YouTube2Text

Obsessed: Unraveling Jodi Arias | True crime documentary — Transcript

by Arizona’s Family (3TV / CBS 5) · 9,101 words · 1,391 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:02It is Sunday, June 22nd. [music]
  2. 0:06I just checked my work phone and I had
  3. 0:09an email that came in from the prison.
  4. 0:13[music]
  5. 0:14It says, "You have received a new
  6. 0:17message. The prisoner is Jodie A. Aras."
  7. 0:24I'm nervous. You do this whole
  8. 0:25documentary and all I want to know is
  9. 0:28more about Jod and
  10. 0:29>> Jod's locked in.
  11. 0:30>> Don't roll the tape yet.
  12. 0:31>> I didn't think she was going to respond.
  13. 0:34>> Here we go. All right.
  14. 0:37[music]
  15. 0:50>> [music]
  16. 1:16[music]
  17. 1:19>> We went to the same church in Riverside
  18. 1:21[music] and I met him there. Travis was
  19. 1:24extremely outgoing [music] and he would
  20. 1:28welcome everybody at church. He would
  21. 1:29talk to everybody. Um he was hilarious.
  22. 1:32I started dating his friend Chris and
  23. 1:35because Travis talked me into [music] it
  24. 1:37and we ended up getting married and
  25. 1:39Chris and Travis worked together and we
  26. 1:41just became close through that.
  27. 1:42>> We both worked for a company called
  28. 1:44Legal Shield and independent [music]
  29. 1:46contractors. So, we pretty much were our
  30. 1:48own bosses.
  31. 1:51The first time I met him was he came to
  32. 1:53Utah and did a presentation [music] and
  33. 1:56he was just funny. Most of the time it
  34. 1:58was, "Hi, I'm Travis." Bam. And he would
  35. 2:00show you his muscles. [music]
  36. 2:02That was his favorite.
  37. 2:04I don't think there was anybody that met
  38. 2:06Travis that didn't want to be his
  39. 2:08friend.
  40. 2:12When does Jodie come into the picture?
  41. 2:14[snorts]
  42. 2:15She was at a convention that we were at
  43. 2:18in 2006.
  44. 2:20>> So he called me and he says, "You got to
  45. 2:21I just met this chick. She's amazing.
  46. 2:24She's gorgeous. You got to meet her. I
  47. 2:26can't wait for you guys to meet." What
  48. 2:27was your initial perception? She's
  49. 2:30beautiful. She was very kind, very
  50. 2:32softspoken. She was very into Travis.
  51. 2:34Travis was very into her. So yeah, she
  52. 2:36[music] seemed great.
  53. 2:40Travis was looking [music] for someone
  54. 2:42of the similar faith. He brought her
  55. 2:44over and introduced her to me and I was
  56. 2:46just excited cuz she was a pretty blonde
  57. 2:48[music] that you know she was all smiles
  58. 2:50and he was all smiles and I was excited
  59. 2:52for him. [music]
  60. 2:53>> So you liked Jodie off the back?
  61. 2:55>> Mhm. Travis thought he was going to
  62. 2:57marry pretty much every girl he dated.
  63. 2:58[laughter]
  64. 3:00>> But she was not Mormon. [music]
  65. 3:01>> She was not.
  66. 3:02>> So did he have pause about that?
  67. 3:05>> He did, but he um they [music] had
  68. 3:07talked about his beliefs and she was
  69. 3:10like totally like, "Oh, I love that. I
  70. 3:13could get behind that. Oh, I believe in
  71. 3:14that, too. [music] Things were going
  72. 3:16well and maybe around two or 3 months,
  73. 3:18Chris and I start noticing like some
  74. 3:20weird behaviors with her.
  75. 3:24She's like [music] obsessed with the
  76. 3:26idea like they are getting married.
  77. 3:28Travis needs to commit to me. He needs
  78. 3:30to ask me to move to Arizona. It was
  79. 3:32about 6 months later that I got to know
  80. 3:34her a little bit better and she walked
  81. 3:35up and she gave me a hug and I just got
  82. 3:39the sickest feeling. Second time I've
  83. 3:41ever met her. Right after that, I turned
  84. 3:43around, went outside, and talked to one
  85. 3:45of my friends, and she looked at me and
  86. 3:47she said, "She gives me [music] the
  87. 3:49creeps." I knew something was off, but I
  88. 3:53didn't know what. Like, it just I mean,
  89. 3:54even talking about it now gives me makes
  90. 3:57me sick to my stomach. At this time, Jod
  91. 3:59was living in California, and Travis had
  92. 4:01moved to Mesa, Arizona a couple years
  93. 4:03prior [music] for his job. But Jod and
  94. 4:05Travis were on and off again all the
  95. 4:07time, constantly breaking up and getting
  96. 4:10[music] back together. So, who was
  97. 4:12Jodie? Where did this all start? We
  98. 4:15talked to our high school classmate who
  99. 4:16asked we change his name.
  100. 4:19>> Hello.
  101. 4:20>> Hi. How are you?
  102. 4:23>> I went to high school with Jodie. We
  103. 4:26didn't grow up in the same town, but
  104. 4:28everybody in our community kind of goes
  105. 4:29to one high school. And so, I had all my
  106. 4:32core classes with her. She was always
  107. 4:35really nice and courteous, pretty smart.
  108. 4:37I think a little kind of on the titsy
  109. 4:39side, you could say. She wasn't like the
  110. 4:42popular girl by any means, but I think,
  111. 4:45you know, people she interacted with
  112. 4:47tend to like her.
  113. 4:49>> Do you think all of you that went to
  114. 4:51high school with her actually knew the
  115. 4:52real Jodie?
  116. 4:53>> I don't think we did. No, I don't think
  117. 4:55anybody I think some people got glimpses
  118. 4:57of it. She was dating this guy. For
  119. 5:00whatever reason, they broke up and
  120. 5:03[music] this guy started seeing a new
  121. 5:04girl and I think they were at the new
  122. 5:07girl's house and they were hanging out
  123. 5:08and they just happened to look up out
  124. 5:10the [music] window and Jod was out there
  125. 5:12on the street kind of looking in the
  126. 5:14window at them.
  127. 5:15>> Anytime Travis started dating somebody
  128. 5:17else, Jod would become their friend.
  129. 5:19[music] She would add them on MySpace.
  130. 5:21She would see them at meetings if they
  131. 5:23were in Legal Shield and that she would
  132. 5:25become their BFF. You know, it was it
  133. 5:27was really weird. She knew he was dating
  134. 5:30other people. [music] He started dating
  135. 5:32Lisa and he really liked Lisa and he
  136. 5:34would do all these really cute things
  137. 5:36for her and it got very [music] serious.
  138. 5:37And there were times when he and Lisa
  139. 5:39were sitting on the couch watching a
  140. 5:41movie and [music] she looks up and Jod's
  141. 5:43in the kitchen. There was another time
  142. 5:45where she was at the back window. When
  143. 5:47he was over at Lisa's house, his tires
  144. 5:49got slashed. It wasn't [music] just
  145. 5:51bizarre actions. What people didn't know
  146. 5:53at the time was how and what Jod was
  147. 5:56writing. IM and emails between the two
  148. 5:59depict the secret they were keeping from
  149. 6:00[music] family and friends. They were
  150. 6:02having a sexual relationship that didn't
  151. 6:05align with Travis's religious beliefs.
  152. 6:07But most intriguing, Jod's personal
  153. 6:09journal that becomes a key part of this
  154. 6:12case.
  155. 6:14We [music] both want to get married and
  156. 6:16I don't think either of us is anywhere
  157. 6:18near that if we continue to act
  158. 6:19immorally.
  159. 6:23>> [music]
  160. 6:24>> We have many fights in Q right now.
  161. 6:26>> You just told me I'm cute last time. I
  162. 6:28was persistent [music] about it. Take it
  163. 6:30as a freaking compliment that I'm way
  164. 6:32excited to see you.
  165. 6:34>> I have been looking forward to it, but I
  166. 6:36don't want it to be a source of stress.
  167. 6:38>> You'll be a lot less stressed about it
  168. 6:39once you just get in your car and get
  169. 6:42over [music] here and let me distress
  170. 6:44you.
  171. 6:47>> I'm Aaron Nelson and I'm a forensic
  172. 6:49psychologist. So you were actually asked
  173. 6:51to be part of this case. What happened?
