's happening with addiction is
- 54:56that we are rigidly holding on to our
- 55:01mental model and these control loops
- 55:05even when they've stopped working for
- 55:07us. And this is essentially the def
- 55:08definition of neurosis. The definition
- 55:10of neurosis, I think it was Freud way
- 55:12back when said neurosis is doing the
- 55:15same action over and over again and
- 55:17expecting a different outcome. But
- 55:19that's essentially what addiction is,
- 55:21right? You you're you're engaging this
- 55:22behavior. You can see that your life is
- 55:24going to hell, but somehow you keep
- 55:26thinking it's gonna it's going to be
- 55:27different this time. It's really in
- 55:29large part of function because our
- 55:31prediction machines or our mental models
- 55:32become calcified or rigidly in sconc.
- 55:35We're we're too attached to them. And so
- 55:38we do need to on some level have this
- 55:40spiritual pivot. Let go of control. Hit
- 55:43this bottom. Surrender it. Give it over.
- 55:46the control networks finally shut down.
- 55:48This PAG and spirituality network, you
- 55:51know, comes online and we have the
- 55:54ability to sort of melt down these
- 55:57neuronal connections and and begin a
- 55:59new. And many people will talk about
- 56:01when they have a sort of a spiritual,
- 56:03let's say, awakening or just a moment of
- 56:05transcendence that allows them to move
- 56:07forward. It is as if they can perceive
- 56:10more, right? The the the leaves are
- 56:13greener, the sky is bluer. this is
- 56:15probably really happening like
- 56:17perception is enhanced. I'm no longer
- 56:20trying to impose my rigid mental models
- 56:22on the world. Instead, I'm letting go of
- 56:25those pre the precision of my
- 56:27predictions. I'm letting that flatten
- 56:29and I'm opening myself to what is really
- 56:32happening in the world. So, it's like
- 56:35this embracing reality, acknowledging
- 56:37the limits of my will, giving it over
- 56:40and then having the experience of
- 56:42serenity. So it is an affective
- 56:44experience whether we're talking about
- 56:45the spiritual pivot or prayer. It's an
- 56:48affective experience of hope, serenity,
- 56:52peace which then enables a different
- 56:54kind of action in the world.
- 56:56>> It's a um ceasing to uh rely on the
- 57:01algorithms, the strategies that we've
- 57:03been using,
- 57:04>> right?
- 57:04>> And it becomes this openness
- 57:07to the reality that that wasn't working.
- 57:10Those things weren't working. there's
- 57:12something else. I don't yet know what
- 57:14those new strategies are.
- 57:16>> So, I'm going to give it over to God, as
- 57:18they say in 12 steps.
- 57:20>> I'm going to number one acknowledge the
- 57:22limits of my control. So, I'm going to
- 57:24rightsize my ego. I'm going to
- 57:26acknowledge that all of these things
- 57:27that I'm doing like I'm running around
- 57:29like a chicken with my head cut off, you
- 57:30know, trying to manage it because, you
- 57:31know, it t it's a lot, you know, in our
- 57:34disease, right? It's it's a constant
- 57:36management. And I'm just going to stop.
- 57:39I'm gonna just, as one of my patients
- 57:41said, I realized I was at checkmate.
- 57:43There were no more moves, which I just
- 57:44thought was a great analogy. It's like,
- 57:46yeah, it's checkmate. I'm I I'm out of
- 57:48moves. You just stop. You You recognize
- 57:51the limits of your will and you just
- 57:53that this pivot of giving it over to a
- 57:55power greater than ourselves. So, this
- 57:57is the mysterious process. But again, I
- 57:59think we're just wired for this. We
- 58:01evolved for this pivot. Um, and when
- 58:03that happens, it it starts a whole
- 58:06physiologic process which is
- 58:08restorative.
- 58:09>> So, I realize I had it completely wrong.
- 58:11I assumed that the potency of the giving
- 58:16it over to a higher power was about
- 58:19acknowledging our inability to
- 58:23strategize in in a way that's good for
- 58:25us. And just sort of the recognition
- 58:28like my brain can't do it on its own.
- 58:31I'm going to adopt this other rule
- 58:32system that is not of me and make it of
- 58:34me.
- 58:35>> I don't know that that's wrong. I mean,
- 58:36that's that's the language that you've
- 58:38come up with that makes it make sense
- 58:40for you. Um, that kind of pivot. I think
- 58:43>> the place where I get stuck is
- 58:44everything I know to be true about the
- 58:47dopamine reward reinforcement circuitry
- 58:49that you've described
- 58:51>> says that giving up control ought to
- 58:54send somebody further down the path of
- 58:57addiction, not overcome it. Right. Cuz
- 58:59it's like, okay, let's say this had
- 59:00alcohol in it and I felt like I
- 59:02literally couldn't help help it. I could
- 59:04ask
- 59:04>> Rob to help me out. I could ask you to
- 59:06take the cup out of the room. We could
- 59:08talk about it. We could talk about what
- 59:09led to, you know, a tendency to drink.
- 59:12But there's this kind of weird twist in
- 59:13all this where if I just say, "Wait a
- 59:15second. I can't do it. You're not here.
- 59:18>> Producer Rob isn't here. So, I'm just
- 59:20going to I'm going to give it over to
- 59:21God."
- 59:21>> Yeah.
- 59:22>> And then suddenly, and I've seen this
- 59:24over and over again,
- 59:25>> right?
- 59:26>> I've experienced this. like then then we
- 59:28can abstain.
- 59:29>> It it doesn't work with our existing
- 59:32models of just the dopamine reward
- 59:33circuitry because it would say like I'm
- 59:35going to take my hands off the steering
- 59:36wheel and the car is actually going to
- 59:37drive better and it's not a Tesla.
- 59:40>> In many ways, at least when it comes to
- 59:42this, dopamine and serotonin work like
- 59:45opposites, right? So, so dopamine is the
- 59:47ultimate gain function modulator. It's
- 59:49what tells your brain whatever you're
- 59:50doing now, get more of it, do more of
- 59:52it, more of that thing. And it's a very
- 59:54strong signal. Whereas whereas serotonin
- 59:57is the oh wait a minute um retreat uh
- 1:00:01re-evaluate and potentially find a new
- 1:00:04way around because what you've been
- 1:00:06doing isn't working.
- 1:00:07>> And in fact repeated frustration or our
- 1:00:11inability to accurately predict what's
- 1:00:13coming next or to solve the problems in
- 1:00:14our lives. There's a lot of evidence
- 1:00:17that shows they're characterized by the
- 1:00:19proliferation of 5HT2A serotonin
- 1:00:22receptors. So, it's almost like our
- 1:00:24brain is getting ready for this
- 1:00:27transformative moment when we finally
- 1:00:29acknowledge my mental maps are not
- 1:00:32working.
- 1:00:34This is not working. And it's it's and
- 1:00:36you have to come pretty low to get there
- 1:00:38because nobody likes to give up control
- 1:00:40because we all want more dopamine,
- 1:00:41right? We all want the gain function
- 1:00:43modulator. But that moment when we
- 1:00:46finally accept that we are not in
- 1:00:48control and we let it go then you get a
- 1:00:52very different I mean first of all there
- 1:00:54there's maybe a spiritual thing
- 1:00:56happening like a god thing happening I
- 1:00:58don't know but also we have the natural
- 1:01:01wiring to have a very then different
- 1:01:04physiologic experience where we our
- 1:01:06executive function our planning all of
- 1:01:09that goes quiet and you get this massive
- 1:01:14activation of serotonin which is the
- 1:01:18down reggulation of our precision
- 1:01:22predictions. Right? So now we're we're
- 1:01:24we're saying hey my rigid mental models
- 1:01:26are not working and it's a moment of
- 1:01:29plasticity. So it's like we're going
- 1:01:31back in time to a more open receptive
- 1:01:34state and you get with that an again a
- 1:01:37felt experience an affective experience
- 1:01:39of analesia.
- 1:01:41So right less pain of connectedness
- 1:01:45of the thought that where I couldn't
- 1:01:48rely on my own strength I can rely on
- 1:01:50the strength of surrender and giving it
- 1:01:53over and that is what allows people then
- 1:01:58through that experience to to not have
- 1:02:01that drink. They're getting the strength
- 1:02:04from the surrender itself. Right? And
- 1:02:07and then also I think importantly for
- 1:02:09many people from the handing it over,
- 1:02:13right? This idea that okay, I'm not in
- 1:02:14control, but this higher power is and
- 1:02:17I'm just going to try to follow that,
- 1:02:19right? Instead of me trying to juggle 14
- 1:02:21balls in the air, I'm I'm going to let
- 1:02:23them all drop and I'm just going to show
- 1:02:25up here and I'm going to do the next
- 1:02:27right thing and I'm going to take it one
- 1:02:29day at a time. So you also narrow the
- 1:02:31sort of scope of what you're trying to
- 1:02:33manage.
- 1:02:35>> The serotonin piece is really
- 1:02:36interesting. I know you have mixed
- 1:02:38skeptical you'll update us feelings
- 1:02:41about the use of psychedelic medicine
- 1:02:43for um treatment of addiction like
- 1:02:45taking a drug to get over drugs but in
- 1:02:47the case of at least let's just say
- 1:02:48psilocybin I mean it's main mechanism
- 1:02:53for engaging plasticity is to you know
- 1:02:57activate the serotonurgic pathway and
- 1:02:59these particular receptors seems not
- 1:03:01coincidental. Um maybe maybe unmasking
- 1:03:04connections maybe allowing new
- 1:03:06contingencies to be formed. But I'm also
- 1:03:09reminded there's a really cool paper uh
- 1:03:10it doesn't get talked about very much
- 1:03:12but a guy by the name of Lombberto Mafay
- 1:03:15did some really cool studies reopening
- 1:03:17critical period plasticity by
- 1:03:18administering it was rats SSRIs
- 1:03:22>> and you could reopen plasticity and I
- 1:03:24know SSRIs get a really bad rap these
- 1:03:26days but in both cases psilocybin and
- 1:03:28SSRIs the net effect is increased
- 1:03:31serotonin tone in the synapses. So, you
- 1:03:36know, love them or hate them, uh, the
- 1:03:38the SSRI are effectively getting to a
- 1:03:40similarish place of increasing serotonin
- 1:03:42and thereby plasticity. So much of what
- 1:03:45we're beginning to understand about the
- 1:03:47spirituality and spiritual surrender is
- 1:03:51through the research with psychedelics
- 1:03:53and psilocybin. I mean, so that that
- 1:03:54research is amazing. You know, people's
- 1:03:57subjective experience. I've talked to
- 1:03:59many people for whom their first access
- 1:04:02to the sacred in our secular world was
- 1:04:05through psilocybin or other psychedelic.
- 1:04:08So it it's very clear that not only has
- 1:04:12this given us a tool to begin to
- 1:04:14understand what may be happening with
- 1:04:16spiritual surrender but for many people
- 1:04:19it's it's a pivotal moment in their
- 1:04:22lives life-changing and incredibly
- 1:04:24positive. My reservation just comes with
- 1:04:26I want to make sure that people also
- 1:04:28understand the risks associated with it
- 1:04:31and that the sort of um you know the
- 1:04:34promise just doesn't get too far ahead
- 1:04:36of the the evidence because of course in
- 1:04:38my clinic what I see is people misusing
- 1:04:41and addicted to psychedelics in many
- 1:04:43different forms
- 1:04:44>> including psilocybin.
- 1:04:45>> Yeah, absolutely. because the the word
- 1:04:47out there is that you know it has a very
- 1:04:50very high uh you know lethal dose uh
- 1:04:53that you know it's far safer than
- 1:04:56alcohol um you know you know barring
- 1:04:58people with you know predisposition to
- 1:05:01psychosis or or mania you know this is
- 1:05:03kind of the the new frontier and and
- 1:05:05I've I've talked openly I've had
- 1:05:07positive experiences with clinical use
- 1:05:09not recreational use but clinical use of
- 1:05:12of psilocybin but it is no easy ride I
- 1:05:14mean it's it's a I mean to be quite
- 1:05:15blunt It's an asskicking of a whole
- 1:05:17other kind and it involves therapy
- 1:05:19before, during, and after. And I felt it
- 1:05:22benefited me tremendously.
- 1:05:23>> But I can think of a many many people
- 1:05:26for whom it would probably be the worst
- 1:05:28possible thing for them to do.
- 1:05:30>> Right. It's it's highly unpredictable is
- 1:05:33part of it. Probably more unpredictable
- 1:05:34than other drugs. You just don't know
- 1:05:36what what kind of response someone is
- 1:05:38going to have. And also importantly, the
- 1:05:39the early data that was out there about
- 1:05:41saying it was much less harmful than
- 1:05:43let's say alcohol was primarily
- 1:05:45attributable to the fact that not many
- 1:05:47people were using it.
- 1:05:49>> We published a paper looking at the
- 1:05:51number of uh ED visits and
- 1:05:53hospitalizations as a result of
- 1:05:54hallucinogens. And what we have shown is
- 1:05:57that as use goes up, the number of ED
- 1:06:01related harms and hospital admission
- 1:06:03related harms also goes up.
