YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → YouTube transcript (n8Yb6m34_Ao)

YouTube transcript (n8Yb6m34_Ao) — Transcript

7,906 words · 1,283 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00The county road into the Hail property
0:01had been plowed once that morning, and
0:04by noon it was already filling back in.
0:06I drove the old Silverado slow, Mason
0:09riding quiet in the passenger seat, both
0:11of us watching the way the snow came
0:13sideways off the ridge and swallowed the
0:15fence posts one by one. The thermometer
0:18on the dash read 11°. The kind of cold
0:21that doesn't feel dramatic.
0:23It just settles in like it belongs
0:26there. Walter had asked to have his
0:28ashes buried near the east pond. No
0:30service at the church, no reception
0:32afterward, no neighbors he barely knew
0:35standing around telling stories that
0:37didn't quite fit him, just family. Just
0:39the land he'd worked since 1974.
0:42I had respected that.
0:44I had always respected Walter. We stood
0:47at the edge of the frozen pond, Mason
0:49and I, the box of ashes between my
0:51hands.
0:53The ground was hard enough that the hole
0:55we'd dug that morning had taken 40
0:57minutes with a pickaxe. Afterward, I'd
0:59packed the soil back, smoothed it,
1:02marked the spot with a flat river stone
1:04I'd found in the barn.
1:06Walter would have liked that.
1:08No fuss. I was still standing there, hat
1:11in my hands,
1:13watching the light come gray through the
1:14pines,
1:16when I heard the car. It wasn't a sound
1:18that belonged on this road.
1:21Not the knock of a working truck or the
1:23wet crunch of a rancher's worn tires.
1:26This was something heavier, quieter,
1:29expensive. I turned and watched a black
1:32Cadillac Escalade move up the drive.
1:35Its paint so dark,
1:37it looked like a hole cut in the white
1:39landscape.
1:40It stopped 30 ft from us.
1:43The engine idled.
1:45Steam rose from the exhaust. The woman
1:47who stepped out was dressed for a
1:48different kind of cold. White wool coat,
1:51leather gloves,
1:53tall boots with fur at the top that had
1:55never walked through actual mud. She was
1:58maybe 55 with the kind of posture that
2:01comes from years of being the most
2:02important person in whatever room she's
2:04standing in. She held an envelope in one
2:06hand like it was a document she was
2:08proud of. Mr. Hale. Her voice carried
2:11through the still air without effort.
2:14Elijah Hale? Mason looked at me.
2:17I looked at her. That's right, I said.
2:20I'm Vanessa Carrington, president of the
2:23Aurora Ridge Estates Homeowners
2:24Association. She crossed the snow toward
2:27me, her boots punching clean holes in
2:29the surface crust, and held out the
2:31envelope. You've been served. I didn't
2:33reach for it right away.
2:35I looked at it.
2:37Looked at her.
2:39Then I looked at the river stone on the
2:41ground near my feet.
2:43The one marking the spot where I just
2:45buried the man who'd raised me. We're in
2:47the middle of something, I said. I'm
2:49aware, she said. I apologize for the
2:52timing. She didn't sound apologetic. She
2:55sounded like she'd calculated the timing
2:57and decided it was effective. Mason's
3:00jaw was set.
3:02His hands were at his sides and I could
3:04see by the way he was standing that he
3:06was working hard to keep them there. He
3:08was 21 and had his mother's temper and
3:10his grandfather's patience.
3:13And right now the temper was winning. I
3:15gave him a short look. He held still. I
3:18took the envelope. I didn't open it.
3:21We'll see ourselves out, I said. She
3:23smiled. It was a smile that didn't
3:25involve her eyes. Of course. Have a nice
3:28afternoon, Mr. Hale. She walked back to
3:30the Escalade, got in, and pulled away.
3:34I watched her tail lights disappear down
3:35the drive and back toward the county
3:37road. Mason waited until she was gone.
3:41Homeowners Association, I said.
3:44The new development up on the ridge.
3:47Aurora Ridge Estates. He looked at the
3:50envelope. What do they want? I slid the
3:52envelope into my coat pocket. I didn't
3:55have an answer yet, not a real one, but
3:57I'd been working county records in
3:58Sheridan for 27 years, and I knew the
4:01shape of what I was holding before I'd
4:03read a single word. The weight of it.
4:06The way the paper felt under my fingers.
4:08We stood there another minute in the
4:10cold, looking at the river stone,
4:12listening to the wind work through the
4:13trees. Let's go back to the cabin, I
4:16said. I'll make coffee. What I didn't
4:18say yet, because I hadn't fully
4:20confirmed it, was what I'd noticed when
4:22the Escalade turned around at the top of
4:24the drive. It had to swing wide, almost
4:27into the fence, because there was no
4:29other way to maneuver.
4:31No other way out. The road up to Aurora
4:33Ridge Estates branched off from my main
4:35drive at the second gate.
4:38One road in, one road out.
4:41And that road ran a quarter mile through
4:43land that Walter had owned since 1989.
4:46Land that, as of 3 days ago, was mine.
4:50My parents died in January of 1982.
4:53I was 7 years old. There was a blizzard
4:56that came down from the Bighorn
4:57Mountains without much warning.
5:00The way those storms sometimes do in
5:01early winter.
5:03And their truck went off the road on the
5:05highway outside of Buffalo. Nobody's
5:07fault. Nobody to blame. Just weather and
5:10dark, and a curve that came a little
5:12faster than expected. Walter was my
5:15father's older brother.
5:17He'd never married, never had children.
5:20He had a ranch in Sheridan County, and a
5:23general distrust of anything that
5:25couldn't be fixed with his own hands.
5:27When the county called him, he drove
5:29through the tail end of the same storm
5:30to come get me.
5:32I remember sitting in his truck with a
5:34blanket from the hospital, and watching
5:36the snow blow across the headlights. He
5:38didn't say much. He put on the radio and
5:41drove. He gave me the north bedroom.
5:44The one that looked out toward the
5:45ridge.
5:47He made me do chores.
