“Non è colpa dei giovani”: l’intervista al professor Rosina su denatalità, innovazione e futuro — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Where do pensions come from? From those
- 0:01who work. But if we have fewer and
- 0:04fewer workers because there are fewer
- 0:06young people or they go abroad, it
- 0:07becomes increasingly difficult to pay
- 0:09for and guarantee pension expenses,
- 0:11while in the meantime the elderly
- 0:13population is growing. So you have an
- 0:15aging population that is growing, you
- 0:17have to increase pension spending, but
- 0:18you have fewer young people entering
- 0:20the workforce and more young people who
- 0:22, because they can't find work or earn
- 0:24adequate salaries, go abroad. It's not
- 0:27that young Italians go to countries
- 0:28where there are fewer elderly people,
- 0:30they go to countries where young people
- 0:32are valued more, and it is the valuing
- 0:34of the young that then allows all
- 0:36generations to live well and to live
- 0:38well for a long time with quality and
- 0:40sustainability. If we think of a young
- 0:44person entering, for example, the
- 0:46workforce in the 50s and 60s, they
- 0:48entered with skills that were very
- 0:50clear—you knew what skills were
- 0:52needed for the world of work—those
- 0:54skills were then directly applicable;
- 0:56you started a job and that job you
- 0:58started at 20, you would do for your
- 1:00whole life, and with a salary high
- 1:02enough to start a family, become
- 1:03independent from your family of origin,
- 1:06and have children. All these points of
- 1:09reference today no longer exist, and
- 1:11you cannot tell young people, "Well,
- 1:12they're not there, figure it out."
- 1:16We are the most educated generation
- 1:18ever, we have studied a lot, we adapt,
- 1:20we are flexible, and yet we are also
- 1:23the ones who struggle most to be
- 1:25independent, earn less than our parents
- 1:27, and have fewer children if we choose
- 1:30to have them at all. This is not just
- 1:34an individual problem; it is a
- 1:35structural problem for the entire
- 1:37country, and in fact, Italy is one of
- 1:39the oldest countries in the world.
- 1:42There are fewer and fewer young people,
- 1:43and their situations are increasingly
- 1:45precarious. The question then is, is it
- 1:48a matter of personal choices, or is it
- 1:50perhaps the system that is truly
- 1:52leaking from every side? Today we are
- 1:56talking about this with Alessandro
- 1:58Rosina, a demographer, university
- 2:00professor, and scientific coordinator
- 2:02of the Toniolo Institute's Youth
- 2:04Observatory; he is also one of the main
- 2:07experts in Italy dealing with young
- 2:09people, work, social transformations,
- 2:11and of course, demography. Good morning
- 2:14, Professor.
- 2:15Good morning.
- 2:17So today we are discussing, obviously,
- 2:20new generations and work, and how all
- 2:23these changes are affecting our "
- 2:25suspended generation." Let's get
- 2:29started.
- 2:30The future of young people is in the
- 2:31balance.
- 2:32More and more young people are leaving
- 2:33Italy.
- 2:34Rents in big cities are out of reach.
- 2:36Salaries haven't grown in 30 years. But
- 2:40then why is the future of young
- 2:42Italians never a priority on the
- 2:44political agenda?
- 2:45Why does no one pass laws to change
- 2:47things?
- 2:47Why are the real problems of young
- 2:49people never discussed?
- 2:50And in the meantime, we remain here
- 2:52suspended, like our generation.
- 2:57I am Tommaso Coluzzi. I am Sofia
- 2:59Pasotto,
- 3:00and this is Suspended Generation, the
- 3:01Factanza podcast where we will talk to
- 3:03politicians, asking for answers to our
- 3:05questions,
- 3:06with experts to address the systemic
- 3:08problems of our country,
- 3:09and with those who report on this
- 3:11reality and live through it every day,
- 3:13to understand what is not working, who
- 3:15needs to intervene,
- 3:16and above all, how to save our future.
- 3:24So, Professor, let's start very simply.
- 3:26In 2026, does it still make sense to
- 3:28talk about demographic groups and
- 3:30generations? Is it useful for anything?
- 3:33Yes, it is even more relevant in 2026,
- 3:35and likely in future years as well,
- 3:37because we live in a world that has
- 3:39become increasingly complex, that
- 3:41changes much faster than in the past,
- 3:43and that therefore places people in
- 3:45different conditions regarding
- 3:47opportunities and the circumstances
- 3:49they encounter, leading them to mature
- 3:51and develop life projects, desires, and
- 3:54expectations that are different from
- 3:56those of their parents and grandparents
- 3:58, because they are not living in the
- 4:00same era. era, and thus they face
- 4:03different challenges, growing and
- 4:06developing their personal and
- 4:07generational identity in a context that
- 4:10is different and constantly changing.
- 4:13Just to get an idea and clarify this
- 4:16concept a bit. If we take a
- 4:19fifteen-year-old in the past, a
- 4:20fifteen-year-old in the past who looked
- 4:22at, for example, their grandfather at
- 4:2465, they saw more or less how they
- 4:26would be at the same age: that is, they
- 4:28could compare themselves to their 65-
- 4:30year-old grandfather, thinking that
- 4:31when they reached 65, they would be
- 4:33exactly like their grandfather, because
- 4:35life expectancy was passed on steadily
- 4:37from one generation to the next. The
- 4:40phases of life were experienced in the
- 4:41same way from one generation to the
- 4:43next. The experience that a young
- 4:45person, a 15-year-old, had of the
- 4:47elderly in their own present was highly
- 4:49informative of how they themselves
- 4:51would be as an elderly person, and
- 4:53therefore, it essentially changed very
- 4:55little.
