YouTube2Text

Промышленная Революция - главный обман в истории человечества. — Transcript

by Другая История · 3,631 words · 587 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:08Ladies and gentlemen, another history
  2. 0:10myth has been debunked. Time and again,
  3. 0:12we read, hear in podcasts, and see in
  4. 0:14videos quotes of the same historical
  5. 0:17myth. Every advocate of AI and
  6. 0:19revolution, from Elon Musk to Sam
  7. 0:22Altman, claims in one voice that the 18
  8. 0:24th-century Industrial Revolution didn't
  9. 0:27reduce, but increased the number of
  10. 0:29jobs and made people wealthier.
  11. 0:32Therefore, neither we nor the AI
  12. 0:34revolution should be feared. Are you
  13. 0:37afraid that a robot will replace you,
  14. 0:38or not? Let us know in the comments.
  15. 0:41Our business is history, and from its
  16. 0:43perspective, these references by
  17. 0:45billionaires to the Industrial
  18. 0:46Revolution are a crude historical myth.
  19. 0:50And as you know, when we see myths, we
  20. 0:52immediately release a video; in the
  21. 0:54next few minutes, we will tell you how
  22. 0:57the Industrial Revolution actually
  23. 0:59turned into hell for the planet, with
  24. 1:01civil wars involving more people than
  25. 1:03the Napoleonic ones. Yes, yes, you
  26. 1:06heard that right. In fact, the
  27. 1:08Industrial Revolution didn't lead to
  28. 1:10paradise on Earth, as we are told, but
  29. 1:12to repression and conflicts of
  30. 1:14unimaginable scale, involving secret
  31. 1:16societies and the first organized mafia
  32. 1:18in history. It will be, as always, very
  33. 1:21interesting, and even more so with your
  34. 1:23like and comment on the video. And we
  35. 1:26will once again prove that history is a
  36. 1:28very useful science that provides
  37. 1:30knowledge relevant to modern times.
  38. 1:32After all, what is the main fear people
  39. 1:34have regarding AI? Of course, that AI
  40. 1:37will take everyone's jobs. To counter
  41. 1:40this, the billionaires profiting from
  42. 1:42AI constantly point to the 18
  43. 1:44th-century Industrial Revolution. They
  44. 1:47argue that last time, automation didn't
  45. 1:49decrease, but increased the number of
  46. 1:51jobs, wages, and the wealth of the
  47. 1:53working class. In one form or another,
  48. 1:56almost everyone has heard claims that
  49. 1:57AI will make everyone richer. And
  50. 1:59considering they are made by
  51. 2:01billionaires who are indeed getting
  52. 2:04richer, many began to suspect that
  53. 2:06there is a catch somewhere. You aren't
  54. 2:09mistaken, friends. There is a catch,
  55. 2:11and whether conscious or not, we are
  56. 2:13being deceived by someone quoting a
  57. 2:15historical myth. Although at first
  58. 2:17glance, everything seems just fine.
  59. 2:19There is a famous "hockey stick" graph
  60. 2:22that AI visionaries use to support
  61. 2:24their claims. It shows capitalism,
  62. 2:27happiness, and all that. GDP per capita
  63. 2:30stagnates for thousands of years, and
  64. 2:32then the Industrial Revolution hits,
  65. 2:34and boom, we live like kings. But there
  66. 2:37is a famous nuance, familiar to
  67. 2:38everyone. If the official eats meat and
  68. 2:41we eat cabbage, on average, we are both
  69. 2:43eating stuffed cabbage rolls. If Elon
  70. 2:46Musk subscribes to our channel, the
  71. 2:49average net worth of our 1.5 million
  72. 2:51subscribers would be $ 667,000 each.
  73. 2:55But that figure only comes from Musk,
  74. 2:57whose fortune is in the trillions. The
  75. 3:00same applies to the GDP "hockey stick"
  76. 3:02graph. If there are ultra-wealthy
  77. 3:04people, the average per-person figure
  78. 3:06will be inflated. Let’s not just take
  79. 3:09billionaires at their word and look at
  80. 3:11how things really were during the
  81. 3:12Industrial Revolution. The simplest way
  82. 3:15is to look at people's real wages.
