O QUE DEVERIAMOS TER FEITO DIFERENTE? — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:00Hey, everyone. It's been a while since
2. 0:02I posted a video here, hasn't it? Let
3. 0:04me tell you something; I’m going to
4. 0:06announce a change right now. I’m
5. 0:09going to do a live stream every day at
6. 0:119:00 AM, okay? So, we’re going to
7. 0:12hold lives on this channel about the
8. 0:14topics of the day. It’s good that
9. 0:15it’s in the morning so you can start
10. 0:17your day informed, knowing everything,
11. 0:19you'll send super chats, and we’ll
12. 0:21talk. Very cool. That said, when
13. 0:23there's a topic that I think deserves a
14. 0:25video, a standalone video, I’ll make
15. 0:27a standalone video. What do you think
16. 0:28about that? Let's, let's. Give it a try
17. 0:30. Let’s see if it works. And a
18. 0:31suggestion that was sent to me was this
19. 0:33video right here. American decay, the
20. 0:35new world, Renan Santos, MBL, the
21. 0:37elections in Brazil from the Arte da
22. 0:39Guerra channel. I don’t know what
23. 0:42this gentleman said, I don’t know if
24. 0:43he’s smart, if he’s stupid, if
25. 0:45he’s cool, if he’s not, if he’s a
26. 0:46friend or an enemy, but I was told to
27. 0:47watch this video. It has 78,000 views,
28. 0:50which isn't huge, but it's a relevant
29. 0:52video. So let’s see, right? Let’s
30. 0:54see what he had to say. Go ahead and
31. 0:56like the video, subscribe to the
32. 0:58channel, and get in shape. Link here
33. 1:00for the "your best version" challenge
34. 1:03so you can get in shape, brother.
35. 1:05Let’s go.
36. 1:06>> Fighter of good character, as our
37. 1:08audience generally knows, I rarely
38. 1:11address national issues. But what’s
39. 1:14happening is the following: the
40. 1:16geopolitical situation is so complex
41. 1:18that it’s starting to influence
42. 1:20Brazil, right? Brazil is starting to
43. 1:23realize that it is important in the
44. 1:26world. And all of this is happening in
45. 1:28the current scenario, which is a
46. 1:30scenario of decay for the United States
47. 1:31. Mind you, I’m not saying the United
48. 1:34States will end tomorrow, that won’t
49. 1:36happen, forget it, it will still take
50. 1:38some time, but I always say the
51. 1:40following: in 5 or 10 years you won’t
52. 1:43recognize the United States as it was
53. 1:45in its peak around the 80s or so. Why
54. 1:47is that? There is enormous income
55. 1:50concentration. Corruption has increased
56. 1:53a lot, politics has turned into a
57. 1:55patriciate that doesn’t care, that
58. 1:57governs with its back turned to the
59. 1:58American people, right?
60. 2:01>> In a way that, more than that, I would
61. 2:03add the following: the unipolar world,
62. 2:05post-World War II and post-Cold War,
63. 2:07with the United States dominating
64. 2:09everything, all narratives, all
65. 2:10propaganda, it’s over. I'll give you
66. 2:12an example of what's happening in
67. 2:13Brazil today. I, I, I go down to the
68. 2:15garage in my building, and I see a lot
69. 2:18of Chinese cars, a lot. Just yesterday
70. 2:20I went down and saw a cool little jeep.
71. 2:21I said, "What kind of jeep is this?" A
72. 2:22little Chinese jeep I'd never heard of,
73. 2:25you know? Uh, China is truly in full
74. 2:29expansion, right? In full expansion.
75. 2:31>> There is a decline of the United States
76. 2:33with several consequences, including
77. 2:35for Brazil. Why do I say that? A
78. 2:40probable defeat of NATO in the Ukraine
79. 2:42war is beginning to take shape. And the
80. 2:45situation in the Middle East isn't good
81. 2:47for the United States either, is it?
