Où habiter en France pour survivre à l’effondrement ? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Global warming, pesticides, pollution,
- 0:03economic misery, crises are piling up
- 0:05and one might think that France is
- 0:06becoming uninhabitable, that no place is
- 0:08safe in the face of global collapse. But
- 0:10this is completely false, because in
- 0:12reality, there are hidden little-known
- 0:13territories in France that are resisting
- 0:15and that are perfectly adapted to what
- 0:16is happening to us. The question is how
- 0:18do these territories protect us from all
- 0:20these risks, what makes them so special
- 0:22and, above all, where are they? To
- 0:23answer these questions, I invited
- 0:25Guillaume Faburel, a geographer who
- 0:27participated in a report on where to
- 0:28live in France to cope with ecological
- 0:30crises.
- 0:31In this video, using maps and more than
- 0:3330 scientific criteria, we will see what
- 0:34are the three main conditions that must
- 0:36be met to be a region resilient in the
- 0:37face of collapse.
- 0:39We'll show you why only 15%of the French
- 0:41population will be able to live in a
- 0:43refuge area and, most importantly, at
- 0:44the end of the video, we'll answer the
- 0:46dilemma of what to do with the remaining
- 0:4885%who won't be able to move there. Do
- 0:50we abandon them or is there another
- 0:52option? But before we look at all that
- 0:54and reveal these areas to you, we need
- 0:56to go back to basics and explain why
- 0:58France, and its cities in particular,
- 1:00are facing collapse. Yoann is the limit
- 1:02, enjoy watching, let's go.
- 1:07It's
- 1:07>> often said that the carbon footprint of
- 1:09an urban and rural dweller in France
- 1:10would be roughly equivalent, but for
- 1:11different reasons. Without generalizing
- 1:13or overstating it, the issue of
- 1:15transportation weighs heavily in rural
- 1:17areas due to the need to depend on cars
- 1:19or to use fossil-fuel vehicles at the
- 1:20end of the thermal era, while for urban
- 1:22dwellers, it's the issue of food.
- 1:25Living in the city, it's complicated to
- 1:27produce what we need for our daily diet
- 1:29. Except that some things are going to
- 1:32change. As we've already noticed, energy
- 1:35is becoming scarcer, materially, there
- 1:38is compression, depletion, and
- 1:40ecosystems have changed.
- 1:43If we compare these two realities, we
- 1:44could say they are equivalent, but given
- 1:46their different determinations, the
- 1:48question of eating before moving around
- 1:49, I don't know about you, but it's
- 1:51perhaps a bit more important.
- 1:53And so, well, rural areas, which have
- 1:55less to worry about their own food
- 1:57dependency, perhaps and certainly have a
- 1:59comparative advantage, you see, they
- 2:01come back with an asset that they had
- 2:03not lost but that had been taken away
- 2:05from them.
- 2:07In this regard, I particularly emphasize
- 2:09urban lifestyles which are clearly
- 2:11impactful and penalizing, contrary to
- 2:13what is usually said.
- 2:16It is part of the preconceived idea that
- 2:18living in the city would allow for
- 2:20better ecology, particularly through
- 2:22energy savings or through some kind of
- 2:24sharing.
- 2:25>> Because for example, for example, we
- 2:26would not use cars compared to those who
- 2:28live in the countryside and so on.
- 2:29>> Exactly, let's take the example of the
- 2:30rural and carbon footprints.
- 2:33Except that there are rebound effects
- 2:34everywhere, there are massive
- 2:36infrastructures that need to be supplied
- 2:38, repaired, and extended endlessly.
- 2:40In fact, more than just a misconception
- 2:42, it is an error of judgment.
- 2:44And we should not make a second mistake
- 2:46, which is to consider that urban
- 2:48lifestyles stop roughly at the ring road
- 2:50or at the borders or limits of cities.
- 2:54In fact, it is an entire civilization, I
- 2:56don't like that term but nevertheless I
- 2:58think it is appropriate, which for
- 3:00centuries, even millennia, has been
- 3:02guiding us towards a determination of
- 3:04societies that have made the entire
- 3:06world in their hands.
- 3:08And I'll take this very concrete example
- 3:10today: the rural exodus of the 1960s was
- 3:11forced in France, people were taken out
- 3:13of the countryside and put in the cities
- 3:15, the countryside became a machine
- 3:16because the city was closed off like a
- 3:17factory, that's it. The problem today is
- 3:20that industrial and conventional
- 3:21agriculture is the direct product of the
- 3:23widespread urbanization of the world.
- 3:25And today, let's be clear, an example
- 3:28that for me highlights a second
- 3:30sacrifice of rural areas, of the
- 3:32countryside, is that rural areas are now
- 3:35being asked to accommodate all
- 3:36industrial renewable energy, wind farms
- 3:39, agrivoltaic parks, mega-methanizers.
- 3:42All of this has very urban purposes of
- 3:44consumption and electrification of the
- 3:45vehicle fleet, of consumption systems.
- 3:48So if we want to decently come back
- 3:49below planetary boundaries, we're going
- 3:51to have to divide our ecological
- 3:53footprints by four to six overall.
- 3:56Only self-limitation, self-subsistence
- 3:58and self-determination, in short,
- 4:00autonomy, would allow us to move towards
- 4:02that.