  174. 6:53[music]
  175. 6:54>> Yes, I was contacted during the rebuttal
  176. 6:57phase of the matter and I had a
  177. 6:59scheduling conflict um but was able to
  178. 7:01refer the case to a colleague. The Aras
  179. 7:04case had like every extreme sort of
  180. 7:07scenario all in one matter. We
  181. 7:10interviewed Dr. Nelson because this
  182. 7:12project and documentary is all about
  183. 7:14studying the mind of Jodie Aras, her
  184. 7:16psychology from then until now. I'm not
  185. 7:20pressuring your trip. I know that'll
  186. 7:22happen, but I can't stand the wait.
  187. 7:24>> Soon. Really soon. Realistically, the
  188. 7:27first of the month.
  189. 7:28>> Isn't that when you go to Cancun?
  190. 7:30>> The 10th.
  191. 7:31>> If you can't watch me saying no worries.
  192. 7:33I just wanted you to be proud of me.
  193. 7:35>> Record it. I'll be proud of you.
  194. 7:37>> Another reason for you to say to
  195. 7:39yourself, "Look at her." In front of
  196. 7:41hundreds of [music] people.
  197. 7:42>> I'll show how proud I am by licking your
  198. 7:45>> There's no question that their
  199. 7:47relationship was volatile. I've heard it
  200. 7:49described as toxic. I certainly agree.
  201. 7:51People call it passionate and intense.
  202. 7:54All of those adjectives could describe
  203. 7:56their relationship.
  204. 7:57>> It would make a steamy romance novel
  205. 7:59sound like a G-rated Disney movie.
  206. 8:02>> I mean, he liked her a lot. And I think
  207. 8:04in the beginning, he did think of her as
  208. 8:06someone he could marry. [music] But the
  209. 8:08more he got to know her, and the more
  210. 8:11she pushed sexually, I think the less he
  211. 8:14saw her as his forever wife. I've
  212. 8:17somehow managed to become his whipping
  213. 8:19girl, and we're both addicted to it.
  214. 8:22It's the same pattern as always. He gets
  215. 8:24pissed, goes off on me, feels bad, we
  216. 8:27make up. Yes, Travis, you're [music]
  217. 8:30right, Travis. Whatever you say, Travis,
  218. 8:33we're crazy being addicted to this
  219. 8:34cycle.
  220. 8:39She decides she's moving to Arizona. And
  221. 8:41Travis is like, "Why are you moving to
  222. 8:43Arizona? We broke up." Did they ever get
  223. 8:45back together once she moved to Arizona?
  224. 8:47>> They kept hooking up, but they never
  225. 8:48were back in a relationship. She moved
  226. 8:50within like a mile or mile and a half,
  227. 8:52like very close to his house. Like super
  228. 8:55weird. She snuck into through his doggy
  229. 8:57door and would climb into his bed with
  230. 8:59no clothes on when they were on the
  231. 9:02outs. [music] I told him, I said,
  232. 9:03"Travis, I'm afraid we're going to find
  233. 9:05you chopped up in her freezer. Like, she
  234. 9:06scares me." And he starts laughing. He's
  235. 9:08like, "There's no way, Skye. You don't
  236. 9:10know her." That's what he said to me.
  237. 9:12"You don't know her like I do." And I
  238. 9:14was thinking, you don't know her like I
  239. 9:15do.
  240. 9:18She moved to Arizona in June and then
  241. 9:21moved back to Hu Rica in April. And
  242. 9:24Travis becomes immediately becomes a
  243. 9:27different person. [music] We got like
  244. 9:28our old Travis back. Like he's
  245. 9:30energetic. He's happy. He's funny. But
  246. 9:33that didn't last because Travis was
  247. 9:35never able to fully get rid of Jod.
  248. 9:37[music]
  249. 9:38The two kept coming back for more,
  250. 9:39knowing what would entice the other,
  251. 9:41either sex or guilt.
  252. 9:44>> Every time that Travis tried to cut Jod
  253. 9:46off completely, she would threaten to
  254. 9:48kill herself. And she's like, "You're
  255. 9:50all I have. You can't cut me off. I have
  256. 9:52no one else." And he would [music] feel
  257. 9:53terrible.
  258. 9:54>> Well, I've decided to go next week to
  259. 9:56Utah. I'm pretty stoked about it. Plus,
  260. 9:58I'll have two whole days to spend with
  261. 10:00Ryan. I mentioned my road trip [music]
  262. 10:02to Travis. He didn't sound all that
  263. 10:04thrilled for me. As far as I know, he
  264. 10:07knows nothing of Ryan.
  265. 10:08>> It [music] appeared to me that the
  266. 10:10journal itself did not begin as with the
  267. 10:14intentional aspects. It seemed to become
  268. 10:17more intentional.
  269. 10:20>> Just getting ready for the road mostly.
  270. 10:23I'll be leaving [music] in a few hours.
  271. 10:26>> It certainly seemed to me that she was
  272. 10:28creating a narrative or a story.
  273. 10:39Travis was tentatively [music]
  274. 10:41planning to come and see me, but now
  275. 10:43it's been pushed back to the beginning
  276. 10:44of June. [music]
  277. 10:46I don't think it's a good idea that he
  278. 10:47comes, as much as I miss his company.
  279. 10:52Sad [music] news. I finally had the
  280. 10:54conversation with Travis and it did not
  281. 10:57go well. Well, [music] even sadder is we
  282. 10:59agreed to amicably part ways.
  283. 11:04Well, I've decided to go next week to
  284. 11:06Utah. [music] I'm pretty stoked about
  285. 11:08it. Plus, I'll have two whole days to
  286. 11:10spend with Ryan.
  287. 11:13[music] We knew she had gone to Utah
  288. 11:15because my little brother had set her up
  289. 11:17with Ryan Burns.
  290. 11:18>> Just getting ready for the road mostly.
  291. 11:19[music] I'll be leaving in a few hours.
  292. 11:21Travis also began to sweet talk/gilt me
  293. 11:24that I was making this road trip to Utah
  294. 11:26to visit [music] friends, etc. when I
  295. 11:28could instead come out to a to see him.
  296. 11:31He actually made me regret my itinerary
  297. 11:33for a few moments. [music]
  298. 11:34He is incredibly persuasive, but I stood
  299. 11:37my ground. Jod didn't just drive to
  300. 11:39Utah. She details several stops along
  301. 11:41the way in her journal. Reading, Santa
  302. 11:44Cruz, Pacific Grove, Pasadena. She even
  303. 11:47visited her ex-boyfriend named [music]
  304. 11:48Daryl. Jod was really late to Utah. An
  305. 11:52entire day late. So much so, her friends
  306. 11:54thought something may have happened to
  307. 11:55her. [music]
  308. 11:58Well, we're all at dinner on Wednesday
  309. 12:01and I'm like, "So, Ryan, where's [music]
  310. 12:02Jodie?" And he says, "Um, I don't know.
  311. 12:05She was supposed to be here like this
  312. 12:07afternoon." He called when we were
  313. 12:08sitting at the table. Straight to
  314. 12:10voicemail. I called her straight to
  315. 12:12voicemail. [music]
  316. 12:14At the briefing, she comes in, but she
  317. 12:17walked straight for [music] me and gave
  318. 12:18me a hug. She was so happy like all airy
  319. 12:22and
  320. 12:24you know like she was all excited to be
  321. 12:26here and we get this story of oh we were
  322. 12:29expecting her we were nervous [music]
  323. 12:31and like we didn't know where she was
  324. 12:32but she said that she got lost getting
  325. 12:35to Utah from here you just get on the 15
  326. 12:37like you don't get lost and that's when
  327. 12:38we were sitting there and I noticed the
  328. 12:39band-aids on [music] her fingers so I
  329. 12:41just asked her why do you have band-aids
  330. 12:43all over your fingers and she's like oh
  331. 12:45I'm a bartender I cut myself all the
  332. 12:47time and I just looked at her kind of
  333. 12:48weird
  334. 12:49We started talking about going
  335. 12:50four-wheeling the next day and I was
  336. 12:52like, "Oh, [music] great." Because of
  337. 12:54course she's going to go, "Yan, you
  338. 12:55know, she's trying to." And she's like,
  339. 12:57"Oh, I got to get back." And I was like,
  340. 13:00"Oh, how come?"
  341. 13:03>> Wow. Utah was amazing. I so wish I could
  342. 13:07have stayed longer, as in like a whole
  343. 13:08month.