- 1:06:04>> Sorry, ED,
- 1:06:05>> sorry, emergency department harms. Yeah.
- 1:06:07So, so the that you know that early
- 1:06:10narrative about it being much less
- 1:06:11harmful than other drugs, I I don't
- 1:06:13think that's going to pan out and and
- 1:06:15our studies show that it's already the
- 1:06:18related harms are already increasing.
- 1:06:20Psychosis, you know, suicide, pers
- 1:06:23persistent hallucinosis,
- 1:06:25severe mood. So again, you know, every
- 1:06:29drug is going to have risk, benefits,
- 1:06:31and alternatives. And I'm not sitting
- 1:06:33here saying we shouldn't study it or
- 1:06:35that there's no benefit because clearly
- 1:06:37I've met and talked to many people who
- 1:06:39have had um amazing benefit, but I've
- 1:06:42also talked to and seen a lot of harm.
- 1:06:46So, it's just a matter of being really
- 1:06:47thoughtful about it and and sort of
- 1:06:49following the data.
- 1:06:51>> I'd like to take a quick break and
- 1:06:52acknowledge our sponsor, Function.
- 1:06:55Function provides over 160 advanced lab
- 1:06:58tests to give you a clear snapshot of
- 1:07:00your bodily health. This snapshot gives
- 1:07:02you insights into your heart health,
- 1:07:03your hormone health, autoimmune
- 1:07:05function, nutrient levels, and much
- 1:07:07more. They've also recently added access
- 1:07:09to advanced MRI and CT scans. Function
- 1:07:12not only provides testing of over 160
- 1:07:15biomarkers key to your physical and
- 1:07:16mental health, it also analyzes these
- 1:07:19results and provides recommendations for
- 1:07:21improving your health from top doctors.
- 1:07:23For example, in a recent test with
- 1:07:25function, I learned that some of my
- 1:07:26blood lipids were slightly out of range.
- 1:07:29As a result, I decided to start
- 1:07:30supplementing with nattokinise, which
- 1:07:32can naturally help reduce LDL
- 1:07:34cholesterol, and it did. In a follow-up
- 1:07:36test, I could confirm that this strategy
- 1:07:38worked. My blood lipids are now back
- 1:07:40exactly where I want them. Comprehensive
- 1:07:42lab testing of the sort that function
- 1:07:44offers is just so important for health.
- 1:07:46I mean, how else are you going to know
- 1:07:47what's going on under the hood? And
- 1:07:49while I've been doing blood work for
- 1:07:50years, it used to be timeconuming,
- 1:07:52complicated, and expensive. In fact, I
- 1:07:54used to spend thousands of dollars per
- 1:07:56year trying to get this kind of data.
- 1:07:58and the data frankly were not all that
- 1:08:00good. But now with Function, it's
- 1:08:02extremely easy and affordable. A
- 1:08:04Function membership is only a dollar a
- 1:08:06day, $365 a year. And if you think about
- 1:08:08the information it provides and the
- 1:08:10health challenges it helps you avoid and
- 1:08:12the proactive things that it can do for
- 1:08:14you to enhance your health, I truly look
- 1:08:16at it as a savings. To learn more, visit
- 1:08:19functionhealth.com/huberman
- 1:08:21and use the code hubberman for a $50
- 1:08:23credit towards your membership. Again,
- 1:08:25that's functionhealth.com/huberman.
- 1:08:29So, we've got this model now, if I'm not
- 1:08:31mistaken, that a lot of addiction is the
- 1:08:33need to control. Sometimes, so much so
- 1:08:36that it's really the thing separate from
- 1:08:39the high. It's the ability to get high.
- 1:08:42It's the ability to um control the sleep
- 1:08:45score, dare I say. Right.
- 1:08:47>> I don't know. I know a few people for
- 1:08:48whom their you know their um commitment
- 1:08:51to for lack of a better word protocols
- 1:08:54has taken them away from life. I mean I
- 1:08:56get asked about this a lot. I think that
- 1:08:57the line at between optimization a
- 1:09:00healthy life and over optimization is
- 1:09:03just all of the practices are so that
- 1:09:04you can lean into the rest of your life
- 1:09:06with more vigor and for longer and more
- 1:09:08presence and like that's all the whole
- 1:09:09purpose of a good night's sleep is not
- 1:09:11to just get another good night's sleep.
- 1:09:12But with that said, it seems that the
- 1:09:15Pag gets activated when we run out of
- 1:09:18options, nothing's working,
- 1:09:19>> right?
- 1:09:20>> Then serotonin
- 1:09:22related mechanisms and other neurom
- 1:09:26modulators help our brains come up with
- 1:09:29new
- 1:09:30>> new plans that might work.
- 1:09:32>> Yeah.
- 1:09:33>> But the only way to take that step is in
- 1:09:35acknowledging that what I've been doing
- 1:09:37hasn't worked and the new plan is going
- 1:09:39to come. The word surrender kind of
- 1:09:42makes it seem like it's it's going to
- 1:09:43come from out there,
- 1:09:45>> right?
- 1:09:45>> Not not from the PAG, but from out
- 1:09:47there. But you're saying in a in the
- 1:09:49strictly neurobiological model, the PAG
- 1:09:52is actually like offering up new
- 1:09:54opportun new strategies to try like,
- 1:09:56hey, maybe try this strategy instead.
- 1:09:59Well, I mean, I I think, you know, in
- 1:10:01talking about the PGA and serotonin and
- 1:10:04psychedelics and what's happening in the
- 1:10:05brain, all we're really saying is that
- 1:10:08there's a there's a neurobiological
- 1:10:12machinery that gets activated in this
- 1:10:15moment of spiritual surrender and in
- 1:10:17surrendered practices, right? So, like
- 1:10:20in in prayer focused on surrender,
- 1:10:22again, the prefrontal cortex goes quiet.
- 1:10:25uh the PAG and other related structures
- 1:10:28become activated possibly in like an
- 1:10:31opponent process mechanism. That in and
- 1:10:33of itself is not a commentary on whether
- 1:10:35or not there is a higher power who's
- 1:10:38actually you know involved in providing
- 1:10:40wisdom and guidance. I think the
- 1:10:41subjective experience is very much that
- 1:10:45we are opening ourselves up to guidance
- 1:10:48from a higher power and people will talk
- 1:10:50about getting that wisdom and getting
- 1:10:52that guidance um and even you know
- 1:10:55hearing the voice of you know their
- 1:10:57higher power however they conceive of
- 1:10:59that and it's such a subjective thing
- 1:11:01for many people their higher power is
- 1:11:02simply nature or the cosmos or the
- 1:11:05beauty and mystery of the universe and
- 1:11:07that's not you know they may talk to
- 1:11:09nature but that's because we're human
- 1:11:11and that's how we interrelate not
- 1:11:13because they think that their higher
- 1:11:14power is human. Right? So these are all
- 1:11:17very personal subjective and I mean I
- 1:11:20have a lot of respect and honor for
- 1:11:22however people are conceiving of of
- 1:11:24their higher power. What I think is
- 1:11:27really salient for me, having grown up
- 1:11:29in a secular household, having practiced
- 1:11:32psychiatry, being in, you know, the
- 1:11:34bastion of science and rational
- 1:11:36materialism, is that this sort of
- 1:11:40inwardlooking
- 1:11:42reflection, which is so predominant in
- 1:11:46mental health treatment, this sort of
- 1:11:49like if I look inward far enough and
- 1:11:52know myself well enough and find my
- 1:11:54authentic self, I'll find the answers.
- 1:11:56there. And for me personally, that was
- 1:11:58helpful to a point, but was not helpful
- 1:12:02when I was faced with like a serious
- 1:12:05existential crisis in the form of, as I
- 1:12:08talk about in radical surrender, our son
- 1:12:11being diagnosed with and dying from
- 1:12:12leukemia. Like the I did many hours of
- 1:12:15psychotherapy. I read every paper there
- 1:12:18was on, you know, Q23 transllocation,
- 1:12:22congenital leukemia that was empty for
- 1:12:25me. And it really wasn't until I got to
- 1:12:27this point of sort of a spiritual pivot
- 1:12:28and say, I'm not in control and no other
- 1:12:31human being can tell me why this
- 1:12:33happened. You know, I'm going to
- 1:12:35surrender my attempts to overmanage this
- 1:12:39situation and I'm just going to instead
- 1:12:42sort of just show up for life and see
- 1:12:43what happens. And in my life, that has
- 1:12:46made all the difference. So, you know,
- 1:12:48my sort of rock bottom, so to speak, was
- 1:12:50was different maybe from someone with
- 1:12:52severe addiction and yet really quite
- 1:12:54similar because in many ways prior to
- 1:12:56that moment, I also was addicted to
- 1:12:58control, to achievement, to
- 1:13:00optimization. I was going to tell my
- 1:13:03husband how he should grieve, you know,
- 1:13:05in the wake of that loss. And we were
- 1:13:07going to have another baby right away
- 1:13:08and replace the baby that we lost. And
- 1:13:10that didn't work out. So there had to be
- 1:13:14the multiple consequences before it was
- 1:13:16like this isn't working, you know. And
- 1:13:18then when I did have that moment of of
- 1:13:20spiritual surrender, it felt profoundly
- 1:13:23spiritual but also physiologic like my
- 1:13:27brain got reset. I mean it was really
- 1:13:29very powerful and mysterious.
- 1:13:32>> Is the book the first time you've talked
- 1:13:34about that publicly?
- 1:13:35>> Yeah.
- 1:13:35>> Yeah. This I have
- 1:13:36>> I may have occasionally mentioned it but
- 1:13:38I' I've never written about it. Yeah. I
- 1:13:40find it um at once amazing that many of
- 1:13:45my colleagues, our colleagues in uh
- 1:13:48science and medicine don't even want to
- 1:13:51go close to the conversation about
- 1:13:53spirituality, surrender,
- 1:13:55>> and they're not alone in that. But every
- 1:13:58major hospital, including Stanford
- 1:13:59Hospital, which is a very, very fine
- 1:14:01hospital. I'm not just saying that. It's
- 1:14:03also beautiful. I think I think thanks
- 1:14:05to the generosity of donors, it's like
- 1:14:08really true. It's a beautiful place. um
- 1:14:10where hard things and great things
- 1:14:11happen.
- 1:14:12>> Yes,
- 1:14:12>> they have a chaplain.
- 1:14:14>> They have uh people from every religious
- 1:14:17denomination that can come talk to
- 1:14:19people like these people are paid a
- 1:14:20salary for a reason, right? So we so
- 1:14:23like at once we acknowledge there's a
- 1:14:24memorial church on campus, there's a
- 1:14:26meditation center, wind hover, uh you
- 1:14:29know, like so it to me it's like there's
- 1:14:31this like collision of values that no
- 1:14:33one really uh wants to acknowledge. So
- 1:14:36it's like it's just kind of there. Yeah,
- 1:14:37>> it's supposed to be anti-science or
- 1:14:39anti-modern medicine to acknowledge
- 1:14:41these things, but you got these uh
- 1:14:44people hired specifically to to help
- 1:14:46people and you got a place for people to
- 1:14:48go pray and listen to music and
- 1:14:50[laughter] you know and to meditate. So
- 1:14:52So what do you think of that? I'm not
- 1:14:54asking you to comment on Stanford
- 1:14:55specifically, but like why is it so hard
- 1:14:57for most people to see the ways that
- 1:15:00these things can fit together and
- 1:15:01enhance one another as opposed to the
- 1:15:04view that like oh no no like you want me
- 1:15:05to be believe in magic like a like like
- 1:15:08Santa Claus. That's that's how some
- 1:15:09people feel about it. They think it's
- 1:15:11nonsense,
- 1:15:12>> right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I mean I you
- 1:15:14know in preparation for for writing this
- 1:15:18book, I can't tell you how many Stanford
- 1:15:21faculty I spoke to who have these secret
- 1:15:25spiritual lives. Like they're very
- 1:15:27spiritual people and they have deep
- 1:15:28spiritual practices which are at the
- 1:15:30core of their lives and the lives of
- 1:15:32their families and yet very reluctant to
- 1:15:35talk about it, you know, reluctant to
- 1:15:37admit it in scientific circles. And I
- 1:15:40think it's a it's a shame. I think it's
- 1:15:42really a shame because you know also in
- 1:15:45in in in working with patients I have so
- 1:15:48many patients who never get asked about
- 1:15:51their spiritual lives and yet again
- 1:15:52their spiritual faith their practices
- 1:15:55are at the core of their ability to
- 1:15:58handle their mental illness whatever
- 1:16:00their mental illness may be. the core of
- 1:16:02their ability to you know overcome even
- 1:16:05while they're also engaging in modern
- 1:16:07western medicine and doing psychotherapy
- 1:16:09like it's it doesn't have to be to the
- 1:16:12exclusion of um furthermore you know if
- 1:16:15you look at so many great scientists
- 1:16:18over the centuries I mean their faith
- 1:16:21and their worship of God was at the core
- 1:16:23of their science part of what makes
- 1:16:26science happen is an openness to
- 1:16:29understanding nature Right? It it's in
- 1:16:32the service of God wanting to understand
- 1:16:35this miraculous thing that is the
- 1:16:38universe. And yet so much of science now
- 1:16:41it feels more adulterated with again
- 1:16:44sort of like optimizing for achievement.