- 4:03And here, geographical areas do not
- 4:05offer the same possibilities. I'm not
- 4:07talking about determinism, but they do
- 4:08not offer the same capacities. As we
- 4:10have just
- 4:10>> seen, not all territories will be equal
- 4:12when faced with collapse and the need to
- 4:14live within planetary boundaries.
- 4:16Beyond the fact that it is imperative to
- 4:18change the system by leaving capitalism
- 4:20behind, some territories will be and are
- 4:21better suited than others to deal with
- 4:23what is coming. And this is precisely
- 4:25what this report produced by the
- 4:26post-urban movement of which Guillaume
- 4:28is a part explains.
- 4:29Over several months, they analyzed more
- 4:31than 30 criteria to see how they impact
- 4:33France and compiled them into three main
- 4:35categories: ecological conditions,
- 4:36subsistence conditions and habitability
- 4:38conditions.
- 4:40And when we put all of this together, we
- 4:41get this map.
- 4:43And yes, I'm intentionally blurring it
- 4:44out for you, because before I tell you
- 4:46about the seven areas that fit into the
- 4:47three main categories and explain why
- 4:49they are safe havens, I first need to
- 4:50tell you about a previous video that I
- 4:52published: the one on "Where to live in
- 4:53France to survive climate change?"
- 4:56In that video, I actually tried to
- 4:58analyze different maps related to
- 4:59climate risks, such as fires, floods,
- 5:01the RGA, and so on, in order to identify
- 5:03the safest area in France. And I came to
- 5:06the conclusion that, for the most part,
- 5:08part of the diagonal of the void was the
- 5:10best area because it was almost
- 5:11completely free of any risk. However,
- 5:13this analysis, in order to answer the
- 5:15question "Where to live in France?"
- 5:17"is actually incomplete because,
- 5:19ultimately, climate risks do not tell us
- 5:21at all about: is a territory resilient
- 5:23to energy decline, food production
- 5:25decline, logistics flows, and so on.
- 5:28In other words, climate risk analysis
- 5:30only answers the question" Is this
- 5:32territory? "Not" Can we live there and
- 5:34even live well there?
- 5:35"And that's where the other two
- 5:37categories that Guillaume identified are
- 5:39extremely important because they help us
- 5:40understand what constitutes a resilient
- 5:42and self-sufficient territory to cope
- 5:44with collapse.
- 5:45And what are the conditions necessary
- 5:46for the latter to function properly and
- 5:48live well despite the tensions that will
- 5:50be created by the scarcity of resources
- 5:51.
- 5:52If we take these two categories into
- 5:53account, we suddenly move from my map
- 5:55where only part of the diagonal of the
- 5:56void is liveable to this one.
- 5:58Seven zones with unique characteristics
- 6:00that make them refuge zones for tomorrow
- 6:02. Spread over 42 departments and 5,155
- 6:04municipalities. Yes, that's very precise
- 6:07. They currently have nearly 4 million
- 6:09inhabitants and in the future they could
- 6:11accommodate between 8 and 10 million at
- 6:13most in order to remain refuge areas, or
- 6:15about 15%of the population. Now, if we
- 6:17look at my map again, we can see that
- 6:19some others that I excluded, such as the
- 6:21hills of Brittany, Normandy or the Alps
- 6:23, are present on their map. And that's
- 6:25because no territory is perfect if we
- 6:26take the 30 criteria that they analyzed
- 6:28. In fact, the areas that they
- 6:30identified as refuges for tomorrow meet
- 6:32at least 24 of the 30 criteria.
- 6:35Then, there are other micro-areas like
- 6:36the Ardennes, the Vosges or the Jura
- 6:37that are not far from being considered
- 6:39refuge areas, but they lack a little
- 6:40something and we'll come back to that
- 6:42later.
- 6:43Because right now, in the rest of the
- 6:45video, we're going to develop the most
- 6:47important criteria in relation to the
- 6:48categories of subsistence and
- 6:50habitability, while going into detail
- 6:52about why the seven areas they selected
- 6:53perfectly meet the criteria.
- 6:56Let's start with the first category,
- 6:58subsistence.
- 7:00So, Guillaume, can you explain to me why
- 7:03>> local agriculture is...We can see on the
- 7:05scale of France, why could we produce in
- 7:07the south not be brought directly to the
- 7:09...And why is the question of organic
- 7:11farming also fundamental in the way we
- 7:13produce?
- 7:15>> Well, as we said earlier, one of the
- 7:16reasons why we're going to have to
- 7:18relocate production is the scarcity of
- 7:19energy.
- 7:22There are also other elements of
- 7:24degradation, like the production of
- 7:26resources, which means that our
- 7:28interdependencies are a geography that
- 7:31is going to shrink by necessity and
- 7:33obligation.
- 7:35So, we're going to have to produce
- 7:37locally, which is going to change diets
- 7:39, let's be clear.? We won’t be able to
- 7:41produce.
- 7:42We’ve gotten used to having avocados,
- 7:44guavas, coffee, or chocolate shipped
- 7:45from very, very far away.
- 7:47Well, there are two or three appetites
- 7:48that will be thwarted. But hey, I prefer
- 7:50to have a full stomach and survive, and
- 7:51then ask ourselves the question of
- 7:53tastes, but that’s something to discuss
- 7:54. It’s a debate that I’m starting
- 7:56quietly.
