YouTube2Text

Neil deGrasse Tyson and Sean Carroll Discuss Controversies in Quantum Mechanics — Transcript

by StarTalk · 8,475 words · 1,200 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Schrodinger's cat everything in the Box
  2. 0:02the air the light you know everything
  3. 0:04moving around in the background
  4. 0:06interacts differently with the awake cat
  5. 0:10running around trying to get out and the
  6. 0:11asleep cat just snoring peacefully on
  7. 0:14the ground is there a world where I open
  8. 0:17the box and I see the awake cat as a
  9. 0:20different world from the one in which I
  10. 0:22open the box and it's asleep there will
  11. 0:24be two worlds and it happens long before
  12. 0:26you open the box because as soon as the
  13. 0:28other stuff in the Box as soon as the
  14. 0:30photons and the atoms and everything
  15. 0:31become entangled with the cat boom
  16. 0:33there's two worlds so where are those
  17. 0:35two worlds or is that the wrong question
  18. 0:37that's the wrong question the worlds are
  19. 0:38not located in space space is located in
  20. 0:41each world holy CRA I got to go I got to
  21. 0:44go believe be anymore it's over there is
  22. 0:48no God oh
  23. 0:51[Music]
  24. 0:53no this is Star Talk Neil degrass Tyson
  25. 0:57here your personal astrophysicist got
  26. 1:00with me Chuck Nice Chuck hey hey Neil
  27. 1:02hey what's happening all right what are
  28. 1:03you holding in your hand here holding a
  29. 1:05book oh okay a book that I uh you know
  30. 1:08that I um picked up off of the coffee
  31. 1:11table the biggest ideas in the universe
  32. 1:14well that's what this episode is going
  33. 1:15to be about yes but I know some big
  34. 1:18Ideas right but I don't know the biggest
  35. 1:21ideas there's a the in the front of this
  36. 1:22title right and like the qualifier yeah
  37. 1:28so this is written by the one and only
  38. 1:30Sean Carol Shan welcome to my office
  39. 1:33thank you so much New York your office
  40. 1:35these are the best places most exciting
  41. 1:37places that I we have corresponded and
  42. 1:40emailed and talked and we have never
  43. 1:42been in the same space no I think we did
  44. 1:45in La once right I think so I think
  45. 1:47briefly very very briefly but yeah many
  46. 1:50phone calls many emails delighted to
  47. 1:52have a meaningful exchange with you at
  48. 1:54this point right with microphones in
  49. 1:55front of us camera trained TR meaningful
  50. 1:58exactly Okay so just up before we delve
  51. 2:02in which Sean Caroll are you I'm the
  52. 2:05physicist one the physicist Sean Caroll
  53. 2:07yes and the other Sean Carol is who my
  54. 2:09evil twin he has the Beards you know
  55. 2:12which one is the evil twin but is it
  56. 2:14like is it a is it a it's not quite as
  57. 2:16evil it's more like bushy Santa Claus be
  58. 2:18it doesn't really look like but he's a
  59. 2:20very accomplished biologist uh also
  60. 2:22writes books you should buy those too
  61. 2:24okay very nice all right very good so
  62. 2:27Sean Carol let me get your your your bio
  63. 2:29going here the Homewood professor of
  64. 2:31natural philosophy that's very
  65. 2:34retro man just like Newton I was going
  66. 2:37to say yeah good Ike had some title like
  67. 2:39that natural philosophy at at the Johns
  68. 2:42Hopkins University down in Baltimore
  69. 2:44which is the home of the headquarters of
  70. 2:47the Hubble Space Telescope the Space
  71. 2:48Telescope Science Institute is right
  72. 2:50there cool uh and you're also on the
  73. 2:52faculty at the Santa Fe Institute but
  74. 2:55you're only on a visiting faculty so
  75. 2:56they got really cute here fractal
  76. 2:59faculty you got pretty cute get get CU
  77. 3:03you can't get cuter than that no you
  78. 3:04can't I mean unless there are a bunch of
  79. 3:06Sean carols who are tinier and look
  80. 3:08exactly like Sean Carol oh oh to
  81. 3:10continue the fractal continue the
  82. 3:12fractal right move on in Sean Carol at
  83. 3:15all scale exactly
  84. 3:18frightening and your research areas
  85. 3:21quantum physics SpaceTime cosmology
  86. 3:24emergence I love emergence maybe we can
  87. 3:26hit on that entropy I've seen a lot of
  88. 3:28that lately we can can you do something
  89. 3:30about entropy if you can't do anything
  90. 3:31about it I you have nothing for us I
  91. 3:33increase
  92. 3:35it we can do that without
  93. 3:38you Dark Energy Symmetry and origins of
  94. 3:41the universe you're all in you got a
  95. 3:43podcast podcast of your own mindscape I
  96. 3:46think I've been on that have I been on
  97. 3:47that podcast no not yet not yet okay we
  98. 3:50see
  99. 3:52maybe it's in my inbox maybe I haven't
  100. 3:54got to
  101. 3:56yet and this latest book the biggest
  102. 3:59ideas in the universe the second in a
  103. 4:01Trilogy this one Quant and Fields quanta
  104. 4:05well wouldn't that be the smallest idea
  105. 4:07in the
  106. 4:08universe smallest thing can be the
  107. 4:10biggest
  108. 4:12idea oh
  109. 4:13[Laughter]
  110. 4:15dear
  111. 4:18snap you got to put Chuck in his place
  112. 4:20early otherwise he'll just run ramp all
  113. 4:24over you yeah he got you on that one
  114. 4:26just he got you so if this is a Trilogy
  115. 4:28the first Big Ideas Book was what it was
  116. 4:31called SpaceTime in motion which is like
  117. 4:33Publishers speak for classical phys
  118. 4:35regular ordinary armchair physics Isaac
  119. 4:38Newton physics yeah Isaac Newton physics
  120. 4:40and Albert Einstein for that matter he
  121. 4:42was the star isn't it funny at this
  122. 4:43point Albert Einstein is the old physics
  123. 4:46classical physics classical physics now
  124. 4:48we're going Quant and Fields two very
  125. 4:50big ideas and can we get a hint in what
  126. 4:53you'll be happy to hear it's complexity
  127. 4:55and emergence is volume three that's
  128. 4:58going to be it's basically appeti is her
  129. 4:59main course dessert here so the third
  130. 5:02one's going to be fun okay very good
  131. 5:04you're an active research scientist you
  132. 5:06you publish books you're active on
  133. 5:08social media you so this is great just
  134. 5:10to see kindred soul out there it's very
  135. 5:13tiring isn't it why do we do
  136. 5:15this who idea was this let's go out and
  137. 5:18have a drink we'll talk about it in
  138. 5:21service to the universe yeah we are
  139. 5:23Servants of cosmic curiosity that
  140. 5:26permeates within us all we know that the
  141. 5:28idea of field
  142. 5:30as my memory of the history of physics
  143. 5:32began with Michael Faraday is that
  144. 5:34correct or does it go farther back than
  145. 5:35that that would be fine if you gave it
  146. 5:37to Faraday I mean he certainly played a
  147. 5:39huge role in figuring out mid 19th
  148. 5:41century mid 19th century electricity
  149. 5:43magnetism both had Fields associated
  150. 5:45with them technically no one ever
  151. 5:47mentions this but our old friend Pierre
  152. 5:50Simone
  153. 5:51LL Circa
  154. 5:531800 realized that you know Isaac Newton
  155. 5:56had this idea of gravity the inverse
  156. 5:59Square law and and Newton was very
  157. 6:01puzzled like you have the Earth here you