82. 2:48Iran has been humiliating the Americans
83. 2:51. So now, all that will be left for the
84. 2:54United States is Latin America. And
85. 2:56that's why we understand Donald Trump's
86. 2:58offensive. I don't know if it would be
87. 3:01different under a potential Democratic
88. 3:03government. Maybe it would change,
89. 3:05let's say, the way the picture is
90. 3:08painted, but it would be a bleak
91. 3:10picture all the same. And in this
92. 3:14whirlwind of events that will impact
93. 3:16Brazil, a very interesting person
94. 3:18emerges, this young man from the MBL,
95. 3:20who is now Mission, Renan Santos. Why
96. 3:24do I say that? Because for a new party,
97. 3:28formed mostly by young people, to come
98. 3:31in fourth place in the elections, ahead
99. 3:34of even Ronaldo Caiado, who is a state
100. 3:37governor, the state of Goiás, and has
101. 3:39been a presidential candidate. That's
102. 3:42leadership.
103. 3:43>> Let me say one thing, this is an
104. 3:44interesting point. People aren't
105. 3:46reading it, aside from the
106. 3:49Bolsonaristas, people aren't reading
107. 3:53the Mission's election result as a
108. 3:54defeat. It's just that we had high
109. 3:57expectations and it's frustrating
110. 3:59because, for instance, Renato didn't
111. 4:01win by, by man, by just a hair. Ana had
112. 4:05to move up, man, she was just a little
113. 4:06short. We won the seat, we got more
114. 4:09votes than the Novo Party. And Ana
115. 4:10isn't a congresswoman, a first-timer.
116. 4:15She only didn't become a federal deputy
117. 4:17because of a tiny bit, a tiny bit she
118. 4:19needed. It was, ironically, a very
119. 4:24unfair distribution of our own votes.
120. 4:29That said, that said, people are seeing
121. 4:32Mission as an impressive party. It
122. 4:36appeared just now with a tough
123. 4:38discourse, no money, and man, oh man.
124. 4:41Okay, let's go. Nationally, in the
125. 4:44agricultural sector, right? And Renan
126. 4:48finished ahead of him; that's no small
127. 4:50feat, it can't be disregarded. What I
128. 4:53see out there is a lot of people
129. 4:55viewing the MBL either as a radical
130. 4:57movement or in a cartoonish way. I
131. 5:00don't think it's either one or the
132. 5:01other. I think what's happening is this
133. 5:05: this youth, this generation, will
134. 5:07reach power sooner or later. I'm not
135. 5:09saying it will be Renan Santos, or that
136. 5:11it will be the MBL, but this generation
137. 5:13will reach power, because it's the
138. 5:14natural order of things. The current
139. 5:18generation governing the country won't
140. 5:20be there forever. Either they will burn
141. 5:23out, step away from politics, or
142. 5:25eventually fade away. It's normal. But
143. 5:28this generation, it will take the reins
144. 5:31of power one day, sooner or later. So I
145. 5:34think what needs to be done is to start
146. 5:37preparing these young people. I repeat,
147. 5:39I'm not telling you that those who will
148. 5:42govern Brazil in the future are the MBL
149. 5:45, Renan Santos, or whoever it may be,
150. 5:47but this generation, regardless of the
151. 5:50movement, will reach power. So I think
152. 5:52it's necessary to start preparing these
153. 5:54young people. Why? Because it's
154. 5:57necessary to explain to them how the
155. 5:58world works. For example, what do I see
156. 6:00out there? I get tired of seeing some
157. 6:01young people saying: "Oh, no, because
158. 6:03the United States is the defender of
159. 6:04democracy in the world.""They are not,
160. 6:06folks." The United States has already
161. 6:08overthrown several democratically
162. 6:09elected governments and has supported
163. 6:11several dictatorships.
164. 6:12>> I'll cite the first one that created a
165. 6:13huge problem even today, which is the
166. 6:15government of Mohammad Mossadegh in
167. 6:17Iran, in 1953. Mossadegh was prime
168. 6:20minister, he nationalized oil, he was
169. 6:22elected democratically, and was
170. 6:24overthrown in a violent coup d'état,
171. 6:27sponsored by the United States and
172. 6:29England. So, this story of saying that
173. 6:32the United States only overthrows
174. 6:34governments that are not democratic is
175. 6:35wrong, because there isn't just this
176. 6:37one case, okay? Peron had also been
177. 6:41democratically elected in Argentina and
178. 6:44was...was overthrown, okay? We have the
179. 6:48case of Jacobo Árbenz in Guatemala,
180. 6:50who was also overthrown. Even Getúlio
181. 6:52Vargas here in Brazil, okay? João
182. 6:55Goulart in 1964. These were all
183. 6:57governments that reached power
184. 6:58democratically and were overthrown with
185. 7:00U.S. interference.
