NSDC training_2nd gov_Albrain — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:01Three things I will talk in my speech.
2. 0:02Number one is on the rebuttal why
3. 0:04opposition civilizations was wrong.
4. 0:06Secondly, on the rebuttal why opposition
5. 0:08establishment of better law was wrong.
6. 0:10But thirdly, on the extension on how
7. 0:11individual can lead to more balance and
8. 0:13peaceful environmental condition on our
9. 0:15side of the house. But firstly, on the
10. 0:16rebuttal on the civilization side. I
11. 0:18think what they aim to be civilization
12. 0:20is something that is principally wrong
13. 0:22because what we have to understand the
14. 0:24background historically, civilization
15. 0:26happened through lots of tragedies that
16. 0:27exist. After post neolithic
17. 0:30during post neolithic revolution even
18. 0:32until right now, billions of war exist
19. 0:35everywhere and we have seen tragic death
20. 0:37of trillions of people who's not
21. 0:39supposed to die but should suffer just
22. 0:41because of the one people command. Why
23. 0:43this is problematic? A, they have to
24. 0:45actually only explanation that come from
25. 0:47their side about how community shape
26. 0:49because people opposition framing is
27. 0:50only about because they need protection.
28. 0:52We think this war exactly exists because
29. 0:53on the sharing of the different
30. 0:55interest. When you have fun, others
31. 0:57don't share the same interest, you hate
32. 0:59them and hate to accept different
33. 1:00opinions on them and the only resolution
34. 1:02to finish it is to start conflict
35. 1:04because discussion musyawarah mufakat
36. 1:06does not exactly work and this is likely
37. 1:08since human with each of their ego to
38. 1:10want to maintain their communal
39. 1:11interest, want to show their pride when
40. 1:13the other one lose on the debate or lose
41. 1:15life when their interest is exactly
42. 1:17folded. But B, I think there is lack of
43. 1:19definition of what is morally right and
44. 1:21what is morally wrong even until after
45. 1:23post neolithic revolution because there
46. 1:25will always be a problematic actor who's
47. 1:27not standing on peace but standing on
48. 1:29the evil side which is authoritarianism.
49. 1:31They brought development but by lots of
50. 1:33sacrificing of accusing people aligned
51. 1:35with different ideologies and
52. 1:37importantly when they have seen a
53. 1:38different skin race and ethnicities,
54. 1:40they will attempt to eliminate as what
55. 1:42exactly happened to Hutu and Tutsi
56. 1:43conflict when there is lots of
57. 1:45sacrificing of Tutsis who don't even
58. 1:46have a weapon. This is what human don't
59. 1:48want like because they actually put a
60. 1:50life on sacrificing other people. Humans
61. 1:52don't want the ultimate value of this
62. 1:54actor when they only saw their families
63. 1:55got beaten. When there is lots of
64. 1:57campaign saying world peace, but there
65. 1:59is less a resolution. Therefore, the
66. 2:01trade-off is even if opposition said
67. 2:03they will achieve civilization when
68. 2:04human become much more established, they
69. 2:06achieve it by sacrilegation. But
70. 2:07moreover, they failed to maintain even
71. 2:10if peace can happen, they failed to
72. 2:11maintain the peace right now. Because
73. 2:13look, it is still untouched. Status quo,
74. 2:15United Nations, lots of sanction already
75. 2:17exist, but still lots of terrorists
76. 2:19exist out there to terrorize people.