  83. 3:18Let’s zoom in on the hockey-stick
  84. 3:20graph of GDP per capita and add another
  85. 3:22one to it. The wages of ordinary
  86. 3:25blue-collar workers. And we see a
  87. 3:27curious picture. Because since the
  88. 3:29start of the Industrial Revolution in
  89. 3:311770, the GDP per capita figure did
  90. 3:35indeed climb, but wages, uh, stayed
  91. 3:37flat until 1850, and at times even fell
  92. 3:42. The real kicker is that wages are one
  93. 3:45thing, but the ability to actually get
  94. 3:47them is another. Looking at the graph,
  95. 3:50we see that with the start of the
  96. 3:52Industrial Revolution, unemployment in
  97. 3:54Britain crept up, and with it, the
  98. 3:56number of poor people. Although, if you
  99. 3:58believe the myth, everything should
  100. 4:00have been the exact opposite. Wage
  101. 4:02growth begins around the year 1860,
  102. 4:06when the Industrial Revolution had been
  103. 4:08over for 20 years, while for 60 years
  104. 4:10of the first Industrial Revolution, the
  105. 4:12wealth of workers didn't just fail to
  106. 4:14grow—in certain eras, it even fell.
  107. 4:17Pause and let that number sink in. 60
  108. 4:20years is at least two, or even three,
  109. 4:22generations of workers. And so they
  110. 4:25lived in an era that businessmen today
  111. 4:27paint as a paradise on earth, even
  112. 4:29though for the workers of that time, it
  113. 4:31was a living hell. Wage growth for
  114. 4:35laborers actually began only after the
  115. 4:37Industrial Revolution had ended, and
  116. 4:39all that notorious GDP growth they cite
  117. 4:41now belongs exclusively to the
  118. 4:43ultra-wealthy. Welcome, friends. You
  119. 4:47have unlocked knowledge about Engels '
  120. 4:49Pause. That is exactly what historians
  121. 4:52and economists call this phenomenon. It
  122. 4:54is what utterly demolishes the
  123. 4:56historical myth that the Industrial
  124. 4:58Revolution made life better for people
  125. 5:00right away. It didn't. And scientists
  126. 5:04have reasons to assume that the
  127. 5:05subsequent wage growth isn't connected
  128. 5:07to the revolution at all, because
  129. 5:09during that time, ordinary laborers
  130. 5:11were rioting all over the planet. First
  131. 5:14stop: the Luddites. And you will be
  132. 5:16shocked by the number of historical
  133. 5:19parallels. At the start of the 19th
  134. 5:21century, amidst the Industrial
  135. 5:22Revolution, machines allowed factory
  136. 5:24owners to reduce the number of workers
  137. 5:27and cut the wages of those remaining,
  138. 5:29because there were plenty of hungry
  139. 5:31mouths waiting to take their place. The
  140. 5:33tip of the spear for British workers'
  141. 5:35discontent became Ned Ludd, who was
  142. 5:38nicknamed "General Ludd" by the people.
  143. 5:40According to legends, he began smashing
  144. 5:42the stocking frames that were taking
  145. 5:45work away from knitters. In reality, we
  146. 5:47cannot say whether Ludd existed, but
  147. 5:50the fact that a civil war began under
  148. 5:52his name is undeniable. On December 23,
  149. 5:551811, King Ludd publishes a handwritten
  150. 5:59order to all his followers. It strictly
  151. 6:02forbids reporting information about the
  152. 6:04destruction of factories to the
  153. 6:05authorities. For everyone from
  154. 6:07commoners to police officers, helping
  155. 6:09the state meant the death penalty. By
  156. 6:11March 6, 1812, The police report by
  157. 6:16John Sykes mentions how 30 armed men in
  158. 6:19masks arrived at a factory, held the
  159. 6:21workers under guard, and smashed it up,
  160. 6:23destroying 10 pairs of automated shears
  161. 6:25, one machine, and a pile of parts.
  162. 6:29This is no longer just a disgruntled
  163. 6:30worker breaking a machine. What we have
  164. 6:32here is an organized secret movement
  165. 6:35and actual armed raids. January of that
  166. 6:38same year, 1812, and another document
  167. 6:41describes how another group of armed
  168. 6:43men destroyed George Ball’s workshop.
