YouTube2Text

Olivia Rodrigo is so much smarter than you think: serena joy analysis — Transcript

by Kristina Reinis · 4,355 words · 639 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hi friends, welcome to my new yet kind
  2. 0:02of old YouTube channel and I'm so
  3. 0:04excited to be talking to you guys in my
  4. 0:06beautiful little studio. My name is
  5. 0:08Kristina, I'm an artist and a public
  6. 0:09scholar and I study conservative
  7. 0:11Christian women in the United States. So
  8. 0:13when Olivia Rodrigo's Serena Joy dropped
  9. 0:15last week, let me tell you I was sitting
  10. 0:17on the train having a nice calm peaceful
  11. 0:19time and I got a text from a very dear
  12. 0:21friend of mine asking if I had listened
  13. 0:23to it in the moment I clicked play, I
  14. 0:24genuinely looked insane. I was truly
  15. 0:27gagged because we know that Olivia
  16. 0:29Rodrigo is this feminist activist
  17. 0:31especially with the Daisy Chain Fields
  18. 0:33Festival. I mean she's done really done
  19. 0:34some incredible work. But let me explain
  20. 0:36to you just like how well she did her
  21. 0:38homework on this song. She goes beyond
  22. 0:40just making a passive reference to The
  23. 0:42Handmaid's Tale and provides a biting
  24. 0:44critique of conservative Christian women
  25. 0:46and their complex relationship with
  26. 0:48enforcing the patriarchy. And that's why
  27. 0:50the moment I heard it, I was just
  28. 0:52writing frantically on my phone because
  29. 0:54I knew that this song deserved a
  30. 0:56religion and gender analysis. This
  31. 0:58research really runs deep for me. I grew
  32. 1:01up evangelical in Texas and then I went
  33. 1:03to go get my masters studying it at
  34. 1:05Harvard and now I talk about it a lot
  35. 1:07online. The reason I can claim so
  36. 1:09confidently that this song is about
  37. 1:10conservative Christian women is because
  38. 1:12Olivia doesn't really leave any room for
  39. 1:14any misunderstanding by titling it
  40. 1:16Serena Joy. She hones in on their
  41. 1:18hypocritical belief that the oppressive
  42. 1:20systems that they uphold will somehow
  43. 1:22spare them. So in many ways Serena Joy
  44. 1:25is really just as much of a warning as
  45. 1:27it is a protest song especially with the
  46. 1:29ominous refrain of if they do it to
  47. 1:31them, they'll do it to you. And we
  48. 1:33really can't talk about anything else
  49. 1:35till we talk about everything that comes
  50. 1:37with that title choice. So welcome to
  51. 1:39the first section of this video which I
  52. 1:40like to call only Olivia Rodrigo can
  53. 1:43reference Serena Joy and not piss me
  54. 1:45off. Now I'm going to get into my
  55. 1:46personal beef with the overuse of this
  56. 1:48term online at the end of this video but
  57. 1:49that's like as a little treat, a little
  58. 1:51something to look forward to. But if you
  59. 1:52don't know who I'm talking about, Serena
  60. 1:54Joy is is fictional character from
  61. 1:56Margaret Atwood's 1985 dystopian novel
  62. 1:58The Handmaid's Tale. In the novel,
  63. 2:00Serena Joy is this prominent
  64. 2:01conservative activist and public speaker
  65. 2:03who promotes traditional values and was
  66. 2:06so influential that she helped create
  67. 2:08the patriarchal authoritarian state of
  68. 2:09Gilead that ended up replacing the
  69. 2:11United States. Super fun, right? Yeah.