- 7:57We’re going to have to relocate, and
- 7:58that’s precisely a resilience card
- 8:00through proximity. And what about
- 8:02organic? Because, of course, organic
- 8:03doesn’t create more diversity.
- 8:06It’s adapted to the ecosystem, but it
- 8:08has a much lower impact and it thinks
- 8:09about regenerating the ecosystem, that
- 8:11is to say, ensuring systems that, when
- 8:12looped back locally, food systems that
- 8:14are sustainable over time rather than
- 8:16degrading them.
- 8:17And, broadly speaking, all the inputs
- 8:19that we usually use that aren’t organic
- 8:21, as everyone knows. That's why it's
- 8:23both about certifying and anticipating
- 8:26relocation and at the same time planning
- 8:29for activities that would
- 8:33make this relocation sustainable.
- 8:36>> We see, can you perhaps explain why the
- 8:38area around Paris is still very much in
- 8:39the red, which indicates a priori a low
- 8:41local resilience of production, and the
- 8:43same for Bordeaux, I don't know if you
- 8:45have any explanations for that. It's
- 8:47>> not the hinterlands that you see that
- 8:49will mainly serve Paris.
- 8:51The red that you see around Paris or
- 8:52Bordeaux is also for international trade
- 8:54.
- 8:55And so that's an indirect knock-on
- 8:56effect of metropolitanization, it's
- 8:58having enjoined yields that don't
- 9:00necessarily serve the capital or the
- 9:01large metropolises.
- 9:03So, one of the areas that responds
- 9:04particularly well to the food production
- 9:06indicator is the Alps and the Pyrenees
- 9:08for at least three major reasons that
- 9:09play a decisive role: agricultural
- 9:11practices that we have already seen
- 9:12elsewhere, livestock farming, fodder
- 9:14crops, even some cereals but mainly for
- 9:16animal consumption.
- 9:17There you have it.
- 9:19These are types of crops and agriculture
- 9:21due to the mid-mountains that are much
- 9:23better suited to local resilience and
- 9:25consume much less inputs, as we saw at
- 9:27one point with the phytosanitary
- 9:29products on a previous map.
- 9:31The second reason relates to the steep
- 9:33valleys and the water resource and its
- 9:35proximity, which plays a fairly decisive
- 9:37role here.
- 9:38Well, it is for the small dose possibly
- 9:40but to guarantee the sustainability of
- 9:42the crops through the water resource,
- 9:44but which would be more modest and less
- 9:46lulled by illusions about mega-basins,
- 9:47there you have it. And then we will have
- 9:49to get up early to imagine setting them
- 9:51up there. And the third reason, it again
- 9:53refers to the urban network that I
- 9:55mentioned in the area in question, the
- 9:57largest city, Gap, has fewer than 40,000
- 9:59inhabitants.
- 10:01If we go back to the general map that we
- 10:03saw earlier, we can clearly see that
- 10:05large urban areas are draining the
- 10:07surrounding areas through their
- 10:09demographic pressure and economic
- 10:11activities.
- 10:13We can clearly see that the urban
- 10:16network is small.
- 10:18There you have it, with Digne, with Gap
- 10:20...but the large Mediterranean cities
- 10:22are far away!
- 10:23They sometimes try to find resources
- 10:26there, but it is much more complicated,
- 10:28because the morphology and the
- 10:30agricultural practices are unsuited to
- 10:33the yields needed to feed populations of
- 10:36hundreds of thousands of inhabitants.
- 10:39>> So Guillaume, we have just seen together
- 10:40the importance of having food or at
- 10:42least food production close to the area
- 10:44where you want to live, but another
- 10:45resource that we must take into account
- 10:47is the question of wood. Can you explain
- 10:49to me why wood is so important and in
- 10:50particular what this map does not show
- 10:52us, if we can talk about the Bordeaux
- 10:53area, for example, and the megafires
- 10:55that have occurred there?
- 10:56>> The question of trees, wood and forests
- 10:58is the solution, it is the only solution
- 11:00. So, we will have to plant, but not
- 11:02just any old way and not to do anything
- 11:04.
- 11:05But wood can be nourishing, look at what
- 11:08Forêt Gourmande is doing.
- 11:11This is firewood, this is timber, it is
- 11:13a place of refuge, of refreshment, a
- 11:15place of imagination through refuge in
- 11:18particular.
- 11:19So, we cannot do without wood as a
- 11:22resource. The question that this map
- 11:24shows and does not show is that there is
- 11:26indeed wood and wood.
- 11:28There are woods that are monospecific
- 11:30and industrially cultivated. Any
- 11:32resemblance to the Landes de Gascogne is
- 11:33purely coincidental, as you may have
- 11:35noticed. On the map in question,
- 11:37diversity must be considered.
- 11:39We need forestry production methods that
- 11:42are sufficiently adapted, and
- 11:43regeneration for the reasons I have
- 11:45mentioned. So we should not mistake
- 11:47wishful thinking for excuses, and we
- 11:49should not be under any illusions about
- 11:51the 17 million hectares of forest in
- 11:52France.
- 11:54Some of them are unsuitable for
- 11:55sustainability or, in any case, are not
- 11:57included in an ecological sustainability
- 11:59plan.
