【日本市場】不安要素だらけの高市政権。もしも積極財政で崩壊するならこれ 【マイキー佐野 投資】 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00It's changed to Liz Truss. And in 2022,
- 0:02she became a prime minister and
- 0:03resigned due to mental health issues.
- 0:06It's like a tripple down, and Liz Truss
- 0:09resigned after 44 days, and people are
- 0:11actually starting to compare her to
- 0:13Takaishi himself.
- 0:15Hello, it's Ki. I'll be recording
- 0:17another YouTube video today. I'll do it
- 0:19.
- 0:19Please. Today, I've seen it in articles
- 0:21, but a little while ago, when Geese,
- 0:24um, Truss, became prime minister, he
- 0:26made a lot of changes to the financial
- 0:28system, and things changed pretty
- 0:30quickly. It's been called the Truss
- 0:32shock, and there have been a lot of
- 0:34articles about it. And as a result,
- 0:36there have been a lot of articles
- 0:37saying that the current Takaishi
- 0:38administration is also making a lot of
- 0:40changes to the financial system, and
- 0:42that this could be a Japanese version
- 0:43of the Truss shock. There have been
- 0:45quite a few articles about it.
- 0:46Yes. I was a little curious about that,
- 0:48so I wanted to ask you about it. When
- 0:52Takahashi-san took office, he kept
- 0:54saying that Gareth Thatcher and Liz
- 0:56Strauss would be seen through either of
- 0:58their eyes, and that's still happening.
- 1:00He had been saying it since before he
- 1:02first took office. When Takahashi-san
- 1:04became prime minister, people were
- 1:06comparing her to Margaret Thatcher and
- 1:07saying things like, "You know what?
- 1:09You're like Margaret Thatcher." When
- 1:11Thatcher-san took office, people were
- 1:12comparing her to Margaret Thatcher and
- 1:13saying things like, "You're like
- 1:14Margaret Thatcher." They actually had
- 1:16something in common, whether it was in
- 1:17terms of political branding, finances,
- 1:19or sex. When Thatcher became prime
- 1:21minister, it was in the 1970s, and
- 1:23people often say that she was suffering
- 1:24from what's called the British disease,
- 1:26and that she was structurally stagnant.
- 1:28Thatcher was the one who demonstrated
- 1:30leadership in areas such as supply-side
- 1:32reform, deregulation of the private
- 1:33sector, privatization of North American
- 1:35companies, and labor union reform. In
- 1:37fact, Mr. Takaichi also said that
- 1:40Thatcher herself was a model for
- 1:42politics. Thatcher possessed this power
- 1:44of self-repair and self-production, and
- 1:46they are similar. What happened after
- 1:48the Taka administration came to power
- 1:49was this responsible and active fiscal
- 1:51policy, and things like strengthening
- 1:53supply capacity and strategic
- 1:54investment in cutting-edge technology.
- 1:56In fact, there was a big goal of
- 1:58investing 370 yen, but once specific
- 2:00things came out, the market comparison
- 2:02itself changed from being called
- 2:04Thatcher to Liz Truss. So, what is Liz
- 2:07Truss? She was the prime minister who
- 2:09resigned in 2022 due to mental health
- 2:11issues. In fact, there was market
- 2:13turmoil and a triple down, and someone
- 2:15did something really bad, like quitting
- 2:17after 44 days. Liz Truss and Takaishi
- 2:20themselves are actually starting to be
- 2:21compared. Let's talk about why. First
- 2:24of all, starting next year, the
- 2:25consumption tax will be reduced,
- 2:27especially for employees, and it will
- 2:29be temporarily zero. Then, there is the
- 2:31policy of raising the basic exemption
- 2:33for gasoline tax. This is good, but
- 2:35while they claim to be responsible,
- 2:37there is no evidence that it will
- 2:38increase revenue. During the Truss
- 2:40administration, there was a person
- 2:42called Quang, who was in charge of the
- 2:43Treasury, which is the equivalent of
- 2:45the Chancellor of the Exchequer in
- 2:47Japan. Quang actually published an
- 2:49evaluation of the Budget Accountability
- 2:51Office, an independent financial body,
- 2:53without any involvement. And this 45
- 2:56billion pounds was spent on this
- 2:58large-scale tax and, um, energy
- 3:00subsidies, and it is seen as similar.
- 3:03So where do we get those numbers from?
- 3:06Japan itself has a goal of fiscal
- 3:09health. A primary balance surplus means
- 3:11debt balance. Stability as a percentage
- 3:13of GDP. All of this has disappeared.
