YouTube2Text

Online Course: Introduction to Road Safety Audits Day 1 — Transcript

by International Road Federation - IRF · 30,289 words · 5,208 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01i believe we start now so uh
  2. 0:06uh ladies and gentlemen uh dear
  3. 0:09participants from around the globe uh my
  4. 0:12name is alhaji asian associate professor
  5. 0:14at qatar transportation and traffic
  6. 0:16safety center
  7. 0:17i would like on behalf of myself and dr
  8. 0:21mohamed karadawi the director of
  9. 0:24qatar transportation center and dr
  10. 0:26khalid naji the dean of college of
  11. 0:28engineering to welcome you on this
  12. 0:30session on this webinar which is
  13. 0:32organized
  14. 0:34between qatar university qatar
  15. 0:36transportation traffic safety center and
  16. 0:37the international road federation
  17. 0:40this this work workshop or webinar is
  18. 0:43actually
  19. 0:44one of the several webinars that we have
  20. 0:47been organizing uh with the
  21. 0:50international road federation do
  22. 0:52during the last five years
  23. 0:54and we are always
  24. 0:56trying to do this as part of our global
  25. 0:59contribution to raise awareness on road
  26. 1:01safety and help to contribute to safer
  27. 1:03roads
  28. 1:06and today webinar is particularly about
  29. 1:09road safety audits will try to shade
  30. 1:12more technical information about
  31. 1:14these uh official
  32. 1:17documents and their preparations and
  33. 1:20what are the requirements to conduct
  34. 1:22them
  35. 1:23in
  36. 1:24today uh
  37. 1:26prep
  38. 1:27webinar this webinar is will be uh uh
  39. 1:30going for three days starting from today
  40. 1:33from uh now is 12 p.m doha time
  41. 1:37until 4 p.m doha time for a period of
  42. 1:39around four hours tomorrow we have the
  43. 1:42second day where we where it will start
  44. 1:45around five pm doha time going to 7 p.m
  45. 1:49for two hours at the same for day three
  46. 1:52in day one we will be uh covering two
  47. 1:55uh major aspects uh starting from uh our
  48. 2:00colleague susannah zamataro the director
  49. 2:02general of international federation who
  50. 2:04will be giving us
  51. 2:05a very important overview
  52. 2:08about the new decade of action that uh
  53. 2:11sub i think about to be launched in 28
  54. 2:15october this month uh
  55. 2:17and followed by starting our technical
  56. 2:20information about road safety audits
  57. 2:22will be which will be
  58. 2:24presented through the next two days by
  59. 2:26our close
  60. 2:28friend and colleague engineer miguel
  61. 2:30santos who is
  62. 2:32a senior road safety specialist at the
  63. 2:34public works uh public authority public
  64. 2:37works authority asukal in qatar and he
  65. 2:40was also a senior safety specialist at
  66. 2:43the
  67. 2:44public
  68. 2:45the projects department in the united
  69. 2:47nations
  70. 2:49before we start now with our uh
  71. 2:53program for today i would like to remind
  72. 2:55you about general ground rules as
  73. 2:58susannah mentioned that all of you are
  74. 3:01all participants by default are muted
  75. 3:03and no video can be shared however if
  76. 3:05you have any question please drop it on
  77. 3:08the chat
  78. 3:09we have so far until this moment more
  79. 3:11than 400 almost 150 participants so i'm
  80. 3:14expecting a lot of questions it will be
  81. 3:17difficult to answer all of these so
  82. 3:19we'll try to summarize
  83. 3:20major questions however at the end of
  84. 3:23the presentation we will have email
  85. 3:25links where you can drop us your
  86. 3:27comments or your questions and we'll get
  87. 3:29back to you with answers and one more
  88. 3:33point is that we will have during the
  89. 3:35break during the four hour session today
  90. 3:37we will have two short breaks
  91. 3:39and during of these bricks we will have
  92. 3:41one questionnaire that we will send you
  93. 3:44the link in the chat asking those who
  94. 3:46would like to participate with us
  95. 3:48to do that because this will give us a
  96. 3:51lot of information for uh your
  97. 3:54understanding and and your perspectives
  98. 3:56on road safety audits and will help us
  99. 3:59to direct what kind of information to be
  100. 4:02presented in the next two days tomorrow
  101. 4:03on the day after tomorrow
  102. 4:06based on these two we can now start and
  103. 4:09please allow me in the beginning to
  104. 4:11give the floor to susana zamataro who is
  105. 4:14you know kindly
  106. 4:15joining us
  107. 4:16regardless of her very busy schedule uh
  108. 4:19to give us a short presentation about
  109. 4:22the new indicative actions uh suzanna
  110. 4:25the florida is yours and you can't start
  111. 4:29thank you very much
  112. 4:30and hello and welcome also on behalf of
  113. 4:33the international road federation to uh
  114. 4:35to all of you i have to say every time
  115. 4:38we put up an announcement for
  116. 4:41courses on road safety audits i'm always
  117. 4:43impressed by the number of people that
  118. 4:46sign up just for your information we
  119. 4:48have
  120. 4:48right now 1 600 registered participants
  121. 4:52for this course
  122. 4:53um so as mahel was saying let's let's be
  123. 4:57a discipline um please use the chat to
  124. 5:00really exchange in between yourself uh
  125. 5:02this type of uh
  126. 5:04courses are also an opportunity to uh
  127. 5:07connect uh in between uh different
  128. 5:09experts from around the world but make
  129. 5:11sure that you use question answer
  130. 5:13function
  131. 5:15in your navigation bar to
  132. 5:17ask specific questions especially to our
  133. 5:20lead trainer engineer miguel angel
  134. 5:23santos whom i i really want to thank
  135. 5:26from the bottom of my heart uh for
  136. 5:28taking the time um to to really deliver
  137. 5:31this this course on the top of his also
  138. 5:33busy agenda uh he's doing uh he is doing
  139. 5:37uh quite uh quite a lot of work around
  140. 5:39those issues around the world and right
  141. 5:41now i understand in qatar most
  142. 5:43specifically our thanks as well to uh
  143. 5:45professor vagel
  144. 5:47um
  145. 5:48well i i can't say uh how pleased we are
  146. 5:51for the friendship uh and the
  147. 5:53collaboration that we have
  148. 5:54with the uh qatar traffic traffic
  149. 5:57traffic
  150. 5:58transportation traffic safety center of
  151. 6:01the university of qatar and it's a it's
  152. 6:04a collaboration uh that we see growing
  153. 6:07and we're happy to keep growing
  154. 6:09uh over the years without further adieu
  155. 6:13uh but maybe you stop sharing a screen
  156. 6:15i'll i have a very few uh very very few
  157. 6:18slides to tell you a couple of
  158. 6:21[Music]
  159. 6:22just give you some hints on the new
  160. 6:24decade of action and the decade of
  161. 6:26action plan more specifically um let me
  162. 6:29try to share my screen and see if that
  163. 6:32works i hope you can see that well
  164. 6:35give me a sign
  165. 6:37perfect and i apologize for my bad cold
  166. 6:41today
  167. 6:42um let me start maybe uh first of all by
  168. 6:46saying a few words on the uh
  169. 6:49on the irf maybe some of you are not
  170. 6:51familiar with our organization um
  171. 6:55knowledge sharing and expertise sharing
  172. 6:57like we're doing today and one of the
  173. 6:59key strategic strategic pillars of
  174. 7:02activities of the irf together with
  175. 7:05the networking really bringing
  176. 7:08people organizations uh
  177. 7:10and businesses as well to together
  178. 7:13and on the top of that also policy and
  179. 7:15advocacy work we are a global
  180. 7:17independent not-for-profit organization
  181. 7:19which was created
  182. 7:2173 now i believe almost uh years ago
  183. 7:26um in 1948 we're based in geneva in
  184. 7:30switzerland but we operate
  185. 7:32all over the world and we work very
  186. 7:34closely with the united nations and have
  187. 7:37a ecosocal status with the united
  188. 7:39nations since
  189. 7:411951.
  190. 7:43just to give you an example of the the
  191. 7:45type of
  192. 7:46knowledge and expertise sharing and
  193. 7:48dissemination of course uh very happy of
  194. 7:51our collaboration with the qatar
  195. 7:53university and the center
  196. 7:56we also have collaborations with other
  197. 7:57universities around the world technical
  198. 8:00committees within our federation and the
  199. 8:03knowledge hub which is called the global
  200. 8:05transport knowledge partnership gtkp
  201. 8:07which i invite you really to take a look
  202. 8:10at the it has completely been revamped
  203. 8:14um this year thanks to the support from
  204. 8:16the high volume transporter program
  205. 8:19funded by the uk you will find in there
  206. 8:22a new uh hub with resources specifically
  207. 8:25about kobe 19 and transport but as well
  208. 8:29another specific pillars that provides
  209. 8:32you lots of insights and useful
  210. 8:34information access to documents when it
  211. 8:37comes to road safety the gdkp
  212. 8:40hosts in fact
  213. 8:42some of the knowledge outputs which are
  214. 8:44produced within the united nations road
  215. 8:46safety collaboration group
  216. 8:48data is also one of the core
  217. 8:51activities within the iarf we you might
  218. 8:53be familiar with the irf world war
  219. 8:55statistics um
  220. 8:57that we produced since 58 years
  221. 9:002021 edition i should have updated this
  222. 9:03one but the 2021 edition just came out
  223. 9:07and thanks to the support of the total
  224. 9:09energy foundation all our data have now
  225. 9:11been digitalized and available on a data
  226. 9:15what we call the data warehouse
  227. 9:17in terms of connections just to give you
  228. 9:19a sense of how we connect people
  229. 9:21businesses countries and organizations
  230. 9:23together on the screen some of the key
  231. 9:26partners we work with around the world
  232. 9:28to foster and bring forward the
  233. 9:30transport and the roads agenda when it
  234. 9:33comes to advocacy and here i come back
  235. 9:35now to specifically the decade of action
  236. 9:38uh
  237. 9:39of course we work at international uh at
  238. 9:42the international level but as well
  239. 9:44national level
  240. 9:46on the screen a couple of the key
  241. 9:48processes through which we do advocacy
  242. 9:51work
  243. 9:52unrsc the sustainable mobility for all
  244. 9:54initiative which is led by the world
  245. 9:56bank our irf africa and of course now
  246. 10:00there's a lot of work around the next
  247. 10:02cup
  248. 10:03now talking about the
  249. 10:06more specifically the decade of action
  250. 10:08as you know the decade of action uh
  251. 10:11a new decade of action has been launched
  252. 10:13um and established with the resolution
  253. 10:15of the united nations um from august to
  254. 10:192020 the the
  255. 10:21the new decade will run from this year
  256. 10:23till 2030 so we are aligning ourselves
  257. 10:27with the target that has been set
  258. 10:29and the timeline that has been set for
  259. 10:32the sustainable development goals
  260. 10:35uh the the the target fixed for the
  261. 10:38decade of actions is to reduce road
  262. 10:41traffic deaths and injuries by at least
  263. 10:44uh 50
  264. 10:45in this uh in this decade and
  265. 10:49miguel will uh will be able to give you
  266. 10:51some insights on at least from the
  267. 10:53engineering part of what we can do
  268. 10:57what we can do to make that happen and
  269. 10:59really try to get us closer and why not
  270. 11:02reach that target if not by pass it
  271. 11:05now know that beside the decade of
  272. 11:08action per se uh the decade is
  273. 11:10underpinned as well by a global plan of
  274. 11:13action which is basically that document
  275. 11:16that has to give some guidance to
  276. 11:19operationalize
  277. 11:21uh everything that is stated in the
  278. 11:23decade of action um but i'll just
  279. 11:25mention it the global plan will be
  280. 11:27launched
  281. 11:28uh by a global online event to be hosted
  282. 11:31by the double h show on the 28th of
  283. 11:34october we are considering this training
  284. 11:36as a as a
  285. 11:38way as well to create that momentum
  286. 11:41that will bring us to to this launch
  287. 11:44official launch on on the 28th it
  288. 11:47doesn't mean that the work starts only
  289. 11:49on the 28th the work has started already
  290. 11:51uh from uh
  291. 11:53from january for some of us the work has
  292. 11:55never it's never stopped i don't think
  293. 11:58the uh
  294. 11:59the size of this road safety pandemic if
  295. 12:02i can use that word um allow us to
  296. 12:06sit down and relax it's it's it's uh
  297. 12:09it's something that uh caesar's fighting
  298. 12:11uh every day on on the road the global
  299. 12:14plan of course describes what is needed
  300. 12:17to achieve that uh the target and has a
  301. 12:20specific call
  302. 12:21for governments and a lot more than
  303. 12:24governments to really embrace and
  304. 12:26integrate the safe system approach the
  305. 12:29system uh thinking in in doing that let
  306. 12:33me try to go fast
  307. 12:35[Music]
  308. 12:37i uh broke i broke it down uh into three
  309. 12:40slides so you will see uh it's gonna be
  310. 12:43pretty fast uh it's just to give you um
  311. 12:46uh a sense of what what is in that in
  312. 12:49that plan
  313. 12:50um because the document is still not uh
  314. 12:54not not public
  315. 12:55there's a strong uh
  316. 12:57um
  317. 12:58focus again on this idea of the
  318. 13:00multimodal transport and there's a
  319. 13:03there's a new uh and very much welcomed
  320. 13:06also from our sides attention to land
  321. 13:09use planning
  322. 13:11so trying to think about the road safety
  323. 13:15in a much more proactive way and
  324. 13:17upstream rather than just trying to fix
  325. 13:20down the problems down down the road in
  326. 13:22fact
  327. 13:23so
  328. 13:24the focus will be there and you will see
  329. 13:26that this this still the five pillars
  330. 13:28are still uh there so there's a strong
  331. 13:30focus on uh on the importance of safe
  332. 13:33road infrastructure the vehicles uh safe
  333. 13:36road use so the users and the post crash
  334. 13:39care response which still remains uh
  335. 13:42central but the document uh gives
  336. 13:44specific indication on how we should do
  337. 13:47that so not only on what we should be
  338. 13:49focusing but how are we going to uh to
  339. 13:53to do that
  340. 13:54so in here we will see that you will see
  341. 13:57when the document comes up
  342. 13:59out
  343. 14:00that there's some
  344. 14:02innovation in that respect why there's a
  345. 14:04specific focus on a speed management
  346. 14:08which is quite uh central there's a
  347. 14:10renewed interest in bringing forward the
  348. 14:12importance of the adherence to the uh
  349. 14:15legal instruments that already exist
  350. 14:17there's a
  351. 14:18an attention also the role of of gender
  352. 14:21and how um
  353. 14:24specific um categories and also women
  354. 14:27are
  355. 14:28affected by road safety we're looking at
  356. 14:31the importance of technology and i think
  357. 14:34the document really stresses much more
  358. 14:36than before the importance to focus on
  359. 14:39low and middle income country which are
  360. 14:41which actually are those who bear
  361. 14:43the
  362. 14:44greatest numbers when it comes to road
  363. 14:47deaths and injuries
  364. 14:48who should do it and i can tell you from
  365. 14:50behind the scenes there was a lot of
  366. 14:53very
  367. 14:55how can i say excited conversation about
  368. 14:59the document making sure that the
  369. 15:00document stresses that yes indeed it's a
  370. 15:04responsibility of the governments but at
  371. 15:06the same time
  372. 15:08all of us you know all the different
  373. 15:10stakeholders in this ecosystem
  374. 15:12have a role to play so you will find in
  375. 15:14the document
  376. 15:16a clear
  377. 15:18a clear part about the role the civil
  378. 15:21society can play so the ngos the youth
  379. 15:24and the academia
  380. 15:26i'm very pleased to see in the document
  381. 15:27as well a specific call for the private
  382. 15:30sector and the recognition of the key
  383. 15:32role that private sectors place when it
  384. 15:34comes to road safety
  385. 15:36the funders
  386. 15:38of course because uh let's not forget
  387. 15:40that investments in road safety do
  388. 15:42remain uh a key issues and the role of
  389. 15:44the united nations and um agencies in
  390. 15:48terms of the type of and as well the
  391. 15:50type of coordination that they need to
  392. 15:53install in between themselves
  393. 15:55when it comes to safe uh road
  394. 15:57infrastructure and and i'll be
  395. 15:59i'll be wrapping up this presentation
  396. 16:02fairly quickly this idea of course of
  397. 16:05the multi-modality uh
  398. 16:07multi-modal mobility is brought back
  399. 16:09into the picture
  400. 16:11and uh and and so you will see it coming
  401. 16:15forward uh specifically in the part
  402. 16:17dedicated to the safe roading
  403. 16:19infrastructure
  404. 16:21we have to plan the recommendation of
  405. 16:23course it's very clear we have to plan
  406. 16:26infrastructure so that
  407. 16:30it can really operate as a truly
  408. 16:32multimodal system but also plan
  409. 16:34infrastructure in in a way that
  410. 16:36minimizes the risk for all the road
  411. 16:38users and not just the drivers
  412. 16:41so really a strong focus on the most of
  413. 16:43a level
  414. 16:44the indicative action plan has
  415. 16:48amongst these annexes and and draws a
  416. 16:51very tight connection with the un
  417. 16:53voluntary targets
  418. 16:55for road safety and on the screen you
  419. 16:57have the two targets that specifically
  420. 16:59uh really uh deal with infrastructure
  421. 17:02target three and target four
  422. 17:04uh if you follow irf you will see that
  423. 17:06we do a lot of work and a lot of our
  424. 17:08events around this famous target three
  425. 17:11and target four target three is for all
  426. 17:13new roads basically um the target set
  427. 17:16for 2020 says that by 2030 all new roads
  428. 17:20should achieve technical standards for
  429. 17:22all road users
  430. 17:24that take into account road safety or at
  431. 17:26least meet three star rating or better
  432. 17:29target number four is referring to
  433. 17:32existing roads and so
  434. 17:34the target in here is that uh more than
  435. 17:3775 percent of travel by 2030 should be
  436. 17:40on existing roads that meet technical
  437. 17:42standards for all road users and take
  438. 17:45into account
  439. 17:46uh road safety
  440. 17:48when it comes to uh infrastructure
  441. 17:51safety and the decade of action plan you
  442. 17:53will find in the plan and i'm just
  443. 17:56anticipating something that you will
  444. 17:57learn only at the end of the month
  445. 17:59officially that
  446. 18:02road safety um there's a specific
  447. 18:05recommendations to undertake road safety
  448. 18:07audits and all sections of new uh of new
  449. 18:10roads and of course on the importance of
  450. 18:13having an independent and accredited
  451. 18:15experts
  452. 18:17to
  453. 18:18perform those audits
  454. 18:20there's a central role
  455. 18:23for capacity building and that is really
  456. 18:25stressed into the document that is
  457. 18:27coming um that is coming out
  458. 18:30uh hence we are extremely pleased to
  459. 18:33continue our work together with
  460. 18:35the qatar university and and the center
  461. 18:38and and other and others to build this
  462. 18:40capacity around the world when it comes
  463. 18:43to a safer road in infrastructure
  464. 18:48i just want to close with two
  465. 18:50announcements
  466. 18:52know that next week is going to be a
  467. 18:53very very busy week the un
  468. 18:56sustainable transport conference is
  469. 18:58taking place uh in between the 14th and
  470. 19:01the 16th of october
  471. 19:02together with all the colleagues within
  472. 19:04the united nations road safety
  473. 19:06collaboration unrsc
  474. 19:08we are hosting a dedicated side event
  475. 19:12uh
  476. 19:13uh it's on the 15th of october at 4 15
  477. 19:17geneva time so central european time
  478. 19:20you will find all the information on the
  479. 19:23irf websites that you saw on my on my
  480. 19:26slides i'll put it also on on the chat
  481. 19:29it's a free registration join us because
  482. 19:32we will go
  483. 19:33through the 12
  484. 19:35global
  485. 19:36voluntary targets and provide you with
  486. 19:38some some guidance and some concrete
  487. 19:40examples uh together with the other
  488. 19:43colleagues
  489. 19:44uh road safety will be also central in
  490. 19:46the ira funnel conference
  491. 19:48that is
  492. 19:49taking place on 20 and 21st of october
  493. 19:53the very first session of our annual
  494. 19:55conference will be dedicated to
  495. 19:57investing into road safety
  496. 19:59and so we'll be talking about different
  497. 20:02things including
  498. 20:03innovative finance for world safety so
  499. 20:06there's a there's a an ongoing
  500. 20:08conversation about the possibility for
  501. 20:10example of creating road safety
  502. 20:12bonds so come and join us i'll also put
  503. 20:16that in the chat it's a free
  504. 20:17registration
  505. 20:19but make sure you secure your spot
  506. 20:21because a limited number of seats uh
  507. 20:24available
  508. 20:25i think i'm uh i'll stop here and
  509. 20:28i thank you very much for your attention
  510. 20:31and i i look forward to uh hearing
  511. 20:34miguel today on on this course thank you
  512. 20:38well back to you
  513. 20:42thank you susannah thank you for the
  514. 20:45information the overview of the new
  515. 20:47decade of action
  516. 20:49and i believe uh this is a very
  517. 20:51important uh
  518. 20:53issue and
  519. 20:55understanding of different
  520. 20:57experts in different countries to this
  521. 21:00new decade of action and what need to be
  522. 21:02done and what policies need to be
  523. 21:04implemented to improve road safety is
  524. 21:05very important
  525. 21:06and i think we need another workshop
  526. 21:08probably targeting only the new decade
  527. 21:11of action to understand well
  528. 21:14what needs to be done and
  529. 21:16very
  530. 21:18promising targets have been put
  531. 21:21and whether the world can work all
  532. 21:23effectively to achieve such targets is
  533. 21:25very important and to do that we need to
  534. 21:28have a good understanding and good uh
  535. 21:30knowledge and awareness about the act
  536. 21:32the the the
  537. 21:34the plan itself so maybe we can have
  538. 21:37another workshop because it's very
  539. 21:38interesting and i think many people have
  540. 21:40many questions i can see on the chat
  541. 21:42about that
  542. 21:44i received before we moved to
  543. 21:47engineer miguel i received several
  544. 21:50comments
  545. 21:52about the slides
  546. 21:54and the video of the recording the video
  547. 21:56of the recording will be shared through
  548. 21:58irf website and on youtube through uh
  549. 22:01social media uh tools
  550. 22:03and this will be sent by email to all
  551. 22:05participants automatically later on
  552. 22:06after the end of this workshop on three
  553. 22:09days
  554. 22:10regarding the uh
  555. 22:13link for tomorrow and the day after
  556. 22:15tomorrow uh sessions we will use the
  557. 22:18same link of today so please when if you
  558. 22:21received and for for sure you received
  559. 22:23the link for today and you have joined
  560. 22:24us use the same link to access
  561. 22:27this session then tomorrow session and
  562. 22:30the day after tomorrow session we will
  563. 22:31not be changing links the same link can
  564. 22:34be accessed through the whole program in
  565. 22:36this three days and this i think is
  566. 22:38easier for everyone to deal with
  567. 22:40and if you lost the
  568. 22:43link for any reason please just send us
  569. 22:45email and we'll send it to you again
  570. 22:48uh
  571. 22:49regarding also comments about
  572. 22:51certificate this very short workshop
  573. 22:56through this three days will not have
  574. 22:59any certificate this is a kind of
  575. 23:01awareness program where we're trying to
  576. 23:04spread awareness about road safety
  577. 23:06audits and provide technical information
  578. 23:08that is usually not always available for
  579. 23:11everyone to know about road safety
  580. 23:12audits and the correct approach for
  581. 23:14implementing them and conducting them
  582. 23:17that's
  583. 23:18what i can see from the comments so far
  584. 23:20and now we move to uh
  585. 23:23engineer miguel who will start our
  586. 23:25technical first technical presentation
  587. 23:27on this workshop by addressing
  588. 23:30concepts of road safety in general
  589. 23:33under the umbrella of safe systems
  590. 23:36miguel the floor is yours i will share
  591. 23:38your slides now
  592. 23:40just give me a sign and i will be
  593. 23:43always
  594. 23:45skip
  595. 23:46moving between slides
  596. 23:49no worry doctor why
  597. 23:51okay hello everybody first before i
  598. 23:54start i would like to say thank you to
  599. 23:57qatar university dr weil and
  600. 24:00susanna with irf to allow me to present
  601. 24:03again something that hopefully is going
  602. 24:06to be interesting for all of you
  603. 24:08of course all the information that you
  604. 24:10are having here
  605. 24:11you can find it okay the world bank the
  606. 24:14european bank of reconstruction and
  607. 24:16development the asian development bank
  608. 24:18they prepare guidelines that they are
  609. 24:20very useful that they also prepare
  610. 24:22online training courses so that is
  611. 24:24fantastic so the thing that i did is
  612. 24:26compile
  613. 24:27all this kind of information prepare one
  614. 24:30thing where you can conglomerate and you
  615. 24:32can see everything that they were
  616. 24:33talking here
  617. 24:35also i need to say thank you to
  618. 24:37three special people that is funny
  619. 24:40kalpakis that he was working with me to
  620. 24:42produce this kind of presentation
  621. 24:44michael darus that he opened my eyes you
  622. 24:47know when i when i started to work here
  623. 24:49in the middle east for different kind of
  624. 24:51approaches
  625. 24:52my dear friend and colleague javier
  626. 24:54lopez delgado that he's the current
  627. 24:56president of the spanish official raw
  628. 24:58safety auditors that he also contribute
  629. 25:00to this kind of presentation all around
  630. 25:02the world
  631. 25:04of course my wifey my family my friends
  632. 25:07that they support and they give me a lot
  633. 25:09of support to do this kind of
  634. 25:10presentations and trainings
  635. 25:12and notwithstanding all of this i need
  636. 25:14to tell you that this is the first time
  637. 25:16due because i'm having problems where i
  638. 25:19am that is a hotel tomorrow hopefully i
  639. 25:21will be in another environment that i'm
  640. 25:23not going to be using my own control of
  641. 25:25the slide so dr weil thank you thank you
  642. 25:27for assisting me with this kind of
  643. 25:30tedious tedious thing that is passing a
  644. 25:32slide for me
  645. 25:33hopefully is not going to
  646. 25:35[Music]
  647. 25:36is not going to detriment the way that i
  648. 25:39normally talk and give the
  649. 25:41the presentation a nice rhythm okay so
  650. 25:44without anything else
  651. 25:45i would like to start with the
  652. 25:47introduction to pro safety impact
  653. 25:49assessment draw safety audits and
  654. 25:50through safety inspections okay
  655. 25:54you see now i will pass the the slide
  656. 25:58we need to we need to
  657. 26:00bind the team a little bit but we will
  658. 26:02do it
  659. 26:03uh
  660. 26:05the
  661. 26:06in the wall the road safety as susana
  662. 26:08has said
  663. 26:09i would call it too as a pandemic not
  664. 26:12just copied okay so susanna has been
  665. 26:15very kind because
  666. 26:17she has explained what is the new decade
  667. 26:20of raw safety
  668. 26:21actions that they are going to be taking
  669. 26:23on the wall i'm going to go a little bit
  670. 26:25back i'm going to say the brutal reality
  671. 26:27about what has happened before since
  672. 26:292011 that we started to have our
  673. 26:32our first decade of road safety and with
  674. 26:35that after i will evolve to
  675. 26:38to the place that what is road safety
  676. 26:40the definition of that one and later we
  677. 26:42will see what is the
  678. 26:45the tools that we have to deliver this
  679. 26:46kind of road safety there are many
  680. 26:48international agencies you know like the
  681. 26:50world bank or the
  682. 26:53the world health organization that they
  683. 26:54dedicate themselves in order to help and
  684. 26:57then commit it in draw safety for
  685. 26:59developing countries okay
  686. 27:01so
  687. 27:02the thing that they are doing there are
  688. 27:04many kind of different ways that they
  689. 27:06act like the united nations pro safety
  690. 27:08funds or the global state or road safety
  691. 27:11report or the world report for
  692. 27:13prevention injuries of traffic accidents
  693. 27:15and in latin america you got other banks
  694. 27:17like the evil american development bank
  695. 27:19that they also take the approach for
  696. 27:21road safety audits and road safety
  697. 27:23inspection okay so we can see
  698. 27:26a very a real concern
  699. 27:28about road safety all around the world
  700. 27:32okay
  701. 27:36and dr
  702. 27:37dr do you prefer that that you pass or
  703. 27:40are you with me
  704. 27:42the united nations
  705. 27:44they deliver five pillars you know about
  706. 27:47the road safety that's the one that
  707. 27:49susana was saying that they we were
  708. 27:51acting in two and three the volunteer
  709. 27:54well the pillars that you got in here is
  710. 27:57the road safety management spirit number
  711. 27:59one
  712. 28:00the draw safety sorry the safer transit
  713. 28:03and mobility routes that that is the
  714. 28:04pilot number two that is where
  715. 28:06infrastructure is allocated the safer
  716. 28:09vehicle safer uses and transit routes
  717. 28:11and their response after accident
  718. 28:14because that is very important also in
  719. 28:16order that we can enhance the the
  720. 28:17possibilities of someone that has an
  721. 28:19accident to be
  722. 28:21to be alive or not to suffer seriously
  723. 28:29my presentation or this presentation
  724. 28:31is going to be around the pillar 2 the
  725. 28:34cipher transient mobility roots okay
  726. 28:37in that pillar they say that we increase
  727. 28:38the increased safety and quality of
  728. 28:41protection for the road network in order
  729. 28:43that that is going to benefit
  730. 28:45all the road users
  731. 28:47listen
  732. 28:48all the road users
  733. 28:50so the uses of the network is not just
  734. 28:52the motorcyclist the motor vehicles no
  735. 28:56it's just also pedestrians it's cyclists
  736. 28:58okay so all these kind of things they
  737. 29:01are going to be included in this pillar
  738. 29:03okay and we'll achieve this one through
  739. 29:05the implementation of different kind of
  740. 29:08infrastructure agreement that we have
  741. 29:10okay
  742. 29:10we will do gross infrastructure
  743. 29:12assessment and we improve the road
  744. 29:14planning
  745. 29:15please understand that safety start at
  746. 29:19the beginning of the road planning
  747. 29:21okay
  748. 29:22i have put this slide because for me
  749. 29:24it's brutal okay
  750. 29:27it gives you
  751. 29:28many data
  752. 29:30that we should be aware
  753. 29:32if the people around the world they are
  754. 29:34aware about this data not just
  755. 29:36professionals because most of you are
  756. 29:38going to are going to be working in the
  757. 29:39same field that i'm working okay
  758. 29:41but if you know that
  759. 29:441.35 million
  760. 29:46died on the road
  761. 29:48okay every year
  762. 29:50then you will be able to call this one
  763. 29:52as a pandemic okay or that is the first
  764. 29:56cause
  765. 29:57of death among the young people
  766. 30:00okay
  767. 30:01dr well if you pass to the next one i
  768. 30:03will show them more clear all this data
  769. 30:06okay because every 23 seconds
  770. 30:08for into 24 seconds one person dies in
  771. 30:11reaction okay
  772. 30:12so
  773. 30:13a part of all the life that is costing
  774. 30:16this to us
  775. 30:18every single life has a value we are
  776. 30:21like that we are in in this kind of
  777. 30:23world that we need to put value for the
  778. 30:24life that we got
  779. 30:26so the economic cost
  780. 30:28okay in developing countries for this
  781. 30:30one is at least 100 billion per year
  782. 30:33so what do we do
  783. 30:35in order to attack this one
  784. 30:38dr well please
  785. 30:42we started with the moscow declaration
  786. 30:45in 2009 okay and in there we set up our
  787. 30:49first decade of action okay that it went
  788. 30:52from 2011 to 2020. in there
  789. 30:57our target okay it was reduction 50
  790. 31:01death
  791. 31:02by 2020
  792. 31:04is familiar susana has just talked to
  793. 31:07you about what is the new decade 21 to
  794. 31:102030 okay and what is the
  795. 31:13the target
  796. 31:15exactly the same
  797. 31:16okay
  798. 31:18in the past
  799. 31:19in the brazilian declaration of 2015
  800. 31:23uh that it was the middle point of that
  801. 31:25one we decided to create that one in
  802. 31:28earth to see how the countries they were
  803. 31:30doing
  804. 31:31so
  805. 31:32because the countries some of them they
  806. 31:34were acting and some they were not
  807. 31:35acting with the brazilian declaration we
  808. 31:37say hey you haven't done anything yet
  809. 31:39just still got time until 2020.