  169. 6:46And for information about them, they
  170. 6:48offered an insane 200 pounds. Just for
  171. 6:50a second, the annual rent for housing
  172. 6:53for the wealthy class at that time was
  173. 6:5514 pounds. So we are talking about an
  174. 6:58entire house as a reward. That is how
  175. 7:00actively the authorities were searching
  176. 7:02for the Luddites. And this same
  177. 7:04document, for some reason, also states
  178. 7:06that the destroyed factory operated
  179. 7:08fairly, did not lower wages, and did
  180. 7:09not manipulate the market. It is as if
  181. 7:13the owner, after the devastation, is
  182. 7:14not outraged but is making excuses to
  183. 7:16the public, which hints that the
  184. 7:18Luddites 'actions found a positive
  185. 7:20response among the people. This was
  186. 7:22indeed the case. King Ludd and his
  187. 7:25supporters, among other things, claimed
  188. 7:27that machines were being used to flood
  189. 7:29the market with low-quality goods,
  190. 7:31funneling profits to the rich and
  191. 7:32depriving skilled people of work. The
  192. 7:35fact that the victim had to publicly
  193. 7:37justify himself confirms that public
  194. 7:39opinion was not on the side of the
  195. 7:41industrialists. On March 10, 1812,
  196. 7:45George Smith received a letter from a
  197. 7:47mysterious man who introduced himself
  198. 7:50as Lieutenant Ned Ludd, demanding that
  199. 7:52he remove the new machines from
  200. 7:55production nicely, otherwise 300 men
  201. 7:57would come and remove everything by
  202. 8:00force. That is something straight out
  203. 8:02of the mafia. And it is precisely
  204. 8:04because of this that another historical
  205. 8:05myth was born. This is how blatant
  206. 8:08villains talk, and the word "Luddism"
  207. 8:10itself entered dictionaries to describe
  208. 8:12people who blindly hate technology. Now
  209. 8:15, against the backdrop of the AI boom,
  210. 8:17the term is being resurrected and
  211. 8:19called "neo-Luddism." But in reality,
  212. 8:21everything was much more complex. The
  213. 8:24Nottingham Review of December 6, 1811,
  214. 8:27analyzes the goals of the Luddites in
  215. 8:29detail. And there, a government
  216. 8:33commission, mind you, comes to the
  217. 8:34conclusion that the Luddites were not
  218. 8:36protesting and tearing down all
  219. 8:38machines indiscriminately, but only
  220. 8:40those used to produce low-quality goods
  221. 8:42that took jobs away from people capable
  222. 8:44of making good ones. The list of
  223. 8:47reasons includes terms like "
  224. 8:49discrediting the trade,""unpleasing to
  225. 8:51the eye," and many others. This story
  226. 8:54is worthy of a separate video. It is
  227. 8:56important for us to note that the
  228. 8:58Luddites were not some kind of heathens
  229. 9:00or traditionalists calling for the
  230. 9:01destruction of everything new. There
  231. 9:04was a complex political agenda,
  232. 9:06although, of course, in reality, the
  233. 9:08lines between black and white were
  234. 9:09blurred. A striking example is the
  235. 9:12Luddite murder of industrialist William
  236. 9:14Horsfall. He owned the Wells Mill
  237. 9:16textile factory and hated the Luddites
  238. 9:19fiercely. Horsfall is credited with the
  239. 9:21phrase about his readiness to ride into
  240. 9:24the future: "Riding my horse knee-deep
  241. 9:26in Luddite blood." Ironically, on April
  242. 9:2928, 1812, Horsfall was riding his horse
  243. 9:32when he was shot by four masked men
  244. 9:34from the underground. Furthermore, in
  245. 9:38reality, the scale of the popular
  246. 9:40protests was so gigantic that, on one
  247. 9:43hand, a high-ranking Luddite wrote at a
  248. 9:45meeting in May 1812 that 400,000 people