- 3:15This is where the problem of neglecting
- 3:18the major procedures comes in. There
- 3:21are concerns about a triple down, but
- 3:23what is actually happening in Japan is
- 3:25that long-term interest rates have
- 3:27reached 17%. They are rising. The yen
- 3:30is expected to weaken even if we manage
- 3:31it vigorously, so it has weakened. This
- 3:33is the situation we are in. Stock
- 3:36prices themselves are actually rising,
- 3:38but at the same time, the
- 3:39reconstruction price is falling and the
- 3:41currency is falling. When the crash
- 3:43occurred in September 2022, we can see
- 3:45that the pound, the international
- 3:46market, and stocks are falling. There
- 3:48are opinions that the early symptoms of
- 3:50this triple weakness are showing, and
- 3:51that this will lead to a tiger shock.
- 3:54When it comes to whether a Japanese
- 3:56version of a tiger shock will really
- 3:58occur, the discussion turns to no. For
- 3:59example, in the past, during Abenomics,
- 4:02there was an overwhelming difference.
- 4:04Abenomics was intended to escape from a
- 4:05long-term deflationary state, so money
- 4:07was lent out in large quantities at
- 4:09fixed interest rates. However, the
- 4:10current situation is the opposite. The
- 4:12consumer price index is rising rapidly,
- 4:14import costs are increasing rapidly,
- 4:16there is a labor shortage, and
- 4:18inflation has become entrenched. In
- 4:22fact, large-scale fiscal stimulus could
- 4:25overly stimulate inflation and cause
- 4:27prices to accelerate. In reality, the
- 4:30Bank of Japan has raised the policy
- 4:31interest rate and said it will increase
- 4:33long-term international borrowing in
- 4:35order to stabilize prices, but the
- 4:36trend is that it will reduce it. So,
- 4:38things are moving in the opposite
- 4:39direction. The current trend is that
- 4:41monetary policy and fiscal policy are
- 4:43seen as inconsistent, and trust in the
- 4:45central bank is declining, leading to
- 4:47an increase in international risk
- 4:49premiums, and there is growing concern
- 4:51about a potential shock. The article
- 4:54states that the government is currently
- 4:56expanding its fiscal scale, and that it
- 4:57will spend 370 trillion yen on growth
- 4:59investments in industries such as AI,
- 5:00shipbuilding, and the defense industry.
- 5:02The self-sufficiency alone is 42.8
- 5:04trillion yen. Of this, 17.7 trillion
- 5:06yen is calculated for a single period,
- 5:08and economic policy is 21.3 trillion
- 5:09yen. Since fiscal spending is not
- 5:11sufficient through increased tax
- 5:13revenue alone, it will have to rely on
- 5:15issuing international bonds. As I
- 5:16mentioned before, Japan is the one that
- 5:18creates the initial framework, and the
- 5:20lack of a medium-to long-term framework
- 5:22is a problem that will cause market
- 5:24confusion. Even if the government tries
- 5:26to spend money in the future, there is
- 5:27no clear path to repaying it. This is
- 5:29something I've often explained before
- 5:31using the concept of FTPL, but in
- 5:32reality, despite the fact that this
- 5:33financial crisis is not visible,
- 5:35investors are seeing the government as
- 5:36trying to force the Japanese military
- 5:37to fill the gap, which has led to
- 5:39selling of Japanese stocks and the yen,
- 5:40and the situation is such that prices
- 5:42are returning to normal after
- 5:43intervention. If there is no
- 5:45medium-term plan in place despite
- 5:47increased spending, the market will
- 5:49naturally become anxious. The
- 5:50government's policy also includes
- 5:52language that pressures the BOJ not to
- 5:54raise interest rates too quickly, and
- 5:56the market itself, seeing this,
- 5:58interpreted it as the government
- 5:59intending to have the BOJ borrow money
- 6:01to reduce interest payments on the debt
- 6:03and thereby release the national debt.
- 6:05I think this is an easy explanation.
