YouTube2Text

On Socialism | "Communism, Socialism & Democratic Socialism…What’s the Difference?" –Dr. Paul Kengor — Transcript

by GroveCityCollege · 4,519 words · 729 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00foreign
  2. 0:09[Music]
  3. 0:33thank you
  4. 0:37thank you
  5. 0:41hi everybody welcome I'm Paul kengor
  6. 0:43Grove City College I've been teaching
  7. 0:45here since 1997. political science and a
  8. 0:48number of other courses including
  9. 0:50Marxism which is a course where I talk
  10. 0:52about a lot of these things that you're
  11. 0:54going to hear today and I'm also the
  12. 0:56senior academic fellow of the institute
  13. 0:58for Faith and freedom which prior to
  14. 1:00that was the center for vision of values
  15. 1:02faith and freedom.com is our website so
  16. 1:05good to be with you all and I'm glad the
  17. 1:06college is doing this series and I'm
  18. 1:08glad they asked me to do this
  19. 1:10presentation on communism socialism and
  20. 1:13Democratic socialism what's the
  21. 1:15difference it's a question that that a
  22. 1:18lot of people ask all the time and are
  23. 1:20wondering about more and more today
  24. 1:22especially as these ideas strangely
  25. 1:25become more popular in America unlike
  26. 1:29any time maybe ever before and certainly
  27. 1:32in the last maybe 70 80 years going back
  28. 1:35to the 1930s maybe so the Communist
  29. 1:38Manifesto published by Karl Marx and
  30. 1:41Friedrich Engel in 1848 it was the
  31. 1:44official programmatic statement of what
  32. 1:46was then the Communist League which was
  33. 1:49a group of about 40 to 50 people and
  34. 1:51Marx and Ingles were tasked by the
  35. 1:54league it's a group of almost entirely
  36. 1:57men German men you know white European
  37. 2:00males one female that was that was
  38. 2:03Marx's wife and they were they tasked
  39. 2:06Karl Marx and Friedrich Ingles with
  40. 2:08writing a Manifesto a programmatic
  41. 2:11statement of what we really believe in
  42. 2:14fact Ingalls said to Marx he said give a
  43. 2:17little bit more attention to to our
  44. 2:19title for our for our piece I think we
  45. 2:22should we should drop the idea of a
  46. 2:25communist confession of faith
  47. 2:27and just call it the manifesto so they
  48. 2:31they use this sort of religious-like
  49. 2:33language all the time which is perfect
  50. 2:35because for many Communists communism
  51. 2:38ended up becoming almost like a faith
  52. 2:41Raymond Aaron called it the Opium of the
  53. 2:44intellectuals
  54. 2:45Ronald Reagan said Marxism leninism that
  55. 2:48religion of theirs and the people in the
  56. 2:50party especially the people who left the
  57. 2:52party Arthur Kessler Darkness at noon
  58. 2:54the book The God That Failed all the
  59. 2:56time they would say that Marxism
  60. 2:58leninism communism was like a faith to
  61. 3:01the people who followed it which is
  62. 3:02ironic because they were all atheists or
  63. 3:05they're supposed to be atheists
  64. 3:07so they wrote in 1846 1848 The Communist
  65. 3:10Manifesto the opening words of the
  66. 3:13Communist Manifesto A specter is Honda
  67. 3:16Europe the Specter of Communism so they
  68. 3:19actually looked at they described
  69. 3:21communism as the Specter in fact the
  70. 3:24next line they said all of the ancient
  71. 3:26powers of Europe from Metternich to the
  72. 3:28Tsar to the Pope in fact the pope who
  73. 3:31was Pope Pius IX two years earlier in
  74. 3:331846 published Qui pluribus denouncing
  75. 3:37communism and and they said markson
  76. 3:39Engel said all of these ancient powers
  77. 3:41are Allied in this attempt to exorcise
  78. 3:45the Specter they described it as kind of
  79. 3:48like a demonic Specter that needed to be
  80. 3:52exercised purged that's how people saw
  81. 3:55it that's people from the very beginning
  82. 3:57saw communism as a very very dangerous
  83. 4:00ideology so we could spend a lot of time
  84. 4:02just on the manifesto I give the entire
  85. 4:04talk just on the manifesto but people
  86. 4:07will ask me often okay if you had to
  87. 4:09Define communism in a single sentence
  88. 4:11how would you do it so well that's easy
  89. 4:14marks and Ingles did it in a single