5:49He made me go to school.
5:51He didn't try to replace what I'd lost.
5:54And I respected that.
5:56Even then, he just kept me going.
5:59Kept the days moving. Kept me fed and
6:01sheltered and, in the way that mattered
6:03most, present. By the time I was 12, he
6:06had me pulling survey flags and reading
6:08plat maps.
6:10By 15, I knew the difference between a
6:12fee simple deed and a life estate. He
6:15wasn't doing it to fill my head with
6:17useless information. He was teaching me
6:19how to protect what was yours.
6:22Because he'd seen what happened when
6:24people didn't know the language of land
6:25ownership. He'd watched neighbors lose
6:27ground they'd worked for decades to
6:29developers and lawyers who understood
6:31the paperwork, and they didn't. Paper
6:33lasts longer than memory, he told me
6:35once.
6:37We were riding the fence line in
6:38October. The aspens gone gold. The sky
6:41that deep Wyoming blue.
6:44Write things down.
6:45Read what other people write down. Don't
6:47let anyone tell you what a document says
6:49without reading it yourself. I took that
6:52seriously.
6:53I went to the University of Wyoming,
6:55studied real property law and land
6:57assessment, came home with a degree and
7:00a job in the county assessor's office.
7:0227 years later, I was the senior land
7:05valuation specialist for Sheridan
7:07County. I knew every major parcel in the
7:09county, most of the minor ones, and the
7:12history of land transactions going back
7:14to territorial days. I knew Walter's
7:16land the way I knew my own face. The
7:19Hale property was 2,500
7:22acres of mixed terrain, high pasture,
7:24timbered slopes, a creek that ran from
7:27the ridge down to the flatlands, and the
7:29east pond that was fed by an underground
7:31spring and never fully froze even in the
7:34worst winters, except for the edges.
7:38The main cabin had been built in 1911 by
7:40a man named Horace Plimpton, who had
7:42homesteaded the bottom land and slowly
7:45acquired the surrounding parcels. Walter
7:47had bought the whole thing from
7:48Plimpton's granddaughter in 1974
7:51for what was even then a remarkable
7:52price because nobody wanted ranch land
7:55that remote. He'd spent 50 years
7:57improving it, fencing it, running cattle
8:00on it, caring for it the way a person
8:02cares for something they intend to pass
8:04on. He had no children.
8:06He had me. The will had been executed
8:08six years ago, witnessed by his attorney
8:11and two neighbors, filed with the county
8:13clerk.
8:14No surprises, no complications. The
8:17ranch, all 2,500
8:20acres, the cabin, the equipment, the
8:23cattle, transferred to Elijah Raymond
8:25Hale upon Walter's death. I had his old
8:28drafting table,
8:30his collection of topographic maps,
8:33and a note he'd left in an envelope
8:34marked for Eli that said,
8:37simply
8:39"Don't let them push you around. You
8:41know the land better than any of them."
8:43Mason had taken the semester off to come
8:45back. He was studying agricultural
8:47management at Laramie, and he had the
8:49kind of natural feel for land and cattle
8:51that Walter had always said skipped a
8:53generation and then came back strong.
8:57He didn't have to come. I hadn't asked
8:59him to.
9:00He just showed up 2 weeks before Walter
9:02died with a truck full of his things and
9:04said he'd been remote for all his
9:05courses anyway, and there was work to
9:07do. The three of us had spent Walter's
9:10last weeks in the cabin, good weeks,
9:12mostly quiet ones.
9:15Walter talked when he felt like it and
9:16slept when he didn't, and Mason and I
9:19kept the place running. That was what
9:21Walter had wanted. Grant Mercer had
9:23driven up from his office in Sheridan
9:24the morning after the funeral. He was 63
9:27years old, thin,
9:29with a face like weathered saddle
9:31leather and the kind of stillness that
9:32came from three decades of working land
9:34law in the Wyoming courts. He'd been
9:37Walter's attorney for 15 years. He was
9:39now mine. He read the lawsuit at my
9:41kitchen table while the coffee pot
9:44cycled and the wind knocked at the
9:46windows. He read it slowly, turning each
9:48page with deliberate care, the way a man
9:51reads something when he wants to
9:52understand not just what it says but why
9:54it was written. When he finished, he set
9:57it down and looked at me over the top of
9:59his glasses. Five counts, he said.
10:02Encroachment on a shared boundary.
10:05Nuisance claim for the cattle.
10:08A water rights dispute on the creek that
10:10feeds the lower pasture. An
10:12environmental claim about runoff from
10:14the east section. And a demand for
10:16mandatory injunctive relief to remove
10:18fencing from what they're calling common
10:20access land. All of it manufactured, I
10:23said. Most of it, yes.
10:26He picked up the water rights page
10:28again.
10:29This one's more creative.
10:31They've got a surveyor's report.
10:34Which means they spent money on this
10:35before Walter died. He looked at me.
10:38They knew this was coming. Mason was
10:40leaning against the counter. Why? What
10:43do they actually want? Grant set down
10:45the page. They want the land. Not all of
10:48it. They want the lower two sections,
10:51the ones that border the development.
10:54That's where their amenity plan requires
10:56expansion. They tried to buy it from
10:58Walter three times in the last four
11:00years. He refused. He told me, I said.
11:04So now they're trying to litigate him
11:06into selling.
11:07He paused.
11:09Or rather, litigating you into selling.
11:13Congratulations on the inheritance, by
11:15the way. They're counting on the legal
11:17costs to break you down. This lawsuit
11:20will cost you $40,000 to defend if it
11:22runs its full course. They know that. I
11:25poured the coffee.
11:26Set a cup in front of him. We're not
11:28selling, I said. Grant nodded like he
11:31expected that.
11:33He picked up his coffee. Then we start
11:35with the road, he said. The lawsuit had
11:37been filed in the Sheridan County
11:39District Court 8 days before Walter
11:41died. I hadn't known that at the time.
11:44Grant told me later that the Carringtons
11:46had been watching Walter's health
11:48closely through their own channels,
11:50whether that was a mutual acquaintance
11:52or someone in the county offices, he
11:54didn't say, but the implication was
11:56clear.