- 4:57Today this is no longer the case
- 4:59because longevity is increasing life
- 5:01expectancy. Every young person, every
- 5:03member of the new generation lives on
- 5:05average 6-7 years longer than their
- 5:07parents, which means 13-14 years longer
- 5:09than their grandparents. And so, when a
- 5:13fifteen-year-old reaches 65, that is,
- 5:15in 50 years, being elderly and the
- 5:18world they will be in at sixty-five
- 5:20will be completely different compared
- 5:22to their current sixty-five-year-old
- 5:24grandfather. And this means, precisely,
- 5:28that this profound change puts young
- 5:30people in a completely new condition.
- 5:33In other words, in the past it was easy
- 5:35to anticipate the subsequent phases of
- 5:37life, that is, to imagine what your
- 5:39future would be like, because you
- 5:41essentially lived as others had lived,
- 5:44what you experienced and saw around you
- 5:46. However, while you had much less
- 5:49chance to change that future, because
- 5:50if you were a farmer's son you became a
- 5:52farmer, if you were a nobleman's son
- 5:54you remained a nobleman, if you were a
- 5:56craftsman's son you became a craftsman,
- 5:58you could still anticipate what you
- 5:59would become. Today that is no longer
- 6:03the case, which means it is much harder
- 6:05to imagine what your future will be,
- 6:07but you theoretically have much more
- 6:08opportunity to change that future
- 6:10because the world is changing more
- 6:12rapidly, more deeply, and more
- 6:13intensely. But if you want to change it
- 6:18—because you certainly won't do the
- 6:20work your grandparents did, you will
- 6:22hardly do the work your parents do, and
- 6:24you will be in a position to live your
- 6:26life phases differently than previous
- 6:28generations—to seize it as an
- 6:30opportunity, you need to be
- 6:32well-trained, much more so than
- 6:33previous generations, and have the
- 6:35tools to feel like a protagonist of
- 6:37change and feel that change produces
- 6:39improvement for you, and therefore,
- 6:41give direction: to feel part of a
- 6:45generation that gives direction to a
- 6:47changing world and brings its own
- 6:48novelty; and this novelty becomes, in
- 6:50fact, the future you desire. So, in the
- 6:53end, are points of reference somewhat
- 6:55lacking for the younger generations now
- 6:58? Absolutely, in the sense that the
- 7:01maps of the world that were passed down
- 7:03from one generation to the next, which
- 7:06were more or less the same and
- 7:08therefore allowed a young person to
- 7:10orient themselves in stable maps, are
- 7:13today in flux. What does that mean? It
- 7:15means that the map passed down by the
- 7:18previous generation, both educators and
- 7:20parents, to the new generations is a
- 7:23map that quickly becomes obsolete.
- 7:26Because it is built in a world that is
- 7:28changing, so the categories and points
- 7:30of reference are no longer those of the
- 7:32past.
- 7:34So it means you not only need the
- 7:37ability to identify your own life path
- 7:39—that is, what you want to become—
- 7:42but also to build, while developing
- 7:44this life course and carrying out your
- 7:47own projects, the need to redefine the
- 7:50coordinates of these maps, the points
- 7:52of reference of these maps, because
- 7:55they are no longer those of the past;
- 7:57and therefore, the world of work today
- 8:00is not what it was 20 years ago, let
- 8:04alone 40 years ago. And what does it
- 8:07mean to participate socially and
- 8:08politically today? That is, what does "
- 8:10being" and "doing" in today's world
- 8:12mean compared to what it was in
- 8:14previous generations?
- 8:17And so, the points of reference that
- 8:18previous generations had, which were
- 8:20quite stable, are now in constant
- 8:22change, in constant redefinition. Which
- 8:26means it's not enough to have a clear
- 8:29idea of what you want to become;
- 8:31instead, you must continuously connect
- 8:34with the changes of your time, redefine
- 8:37your maps, find new reference points,
- 8:39and find your own path within this
- 8:42shifting landscape. I would make people
- 8:46listen to these words who say: "Oh, but
- 8:49my generation, we really worked hard.
- 8:54You young people today are lazy, you
- 8:56don't want to do anything, you say
- 8:59there's one crisis after another,"
- 9:01basically saying that young boys and
- 9:03girls are weak because they can't
- 9:06handle reality, but clearly, that is
- 9:08just not the case,
- 9:10is it? Because they are facing a
- 9:12reality that changes constantly, and
- 9:14which removes those reference points
- 9:16that existed in the past. I mean, if we
- 9:18think of a young person entering the
- 9:20job market in the 50s and 60s, they
- 9:22entered with clear skills; they knew
- 9:25exactly what skills were needed for the
- 9:27workforce. Those skills were
- 9:30immediately applicable, and you would
- 9:32start a job; and that job you started
- 9:34at 20, you would keep for your whole
- 9:36life, with a salary high enough to
- 9:38start a family, become independent from
- 9:40your parents, and have children.
- 9:44Besides, a single salary was enough
- 9:46because, shall we say, gender roles
- 9:47were much more traditional, and with
- 9:49one income you could support your
- 9:51family, reach old age, and have a
- 9:53secure pension. All these reference
- 9:56points are gone today, and we can't
- 9:58just tell young people, "Well, they're
- 10:00gone, deal with it." We need to put
- 10:02them in a position to develop different
- 10:04skills—not the ones from the past,
- 10:06but new ones that actually work.
- 10:09And in your opinion, how do we begin to
- 10:11cultivate these skills? I mean, where
- 10:14can we start to do something? Well, we
- 10:17must start with education.
- 10:22Because we continue to have a school
- 10:25system, and even a university system,
- 10:29with a way of training that is somehow
- 10:33tied to how I evaluate a young person
- 10:37—I tell them, "Prepare this text,
- 10:41prepare this topic, and then give me
- 10:44the answers I expect."