  810. 31:42but all of this failed
  811. 31:44okay this is why we decided to start
  812. 31:47well they decided to start a new uh
  813. 31:51draw safety decade of action where are
  814. 31:54we at the moment well
  815. 31:55we are
  816. 31:57uh with the stockholm resolution in 2020
  817. 32:00they recommended the second decline of
  818. 32:03action for road safety that is going to
  819. 32:04have
  820. 32:05again
  821. 32:07a new target new target okay of
  822. 32:09reduction of 50 percent death toll
  823. 32:12stop being here one moment dr well
  824. 32:14do you realize
  825. 32:16that because
  826. 32:18everything failed between 2011 and 2020
  827. 32:21we need to repeat the same kind of
  828. 32:23things between 2021 and 2030.
  829. 32:27don't you feel that we have wasted 10
  830. 32:30years
  831. 32:3110 years no one not to 10 years
  832. 32:34where people continue dying on the roads
  833. 32:37just because
  834. 32:38no one was able to implement something
  835. 32:41that it was thoughts in 2011 here we are
  836. 32:45and now we got the same kind of of
  837. 32:47target again
  838. 32:48are we going to deal with that is it
  839. 32:50going to be visible to do it these are
  840. 32:52the kind
  841. 32:53of big questions that we need to do and
  842. 32:55for that you can continue well for that
  843. 32:58we have
  844. 32:59already recommended to every country you
  845. 33:02know that they need to adhere themselves
  846. 33:05to the stockholm resolution okay in
  847. 33:07order that they can make initiative
  848. 33:09based on that one
  849. 33:11they need to create raw safety
  850. 33:13observatories it can be the country ones
  851. 33:16and it can be also the regional ones
  852. 33:18okay with that way you will share
  853. 33:20information and sharing information is
  854. 33:23paramount in order that this kind of
  855. 33:26knowledge is passed by and the people
  856. 33:28they know how to react okay and of
  857. 33:31course we need to have mandatory row
  858. 33:33safety components
  859. 33:34across the network
  860. 33:36okay dr well
  861. 33:39okay now past we got in here the 12
  862. 33:43uh targets that we have seen before that
  863. 33:45susanna showed you target three and
  864. 33:47tower target fourth okay all these
  865. 33:49targets that we got in here they were
  866. 33:52done in 2017
  867. 33:54okay so they were expecting that the
  868. 33:58the
  869. 33:59uh
  870. 34:00the decade was going to fail so they
  871. 34:02prepared this one for the failure and
  872. 34:04all the all these kind of
  873. 34:06of targets they are associated to one of
  874. 34:09the pillars that the united nations
  875. 34:11created okay
  876. 34:13so the three and four as susana has
  877. 34:15described is the one where draw safety
  878. 34:18audits road safety inspection and road
  879. 34:19safety impact assessment and they they
  880. 34:22they come inside okay
  881. 34:25please
  882. 34:28yep
  883. 34:30so now
  884. 34:32no no doctor well don't go don't go so
  885. 34:34fast please let me leave it in there
  886. 34:36please
  887. 34:37so now
  888. 34:38let's ask ourselves
  889. 34:40what is road safety
  890. 34:42i would like to see if you know what is
  891. 34:44road safety because
  892. 34:46people they cannot define
  893. 34:48this kind of things and for me the
  894. 34:49definition that i learned from michael i
  895. 34:52really love it okay
  896. 34:55now you can go
  897. 34:57thank you
  898. 35:00draw safety is going to be related to
  899. 35:03this formula okay
  900. 35:05a lot of people
  901. 35:07will know this formula as the kinetic
  902. 35:08energy okay
  903. 35:10so the way that we manage
  904. 35:13the
  905. 35:14kinetic energy in order to protect
  906. 35:17all users from death or seriously
  907. 35:18injured
  908. 35:19is what we call row safety beautiful
  909. 35:22associated to engineering you know it's
  910. 35:25a it's a beautiful formula and it's
  911. 35:28telling us
  912. 35:29that when we got a crash
  913. 35:31okay we got a transfer of energy
  914. 35:34and that is the main thing that the safe
  915. 35:37system is going to have okay we will
  916. 35:39focus
  917. 35:40in reducing the trauma we don't focus
  918. 35:43introducing the crashes no the crashes
  919. 35:45imagine that you are in a place where
  920. 35:47you got
  921. 35:4820 classes per year okay and of those 20
  922. 35:51classes you got five people that they
  923. 35:53are dying and 10 seriously injured
  924. 35:55after you do all your treatment for that
  925. 35:58place
  926. 35:59you still got 20 classes per year and
  927. 36:02you say well nothing has happened yes
  928. 36:04because now instead of five people dying
  929. 36:06you got maybe only one or maybe no one
  930. 36:09is dying in there and instead of 10
  931. 36:11people that they are seriously injured
  932. 36:13maybe you got one two five but you
  933. 36:15reduce that one when you reduce that one
  934. 36:18you are doing your job properly
  935. 36:20independently if the number of crashes
  936. 36:23is stay stay it stays the same okay and
  937. 36:26we need to stop blaming the user okay
  938. 36:29the driver yes we know that is going to
  939. 36:31have that is going to be guilty because
  940. 36:33of the human factors that we got in here
  941. 36:36for many for many things okay but not
  942. 36:39everything is their fault okay so
  943. 36:42instead of blaming we need to start
  944. 36:44sharing responsibilities
  945. 36:46dr well please
  946. 36:50so the thing that we will do is to apply
  947. 36:53the safe system and the safe system is
  948. 36:55very simple ah in the center as we got
  949. 36:57in here
  950. 36:58uh we are going to have the human okay
  951. 37:01the human being and the human being it
  952. 37:03will be surrounded for four different
  953. 37:06kind of
  954. 37:08of pillars okay that we got in there
  955. 37:10it's going to be safe roads say vehicles
  956. 37:13the principles okay the safe road safe
  957. 37:15vehicles several uses and safe speed
  958. 37:18okay
  959. 37:19above that we will have the management
  960. 37:22the manager
  961. 37:24the managers in every single country
  962. 37:25needs to appear in order to do the the
  963. 37:29safe system applicable in here and also
  964. 37:31we need to have also the post crash
  965. 37:33response just remember about the the
  966. 37:36gold hour that you got after an accident
  967. 37:38in order in order to to increase the
  968. 37:40chances of the people to survive please
  969. 37:42after well
  970. 37:47so the principles that we are going to
  971. 37:49have in the same system they are very
  972. 37:51simple
  973. 37:52we are humans okay and our body has
  974. 37:55limitations okay
  975. 37:57not
  976. 37:58we cannot absorb all the kinetic energy
  977. 38:01that is going to be
  978. 38:03liberated uh in a in a crash okay so our
  979. 38:07body is not going to tolerate that one
  980. 38:09this is why we need to learn how to
  981. 38:11manage this energy in order that we
  982. 38:13don't absorb everything some of them
  983. 38:16will go to the car some of them will go
  984. 38:18to the raw furniture okay
  985. 38:20we are trying to do that the minimum of
  986. 38:22that one pass on our bodies okay
  987. 38:26we need to forgive the human error
  988. 38:29just imagine
  989. 38:30you are a good driver or an average
  990. 38:32driver let's let's don't put the
  991. 38:34qualification of good but no no
  992. 38:37average driver okay
  993. 38:39and you made a mistake
  994. 38:41come on it's very expensive to pay with
  995. 38:44your life because you made one mistake
  996. 38:48okay so this is why we need to build
  997. 38:50things that they are going to forgive
  998. 38:53that we made a mistake and we are human
  999. 38:55we are going to have
  1000. 38:57uh we are going to do mistakes okay it's
  1001. 39:00in our nature okay
  1002. 39:03yeah it's something is something that is
  1003. 39:05inheriting ourselves so we will do
  1004. 39:07mistakes
  1005. 39:08the things that we need to try is not to
  1006. 39:10pay with our lives
  1007. 39:12that the mistake that we are doing okay
  1008. 39:16we need to have a joint responsibility
  1009. 39:18okay
  1010. 39:19every single part of the road uh not of
  1011. 39:23the road of the road system work
  1012. 39:25together road users designers people in
  1013. 39:29maintenance the politicians everyone
  1014. 39:32they need to work together okay and we
  1015. 39:34need to learn how to manage the road
  1016. 39:37okay
  1017. 39:38please don't
  1018. 39:42so as i said we will have four key
  1019. 39:45elements in here
  1020. 39:46the speed the vehicle the road and the
  1021. 39:49user okay the speed
  1022. 39:52why we
  1023. 39:53why we have the speeding here because in
  1024. 39:55the kinetic energy is fundamental part
  1025. 39:57and also because it's elevated to the
  1026. 39:59square
  1027. 40:00okay that means that it has an
  1028. 40:02exponential reaction
  1029. 40:04to to whatever an exponential
  1030. 40:06contribution to the kinetic energy
  1031. 40:08factor
  1032. 40:09that means that it's not the same it's
  1033. 40:11not going to be the same to crash 70
  1034. 40:13kilometers per hour that are 30
  1035. 40:16okay the reduction you know of the
  1036. 40:18energy that is going to be deliberated
  1037. 40:20is
  1038. 40:21is impressive okay
  1039. 40:24so
  1040. 40:26we need to focus in these areas in order
  1041. 40:28that we can have a holistic approach to
  1042. 40:31the safe system
  1043. 40:32please after well
  1044. 40:38okay for the sake system there will be
  1045. 40:40also supporting areas as i said the
  1046. 40:43first one is the management the people
  1047. 40:45that they are in charge of the national
  1048. 40:48observatories or the people that are in
  1049. 40:49charge of the roads in the country they
  1050. 40:52must be aware what we need to and for
  1051. 40:54what how we need to have our roads in
  1052. 40:57order that they are forgiving the people
  1053. 40:58for the mistake that they do
  1054. 41:00we have also a very important aspect
  1055. 41:03that is the enforcement
  1056. 41:04okay a lot of people they consider that
  1057. 41:08because they don't have any kind of
  1058. 41:10transforming on the road you can have
  1059. 41:12the jungle low
  1060. 41:13in here the jungle law we can say that
  1061. 41:16is whoever has the bigger car has
  1062. 41:18preference or priority to pass
  1063. 41:20and that is not good okay is b is very
  1064. 41:23important to have the collaboration of
  1065. 41:25the police you know in order that they
  1066. 41:28can enforce the laws that the management
  1067. 41:30they are going to
  1068. 41:31implement in order that the
  1069. 41:34that the safe system is in
  1070. 41:36in place
  1071. 41:37and of course this one entry and exit
  1072. 41:41is very curious because
  1073. 41:43in order to enter into the safe system
  1074. 41:45unless that you are a pedestrian
  1075. 41:47you should be able to pass a test
  1076. 41:49okay that is going to give you the the
  1077. 41:52certification that you are allowed to
  1078. 41:55enter in the system where everybody is
  1079. 41:57certified everybody has a driver's
  1080. 41:59license and everybody can go
  1081. 42:01and everybody can
  1082. 42:02follow the rules so you need to have
  1083. 42:04that kind of
  1084. 42:05of knowledge okay but the exit is also
  1085. 42:07very important
  1086. 42:09the exit
  1087. 42:10knowing how to say
  1088. 42:12i cannot drive anymore
  1089. 42:14it can be hard
  1090. 42:15for me was
  1091. 42:17her breaking last year because i talked
  1092. 42:19to my dad
  1093. 42:21and i recommend him not to continue
  1094. 42:23driving
  1095. 42:24at the beginning you know
  1096. 42:26there was a little bit of tension but
  1097. 42:28when i explained all the things that i
  1098. 42:30have seen in his driving behavior
  1099. 42:33he understood he followed my advice and
  1100. 42:35now he's super happy because he is not
  1101. 42:38going to be able to
  1102. 42:40to live
  1103. 42:41with uh
  1104. 42:42an accident that is done by himself even
  1105. 42:45you got and you don't need to renew the
  1106. 42:48tribulation every five years just
  1107. 42:50imagine that after the second year that
  1108. 42:52you got that driving license
  1109. 42:53your reflects your capabilities they are
  1110. 42:56dropping you know
  1111. 42:58and you're still capable by this one to
  1112. 43:01do it but you know that you are not in
  1113. 43:03your back in your in your best in order
  1114. 43:05to drive and for driving you must be at
  1115. 43:08your best okay
  1116. 43:10okay
  1117. 43:11so
  1118. 43:12the same system the design principles
  1119. 43:14that we got in here there are four
  1120. 43:16questions that i really like these four
  1121. 43:18questions okay
  1122. 43:19normally they are related all with with
  1123. 43:22a kind or a different type of accident
  1124. 43:24okay when we are talking about crashes
  1125. 43:28uh and the question that we got for the
  1126. 43:30design principle this is to help the
  1127. 43:31people
  1128. 43:32uh how to improve their design you can
  1129. 43:35say that okay
  1130. 43:37is it possible to had to have a heads on
  1131. 43:40collision at 70 kilometers per hour or
  1132. 43:42more
  1133. 43:43if the answer is yes
  1134. 43:45you should be changing okay your design
  1135. 43:49in order
  1136. 43:50uh that people they don't have that
  1137. 43:53chance to crash in a headstrong
  1138. 43:55collision at 70 kilometers or more
  1139. 43:58the other one that we have is
  1140. 44:00when you are in a junction you know is
  1141. 44:02it possible that you have a t-bone
  1142. 44:04junction a t-bone collision
  1143. 44:07at 50 kilometers per hour or more
  1144. 44:10again if the answer is yes we need to
  1145. 44:12change our design in order to avoid that
  1146. 44:14to happens
  1147. 44:16if you got
  1148. 44:17you know
  1149. 44:18hazards on the road on the clear song of
  1150. 44:21the road you know that they are
  1151. 44:22non-frangible
  1152. 44:24well the question would be can i crash
  1153. 44:27with them that they are not frangible
  1154. 44:28okay
  1155. 44:29at 40 kilometers per hour or more
  1156. 44:32if the answer is yes
  1157. 44:34we will be
  1158. 44:35removing the hazard
  1159. 44:37or relocating the hazard outside of the
  1160. 44:39clear zone
  1161. 44:41or we will be protecting but we need to
  1162. 44:44remove the possibility that someone
  1163. 44:47crashed with the kind of hazard
  1164. 44:49at 40 kilometers per hour or more okay
  1165. 44:52of course
  1166. 44:53the most important for vulnerable road
  1167. 44:55users okay
  1168. 44:57if can i crash or can i collide with a
  1169. 45:00road with a pedestrian or a cyclist at
  1170. 45:0430 kilometers per hour or more
  1171. 45:06again if the answer is yes
  1172. 45:08we need to find out the way that this
  1173. 45:11and this question is answer no because
  1174. 45:14meanwhile any of these questions
  1175. 45:17remain a suggest
  1176. 45:19meaning while you are doing your design
  1177. 45:22you are going to be liable according to
  1178. 45:24the safe system remember all the
  1179. 45:26disciplines they must work together okay
  1180. 45:29and designer
  1181. 45:31has a very important
  1182. 45:33part within the safe system approach
  1183. 45:36okay
  1184. 45:38so please after well
  1185. 45:43this is my favorite sentence i say this
  1186. 45:46every single time comply with the
  1187. 45:48standard does not guarantee draw safety
  1188. 45:50okay
  1189. 45:52still nowadays there are countries that
  1190. 45:55they don't have a standard that they
  1191. 45:57recognize
  1192. 45:58raw safety of the israel safety
  1193. 45:59inspection and these kind of things and
  1194. 46:00they consider that they understand that
  1195. 46:02they are so good
  1196. 46:03that with them
  1197. 46:05they don't need to have this other
  1198. 46:06approach however they are changing now
  1199. 46:08i'm talking about the states okay the
  1200. 46:10states they used to have the highway
  1201. 46:13capacity manual but now they got the
  1202. 46:16highway safety manual okay because they
  1203. 46:19realized that with that design that they
  1204. 46:20have only it was not enough so well done
  1205. 46:23for them hopefully one day they will
  1206. 46:25start doing raw safety audits too and
  1207. 46:28we will welcome the
  1208. 46:30the feeling okay but there are many
  1209. 46:32countries now around the world
  1210. 46:34that they got different kind of
  1211. 46:36standards okay if you click the next one
  1212. 46:38please i have put in here just
  1213. 46:41the the slide
  1214. 46:43with standards from different parts of
  1215. 46:44the world we go qatar saudi arabia we go
  1216. 46:47to australia
  1217. 46:49did you click
  1218. 46:51please
  1219. 46:53and we got the united kingdom i like no
  1220. 46:55no go back please
  1221. 46:58i like to put the united kingdom as a
  1222. 47:00deference
  1223. 47:01because for me
  1224. 47:04they are the pioneers when we are
  1225. 47:06talking about draw safety audits okay
  1226. 47:08they started in late 80s
  1227. 47:12and they were undertaking the same kind
  1228. 47:14of approach that they were doing for the
  1229. 47:15rail tracks
  1230. 47:16and that was a brilliant idea and since
  1231. 47:19then they have been developing many many
  1232. 47:21standards and this is why i i put them
  1233. 47:24the last one because for me they are
  1234. 47:25still the best even
  1235. 47:27uh now the safe system is not yet fully
  1236. 47:30implemented in the in the system they
  1237. 47:32will change they will change very soon
  1238. 47:34for for that kind of approach
  1239. 47:36okay so dr well please
  1240. 47:42the strategy
  1241. 47:44when we are talking about road safety it
  1242. 47:47can be divided in two different ways
  1243. 47:50okay the first one is are we going to
  1244. 47:53study an existing road
  1245. 47:55or are we going to study a new road
  1246. 47:59so
  1247. 48:00the approach that we are doing with road
  1248. 48:02safety audits draw safety inspections
  1249. 48:04and draw safety input assessment is an
  1250. 48:07approach that we call preventive
  1251. 48:10before it happens okay
  1252. 48:14later when we are studying
  1253. 48:17the accident or we do an accident
  1254. 48:19reconstruction or accident analysis this
  1255. 48:21is a reactive way
  1256. 48:23okay after that happens
  1257. 48:26okay
  1258. 48:26so what we are going to be doing is
  1259. 48:29different kind of things for different
  1260. 48:31kind of treatment that we need to
  1261. 48:32allocate on the road for example if you
  1262. 48:34click the next one
  1263. 48:36you will see
  1264. 48:38that
  1265. 48:40dr weil
  1266. 48:41if you click thank you
  1267. 48:44we need to have
  1268. 48:46different kind of tools for different
  1269. 48:48kind of facing that we have in here when
  1270. 48:50we are planifying
  1271. 48:52okay when we are magnifying the road or
  1272. 48:55the area that is going to be implemented
  1273. 48:58the new road or the new area that is
  1274. 48:59going to be implemented we will do our
  1275. 49:02raw safety impact study we will have you
  1276. 49:05know this kind of studies we will we
  1277. 49:07will see later on okay
  1278. 49:09when we are at the same phase in every
  1279. 49:11single phase okay
  1280. 49:13we will undertake row safety audits and
  1281. 49:16when the road is in operation we will do
  1282. 49:19our row safety inspections
  1283. 49:21okay
  1284. 49:22please doctor well
  1285. 49:29so we have as i said different kind of
  1286. 49:32tools for different kind of of decisions
  1287. 49:35that we have in the
  1288. 49:37in the road safety
  1289. 49:39world
  1290. 49:40we are going to study in here the road
  1291. 49:41safety impact assessment the road safety
  1292. 49:43audits and the road safety inspection
  1293. 49:45and dr well if you want don't continue
  1294. 49:48because i'm going to start with this but
  1295. 49:50i prefer not to have any more breaks so
  1296. 49:53do your break now if you don't mind
  1297. 49:55and later i can continue with these ones
  1298. 50:00hello
  1299. 50:06i think it will be difficult to continue
  1300. 50:08for the next three hours without any
  1301. 50:10break if you are targeting to
  1302. 50:12is this till the end of the session
  1303. 50:14today
  1304. 50:16yeah i can do as man no we can we can do
  1305. 50:20okay let's do it difficult to continue
  1306. 50:22for three hours again without a break uh
  1307. 50:26i prefer that maybe you continue for
  1308. 50:28another 30 minutes
  1309. 50:29then we can have one break if if it is
  1310. 50:31okay
  1311. 50:34um the problem is dr welder that i i
  1312. 50:36don't
  1313. 50:37i cannot manage myself the timing with
  1314. 50:40this one i prefer
  1315. 50:41i prefer that you do the the break that
  1316. 50:43you need to do now for the
  1317. 50:45questionnaire do that one and let me try
  1318. 50:48if i can do the presentation by myself
  1319. 50:50because seriously i feel i feel more
  1320. 50:52comfortable if i got the the fully
  1321. 50:54control of the of the slides okay sorry
  1322. 50:57no i'm not saying that you're not doing
  1323. 50:58a good job okay i'm not saying that
  1324. 51:00you're not doing that yeah dear
  1325. 51:01colleagues so now we will have a break
  1326. 51:04for 15 minutes but please allow me
  1327. 51:07meanwhile just to stop the share
  1328. 51:10and
  1329. 51:11to send you a link
  1330. 51:14for a
  1331. 51:16short questionnaire where we would like
  1332. 51:19everyone to participate with so please
  1333. 51:22go to your chat icon
  1334. 51:24in your screen
  1335. 51:26and
  1336. 51:27you will see
  1337. 51:32everyone
  1338. 51:33so i'm sending now the link of the
  1339. 51:36questionnaire to everyone
  1340. 51:38in this webinar
  1341. 51:40i will send it several times
  1342. 51:43i hope that every one of you will
  1343. 51:44receive it
  1344. 51:46so it has been sent now so please
  1345. 51:48fill this
  1346. 51:50questionnaire
  1347. 51:51it will it is very short around 10 to 11
  1348. 51:54questions it will take a few minutes
  1349. 51:55from you
  1350. 51:56and
  1351. 51:58it will end
  1352. 51:59quickly and then we will come back at 1
  1353. 52:0215. now it is 1 pm du time
  1354. 52:06we will come back after 15 minutes from
  1355. 52:08now to continue our webinar
  1356. 52:11with the
  1357. 52:12road safety assessments and road safety
  1358. 52:15audits and
  1359. 52:16inspections thank you
  1360. 52:18if you have any question please don't
  1361. 52:21hesitate to send us on the chat bar or
  1362. 52:24in the q and a
  1363. 52:26iphone also
  1364. 52:28thank you
  1365. 52:34in the meantime maybe we can pass remote
  1366. 52:37control to miguel so that you will be
  1367. 52:40sharing the slides and he can move the
  1368. 52:42slides himself
  1369. 52:44um to help him can i do that
  1370. 52:47yes we will try to do that yes oh
  1371. 52:49try the function now while uh the
  1372. 52:51participants are doing the uh the
  1373. 52:53questionnaires
  1374. 52:55and and certainly to the participants
  1375. 52:57don't go away
  1376. 52:58you shouldn't be uh leaving the
  1377. 53:00connection right now because we will be
  1378. 53:02soon starting
  1379. 53:04we're just
  1380. 53:06harvesting some information from you by
  1381. 53:08the questionnaire that will help us
  1382. 53:11in
  1383. 53:13in a study miguel can you can you
  1384. 53:15control now please
  1385. 53:17let me see
  1386. 53:21let me see
  1387. 53:26let's see
  1388. 53:30we come back now to our to continue our
  1389. 53:33uh uh workshop today
  1390. 53:35and uh
  1391. 53:36we will go ahead with the
  1392. 53:39next part of this webinar addressing
  1393. 53:42road safety assessments and audits as
  1394. 53:44well as inspections uh miguel the floor
  1395. 53:48is yours you can continue
  1396. 53:50and if you need any assistance we are
  1397. 53:51always here to support you thanks thank
  1398. 53:54you sir well thank you very much sorry
  1399. 53:56for all the technical details that i'm
  1400. 53:58having before but
  1401. 53:59okay my connection is bad what can i do
  1402. 54:02okay
  1403. 54:06and it's not working
  1404. 54:12there is no working
  1405. 54:20okay so let's see what is a row safety
  1406. 54:22impasse assessment let's start for the
  1407. 54:24first of the tools that we have already
  1408. 54:27described before
  1409. 54:28okay
  1410. 54:30the road safety impact assessment
  1411. 54:32normally it is done at the planning
  1412. 54:34stage okay
  1413. 54:36it's going to be a strategic assessment
  1414. 54:38for safety impact where we are going to
  1415. 54:41have a new road or we're going to have a
  1416. 54:44major modification
  1417. 54:46of an existing road okay
  1418. 54:49remember planning a stage okay no
  1419. 54:52designing yet no no planning a stage
  1420. 54:54when we are thinking about what we are
  1421. 54:56going to put in there
  1422. 54:58the earliest that we bring road safety
  1423. 55:00into our
  1424. 55:03into our thoughts you know
  1425. 55:05the best is going to be raw safety apply
  1426. 55:08in that in the
  1427. 55:10new development that we are doing or in
  1428. 55:12that major modification that we need to
  1429. 55:14do
  1430. 55:16we need to see and consider the impact
  1431. 55:18of the skin on the road network okay so
  1432. 55:22it's going to be a wider approach than
  1433. 55:24the road safety of it okay
  1434. 55:26and we can assess the impact for
  1435. 55:29different kind of groups for example
  1436. 55:32pedestrian cyclist
  1437. 55:34anything that
  1438. 55:36motorcyclist if you got any kind of
  1439. 55:38motorcyclist um
  1440. 55:41group that they decided to ride on the
  1441. 55:43road if you got that one that kind of
  1442. 55:45things okay
  1443. 55:52doctor well this is not
  1444. 56:00okay in order to
  1445. 56:02dr wild please if you can continue doing
  1446. 56:04your best with that one because for me
  1447. 56:06it's not working properly so it's better
  1448. 56:09that you continue doing the the slide
  1449. 56:14don't worry just try to do it if it's
  1450. 56:16not coming with you i will support you
  1451. 56:17there just thank you
  1452. 56:19welcome
  1453. 56:20thank you very much
  1454. 56:22okay sorry for the technical problems
  1455. 56:24again
  1456. 56:26the road safety impact assessment it
  1457. 56:28must be done or it must be performed at
  1458. 56:30least
  1459. 56:31for two independent experts as a minimum
  1460. 56:35okay we can always bring more people but
  1461. 56:37large number of professionals is always
  1462. 56:40difficult to control
  1463. 56:41okay so minimum of two independent
  1464. 56:44experts okay
  1465. 56:45that they are going to consider the
  1466. 56:47different planning options because it's
  1467. 56:49not the same to allocate a
  1468. 56:52a city or a new development where you
  1469. 56:54got the connection in the
  1470. 56:56interconnection from the city like
  1471. 56:58linear or you are going to do it but
  1472. 57:00different kind of spots okay
  1473. 57:03you will need to do
  1474. 57:05a cost benefit analysis okay you will is
  1475. 57:08the only one where we are also trying to
  1476. 57:12to maximize the benefit according to the
