NANA Análisis Psicológico y Mitos del Amor Romántico (manga y anime) Reseña — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hey, Nana, do you remember how we met?
- 0:05Hello, good evening, afternoon, or
- 0:06morning. My name is Sofía Celis. Today
- 0:09I bring you a review and a brief
- 0:11psychological analysis of the manga and
- 0:14anime Nana. This story falls into the
- 0:18Josei category, although I have also
- 0:20seen it in the Shojo category. Its
- 0:22genre is music, drama, and romance. The
- 0:26first time I saw the Nana story was
- 0:28through the anime, which has an open
- 0:31ending—very close, actually, to the
- 0:33manga—but it remains somewhat
- 0:35unfinished. For this reason, I looked
- 0:38for the manga and that is how I
- 0:39continued reading it. However, despite
- 0:42having more story than the anime, it is
- 0:44not finished either. Even though it is
- 0:48a story that has not had a definitive
- 0:50ending, I think the characters 'roles
- 0:52are very well developed. And it is for
- 0:57this reason that I would like to do a
- 0:59psychological analysis, at least of the
- 1:02main characters and some other aspects
- 1:05as well. Well, the main story, as you
- 1:09know, is about two girls both named
- 1:12Nana who meet on the train the day they
- 1:14are moving to Tokyo. Once they both
- 1:18arrive in Tokyo, they go their separate
- 1:20ways and don't hear from each other for
- 1:22a while, but they accidentally meet
- 1:24again and end up starting a life
- 1:26together in Tokyo. At first glance, we
- 1:30see the two Nanas and, well, one could
- 1:32say they are polar opposites. Nana
- 1:35Komatsu, alias Hachi. Hachi fits
- 1:39perfectly into dependent personality
- 1:42disorder. In general, Hachi reflects a
- 1:46dominant and excessive need to be taken
- 1:48care of. We see this from the beginning
- 1:52of the story, how she is super attached
- 1:55to her friend Jun, Jun's boyfriend, and
- 1:57in this case, the friend that Jun
- 1:59introduces to her, which is Shoji, who
- 2:01eventually becomes her boyfriend. There
- 2:05is even a scene where Jun tells her
- 2:08that now Shoji will be able to fulfill
- 2:11the caretaking pattern she provided,
- 2:13referring to the moment when Nana and
- 2:16Shoji start a relationship. Another
- 2:19notorious trait is that she struggles
- 2:21to make everyday decisions. For example
- 2:25, the strawberry glasses scene is very
- 2:27symbolic, since at first she feels
- 2:29insecure about wanting to buy them
- 2:31because Nana doesn't entirely like them
- 2:34, let's say. And not until she shows
- 2:37her approval does she agree to buy them
- 2:39. Nana goes too far to obtain the
- 2:43acceptance and support of others to the
- 2:46point of voluntarily doing things she
- 2:48dislikes. There are two very symbolic
- 2:52aspects referring to this that I am
- 2:54telling you. Only one appears in the
- 2:56anime, but both are really the same
- 2:58thing. In the anime, it’s the scene
- 3:01where Nana is with Takumi after having
- 3:04accepted his support regarding the baby
- 3:06. And Takumi insists on having sex,
- 3:10even though Nana is not doing well
- 3:12emotionally because of the whole crisis
- 3:14at that moment. Despite this, Nana
- 3:18finally agrees so that Takumi feels
- 3:21better with her and, let's say, to gain
- 3:23his acceptance and support. The scene
- 3:27is very intense, as it is also the
- 3:29moment when the two strawberry glasses
- 3:32are broken. Or rather, Nana breaks them
- 3:35, but because of her anxiety attacks,
- 3:37she doesn't remember doing it. I would
- 3:41say that these memory lapses could be a
- 3:43defense mechanism that Nana uses to
- 3:45cope with the situation. And by coping,
- 3:49I mean with Nana's moment of stress, of
- 3:52not knowing what to do, since in this
- 3:54scene Hachi is in her room with Takumi,
- 3:56going through this whole unpleasant
- 3:59moment, and Nana, sitting at the table
- 4:01outside, doesn't know what to do and
- 4:03the only thing she can do is run to
- 4:05Ren's house; which, thinking about it,
- 4:07wouldn't just be one defense mechanism,
- 4:10as it shows both the forgetting and the
- 4:12flight, that would be two. Returning to
- 4:16talk about Hachi, we highlight
- 4:18something else about her dependency,
- 4:20which is that when a close relationship
- 4:22ends, she urgently seeks another one so
- 4:24that she can be cared for and supported
- 4:27. This is super noticeable because,
- 4:30well, they don't show all of Hachi's
- 4:33relationships, but the ones they show a
- 4:36bit more are first Asano's, then
- 4:38Shoji's, and then together with Takumi
- 4:41and Nobu, all very close to each other.