  344. 13:10>> Travis was going to Cancun to meet some
  345. 13:11friends and take some work calls. Jody
  346. 13:14knew about it, but Travis was taking
  347. 13:16another girl with him. Mimi Sky and
  348. 13:18Chris were already in Cancun waiting for
  349. 13:21Travis's arrival.
  350. 13:23We kept calling him and he wouldn't
  351. 13:25answer
  352. 13:27and Chris called and left him voicemail
  353. 13:31dude like you missed the conference call
  354. 13:34and nothing back. And then I believe it
  355. 13:37was the next day we called again and his
  356. 13:39voicemail was full. We're like what is
  357. 13:41going on? Like something's wrong.
  358. 13:42>> I do remember hearing a knock at what
  359. 13:44sounded like a knock at the door. We
  360. 13:46called some friends to go over there and
  361. 13:48at the same time Mimi Michelle and
  362. 13:50Michelle's boyfriend had gone over there
  363. 13:52to see where's Travis, what's going on
  364. 13:54because he's not answering his phone. So
  365. 13:55they knock on the door, the door is
  366. 13:57locked. Then they called somebody, got
  367. 14:00the garage code, they went inside the
  368. 14:03house, they go upstairs, they knock on
  369. 14:05the roommate's door, and he's like, "No,
  370. 14:07Travis went to Mexico." And Mimi's like,
  371. 14:08"No, I'm supposed to go with him
  372. 14:11tomorrow." I came out of the shower and
  373. 14:13went into my room and at that point they
  374. 14:16were searching around the house.
  375. 14:17>> He finds a key to Travis's room.
  376. 14:19>> Zach came into the room.
  377. 14:20>> They opened the door
  378. 14:21>> and said, "We need to um get out of the
  379. 14:24house now."
  380. 14:24>> And that's when they found Travis.
  381. 14:26>> You know how we thought Travis was away.
  382. 14:29Turned out he was in his bathroom.
  383. 14:31>> Someone called and said, "Travis is
  384. 14:33dead."
  385. 14:35And we both were kind of like, "What?
  386. 14:42>> [music]
  387. 14:48>> And at the time of this incident, I was
  388. 14:49a lieutenant in the patrol at Mesa
  389. 14:52Police Department.
  390. 14:52>> Have you ever publicly talked about this
  391. 14:54case?
  392. 14:54>> No, I haven't. [music]
  393. 14:57So, I was out on patrol when the call
  394. 14:59came out. I would describe it as a
  395. 15:02typical East Valley neighborhood. These
  396. 15:03things typically don't happen here. I
  397. 15:05remember we were on the corner across
  398. 15:06from where the house was and we had it
  399. 15:08all secured. When I arrived, it was
  400. 15:10apparent that it was going to be either
  401. 15:12suspicious death or or a homicide.
  402. 15:14>> All we knew was that a person was found
  403. 15:17dead inside a home [music] in Mesa. We
  404. 15:19didn't know all the details
  405. 15:21>> at that point. Did you think it was
  406. 15:23going to be as big as it ended up
  407. 15:25becoming?
  408. 15:26>> Not at that time, but it was it was
  409. 15:27unique cuz when I arrived, there was a
  410. 15:29large crowd around the house.
  411. 15:30>> There's obvious signs of blood [music]
  412. 15:32on the carpet. As you go in further, we
  413. 15:34found other signs of a struggle or
  414. 15:36something in in the hallway leading into
  415. 15:38the master bathroom. And uh once you go
  416. 15:41inside the bathroom is when you can see
  417. 15:43the body [music] of of Travis in the
  418. 15:45shower.
  419. 15:45>> This young good-looking guy had been
  420. 15:48stabbed 27 times, that his [music]
  421. 15:50throat had been slashed, that he had
  422. 15:52been shot in the head. You just knew
  423. 15:55that there was something more to it.
  424. 15:57That started to perk everyone's ears up
  425. 15:59that this may be bigger than [music]
  426. 16:00what was first thought. The initial
  427. 16:02information right from the get-go was
  428. 16:04that they had a suspect in mind from all
  429. 16:06these friends that were there. They
  430. 16:08believed they knew who did this.
  431. 16:09>> And I looked at him and I said, "Jod."
  432. 16:10[music]
  433. 16:11He's like, "No, she's a little girl."
  434. 16:13I'm like, "Jo, it was Jodie." I knew it
  435. 16:16was her because then I knew she was late
  436. 16:19getting here. I didn't want it to be
  437. 16:21Jod. I thought it's probably Jod, but I
  438. 16:24[music] didn't want it to be Jod because
  439. 16:25of what that meant for Travis. that this
  440. 16:27person who he's defended for [music] two
  441. 16:29years, who he loved and took care of and
  442. 16:32helped, is the person who killed him.
  443. 16:34[music] Like, it just wasn't real at
  444. 16:36first. I was sitting there and it hit me
  445. 16:39that [music] he was he's dead.
  446. 16:42>> Our detectives were very meticulous of
  447. 16:43going through every inch of that house,
  448. 16:45looking for DNA evidence, looking for
  449. 16:46blood, looking for any type of evidence.
  450. 16:49And they eventually did find that
  451. 16:50[music] camera. That camera actually
  452. 16:52provided key details of when it actually
  453. 16:54occurred.
  454. 16:56>> That digital camera was found inside the
  455. 16:59washing machine and on it were pictures,
  456. 17:02naked pictures of Travis Alexander and
  457. 17:05Jodie Aras in a matter of minutes seen
  458. 17:08in [music] timestamps on the photos from
  459. 17:10June 4th. They go from being sexual and
  460. 17:12fun to pictures accidentally taken of
  461. 17:15Travis bloody in the shower. And there's
  462. 17:18a blurry picture that appears to be
  463. 17:20Jod's pant leg. Meanwhile, Travis's
  464. 17:22family and friends are learning new info
  465. 17:24in the investigation [music] every day
  466. 17:26and putting these pieces together for
  467. 17:28themselves. But Jod doesn't know that
  468. 17:31police have all this evidence. She's
  469. 17:33still journaling a lot. Then he told me
  470. 17:38it was about Travis. This is horrendous.
  471. 17:41[music]
  472. 17:42The most awful thing I've ever had to
  473. 17:44deal with. I am in total shock right
  474. 17:46now. It hasn't fully [music] hit me.
  475. 17:48This can't really be real. This just
  476. 17:50can't be happening.
  477. 17:52>> It appeared [music] as if she was giving
  478. 17:54written practice to back up how she
  479. 17:57would portray herself with others.
  480. 18:00>> So, I've been numb mostly, but last
  481. 18:02night [music] was extremely hard. I
  482. 18:04broke down. I hear him singing. I hear
  483. 18:07him laugh.
  484. 18:08>> This went well. I [music] told so and so
  485. 18:10how sad I was and how horrified and how
  486. 18:13could this happen. My guess [music]
  487. 18:15would be that sometimes she said it
  488. 18:17first and wrote it down and other times
  489. 18:18as she was writing [music] she had a
  490. 18:20thought that she then used in
  491. 18:22conversation.
  492. 18:23>> We're getting all this information like
  493. 18:25how she shows up in this rental car and
  494. 18:28how her license plate was upside down
  495. 18:30and she got pulled over and [music] so
  496. 18:32obviously she took her license plates
  497. 18:33off to go to Travis's house.
  498. 18:36>> Tonight I went to the police station to
  499. 18:37give elimination prints. I am so angry
  500. 18:40about all of this. I can't imagine what
  501. 18:42his family [music] is feeling.
  502. 18:44>> She bought a gas can. She borrowed two
  503. 18:46gas cans from Daryl that she planned
  504. 18:48ahead of time. Some people think that
  505. 18:50her changing her hair color right before
  506. 18:51had a lot to do with it because people
  507. 18:53were familiar with her on Travis's
  508. 18:54street. [music]
  509. 18:55Travis was at my bedside this morning. I
  510. 18:58could feel his presence.
  511. 18:59>> But she butchered Travis, got in her
  512. 19:02car, drove to Utah, and hooks up with
  513. 19:04Ryan Burns. Like, it was so bizarre. I'm
  514. 19:10for thou shalt [music] not kill, but is
  515. 19:12it wrong to want the perpetrator to get
  516. 19:14the needle? Perhaps. Oh, Travis, to be
  517. 19:16as strong as you are, [music] Ja.
