Nvidia Crisis Reshapes Washington’s Technology Debate — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Is Henrietta Trace of Veda Partners, the cofounder and director of economic policy research there as
- 0:04well, and Tara Kopp, a national security correspondent, at the Washington Post. Henrietta, let me start
- 0:09with you. I wanna ask her how this has reframed the conversation on Capitol Hill. Obviously,
- 0:13there's this huge impulse here for oversight, getting Jensen Huang to Capitol Hill to answer questions
- 0:18from from lawmakers. But on this issue that Christina just mentioned a moment ago, export restrictions
- 0:23on on chips, there are a number of pieces of legislation that have been making their
- 0:27way around the desks on on on Capitol Hill. Does this change the appetite for getting
- 0:32them passed into law?
- 0:34It's a great question, David. And I would say it doesn't just change the appetite. It
- 0:38changes the entire power dynamic. So, you know, there's really two ways to get power in
- 0:42DC, money and oversight. And momentum tends to follow politically, whichever party has the biggest drive.
- 0:50So we just saw an election where Democrats ran away with the game, right, across the
- 0:53house, across the senate. And so the tech companies that had been so closely affiliated with
- 0:58commerce secretary, Nick, with president Trump, Jensen Huang, Elon Musk, that contingent meeting literally in the
- 1:04Oval Office, having grand dinners at the White House, that level of interconnectedness created a vacuum
- 1:11for the Democratic party to step in. So now as they see the, the exchange of
- 1:17chip sales, the billions of dollars that were invested into individual companies, what the politicians in
- 1:23in Washington see and specifically Democrats just gained from is that divide, that sort of chasm
- 1:29that existed between those industries and the Republican party, and they're now moving into the direction
- 1:35of the Democratic party. So the investigations will proceed. The oversight will be expansive, and Republicans
- 1:43want to jump on that bandwagon. That's driving bipartisanship. That's raising our odds internally here at
- 1:48beta that some of this legislation could pass, could get attached to the defense authorization bill
- 1:53in the coming weeks, and certainly will be all that they focus on next year.
- 1:57Tara, I'm wondering what the biggest national security concerns are for this affair. And I use
- 2:02the words affair in the goings on sense, not the more specific sense.
- 2:06Not the dalliance.
- 2:06Not not the dalliance sense. But for me, it seems like there are two issues to
- 2:11pursue for the agencies, and I'm unclear who's doing what. It's whether this individual had influence
- 2:17over US policy through the CEO and then also whether or not this individual was facilitating
- 2:22the smuggling of chips that may or not have been eligible to go to China. What
- 2:27are the big issues, and and who's looking into them?
- 2:30Exactly. Well, the biggest point of vulnerability for the Pentagon in this is that NVIDIA trips
- 2:37have become deeply embedded in the Pentagon's effort to rapidly accelerate its AI programs. Last May,
- 2:43it was one of six companies that was selected to basically help fast forward the Pentagon's
- 2:50AI programs, which are now used to... With about a million service members across the military.
- 2:56But even more so, like, Jensen Huang actually did a ribbon cutting ceremony with the Navy
- 3:02out in Monterey, California earlier this year for the first ever AI supercomputer that they donated
- 3:09to the Navy and will be used as a test bed. So the the integrity of
- 3:15these chips for the Pentagon and for being able to maintain an edge over China and
- 3:20to make sure that there's not any sort of reverse engineering going on is really critical.
- 3:26So when you talk about what the agencies are looking for, both of your questions are
- 3:30very relevant. You know, what were they trying to gain information as to what the ships
- 3:35are being used for? Were they just trying to gain access? You know, reverse engineering is
- 3:40one of the key ways that any sort of peer competitor starts to catch up either
- 3:46with The US or surpass. And we've seen this in China over the decades with, you
- 3:50know, how they were able to basically replicate the f 35 stealth fighter jet and all
- 3:57of our other fighter jets over the years, our ships, our missiles. So the fact that
- 4:01this person had such a close relationship with Jensen Huang, at a time when the US
- 4:08military is so deeply reliant on NVIDIA has really raised concerns in the building.
- 4:14Henry, I go back to what you said about the levers of power in Washington and
- 4:17oversight is is a big one. I I wonder sort of what you think that spectacle
- 4:20is going to be like when Jensen Huang does make his way to Capitol Hill to
- 4:24to testify. And I'm I'm curious now that he's out of that position. If you compare
- 4:28the worth of his testimony with that perhaps of Howard Ludlow, the the commerce secretary, testifying
- 4:33about his relationship with Jensen Huang, what's more important? What's likely to give, lawmakers the the
- 4:38more information here about that relationship and about this issue more broadly?