- 1:16:48I mean there's great great work don't
- 1:16:50don't get me wrong but just wanting to
- 1:16:53emphasize like the spirit of science is
- 1:16:56a spirit of open curiosity.
- 1:16:58And the spirit of open curiosity is at
- 1:17:01the core of spiritual surrender. It's
- 1:17:04basically saying, "Hey, like you know,
- 1:17:06William James said, like we're like dogs
- 1:17:08and cats in the library." You know, we
- 1:17:11see the books, but we don't have any
- 1:17:12idea what it means. I mean, that that's
- 1:17:14basically us, you know, on the planet.
- 1:17:17Like there's so much mystery out there
- 1:17:20and it, you know, and let's be enchanted
- 1:17:23by it and let's let's celebrate it.
- 1:17:25Let's have it be a source of wisdom and
- 1:17:28guidance and all of that. You can even
- 1:17:30go back to the the Stoics of ancient
- 1:17:33Greece who said to live in accordance
- 1:17:35with God, we must live in accordance
- 1:17:37with nature. To live in accordance with
- 1:17:39nature, we must pursue virtue. And I
- 1:17:42think this is also has been largely
- 1:17:45devoid in psychotherapy and in mental
- 1:17:49health. the idea that values matter and
- 1:17:52that we can enrich our lives by you know
- 1:17:54living a valuebased life. Now this is
- 1:17:56coming online with some newer
- 1:17:58psychotherapies like acceptance and
- 1:18:00commitment therapy which talks in
- 1:18:02non-religious secular ways about really
- 1:18:06acceptance and living a values-based
- 1:18:08life and is completely resonating with
- 1:18:10people because what happens at some
- 1:18:12point in psychotherapy is you encounter
- 1:18:14a problem that's just simply not
- 1:18:16solvable. It's not solvable. No amount
- 1:18:18of Prozac and no amount of psychotherapy
- 1:18:21is going to change the facts of your
- 1:18:23life. What do you do then? That's where
- 1:18:26I think spirituality comes in. It's like
- 1:18:28from the heart of human helplessness.
- 1:18:31How do we endure and continue on when we
- 1:18:35can't change the reality of our
- 1:18:36existence? And spirituality is is
- 1:18:39absolutely huge there.
- 1:18:41>> Yeah. I get um let's just say frustrated
- 1:18:45when spirituality gets cast by uh very
- 1:18:50accomplished people as low IQ.
- 1:18:52>> Yeah.
- 1:18:52>> I mean let's just be really direct here,
- 1:18:54right? It's seen as like people will
- 1:18:56believe things that they're told if they
- 1:18:58have low IQ. And so if they're believing
- 1:19:01in something for which you can't present
- 1:19:02me absolute evidence, they people like,
- 1:19:05"Oh, that's like for dumb people."
- 1:19:07>> That's that's kind of the stance, right?
- 1:19:09>> Yes. And then you look at people's lives
- 1:19:12and you get a a closer look. And I I
- 1:19:15don't take any pleasure in people's, you
- 1:19:16know, unfortunate circumstances or
- 1:19:18discomfort and and you start to realize
- 1:19:20like often times the people saying that
- 1:19:21are the people with the most with some
- 1:19:24issues in their life. I mean actually I
- 1:19:26don't want to reference my book but I
- 1:19:28will just say that in the introduction I
- 1:19:29talk about a colleague of ours who was a
- 1:19:31this was down at the Sulk Institute who
- 1:19:33was member of the National Academy of
- 1:19:35Sciences incredible scientist and he
- 1:19:37because of a back surgery developed a a
- 1:19:39really bad oxy addiction. Um then his
- 1:19:42brother passed and then he like died. I
- 1:19:44still don't know if he overdosed, if he
- 1:19:46took his own life, if he died like no
- 1:19:48one no one was willing to talk about it.
- 1:19:49And I went to many colleagues and like
- 1:19:51hey like what happened to this person?
- 1:19:53And they're like, "Yeah, uh, it was like
- 1:19:55literally like these are people who can
- 1:19:57talk about anything. They're hyper
- 1:19:58articulate, right? If I had said like,
- 1:20:00oh, like tell me what's going on with
- 1:20:01like plexin receptors in the developing
- 1:20:03hippoc campus." They're like, they can
- 1:20:05tell you.
- 1:20:05>> Yeah.
- 1:20:05>> But you go like, "What's going on in
- 1:20:07your life?" They can tell you, but you
- 1:20:08go, "Let's let's talk about this."
- 1:20:09>> Yeah.
- 1:20:10>> And it's as if the circuits that we
- 1:20:12understand thanks to your work and
- 1:20:14others like Malanka and others, it's
- 1:20:16like we we don't actually think they
- 1:20:18apply to us,
- 1:20:19>> right? in some way that it's almost like
- 1:20:21if we were to go there, it makes us more
- 1:20:24mortal.
- 1:20:24>> Yeah.
- 1:20:25>> So, I feel like there's also in in this
- 1:20:27thing about spirituality, in this um
- 1:20:29kind of aversion to thinking about it
- 1:20:31for some people, it's also to
- 1:20:33acknowledge that we're not in complete
- 1:20:34control is also to acknowledge that
- 1:20:35we're going to die.
- 1:20:37>> Yes.
- 1:20:37>> Which I actually believe is at the root
- 1:20:39of all addictions. Like, like it's a
- 1:20:41it's scary as hell. Like, we're going to
- 1:20:43die. We don't know what happens after.
- 1:20:44It's got to be terrifying. So we started
- 1:20:46doing all this stuff in between now and
- 1:20:47then to try and control
- 1:20:49>> which is kind of the essence of this
- 1:20:51whole thing.
- 1:20:51>> Yeah. It's all the different levels of
- 1:20:53denial, right? There's denial about my
- 1:20:55addictive behaviors, but then there's
- 1:20:57the everyday denial that we all engage
- 1:20:59in most of the time, which is, yep, I
- 1:21:01could die today. Like this could I could
- 1:21:03walk out of here, get hit by a truck,
- 1:21:05that's it, I'm gone. And that
- 1:21:07proposition
- 1:21:09is, you know, can be terrifying, but it
- 1:21:12becomes more terrifying the more we
- 1:21:14avoid it, right? [clears throat] Whereas
- 1:21:16if we actually look at that and let that
- 1:21:20inform our lives, it becomes less scary.
- 1:21:23And of course, that that's true for so
- 1:21:25much of our pain and our suffering. And
- 1:21:26that is at the core of surrender, too.
- 1:21:28And part what we're surrendering to is
- 1:21:30we're not running away from that
- 1:21:32anymore. We're turning and we're saying,
- 1:21:34"Yeah, that's true. that's really the
- 1:21:37truth and I'm I'm afraid you know or I'm
- 1:21:40anxious or you know I'm I'm sad or
- 1:21:43whatever it is we like embrace that
- 1:21:46affective experience
- 1:21:49and yet in doing that paradoxically we
- 1:21:51get some respit from the suffering so
- 1:21:54again it's just this fascinating you
- 1:21:56know surrender paradox
- 1:21:58>> let's talk about crisis when
- 1:22:00everything's falling apart
- 1:22:02>> yes
- 1:22:02>> we want to fix it
- 1:22:04>> yes
- 1:22:05>> we want to know how long it's going to
- 1:22:06last, when it'll be fixed.
- 1:22:08>> Uh you're suggesting a potentially
- 1:22:10different uh set of solutions.
- 1:22:12>> Well, I mean, the modern crisis is
- 1:22:15really a crisis of the will because
- 1:22:16we've gotten so used to control so much
- 1:22:18in our lives that now even the the
- 1:22:21merest amount of uncertainty sends us
- 1:22:24into crisis. And essentially, a crisis
- 1:22:28of the will is a narcissistic injury.
- 1:22:30And the narcissistic defense is rage,
- 1:22:33denial, and doubling down on control.
- 1:22:35And that's typically where we are. And
- 1:22:38that's also kind of the heart of what
- 1:22:4012step says is at the core of the
- 1:22:42disease of addiction. Self-will run
- 1:22:43riot, right? So, it's these things that
- 1:22:46I can't control that I'm trying to
- 1:22:47control. Now, there are other things
- 1:22:48over here that I can control. I'm
- 1:22:50actually ignoring those because I'd
- 1:22:52rather focus on these things I can't
- 1:22:54control. And that just gets us to a much
- 1:22:56worse place ultimately to this place of
- 1:22:59modern despair which I characterize as
- 1:23:01again paralyzing anxiety, self-loathing
- 1:23:04shame, loneliness and this nihilistic
- 1:23:06boredom. And from there we can get stuck
- 1:23:10in that place and many many of us do or
- 1:23:14we can acknowledge the limits of our
- 1:23:16control and become you know embedded and
- 1:23:19a part of porous with the greater
- 1:23:23universe which is a very different
- 1:23:25worldview than the kind of rational
- 1:23:27materialist worldview of I'm going to
- 1:23:30hold the world in the palm of my hand
- 1:23:31and shape shape it into whatever I want
- 1:23:33it to be. [snorts]
- 1:23:35And with that spiritual pivot, that
- 1:23:37acceptance, that surrender, we access,
- 1:23:41you know, our own innate ability to
- 1:23:44transcend suffering. We rightsize our
- 1:23:47place in the universe. Um, I mean, this
- 1:23:49and these are, you know, all of the
- 1:23:50major religions as and philosophies.
- 1:23:53It's it's really the same basic concept.
- 1:23:56In terms of everyday practice, I really
- 1:24:00recommend that people pray, even if
- 1:24:02they're not sure they believe in a
- 1:24:04higher power. And I think all that's
- 1:24:06really required for prayer is just
- 1:24:08simply admitting the limits of our
- 1:24:10control and asking for help from a power
- 1:24:13outside of ourselves. I don't think you
- 1:24:15need to further define it. uh just an
- 1:24:18acknowledgement that yeah like I'm not
- 1:24:19running the show and when I try to run
- 1:24:22the show it doesn't go well or at least
- 1:24:24it can go seriously arrive and also it
- 1:24:27becomes a way to ignore the things I I
- 1:24:29can actually have agency over which is
- 1:24:32why one of the most important things I
- 1:24:34tell myself and my patients is do the
- 1:24:37next right thing that is a core piece of
- 1:24:40radical surrender because instead of
- 1:24:42trying to engineer some distant future
- 1:24:45I'm owning that I I have no idea what
- 1:24:47the future holds, right? I don't have
- 1:24:49control over that. But I probably do
- 1:24:51have control right now over whether I
- 1:24:52take out the garbage. So I can take out
- 1:24:54the garbage. That's something that I can
- 1:24:56do. And I really believe that positive
- 1:24:59change happens in human communities when
- 1:25:03we are each of us doing the next right
- 1:25:06thing one day at a time and then
- 1:25:08stringing good days together into good
- 1:25:10weeks, good months, and good years. so
- 1:25:12that we sort of find ourselves in a good
- 1:25:15place that we couldn't have engineered
- 1:25:17on our own. But it is it again this
- 1:25:20concatenation of doing the next right
- 1:25:22thing that that has become really core
- 1:25:25to my own spiritual practice and again
- 1:25:27you find it expressed in different ways
- 1:25:29you know values-based life values driven
- 1:25:32life uh the stoics in order to live in
- 1:25:34accordance with God we live in
- 1:25:36accordance with nature we must pursue
- 1:25:37virtue so that's really key the other
- 1:25:40thing I think that's really central to
- 1:25:43the disease of addiction and also has
- 1:25:45been one of the key things I've grappled
- 1:25:47with in my life is the problem of
- 1:25:50codependency. So where we are not just
- 1:25:52trying to control our be our own
- 1:25:54behaviors, we're actually trying to
- 1:25:56control other people's behaviors and
- 1:25:58we're sort of using people other people
- 1:26:01as our drug of choice as the way that we
- 1:26:05manage our own emotions. And this is a
- 1:26:08well-known phenomenon in addicted
- 1:26:10families where loved ones can actually
- 1:26:12in the spirit of the professed spirit of
- 1:26:15trying to help their addicted loved one,
- 1:26:17they actually become enablers because
- 1:26:19they become caught up in the same rigid
- 1:26:21family system. So for me, you know,
- 1:26:24after my own kind of spiritual pivot and
- 1:26:27my decision to just try to live a
- 1:26:28surrendered life, taking it one day at a
- 1:26:30time, one of the hugest parts of the
- 1:26:34relief for me was the thinking that
- 1:26:37okay, well, if if my higher higher power
- 1:26:40is taking care of me, then my higher
- 1:26:43power is also taking care of the people
- 1:26:46that I love. So I can stop doing all of
- 1:26:49that, you know. I I can stop sort of
- 1:26:51trying to manage their experience
- 1:26:54because so much of my burden without
- 1:26:56even really consciously realizing it was
- 1:26:58like trying to manage your impression of
- 1:27:00me right right now or manage your
- 1:27:03listeners and what it's like I I I have
- 1:27:05no control over that. [laughter] I don't
- 1:27:07know what you're going to think about
- 1:27:08this conversation after you go home or
- 1:27:10what any of your listeners are going to
- 1:27:11think. So I I I I don't I'm not trying
- 1:27:14right I I'm just what are the things
- 1:27:16that I believe you know how can I be
- 1:27:18truthful and honest and try to
- 1:27:19communicate clear that's all I can do I
- 1:27:22can only show up and do that but for me
- 1:27:25that has been one of the greatest gifts
- 1:27:27of sort of radical surrender or this
- 1:27:29spiritual pivot is like
- 1:27:32all I can do is just show up for my life
- 1:27:34unfolding and that's all other people
- 1:27:36can do either and and and then we sort
- 1:27:39of come together and then we go go
- 1:27:41apart. You know, I I can't manage their
- 1:27:44experience just like I really can't
- 1:27:47manipulate and control my own. And as a
- 1:27:49parent, all I can tell you is that has
- 1:27:53just made me I've made so many mistakes,
- 1:27:56but whatever mistakes I've made are
- 1:27:58greatly lessened by the practice of
- 1:28:01surrender and knowing that, you know, my
- 1:28:04kids have their lives. They're going to
- 1:28:05make their decisions. They're going to
- 1:28:07have their suffering. I can really only
- 1:28:09be here and bear witness to it and try
- 1:28:11to help if they ask me to help. But
- 1:28:13otherwise, there's really nothing that I
- 1:28:15can do. And I I to me that's just has
- 1:28:18been core to my ability to try to be a
- 1:28:21good parent, but also enjoy parenting.