- 10:48Right,
- 10:49a middle school teacher, a high school
- 10:51teacher, or a professor all do the same
- 10:53: you prepare, then you give me the
- 10:54answers I already know, and I decide if
- 10:56those answers are correct. This is
- 10:58about the past, about how the past used
- 11:00to work. Hm.
- 11:01But if we want to enable young people
- 11:04to build a different future because
- 11:06change brings different challenges,
- 11:08what is truly needed is not that they
- 11:11repeat what older generations already
- 11:13know, but that they ask new questions.
- 11:17And that is what makes the difference,
- 11:20that is, helping young people not so
- 11:22much to learn how the world worked in
- 11:24the past or how it works today, but how
- 11:27they can change it and make it work
- 11:29better tomorrow.
- 11:31Of course. And in fact, one of the
- 11:34proposals by "Generazione Sospesa" is
- 11:37to provide vouchers for continuous
- 11:39training, in this case for workers, so
- 11:42that they can keep their skills updated
- 11:45. To stay on track because, obviously,
- 11:48in a changing world, job skills change
- 11:51as well.
- 11:51Exactly. That is, what worked yesterday
- 11:53, and even what works today, is no
- 11:55guarantee that it will work tomorrow.
- 11:58And those who remain stuck to the
- 12:00certainties of the past or to
- 12:02essentially rent-seeking positions in
- 12:05the present are already at a
- 12:06disadvantage because the future will
- 12:09inevitably challenge them due to the
- 12:11ongoing change. What works today. If
- 12:15you wait until it no longer works, you
- 12:18are already in a losing position. If
- 12:20instead you challenge it while it is
- 12:22still working, while knowing that you
- 12:24must find new solutions while it is
- 12:26still functional because they adapt
- 12:28better to what will be needed tomorrow,
- 12:31Not because it works like it did
- 12:33yesterday, but because you want it to
- 12:35work better tomorrow, then you must
- 12:37start training and understanding what
- 12:39the new coordinates are and start
- 12:41experimenting, implementing solutions,
- 12:44and making mistakes. Because mistakes
- 12:48help you understand how change is
- 12:50happening, what works and what doesn't;
- 12:52and only through experimentation can
- 12:55something new be produced, and through
- 12:57experimentation, new solutions are
- 12:59found, through experimentation, new
- 13:01generations, and openness to the new,
- 13:04not the defense of past certainties.
- 13:07And yet we continue to think in ways,
- 13:09to have a country system that keeps
- 13:11defending itself, staying entrenched in
- 13:13the certainties of the 20th century,
- 13:14and struggles instead to open up
- 13:16opportunities for those born in the
- 13:1821st.
- 13:19Yes, things that therefore no longer
- 13:21work. Well, let's just say there is a
- 13:24need, in my opinion, for foresight
- 13:26which at this moment perhaps is lacking
- 13:29in some areas. Why is it so difficult
- 13:32to project ourselves into the future? I
- 13:35mean, why, because what you are saying,
- 13:37obviously, if we all listened to it, it
- 13:40would already be a different world, it
- 13:42would be a different Italy. And why do
- 13:45we find it so hard to project ourselves
- 13:47into the future? Obviously, we say, "Ah
- 13:49, from tomorrow it will be." Um,
- 13:52perhaps we tend to, how should I say,
- 13:55um, find scapegoats, um, pass the buck
- 13:57from one side to the other so as not to
- 14:00take responsibility. Whose
- 14:03responsibility might it be? It is
- 14:05certainly shared, but where should we
- 14:07start?
- 14:08Well, the reasons are various. For one
- 14:11thing, there is the fact that Italy
- 14:13experienced a period of growth and
- 14:15prosperity built in the first decades
- 14:17after the Second World War. So, after
- 14:21the war, the Second World War, and
- 14:23after the reconstruction period, we
- 14:25were a country that had many young
- 14:26people, that produced social mobility,
- 14:28expanded rights and the welfare system,
- 14:30and even became one of the most
- 14:32important economies in the world. We
- 14:35joined the G7 in 1975,
- 14:39but precisely because that was a phase
- 14:41where Italy built its own economic and
- 14:43social model of prosperity, we remained
- 14:45convinced that it was that model that
- 14:47needed to be preserved. But that model
- 14:50doesn't work today, so we didn't call
- 14:52it into question in time. We remained
- 14:54stuck to that model that worked in the
- 14:56past, but won't work tomorrow, and so
- 14:59we didn't commit ourselves to
- 15:00understanding how the world was
- 15:02changing and how to enable new
- 15:04generations to be active subjects in
- 15:06building a new social and economic
- 15:08model. And all these choices, we didn't
- 15:11make them; we invested less than other
- 15:13countries in research, development, and
- 15:15innovation. I mean, how can you build,
- 15:17look to the future, build it in time,
- 15:19and give young people new skills if you
- 15:21don't invest in research, development,
- 15:24and innovation? And if we invest less,
- 15:27it is clear that young people remain
- 15:29there waiting to find a job because a
- 15:32sixty-year-old retires, instead of
- 15:34or they go abroad as well,
- 15:35or they go abroad where, indeed, they
- 15:37invest more in research, development,
- 15:39and innovation, instead of expanding
- 15:41job opportunities with quality work in
- 15:43the more dynamic and competitive
- 15:45sectors that grow if you invest in
- 15:46research, development, and innovation.