- 12:02Nevertheless, this map combines all of
- 12:02that. We are adding an indicator, which
- 12:05is hedge density, which can supplement
- 12:11>> smaller plots, by the division of hedges
- 12:13, by the slopes and also by the meadows
- 12:15that they can sometimes create, and that
- 12:17hedges and slopes are ecological
- 12:18continuities, are also places where you
- 12:20can find kindling for heating.
- 12:24But in any case, they punctuate a
- 12:25history that, locally, is still on a
- 12:27scale, uh, not excessive to produce, as
- 12:28a result, crops, as I mentioned earlier
- 12:30, grassland, fodder, mixed farming and
- 12:32livestock farming.
- 12:33Anyway, I won't go over everything I
- 12:35said: they are, particularly in these
- 12:37wooded areas, in this case, if we look
- 12:39at the map, the whole of the Great West
- 12:41, part of the Center, are clearly wooded
- 12:43.
- 12:44I'll open a parenthesis for you, there
- 12:46are areas that were ready to be included
- 12:47in the 7, but which at one time were not
- 12:49included because of clear-cutting,
- 12:51because of the forests that tend to be
- 12:52cut down, I'm thinking in particular of
- 12:54part of the Vosges. I'll close the
- 12:56parenthesis. And so the area that
- 12:58emerges from the cross-reference, there
- 13:00is not just one, in fact all of them are
- 13:02directly concerned, it is even the first
- 13:04parameter that explains the delimitation
- 13:06of the areas that we have highlighted,
- 13:08it is the rate of afforestation and
- 13:10diversity. And the issue of hedgerows
- 13:12with hedges, I was talking about the
- 13:13hills of Brittany, Poitou and so on and
- 13:14so forth. Overall, on a French scale, as
- 13:16I told you, there are a lot of forests,
- 13:18but you have to look at it twice, it is
- 13:20about 32%of the French surface area, the
- 13:22forest cover in France. In the areas in
- 13:24question, it is more than 40%, the first
- 13:25element. The 4 of the 7 are particularly
- 13:28contributory to this percentage.
- 13:31Then, there is also a 20%diversity per
- 13:34hectare.
- 13:35This is an indicator that is used to see
- 13:38precisely the mix that can occur and the
- 13:40multi-specificity.
- 13:43Finally, there is one last element,
- 13:45there is a lot of private property in 4
- 13:48of the 7 areas, the mountain or
- 13:50mid-mountain areas. I'm not talking
- 13:52about the large public domains, as far
- 13:53as the eye can see.
- 13:55And there is a renewal that will be seen
- 13:56, there is a transfer announced over the
- 13:58next 30 years, we are talking about the
- 13:59large transfer of real estate ownership
- 14:01, which means that billions of euros
- 14:03will pass through inheritance in
- 14:04particular.
- 14:05And well, for the forest plots in the
- 14:07mid-mountain areas, there is also a
- 14:09transfer, we talk about it much less.
- 14:11And it also seemed important to us to
- 14:13plan or to plan for 30 years, because
- 14:14this question will arise and it is
- 14:16perhaps a way for those interested,
- 14:18those who would like to come and settle
- 14:20there.
- 14:21We will come back to this at some point
- 14:23, since it is about rebalancing, and
- 14:26well, this would perhaps be a way
- 14:28through citizen initiatives, like forest
- 14:30groups, citizen forest groups, to settle
- 14:32, uh, with the idea of preserving forest
- 14:35resources, and more broadly for what I
- 14:37was saying, because it is not just a
- 14:39resource of wood, it is, uh, a way of
- 14:41living in these places.
- 14:44>> The two most important criteria for
- 14:46having a resilient territory are those
- 14:48of food and wood in order to be able to
- 14:50feed oneself, have biodiversity,
- 14:52renewable building materials and heating
- 14:54. But in the study of the post-urban
- 14:55movement, they also integrated something
- 14:57else that I found extremely interesting
- 14:58, which is the high mining potential of
- 15:00the territory. So, the goal is not to be
- 15:02self-sufficient in rare earths to
- 15:03produce solar energy or be
- 15:04self-sufficient in electricity, but
- 15:06rather to have resources to repair tools
- 15:08, buildings, engines and networks
- 15:09locally. Basically, less lithium, nickel
- 15:12, cobalt, rare earths and more copper,
- 15:14zinc, lead, iron. Essential materials
- 15:16for farming and craft activities and not
- 15:18for the headlong rush towards digital
- 15:20technology or industrial renewable
- 15:21energy. Now that we've said that and we
- 15:23have a territory that allows us to
- 15:25provide for our needs, the question
- 15:26arises of how to live well there in the
- 15:28long term. The last major category to
- 15:30take into account is that of
- 15:31habitability.
- 15:35One of the criteria that we must also
- 15:37take into account when considering where
- 15:38to live, once again, is the local
- 15:40population density. Can you explain to
- 15:42me why that is? And we'll come back to
- 15:44vacant housing later, why that's also
- 15:46another major issue that we must think
- 15:48about.
- 15:49>> Well, if it's a question of rebalancing
- 15:50the population, demographically, well
- 15:52France is very unbalanced. It's also one
- 15:54of the most unbalanced countries. The
- 15:57Parisian macrocephaly and henceforth the
- 15:59metropolises have a significant impact.
- 16:01Overall, as a reminder, a third of
- 16:03French people live in metropolises, a
- 16:04third in so-called medium-sized or
- 16:06intermediate cities and a third in small
- 16:08towns and rural areas.