- 1:28:23>> The letting go process is is um nothing
- 1:28:26short of magic uh in life. Uh I'm a big,
- 1:28:29you know, I've been open about this. I'm
- 1:28:30I'm a big proponent of prayer and not
- 1:28:32just because David Denno's lab at Nor
- 1:28:35Eastern shows that all these health
- 1:28:36benefits. I mean, there's that, too.
- 1:28:38[laughter] But, um, but for the reasons
- 1:28:39that you describe and and others, I
- 1:28:41think there's there's a ton there.
- 1:28:43Again, knowing as I say that that there
- 1:28:46going to be people who are going to
- 1:28:47bristle and be like, "Oh my god." Like,
- 1:28:49really? We were talking about this
- 1:28:50before we uh started recording. I I
- 1:28:52benefit greatly from having no
- 1:28:54religion-based or faith-based trauma.
- 1:28:57>> Like, I grew up in a mixed religion,
- 1:28:59complicated family home. And like I
- 1:29:00don't I don't have any like negative
- 1:29:02experiences to draw on uh there. So, I'm
- 1:29:05coming into it clean. I realize some
- 1:29:07people it's very loaded, right? Stuff
- 1:29:09they had horrible experiences, traumatic
- 1:29:11experiences, or it just was like
- 1:29:13force-fed to them in a way that that
- 1:29:15makes it harder for them to digest a
- 1:29:17conversation like this, right? It would
- 1:29:19be like having an abusive like track
- 1:29:21coach and we're telling everyone how
- 1:29:22like great running is, you know? It's
- 1:29:24like it's a different for them.
- 1:29:25[laughter] So, I I acknowledge that.
- 1:29:27But, you know, I was I was just having
- 1:29:31this this thought as you were talking
- 1:29:32about the the letting go and in
- 1:29:35particular the codependency. We've never
- 1:29:37talked about codependency on on this
- 1:29:39podcast. And the stereotypical model of
- 1:29:42past was you've got an alcohol. You're
- 1:29:45not allowed to call them alcoholics
- 1:29:46anymore. Sorry, I no longer tap dancer.
- 1:29:48I don't know all the nomenclature.
- 1:29:50>> There's a guy who's an alcoholic. He
- 1:29:52drinks too much. He meets all the
- 1:29:53criteria for alcoholism. Yes, he has
- 1:29:55another identity. But then the the
- 1:29:58stereotypical picture was then he's got
- 1:30:00a wife who is codependent or a partner
- 1:30:03who's codependent. She gets something
- 1:30:05out of the fact that he's essentially
- 1:30:07chemically disabled in certain ways. He
- 1:30:09gets something out of the fact that she
- 1:30:11keeps pouring his drink or
- 1:30:14>> helps him with his denial or makes
- 1:30:15excuses like that was the old model. And
- 1:30:18when PM melody I think was the one of
- 1:30:19the first people to coin this phrase of
- 1:30:21codependency
- 1:30:22>> that it was very much couched in those
- 1:30:24terms. But nowadays, I see codependency
- 1:30:27in men, in women, around in parenttokid
- 1:30:30relationships, in pretty much in every
- 1:30:32direction, right? You've got someone
- 1:30:34maybe she's the super overachiever and
- 1:30:37he's the stay-at-home dad who resents
- 1:30:40her but does it anyway, but it allows
- 1:30:42him to never have to challenge himself
- 1:30:43in a work environment. You can see so
- 1:30:45many iterations of this. So, if we
- 1:30:47could, may we just drill into
- 1:30:48codependency a little bit because I
- 1:30:50think it's so common.
- 1:30:51>> Yes.
- 1:30:52>> And it's really its own form of
- 1:30:53addiction.
- 1:30:53>> Yes, absolutely. And I mention all of
- 1:30:55that backdrop because I think that still
- 1:30:57to this day people hear codependency and
- 1:30:59they default to the the inaccurate sort
- 1:31:02of classic stereotype.
- 1:31:04>> Well, I think it's it's evolving. So it
- 1:31:06really originated in the early days of
- 1:31:08Alcoholics Anonymous in the 1930s as the
- 1:31:10mostly men got together and had their
- 1:31:12Alcoholics Anonymous meetings. Their
- 1:31:14wives got together and had their own
- 1:31:17meetings which eventually became Alanon
- 1:31:19which is a 12step group for the loved
- 1:31:23ones of people with an alcohol
- 1:31:25addiction. And there there are many
- 1:31:27different forms of it today.
- 1:31:28Codependency Anonymous, Pia. Melody has
- 1:31:30done beautiful work in this space,
- 1:31:32others as well, writing about how people
- 1:31:36get caught up and inshed in an addictive
- 1:31:38family system. And then even, you know,
- 1:31:41when they think they're being helpful or
- 1:31:43trying to get their loved one to stop
- 1:31:44using, yes, they're on some level either
- 1:31:46literally or metaphorically pouring the
- 1:31:48drink.
- 1:31:50But codependency, I agree with you. I
- 1:31:53think it's become a much bigger problem.
- 1:31:57And even in families where there's not
- 1:32:00clearly an identifiable
- 1:32:02um addicted person, you know, I would
- 1:32:04posit because we're all on some level
- 1:32:07now addicted to control. Um it is a
- 1:32:11natural extension for us to now be
- 1:32:14trying to control the people around us.
- 1:32:16And I'm just going to talk about two
- 1:32:18very specific examples. One is the way
- 1:32:22that parenting now is so focused on
- 1:32:25achievement and skills acquisition. It
- 1:32:28is very hard to be a parent now and not
- 1:32:31be narcissistically invested in your
- 1:32:34child's achievement. I mean, I I'm
- 1:32:35speaking from my own experience here and
- 1:32:37and I work on these things in myself on
- 1:32:39a regular basis and yet still get pulled
- 1:32:42in, you know, like, oh, how did the race
- 1:32:44go? You know, it's like I want to hear
- 1:32:46that my kid won, right? What grade did
- 1:32:48you get? And it's horrible. It's
- 1:32:49horrible. I wish I weren't caught up and
- 1:32:51I try to resist it. My kids can feel it
- 1:32:53when I'm like, you know,
- 1:32:54narcissistically attached to a certain
- 1:32:56outcome or I'm obsessively worried about
- 1:32:58my kids, right? And and then wanting,
- 1:33:01you know, in that OCD loop, wanting
- 1:33:03reassurance that they're okay, getting
- 1:33:05reassurance, being calm for two seconds,
- 1:33:09and then needing more reassurance, which
- 1:33:10is the OCD loop. The reassurance seeking
- 1:33:13actually makes it worse. But these
- 1:33:15really any way in which we
- 1:33:18rely on other people to have a certain
- 1:33:22kind of reaction or a response in order
- 1:33:25for us to be okay. Right? So and when we
- 1:33:29don't get the response that we want,
- 1:33:31i.e. control, we become emotionally
- 1:33:34disregulated. And the technology has
- 1:33:37made all of this much worse. So all of
- 1:33:40this technology that we have to like
- 1:33:41track each other and to know what so-
- 1:33:43and so is doing here online and what
- 1:33:45what the quants were on that. You would
- 1:33:48think that all of those numbers and all
- 1:33:50of that track like we'd be so calm and
- 1:33:52peaceful because no we're we're more
- 1:33:54neurotic than ever. It's like now we're
- 1:33:57constantly checking. Oh, did that person
- 1:33:59text me back? Why didn't they text me
- 1:34:00back? Why did I why did I just get a
- 1:34:02pink heart emoji and not a red heart
- 1:34:04emoji? I mean it it we're all now caught
- 1:34:07up in this kind of constant reactivity.
- 1:34:11We've lost the ground of ourselves.
- 1:34:13We've lost that spiritual tether to our
- 1:34:17transcendent selves, right? We're just
- 1:34:19all caught up in this kind of co
- 1:34:21constant codependent loop. And it's just
- 1:34:23such a it's a terrible place to land.
- 1:34:25>> I know so many people that are
- 1:34:27codependent with addicts.
- 1:34:29>> Yes. And you know, we all have to ask
- 1:34:31ourselves like, you know, like uh like I
- 1:34:34have the Furbo thing to monitor my dog,
- 1:34:36>> right?
- 1:34:38And it's actually worse. We were on
- 1:34:39vacation this summer in Europe and and
- 1:34:41at one point my girlfriend and I were
- 1:34:42like, "Let's not look at it because then
- 1:34:44we see it and then we're like, "Oh, does
- 1:34:45he have enough water? Is he warm enough?
- 1:34:47Is he cold?" It's better if we just
- 1:34:48don't know. That's right. You just don't
- 1:34:49want to know at some level, but of
- 1:34:51course, you want him to be comfortable.
- 1:34:52So there it's it's different than
- 1:34:54addiction at some level because it isn't
- 1:34:56this obvious like harm to sell for
- 1:34:58others. It's more it's more subtle.
- 1:35:01>> I disagree. It's more cryptic. Excuse
- 1:35:02me. Yeah. It's more cryptic hidden.
- 1:35:04>> And of course we're the martyrs, you
- 1:35:07know, we're sacrificing oursel for the
- 1:35:08other. But I I think it's
- 1:35:10>> I think it's just as addictive, just as
- 1:35:12harmful and pernicious. And the amazing
- 1:35:15thing is that in clinical care, what you
- 1:35:17see in a family when you get the
- 1:35:21codependent person in that family to let
- 1:35:24go and just just surrender and just
- 1:35:27start going to Alanon meetings or
- 1:35:29codependency anonymous and and like take
- 1:35:31care of themselves and just say case
- 1:35:34saras with my loved one who's add what
- 1:35:38happens of course you know what happens
- 1:35:40as soon as the codependent lets go this
- 1:35:42person gets into recovery.
- 1:35:44or starts to make the moves. It's like
- 1:35:46when you're pulling on the opposite
- 1:35:48sides of the same rope, you're not going
- 1:35:49to get anywhere. You drop that one end.
- 1:35:52Oh, they're not pulling on anymore. I
- 1:35:53guess I'll drop the rope, too, and
- 1:35:54maybe, you know, go get into some
- 1:35:56recovery. I mean, it it it like
- 1:35:58clockwork. Like absolute clockwork.
- 1:36:01>> Based on our uh mutual colleague uh Carl
- 1:36:04Des's words at one point, uh by the way,
- 1:36:07congratulations Carl for winning a Nobel
- 1:36:08Prize. So deserved. So deserved. It was
- 1:36:11only a matter of when, not if. Yes.
- 1:36:13>> Once I heard him give a a lecture and he
- 1:36:16said, "We don't have any idea how other
- 1:36:18people feel. In fact, most of the time
- 1:36:20we don't even know how we feel." And
- 1:36:21ever since then, I've tried tried I fail
- 1:36:24often, but tried to stay out of other
- 1:36:26people's heads
- 1:36:28>> to just not even
- 1:36:29>> try and understand what they might be
- 1:36:31thinking. Now, some people could say
- 1:36:32that's, you know, like that's what we're
- 1:36:34supposed to do. We want to be empathic,
- 1:36:36but not what they're feeling or what
- 1:36:38they're expressing they need or maybe uh
- 1:36:41non-verbbally expressing, but like
- 1:36:42really try and stay out of other
- 1:36:44people's heads.
- 1:36:44>> Yeah.
- 1:36:45>> Especially when there's nothing to do
- 1:36:46about it.