  1477. 57:15solutions that we are going to have in
  1478. 57:16here okay
  1479. 57:18and of course all of these all our
  1480. 57:20discoveries all our findings we are
  1481. 57:23going to pass to the project design
  1482. 57:24manager in order that he has the last
  1483. 57:26word to see how this is going to be
  1484. 57:29affecting the planification that they
  1485. 57:31are having
  1486. 57:32okay
  1487. 57:33so
  1488. 57:35for the russia
  1489. 57:36safety impact assessment okay
  1490. 57:39we need to do site visits
  1491. 57:41but not only for that
  1492. 57:43it's going to be done for every single
  1493. 57:45tool that we have
  1494. 57:47okay like the raw safety of the raw
  1495. 57:49safety inspection that we will see later
  1496. 57:51there are different kind of
  1497. 57:53side pieces that we will be undertaking
  1498. 57:55but for this one
  1499. 57:57it needs to be our initial planning that
  1500. 58:00we got it will be review through all the
  1501. 58:03design phases that we're going to have
  1502. 58:05okay
  1503. 58:06we're going to have and we are going to
  1504. 58:08ask for at least
  1505. 58:10five years collision data well i say at
  1506. 58:12least but some countries they don't have
  1507. 58:15all the records for the last five years
  1508. 58:17they got only three years okay whatever
  1509. 58:19is available
  1510. 58:21every country is going to have their own
  1511. 58:23ideas in crazy okay and we need to come
  1512. 58:27with that when we are asking for a
  1513. 58:29different kind of information
  1514. 58:31okay
  1515. 58:33we need to see what is going to be the
  1516. 58:36main role that vulnerable road users
  1517. 58:38they are going to have in here
  1518. 58:40okay
  1519. 58:41is not the same to
  1520. 58:43design or planify
  1521. 58:45the industrial area okay of a city
  1522. 58:49that a residential area
  1523. 58:52so we need to adjust the needs for
  1524. 58:55vulnerable users okay to the
  1525. 58:57planification that we are having they
  1526. 59:00are going to have also
  1527. 59:02uh
  1528. 59:04a row safety input very important okay
  1529. 59:08and of course we cannot forget about the
  1530. 59:11vulnerable road user wherever we are
  1531. 59:13even if it's an industrial area that we
  1532. 59:15are not expecting too many vulnerable
  1533. 59:17road users they are going to be
  1534. 59:20the most safety considerations
  1535. 59:22because they are going to have the
  1536. 59:24biggest problem if they are extracted by
  1537. 59:26any kind of vehicle
  1538. 59:28okay
  1539. 59:30well
  1540. 59:30when we got the
  1541. 59:32the road safety impact assessment
  1542. 59:35done we need to elaborate a report as i
  1543. 59:37said that we will go
  1544. 59:39to the
  1545. 59:41that we will go to the project manager
  1546. 59:43for his approval okay
  1547. 59:46so
  1548. 59:47our process in order to elaborate it is
  1549. 59:50going to say
  1550. 59:51the objectives okay the road safety
  1551. 59:54objectives that we need to be very
  1552. 59:56clearly defined okay in this kind of of
  1553. 59:59report
  1554. 1:00:00uh we are going to be assessing okay the
  1555. 1:00:04safety impact on the existing road
  1556. 1:00:06network okay any tool any consideration
  1557. 1:00:10that we are
  1558. 1:00:11taking outside of the road network is
  1559. 1:00:13not going to be valid or is not going to
  1560. 1:00:15be replicated okay we cannot do copy
  1561. 1:00:18paste from different areas of different
  1562. 1:00:21reports
  1563. 1:00:22because each area it needs to be studied
  1564. 1:00:25in isolation okay
  1565. 1:00:27we need to study different options okay
  1566. 1:00:30do
  1567. 1:00:31uh in five years doing 10 years do with
  1568. 1:00:34this kind of of money with this funding
  1569. 1:00:37that we have even do nothing they don't
  1570. 1:00:40know do nothing a scenario needs to be
  1571. 1:00:42assessed
  1572. 1:00:43we need to see
  1573. 1:00:44how that kind of area is going to be
  1574. 1:00:47done if we don't do anything inside
  1575. 1:00:50okay
  1576. 1:00:52we need to analyze
  1577. 1:00:53all the options okay for the road safety
  1578. 1:00:56impact and we need to present all the
  1579. 1:00:59possible solutions that we engineers or
  1580. 1:01:02people that we are dedicated to road
  1581. 1:01:04safety are going to be able to provide
  1582. 1:01:08okay
  1583. 1:01:09so as i said
  1584. 1:01:11this is the
  1585. 1:01:12draw safety impact assessment for the
  1586. 1:01:14planification
  1587. 1:01:16now
  1588. 1:01:17what is a row safety audit well
  1589. 1:01:20there are different ways to define
  1590. 1:01:23a row safety audit okay
  1591. 1:01:25my favorite one
  1592. 1:01:27is the the one from also road that is a
  1593. 1:01:29formal examination okay
  1594. 1:01:32of a future road or traffic project
  1595. 1:01:35or an existing road in which an
  1596. 1:01:38independent
  1597. 1:01:39unqualified team
  1598. 1:01:41reports on project crash
  1599. 1:01:43potential and safety performance
  1600. 1:01:45listen because i have put in
  1601. 1:01:48bold
  1602. 1:01:49the things that i consider this
  1603. 1:01:50definition is bringing to us
  1604. 1:01:53okay
  1605. 1:01:54it's a formal examination
  1606. 1:01:56so it's not a matter of opinion or
  1607. 1:01:58random checking that we do no no formal
  1608. 1:02:01examination okay so there might be
  1609. 1:02:04parameters there must be a standard
  1610. 1:02:05there might be guidelines in order that
  1611. 1:02:08they instruct you how to perform these
  1612. 1:02:11kind of things
  1613. 1:02:12okay
  1614. 1:02:13and they say the word independent and
  1615. 1:02:16qualified team independent yes of course
  1616. 1:02:19if i'm doing
  1617. 1:02:21the road safety sorry the road safety
  1618. 1:02:24audit of a project
  1619. 1:02:25i cannot be involved in the design of
  1620. 1:02:27that project
  1621. 1:02:29i cannot be involved either
  1622. 1:02:31in the construction of that project so i
  1623. 1:02:33must be
  1624. 1:02:34an independent
  1625. 1:02:36auditor
  1626. 1:02:38in the way
  1627. 1:02:39that
  1628. 1:02:41i can
  1629. 1:02:42make all my comments without any kind of
  1630. 1:02:44pressure of stress or stress
  1631. 1:02:47from the parties that they are
  1632. 1:02:48elaborating and they are
  1633. 1:02:50performing that they are doing this
  1634. 1:02:51project
  1635. 1:02:52okay
  1636. 1:02:54well
  1637. 1:02:56as i said is going to be a process where
  1638. 1:02:58we are checking you know
  1639. 1:03:01the road infrastructure
  1640. 1:03:03that this require
  1641. 1:03:05a
  1642. 1:03:06an independent design team
  1643. 1:03:08that have been done by an independent
  1644. 1:03:10design team
  1645. 1:03:11so the people that they are conducting
  1646. 1:03:14this design okay cannot be involved in
  1647. 1:03:17any case
  1648. 1:03:18for uh with the raw safety of it
  1649. 1:03:21in fact there will be communication
  1650. 1:03:23between the row safety auditors and the
  1651. 1:03:25design team
  1652. 1:03:26but needs to be registered every single
  1653. 1:03:28thing in order that the rosehip theodore
  1654. 1:03:30doesn't compromise his position and
  1655. 1:03:33become a designer okay
  1656. 1:03:37so we are going to try to minimize the
  1657. 1:03:39risk and the severity of the crashes in
  1658. 1:03:41every single new project okay so arrow
  1659. 1:03:45safety audit is also well defined
  1660. 1:03:48or what is not
  1661. 1:03:50and whatever is not is not a check of
  1662. 1:03:53the scheme of the standards that has
  1663. 1:03:55been constructed okay it's not a
  1664. 1:03:57technical check because we are not there
  1665. 1:04:00to see if the engineers they have done a
  1666. 1:04:03good job or they haven't done a good job
  1667. 1:04:06if they have followed the standard or
  1668. 1:04:07not because
  1669. 1:04:08we suppose that they have done it
  1670. 1:04:10properly we suppose that we are all
  1671. 1:04:12professionals okay
  1672. 1:04:14we need to see beyond the standard
  1673. 1:04:17okay this hd 1915 that i have put in
  1674. 1:04:20here is because in there they define
  1675. 1:04:22what is not a row safety audit okay but
  1676. 1:04:26now the standard that we got is the
  1677. 1:04:27version two of the g119 in the uk
  1678. 1:04:31okay
  1679. 1:04:32so as i said independence is critical
  1680. 1:04:35if you are not independent you cannot do
  1681. 1:04:37any raw safety of it okay
  1682. 1:04:41we need to check
  1683. 1:04:42the safety of the road
  1684. 1:04:46under every single condition
  1685. 1:04:48i always say that
  1686. 1:04:50if you got the opportunity
  1687. 1:04:52to go to a road when you got a very bad
  1688. 1:04:55rain or when you got a very bad wind you
  1689. 1:04:58know the weather conditions they are
  1690. 1:04:59changing
  1691. 1:05:00it's much better that you go in a sunny
  1692. 1:05:03day and you enjoy
  1693. 1:05:05the trip that you are doing
  1694. 1:05:07because the road may behave in a
  1695. 1:05:09different way
  1696. 1:05:11depending on the weather condition okay
  1697. 1:05:13and you will perceive the risk that they
  1698. 1:05:15are associated to the kind those kind of
  1699. 1:05:17weather conditions that in other
  1700. 1:05:19situations you are not going to be able
  1701. 1:05:21to perceive
  1702. 1:05:22okay
  1703. 1:05:24so
  1704. 1:05:25when we do our report
  1705. 1:05:27we need to focus in our vulnerable road
  1706. 1:05:30users the same that we had in the
  1707. 1:05:33impacts assessment exactly the same in
  1708. 1:05:35the road safety impact assessment focus
  1709. 1:05:37in the vulnerable your broad user the
  1710. 1:05:40raw safety audit they will focus in
  1711. 1:05:42every single user
  1712. 1:05:43but most
  1713. 1:05:44in the
  1714. 1:05:45vulnerable users okay
  1715. 1:05:48so at the end the report will be
  1716. 1:05:50submitted to the design team okay and
  1717. 1:05:54they will have a certain list of
  1718. 1:05:57identified problems that that we have
  1719. 1:05:59done
  1720. 1:06:00where
  1721. 1:06:02we are going to be
  1722. 1:06:03able to discuss with them what is going
  1723. 1:06:06to be our way forward
  1724. 1:06:09okay
  1725. 1:06:11so
  1726. 1:06:12now the question is
  1727. 1:06:13why are we undertaking draw safety
  1728. 1:06:15audits
  1729. 1:06:17well it's clear
  1730. 1:06:19because we're going to mitigate the
  1731. 1:06:21chance that accident happens okay
  1732. 1:06:24if we don't mitigate the chance of
  1733. 1:06:26accident happens we will mitigate the
  1734. 1:06:28consequences of those accidents okay
  1735. 1:06:33and we want to create draw safety
  1736. 1:06:35consciousness
  1737. 1:06:37okay
  1738. 1:06:38that is that is something that is very
  1739. 1:06:39important in order that the people that
  1740. 1:06:41they are using the road or the people
  1741. 1:06:43that they are designing the road or the
  1742. 1:06:45people that they are managing the
  1743. 1:06:47operations of the road
  1744. 1:06:49they realize what we are doing
  1745. 1:06:51according to road safety and as you see
  1746. 1:06:54i'm not saying only the road users i'm
  1747. 1:06:56putting every single one that is related
  1748. 1:06:58to the road as we said the safe system
  1749. 1:07:01is coming for every single discipline
  1750. 1:07:03okay
  1751. 1:07:05and they're taking their safety audits
  1752. 1:07:07is going to reduce drastically the cause
  1753. 1:07:09of the project that is something that we
  1754. 1:07:11will see later on that is not that is
  1755. 1:07:13not a problem
  1756. 1:07:14okay
  1757. 1:07:17so
  1758. 1:07:18how are going to undertake a row safety
  1759. 1:07:20audit well first we need to define the
  1760. 1:07:23scope
  1761. 1:07:24of the row safety audit okay what is
  1762. 1:07:26going to be audited and what is not
  1763. 1:07:28going to be audited what kind of what
  1764. 1:07:30kind of project they require a road
  1765. 1:07:32safety audit or if a project require a
  1766. 1:07:35road safety audit
  1767. 1:07:36why
  1768. 1:07:37is it going to be wrong or not or is
  1769. 1:07:39exempted for for any kind of reason so
  1770. 1:07:42we need to set up our scope okay
  1771. 1:07:45and we need to set up also the road
  1772. 1:07:48safety of the brief
  1773. 1:07:50the other brief
  1774. 1:07:52is
  1775. 1:07:53a document that the designer should
  1776. 1:07:56provide us the designer contractor
  1777. 1:07:58whoever is in charge of that one whoever
  1778. 1:08:00is telling you that you need to do a raw
  1779. 1:08:01safety audit
  1780. 1:08:02he needs to provide you this kind of
  1781. 1:08:04information
  1782. 1:08:06with all the details as much detail
  1783. 1:08:09as much
  1784. 1:08:12okay
  1785. 1:08:13as much details as they give you
  1786. 1:08:16regarding the location of the road what
  1787. 1:08:19is happening on the road what kind of
  1788. 1:08:21development you got
  1789. 1:08:23who is the local authority who is going
  1790. 1:08:25to be responsible engineer for that one
  1791. 1:08:28what kind of things they are expecting
  1792. 1:08:30you to see so this kind of audit brief
  1793. 1:08:33normally is given and is the main piece
  1794. 1:08:36of information that the auditor will
  1795. 1:08:37receive independently of the states that
  1796. 1:08:39you are okay so with this
  1797. 1:08:42uh the
  1798. 1:08:44the authority
  1799. 1:08:46the previous sponsor
  1800. 1:08:48will
  1801. 1:08:49will agree or have a grip in advance
  1802. 1:08:52about the audit team we will see later
  1803. 1:08:54the characteristic of the audit team
  1804. 1:08:56okay and the other thing
  1805. 1:08:58will prepare
  1806. 1:08:59a rose safety report
  1807. 1:09:01okay the road safety of the report in
  1808. 1:09:03that report as i said we will find
  1809. 1:09:05problems and recommendations okay
  1810. 1:09:08all of this is going to be done on the
  1811. 1:09:10stages of the road safety audit there
  1812. 1:09:12are different kind of stages different
  1813. 1:09:14kind of countries we will see that in
  1814. 1:09:16in a minute too
  1815. 1:09:18and of course
  1816. 1:09:20the road safety audit it cannot be done
  1817. 1:09:23if you don't undertake a roadside visit
  1818. 1:09:25okay the road safety audit requires side
  1819. 1:09:27visits even if it's in the feasibility
  1820. 1:09:30study that there is nothing in there
  1821. 1:09:32okay
  1822. 1:09:33is compulsory to have that one there are
  1823. 1:09:36different ways
  1824. 1:09:37there are different ways for
  1825. 1:09:39undertaking safe disease and during this
  1826. 1:09:41pandemic we have been very
  1827. 1:09:43we in road safety editor we have been
  1828. 1:09:45very restricted and limited at the time
  1829. 1:09:47to do
  1830. 1:09:48to do the
  1831. 1:09:49the road safety audits so
  1832. 1:09:52some authorities they were allowing us
  1833. 1:09:55just to travel in different days you
  1834. 1:09:57know the
  1835. 1:09:58the raw safety auditors or
  1836. 1:10:01using you know tools like google that i
  1837. 1:10:04don't like a lot because normally the
  1838. 1:10:05information is not very good or it's not
  1839. 1:10:07up to date
  1840. 1:10:08as a if it was something that it was
  1841. 1:10:11going to be a stage one two or three
  1842. 1:10:14but if it was the other ones you need to
  1843. 1:10:16you need to do it in different cars so
  1844. 1:10:18there has been certain restrictions that
  1845. 1:10:21they have been eased now and we can go
  1846. 1:10:23and work as we used to do
  1847. 1:10:27the other team
  1848. 1:10:29the other team the other thing it has
  1849. 1:10:31different kind of
  1850. 1:10:33conditions in every single country that
  1851. 1:10:36you are going to do raw safety audits
  1852. 1:10:38but there are common things for all of
  1853. 1:10:40them
  1854. 1:10:42the other team must be trained
  1855. 1:10:45okay
  1856. 1:10:47and my they must be independent
  1857. 1:10:50okay
  1858. 1:10:52the other team must be multidisciplinary
  1859. 1:10:55and need to be objective and impartial
  1860. 1:10:58okay now we can debate and we can say
  1861. 1:11:01what is the minimum qualification that
  1862. 1:11:03the audit team leader the other team
  1863. 1:11:05member or the audit observer or the
  1864. 1:11:08specialist they must have okay
  1865. 1:11:11because the other team aside
  1866. 1:11:13is divided in this kind of four
  1867. 1:11:16categories the leaders the member of
  1868. 1:11:18server and specialist okay
  1869. 1:11:21the team leader
  1870. 1:11:23we know and the thing that we use in
  1871. 1:11:25different kind of
  1872. 1:11:27associations like acevi or sorsa that we
  1873. 1:11:30follow the english model we need to do a
  1874. 1:11:3310 days training course
  1875. 1:11:35just to have a one year
  1876. 1:11:38of
  1877. 1:11:40one year of experience about class
  1878. 1:11:42investigation or raw safety engineering
  1879. 1:11:45okay
  1880. 1:11:46and you need to have your cpd continuous
  1881. 1:11:49professional development
  1882. 1:11:50that is what we do in order that you
  1883. 1:11:53become observer
  1884. 1:11:55after two years of that and continue
  1885. 1:11:57with your professional development and
  1886. 1:11:59continue with the number of audits that
  1887. 1:12:00they are required it can be five in
  1888. 1:12:03twelve in one year or in
  1889. 1:12:05in two years it can be five it can be
  1890. 1:12:07ten whatever country you are it can be
  1891. 1:12:09eight
  1892. 1:12:10depending on which organization or which
  1893. 1:12:12country you are visiting this kind of
  1894. 1:12:15rules they are going to set up in
  1895. 1:12:16different way but in different numbers
  1896. 1:12:19but the rules they are the same so they
  1897. 1:12:21are telling you that you must have
  1898. 1:12:23experience you have you must be exposed
  1899. 1:12:26to the road you must
  1900. 1:12:28write draw safety audits in order to
  1901. 1:12:30understand what you are saying so you
  1902. 1:12:32start collaborating and you start being
  1903. 1:12:35a team member
  1904. 1:12:36okay
  1905. 1:12:38and when you gain a lot of experience it
  1906. 1:12:39can be four years it can be 10 years for
  1907. 1:12:41some people
  1908. 1:12:42people in the european investment ban
  1909. 1:12:45they're asking for 15 years experience
  1910. 1:12:47just to become the leader so depending
  1911. 1:12:49on where you are
  1912. 1:12:51when you have accumulated and gain
  1913. 1:12:53experience you know in the field and you
  1914. 1:12:55have been doing your continuous
  1915. 1:12:58professional development every year in
  1916. 1:13:00order that you keep up to date with the
  1917. 1:13:02last things that they happen in the
  1918. 1:13:03world for raw safety
  1919. 1:13:05what they call you team leader
  1920. 1:13:07okay
  1921. 1:13:08and and that is and that is the one that
  1922. 1:13:12is the responsible
  1923. 1:13:14to organize the other team
  1924. 1:13:17the other team
  1925. 1:13:19must have a minimum of two
  1926. 1:13:22okay
  1927. 1:13:23these are
  1928. 1:13:24the team leader
  1929. 1:13:25and the team member
  1930. 1:13:27but is not limited to two
  1931. 1:13:29okay because there will be moments
  1932. 1:13:32where you will require to have
  1933. 1:13:35a specialist in things that you are not
  1934. 1:13:37an expert imagine if i need to do a
  1935. 1:13:40a road safety audit for a traffic signal
  1936. 1:13:42control
  1937. 1:13:44and i want someone that knows exactly
  1938. 1:13:46how the traffic signal is programmed
  1939. 1:13:48in order they can check and give me
  1940. 1:13:50advice about that one
  1941. 1:13:52okay or imagine that i'm doing a road
  1942. 1:13:54safety audit on a bridge
  1943. 1:13:57and i'm not a specialist in a
  1944. 1:13:59so i will call
  1945. 1:14:01a structural engineer in order that he
  1946. 1:14:03can help me with this raw safety audit
  1947. 1:14:05okay
  1948. 1:14:07observer is a key
  1949. 1:14:09word of the audit team
  1950. 1:14:12you don't need to have or you shouldn't
  1951. 1:14:14have
  1952. 1:14:15more than two of servers in a row safety
  1953. 1:14:17audit
  1954. 1:14:19but they are going to appreciate a lot
  1955. 1:14:21that they are in there because they are
  1956. 1:14:23starting their career in row safety
  1957. 1:14:26auditing and they need to be with people
  1958. 1:14:28that they can advise them and they can
  1959. 1:14:30do like they all you know just to see
  1960. 1:14:32and listen but they are not going to be
  1961. 1:14:34talking the only thing
  1962. 1:14:36is for them to start feeling you know
  1963. 1:14:40what is a road safety audit and how you
  1964. 1:14:42perform the duties of a row safety
  1965. 1:14:44auditor
  1966. 1:14:45so
  1967. 1:14:46you must remember that you don't finish
  1968. 1:14:49your training course that it can be many
  1969. 1:14:52different training courses
  1970. 1:14:54but
  1971. 1:14:55the one that we got in the gg119 or in
  1972. 1:14:58qatar or in saudi you got a 10 days
  1973. 1:15:00training course that is
  1974. 1:15:02broadly acceptable okay in the united
  1975. 1:15:04nations is also the same kind of
  1976. 1:15:06training course that they were doing
  1977. 1:15:08well remember that when you finish your
  1978. 1:15:11training course
  1979. 1:15:13you don't come and you are
  1980. 1:15:15out of that training course
  1981. 1:15:17as a team leader bro safety auditor
  1982. 1:15:19impossible
  1983. 1:15:21and i know
  1984. 1:15:22that there are people that they say that
  1985. 1:15:25they are team leaders when they haven't
  1986. 1:15:26done a proper
  1987. 1:15:28uh they haven't
  1988. 1:15:30they haven't faced the problems
  1989. 1:15:33uh of being a team member first or our
  1990. 1:15:37server earlier than that
  1991. 1:15:40the training course
  1992. 1:15:41is just
  1993. 1:15:42the foundation
  1994. 1:15:44okay
  1995. 1:15:46the training course is something that is
  1996. 1:15:48going to give you the knowledge that you
  1997. 1:15:50don't have
  1998. 1:15:52but after that you need time to settle
  1999. 1:15:55that knowledge
  2000. 1:15:56okay you need time to understand
  2001. 1:15:59the things that they were said on the
  2002. 1:16:01training course this is why
  2003. 1:16:03you build your capabilities with time
  2004. 1:16:06and you cannot be directly a team leader
  2005. 1:16:08after you finish your training course
  2006. 1:16:10you need time to settle and you need
  2007. 1:16:12time to gain your experience okay
  2008. 1:16:16there are different kind of associations
  2009. 1:16:18around the world i'm very lucky that i
  2010. 1:16:20belong to sosa and i belong to acevi
  2011. 1:16:23and i'm super happy you know but these
  2012. 1:16:26are the associations that they are going
  2013. 1:16:28to
  2014. 1:16:28keep you
  2015. 1:16:29updated they are going to recognize
  2016. 1:16:33that you have a valuable
  2017. 1:16:35input in draw safety because
  2018. 1:16:38if you are member of any professional
  2019. 1:16:40association like these ones
  2020. 1:16:42they are like the
  2021. 1:16:45granted association for your quality as
  2022. 1:16:47an auditor if you don't comply with the
  2023. 1:16:50rules and regulations you're not going
  2024. 1:16:52to be able to enter there
  2025. 1:16:53okay so they are quite strict to accept
  2026. 1:16:56the people
  2027. 1:16:57but when you are in
  2028. 1:17:00that that is not the most difficult part
  2029. 1:17:04you will you will realize that the
  2030. 1:17:06difficult part
  2031. 1:17:08is to stay in
  2032. 1:17:10is to continue performing your
  2033. 1:17:12activities and duties up to their
  2034. 1:17:14standards okay
  2035. 1:17:16so yeah that is that is a very important
  2036. 1:17:18part of the row safety editing process
  2037. 1:17:20too
  2038. 1:17:22okay
  2039. 1:17:23so now i'm going to talk about the row
  2040. 1:17:25safety of the stages
  2041. 1:17:27how many stages can we find in a row
  2042. 1:17:30safety audit well
  2043. 1:17:32depends
  2044. 1:17:33we're going to find
  2045. 1:17:35different kind of stages like in here
  2046. 1:17:38the the one that i have put that you got
  2047. 1:17:40the stage 1 concept stage two
  2048. 1:17:43preliminary stage three detail
  2049. 1:17:46that means that you can combine two and
  2050. 1:17:48three
  2051. 1:17:49if the project is not very good it's not
  2052. 1:17:51very small it's not very big
  2053. 1:17:53stage four construction stage five port
  2054. 1:17:55construction stage six existing road pro
  2055. 1:17:58safety inspection and later you got the
  2056. 1:18:00interim the thematic the war zones okay
  2057. 1:18:04so
  2058. 1:18:05very distinctive different kind of
  2059. 1:18:06stages
  2060. 1:18:08oh but in my country we got four stages
  2061. 1:18:10perfect it doesn't matter
  2062. 1:18:14the thing that matters
  2063. 1:18:15is that you follow
  2064. 1:18:17your formal checking way for doing that
  2065. 1:18:21the process that you are following
  2066. 1:18:23is going to be consistent you know so
  2067. 1:18:25you got one four or 22 different stages
  2068. 1:18:30it doesn't matter you will define them
  2069. 1:18:32in your standards
  2070. 1:18:34okay
  2071. 1:18:35ideally ideally we should have all row
  2072. 1:18:38safety editors in the world the same
  2073. 1:18:40kind of guidance the same kind of
  2074. 1:18:42standard the same kind of process to
  2075. 1:18:44follow to unify criteria
  2076. 1:18:46okay
  2077. 1:18:47this is why
  2078. 1:18:49it's very important that the different
  2079. 1:18:51association or row safety editors in the
  2080. 1:18:52world they
  2081. 1:18:54they come across different kind of
  2082. 1:18:56things and and get the support of the
  2083. 1:18:59united nations or the
  2084. 1:19:01federation international automobilism in
  2085. 1:19:04order that we can have a beautiful
  2086. 1:19:06unified standard in order that we have
  2087. 1:19:08common ground of knowledge okay but
  2088. 1:19:10believe me if you don't have a stage one
  2089. 1:19:13concept and a stage two preliminary and
  2090. 1:19:15you combine this stage one and two and
  2091. 1:19:17you call it feasibility it's okay
  2092. 1:19:19it's okay depending what you are working
  2093. 1:19:21you need to adapt
  2094. 1:19:22but remember
  2095. 1:19:24the raw safety editing is a philosophy
  2096. 1:19:26okay so it's not a problem the way that
  2097. 1:19:29you call this one call it tomato if you
  2098. 1:19:30want
  2099. 1:19:31okay
  2100. 1:19:32staged tomato it doesn't matter the
  2101. 1:19:35thing that they want to see is that you
  2102. 1:19:37follow the process okay
  2103. 1:19:39so
  2104. 1:19:40what have we got in here
  2105. 1:19:42well we got the stage for conflict okay
  2106. 1:19:45in there we are going to see the
  2107. 1:19:47planning for the area okay and we're
  2108. 1:19:50going to see what is going to be the
  2109. 1:19:52interaction that we have with all the
  2110. 1:19:55road the adjacent adjacent road network
  2111. 1:19:57okay
  2112. 1:19:59we are going to assess and we are going
  2113. 1:20:00to understand what is going to be the
  2114. 1:20:02land use
  2115. 1:20:03because maybe in the future we are going
  2116. 1:20:04to have to have
  2117. 1:20:06potential residential uses that they are
  2118. 1:20:09going to be in conflict with industrial
  2119. 1:20:11or they are going to have focal points
  2120. 1:20:13like a supermarket or or a school or a
  2121. 1:20:16hospital okay
  2122. 1:20:18we are going to see the traffic