  90. 4:16sentence and as it says in the slide
  91. 4:18they said the entire communist Theory or
  92. 4:21program may be summed up in the single
  93. 4:23sentence abolition of private property
  94. 4:26four words abolition of private property
  95. 4:30and they double down on that in case
  96. 4:32anyone thinks well they didn't really
  97. 4:35think about eliminating private property
  98. 4:38I mean you can't do that that's gonna
  99. 4:40that's gonna cause
  100. 4:42it's going to cause Bloodshed I mean my
  101. 4:45daughter can tell you my 10 year old
  102. 4:47daughter could tell you if you try to
  103. 4:48take away people's private property
  104. 4:50you're going to need guns you're going
  105. 4:52to need gulags you're gonna you're gonna
  106. 4:54have a war on your hand you're gonna
  107. 4:55have to kill a lot of people I mean the
  108. 4:57the idea of private property a basic
  109. 4:59right a fundamental right some consider
  110. 5:01it a natural right back to the cave the
  111. 5:04courthouse judeo-christian law the idea
  112. 5:07The Ten Commandments Thou shalt not
  113. 5:09steal assumes that people have the right
  114. 5:12to property which which isn't to say
  115. 5:13that you can't share that property
  116. 5:15especially willingly but they wanted to
  117. 5:17actually abolish private property so
  118. 5:19they Double Down On It in the manifesto
  119. 5:22you are horrified and are intending to
  120. 5:24do away with private property precisely
  121. 5:26so that is just what we intend that is
  122. 5:30exactly what we intend to do
  123. 5:33they they understood Marx and Ingalls
  124. 5:36just how radical this was they described
  125. 5:39communism as representing quote the most
  126. 5:41radical rupture in traditional relations
  127. 5:44Marx acknowledged that his views on
  128. 5:47property stood contrary to the social
  129. 5:49and political order of things so for
  130. 5:51people wondering didn't they realize how
  131. 5:53radical this idea was to abolish private
  132. 5:55property yeah they got it they knew it
  133. 5:58they knew how radical it was I mean this
  134. 6:00isn't just like tinkering with tax rates
  135. 6:03or sharing a little bit of wealth and
  136. 6:06we'll talk about this later one of the
  137. 6:08attractions of socialism and even
  138. 6:09Marxism to a lot of younger people is
  139. 6:11they describe it as as sharing right
  140. 6:14people being kind to one another
  141. 6:17free stuff but but these guys said no
  142. 6:20communism represents the most radical
  143. 6:22rupture in traditional relations Marx
  144. 6:25said that communism seeks to do nothing
  145. 6:27less than abolish the present state of
  146. 6:31things abolish the present state of
  147. 6:35things
  148. 6:36again Not Mere tinkerers they did their
  149. 6:39most favorite word Marx and Ingles other
  150. 6:41than criticism was abolish abolish
  151. 6:44abolish abolish start over from the very
  152. 6:47beginning
  153. 6:48the clothes of the manifesto everybody
  154. 6:49remembers the line workers of the World
  155. 6:51Unite with Communists everywhere have a
  156. 6:53world to win they also said this and no
  157. 6:56one remembers this quote
  158. 6:58Communists everywhere support every
  159. 7:00revolutionary movement against the
  160. 7:03existing social and political order of
  161. 7:06things and remember that because
  162. 7:08oftentimes I'll get emails from people
  163. 7:10today who will talk about a particular
  164. 7:12protest that's going on a particular
  165. 7:14Rally or Riot that's going on on a cause
  166. 7:18it seems to have nothing to do with
  167. 7:19economics or redistribution of wealth
  168. 7:21and they'll say hey professor Kenmore
  169. 7:23why is this guy there waving this hammer
  170. 7:25and sickle flag what are the Communists
  171. 7:27doing there right I mean this is a rally
  172. 7:30for you know same-sex marriage why why
  173. 7:33are the Communists Marx didn't write
  174. 7:34about that stuff if it's a movement
  175. 7:36that's against the existing political
  176. 7:39order of things a revolutionary movement
  177. 7:42that's about abolishing the present
  178. 7:44state of things they'll be there because
  179. 7:47the idea of Marx and Ingles was to burn