- 15:49Other countries also invested in active
- 15:51labor policies. Since the labor market
- 15:53was becoming increasingly articulate
- 15:55and complex, and young people were
- 15:56attaining higher educational
- 15:58qualifications, expert systems for
- 15:59matching labor supply and demand were
- 16:01also needed. Other countries invested
- 16:03and we did not. I mean, young people in
- 16:06Italy currently still find work, in the
- 16:08majority of cases, through
- 16:10acquaintances, referrals—that is,
- 16:12informal channels—rather than through
- 16:14channels that efficiently connect the
- 16:16skills you have and have been trained
- 16:19in with those the labor market is
- 16:21looking for, and bring them together at
- 16:23a higher level to the benefit of both.
- 16:27While today finding work is basically a
- 16:29matter of chance—that is, whatever
- 16:31comes along—this obviously puts those
- 16:33with less strong families behind them
- 16:35at a disadvantage, because if these
- 16:37expert systems matching supply and
- 16:39demand are missing, having a strong
- 16:41family background can help you land a
- 16:43good position, regardless of your
- 16:45skills or anything else. If you have a
- 16:49weak one, you find yourself having to
- 16:50give up or, in fact, the reason why
- 16:52social mobility has stalled in Italy is
- 16:54also due to the fact that we haven't
- 16:56invested in the conditions that allow
- 16:58young people to be well-trained and
- 17:00well-integrated into the job market.
- 17:04And then there is the aspect that we
- 17:06also undervalue female human capital;
- 17:09that is, one of the key components that
- 17:11makes a difference in driving change is
- 17:14the ability to incorporate a female
- 17:16perspective and sensibility into the
- 17:19processes of change in a world that is
- 17:21shifting. And if we continue to
- 17:26constrain women with gender differences
- 17:29and traditional roles, resulting in
- 17:32some of the lowest female employment
- 17:35rates in Europe, and having invested
- 17:38less in work-life balance policies, we
- 17:41end up with less drive for growth and
- 17:44development because female employment
- 17:47is lower. Less balance also means lower
- 17:51birth rates, because if you can't
- 17:52reconcile work and family, it means
- 17:54that those who work don't have children
- 17:55, and those who have children don't
- 17:57work. So you currently find the country
- 17:59with both low female employment and low
- 18:02fertility, and so what happens then?
- 18:05Lower birth rates reduce the
- 18:07demographic size of new generations,
- 18:09and this is another factor: if there
- 18:11are more elderly people because
- 18:13longevity is increasing, their
- 18:14electoral weight will also be greater,
- 18:16but the electoral weight of the elderly
- 18:19will shift the political agenda toward
- 18:21defending established interests of the
- 18:23present or past well-being. Meanwhile,
- 18:27those who have an interest in
- 18:29questioning the present and
- 18:30experimenting with new things are the
- 18:33younger generations, but their
- 18:35electoral weight is shrinking, and this
- 18:37is another element that risks making
- 18:39our country more rigid regarding
- 18:41projecting itself toward change and the
- 18:44transformations underway. And then
- 18:47there is the fact that if young people
- 18:49are already few in number, they are
- 18:51already struggling to enter the world
- 18:53of work; therefore, they are worried
- 18:55about their present, and their ability
- 18:57to act toward collective change is
- 18:58weakened. That is, each young person
- 19:02seeks their own escape route or private
- 19:05protection: therefore, longer stays in
- 19:07their family of origin, more help from
- 19:09parents, postponing life choices, or "
- 19:12I'm moving abroad." And this weakens,
- 19:15instead, the generational drive to
- 19:18produce change; meaning, I find my own
- 19:20single, individual escape route or way
- 19:22of adapting to a reality that is
- 19:25penalizing the new generations, rather
- 19:27than being a generation that
- 19:29collectively changes things, changes
- 19:31the rules of the game so that the whole
- 19:34country can function better with the
- 19:36new generations. Well, we risk
- 19:38weakening all these mechanisms, and
- 19:40this weakening means that the country
- 19:43is crushed in the present, the future
- 19:45continues to be postponed, and every
- 19:47year we find ourselves getting worse.
- 19:50Certainly. So, ultimately, you said
- 19:53it's a model that doesn't work, and I
- 19:55would add that it currently doesn't
- 19:58work for any generation because,
- 20:00obviously, if there is a generation
- 20:02that provides no kind of drive or
- 20:04cannot contribute because it lacks the
- 20:07space to do so, the other generations
- 20:09also, of course, don't.
- 20:12We are a country that risks aging
- 20:14poorly.
- 20:14Exactly.
- 20:15And why, where do pensions come from?
- 20:17From those who work. But if we have
- 20:19fewer and fewer workers because there
- 20:20are fewer young people or they go
- 20:22abroad, it becomes increasingly
- 20:23difficult to pay for the expenses and
- 20:25guarantee the funding for pensions,
- 20:27while in the meantime the elderly
- 20:28population is increasing. So you have
- 20:30an aging population that is growing,
- 20:32you have to increase pension spending,
- 20:34but you have fewer young people
- 20:35entering the workforce and more young
- 20:37people who, since they cannot find jobs
- 20:39or get adequate salaries, are leaving
- 20:40for abroad. So they cannot enter the
- 20:42workforce, they cannot contribute to
- 20:44the collective expenses needed for
- 20:46pensions, but they also cannot build
- 20:48their own pensions because if they
- 20:49don't enter the workforce properly and
- 20:51don't have adequate wages, what kind of
- 20:53pensions will they have in their future
- 20:55? In other words, it's better to leave
- 20:57and go to other countries where these
- 20:59opportunities are more favored. And
- 21:01then it's not just about pension
- 21:03spending, it's about the entire welfare
- 21:05system in general, because if you lack
- 21:08young people, you lack doctors, you
- 21:10lack nurses, it's not just engineers
- 21:12you're missing; you're missing the bus
- 21:14drivers, you're missing everything that
- 21:16makes the public welfare system
- 21:18function—not just what finances it,
- 21:20but the personnel and staff that
- 21:22actually run it: and this is the main
- 21:24problem. It is the aging of the
- 21:26population, because this is analogous
- 21:27to what is happening in other countries
- 21:29. I mean, it's not that young Italians
- 21:33go to countries where there are fewer
- 21:34elderly people, they go to countries
- 21:36where young people are valued more, and
- 21:38it is the appreciation of young people
- 21:40that then allows all generations to
- 21:42live well and to live well for a long
- 21:44time with quality and sustainability.