  158. 6:03have the moon over there there's a
  159. 6:04gravitational force how does the moon
  160. 6:07know what the gravitational force is
  161. 6:10there's nothing between them nothing
  162. 6:11between them action at a distance right
  163. 6:13and llas figured out you could rewrite
  164. 6:16Newton's theory of gravity in terms of a
  165. 6:19gravitational field so I kind of give
  166. 6:21him credit wow look at that so in my
  167. 6:24high school I had a friend who uh his
  168. 6:28name was Frank lce
  169. 6:30and we just learned about some of these
  170. 6:34great French physicist mathematicians
  171. 6:36lrange La PL and and over lunch one day
  172. 6:40he says will there will be the Larice
  173. 6:43equations this was this was just a fun
  174. 6:46little dream state that we all occupied
  175. 6:48in high school okay so Fields why are
  176. 6:52Fields real or are they just the
  177. 6:54convenience Because by the way you you
  178. 6:56are partially in the department of
  179. 6:58philosophy there get to ask you
  180. 7:00philosophically leaning questions I'm
  181. 7:03not allowed to say that's a philosophy
  182. 7:04question and ignore it I actually have
  183. 7:05to answer those question to answer
  184. 7:07that's my job good all right yeah so the
  185. 7:09story that we tell in the book is if you
  186. 7:11were 1895 right if you were just before
  187. 7:14the turn to the 20th century you would
  188. 7:16have thought that matter tables and
  189. 7:19chairs was made of particles right stuff
  190. 7:22we knew about electrons you knew about
  191. 7:23atoms and you would have thought that
  192. 7:25the forces between the atoms were
  193. 7:27mediated by Fields gravitational field
  194. 7:29the electric field the magnetic field
  195. 7:31and one of the great triumphs of quantum
  196. 7:33physics in the 20s and 30s was it said
  197. 7:36it's all field electricity magnetism are
  198. 7:40Fields but so are electrons and quarks
  199. 7:42and
  200. 7:42neutrinos and they vibrate in different
  201. 7:45ways and through the miracle of quantum
  202. 7:46mechanics when you look at those
  203. 7:48vibrating Fields they appear to us as
  204. 7:50particles the particles come out of the
  205. 7:53field is this an early variant of what
  206. 7:55would later be String Theory where
  207. 7:57they're saying particles or vibration in
  208. 7:59the strings well particles are
  209. 8:01vibrations in the fields and that's
  210. 8:03absolutely accurate in the regimes we're
  211. 8:05talking about here is there something
  212. 8:07deeper that they could be vibrations of
  213. 8:10strings Etc that's a speculative idea
  214. 8:12very very promising don't know yeah much
  215. 8:15small we don't need to know for
  216. 8:16predicting what's going to come out of
  217. 8:17the Large Hadron cide okay so you so let
  218. 8:20me ask you a blunt question which sounds
  219. 8:22stupid but I think it's me it's a
  220. 8:23meaningful question do electrons
  221. 8:26exist as as as now wait is that is that
  222. 8:30uh a science or a philosophical question
  223. 8:32well well because philosophy as I
  224. 8:36understand it we have never measured the
  225. 8:38size of the electron it is smaller than
  226. 8:40the smallest capacity we have ever
  227. 8:43conjured to measure its size okay I got
  228. 8:46to ask you uh a preliminary question how
  229. 8:49truthful do you want me to
  230. 8:51be I love it okay give me give me what
  231. 8:55you say in the back room in the back
  232. 8:57room with the cigars no first lie to me
  233. 9:02then tell me the truth okay the LIE is
  234. 9:05what is real is the electron field and
  235. 9:08little vibrations in those electron
  236. 9:10Fields show up in our detectors as
  237. 9:13particles so it's not that we haven't
  238. 9:15measured the size of the electron is
  239. 9:16that there is no such thing as the size
  240. 9:19of the electron the electron is a
  241. 9:20vibration in a field it can have
  242. 9:22different vibrational wavelength but so
  243. 9:24and it shows up as the particle yes
  244. 9:27that's right oh my God yeah that's right
  245. 9:29to the party that way but otherwise it's
  246. 9:31not yeah yeah okay that is so trippy
  247. 9:35that is so freaky man wait wait wait
  248. 9:37wait wait you and Einstein both were
  249. 9:39bothered by this bothered by this so you
  250. 9:42cannot measure the electron in its wave
  251. 9:47state to be a particle because the act
  252. 9:49of measuring it turns it into the
  253. 9:51particle the way that we usually measure
  254. 9:53things you say where is it and you get a
  255. 9:56little track in your particle detector
  256. 9:58cuz you keep asking where it is you
  257. 9:59always get a definite answer to the
  258. 10:00question where is it but when you're not
  259. 10:03asking that question it's spread out all
  260. 10:05over the place okay is that a lie or the
  261. 10:07truth that's the lie I Haven even gotten
  262. 10:08to the truth yet okay now now give me
  263. 10:10the truth okay when quantum mechanics
  264. 10:12came along in the 1920s we realized that
  265. 10:15instead of an elect let celebrate we in
  266. 10:16the Centennial we're very close of this
  267. 10:19of the of the discovery of quantum
  268. 10:21physics the centenial decade the quantum
  269. 10:23year yeah yeah yeah the Centennial
  270. 10:24decade and and that was a watershed
  271. 10:26decade where Hubble discovers that the
  272. 10:29Milky Way is not alone among galaxies in
  273. 10:32the universe and he discovers the
  274. 10:33universe is expanding and I'm just
  275. 10:35saying we got to tip our hat to the
  276. 10:381920s here the Roaring 20s we live in in
  277. 10:41shame that we can't live up to that
  278. 10:42anymore think about that all the time
  279. 10:45yeah it was too bad I mean let's be
  280. 10:47honest they weren't working with much to
  281. 10:49start with like you know low hanging
  282. 10:51yeah low hanging you guys are building
  283. 10:53on top of everything that they've
  284. 10:54actually discovered you know absolutely
  285. 10:57all right we're building up to the truth
  286. 10:58here so you realize in the 1920s that
  287. 11:01you thought the electron was a little
  288. 11:02particle in fact you should describe it
  289. 11:05in quantum mechanics by a wave function
  290. 11:07if you ever took chemistry if you ever
  291. 11:09saw those pictures of the orbitals of
  292. 11:11electrons Etc that's the wave function
  293. 11:13of the electron mhm soon thereafter you
  294. 11:16realize no actually you should be doing
  295. 11:18field Theory Quantum field Theory and so
  296. 11:20there's a field that the electron is a
  297. 11:23vibration in and you're asking what
  298. 11:25really exists well there's a wave
  299. 11:28function of that field so there's like
  300. 11:30fieldin on top of fieldin and finally
  301. 11:34you say that okay what if you have like
  302. 11:35different fields different particles do
  303. 11:37they each have a wave function no
  304. 11:39there's one wave function for the whole
  305. 11:42kitten Kaboodle of them the wave
  306. 11:43function of the
  307. 11:45universe that's what's real the wave
  308. 11:48function of the universe is you know he
  309. 11:50been smoking something that's crazy you