77. 2:21Superpower nations like Russia continues
78. 2:23to invade Ukraine in comparison to our
79. 2:25side. Human before this era don't
80. 2:27understand what war is, what better
81. 2:29interest life is. What they do is
82. 2:30following their natural instinct and
83. 2:32communal interest to maintain their
84. 2:33species to not exist. They understand
85. 2:36more about the fulfillment of life, that
86. 2:38is survival and protecting each other,
87. 2:40serving your children to how to survive
88. 2:42and grow based on their life. When the
89. 2:43right now, the violations is much more
90. 2:46um radical and pragmatic. The second you
91. 2:48on the idea that how opposition says
92. 2:50after post this era, they will have
93. 2:51better society because of this
94. 2:53establishment of law. I think there is a
95. 2:54certain problem to begin with. Number
96. 2:56one, is that law is actually principally
97. 2:58written and that is actually very
98. 2:59perfect, but the execution executions of
99. 3:02law is so much imperfect. There is
100. 3:04tendency of people to violate the law
101. 3:06just because they want to satisfy their
102. 3:08interest. For example, because they felt
103. 3:09it is actually going to benefited them
104. 3:11when they corrupt and they can fight the
105. 3:12entire family of it even if they
106. 3:14sacrifices the
107. 3:16fund to actually being allocated to the
108. 3:18disaster victim. This is something that
109. 3:20is very justified, right? Because there
110. 3:21is also gap to actually understand this
111. 3:23type of thing. But B, tragically, law is
112. 3:26actually very unfair, right? Because it
113. 3:27depends on the nation who you live in,
114. 3:29the community who you live in. You
115. 3:31cannot generalize that law to serving
116. 3:32human is actually acceptable in every
117. 3:34type of the world because there is
118. 3:36prerequisite. For example, in Iran right
119. 3:38now, they can simply kill you just
120. 3:39because you are a supporting family's
121. 3:41movement or in Afghanistan, you can be
122. 3:43you can be killed just because you are
123. 3:44as you are a woman and you try to seek
124. 3:47for a better education. Law is something
125. 3:49that is very unstable, especially there
126. 3:51is different characterization of it. In
127. 3:53comparison, when human don't understand
128. 3:55to even establish before it, they don't
129. 3:57have capacity to understand which gap of
130. 3:59law to actually we can simply violate
131. 4:01right now. Because human right now, even
132. 4:03if they can settle out, they can use law
133. 4:04to actually manipulate other thing,
134. 4:06which is to hide their morally bad
135. 4:08action. They only know which is right
136. 4:10and wrong. People within Neolithic
137. 4:12revolution does not know it, right? They
138. 4:13actually just know how to live when they
139. 4:15are surviving. For example, even if
140. 4:17there is rule before, like man and
141. 4:18woman, they just going to actually men
142. 4:20going to um hunting, and woman can
143. 4:23simply like growing the child with love.
144. 4:25That is something that is principally
145. 4:26just exist in Neolithic revolution. But
146. 4:29moving on to the extension on how
147. 4:30individual can adapt to more balanced
148. 4:31and peaceful environmental condition.
149. 4:33What does human run right now? They are
150. 4:35contributing directly to climate change.
151. 4:37They run such a massive
152. 4:38commercialization of industries, and
153. 4:40therefore destroy the harmony within it.
154. 4:42The problem is when they try to build
155. 4:44those thing, they want to exploit the
156. 4:45environment just to ensure that they
157. 4:46will maximize this lots of incentive and
158. 4:48benefit and money. But it is
159. 4:50problematic, because they improve this
160. 4:52by making environmentally damage. They
161. 4:54left other creatures should move their
162. 4:56home and basic place this creatures
163. 4:57should get actually only available to
164. 4:59this creatures. They killed other
165. 5:01creatures just because they felt like
166. 5:03this is actually they are the special
167. 5:04creatures, they are the image of God
168. 5:06itself. But secondly, even if right now
169. 5:08human are also attempt to stop those
170. 5:10thing. Exactly, we have Kyoto Protocol,
171. 5:12Paris Agreement to show that they can
172. 5:14run out from this problem by agreement.
173. 5:15But agreement cannot exactly work,
174. 5:17because there is still the one who is
175. 5:19evil and dangerous out there. There is
176. 5:21violations of rules, the conscription of
177. 5:23each nation to actually sign this.