  518. 19:18>> I think that a journal was something
  519. 19:20that she likely used as a common [music]
  520. 19:23practice, and it very intentionally
  521. 19:26became the establishment of an alibi.
  522. 19:30I had a dream that two people were
  523. 19:32charged in the case of Travis Alexander.
  524. 19:34Anyway, keep praying, Ja.
  525. 19:40Hillary called me and she said, "They
  526. 19:43got her. They got her. They arrested
  527. 19:45her. They arrested her for killing my
  528. 19:46brother.
  529. 19:56[music]
  530. 19:58How many times was Travis stabbed?"
  531. 20:04More than I want to remember.
  532. 20:10And I'm not going to sit here and
  533. 20:14show [music] you pictures of him after
  534. 20:16the fact. I don't do that. That's not
  535. 20:18how I work.
  536. 20:22If [music] Travis were here today, he
  537. 20:23would tell you that if it wasn't me.
  538. 20:28We had [music] watched her manipulate so
  539. 20:30many people um over the two years and
  540. 20:33[music]
  541. 20:34people would believe her. Is she going
  542. 20:37to be able to talk her way out of this?
  543. 20:40It's your fault, Joey.
  544. 20:42These are your parents.
  545. 20:47>> This is this bathroom.
  546. 20:51>> That [music] is not my foot.
  547. 20:54She's really smart in some ways and very
  548. 20:55dumb in other ways, but she's not dumb
  549. 20:57enough to think, I'm going to throw this
  550. 20:58camera in there and nobody's going to be
  551. 21:00able to pull stuff off it.
  552. 21:04I think she deleted them. And then I
  553. 21:06think she was either going to take it or
  554. 21:07damage it or do something. But I think
  555. 21:09when she grabbed all that all the
  556. 21:11bedding and put it in the laundry in the
  557. 21:13washer, I don't think she knew the
  558. 21:14camera was in it.
  559. 21:15>> That right there is blood.
  560. 21:19It's a mixture of yours and his.
  561. 21:22And that's your palm bro.
  562. 21:25Have your last palm.
  563. 21:27>> I don't have any cats in my life.
  564. 21:30>> She appeared to have this delusional
  565. 21:31mentality about her that she was in
  566. 21:34denial of everything that happened.
  567. 21:37>> There's no doubt in my mind that you
  568. 21:39were the girl. There's no doubt in my
  569. 21:41mind that you did this. None.
  570. 21:45>> It's killing me. So I don't know why.
  571. 21:47>> Like there's no reason for it. There's
  572. 21:49no reason why. There's no reason I would
  573. 21:52ever want to hurt him. If I was going to
  574. 21:56ever try to kill somebody, I would
  575. 21:59[music]
  576. 21:59use gloves. I found plenty of them.
  577. 22:02>> When they arrested her, she [music] had
  578. 22:04a gun. She had a knife. She was leaving.
  579. 22:07She was getting out of town. She was
  580. 22:09packed. Her car was packed. She was
  581. 22:11ready to go. So, if they hadn't arrested
  582. 22:13her then, she would have been who knows
  583. 22:16where. It's at this point Detective
  584. 22:18Flores leaves the room, leaving Jod
  585. 22:20alone. This is when things start to get
  586. 22:23just downright strange.
  587. 22:25>> I didn't hear you.
  588. 22:30I wonder how am I still here
  589. 22:35[snorts]
  590. 22:42all night
  591. 22:45[snorts]
  592. 22:46when Christ was born.
  593. 22:50[music]
  594. 22:51just based on those types of um
  595. 22:54observations
  596. 22:56I would be thinking [music] and a range
  597. 22:59of the personality disorder diagnosis.
  598. 23:02The cluster [music] of personality
  599. 23:05disorders that would start to emerge as
  600. 23:07relevant contains [music] antisocial
  601. 23:10personality disorder, borderline
  602. 23:12personality disorder, uh histrionic
  603. 23:15personality disorder, [music]
  604. 23:17and narcissistic personality disorder.
  605. 23:20And so you have like her smiling for the
  606. 23:22mug shot and like it was just such a
  607. 23:25slap in the face. She had zero remorse.
  608. 23:29Jod had certainly never seen a jail cell
  609. 23:31before. It was an opportunity to meet a
  610. 23:33whole new set of people, inmates. They
  611. 23:36knew nothing about her life before or
  612. 23:38really even the crime leading up. So she
  613. 23:41could start her narrative from scratch.
  614. 23:43And that's where she met Donovan, who
  615. 23:45becomes a key player in [music] this
  616. 23:46saga.
  617. 23:49We really clicked because one, I had
  618. 23:52never been in trouble a day in my life
  619. 23:54before. [music] So, I was very nervous
  620. 23:56and scared. She was coming in to with
  621. 23:59not knowing anybody [music]
  622. 24:01and we kind of just I would be sitting
  623. 24:04there watching TV and she f would come
  624. 24:05over and we would start talking. [music]
  625. 24:07Yeah. She was very nice. Oh my goodness.
  626. 24:09I mean, spending time with her was
  627. 24:11great.
  628. 24:11>> Did you hate Travis because of what you
  629. 24:13[music] had heard?
  630. 24:14>> Yeah. Telling me horrible stuff. Yeah,
  631. 24:16of course. I got to where I was like,
  632. 24:17how, you know, how dare her, you know,
  633. 24:19and [music] she was obsessed with him. I
  634. 24:22mean, it was she would have done
  635. 24:23anything to be for him to [music] stay
  636. 24:27and like her. We told her, "Do not do
  637. 24:30interviews."
  638. 24:32>> I guess that's really all I needed.
  639. 24:34Sorry, don't roll the tape yet.
  640. 24:37>> Does that help her?
  641. 24:42>> Thank [music] you. I appreciate it. If I
  642. 24:43didn't commit a murder, I didn't hurt
  643. 24:45Travis. I would never hurt Travis, would
  644. 24:47never harm him physically. Um I may have
  645. 24:50hurt him emotionally and [music] I'll
  646. 24:51always regret that. I was on the road
  647. 24:53that week. I don't know a lot about
  648. 24:56that, but I do I did hear that um that
  649. 25:00there was quite a struggle. I really
  650. 25:02don't remember the day at all. I just
  651. 25:04remember when I got the [music] phone
  652. 25:05call. I need to be honest, and it the
  653. 25:07evidence is very compelling, but
  654. 25:10none of it proves that [music] I
  655. 25:11committed a murder. She always she
  656. 25:14always had to make sure that she was put
  657. 25:16together and that she knew what she was
  658. 25:18going to say and it had to be um it's
  659. 25:22like she was wanted to be perfect on TV.
  660. 25:26>> It's so rare that you get somebody who's
  661. 25:29accused of murder who is so open and
  662. 25:31upfront about talking about it. And so
  663. 25:34that in itself created a lot of buzz and
  664. 25:37interest not just locally but across the
  665. 25:39country and around the world.
  666. 25:42She didn't have ever never had any
  667. 25:44remorse. She never cried. Um but at that
  668. 25:48time she was telling stories.
  669. 25:49>> I witnessed um Travis being [music]
  670. 25:51attacked by two other individuals.
  671. 25:55>> Who
  672. 25:56>> I don't know who they were. I couldn't
  673. 25:57[music] pick them out in a police
  674. 25:58lineup. She had talked about the fact
  675. 26:00that uh there were some intruders that
  676. 26:03went into the house and that this was a
  677. 26:06[music] you know this was a case of of
  678. 26:08somebody breaking into the house and
  679. 26:09just a violent crime that took place.
  680. 26:11>> But they didn't hurt her.
  681. 26:12>> But they [music] didn't hurt her. Yes.
  682. 26:14>> Two people took Travis's life. Two
  683. 26:16monsters.
  684. 26:16>> You did [music] not shoot Travis.
  685. 26:18>> No. I've never even shot a real gun.
  686. 26:20>> She threw pretty much everything out on
  687. 26:23the table uh hoping something would
  688. 26:25stick.
  689. 26:26It was like like my child that tells a
  690. 26:29lie that everyone knows they're lying
  691. 26:32and they keep going.
  692. 26:33>> A little bit like a Roomba. When she
  693. 26:35hits a bump, she just goes another
  694. 26:38direction.
  695. 26:38>> And that was about to happen again.
  696. 26:41Story number three. Of course.
  697. 26:44>> Did you kill Travis Alexander on June
  698. 26:474th, 2008?