  310. 11:52know was he before
  311. 11:55this are you just talking this or or is
  312. 11:58this hypothesis ized soon to be
  313. 12:01experimentally verified I encourage all
  314. 12:03of the listeners out there to check out
  315. 12:05my paper entitled reality this be a
  316. 12:08research paper research paper called
  317. 12:10reality as a vector in Hilbert space
  318. 12:13okay that's what reality is so look
  319. 12:15first let me explain not everyone agrees
  320. 12:18with the true thing I just said so
  321. 12:19there's disagreement because of this
  322. 12:22fact that physicist it's your personal
  323. 12:24truth can't agree on what quantum
  324. 12:26mechanics really says so we have idea
  325. 12:29that everyone uses in quantum mechanics
  326. 12:31Hilbert space which is the space of all
  327. 12:34possible imaginal qu imaginable Quantum
  328. 12:36states of the universe and someone like
  329. 12:38me who is a purist an extremist about
  330. 12:40this says we have all possible Quantum
  331. 12:43States the actual universe is one of
  332. 12:45them and it changes with time other
  333. 12:48people will say no that's not reality
  334. 12:51that's just a tool we use to describe
  335. 12:52predictions to you know make predictions
  336. 12:55for experiments other people will say
  337. 12:57that's part of reality but there's other
  338. 12:58parts of as well we don't have a
  339. 13:00consensus on this okay I like the
  340. 13:02absence of consensus yeah exactly keeps
  341. 13:04you it wakes you up in the morning and
  342. 13:07and whole thing sounds very
  343. 13:09political oh yeah oh my God all right so
  344. 13:14where how do you square all the
  345. 13:17successful predictions of quantum
  346. 13:18physics with any intuitive understanding
  347. 13:21of what's going on because I I've said
  348. 13:24many times and I'm I'm happy to say it
  349. 13:26again the universe is under no
  350. 13:28obligation to make sense sense to us so
  351. 13:30once you accept that why try to make
  352. 13:33sense of it and and jump through hoops
  353. 13:35and brain twists just to say well it's
  354. 13:38got to be this or it's got to be that
  355. 13:40but it calculates and it works move on
  356. 13:43the universe is under no obligation to
  357. 13:44make sense but remarkably it keeps
  358. 13:47making sense once we really let
  359. 13:52ourselves listen to what the universe is
  360. 13:54trying to tell us Universe seems to be
  361. 13:56intelligible it's not deeply ineffably
  362. 14:00mysterious and it's a give and take it's
  363. 14:02not like our intuition just maps on to
  364. 14:05reality reality is like no you're
  365. 14:07intuition was a little bit off there try
  366. 14:09to update and if you're open-minded
  367. 14:11about it and you buy the right books
  368. 14:14very updatable you can absolutely get
  369. 14:16there is what I'm saying yeah hey Star
  370. 14:19Talk fans I don't know if you know this
  371. 14:21but the audio version of the podcast
  372. 14:25actually posts a week in advance of the
  373. 14:28video version version and you can get
  374. 14:30that in Spotify and apple podcast and
  375. 14:34most other podcast Outlets that are out
  376. 14:37there multiple ways to ingest all that
  377. 14:40is Cosmic on Star talk I'm reminded of
  378. 14:44the the the Charming illustrated book
  379. 14:47series by George cam uh Mr Tomkins in I
  380. 14:52guess Wonderland or and what he would do
  381. 14:55is he's a business famous business is
  382. 14:58mid 20th century okay lived only just
  383. 15:01died only 20 years ago or so but he yeah
  384. 15:05George gamma he was one of the original
  385. 15:07predictors of the temperature of the
  386. 15:11universe yeah if the universe began as a
  387. 15:13as an explosion with the big bang could
  388. 15:15you measure that and then he was on a
  389. 15:17paper that that okay so what what
  390. 15:20temperature did he get for it was like
  391. 15:22uh factor of 10 yeah no was it 10 factor
  392. 15:25of 10 no I within a factor of 10 they
  393. 15:28had different I think it was like 5 de
  394. 15:29he said the universe is 5° and the
  395. 15:32universe turned out to be 3° oh okay
  396. 15:35okay so rich God okay friend of the show
  397. 15:38has said that's like predicting that a
  398. 15:4350 foot fllying sorcerer will land on
  399. 15:46the White House lawn but a 30 foot
  400. 15:48flying sorcer lands
  401. 15:50on right yeah yeah it's not even that
  402. 15:54that the numbers are different it's that
  403. 15:55it's a prediction at all that would come
  404. 15:58true right but this story you're telling
  405. 15:59right here is exactly why this crazy
  406. 16:03talk about Hilbert spaces in Quantum
  407. 16:05Fields has some plausibility because we
  408. 16:09have some data in front of us we try to
  409. 16:11explain it we invent an equation that
  410. 16:13explains it and then we extrapolate that
  411. 16:15equation to Wild places that it's never
  412. 16:17been before and it comes back telling us
  413. 16:20yeah that's what I said that's what I
  414. 16:21said was going to happen and the Big
  415. 16:22Bang is an example Quantum field theory
  416. 16:24is another example but Mark Twain did
  417. 16:26this first you know you know the Mark
  418. 16:28Twain ISM yeah yeah yeah so he had read
  419. 16:30that there was some research paper about
  420. 16:32the rate at which the Mississippi River
  421. 16:35is depositing uh silt in the in the
  422. 16:38Delta and so it's growing in this
  423. 16:40direction and then he says oh uh that
  424. 16:44means you know 30 million years ago the
  425. 16:47Mississippi River ended in
  426. 16:50Canada and then he says the great thing
  427. 16:53about science there's such uh wholesale
  428. 16:56conclusions drawn from a trifling
  429. 16:58investment fact
  430. 17:00oo man that's brilliant yeah that's Mark
  431. 17:03Twain doing it in Mr Tomkins in
  432. 17:05Wonderland what made it entertaining
  433. 17:07especially if you're a budding scientist
  434. 17:09is he changes the values of the physical
  435. 17:11constants in an Ordinary World okay so
  436. 17:15and then you get to see what happens in
  437. 17:17an ordinary way otherwise these
  438. 17:19phenomena are inaccessible to us one of
  439. 17:22them he said all right 60 miles an hour
  440. 17:25is the speed of light and now you're
  441. 17:27driving down the street what do you see
  442. 17:28and then another one I think he changed
  443. 17:30planks constant yeah sure and so could
  444. 17:33you just give me a handle cool on things
  445. 17:37that would happen if Plank's constant
  446. 17:40were macroscopic like if I walked
  447. 17:42through the doorway I would like defract
  448. 17:44right right wouldn't I yeah you would
  449. 17:47defract and we wouldn't be able to know
  450. 17:49exactly that you had a position and
  451. 17:51velocity at the same time right you know
  452. 17:53the old joke about verer Heisenberg
  453. 17:55being pulled over and the cop says you
  454. 17:58know how fast you were going and
  455. 17:59Heisenberg says no but I know exactly
  456. 18:00where I am because you can't know
  457. 18:03according to the Heisenberg uncertainty
  458. 18:04principle both your velocity and