- 21:49So, returning for a moment to the young
- 21:52generation and the title, the "
- 21:54suspended generation,"
- 21:58in your opinion, is it a fitting name
- 22:00for us, for the young people of today?
- 22:04In my opinion, it is very fitting
- 22:06because it can be interpreted in
- 22:09various ways. It is suspended between
- 22:11the present and the future,
- 22:13meaning it is caught between the
- 22:15shortcomings of the present—what the
- 22:17present fails to offer—and the
- 22:19uncertainty of a future that cannot be
- 22:21built solidly, precisely because in the
- 22:23present, you don't find the conditions
- 22:25to be forward-looking and build your
- 22:27life path on a solid foundation. But
- 22:29does this make the country's future
- 22:31uncertain and suspended as well?
- 22:33Certainly,
- 22:34because young people, the new
- 22:35generations, are the bridge between the
- 22:37present and the future; if this bridge
- 22:39is solid and functions well, it carries
- 22:41the whole country forward and pushes it
- 22:43toward something positive. But if this
- 22:45bridge remains incomplete, the country
- 22:47essentially remains at a standstill.
- 22:50And what is it that remains incomplete
- 22:51and keeps everything suspended? The
- 22:53suspended choices of young people—
- 22:55that is, the possibility for young
- 22:57people to realize their life projects,
- 22:59their desires, and their expectations.
- 23:01And it is this difficulty in achieving
- 23:03professional fulfillment, in making
- 23:05solid educational choices, and in being
- 23:07able to realize one's life projects—
- 23:10which are weakening, particularly for
- 23:12young people compared to previous
- 23:14generations, and for Italian youth
- 23:16compared to their peers in other
- 23:17European countries—that ensures not
- 23:19only are there fewer young people, but
- 23:22their choices are weakened as well; and
- 23:24if their choices are weakened, they
- 23:26remain at a standstill, they remain
- 23:28stuck, and with them, the whole country
- 23:30. The entire country system.
- 23:33If we take this vicious cycle and,
- 23:36let's say, think of it as a chain,
- 23:39which link in this chain should we act
- 23:42upon right now? Beyond education, which
- 23:47is obviously something for the medium
- 23:49to long term, starting tomorrow, what
- 23:51should we act upon, both from the
- 23:53perspective of young people and from
- 23:55the perspective of politics? I think
- 23:59the vision must be systemic; there are
- 24:02no, shall we say, extemporaneous or
- 24:05fragmented choices, and there isn't one
- 24:08, let's say, single lever, magic wand,
- 24:11or knot that you can just touch to
- 24:14solve everything. There isn't one,
- 24:17but in my opinion, there is one element
- 24:19to start from that then allows
- 24:20everything else to move in the right
- 24:22direction, and that is the quality of
- 24:24work. Mm.
- 24:27I mean, if you allow young people, the
- 24:29new generations, to enter the workforce
- 24:31with adequate wages and the possibility
- 24:33for their human capital to be valued,
- 24:35you will have young people who become
- 24:37independent from their families of
- 24:39origin because they have a proper
- 24:40salary and do good work, who stay in
- 24:42Italy because they find jobs with fair
- 24:44pay, and who make businesses and
- 24:46organizations function because, if they
- 24:48are valued and enter the workforce,
- 24:50productivity increases and the
- 24:52competitiveness of those businesses
- 24:53rises. They won't stay in the market
- 24:57because they pay young people as little
- 24:59as possible, they will stay in the
- 25:01market because, through young people,
- 25:03they are more productive, more
- 25:04competitive, and therefore the
- 25:06country's capacity to produce
- 25:07high-quality goods and services
- 25:09increases, which in turn allows the
- 25:11economy to function better and position
- 25:13itself better in the global market. And
- 25:15then, all of this allows young people
- 25:18to have more solid prospects, so if
- 25:20they wish to start a family and have
- 25:22children, they will also have the
- 25:24adequate resources to pay social
- 25:25security contributions and even think
- 25:28about their own future pension. So,
- 25:31from there, in my opinion, is the
- 25:33element where, if you act, everything
- 25:35else somehow falls back into place,
- 25:38keeping in mind that if you invest in
- 25:40and improve the condition of young
- 25:42people in the labor market—that is,
- 25:45you ensure well-trained young people
- 25:47are valued in the workplace—well,
- 25:49training will also increase, meaning
- 25:52the investment in education, because
- 25:54even younger kids will say: "Well, if I
- 25:57get trained here, I am valued." And so,
- 26:00the more I train, the more I invest in
- 26:02my education; and the same strategic
- 26:04reasoning will be used by families: the
- 26:07more opportunities there are for
- 26:09children to improve their situation.
- 26:12And so, investing in training also
- 26:14becomes a strategic element that
- 26:16enables social mobility and therefore
- 26:18also helps reduce territorial, social,
- 26:20and gender inequalities from the start.