186. 7:03>> So I need to tell the youth the
187. 7:05following: you have to realize that
188. 7:08American influence has always been
189. 7:10harmful to Brazil.
190. 7:13>> It's just that, Paulo,
191. 7:14>> always
192. 7:14>> I'm What do you call American influence
193. 7:17? Trade with the United States is also
194. 7:20a kind of influence, and this one isn't
195. 7:22harmful, it's beneficial. That said,
196. 7:23the United States thinks about the
197. 7:25United States. It's a thing, man, like,
198. 7:27it's a huge illusion to think that any
199. 7:29other country thinks about you,
200. 7:30especially Brazil, which is seen as,
201. 7:32like, trash, ah, some shitty little
202. 7:34Latinos there, some dishonest little
203. 7:36Latinos. "Oh, we'll go there to see
204. 7:39some carnival butts, okay?" Okay.
205. 7:41That's it. The world thinks that about
206. 7:43us, regarding
207. 7:44>> Brazil and other countries in the world
208. 7:46. That is the first thing I need to
209. 7:48point out to you guys. Secondly,
210. 7:50something I think will end up happening
211. 7:53is that these youth movements will be
212. 7:56lured by the old talk about pension
213. 7:58reform because people are living longer
214. 8:01, there's no money, etc. But as a rule,
215. 8:04every time a pension reform is carried
216. 8:06out, right, it's the worker who loses
217. 8:09and the banks that get fatter.
218. 8:11>> Yeah. It's just that, let's see. First
219. 8:13of all, the pension problem isn't just
220. 8:15that. The pension problem isn't just
221. 8:17that people are living longer, aging
222. 8:20more, right, and costing more because
223. 8:22they live longer. It's not just that.
224. 8:25The pension problem is also, number one
225. 8:27, the worst problem, poor management of
226. 8:29people. We just saw the Daniel Vorcaro
227. 8:32scandal involving pension funds.
228. 8:36Basically, people work, leave their
229. 8:38money in pension funds, and then these
230. 8:40guys pay political leaders to invest in
231. 8:42rotten bonds, get rich, and party.
232. 8:45That's it. That is the first reason.
233. 8:47The second reason is the following: a
234. 8:49change in the labor market. Our
235. 8:50rigidity in terms of labor regulation
236. 8:53with the CLT makes people seek out
237. 8:56informality. When a guy seeks out
238. 8:58informality, he has left the wheel. You
239. 9:00have a wheel spinning here. The one
240. 9:02from today works to support the one who
241. 9:04worked back then. This wheel is not
242. 9:07only being destroyed demographically,
243. 9:10but the very design of Brazilian labor
244. 9:13pushes this guy out, even if he's young
245. 9:16. The guy is young, he's a worker, he's
246. 9:20active, and he's out. Plus another
247. 9:22problem too, which is the young person
248. 9:24who is healthy and isn't working,
249. 9:26they're receiving "bolsa família."
250. 9:28There's a series of problems, okay? And
251. 9:31our suggestion is, it's not just about
252. 9:33swapping the bucket for the leak for a
253. 9:34bigger bucket, you have to change the
254. 9:36pension system. It has to be a mixed
255. 9:39system between capitalization and
256. 9:41distribution. That's it. It has to be
257. 9:43just a distribution system today. Today
258. 9:45, those working support those who
259. 9:47worked in the past. You have to add to
260. 9:49that the fact that you will work and
261. 9:52save money to build capital for the
262. 9:54future, okay? Let's go. The financial
263. 9:57sector is the one that ends up getting
264. 9:58fat. So I ask you, guys, don't fall for
265. 10:01it, don't fall for it. It is very
266. 10:04important that you stay away from this,
267. 10:07from this story of, "Oh, we're going to
268. 10:09do a pension reform and Brazil will get
269. 10:11better." No, Brazil will not get better
270. 10:13.