- 4:46When we see Hachi's thoughts, we see
- 4:48how she tries to oppose these patterns,
- 4:50but in the end, her dependency ends up
- 4:52being stronger and she falls back into
- 4:54it, having a great fear of taking
- 4:56responsibility for herself and seeking
- 4:58it in one person or another. Nana Osaki
- 5:04, vocalist for Blast. At first glance,
- 5:07they show her as proud and controlling.
- 5:12The proud part, as you might have
- 5:13noticed, she herself mentions several
- 5:15times. The controlling part, I could
- 5:19point out specifically in the scene
- 5:21where Nana tells Nobu, upon seeing that
- 5:23Hachi is distancing herself a little,
- 5:26that she will make Hachi stay tied to
- 5:28her garden again. As the story
- 5:31progresses, we see more aspects of
- 5:33Nana's life. Nana's emotional crises
- 5:37are much more explicit and better
- 5:40illustrated in the manga, as this is
- 5:44where her panic and anxiety attacks
- 5:47reach their peak. We can see scenes of
- 5:51her anxiety growing little by little,
- 5:54because things aren't turning out the
- 5:56way she wants and are spiraling out of
- 5:58her control. When her anxiety levels
- 6:03become very high, that is when the
- 6:06panic attacks begin, which we can
- 6:08identify and also characterize by the
- 6:11sudden onset of intense fear or extreme
- 6:14discomfort. Nana's distress is
- 6:19illustrated through her sweating, her
- 6:22shaking, and above all, the sensation
- 6:24of difficulty breathing and choking. We
- 6:29also see probable dizziness and
- 6:31instability, since we see Nana needing
- 6:33to drop down or lie down in some way.
- 6:38The scene is extremely frustrating, as
- 6:40Nana truly reflects her fear of dying
- 6:42in those moments. Definitely, all these
- 6:46traits leave us in no doubt about the
- 6:48anxiety that led to Nana's panic
- 6:50attacks. Let's now take a look at the
- 6:54character Takumi. I think Takumi is
- 6:58someone who represses his feelings too
- 7:00much and lets them out in the, let's
- 7:03say, incorrect or socially unacceptable
- 7:05way. What do I mean by this? I would
- 7:10say that he lets out his feelings, for
- 7:12example, through sexuality. As you can
- 7:15see, he is stressed and forces himself
- 7:17to have sex with Nana, even though she
- 7:18doesn't want to. Or I also think he
- 7:22exerts all his repressed feelings by
- 7:25organizing and bossing the whole band
- 7:27around, as you already know how he is
- 7:30with Trapnest, not to mention the
- 7:33multiple lovers he has throughout the
- 7:35story. As you know, Takumi lacks
- 7:40obvious empathy, takes advantage of
- 7:42others for his own benefit, and has
- 7:45arrogant behaviors and attitudes of
- 7:47superiority. These last traits
- 7:51mentioned point to a narcissistic
- 7:53personality in Takumi. Now let's move
- 7:57on to Reira. Reira is someone with
- 8:01tremendously low self-esteem, and we
- 8:03can see it very clearly in a part where
- 8:06she says that the only thing she is
- 8:08good for is singing. She has no other
- 8:11value in her own perception, only for
- 8:13singing. Another aspect is how she
- 8:17starts to get involved with Shin, which
- 8:20is through money, and she also shows a
- 8:22great lack of empathy. We see the lack
- 8:26of empathy in several different aspects
- 8:28. We see it in the simple fact that she
- 8:32has always been in love with Takumi,
- 8:34and even though Takumi is not in love
- 8:36with her, she doesn't respect his
- 8:37decision not to be with her, and she
- 8:39keeps insisting and insisting, and she
- 8:41just doesn't get it. Right, now let's
- 8:45mention Shin. Shin is a very young
- 8:49character in the anime and in the manga
- 8:52. He is, well, he is just turning 16
- 8:55years old. He is someone very careless
- 8:59and naive, I would say, with a well, a
- 9:02notorious Oedipus complex. Why? Because
- 9:08his father figures are simply absent in
- 9:12this story; he is neglected by them and
- 9:15also doesn't gauge dangers. I think it
- 9:22is for these reasons that he ends up
- 9:24relating to older women through money.