- 16:09So there are more than 22 million
- 16:11metropolitan residents, that's a lot of
- 16:12weight, and let's not even talk about
- 16:14the Paris basin or the Parisian
- 16:15agglomeration.
- 16:17So one of the reasons is that you see on
- 16:19the map the shimmering diagonal of
- 16:21emptiness, right?
- 16:23From northeast to southwest.
- 16:25I say shimmering because institutions
- 16:27have a slight tendency to name things in
- 16:28a somewhat disparaging way. There you
- 16:30have it.
- 16:31This diagonal is not empty, there are
- 16:32still people who live there, there are
- 16:33still cultures. Indeed, uh, its
- 16:34population has declined, but it has
- 16:36stabilized over the last 30 or 40 years
- 16:38depending on the location. So, the
- 16:40decline has been slowed down. The
- 16:41decline exists in itself, right?
- 16:43It creates space, it opens up
- 16:45possibilities. So, to relocate, to
- 16:47re-establish oneself. The thing is, it
- 16:49can't be done solely or especially not
- 16:51through artificialization and
- 16:53residential areas.
- 16:54So, we would come and open up, build,
- 16:56and move into our little house with our
- 16:58own square lawn, which we would mow
- 17:00about three times a month, which is
- 17:01three times too many. Let's be clear, we
- 17:04have to stop mowing. So, the issue of
- 17:05vacant housing arose.
- 17:07We had to cross-reference this with the
- 17:09accommodation capacities, that is to say
- 17:11, to come and settle without it having
- 17:12an additional impact, it increases the
- 17:14footprints already specific to the
- 17:16territory.
- 17:17That's where we find the shimmering
- 17:19diagonal of emptiness, which was renamed
- 17:22the diagonal of low density. I must say
- 17:24, in all honesty, that INSEE changed its
- 17:27vocabulary late.
- 17:29But we can clearly see that there is
- 17:31vacant housing, in France, more than 3
- 17:33million vacant homes.
- 17:35For information, let's get an idea. You
- 17:38have more than 3.2 million second homes
- 17:40, you have more than 1.3 million
- 17:41furnished tourist accommodations that
- 17:43are dormant for about 10 months of the
- 17:45year.
- 17:46You have more than 6 million that are
- 17:48underoccupied. In short, there are 37
- 17:50million homes for 68 million inhabitants
- 17:52.
- 17:52We don't have a shortage problem, except
- 17:54in certain places because we want to
- 17:55concentrate everything, i.e. the big
- 17:56cities. We have a distribution problem.
- 17:59Hence the question of vacant housing as
- 18:01a potential.
- 18:02I must also say, in terms of scientific
- 18:04ethics and intellectual honesty, that of
- 18:07the 3.2 million vacant homes, some are
- 18:09dilapidated and so on.
- 18:11However, a good half of them can be
- 18:13restored fairly quickly provided that
- 18:14the market is freed up. I'll close the
- 18:16parenthesis. So, in fact, the two
- 18:18cross-references were to determine what
- 18:20the accommodation capacities are at a
- 18:22constant level of pressure, at least
- 18:24around housing. So, among the 7 areas
- 18:27that we have identified, this area
- 18:28stands out.
- 18:30It has one of the lowest densities in
- 18:32France. Here, in the Morvan massif
- 18:33itself, there are 15 to 20 inhabitants.
- 18:35The national average is over 100, but
- 18:37this includes all the spaces known as
- 18:38the diagonal of emptiness.
- 18:40So, in metropolitan urban areas, believe
- 18:42me, it amounts to thousands per square
- 18:44kilometer.
- 18:45So here, one of the lowest densities
- 18:47among the 7 zones, it is the one with
- 18:49the most vacant housing, more than 11%,
- 18:51the national average is 7.2%. So there
- 18:54is real capacity.
- 18:55And we insisted on the fact that the
- 18:56Morvan massif, which gave its name to a
- 18:58larger area, has the historical
- 19:00distinction of having been one of the
- 19:01main areas used by Paris.
- 19:03That's particularly true for the issue
- 19:04of wood. But not only that.
- 19:05It also seems to us to always be in the
- 19:07idea of thinking about the evolution of
- 19:09a debate.
- 19:12It always seems interesting to us to
- 19:14highlight, without exaggerating since it
- 19:17emerged from cross-referenced data, an
- 19:19area that for a long time has been
- 19:22subject to forms of depredation.
- 19:24That's very Parisian and metropolitan
- 19:27colonialism in this case.
- 19:30And that perhaps it is not that history
- 19:32is turning around, it is not a question
- 19:34of opposing fronts, but that the
- 19:36ecological issue, the issue of wood, in
- 19:39this case the Morvan massif is known for
- 19:41that, reflects a historical evolution
- 19:43for ecological reasons.
- 19:46So it is both a question of
- 19:47accommodation capacities but at the same
- 19:50time a reversal, an inversion of the
- 19:52very function of the area thus
- 19:54highlighted by the indicators that we
- 19:56have cross-referenced.
- 19:57>> Another criterion to take into account
- 19:59is the unequal areas as you called them
- 20:01in your study. Why is this a thing? Is
- 20:04it serious to have unequal areas in the
- 20:05logic of where is it necessary?