178. 5:25Humans are actually very inconsistent
179. 5:27within this rule. Government never
180. 5:28realize Opposition never realizes that
181. 5:30human are inconsistencies when they
182. 5:32actually felt like
183. 5:33it is benefited for them that they can
184. 5:35actually follow the rules. But if it is
185. 5:37not benefited, they can actually violate
186. 5:38the rule even if it actually sac- means
187. 5:40by sacrificing other people's life. But
188. 5:42thirdly, it is likely to happen, since
189. 5:44human is the solely and the only one who
190. 5:46is smart right now within this planet
191. 5:47right now with this massive
192. 5:49civilization. They are the only one
193. 5:50who's smart to operate all these
194. 5:51incentive and there are imbalances of
195. 5:53power between any living creatures who
196. 5:55live in this world. Understand right now
197. 5:57that in comparison the pre-neolithic
198. 5:59lives with all creators living within
199. 6:01their own communities just based on
200. 6:02themselves and based on what the
201. 6:03classification of what their genes looks
202. 6:05like, they are only all humans and even
203. 6:08animal was classified as an animal. They
204. 6:10live in a perfect symbiosis with the
205. 6:12other one and live with the
206. 6:13survivability from not exploiting the
207. 6:15environment. They only kill one bear,
208. 6:18only kill one bear to feed the entire
209. 6:19families in comparison to what
210. 6:21government exactly frame to do is that
211. 6:23they built a massive agricultural and
212. 6:25farming land and produce massive stock
213. 6:27life just to being killed and eat and
214. 6:29they repeat the same cycles again and
215. 6:30again. Why this is actually better in
216. 6:32our side of the house? Number one is
217. 6:33that they don't exploiting the
218. 6:35environment overly, over use these types
219. 6:37of thing because they live on their hunt
220. 6:39and equal with what they should consume
221. 6:41because what they
222. 6:43uh get on the hunt exactly what is that
223. 6:45they can actually
224. 6:47get. That being said, they understand
225. 6:48the meaningful of the life more because
226. 6:50they respect how they nature work
227. 6:52because you know to restore the entire
228. 6:54environment there need a time of period
229. 6:56when human can actually live. In
230. 6:57comparison to right now when they want
231. 6:58to restore, the damage is already there
232. 7:00because there is a massive corruption of
233. 7:02the environment right now. But secondly,
234. 7:04on the principle of utilitarianism, even
235. 7:06if there is threat of predators like
236. 7:07lion, they protect each other from those
237. 7:09attack. There is morally justified
238. 7:11because that is the real law. After
239. 7:12neolithic revolution, one, human lives
240. 7:15with their communities but it is divided
241. 7:16to
242. 7:17until right now with different ideas and
243. 7:19different belief. They hurt each other
244. 7:21through war and don't even care even if
245. 7:22they kill human, they have justification
246. 7:24of it just because they said that this
247. 7:25human was actually very unfair to me.
248. 7:27They kill people, they take the lives of
249. 7:29the people that actually uh become the
250. 7:31contributor for the entire family. But
251. 7:32B, even if human develop better system
252. 7:34as what they characterize in law to
253. 7:36comparison, we have law of jungle system
254. 7:38hukum rimba. The problem is on how they
255. 7:40get the sanction because the
256. 7:41implementation was broken. They punish
257. 7:44people without a bargaining power, but
258. 7:45they give generosity to people in power
259. 7:48even if these people are wrong morally.
260. 7:50This is important because without these
261. 7:52presents, human was folder in tears just
262. 7:54to see that they have been treated
263. 7:56unfairly by the by this broken system
264. 7:58and they can see that all the
265. 8:00environment was better on them. The
266. 8:01trade off is one based on the law. We
267. 8:03have proven why the establishment of law
268. 8:05is better on our side. Secondly, on the
269. 8:07civilization, we have proven that why
270. 8:08opposition civilization was achieved
271. 8:10through a better thing. But thirdly, on
272. 8:12comparison, we think we already proven
273. 8:13the counterfactual why then life
274. 8:16pre-neolithic was already good. For that
275. 8:18reason, we declare we win this debate.