  180. 7:49down the house and start over from from
  181. 7:52the very beginning
  182. 7:54they also said that Communists openly
  183. 7:58declare that their ends can be that
  184. 8:01their ends can be attained all right
  185. 8:03look at this very carefully
  186. 8:04their ends can be attained these are the
  187. 8:07Communists Marx and Ingles speaking for
  188. 8:08themselves only by the forcible
  189. 8:12overthrow of all existing social
  190. 8:15conditions forcible overthrow of all
  191. 8:20existing social conditions they're
  192. 8:23talking about changing just a few things
  193. 8:24I'm going to overthrow by force all
  194. 8:27existing social conditions which is why
  195. 8:30people in the day who actually read this
  196. 8:31stuff unlike a lot of people today who
  197. 8:33haven't read the stuff but still think
  198. 8:35that they probably believe it the people
  199. 8:37who read the stuff said this is the
  200. 8:38craziest thing we've ever heard this is
  201. 8:41beyond revolutionary this is really
  202. 8:43really really radical to which Marx and
  203. 8:45inglesworth said yes it is
  204. 8:48marks in a letter to his friend Arnold
  205. 8:50Rouge called for the ruthless criticism
  206. 8:53of all that exists the ruthless
  207. 8:56criticism of all that exists all
  208. 8:59everything abolish criticize
  209. 9:03my next slide
  210. 9:05there is a 10-point plan in The
  211. 9:08Communist Manifesto people will often
  212. 9:11say well yeah Manifesto is a pretty good
  213. 9:13book if you just read it it talks in
  214. 9:15real general terms about sharing the
  215. 9:17wealth you know right away anyone who
  216. 9:19said that has not actually read it and I
  217. 9:22I often hear too they don't get very
  218. 9:24many specifics in the manifesto they
  219. 9:26just talk broadly about ideas there's a
  220. 9:2910-point plan in The Communist Manifesto
  221. 9:31you have all kinds all kinds of
  222. 9:33specifics here are just a few and I
  223. 9:36could do all 25 minutes just on this I'm
  224. 9:39not I'm not going to because I would run
  225. 9:41out all of my time but again you could
  226. 9:43freeze this and look at it study it
  227. 9:46abolition of property and land and
  228. 9:47application of all rents land to public
  229. 9:50purposes look at point two a heavy
  230. 9:52Progressive or graduated income tax
  231. 9:55which is what America got permanently in
  232. 9:581913. we had to amend the Constitution
  233. 10:01the 16th Amendment in order to get a
  234. 10:04permanent graduated progressive income
  235. 10:06tax my favorite number three
  236. 10:09abolition of all right of inheritance
  237. 10:13abolition of all right of inheritance
  238. 10:17share this with the millennial at
  239. 10:21Starbucks drinking a grande skim latte
  240. 10:23with a little Karl Marx bumper sticker
  241. 10:25on her laptop ask her how would she like
  242. 10:27it if she couldn't inherit any of her
  243. 10:29parents money when they died if all of
  244. 10:32that all of it all right of it just went
  245. 10:35to the federal Collective to
  246. 10:38redistribute abolish all right of
  247. 10:40inheritance what's especially
  248. 10:41hypocritical about this is that Marx and
  249. 10:44Ingalls lived entirely off of their
  250. 10:48parents inheritance and when Marx was
  251. 10:50cut off by his mom and dad he sponged
  252. 10:53totally for the rest of his life off of
  253. 10:55Ingles Ingles was a sugar daddy Ingles
  254. 10:58subsidized Marx for the rest of his life
  255. 11:00off of his father's inheritance there's
  256. 11:04tremendous hypocrisies all through Marx
  257. 11:07and the life of Marx
  258. 11:09five centralization of credit in the
  259. 11:11hands of the state by means of a
  260. 11:13national bank with an exclusive Monopoly
  261. 11:16look at point six centralization of all
  262. 11:19communication and transport in the hands
  263. 11:22of the state all communication and
  264. 11:24transport by the way in communication in
  265. 11:251848 was what I mean it wasn't much
  266. 11:29today it would be phones internet
  267. 11:33texting uh you know all means of
  268. 11:37communication which is why too it drives
  269. 11:39me crazy when people are marxists today
  270. 11:43this is a book written for 1848.