11:58They had timed the filing carefully. The
12:00encroachment claim was the thinnest.
12:03The fence in question had been in place
12:05since 1987,
12:07predating the Aurora Ridge development
12:10by 20 years. Walter had the original
12:12survey stakes and the permit records.
12:15That one wouldn't survive a preliminary
12:17hearing. The nuisance claim was about
12:19cattle, specifically that cattle from
12:21the Hale property had wandered onto the
12:23landscaped borders of Aurora Ridge and
12:26caused damage. I had the fence
12:27inspection records going back 4 years.
12:30The fence was sound. The cattle hadn't
12:32wandered.
12:34If anything had crossed the line,
12:37it hadn't come from our side. The water
12:39rights claim was the one they'd spent
12:41money on. Their surveyor's report
12:43claimed that a drainage channel Walter
12:44had installed in the east section
12:46diverted natural runoff in a way that
12:49affected downstream flow patterns that
12:51Aurora Ridge had, they argued, a prior
12:54appropriation right to. This was, to put
12:56it plainly, nonsense dressed up in
12:59technical language.
13:01But nonsense with a surveyor's signature
13:04costs money to fight. The environmental
13:06claim was about road salt and snowmelt
13:08contamination of a shared watershed. It
13:11was the weakest of the five counts and
13:13seemed to exist mainly to add bulk to
13:15the filing and increase the apparent
13:17legitimacy of the overall suit. In
13:20total, they were asking for $5.2 million
13:23in damages
13:25plus injunctive relief
13:27plus attorney's fees. Vanessa Carrington
13:30made sure everyone in the county knew
13:31about it.
13:33I learned this not from any direct
13:34contact with her, but from the way
13:36people started looking at me in town.
13:39The feed store,
13:41the county coffee shop, the hardware
13:43store on Main where I'd been buying
13:44supplies for 30 years.
13:46I'd come in and the conversation would
13:48shift or go quiet,
13:50and I'd catch people checking their
13:52phones. I ran into Vanessa herself one
13:54afternoon in the parking lot of the feed
13:56store, which was coated in gray slush
13:59and ice, and had that particular
14:00miserable quality of a Wyoming winter
14:03afternoon. She was coming out with
14:05nothing in her hands, which told me she
14:07hadn't actually come to buy anything.
14:09She smiled when she saw me.
14:11The same smile as at the pond.
14:14Mr. Hale,
14:16I hope you're getting good legal
14:17counsel. Afternoon, I said. We don't
14:20have anything personal against you, she
14:22said.
14:24We just have obligations to our
14:25homeowners.
14:27Surely you understand that. I understand
14:30a lot of things, I said. I loaded my
14:32supplies in the truck and drove back to
14:34the ranch.
14:35I didn't engage further. There was
14:37nothing to gain from it, and I had
14:39learned a long time ago that people like
14:41Vanessa Carrington weren't interested in
14:43conversation. They were interested in
14:46audience. The moment you remove the
14:48audience, they lost most of their power.
14:51But I noted the encounter.
14:53The way she'd positioned herself,
14:55the timing.
14:57She was managing a public narrative,
14:59and she was good at it. Mason had taken
15:02to driving the fence line every morning
15:03in the old four-wheeler,
15:05documenting everything with his phone.
15:08He'd started keeping a log dated
15:09entries, GPS coordinates, photographs,
15:13weather conditions. He hadn't asked me
15:15if he should do this. He just started
15:17doing it. Walter would have approved.
15:19Grant came back out to the ranch 3 days
15:22after the filing and sat at the drafting
15:24table with a topographic map and a set
15:26of county plat records. He spread them
15:29across the table and put his coffee on a
15:31coaster and spent an hour not saying
15:33much. Then he said,
15:35"Tell me about the road." We walked it
15:37in the early morning before the light
15:39was full.
15:41When the sky was the color of a tin roof
15:43and the temperature was still below
15:45zero,
15:46our breath went ahead of us in white
15:48clouds. The snow on the road was packed
15:50hard and tracked with the previous day's
15:52tire marks, deep ruts from SUVs and
15:55delivery trucks going up to Aurora
15:57Ridge. The road left the county road at
15:59a gate on the south corner of my
16:01property. From there it ran
16:03north-northeast for approximately a
16:05third of a mile across terrain that was
16:07unambiguously Hail land, according to
16:10every plat map I'd ever read. It climbed
16:12the lower slope of the ridge on a graded
16:14cut that had been blasted in the early
16:162000s, passed through a gap in the
16:18natural rock outcropping, and emerged
16:21into the Aurora Ridge development on the
16:23other side. That was it.
16:25That was the only road in or out. I'd
16:28known this abstractly for years. The
16:30development had gone in during a period
16:32when I was working long hours at the
16:34assessor's office and paying less
16:36attention to the parcel details than I
16:38should have. I'd seen the construction
16:40traffic.
16:41I'd assumed the access question had been
16:43handled legitimately. Now I walked it
16:46and looked at it with different eyes.
16:48Grant walked beside me, moving carefully
16:50on the ice, hands in his coat pockets.
16:54He didn't say anything for most of the
16:55walk. He was looking at the same things
16:57I was, the survey markers, the fence
17:00posts, the way the road cut through
17:02terrain that was mineral rights listed
17:04under the Hail parcel going back to the
17:06original homestead grant. "No easement
17:08signage," I said. "No," he said. "No
17:12utility easement markers. No." We
17:15reached the gate at the top of the cut,
17:17the one that separated the road from the
17:19Aurora Ridge main entrance.
17:21It was a large timber gate with the
17:23development's name on it in wrought iron
17:25lettering.
17:27Expensive, permanent-looking, built like
17:29it had always been there and always
17:31would be. They spent a lot of money on
17:33this entrance, I said. They did,
17:36Grant said. We turned around and walked
17:39back down.
17:40The sun was coming up behind the ridge
17:42and casting long cold shadows across the
17:45snow.