  699. 26:49[music]
  700. 26:49>> Yes, I did.
  701. 26:50>> We hear the term media circus. This was
  702. 26:52a media circus on steroids. She told me
  703. 26:55that he wouldn't die. He was like a
  704. 26:57Terminator.
  705. 26:58>> That's the word she used.
  706. 26:59>> Mhm.
  707. 27:00>> Yeah. He just He wouldn't die.
  708. 27:01[clears throat] He was like the [music]
  709. 27:01Terminator. That was her exact words. I
  710. 27:04never have thought in a million years it
  711. 27:05was going to be her admitting that she
  712. 27:06killed it.
  713. 27:12Yeah.
  714. 27:18When was the last time you opened this?
  715. 27:22It had to be after the second trial. I
  716. 27:25was juror number six on the Jodi Arias
  717. 27:28trial. Kevin was juror number 13.
  718. 27:33>> Jodi Arias case. Juror number 13.
  719. 27:37>> Being a part of it was definitely an
  720. 27:39interesting portion of my life.
  721. 27:41>> You had no idea what you were going to
  722. 27:43be in for.
  723. 27:44>> No. No.
  724. 27:52The hype outside the courtroom continues
  725. 27:54to grow.
  726. 27:56>> Justice returns.
  727. 27:58>> I just felt like I needed to be here. Um
  728. 28:00I was actually on a death penalty case
  729. 28:02as a juror. [cheering and applause]
  730. 28:04>> I was a general assignment reporter
  731. 28:06>> live late breaking investigative during
  732. 28:09the trial [music] in 2013. It was quite
  733. 28:11a quite a trial, something I've I've
  734. 28:13never experienced before.
  735. 28:14>> I just feel bad for Travis's family. So,
  736. 28:17>> I had never heard the term trial groupy
  737. 28:19until this trial. These are people who
  738. 28:21would just show up at the courthouse,
  739. 28:23outside the courthouse, hoping to get
  740. 28:26one of the few seats in the gallery that
  741. 28:27were available each day. [music]
  742. 28:29>> I I still wanted to be here. I just
  743. 28:31cannot believe even going through
  744. 28:32security would have been enough for me
  745. 28:34this morning, but to actually be one of
  746. 28:36the people that picked, I I still can't
  747. 28:38believe it.
  748. 28:39>> All of a sudden, I'm, you know, this
  749. 28:41celebrity and I can't even walk through
  750. 28:43these people and it's not really
  751. 28:45celebrity. I mean, my friend was
  752. 28:47murdered.
  753. 28:48>> It was pretty bananas. It was kind of
  754. 28:49like the Super Bowl of of of court.
  755. 28:56>> This was a very violent attack. There
  756. 28:59was a stab to the heart area. His throat
  757. 29:03was slit from ear to ear.
  758. 29:05>> Jodi Aras killed Travis Alexander.
  759. 29:09There is no question about it.
  760. 29:14The milliondoll question is what would
  761. 29:16have forced her to do it. It was
  762. 29:19Travis's continual abuse.
  763. 29:22>> This is not a case of who done it. The
  764. 29:26person who done it, the person who
  765. 29:28committed this killing sits in court
  766. 29:31today. It's the defendant, Jody. and
  767. 29:34area.
  768. 29:35>> Juan Martinez has wasted no time in
  769. 29:38showing us
  770. 29:40autopsy photos, showing us crime scene
  771. 29:42photos, showing us nudity. It was really
  772. 29:45a hammer over the head is now you have
  773. 29:47to carry the weight of the entirety of
  774. 29:49this trial
  775. 29:51from the early moments on.
  776. 29:53>> I went immediately into thinking
  777. 29:57we are in deep trouble here.
  778. 30:03One Martinez would spend months laying
  779. 30:05out the state's case with many witnesses
  780. 30:07taking the stand, detailing Jod's
  781. 30:09egregious behaviors, her jealous motive,
  782. 30:12her salacious texts, and audio
  783. 30:14recordings with Travis and the gruesome
  784. 30:16crime itself. But as he worked to expose
  785. 30:19her downfalls, Juan Martinez became just
  786. 30:22as much a character in this as Jod,
  787. 30:24catapulting this trial even further into
  788. 30:27the national spotlight. Even the defense
  789. 30:29attorneys played up to the camera a
  790. 30:30little bit, but nothing nothing like
  791. 30:32Juan Martinez.
  792. 30:33>> You don't know where you met her the
  793. 30:34second time. That's what you're telling
  794. 30:36me, right?
  795. 30:37>> I know approximately.
  796. 30:39>> Approximately means you don't know,
  797. 30:41right?
  798. 30:42>> If that makes you happy.
  799. 30:44>> Nothing here is to make the prosecutor
  800. 30:46happy. You understand that? Why don't
  801. 30:48you want to answer my question?
  802. 30:49>> When we were in deliberations, I said I
  803. 30:52would never want to be on the stand
  804. 30:54[music] and have him question me.
  805. 31:01Then you had the defense where Kirk
  806. 31:03Nurmy brought in witnesses to paint the
  807. 31:05picture. Jod was abused by Travis
  808. 31:07Alexander. He even called Daryl Brewer
  809. 31:10to the stand. Jod's [music] ex-boyfriend
  810. 31:12who she visited and borrowed gas cans
  811. 31:14from for her road trip.
  812. 31:16>> Do you know this lady here in the blue
  813. 31:18shirt?
  814. 31:19>> Yes.
  815. 31:20>> How do you know her?
  816. 31:22Um, I know Jod um because we were in
  817. 31:26[music] love
  818. 31:27>> during that time period. Did Jod ever
  819. 31:29act jealous at all?
  820. 31:31>> Not that I saw.
  821. 31:32>> Okay. Did you ever notice her being
  822. 31:35violent or having a violent temper?
  823. 31:38>> Never.
  824. 31:38>> You start to get into this [music]
  825. 31:40was she abused
  826. 31:42defense.
  827. 31:44Did you believe that at all?
  828. 31:46>> Yes. Personally, [music]
  829. 31:48when it comes to the verbal abuse,
  830. 31:50there's text messaging that happened in
  831. 31:53email.
  832. 31:55So, the leap for inperson verbal abuse
  833. 31:58is [music] not a stretch for me.
  834. 32:02>> Would you tell me where the testimony
  835. 32:04you're about to give will be the truth,
  836. 32:05the whole truth, and nothing but the
  837. 32:06truth to help you die?
  838. 32:08>> Yes, I do. Please be seated.
  839. 32:10>> Did you kill Travis Alexander on June
  840. 32:134th, 2008?
  841. 32:16Yes, I did.
  842. 32:18>> Why?
  843. 32:20>> Um, the simple answer is that he
  844. 32:23attacked me and I defended myself.
  845. 32:26>> I thought she'd stick with the the two
  846. 32:28intruders. Um, but I think somebody had
  847. 32:31to have told her at some point, uh, you
  848. 32:33need to try again. Like, this isn't
  849. 32:34working.
  850. 32:35>> Well, after the gun got went off, I
  851. 32:37thought, crap, because now he's really
  852. 32:39going to be pissed. I didn't know that I
  853. 32:40shot him. I thought I [music] shot a
  854. 32:42hole in the wall or something. Do you
  855. 32:43remember
  856. 32:46stabbing Travis Alexander?
  857. 32:48>> I have no memory of stabbing him.
  858. 32:52>> So, it appears then that your memory
  859. 32:53becomes faulty immediately upon you
  860. 32:55shooting him.
  861. 32:58>> Yeah, things get very foggy from there.
  862. 33:01It's confusing. There is like a huge
  863. 33:03gap. Like I don't know if I blacked out
  864. 33:06or what. I was I didn't want anyone to
  865. 33:09know that that had happened or that I
  866. 33:11did it. Were you crying when you were
  867. 33:13stabbing him? [music]
  868. 33:17>> I don't remember.
  869. 33:18>> How about when you cut his throat? Were
  870. 33:20you crying then?
  871. 33:22>> I don't know.
  872. 33:23>> You're the one that did this, right?
  873. 33:26>> Yes.
  874. 33:31>> You do not stay and stab somebody 27
  875. 33:35times and cut their throat um to escape
  876. 33:39someone.
  877. 33:42This thing has blown up. Oh yeah. And
  878. 33:45she loved it. Oh, she loved it. Because
  879. 33:47[music] people were writing her from all
  880. 33:49over, even out of the country.