- 1:36:47>> That's right.
- 1:36:47>> But so much of online behavior is about
- 1:36:49trying like people trying to get into
- 1:36:51each other's heads. True.
- 1:36:52>> To be able to control outcomes that are
- 1:36:54really about them.
- 1:36:54>> Yeah. Or just spin narratives that like
- 1:36:57have a causal chain that is satisfying
- 1:36:59for them. No, you're absolutely right.
- 1:37:01One of the biggest mistakes that I make
- 1:37:04in my work as a psychiatrist and a
- 1:37:06therapist is when I mind readad. Instead
- 1:37:09of asking what the patient is
- 1:37:11experiencing, I assume I know. That's
- 1:37:13often, especially if somehow they're
- 1:37:15similar to me in some way, you know, a
- 1:37:17middle-aged woman who's, I don't know,
- 1:37:19you know, working in academia, and I I
- 1:37:21assume that I know what their operating
- 1:37:22system looks at. Disaster. Absolute
- 1:37:25disaster. Because you just, you never
- 1:37:26know. And unless you ask people and you
- 1:37:30really attend to and listen and they're
- 1:37:33willing to share, you just can't know.
- 1:37:35>> I have a friend, he's got three decades
- 1:37:38plus in sobriety and uh he has this
- 1:37:40great saying, you know, occasionally
- 1:37:42he'll say something and someone will ask
- 1:37:44him like, "Well, are you sure this?" And
- 1:37:46he always just says,
- 1:37:48>> "I don't speak in riddles." [laughter]
- 1:37:50>> It's so good. It's like he really just
- 1:37:52like he's like he's like don't even try
- 1:37:54and get get me to second guess my
- 1:37:56thinking about. He's like I don't speak
- 1:37:58in riddles. And I love it. I love it
- 1:38:00because it's it's like there's this
- 1:38:01tendency in all of us codependent or not
- 1:38:04to just try and understand a bit more
- 1:38:06about what someone might be thinking so
- 1:38:08that you can anticipate outcomes. It's
- 1:38:10like this limiting uncertainty thing.
- 1:38:12>> Oh yeah. I mean a lot of the conflict in
- 1:38:14my own marriage I generally speaking
- 1:38:15have a very good marriage. I'm very
- 1:38:16grateful for a husband who's much ser
- 1:38:18than I am at baseline. Uh, but the the
- 1:38:21recurring conflict is when I assume that
- 1:38:25he knows what I'm thinking, right?
- 1:38:26[clears throat] And just like, well, I
- 1:38:28mean, or or I assume that I know what
- 1:38:30he's thinking. And he's like, no, that's
- 1:38:32not what I was thinking. It's like, but
- 1:38:34that's what you always think in these
- 1:38:35situations. Well, it wasn't what I was
- 1:38:36thinking in this video. It's like,
- 1:38:39>> we are wild creatures, aren't we? That
- 1:38:41we think we know what our
- 1:38:43>> spouses or dogs or kids or whatever are
- 1:38:46thinking, much less somebody on the
- 1:38:47internet. I'd like to take a quick break
- 1:38:50and acknowledge one of our sponsors,
- 1:38:52Element. Element is an electrolyte drink
- 1:38:54that has everything you need and nothing
- 1:38:56you don't. That means the electrolytes,
- 1:38:58sodium, magnesium, and potassium, all in
- 1:39:00the correct ratios, but no sugar. Proper
- 1:39:03hydration is critical for brain and body
- 1:39:05function. Even a slight degree of
- 1:39:07dehydration can diminish your cognitive
- 1:39:09and physical performance. It's also
- 1:39:11important that you get adequate
- 1:39:12electrolytes. The electrolytes, sodium,
- 1:39:14magnesium, and potassium are vital for
- 1:39:17the functioning of all cells in your
- 1:39:18body, especially your neurons or your
- 1:39:20nerve cells. Drinking Element makes it
- 1:39:22very easy to ensure that you're getting
- 1:39:24adequate hydration and adequate
- 1:39:26electrolytes. My days tend to start
- 1:39:28really fast, meaning I have to jump
- 1:39:30right into work or right into exercise.
- 1:39:32So, to make sure that I'm hydrated and I
- 1:39:34have sufficient electrolytes, when I
- 1:39:36first wake up in the morning, I drink 16
- 1:39:37to 32 ounces of water with an element
- 1:39:40packet dissolved in it. I also drink
- 1:39:42Element dissolved in water during any
- 1:39:43kind of physical exercise that I'm
- 1:39:45doing, especially on hot days when I'm
- 1:39:47sweating a lot and losing water and
- 1:39:48electrolytes. Element has a bunch of
- 1:39:50great tasting flavors. In fact, I love
- 1:39:52them all. I love the watermelon, the
- 1:39:54raspberry, the citrus, and I really love
- 1:39:55the lemonade flavor. So, if you'd like
- 1:39:57to try Element, you can go to
- 1:39:59drinkelement.com/huberman
- 1:40:01to claim a free element sample pack with
- 1:40:03any purchase. Again, that's
- 1:40:05drinkelement.com/huberman
- 1:40:07to claim a free sample pack. I'd like to
- 1:40:10dispel some myths if in fact they're not
- 1:40:12true. One of the common myths about
- 1:40:15codependency is that it's women more
- 1:40:16often than men and men are are more
- 1:40:18often the classic addicts. Is that true?
- 1:40:22>> Well, I can say that in all honesty
- 1:40:24clinically when I see families that
- 1:40:28dynamic is relatively true. So mothers
- 1:40:33tend to be more caught up in this
- 1:40:36codependent enshment and enabling and
- 1:40:39fathers tend to withdraw and be
- 1:40:41detached. That's a pretty common dynamic
- 1:40:44with addiction.
- 1:40:45>> Detach from the addict.
- 1:40:46>> Detached from the whole kitten
- 1:40:49kaboodleoodle the all detach from all
- 1:40:51the crazy.
- 1:40:52>> Just like up there spinning over here
- 1:40:54and I'm on my computer.
- 1:40:56>> So in that sense not a whole lot's
- 1:40:58changed. Well, I I don't have numbers,
- 1:41:00but just in terms of yeah, clinically
- 1:41:02what I see that there are gender
- 1:41:05patterns and and I do think that,
- 1:41:07>> you know, by virtue of how women are
- 1:41:10wired a little bit differently than men
- 1:41:13that we will have a tendency to get more
- 1:41:16caught up in these codependent
- 1:41:19kinds of maladaptive cycles. Makes
- 1:41:22sense, right? In order to care for an
- 1:41:24infant child, you essentially have to
- 1:41:26merge with that child. the child is
- 1:41:28utterly helpless, you know. And then
- 1:41:30Winnott talks about the good enough
- 1:41:31mother. The good enough mother is the
- 1:41:33mother who can initially attend to every
- 1:41:35need that the child has and then as time
- 1:41:38goes on gently kind of, you know,
- 1:41:41restrain herself from meeting every need
- 1:41:43so that the child has the opportunity to
- 1:41:46differentiate and begin to experience
- 1:41:49the world autonomously through their own
- 1:41:51agency, not just related to the mother.
- 1:41:54If you can't do that as a mother, that
- 1:41:56that's generally not good for your
- 1:41:58child. Whereas a man has a very
- 1:42:00different biological role early on. And
- 1:42:02so I think the challenges later are
- 1:42:04different.
- 1:42:05>> Yeah. What's that saying from uh
- 1:42:07recovery? It's like when the uh when the
- 1:42:09addict gets sober, uh the sick get
- 1:42:12angry.
- 1:42:13>> Yes.
- 1:42:13>> You know, like you'll see somebody get
- 1:42:14sober and their spouse
- 1:42:16>> or other family member gets really angry
- 1:42:18because their codependency no longer has
- 1:42:20a place to go. You would think, oh,
- 1:42:22they're sober now. Yeah,
- 1:42:23>> they're like they'd be so happy about
- 1:42:24this, but they think they're going to be
- 1:42:26left behind
- 1:42:27>> that there's a lot of fear that comes up
- 1:42:29for people.
- 1:42:29>> Absolutely. Well, I mean it this is this
- 1:42:31is such a common pattern um where when
- 1:42:35the identified sick person in the family
- 1:42:38gets well, like the identified addict
- 1:42:40gets into recovery, all of a sudden the
- 1:42:42other person's like substance use
- 1:42:44disorder kind of blossomed. So, in a
- 1:42:47way, this person being addicted sort of
- 1:42:49helped this person keep their own
- 1:42:51substance use in check. and now this
- 1:42:52person's better. But even more
- 1:42:54importantly, as a family system, what do
- 1:42:57you do when the person who is the
- 1:42:59identified sick person isn't really sick
- 1:43:01anymore? Then then it destabilizes
- 1:43:03everything because it's like, well, if
- 1:43:04all of our problems were related to
- 1:43:06you're being sick and you're not sick
- 1:43:07anymore, what what you know, how do we
- 1:43:10manage that? And so that's really
- 1:43:12interesting to see.
- 1:43:12>> What are some of the steps people can
- 1:43:14take to get out of codependent thinking
- 1:43:16or action? You know, again, it's sort of
- 1:43:19the key steps of surrendering control
- 1:43:22over the things that we can't control,
- 1:43:24shouldn't control, and the harder we try
- 1:43:26to control, the worse we make it. And
- 1:43:28then for you know for those for whom
- 1:43:30it's appropriate kind of that spiritual
- 1:43:32pivot you know is can be very helpful
- 1:43:34looking for guidance and sucker and
- 1:43:38strength and wisdom from a power outside
- 1:43:41of yourself however you may define that
- 1:43:43and reeregulating around that rather
- 1:43:46than regulating your emotions around how
- 1:43:50this person is doing on any given day or
- 1:43:52in any given moment because that's what
- 1:43:53ends up happen. Oh today he didn't drink
- 1:43:55I'm feeling better. Oh he drank I feel
- 1:43:56terrible. you know, it's it's all in
- 1:43:58meshed. So, and then of course 12 steps
- 1:44:01for um people with codependency is is
- 1:44:04really really helpful. There are
- 1:44:06wonderful 12step meetings, you know, in
- 1:44:09in our community. I I've been to, you
- 1:44:11know, some of them, especially for
- 1:44:13parents of kids with se I mean, it's
- 1:44:15just devastating to have a child who's
- 1:44:16addicted and really severely addicted
- 1:44:19might die, you know. I mean, how do you
- 1:44:21how do you self-regulate around that?
- 1:44:23Very hard. But uh codependency anonymous
- 1:44:25alanon very very helpful for those types
- 1:44:28of things.
- 1:44:28>> Yeah. So about youth and addiction being
- 1:44:3151 I can remember a time before social
- 1:44:35media uh obviously but there's a whole
- 1:44:37generation of people whose brains were
- 1:44:39literally shaped around their reward
- 1:44:42circuitry was shaped around interaction
- 1:44:45with devices and and the reward
- 1:44:47contingencies of scrolling or whatever
- 1:44:48it is. Is it much harder for them to get
- 1:44:51out of an addictive trench than it is
- 1:44:53for somebody who has engaged with those
- 1:44:55things less? I mean, I don't think
- 1:44:58anybody's formally studied that, but I
- 1:45:01think we could certainly hypothesize
- 1:45:04that living in the digital age when
- 1:45:06we're constantly in seeking validation,
- 1:45:09um, reacting to digital stimuli, there's
- 1:45:12very little kind of centering or
- 1:45:15contemplative or prayer practices
- 1:45:16happening when we're, you know, in this
- 1:45:19digital vortex. And again, I I I would
- 1:45:22argue that these machines have massively
- 1:45:24decreased our tolerance for uncertainty
- 1:45:26and our tolerance for imperfection,
- 1:45:28right? Because AI holds out the promise
- 1:45:31that there's the exact right answer out
- 1:45:33there if you just keep scrolling and
- 1:45:36looking and querying long enough. So, I
- 1:45:38do think that this this generation, you
- 1:45:41know, their brains have really been
- 1:45:43shaped in a very different way, leading
- 1:45:45to, you know, different types of
- 1:45:47struggles. I don't know if you get into
- 1:45:49this in the book, but uh recently
- 1:45:51because of some guests we've had on the
- 1:45:53podcast, Michael Pollen, Paul Stammits,
- 1:45:55and others that it used to be that young
- 1:45:57people u boys and girls would go through
- 1:46:00some [clears throat] um kind of uh
- 1:46:01rights of passage
- 1:46:03>> and often times those rights of passage
- 1:46:05were about in a in a safe way, in a
- 1:46:08healthy way, taking away all sense of
- 1:46:10control. Like they don't get to decide
- 1:46:12when a ritual starts and ends. It's not
- 1:46:14like, hey, I have to get up and use the
- 1:46:15bathroom and like like scroll Tik Tok or
- 1:46:17like I want to go eat now. It's like,
- 1:46:18no, they're you sort of give yourself
- 1:46:20over to the
- 1:46:21>> to the to the tribe, so to speak.
- 1:46:23>> The goal being that they learn
- 1:46:26>> to give up control.