17:46An osprey was working the frozen edge of
17:48the creek a quarter mile east. That
17:51afternoon, Grant filed a records request
17:53with the Sheridan County Recorder's
17:55Office. He asked for every recorded
17:57instrument affecting the half section
17:59that the road crossed deeds, easements,
18:02licenses, contracts, restrictions,
18:04covenants, the full title chain going
18:07back to territorial patent. 3 days
18:09later, a county records office assistant
18:11named Dorothy Quinn called and asked if
18:13we could come in person. Dorothy was 70
18:16years old and had worked in that office
18:18for 38 years. She wore her reading
18:20glasses on a cord around her neck and
18:23had a memory for documents that I had
18:24always found remarkable. The kind of
18:26institutional knowledge that modern
18:28record systems were slowly making
18:30obsolete. She was one of the reasons I
18:32still trusted paper over databases. She
18:35had the records spread across one of the
18:37long reading tables when we arrived.
18:40She looked at us over her glasses when
18:42we came in. You boys better sit down
18:44before you read folder three, she said.
18:47The deed chain was clean back to 1,000
18:50974.
18:52The Hale property title was
18:53unencumbered, the line of ownership
18:56clear, no gaps, no disputes. Dorothy had
18:59pulled the original homestead patent,
19:02the subsequent transfers, Walter's
19:04acquisition deed, the most recent
19:06probate transfer to me. All of it in
19:08order. Folder one, folder two, clean.
19:12Folder three was where things got
19:14complicated. The road had not been
19:16created under an easement. An easement,
19:18properly executed and recorded, would
19:21have been a permanent property right
19:22attached to the land running with title,
19:25binding on future owners, subject to
19:27specific terms, but not expirable by
19:30corporate action or death. An easement,
19:33done properly, would have been a real
19:35problem for me. What the developer had
19:37actually recorded in 2003
19:40was a temporary access license. Grant
19:42read the document twice without saying
19:44anything.
19:46Then he set it down flat on the table
19:48and smoothed it with both hands.
19:50The way you smooth something when you
19:52want to make sure it's real. The license
19:54had been issued by Walter to a company
19:56called Pinnacle Mountain Development
19:57Corp for the purpose of constructing and
19:59maintaining a private access road across
20:02parcel 14A of the Hale Holdings. The
20:04license was valid for the duration of
20:06the developer's active operation and was
20:09explicitly conditioned on the continued
20:11legal existence and good standing of the
20:13licensee corporation. If the licensee
20:16corporation dissolved or lost legal
20:18standing,
20:20the license terminated automatically.
20:23No notice required.
20:25No court action needed.
20:27Termination upon the fact of
20:29dissolution. Dorothy had already pulled
20:32the Wyoming Secretary of State records
20:34on Pinnacle Mountain Development Corp.
20:36They had dissolved in 2016 chapter 7
20:38liquidation. All assets distributed.
20:41Corporate entity formally terminated by
20:44the state. The registered agent at the
20:46time of dissolution was a man named
20:48Damian Carrington. The same Damian
20:50Carrington who was, at this moment, the
20:53attorney of record on the HOA's lawsuit
20:56against me. Grant looked at me. I looked
20:58at Grant. He knew, I said. He had to,
21:02Grant said.
21:03He was the registered agent.
21:06He filed the dissolution himself.
21:08Dorothy set a second document on the
21:10table.
21:11It was a subsequent license that Walter
21:13had apparently been presented with in
21:142017, the year after the original
21:17licensee dissolved. Walter had refused
21:20to sign it. The document had been
21:22drafted by Carrington's firm. Walter had
21:24written declined across the signature
21:26line in black pen and kept a copy.
21:29Walter had known. He'd never mentioned
21:31it to me directly, but he'd kept the
21:33unsigned document in a folder marked
21:35with a strip of red electrical tape. I
21:37recognized the tape. He used it on
21:39folders he considered important. I'd
21:42found three such folders in his files
21:44after he died. I hadn't gotten to all of
21:46them yet. So, as of the dissolution of
21:49Pinnacle Mountain in 2016,
21:52Grant said slowly,
21:54the HOA and all 87 residents of Aurora
21:57Ridge Estates have been using this road
22:00without any legal right to do so. Yes,
22:03Dorothy said. And Damian Carrington, the
22:06attorney who drafted the original
22:07license and served as the corporate
22:09registered agent, filed and is currently
22:12prosecuting a lawsuit against the owner
22:14of the land the road crosses. That is
22:16what the documents indicate, Dorothy
22:18said. Grant sat back in his chair.
22:21They sued the man who owns their only
22:23way in. The room was very quiet.
22:26Outside the windows, snow was falling on
22:28the parking lot.
22:30I could hear the heating system in the
22:32old county building ticking and humming.
22:34Dorothy looked at me.
22:36Walter came in here once, about a year
22:38ago, she said.
22:40He was asking about the easement
22:42procedure for formalizing access rights.
22:45I helped him look through the license
22:46record. He didn't say much, but when he
22:49was leaving, he said, and I remember
22:51this clearly, he said,
22:53"They'll push until they think they've
22:55won, Dorothy.
22:57Then they'll find out where the line
22:58is." I looked at the unsigned document
23:00on the table. Walter's handwriting
23:03across the signature line. The license
23:05expiration date, according to its own
23:07terms, had been automatically triggered
23:09in August of 2016. We were now in
23:12February. The window for any quiet
23:14validation had long since closed.
23:17Whatever claims the Carringtons wanted
23:18to make about informal extension or
23:21implied consent,
23:23they would be arguing against a document
23:25their own attorney had drafted
23:27that explicitly stated the termination
23:29conditions that terminated 9 years ago.
23:32There was, Grant pointed out, one
23:34remaining procedural thread. A provision
23:36in Wyoming property law allowed for
23:39license validation through continuous
23:41open use under certain conditions. But
23:43that provision had a 10-year window. The
23:45Pinnacle Mountain dissolution had been
23:47in August of 2016. The 10-year window
23:50closed in August of 2026. That was 6
23:53months away. So we have time, Mason
23:56said. We have time, Grant confirmed.