  881. 33:51>> What factors influenced your having a
  882. 33:54memory problem?
  883. 33:56>> Um, usually when men like you are
  884. 33:58screaming at me or grilling me or
  885. 33:59someone like Travis doing the same.
  886. 34:01[music]
  887. 34:01>> She loved playing the role, so it was
  888. 34:03kind of like a game.
  889. 34:04>> She was very flirtatious. She would
  890. 34:06smile and look at people in the [music]
  891. 34:07gallery and look at the attorneys and
  892. 34:09she played that up as best she could. I
  893. 34:11remember sitting in the courtroom one
  894. 34:13day and I texted my wife, uh, I think
  895. 34:16Jod looked at me and my wife, who has a
  896. 34:19good sense of humor, texted me back,
  897. 34:21good luck with that.
  898. 34:25She was on the stand for 18 days. That's
  899. 34:28a long time to be on the stand. I I
  900. 34:31don't think you you know you can do
  901. 34:32yourself any good for being on the stand
  902. 34:34for 18 days. [music]
  903. 34:37Fear,
  904. 34:39love, [music]
  905. 34:41sex,
  906. 34:43lies,
  907. 34:45and dirty little secrets played a
  908. 34:47prominent role in the relationship that
  909. 34:51Jodie Aras shared with [music] Travis
  910. 34:53Alexander. Somebody was not going to
  911. 34:56make it out alive. It's not even about
  912. 35:00whether or not you like Jodie Aras.
  913. 35:04Nine days out of 10, I don't like Jodi
  914. 35:07Arias.
  915. 35:08That was a joke as we [music] went into
  916. 35:10deliberations of I don't like Jodie. And
  917. 35:13that that kind of that was amazing that
  918. 35:16that he said that.
  919. 35:18>> He stabbed him first. He wasn't dying
  920. 35:20quick enough. And she was afraid he was
  921. 35:23going to live. As he stumbles away,
  922. 35:25tries to get away. She chases him down.
  923. 35:28Then she slits his throat and then for
  924. 35:30good measure shoots [music] him in the
  925. 35:31face. She may cry now.
  926. 35:34The jury instructions have told you that
  927. 35:37sympathy is not to be considered.
  928. 35:40>> Something that was very unique in this
  929. 35:42case was that your jury asked a lot of
  930. 35:45questions of the judge.
  931. 35:47>> Boy, did we ever.
  932. 35:49>> They asked so many questions, it made
  933. 35:51[music] you think, wait, do did they
  934. 35:53actually believe her story? Is there
  935. 35:55some additional sympathy going on here
  936. 35:58that maybe they're feeling like maybe
  937. 35:59[music] she was abused?
  938. 36:01>> I was wondering did they do they believe
  939. 36:03her lies? Do they believe that [music]
  940. 36:05he hit her? Do they believe he abused
  941. 36:06her? None of them would look at us. And
  942. 36:08so we were I remember being very nervous
  943. 36:10because when they walked in, not one
  944. 36:12person, not one of the jurors that I
  945. 36:14remember would like even looked at
  946. 36:17[music] us. So were you thinking
  947. 36:18>> I was thinking they feel bad like this
  948. 36:21could be
  949. 36:22>> Yeah, this could be really bad. Was
  950. 36:23there a point in time where you're
  951. 36:25[music] thinking, I don't think she did
  952. 36:27this.
  953. 36:45When we went into the deliberation room,
  954. 36:47we elected a jury for Portman. He said,
  955. 36:51"Let's just take a straw boat and see
  956. 36:54how everybody feels." I believe that we
  957. 36:57were about 73. Seven for guilty and
  958. 37:02three that were a little bit iffy. And
  959. 37:04they were concerned about abuse. And one
  960. 37:07of my comments to them [music] was, "She
  961. 37:09always had the opportunity to pick up
  962. 37:11the phone and report it, [music]
  963. 37:14and she never did that."
  964. 37:16The defense had multiple experts testify
  965. 37:18about several psychological aspects of
  966. 37:21Jod. One of them said Jod was a victim
  967. 37:23of domestic violence, but she came under
  968. 37:26fire after admitting she only
  969. 37:28interviewed Jod and no one else in her
  970. 37:30life.
  971. 37:30>> There was no indication of physical
  972. 37:33violence between the two of them. So,
  973. 37:35she just basically interviewed Jod and
  974. 37:38took her story. And what do we know
  975. 37:39about Jod? [music] She makes up stories.
  976. 37:42Another psychologist said Jod had acute
  977. 37:45stress which led to PTSD which then led
  978. 37:48to amnesia claiming she could not
  979. 37:51remember committing this crime at all.
  980. 37:53>> So what if she has PTSD? Like how is
  981. 37:55that relevant? This wasn't an issue of I
  982. 37:58was psychotic.
  983. 38:01We talked about the timing from the
  984. 38:04camera taking the pictures of him when
  985. 38:06he was in [music] the shower as to then
  986. 38:08when she actually slid his throat and
  987. 38:11filling up the gas cans in Salt [music]
  988. 38:13Lake. Did she have enough time to get a
  989. 38:17gun? Did he have a gun? Hey, here's
  990. 38:19another lie.
  991. 38:20>> The state called their own psychologists
  992. 38:22to try and discredit everything the
  993. 38:24defense had presented about Jod's
  994. 38:26mindset. So, you had these two wildly
  995. 38:28different [music] psychological takes
  996. 38:30that the jury was going to have to try
  997. 38:32and sort out.
  998. 38:33>> Dr. Damarte [music] diagnosed borderline
  999. 38:35personality disorder. Stalking or
  1000. 38:37persistent pursuit type of behaviors
  1001. 38:40were evident.
  1002. 38:41>> One of the interesting things [music] we
  1003. 38:42did as a group is we put everything on
  1004. 38:44post-it notes and we littered the room
  1005. 38:47and the table with every observation and
  1006. 38:50piece of evidence that people saw along
  1007. 38:52the way.
  1008. 38:52>> How many Post-its do you think you put
  1009. 38:54in the room?
  1010. 38:54>> Probably over a hundred. There's too
  1011. 38:56many versions, there's too many things,
  1012. 38:58[music] there's too much evidence. We We
  1013. 39:00went home to sleep on it and make sure
  1014. 39:04that that's the decision we wanted to
  1015. 39:07do.
  1016. 39:10[music]
  1017. 39:11>> The longer the jury is out, that's
  1018. 39:13usually in the favor of the defendant
  1019. 39:15where they're either deadlocked or they
  1020. 39:18can't agree. It was really unnerving
  1021. 39:22because we're like, "Is it good they're
  1022. 39:24staying in there a long time? Is it
  1023. 39:26bad?"
  1024. 39:30[music]
  1025. 39:30>> The next morning, everybody came in and
  1026. 39:32said, "We're ready to go." And told the
  1027. 39:34judge that we had a decision.
  1028. 39:36>> State of Arizona versus Jodianne Aras.
  1029. 39:39Verdict [music] count one. We the jury
  1030. 39:41duly impanled and sworn in and the above
  1031. 39:43entitled action upon our oath do find
  1032. 39:45the defendant as to count one
  1033. 39:47first-degree murder guilty.
  1034. 39:53I believe I'm shaking. [music] I am just
  1035. 39:55so glad that the jury got this verdict
  1036. 39:57right.
  1037. 39:58>> We could see it from the windows. It was
  1038. 39:59just a sea of people and a sea of blue
  1039. 40:02in support of Travis.
  1040. 40:03>> Justice has been done and the next
  1041. 40:05person won't go and do that same thing.
  1042. 40:08I remember when we walked out, it just
  1043. 40:10erupted like it was insane. [cheering]
  1044. 40:15>> It was a little bit satisfactory to say,
  1045. 40:16"Okay, we came here, we did our job, and
  1046. 40:20there's a unanimous choice here."
  1047. 40:22>> And then everything changed.
  1048. 40:24>> Yeah.
  1049. 40:24>> I thought the hardest part is behind us.
  1050. 40:27Little did we know it [music] was not.
  1051. 40:28>> They came back pretty quick with the
  1052. 40:30guilty verdict for the murder
  1053. 40:31conviction, but the whole death penalty,
  1054. 40:34it's it's it's very different.
  1055. 40:38I remember walking out my back door
  1056. 40:40screaming,
  1057. 40:42crying.