  249. 9:48were ready to rise against the
  250. 9:49authorities over automation, with
  251. 9:51another million on the way. On the
  252. 9:55other hand, at the beginning of 1812,
  253. 9:5712,000 soldiers were deployed against
  254. 9:59the Luddites in Britain’s industrial
  255. 10:01regions. Just for a second, consider
  256. 10:05that this was more than General Arthur
  257. 10:07Wellington had in 1808 when he landed
  258. 10:08in Spain to fight Napoleon. And by
  259. 10:11August, including the local militia,
  260. 10:1335,000 people were already fighting
  261. 10:15against the Luddites. And they were
  262. 10:17indeed fighting. Adrian Randall, who
  263. 10:20wrote an article for Oxford, states
  264. 10:22outright that the situation differed
  265. 10:24from martial law only in that no one
  266. 10:26had officially declared it, though a
  267. 10:28civil war was raging on the ground, one
  268. 10:30that had gotten under the authorities'
  269. 10:32skin so much that they resorted to
  270. 10:34extreme measures. In February 1812, the
  271. 10:37House of Lords began considering a bill
  272. 10:40under which attacking factories was
  273. 10:42equated to a capital offense—roughly
  274. 10:44speaking, an act against the state, for
  275. 10:47which people were hanged back then. And
  276. 10:50that is exactly what happened. In
  277. 10:51January of 1813, a judicial commission
  278. 10:54was set up in York, where 64 defendants
  279. 10:56were gathered, 17 of whom were hanged
  280. 10:58right there. The British National
  281. 11:02Archives doesn't even try to hide it,
  282. 11:04admitting that the evidence of guilt
  283. 11:06was dubious and that all attention was
  284. 11:08focused not on justice, but on sending
  285. 11:10a signal. A report on the execution was
  286. 11:13specifically sent to all the troubled
  287. 11:14regions and posted on notice boards so
  288. 11:16that, as they say, it wouldn't be
  289. 11:17tempting to try again. But the Luddites
  290. 11:20had defenders in the big leagues as
  291. 11:22well. You’ve heard of Lord Byron, the
  292. 11:24poet, whose very name became a
  293. 11:27household word. Byronism is still
  294. 11:29classified today as a distinct movement
  295. 11:32in literature. And as for Don Juan, we
  296. 11:34hope everyone among our subscribers has
  297. 11:35heard of him. Although, in reality,
  298. 11:37Byron was a demonstration of how men
  299. 11:40would like to live if not for society's
  300. 11:42imposed stereotypes. He spoke in
  301. 11:45government, calling everyone idiots,
  302. 11:47wrote vulgar and not-so-vulgar poems,
  303. 11:49and then something clicked, and he left
  304. 11:51to fight in Greece during its war for
  305. 11:53independence, where he died—and is
  306. 11:55considered, for the record, a national
  307. 11:57hero of Greece. But right now, Byron's
  308. 12:00era in the House of Lords is what
  309. 12:02matters. It was there in February 1812
  310. 12:05that the lord spoke at the highest
  311. 12:07level for the first time. And
  312. 12:08immediately, he criticized the
  313. 12:09authorities and their measures
  314. 12:11regarding the Luddites. According to
  315. 12:13Byron, machines were only profitable
  316. 12:15for the owners, while people were left
  317. 12:16without work or means to survive.
  318. 12:19Instead of politics, Byron suggested
  319. 12:21looking at the economy and paying
  320. 12:22attention to the merciless poverty in
  321. 12:24the regions where the Luddites were
  322. 12:26active. In conclusion, Byron delivered
  323. 12:29a beautiful phrase that became famous:
  324. 12:31"The Capital Crime of Poverty." The
  325. 12:34Luddites 'capital crime, in Byron's
  326. 12:36view, consisted solely of being poor.