  70. 2:14Now, over the past year or so or maybe
  71. 2:16longer, I just feel like I've seen it a
  72. 2:17lot in Trump's second term. Serena Joy
  73. 2:20has evolved in this type of shorthand
  74. 2:22that people use to identify a very
  75. 2:24specific type of conservative Christian
  76. 2:26woman. Think Erica Kirk, Candace Owens,
  77. 2:28Savannah Stone, Caroline Levitt, Nara
  78. 2:30Smith, Ballerina Farm, etc., etc. The
  79. 2:31list goes on. When these women appear
  80. 2:33online, especially Erica Kirk, it is
  81. 2:36rare that you won't see a comment that's
  82. 2:37like, "OMG, she's trying to be Serena
  83. 2:39Joy in real life." And that is what I
  84. 2:41believe Olivia Rodrigo was tapping into
  85. 2:43by choosing this title. Like the
  86. 2:45character, these accused Serena wannabes
  87. 2:47are usually public figures. They're
  88. 2:49politicians or they're influencers or
  89. 2:52podcasters, and they get their
  90. 2:53influence, power, and oftentimes a lot
  91. 2:56of money by promoting conservative
  92. 2:58Christian gender ideology. Female
  93. 3:00submission, male headship, domesticity,
  94. 3:03sexual purity, aka true womanhood
  95. 3:06forever. If you see my other videos,
  96. 3:08this archetype is interchangeable with
  97. 3:10the tradwife girlboss. Now, these Serena
  98. 3:12Joys may feel recent, but they've
  99. 3:14actually been around since like the 18th
  100. 3:16century. It is also a very specific
  101. 3:18expression of conservative Christian
  102. 3:20womanhood. I am going to fall out of
  103. 3:22this chair. Despite what some would feel
  104. 3:24a lot more comfortable believing,
  105. 3:25conservative Christian womanhood in the
  106. 3:26United States is a very multivalent and
  107. 3:29complicated identity. Its expression
  108. 3:31changes depending on denomination, race,
  109. 3:33class, and generation. In other terms,
  110. 3:35Serena Joy is not referring to some
  111. 3:38stay-at-home mom in Tulsa, Oklahoma who
  112. 3:40is terrorizing her school board, even
  113. 3:42though someone should really sit down
  114. 3:43with her and have a conversation cuz
  115. 3:44she's just as complicit. But I digress.
  116. 3:46These are women who, in a very cruel
  117. 3:48irony, are profiting off of these
  118. 3:50massive public platforms that are built
  119. 3:53off of promoting conservative Christian
  120. 3:55rigid gender ideology. So, Serena Joy
  121. 3:58gives us that juicy specificity. What's
  122. 4:00also so great about Olivia's choice in
  123. 4:03this title is that Serena Joy as a
  124. 4:05character is a cultural reference that
  125. 4:06spans across generations of women. Gen Z
  126. 4:09was introduced to Handmaid's Tale
  127. 4:10through the 2010s Hulu show of the same
  128. 4:12name or its current spin-off, The
  129. 4:14Testaments. Millennials will remember
  130. 4:15the Handmaid protest from the early in
  131. 4:17the Trump administration and throughout
  132. 4:19it, while Gen X and Boomers probably
  133. 4:21read the book itself in school. This
  134. 4:22song title really does so much to set up
  135. 4:25Olivia's critique. Provides a
  136. 4:26specificity that allows for some nuance,
  137. 4:29while also tapping into this recent
  138. 4:30internet phenomenon that speaks to the
  139. 4:32current moment, while still using a
  140. 4:34cultural reference that spans across
  141. 4:36generations. I mean like that is really
  142. 4:38like really hard to do in one title.
  143. 4:41What's really incredible to me was how
  144. 4:43Rodrigo packaged the message itself. By
  145. 4:46that is the actual sound of the track,
  146. 4:48especially the production, which was
  147. 4:50done in collaboration with 2000s indie
  148. 4:52boy Dan Nigro. I'll spend some time
  149. 4:53breaking down how Serena Joy's like
  150. 4:55pacing, backtrack, vocal effects really
  151. 4:58emulates the tone and ethos of the
  152. 5:00conservative Christian women and the
  153. 5:02Serena Joys, which is a soft militancy.