- 4:42I was fortunate enough to be able to be on Capitol Hill last week when the
- 4:46new members were coming in and getting their tours around and meeting with chiefs of the
- 4:50senior committees that are gonna be holding these investigations. I think that there is no limit
- 4:55to what Democrats will want to investigate. And as I mentioned on that power dynamic, there
- 4:59are a number of Republicans, especially moderate Republicans, who will want to try to keep their
- 5:04seats by participating in those investigations. So you're seeing it on a really fundamental bipartisan basis.
- 5:10Tim Scott on the senate banking committee, Ron Wyden on the senate finance committee. They already
- 5:15have requested for World Liberty Financial to have all of their datasets that they've requested by
- 5:20January 4, the day after they get sworn in. So I think what Democrats have been
- 5:24telling me for the last year is that we have not seen oversight of the White
- 5:29House, not including including Lutnick, including their affiliation with Tim Cook, with Meta, with Google, with
- 5:36NVIDIA. The oversight, though, has been lacking. So we're gonna watch what I'm gonna probably call
- 5:41the great unraveling, where Democrats and Republicans get their hands in every single, deal that was
- 5:49done between the Trump administration, the Trump, elder children, their association with defense contracts, with chip
- 5:56contracts, with crypto contracts. And they're able to make the connection successfully to voters that this
- 6:01corruption is actually costing us money, and it's now in... Imperiling in national security, as Tara
- 6:08just pointed out. So that connection is so expansive. I think it's gonna give them fodder
- 6:13for at least two years to perpetuate investigations across the hill.
- 6:17So there's another national security concern in all of this that some people are voicing, and
- 6:21that is following the Busan agreement between China and The US, there's been this tacit looking
- 6:27the other way that China is acquiring some of these chips because... And it was partially
- 6:32the the argument that was making as well. If you don't let China have these chips,
- 6:36they're gonna come up with their own. Or if you take them away, they're gonna retaliate.
- 6:40And how they're gonna do that is by contracting the supply of rare earth minerals, which
- 6:45The US uses in weapons, and China kinda looks the other way on that. Do you
- 6:49buy the retaliation argument? Do you think that is likely, or do you think even if
- 6:54congress does pass some of these measures that that things will kind of keep going as
- 6:57are?
- 6:58Well, China already is limiting access to rare earths, and that has become a a a
- 7:05critical vulnerability for all of the things that the US military needs. It... One of the
- 7:11reasons it takes so long to build some of our weapon systems is you have to
- 7:14have access to these rare earth metals. And so, yes, it's a bargaining chip with China,
- 7:21but more so, you have to figure out how do you ensure the integrity of a
- 7:27US weapon system if there's this back and forth with NVIDIA chips and if they're in
- 7:33reseller markets. And we have seen this in other technologies. We've seen counterfeit trips be used
- 7:38in US weapon systems. So if you don't have tight export controls and tight controls over
- 7:45the supply, how do you make sure that that jet flying overhead doesn't have some sort
- 7:50of deeply embedded malicious code or otherwise. And that really gets to the heart of why,
- 7:55these chips are so, vigorously protected. Not only are they powerful and they they provide The
- 8:01US an edge, but it's also a critical point of vulnerability.
- 8:05Henry, another story we've been tracking over the course of the weekend, of course, is the
- 8:08the ground stop that we saw on Friday and the fallout from it and the entreaties
- 8:11from, both the secretary of homeland security and the secretary of transportation for more money to
- 8:15fortify the air traffic control system, in this country. Wanna play a bit of sound here
- 8:19of secretary Duffy, and the speaker of the house, Mike Johnson, reacting to the request secretary
- 8:24Duffy's made.
- 8:25So I did make a request, for $30,000,000,000. I've talked about $30,000,000,000. And, what I'm trying
- 8:31to do is get a number that I think the congress will give that gets a
- 8:35a massive portion of, of of the needs of the airspace completed.
- 8:41We were working on an aggressive legislative package to finish out the year strong, run through
- 8:45the tape, Kailey, and and this will be added to that. Look. I I give a
- 8:48lot of credit to president Trump and secretary Duffy. They've been sounding the alarm since the
- 8:52beginning of this congress. I tried to echo those alarms.
- 8:55Keeping in mind here his race has nearly run, Henrietta. I wonder sort of what you
- 8:59think gets accomplished here when it comes to this issue in the weeks ahead. I think
- 9:03something we've heard from certainly past administration. Had John Fistle on the show a few moments
- 9:07ago. Is this something that's really dogged the FAA transportation department for a long time? You're
- 9:13having this very outdated system. Yes. There has been money that's been poured into fixing it,
- 9:17but it but it hasn't happened. Why has this been something that's so stymied the federal
- 9:21government getting this fixed, and and is there any appetite to pour more money into this
- 9:24yet?