23:59But we use it carefully. Vanessa
24:01Carrington did not back off when the
24:03lawsuit stalled. Grant had filed a
24:05motion to dismiss the encroachment
24:07claim, which was handled efficiently at
24:10a preliminary hearing in mid-February.
24:12The judge, a patient, methodical man
24:14named Howard Briggs, looked at the fence
24:16permit records, looked at the 1,987
24:21survey, and dismissed that count without
24:23prejudice, noting that the filing
24:25appeared to lack evidentiary support. It
24:27was a minor win, but Vanessa had
24:30evidently decided that concession was
24:32not in her vocabulary. The animal
24:34control calls started the week after the
24:36dismissal.
24:37Three separate complaints in 10 days,
24:40all from Aurora Ridge.
24:42All claiming hail cattle had been seen
24:44near the development's perimeter
24:46landscaping. The sheriff's deputy who
24:48responded each time was a young man
24:50named Kyle Draper,
24:53who I had known since he was in high
24:54school. He made the drive out, looked at
24:57the fence line, wrote in his report that
24:59no cattle were found off property, and
25:01told me privately that the calls were
25:03coming in from the same address each
25:05time. Damien Carrington subpoenaed 4
25:08years of my tax returns in connection
25:10with the water rights claim. This was
25:11technically within his legal rights as
25:14part of discovery, but it was clearly
25:16intended to be burdensome. Pulling those
25:18records together consumed three evenings
25:21that Mason and I spent at the dining
25:23room table with file boxes. Grant filed
25:26a motion to limit the scope of
25:27discovery, which was granted in part. A
25:30private investigator appeared. I first
25:32noticed him parked at the county road
25:34gate on a Tuesday morning, a dark sedan
25:36with Wyoming plates I didn't recognize,
25:39sitting at the edge of my drive in the
25:40pre-dawn dark. He was there again on
25:42Thursday. By the following week, I had
25:45his name because he wasn't particularly
25:47careful, Dennis Fawcett, formerly of the
25:49Sheridan County Sheriff's Department,
25:51now working private cases. I knew his
25:54work, methodical and patient, not
25:56especially creative. What I didn't know
25:59at first was that Dennis was also doing
26:01a second job on the side, one that
26:03Damien Carrington hadn't authorized.
26:06He was talking to Grant. Grant told me
26:08about this carefully, saying only that
26:10he had reason to believe Dennis found
26:12the Carringtons' conduct in this matter
26:14troubling, and that any information
26:16Dennis provided would be handled
26:18appropriately under applicable ethics
26:20rules. I didn't ask more questions. Some
26:23things are better understood at a
26:25distance. The worst night was the last
26:27Friday of February. A storm came in off
26:30the mountains around 9:00 in the
26:31evening, the kind that moves fast and
26:33drops 8 inches in 3 hours and makes the
26:36world into a narrow cone of headlights
26:37and white noise. Mason and I were in the
26:40barn checking on the cattle when we
26:41heard a car at the gate. We came out and
26:44walked up the drive with flashlights and
26:46found Vanessa Carrington's Escalade
26:48sitting at the closed gate, its hazard
26:50lights blinking orange through the
26:52falling snow. Vanessa was out of the
26:54car, standing at the gate trying to find
26:57the latch in the dark. She had on the
26:58white coat again and the fur trimmed
27:00boots and she looked genuinely cold for
27:03the first time I'd ever seen her. The
27:05gate's locked, Mason said. I need to
27:07speak with your father, she said.
27:10Her voice had lost some of its composed
27:13quality. There was something underneath
27:15it now, something that might have been
27:16worry or might have been anger, hard to
27:18tell with her. Gate's locked, Mason said
27:21again. I can see that. I need He's not
27:24available. She looked at him. She was
27:27accustomed to being looked through, not
27:29back at.
27:31Do you know who I am? Mason was very
27:33still in the snow and the dark.
27:35He was 21 years old and had his
27:37grandfather's patience
27:40when he chose to use it.
27:42I know who you are, he said.
27:44Gate's locked. Drive safe. He turned and
27:48walked back to the barn.
27:49I watched Vanessa stand at the gate for
27:51another moment. Then she got back in the
27:54Escalade and turned around and the
27:56hazard lights disappeared into the white
27:58dark. I went back to the cattle. 36 days
28:01until the Carrington 10-year window
28:03closed. The hardest part of the
28:05following weeks was not the legal work.
28:08It was the silence. Grant's strategy was
28:11simple and correct.
28:13Do not reveal the road license discovery
28:16until the moment it could be used most
28:17effectively. File no motions, send no
28:20letters, give no indication that we were
28:22sitting on anything. Let Damien
28:24Carrington and his wife continue to
28:26believe they had the initiative.
28:29Let them spend money.
28:31Let them escalate. The longer they
28:33escalated without resistance, the more
28:36their own conduct became part of the
28:38record. This meant I had to endure
28:40things I would otherwise have addressed
28:42directly. The water rights claim dragged
28:44into a deposition schedule. I spent a
28:46full day at Damian's office answering
28:48questions about drainage infrastructure
28:50I'd installed on my own property, on my
28:52own land, with proper permits, in a
28:55process that was entirely legitimate.
28:57Damian sat across the table from me with
28:59the manner of a man who believed he was
29:01in complete control of the situation.
29:05His tie was expensive.
29:07His cuff links were monogrammed.
29:10He asked his questions with the kind of
29:11mild, polite condescension that is
29:14practiced, not natural. I answered
29:16everything accurately and concisely.
29:19Grant had told me,
29:21"Answer what is asked, nothing more."
29:24I had spent my career reading documents.
29:27I knew how to give a clean deposition.
29:30At the cabin, the nights were long.
29:33March in Wyoming still means real
29:35winter, 10 below nights.
29:37Hard frost on the window glass.
29:40The wood stove working through a cord of
29:42pine a week. Mason and I fell into a
29:44working rhythm that I found, under the
29:46circumstances, genuinely sustaining.