  154. 5:05Now, not a lot of scholars recognize the
  155. 5:08militancy that is behind the
  156. 5:09conservative Christian women's movement,
  157. 5:11which is crazy to me because it is all
  158. 5:13that I think about. But basically what I
  159. 5:15mean by a soft militancy is invoking
  160. 5:17rhetoric of violence, fear, and anger,
  161. 5:20but wrapping it up in this like feminine
  162. 5:22softness under the comforting visage of
  163. 5:24American domesticity and female
  164. 5:26submission. Now, this is an imperfect
  165. 5:28term that I came up with, but to really
  166. 5:30understand it, all you have to do is get
  167. 5:31this meme Erica Kirk. Like this this is
  168. 5:35the soft militancy I'm talking about.
  169. 5:37It's actually kind of incredible to how
  170. 5:39well this sums up this concept. And it's
  171. 5:41probably because Erica Kirk arguably
  172. 5:43embodies this ethos the best. I think
  173. 5:46the only person who could really tie
  174. 5:47with her is Candace Owens. But Erica
  175. 5:49Kirk cries, she she smiles, she wears
  176. 5:53sequins, but she also says things like,
  177. 5:56"If you thought my husband's mission,
  178. 5:58Charlie Kirk, was powerful before, you
  179. 6:00have no idea what you just have
  180. 6:01unleashed across this country and this
  181. 6:04world. The cries of this widow will echo
  182. 6:06around the world like a battle cry." So,
  183. 6:08yeah, F I for me, "Serena Joy" as a song
  184. 6:11takes on both this softness and this
  185. 6:14militancy, but it turns it on its head
  186. 6:16and it directs it towards them. If you
  187. 6:18listen to it, I understand that
  188. 6:20technically it's this like post-punk
  189. 6:22'80s vibe or whatever, but like for me,
  190. 6:25when I heard the da da da da da da,
  191. 6:26okay, you know what? I'm not a musician
  192. 6:28and I can't play for copyright, so you
  193. 6:30just have to listen to it and know what
  194. 6:31I'm talking about. It's like the main
  195. 6:33riff. But what that made me think of is
  196. 6:36like the beat behind like old-timey
  197. 6:38detective music. And I had a very
  198. 6:40specific song in mind and it turns out
  199. 6:42it has a name. It's the Peter Gunn theme
  200. 6:44song, if you want to listen to it. But
  201. 6:46if you listen to kind of like 15 seconds
  202. 6:48in with that main bassline, if you like
  203. 6:50speed it up, it's a very similar sound.
  204. 6:52Because as you listen to "Serena Joy",
  205. 6:54this like anxiety and energy builds up
  206. 6:56almost like it's feeling like someone
  207. 6:58someone's behind your corner and like
  208. 6:59you got to
  209. 7:00you got to be on the lookout. Um um
  210. 7:02Erica, please, not right now. But the
  211. 7:04whole time Olivia's voice stays really
  212. 7:07soft and kind of like muffled and
  213. 7:09suppressed. And I'm going to level with
  214. 7:10you guys, I'm a fan, but I'm not an
  215. 7:12expert on Olivia Rodrigo's entire
  216. 7:13discography, but what I do know is that
  217. 7:16she is a fan of screaming. "Serena Joy"
  218. 7:18being a type of protest song, I feel
  219. 7:20like this would have been a really easy
  220. 7:21choice to make, but I'm so happy that
  221. 7:23she didn't because it just makes it so
  222. 7:25perfect. It really allowed her to like
  223. 7:28mirror that type of soft militancy that
  224. 7:31I think
  225. 7:33Let me write a book.
  226. 7:35That really defines this movement. And
  227. 7:37it kind of mirrors that like soft and
  228. 7:39sweet submissiveness that like covers
  229. 7:41the voice to hide the much more sinister
  230. 7:44message underneath. Like I grew up in
  231. 7:46the South and if you were in trouble
  232. 7:47with a woman at the church, she would
  233. 7:49not yell at you. She would talk really
  234. 7:51calmly and and smile really sweetly and
  235. 7:53it was it was it was [ __ ] terrifying.