  271. 11:46there's no way that you could do this
  272. 11:50this is written for a certain time in
  273. 11:52the industrial revolution this cannot
  274. 11:54possibly fit in any way our day it's
  275. 11:58just impossible it's it's completely
  276. 12:01anachronistic no way doesn't fit
  277. 12:05my favorite
  278. 12:070.9 gradual abolition think about this
  279. 12:11stop and think about this
  280. 12:13gradual abolition of all the distinction
  281. 12:17between Town and Country
  282. 12:21how are you going to do that by a more
  283. 12:24equitable distribution of the population
  284. 12:27over the country
  285. 12:29so they didn't want to just redistribute
  286. 12:31your stuff they wanted to redistribute
  287. 12:33you they wanted to more equitably
  288. 12:36distribute the population
  289. 12:39people human beings across the Town and
  290. 12:42Country so when you see the beginning of
  291. 12:44movies like The Killing Fields where
  292. 12:46everybody's coming out of the capital of
  293. 12:47Phnom Penh Cambodia being emptied out
  294. 12:50into the countryside right they are they
  295. 12:52are redistributing people out into the
  296. 12:55countryside Mal did it right
  297. 12:58collectivists do this they don't want to
  298. 13:00just redistribute your stuff but you but
  299. 13:03you I would think a liberal would think
  300. 13:06that's really bad
  301. 13:08right point 10
  302. 13:11didn't know this was in there right free
  303. 13:13education for all children in public
  304. 13:15schools
  305. 13:17they wanted to ban private education
  306. 13:19religious education and put all people
  307. 13:22in government schools the Bolsheviks and
  308. 13:24others did that immediately
  309. 13:27as marks and Ingles say in the preface
  310. 13:29to these 10 points of course in the
  311. 13:32beginning this cannot be affected except
  312. 13:33by a means of despotic inroads in other
  313. 13:36words you're going to need tyranny
  314. 13:39despotism to be able to do this there
  315. 13:41are people reading the ten points
  316. 13:43thinking dude there's no way you can do
  317. 13:45this without using despotism mark
  318. 13:47sningles would have said correct
  319. 13:49that's that's exactly right that's
  320. 13:52exactly right so this idea the manifesto
  321. 13:55is just about being kind and sharing
  322. 13:57things nonsense absolute ignorance
  323. 14:03Mark's hated religion
  324. 14:05uh I did a book called The Devil and
  325. 14:07Karl Marx where I go through all of
  326. 14:09Marx's thinking on religion the famous
  327. 14:11line of the opiate of the masses opium
  328. 14:14of the masses that's often people will
  329. 14:16say well Marx is just talking there
  330. 14:18about how people kind of lean on
  331. 14:20religion as a sort of crutch and I can
  332. 14:22understand that you know and that's true
  333. 14:24people do that read the whole essay all
  334. 14:27right here's just one section of it
  335. 14:29the money quote with the Opium of the
  336. 14:31people Mark said religion is the sigh of
  337. 14:34the oppressed creature the heart of a
  338. 14:37heartless world the soul of soulless
  339. 14:41conditions it is the Opium of the people
  340. 14:45Marxism like religion
  341. 14:47it was also very anti-Semitic
  342. 14:49strict evolutionists
  343. 14:52and and also too and I could give an
  344. 14:54entirely separate presentation on this a
  345. 14:56racist in fact you go to our website for
  346. 14:59The Institute for Faith and freedom and
  347. 15:00look at the peace that I did on marks on
  348. 15:03Christianity uh Christianity Judaism and
  349. 15:07and
  350. 15:08um and religion did I say that right and
  351. 15:10race and race you'll be able to find it
  352. 15:13it was my name on our website
  353. 15:15Mark said communism begins where atheism
  354. 15:17begins Lenin who was Marx's leading
  355. 15:20disciple it's often called Marxism
  356. 15:22leninism we'll get to him in a minute