  2123. 1:20:20estimation during this during this stage
  2124. 1:20:23okay is where we are going to define
  2125. 1:20:26what kind of roads we are going to put
  2126. 1:20:28inside collector roads arterial are
  2127. 1:20:30going to have local roads or is going to
  2128. 1:20:32be rural road so this kind of a stage is
  2129. 1:20:35is very crucial to take big changes
  2130. 1:20:39about the physonomy that we are that we
  2131. 1:20:42are planning okay
  2132. 1:20:44we are going to decide in here very
  2133. 1:20:46important thank you the type of junction
  2134. 1:20:48just imagine that you are saying oh no
  2135. 1:20:50very good very good we are going to put
  2136. 1:20:52in here on our run about and when you
  2137. 1:20:54are in the detailed design that
  2138. 1:20:57everybody has been planning for ronaldo
  2139. 1:20:59you say no no no run about is not going
  2140. 1:21:01to be good i want a great separator come
  2141. 1:21:04on you cannot say that at this stage
  2142. 1:21:06it's too late already at that stage the
  2143. 1:21:09only thing that you will mitigate
  2144. 1:21:11whatever is happening in there but this
  2145. 1:21:13is the stage where you are going to be
  2146. 1:21:15thinking about the typology of the
  2147. 1:21:17junctions that you're going to have
  2148. 1:21:20how are we going to be treating the
  2149. 1:21:22special places you know the communities
  2150. 1:21:24the community center the schools the
  2151. 1:21:26hospital the pedestrian areas that we
  2152. 1:21:28have we need to know how to access their
  2153. 1:21:31emergency okay that is going to be the
  2154. 1:21:34emergency
  2155. 1:21:36fest plan the emergency plan the first
  2156. 1:21:39one that we're going to have for this
  2157. 1:21:40area too
  2158. 1:21:41so it's our first
  2159. 1:21:43approach
  2160. 1:21:44to the concept design okay
  2161. 1:21:47so when we go to one we need to ask
  2162. 1:21:49ourselves okay it's concept design why
  2163. 1:21:51do we need to do a road safety audit
  2164. 1:21:53when we are just in concept that we
  2165. 1:21:55haven't put anything anything formally
  2166. 1:21:57designed yet okay
  2167. 1:22:00because we need to be assured that raw
  2168. 1:22:02safety is included in the decision many
  2169. 1:22:05times many times it's happening to me
  2170. 1:22:07that
  2171. 1:22:08i'm not even called for meetings
  2172. 1:22:11where i know that they are trying to do
  2173. 1:22:13for example uh a world song you know
  2174. 1:22:16they are preparing our song and nobody
  2175. 1:22:19no representative from the rose safety
  2176. 1:22:20section is there
  2177. 1:22:22how can you okay so draw safety must be
  2178. 1:22:26included in order that they are taking
  2179. 1:22:28decisions with us i don't say that rose
  2180. 1:22:31safety is the last one taking the
  2181. 1:22:32decision that would be ideal but that is
  2182. 1:22:34in the ideal world not in the reality
  2183. 1:22:37but i said that at least they should
  2184. 1:22:38listen us okay because when they call us
  2185. 1:22:43it's because it's too late
  2186. 1:22:44they're having already problems okay
  2187. 1:22:47bring
  2188. 1:22:48the road safety at the beginning as i
  2189. 1:22:50said before okay
  2190. 1:22:52in here is possible
  2191. 1:22:54to change things
  2192. 1:22:56without any cost
  2193. 1:22:58okay the cost implication is nil or
  2194. 1:23:01nothing okay and we can obviously
  2195. 1:23:04avoid the problems that we can have in
  2196. 1:23:06the design so we can say okay how is
  2197. 1:23:10that possible that you have put a road
  2198. 1:23:11in here or a cycle path that finish on a
  2199. 1:23:15on a wall or you are not giving
  2200. 1:23:16continuity or for the road for the road
  2201. 1:23:20markings sorry for the market for the
  2202. 1:23:22road exit doesn't run about you're not
  2203. 1:23:24giving continuation
  2204. 1:23:26so that kind of obvious mistakes that it
  2205. 1:23:29can happen at the beginning of the
  2206. 1:23:31design phase it's very easy to to define
  2207. 1:23:34to find
  2208. 1:23:36and to correct them okay
  2209. 1:23:38of course it's our first approach
  2210. 1:23:41for the safety
  2211. 1:23:42for all users
  2212. 1:23:44okay
  2213. 1:23:45just remember
  2214. 1:23:46that the the right of way of a road is
  2215. 1:23:50is shared by many road users okay
  2216. 1:23:54so
  2217. 1:23:55we need to start
  2218. 1:23:56bringing draw safety
  2219. 1:23:58the sooner the better
  2220. 1:24:00okay with the stage two the stage two is
  2221. 1:24:04the preliminary design
  2222. 1:24:07and here
  2223. 1:24:08we know what we are going to be doing
  2224. 1:24:10here well we are going to do the
  2225. 1:24:14the design speed
  2226. 1:24:15we are going to choose what is going to
  2227. 1:24:17be the design speed
  2228. 1:24:19fantastic design speed that later people
  2229. 1:24:22they decided to to convert in the posted
  2230. 1:24:24speed and later we got the operational
  2231. 1:24:27speed but that is another another matter
  2232. 1:24:29that i would like to talk at some point
  2233. 1:24:32the design speed this is important
  2234. 1:24:34because according to the one
  2235. 1:24:37the contractor they will try to cheat
  2236. 1:24:40you know using design speed
  2237. 1:24:42in order that they can allocate uh
  2238. 1:24:46things or features that they are not
  2239. 1:24:47going to be
  2240. 1:24:48the
  2241. 1:24:49the right ones for the road but it's
  2242. 1:24:51okay we will go that later on
  2243. 1:24:54in in here preliminary we're going to
  2244. 1:24:56see our geometry the geometry the
  2245. 1:24:58vertical alignment the resultant
  2246. 1:24:59alignment the way that they conquer
  2247. 1:25:01central and vertical alignment is very
  2248. 1:25:03important just to avoid things like when
  2249. 1:25:06you are having a crest after after that
  2250. 1:25:08one you you put a bend and you cannot
  2251. 1:25:11see the
  2252. 1:25:12the road the way that is going to be so
  2253. 1:25:15the variations in geometry now is when
  2254. 1:25:18we need to do it now when it's built
  2255. 1:25:20okay
  2256. 1:25:22if we got any kind of constraint when we
  2257. 1:25:24are talking about the visibility the
  2258. 1:25:26stop-inside distance okay
  2259. 1:25:28is there because you have to decide this
  2260. 1:25:30is it okay and they have provided you
  2261. 1:25:33with this okay they are giving you the
  2262. 1:25:36road that is going to be plannified is
  2263. 1:25:38there any obstacles in there you have
  2264. 1:25:40been there and you realize like come on
  2265. 1:25:41how are they going to remove that house
  2266. 1:25:44have they got that one no no no we don't
  2267. 1:25:46have more language question so that is
  2268. 1:25:48going to be a problem
  2269. 1:25:50or the band if you are having a
  2270. 1:25:53sharp bend that
  2271. 1:25:55that it hasn't got any kind of
  2272. 1:25:56visibility after that because in one of
  2273. 1:25:58the lateral side they cannot they cannot
  2274. 1:26:01maintain with the visibility distance
  2275. 1:26:03that they need to have
  2276. 1:26:04okay the clear sound that they need to
  2277. 1:26:06have for that one
  2278. 1:26:09we will know in here how many
  2279. 1:26:10infrastructure and what type of
  2280. 1:26:12infrastructure we're going to have if
  2281. 1:26:14we're going to have any underpass any
  2282. 1:26:16tunnel any bridge
  2283. 1:26:18okay that is going to come in here
  2284. 1:26:20very important to assess those
  2285. 1:26:22independently of course you are going to
  2286. 1:26:24assess that as a
  2287. 1:26:26as a whole road
  2288. 1:26:27but make a special
  2289. 1:26:30deal
  2290. 1:26:31with the with the structure itself okay
  2291. 1:26:35the public transport
  2292. 1:26:37we need to know which are going to be
  2293. 1:26:39the routes uh what kind of published
  2294. 1:26:41transport are we going to have a lt are
  2295. 1:26:43going to have buses are going to have
  2296. 1:26:45metro so everything we should know what
  2297. 1:26:48is going to be the
  2298. 1:26:50what is going to be the
  2299. 1:26:52the significant approach for public
  2300. 1:26:54transport that we are having in this
  2301. 1:26:56area okay
  2302. 1:26:59public transporter of course you are
  2303. 1:27:01using the metro is it there any kind of
  2304. 1:27:04bicycle facilities to go there any
  2305. 1:27:06pedestrian crossing in the vicinity
  2306. 1:27:09all this kind of stuff is related so
  2307. 1:27:13multi-modal transport that you are
  2308. 1:27:15coming by coach from the outskirts of
  2309. 1:27:18the city and they bring you directly to
  2310. 1:27:21the metro or you are coming by bicycle
  2311. 1:27:24and you need to use the
  2312. 1:27:26you need to use the bus station you know
  2313. 1:27:28all this kind of stuff need to be into
  2314. 1:27:30consideration in this preliminary one
  2315. 1:27:33okay
  2316. 1:27:34the number of lanes of course number of
  2317. 1:27:36lanes heart shoulder that we have the
  2318. 1:27:38width of the lanes all of that is coming
  2319. 1:27:41you know in accordance with the volume
  2320. 1:27:43traffic that we're going before in the
  2321. 1:27:44previous one we already saw what is
  2322. 1:27:46going to be the traffic volume well now
  2323. 1:27:48we are designing in accordance with the
  2324. 1:27:51traffic volume that we have before okay
  2325. 1:27:54and of course the typology of the
  2326. 1:27:55junction we need to confirm that the one
  2327. 1:27:58that we have chosen before in the
  2328. 1:28:00conference stage is the one that we want
  2329. 1:28:03to continue the process because
  2330. 1:28:06if we if we have any doubt now is the
  2331. 1:28:09time
  2332. 1:28:10before you start doing the detailed
  2333. 1:28:12design now is the time to change it
  2334. 1:28:15okay
  2335. 1:28:17and number four
  2336. 1:28:18why do we need to do a row safety audit
  2337. 1:28:20at this stage we have done already the
  2338. 1:28:22concept why do we need what do we need
  2339. 1:28:24to do a preliminary one well maybe you
  2340. 1:28:27haven't done the concept
  2341. 1:28:29maybe this is your first stage the first
  2342. 1:28:32audit that this project is going to have
  2343. 1:28:35so if this is the first one or nobody
  2344. 1:28:38has been checking or overlooked the the
  2345. 1:28:40config one we will start with starting
  2346. 1:28:43preliminary it's not too late to start
  2347. 1:28:45okay
  2348. 1:28:47we don't want to have any kind of delay
  2349. 1:28:49when we are doing the detail design
  2350. 1:28:51ask any designer
  2351. 1:28:53ask any designer
  2352. 1:28:55if they got any kind of problems if you
  2353. 1:28:58delay because you haven't no no they as
  2354. 1:29:01soon as they are starting the the design
  2355. 1:29:03they don't want anything to be changed
  2356. 1:29:05they just want a small a smooth flow you
  2357. 1:29:08know and with that smooth flow
  2358. 1:29:10they will be uh they will be working
  2359. 1:29:13without interruption so this is
  2360. 1:29:15important that
  2361. 1:29:16if you want to avoid any kind of delay
  2362. 1:29:19okay do the row safety id at this stage
  2363. 1:29:24okay
  2364. 1:29:25in order to check a standard going
  2365. 1:29:26beyond them
  2366. 1:29:29when i said that we don't check
  2367. 1:29:31standards that we go beyond them
  2368. 1:29:33is because the standard is
  2369. 1:29:35the minimum
  2370. 1:29:37and sometimes
  2371. 1:29:39the designers
  2372. 1:29:41as a technique
  2373. 1:29:43i have been a designer and i have used
  2374. 1:29:44this one also
  2375. 1:29:46we try to justify departures
  2376. 1:29:48okay
  2377. 1:29:50for whatever reason
  2378. 1:29:52we don't want to have a lung acquisition
  2379. 1:29:55or we consider that we need something
  2380. 1:29:58else in here so we try to justify
  2381. 1:30:00departure departure remember needs to be
  2382. 1:30:02approved okay
  2383. 1:30:04and
  2384. 1:30:05uh is not in accordance with the
  2385. 1:30:07standard it's a departure
  2386. 1:30:09so that means that your standard at that
  2387. 1:30:11point is going to make you a weak point
  2388. 1:30:13later you will have mitigation
  2389. 1:30:15and this kind of stuff but is not the
  2390. 1:30:17design that it should be
  2391. 1:30:19okay
  2392. 1:30:20so
  2393. 1:30:21ask a contractor or a designer
  2394. 1:30:24what does he prefer to go beyond the
  2395. 1:30:26standard that means that if you need to
  2396. 1:30:28do a radio of 300 go for a radio 500
  2397. 1:30:32that needs more more more extension of
  2398. 1:30:34the event
  2399. 1:30:35or if he prefers to go for 250 applying
  2400. 1:30:39for a departure
  2401. 1:30:41you will be surprised with the answer
  2402. 1:30:44okay
  2403. 1:30:45yeah a lot of people they will tell me
  2404. 1:30:47yes if you go beyond the standard you're
  2405. 1:30:48going to be more expensive of course
  2406. 1:30:50it's going to be more expensive
  2407. 1:30:52but nobody is telling you that you
  2408. 1:30:54cannot go beyond the standard
  2409. 1:30:56the standard is a minimum is the minimum
  2410. 1:30:59for that road to be transit okay just
  2411. 1:31:02like that remember that one
  2412. 1:31:05and again
  2413. 1:31:06we will bring draw safety for all users
  2414. 1:31:09again
  2415. 1:31:10okay
  2416. 1:31:11not just the first approach that we have
  2417. 1:31:13seen before
  2418. 1:31:15okay
  2419. 1:31:17our stage three
  2420. 1:31:18the detail design
  2421. 1:31:21this for me
  2422. 1:31:22is the
  2423. 1:31:23most important one
  2424. 1:31:25of all the
  2425. 1:31:26of all the stages it doesn't matter it
  2426. 1:31:29doesn't matter if is
  2427. 1:31:30stage three or stage two or whatever is
  2428. 1:31:32detailed design
  2429. 1:31:34whatever we do
  2430. 1:31:36okay here
  2431. 1:31:38uh later is going to be built think
  2432. 1:31:40about that okay
  2433. 1:31:42in here we're going to have the final
  2434. 1:31:44geometry
  2435. 1:31:45okay
  2436. 1:31:46and here is where we're going to put the
  2437. 1:31:48vertical signs
  2438. 1:31:50the resultant room markings
  2439. 1:31:52the vehicle restraint system all the
  2440. 1:31:54various the safety barriers is going to
  2441. 1:31:56be here
  2442. 1:31:57illumination
  2443. 1:31:59drainage
  2444. 1:32:01curbs
  2445. 1:32:02okay curbs i say this because curbs can
  2446. 1:32:05be fundamental also for road safety
  2447. 1:32:08what kind of raw furniture
  2448. 1:32:11beautification
  2449. 1:32:12that we are going to have all around
  2450. 1:32:14okay
  2451. 1:32:15what is going to be what we got on the
  2452. 1:32:18edge of the road
  2453. 1:32:19are we giving the clear song
  2454. 1:32:21with no hazards or we've had frangible
  2455. 1:32:24furniture
  2456. 1:32:25okay
  2457. 1:32:26how are we protecting if needed the
  2458. 1:32:29pedestrian and the cyclist all of this
  2459. 1:32:32okay
  2460. 1:32:33is coming together
  2461. 1:32:34to a whole is when the project is having
  2462. 1:32:37the final shape
  2463. 1:32:39the safety that we need to apply on the
  2464. 1:32:41junctions okay
  2465. 1:32:43and of course we need to include in here
  2466. 1:32:46all the departure for a standard that
  2467. 1:32:47they have been associated to this
  2468. 1:32:49project so
  2469. 1:32:50realize that is
  2470. 1:32:52our result our product the the
  2471. 1:32:56first one the last one that we are going
  2472. 1:32:57to have before we start building
  2473. 1:33:00okay
  2474. 1:33:01so if is the last one that we are having
  2475. 1:33:03before it start building
  2476. 1:33:05okay why do we need to do a road safety
  2477. 1:33:08editing here
  2478. 1:33:09well the most important thing is the
  2479. 1:33:11last chance that we have
  2480. 1:33:14to make change before construction
  2481. 1:33:18i am saying this because
  2482. 1:33:21i'm pretty sure all of you is going to
  2483. 1:33:22know this but
  2484. 1:33:24what is cheaper and easier to do
  2485. 1:33:27delete a line
  2486. 1:33:29on an autocad drawing
  2487. 1:33:31or remove
  2488. 1:33:33a curve that we have already built on
  2489. 1:33:35site
  2490. 1:33:37okay
  2491. 1:33:39but things like that
  2492. 1:33:41for things like that
  2493. 1:33:42is why we need to understand this
  2494. 1:33:45we need to undertake this
  2495. 1:33:48very important and for me is the most
  2496. 1:33:49important one
  2497. 1:33:52if i need to choose
  2498. 1:33:54any
  2499. 1:33:55stage of it that i cannot miss ever
  2500. 1:33:58in order for me to do it
  2501. 1:34:00in an appropriate from the
  2502. 1:34:02one
  2503. 1:34:03stage that i cannot miss
  2504. 1:34:06from the one that we have in planning
  2505. 1:34:07like the concept preliminary and detail
  2506. 1:34:09design it will be this one the other two
  2507. 1:34:12if you have missed them this is your
  2508. 1:34:14last chance before it's built
  2509. 1:34:16okay
  2510. 1:34:17so it's very important
  2511. 1:34:19to undertake the detailed design
  2512. 1:34:22row safety of this later when we are
  2513. 1:34:24talking about construction we will see
  2514. 1:34:26that this is required also to do it
  2515. 1:34:29another one that it will be angular i'm
  2516. 1:34:31going to tell you exactly the same kind
  2517. 1:34:32of question but for this kind of concept
  2518. 1:34:34preliminary and detailed design this is
  2519. 1:34:36the most important one this is the one
  2520. 1:34:38that we cannot miss
  2521. 1:34:39okay
  2522. 1:34:40good
  2523. 1:34:42what is the next one that we have
  2524. 1:34:44construction our course action we start
  2525. 1:34:46doing that and we need to verify
  2526. 1:34:50that all the changes
  2527. 1:34:52that we have asked
  2528. 1:34:54in the previous row safety edit they are
  2529. 1:34:55done
  2530. 1:34:57it's not the first time that this
  2531. 1:34:59happened to me
  2532. 1:35:00that i have done the feasibility study
  2533. 1:35:02or the concept of preliminary
  2534. 1:35:06i say some things that they need to
  2535. 1:35:08change
  2536. 1:35:09when they go to detail design
  2537. 1:35:11i realize that they haven't changed that
  2538. 1:35:13one
  2539. 1:35:14so we leave that open
  2540. 1:35:17we continue
  2541. 1:35:19we find more things in the detailed
  2542. 1:35:21design that they need to change
  2543. 1:35:24an awesome price
  2544. 1:35:26when you are going on site
  2545. 1:35:28they are building the old project the
  2546. 1:35:31first project that they have at the
  2547. 1:35:33beginning with no references
  2548. 1:35:35to the audit that we have done before
  2549. 1:35:38how come
  2550. 1:35:39so what is my job what is my work done i
  2551. 1:35:43cannot i cannot
  2552. 1:35:45accept this kind of mistakes
  2553. 1:35:48okay
  2554. 1:35:49and this is very common when we are
  2555. 1:35:51having the design and builds projects
  2556. 1:35:54okay there are before we used to have
  2557. 1:35:56this kind of timing that would you build
  2558. 1:35:58the you start thinking about the project
  2559. 1:36:00the concept predominantly you do your
  2560. 1:36:02project you pass it on to construction
  2561. 1:36:04no no no nowadays
  2562. 1:36:07most of the projects that you are now i
  2563. 1:36:08have been involved lately all of them
  2564. 1:36:10they are design and build design and
  2565. 1:36:11build so they start building at the same
  2566. 1:36:14time that they are doing the design so
  2567. 1:36:16if something in the design is wrong
  2568. 1:36:18they you can find that they have already
  2569. 1:36:20built and you say about why did you
  2570. 1:36:22build you idiot that is not good
  2571. 1:36:25so you need to remove it and they said
  2572. 1:36:27no no we have built it already now you
  2573. 1:36:29need to mitigate why are we doing things
  2574. 1:36:31in such a rush
  2575. 1:36:33okay
  2576. 1:36:34because if you rush you're not going to
  2577. 1:36:36have full potential of the draw safety
  2578. 1:36:38changes as you must do
  2579. 1:36:41okay so this is important if we're in a
  2580. 1:36:43normal project with the facing that i'm
  2581. 1:36:45saying not designing a build for example
  2582. 1:36:47you need to verify
  2583. 1:36:48that all the changes they have been
  2584. 1:36:50tracked you know for previous research
  2585. 1:36:52they are implemented
  2586. 1:36:54so they got the last copy of the project
  2587. 1:36:56of the design that they needed to have
  2588. 1:36:59in there okay
  2589. 1:37:00you need to see what is uncheck what is
  2590. 1:37:02the perception
  2591. 1:37:04of the users
  2592. 1:37:05about the project
  2593. 1:37:07what messages are sending to the project
  2594. 1:37:08okay what message are sending to them
  2595. 1:37:11you need to see if the player is
  2596. 1:37:12accepted or not
  2597. 1:37:14there will be there will be associations
  2598. 1:37:16that they will tell you no i don't like
  2599. 1:37:17that you put this in here or
  2600. 1:37:18neighborhood that they are going to put
  2601. 1:37:20a road close to them so you need to see
  2602. 1:37:22what is the perception of the one when
  2603. 1:37:24they are building okay
  2604. 1:37:26you need to do the site visit okay
  2605. 1:37:29in all direction and all conditions for
  2606. 1:37:30all road safety users as i said the site
  2607. 1:37:33basically we will see it later but
  2608. 1:37:35depending on the stage that you are
  2609. 1:37:37the site visit must be taken in a
  2610. 1:37:39different kind of condition for example
  2611. 1:37:41for preliminary concept and detail
  2612. 1:37:43design you will be doing a day side
  2613. 1:37:46visit daylight site visit okay just to
  2614. 1:37:49be informative with the with the area
  2615. 1:37:52that you are going to be
  2616. 1:37:53that you're going to be designing on
  2617. 1:37:55however when we are talking about
  2618. 1:37:57construction
  2619. 1:37:58okay
  2620. 1:37:59you will be
  2621. 1:38:00doing the roadside visit
  2622. 1:38:02during the day and during the night and
  2623. 1:38:04as i said if you do it during the day
  2624. 1:38:06during the night and when it's raining
  2625. 1:38:08or when it's snowing even better it will
  2626. 1:38:11give you a better approach how this is
  2627. 1:38:14going to be
  2628. 1:38:15the weather conditions that are going to
  2629. 1:38:16be affecting your road okay
  2630. 1:38:19and of course we need to check the
  2631. 1:38:20illumination during the hours of
  2632. 1:38:22darkness it's not the first time that
  2633. 1:38:23they tell you oh fantastic contractor i
  2634. 1:38:26i already have put all the lights but do
  2635. 1:38:28they work
  2636. 1:38:30no
  2637. 1:38:31we haven't connected yet
  2638. 1:38:33so how i'm going to assess if the
  2639. 1:38:35illumination is right or not if you
  2640. 1:38:37haven't oh no no all of them is
  2641. 1:38:39perfectly connected yeah but
  2642. 1:38:41i need to believe you if i receive just
  2643. 1:38:44one euro for everyone that is telling me
  2644. 1:38:47like that
  2645. 1:38:48i wouldn't need to play yesterday euro
  2646. 1:38:50millions
  2647. 1:38:51just to be millionaire with the money
  2648. 1:38:53that i was going to receive
  2649. 1:38:55but it's okay
  2650. 1:38:56so after construction
  2651. 1:38:58again same question that before i like
  2652. 1:39:00this question a lot
  2653. 1:39:02why do we do a row safety at this stage
  2654. 1:39:05okay
  2655. 1:39:06well
  2656. 1:39:07if the detailed design
  2657. 1:39:08hasn't been done okay or has been
  2658. 1:39:11overlooked or forgotten
  2659. 1:39:13that would be a serious mistake because
  2660. 1:39:15the detailed design one is the one that
  2661. 1:39:18is a must you must do that okay but it
  2662. 1:39:21can happen
  2663. 1:39:22that this is the first audit that you do
  2664. 1:39:24that is the first outing that the road
  2665. 1:39:26is going to have
  2666. 1:39:28don't ask me why but i realized that
  2667. 1:39:31sometimes
  2668. 1:39:32is the truth
  2669. 1:39:34nobody has checked
  2670. 1:39:36the previous stages
  2671. 1:39:38and when they are building it is when
  2672. 1:39:40they call you to do the road safety
  2673. 1:39:41audit okay
  2674. 1:39:44check that this build a spare design per
  2675. 1:39:46design per the latest design okay no per
  2676. 1:39:49the design that they have at the
  2677. 1:39:51beginning per the last modification okay
  2678. 1:39:54that it could be sorting all the
  2679. 1:39:56problems or they haven't been seeing
  2680. 1:39:58anticipated on the drawings that we have
  2681. 1:40:00check the visibility and the operation
  2682. 1:40:02during their hours of darkness okay and
  2683. 1:40:06very important general markings and
  2684. 1:40:08vertical side oh no no
  2685. 1:40:10i cannot do that
  2686. 1:40:13why
  2687. 1:40:14because
  2688. 1:40:15it's sad but is the truth
  2689. 1:40:18road markings
  2690. 1:40:20and signs
  2691. 1:40:21vertical signs is the last thing
  2692. 1:40:23that they put in the construction and
  2693. 1:40:26sometimes
  2694. 1:40:27where they say money is in there
  2695. 1:40:30so they are missing
  2696. 1:40:32the functionality of from markings
  2697. 1:40:35and road signs
  2698. 1:40:36that is the language
  2699. 1:40:38that the road
  2700. 1:40:40used to communicate with us
  2701. 1:40:42if you don't put those
  2702. 1:40:44the road is not going to be able
  2703. 1:40:46to tell us
  2704. 1:40:48the way that we need to negotiate it
  2705. 1:40:50and i'm saying this because sometimes
  2706. 1:40:53the roads
  2707. 1:40:54are open
  2708. 1:40:55before they are fully finished okay so
  2709. 1:40:59they should be open in a temporary
  2710. 1:41:01manner with
  2711. 1:41:02temporary uh with temporary signs okay
  2712. 1:41:07but just tell me how is possible to
  2713. 1:41:09control put a temporary sign of 80
  2714. 1:41:11kilometers per hour on a five
  2715. 1:41:14five lanes motorway
  2716. 1:41:17you put 80
  2717. 1:41:18straight alignment
  2718. 1:41:20five lanes motorway
  2719. 1:41:21and you know who's the only one that is
  2720. 1:41:23complying with that with that speed
  2721. 1:41:26myself because i'm doing the road safety
  2722. 1:41:28of it okay so we need to be careful and
  2723. 1:41:31considerate and consideration for the
  2724. 1:41:34road markings and the vertical sign that
  2725. 1:41:36they are very useful okay these are the
  2726. 1:41:38the
  2727. 1:41:39using this in a proper in appropriate
  2728. 1:41:41manner it gives you a humongous uh
  2729. 1:41:46first-year return rate
  2730. 1:41:48when we are talking about the course we
  2731. 1:41:50will see that tomorrow if everything
  2732. 1:41:51goes all right
  2733. 1:41:52of course during the construction i put
  2734. 1:41:54this you know
  2735. 1:41:56a little
  2736. 1:41:58a little bit a
  2737. 1:41:59bigger font than before because it's
  2738. 1:42:03safety for all users now is serious okay
  2739. 1:42:05it's the construction stage
  2740. 1:42:08our stage five
  2741. 1:42:11is when we had just open to the traffic
  2742. 1:42:14the previous one the construction is
  2743. 1:42:15when it's finished but it's not open to
  2744. 1:42:17the traffic
  2745. 1:42:19okay but now it's open to the traffic
  2746. 1:42:21and we need to monitor
  2747. 1:42:23how our design has been done
  2748. 1:42:25okay
  2749. 1:42:26so we monitor at 12 months 24 or 36
  2750. 1:42:30or when we start having a trend of
  2751. 1:42:32accident
  2752. 1:42:34because you can open the road and after
  2753. 1:42:35a week you can start having accident one