  1058. 40:43>> To this day, I can hardly believe I was
  1059. 40:45capable of such violence, but I know
  1060. 40:47that I was.
  1061. 40:48>> When you have a capital case and death
  1062. 40:49penalties on the line, [music] there's
  1063. 40:51almost this second mini trial to prove
  1064. 40:53why they should or shouldn't be put to
  1065. 40:55death. During this sentencing phase, the
  1066. 40:58victim's family and the defendant can
  1067. 40:59address the court in [music] impact
  1068. 41:01statements. Travis's family did. So did
  1069. 41:04Jodie. Our minds are permanently stained
  1070. 41:08[music] with the images of our poor
  1071. 41:09brother's throat slit from ear to ear. I
  1072. 41:13never meant to cause him so much pain.
  1073. 41:15>> Travis used to write out his day on a
  1074. 41:17flash card.
  1075. 41:20The last one he wrote said to call
  1076. 41:22Steven.
  1077. 41:26I never got that call. When Steven said
  1078. 41:29he read on Travis's 3x5 card that it
  1079. 41:32said call Steven and that he never got
  1080. 41:34that call. I know that's because of me.
  1081. 41:38>> I don't want to have to see my brother's
  1082. 41:40murderer anymore.
  1083. 41:42>> Steven said he doesn't want to look at
  1084. 41:43his brother's murderer anymore. If I get
  1085. 41:45life, he won't have to. [music]
  1086. 41:50the the night before we started
  1087. 41:52deliberating, [music]
  1088. 41:53um, I was home alone and I was out on
  1089. 41:58the patio
  1090. 41:59and it [music] was it must have been 2
  1091. 42:013:00 in the morning
  1092. 42:05just saying prayers
  1093. 42:07and [music] that was the feeling that I
  1094. 42:10had is it needs to be the death penalty
  1095. 42:13and is [music] that the right decision?
  1096. 42:22That was a messy room that day. The
  1097. 42:25tears came up and the arguments came
  1098. 42:28out. But I think the other part was that
  1099. 42:31the jurors felt that she was a young
  1100. 42:34girl.
  1101. 42:35And the other was I think maybe that she
  1102. 42:38was abused [music] and you know that she
  1103. 42:41had a reason. And there was no changing.
  1104. 42:45There was absolutely [music] no
  1105. 42:47changing.
  1106. 42:49>> State of Arizona versus Jodianne Aras.
  1107. 42:52Sentencing [music] verdict. We the jury
  1108. 42:54duly impanled and sworn in and above
  1109. 42:56entitled action upon our oaths
  1110. 42:58unanimously fined having considered all
  1111. 43:00of the facts and circumstances. No
  1112. 43:02unanimous agreement [music] signed for a
  1113. 43:04person
  1114. 43:05ordered declared in mistrial as to the
  1115. 43:07penalty phase.
  1116. 43:08>> What were you personally feeling?
  1117. 43:10Failure. Yeah, it was one that we've
  1118. 43:14worked so hard and we've got to be able
  1119. 43:17to do this and that's what she needed.
  1120. 43:20She took his life violently. [music] She
  1121. 43:23was horrible, lied about it and it was
  1122. 43:26like that's what it has to be. Did you
  1123. 43:29believe Jod should die?
  1124. 43:32>> Yeah, and I still do. But it is
  1125. 43:35disappointing when you, you know, work
  1126. 43:37so hard for an outcome and it doesn't
  1127. 43:40come to fruition.
  1128. 43:41>> It was what it was and and [music] it's
  1129. 43:44t it took me a long time to say it was
  1130. 43:47what it was because I was very [music]
  1131. 43:51adamant that it was the death penalty.
  1132. 43:53The first round we ended up with a hung
  1133. 43:55jury because in Arizona you're allowed
  1134. 43:57to retry the penalty phase. So we go
  1135. 44:00again and it's months of testimony. So
  1136. 44:03his family has to go through this all
  1137. 44:05over again. [music] And then that time
  1138. 44:08it came back 11 to 1 for the death
  1139. 44:11penalty, which meant the second round
  1140. 44:14that she would if it wasn't unanimous
  1141. 44:16that she would automatically get life in
  1142. 44:18prison. She turned to us after she was
  1143. 44:23sentenced
  1144. 44:25and she looked at all of us and said,
  1145. 44:27"He was alive when I slit his throat."
  1146. 44:30makes me wonder why
  1147. 44:34she chose to add that detail at that
  1148. 44:38point. Why do you think it was?
  1149. 44:42I think [music] it was to be hurtful and
  1150. 44:46shocking. She knows exactly what she was
  1151. 44:48doing. Like she's incredibly evil. It
  1152. 44:51consumed my life. I mean, it completely
  1153. 44:54consumed my life. A lot of people had to
  1154. 44:56go through a lot of therapy after this
  1155. 44:58trial because it was so much
  1156. 45:01>> grew a stress beard is a lot of this was
  1157. 45:05just kind of internalizing what was
  1158. 45:07going on.
  1159. 45:08>> Wine, a lot of wine. I and there were
  1160. 45:12there were a lot of us that talked
  1161. 45:15[music] about how much wine we drank
  1162. 45:16during that trial. I mean, it was a part
  1163. 45:18of history, you know. I mean, it was
  1164. 45:20news all over. Everyone always wants to
  1165. 45:23know the killer's motive with [music]
  1166. 45:24Jod, and it might be kind of obvious
  1167. 45:27until I heard this for the first [music]
  1168. 45:29time.
  1169. 45:29>> I can't ignore the big fight that they
  1170. 45:31got in on the 26th, cuz it's everything
  1171. 45:35happens within a couple days of that
  1172. 45:37fight.
  1173. 45:43[music]
  1174. 45:45[singing] It is Sunday, June 22nd. I
  1175. 45:48just checked my work phone and I had an
  1176. 45:51email [music] that came in from the
  1177. 45:52prison. It says, "You have received a
  1178. 45:54new message.
  1179. 45:57The prisoner is Jodie A. [music] Aras."
  1180. 46:01I wanted to visit Jod in prison. That
  1181. 46:03was the goal. I want to get a feel for
  1182. 46:05her one- on-one, but her appeals team
  1183. 46:07shut [music] down any and all
  1184. 46:08conversation or involvement. So, last
  1185. 46:10ditch effort, I decided to email her
  1186. 46:12personally, thinking [music] she won't
  1187. 46:14respond. Months later, I got this. Hi,
  1188. 46:18Brianna. Thanks for reaching [music] out
  1189. 46:20to me. I would love for you to do a
  1190. 46:22story on my art and what I have done
  1191. 46:24with my time [music] at Pville, but my
  1192. 46:26lawyers are completely against my
  1193. 46:28participation with you at this time. And
  1194. 46:30I don't mean just you, [music] of
  1195. 46:32course, but in general. They're taking a
  1196. 46:34cautious approach to things as lawyers
  1197. 46:36are known to do [music] and have advised
  1198. 46:38me accordingly.
  1199. 46:40Also, thank you for reading my Substack.
  1200. 46:42I try to share exclusive content and I'm
  1201. 46:45always trying to [music] think of what I
  1202. 46:46can share with readers that they can't
  1203. 46:48find out elsewhere. I'm sorry I'm unable
  1204. 46:51to chat with you [music] about things.
  1205. 46:53I'll save your phone number in case
  1206. 46:54anything changes. Thanks again for
  1207. 46:56thinking of me. Take care, Jodie. What
  1208. 47:00Jod's referring to in her message to me,
  1209. 47:02she runs a blog from prison called Just
  1210. 47:05[music] Jodie. She's so detailed. I know
  1211. 47:07so much about her life now. like she has
  1212. 47:10a pet pigeon named April and she knows
  1213. 47:12how AI and updated technology works. She
  1214. 47:15also believes she still has knowledge
  1215. 47:16and wisdom to share with the world.
  1216. 47:20I identify as a straight woman if I'm
  1217. 47:22putting a label on it. I had a few by
  1218. 47:24curious moments in my youth. [music]
  1219. 47:26To appropriate Katy Perry refrain, let's
  1220. 47:29just say I kissed her when someone
  1221. 47:30asked. Jodie, when are you going to
  1222. 47:32[music] get a girlfriend?
  1223. 47:34A lot of things have almost begun that
  1224. 47:36don't get a perpetual state of not
  1225. 47:38[music] yet.