- 20:08>> From our point of view, there are two
- 20:09reasons that implied taking this
- 20:10indicator for its environmental effects
- 20:12in particular.
- 20:13First, too great inequalities tend to
- 20:15show that things can become gentrified
- 20:17and that lifestyles can have a greater
- 20:19impact.
- 20:20Okay, we'll come back to that, but for
- 20:22example, being a multi-owner, having
- 20:24second homes, that contributes a little
- 20:25.
- 20:27There's a second element that's also
- 20:28important to us, which has been shown in
- 20:30studies, particularly in the European
- 20:31Parliament, that where inequalities or
- 20:32disparities are greatest, that's where
- 20:34there are also knock-on effects.
- 20:37And as a result, populations that don't
- 20:39always have the means can be, through
- 20:41imitation, encouraged to consume like
- 20:43others.
- 20:44So there is a territorial knock-on
- 20:46effect due to the diversity of social
- 20:48situations.
- 20:49So, if I had to summarize, what is it?
- 20:52Indeed, large urban areas once again
- 20:54play a decisive role.
- 20:57In fact, today, the greatest
- 20:58inequalities are seen in metropolitan
- 21:01areas due to the effect and imposition
- 21:03of coming to live there, due to the fact
- 21:05that the least well-off, the most
- 21:08precarious, the most vulnerable, can
- 21:10possibly find work there, right?
- 21:13For the sake of the profession, and we
- 21:16can indeed ask ourselves the question,
- 21:18but nevertheless there is an increase in
- 21:20activity in these areas.
- 21:22In the continuity, the affordability of
- 21:25housing and houses in particular varies
- 21:27greatly, depending on whether you live
- 21:30in metropolitan areas or elsewhere.
- 21:33There are factors from 1 to 4, from 1 to
- 21:355, from 1 to 10, and it is also an
- 21:36exurbanization of capital, you know, we
- 21:38can say that. That is to say, if you
- 21:40have ever bought a small second home, or
- 21:42at least moved, but because you have
- 21:44flipped over a property that has
- 21:45increased in value by around 50, 60, 70
- 21:47%, or even doubled or tripled in the
- 21:49last 20 years, a small apartment that
- 21:51you have inherited, well that gives you
- 21:53a castle, I am barely exaggerating, huh
- 21:55, uh, elsewhere, when it is less
- 21:57populated. So there are also phenomena
- 21:59of gentrification that can occur.
- 22:02It is all of this in fact that has led
- 22:04us to particularly highlight Brittany.
- 22:06There are many reasons, uh, that explain
- 22:08why Brittany has stood out, both in
- 22:10terms of the question of structuring
- 22:11factors, the presence of wood, the
- 22:13agricultural question, its diversity,
- 22:15and its territorial network. As you may
- 22:17have noticed, Vannes, Lorient,
- 22:18Saint-Brieuc, Rennes, and Brest are not
- 22:20in the area.
- 22:21But also to respond to this indicator,
- 22:24coastal pressure, the arrival of
- 22:26Parisians and others, and the place and
- 22:29role of second homes play a decisive
- 22:31role today in the distortion that is
- 22:34taking place.
- 22:35Locals in Brittany, but also along the
- 22:38entire ocean coastline,
- 22:42are finding it increasingly difficult to
- 22:43find accommodation. That's it.
- 22:45They are forced to go into the
- 22:46hinterland or go inland, where there may
- 22:48still be housing.
- 22:50But, uh, if there is no policy and has
- 22:52been committed in certain places, uh,
- 22:53conducted to contain, uh, well,
- 22:55ultimately, the real estate pressure by
- 22:57people who, uh, well, want Brittany
- 22:59because we often talk about it, or who
- 23:01want the oceanic cordon because it is
- 23:03called, well, ultimately, heliotropism,
- 23:05you know. After Mediterranean
- 23:06heliotropism, it would be a question of
- 23:08, it is not a fashion, but a demographic
- 23:10wave of moving closer to the ocean.
- 23:12There you have it. Uh, any resemblance
- 23:14to where we are today is purely
- 23:15coincidental. So, suddenly, there is
- 23:17something that has been a criterion
- 23:19there, for once, you know, which is
- 23:20confirmed by a recent source that
- 23:22crosses the artificial surface with the
- 23:24demographic evolution over the period
- 23:262013 to 2023, which tends to show that
- 23:28the coastline is under pressure, you
- 23:29know, from artificialization. There is
- 23:32also another criterion that excludes the
- 23:34coastline from the Breton hills of
- 23:35Brittany, which is the issue of erosion
- 23:37and marine submersion. That's it. That
- 23:39will play a decisive role.
- 23:41It won't go up to that point, but
- 23:43nevertheless, there is a risk in
- 23:45continuing to absolutely want to live in
- 23:48coastal areas.
- 23:49So, for this indicator of inequality and
- 23:52affordability, Brittany seemed
- 23:53particularly expressive to me.
- 23:56>> Having a territory with less inequality
- 23:58and population density is essential for
- 24:00staying below planetary boundaries and
- 24:01limiting conflicts.
- 24:03In addition to that, one of the indirect
- 24:05consequences is that life is generally
- 24:06less expensive. So top notch. And by the
- 24:09way, there are many other criteria that
- 24:10Guillaume and the post-urban movement
- 24:12developed in their study, in particular
- 24:13that of work in relation to the
- 24:15ecological transition and the
- 24:16transformations in professions that it
- 24:17implies.