- 26:24This is what we must keep in mind,
- 26:25right? That is, what are the elements
- 26:27that simultaneously allow for the
- 26:29reduction of generational inequalities,
- 26:30but in combination with social, gender,
- 26:32and territorial ones, and that allow
- 26:34the country to grow. Well, if you start
- 26:37from there, meaning from the fact that
- 26:39young people entering the workforce can
- 26:41have adequate wages and be properly
- 26:43valued, it will be even more so for
- 26:45women, because they start at lower
- 26:47levels; it will be more so for young
- 26:49people from regions that offer fewer
- 26:52opportunities, who will then be able to
- 26:54earn more compared to the conditions
- 26:56they are currently in, and this will
- 26:58then improve their life choices, but
- 27:00also, as mentioned, enable businesses
- 27:03and the economy to function better.
- 27:06Unless we think the world and companies
- 27:08function better with a sixty-year-old
- 27:11worker rather than 25 or 30-year-olds.
- 27:15Perhaps they function better if they
- 27:17collaborate together, that is, if the
- 27:19experience of seniors and the
- 27:21innovation and fresh vision of the new
- 27:23generations are helped to come together
- 27:25and thus become a combination. It also
- 27:29allows everyone and different life
- 27:31stages to, uh, collaborate positively,
- 27:34because the world we live in is made
- 27:36this way; it's made of young people
- 27:39arriving, but it's also made of life
- 27:41stages that are lengthening. And so it
- 27:44is also made not of tensions between
- 27:46generations, but of collaboration
- 27:47between different generations.
- 27:50In fact, uh, you recently wrote an
- 27:52article on this, Professor, in which
- 27:54you say that every generation is
- 27:55different from previous ones, and
- 27:57different does not mean better or worse
- 27:59, but a bearer of sensitivities, skills
- 28:01, and ways of interpreting the world
- 28:03that are born within a specific
- 28:05historical context. This, let's say, is
- 28:10not something everyone says; especially
- 28:13now, in 2026, reaching such a sincere
- 28:15and transparent synthesis is not really
- 28:18something to be taken for granted. So
- 28:22there must certainly also be a, let's
- 28:26say, dimension of intergenerational
- 28:32collaboration within the policies and
- 28:35prospects for Italy's future. Yes, it
- 28:39is fundamental that there be
- 28:41collaboration between generations
- 28:44because, precisely, even if we were to
- 28:47put young people in the position to be
- 28:50absolutely well-integrated into the
- 28:53workforce and adequately valued, their
- 28:56reduced numbers would still not be
- 28:58sufficient for companies 'needs to grow
- 29:01and be competitive. Keep in mind that
- 29:05over the next 10 years, more than 6
- 29:08million people will retire. Italy will
- 29:13experience an exodus from the workforce
- 29:16to retirement like never before, and we
- 29:18do not have enough young people who can
- 29:21replace these 6 million who are
- 29:23retiring. This means that we not only
- 29:26need to invest in young people so that
- 29:28they are well-trained and enter the
- 29:29workforce as much and as well as
- 29:31possible; we also need to put all
- 29:33generations in a position to
- 29:34collaborate within the workplace and,
- 29:36additionally, to attract immigrants,
- 29:38precisely because otherwise demographic
- 29:40imbalances would be exacerbated. The
- 29:43thing is, we aren't doing this; we have
- 29:45more trouble thinking that immigration
- 29:48could also be a positive lever for
- 29:50demographic imbalances in the labor
- 29:52market, and on top of that, we have
- 29:55many young people leaving for abroad
- 29:57instead of valuing them within our own
- 30:00context. And these two things are
- 30:02linked, meaning that countries that
- 30:03most value their own young people
- 30:05manage to be attractive to them, and
- 30:07what's more, others arrive because by
- 30:09valuing their own, they manage to
- 30:10attract others as well. Countries that
- 30:13fail to value their own young people,
- 30:15on the other hand, also fail to be
- 30:17attractive to others, who end up using
- 30:19Italy, so to speak, as a transit
- 30:21country to go elsewhere where
- 30:23opportunities are better. Therefore,
- 30:26being attractive to the new generations
- 30:28, starting with the young people you
- 30:30train and enabling them to be
- 30:32well-integrated into the workforce and
- 30:34to feel fully realized in their life
- 30:36projects, is fundamental. This benefits
- 30:40all stages of life, generational
- 30:42collaboration, and economic growth, as
- 30:44well as attractiveness for human
- 30:46capital arriving from other countries.
- 30:50This point is also very interesting
- 30:52regarding the population decline, the
- 30:55demographic crisis we are experiencing,
- 30:58because, objectively, young people do
- 31:00not feel like having children in a
- 31:03climate of uncertainty and such
- 31:05precariousness—truly in a state of
- 31:07total suspension. I remember when I
- 31:12lived in Denmark, my roommate already
- 31:15had a child; we parted ways because she
- 31:17was pregnant, and she said, "I need to
- 31:20move out of this house, get a place of
- 31:23my own, and, well, raise my son in
- 31:25peace and tranquility." Then, of course
- 31:29, there are all sorts of subsidies and
- 31:32a very significant support system in
- 31:35place. And in Italy, what is our future
- 31:39? Both from the perspective of the
- 31:42demographic decline, the democratic and
- 31:44demographic crisis, and also the future
- 31:45of young people itself. Yes, the two
- 31:49things are clearly linked because, as
- 31:52long as we prolong the state of young
- 31:54people remaining in the role of "
- 31:56children"—that is, feeling like
- 31:57children until they are 30 because they
- 32:00lack housing autonomy, financial
- 32:02stability, and access to a home—as
- 32:04long as you are in the position of a
- 32:06child, it is hard to imagine yourself
- 32:08as a parent.
- 32:10Indeed, we are one of the countries in
- 32:12Europe with the oldest age for having a
- 32:14first child. The age at first child in
- 32:19Italy is about 2–3 years later
- 32:21compared to, for example, France, which
- 32:24has the highest birth rate in Europe.