  357. 15:24said all worship of a Divinity is a
  358. 15:27necrophilia
  359. 15:30there is nothing more abominable than
  360. 15:32religion Lenin said religion is a kind
  361. 15:35of medieval mildew a sort of spiritual
  362. 15:39booze booze
  363. 15:42in addition to wanting to abolish
  364. 15:44religion
  365. 15:45my next slide here they wanted to
  366. 15:47abolish the family did you know that
  367. 15:49this is in the manifesto
  368. 15:51abolition of the family
  369. 15:53exclamation mark even the most radical
  370. 15:56flare up at this Infamous proposal of
  371. 15:58the Communists it was already Infamous
  372. 16:00in 1848 in fact Pope Pius IX warned
  373. 16:04about it in 1846 the Communists were
  374. 16:06already known for their attacks on the
  375. 16:09family all right add that to the list of
  376. 16:11different things to abolish Marx wrote
  377. 16:14to Ingles who had no children Marx had
  378. 16:16several children blessed is he who has
  379. 16:19no family
  380. 16:21two of Marx's daughters committed
  381. 16:22suicide and suicide pacts with their
  382. 16:24husbands
  383. 16:25it's the only figure I know of in
  384. 16:27history who had two daughters who
  385. 16:29committed suicide and suicide pacts with
  386. 16:32with their husbands
  387. 16:34Marx and Ingles in the manifesto oh
  388. 16:36you're right Manifesto is a pretty good
  389. 16:38book talks about sharing the wealth
  390. 16:39right it also it says this do you charge
  391. 16:43us with wanting to stop the exploitation
  392. 16:44of children by their parents but what
  393. 16:47you think they would say here oh no no
  394. 16:49no we don't want to do that no they say
  395. 16:51to this crime we plead guilty
  396. 16:54but you will say we destroyed the most
  397. 16:56hallowed of relations when we replace
  398. 16:59home education by social they they
  399. 17:02blasted what they call the disgusting
  400. 17:05Bourgeois clap trap about the family and
  401. 17:08education the hallowed correlation of
  402. 17:10parent and child
  403. 17:12good news for you folks the relationship
  404. 17:15between parent and child is hallowed
  405. 17:18and these guys have no right to stop it
  406. 17:23so these ideas are put in place who are
  407. 17:26these three
  408. 17:28we got Stalin Lenin and Trotsky
  409. 17:32October 1917 the Bolshevik Revolution
  410. 17:35they eventually seized control in a coup
  411. 17:38that leads to a Russian Civil War
  412. 17:40Bolsheviks and mensheviks seven million
  413. 17:43men women and children died in that
  414. 17:45Civil War that was after Russia lost
  415. 17:47more people in World War One than any
  416. 17:49other country
  417. 17:51Russia would never be the same
  418. 17:54but it's not just Russia communism
  419. 17:57sought to be Global Mark said in the end
  420. 18:01of the Communist Manifesto Marx and
  421. 18:03Ingles the Communists have a world to
  422. 18:05win a world to win workers of the World
  423. 18:09Unite this had to be a worldwide
  424. 18:12Revolution which is what so bothered so
  425. 18:15many American presidents including
  426. 18:18progressives like Woodrow Wilson
  427. 18:20who um though though he was the
  428. 18:22progressives Progressive was intensely
  429. 18:24anti-communist he read their stuff and
  430. 18:27he would tell his fellow progressives
  431. 18:28you don't go here this these guys are
  432. 18:32really bad Wilson was a was a was a
  433. 18:35devout five-point calvinist he also saw
  434. 18:38how bad these guys were toward toward
  435. 18:40religion Marx in 1850 at the Communist
  436. 18:43League speech our task is to make the
  437. 18:46revolution permanent and all the leading
  438. 18:48countries in the world
  439. 18:50Lenin our Victory will be a lasting
  440. 18:52Victory only when our undertaking will
  441. 18:55conquer the whole world
  442. 18:58because we launched it exclusively
  443. 19:00counting on World Revolution
  444. 19:03and look at this this is when Lenin in