- 24:18Because it's all well and good living in
- 24:20one of the seven refuge zones, living
- 24:21locally and so on, but if you can't make
- 24:23a living there because there's no work,
- 24:24well, you're not going to stay there for
- 24:26very long.
- 24:27Anyway, I'll put the link to the report
- 24:28in the description. If you want to
- 24:29explore the other criteria, feel free to
- 24:31do so. Now, we come to the thorny
- 24:32question of who will be able to live in
- 24:34the zones? Because yes, they will only
- 24:36be able to accommodate 4 to 6 million
- 24:38additional people, or 8 to 10 million
- 24:40inhabitants in total.
- 24:42So obviously, not everyone will be able
- 24:43to settle there. But then, what do we do
- 24:45with all those who will have to stay in
- 24:47them?
- 24:50It's
- 24:50>> not a question of reversing history,
- 24:52that is, building cities in the
- 24:53countryside. There you have it. No, what
- 24:54we advocate is developing the territory
- 24:56in a way that rebalances it. So, the 4
- 24:58to 6 million people have no additional
- 25:00ecological footprint. These are the
- 25:03housing units we talked about, vacant or
- 25:04otherwise. These are the lands that can
- 25:06potentially be acquired collectively, as
- 25:09citizens. These are the groups that I
- 25:10mentioned earlier. This does not mean
- 25:12that other people could not come and
- 25:14settle there.
- 25:15It is simply a capacity to accommodate
- 25:17without increasing the footprint that we
- 25:19talked about. In fact, we estimate that
- 25:20if we really thought about the
- 25:22rebalancing that is being discussed
- 25:23between city and countryside, in other
- 25:25words large cities and small towns,
- 25:26nearby and countryside, it would be in
- 25:28the order of 10 to 12 million people who
- 25:30would have to go from one to the other.
- 25:31So, for the rebalancing in question. 10
- 25:33to 12 million out of 22 million
- 25:35metropolitan residents, as you will have
- 25:36noticed, it is not the total.
- 25:38But it will free up space. So, what do
- 25:40we do with this? And for those who would
- 25:42like to stay there, and especially
- 25:43others who are under house arrest and do
- 25:45not have the means to do so, this is
- 25:46where there should be political
- 25:48authorities to help and avoid the
- 25:49inequalities in affordability that we
- 25:51have discussed.
- 25:52In the book, at the end, I allow myself
- 25:54not to say it like that, but to provide
- 25:55some elements of experience that could
- 25:57potentially serve as advice.
- 25:59And I would like to start with those who
- 26:01are still in the process. What could
- 26:03they do? We will have to free up land.
- 26:04There you have it. That is clear, we
- 26:06will have to clear undergrowth, remove
- 26:07asphalt, remove concrete, and
- 26:08de-urbanize.
- 26:09Overall, it is estimated, particularly
- 26:11for the issue of food autonomy, that we
- 26:13would need to de-urbanize or remove
- 26:15concrete from around 40 to 50%of
- 26:16built-up areas, which is quite a lot.
- 26:18And we are not there at all, are we?
- 26:20There you have it. I will open a small
- 26:21parenthesis with you and close it, but
- 26:22it is the one that will still attract
- 26:23many friends to me. Overall,
- 26:25metropolitan policies are quite limited
- 26:27, if not insignificant. They are not up
- 26:30to the challenge, in particular, but not
- 26:31only, and they are also rather
- 26:33aggravating because they suggest that,
- 26:34without asking the question of size, we
- 26:36would have the solution to what
- 26:37agglomeration, metropolitanization has
- 26:39caused, you see.
- 26:40And in the book, uh, there are ways to
- 26:43get involved individually, collectively
- 26:45, but it is around food autonomy and
- 26:48reforestation, in any case greening,
- 26:50that the emphasis must be placed. When
- 26:53we said that, that is to say, taking
- 26:55into account those who, uh, will not be
- 26:57able to or do not wish to, uh, for me,
- 26:59the challenge is really to pose the
- 27:01question of moving as an option for land
- 27:03management, and not for development.
- 27:06And so, the question arises of those, uh
- 27:08, well, who have decided or who could or
- 27:11would like to plan to move. And across
- 27:13all classes, 80%of the French population
- 27:15would like to live in the countryside.
- 27:17And this figure of 80%who want to live
- 27:19in the countryside has continued to grow
- 27:21over the last 50 years. It didn't appear
- 27:23unexpectedly due to a misinterpretation
- 27:26of Covid.
- 27:27It is much more sustainable in the
- 27:28cohorts that have been monitored and the
- 27:30surveys that have been conducted
- 27:32regularly.
- 27:34But nevertheless, wanting to do so and
- 27:35achieving it, there is a problem that
- 27:37arises, which is also the case today,
- 27:39and which creates tensions locally in
- 27:41certain places: the newcomers to the
- 27:43city are generally more of a cultural
- 27:45bourgeoisie, those who still have the
- 27:47means to arbitrate on the market, will
- 27:48either be a bit arrogant, under the
- 27:50guise of a miserable outlook on rural
- 27:52areas, since we have been trained for
- 27:54that.
- 27:55The countryside is still seen as a place
- 27:57of hicks, bumpkins and dirtbags, huh?