  236. 7:56So even in the moments where she raises
  237. 7:57her voice, it's still muffled and
  238. 7:59suppressed. And I would argue that is
  239. 8:00exactly what Olivia is doing because at
  240. 8:02the most ominous part of the song of
  241. 8:04like if they'll do it to them, they'll
  242. 8:05do it to you, she gets even quieter.
  243. 8:07Like the verses ramp up in energy and
  244. 8:10like yelling and then she gets even
  245. 8:12quieter telling them to come in and
  246. 8:14whisper in their ear to tell them about
  247. 8:15their demise. So not only is the
  248. 8:17patriarchy coming for the Serena Joys,
  249. 8:19Olivia is as well. And she makes that
  250. 8:22really clear with the line that will
  251. 8:23never submit, will never give up. And
  252. 8:25whether she knew it or not, she pulled
  253. 8:26from their playbook, flipped it on their
  254. 8:28head, and it was just it was just
  255. 8:30perfect. Now let me remind you that we
  256. 8:31haven't even really talked about the
  257. 8:33lyrics yet, but that's exciting cuz
  258. 8:34we've already learned so much. And now
  259. 8:37we're really getting to work, so I'm
  260. 8:38going to just take a moment, I'm going
  261. 8:39to roll my sleeves.
  262. 8:41They're not They're not really rolling
  263. 8:43up.
  264. 8:44Because I need [clears throat] to tell
  265. 8:45you how well Olivia executed this song.
  266. 8:47So to orient ourselves, we've got this
  267. 8:49little suspenseful vibe. We have the
  268. 8:51Serena Joy title that does so much
  269. 8:53contextual work. And now we're at the
  270. 8:54start of the song which opens with,
  271. 8:56"Yeah, it's all for the cause, for the
  272. 8:58good of us all." And in hearing this
  273. 8:59opening line, I was immediately thrilled
  274. 9:01cuz Olivia identifies the most important
  275. 9:03thing to understanding in conservative
  276. 9:04Christian women in the United States.
  277. 9:06They belong to a defined belief system
  278. 9:09and worldview. I know, it's crazy.
  279. 9:12Religion, man. It matters. Who would
  280. 9:14have guessed? But in all seriousness, it
  281. 9:16is shocking how many people dismiss the
  282. 9:19role of religion in understanding this
  283. 9:22demographic. And to be fair, I do get
  284. 9:24it. I think the reason people are so
  285. 9:25quick to dismiss its importance is
  286. 9:27because of some of the blatant hypocrisy
  287. 9:30that happens, especially with the Serena
  288. 9:31Joys. And this was a wall that I ran
  289. 9:33into a lot with my yesteryear video
  290. 9:35essay series. If they tell a woman to
  291. 9:37stay home and to submit, but they're
  292. 9:38literally doing the opposite thing, then
  293. 9:40clearly it's just a grift and they don't
  294. 9:42believe anything. So then religion
  295. 9:44doesn't really matter in this whole
  296. 9:45conversation. But as Olivia beautifully
  297. 9:47points out with the opening lines, the
  298. 9:48religion of it all really does matter.
  299. 9:50And that's because the very belief
  300. 9:52system they critique also gives them the
  301. 9:54language to justify their hypocrisy. Now
  302. 9:58I know that may sound counterintuitive
  303. 9:59unless you grew up evangelical as well.
  304. 10:01Stay with me here because I promise it's
  305. 10:03important and it'll help you fully
  306. 10:05appreciate everything Olivia is doing
  307. 10:06with this song. Central to this
  308. 10:08conservative Christian gender ideology
  309. 10:09in the US, especially in evangelicalism,
  310. 10:12but really across denominations, is this
  311. 10:14idealization of female submission and
  312. 10:17male headship. And FYI, headship is just
  313. 10:19like an evangelical way of saying that
  314. 10:21men are in these natural born leaders
  315. 10:22ordained by God.