  445. 19:06March 1919 launched the Soviet common
  446. 19:09turn the Communist International more on
  447. 19:12that in a second of my next slide he
  448. 19:14said the existence of the Soviet
  449. 19:16Republic side by side with the Imperial
  450. 19:18Estates is unthinkable
  451. 19:20in the end either one or the other Will
  452. 19:23Conquer and before this result a series
  453. 19:26of horrible conflicts between the Soviet
  454. 19:29Republic and the Bourgeois States is
  455. 19:32unavoidable
  456. 19:33this was going to be next slide a World
  457. 19:37Revolution
  458. 19:39orchestrated by the common turn the
  459. 19:41Communist International out of Moscow
  460. 19:43which was going to direct all the
  461. 19:45different communist parties in the world
  462. 19:47America several months later in
  463. 19:49September 1919 formed in Chicago the
  464. 19:54American Communist Party
  465. 19:57there's some quotes on that in this
  466. 19:59slide I'm going to flip to the next
  467. 20:01slide as well
  468. 20:02here are some quotes from members of
  469. 20:04Communist Party USA in the United States
  470. 20:07what they committed themselves to freeze
  471. 20:11the screen and read through those quotes
  472. 20:13as Langston you said put one more s in
  473. 20:16the USA to make it the USSA when we take
  474. 20:20over
  475. 20:21and before we exit communism
  476. 20:24that's the Black Book of Communism
  477. 20:26published by Harvard University press
  478. 20:28the seminal book on the subject
  479. 20:30estimated the Communist regimes in the
  480. 20:3320th century killed about 100 million
  481. 20:35people
  482. 20:37here's an added slide on some additional
  483. 20:40numbers on how many people the
  484. 20:43Communists killed it's easily over 100
  485. 20:45million it's probably closer to 140
  486. 20:48million and as you can see there I give
  487. 20:50actual numbers and at the end of the
  488. 20:52slide I'll put up four of my books which
  489. 20:54you could go to as added references for
  490. 20:57some of the documentation on this
  491. 20:59all right here's what's so troubling
  492. 21:01today
  493. 21:02we have an America many modern
  494. 21:04Millennials who support communism and
  495. 21:07socialism this young man a West Point
  496. 21:10Cadet is wearing a picture of Che
  497. 21:12Guevara under his Cadet uniform Che who
  498. 21:15called America the great enemy of
  499. 21:17mankind
  500. 21:19and communism is uh here's another slide
  501. 21:22with some data
  502. 21:24you can see here with these polling
  503. 21:26numbers a 2014 reason group survey found
  504. 21:30that 53 of 18 to 29 year olds view
  505. 21:33socialism favorably and Gallup found
  506. 21:36that 69 percent of Millennials said
  507. 21:38they'd be willing to vote for a
  508. 21:40socialist for president
  509. 21:41and millions did so in the person of
  510. 21:44Bernie Sanders I'll give some data on
  511. 21:46that in a minute
  512. 21:47okay so what's socialism how is that
  513. 21:51different
  514. 21:54the universally accepted definition of
  515. 21:56socialism is this common ownership of
  516. 21:59the means of production now if you ask
  517. 22:0210 different socialists today for a
  518. 22:04definition of socialism you're probably
  519. 22:05going to get 10 different answers all
  520. 22:07right but here's what it really means
  521. 22:09and is what it what it's supposed to
  522. 22:10mean in fact if you Google it one of the
  523. 22:12first thing that pops up is a
  524. 22:13Merriam-Webster definition
  525. 22:15socialism States Merriam-Webster is
  526. 22:18government ownership of the means of
  527. 22:20production
  528. 22:22according to Marxist theory socialism is
  529. 22:25the final transitionary step toward
  530. 22:28communism so communism would progress
  531. 22:30through various stages from feudalism to
  532. 22:33capitalism to socialism to Communism and
  533. 22:36during that process all of these
  534. 22:38institutions property democracy family