- 32:27This means that we start having our
- 32:30first child when French women are
- 32:32already planning their second, and,
- 32:34obviously, this shifts everything
- 32:37forward. So, you either give up, have
- 32:40just one, or find it very difficult to
- 32:42have more. This further accentuates the
- 32:45demographic crisis and makes the
- 32:47country even more unbalanced, with the
- 32:50elderly population continuing to grow
- 32:52because longevity extends life, while
- 32:54the number of young people continues to
- 32:57dwindle. I mean, with this process of "
- 33:01de-youth-ification," which is the real
- 33:03issue, this quantitative decline that
- 33:05reduces the presence of young people in
- 33:08Italian society, has its cause in the
- 33:10qualitative decline—that is, the fact
- 33:12that we do not invest in the conditions
- 33:14that allow young people to become fully
- 33:17adult, to make the right choices at the
- 33:19right time, and to feel that these
- 33:21choices are supported, sustained, and
- 33:25produce value for their own lives and
- 33:27collective value because they
- 33:28contribute to a society and an economy
- 33:31that functions better. And as long as
- 33:33all this is lacking, it is clear that
- 33:35young people postpone, give up, or
- 33:37indeed leave for abroad. And it is
- 33:39interesting to see that young people
- 33:41who go abroad not only have better
- 33:43careers and better salaries, but also
- 33:44higher birth rates. And this makes it
- 33:47clear how the desire for
- 33:48self-fulfillment in a broad sense, when
- 33:51it finds the right conditions, bears
- 33:53the right fruit because you are put in
- 33:55a position to give your best and
- 33:57therefore also look towards what lies
- 33:59in the future, beyond yourself. But if
- 34:03you yourself are struggling to make
- 34:04your own life choices, how can you
- 34:06think about making the choice to have a
- 34:08child? If you do make it, that choice
- 34:12is a deliberate, conscious, empowering,
- 34:14and demanding one—that is, the most
- 34:16demanding choice in relation to the
- 34:18future. And if the suitable conditions
- 34:21are not there, you don't feel obligated
- 34:22to make it; in fact, you would feel
- 34:24irresponsible doing so. And rightly so,
- 34:27therefore, low birth rates are also
- 34:29linked to the condition of young people
- 34:32who, in these difficulties, struggle to
- 34:34fit that choice in, because they do not
- 34:37see it as a sustainable choice or one
- 34:39that allows them to fully realize
- 34:41themselves.
- 34:44So I see, let's say, a universe of many
- 34:46small or large things that obviously go
- 34:49on to influence the demographic crisis.
- 34:52It is obviously a cultural and
- 34:54work-related issue. And I know you also
- 34:58wrote a piece on the fact that the
- 35:01housing emergency worsens the
- 35:03demographic crisis, and we have just
- 35:07heard about it. In other words, there
- 35:13is another crisis that is not
- 35:15intuitively linked directly to the
- 35:17demographic crisis, but in reality, we
- 35:20can, let's say, trace this common
- 35:22thread. Well, everything that weakens
- 35:27not only the conditions of the present
- 35:29but also the possibility of projecting
- 35:32oneself into a positive and solid
- 35:34future hinders choices that look toward
- 35:37this future, which is your future life
- 35:39and another life, compared to the
- 35:41choice of having children. And so, for
- 35:45example, public debt—the fact that
- 35:47Italy is one of the countries with the
- 35:49highest public debt—is a generational
- 35:51injustice because it was accumulated to
- 35:53defend the prerogatives and well-being
- 35:55of previous generations and dumped onto
- 35:58the generations that follow. The public
- 36:01debt burns through percentages of GDP,
- 36:04and the Governor of the Bank of Italy
- 36:06said last year that we spend the
- 36:10equivalent of what we spend on
- 36:12education just on interest for the
- 36:15public debt. This shows just how much
- 36:18of a burden it is, hindering the
- 36:20possibility of investing in new
- 36:21generations, as well as the very idea
- 36:24that this generational pact has broken
- 36:26down; that is, we have to work to
- 36:28guarantee pensions for those who are
- 36:30elderly today, yet we don't know if we
- 36:32will have a pension ourselves. We have
- 36:36to work, and we have a public debt that
- 36:39is offloaded onto us and burns through
- 36:42the gross domestic product we
- 36:44contribute to, yet this debt becomes a
- 36:47constraint on our future that is simply
- 36:49passed down by previous generations.
- 36:53And all these aspects are aspects that
- 36:55undermine the possibility of feeling
- 36:57like we are in a country that values
- 36:59new generations, one that puts them in
- 37:02a position to feel part of a solid
- 37:04future. Therefore, demographic
- 37:07imbalances, public debt, and imbalances
- 37:09regarding social security and social
- 37:11spending are all elements that put the
- 37:14possibility for young people to think
- 37:16of a positive future into crisis, and
- 37:19thus they undermine, at the root, their
- 37:21ability to look beyond the present and
- 37:24make demanding and binding choices that
- 37:26reach further ahead.
- 37:29Certainly. So it also has an impact on
- 37:31the quality of life and future projects
- 37:33. In general. Well, as "Generazione
- 37:38Sospesa," we are putting forward some
- 37:41proposals, and I would like to know
- 37:44your thoughts on the four proposals,
- 37:46which, by the way, can be signed on the
- 37:49website generazionesospesa.it. So, the
- 37:55proposals are an income tax cut for
- 37:58those under 35, proportional to age.