  316. 10:24So if you're out there like Erica Curka,
  317. 10:26a newly branded CEO of one of the
  318. 10:28largest conservative youth organizations
  319. 10:30in the United States, her desire for her
  320. 10:32own power will never and can never be
  321. 10:35admitted. In this world, the Serene
  322. 10:36Joyces only have power as a holy vessel,
  323. 10:39a mere conduit who submitted herself to
  324. 10:41God's or a man's authority. It is their
  325. 10:44power that flows through her, not her
  326. 10:46own. At least that's what you say as a
  327. 10:48female conservative public figure in
  328. 10:50order to not be called hypocritical,
  329. 10:51sinful, or be ousted by the community.
  330. 10:53But I do genuinely believe and I know
  331. 10:55because I have met them, there are also
  332. 10:57women who truly, truly believe this. So
  333. 11:00TLDR, while the Serene Joyces can never
  334. 11:01claim that they have power, that does
  335. 11:03not mean that they can't have it. All
  336. 11:05they have to do is make clear over and
  337. 11:07over again that their public image is
  338. 11:09not their own power, but it's for
  339. 11:10furthering God's kingdom or bringing
  340. 11:12women back onto the right path. Or to
  341. 11:15use Olivia's words, it has to be all for
  342. 11:17the cause, all for the good of us all.
  343. 11:19And that's why I was immediately got by
  344. 11:21this song. [laughter] As someone who
  345. 11:22studies conservative Christian women,
  346. 11:23because she literally laid out their
  347. 11:25entire justification system in two
  348. 11:27lines. In two lines. This is the process
  349. 11:30that allows Erica Curka to be CEO, that
  350. 11:32allows Allie Beth Stuckey to do
  351. 11:34theological debates on Jubilee, and also
  352. 11:36explains why Candace Owens constantly
  353. 11:38relies on spiritual warfare as this
  354. 11:40crutch to explain why she's stepping out
  355. 11:42of her conservative, traditional role.
  356. 11:44You see, these women are sacrificing
  357. 11:46their own natural desires to be at home
  358. 11:49and lead a pious life all to help you.
  359. 11:52So, the hypocrisy is important to point
  360. 11:54out, but it is not the end-all, be-all
  361. 11:55of this conversation cuz they can be
  362. 11:57these ambitious, cutthroat, strong
  363. 12:00leaders and these paragons of
  364. 12:01conservative Christian womanhood as long
  365. 12:03as they tell the story the right way.
  366. 12:05So, shout out Olivia. Thank you for
  367. 12:06taking out the belief system seriously.
  368. 12:08So, Olivia beautifully identifies this
  369. 12:10justification process and then moves
  370. 12:12into her actual critique, which is kind
  371. 12:14of spans throughout the rest of the
  372. 12:15song. And for me, what I see as the core
  373. 12:18of Olivia's beef with the Serena Joys is
  374. 12:20this sense of self-righteousness. We get
  375. 12:22this imagery of them in this tower with
  376. 12:24gold paint on the walls, like some
  377. 12:26medieval type [ __ ] with royalty like
  378. 12:28looking down at the poor on the streets
  379. 12:31below. Obviously, images of class,
  380. 12:33wealth inequality, and all things MAGA
  381. 12:35come up here in this section. All while
  382. 12:37honing in in their unwavering belief
  383. 12:39that they are this protected class,
  384. 12:40defiantly believing that they will never
  385. 12:42be beat or fall from their status. And
  386. 12:44the reason I spent all of this time
  387. 12:46breaking down the whole justification
  388. 12:47process of the Serena Joys is because
  389. 12:50this sense of self-sacrifice, giving up
  390. 12:52their natural role as a woman to be this
  391. 12:55holy vessel for God's larger purpose and
  392. 12:58to better you, also gives them this
  393. 13:01sense of self-righteousness and
  394. 13:03untouchability. As someone who studied
  395. 13:04this for 10 years and grew up in it, I
  396. 13:06always think it's really funny when
  397. 13:08people think it's like, "Gotcha. You're
  398. 13:10being used. You are only a means to an
  399. 13:12end. They're going to use you and
  400. 13:14they're going to toss you out and you're
  401. 13:15going to just be nothing when they're
  402. 13:16done with you." Or as Olivia puts it,
  403. 13:18"If they do it to them, they'll do it to
  404. 13:20you." Yes, all of that is true, but they
  405. 13:23know that, too. And many are proud of
  406. 13:26it. Of course I'm just a holy vessel.