29:50He ran the cattle operation and the
29:51fence records. I managed the legal
29:54correspondence and kept my own files on
29:56what Grant called the road matter. We
29:58ate dinner at the same table Walter had
30:00eaten at for 50 years and didn't talk
30:02about it much. The papers were stacked
30:04on the drafting table.
30:07Topographic surveys, the license
30:09document, the Secretary of State
30:11dissolution records, the Carrington HOA
30:14filings going back to the development's
30:16founding. I had read all of it multiple
30:18times. I knew the case the way I knew
30:21property lines by walking them, not just
30:23looking at them on a map. I drafted 32
30:26letters,
30:27one for each homeowner in Aurora Ridge
30:29Estates, not including the Carringtons.
30:32Grant reviewed them.
30:34They were factual, restrained, and
30:37precise. They informed each homeowner of
30:39the the status of the access road, the
30:42history of the license, the dissolution
30:44of the original licensee, and the
30:46current ownership status of the road's
30:48underlying land. They did not make
30:51demands.
30:52They did not threaten. They stated facts
30:54and offered to answer questions. We did
30:57not send them yet. Damian began to show
30:59signs of pressure in the court record in
31:01mid-March.
31:03Two motions he filed were rejected on
31:05procedural grounds. His deposition of
31:07Grant ran into problems when Grant
31:09produced documents Damian had apparently
31:11not anticipated. The HOA meeting minutes
31:14from February and March showed
31:15increasingly heated internal debates
31:17about the lawsuit's progress and cost.
31:20Dennis Fawcett had obtained those
31:21records through a public disclosure
31:23request, which was entirely proper.
31:25Vanessa was still performing publicly.
31:29A letter to the Sheridan County Gazette
31:31citing environmental concerns about
31:33ranching operations near Aurora Ridge. A
31:36petition circulated among homeowners
31:38regarding land use conflicts in the
31:40corridor. She was building a narrative,
31:42and she was building it carefully. But
31:44narratives are built on assumptions.
31:48Assumptions about what the other side
31:50knows.
31:51Assumptions about what the documents
31:53say. I had read the documents. The
31:55tenure window closed on a Thursday night
31:57in August at midnight.
32:00I was sitting at the drafting table with
32:02a cup of coffee gone cold. Outside, the
32:05Wyoming dark was absolute. No moon, no
32:08wind, just the particular silence of
32:11land that has been well kept for a long
32:13time. I looked at the clock. Then I
32:15called Grant. The next morning, Grant
32:18filed in Sheridan County District Court.
32:21The filing was a quiet title action, a
32:23formal legal proceeding to establish the
32:25Hale property's clear title to the half
32:27section that the road crossed, including
32:29a declaration that no valid access
32:32rights existed in favor of any party.
32:35Attached to the filing was the original
32:37license document.
32:39The dissolution records for Pinnacle
32:40Mountain Development Corp,
32:42the Walter Hale unsigned license from
32:442017,
32:46and the current deed showing my
32:48ownership. Simultaneously, Grant filed a
32:51fraud allegation as a separate motion in
32:54the original HOA lawsuit.
32:56Damien Carrington, as attorney of record
32:59in a case premised partly on alleged
33:01shared access rights, had failed to
33:03disclose that he personally had
33:05knowledge that those access rights had
33:07terminated 9 years ago, that he had been
33:10the registered agent for the company
33:12whose dissolution triggered the
33:13termination, and that he had drafted the
33:15subsequent license that Walter refused
33:17to sign. The 32 letters went into the
33:20mail the same morning, certified, return
33:23receipt requested. I did not hear
33:25anything for 4 days.
33:27Then the phone calls started, not to
33:29meet a Grant. Homeowners calling his
33:31office, confused and frightened. People
33:34who had paid 400,000, 500,000,
33:38some of them over a million dollars for
33:40properties in Aurora Ridge, properties
33:42they'd assumed had legal road access,
33:44calling to ask what was happening, what
33:47this meant, whether they could get in
33:49and out of their own homes. Grant
33:51handled each call with the same measured
33:53patience he brought to everything.
33:55He explained the legal situation
33:57factually.
33:59He directed them to review their own
34:01title insurance policies.
34:03He told them that Mr. Hale had no
34:06intention of closing the road
34:07immediately, and that any resolution
34:10would be handled through proper legal
34:11process. He called me after the fourth
34:14day. There are 27 homeowners in Aurora
34:16Ridge who are not the Carringtons, he
34:18said.
34:20Of those, 23 have now contacted my
34:23office. Of those 23, 19 have retained
34:26their own legal counsel, and are asking
34:28pointed questions about the HOA's
34:30management of access road matters. I was
34:33quiet for a moment. "What are the other
34:35four doing?" I asked. "Two are in
34:37Florida for the winter. One is
34:39traveling. One is Vanessa's sister."
34:41"What about Damian?" "His office
34:43called." Grant said. "This morning, his
34:46paralegal left a message asking whether
34:48Mr. Hale would be interested in a
34:50pre-trial settlement conference." I
34:52looked out the window at the snow on the
34:53pasture.
34:55The cattle were visible along the south
34:57fence.
34:58Dark shapes moving slowly in the white.
35:01"Tell him to bring his client." I said.
35:03The settlement conference went nowhere.
35:05Damian came in wanting to negotiate a
35:07new access license on terms favorable to
35:10the HOA. He had prepared a formal
35:13proposal, multi-year license, nominal
35:16fee, maintenance split, everything laid
35:18out in the kind of professional document
35:21that was meant to make his position look
35:22reasonable and settled. He had the
35:25confident manner of a corporate attorney
35:27who believed the other side would
35:28eventually take the deal because the
35:30other side always eventually took the
35:33deal. Grant listened to the entire
35:35proposal.
35:37Then he said, "We weren't interested in
35:38a license arrangement.
35:40We were proceeding with the quiet title
35:42action and the fraud allegation."
35:44Damian's face did something complicated.