  327. 12:40Doesn't that resonate quite strongly in
  328. 12:422026, doesn't it? And yet, Byron was
  329. 12:45stating facts. Before the Industrial
  330. 12:47Revolution, in 1770, the unemployment
  331. 12:50rate in Britain was 3.7%. At the time
  332. 12:54he gave the speech, it was 7.7%. But
  333. 12:58after the Industrial Revolution, in
  334. 13:001842, it was 4%. The situation with the
  335. 13:06Poor Laws was even worse. In Britain,
  336. 13:08there had been a special decree since
  337. 13:111601, according to which the poor, the
  338. 13:14unemployed, and the disabled could
  339. 13:16apply for benefits. The Economic
  340. 13:20History Association notes a real
  341. 13:22explosion in applications after the
  342. 13:25start of the Industrial Revolution;
  343. 13:28from 1750 to 1803, the money spent by
  344. 13:30the government under the Poor Laws
  345. 13:33doubled, and by 1820, it had tripled. A
  346. 13:37truly apocalyptic scenario. Moreover,
  347. 13:40the British poor had become younger.
  348. 13:42The majority of benefit recipients were
  349. 13:45people between 20 and 59 years old. The
  350. 13:47share of the elderly, conversely,
  351. 13:49declined. And while in 1760 only a
  352. 13:51third of benefits went to men, by 1820
  353. 13:54it was two-thirds. In 2009, Cambridge
  354. 13:59University separately studied all the
  355. 14:01papers and modified that very hockey
  356. 14:03stick graph, adding adjustments for
  357. 14:05unemployment and poverty. Throughout
  358. 14:08the entire Industrial Revolution, and
  359. 14:11even after its completion, only the
  360. 14:13rich grew even richer. Ordinary people
  361. 14:16began to live poorer or, at best,
  362. 14:17continued to live as they had. Lord
  363. 14:20Byron turned out to be right. And it's
  364. 14:22not like the Luddite rebellion happened
  365. 14:24because life was good. And it wasn't
  366. 14:26just them either. In 1816 Britain,
  367. 14:29already suffering from unemployment due
  368. 14:31to the Industrial Revolution, saw half
  369. 14:33a million soldiers from the Napoleonic
  370. 14:35Wars return home. On top of that, the
  371. 14:37Year Without a Summer occurred, and all
  372. 14:40of eastern England plunged into riots
  373. 14:42collectively known as "Bread or Blood."
  374. 14:45In a letter, one of the workers of that
  375. 14:47era writes directly: "Either you change
  376. 14:48the rules, or we are going to fight and
  377. 14:50smash everything." And he writes this
  378. 14:54not regarding the government, but
  379. 14:56regarding the rich, who, he claims,
  380. 14:57drove the people into poverty with
  381. 14:59their reforms and promises of a bright
  382. 15:01future. In 1817, the so-called Blanket
  383. 15:06March took place in Manchester, during
  384. 15:08which textile workers rebelled against
  385. 15:10the dire situation regarding wages in
  386. 15:13their sector. And in Derbyshire that
  387. 15:16same year, they went further and
  388. 15:18organized a real pent-rich uprising.
  389. 15:21The culmination of the workers'
  390. 15:23indignation was Peterloo. An allegory
  391. 15:25for Napoleon's Waterloo, only for the
  392. 15:28workers, because cavalry crashed into
  393. 15:3060,000 protesters and dispersed them by
  394. 15:32force. There were even full-scale
  395. 15:35captures of cities. In 1831, workers
  396. 15:37seized the iron industry center of
  397. 15:40Merthyr Tydfil, which produced 40%of
  398. 15:42Great Britain's annual metal volume.
  399. 15:47They protested against low wages and
  400. 15:49the tokens used to pay them, which
  401. 15:51could only be spent at company-owned
  402. 15:53stores where, of course, goods were
  403. 15:55sold at triple the price. This, by the
  404. 15:59way, is one of the first cases in
  405. 16:00history where workers united under a
  406. 16:02red flag. What this means, we think,
  407. 16:05does not need explaining. What is worth
  408. 16:08explaining is that Britain was not
  409. 16:10unique. As the Industrial Revolution
  410. 16:13spread across Europe, the same events
  411. 16:15unfolded there. In 1844, weavers in
  412. 16:19Prussia rebelled, and during a shootout
  413. 16:22at the home of a hated industrialist,
  414. 16:24the arriving army shot 11 workers,
  415. 16:27while 24 others were severely wounded.