  2754. 1:42:37point and you need to start monitoring
  2755. 1:42:39that okay to see what is happening
  2756. 1:42:43okay
  2757. 1:42:44so this is going to be
  2758. 1:42:46very related very much related to the
  2759. 1:42:47operation and maintenance of this
  2760. 1:42:49project that we have in here
  2761. 1:42:52okay
  2762. 1:42:53why do we do the row safety audits at
  2763. 1:42:55this stage
  2764. 1:42:56well
  2765. 1:42:57to promote and maintain safer roads
  2766. 1:43:00network
  2767. 1:43:01it's very
  2768. 1:43:02unusual
  2769. 1:43:05that in a project when you are doing the
  2770. 1:43:08detailed design project
  2771. 1:43:10the people present you everything and
  2772. 1:43:12they present you also
  2773. 1:43:14the maintenance plan
  2774. 1:43:16for all the things and all the furniture
  2775. 1:43:19and all the vrs that they are having
  2776. 1:43:20there they put for you
  2777. 1:43:22the kind of brs that they are using the
  2778. 1:43:24level of containment everything but they
  2779. 1:43:26don't tell you how to maintain that one
  2780. 1:43:29okay they don't tell you you are going
  2781. 1:43:31to require
  2782. 1:43:33a
  2783. 1:43:36short term mobility or mobile works to
  2784. 1:43:39do that or you need to to close one lane
  2785. 1:43:43for more time
  2786. 1:43:45so that kind of things is something that
  2787. 1:43:48we need to is we haven't seen it in the
  2788. 1:43:50detailed design we need to be sure that
  2789. 1:43:53it appears here
  2790. 1:43:54in the post construction when we are
  2791. 1:43:56monitoring okay
  2792. 1:43:58we need to check if there is any kind of
  2793. 1:44:00traffic accident because maybe we are
  2794. 1:44:02going to start having black spot
  2795. 1:44:05sorry because now i have been this was
  2796. 1:44:08uh done
  2797. 1:44:09before i was advised that you cannot
  2798. 1:44:11call it black spot anymore you can you
  2799. 1:44:13need to call it hot spot i'm sorry i was
  2800. 1:44:15educated as black spot but now
  2801. 1:44:18it's not good so i need to use the word
  2802. 1:44:20hot spot sorry for that
  2803. 1:44:23and of course you need to check the
  2804. 1:44:24operation and maintenance of the project
  2805. 1:44:26at the end
  2806. 1:44:27is going to be
  2807. 1:44:28the misuse
  2808. 1:44:30of the road
  2809. 1:44:32the way that the use of the road for
  2810. 1:44:35operation and maintenance what is going
  2811. 1:44:36to create more problems okay again
  2812. 1:44:40safety for all users that we got in here
  2813. 1:44:44uh dr well if you want five minutes i
  2814. 1:44:47can continue this enemy because he told
  2815. 1:44:49me that i cannot continue talking in
  2816. 1:44:51three hours
  2817. 1:44:52so you can have five minutes break now
  2818. 1:44:56i think we will have another
  2819. 1:44:5815 minutes
  2820. 1:45:01you like to break
  2821. 1:45:01more five minutes or it's okay to stop
  2822. 1:45:03here up to you
  2823. 1:45:05never this is why i'm saying we can't
  2824. 1:45:07stop in here and they
  2825. 1:45:10they can have the
  2826. 1:45:12they can have the break now and later i
  2827. 1:45:14continue because in here i
  2828. 1:45:16it's a good place it's a good place to
  2829. 1:45:18stop okay thank you uh
  2830. 1:45:21dear participants we will stop here for
  2831. 1:45:2315 minutes i will share again
  2832. 1:45:26the
  2833. 1:45:27link
  2834. 1:45:28for uh
  2835. 1:45:30let me stop sharing
  2836. 1:45:33okay we will share again the link for
  2837. 1:45:35the questionnaire for those who did not
  2838. 1:45:37uh
  2839. 1:45:39participate yet i'll be very thankful
  2840. 1:45:42if you can fill the questionnaire again
  2841. 1:45:44on the following link i will send it
  2842. 1:45:46immediately now to everyone
  2843. 1:45:51on the chat bar
  2844. 1:45:54so this is the link for the
  2845. 1:45:55questionnaire we having
  2846. 1:45:57please if you do not if you if you did
  2847. 1:45:59not fill it do it now and we will come
  2848. 1:46:01back
  2849. 1:46:02after 15 minutes
  2850. 1:46:04at uh 2
  2851. 1:46:0625 p.m
  2852. 1:46:08doha time
  2853. 1:46:09thank
  2854. 1:46:10you no
  2855. 1:46:13not coming
  2856. 1:46:15okay so i will control just let me know
  2857. 1:46:18okay
  2858. 1:46:20okay but just before we
  2859. 1:46:23move forward
  2860. 1:46:25i have some questions summarize
  2861. 1:46:27questions from
  2862. 1:46:28what colleagues
  2863. 1:46:30and participants have raised in there
  2864. 1:46:32okay okay good
  2865. 1:46:33let's do a break a longer break for them
  2866. 1:46:36because i know that i can be talking
  2867. 1:46:38hours and hours and hours and you need
  2868. 1:46:40to stop me every single time so no
  2869. 1:46:42problem
  2870. 1:46:43let's see if i can answer any question
  2871. 1:46:46yes
  2872. 1:46:46the first question is regarding crash
  2873. 1:46:49data so to do a proper road safety
  2874. 1:46:52audits basically we need to have a
  2875. 1:46:55crash data to be available for that so
  2876. 1:46:58the question
  2877. 1:46:59if crash data is difficult to be
  2878. 1:47:01obtained how road safety editors can
  2879. 1:47:05base
  2880. 1:47:06some of their evaluations on safety
  2881. 1:47:09risks
  2882. 1:47:12okay yes i have found places
  2883. 1:47:14all over the world you know when you are
  2884. 1:47:16in developing countries
  2885. 1:47:18that they don't have available the class
  2886. 1:47:20data
  2887. 1:47:22so
  2888. 1:47:23it's a
  2889. 1:47:24big issue because you don't have
  2890. 1:47:27the
  2891. 1:47:28the real picture
  2892. 1:47:30of what you are going to be assessing in
  2893. 1:47:32there
  2894. 1:47:34so seriously i'm not going to tell you
  2895. 1:47:36that you can do superstitions i'm not
  2896. 1:47:37going to tell you that you can invent
  2897. 1:47:39whatever you got in there if you got the
  2898. 1:47:41data good if you don't got the data you
  2899. 1:47:43need to find a way
  2900. 1:47:45to use to do your work without that kind
  2901. 1:47:47of data that means you need to go to
  2902. 1:47:51hospitals
  2903. 1:47:53and try to ask for hospital records that
  2904. 1:47:55they will have when they are coming for
  2905. 1:47:58different kind of accident that they got
  2906. 1:48:00on the road so maybe it's
  2907. 1:48:02non-official but it will give you
  2908. 1:48:06a vision about what is happening on the
  2909. 1:48:08road okay that is what i suggest that
  2910. 1:48:11you visit hospitals
  2911. 1:48:14and they will tell you about the without
  2912. 1:48:16of course not i don't want any kind of
  2913. 1:48:18confidential information about names no
  2914. 1:48:21no just if they are involved and they
  2915. 1:48:23can tell you okay in the traumatology
  2916. 1:48:25section
  2917. 1:48:26dramatology section they can tell you
  2918. 1:48:28about the
  2919. 1:48:29about the patients that they got every
  2920. 1:48:31day or how they have this issue how many
  2921. 1:48:34are coming from accident if they got any
  2922. 1:48:36that is the kind of approach that they
  2923. 1:48:38would do if you don't have
  2924. 1:48:39appropriate crash accident data
  2925. 1:48:43great
  2926. 1:48:44the second question is actually
  2927. 1:48:46been raised by several participants is
  2928. 1:48:49regarding the
  2929. 1:48:50uh
  2930. 1:48:52the road safety audits in the
  2931. 1:48:54preliminary or in the design stage
  2932. 1:48:57on the concert stage
  2933. 1:48:59we all know that
  2934. 1:49:01some auditors and based on the current
  2935. 1:49:03requirements they might not be with an
  2936. 1:49:05engineering background or raw design
  2937. 1:49:06background so they might propose
  2938. 1:49:08treatments or raise some issues that is
  2939. 1:49:11not accepted by the design team
  2940. 1:49:14and if the design team rejected to
  2941. 1:49:16implement some of the of the suggestions
  2942. 1:49:18proposed by the road safety auditors
  2943. 1:49:20then who should take the responsibility
  2944. 1:49:22and what actions should be taken
  2945. 1:49:24and
  2946. 1:49:25how such kind of issues being resolved
  2947. 1:49:28okay that's very simple that is not that
  2948. 1:49:30is not a problem okay
  2949. 1:49:33the road safety auditor cannot impose
  2950. 1:49:37whatever solution they consider for the
  2951. 1:49:39road even though
  2952. 1:49:41i have been involved in road safety
  2953. 1:49:43audits where
  2954. 1:49:45recommendations they were not compulsory
  2955. 1:49:48for for for me to give it to them
  2956. 1:49:51so that happens that
  2957. 1:49:53you go
  2958. 1:49:54you
  2959. 1:49:55are so kind that you give them what is
  2960. 1:49:57your vision what is the the thing that
  2961. 1:50:00they should be doing okay
  2962. 1:50:02and if they don't want to accept
  2963. 1:50:04is the
  2964. 1:50:07authority responsible or the owner of
  2965. 1:50:09the road who is responsible to impose
  2966. 1:50:12the designer or the contractor
  2967. 1:50:14the measures that they need to take into
  2968. 1:50:16consideration
  2969. 1:50:17i mean with that
  2970. 1:50:19imagine
  2971. 1:50:20that we say
  2972. 1:50:22that is required to change
  2973. 1:50:24the curve that they got you know for a
  2974. 1:50:28high protective curve a high containment
  2975. 1:50:31curve like the three of curve
  2976. 1:50:33that's the
  2977. 1:50:35the thing that they say the auditor they
  2978. 1:50:37say something like that
  2979. 1:50:39and the designer said i know that
  2980. 1:50:40they're not going to be using that
  2981. 1:50:42because they consider that there is no
  2982. 1:50:43such a risk they don't accept the risk
  2983. 1:50:45that we are proposing because it's
  2984. 1:50:48important that when we're having this
  2985. 1:50:50kind of meeting the closed sub meeting
  2986. 1:50:53okay
  2987. 1:50:53they decide the
  2988. 1:50:55the designer must accept the risk not
  2989. 1:50:58the comment from the road safety auditor
  2990. 1:51:01must accept the risk that they are on
  2991. 1:51:02the road okay
  2992. 1:51:05so if the deciding doesn't affect the
  2993. 1:51:06risk the ball passed
  2994. 1:51:08to the owner of the road the authority
  2995. 1:51:10that owns the road and the authorities
  2996. 1:51:13who say okay
  2997. 1:51:14i consider that that risk exist
  2998. 1:51:17or i consider that the risk does not
  2999. 1:51:19exist
  3000. 1:51:21if he considered that the risk exists he
  3001. 1:51:23must ask for a solution to the designer
  3002. 1:51:26or the contractor
  3003. 1:51:28okay
  3004. 1:51:29if he considered that that risk it can
  3005. 1:51:31be mitigated easily and doesn't assist
  3006. 1:51:34or he hasn't considered that does this
  3007. 1:51:36assist then
  3008. 1:51:38that is going to be
  3009. 1:51:39a
  3010. 1:51:41to to be superseded okay but it's not
  3011. 1:51:44the mission of the auditor
  3012. 1:51:46to choose what is the solution that you
  3013. 1:51:49are going to be doing
  3014. 1:51:50is a mission of the designer or is a
  3015. 1:51:52mission of the contractor the auditor
  3016. 1:51:54only exposed the risk and is so kind
  3017. 1:51:58that gives you an idea
  3018. 1:52:00but the designer knows more than than
  3019. 1:52:03the auditor about the road that they are
  3020. 1:52:04designing so maybe my idea is not good
  3021. 1:52:07for them because they got any another
  3022. 1:52:09idea
  3023. 1:52:10to to solve the problem that we have
  3024. 1:52:12found
  3025. 1:52:13i don't know if i have answered yes you
  3026. 1:52:15are you are i think it is you directly
  3027. 1:52:17answered so basically
  3028. 1:52:19whatever proposed solution by auditors
  3029. 1:52:24the auditors may raise
  3030. 1:52:26the safety risks
  3031. 1:52:28and may propose some treatments but
  3032. 1:52:30wrote road designers usually
  3033. 1:52:33they should address the risk
  3034. 1:52:35and
  3035. 1:52:36whether they use the proposed solution
  3036. 1:52:38by the auditor or they identify bitter
  3037. 1:52:40solution it's up to them but they should
  3038. 1:52:42mitigate and address the risk raised by
  3039. 1:52:45auditors
  3040. 1:52:46yeah am i right
  3041. 1:52:47exactly and i wouldn't say better in
  3042. 1:52:49fact you have said that more brief than
  3043. 1:52:52me and better than me
  3044. 1:52:53this is why you're in the university and
  3045. 1:52:55i'm just a normal engineer no no thank
  3046. 1:52:58you thank you
  3047. 1:52:59it's okay
  3048. 1:53:00the other point raised also is uh
  3049. 1:53:04regarding
  3050. 1:53:05uh
  3051. 1:53:06how road safety others so we'll take the
  3052. 1:53:09last two questions actually one of them
  3053. 1:53:11is regarding the how road safety audits
  3054. 1:53:13are relevant to developing countries and
  3055. 1:53:14how this experience can be moved to
  3056. 1:53:16improve road safety in developing
  3057. 1:53:17countries and this is very important i
  3058. 1:53:20think because
  3059. 1:53:21we need to understand what is road
  3060. 1:53:23safety audit it's a philosophy the road
  3061. 1:53:25safety edit is a kind of preventive
  3062. 1:53:27measure so that we make sure that all
  3063. 1:53:29our newly developed roads
  3064. 1:53:32or general developments
  3065. 1:53:34they have
  3066. 1:53:36been audited for safety to make sure
  3067. 1:53:39that any risks being raised
  3068. 1:53:41during the in the design is being
  3069. 1:53:44addressed
  3070. 1:53:45not only that but also for existing
  3071. 1:53:47roads to be audited to identify what
  3072. 1:53:50kind of flex is existing that can help
  3073. 1:53:52to improve road safety so developing
  3074. 1:53:54countries many of the developing
  3075. 1:53:56countries are undergoing a huge
  3076. 1:53:58infrastructure development
  3077. 1:54:00and they are in the stage where
  3078. 1:54:02developed countries they have been 20 30
  3079. 1:54:0640 years ago with a lot of
  3080. 1:54:07infrastructure
  3081. 1:54:08projects are being built
  3082. 1:54:10for that having brought safety audits
  3083. 1:54:12now
  3084. 1:54:13it's very advantageous
  3085. 1:54:14for them so that they can identify
  3086. 1:54:16safety problems they can enhance their
  3087. 1:54:19design
  3088. 1:54:20to become more safe and i totally agree
  3089. 1:54:23with what miguel mentioned that
  3090. 1:54:25complying with standards doesn't mean
  3091. 1:54:27your roads are safe
  3092. 1:54:28so there are things need to be
  3093. 1:54:30considered there are things to be go
  3094. 1:54:31beyond the standards to ensure and to
  3095. 1:54:34mitigate risks on road and ultimately
  3096. 1:54:37reduce crashes and their fertilities and
  3097. 1:54:39injuries so it's very important for for
  3098. 1:54:42developing countries to pick up this now
  3099. 1:54:45and while they are developing and going
  3100. 1:54:47in the journey to be developed country
  3101. 1:54:50to implement and to
  3102. 1:54:53audit the
  3103. 1:54:54the the road projects for
  3104. 1:54:56safer operation in the future
  3105. 1:54:59i hope this is can be understood this
  3106. 1:55:02question and miguel if you would like to
  3107. 1:55:03add anything you almost i i concur with
  3108. 1:55:06the things that you have just said but i
  3109. 1:55:08also would like to say one thing that
  3110. 1:55:09the people they are not having into
  3111. 1:55:11consideration
  3112. 1:55:12they are talking about developing
  3113. 1:55:14countries okay but i can tell you that
  3114. 1:55:16developed countries
  3115. 1:55:18where the road safety culture is not
  3116. 1:55:20installed within the among them okay
  3117. 1:55:23so
  3118. 1:55:24maybe they got the money they got the
  3119. 1:55:26resources but they don't have the
  3120. 1:55:28culture behind so those countries they
  3121. 1:55:30also need you know professional life
  3122. 1:55:32road safety auditors in order that they
  3123. 1:55:34can develop the road safety concept
  3124. 1:55:37within their within their boundaries but
  3125. 1:55:39completely agree with the thing that you
  3126. 1:55:40have said after a while
  3127. 1:55:42thank you i totally agree also you
  3128. 1:55:44mentioned a very important point road
  3129. 1:55:46safety culture
  3130. 1:55:48and the the the
  3131. 1:55:50public understanding of road safety
  3132. 1:55:52requirement including drivers and road
  3133. 1:55:54users and how they behave on your road
  3134. 1:55:56network and how they comply with traffic
  3135. 1:55:58rules this is very important but when we
  3136. 1:56:00talk about developing countries
  3137. 1:56:03these are developing undergoing a
  3138. 1:56:05development and many of these countries
  3139. 1:56:07are in the stage of infrastructural
  3140. 1:56:08development and then the roads are being
  3141. 1:56:10built their infrastructure the major
  3142. 1:56:12highways and networks are being built
  3143. 1:56:14they need to have audits they need to
  3144. 1:56:16audit these projects and to make sure
  3145. 1:56:18that they are
  3146. 1:56:20and learn from developed countries
  3147. 1:56:22experience in order to have a more safer
  3148. 1:56:23roads and well-developed roads the last
  3149. 1:56:26question is we have road safety audits
  3150. 1:56:30for the design
  3151. 1:56:31for the
  3152. 1:56:33concept
  3153. 1:56:34and the planning stage
  3154. 1:56:36concept
  3155. 1:56:38planning and design skills preliminary
  3156. 1:56:42and road safety assessments
  3157. 1:56:45or oh yeah because no no no very simple
  3158. 1:56:47very simple i said the road safety
  3159. 1:56:50impact assessment is something that you
  3160. 1:56:52do in the planning and is for a network
  3161. 1:56:55okay and you will have into
  3162. 1:56:57consideration also the crash data
  3163. 1:56:59analysis that you will need for that one
  3164. 1:57:00for that area if you know
  3165. 1:57:02when we are talking about
  3166. 1:57:04the stages of a project is a a lot more
  3167. 1:57:07reduced okay is the project is not going
  3168. 1:57:10to be to build a city the project is
  3169. 1:57:12going to be to build a row from a to b
  3170. 1:57:14so it's not going to be as as big as the
  3171. 1:57:17road safety impact assessment okay but
  3172. 1:57:20the foundation the way that they are
  3173. 1:57:22going to be working a part of the having
  3174. 1:57:24into consideration because in that area
  3175. 1:57:26maybe you know if he's in the middle of
  3176. 1:57:27the desert or the middle of nowhere you
  3177. 1:57:29don't have accident in there okay you
  3178. 1:57:31don't have any kind of accident in there
  3179. 1:57:33but the other one the road safety
  3180. 1:57:34impassement can be done for new roads
  3181. 1:57:36and also for major uh changes in
  3182. 1:57:41in a existing road okay so for me it's
  3183. 1:57:44very clear it's the extension of the of
  3184. 1:57:47the area that we're going to be doing
  3185. 1:57:49okay so
  3186. 1:57:51to summarize road safety audits road
  3187. 1:57:53safety impact assessments are more macro
  3188. 1:57:55level they are done
  3189. 1:57:58but when we go to the micro assessment
  3190. 1:58:00for a specific road for a specific
  3191. 1:58:02project then we have a road safety audit
  3192. 1:58:04and it is an official procedure
  3193. 1:58:06as part of the approval of the designs
  3194. 1:58:10and
  3195. 1:58:12of a project
  3196. 1:58:13but road safety impact
  3197. 1:58:15assessments are more in a larger scale
  3198. 1:58:20so please
  3199. 1:58:22all participants i wish that they
  3200. 1:58:23understand these are all general namings
  3201. 1:58:26that you can for example when you talk
  3202. 1:58:28about road safety audit in the
  3203. 1:58:29operational stage
  3204. 1:58:33they call it inspections
  3205. 1:58:35you still can call it an audit
  3206. 1:58:37so this is called tomato as i said call
  3207. 1:58:39it tomato the important thing is the
  3208. 1:58:42process yes okay you can call it the way
  3209. 1:58:44that you want but follow the formal
  3210. 1:58:46process okay i don't care if it's called
  3211. 1:58:49post-construction pre-construction
  3212. 1:58:51pre-opening
  3213. 1:58:52whatever you want to call it but follow
  3214. 1:58:54the process it's like that
  3215. 1:58:56okay
  3216. 1:58:57exactly so please every participants you
  3217. 1:59:00know do not stick to the namings rather
  3218. 1:59:01than the concept and the process and the
  3219. 1:59:04background philosophy of having a road
  3220. 1:59:06safety ordinance in terms of requirement
  3221. 1:59:08and how to conduct it now we give you
  3222. 1:59:10the floor miguel i will follow up with
  3223. 1:59:12you with the slides and uh
  3224. 1:59:16you can have the floor to continue the
  3225. 1:59:18last part of our session today thank you
  3226. 1:59:21thank you can you go back one please
  3227. 1:59:23let's see
  3228. 1:59:27and one more
  3229. 1:59:31perfect here is where we were okay the
  3230. 1:59:34sorry again because it seems that my
  3231. 1:59:36computer is a little bit temperamental
  3232. 1:59:38okay and it doesn't allow me to pass the
  3233. 1:59:41slides in the way that i would like
  3234. 1:59:43so
  3235. 1:59:44uh
  3236. 1:59:45we're going to see now which are the
  3237. 1:59:47most frequent problems that we have in
  3238. 1:59:50row safety of it okay
  3239. 1:59:52and
  3240. 1:59:53this is coming from a different kind of
  3241. 1:59:56studies that we have done okay in order
  3242. 1:59:59that we can assess a common ground of
  3243. 2:00:02knowledge and establish common ground
  3244. 2:00:04for knowledge about the raw safety
  3245. 2:00:06editor along the around the world
  3246. 2:00:08what happening here is that you got a
  3247. 2:00:10bunch of of audits and you realize
  3248. 2:00:13that when you got a problem with the
  3249. 2:00:15vertical signs you know vertical sign if
  3250. 2:00:18they are obscure they are dirty or they
  3251. 2:00:21are not clear or they are damaged this
  3252. 2:00:23kind of
  3253. 2:00:24problems is going to come
  3254. 2:00:2630 percent of the times that you are
  3255. 2:00:28doing an audit
  3256. 2:00:30okay
  3257. 2:00:31and wrong markings problems with raw
  3258. 2:00:33markings is going to come 10 percent
  3259. 2:00:36you can realize the big difference that
  3260. 2:00:38you got between these two with the next
  3261. 2:00:40one that it should be the visibility is
  3262. 2:00:42visibility issues okay so that means
  3263. 2:00:46these two
  3264. 2:00:47that is vertical sign and row markings
  3265. 2:00:49is one of the cheapest thing
  3266. 2:00:52that we can do when we are talking about
  3267. 2:00:55a project about to enhance the road
  3268. 2:00:57safety of the project
  3269. 2:00:59and we are going to be avoiding
  3270. 2:01:0113 and 2 and 10 percent all together is
  3271. 2:01:0323 of the comment that we have in the
  3272. 2:01:06raw safety audit in the general
  3273. 2:01:08so that is that is started to think that
  3274. 2:01:11a quarter of the problems okay more or
  3275. 2:01:14less a quarter of the problems that we
  3276. 2:01:15are going to have in a row safety that
  3277. 2:01:16are related to these two can be easily
  3278. 2:01:18sorted
  3279. 2:01:20if we allocate appropriate drug markets
  3280. 2:01:23and appropriate traffic signs okay just
  3281. 2:01:25think about that
  3282. 2:01:26and they are not expensive if you
  3283. 2:01:28compare with the
  3284. 2:01:30with the money that you spend on a
  3285. 2:01:32project okay
  3286. 2:01:34later other problems that we have that
  3287. 2:01:37they are all of them more around more or
  3288. 2:01:39less about the five percent of the
  3289. 2:01:41comments that we have is visibility
  3290. 2:01:43issues the stop inside distance if you
  3291. 2:01:44got any problem with the visibility
  3292. 2:01:47uh the distance that you got when you
  3293. 2:01:50are arriving to a junction or something
  3294. 2:01:51like that weaving
  3295. 2:01:53weaving is another thing
  3296. 2:01:55that we need to have into consideration
  3297. 2:01:57very clear a lot of problems that they
  3298. 2:02:00are coming in there five percent of the
  3299. 2:02:01problems of the other that we have
  3300. 2:02:02analyzed they got weaving issues okay
  3301. 2:02:06disabled people disabled people usually
  3302. 2:02:08i put in here at tail paving or drop
  3303. 2:02:10curve
  3304. 2:02:11but you realize that the width of the
  3305. 2:02:14without the footpath
  3306. 2:02:16sometimes they are super standards okay
  3307. 2:02:18or if they need to access and cross a
  3308. 2:02:22how i say if you need to cross a
  3309. 2:02:23motorway that you have put a bridge a
  3310. 2:02:26pedestrian bridge for that one sometimes
  3311. 2:02:29the ramp they don't have the inclination
  3312. 2:02:31the slope that they should have in order
  3313. 2:02:33to facilitate this kind of things
  3314. 2:02:35pedestrian cyclist issue okay so you can
  3315. 2:02:38see that these two they are related the
  3316. 2:02:41disabled people issues and the
  3317. 2:02:43pedestrian cyclists they're related with
  3318. 2:02:44the vulnerable road users so we are
  3319. 2:02:47having 10 percent of the problems of the
  3320. 2:02:49raw safety that we have studied they are
  3321. 2:02:51related with vulnerable road users it's
  3322. 2:02:54another thing that is very simple to
  3323. 2:02:57sort it out
  3324. 2:02:58okay so if we sorted out the problems
  3325. 2:03:01with the vertical signs and the road
  3326. 2:03:03markings plus the vulnerable producers
  3327. 2:03:06we're having 35 percent of the total of
  3328. 2:03:09the problems that we're going to have in
  3329. 2:03:10our audit sorted
  3330. 2:03:12come on and this is not difficult to do
  3331. 2:03:15it okay
  3332. 2:03:17i'm not talking about visibility and
  3333. 2:03:18weaving because they are intrinsical to
  3334. 2:03:20the design and having those related and
  3335. 2:03:23having tried to sort that out it can be
  3336. 2:03:26more costly than the ones that are
  3337. 2:03:27insane but vertical signs roll markings
  3338. 2:03:30vulnerable reducers all of that is cheap
  3339. 2:03:34okay it's low cost measure
  3340. 2:03:36okay
  3341. 2:03:37the other ones that we got in here
  3342. 2:03:39around four percent that is the number
  3343. 2:03:40and width of the lens issue
  3344. 2:03:42okay it can be sorted with raw markings
  3345. 2:03:45too okay and the illumination the
  3346. 2:03:46illumination during the night hours and
  3347. 2:03:49we need to check if we got the kind of
  3348. 2:03:51cone of shadows you know when we are
  3349. 2:03:53driving on a road that we don't pass by
  3350. 2:03:56from
  3351. 2:03:57light not la
  3352. 2:03:58lit non lead lead
  3353. 2:04:00no lead because our problem is that the
  3354. 2:04:03eyes of the driver it will change
  3355. 2:04:05constantly and that can can be a serious
  3356. 2:04:08problem okay the cone of shadows dr well
  3357. 2:04:11please
  3358. 2:04:12now i will
  3359. 2:04:14explain you
  3360. 2:04:15about the most frequent problems that we
  3361. 2:04:17are going to have in the concept stage
  3362. 2:04:20dr well are you there
  3363. 2:04:23ah jordan thank you so in the country of
  3364. 2:04:26states as i said
  3365. 2:04:28this kind of of stage is where we are
  3366. 2:04:31going to be
  3367. 2:04:32dealing with the
  3368. 2:04:33big answers you know um
  3369. 2:04:36very little money
  3370. 2:04:38in order to implement them because as we
  3371. 2:04:40say there is nothing decided yet and in
  3372. 2:04:43here is where you need to decide the big
  3373. 2:04:45questions the topology of junction you