  1226. 47:39>> To me, a lot of it sounded so still so
  1227. 47:43self-absorbed. I mean, and so she's
  1228. 47:47almost trying to be professorial with
  1229. 47:49the world.
  1230. 47:50>> The juicy lie that I flirt [music] with
  1231. 47:51prison guards. They're called officers.
  1232. 47:53My friendliness with flirtation.
  1233. 47:55>> I've had a hell of a time recently. My
  1234. 47:57tablet wiped out. I'm sorry I left you
  1235. 48:00hanging. It's been rough. It's [snorts]
  1236. 48:02disturbing. I don't know how people see
  1237. 48:06that as okay. Uh for someone who's
  1238. 48:08destroyed so many lives [music]
  1239. 48:10to be able to continue to influence
  1240. 48:14others. She does not deserve the
  1241. 48:17freedoms that she has. I mean, what
  1242. 48:19freedom [music] does Travis have? And
  1243. 48:21really, like, what prison has she put
  1244. 48:23all of his family and friends in?
  1245. 48:28Jodie [music] is very smart and she's
  1246. 48:30very good at what she does.
  1247. 48:32>> So you don't think she was delusional?
  1248. 48:34>> No, absolutely not.
  1249. 48:35>> You think she was what?
  1250. 48:36>> She played a very good role. She was a
  1251. 48:39good actress. [music] She fooled us all.
  1252. 48:41>> Jod is a lot of things. There is so much
  1253. 48:43that makes up who she is. But Dr. Aaron
  1254. 48:46Nelson says there is one [music]
  1255. 48:47psychological diagnosis that appears to
  1256. 48:49rise above the rest and explains
  1257. 48:52everything.
  1258. 48:53>> Borderline personality [music] disorder.
  1259. 48:55She unequivocally
  1260. 48:58had a complete disregard [music] for the
  1261. 49:00life of Travis Alexander, for the
  1262. 49:03Alexander family. So that makes her a
  1263. 49:07sociopath. Uh does she fit?
  1264. 49:10>> I think in the beginning she totally
  1265. 49:13knew every lie like she [music] knew she
  1266. 49:15was lying. But with all liars over time
  1267. 49:19as they tell themselves over and over
  1268. 49:21and over again it becomes their reality.
  1269. 49:23[music]
  1270. 49:23I think she would embrace and immerse in
  1271. 49:27whatever character or whatever version
  1272. 49:29she was in [music] and she could do that
  1273. 49:32um with the depth that you know a great
  1274. 49:34actor takes [music] on the character
  1275. 49:37that they're representing.
  1276. 49:38>> I think Kirk Nurmmy said it the best
  1277. 49:40that Jodie has a line of [music] tragedy
  1278. 49:44behind her.
  1279. 49:45>> In 2016, Kirk Nurmy was disbarred after
  1280. 49:47writing a tell- all [music] book about
  1281. 49:49representing Jod, violating the attorney
  1282. 49:51client privilege. He is now a speaker,
  1283. 49:54TV personality, and stand-up comedian.
  1284. 49:57>> I mean, her attorney's not an attorney.
  1285. 49:59The prosecutor's not an attorney. Uh,
  1286. 50:02you know, like there's a lot of stuff
  1287. 50:03that has happened. So, it it worries me.
  1288. 50:06>> There were always rumors of legal
  1289. 50:09[music] misconduct that they were kind
  1290. 50:10of doing things that they shouldn't be
  1291. 50:12doing. Uh, rumors of Juan Martinez
  1292. 50:15having an affair [music] with a member
  1293. 50:16of the media. In 2020, Juan Martinez was
  1294. 50:19disbarred for prosecutorial misconduct,
  1295. 50:22including allegations he leaked
  1296. 50:24information to a blogger during the
  1297. 50:25murder trial, lied to investigators
  1298. 50:27about having a sexual relationship with
  1299. 50:29that blogger, [music] and communicated
  1300. 50:31with a dismissed juror. He was also
  1301. 50:34fired from the Maropa County Attorney's
  1302. 50:35Office after multiple sexual harassment
  1303. 50:38allegations.
  1304. 50:39>> That's so scary because it was one of
  1305. 50:41the jurors. I think it's so sad because
  1306. 50:43I [music] think that Juan's attitude
  1307. 50:47um his approach to cases was
  1308. 50:52>> he he just [music] grabbed him by by the
  1309. 50:54teeth and just shook them.
  1310. 50:59I still have days where I and I didn't
  1311. 51:02think I'd get emotional, but where I
  1312. 51:05miss him so much. Like if I could just
  1313. 51:07call him and talk to him and things that
  1314. 51:09are happening and like everybody that's
  1315. 51:11his age has families and you know his
  1316. 51:15children would be in grade school,
  1317. 51:17junior high,
  1318. 51:19and he didn't get to have any of that.
  1319. 51:22Um,
  1320. 51:26I miss my friend. Like, I've definitely
  1321. 51:30made Travis over the years. Um,
  1322. 51:34my two older boys have amazing memories
  1323. 51:36with him, but only up until,
  1324. 51:40you know, they were like
  1325. 51:43five and four. And I think of how what a
  1326. 51:47great impact he could have been on their
  1327. 51:49lives. [music]
  1328. 51:50>> From a psychological standpoint, what
  1329. 51:52are you thinking the motive is?
  1330. 51:54>> Abandonment, [music] betrayal, jealousy,
  1331. 51:57all of it.
  1332. 51:57>> All of it.
  1333. 51:58>> When he invited that other gal to go to
  1334. 52:01Cancun,
  1335. 52:04that was it with her. That was the straw
  1336. 52:06that broke the camel's back. If she
  1337. 52:08couldn't have him, no one could. She
  1338. 52:10wanted to make sure she had one last
  1339. 52:12time with him and then no one else. She
  1340. 52:14wanted to make sure she was the last.
  1341. 52:18>> What I don't have a good answer to is,
  1342. 52:20you know, why that day in June? What was
  1343. 52:23the [music]
  1344. 52:24catalyst right now? This day,
  1345. 52:27>> I can't ignore the big fight that they
  1346. 52:29got in on the 26th cuz everything after
  1347. 52:32that, everything [music] goes into play.
  1348. 52:35Like that's when she plans her trip to
  1349. 52:36meet Ryan. That's when she contacts
  1350. 52:38Daryl for gas cans. That's when she
  1351. 52:40changes her hair. She rents the car.
  1352. 52:43[music] She steals the gun. Everything
  1353. 52:45happens within a couple days of that
  1354. 52:48fight of where she's exposed. He says,
  1355. 52:51"I know exactly who you are. You're the
  1356. 52:52worst thing that's ever happened to me."
  1357. 52:54She didn't want to incriminate herself
  1358. 52:55by putting it in writing. And so that
  1359. 52:58had to have something to do with it. But
  1360. 53:00something about that fight, something
  1361. 53:02about what she did and that he knew and
  1362. 53:05that he was going to tell people who she
  1363. 53:07really was, like who, oh my gosh, this
  1364. 53:09is who Jod actually is. Um, that's when
  1365. 53:12everything like [snorts] went into
  1366. 53:15effect.
  1367. 53:16>> What is she talking about?
  1368. 53:18>> I have no idea.
  1369. 53:19>> Does anybody know?
  1370. 53:20>> No. She said she was going to tell him
  1371. 53:22everything over the phone, but she
  1372. 53:24wouldn't put anything in writing that
  1373. 53:25would incriminate herself. [music]
  1374. 53:26>> Do you know if she ever told Travis
  1375. 53:28anything?
  1376. 53:28>> I have no idea.
  1377. 53:29>> Only she knows what happened in that
  1378. 53:32exact moment was going on in [music] her
  1379. 53:35heart and mind. And and frankly, she
  1380. 53:37might have convinced herself of a
  1381. 53:39million different versions of that.
  1382. 53:40>> To me, I think she got the fame she
  1383. 53:41[music] wanted. I'm being honest. I
  1384. 53:43think she's in there and she's loving it
  1385. 53:45because never, you know, everybody's
  1386. 53:47going to know Jodi Aras.
  1387. 53:48>> You'll never kind of truly know who who
  1388. 53:51Jodi Aras is. She's done a very good job
  1389. 53:54of trying to maintain her own ideal of
  1390. 53:58who she is.
  1391. 54:08>> [music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Obsessed: Unraveling Jodi Arias | True crime documentary by Arizona’s Family (3TV / CBS 5) , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,101 words across 1,391 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.