  407. 13:28That's the whole point. God is bigger.
  408. 13:31You should only be so lucky for God to
  409. 13:35choose to destroy your personhood to
  410. 13:37further his message. So there is in the
  411. 13:40minds of these women this idea of
  412. 13:42self-sacrifice. Being used is not news
  413. 13:45to them or at least to many of them for
  414. 13:47a higher purpose. So why should they be
  415. 13:49selfish and get in the way of God? Like
  416. 13:51I don't know man, [clears throat]
  417. 13:51they're not dumb. People wouldn't just
  418. 13:53like sign up to be a part of this if
  419. 13:55there was not some like larger thing
  420. 13:56that was compelling. I just anyways, I I
  421. 14:00make many videos about that. But what is
  422. 14:03actually ignored and avoided, which
  423. 14:05Olivia points out, is that that
  424. 14:07self-sacrifice is contingent on the
  425. 14:10sacrificing of others. And for me that
  426. 14:13observation elevates her critique from
  427. 14:15the normal gotcha because she points out
  428. 14:18how they avoid accountability and how
  429. 14:20they specifically harm people. In the
  430. 14:22first person in particular, Olivia
  431. 14:23really leans into the Serena Joy's
  432. 14:26self-imposed lack of perspective to the
  433. 14:28world sitting around them outside of
  434. 14:30their tower. The tower, gold, and ball
  435. 14:33energy all really makes me think of like
  436. 14:35this princess locked in a tower for her
  437. 14:37own good. The Serena Joy's are
  438. 14:39enveloping themselves in this almost
  439. 14:40like fairy tale-esque social politics,
  440. 14:44which Olivia specifically calls out with
  441. 14:46the line, "And if you close your eyes,
  442. 14:48then it can't be your fault." And by
  443. 14:50calling that out, I think that Olivia is
  444. 14:52to some extent recognizing this denial
  445. 14:54can be a form of self-protection from
  446. 14:56the psychic harm of knowingly
  447. 14:58disenfranchising the disenfranchised,
  448. 15:01especially if loving Jesus is your whole
  449. 15:02thing. Like like he was famously a big
  450. 15:05fan of the disenfranchised. On some
  451. 15:07level, many of these people know,
  452. 15:09despite the narratives or the stories
  453. 15:11that they tell, that they are doing bad
  454. 15:13things to people. They're not just up in
  455. 15:15their tower keeping to themselves. Like
  456. 15:18that's what she also points out with
  457. 15:20like the bothering your neighbors thing.
  458. 15:21Like that's also part of what kind of
  459. 15:23led into the Karen archetype. Even if
  460. 15:25they want to avoid the harm outside of
  461. 15:27their tower, it's inevitable because
  462. 15:29this protected status that they have has
  463. 15:32to be defiantly maintained. And Olivia
  464. 15:34not only acknowledges that fact, writing
  465. 15:36from their POV "We'll never be beaten or
  466. 15:38we'll never will fall." but also forces
  467. 15:41them to face the soft militarism that
  468. 15:43they use. And not just by the tone in
  469. 15:45the song like we already talked about,
  470. 15:46but specifically in my favorite part of
  471. 15:49the entire song. It's just really what
  472. 15:51sold me on the whole thing. Have a Coke
  473. 15:52and a smile. Let me show you a trick. If
  474. 15:55you can't throw a punch, you can learn
  475. 15:57how to spit. This is so good. Because
  476. 16:01like right up front, right? You get this
  477. 16:03softness. You know, have a Coke, a
  478. 16:05smile. And then we escalate straight
  479. 16:07into violence. And a specific type of
  480. 16:10violence at that. One out of spite,
  481. 16:12self-righteousness, and disgust.