  459. 18:05position at the same BR at physics
  460. 18:10conf I was going to say who wrote that
  461. 18:13can I try that out I don't know
  462. 18:15yeah that's the uncertainty principle no
  463. 18:17one would pin you down in quantum
  464. 18:20mechanics you're fundamentally not a set
  465. 18:22of particles you're a set of waves if
  466. 18:24the plun constant which sort of sets the
  467. 18:26scale for quantum physics were much
  468. 18:29bigger macroscopic then we would all be
  469. 18:31these kind of undulating waves moving
  470. 18:33through the universe interfering with
  471. 18:35each other and becoming entangled and
  472. 18:38then measuring things and you we don't
  473. 18:39want to live there it's not no place to
  474. 18:41be really and so you mentioned entangled
  475. 18:45that's been a buzz phrase everybody
  476. 18:46loves it everybody loves it's one of the
  477. 18:48biggest hits hearing about it's one of
  478. 18:50the biggest hits right now entanglement
  479. 18:53entanglement so uh one of the the goals
  480. 18:58is what's the farthest particle that you
  481. 19:01can entangle on the premise that maybe
  482. 19:03that'll be useful one day and from all
  483. 19:05the news articles I've seen China leads
  484. 19:07the world uh in in Tangled particle
  485. 19:11distances so so what do you have to do
  486. 19:14to I'm sorry I because I'm I'm just
  487. 19:17losing something right here I'm missing
  488. 19:19something if something is entangled what
  489. 19:22difference would it make about the
  490. 19:24distance I'm missing that who knows I'm
  491. 19:27saying in science you just push the
  492. 19:29envelope if you've never pushed it
  493. 19:30before I got you one day are they we
  494. 19:33heard in Congress that just did you hear
  495. 19:35in Congress China is going to land
  496. 19:37something on The Far Side of the Moon
  497. 19:39and Congress wants to know why how come
  498. 19:41we're not landed something on the far
  499. 19:43side of this was an entire conversation
  500. 19:45in Congress right right no but Chuck is
  501. 19:47completely right about entanglement it
  502. 19:49doesn't matter how far away things are
  503. 19:51but the problem with two entangled
  504. 19:53particles which we haven't even defined
  505. 19:55what that means but you have a very
  506. 19:56sophisticated audience so they know what
  507. 19:58this means is that as soon as you
  508. 20:00measure one of them the entanglement
  509. 20:02breaks so it's not that they get further
  510. 20:04apart just that as you bring them
  511. 20:06further apart the chances that one of
  512. 20:07them bumps into something gets bigger
  513. 20:09and bigger and so therefore so that's
  514. 20:11what makes this distance record
  515. 20:14meaningful as a as a record so one of
  516. 20:16them was they entangled
  517. 20:18particles between orbit and Earth's
  518. 20:20surface and another one was they
  519. 20:23entangled particles inside a fiber optic
  520. 20:27uh uh Network okay 50 km which which is
  521. 20:31about City size and so then the
  522. 20:34suspicion is with entangled particles
  523. 20:36you might be able to make a secure
  524. 20:39internet
  525. 20:41undecodable
  526. 20:43un unhackable you can't you can't it
  527. 20:46encryption wouldn't make a difference at
  528. 20:47that point right because it's instant so
  529. 20:49is this is this a pipe dream well it's
  530. 20:52very hard because once you get Beyond a
  531. 20:55few particles it becomes harder and
  532. 20:56harder and harder to remain all of them
  533. 20:58being entangled with each other and
  534. 20:59that's ultimately what you need but
  535. 21:02that's a technology problem it's not
  536. 21:03like you're violating the laws of
  537. 21:04physics so we're setting our best
  538. 21:06Engineers on it trying to build quantum
  539. 21:08computers etc got a brad Engineers you
  540. 21:10fixed it you do that we've shown it's
  541. 21:13conceivable what are you want from us
  542. 21:15yeah what more do you need the math
  543. 21:17works all right Johnson there's no law
  544. 21:19of physics against it right exactly you
  545. 21:22know the the the engineers who said we
  546. 21:24will never fly faster than sound did not
  547. 21:26get that from a physicist that's right
  548. 21:28okay
  549. 21:29because we bols went faster than sound
  550. 21:32the crack of a whip is faster than sound
  551. 21:34you know we we we had that so I but so
  552. 21:38back to this can you foresee a value to
  553. 21:42a 50
  554. 21:43kilometer Quantum entangled Network the
  555. 21:47size of a city you know mostly that's
  556. 21:49just showing off I think it's much more
  557. 21:52important technologically to have a
  558. 21:54thousand or a million Quantum entangled
  559. 21:57things very close to each other
  560. 21:59then you can manipulate them build a
  561. 22:00computer do isn't that what goes on in a
  562. 22:03Quantum chip isn't there a lot of
  563. 22:05entangled would like it to be you don't
  564. 22:07it's very very hard because literally
  565. 22:10any Photon that bumps into them messes
  566. 22:12things up that's why you need to push it
  567. 22:14down to absolute zero or very very close
  568. 22:16oh I not fully appreciated that the
  569. 22:18photos I saw most of that was just like
  570. 22:21refrigerator the
  571. 22:23door the freezer compartment just to to
  572. 22:26have the little bitty thing in the
  573. 22:27middle otherwise cuz like you and I
  574. 22:29radiating our infrared all over the
  575. 22:30place would would totally decohere those
  576. 22:33Quantum bits that would be the opposite
  577. 22:35of cohere which which is what this
  578. 22:38conversation makes me feel like are you
  579. 22:40de decoherent decoherent I'm
  580. 22:44decoherent catch us up on entangled
  581. 22:46particles well this is part of this fact
  582. 22:48that we said before that there's not a
  583. 22:51separate Quantum wave function for every
  584. 22:54individual thing in the universe there's
  585. 22:55only one wave function for all of them
  586. 22:57at once and what the wave function tells
  587. 22:59us is the probability of observing
  588. 23:01something so if you have two particles
  589. 23:04and let's say they have positions you
  590. 23:05don't know where it is in fact literally
  591. 23:07when something like the higs boson
  592. 23:09decays decays into an electron and a
  593. 23:12positron the anti-electron and you say
  594. 23:14well what direction are they going in
  595. 23:16the answer is they're both going in all
  596. 23:17directions their wave functions are
  597. 23:19coming out sort of in a spherical
  598. 23:20pattern but then when you observe one of
  599. 23:23them that's where it is that's where it
  600. 23:25is and and momentum is conserved so now
  601. 23:28you know the other one is going exactly
  602. 23:31so you know where the other one is
  603. 23:32without having detected it yet that's
  604. 23:34entanglement so what entangles them the
  605. 23:36rules of physics okay that doesn't
  606. 23:39that's not stop it that's
  607. 23:42just out of
  608. 23:45here that's my mother saying because I
  609. 23:48said so that's what Mom why can't I have
  610. 23:51ice cream for breakfast because I said