271. 10:13>> Yeah, yeah, actually, it's like this,
272. 10:15it's not that you'll just do a pension
273. 10:16reform and Brazil will improve. When
274. 10:17you signal, right, that you're going to
275. 10:19do a pension reform, interest rates
276. 10:20drop, because people immediately say: "
277. 10:22Whoa, these guys are being fiscally
278. 10:23responsible." That said, that is not
279. 10:26enough for Brazil to improve. It's
280. 10:28useless to have that, oh cool, the
281. 10:29interest rate dropped for this period,
282. 10:30and then not continue being responsible
283. 10:32with your accounts, right? So, oh, I
284. 10:34signaled I'll reform the pension, cool,
285. 10:36interest rates will go down, let's
286. 10:38reform the pension, great. But besides
287. 10:41that, I'm going to fight public servant
288. 10:43privileges, I'm going to modernize my
289. 10:45labor laws, I'm going to shift the tax
290. 10:47burden away from the production chain
291. 10:49and onto income. It's a series of
292. 10:52things. The fact that the pension
293. 10:55reform alone isn't enough for Brazil to
294. 10:58improve doesn't mean it isn't necessary
295. 11:00, okay?
296. 11:03>> There is absolute proof that every time
297. 11:06you cut these social rights, that you
298. 11:09decrease the worker's income, violence
299. 11:11increases. There are Gini index
300. 11:15calculations that you can research.
301. 11:17Let's go. It's not just that, either.
302. 11:19Oh, dammit, the guy gets poorer, he
303. 11:20commits more crimes. It's again, a set
304. 11:23of things. You end social benefits, but
305. 11:27at the same time you destroy the
306. 11:28police's investigative power. You
307. 11:31create criminal legislation to save
308. 11:33white-collar crime that interferes with
309. 11:35the guy stealing a cell phone, and that
310. 11:37guy also gets out of jail. You let the
311. 11:40Comando Vermelho, you let the PCC, you
312. 11:42let criminal organizations dominate
313. 11:43territory, dominate entire financial
314. 11:45sectors. So it's a set of harmful
315. 11:47incentives for Brazil not to succeed,
316. 11:50okay?
317. 11:52>> I won't go into the details of the
318. 11:54internet. And so, what is the biggest
319. 11:59problem we see? Youthful indignation, I
320. 12:02think it's a normal, necessary thing;
321. 12:04it's the renewal of ideas. It is
322. 12:07healthy for young people to feel
323. 12:09indignant, to revolt against the
324. 12:11conditions, against the contradictions
325. 12:13of our time. That is normal. My fear is
326. 12:16this group being manipulated as they
327. 12:18were in Nepal, right? Because these
328. 12:20revolutions are made, everything is
329. 12:22torn down, right? And almost nothing
330. 12:24new is born in its place. It’s the
331. 12:26truth.
332. 12:27>> Exactly.
333. 12:28>> I think that's why every conservative
334. 12:30is skeptical about revolutions in this
335. 12:32way. Changes must come in an orderly
336. 12:35fashion, right?
337. 12:36>> We must teach young people that a
338. 12:38country only improves through evolution
339. 12:41. If we keep perfecting this country,
340. 12:43we will get somewhere. I wanted to put
341. 12:46it to you folks as well, for the MBL
342. 12:48and other youth movements, the
343. 12:50following: for those of us with a bit
344. 12:53more age, a bit more gray hair, we saw
345. 12:55a movement that looked like you back in
346. 12:57the 80s. The movement was sensational,
347. 13:00the face-painted protesters.
348. 13:01>> Everything could change,
349. 13:02>> that's it,
350. 13:02>> what was happening, tearing down those
351. 13:04structures, starting over, refounding a
352. 13:06country, right? From now on everything
353. 13:09will be different, etc. The name of
354. 13:11that movement was the Workers 'Party.
355. 13:13>> It’s true. It’s true.
356. 13:15>> And look how it ended up. So, like,
357. 13:17>> it’s true. It’s very true.
358. 13:18>> It’s true. What you said is
359. 13:20completely right. You are absolutely
360. 13:21right. I thought you were talking about
361. 13:23the face-painted protesters, but no.
362. 13:24You are talking about the PT. It’s
363. 13:25true. What you are saying is very true.