  3374. 2:04:47need to see what is going to be the
  3375. 2:04:49proximity okay so in here it's very
  3376. 2:04:52simple that we are going to realize if
  3377. 2:04:54the junctions that we are located
  3378. 2:04:57that we have already agreed to put in
  3379. 2:04:59constant design
  3380. 2:05:00they are
  3381. 2:05:01more far they are far or they are close
  3382. 2:05:04each other okay so what is going to be
  3383. 2:05:07because if they are very far we are
  3384. 2:05:09going to find that if is for pedestrians
  3385. 2:05:12you know that they are not going to be
  3386. 2:05:13able to walk from one to the other or if
  3387. 2:05:16they are very close we are going to have
  3388. 2:05:18the problem of the weaving for the
  3389. 2:05:21people that they are accessing or not so
  3390. 2:05:24these are the 60 percent as you can see
  3391. 2:05:2760 percent of the common they are
  3392. 2:05:29related to that one
  3393. 2:05:31okay
  3394. 2:05:32at this stage as i said
  3395. 2:05:34we are going to be most likely not
  3396. 2:05:37having any kind of accident data and
  3397. 2:05:40another 60 57 60 percent of the comments
  3398. 2:05:43that we have they are related to this
  3399. 2:05:45that is in the concept stage where are
  3400. 2:05:48we going to put bus stops if we are
  3401. 2:05:50putting some of them
  3402. 2:05:53this is why i said that we need to start
  3403. 2:05:54thinking and all the
  3404. 2:05:57all the public transport that we are
  3405. 2:05:59having not just bus stop
  3406. 2:06:01please think about other things or if
  3407. 2:06:03you need
  3408. 2:06:04or if you need to talk about the metro
  3409. 2:06:07okay all of this needs to have needs to
  3410. 2:06:10be done and need to be brought into
  3411. 2:06:11consideration
  3412. 2:06:13okay
  3413. 2:06:14we need to check
  3414. 2:06:15according to the volumetric traffic that
  3415. 2:06:17we are going to be supplying because
  3416. 2:06:19that's something that we are going to
  3417. 2:06:20know
  3418. 2:06:21uh
  3419. 2:06:22what kind of junction were decided is it
  3420. 2:06:24that other weight or not what this kind
  3421. 2:06:27of problem or comments is it going to
  3422. 2:06:29appear so imagine if you are doing the
  3423. 2:06:31concept design okay you're doing the
  3424. 2:06:34concept design of a project
  3425. 2:06:36with this guidance that i'm telling you
  3426. 2:06:37you know more or less what goes what is
  3427. 2:06:40going to be the content of your of your
  3428. 2:06:43you will have problem the auditor is
  3429. 2:06:45going to tell you that they cannot find
  3430. 2:06:46any accident data they are going to tell
  3431. 2:06:48you the
  3432. 2:06:49the junctions they are very far away the
  3433. 2:06:52pedestrian they will have issues to
  3434. 2:06:54travel or to cross if you don't have a
  3435. 2:06:56mid block you know in order to cross in
  3436. 2:06:58there
  3437. 2:06:59so
  3438. 2:07:01uh please afterwards pass to the next
  3439. 2:07:02one to the preliminary ones
  3440. 2:07:06in the preliminary one
  3441. 2:07:08remember
  3442. 2:07:09uh we are going to be having this
  3443. 2:07:12following comments
  3444. 2:07:13overtaking issues
  3445. 2:07:15if we are having any kind of conflict
  3446. 2:07:18because the stopping side distance okay
  3447. 2:07:21is going to is going to be very it can
  3448. 2:07:24be restricted and we are going to
  3449. 2:07:26analyze that in here okay so restrictive
  3450. 2:07:29visibility is going to bring us
  3451. 2:07:31overtaking issues okay we're going to
  3452. 2:07:34have also issues with the street
  3453. 2:07:35furniture
  3454. 2:07:37i have seen in here
  3455. 2:07:39rocks that they have been allocated in
  3456. 2:07:41the medium
  3457. 2:07:43as a street furniture
  3458. 2:07:45fantastic architect that they have put
  3459. 2:07:46that beautiful rock
  3460. 2:07:48that is more than
  3461. 2:07:50five tons you know
  3462. 2:07:52in the middle of the medium without any
  3463. 2:07:53kind of protection but it's beautiful
  3464. 2:07:57it's also beautiful to see how the
  3465. 2:07:58people they are going to crash and die
  3466. 2:08:00okay so we are going to have those kind
  3467. 2:08:02of comments and all of this the thing
  3468. 2:08:04that i'm telling you the first three
  3469. 2:08:05that we got the restrictive visibility
  3470. 2:08:07that we're taking is on the street
  3471. 2:08:09furniture is going to be over the 40
  3472. 2:08:10percent of the comments that we're
  3473. 2:08:12having between 40 and 50 percent
  3474. 2:08:14so our audit is very clear
  3475. 2:08:17that is going to show us
  3476. 2:08:19this kind of comments in order that we
  3477. 2:08:21sort it out on the design stage that we
  3478. 2:08:24are the preliminary design
  3479. 2:08:26in here
  3480. 2:08:27we reduce and we don't have any comment
  3481. 2:08:30about the vr resistance some people they
  3482. 2:08:32don't put it in here they put it later
  3483. 2:08:34in the detail design okay
  3484. 2:08:36but
  3485. 2:08:37i i believe that it should allocate it
  3486. 2:08:40in here in the preliminary because in
  3487. 2:08:42here you can
  3488. 2:08:43say also and you can ask for the what is
  3489. 2:08:46going to be the level of containment
  3490. 2:08:48that you need to put in here
  3491. 2:08:50because you already know the number of
  3492. 2:08:51vehicles that they are traveling
  3493. 2:08:53you have already decided in here the
  3494. 2:08:55design speed
  3495. 2:08:57okay and you know the number of heavy
  3496. 2:08:58traffic that you are having on the road
  3497. 2:09:00is very simple for you to calculate what
  3498. 2:09:03is going to be the level of contaminant
  3499. 2:09:04that is required on this road and if you
  3500. 2:09:06know the level of containment you will
  3501. 2:09:08know
  3502. 2:09:09what kind of vrs systems you need to
  3503. 2:09:11allocate in here and what is going to be
  3504. 2:09:12your preferred one okay
  3505. 2:09:15me as a row safety auditor the only
  3506. 2:09:16thing that i care is that you comply
  3507. 2:09:18with the level of containment required
  3508. 2:09:20on the road i don't care if you use
  3509. 2:09:22steel if you use cable or you use
  3510. 2:09:24concrete or you use glass whatever you
  3511. 2:09:27want to put
  3512. 2:09:28meanwhile you comply with the level of
  3513. 2:09:31containment that is needed on the road
  3514. 2:09:33okay and of course
  3515. 2:09:35uh as i said before if you don't have
  3516. 2:09:38pedestrian crossing enough in between of
  3517. 2:09:40two different junctions that we have
  3518. 2:09:42already remember that in here is where
  3519. 2:09:44we're going to agree with the concept
  3520. 2:09:47design that we have for junctions okay
  3521. 2:09:49so in here we are going to agree if the
  3522. 2:09:52distance of that juncture that we have
  3523. 2:09:54before it was too much or too less okay
  3524. 2:09:57and we are going to have the a we can
  3525. 2:09:58have lack of pedestrian across normally
  3526. 2:10:02we are going to see that the weaving is
  3527. 2:10:04not going to be a big problem because
  3528. 2:10:06they will separate the junction but we
  3529. 2:10:08will have problems with pedestrian
  3530. 2:10:10because they cannot access to cross
  3531. 2:10:12safely the road okay
  3532. 2:10:15and of course in here in preliminary
  3533. 2:10:16design is where we're going to see the
  3534. 2:10:18horizontal and vertical design issues
  3535. 2:10:20that is going to be a very very common
  3536. 2:10:23and very common problem
  3537. 2:10:25dr well please
  3538. 2:10:31okay
  3539. 2:10:32in the stage 3 in the detail design
  3540. 2:10:35and here is where we are going to to
  3541. 2:10:38have all our artillery ready okay in
  3542. 2:10:42here
  3543. 2:10:43the first thing is
  3544. 2:10:45how different users they are going to
  3545. 2:10:47enter into conflict okay
  3546. 2:10:50we will have our junctions we will have
  3547. 2:10:53our side of the road our roadside we
  3548. 2:10:56will have our street furniture and we
  3549. 2:10:58will need to see
  3550. 2:10:59how can we make that all these kind of
  3551. 2:11:01different users they are
  3552. 2:11:03effectively interacting between them
  3553. 2:11:05without any kind of problems so most of
  3554. 2:11:07our comments more than half of the
  3555. 2:11:09comments they are going to be oh
  3556. 2:11:11this car can extract in this pedestrian
  3557. 2:11:14or this pedestrian it seems that it
  3558. 2:11:16cannot cross because it hasn't got the
  3559. 2:11:18facility to cross or this crossing
  3560. 2:11:21hasn't been provided with the textile
  3561. 2:11:23paving
  3562. 2:11:24we are going to have also you can see
  3563. 2:11:26the drop care and the calming traffic
  3564. 2:11:28issues the drop cure
  3565. 2:11:30fundamental i have seen many crossings
  3566. 2:11:33in many many countries where they don't
  3567. 2:11:36drop the curve
  3568. 2:11:37i'm not talking just about disabled
  3569. 2:11:39people i'm talking about also the
  3570. 2:11:41the parents that they are with the
  3571. 2:11:44trolley with the with the children with
  3572. 2:11:45the little ones and they don't have a
  3573. 2:11:47drop curve in order that they can cross
  3574. 2:11:49the road in an easy manner
  3575. 2:11:51okay
  3576. 2:11:52or even the
  3577. 2:11:54how can you say
  3578. 2:11:55the postman
  3579. 2:11:57the postman normally they don't go
  3580. 2:12:00always in a bank or they are going
  3581. 2:12:02always in a in a bicycle no no
  3582. 2:12:05they can also carry the
  3583. 2:12:07the trolley where they got all the cars
  3584. 2:12:10and is helping them to have this kind of
  3585. 2:12:12drug cart and and people that they are
  3586. 2:12:15elderly okay not disabled are there
  3587. 2:12:17people that they got problem for
  3588. 2:12:19mobility
  3589. 2:12:20okay and they don't need to be disabled
  3590. 2:12:22just that they got problem or they work
  3591. 2:12:24slow
  3592. 2:12:25do you think that your grandpa or your
  3593. 2:12:27grandma they are going to have the same
  3594. 2:12:29kind of brutality that you have in order
  3595. 2:12:31to jump through a fantastic curve okay
  3596. 2:12:35we know 40 millimeters more or less but
  3597. 2:12:37sometimes they require more time
  3598. 2:12:39okay so if they can see a slope you know
  3599. 2:12:42the other the the kirby's drop you are
  3600. 2:12:45easy in their life okay so that kind of
  3601. 2:12:47comments they are going to come in here
  3602. 2:12:50in the intersection when they are very
  3603. 2:12:51close we will have the weaving issue and
  3604. 2:12:53tell you that this at this stage if we
  3605. 2:12:56find this one is very difficult to
  3606. 2:12:58correct
  3607. 2:13:00very difficult because the designer he
  3608. 2:13:02will try to mitigate
  3609. 2:13:04he is not going to try to correct
  3610. 2:13:06but
  3611. 2:13:08and a big button here
  3612. 2:13:10is where the safe system approach should
  3613. 2:13:12enter
  3614. 2:13:13and you need to ask
  3615. 2:13:15okay i'm in an intersection okay
  3616. 2:13:18am i going to have any kind of
  3617. 2:13:21t-bone crash at 50 kilometers per hour
  3618. 2:13:23or more
  3619. 2:13:24if the answer is say yes and normally if
  3620. 2:13:27you're having problems with weaving is
  3621. 2:13:29because the junction they are very close
  3622. 2:13:31and
  3623. 2:13:32you have a humongous
  3624. 2:13:34volumetric traffic that they are
  3625. 2:13:36diverting from one side to the other if
  3626. 2:13:38they say yes you need to tell them look
  3627. 2:13:40you need to change it you cannot
  3628. 2:13:41continue like that so instead of
  3629. 2:13:43affecting a departure the thing that you
  3630. 2:13:45are telling them is changing the design
  3631. 2:13:46not changing the typology in here as i
  3632. 2:13:49said you cannot change the typology of
  3633. 2:13:51the of the junction okay unless that the
  3634. 2:13:54that the designer decided to do
  3635. 2:13:55something like that
  3636. 2:13:57and do a great separation and no not
  3637. 2:13:59like that okay that is earlier in an
  3638. 2:14:01earlier state
  3639. 2:14:03of course
  3640. 2:14:04at detailed design another comment that
  3641. 2:14:06we have is the lack of
  3642. 2:14:07accident data it can happen depending on
  3643. 2:14:10where you are or the lateral clearance
  3644. 2:14:12between the lanes and the curves that's
  3645. 2:14:14another thing that is important if you
  3646. 2:14:16don't know
  3647. 2:14:18if you are passing by
  3648. 2:14:19imagine that you got a segregated
  3649. 2:14:22footpath or segregated
  3650. 2:14:24bicycle path
  3651. 2:14:25if you don't give different uh
  3652. 2:14:28enough
  3653. 2:14:29you know enough safety distance between
  3654. 2:14:32the live traffic and the
  3655. 2:14:34and the care that where you are where
  3656. 2:14:36you go that kind of things the people
  3657. 2:14:38they are going to feel insecure okay and
  3658. 2:14:40even though if you can have a losing
  3659. 2:14:43control if that kerb is not a high
  3660. 2:14:45containment curve
  3661. 2:14:47that care can be overrun
  3662. 2:14:49okay i'm not saying that the kerp is
  3663. 2:14:51mountable because it shouldn't be
  3664. 2:14:52mountable but a normal curve
  3665. 2:14:54if you go at 50 60 kilometers per hour
  3666. 2:14:57and you lose control normally you pass
  3667. 2:14:59it
  3668. 2:14:59you it's like you have nothing okay
  3669. 2:15:02so this is why it's important to have
  3670. 2:15:04that into consideration
  3671. 2:15:06please after well the next one
  3672. 2:15:10construction in the construction
  3673. 2:15:1290 of the programs that we have in
  3674. 2:15:14maintenance
  3675. 2:15:15like that
  3676. 2:15:17you are going to be dealing with people
  3677. 2:15:19that they haven't prepared a maintenance
  3678. 2:15:20plan
  3679. 2:15:21or that they don't know how to do a
  3680. 2:15:24proper maintenance or they want to they
  3681. 2:15:26know how to do it
  3682. 2:15:28and they don't want to implement a safer
  3683. 2:15:30maintenance class
  3684. 2:15:33so maintain a plan so
  3685. 2:15:35you're going to find 90 of the comments
  3686. 2:15:37related to that one
  3687. 2:15:39illumination or reflectivity issues
  3688. 2:15:42because they will try as i said
  3689. 2:15:45here is where you are having the
  3690. 2:15:46[Music]
  3691. 2:15:48the
  3692. 2:15:49road markings and the traffic sign at
  3693. 2:15:50the end okay so they will try to save
  3694. 2:15:53peanuts you know
  3695. 2:15:55the money that they say with the road
  3696. 2:15:56markings and with the
  3697. 2:15:58with the
  3698. 2:15:59with the signs is peanuts from the
  3699. 2:16:01project but they are going to have
  3700. 2:16:03problems for reflectivity or problem
  3701. 2:16:05with the illumination okay
  3702. 2:16:07they are going to find also the vrs the
  3703. 2:16:11problems with the vrs that is not
  3704. 2:16:12appropriate
  3705. 2:16:13of course if i tell you that you can
  3706. 2:16:15calculate in advance
  3707. 2:16:17what is going to be the level of
  3708. 2:16:18containment of the road
  3709. 2:16:20the needed level of containment
  3710. 2:16:24well later you will arrive to this and
  3711. 2:16:27you say excuse me this vrs is not enough
  3712. 2:16:29instead of having a tl5 or an h2
  3713. 2:16:34you are putting here and n2 why
  3714. 2:16:37didn't why didn't you calculate this one
  3715. 2:16:39before
  3716. 2:16:40you will be surprised
  3717. 2:16:42that there are not a lot of engineers
  3718. 2:16:44that they that they know how to
  3719. 2:16:45calculate what is the level of
  3720. 2:16:46containment that is required on a road
  3721. 2:16:49simple formula simple simple espresso
  3722. 2:16:52it's an algorithm but not a lot of
  3723. 2:16:54people they know
  3724. 2:16:56that is okay
  3725. 2:16:58visibility and perception issues okay we
  3726. 2:17:01are going to see that the visibility
  3727. 2:17:03when everything is built you will
  3728. 2:17:05realize that maybe you have obscures and
  3729. 2:17:07signs or you are not allowing the
  3730. 2:17:10stopping side distance that you thought
  3731. 2:17:12that you are going to have because the
  3732. 2:17:14people on site when they put the signs
  3733. 2:17:16or where they put
  3734. 2:17:18the
  3735. 2:17:18the
  3736. 2:17:19landscaping
  3737. 2:17:21they were not being considered
  3738. 2:17:23uh in the in the project
  3739. 2:17:25i know that a lot of people they will
  3740. 2:17:27tell you oh no don't worry don't worry
  3741. 2:17:30the vertical signs we will put it on
  3742. 2:17:32site
  3743. 2:17:33not according to the drawing that you
  3744. 2:17:34got in here no no no we'll send our
  3745. 2:17:37engineer we will check the visibility
  3746. 2:17:40and after that we have checked the
  3747. 2:17:42visibility we will put the sign in
  3748. 2:17:44appropriate manner that is the answer
  3749. 2:17:46that i have listened every single time
  3750. 2:17:49when i'm closing a row safety audit
  3751. 2:17:52unfortunately
  3752. 2:17:54this is not the reality
  3753. 2:17:56what is happening in reality is that the
  3754. 2:17:58contractor take the drawing
  3755. 2:18:01the designer never send any engineer
  3756. 2:18:05on site just to check that one the
  3757. 2:18:07contractor never sent anybody just to
  3758. 2:18:10check like that and the poor worker saw
  3759. 2:18:12the
  3760. 2:18:14the drawing and put
  3761. 2:18:16the things accord in accordance with the
  3762. 2:18:18drawing that not always is right
  3763. 2:18:21okay
  3764. 2:18:22so you need to be careful with this kind
  3765. 2:18:25of things when we are when we are doing
  3766. 2:18:27our row safety audits because a lot of
  3767. 2:18:29comments they are going to come like
  3768. 2:18:31that
  3769. 2:18:32and is double work for them
  3770. 2:18:34because if it's not good
  3771. 2:18:36you are going to detect as a row safety
  3772. 2:18:37auditor you are going to put your
  3773. 2:18:38comment until later they will tell you
  3774. 2:18:40yes we are going to change but imagine
  3775. 2:18:43you have already finished everything
  3776. 2:18:45everything is set
  3777. 2:18:47for start using the road and you need to
  3778. 2:18:48delay just because you need to change
  3779. 2:18:51now things okay
  3780. 2:18:53dr well please the next one
  3781. 2:18:58post construction when we are monitoring
  3782. 2:19:00the road okay
  3783. 2:19:0290 percent the same than before
  3784. 2:19:04maintenance issue
  3785. 2:19:05we are going to have a big problem with
  3786. 2:19:07the people that they are doing for
  3787. 2:19:09example
  3788. 2:19:10uh putting putting water for the plants
  3789. 2:19:13okay or the people that they need to
  3790. 2:19:15to change a vrs that it has been damaged
  3791. 2:19:18all these kind of comments they will
  3792. 2:19:20come in the stage five okay 90 percent
  3793. 2:19:23as i said damage vrs that we got in here
  3794. 2:19:26has anybody thought about the frequency
  3795. 2:19:29that the
  3796. 2:19:30that the maintenance people they had in
  3797. 2:19:33order to replace damaged vrs
  3798. 2:19:36because
  3799. 2:19:39you can have a
  3800. 2:19:40vrs that it has been damaged you know
  3801. 2:19:43a month two months five months ago and
  3802. 2:19:46still damage in there and you know that
  3803. 2:19:48the vls is not working properly because
  3804. 2:19:49you got that one what if
  3805. 2:19:51you got instead of only one hit a hot
  3806. 2:19:54spot in there
  3807. 2:19:55and your vrs is already damaged
  3808. 2:19:58so this is why is very important that
  3809. 2:20:00the auditor is provided with the
  3810. 2:20:02maintenance plan and if he is not
  3811. 2:20:03provided within the audit brief
  3812. 2:20:06the auditor should ask for it
  3813. 2:20:08okay our responsibility is to ask for it
  3814. 2:20:11the contractor or the designer will tell
  3815. 2:20:13us no we don't have it
  3816. 2:20:15okay but we need to put a note if we
  3817. 2:20:16have been provided with that one
  3818. 2:20:18okay
  3819. 2:20:19of course we're going to have the
  3820. 2:20:21illumination or reflectivity issue if
  3821. 2:20:23it's damaged okay all this kind of stuff
  3822. 2:20:26as i as i said the contractor will try
  3823. 2:20:28to to install
  3824. 2:20:30the minimum possible in order they can
  3825. 2:20:32save money
  3826. 2:20:33please answer well
  3827. 2:20:38ok now
  3828. 2:20:40let's see
  3829. 2:20:41what is a rose safety inspection okay
  3830. 2:20:44you remember the graph that we have
  3831. 2:20:45before
  3832. 2:20:47we have for the planning later we have
  3833. 2:20:49for the design and later we have for the
  3834. 2:20:51operation so please press the next one
  3835. 2:20:54the road safety inspection okay as we
  3836. 2:20:56have seen before is
  3837. 2:20:59i there is no one before
  3838. 2:21:05no okay
  3839. 2:21:06we have seen before the russian special
  3840. 2:21:08is already
  3841. 2:21:09the one that we are going to be doing
  3842. 2:21:11when
  3843. 2:21:12we have
  3844. 2:21:13a road that is already hasn't got any
  3845. 2:21:16kind of road safety or before
  3846. 2:21:18and is open to the traffic and is the
  3847. 2:21:21first audit that we are doing okay
  3848. 2:21:24sometimes stage c sometimes row safety
  3849. 2:21:26inspection the way that you want the way
  3850. 2:21:28that we're going to perform is the same
  3851. 2:21:30but in here
  3852. 2:21:31we are going to have
  3853. 2:21:33accident data it's very easy to to find
  3854. 2:21:35accident data for the job because it has
  3855. 2:21:37been in operation for a long time okay
  3856. 2:21:40as i said
  3857. 2:21:42there are if we got changes on the road
  3858. 2:21:45okay and in the adjacent area is where
  3859. 2:21:47we are going to be
  3860. 2:21:49undertaking this kind of inspection also
  3861. 2:21:52when we are having a problem of a hot
  3862. 2:21:55spot okay that means that the
  3863. 2:21:58the road will evolve it will come to
  3864. 2:22:01that group that it has been already
  3865. 2:22:04audited this one inspected but is part
  3866. 2:22:07of the audit process okay we need to
  3867. 2:22:10have into consideration that the
  3868. 2:22:11standards they are always alive okay so
  3869. 2:22:13if the road was built in 1950 we need to
  3870. 2:22:16bring the road to the standards okay
  3871. 2:22:18because the standard they evolved fast
  3872. 2:22:20and the technology have all even faster
  3873. 2:22:23okay
  3874. 2:22:24so we need to check
  3875. 2:22:26in order that if it's an old road from
  3876. 2:22:281950 and all the surrounded area there
  3877. 2:22:31are roads that they have been built 10
  3878. 2:22:32years ago
  3879. 2:22:33we need to bring that up to a standard
  3880. 2:22:35you cannot say it no
  3881. 2:22:37i cannot do that no you need to do it
  3882. 2:22:39you need to inspect and you need to
  3883. 2:22:41bring to understand that because
  3884. 2:22:42the roads like us
  3885. 2:22:45we get old
  3886. 2:22:46okay and the good thing is that we get
  3887. 2:22:49all together
  3888. 2:22:50okay no
  3889. 2:22:51i
  3890. 2:22:52i'm cut and i die soon because my road
  3891. 2:22:55is getting old okay i just want to get
  3892. 2:22:58all the scene down the road
  3893. 2:23:00dr will please the next one
  3894. 2:23:05so
  3895. 2:23:06why do we need to do it at this stage
  3896. 2:23:08because we can detect different kind of
  3897. 2:23:10problems like the dangerous or hazardous
  3898. 2:23:13locations that we got on the road the
  3899. 2:23:15hottest spot that we were talking okay
  3900. 2:23:17even if you got flooding risk
  3901. 2:23:20you need you can identify where uh
  3902. 2:23:24what's that happening because you got a
  3903. 2:23:25trend of information okay that is also
  3904. 2:23:29all of this kind of data is always
  3905. 2:23:31available
  3906. 2:23:32okay
  3907. 2:23:33we need to detect we also can detect
  3908. 2:23:35things like the lack of equipment of the
  3909. 2:23:37road
  3910. 2:23:38in the 1950s
  3911. 2:23:40nobody was a lot of you know caring
  3912. 2:23:44about the name the kind of raw safety
  3913. 2:23:46barriers that they were put in the vrs
  3914. 2:23:47the vehicle restraint system that they
  3915. 2:23:49were putting
  3916. 2:23:50but now we are carrying so maybe there
  3917. 2:23:52is a lack of the criteria that they got
  3918. 2:23:55in 1950 because they didn't have the
  3919. 2:23:57technology at that time
  3920. 2:23:59and the criteria that we have nowadays
  3921. 2:24:01okay
  3922. 2:24:02so all these kind of things they can
  3923. 2:24:04make that our road is not up to the
  3924. 2:24:06standards that we have now
  3925. 2:24:08it will have a road that is not up to
  3926. 2:24:10the standards okay
  3927. 2:24:12it's a departure and if it's a departure
  3928. 2:24:14the people they can be confused and the
  3929. 2:24:15people is confused it's itchy that they
  3930. 2:24:18make mistake and if they make mistake
  3931. 2:24:19they can have an accident and they can
  3932. 2:24:22have an accident you know an incident on
  3933. 2:24:24the road they can lose their life so
  3934. 2:24:26this is why it's very important our work
  3935. 2:24:28okay
  3936. 2:24:30and is the real risk location for the
  3937. 2:24:32road users if you got the whole network
  3938. 2:24:35upgraded you know to the standard that
  3939. 2:24:37we got now but we don't have
  3940. 2:24:39this particular one that never
  3941. 2:24:42was brought to a standard is going to be
  3942. 2:24:44a real risk location
  3943. 2:24:46dr weil please
  3944. 2:24:49okay
  3945. 2:24:50how are we going to be doing this one
  3946. 2:24:52well we are going to be doing
  3947. 2:24:54periodic reviews okay of all the
  3948. 2:24:56existing road that we have okay and we
  3949. 2:24:59need to address which are going to be
  3950. 2:25:01the risk factors
  3951. 2:25:02okay because
  3952. 2:25:04when we address the risk factor
  3953. 2:25:06when we know the risk factor we can
  3954. 2:25:09address a solution
  3955. 2:25:11okay remember these are existing roads
  3956. 2:25:14okay
  3957. 2:25:15they never had before the process of
  3958. 2:25:17road safety auditing and this is the
  3959. 2:25:19first audit that they receive
  3960. 2:25:21so they are designed to identify
  3961. 2:25:23safely related issues that they require
  3962. 2:25:26a review so you will have inspector
  3963. 2:25:29teams
  3964. 2:25:30you know that they're going to be
  3965. 2:25:32qualified inspectors that they will go
  3966. 2:25:34inside and they will check all the
  3967. 2:25:36things that they need to see as if it
  3968. 2:25:39was a road safety audit
  3969. 2:25:41okay
  3970. 2:25:42later i will talk about the checklist
  3971. 2:25:45i don't like checklists for raw safety
  3972. 2:25:47audits but for here
  3973. 2:25:49due that the inspector maybe they are
  3974. 2:25:51not fully knowledgeable about the road
  3975. 2:25:52safety return process a checklist is a
  3976. 2:25:55very helpful a very helpful thing okay
  3977. 2:25:58when we are talking about the road
  3978. 2:25:59safety inspection the saying that we got
  3979. 2:26:02in the construction and that we got the
  3980. 2:26:04monitoring day and night side visit
  3981. 2:26:07don't go only during the day okay if you
  3982. 2:26:10go during the day only you will miss a
  3983. 2:26:12lot of problems and remember that it's a
  3984. 2:26:15super standard road because it hasn't