- 1:46:27>> Yeah.
- 1:46:28>> And once they do that, it hopefully it
- 1:46:30becomes a state that's familiar enough
- 1:46:32that they they realize that they can
- 1:46:34survive [clears throat] it. It was in
- 1:46:35their best interest in those situations.
- 1:46:37Anyway, is there a way that we can bring
- 1:46:40healthy lack of control ritual and right
- 1:46:43of passage back into American society? I
- 1:46:46mean, what would that even look like?
- 1:46:48>> Yeah, I mean, I think we can get back to
- 1:46:51some of that. I think we absolutely need
- 1:46:54to. And I do think it be it begins with
- 1:46:56at least spending some part of every day
- 1:46:59out from behind our screens. You know,
- 1:47:02go outside, leave your device behind,
- 1:47:05look at the sky, look at the trees, talk
- 1:47:08to a human, make a mistake, apologize,
- 1:47:12keep going. You know, just embrace
- 1:47:15uncertain, do something you're bad at,
- 1:47:17cultivate something you will never ever
- 1:47:19be good at. I do think there's optimism
- 1:47:23and hope here. A lot of Jenzers are with
- 1:47:27intention coming together in spaces
- 1:47:30where they're not on their devices, not
- 1:47:32connected to the internet, playing music
- 1:47:34together, not to become the next pop
- 1:47:36sensation, but just because they're
- 1:47:38enjoying the music. I I was really
- 1:47:41struck recently uh in South Korea
- 1:47:43talking to some folks who are really
- 1:47:46leaning into this sort of like getting
- 1:47:48off their devices, meeting up, you know,
- 1:47:51doing crochet, chatting, having
- 1:47:55unstructured, uncertain interactions,
- 1:47:58not knowing where it's going to go. And
- 1:48:00you know, for all these young people who
- 1:48:01are trying to like optimize for their
- 1:48:03career, optimize their for their
- 1:48:05relationships, I mean, it's terrible
- 1:48:06now. It's like the dating apps, you
- 1:48:08know, oh well, she's nice, but maybe
- 1:48:10there's somebody even better out there
- 1:48:11for me. You know, it's like they they
- 1:48:13never settle because there's always this
- 1:48:15thing I'm I'm there's a perfect person
- 1:48:17and how can I find her, you know, or him
- 1:48:20or whatever the case may be, but you
- 1:48:23know, instead just opening yourself up
- 1:48:25to kind of not knowing what's going to
- 1:48:28be next or maybe the person who's
- 1:48:30exactly right for you is not the person
- 1:48:32you would ever check the boxes on,
- 1:48:35right? So it's again that openness, that
- 1:48:37curiosity,
- 1:48:39show up for the unfolding of experience.
- 1:48:41I think that's really where we need to
- 1:48:43go.
- 1:48:44>> Yeah. These days I play with the idea of
- 1:48:46doing things with no intention of it
- 1:48:49being
- 1:48:50>> put out into the world.
- 1:48:51>> Yes.
- 1:48:52>> Ever.
- 1:48:52>> Yeah.
- 1:48:53>> Deliberately.
- 1:48:54>> Yes.
- 1:48:55>> Like no vaulted. Just because it then
- 1:48:58you can just be in the puress of the
- 1:49:00experience.
- 1:49:00>> Yes. That's right. That's very nice.
- 1:49:02Yeah. And for you such a public persona
- 1:49:04that that kind of space would be really
- 1:49:06important.
- 1:49:06>> Like one of the great gifts of I think a
- 1:49:10healthy relationship to exercise or
- 1:49:11running is you don't tell anyone what
- 1:49:14you did. You just do the workout.
- 1:49:16>> It's not on straa.
- 1:49:17>> It's not exactly. It's you just do it
- 1:49:19like you do it for you and then you just
- 1:49:21get really into the the joy of it. It's
- 1:49:22complicated. I also understand the
- 1:49:24desire to share an accomplishment. I
- 1:49:26[clears throat] mean I think that's
- 1:49:27innately human.
- 1:49:28>> Yeah. And that's okay. Again, it's not,
- 1:49:29you know, one extreme or the or the
- 1:49:32other. It's trying to find that happy
- 1:49:33medium.
- 1:49:34>> Yeah, I'm a hypocrite cuz um if I don't
- 1:49:36acknowledge I have some workouts out on
- 1:49:38the web, but they were trying to be
- 1:49:39educational. But yeah, it's it's there's
- 1:49:41a problem with
- 1:49:43>> adults and kids being able to broadcast
- 1:49:46with essentially no latency,
- 1:49:48>> their emotion,
- 1:49:50>> right,
- 1:49:50>> their feeling. I think it takes the the
- 1:49:52the rawness of the emotion away. I think
- 1:49:54it it just literally goes out there.
- 1:49:56>> It doesn't incubate. you're not
- 1:49:58processing it. You don't have time to
- 1:50:00really sort the meaning of it.
- 1:50:02>> I mean, I'm struck by people who go to
- 1:50:03concerts and then are on their phones at
- 1:50:05the concert,
- 1:50:07>> but I acknowledge that I'm probably just
- 1:50:10getting old. Um, [laughter]
- 1:50:12and happily so. Um, so what are some
- 1:50:16other concepts of of surrender? We
- 1:50:18talked about codependency. We talked
- 1:50:19about you talked about praying even if
- 1:50:22you don't necessarily believe that
- 1:50:24you're praying to something specific.
- 1:50:26>> Right. Right.
- 1:50:27>> I think uh I heard and I don't know if
- 1:50:29this is true. We have to fact check
- 1:50:30this. Internet, do your do your thing.
- 1:50:33Um that Mother Teresa claims that on
- 1:50:36only three
- 1:50:37>> before she died claimed that on only
- 1:50:40three nights of her entire life did she
- 1:50:42did she have a complete absence of doubt
- 1:50:44>> about the existence of God? Which I was
- 1:50:46like, okay, if Mother Teresa had doubts
- 1:50:49>> and could live the way that she did,
- 1:50:51then like I think we're we're all on
- 1:50:52stable ground praying anyway,
- 1:50:54>> right? Yeah.
- 1:50:55>> I don't know if it's true, but I I like
- 1:50:56the story.
- 1:50:57>> Yeah. And I I learned from my friend and
- 1:50:59colleague Kent Dunnington, who's a
- 1:51:01theologian and philosopher, that part of
- 1:51:03the problem is the language that we use,
- 1:51:07that we don't have a verb for fathing.
- 1:51:09Because there is apparently a whole
- 1:51:11tradition of having faith without belief
- 1:51:14or having faith with an enormous amount
- 1:51:16of doubt that you don't need belief in
- 1:51:18order to have faith. It is the practice
- 1:51:21of engaging in this kind of submissive
- 1:51:25surrender, acknowledging the limits,
- 1:51:28acknowledging our great need for
- 1:51:30guidance and and and comfort. You know,
- 1:51:33that is at the core of prayer really.
- 1:51:35It's it's an affective experience uh
- 1:51:38that doesn't require um belief. It just
- 1:51:41requires taking the posture, you know,
- 1:51:44the humble posture and asking for help.
- 1:51:47What are the data, if any, on praying
- 1:51:49for others? Like so often we hear prayer
- 1:51:51and it's like we're praying for this or
- 1:51:53for that or for ourselves, but what
- 1:51:54about because it's common in uh for
- 1:51:57people with a religious um bend to say,
- 1:52:02"I'll pray for you." There's good
- 1:52:03evidence that engaging in that kind of
- 1:52:06prayer for others serves the function of
- 1:52:09changing our mindset
- 1:52:12toward people more broadly and leading
- 1:52:15us to act more pro-socially you know to
- 1:52:19pursue virtue. So I think you know that
- 1:52:22is pretty well established. Also, the
- 1:52:24idea of a sort of um God watching us
- 1:52:27also promotes pro-social behavior. But
- 1:52:31like whether or not our prayer actually
- 1:52:33leads to some material change for some
- 1:52:36person remote for me, I I really don't
- 1:52:39know anything about that. That's not
- 1:52:41something I've really looked at.
- 1:52:42>> In researching the book and spending
- 1:52:44time on on the book, was there anything
- 1:52:46that you encountered where you like,
- 1:52:48whoa, that's wild?
- 1:52:51>> A lot of things. I mean I I was really
- 1:52:54fascinated by the whole like
- 1:52:58spirituality network and the role of
- 1:53:00serotonin.
- 1:53:02Really fascinated by the ways in which
- 1:53:05proverating
- 1:53:06around trying to keep doing the right
- 1:53:09thing and not getting the response we
- 1:53:10need actually is a type of suffering
- 1:53:13that leads to this proliferation of
- 1:53:15serotonin receptors. again as if laying
- 1:53:17the foundation for this pivotal uh
- 1:53:22moment when we will let go of these
- 1:53:24rigid models and be open to something
- 1:53:26new. That was fascinating to me. I was
- 1:53:28struck by how convergent so many
- 1:53:31different religions and philosophies are
- 1:53:33including you know Buddhist practices
- 1:53:35which for some people is religion for
- 1:53:37other people it's more of a psychology
- 1:53:39of philosophy but ultimately again
- 1:53:42wanting to transcend the self wanting to
- 1:53:44have an affective experience that then
- 1:53:46leads to right action that's all sort of
- 1:53:49part of it I was struck by that I really
- 1:53:52enjoyed researching the chapter on
- 1:53:54symbols and synchronicity
- 1:53:57and the ways in which in moments of
- 1:53:59crisis we're all looking for patterns to
- 1:54:03provide a causal explanation for what
- 1:54:06happens. It's just again kind of
- 1:54:08reflexive. We just do it. And certainly
- 1:54:10that that was true for me when our son
- 1:54:13Lucas died. I began having these
- 1:54:16thoughts that he died of leukemia
- 1:54:18because I named him Lucas. So of course
- 1:54:21completely irrational thought. I didn't
- 1:54:23really believe that there was a causal
- 1:54:24relationship. And yet at the same time
- 1:54:27my mind um had produced this kind of
- 1:54:29narrative which again is not comforting
- 1:54:33um you know and and and and was a source
- 1:54:35of distress to me. But this was before
- 1:54:38this spiritual surrender. After the
- 1:54:40spiritual surrender I had a very
- 1:54:41different view on it. I had the view
- 1:54:43that it's a symbol for me that
- 1:54:45represents how it's good for me not to
- 1:54:48always be exerting my control and
- 1:54:51instead [clears throat] letting things
- 1:54:52unfold. So that when we had our
- 1:54:53daughter, I didn't talk about a name. I
- 1:54:57didn't think about a name. And when she
- 1:54:58was born, I just turned to my husband
- 1:54:59and said, "What do you what do you
- 1:55:01think?" And he offered a name and I
- 1:55:03said, "That sounds good to me." So it
- 1:55:06became a symbol for me of of surrender
- 1:55:09of of just trying to let my life unfold
- 1:55:12in this spontaneous organic way, which
- 1:55:15is just just made my life so much
- 1:55:17better.
- 1:55:18>> Yeah, it is wild. We in moments of
- 1:55:21stress and uncertainty, we we
- 1:55:23>> like bumper stickers like can matter all
- 1:55:25of a sudden. We think they're there to
- 1:55:27tell us something for a reason. Like we
- 1:55:29we're looking for symbols. There's and
- 1:55:30then there's this uh I don't like the
- 1:55:32word. Um but there's this what is it? Uh
- 1:55:35periodia, which is like when you look at
- 1:55:38a cloud or an object and it has a shape
- 1:55:40and you see you think oh like that's in
- 1:55:42the shape of this thing. It's like or a
- 1:55:44tree that looks and like people we
- 1:55:46project these ideas onto objects. It's
- 1:55:49insanity. It's like, well, okay.
- 1:55:51>> I don't think it is. I don't think it is
- 1:55:53insanity. So, I I I talked to a lot of
- 1:55:55interviewed a lot of folks and I was
- 1:55:57struck by
- 1:55:58>> especially after a loss um you know, in
- 1:56:01the state of grief. So many people will
- 1:56:03have an experience where they're
- 1:56:05interacting with nature and they see a
- 1:56:07shape in the clouds or they see a bird
- 1:56:09and that bird they think it's maybe
- 1:56:11their loved one or their, you know,
- 1:56:13their deceased loved one talking to them
- 1:56:15or communicating through them. And these
- 1:56:16are like atheists, right? So, we're not
- 1:56:18just talking about sort of people who
- 1:56:20regularly engage in kind of woo woo
- 1:56:22thinking. These are like flatout
- 1:56:24scientists, atheists. They will endorse
- 1:56:26having these experiences. I think it's
- 1:56:28healthy, you know, unless it sort of
- 1:56:30teeters into frank delusions and mental
- 1:56:33illness. It's a way of reminding
- 1:56:35ourselves that there's a greater pattern
- 1:56:37out there and we're all a part of it and
- 1:56:40there's a benevolent structure and and
- 1:56:42and we can take comfort in in these sort
- 1:56:46of symbolic and synchronistic types of
- 1:56:49events and and really just be in awe,
- 1:56:52you know, even if as we rationally know
- 1:56:54that there's no causal relationship
- 1:56:56between these things.