- 9:25I think you're right to point out that this is a two year long story at
- 9:29a minimum around the FAA. I mean, the ineptitude is staggering. And as somebody who was
- 9:33flying back from Phoenix here yesterday
- 9:36Congratulations. Glad you made it.
- 9:39That was brutal. I mean, people sleeping on cots. The the staff at the airports deserves
- 9:43a raise. Some of the money should go to that. That's my position. But I would
- 9:47say this is probably the most important thing for investors. I I wanna segue it just
- 9:52a little bit or connect it to the need for a reconciliation bill in the fourth
- 9:57quarter, my odds are 30% that this is gonna pan out. But hear me out. We
- 10:01need money for the Iran war. The president wants money, $350,000,000,000 to be precise. And no
- 10:08party, not Democrats or Republicans, have been voting to authorize that release of funding. Now secretary
- 10:13of transportation Duffy is coming out and saying, want another 30. I've heard even $50,000,000,000. The
- 10:18path forward for that money actually runs through a reconciliation bill or extraordinarily problematic demanding oversight
- 10:25and amendment votes from the Democratic party. So you pick your poison. Do you wanna demo...
- 10:29Negotiate with Democrats, or do you wanna push and hammer through a reconciliation bill with your
- 10:34Republican conference in the next twelve legislative days? Speaker Johnson is alluding to the idea that
- 10:40is percolating in the house and Steve Scalise has advanced to pass a third reconciliation bill.
- 10:45And it would include not just that Pentagon funding and presumably this FAA funding if it's
- 10:50ready to go, but also a hike to the debt ceiling. And the debt ceiling is
- 10:53going to be a major showdown that we deal with in the second or third quarter
- 10:58of next year with the Trump administration and Democrats in control of all levers of congress.
- 11:04You can either have that fight then or you could have it now and protect the
- 11:06president before he has to deal with Democrats. This all is gonna get jumbled together. I
- 11:11would say follow the budget committees for the next two weeks and see whether they're able
- 11:15to advance a third reconciliation budget resolution that will get us this bill before Trump needs
- 11:21to negotiate with Democrats next year. That is a critical question for investors going into the
- 11:26end of this year.
- 11:26And also waiting on a defense supplemental. Tara, one of the things Democrats also have to
- 11:30figure out when they come into Washington is what they're going to do if they can't
- 11:34do anything about the Iran war that the administration seems to now say is maybe not
- 11:37a war and is kind of where it needs to be. I'm gonna play you some
- 11:40sound from secretary of state Marco Rubio.
- 11:42No war is popular. No conflict... Military conflict is popular. And right now, frankly, the economic
- 11:49pain that we are inflicting on that regime is so great that there's no need for
- 11:53for for military action because we've weakened them so much.
- 11:57Sir, Iran is claiming it struck an air base in, Bahrain today. The US has also
- 12:01been striking isolated targets in Iran. What does that tell us about where this war is
- 12:05going and if it's coming to an end anytime soon?
- 12:09That is not necessarily up to secretary Rubio or or president Trump whether this war continues.
- 12:15You know, once the genie's out of the bottle, the other side has a say, and
- 12:19we've seen this in every conflict that the Pentagon has engaged in. Right now, you know,
- 12:24Iran for the second time in three days has targeted Bahrain's air defense systems and radars.
- 12:31That's one potential match that could be lit that could reignite the region and force The
- 12:36US' hand to get back into the swing of things. Right now, we have three aircraft
- 12:41carrier groups, 50,000 personnel, but it's not just limited to The Middle East. You've seen twice
- 12:49now in the last month, the US Air Force has evacuated its bombers and its tanker
- 12:55aircraft and its Ospreys from various UK air bases because of perceived threats to those aircraft.
- 13:03So there are a lot of ways that The US' hand could be forced. You know,
- 13:08president Trump has indicated he doesn't want to resume war operations, and the people that we've
- 13:13spoken to in his, presidential daily briefings has said he really just doesn't have the interest
- 13:20in getting back into full scale war. Okay. But this may no longer be
- 13:23up to him.
- 13:24Alright. Thank you so much. Erica for the Washington Post. She's their national security correspondent. And
- 13:28Henrietta Trace of Beta Partners, of course, and cofounder and director of economic policy research over
- 13:33there. Thank you both so much for joining us.
- 13:34Alright. Oil
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Nvidia Crisis Reshapes Washington’s Technology Debate by Bloomberg Podcasts, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,573 words across 173 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.