  3985. 2:26:17been upgraded yet to the standard that
  3986. 2:26:19we have now and you will realize about
  3987. 2:26:21the problems that you're having in there
  3988. 2:26:24we need to do
  3989. 2:26:25the
  3990. 2:26:26maintenance the inspection as a routine
  3991. 2:26:30i know that there will be many countries
  3992. 2:26:32and i'm not talking just about doha that
  3993. 2:26:34dokai is small it's a small peninsula
  3994. 2:26:37okay but there are many countries that
  3995. 2:26:39they are large okay but the countries
  3996. 2:26:41that they are large that they got a very
  3997. 2:26:44big road network please you need to
  3998. 2:26:46establish a routine you need to start a
  3999. 2:26:50sequence of maintenance okay in order
  4000. 2:26:53the people they can inspect the roads
  4001. 2:26:54that they have open developing countries
  4002. 2:26:57the good thing that they got is that
  4003. 2:26:59normally
  4004. 2:27:01because they are developing all the
  4005. 2:27:02roads that they are bringing they are
  4006. 2:27:03bringing to standards and the all the
  4007. 2:27:05roads that they are all they were not
  4008. 2:27:07being considered road because some of
  4009. 2:27:09them they are not even asphalt you know
  4010. 2:27:11but this one
  4011. 2:27:12because they communicate they got a a
  4012. 2:27:15proper functionality and it's going to
  4013. 2:27:18be continuing that way this one they
  4014. 2:27:20also need to be included into the
  4015. 2:27:23routine for the maintenance and the
  4016. 2:27:24inspection and of course maybe they are
  4017. 2:27:27not going to be the ones that all the
  4018. 2:27:29people they are now traveling in the new
  4019. 2:27:31in the new in the neural that they have
  4020. 2:27:33built but to go to the small village a
  4021. 2:27:36to the small village we they will be
  4022. 2:27:38continuing using this kind of one and we
  4023. 2:27:41need to bring these ones also to a
  4024. 2:27:42standard okay of course we go with the
  4025. 2:27:45inspection
  4026. 2:27:47potentially we can identify issues that
  4027. 2:27:50they need another design imagine that
  4028. 2:27:53you are in a in a road and the road has
  4029. 2:27:56a very sharp bend okay maybe now
  4030. 2:27:59you are able to identify this one
  4031. 2:28:02and bring it to the standard and make
  4032. 2:28:04that sharp bend a little bit more smooth
  4033. 2:28:07safer for the road users
  4034. 2:28:09please after well
  4035. 2:28:15okay
  4036. 2:28:16the road safety inspections they are
  4037. 2:28:18carried out by professionals appointed
  4038. 2:28:20by the reliable authority
  4039. 2:28:22maybe
  4040. 2:28:23this is something that it can be done
  4041. 2:28:26uh
  4042. 2:28:27not as independent as a road safety
  4043. 2:28:29audit okay
  4044. 2:28:31ideally uh you will have a team you know
  4045. 2:28:35the authority will have a team of
  4046. 2:28:37inspectors you know and because the
  4047. 2:28:39owner of the
  4048. 2:28:40of the road is the one that is doing
  4049. 2:28:43inspection we can say that is not very
  4050. 2:28:45independent okay
  4051. 2:28:47but
  4052. 2:28:48it's okay if they are well trained
  4053. 2:28:50because is
  4054. 2:28:52the
  4055. 2:28:52the main objective of the
  4056. 2:28:55of the main
  4057. 2:28:56aim that the
  4058. 2:28:58owner of the road has is that no having
  4059. 2:29:01any problem within their network so
  4060. 2:29:04normally is going to be carry out by
  4061. 2:29:06people that they belong to that
  4062. 2:29:07organization okay
  4063. 2:29:10the brief it will be prepared okay by
  4064. 2:29:14the
  4065. 2:29:14engineers that they got within the local
  4066. 2:29:17authority and they will be given to the
  4067. 2:29:19inspector
  4068. 2:29:20and the inspector will assess the road
  4069. 2:29:23as if it was the first time that they
  4070. 2:29:24were passing by there
  4071. 2:29:26okay because
  4072. 2:29:28you cannot ask
  4073. 2:29:30people that they are
  4074. 2:29:31very familiar with the road because they
  4075. 2:29:34pass that road once and again and again
  4076. 2:29:36and the eyes they are used
  4077. 2:29:38to the mistakes that the road used to
  4078. 2:29:40have or that road it has so you need
  4079. 2:29:43fresh vision fresh eyes in order to do
  4080. 2:29:46this kind of inspection okay
  4081. 2:29:49later you will be reporting
  4082. 2:29:51uh
  4083. 2:29:52road safety engineering team to the road
  4084. 2:29:53safety engineering team
  4085. 2:29:54the
  4086. 2:29:56the problems that you have found and
  4087. 2:29:58they will act assessing the problems
  4088. 2:30:00that you have identified and proposing
  4089. 2:30:02engineering solution okay if they don't
  4090. 2:30:05propose an engineering solution
  4091. 2:30:07we haven't done anything
  4092. 2:30:09because do you go there to inspect and
  4093. 2:30:12to bring the road up to the standard so
  4094. 2:30:15the standard that you have in the past
  4095. 2:30:17they're not going to be the ones that
  4096. 2:30:18you got in here so don't tell me that
  4097. 2:30:21you cannot propose a engineering
  4098. 2:30:23solution for that one don't tell me that
  4099. 2:30:25the engineers that they were doing this
  4100. 2:30:27road in 1950 they are going to have the
  4101. 2:30:29same kind of knowledge that the
  4102. 2:30:30engineers that they are doing roads in
  4103. 2:30:322021
  4104. 2:30:33know techniques has evolved a lot
  4105. 2:30:37and the science has evolved a lot so we
  4106. 2:30:39are able to bring that road up to the
  4107. 2:30:41standards
  4108. 2:30:43please dr well next one
  4109. 2:30:47okay
  4110. 2:30:48so
  4111. 2:30:49how is it going to be our process for
  4112. 2:30:51root for doing a row safety inspection
  4113. 2:30:55it's going to be very similar to the one
  4114. 2:30:57that we have seen before okay we're
  4115. 2:31:00going to study all the data okay
  4116. 2:31:03the related to the
  4117. 2:31:05to the road or the route or the network
  4118. 2:31:07that we're going to be inspecting
  4119. 2:31:09including class data in here it's easy
  4120. 2:31:11to have it because all of these as i
  4121. 2:31:14said they are existing road
  4122. 2:31:16okay they are in operation
  4123. 2:31:18they were not included in the road
  4124. 2:31:21safety auditing process because it
  4125. 2:31:23didn't exist that process when they were
  4126. 2:31:25built
  4127. 2:31:26but the fact that they have been built
  4128. 2:31:28like that
  4129. 2:31:29they tell you that they may have very
  4130. 2:31:32good crash data collision data
  4131. 2:31:35okay
  4132. 2:31:37we will need to undertake
  4133. 2:31:39comprehensive site visits okay
  4134. 2:31:41always remember you cannot do this work
  4135. 2:31:44from your desk it's impossible
  4136. 2:31:47you must go on site
  4137. 2:31:49okay you need to fill the road you need
  4138. 2:31:51to feel how everything is is developing
  4139. 2:31:54in the on the road you need to see with
  4140. 2:31:56your eyes which are the problems so this
  4141. 2:31:59is not something that you can do from
  4142. 2:32:00your desk
  4143. 2:32:01in fact i would recommend that if you
  4144. 2:32:04are doing that kind of things record it
  4145. 2:32:06in video
  4146. 2:32:07but
  4147. 2:32:08don't trust someone recording for you
  4148. 2:32:10you record it by yourself and later when
  4149. 2:32:12you are doing this exercise the thing
  4150. 2:32:15that you need to do is remember how are
  4151. 2:32:18you feeling the things that you were uh
  4152. 2:32:21noting you know when you were driving
  4153. 2:32:23for that area okay
  4154. 2:32:26okay you need to assess the perspective
  4155. 2:32:28from every single user this is always
  4156. 2:32:30and you need to do analysis and report
  4157. 2:32:33your analysis you need to
  4158. 2:32:34comprehensively telling them what is
  4159. 2:32:37happening okay of course
  4160. 2:32:39all of this at the end is going to be
  4161. 2:32:42reverting is going to revert it to the
  4162. 2:32:45authority that is that it has the power
  4163. 2:32:47on the road okay
  4164. 2:32:49and you expect to see implementation of
  4165. 2:32:52the improvement that they are going to
  4166. 2:32:53recombine always in always is going to
  4167. 2:32:56be engineering solutions to bring from
  4168. 2:32:58the past to the present technique
  4169. 2:33:01dr weil please
  4170. 2:33:08okay
  4171. 2:33:09as i said before you can put the next
  4172. 2:33:11one to a click another one
  4173. 2:33:14that's it keep it in there as i said
  4174. 2:33:16before no no
  4175. 2:33:18that's the one as i said before we are
  4176. 2:33:20having a
  4177. 2:33:22an another useful tool
  4178. 2:33:24a useful tool i'm
  4179. 2:33:26using my fingers to put in commas you
  4180. 2:33:28know between commas that is the
  4181. 2:33:31the
  4182. 2:33:33the list the
  4183. 2:33:35the checking list that we have for raw
  4184. 2:33:37safety auditing okay
  4185. 2:33:40the second list for road safety editing
  4186. 2:33:42is very useful
  4187. 2:33:44when
  4188. 2:33:44you are starting
  4189. 2:33:47in this kind of career
  4190. 2:33:49and you don't want to forget anything
  4191. 2:33:52however we always say that the list is
  4192. 2:33:54not limited to the list that they can be
  4193. 2:33:56added more things however
  4194. 2:33:59a lot of people they use the checklist
  4195. 2:34:00just as a checklist
  4196. 2:34:02no they don't go beyond they don't see
  4197. 2:34:04beyond that one this is why it's very
  4198. 2:34:06important your experience the ideas that
  4199. 2:34:08you have spent
  4200. 2:34:09forming yourself and developing yourself
  4201. 2:34:11in role safety auditing i have put in
  4202. 2:34:14here three different ones from different
  4203. 2:34:16standards every single standard in the
  4204. 2:34:17world at the end of the standard you
  4205. 2:34:19will have
  4206. 2:34:21how to write a
  4207. 2:34:22a report
  4208. 2:34:24that is the way that normally comes and
  4209. 2:34:26they will put for you also the checklist
  4210. 2:34:28what you need not to forget and it's
  4211. 2:34:31like a guidance for you
  4212. 2:34:32but
  4213. 2:34:34i will say that the checklist should be
  4214. 2:34:35done after you have done
  4215. 2:34:37all your audit
  4216. 2:34:39don't do the checklist unless you do the
  4217. 2:34:42audit because you can overrule over
  4218. 2:34:44seeing
  4219. 2:34:45things
  4220. 2:34:46that they don't come on the checklist
  4221. 2:34:48okay
  4222. 2:34:49just do your audit
  4223. 2:34:51put everything that you have found and
  4224. 2:34:53later use the checklist to see
  4225. 2:34:55if this is applicable or not applicable
  4226. 2:34:57to the thing that you are doing
  4227. 2:34:59okay that is the most important thing
  4228. 2:35:01for checklist i don't like a lot in
  4229. 2:35:04order to use it as the raw safety as a
  4230. 2:35:06substitute or draw safety of it however
  4231. 2:35:09when we are talking about inspections
  4232. 2:35:11when we are talking about inspection
  4233. 2:35:13i would do a checklist for the inspector
  4234. 2:35:16if they are not qualified road safety
  4235. 2:35:18auditors okay if they are inspector and
  4236. 2:35:21we know that for inspector we say that
  4237. 2:35:23sometimes they don't have the
  4238. 2:35:25engineering degree
  4239. 2:35:29you need to
  4240. 2:35:30you need to deal with people that you
  4241. 2:35:32need to explain everything very clear
  4242. 2:35:34and you need to make them aware about
  4243. 2:35:36the risk that they are going to be
  4244. 2:35:38seeing
  4245. 2:35:39in the on the road
  4246. 2:35:41and realizing that because i have done
  4247. 2:35:42the worse on traffic management guidance
  4248. 2:35:46works on traffic management
  4249. 2:35:48training
  4250. 2:35:49and i realized that people that they are
  4251. 2:35:51normally doing this kind of diversion
  4252. 2:35:53they don't realize about the risk
  4253. 2:35:55because they are not educated so a
  4254. 2:35:58checklist for them can be very useful in
  4255. 2:36:00order they can identify risk but again a
  4256. 2:36:04checklist is limited okay
  4257. 2:36:07so maybe it can cover 80 to 85 percent
  4258. 2:36:10of all the issues that you got in there
  4259. 2:36:12if the inspector brings you 80 to 85
  4260. 2:36:14percent of the issues it's a good number
  4261. 2:36:17but the other 15 it needs to be the
  4262. 2:36:19person the appropriate safety editor who
  4263. 2:36:21goes on site and check that kind of
  4264. 2:36:23things please don't talk about the next
  4265. 2:36:25one
  4266. 2:36:27okay
  4267. 2:36:28projects to be audited okay this is
  4268. 2:36:31in every single country you got
  4269. 2:36:32different kind of things of course i
  4270. 2:36:34have put this table because i really
  4271. 2:36:36like it
  4272. 2:36:37it's very very easy to understand
  4273. 2:36:39and for mandatory
  4274. 2:36:41uh
  4275. 2:36:42the all optional
  4276. 2:36:44okay
  4277. 2:36:45and the d is for the
  4278. 2:36:48the people to disclosure to the
  4279. 2:36:50discretion of the of the authority okay
  4280. 2:36:53so
  4281. 2:36:54you can see here different kind of
  4282. 2:36:56project
  4283. 2:36:57okay
  4284. 2:36:57that they are going to be
  4285. 2:36:59that they need to be
  4286. 2:37:01audited stage one two three four or five
  4287. 2:37:04um
  4288. 2:37:05you can see when you got a new
  4289. 2:37:06expressway or a new road
  4290. 2:37:08or a
  4291. 2:37:10an alteration of the physical
  4292. 2:37:13of the geometrical alignment vertical
  4293. 2:37:15horizontal road all of these they are
  4294. 2:37:18going to have a mandatory mandate
  4295. 2:37:19mandatory
  4296. 2:37:21another ones that
  4297. 2:37:23i haven't said before i put it in at the
  4298. 2:37:25beginning but i'm going to say now
  4299. 2:37:27is that
  4300. 2:37:28in europe we used to have from 2008 an
  4301. 2:37:32european directive you know
  4302. 2:37:34and the european directed now it has
  4303. 2:37:35been super cd for the 2019 136
  4304. 2:37:381
  4305. 2:37:391936 okay and in there now it's
  4306. 2:37:42compulsory to undertake research today
  4307. 2:37:44for war zones gorzon's is a very
  4308. 2:37:47important place where we must do raw
  4309. 2:37:50safety audits and if you realize in here
  4310. 2:37:53we got it at the end at the end we got
  4311. 2:37:55war zones that they must be audited okay
  4312. 2:37:58so
  4313. 2:37:59out of the project that we are having
  4314. 2:38:02you know that they must be audited one
  4315. 2:38:04song i will say that is one of the
  4316. 2:38:08they are ones
  4317. 2:38:09of the
  4318. 2:38:11of the ones that they got more accident
  4319. 2:38:13and more casualties okay not just for
  4320. 2:38:16workers but also for people that they
  4321. 2:38:17are
  4322. 2:38:18that they are passing by and then
  4323. 2:38:20negotiating the war zone of course
  4324. 2:38:22new expressway new local road major road
  4325. 2:38:25projects minor road projects developed
  4326. 2:38:27all of them you realize the ant to the
  4327. 2:38:30design and the under construction is
  4328. 2:38:33mandatory all of those logically
  4329. 2:38:36the last one
  4330. 2:38:37the stage five
  4331. 2:38:40the monitoring they say up to the
  4332. 2:38:42discretion of the local authority i
  4333. 2:38:44don't understand why don't do it
  4334. 2:38:46mandatory i'm going to i i don't
  4335. 2:38:48understand but i know why because
  4336. 2:38:50normally when you finish your
  4337. 2:38:51construction project
  4338. 2:38:53the only thing that you want to do is to
  4339. 2:38:54disappear from there pay your guarantee
  4340. 2:38:58that you have already given to the
  4341. 2:38:59authority in order they allow you to do
  4342. 2:39:01the
  4343. 2:39:02to the work you take your deposit and if
  4344. 2:39:05i see you i don't remember you he's like
  4345. 2:39:07that this is why they put it like
  4346. 2:39:09discretionary okay but it should be
  4347. 2:39:13it should be mandatory too
  4348. 2:39:15because
  4349. 2:39:16imagine that you are going to do the
  4350. 2:39:18monitoring of the 12th month or the 24
  4351. 2:39:21or 20 or the 36 whenever you want to do
  4352. 2:39:23it and you realize that there is a
  4353. 2:39:25problem in there who is going to sort it
  4354. 2:39:27out
  4355. 2:39:27but now it's going to be the authority
  4356. 2:39:29and all the cost implications for that
  4357. 2:39:31one is going to be under the authority
  4358. 2:39:34funding
  4359. 2:39:35before if you do it within the the two
  4360. 2:39:38years that they go guarantee
  4361. 2:39:40a time after that they have been built
  4362. 2:39:43if you extend that time for doing this
  4363. 2:39:45raw safety or you make a condition that
  4364. 2:39:48within two years you don't have a
  4365. 2:39:50problem blah blah blah and you undertake
  4366. 2:39:52a stage five row safety audit then it
  4367. 2:39:54will be the funding will be from the
  4368. 2:39:56contractor
  4369. 2:39:57okay
  4370. 2:39:59so as i said this list this is an
  4371. 2:40:02example from qatar but you can have this
  4372. 2:40:05one in many different countries many
  4373. 2:40:07different projects of course you can
  4374. 2:40:10also can see that
  4375. 2:40:11some of the projects they must do it
  4376. 2:40:14but someone decided from the local
  4377. 2:40:16authority or from the governmental
  4378. 2:40:17authority that they don't need to be
  4379. 2:40:19done so they will do an exemption report
  4380. 2:40:22and with that exemption report they will
  4381. 2:40:25they will be giving
  4382. 2:40:27this kind of
  4383. 2:40:29i don't know
  4384. 2:40:32this kind of privilege okay
  4385. 2:40:36okay
  4386. 2:40:37so
  4387. 2:40:38let's talk about non-motorized user nmu
  4388. 2:40:41audits okay
  4389. 2:40:43in here
  4390. 2:40:44we are going to see that the road safety
  4391. 2:40:46they can be focusing
  4392. 2:40:48in one specific
  4393. 2:40:50group of users okay
  4394. 2:40:53non-motorized users as i said they are
  4395. 2:40:56users as they say here
  4396. 2:40:58user of the same kind of network the
  4397. 2:40:59same kind of roads okay so they must be
  4398. 2:41:02brought into consideration
  4399. 2:41:05and this can be pedestrian bicycle
  4400. 2:41:07children and people with disabilities
  4401. 2:41:08and i will say also
  4402. 2:41:10that we need to have those even into
  4403. 2:41:12more consideration we're talking school
  4404. 2:41:14zones okay
  4405. 2:41:16we're talking a
  4406. 2:41:19close in the vicinity of a shopping mall
  4407. 2:41:22or in the vicinity of a hospital okay
  4408. 2:41:25all these kind of areas they are going
  4409. 2:41:26to be very sensitive for non-motorized
  4410. 2:41:29user audit okay now it's called
  4411. 2:41:32vulnerable users okay but before it was
  4412. 2:41:34called like that
  4413. 2:41:36please dr well
  4414. 2:41:40okay so the thing that i that we will be
  4415. 2:41:42doing when we finish a road safety audit
  4416. 2:41:45or a road safety impact assessment or a
  4417. 2:41:47road safety inspection we will be
  4418. 2:41:49reporting and we are expecting a
  4419. 2:41:52response back
  4420. 2:41:54telling us that they are accepting or
  4421. 2:41:55they are not affecting
  4422. 2:41:57what we have subjected suggesting okay
  4423. 2:42:00so the report will be sent to the
  4424. 2:42:02project sponsor to the product manager
  4425. 2:42:05to whoever is interested in reading what
  4426. 2:42:07we are saying because seriously from
  4427. 2:42:09time to time our reports they go back on
  4428. 2:42:12the shelf and they start taking dust
  4429. 2:42:14and it's just a
  4430. 2:42:16checkpoint for them but they don't care
  4431. 2:42:19about that
  4432. 2:42:20the project manager is the one that
  4433. 2:42:22might respond to every single concern
  4434. 2:42:24well he should he should respond to
  4435. 2:42:27every single concern as i said we should
  4436. 2:42:29have a meeting where all parties they
  4437. 2:42:31are in there is the close-out session
  4438. 2:42:32that we do here and that is quite
  4439. 2:42:35interesting because you can listen every
  4440. 2:42:37single party you know at the table and
  4441. 2:42:40the authority
  4442. 2:42:41responsible for the road will have the
  4443. 2:42:43last word in that one
  4444. 2:42:45okay
  4445. 2:42:46so the responsible of the project
  4446. 2:42:48manager to make the decision if this is
  4447. 2:42:50going to be done or this is not going to
  4448. 2:42:51be wrong and we need to see what is
  4449. 2:42:54important we need to see what is going
  4450. 2:42:56to be the impact on rock collision and
  4451. 2:42:58casualties as i told you i don't mind if
  4452. 2:43:00the number of collisions stays the same
  4453. 2:43:03but i want to minimize or mitigate the
  4454. 2:43:06consequences of rogue collision please
  4455. 2:43:08after well
  4456. 2:43:13okay
  4457. 2:43:14uh rose safety others saved lives and
  4458. 2:43:16money okay we have
  4459. 2:43:19many
  4460. 2:43:20many studies you know across the world
  4461. 2:43:22where we can say that they save money
  4462. 2:43:25because they
  4463. 2:43:26uh reduce the number of casualties that
  4464. 2:43:28you got
  4465. 2:43:29okay
  4466. 2:43:30in the uk we got the the
  4467. 2:43:34schemes that they have been audited okay
  4468. 2:43:37they are five times more effective
  4469. 2:43:39reducing crashes than skins that they
  4470. 2:43:41haven't been audited okay
  4471. 2:43:43and
  4472. 2:43:44if you implement
  4473. 2:43:46the safety change that they are set
  4474. 2:43:48because you can audit but later they say
  4475. 2:43:50okay thank you for the audit but i'm not
  4476. 2:43:52going to implement anything
  4477. 2:43:54okay
  4478. 2:43:55but if you implement the changes okay at
  4479. 2:43:57the same phase you can save an average
  4480. 2:44:00of 22 000 per the site that you are
  4481. 2:44:03applying this one okay
  4482. 2:44:06later you go to other countries like
  4483. 2:44:07denmark that the first year rate return
  4484. 2:44:11for the dts team is 146 146 percent or
  4485. 2:44:15in jordan is 120
  4486. 2:44:18or in australia the benefit the core
  4487. 2:44:20ratio benefit that you got
  4488. 2:44:22of the
  4489. 2:44:23at the design stage is 36.1 or if you do
  4490. 2:44:26it for the inspection or the the
  4491. 2:44:28existing one is 6-1 so you can see
  4492. 2:44:32that the road safety audits and road
  4493. 2:44:34safety inspections and also
  4494. 2:44:36traffic impact assessment the the road
  4495. 2:44:38safety impact assessment they can bring
  4496. 2:44:40a lot of value for the things that we
  4497. 2:44:42are having okay
  4498. 2:44:44so please don't hesitate
  4499. 2:44:48in embrace draw safety this kind of
  4500. 2:44:50tools okay
  4501. 2:44:52i don't know if you were expecting me to
  4502. 2:44:53explain a little bit more about the raw
  4503. 2:44:56safety of the report or how to write no
  4504. 2:44:58that is that is independent the place
  4505. 2:45:00that you are you got the standard you do
  4506. 2:45:01it like that please pass the next one
  4507. 2:45:03please
  4508. 2:45:05you will see
  4509. 2:45:06uh
  4510. 2:45:07standards everywhere you know and now
  4511. 2:45:10i'm going to explain you about something
  4512. 2:45:12that susanna said before the three star
  4513. 2:45:15rating okay
  4514. 2:45:18okay irap
  4515. 2:45:19is a an organization that is very famous
  4516. 2:45:22in the world you've got item everywhere
  4517. 2:45:24you go to spain you've got arabs you go
  4518. 2:45:26to doha you got iran
  4519. 2:45:27everywhere in the world okay
  4520. 2:45:29so the international road safety program
  4521. 2:45:32is going to give you
  4522. 2:45:34a rate
  4523. 2:45:35for the road that you got in your
  4524. 2:45:37country or the road that you are going
  4525. 2:45:38to design in your country okay
  4526. 2:45:40they are very advanced program and they
  4527. 2:45:43are going to tell you
  4528. 2:45:44if your road is going to be up to a
  4529. 2:45:46standard and up to safety for that one
  4530. 2:45:50and then allow me to tell you that idap
  4531. 2:45:53fantastic tool
  4532. 2:45:54but i would use this tool
  4533. 2:45:56in countries where they don't have
  4534. 2:45:59appropriate rows safety auditors
  4535. 2:46:02is for me the first approach to road
  4536. 2:46:05safety
  4537. 2:46:06fantastic seriously is a very good tool
  4538. 2:46:08okay but if you got people that they can
  4539. 2:46:11do this work why do you need this
  4540. 2:46:13program
  4541. 2:46:14because this program
  4542. 2:46:17allows you to increase is a rating
  4543. 2:46:19program is like the hotels okay
  4544. 2:46:22you go hotels from one start to five
  4545. 2:46:24star
  4546. 2:46:25seven you are in dubai okay where about
  4547. 2:46:27this okay you got you go hotels that the
  4548. 2:46:29classification is one two three four
  4549. 2:46:31five star waiting here they use the
  4550. 2:46:33similar classification for the roads
  4551. 2:46:35being the worst road in guangzhou and
  4552. 2:46:37being the best excellent road in five
  4553. 2:46:39stars okay
  4554. 2:46:42so
  4555. 2:46:42doing changes
  4556. 2:46:44lowering the speed or allocating vrs
  4557. 2:46:48or
  4558. 2:46:50putting and protecting the
  4559. 2:46:52and putting illumination
  4560. 2:46:54is going to to have a huge impact on the
  4561. 2:46:57road on the safety of the road and it
  4562. 2:46:59can go from one to three to four very
  4563. 2:47:01fast
  4564. 2:47:03the problem that you see in here with
  4565. 2:47:05this program
  4566. 2:47:06that is that it should be working
  4567. 2:47:09together with a row safety auditor
  4568. 2:47:11because if you tell them look if you put
  4569. 2:47:13the vrs in here
  4570. 2:47:15your road that is to a star it will pass
  4571. 2:47:17to three star
  4572. 2:47:19you say fantastic i will put vrs
  4573. 2:47:22but
  4574. 2:47:23i app is not going to tell you what kind
  4575. 2:47:25of vrms you need to put they are not
  4576. 2:47:26going to calculate for you the level of
  4577. 2:47:28containment that is needed
  4578. 2:47:30that is something that someone else
  4579. 2:47:31needs to do it
  4580. 2:47:32okay and someone needs to check that one
  4581. 2:47:35or if they tell you
  4582. 2:47:38you got 100 kilometers per hour road and
  4583. 2:47:40they tell you if you reduce the speed
  4584. 2:47:42uh
  4585. 2:47:43your road it will pass from two start to
  4586. 2:47:45three star or from three star to four
  4587. 2:47:47star you go from 100 to 80 fantastic
  4588. 2:47:50yeah reducing the speed is not just
  4589. 2:47:52changing the plate come on it's not
  4590. 2:47:54changing the marking
  4591. 2:47:56it's not there just saying i i got a
  4592. 2:47:58hundred sign posting here and i put 80
  4593. 2:48:01now no you need to apply measures in
  4594. 2:48:03order to do that okay so it's a very
  4595. 2:48:06good tool when you don't have any other
  4596. 2:48:07thing okay but when you have other
  4597. 2:48:09things if you want to continue with
  4598. 2:48:10either bring
  4599. 2:48:12a row safety specialist to work close
  4600. 2:48:15with the item please doctor well the
  4601. 2:48:17next one
  4602. 2:48:22so the way that ida works as i said is
  4603. 2:48:24with the start rating they will inspect
  4604. 2:48:27with videos all the surrounding area
  4605. 2:48:29they also do it with drawings okay
  4606. 2:48:32and they will assess and they will code