  482. 16:14Spitting isn't self-defense. Punching,
  483. 16:16even firearms, can be written off as a
  484. 16:18way to defend yourself. Spitting is
  485. 16:20something that is almost always done by
  486. 16:21an aggressor who is safe in the
  487. 16:24knowledge that their aggression will not
  488. 16:26be policed but protected. That is how
  489. 16:28Serena Joy's soft militancy operates.
  490. 16:31Just as violent but made to seem above
  491. 16:33reproach or warranted. I think a lot
  492. 16:35about this time that happened a few
  493. 16:37years ago where I saw a lot of the girls
  494. 16:39that I went to church with growing up
  495. 16:41and I I hadn't seen them for like, I
  496. 16:42don't know, 5, 6 years because I left
  497. 16:45the church when I was like 16, 17. I
  498. 16:47can't really remember.
  499. 16:48>> Missing memory.
  500. 16:50>> [laughter]
  501. 16:50>> But we got into this conversation about
  502. 16:52sexual shaming in our youth group, super
  503. 16:54light topic. And one of the girls who I
  504. 16:56was honestly really surprised by, you
  505. 16:57know, agreed with me that it was really
  506. 16:58bad. It was permanently damaging. And it
  507. 17:01was harmful. But then she said something
  508. 17:03I will never forget. But sometimes women
  509. 17:05need to be shamed to be put back on the
  510. 17:08right path to God. And that is exactly
  511. 17:10how this cycle continues. Serena Joy's
  512. 17:13power and protected status doesn't just
  513. 17:15have to be maintained, but all of
  514. 17:16conservative Christian womanhood does.
  515. 17:18It is this continual cleansing ritual of
  516. 17:22testimony, praying it away, and emptying
  517. 17:25yourself more and more, and shoving it
  518. 17:28down more and more until you are
  519. 17:30transformed in the perfect holy vessel
  520. 17:32for God. But then there's nothing left.
  521. 17:35And that's why the outro is really
  522. 17:36phenomenal to me. Singing everything is
  523. 17:38fine over and over again is exactly how
  524. 17:42this ideology is maintained. It truly is
  525. 17:45repetition as ritual. And it was really
  526. 17:47interesting because a lot of like the
  527. 17:48reviews were like, "Oh yeah, the song, I
  528. 17:49like the message, but honestly it was
  529. 17:51just like way too repetitive, but like
  530. 17:53uh I don't even know like there's no way
  531. 17:55that she's like looking in the role of
  532. 17:57repetition in like religious ideology
  533. 17:59and belief and like Christian narrative
  534. 18:01tradition." But I'm going to give her
  535. 18:02the credit. I'm going to say that she
  536. 18:04knew it and that's that's why it was so
  537. 18:05repetitive. It wasn't just a warning,
  538. 18:07but it was the singing along. It makes
  539. 18:09me think of worship music, of call and
  540. 18:11response. It's that understanding that
  541. 18:13these women, like the girl that I grew
  542. 18:15up with, even if they know that it hurts
  543. 18:17them or harms others, they will continue
  544. 18:19to maintain it. If this cycle of a bad
  545. 18:21feeling comes up, push it down, and
  546. 18:23you've served God. And a lot of that
  547. 18:25ritual actually comes from 19th century
  548. 18:26sentimental literature. Woo, maybe
  549. 18:28another essay. Let me know. And with all
  550. 18:30that complexity laid out, that is why I
  551. 18:32don't take Serena Joy as this just cut
  552. 18:34and dry diss track. Where even as this
  553. 18:36like singular POV of Olivia just mocking
  554. 18:38these women and taunting them by like
  555. 18:40throwing their words back at them. I
  556. 18:41really think it becomes this kind of
  557. 18:44dual POV. This kind of like shared
  558. 18:46responsibility almost. At least by the
  559. 18:47end. This feeling of suspense and like
  560. 18:50something is coming for you could be
  561. 18:52read just as Olivia warning that the
  562. 18:54patriarchy is coming for them, but I
  563. 18:56also think it could be this sense that
  564. 18:57conservative Christian women are coming
  565. 18:59for us and for our rights. For me, the
  566. 19:01outro is the biggest part of this like
  567. 19:04dual POV. In one reading, everything is
  568. 19:06fine is clearly just a Serena Joy is
  569. 19:08telling herself that everything they're
  570. 19:09doing and all the harm that they're
  571. 19:10causing and everything to themselves,
  572. 19:12it's okay. It's okay. It's okay. But if
  573. 19:13I really wanted to push it, I think I
  574. 19:15could also read it as like this kind of
  575. 19:17manic self-talk. I think when politics
  576. 19:19get really scary and get overwhelmed by
  577. 19:21the nefariousness of politics right now,
  578. 19:24there could just be this manic self-talk
  579. 19:25of like, "It's fine. Everything's going
  580. 19:27to be fine. It's fine." It's almost like
  581. 19:28this chorus of self-soothing of women.