- 9:30If we talk about Yasu now, I think Yasu
- 9:33acted for his own well-being. This gave
- 9:38him an image of kindness. However, I
- 9:41think he did it to feel good about
- 9:44himself. Also, he tended to over-take
- 9:48responsibility for others. Now, if I
- 9:52mention Nobu, the opposite was true. I
- 9:55think he lacked responsibility in some
- 9:57aspects. For this very reason, he
- 10:01tended to be insecure. Finally, I
- 10:04mention Ren. Ren, another character
- 10:07with many emotional shortcomings, one
- 10:10more who was abandoned and grew up in
- 10:13loneliness, only he handled it in a
- 10:15different way. The subject is deeper in
- 10:20the manga, but I suppose you remember
- 10:23that Ren had signs of severe addictions
- 10:26, not the typical ones like cigarettes
- 10:28and alcohol, which by the way are shown
- 10:31a lot throughout the story. He had
- 10:35other, more severe, stronger addictions
- 10:38. I think we should ask ourselves, more
- 10:41than anything, that addictions do not
- 10:44have a "why," but a "what for." That is
- 10:49why we should analyze what Ren was
- 10:51doing all this for, what these
- 10:53addictions were filling in him
- 10:55emotionally. Here, as the story shows,
- 11:00the "what for" was to feel secure,
- 11:02because they even mention somewhere in
- 11:05the manga that it helps him do better
- 11:08work. Now I would like us to analyze
- 11:12some myths of romantic love that drive
- 11:14the lives of both Nanas quite a lot.
- 11:18First, let's define what romantic love
- 11:20is. It is a cultural model. They are
- 11:24gender role expectations, guidelines
- 11:26for what should or should not be. I
- 11:29would say they are the stereotypes that
- 11:31are formed by all this social aspect.
- 11:34However, even if there are things that
- 11:37our society and culture tell us should
- 11:39be, it does not mean they are real.
- 11:42That is why they are called myths of
- 11:44romantic love. I will start by
- 11:47mentioning one that we have been taught
- 11:49through fairy tales, which is the
- 11:51typical story where the prince rescues
- 11:53the princess, they get married, and
- 11:55live happily ever after. This myth
- 11:58reminds me a lot of what happened with
- 12:00Hachi and Takumi. When Hachi was in
- 12:04despair over the pregnancy and didn't
- 12:06know what to do, Takumi suddenly
- 12:07arrives and tells her he will take
- 12:09responsibility for the baby, whoever's
- 12:11it is. So, Hachi feels like her prince
- 12:14has arrived, he rescues her, and even
- 12:17tells her they can get married. Well,
- 12:20just imagine, she is perfectly
- 12:22fulfilling that myth. And then we move
- 12:25on to the myth that love conquers all.