- 38:03Then, tax relief on salary increases,
- 38:05bonuses, and so on; the abolition of
- 38:08extracurricular internships replaced by
- 38:10an entry-level contract; and finally,
- 38:13what we talked about earlier, namely
- 38:15vouchers and credits for continuous
- 38:18professional training. Do you see a
- 38:22glimmer of a future in these proposals?
- 38:26Well, they are very concrete proposals
- 38:27that affect the levers I was talking
- 38:29about earlier, that is, improving both
- 38:31the training of young people and their
- 38:33entry into the world of work, as well
- 38:35as the possibility of having slightly
- 38:37more solid wages. And we know that
- 38:40these are elements that hold back the
- 38:43possibility for young people to be in a
- 38:46position to feel valued and therefore
- 38:49make choices that improve their
- 38:51situation. However, there is something
- 38:56I would add regarding housing autonomy,
- 38:59and therefore policies that address the
- 39:01housing emergency. And Furthermore, it
- 39:07is true that we must also take concrete
- 39:10and specific measures that encourage
- 39:12companies to train and hire young
- 39:14people rather than simply exploiting
- 39:17them with internships and the like; but
- 39:19, on the other hand, in theory, in an
- 39:21ideal world, we shouldn't need them. I
- 39:25mean, we shouldn't have to incentivize
- 39:27companies to hire young people, treat
- 39:30them well, and value them; because for
- 39:32companies, if they want to grow, be
- 39:34competitive, and be productive, it is
- 39:37in their best interest to hire young
- 39:39people, engage them positively, and
- 39:41integrate them into the processes that
- 39:44create development and innovation. And
- 39:47this will be increasingly true in the
- 39:48coming years because, as we were saying
- 39:50before, the workforce is shrinking,
- 39:52right? That is, more and more people
- 39:54will retire; in fact, more people will
- 39:56retire in the next 10 years than ever
- 39:58before. And if companies want to
- 40:01continue to grow, have a workforce, and
- 40:03have new skills...where can they find
- 40:05them if not, precisely, from the new
- 40:07generations? This is even more vital,
- 40:10not only to respond to the demographic
- 40:12shortage, but also to the challenges of
- 40:13the green and digital transition, which
- 40:15requires new skills and new
- 40:16sensibilities to be brought into
- 40:18companies, because it is these
- 40:19companies that will become competitive
- 40:21and drive development in the coming
- 40:22years. So we must act on both aspects:
- 40:26concrete measures in the present that
- 40:29make young people realize immediately
- 40:31that a difference is being made, that
- 40:34things are improving; making them feel
- 40:36it right away, but then, progressively,
- 40:39having companies themselves become a
- 40:41context where the world improves
- 40:43through their ability to fully value
- 40:46the capacity and potential of the new
- 40:48generation, and what they know and want
- 40:52to do—the novelty they bring.
- 40:55Obviously, hoping that in all of this,
- 40:58the younger generations are not
- 41:00continuously exploited, underpaid, and
- 41:02treated the way they often are. Let’s
- 41:05keep in mind that this is the direction
- 41:07. The fact is that if they don't do it
- 41:11in Italy, they will do it in other
- 41:13countries; there will be ever-growing
- 41:15competition between companies and
- 41:16countries to attract the best talent—
- 41:19young, educated, dynamic, and
- 41:20enterprising—because they will be the
- 41:22primary energy that allows for the
- 41:24generation of development,
- 41:26competitiveness, and innovation. So the
- 41:29problem is partly for young people
- 41:31because they cannot find fulfillment
- 41:33and opportunities in the context in
- 41:35which they live, but it is above all a
- 41:37problem for those contexts that do not
- 41:39invest in young people, because young
- 41:41people can always move across borders
- 41:43and thus find opportunities elsewhere.
- 41:46Certainly, by giving up on finding
- 41:48value in their original context, but
- 41:50surely if the world is heading in any
- 41:52direction, it is heading in a direction
- 41:54where it needs well-prepared, dynamic,
- 41:57and enterprising young people.
- 41:59And let me ask you one last question on
- 42:01this topic. In your opinion, can Italy
- 42:05become attractive and competitive for
- 42:07those coming from abroad before
- 42:10becoming so for young Italians? Well no
- 42:13, that is not possible, in the sense
- 42:15that if you don't value the young
- 42:17people already here, you won't be able
- 42:20to attract others because they will
- 42:22find themselves in even worse
- 42:23conditions than the local youth. I mean
- 42:27, if there are difficulties in valuing
- 42:30the opportunity to enter the workforce
- 42:32or being well-paid for young Italians,
- 42:35it’s unlikely that those arriving
- 42:37from abroad won’t face the same
- 42:39difficulties. If there is difficulty in
- 42:42accessing housing with affordable rent,
- 42:45a young person arriving from abroad
- 42:47will find even more difficulty. And
- 42:50likewise, if there is difficulty for
- 42:51women to balance work and family—not
- 42:53just for women, but in general—
- 42:54families and couples arriving from
- 42:56abroad will find even more difficulty.
- 42:58Meaning all the aspects that don’t
- 43:00work regarding generational or gender
- 43:02imbalances in Italy are even more
- 43:04pronounced for those coming to our
- 43:06country from another. So that means we
- 43:10become attractive if we value young
- 43:12Italians well and if we reduce
- 43:14generational, gender, and regional
- 43:17imbalances. As long as these imbalances
- 43:19remain, immigration in itself will not
- 43:22solve the country's problems.
- 43:25Therefore, for Italy to become the fair
- 43:27Italy of the future, it needs the new
- 43:29generations too, and perhaps above all.
- 43:33Thank you, Professor Rosina, for being
- 43:35here with us. Thank you to you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of “Non è colpa dei giovani”: l’intervista al professor Rosina su denatalità, innovazione e futuro by Factanza Media, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,930 words across 1,125 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.