  611. 23:53so that's why what law of physics
  612. 23:56prescribes this quantum mechanics that's
  613. 23:59the nature of quantum mechanics it's
  614. 24:00sort of that this is how science works
  615. 24:02you sort of conjecture an idea then you
  616. 24:05say is that right or not and so in
  617. 24:08quantum mechanics the the fundamental
  618. 24:10way things work is that the state of the
  619. 24:12universe is a vector in Hilbert space
  620. 24:15which means that the combined state of
  621. 24:18every particle in the universe and every
  622. 24:19field and every everything is described
  623. 24:22by one single mathematical object and in
  624. 24:25fact I don't like the word entanglement
  625. 24:27because it kind of it it makes it hard
  626. 24:29to update your intuition it makes it
  627. 24:31sound like what really exists are these
  628. 24:34two particles and you measure one then
  629. 24:36you're like why did the other one change
  630. 24:38if you just accept that what exists is
  631. 24:41the combined Quantum state of everything
  632. 24:42in the universe then it's no surprise at
  633. 24:44all that when you look at a little bit
  634. 24:45of it it affects the rest okay but
  635. 24:48interesting can I just take two random
  636. 24:51particles okay that's I gotta admit that
  637. 24:55makes a lot of sense can I take two
  638. 24:58random particles that were not born
  639. 25:01together and entangle them sure okay
  640. 25:03yeah entanglement happens whenever you
  641. 25:06have two objects that are not entangled
  642. 25:09but they interact with each other in
  643. 25:11different ways depending on different
  644. 25:13parts of their wave function so let me
  645. 25:14just give you a down toe example
  646. 25:16Schrodinger's cat you've heard about
  647. 25:18this schinger uh who apparently didn't
  648. 25:20like cats uh goes to a great amount of
  649. 25:24thought experiment effort to put a cat
  650. 25:26in a super position that's right that
  651. 25:27would have never work with Schrodinger's
  652. 25:29dog that that would not have flown
  653. 25:31sher's daughter would had it said that
  654. 25:33he didn't like cats this why he picked
  655. 25:35the cat so it's in a super position of
  656. 25:38alive and dead I'm a cat person so I in
  657. 25:40my version they're a super position of
  658. 25:42awake and asleep oh it's very sweet you
  659. 25:44don't have to kill the cat you don't
  660. 25:45have to it I didn't know you didn't have
  661. 25:47to kill the cat point is you don't have
  662. 25:48to kill the cat but the point is there
  663. 25:49are different places in the Box okay and
  664. 25:53what that means is that everything in
  665. 25:55the Box the air the light you know
  666. 25:57everything moving around in the
  667. 25:59background interacts differently with
  668. 26:02the awake cat running around trying to
  669. 26:04get out and the asleep cat just snoring
  670. 26:07peacefully on the ground and so the
  671. 26:09environment as we say entangles with the
  672. 26:12cat right away because it interacts with
  673. 26:14it but interacts with it differently
  674. 26:16depending on different parts of the wave
  675. 26:17function okay I don't know that that's
  676. 26:19more clear to me so you're you're sleep
  677. 26:23and awake
  678. 26:24cat but we declared that without
  679. 26:27actually sleep and awake cat in the Box
  680. 26:30I mean we just asserting that why does
  681. 26:32that make could the cat just be
  682. 26:36drowsy you know this is in out this is
  683. 26:39sher's whole point this is why he set up
  684. 26:41in the in the experiment there's a
  685. 26:43radioactive sub thought experiment he
  686. 26:46didn't do it so radioactivity and
  687. 26:48there's a Geer counter and the guer
  688. 26:50counter will click when it detects a
  689. 26:52radioactive decay in radioactivity you
  690. 26:55have no idea which particle is going to
  691. 26:57Decay well okay just statistically you
  692. 27:00know very accurately what fraction of
  693. 27:02them will but the fact that you don't
  694. 27:03know creates a brilliant beautiful
  695. 27:06random number in a sense yeah okay so if
  696. 27:10you needed a random thing you get a
  697. 27:11decaying set of particles and you can
  698. 27:13build you can draw Randomness from that
  699. 27:17that is as is that that's as good of
  700. 27:19random as we can produce 100% random as
  701. 27:21far as we know right as far as we
  702. 27:22nothing nothing better and this is you
  703. 27:24know the 1930s when sheringer was very
  704. 27:26unhappy with the state of quantum
  705. 27:27mechanic he was not bragging about
  706. 27:29quantum mechanics he was saying surely
  707. 27:31you don't believe this and he says when
  708. 27:34we say this particle has a probability
  709. 27:37of decaying what quantum mechanics
  710. 27:39actually says is that there's a wave
  711. 27:41function for the particle and it is in a
  712. 27:44superposition of I have decayed and I
  713. 27:46have not decayed uhhuh and the part of
  714. 27:48it that is decayed sets off the Geer
  715. 27:51counter now the guer counter is in a
  716. 27:53superposition of I have clicked and I
  717. 27:55have not clicked and the guer counter in
  718. 27:57the part that clicks knocks over a
  719. 27:59hammer breaks a vial full of sleeping
  720. 28:02gas and the cat goes to sleep to sleep
  721. 28:06so the cat goes into a superp position
  722. 28:10of being awake and being asleep that's
  723. 28:12the whole point of the sort of Ru girl
  724. 28:14Ru Goldberg Gizmo that schinger builds
  725. 28:16in there but how does that help anything
  726. 28:19like well schinger is trying to say in
  727. 28:23in the way that we thought of quantum
  728. 28:24mechanics back then there was these
  729. 28:26giant debates between bore and Einstein
  730. 28:28about what quantum mechanics really
  731. 28:29means Neil and Neil bore would have said
  732. 28:32look when you open the box and look the
  733. 28:35cat suddenly changes from being in a
  734. 28:37superp position of awake and asleep to
  735. 28:39being one or the other okay and shinger
  736. 28:41is like come on you think that when I
  737. 28:44look at it it changes like that I got
  738. 28:46you I got you so his thing is that
  739. 28:49superposition exists at all times
  740. 28:51everywhere no matter what and it has
  741. 28:54nothing to do with the fact that I
  742. 28:56looked at it it's in that super position
  743. 28:58you just got to accept that should have
  744. 29:01said that he he blinked he lost courage
  745. 29:03at the last second oh and it was uh a
  746. 29:06decade and a half later uh or two
  747. 29:08decades later a graduate student at
  748. 29:10Princeton named Hugh Everett said
  749. 29:12exactly those words he said just believe
  750. 29:14what the what the formula is telling you
  751. 29:16and what the formula tells you is when
  752. 29:18you look at it guess what you enter into
  753. 29:21a super position there's a part of you
  754. 29:24that has seen the cat awake and a part
  755. 29:26of you that has seen the cat asleep and
  756. 29:28Hugh Everett says that's cuz both of
  757. 29:31those possibilities exist just in two
  758. 29:34separate worlds because what we're