  582. 19:31Knowing their rights are being taken,
  583. 19:32but both taking a very different
  584. 19:34approach. One is buying in and one is
  585. 19:36pushing back. And trust me, I did not
  586. 19:38forget my little treat at the end of
  587. 19:40this video. If you still want to hear me
  588. 19:41talk about it, I think that the Serena
  589. 19:43Joy reference is incredibly useful. I
  590. 19:44made that very clear in the analysis of
  591. 19:46this video. I think it's because online
  592. 19:48Serena Joy is treated as this like newly
  593. 19:49devised dystopian figure from far-off
  594. 19:52reality is now coming true in America.
  595. 19:55Reality is that Atwood took a lot of
  596. 19:57inspiration for Serena Joy from
  597. 19:59televangelists. Typically, the
  598. 20:01conservative evangelical
  599. 20:03counter-movement to the second-wave
  600. 20:04feminist movement in the 1980s, the 700
  601. 20:07Club, Tammy Faye, except for, "Love you,
  602. 20:09girl." I mean, out of all of them, you
  603. 20:11are my favorite. Of course, younger
  604. 20:13people are not going to have context for
  605. 20:15the televangelist movement in the 1980s
  606. 20:17like I do not expect that. I think it's
  607. 20:19more when comments like this where it's
  608. 20:21like, "Don't Don't mean to be annoying,
  609. 20:23but, you know, Serena Joy really made
  610. 20:25the playbook." And it's like,
  611. 20:26>> [laughter and gasps]
  612. 20:27>> It's been 200 years. But that's because
  613. 20:29I study 19th century history and like
  614. 20:31how that can relate and help us
  615. 20:32understand like 21st century
  616. 20:34conservative Christian women. So, it's a
  617. 20:36pet peeve. Doesn't piss me off. It does.
  618. 20:38It does piss me off. You can actually
  619. 20:39watch this like video I made when I was
  620. 20:41really early on in my TikTok posting
  621. 20:43days. I know it wasn't as salacious as
  622. 20:45maybe you hoped, but thank you so much
  623. 20:47for watching my first long-form video.
  624. 20:49It was truly a blast. And please let me
  625. 20:51know what you think. Ask questions.
  626. 20:53Leave comments. You can yell at me, but
  627. 20:54if you yell at me, please yell at me
  628. 20:55nicely. I have been thinking about this
  629. 20:57song for weeks, so our posting this is
  630. 20:59really just starting the conversation,
  631. 21:01not leaving it. So, thank you for being
  632. 21:02here. I hope you subscribe and comment.
  633. 21:05Let me know if you enjoyed this
  634. 21:07long-form. I actually genuinely do
  635. 21:09appreciate any feedback and I want to
  636. 21:13make stuff that I enjoy, but also things
  637. 21:15that you guys are going to like, too.
  638. 21:16So.
  639. 21:19Thanks.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Olivia Rodrigo is so much smarter than you think: serena joy analysis by Kristina Reinis, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,355 words across 639 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.