364. 13:28The problem is that the PT emerged with
365. 13:31the wrong ideological foundations, okay
366. 13:34? Okay? So they already ideologically
367. 13:36defended things that didn't work. And
368. 13:37the PT, the PT movement was composed of
369. 13:40people with bad character, people of
370. 13:42bad character, right? Uh, who used
371. 13:44their influence for personal benefit
372. 13:47and not the other way around. The
373. 13:49difference with the MBL is that we see
374. 13:51a series of temptations around us and
375. 13:53we refuse all of them. So much so that
376. 13:56when we see, for example, Pavanato
377. 13:57getting 3 million votes, saying: "We
378. 13:59are going to refound Brazil," etc. It
379. 14:00is exactly the PT with the signs
380. 14:02reversed. What we do is the opposite,
381. 14:05because we are actually losing votes,
382. 14:07losing prestige, by denouncing
383. 14:09everything those around us are seeking
384. 14:11in deceptive temptations, right? That
385. 14:14is our profound difference. More than
386. 14:17that, we write down, man, our proposals
387. 14:19, we put something written up for
388. 14:21public scrutiny. I am writing down that
389. 14:24I want this. If I betray my proposals,
390. 14:26it will be very, very blatant. I wrote
391. 14:28one thing and did another, get it? You
392. 14:30are the Workers' Party of tomorrow. If
393. 14:32you don't do things the right way, the
394. 14:35correct way, in 30, 40 years there will
395. 14:37be another young person holding you
396. 14:39accountable. Why didn't you get it
397. 14:41right? Why didn't you do anything good?
398. 14:44You had power. So I think what's
399. 14:46appropriate, what should be done, is to
400. 14:49look at this youth and start preparing
401. 14:51them. It is very important. I think
402. 14:53it's healthy and interesting. A
403. 14:55leadership we have to keep an eye on,
404. 14:57right? You really have to look, it's a
405. 14:58phenomenon.
406. 14:59>> Just one thing, I'm seeing the name tag
407. 15:00Robson Farinazo passing by here now. I
408. 15:02am, I am very, very bad at this. Very
409. 15:06bad. This is Farinazo. So I, man, I am
410. 15:09a total klutz. I, man, am different
411. 15:11from Renato, who knows everything about
412. 15:13everything, about the smallest details
413. 15:15and minutiae of politics and political
414. 15:16influencers in Brazil. I know nothing.
415. 15:18I'm just meeting you now, man. Look how
416. 15:20interesting. I swear, I swear I hadn't
417. 15:22seen you before. I agree with 90%of
418. 15:24what you said there, man. To me, you
419. 15:27seem like a very intelligent guy, a guy
420. 15:28who is very, right? I don't know, I
421. 15:30don't know. Soon someone will come
422. 15:32along and say: "Oh, you're such an
423. 15:33idiot, Artur." This guy already cursed
424. 15:35you, Dani, but this guy, his analysis
425. 15:36is very sensible, okay? The MBL mission
426. 15:39right now is a phenomenon, placing
427. 15:41fourth in an election in a continental
428. 15:44country like Brazil, which is very
429. 15:46expensive. That's the truth. With few
430. 15:48resources, they managed to reach that
431. 15:50position. I have no doubts about that.
432. 15:53Now, what I see, I observe this a lot
433. 15:55on the left, is that they combat ideas
434. 15:58that aren't left-wing, aren't pro-Lula,
435. 16:01etc., as if they were wrong. Look guys,
436. 16:04it's not quite like that. It is
437. 16:07necessary to talk to the youth. I was
438. 16:09recently in Donetsk, in Donbas, which
439. 16:12are regions of Novorossiya, right? And
440. 16:16our guides were all young people around
441. 16:1830 years old. It's beautiful to see
442. 16:21this youth engaged in this political
443. 16:23struggle. Russia has been making a huge
444. 16:26effort, even more than China, and more
445. 16:28than Iran, to educate its youth,
446. 16:30provide them with a political education
447. 16:32, and prepare them for the future. When
448. 16:34you talk to this 30-year-old, there was
449. 16:37a young woman with me; besides Russian,
450. 16:39she spoke English, Chinese, and
451. 16:41Japanese. There was a Chinese man next
452. 16:43to me, I saw her talking in Chinese
453. 16:44with him, and I was, I was amazed. I
454. 16:46said: "How wonderful, right?" Uh, so we
455. 16:48need to involve the youth. I say this,
456. 16:50it's no use being antagonistic, saying
457. 16:52the MBL is this or that; you have to
458. 16:54sit down and talk to these people, okay
459. 16:55? So I’m going to make another video.