  759. 29:36dealing with is a probability in the
  760. 29:38first place so that always exists it
  761. 29:40doesn't change because you observed it
  762. 29:43it's still the same wait you just
  763. 29:45mentioned in that world I have some
  764. 29:47memory that I haven't heard about lately
  765. 29:50but
  766. 29:51that it was was it the Copenhagen
  767. 29:55interpretation that was Neil B Neils
  768. 29:57bore is is Danish okay and so they
  769. 30:01credited I guess the city but it was
  770. 30:03really a a bore interpretation not a
  771. 30:06Copenhagen well he had his people who
  772. 30:08would come into His Institute and hang
  773. 30:09around and go out you know spreading the
  774. 30:11gospel abore so this was the idea yeah
  775. 30:15Heisenberg poy there's a bunch there's a
  776. 30:17bunch okay so uh can you catch us up on
  777. 30:20the many worlds interpretation right so
  778. 30:22the Copenhagen interpretation really
  779. 30:24frustrated people like Einstein and
  780. 30:26schinger because it seemed to give up on
  781. 30:29arguably the single most crucial feature
  782. 30:32of science which is realism about the
  783. 30:35physical world you know before quantum
  784. 30:37mechanics came along you knew there was
  785. 30:39a real world out there even if you
  786. 30:41didn't know exactly what it was doing
  787. 30:44and bore and his friends seem to be
  788. 30:46saying that before you open the box and
  789. 30:49look at the cat there is no fact of the
  790. 30:51matter about what the cat
  791. 30:53is and Einstein schinger said you know
  792. 30:57even if you don't know what the fact of
  793. 30:58the matter is there should be some and
  794. 31:01so Everett sort of lives up to the
  795. 31:05dreams of Einstein and schinger says yes
  796. 31:07there is a reality there but sadly for
  797. 31:10you the reality is there's many
  798. 31:11different worlds and they don't interact
  799. 31:13with each other so ever is just saying
  800. 31:15that in this world of
  801. 31:17superpositions that quantum mechanics
  802. 31:19always describes you should just take
  803. 31:22them all seriously they're all actually
  804. 31:24there it's not just a mathematical trick
  805. 31:26that is real really really
  806. 31:30tough that is rough you got the sleepy
  807. 31:33cat you got the awake sleep cat you got
  808. 31:35the awake cat is there a
  809. 31:38world where I open the box and I see the
  810. 31:42awake cat as a different world from the
  811. 31:46one in which I opened the box and it's
  812. 31:47asleep there is there are will there
  813. 31:50will be two worlds and it happens long
  814. 31:52before you open the box because as soon
  815. 31:54as the other stuff in the Box as soon as
  816. 31:56the photons and the atoms and everything
  817. 31:58become entangled with the cat boom
  818. 32:00there's two worlds so where are those
  819. 32:02two worlds or is that the wrong question
  820. 32:04that's the wrong question I see that you
  821. 32:06quickly got it as soon as you asked it
  822. 32:07you knew no I knew but the worlds are
  823. 32:09not located in space space is located in
  824. 32:12each world he knows it get got I got to
  825. 32:16leave I Need You Chuck Chuck I need you
  826. 32:19I don't believe you anymore it's over no
  827. 32:22there is no God oh
  828. 32:25no I mean that's also true but okay
  829. 32:28another
  830. 32:30podcast wow that is so cool I mean that
  831. 32:34is really really freaky trippy cool and
  832. 32:37many many people believe this not
  833. 32:39everyone does so it's a it's something
  834. 32:41we don't have a consensus on people
  835. 32:42don't believe it have a better I was
  836. 32:44going to say if you don't believe that
  837. 32:45then you got to go back to what we were
  838. 32:48just talking about which is the Neil's
  839. 32:50boore now you're actually I'm sorry that
  840. 32:54sounds more like magic that doesn't that
  841. 32:57sounds like magic to me like I opened it
  842. 33:00up or I looked at it or because I looked
  843. 33:02at the electron that's when it is where
  844. 33:05it is and became what it became why
  845. 33:08would that be why I mean why would that
  846. 33:10I have to clear something up here go
  847. 33:11ahead just before help me out okay no
  848. 33:14let me just clear something go ahead in
  849. 33:17physics we talk about the Observer uhuh
  850. 33:20okay on on many levels and okay in
  851. 33:23quantum physics The Observer is not
  852. 33:25simply some conscious entity look
  853. 33:29if you want to a measurement you have to
  854. 33:31like shine on it you have to interact
  855. 33:33with it in some way and what happened
  856. 33:36over the years over the decades is like
  857. 33:38the there's like a New Age movement that
  858. 33:42was convinced after hearing this kind of
  859. 33:44vocabulary started saying oh it's our
  860. 33:47Consciousness that's affecting the
  861. 33:49outcome look at it it's your your brain
  862. 33:53energy going into the thing yeah that's
  863. 33:55like some Quantum field of dream stuff
  864. 33:57right there yeah that's
  865. 33:59crazy that's crazy so do you get a lot
  866. 34:01of this new age folks com back
  867. 34:04absolutely respectable physicists who
  868. 34:05said exactly things like that who really
  869. 34:08oh yeah bner howy yeah they oh yeah oh
  870. 34:13yeah okay but they're all dead now look
  871. 34:15quantum mechanics is forcing you to make
  872. 34:19some hard decisions about how reality
  873. 34:21works and so they're all freaky one way
  874. 34:23or the other either there's many many
  875. 34:25worlds or you bring it into existence by
  876. 34:27looking at it or there is no reality and
  877. 34:29you know none of them are exactly what
  878. 34:31we grew up thinking the Star Talk
  879. 34:33interview with physicist Sean Carroll
  880. 34:35had some spillage that didn't fit in
  881. 34:38what we posted to the general public it
  882. 34:40was at that meeting where I met Seth
  883. 34:42McFarlin oh cool if she continues to do
  884. 34:45what she does and uh successfully so it
  885. 34:48will ruin Neil's chances of ruining
  886. 34:50every other movie you
  887. 34:53stop stop when I saw the Thor movie I
  888. 34:55always wondering how much does that
  889. 34:56hammer weigh we we all Wonder this right
  890. 34:59Miller forged in the heart of a Dying
  891. 35:01star and I said yes I got this the heart
  892. 35:05of a Dying star if you want to get the
  893. 35:08rest of that content either become a
  894. 35:10patreon member and that gives you access
  895. 35:12or if you're already a patreon member go
  896. 35:15right on in and continue that
  897. 35:17episode quantum
  898. 35:19physics uh is would you'd agree it's the
  899. 35:22most successful idea of the universe
  900. 35:24we've ever had yes yes there's nothing
  901. 35:26comes close so I can exist in my
  902. 35:29macroscopic state because the
  903. 35:33quantum averages of me make me a
  904. 35:37physical object that's fair probably to
  905. 35:39say that okay I see what you're say I
  906. 35:41got so I can still be described by
  907. 35:43quantum physics that's just not as
  908. 35:45convenient as Newtonian physics and all
  909. 35:48the light in the room is constantly