- 6:08Now, when it comes to whether or not a
- 6:10trash shock will actually occur, I
- 6:12believe that if we compare the
- 6:14macroeconomic fundamentals and the
- 6:16microstructure of the international
- 6:18market in detail, Japan will not face a
- 6:20liquidity crisis like the United States
- 6:22. What I mean is that there are some
- 6:25fundamental differences from the trash
- 6:27shock, and it is true that the fiscal
- 6:29credibility may have declined. This is
- 6:31the truth. However, the problem was not
- 6:33there, but rather the debt-driven
- 6:35investment structure. When the
- 6:37situation was positive, in the UK,
- 6:39there was this DB, which is a defined
- 6:41benefit corporate pension plan, and in
- 6:44order to match the duration of future
- 6:46liabilities and employment assets, the
- 6:48UK introduced a lot of LDI, which is a
- 6:51type of international investment in
- 6:53near-leverage risk, called
- 6:54dilivaluation. The market size itself
- 6:57is said to be 1.6 trillion, which is a
- 7:00fairly high ratio to GDP. Following the
- 7:03announcement by the Ministry of Finance
- 7:05, the 30-year US international leverage
- 7:07rose sharply, rising 120 basis points
- 7:09in three days. The value of the LDI
- 7:12fund's deliveries suddenly increased,
- 7:14and in order to pay margin calls and
- 7:16issue cash as collateral, the LDI fund
- 7:18itself held UK government bonds, which
- 7:21are in cash. This was sold off urgently
- 7:23. As a result, there was a sell-off and
- 7:25the yield went up in a vicious cycle.
- 7:27This is the trend in the UK. However,
- 7:30in the case of Japan, defined benefit
- 7:32pensions, GPI, and life insurance
- 7:34deliveries are not managed with such
- 7:37high leverage to begin with. Therefore,
- 7:40interest rates are high. Even if there
- 7:42has been a recent decline, it was due
- 7:44to the margin call I mentioned earlier,
- 7:46so there is no need to forcibly sell
- 7:48international assets and raise funds in
- 7:50a major way. Therefore, the meaning is
- 7:53different to begin with. Now, I would
- 7:54like to talk a little bit about the
- 7:56academic aspects of the FTPL that I
- 7:57mentioned earlier. It is a framework of
- 7:59thinking called the Fiscal System of
- 8:01Price Model, and I have talked about
- 8:02this before. This is a concept proposed
- 8:04by Christopher Sims, a Nobel Prize
- 8:06winner in economics, and it was
- 8:08published in 2016. I explained it like
- 8:10this before. If a country's debt is too
- 8:13large, it will be difficult to repay it
- 8:15through taxes. If that is not the case,
- 8:17the yen will return to a weaker state,
- 8:19as I explained in the previous meeting,
- 8:21as an economic model. Countries with
- 8:23large debts like Japan basically put
- 8:25them on the back burner and, well, they
- 8:26just keep sifting through international
- 8:28debt. Naturally, the market will see
- 8:30this as something like, "Wow, these
- 8:31guys aren't going to pay it back," and
- 8:33then when international debt is sold
- 8:35off and the yen depreciates, it will
- 8:36become even more concerning. Unless
- 8:38this is fixed, the topic will basically
- 8:39continue to be a hot topic, and I think
- 8:41we will probably see another trash
- 8:43shock in the future. However, as I
- 8:44explained earlier, in the case of the
- 8:46UK, there was leverage, but there is no
- 8:49high leverage like in the UK. In the
- 8:51case of a trash shock, it was resolved
- 8:53within one to two months. The reason
- 8:55for this is that the British government
- 8:57and the central bank, the BOE, were
- 8:59sensitive to the market's reaction and
- 9:01wanted to make quick adjustments. In
- 9:04fact, the Ministry of Finance reversed
- 9:06the reduction in the top tax rate three
- 9:08days after the budget was announced.
- 9:10And Prime Minister Truss was confirmed.
- 9:13The plan was to freeze the corporate
- 9:14tax hike itself. After the withdrawal,
- 9:16five people, including Quarting,
- 9:17resigned from the Treasury. And then,
- 9:19this person called the Half Treasury
- 9:21came in, and this tax cut plan was
- 9:23almost completely withdrawn, and they
- 9:25proposed a solid medium-term fiscal
- 9:27plan to the market. This was said to
- 9:28have restored trust. And this BOE is
- 9:31the central bank. Since the EOA itself
- 9:33has the potential to destroy the
- 9:34financial system, until that happens,
- 9:36they decided to purchase long-term
- 9:38government bonds for a limited period,
- 9:39with a cap of 5 billion pounds per day.
- 9:42However, this purchase was revised to
- 9:44prevent interest rates from rising even
- 9:46if the LDA sold off. And what's
- 9:50important is that they announced that
- 9:52they would actually take short-term
- 9:53measures as a financial stability
- 9:55measure, rather than a tightening
- 9:57policy for the sake of price stability.