460. 16:58>> Hey man, look, uh, I’d invite you to
461. 17:00my pod—no, I am inviting you to my
462. 17:02podcast; I’ll send you a message on
463. 17:04Instagram, if you want to come on, we
464. 17:06can chat, man. I don’t know your
465. 17:09ideas, your convictions. We can agree,
466. 17:12we can disagree in a polite way. You
467. 17:14seem like a sensible, intelligent, nice
468. 17:16person. Uh, we can talk like that. I
469. 17:18think it’s good, I thought it was
470. 17:19really cool. Let’s see.
471. 17:20>> Yeah, maybe I'll make one or two more.
472. 17:21Let's look. Put in the comments what
473. 17:23you think. Whether you are against the
474. 17:25MBL, or in favor. You who are from the
475. 17:27MBL, also say what you think of all
476. 17:29this. And I make an appeal to the
477. 17:31people now who want to re-elect
478. 17:32President Lula. You have to talk to
479. 17:35this youth. This youth is extremely
480. 17:38important, not only in these elections,
481. 17:40but in those to come. Because what I
482. 17:44say, guys, I repeat, and this is the
483. 17:46mantra of my video: the youth will
484. 17:49inevitably come to power. It is the
485. 17:52natural sequence of life. So, we need
486. 17:56to prepare them. I think this is very
487. 17:59important. I talk a lot with young
488. 18:00people from the left, the right, and
489. 18:02the center. I think all of this, all of
490. 18:04this is very important. I think that
491. 18:06the statement by President Lula, when
492. 18:10he participated in the Flow podcast
493. 18:13last week before his elections, asking
494. 18:15young people to engage in politics, I
495. 18:17think it was crucial, but I think the
496. 18:19PT also needs to rejuvenate, okay? The
497. 18:23advice I give to the youth is the
498. 18:25following, guys. Make a great movement
499. 18:28of national reconciliation, but have
500. 18:31ideals. Don't be a young person with
501. 18:33old-fashioned ideas. I always say this,
502. 18:34I'm 60 years old. I have always thought
503. 18:37ahead, I have always thought about the
504. 18:39future, okay? The saddest thing in life
505. 18:42is when we see a young person, a young
506. 18:44person in their 30s with old ideas,
507. 18:46neoliberal ideas, rentierism, the
508. 18:48spending cap, all that nonsense, folks.
509. 18:51No country that is developing, if
510. 18:53>> Hold on, hold on. To some extent, this
511. 18:57is necessary. Is that what develops the
512. 18:59country? No, it isn't, but sometimes it
513. 19:00is necessary. The spending cap was very
514. 19:02necessary in 2016, but that's another
515. 19:04debate. Let's go.
516. 19:05>> You got stuck on these neoliberal ideas
517. 19:07. That's the truth. Go talk to a
518. 19:09Chinese person about spending caps, go
519. 19:11talk to them about a 14%interest rate,
520. 19:13right? Go tell them to strip away
521. 19:16workers 'rights to fatten up bankers
522. 19:17and they'll say you're an idiot. So I
523. 19:20end this video saying the following to
524. 19:23the youth: "Look, you on the left,
525. 19:25right, center, from below, from above,
526. 19:28you are the future. There's no way
527. 19:30around it, the country will be in your
528. 19:31hands. Whether you will do a good job
529. 19:34or not, I can't say. We can only give
530. 19:36advice, right, or at least say what
531. 19:38went wrong in my generation. But I'm
532. 19:40sure of one thing, just as your
533. 19:43generation holds mine accountable today
534. 19:45, and rightly so, 30 years from now
535. 19:47another generation will hold you
536. 19:50accountable if you don't do what needs
537. 19:52to be done.
538. 19:53>> Great video, you know? Great video.
539. 19:55You're invited. I'll send you a message
540. 19:56on Insta now. I hope you liked the
541. 19:58video. Comment below. Best regards.
542. 19:59Cristiado.