35:47The evidentiary hearing was scheduled
35:49for the first week of April before Judge
35:51Eleanor Pierce, who had been on the
35:53Sheridan County bench for 16 years. She
35:56had a reputation for short patience with
35:57procedural games and a long memory for
36:00attorneys who tried them in her court.
36:02It snowed the morning of the hearing.
36:04Not a storm, just a steady, soft Wyoming
36:07April snow that came down like it had
36:09nowhere particular to be.
36:11The courthouse parking lot was white by
36:13the time we arrived. Homeowners from
36:15Aurora Ridge were already in the gallery
36:18when we entered. I recognized faces from
36:20the letters, people who had come to hear
36:22what the judge would say, people whose
36:24lives and investments hung on the
36:26outcome of a document dispute going back
36:28to 2003.
36:30Damian sat at the plaintiff's table with
36:32two associates and a thick binder.
36:34He was dressed the same as he'd been at
36:36the deposition.
36:38Expensive, precise, composed. His wife
36:41sat in the front row of the gallery in a
36:43different coat this time, charcoal gray.
36:45She had not spoken to me or looked at me
36:48since we entered. Grant laid out the
36:50case without drama.
36:52He walked through the license, the
36:54dissolution, the 10-year window, the
36:56failed relicensing attempt, the current
36:59status. He introduced each document in
37:01order. He spoke clearly and without
37:03excess. He was 73 seconds under the
37:06allotted time. Damian's response was to
37:08argue implied easement by necessity,
37:11that because Aurora Ridge Estates had
37:13only one access road,
37:15and because that road had been openly
37:17used for more than 20 years, the
37:19doctrine of easement by necessity should
37:21apply to give the HOA a legal right of
37:24access, regardless of the license's
37:26formal status. It was not a bad
37:28argument. It had legal support in some
37:30jurisdictions. Judge Pierce let him
37:32finish.
37:34Then she asked one question. Mr.
37:36Carrington,
37:37in your role as registered agent for
37:39Pinnacle Mountain Development Corp,
37:42at the time of its dissolution in 2016,
37:46did you have knowledge of the terms of
37:47the access license currently at issue?
37:50The courtroom was very quiet. Damian
37:52said that he would need to consult his
37:54records. Judge Pierce said that she
37:56would take a 15-minute recess to allow
37:58him to do so. During the recess, I sat
38:01at the defense table and watched the
38:03snow through the tall courthouse
38:04windows.
38:06Mason was in the gallery, three rows
38:08back.
38:10He gave me a short nod. When the court
38:12reconvened, Damian's composure was still
38:15there, but it was working harder than it
38:17had been before the recess. He
38:18acknowledged that as registered agent,
38:21he would have received formal notice of
38:23the dissolution proceedings and the
38:25related corporate documentation. The
38:27judge asked whether that documentation
38:30included the access license. He said he
38:32did not recall specifically. Grant
38:35introduced the dissolution filing, which
38:37listed the Hale access license as a
38:40material contract being wound down as
38:42part of the corporate closure.
38:44Damien Carrington's signature was at the
38:47bottom. The room was very quiet again.
38:50Judge Pierce looked at the document for
38:51a long time.
38:53She was not a theatrical woman.
38:56She did not make speeches from the bench
38:58or deliver verdicts with flourish. She
39:00set the document down and said evenly,
39:03"The court finds that the plaintiff's
39:05original suit was filed by an attorney
39:07of record with material prior knowledge
39:09of the legal deficiency in the access
39:12claim underlying several of its counts.
39:14The court further finds that this
39:16constitutes a violation of the duty of
39:18candor to the tribunal. The suit is
39:20dismissed with prejudice. The defendant
39:23is awarded attorney's fees.
39:25The court is referring this matter to
39:27the Wyoming State Bar's office of
39:28disciplinary counsel for review." She
39:31paused. "I would also note for the
39:33record that I find easement by necessity
39:35inapplicable in this instance as the
39:38access situation was created by the
39:40developer's own contractual arrangements
39:43and is not a natural result of the
39:44property's configuration." She stood.
39:47The bailiff called the court to order.
39:49Vanessa stood up from the gallery.
39:52She said loudly enough that the entire
39:54room heard it.
39:56"This is ridiculous.
39:58This man is trying to steal our
39:59community." The bailiff moved toward
40:01her.
40:03She said several more things that I will
40:04not repeat here. Two homeowners from
40:06Aurora Ridge, people I recognized from
40:09the letters, got up and moved away from
40:11her to the far side of the gallery. A
40:13man I later learned was named Fletcher
40:15Brock,
40:17who had a home in Aurora Ridge and had
40:19been one of the first to call Grant's
40:21office,
40:22put his hand on his wife's arm, and they
40:24stood very still and looked at the
40:26floor. Vanessa was escorted out by the
40:29bailiff and a deputy.
40:31I watched her go.
40:33She did not look at me on the way out.
40:35Damian sat at the plaintiff's table for
40:37a moment after the room had begun to
40:39clear.
40:40His associates were gathering papers. He
40:43looked, for the first time since I'd met
40:45him, like a man who understood exactly
40:47where he was standing and did not like
40:49it. He did not look at me. I sat with
40:52Grant for a few minutes after the room
40:53was mostly empty,
40:55not talking, just letting the thing
40:57settle. Outside the snow was still
40:59coming down, soft and steady, covering
41:02the parking lot and the cars and the
41:04street and the mountains behind the
41:06town. What happens to the road now? I
41:08said. That's yours to decide, Grant
41:11said. I took 2 weeks before deciding
41:14anything. The HOA held an emergency
41:16meeting the week after the hearing.
41:19I know this because three homeowners
41:21who'd been corresponding with Grant's
41:23office sent summaries. Vanessa attempted
41:26to control the meeting and was voted
41:28down on every procedural item. A motion
41:30to remove her as HOA president passed
41:33with 21 votes.
41:35Damian had already withdrawn from the
41:37HOA's legal representation quietly, by
41:40letter, before the vote. A new board was
41:42elected on an emergency basis. The new
41:45president was Fletcher Brock, who had
41:47sat in the courtroom gallery with his
41:49wife on the day of the hearing. Brock
41:51called Grant directly.