  910. 35:49measuring you and localizing you okay
  911. 35:52yes exactly exactly okay so now now are
  912. 35:55you here at the moment you're here right
  913. 35:58now okay so if all the
  914. 36:01quantum phenomenon average out into my
  915. 36:05macroscopic
  916. 36:06state is there any
  917. 36:09Quantum manifestation in the large scale
  918. 36:12Universe oh yeah sure um our favorite
  919. 36:16has to be the microwave background the
  920. 36:18cosmic microwave background right now we
  921. 36:20don't know this for sure but you look at
  922. 36:22the Relic radiation from The Big Bang
  923. 36:25okay big bang 14 billion years ago was
  924. 36:28hot and dense and glowing about 300 and
  925. 36:31some
  926. 36:32100,000 380 I think 100,000 years after
  927. 36:36the big bang it became transparent and
  928. 36:39so we see the Relic radiation from The
  929. 36:41Big Bang and for reasons we don't
  930. 36:43completely understand it's super duper
  931. 36:45smooth it's almost exactly the same
  932. 36:47temperature radiation from place to
  933. 36:49place but it's not exactly the same
  934. 36:51direction you can look at this direction
  935. 36:53opposite direction two completely
  936. 36:56opposite directions
  937. 36:58the temperature in this office is
  938. 37:00nowhere near that stable right right in
  939. 37:03this corner it's like 2 degre higher 3
  940. 37:05five and what's it's you're saying one
  941. 37:08part in 100,000 one part in 100,000
  942. 37:11difference in temperature from this side
  943. 37:12of the universe to that side and it's
  944. 37:15that uniform all the way across yeah
  945. 37:17that's insane it's insane that's insane
  946. 37:19and my office can't wellow that but that
  947. 37:22that really does kind of say that you
  948. 37:26know that all of that that the Big Bang
  949. 37:28happened and that you know it came from
  950. 37:30this one thing it had to come from the
  951. 37:32one thing because that's how that's the
  952. 37:34only way as it spreads out that you can
  953. 37:36get that kind of uniformity is that it
  954. 37:38comes from this one thing that's right
  955. 37:40and the best theory that we have for why
  956. 37:42it's so uniform is called inflation okay
  957. 37:45you might have heard before the universe
  958. 37:46expands at some super fast rate very
  959. 37:48very early on and it's very much like
  960. 37:51stretching your sheet on your bed and
  961. 37:53smoothing it out right it wants to
  962. 37:54smooth it out but something gets in the
  963. 37:57way quantum mechanics so quantum
  964. 38:00mechanics says you're trying to smooth
  965. 38:01out the universe the best you can but
  966. 38:03when you measure it there'll be little
  967. 38:05Ripples and we think that those tiny
  968. 38:07variations in temperature one part in
  969. 38:10100,000 come from the quantum mechanical
  970. 38:13uncertainty in the state of the universe
  971. 38:15at Early times and of course those grow
  972. 38:17into planets and stars and galaxies the
  973. 38:21quantum it has left its paw print in the
  974. 38:25picture of the early Universe right
  975. 38:28oh man another way to is am I right to
  976. 38:30say that had it been completely smooth
  977. 38:33it's not clear that we would have made
  978. 38:35Galaxy I was going to say would we even
  979. 38:36be here EXA we even be here these
  980. 38:38fluctuations give us the seeds on which
  981. 38:40you collapse matter yeah all right that
  982. 38:43is so nutty but let me bring up one
  983. 38:46other important manifestation makes us
  984. 38:48understand it better hopefully it will
  985. 38:51not if it regresses the chair is solid
  986. 38:54that's all because of quantum mechanics
  987. 38:56you know you've seen the picture the
  988. 38:57cartoon of an atom right little nucleus
  989. 38:59in the middle electrons orbiting around
  990. 39:01like it's a solar system that can't be
  991. 39:04right cuz if you get a bunch of atoms
  992. 39:06together and they're all little solar
  993. 39:07systems they would just squish
  994. 39:09together it's not right that picture
  995. 39:11because the electrons are not little
  996. 39:13Point particles moving in orbits they're
  997. 39:15wave functions that have a size they
  998. 39:18take up space and the reason why the
  999. 39:20chair can be solid is because the wave
  1000. 39:22functions of electrons in the atoms take
  1001. 39:26up space and don't want to over La APAP
  1002. 39:28and therefore matter has extent in space
  1003. 39:31one of my favorite stories was was it
  1004. 39:33from the book Night thoughts of a
  1005. 39:35classical physicist oh yeah LS oh no
  1006. 39:38that's not no or no no maybe no I'm I'm
  1007. 39:40misremembering so either it was
  1008. 39:42fictionalized in that novel or I'm
  1009. 39:44remembering it as a as as a memoir from
  1010. 39:47Ernest Rutherford who first showed how
  1011. 39:50empty the atom is MHM by passing uh was
  1012. 39:54it neutrons or alpha particles alpha
  1013. 39:56particles okay so he's got he's got um
  1014. 40:00helium nuclei and he has a very thin
  1015. 40:03sheet of gold because you can Hammer
  1016. 40:05gold very very thin and so he wants to
  1017. 40:07get like the fewest width atoms of gold
  1018. 40:12foil that he can possibly then he starts
  1019. 40:14firing particles through it and like
  1020. 40:16nearly all of them just go straight
  1021. 40:17through untouched UND undiverted
  1022. 40:21nothing and then he alone at that moment
  1023. 40:24realized how empty matter was mhm MH and
  1024. 40:27and and this is the story what I hear
  1025. 40:29that the next morning he woke up he was
  1026. 40:31afraid to step on the ground out of fear
  1027. 40:33he fall fall through the floor is this
  1028. 40:36just apocryphal that the last part you
  1029. 40:38might have made up I don't know about
  1030. 40:40that one but but the story you can read
  1031. 40:43about in my new book Quant and Fields
  1032. 40:45where I explained this but the the idea
  1033. 40:48that it's empty you know I don't like it
  1034. 40:50when people say that because uh what
  1035. 40:52what what Rutherford really figured out
  1036. 40:54a field guy the fields are they matter
  1037. 40:57but what he really figured out is that
  1038. 40:58most of the Mass is at the center in the
  1039. 41:00nucleus right and so it's not just that
  1040. 41:02they mostly pass through that's
  1041. 41:03important also very occasionally one
  1042. 41:06Ricochet is right back at you so it's
  1043. 41:09not just that the gold is sort of spread
  1044. 41:11out and diffus there's some oomph there
  1045. 41:14right at the middle in the nucleus of
  1046. 41:15the atom just while we're like fired up
  1047. 41:17here uh what's what's the latest
  1048. 41:19thinking on Dark Matter Dark Energy
  1049. 41:21where we where should we see future
  1050. 41:24advances these are you know these are
  1051. 41:26the looking for a dark matter partic is
  1052. 41:27that are you all in on the particle
  1053. 41:29thing you got some other exotic I'm
  1054. 41:31happy for it to be a particle you know
  1055. 41:32I've proposed theories where it's not a
  1056. 41:34particle but they're not very good these
  1057. 41:37theories the dark matter is probably