- 9:59Why was it so clear? The next point. So
- 10:01what did the BOE do the following month
- 10:03? It started selling the bonds it had
- 10:05purchased, and two months later it had
- 10:08almost completely sold off the bonds it
- 10:10had acquired. At the same time, it
- 10:12raised the policy interest rate,
- 10:14ultimately to 5.25%, and brought the
- 10:16inflation rate down from the 11%range
- 10:19to the 2%range. This is a fairly
- 10:20successful example from the Ministry of
- 10:22Finance, so if something like this were
- 10:23to happen to Japan, would it be able to
- 10:25respond quickly? In that regard, it is
- 10:27quite impressive. However, I wonder if
- 10:29something like this would happen before
- 10:32that. In my opinion, Japan is currently
- 10:35reducing its international debt and
- 10:37stopping the erosion of its debt. This
- 10:40is a step towards normalization, but if
- 10:42interest rates remain high and left
- 10:44unchecked, the burden of interest
- 10:46payments on the country and housing
- 10:47prices will skyrocket. Furthermore, if
- 10:49the international debt is actually
- 10:51reduced, it will be seen as a form of
- 10:53fiscal financing in which the BOJ is
- 10:54sucking money out of the market to
- 10:56cover the government's debt. As a
- 10:57result, the Japanese yen could lose
- 10:59credibility, which could lead to a
- 11:01depreciation. If reforms are to be made
- 11:03, then if they are to be implemented
- 11:04like the UK, they will need to convince
- 11:06the market that this is a temporary
- 11:08measure and not a filler measure, and
- 11:09that this is a clear condition. Things
- 11:11like the purpose, duration, and
- 11:13criteria for completion need to be
- 11:14indicated, and Japan is extremely bad
- 11:16at storytelling, so there is a
- 11:17possibility that this will lead to a
- 11:19complete collapse. When it comes to
- 11:24this area, the one who is really bad at
- 11:26it is Katayama. He is so bad at it that
- 11:28I have been telling him to stop talking
- 11:30every time since Davos, so I would like
- 11:32to see how Japan moves in the future,
- 11:33but in my opinion, it will not turn
- 11:35into a trough shock. Yes. That doesn't
- 11:37mean it's okay, but rather, I think
- 11:39it's important to strengthen the
- 11:40economic foundation. However, in order
- 11:42to do that, we need to be international
- 11:44and there are various issues, but when
- 11:46it comes to the trash shock, I wonder
- 11:49if it will actually go that far. Yes.
- 11:52Thank you all for watching until the
- 11:53end today. I'll try to summarize
- 11:55today's talk in a report, so if there's
- 11:56anyone who wants to receive it every
- 11:58day in an easy-to-understand format,
- 11:59please check out the official report.
- 12:01If you found today's YouTube video
- 12:03interesting, educational, or helpful,
- 12:05please subscribe to the channel and
- 12:06leave a comment. Well, there was a bit
- 12:08of talk in the main video about how a
- 12:10trash shock probably won't happen, but
- 12:12when writing an article, I think you
- 12:13want to focus on something that will
- 12:15have a global impact.
- 12:18People don't read articles because they
- 12:19don't care about power.
- 12:21There was a
- 12:21story about a 500 billion yen
- 12:23investment earlier, right? The Japanese
- 12:25government is putting it on the list of
- 12:27candy, but if you look at the content,
- 12:29it's actually surprisingly reasonable
- 12:30and has a huge positive impact on Japan
- 12:32. They don't talk about that at all. To
- 12:34begin with, the media is also at fault,
- 12:36but people only react to powerful words
- 12:38and only look at things that interest
- 12:40them. As long as this structure exists,
- 12:42I think the information itself will
- 12:44continue to be distorted. That's what
- 12:46makes it interesting. There are a lot
- 12:47of people who only read superficial
- 12:49information. They enjoy the fact that
- 12:51that's all they know.
- 12:52Yes, I enjoy that. Yes. I often
- 12:55hear that even on Yahoo News, people
- 12:57make their judgments based on what's at
- 12:58the top of Yahoo News, and I think
- 13:00that's the only way they get
- 13:01information.
- 13:03Oh, I guess that's how it is.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 【日本市場】不安要素だらけの高市政権。もしも積極財政で崩壊するならこれ 【マイキー佐野 投資】 by マイキーの非道徳な社会学, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,580 words across 405 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.