  535. 22:41religion the state even money would
  536. 22:44wither away but socialism would be the
  537. 22:47final transitionary step to Communism it
  538. 22:50was the Union of Soviet Socialist
  539. 22:52republics before the Bolsheviks were the
  540. 22:54Bolsheviks they were the Russian Social
  541. 22:56Democratic labor party
  542. 22:59Vladimir Lenin
  543. 23:02on the distinction between socialism and
  544. 23:05communism
  545. 23:06said Lennon this brings us to the
  546. 23:08question of the scientific distinction
  547. 23:09between socialism and communism wow what
  548. 23:12is it
  549. 23:13he said what is usually called socialism
  550. 23:15was termed by Marx the first or lower
  551. 23:18phase of a communist Society
  552. 23:20and so far as the means of production
  553. 23:22becomes common property the word
  554. 23:25communism is also applicable here
  555. 23:27providing that we do not forget that
  556. 23:29this is not complete communism so
  557. 23:32socialism again leads into communism
  558. 23:36Lennon said in his 1920s speech to the
  559. 23:39Russian young communist League why do we
  560. 23:42call ourselves Communists what is
  561. 23:44Communists communism is a Latin word
  562. 23:47right which means that the people come
  563. 23:51the land the factories are owned and the
  564. 23:53people work in common that is communism
  565. 23:55communism is common ownership of the
  566. 23:58means of production which is what
  567. 24:00socialism is too so socialism is just
  568. 24:04the final transitionary step to getting
  569. 24:06to full communism
  570. 24:08Communists also supported democracy
  571. 24:12look carefully at this
  572. 24:14Lenin who supported democracy really
  573. 24:18democracy means equality
  574. 24:22democracy is of enormous importance to
  575. 24:24the working class in a struggle against
  576. 24:26the capitalists but democracy is only
  577. 24:28one of the stages on the road from
  578. 24:31feudalism to capitalism and from
  579. 24:33capitalism to Communism Communist Party
  580. 24:36USA called it economic democracy so for
  581. 24:40them democracy meant equality equality
  582. 24:45Ingles spoke on the value of democracy
  583. 24:49same kind of thing I'll let you pause
  584. 24:52and read that
  585. 24:55here are two famous right Wingers
  586. 24:59Mussolini and Hitler were both
  587. 25:01socialists these were big government
  588. 25:03guys and Mussolini was not only a
  589. 25:06socialist but a Marxist
  590. 25:10another slide here's a definition of
  591. 25:13socialism by today's world Socialist
  592. 25:16Party note what it says in bold
  593. 25:19we call this common ownership but other
  594. 25:22terms we regard as synonymous are
  595. 25:25communism and socialism they consider
  596. 25:28communism and socialism synonymous
  597. 25:32today there's something called 21st
  598. 25:35century socialism
  599. 25:3721st century socialism this is the
  600. 25:39Wikipedia definition there's Hugo Chavez
  601. 25:42next to his successor Maduro and
  602. 25:45Venezuela
  603. 25:46socialism of the 20th century has
  604. 25:48Democratic Socialist elements they
  605. 25:51concede but primarily resembles Marxist
  606. 25:54revisionism
  607. 25:56all right here we are in America today
  608. 25:5921st century socialism Bernie Sanders
  609. 26:02and Alexandria ocasio-cortez they're the
  610. 26:06leading advocates
  611. 26:08Bernie is a lifetime socialist he was an
  612. 26:10independent before he became a Democrat
  613. 26:12to run for the Democratic party's
  614. 26:14presidential domination in 1980 and 84
  615. 26:17he was a formal presidential elector to
  616. 26:21the trotskyist Socialist Workers Party
  617. 26:23so Democrats and Republicans were
  618. 26:25deciding to vote for Carter or Reagan
  619. 26:27Reagan armandale Bernie was with the
  620. 26:30Trotsky Socialist Workers Party that
  621. 26:32there he is in the bottom in his
  622. 26:34honeymoon of the Soviet Union in 1988.