  4607. 2:48:35all the attributes that the road is
  4608. 2:48:36going to have related to safety risk
  4609. 2:48:39that is brilliant because the equipment
  4610. 2:48:40the technology of the use is so advanced
  4611. 2:48:42that they can detect safety risks easier
  4612. 2:48:44than we wrote safety editor when we are
  4613. 2:48:47in our in our pickup or in our track
  4614. 2:48:50with the camera recording okay so they
  4615. 2:48:53got a fantastic a fantastic equipment
  4616. 2:48:55for that i this is why i have my light
  4617. 2:48:57up for this kind of things but as i said
  4618. 2:49:00it needs the next stage that is working
  4619. 2:49:03closing with a
  4620. 2:49:04with a row safety especially
  4621. 2:49:07of course they also
  4622. 2:49:08they use computers
  4623. 2:49:10they are asceptic
  4624. 2:49:12so they put the characteristic of the
  4625. 2:49:14rose that they have been assessing
  4626. 2:49:16and aesthetically they tell you this is
  4627. 2:49:18three this is two this is four okay
  4628. 2:49:20and of course they tell you how
  4629. 2:49:23and when you need to invest in order
  4630. 2:49:26that everything is going to be upgraded
  4631. 2:49:28to the next rate
  4632. 2:49:29and they will give you a performance
  4633. 2:49:31tracking they will tell you if you are
  4634. 2:49:33doing right or you are doing wrong with
  4635. 2:49:35the with the money that you are
  4636. 2:49:37investing in this kind of things please
  4637. 2:49:40dr weld the next one
  4638. 2:49:44so at the end what we were saying before
  4639. 2:49:47what susanna was telling you before is
  4640. 2:49:49that all the new roads that you have you
  4641. 2:49:51remember the
  4642. 2:49:53the
  4643. 2:49:54it was the number four okay of the
  4644. 2:49:56voluntary
  4645. 2:49:58uh
  4646. 2:49:59of the voluntary for 2017 there were
  4647. 2:50:02three targets okay number four it was
  4648. 2:50:04that minimum three star rating okay so
  4649. 2:50:08with that we are going to grant that
  4650. 2:50:10those roads they're going to be
  4651. 2:50:13safe
  4652. 2:50:14you know again they're going to be as
  4653. 2:50:16safe as they can for a three star rating
  4654. 2:50:19but if you got raw safety auditors maybe
  4655. 2:50:22you can achieve a four or five
  4656. 2:50:24if they follow your advice okay as i
  4657. 2:50:26said ida very good tool
  4658. 2:50:29but it requires help from a road safety
  4659. 2:50:32specialist
  4660. 2:50:33please after well
  4661. 2:50:37this is a very useful manual just in
  4662. 2:50:39case that you don't have any standard
  4663. 2:50:41the asian development bank they did that
  4664. 2:50:44and isa
  4665. 2:50:45is available for everybody is for free
  4666. 2:50:48and you got a lot of a lot of case of
  4667. 2:50:50studies for example that they can be
  4668. 2:50:51used for the checklist that you got in
  4669. 2:50:53here and with this dr well i think i'm
  4670. 2:50:56going to stop in here the presentation
  4671. 2:50:58because the next one is for economy and
  4672. 2:51:00that will do it tomorrow in the in the
  4673. 2:51:02next days okay now if anyone got a
  4674. 2:51:05question or whatsoever i'm here no
  4675. 2:51:08problem at all i think i have been more
  4676. 2:51:10or less good with the timing
  4677. 2:51:11yes yes thank you thank you miguel for
  4678. 2:51:14the presentation and
  4679. 2:51:16i think with this information we have
  4680. 2:51:18covered the basic uh information
  4681. 2:51:21regarding the concept of road safety
  4682. 2:51:22audits requirements and also the
  4683. 2:51:25benefits of roots of the audit and in
  4684. 2:51:27the next two sessions tomorrow and the
  4685. 2:51:29day after tomorrow we will go more on
  4686. 2:51:32examples of road safety problems how to
  4687. 2:51:34identify them as a road safety auditor
  4688. 2:51:37which will be addressed tomorrow and in
  4689. 2:51:38the last day we will talk about what
  4690. 2:51:39kind of treatments
  4691. 2:51:41and countermeasures can be proposed for
  4692. 2:51:43different road safety issues um i have
  4693. 2:51:46some questions uh here and there um
  4694. 2:51:49actually there's a lot of
  4695. 2:51:51questions difficult to summarize them
  4696. 2:51:54but
  4697. 2:51:55one of them is about what kind of tools
  4698. 2:51:57to be used for road safety assessment
  4699. 2:51:59either a road safety in an audit or an
  4700. 2:52:01assessment or an inspection is there
  4701. 2:52:03specific tools that can be used
  4702. 2:52:06to guide road safety audit auditors
  4703. 2:52:09well the important thing the important
  4704. 2:52:11thing is the
  4705. 2:52:12the training course the training course
  4706. 2:52:15you must have a proper trainer that is
  4707. 2:52:18experienced you know in the thing that
  4708. 2:52:19is going to teach you
  4709. 2:52:21i'm not saying that people well i'm
  4710. 2:52:24saying yes people that they haven't been
  4711. 2:52:25on site ever in their life they cannot
  4712. 2:52:27teach you this
  4713. 2:52:28okay they can be fantastic teachers for
  4714. 2:52:31a specialization that they are going to
  4715. 2:52:33be very complicated but if they haven't
  4716. 2:52:35been on site they will not understand
  4717. 2:52:37the way that they need to transmit this
  4718. 2:52:39one so it's very important to choose a
  4719. 2:52:40proper training course where you can
  4720. 2:52:43where you can learn your foundation so
  4721. 2:52:46that is the main tool later as i said
  4722. 2:52:48checklist well sometimes it's good some
  4723. 2:52:50time is not as good but
  4724. 2:52:53leave it for the end for the people that
  4725. 2:52:55they are not qualify us as engineers
  4726. 2:52:57just
  4727. 2:52:58to have a help for them
  4728. 2:53:01great
  4729. 2:53:03also to add to you of course there are
  4730. 2:53:06some international tools that can be
  4731. 2:53:07used
  4732. 2:53:08some of them are free some of them you
  4733. 2:53:10have to buy such as the one in australia
  4734. 2:53:12you have the highway safety manual
  4735. 2:53:14you have different tools that you can
  4736. 2:53:17use to learn more about the relationship
  4737. 2:53:20between
  4738. 2:53:21traffic operation and what kind of
  4739. 2:53:23safety problems could be appear what
  4740. 2:53:25kind of safety problems you can have on
  4741. 2:53:27your roads but again attending more and
  4742. 2:53:30more
  4743. 2:53:31trainings
  4744. 2:53:32regarding road safety
  4745. 2:53:35not only road safety audit in general
  4746. 2:53:37to understand the process of routing
  4747. 2:53:39order but for example attending
  4748. 2:53:41trainings on crash investigation
  4749. 2:53:42attending trainings on vulnerable road
  4750. 2:53:45users safety pedestrian safety attending
  4751. 2:53:47trainings that address through safety
  4752. 2:53:50and work zones uh roadside
  4753. 2:53:53safety
  4754. 2:53:54also
  4755. 2:53:55will
  4756. 2:53:57enhance your knowledge and improve your
  4757. 2:53:59knowledge
  4758. 2:54:00with the experience of conducting road
  4759. 2:54:02safety others you will always find and
  4760. 2:54:04identify different routes of the other
  4761. 2:54:06issues that will also accumulate over
  4762. 2:54:09your experience
  4763. 2:54:11other ex question is
  4764. 2:54:16regarding
  4765. 2:54:19road design standards does not guarantee
  4766. 2:54:22safety
  4767. 2:54:24yes can you elaborate more on that
  4768. 2:54:28miguel
  4769. 2:54:29oh yeah yeah of course
  4770. 2:54:31uh
  4771. 2:54:32okay i got i would like to show you uh
  4772. 2:54:36an example that i got already but uh
  4773. 2:54:39okay
  4774. 2:54:40let me let me do one thing i i don't
  4775. 2:54:42have my camera now let me see if i can
  4776. 2:54:45see the camera
  4777. 2:54:48is it working
  4778. 2:54:51i don't know you can see me if you stop
  4779. 2:54:53sharing your screen dr weil please
  4780. 2:54:59okay hello hello everybody
  4781. 2:55:02let me see if i'm able to show you a
  4782. 2:55:05presentation
  4783. 2:55:07where i can explain exactly
  4784. 2:55:10about uh
  4785. 2:55:12about this kind of things
  4786. 2:55:15here
  4787. 2:55:17uh qatar university master course
  4788. 2:55:19september
  4789. 2:55:21okay i'm opening this one
  4790. 2:55:23let's see if i can if i can share this
  4791. 2:55:26screen with you now and i can explain
  4792. 2:55:28very clear about
  4793. 2:55:30that the road safety doesn't guarantee
  4794. 2:55:33sorry the complaint with the standard
  4795. 2:55:35doesn't guarantee road safety okay
  4796. 2:55:37and it's
  4797. 2:55:38most likely for designers these kind of
  4798. 2:55:40things because
  4799. 2:55:42they they think that complying with the
  4800. 2:55:44standard that they have been doing
  4801. 2:55:46uh the road is going to be safe enough
  4802. 2:55:48to be driven okay that is the minimum
  4803. 2:55:50remember that that is going to be the
  4804. 2:55:52minimum acceptable okay
  4805. 2:55:54look let me
  4806. 2:55:56let me see if i can share this
  4807. 2:55:59hopefully
  4808. 2:56:02okay
  4809. 2:56:03this one
  4810. 2:56:06can you see my screen now
  4811. 2:56:09yes
  4812. 2:56:11yes it's in the slide mode or not yet
  4813. 2:56:17can you see it
  4814. 2:56:20yes
  4815. 2:56:22okay
  4816. 2:56:23so let's have a look to this to this
  4817. 2:56:26road that we got in here okay
  4818. 2:56:29it's a
  4819. 2:56:30it's a normal car this way okay that it
  4820. 2:56:32has
  4821. 2:56:33you know it can have potential problems
  4822. 2:56:36for the people when they are turning to
  4823. 2:56:38the right hand side okay
  4824. 2:56:40and they can have like heads on
  4825. 2:56:42collisions
  4826. 2:56:43not some collision they can have hassle
  4827. 2:56:44collision with the other one but no
  4828. 2:56:46reaction collisions if you are slowing
  4829. 2:56:48down and you want to enter on the minor
  4830. 2:56:50junctions that you got in here okay
  4831. 2:56:53so this intersection it it provides a
  4832. 2:56:56good horizontal side distance for the
  4833. 2:56:58side road okay
  4834. 2:57:00however
  4835. 2:57:01in order to avoid the reassuring
  4836. 2:57:03collisions we say okay
  4837. 2:57:05let's try to do like a filter we create
  4838. 2:57:08a deceleration lane
  4839. 2:57:10and with the deceleration link we are
  4840. 2:57:12going to avoid this kind of reassuring
  4841. 2:57:15collision that we should have that we
  4842. 2:57:17had before dr well are you able to see
  4843. 2:57:19my screen or not yes has it changed
  4844. 2:57:22properly
  4845. 2:57:25uh can you change now one again no no
  4846. 2:57:28it's okay it's still in number two
  4847. 2:57:29deceleration laying allows vehicle is it
  4848. 2:57:31still in there
  4849. 2:57:33it is
  4850. 2:57:34number one now and i think
  4851. 2:57:38so number one an intersection number two
  4852. 2:57:40has changed now to the second one
  4853. 2:57:44we cannot see the second one
  4854. 2:57:48okay the thing that i'm trying to
  4855. 2:57:49explain is that if you create at this
  4856. 2:57:52tomorrow i will put this one as a
  4857. 2:57:54response the the only thing that i'm
  4858. 2:57:56saying is that even if you create
  4859. 2:57:58something that is better and you follow
  4860. 2:57:59the standard you may create a problem
  4861. 2:58:02that they are not comprised with we
  4862. 2:58:04comprised within this standard for
  4863. 2:58:06example the thing that i was putting in
  4864. 2:58:07here when you create the
  4865. 2:58:09the filter the deceleration line for
  4866. 2:58:11that one
  4867. 2:58:13it doesn't allow the people
  4868. 2:58:15when
  4869. 2:58:17when that destination lane is is busy
  4870. 2:58:19the people that they are exiting from
  4871. 2:58:21the junction they don't have the same
  4872. 2:58:22kind of visibility that they have before
  4873. 2:58:24okay so you need to think a little bit
  4874. 2:58:26more to see how it's possible that you
  4875. 2:58:29increase the visibility that you have
  4876. 2:58:30already corrected the deceleration link
  4877. 2:58:32is okay you are following the standard
  4878. 2:58:35you are making safer because you are
  4879. 2:58:37removing the reaction collision however
  4880. 2:58:40you are creating a problem that before
  4881. 2:58:42you didn't have it okay so you are
  4882. 2:58:44complying with all the standard but
  4883. 2:58:46you're not granting the safety of the
  4884. 2:58:48road
  4885. 2:58:49okay
  4886. 2:58:51sorry i'm not going to stop
  4887. 2:58:53because you're going to see
  4888. 2:58:55now just to move to to slide two but
  4889. 2:58:57it's okay
  4890. 2:59:00so can you see us live three now
  4891. 2:59:02no now i think you stopped cheering
  4892. 2:59:05okay it's okay don't worry tomorrow
  4893. 2:59:07tomorrow we will sort it out much better
  4894. 2:59:09because i will be in qatar university
  4895. 2:59:11and we're not going to have this kind of
  4896. 2:59:13problem so
  4897. 2:59:15yeah
  4898. 2:59:16yeah maybe i can add to what you said
  4899. 2:59:18that usually design stubborn for roads
  4900. 2:59:20are giving us general guidelines for how
  4901. 2:59:23to design your roads considering some
  4902. 2:59:26minimum requirements that ensure
  4903. 2:59:28smooth flow smooth movement of vehicles
  4904. 2:59:31and in some context
  4905. 2:59:34contribute to safety to safe to safety
  4906. 2:59:37to safety operation to safe operation
  4907. 2:59:39however
  4908. 2:59:41in the detailed operation of roads there
  4909. 2:59:43are several issues that are not
  4910. 2:59:45addressed
  4911. 2:59:46in the design standards and it has to be
  4912. 2:59:49looked from a different perspective to
  4913. 2:59:51identify how the operation itself
  4914. 2:59:55will lead to a safer
  4915. 2:59:57safety or could induce some
  4916. 3:00:00crash risk
  4917. 3:00:01and here will come the safety auditor
  4918. 3:00:04who just looked to the operation itself
  4919. 3:00:07if this road comes to an operation in
  4920. 3:00:09the design stage
  4921. 3:00:10and it becomes implemented what kind of
  4922. 3:00:12safety risk it can have it can appear
  4923. 3:00:15this process helped a lot
  4924. 3:00:18roads especially new roads to be to be
  4925. 3:00:21in a more safer level of operation
  4926. 3:00:24compared to
  4927. 3:00:25roads that are existing
  4928. 3:00:27uh without conducting road safety audits
  4929. 3:00:31and here this is take us actually to a
  4930. 3:00:33question by one of uh several
  4931. 3:00:34participants who said that there are
  4932. 3:00:36countries they don't have roots of the
  4933. 3:00:37audits concepts
  4934. 3:00:39or they don't have this process
  4935. 3:00:41implemented in that case what kind of
  4936. 3:00:43suggestion we can give them
  4937. 3:00:47some participants proposed for example
  4938. 3:00:49for civil engineers to conduct
  4939. 3:00:52road safety reports let's call it or
  4940. 3:00:55assessments and being submitted to
  4941. 3:00:58government agencies to take decisions
  4942. 3:01:01and to impose improvements
  4943. 3:01:04do you have any comment on this miguel
  4944. 3:01:07no they will realize that the the wall
  4945. 3:01:10is evolving to everybody needs to have
  4946. 3:01:13you know a proper road safety culture
  4947. 3:01:15you know and road safety auditing is
  4948. 3:01:17something that is coming it's coming for
  4949. 3:01:19every single country even they don't
  4950. 3:01:21believe it because they realize that
  4951. 3:01:22they are not as perfect that they were
  4952. 3:01:24thinking okay so because we made
  4953. 3:01:27mistakes and the
  4954. 3:01:29holistic approach that we got for the
  4955. 3:01:30safe system is that we are human beings
  4956. 3:01:32and we can we are going to make mistakes
  4957. 3:01:34they will realize that this kind of
  4958. 3:01:35tools that we have been talking today is
  4959. 3:01:38something that they need to adhere
  4960. 3:01:40stop being so stubborn or so
  4961. 3:01:44unpractical okay and start engaging if
  4962. 3:01:48all what the rest of the world is doing
  4963. 3:01:51i can tell you the people that they are
  4964. 3:01:53the government that they are not uh
  4965. 3:01:56adhering even if they got the resources
  4966. 3:01:58to do raw safety auditing is because
  4967. 3:02:01they are still uh quite proud
  4968. 3:02:04about the things that they say but you
  4969. 3:02:05need to to lose these kind of things and
  4970. 3:02:08and make the best
  4971. 3:02:09for your for the people that they are
  4972. 3:02:11living within your boundaries okay that
  4973. 3:02:13is the kind of thing they will enhance
  4974. 3:02:15i'm quite sure about that the same thing
  4975. 3:02:17in the uk the
  4976. 3:02:19the road safety auditing is very well
  4977. 3:02:20developed they still need to go a little
  4978. 3:02:23bit beyond they need to enhance the
  4979. 3:02:25proper safety system in a in a deeper
  4980. 3:02:28way it's talking about the risk
  4981. 3:02:29assessment that we got and the gd104 and
  4982. 3:02:32these kind of things no no
  4983. 3:02:34we need to we need to start changing our
  4984. 3:02:36philosophy
  4985. 3:02:37yes yes
  4986. 3:02:38and i know that a lot of people that
  4987. 3:02:40they are seeing me now they are from the
  4988. 3:02:41uk i'm member of sorcerer in the
  4989. 3:02:44committee and seriously i'm telling them
  4990. 3:02:47that they need to to improve a little
  4991. 3:02:48bit more but
  4992. 3:02:49they need time everything needs time and
  4993. 3:02:52i promise you
  4994. 3:02:53if if it was not for them that they had
  4995. 3:02:55the first idea to bring draw safety
  4996. 3:02:57auditing into the design process we will
  4997. 3:02:59be a little bit lost maybe other
  4998. 3:03:01countries would take the lead
  4999. 3:03:04indeed
  5000. 3:03:07last
  5001. 3:03:08comment
  5002. 3:03:10that i i saw it interesting but i'm not
  5003. 3:03:13sure if it is should be addressed on
  5004. 3:03:14this uh webinar or not
  5005. 3:03:17um
  5006. 3:03:18for asgar or for
  5007. 3:03:21you uh miguel when you work in nashville
  5008. 3:03:24what kind of impact speed do you use
  5009. 3:03:27or do designers use for
  5010. 3:03:30defining pedestrian treatments
  5011. 3:03:37dr well that is a very compromising
  5012. 3:03:39situation for me
  5013. 3:03:41but it's okay i will i will try to
  5014. 3:03:43answer without compromising myself
  5015. 3:03:45okay
  5016. 3:03:48as i said
  5017. 3:03:49they should be able to answer if 30
  5018. 3:03:51kilometers per hour
  5019. 3:03:53you can extract a pedestrian or not
  5020. 3:03:55okay
  5021. 3:03:56everything that is 30 kilometers per
  5022. 3:03:59hour or beyond or more than that
  5023. 3:04:02you should redesign your
  5024. 3:04:04your design you should think about
  5025. 3:04:06changing the things you should
  5026. 3:04:09allocate protection ways you know but
  5027. 3:04:11rotation is always the last thing try to
  5028. 3:04:14improve your design in order that the
  5029. 3:04:15answer to that question is no
  5030. 3:04:17so do you mean that because when you're
  5031. 3:04:20talking about 30 kilometer per hour
  5032. 3:04:22so if any road speed limit is 30 or 50
  5033. 3:04:25of course the vehicle there is a vehicle
  5034. 3:04:27might
  5035. 3:04:28hit with a speed of more than 30. so it
  5036. 3:04:31is related to the speed limit of the
  5037. 3:04:32road
  5038. 3:04:34of course if you go at 30 kilometers per
  5039. 3:04:36hour the chances of survival is around
  5040. 3:04:3980 percent if you hit a pedestrian over
  5041. 3:04:4330 kilometers per hour the chances of
  5042. 3:04:45survival of the pedestrian will decrease
  5043. 3:04:47exponentially okay
  5044. 3:04:49normally you can have a fatality even at
  5045. 3:04:5240 kilometers per hour you can have a
  5046. 3:04:53fatality so it's something that
  5047. 3:04:56the designer they should consider the
  5048. 3:04:58the population they they should consider
  5049. 3:05:01the areas that they are designing the
  5050. 3:05:02the focus the point of attraction they
  5051. 3:05:05should consider also if it's going to be
  5052. 3:05:07close to a school or a mosque or close
  5053. 3:05:09to a
  5054. 3:05:10hospital you need to have all these kind
  5055. 3:05:12of things and in there
  5056. 3:05:15the speed must be reduced as i told you
  5057. 3:05:18before
  5058. 3:05:19uh
  5059. 3:05:20having a crash is just
  5060. 3:05:22to have a liberation of the
  5061. 3:05:24of the kinetic energy and we cannot take
  5062. 3:05:27all the kinetic energy that is liberated
  5063. 3:05:29in a crash so this is why you need to
  5064. 3:05:32low because you got a car and the car is
  5065. 3:05:35going to take part of your kinetic
  5066. 3:05:36energy you are a pedestrian unless that
  5067. 3:05:38you are like me fati you know you cannot
  5068. 3:05:41take much kinetic energy okay i got a
  5069. 3:05:44good a good cushioning here it's not the
  5070. 3:05:46raptor that they used to say in here but
  5071. 3:05:48this is a good question but it's not
  5072. 3:05:50enough against a car okay
  5073. 3:05:52if i put myself maybe try to understand
  5074. 3:05:55bitter the question from the
  5075. 3:05:56participants
  5076. 3:05:58probably is there any uh different
  5077. 3:06:01treatments for protecting pedestrians as
  5078. 3:06:03part of a road safety audit when you
  5079. 3:06:04identify a problem uh on roads with high
  5080. 3:06:08speeds so example roads with a 50
  5081. 3:06:10kilometer per hour speed limit roads
  5082. 3:06:11with an 80 kilometer per hour speed
  5083. 3:06:13limits regardless of the impact uh speed
  5084. 3:06:16because the speed limit is the critical
  5085. 3:06:17issue here
  5086. 3:06:19in the in this case
  5087. 3:06:20for this kind of different types of of
  5088. 3:06:23of roads do you have a list of different
  5089. 3:06:24treatments that you usually propose as a
  5090. 3:06:26road safety auditor or you highlight of
  5091. 3:06:28course
  5092. 3:06:29of course we always explain about the
  5093. 3:06:32calming measures that you need to have
  5094. 3:06:33in there about reducing the lanes in
  5095. 3:06:35order the people they they start
  5096. 3:06:38you know going you reduce the width of
  5097. 3:06:40the lane they are going to count down
  5098. 3:06:42the the speed you put rumble strips also
  5099. 3:06:45in order the people they got uh you know
  5100. 3:06:47an indication that they are something is
  5101. 3:06:50happening in there so yes you got a lot
  5102. 3:06:51of measure but
  5103. 3:06:53this is not like
  5104. 3:06:54the recipe of doing a paella okay you
  5105. 3:06:58need to study everything independently
  5106. 3:07:00case by case and in that way you can you
  5107. 3:07:04can
  5108. 3:07:04assess better what is happening with the
  5109. 3:07:07potential in that area
  5110. 3:07:09great
  5111. 3:07:10thank you for the
  5112. 3:07:12very interesting presentation today and
  5113. 3:07:14also i would like to thank all
  5114. 3:07:16participants for the wonderful comments
  5115. 3:07:19and the
  5116. 3:07:20thoughts they are giving us through the
  5117. 3:07:22question and answers
  5118. 3:07:25place
  5119. 3:07:26and i think we'll have more and more
  5120. 3:07:28interesting practical information the
  5121. 3:07:30next session tomorrow where we will as
  5122. 3:07:32we see in the screen we will we will
  5123. 3:07:35address issues related to the safety
  5124. 3:07:37problems
  5125. 3:07:38and we take experiences also from
  5126. 3:07:40different safety problems in other
  5127. 3:07:41countries worldwide
  5128. 3:07:43uh to have an and a kind of
  5129. 3:07:45brainstorming about different safety
  5130. 3:07:48issues being faced in different types
  5131. 3:07:50and level of of roads
  5132. 3:07:53tomorrow the session will be a little
  5133. 3:07:55bit in different timings we will be from
  5134. 3:07:575 p.m to 7 p.m doha time
  5135. 3:08:00and again all the times we are talking
  5136. 3:08:02about our doha time so please convert it
  5137. 3:08:04to
  5138. 3:08:05relevant timing that you have in your
  5139. 3:08:07place and also regarding the link we are
  5140. 3:08:09using we will be using the same link you
  5141. 3:08:11used today you don't need any new link
  5142. 3:08:14to join the session the same link you
  5143. 3:08:16can always
  5144. 3:08:17join tomorrow and the day after tomorrow
  5145. 3:08:20uh the last
  5146. 3:08:22point i would like to address here is
  5147. 3:08:24that we are at qatar transportation and
  5148. 3:08:26traffic safety center
  5149. 3:08:28we are now uh
  5150. 3:08:29planning for a new international
  5151. 3:08:32conference will be in march 21 22
  5152. 3:08:37next year 2022 and it is the second
  5153. 3:08:40international traffic safety conference
  5154. 3:08:42that will be held under the patronage of
  5155. 3:08:44the prime minister of qatar and in
  5156. 3:08:46collaboration with many
  5157. 3:08:48international associations such as
  5158. 3:08:50uh irf iats uh and the
  5159. 3:08:55wctrs the world conference and
  5160. 3:08:57transportation society this conference
  5161. 3:09:00will have also channels for submission
  5162. 3:09:03of presentations and also full articles
  5163. 3:09:07journals academic journal scientific
  5164. 3:09:09journals
  5165. 3:09:10with opportunity for publication and
  5166. 3:09:12special issues
  5167. 3:09:13maybe tomorrow at the end of our session
  5168. 3:09:15also i will talk more about it and give
  5169. 3:09:17you some
  5170. 3:09:18more information uh but for today i
  5171. 3:09:21would like to thank you all i would like
  5172. 3:09:22to thank irf and the team there who
  5173. 3:09:25supported us a lot and then
  5174. 3:09:27and worked with us a lot in organizing
  5175. 3:09:29this event and also would like to thank
  5176. 3:09:31miguel uh who uh gave up his uh
  5177. 3:09:35weekend day today uh of taking a risk to
  5178. 3:09:38uh from his very busy schedule in azrael
  5179. 3:09:41with so many projects running and going
  5180. 3:09:43every day to give this presentation we
  5181. 3:09:46hope that
  5182. 3:09:48this call this this workshop had shaded
  5183. 3:09:51some information about safety audits and
  5184. 3:09:53again
  5185. 3:09:55many are asking about certificates this
  5186. 3:09:57is an uncertificate
  5187. 3:09:59it will call it an online webinar or
  5188. 3:10:01workshop however we will have soon and a
  5189. 3:10:04complete
  5190. 3:10:07training courses that are certified
  5191. 3:10:10and they are uh will be
  5192. 3:10:13mostly face to face in qatar
  5193. 3:10:15uh so if you are interested you have our
  5194. 3:10:18emails please drop us an email and once
  5195. 3:10:21this uh courses are announced and
  5196. 3:10:24prepared we will share all the
  5197. 3:10:25information for those who are interested
  5198. 3:10:27to join
  5199. 3:10:28uh and uh participate with us
  5200. 3:10:32so thank you all again thank you miguel
  5201. 3:10:34we would like to thank you again and
  5202. 3:10:36again and we're looking forward to see
  5203. 3:10:38you tomorrow at 5 p.m
  5204. 3:10:41no problem
  5205. 3:10:43see you all tomorrow bye for now
  5206. 3:10:45bye for now thank you have a wonderful
  5207. 3:10:47evening and thank you tomorrow take care
  5208. 3:10:50bye bye

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Online Course: Introduction to Road Safety Audits Day 1 by International Road Federation - IRF, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 30,289 words across 5,208 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.