- 12:28Hachi again and Takumi, an excellent
- 12:30example. Even though Takumi behaves
- 12:34awfully toward Hachi, she believes that
- 12:36love conquers all, that she can endure
- 12:38it and therefore must endure it,
- 12:40because she is married to him. And,
- 12:45aside from all this, I forgot to
- 12:47mention the pressure her mother puts on
- 12:50Hachi doesn't help; you know there is a
- 12:53scene where she sends her money for her
- 12:55wedding, when Hachi hadn't even really
- 12:58taken it seriously, which leads to
- 13:01another myth that the goal is the
- 13:03wedding, that getting married is what
- 13:05it's all about, the ultimate peak you
- 13:08can reach with a person; and,
- 13:10consequently, as myths go, this makes
- 13:14it difficult for poor Hachi to have a
- 13:17happy and healthy life. Psychologically
- 13:21speaking, we see how Hachi also
- 13:23believes that love means total devotion
- 13:26. In fact, we see it starting with
- 13:30Shoji, how she wants to give herself
- 13:32completely to the point where she goes
- 13:34over, cleans his house, does everything
- 13:36she can, and Shoji doesn't even care at
- 13:38all. So we see how this aspect is very
- 13:43marked and she repeats it again with
- 13:46Takumi because she also completely lets
- 13:48herself be a doormat in the life she
- 13:50has with him. She does everything for
- 13:55him, she is there for all of this, and,
- 13:57inside Hachi's mind, she thinks that's
- 13:59how it should be, let's say. The myths
- 14:03justify it, and she herself, based on
- 14:06all these myths, believes that love is
- 14:08sacrifice and that, someday, it will
- 14:11lead her to happiness, which usually
- 14:13isn't the case. Returning a little to
- 14:18Nana, Nana Osaki. She follows the myth
- 14:23that love is possession and exclusivity
- 14:25, and I don't mean exactly with a
- 14:27partner. Where it is very noticeable is
- 14:31with her close circle of friends. For
- 14:35example, Hachi, how she wants to keep
- 14:37her by her side, even though
- 14:38circumstances are pushing them apart
- 14:40and it is Hachi's own decision to have
- 14:42to distance herself a little. It is
- 14:46also very notorious with Yasu, as she
- 14:49herself says that she must stop wanting
- 14:52Yasu exclusively for herself, since
- 14:54every time she has a crisis, a worry,
- 14:57or some sadness, she runs to be with
- 14:59him and, in a way, monopolizes him. Now
- 15:04, speaking of Nana, we have the
- 15:06romantic myth of death, which is very
- 15:08prominent, by the way. And throughout
- 15:12the story, it sounds very beautiful
- 15:14until we reach the end, where all this
- 15:17romanticism regarding death is broken
- 15:19in a way. We see this theme very
- 15:23explicitly in several scenes, as Nana
- 15:26even asks Ren directly if he would die
- 15:28with her. And there is also a part
- 15:32where Ren says he would like to kill
- 15:34Nana. All this disguised within a
- 15:37romantic context. And well, what
- 15:40consequences do all these myths bring
- 15:43us? The story shows us those
- 15:45consequences quite clearly. Beyond the
- 15:49fact that these false beliefs justify
- 15:52bad actions that often occur, they also
- 15:55cause deep disappointment and excessive
- 15:57idealization. For example, in the last
- 16:01scenes...oh, well, I must give a
- 16:03spoiler for the manga, so if you don't
- 16:05want to hear it, don't watch this last
- 16:06part. But let me tell you: in the final
- 16:11part of the manga, which is unfinished,
- 16:14Ren dies, and at least for me as a
- 16:16viewer, it had created a great sense of
- 16:19idealization regarding the whole
- 16:22romantic myth woven into the story
- 16:24about death. So, the fact that Ren dies
- 16:30is extremely disappointing because,
- 16:32after everything Nana had talked about
- 16:35with him, all these false beliefs we
- 16:37are fed are shattered, and the
- 16:39resulting disappointment is truly sad.
- 16:43Speaking of idealization, it also
- 16:45reminds me of the great idealization
- 16:48Hachi had for Takumi. Precisely because
- 16:52she had been a fan of his for a long
- 16:54time, admiring him and so on, she
- 16:56idolized him and had him
- 16:57super-idealized; and when she actually
- 17:00has the chance to get close, know him,
- 17:02and see what kind of person he really
- 17:04is, a great disappointment follows,
- 17:06which is why Hachi suffers so much
- 17:08throughout their relationship. And well
- 17:12, to wrap up, I would just like to say
- 17:16that it is a story I really liked. It
- 17:20kept me hooked, honestly; I liked it a
- 17:23lot because it’s a bit more realistic
- 17:26about all the human sides we experience
- 17:28, and I can only say I wish they had
- 17:31finished it, as the story ended on a
- 17:33very interesting note, at least in the
- 17:36manga. Well, also in the anime; in both
- 17:39cases, the ending is left very open.
- 17:42That would be all from me. Thank you so
- 17:45much for watching. If you have any
- 17:48comments, opinions, or anything to say,
- 17:50or even suggestions for a specific part
- 17:53of the Nana story you'd like us to
- 17:55analyze, or any other manga or anime,
- 17:58feel free to let me know and we'll
- 18:00check it out. Once again, thank you
- 18:03very much, and we'll see you in the
- 18:05next review.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of NANA Análisis Psicológico y Mitos del Amor Romántico (manga y anime) Reseña by Sofia Celis, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,605 words across 384 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.