  623. 26:37look at the quote in bold
  624. 26:39democracy says Bernie
  625. 26:42means public ownership of the means of
  626. 26:46production
  627. 26:47that we just learned no no no no no no
  628. 26:49that's the definition of socialism isn't
  629. 26:51it yes
  630. 26:53and he's defining democracy in the same
  631. 26:55way he's defining socialism as public
  632. 26:58ownership of the means of production
  633. 26:59that guy came in second in 2016 and 2020
  634. 27:03in the Democratic Party primary
  635. 27:07here's Bernie today he told NPR but he
  636. 27:10talks about the Democratic socialism he
  637. 27:13means I want a vibrant democracy
  638. 27:18the leading Democratic Socialist group
  639. 27:20in America today is the Democratic
  640. 27:23socialists of America that's their
  641. 27:25website
  642. 27:26check it out
  643. 27:28and as you can see here they call
  644. 27:29themselves the leading largest socialist
  645. 27:33organization in the United States
  646. 27:37these are the leading members of the DSA
  647. 27:40who are now elected to congress
  648. 27:42Alexandria ocasio-cortez Rashida Talib
  649. 27:45and the olhan Omar today the Democratic
  650. 27:49socialists of America which was begun in
  651. 27:501982 by Michael Harrington and was down
  652. 27:53to like 5 000 members by the end of the
  653. 27:56Cold War is now at almost 95 000 members
  654. 27:59or what they call comrades that number
  655. 28:02is double from 2016-2017 when they were
  656. 28:06at forty thousand members
  657. 28:08they have doubled in just the last five
  658. 28:10years and they have chapters on hundreds
  659. 28:12of campuses Democratic National
  660. 28:14committee chairman Tom Perez says that
  661. 28:17Alexandria ocasio-cortez represents the
  662. 28:20future of our party
  663. 28:23chenk igar and the Justice Democrats
  664. 28:26worked with the DSA they've had a split
  665. 28:28in recent years that's a more
  666. 28:30complicated issue I've written on it in
  667. 28:31articles for the American spectator
  668. 28:33but their goal is to primary vulnerable
  669. 28:37mainstream Democrats in the Democratic
  670. 28:40primary with Democratic socialists of
  671. 28:42America candidates like Alexandria
  672. 28:45ocasio-cortez
  673. 28:46that's how they're winning these seats
  674. 28:49and in the 2022 election they won a
  675. 28:52bunch of them again in fact here in my
  676. 28:55area in Pittsburgh summer Lee who had
  677. 28:57been a member of the DSA got elected by
  678. 29:00again running in a safe Democratic
  679. 29:02District against a mainstream Democrat
  680. 29:04that's how they're winning they're not
  681. 29:06running against Republicans in
  682. 29:07conservative districts they're running
  683. 29:09against Democrats in traditional
  684. 29:10districts
  685. 29:12all right wrapping up
  686. 29:14how to respond to this
  687. 29:16know this kind of information no more
  688. 29:19than the other side does if you ask 10
  689. 29:21out of 10 socialists for a definition of
  690. 29:24socialism you're going to get 10
  691. 29:26different answers ditto for 10
  692. 29:28Democratic socialists and to be fair if
  693. 29:30you ask 10 out of 10
  694. 29:32conservatives her definition of
  695. 29:34conservatism you're probably going to
  696. 29:36get 10 different definitions there too
  697. 29:37but understand what they're all their
  698. 29:41ideology really is educate educate
  699. 29:44educate and as these two kids who are
  700. 29:46wearing these shirts that's not a Che
  701. 29:48Guevara t-shirt like you think it is it
  702. 29:50says Communism killed a hundred million
  703. 29:52people and all I got was this crappy
  704. 29:54t-shirt
  705. 29:55so have fun be a cheerful warrior in
  706. 29:59arguing against these ideas
  707. 30:01and one more slide here a little
  708. 30:03Shameless capitalist plug these are some
  709. 30:06of my books on the subject so if you're
  710. 30:08wondering where I've gotten a lot of
  711. 30:09this information where you can get it
  712. 30:11documented I footnote it in these
  713. 30:13different books completely incorrect
  714. 30:15guide to Communism devil Karl Marx the
  715. 30:17Communist the pope and the president
  716. 30:18these are just some of the books that
  717. 30:21I've written
  718. 30:22so the time has flown by here it's been
  719. 30:2430 minutes I have to wrap up sorry if I
  720. 30:27went through these slides quickly but I
  721. 30:29know in this presentation that you can
  722. 30:31freeze them you can pause them you can
  723. 30:32think about it and if you have any
  724. 30:34questions about any of this feel to free
  725. 30:36to email me at my college address
  726. 30:38kengorpg gcc.edu and I thank you very
  727. 30:43much for tuning in and listening thanks
  728. 30:44God bless
  729. 30:47foreign

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of On Socialism | "Communism, Socialism & Democratic Socialism…What’s the Difference?" –Dr. Paul Kengor by GroveCityCollege, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,519 words across 729 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.