- 1:56:58>> Yeah. There's a thread running through a
- 1:57:00lot of conversations I've had on this
- 1:57:02podcast recently and I just like your
- 1:57:05thoughts on this. So we had Max Crumblon
- 1:57:07who's one of the developers of
- 1:57:08amunotherapy. He's at UCSF. He's an
- 1:57:11immunologist. Uh we've had Michael
- 1:57:13Pollen. He's talking about
- 1:57:14consciousness. We talking the mushroom
- 1:57:16guy Paul Stammits. And you know with
- 1:57:18each of the Robert Green you're here
- 1:57:20with each of these conversations
- 1:57:22something keeps coming up
- 1:57:23>> and that I think is perhaps thematically
- 1:57:25important maybe even provide some
- 1:57:28insight which is like at our core we we
- 1:57:31have an us like you call the ego but
- 1:57:34just like our body us right Anna Andrew
- 1:57:37like and we can become a wei if we say
- 1:57:39oh like we're both at Stanford or we're
- 1:57:41both podcasting like the the the
- 1:57:43flexibility of the Wii is very very
- 1:57:44powerful but the the flexibility of the
- 1:57:47me
- 1:57:48>> for each of us,
- 1:57:49>> for you, for you is not very flexible
- 1:57:53>> inside of psychedelic experiences or
- 1:57:56spiritual awakenings or um birth of a
- 1:57:58child or things that we we feel this
- 1:58:01expansion,
- 1:58:02>> right,
- 1:58:02>> of like me becomes we in some way that
- 1:58:05isn't like a typical affiliation,
- 1:58:08>> right? Like obviously parent to child is
- 1:58:10that but there's so it's dynamic
- 1:58:13>> so much so that we had a like a super
- 1:58:15athlete on here um Ross Edgely and he
- 1:58:17was saying that like when his shoulder
- 1:58:18would start to give out on these like
- 1:58:20excruciatingly long swims he'd be like
- 1:58:22you're coming with me he would
- 1:58:23dissociate from the shoulder like bring
- 1:58:25it along we're still on a team like
- 1:58:27don't quit on me you know but it was
- 1:58:29like it was almost as if it was someone
- 1:58:30else's shoulder or like a a buddy that
- 1:58:32he's like don't quit on me and so in
- 1:58:35thinking about like getting outside of
- 1:58:37ourselves
- 1:58:38It's really I do think it's a way of
- 1:58:40like bypassing the ego
- 1:58:42>> and getting to this notion of like
- 1:58:44you're just opening up to in some cases
- 1:58:47God in some cases the universe and so
- 1:58:49but something outside of you so that
- 1:58:50you're no longer alone
- 1:58:52>> right
- 1:58:52>> you're just no longer alone
- 1:58:54>> and you're relegating your own thinking
- 1:58:57as you've pointed out to
- 1:58:58>> some additional information from out
- 1:59:00there.
- 1:59:01>> Yes.
- 1:59:01>> And it's beautiful and it's clearly
- 1:59:04useful.
- 1:59:05>> Oh yes.
- 1:59:06>> But we hate to do it. Mhm.
- 1:59:07>> at the like we hate to do it until we
- 1:59:09taste the magic, right?
- 1:59:11>> Like why do you think people are so darn
- 1:59:14resistant to it to the point where it
- 1:59:16often like can their well-being?
- 1:59:19I mean, I think a lot of it is modern
- 1:59:21culture where we're very, you know,
- 1:59:23especially western culture, but I would
- 1:59:26say really any capitalist system at this
- 1:59:28point or partially capitalist system,
- 1:59:30which is frankly most systems, very
- 1:59:33individualistic, very focused on
- 1:59:36individual accomplishments. We're more
- 1:59:37and more atomized. You know, as we
- 1:59:40talked about earlier, even the desire to
- 1:59:42be together in a collective is just
- 1:59:44getting harder. More and more people
- 1:59:46physically live alone. Um, I'm not sure
- 1:59:49that this sort of we can be achieved if
- 1:59:53we're just communicating through the
- 1:59:55internet. But also, I would say this is
- 1:59:58an ancient problem. I mean, this is
- 2:00:00essentially,
- 2:00:01you know, the ego as the source of our
- 2:00:03suffering is the foundational belief in
- 2:00:06in Buddhism, right? This idea that the
- 2:00:08self is a delusion. Uh, and yet it's a
- 2:00:11delusion that we're very caught up in.
- 2:00:13uh and when we can let go of that
- 2:00:15delusion, we we e we ease our suffering.
- 2:00:19I think for people who believe in God or
- 2:00:22who think about this higher power
- 2:00:24outside of themselves, it it's the same
- 2:00:26idea but manifested as I am a vessel
- 2:00:29through which God's plan happens um
- 2:00:33rather than which is to me a very
- 2:00:35similar pivot. It's just different
- 2:00:36language, a slightly different
- 2:00:39psychological conceptualization. And I
- 2:00:41think it's great that we have these
- 2:00:42different conceptualizations because not
- 2:00:44everything is going to work for
- 2:00:46everyone. You know, some for some people
- 2:00:47it's going to be the inward meditative
- 2:00:50stance. For other and the mindfulness
- 2:00:52practices, for others it's going to be
- 2:00:54that outward pivot that giving it over
- 2:00:56to a higher power, conceiving of a
- 2:00:59higher power as having an ordered plan
- 2:01:01that we then become a part of. But all
- 2:01:03of that amounts to essentially the same
- 2:01:05things. transcending the self. The self
- 2:01:07being the source of our suffering,
- 2:01:09especially in this age of endemic
- 2:01:11narcissism where, you know, we're
- 2:01:13constantly forced really by the
- 2:01:17technology and by society to focus on
- 2:01:19ourselves.
- 2:01:20>> Well, we've all, at least for those of
- 2:01:21us on social media, we've all been cast
- 2:01:23in a reality TV show. Yeah.
- 2:01:25>> Where it used to be they would pay
- 2:01:27actors to be on shows. It's like then it
- 2:01:30was reality TV, you just kind of like
- 2:01:31give them products and the offer of fame
- 2:01:33and then they'll do it for free.
- 2:01:36people with their time and their own
- 2:01:39TV show that is social media.
- 2:01:45>> Yes. And and the reverse, it's kind of
- 2:01:47wild.
- 2:01:48>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:01:49>> The reason the immunologist Max Crumbl
- 2:01:51was the one who first sparked this this
- 2:01:53line of thinking was because he said,
- 2:01:54you know, the immune system like the
- 2:01:56first thing you have to learn is what's
- 2:01:58of me and what's not of me in order. And
- 2:02:00so it starts at the level of individual
- 2:02:02cells, but then at some point if we're
- 2:02:05so isolated, it's bad for us. Now,
- 2:02:07that's just analogy, but the human mind
- 2:02:09is is really good at at taking concepts
- 2:02:12and and changing ways of living if we're
- 2:02:14super conscious of it. So the problem I
- 2:02:16have with any practice nowadays, any
- 2:02:19practice, is that there's so many other
- 2:02:21counterforces taking us away from that
- 2:02:23healthy practice.
- 2:02:24>> So without getting scripted about how
- 2:02:27people have to do things, right? Um,
- 2:02:29what are some things that you do in
- 2:02:32terms of from when you wake up until you
- 2:02:34go to sleep? Like are you paying
- 2:02:35attention to like certain times of day
- 2:02:36when your mind is more vulnerable to
- 2:02:38getting taken off track? Do you try and
- 2:02:40set the course of your day with certain
- 2:02:42types of thinking or practices as it
- 2:02:44relates to what you've you've covered in
- 2:02:46your books?
- 2:02:46>> Yeah. So, I mean, I I start my day, you
- 2:02:49know, lying in bed with an intentional
- 2:02:51prayer, asking really just help me out
- 2:02:54here. help me, you know, show up the
- 2:02:57best that I can show up and do the next
- 2:02:59right thing. And then I also
- 2:03:01intentionally do not go on any device or
- 2:03:05look at any screen until I have finished
- 2:03:08my morning routine, which usually
- 2:03:09consists of some form of exercise,
- 2:03:11eating breakfast, making my bed,
- 2:03:13brushing my teeth, and kind of preparing
- 2:03:14for my day. Because I find once I go on
- 2:03:17a device, it's a completely different
- 2:03:19wavelength. And then I try to be really
- 2:03:21intentional as I go through the day
- 2:03:23about using my devices as tools and if
- 2:03:27I'm using them for entertainment or to
- 2:03:29change the way I feel that I'm also know
- 2:03:32that I'm doing that and I'm intentional
- 2:03:33about it. I find that for me watching
- 2:03:36moving video is is really a very potent
- 2:03:39drug. So I really try to limit my use of
- 2:03:41video. Reading online auditory
- 2:03:44processing is is much less vulnerable a
- 2:03:47space for me. And then I actually
- 2:03:50practice kind of surrendered practices
- 2:03:52and asking for guidance and help from my
- 2:03:54higher power regularly throughout my
- 2:03:57day. When I'm interacting with my
- 2:03:59children, if I'm seeing a patient and
- 2:04:01I'm not really sure how I can be helpful
- 2:04:03or I feel in doubt or regularly I will
- 2:04:07it's a it's a outward pivot and an
- 2:04:09opening. It's like a, you know, dilation
- 2:04:12rather than, and this is really key for
- 2:04:14me, looking inside myself for the answer
- 2:04:18or relying on my own stories because
- 2:04:21that's where I find I really get into
- 2:04:23trouble.
- 2:04:24>> Before we conclude, I have a few more
- 2:04:25questions about addiction and some
- 2:04:27specific things around it. Ketamine,
- 2:04:30>> not a psychedelic. It's a dissociative
- 2:04:32anesthetic.
- 2:04:33>> What are some of the valid clinical uses
- 2:04:36for ketamine? And where, if any, have
- 2:04:38you seen um challenges, addictions, and
- 2:04:41and serious issues come about with
- 2:04:43ketamine? Because I I think it's
- 2:04:44starting to fall into this kind of
- 2:04:45diffuse and misunderstood category
- 2:04:48>> uh for a lot of people.
- 2:04:49>> So ketamine is FDA approved for the
- 2:04:51treatment of treatment refractory
- 2:04:53depression. And you know, it's good that
- 2:04:57we have new tools and that people have
- 2:05:00access to different types of modalities.
- 2:05:03The concern about ketamine is that it is
- 2:05:06also addictive and that when people are
- 2:05:08given any potentially addictive drug to
- 2:05:10take home and use on their own
- 2:05:12reconnaissance, there's vulnerability
- 2:05:14there. There is something that was
- 2:05:18created by a former mentee of mine,
- 2:05:20Nicholas Guerell, called the Montreal
- 2:05:22model. The Montreal model is a way of
- 2:05:25using ketamine inhouse. So in the
- 2:05:28clinical setting, not to take home, in
- 2:05:30combination with psychotherapy,
- 2:05:33specifically to treat depression, but
- 2:05:35also depression in combination with
- 2:05:38alcohol use disorder. And um Nicholas
- 2:05:41Gerell is seeing really exciting results
- 2:05:43from from this. And let's face it,
- 2:05:46people with treatment refractory alcohol
- 2:05:47use disorder who also are severely
- 2:05:49depressed are a hard population to
- 2:05:52effectively treat. So again, I'm excited
- 2:05:55about these potential uses. You know, we
- 2:05:57need more evidence, but but I think that
- 2:06:00that's a potential future use as well.
- 2:06:02>> But do you have people coming into your
- 2:06:04clinic who are using ketamine
- 2:06:06recreationally and having issues with
- 2:06:07it? Cuz you hear about this or maybe
- 2:06:09hear about it less nowadays. I don't
- 2:06:11know.
- 2:06:11>> We absolutely do. So um we we see people
- 2:06:14get very addicted to ketamine, get it
- 2:06:17from the black market, use you know very
- 2:06:20large amounts, end up with very severe
- 2:06:23psychological and neurological problems.
- 2:06:26We also see people who have no business
- 2:06:29using ketamine to treat depression
- 2:06:32because of their addiction diiathesis
- 2:06:35and their past addiction to ketamine who
- 2:06:37then find a ketamine provider and either
- 2:06:39they don't tell that person that they've
- 2:06:41been addicted to ketamine or that person
- 2:06:43doesn't ask and then they end up getting
- 2:06:45ketamine in that setting and then that
- 2:06:46sets them off. So, it's a it's a
- 2:06:48complicated issue. Certainly anytime a
- 2:06:51doctor is prescribing any addictive
- 2:06:53substance for any illness at all, we
- 2:06:57must keep in mind that
- 2:07:00that individual just because they have
- 2:07:02an illness that might indicate that
- 2:07:06addictive substance doesn't make that
- 2:07:07individual immune to getting addicted.
- 2:07:09So this was the big myth with the opioid
- 2:07:11epidemic, right? As long as you are
- 2:07:13being prescribed opioids for pain,
- 2:07:15you're somehow immune to the problem of
- 2:07:16addiction. Absolutely false. Absolutely
- 2:07:19false. Um, and the same is true for any
- 2:07:22addictive substance, whether it's Xanax
- 2:07:24for anxiety or ketamine for depression
- 2:07:27or stimulants for ADHD.