- 27:59Pride has been undermined.
- 28:01So, generally, the urban population
- 28:02arrives with a bit of suppressed misery
- 28:04and messianism, and is going to save
- 28:06them. Okay.
- 28:07Well, that's a mistake, but a fatal one
- 28:09. The first element needs to be
- 28:10deconstructed, but it's what happens
- 28:12quite often, or at least perhaps still
- 28:13does today. And the second is a
- 28:15romanticism, going there because
- 28:17everything would be settled, it's
- 28:18Eldorado, a little corner, exactly in
- 28:20the countryside, and so on. Okay.
- 28:23That's also very bourgeois, let's be
- 28:25clear.
- 28:26Those are the two major structuring
- 28:27imaginaries. There's a form of urban
- 28:29filter that sees the countryside as a
- 28:32land to conquer or a vacation spot. Okay
- 28:35.
- 28:35Well, those are the two mistakes. And,
- 28:37uh, what we advise here, I advise in any
- 28:40case, is to project yourself slowly, to
- 28:43immerse yourself, to acculturate
- 28:45yourself a little to these forms of life
- 28:48and these ways of being. There you have
- 28:50it. Because otherwise, we will reproduce
- 28:53, how can I say, divisive, dual readings
- 28:55of the world. For me, what is perhaps
- 28:58even more important is that, uh, the
- 29:00question of forming alliances, the
- 29:03question of settling down, uh,
- 29:05inevitably involves a deconstruction of
- 29:08those who arrive in a form of humility
- 29:10and responsibility. There you have it.
- 29:13A modesty in the desire to make yourself
- 29:15known and to act as a social act.
- 29:18Wanting to get involved is very good,
- 29:20but without fanfare. There you have it.
- 29:22There are forms of engagement, there are
- 29:24types of socialization that involve
- 29:26leaning against a bar, if it still
- 29:28exists, or getting involved in a small
- 29:30grocery store that is struggling to
- 29:31survive, or simply taking care of a
- 29:33sports team, or the community center, or
- 29:35kids who need to go out, well, there you
- 29:37have it. There are in fact socialization
- 29:39networks that are already established.
- 29:41And I sincerely believe that it is a
- 29:43lack of knowledge of these realities and
- 29:45how they work that can sometimes cause
- 29:47things to become tense.
- 29:49But in the majority of cases, it works
- 29:50quite well.
- 29:51>> Where to live in the future is not a
- 29:52simple question, but it is something
- 29:54that we need to think about right now.
- 29:55As Guillaume said, not everyone will be
- 29:57able to move, but that is not a problem
- 29:59in itself, since we do not want everyone
- 30:00to move.
- 30:01>> We should not recreate cities in the
- 30:02countryside, far from it.
- 30:04It is more about implementing a planned
- 30:06decrease in the population of cities to
- 30:08improve livability and viability for the
- 30:10entire territory.
- 30:12Furthermore, other areas that are very,
- 30:14very close to being considered refuge
- 30:15areas, such as the Ardennes, the Vosges
- 30:17or the Jura, can be used to accommodate
- 30:19more people to increase the number of
- 30:21people living in France to 25%and
- 30:22therefore allow a rebalancing between
- 30:24the current large cities and the
- 30:25countryside. I will provide more details
- 30:27in the description on why these are
- 30:29almost perfect areas. Now, to go to
- 30:31these refuge areas, you have to take the
- 30:32time to immerse yourself, to explore and
- 30:34, above all, to test them. In his latest
- 30:36book published by Tana, Guillaume
- 30:38analyzes the history of France and why
- 30:39we must ask ourselves where to live
- 30:41because of the problem of population
- 30:43distribution, the unsustainable effects
- 30:44of metropolitanization, etc. But he does
- 30:46not just address the problem, he also
- 30:48develops the solution.
- 30:49In the book, you will find instructions
- 30:51to help you think about whether or not
- 30:53to move and, if so, how to set up your
- 30:55business.
- 30:56I will include all the links in the
- 30:57description once again. Personally, I
- 30:58think that a good way to immerse
- 31:00yourself in a region at a lower cost is
- 31:01to do some kind of woofing to help
- 31:03organic, ethical farms or eco-friendly
- 31:05places. I will include two links in the
- 31:06description to find out more. But in the
- 31:08idea, remember that you give 4 to 5
- 31:09hours of your time and in exchange, you
- 31:11will be housed, washed, and fed. It is a
- 31:13great experience that I highly recommend
- 31:14, as well as supporting Limites. If you
- 31:16enjoyed our work, know that the Limites
- 31:18team and I need your support to keep it
- 31:20going.
- 31:21Without you, we would not be able to
- 31:22produce videos and reach millions of
- 31:24people to create a more sober, joyful,
- 31:26and robust world of tomorrow.
- 31:28So whether it's one euro, five euros, or
- 31:29ten euros, know that there's no such
- 31:30thing as a small donation; we really
- 31:31need everyone.
- 31:32And if not, to find out who's going to
- 31:34watch until the end of the video and to
- 31:36help with referencing, leave me a
- 31:37comment about your favorite area among
- 31:39all the ones we've shown you. That was
- 31:41Yohann for Limites, keep smiling.
- 31:51What's
- 31:51>> your definition of?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Où habiter en France pour survivre à l’effondrement ? by LIMIT, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,343 words across 1,026 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.