  416. 16:31In Switzerland in 1832, the weavers of
  417. 16:33Zurich Oberland demanded an end to wage
  418. 16:35cuts resulting from the automation of
  419. 16:38production. The protest quickly turned
  420. 16:42into arson, and authorities arrested 75
  421. 16:44people: Prague, Vienna, Paris, and even
  422. 16:46the USA. The same thing was happening
  423. 16:49all over the world map. And in France
  424. 16:52in 1831, the Canut revolts began,
  425. 16:54identical to the British Luddites.
  426. 16:58Again weavers, and again the demand to
  427. 17:00restore normal wages. And when a local
  428. 17:03cartel of businessmen refused to meet
  429. 17:05the demands, the protesters literally
  430. 17:07seized Lyon. Just for a second, the
  431. 17:10second largest city in France. Troops
  432. 17:12had to be brought in, and according to
  433. 17:14the Lyon Museum, up to 1,000 people
  434. 17:16died on both sides. The well-known
  435. 17:19Friedrich Engels calls the Lyon
  436. 17:21uprising of 1831 and the subsequent
  437. 17:24uprising of 1834, the starting point
  438. 17:28from which the history of the labor
  439. 17:30movement began. Actually, it is in his
  440. 17:33honor that the Engels 'Pause is named.
  441. 17:36So, historian Robert Allen decided to
  442. 17:38broadly unify the events that took
  443. 17:40place in Europe during the Industrial
  444. 17:43Revolution, because it was Engels who
  445. 17:45first systematically noticed them in
  446. 17:47his 1845 book, The Condition of the
  447. 17:49Working Class in England. Engels'
  448. 17:52figures and estimates have been
  449. 17:53adjusted in light of modern knowledge.
  450. 17:55And it turned out that from 1780 to
  451. 17:591840, GDP per capita in Britain grew by
  452. 18:0246%. But at the same time, wages only
  453. 18:06by 12%. Moreover, almost all the growth
  454. 18:09occurred in the final years after the
  455. 18:11Industrial Revolution. Thus, the claim
  456. 18:14of current leaders that this very
  457. 18:16revolution brought happiness to workers
  458. 18:18is a blatant historical myth. After all
  459. 18:21, it brought them nothing but suffering
  460. 18:23. But we still have one more question
  461. 18:26left. Why did workers 'wages finally
  462. 18:28start to rise closer to the end of the
  463. 18:3019th century? Here, almost every
  464. 18:32philosopher and historian has chosen an
  465. 18:34explanation to their liking. The
  466. 18:36conservative view was represented by
  467. 18:37economist Arthur Lewis, who called what
  468. 18:39was happening a perfectly logical
  469. 18:41process. In his model, as agriculture
  470. 18:43became automated, people flowed into
  471. 18:45the cities, where, as urbanization grew
  472. 18:47, businesses faced a surplus of workers
  473. 18:49and kept their wages low, since there
  474. 18:51were a million applicants for every
  475. 18:53opening. This is exactly the Engels'
  476. 18:57Pause, which, according to Lewis, ends
  477. 18:59on its own once the first wave of shock
  478. 19:01passes, production expands, and there
  479. 19:02are enough jobs for everyone. The pro
  480. 19:05of this theory is its logic. The pace
  481. 19:07of urbanization during the Industrial
  482. 19:09Revolution was truly staggering. The
  483. 19:11con: it is somewhat harsh to describe
  484. 19:1460-80 years of hellish, difficult life
  485. 19:16for ordinary workers as a natural
  486. 19:18process where absolutely nothing could
  487. 19:20be done. And in the end, urbanization
  488. 19:24continued to grow in the 20th century,
  489. 19:26not accompanied by any Engels 'Pauses.
  490. 19:29Therefore, a partial compromise was
  491. 19:31proposed by the aforementioned Allen.