- 2:07:29You can have all of those bonafide
- 2:07:32conditions and you can still get
- 2:07:33addicted to the medication that you're
- 2:07:36being prescribed to treat that
- 2:07:37condition.
- 2:07:38>> Do you see a lot of stimulant addiction
- 2:07:40nowadays because of the well at the
- 2:07:42extreme end things like Adderall,
- 2:07:44Viveance, etc. But at the like kind of
- 2:07:47more over-the-counter uh level like all
- 2:07:50the consumption of oral nicotine and
- 2:07:52energy drinks is it like kind of it
- 2:07:54seems it's like they're kind of a
- 2:07:56mainstay of life now.
- 2:07:57>> Well, we've seen especially since co is
- 2:07:59an explosion of people getting addicted
- 2:08:01to stimulants that they got online
- 2:08:04through a teleaalth prescriber. So it's
- 2:08:06not that tellaalth is innately bad but
- 2:08:10tellaalth can be done very badly and so
- 2:08:12you get a kind of a pill mill situation
- 2:08:14going via tellahalth uh where there's
- 2:08:17very limited ability to kind of steward
- 2:08:20stimulants and make sure that the person
- 2:08:22number one is you know is really taking
- 2:08:24them as prescribed isn't getting
- 2:08:25addicted to them. So, that's a whole
- 2:08:28Pandora's box that we've opened.
- 2:08:30>> The GLPs,
- 2:08:32>> right?
- 2:08:32>> Um, the only peptide we're going to talk
- 2:08:34about on this uh podcast because we
- 2:08:36won't need to talk about all the others.
- 2:08:37We've done other podcasts about all the
- 2:08:39other peptides. The GLPS uh, you know,
- 2:08:42famous for helping people lose weight by
- 2:08:44reducing appetite, but there's also the
- 2:08:47kind of growing number of reports that
- 2:08:49it might they might reduce alcohol
- 2:08:51craving, cravings of all sorts, maybe
- 2:08:53ahidonia, lack of pleasure generally,
- 2:08:55>> right? What have you observed
- 2:08:57clinically?
- 2:08:58>> So clinically what we are seeing is that
- 2:09:01some of our patients who have severe
- 2:09:02alcohol addiction who have tried and
- 2:09:04failed everything else other
- 2:09:07psychosocial interventions other
- 2:09:08medications some of those patients when
- 2:09:11we put them on a GLP1 they get into
- 2:09:13recovery when nothing else worked. So
- 2:09:15that's very exciting because in general
- 2:09:18what we find is that no matter what the
- 2:09:21tool is it's only going to work for some
- 2:09:23of the people. it's not going to work
- 2:09:24for everybody. And so a new tool like a
- 2:09:27GLP-1 that has a totally new new
- 2:09:29mechanism is going to get people who
- 2:09:32haven't responded to other other
- 2:09:34interventions. And it it's also
- 2:09:36interesting because from a you know
- 2:09:38neuroscience or mechanistic perspective
- 2:09:40it may be working centrally right on the
- 2:09:42reward pathway by decreasing the amount
- 2:09:45of dopamine that's released in the
- 2:09:46nucleus encumbent in response to the
- 2:09:49drug of choice which is very much how
- 2:09:52people describe it working like when
- 2:09:53they're taking GLP1s they will look at
- 2:09:56some donuts if they have food addiction
- 2:09:59or alcohol if it's an alcohol addiction
- 2:10:01and they'll just be like meh you know
- 2:10:03like uh not that interested.
- 2:10:05or they might have euphoric recall for
- 2:10:07how good it's going to taste and they
- 2:10:09taste it and it's like not not really
- 2:10:11that reinforcing which, you know, is
- 2:10:14perfectly consistent with this idea that
- 2:10:16dopamine is our reinforcing reward
- 2:10:18neurotransmitter. The more that's
- 2:10:20released, the faster that it's released,
- 2:10:22the more reinforcing. And now if you
- 2:10:23have a drug that dampens that initial
- 2:10:26release, it's just it's exciting.
- 2:10:29>> Can we be addicted to thoughts?
- 2:10:32>> Most definitely. Um, you know, one of
- 2:10:35the core um features of sex addiction is
- 2:10:39fantasy. As one of my patients put it,
- 2:10:42the bar is in my brain. Uh, what do I do
- 2:10:44in that case? And so, it's interesting.
- 2:10:46I've had patients with severe sex
- 2:10:47addiction who could not get into
- 2:10:49recovery until they stopped fantasizing.
- 2:10:52Yeah. And it it was only that when that
- 2:10:54became their sort of bottom line uh that
- 2:10:57they were able to get into a sustained
- 2:10:59recovery from let's say pornography,
- 2:11:01compulsive masturbation or just sex in
- 2:11:03general. So there's no doubt that our
- 2:11:06thought loops can be both triggers in
- 2:11:09the form of craving and can become to
- 2:11:11some extent the drug itself because we
- 2:11:14know that these cues that precede the
- 2:11:17drug also release dopamine and are
- 2:11:19reinforcing. With the example of sex
- 2:11:21addiction, the fantasizing makes sense
- 2:11:24because of the positive anticipation. Uh
- 2:11:27what about negative thoughts? Um like
- 2:11:30can people get addicted to anger,
- 2:11:33resent, us versus them stuff like
- 2:11:35they're we're all being oppressed. In
- 2:11:37some cases, people obviously are being
- 2:11:38oppressed, but uh I'm just curious. You
- 2:11:41see a lot of behavior and language
- 2:11:43online that suggests that maybe people
- 2:11:44are addicted to the feeling of like just
- 2:11:46that negative arousal as opposed to
- 2:11:48positive arousal. Do we What do we know
- 2:11:50about that?
- 2:11:51>> We definitely see that. So, everybody's
- 2:11:52wired a little bit differently and
- 2:11:54what's reinforcing for one person is not
- 2:11:56necessarily going to be reinforcing for
- 2:11:58another and vice versa. So, we see rage
- 2:12:00aholics, you know, people who get
- 2:12:02addicted to becoming enraged and like
- 2:12:04get an adrenalized good feeling from
- 2:12:07that and then we'll manufacture
- 2:12:08situations. We talked about codependency
- 2:12:11that can happen in diads where you have
- 2:12:13a ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra
- 2:12:14ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra aaholic with a a
- 2:12:15codependent and they're doing this kind
- 2:12:17of continual dance that's mutually
- 2:12:19reinforcing. I have written about
- 2:12:22feeling like I got addicted to my own
- 2:12:25worry, my own ruminations. Now the
- 2:12:27overlap between sort of addiction and
- 2:12:29obsessivecompulsive disorder is pretty
- 2:12:31tight here, but I feel like the
- 2:12:33addiction lens does capture the ways in
- 2:12:35which worrying can even be our happy
- 2:12:38place. It's kind of like that at least
- 2:12:39it's the misery I'm controlling type of
- 2:12:41thing
- 2:12:42>> and that part of getting out of that
- 2:12:46>> state of mind that very uncomfortable
- 2:12:48state of mind is uh
- 2:12:49>> yeah you know letting go of or
- 2:12:52abstaining intentionally abstaining from
- 2:12:54uh these kinds of obsessive ruminations.
- 2:12:57>> It's the uh meanest possible question to
- 2:13:00ask for somebody that is uh just about
- 2:13:03to you know hit the the trail for a new
- 2:13:06book. But uh do you think you'll write
- 2:13:08another book? And if so, what in the
- 2:13:10back of your mind it might be the thing
- 2:13:13and don't feel any need to share?
- 2:13:14>> No. You know, I very much have this
- 2:13:17feeling that this may be it for me. Like
- 2:13:20when I finished Dopamine Nation, I knew
- 2:13:22I wanted to write Radical Surrender. I
- 2:13:24originally had a chapter in Dopamine
- 2:13:27Nation on spiritual surrender and its
- 2:13:29role in recovery. I ended up cutting it
- 2:13:31because I couldn't do it justice, but I
- 2:13:34it was justestating and I kind of had a
- 2:13:36feeling eventually I would want to try
- 2:13:37to capture uh this phenomenon and these
- 2:13:39ideas. But right now I got nothing.
- 2:13:42[laughter]
- 2:13:43It's blank up there. So um we'll see. I
- 2:13:46I I'm you know trying to practice what I
- 2:13:48preach and live a surrendered life and
- 2:13:50just see what what life offers me, what
- 2:13:53life calls calls me to do. Anna, thank
- 2:13:56you so much for coming here to talk
- 2:13:58about radical surrender, revisit the
- 2:14:00addiction uh material, some of which we
- 2:14:03touched on before, but most of which,
- 2:14:04you know, will be novel to people. And
- 2:14:07it's always good for us to understand
- 2:14:08how the world is acting on us and how
- 2:14:10we're acting in the world. And I love
- 2:14:12the topic of the new book. I think it's
- 2:14:14fantastic. I can't wait to read it. Um,
- 2:14:16as I loved and, uh, continue to, you
- 2:14:19know, um,
- 2:14:20>> talk uncontrollably about about Dopamine
- 2:14:22Nation. You know, very few people have
- 2:14:24had the guts to just get out from behind
- 2:14:27the walls of clinic and academia and and
- 2:14:30share knowledge that's useful to people.
- 2:14:32And you've been doing this a long while
- 2:14:34with with a lot of fearlessness or if
- 2:14:36the fear is there, you're doing it
- 2:14:37anyway.
- 2:14:37>> The fear's there.
- 2:14:38>> All right. Great. Well, you're doing it
- 2:14:40anyway. And we're all grateful for it.
- 2:14:42>> Thank you. You, too.
- 2:14:43>> Thank you. I really appreciate you as a
- 2:14:46as a colleague and a and a a colleague
- 2:14:48both at Stanford and as a public
- 2:14:49educator. You've really enriched the
- 2:14:51world. Thank you.
- 2:14:52>> Thank you. Likewise,
- 2:14:53>> thank you for joining me for today's
- 2:14:55discussion with Dr. Anna Lumpkkey. To
- 2:14:57learn more about her work and to find a
- 2:14:59link to her new book, Radical Surrender,
- 2:15:01please see the show note caption. If
- 2:15:03you're learning from andor enjoying this
- 2:15:04podcast, please subscribe to our YouTube
- 2:15:06channel. That's a terrific zerocost way
- 2:15:08to support us. In addition, please
- 2:15:10follow the podcast by clicking the
- 2:15:12follow button on both Spotify and Apple.
- 2:15:14And on both Spotify and Apple, you can
- 2:15:16leave us up to a fivestar review. And
- 2:15:18you can now leave us comments at both
- 2:15:20Spotify and Apple. Please also check out
- 2:15:22the sponsors mentioned at the beginning
- 2:15:23and throughout today's episode. That's
- 2:15:25the best way to support this podcast. If
- 2:15:28you have questions for me or comments
- 2:15:29about the podcast or guests or topics
- 2:15:31that you'd like me to consider for the
- 2:15:32Huberman Lab podcast, please put those
- 2:15:34in the comment section on YouTube. I do
- 2:15:36read all the comments. And if you're not
- 2:15:38already following me on social media, I
- 2:15:40am Huberman Lab on all social media
- 2:15:42platforms. So that's Instagram, X,
- 2:15:44Threads, Facebook, and LinkedIn. And on
- 2:15:47all those platforms, I discuss science
- 2:15:49and science related tools. some of which
- 2:15:51overlaps with the content of the
- 2:15:52Hubberman Lab podcast, but much of which
- 2:15:54is distinct from the information on the
- 2:15:55Hubberman Lab podcast. Again, it's
- 2:15:57Huberman Lab on all social media
- 2:15:59platforms. And if you haven't already,
- 2:16:01subscribe to our neural network
- 2:16:02newsletter. The neural network
- 2:16:04newsletter is a zerorost monthly
- 2:16:05newsletter that includes podcast
- 2:16:07summaries as well as what we call
- 2:16:08protocols in the form of one to
- 2:16:10three-page PDFs that cover everything
- 2:16:12from how to optimize your sleep, how to
- 2:16:14optimize dopamine, deliberate cold
- 2:16:16exposure. We have a foundational fitness
- 2:16:18protocol that covers cardiovascular
- 2:16:20training and resistance training. All of
- 2:16:22that is available completely zero cost.
- 2:16:24You simply go to hubermanlab.com, go to
- 2:16:26the menu tab in the top right corner,
- 2:16:28scroll down to newsletter, and enter
- 2:16:30your email. And I should emphasize that
- 2:16:31we do not share your email with anybody.
- 2:16:34Thank you once again for joining me for
- 2:16:35today's discussion with Dr. Anna Lumpky.
- 2:16:38And last, but certainly not least,
- 2:16:40[music] thank you for your interest in
- 2:16:41science.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Overcome Addictions and Obsessions of All Kinds | Dr. Anna Lembke by Andrew Huberman, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 24,590 words across 3,694 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.