41:53He asked whether Mr. Hale would be
41:55willing to meet. I drove up to Aurora
41:57Ridge on a Wednesday morning.
42:00Brock met me at the Timber Gate, the
42:02expensive one, with the wrought iron
42:04lettering, and I noticed he'd left it
42:06open. We shook hands and walked the road
42:08together, the same route I'd walked with
42:10Grant in January. The snow was softer
42:13now, April working on it, the surface
42:16beginning to show the brown and gray of
42:18the gravel underneath. He was about 60,
42:21built like a man who'd been an athlete
42:22once and stayed reasonably close to it.
42:25He had a direct way of talking that I
42:27appreciated. He didn't apologize for the
42:29lawsuit. I hadn't asked him to, but he
42:31made it clear that the majority of
42:33Aurora Ridge homeowners had not known
42:35the legal situation and would not have
42:37supported the suit if they had. I
42:39believed him.
42:41People are not usually villains.
42:43They are usually uninformed. We sat in
42:45his living room and worked through the
42:47terms. Grant was there.
42:50Brock had retained a local attorney
42:52named Craig Forsyth, who had a sensible
42:54manner and no apparent interest in
42:57extending the dispute. The permanent
42:59easement I granted Aurora Ridge Estates
43:01was recorded with the county in May.
43:04The consideration was $1 per year, which
43:07is the standard nominal consideration
43:09for this kind of arrangement. The terms
43:11included a maintenance sharing
43:13provision, the homeowners association
43:15would contribute to road upkeep on a
43:17proportional basis.
43:19The easement was permanent and ran with
43:21the title of both properties. In
43:23exchange, the HOA agreed to dismiss all
43:26remaining claims from the original suit
43:28with prejudice, to pay Grant's
43:30accumulated attorney's fees, and to
43:32acknowledge in writing the legal history
43:34of the road access. Carrington Holdings
43:37LLC, which was it turned out, the
43:40corporate entity Damian and Vanessa had
43:42used for their Aurora Ridge property,
43:44listed their house for sale in late
43:46April. It sold in 6 weeks to a family
43:49from Colorado who had no knowledge of
43:51any of the preceding events,
43:53which was exactly as it should be. I
43:56heard through the county assessor's
43:57network that Damian had received a
43:59notice of formal complaint from the
44:01state bar. I didn't follow the
44:03proceedings closely. That was between
44:05him and his profession. The Hail Land
44:07Defense Foundation was Mason's idea. He
44:10brought it up one evening in early May
44:12when the snow was finally gone from the
44:14lower pastures and we were sitting on
44:16the porch in the thin warm air of a
44:18Wyoming spring. He'd been reading about
44:20HOA disputes in rural areas, about
44:23ranchers and small landowners who'd been
44:25pressured into selling or litigated into
44:28compliance because they didn't have the
44:30resources to fight back. We have what we
44:32have because Walter taught you, he said,
44:35"and you taught me. Most people don't
44:37have that." He was right.
44:39Walter had given me 20 years of informal
44:41education in land law and property
44:43rights before I'd gotten a formal
44:45degree.
44:47Not everyone had a Walter. The
44:49foundation was incorporated in the
44:51summer. We partnered with two other
44:53ranching families in Sheridan County and
44:55retained Grant on a part-time advisory
44:58basis. The purpose was narrow and
45:00specific, to provide information,
45:02resources, and referrals to rural
45:05landowners facing HOA abuse, predatory
45:07developer litigation, or improper access
45:10claims. We weren't a law firm.
45:13We didn't represent anyone. We helped
45:15people find the right people and
45:17understand what they were reading. In
45:19the first 8 months, we handled 23 cases.
45:23Seven of them involved access road
45:24disputes.
45:26Three involved improper HOA fee
45:28structures. The rest were a mix of
45:30boundary disputes, encroachment claims,
45:33and one situation involving a county who
45:36was conducting valuations in a manner
45:38that
45:39Grant noted carefully appeared to favor
45:42certain development interests. That last
45:44case took 14 months. I'll leave it
45:47there. Dorothy Quinn retired from the
45:49county recorder's office in September.
45:52The county threw her a small party in
45:54the parking lot, folding tables, sheet
45:56cake, some of her colleagues from other
45:59county offices. Mason and I drove in for
46:01it. She shook my hand with both of hers
46:04and said she hoped Walter would have
46:05been satisfied with how things turned
46:07out.
46:08I told her I thought he would have been.
46:10She said,
46:12"He always said the land remembers who
46:14stood up for it."
46:16I wrote that down when I got home. It
46:18seemed like something worth keeping. I
46:20went back to Walter's grave in late
46:22October.
46:24The river stone was still there, the
46:26ground firm and cold again.
46:29The first dusting of early snow on the
46:31pine branches above it. Mason came with
46:34me but stayed back at the truck, giving
46:36me some space, which was the right call.
46:38The light was going. The ridge behind me
46:41was throwing a long shadow across the
46:43east pasture.
46:45And somewhere up on the hill,
46:47through the gap in the rock, the lights
46:49of Aurora ridge were just beginning to
46:51come on in the early dusk warm yellow
46:53windows, smoke from chimneys, the
46:55ordinary evidence of people living their
46:57lives on land they could now reach by a
47:00road that was properly, permanently,
47:02legally theirs. I stood there for a few
47:05minutes. I didn't say anything out loud.
47:08Walter wasn't a man who required
47:10speeches. The road up to the ridge was
47:12visible from here, the graded cut
47:14through the rock, the timber gate
47:15standing open.
47:17A car was coming down it slowly,
47:19headlights moving through the trees. I
47:21watched it until it reached the county
47:22road and turned south toward town.
47:25Somewhere down in the valley, the last
47:27light was catching the surface of the
47:29east pond, making it look almost warm. I
47:32put my hat back on, drove home. Paper
47:35lasts longer than arrogance, especially
47:37in winter.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of YouTube transcript (n8Yb6m34_Ao) , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,906 words across 1,283 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.