  492. 19:34He admitted that automation simply put
  493. 19:36too much money into the pockets of the
  494. 19:38rich, which slowed down wage growth for
  495. 19:39the poor. But Allen immediately notes
  496. 19:42that the wealthy reinvested the capital
  497. 19:44they received into expanding production
  498. 19:46, and from there, everything followed
  499. 19:48Lewis’s model. There were enough
  500. 19:50factories for everyone. A labor
  501. 19:52shortage arose, and workers gradually
  502. 19:53began to demand better working
  503. 19:55conditions. As for the third and
  504. 19:58radical position, it was presented, of
  505. 20:00course, by Karl Marx. In his works, the
  506. 20:03problem isn’t that the economy failed
  507. 20:05to adapt, but that the Industrial
  508. 20:07Revolution birthed a bourgeoisie class
  509. 20:09that gained the power to leave workers
  510. 20:10out in the cold. And fend for
  511. 20:13yourselves. Marx believed that the
  512. 20:15bourgeoisie didn’t give a single
  513. 20:17thought to market laws or whether there
  514. 20:19would eventually be enough factories
  515. 20:21for all workers. In his view, they
  516. 20:23simply appropriated capital and walked
  517. 20:26all over the workers who produced it.
  518. 20:29And only when they needed to earn even
  519. 20:31more did the bourgeoisie open more
  520. 20:33factories and slightly raise wages, all
  521. 20:35while continuing to earn even more
  522. 20:37themselves using the same scheme. In
  523. 20:40one form or another, these three
  524. 20:42viewpoints were circulating in society
  525. 20:44even back then, and it’s not hard to
  526. 20:46guess which one won over the masses.
  527. 20:48Naturally, it was the one that explains
  528. 20:50everything simply, identifies a clear
  529. 20:52culprit, and offers a simple way to
  530. 20:54solve it all: take it and share it.
  531. 20:57Congratulations, you’ve unlocked
  532. 20:59humanity’s discovery of communism. It
  533. 21:01is sometimes called Marxism, but
  534. 21:03strictly speaking, it would be more
  535. 21:05accurate to call the ideology Engelsism
  536. 21:07. Marx, of course, is the main
  537. 21:10theoretical architect and author of*Das
  538. 21:12Kapital*, but Engels was something more
  539. 21:14than just his advisor and co-author. It
  540. 21:17was Engels who systematized everything,
  541. 21:20finalized the drafts, and presented
  542. 21:22communism as a full-fledged ideology
  543. 21:24that stands firmly on the foundation of
  544. 21:26the pause that the Industrial
  545. 21:28Revolution forced upon workers. Another
  546. 21:33historical myth is that the lowest-paid
  547. 21:35workers suffered the most during the
  548. 21:37revolution. It was actually the
  549. 21:39opposite. The main blow was taken by
  550. 21:42manual weavers. They were the artisan
  551. 21:44aristocracy of their time. After all,
  552. 21:46why automate something that is already
  553. 21:48cheap? Therefore, industrialists
  554. 21:50primarily sought to replace the
  555. 21:52expensive workers. And this, in part,
  556. 21:55contributed to the insane growth of
  557. 21:57Marx and Engels’ popularity, because
  558. 21:59these ideas weren't spread by manual
  559. 22:02laborers, but by the former elite—
  560. 22:04educated and often influential workers,
  561. 22:06who, ironically, had capital of their
  562. 22:08own. And Engels himself, in an even
  563. 22:11greater irony, financed his and
  564. 22:13Marx’s ideas using his family
  565. 22:15business—the very kind that was
  566. 22:17highly automated and kept worker wages
  567. 22:20low. But that is another story for a
  568. 22:23separate video. If you want to see it,
  569. 22:25let us know in the comments. And don't
  570. 22:27forget to hit the like button hard on
  571. 22:30this video so we know you enjoy
  572. 22:32segments like this. We will end here
  573. 22:34with the massive number of parallels
  574. 22:36that can be drawn between this
  575. 22:38situation and today. And that, friends,
  576. 22:42is precisely why history needs to be
  577. 22:43known and why you should support
  578. 22:45history channels. It's often said that
  579. 22:48physics and mathematics are true
  580. 22:50sciences because they can take a past
  581. 22:52result and predict how everything will
  582. 22:54turn out in the future. But history
  583. 22:56does exactly the same thing. And
  584. 23:00knowing it means being aware of
  585. 23:01historical myths so as not to become
  586. 23:03their victim. See you next time,
  587. 23:05friends.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Промышленная Революция - главный обман в истории человечества. by Другая История, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,631 words across 587 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.