  1058. 41:38kind of a particle we haven't found it
  1059. 41:40yet and I would say that you know we we
  1060. 41:43had a chance of having found it already
  1061. 41:45the experiments are pretty good but it
  1062. 41:48wasn't like a 99% chance it was like a
  1063. 41:5050% chance we would have found it
  1064. 41:51already so the fact that we haven't
  1065. 41:53found it already is not yet cause for
  1066. 41:55concern okay um the dark energy is
  1067. 41:59interesting again i' I've written papers
  1068. 42:01about different possibilities for that
  1069. 42:02but the simplest one is the best
  1070. 42:04Einstein's idea that there's energy in
  1071. 42:07empty space it's just a fact of the
  1072. 42:08matter every cubic centimeter of space
  1073. 42:11has a 100 millionth of an urg of energy
  1074. 42:14inherent in space itself is a unit of
  1075. 42:17energy pushing the universe apart and so
  1076. 42:20we don't know in fact there was a
  1077. 42:21provocative recent result from the Dark
  1078. 42:24Energy spectroscopic instrument which
  1079. 42:27claimed that maybe the dark energy is
  1080. 42:29declining very slowly Desi Dark Energy
  1081. 42:33but there's like three different
  1082. 42:34experiments who nickname is Desi so I I
  1083. 42:36actually like to used all the words this
  1084. 42:38one
  1085. 42:40L A Different yeah yeah so we don't know
  1086. 42:43that would be very very fascinating and
  1087. 42:45exciting that the that the Dark Matter
  1088. 42:47field is changing dark energy field
  1089. 42:49declining with time yeah declining now
  1090. 42:52is that allowed if the Einstein's
  1091. 42:54cosmological constant which was our
  1092. 42:56first indic
  1093. 43:00suchy gravity that is identically a
  1094. 43:03Conant the way it comes out that's right
  1095. 43:05so if this is true then the cosmal
  1096. 43:07constant is not the dark energy the dark
  1097. 43:08energy is something else the cosmal
  1098. 43:10constant the vacuum energy uh which are
  1099. 43:12equivalent that was a candidate that's
  1100. 43:14one possible thing the dark energy could
  1101. 43:16be simp appreciate that and it's a
  1102. 43:19leading candidate because it comes out
  1103. 43:20ofate we're using the equation anyway
  1104. 43:23and it was already there that's right
  1105. 43:24and and everything else is is a little
  1106. 43:26bit more delicate a little more fragile
  1107. 43:28hard to figure out butal constant is
  1108. 43:31pretty easy to put in
  1109. 43:33there this has been
  1110. 43:35exhausting okay one one last thing just
  1111. 43:38just as a teaser for your next book yeah
  1112. 43:40yeah um when I think of emergence I
  1113. 43:42assume you mean it in the in the tree of
  1114. 43:44life there are life forms
  1115. 43:47that have have features that cannot be
  1116. 43:51deduced from their their biological form
  1117. 43:55like flocking birds right you can't
  1118. 43:58analyze anything about a bird that we
  1119. 43:59know of that will tell you will FL with
  1120. 44:02other birds so you will not be surprised
  1121. 44:04to learn there's a lot of philosophical
  1122. 44:06controversy about these Concepts but
  1123. 44:08basically yes you know the point is we
  1124. 44:11can as you said before we can get
  1125. 44:12through the day talking about people and
  1126. 44:15tables and chairs without knowing that
  1127. 44:17they're made of atoms or Quantum Fields
  1128. 44:18right so there's different levels of
  1129. 44:21description that all seem to work they
  1130. 44:23have to be consistent with each other
  1131. 44:25but you don't need to know about your
  1132. 44:28Quantum fields to get through the day or
  1133. 44:30balance your stock portfolio just go
  1134. 44:32through yeah emergence there we are
  1135. 44:35there you go emerg Consciousness free
  1136. 44:37will yeah all part of that package part
  1137. 44:40of emergency Yeah the more I think about
  1138. 44:42free will the less I think we have it
  1139. 44:44it's it's I've I've not reversed in this
  1140. 44:48Vector Direction I'm headed about fre a
  1141. 44:52momentum yeah it makes sense I mean but
  1142. 44:54what if you Stripped Away everything
  1143. 44:56would you then have have free will so if
  1144. 44:58if you don't have free will then what
  1145. 45:00you're talking about is there has to be
  1146. 45:01an influence put upon you no no I'm
  1147. 45:03going to take the whoever said it you'll
  1148. 45:05know um I I don't think we have free
  1149. 45:08will but what choice do I
  1150. 45:10have somebody said that who said that
  1151. 45:12that's fun I I don't know that one
  1152. 45:14there's a there's like philosopher joke
  1153. 45:16like you know you walk into the
  1154. 45:17restaurant and they say what do you want
  1155. 45:18and say I'll what have whatever the
  1156. 45:20universe says I'm going to have like I
  1157. 45:21have no choice about what it's going to
  1158. 45:22be but I don't think that's the right
  1159. 45:24way to talk I think I do have the
  1160. 45:25ability to make choices well I've heard
  1161. 45:27you on other podcasts give for me what
  1162. 45:31was most resonant account of free will
  1163. 45:35that I can think of While others were
  1164. 45:37spouting off all manner of things so I
  1165. 45:40felt very in the in your Club all right
  1166. 45:42I got your back on this one good so we
  1167. 45:45don't have time for that here but I I
  1168. 45:46other oh man you can't leave me hanging
  1169. 45:48like that no look there's another book
  1170. 45:50coming out we got to bring him back'll
  1171. 45:53be good we'll bring him back he used to
  1172. 45:54be in California he's now just down the
  1173. 45:56street btim excellent right yeah one
  1174. 45:59train wi away we can totally do that but
  1175. 46:01uh are you going to make that trip I
  1176. 46:02mean seriously uh I'm literally here
  1177. 46:04right
  1178. 46:05now where are you I was going to say how
  1179. 46:08would I know his vibrational energy is
  1180. 46:12here probability otherwise don't know
  1181. 46:14Sean Delight to have you uh in my office
  1182. 46:17here at the Hayden planetarium the
  1183. 46:18American Museum of Natural History
  1184. 46:20thanks for making the trip you're you're
  1185. 46:21on a on a book tour right now so good
  1186. 46:23luck with that sometimes you need a
  1187. 46:24little bit of that and keep the physics
  1188. 46:27coming I will do that absolutely thanks
  1189. 46:28for having me on there surely an
  1190. 46:30unlimited appetite for the cool stuff
  1191. 46:32lots of cool stuff in the universe all
  1192. 46:34right Chuck always going to have you man
  1193. 46:36always a pleasure all right this has
  1194. 46:37been the latest update on the moving
  1195. 46:39Frontier of the universe through the
  1196. 46:41lens of theoretical physicist Sean Carol
  1197. 46:45I'm Neil degrass Tyson your personal
  1198. 46:47astrophysicist as always keep looking up
  1199. 46:53[Music]
  1200. 47:08[Music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Neil deGrasse Tyson and Sean Carroll Discuss Controversies in Quantum Mechanics by StarTalk, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,475 words across 1,200 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.