YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → My Spoiled Daughter Smirked At The Lawyer, "You Can Skip The Reading, I Already Know What's In It,"

My Spoiled Daughter Smirked At The Lawyer, "You Can Skip The Reading, I Already Know What's In It," — Transcript

by QuokkaReads · 10,648 words · 1,472 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00My spoiled daughter smirked at the
0:01lawyer. You can skip the reading. I
0:03already know what's in it. Not knowing
0:04my late husband and I had planned one
0:06brutal condition that would destroy her
0:08in front of everyone. Brittany walked
0:09into Mr. Bains' office at 10:02 on the
0:11morning of November 3rd, 2 minutes late.
0:13She did not apologize. She wore cream
0:15heels and a camel coat that cost more
0:17than my first car. She crossed her legs
0:18before she even sat down. She looked at
0:20Mr. Bains the way you look at a waiter
0:22who forgot your drink. You can skip the
0:23reading, she said. She smirked. I
0:25already know what's in it. The
0:26conference room smelled like old paper
0:28and burnt coffee. Mr. Bains had
0:30practiced law in Dayton for 41 years.
0:32His office sat on the second floor of a
0:34brick building on East 3rd Street. Tom
0:36and I signed our first wills at that
0:37same oak table in 1998. Tom signed his
0:40last one there, too, from a wheelchair,
0:4211 weeks before he died. Mr. Bai- Bains
0:44looked at me over the top of his
0:45glasses. I nodded once. I'll read it
0:47anyway, he said. It was your father's
0:49wish. Brittany sighed like a teenager.
0:51She pulled out her phone and started
0:52typing. Her nails were long and pale
0:54pink. 12 years without a job and her
0:56nails never chipped. My son Josh sat on
0:58my left. He was 28, and he still wore
1:01his work boots because he'd come
1:02straight from a job site in Fairborn. He
1:04found my hand under the table. His palm
1:05was rough and warm. Mine was shaking.
1:07Mr. Bains cleared his throat and began.
1:09He read the legal opening slowly. The
1:11name of the estate, the name of the
1:12executor, which was me, the clause about
1:15funeral expenses, which were already
1:16paid. Brittany rolled her eyes at every
1:18paragraph. She looked at the clock. She
1:20looked at her phone. She looked at the
1:21window. Then he reached the part that
1:23mattered. To my beloved wife, Diane
1:24Marie Whitaker, I leave all of my
1:26property, real and personal, to hold and
1:28use for the remainder of her life.
1:30Brittany sat up straight. Her thumb
1:31stopped moving. That's it, right? She
1:33said. It goes to Mom first, obviously,
1:35and then when she dies, it all comes to
1:37me. Why would you think that? I asked.
1:39She laughed. It was a short, bright
1:40laugh, like I'd asked something silly.
1:42Because I'm the oldest, Mom. Because Dad
1:44promised me. She held up her fingers and
1:46counted. The house is worth 400,000. The
1:48lake house is 200 more. The savings is
1:50100 at least. That's $700,000. Kyle and
1:53I already made plans. I let her finish.
1:55I had waited 3 weeks to let her finish.
1:57Then I smiled. It was not a kind smile.
1:59I felt it on my own face and didn't
2:01recognize it. Josh receives the lake
2:03house, I said. He earned it with love. I
2:04keep the house until the day I die. And
2:06your share, Britney, has one condition.
2:08She stopped smiling. A full-time job, 5
2:11consecutive years. Miss it and
2:12everything goes to your brother. For a
2:14moment, nothing happened. The radiator
2:16ticked. Somewhere down the hall a phone
2:17rang twice and stopped. Her face went
2:19white, then it went red, then it went a
2:21deep ugly purple I had never seen on a
2:23human being. She jumped to her feet so
2:25fast the chair flipped backward. It
2:27slammed into the bookshelf behind her.
2:28Three heavy law books hit the carpet one
2:30after another. Thud, thud, thud. This is
2:33illegal, she screamed. I'm your
2:34daughter. Mr. Bains did not move. He
2:36folded his hands on the table. Parents
2:38may attach reasonable conditions to an
2:39inheritance, Ms. Whitaker. Courts uphold
2:41them every day. Reasonable? She turned
2:43on him. Her voice cracked. I've never
2:45worked. I can't just get a job. Yes, Mr.
2:47Bains said quietly. I understand that is
2:49the problem. She spun toward Josh. Her
2:51fingers shook in the air. Say something.
2:53Talk some sense into her. She's your
2:55mother, too. Josh did not blink. He did
2:57not let go of my hand. You haven't
2:58worked in 12 years, he said. Dad died
3:00exhausted. Half of what wore him out was
3:02worrying about you. She made a sound I
3:04can only describe as an animal sound. A
3:06wounded, furious noise. She grabbed her
3:08purse off the table. She kicked one of
3:10the fallen books as she passed it. Then
3:12the door swung open and slammed and the
3:13glass in the frame rattled for a full
3:15second after she was gone. Nobody spoke.
3:17Mr. Bains rose slowly, picked up the
3:19three books, and set them back on the
3:21shelf one at a time. His hands were
3:22steady. Mine still were not. Josh leaned
3:25toward me. You okay, Mom? No, I said,
3:27but I will be. I looked at Tom's
3:28signature at the bottom of the will,
3:30still lying on the table. The blue ink
3:31had a slight tremor. He'd signed it with
3:33a pen his shop students gave him when he
3:35retired. He told me that afternoon. Give
3:36her a reason die, not a punishment, a
3:38reason. We did it, Tom, I thought, and
3:40then I started to cry because it did not
3:42feel like winning. It felt like the end
3:43of something I had spent 26 years trying
3:45to keep alive. My name is Diane
3:46Whitaker. I was 58 years old that
3:48November. For 28 years I I the front
3:50office at Hargrove Family Dental on Far
3:52Hills Avenue. I scheduled crowns, fought
3:54insurance companies, and talked crying
3:56children out of the waiting room chairs.
3:58I retired in April to care for my
3:59husband. I was good at staying calm. I
4:01was proud of it. It would turn out to be
4:03the most useful thing I owned. Tom
4:05taught high school shop for 34 years. He
4:07was 3 years older than me and never once
4:09raised his voice at a student. We
4:10married on June 10th, 1995 in his
4:13mother's backyard in Beavercreek.
4:14Folding chairs, a cooler of lemonade.
4:17The whole day cost $1340 and we bragged
4:19about that number for years. We wanted
4:21children. We tried for 6 years. I lost
4:24three pregnancies, the last at 19 weeks.
4:26I won't say more about those years. We
4:28stopped talking about it. Then one night
4:30Tom said, "What about adoption?" and I
4:32said yes before he finished the
4:33sentence. Britney came to us on a cold
4:35March morning when she was 4 years old.
4:37She came through Montgomery County
4:38Children Services with a garbage bag of
4:40clothes and a coat two sizes too big.
4:41Her mother struggled with addiction.
4:43There had been two foster homes before
4:45ours. The case worker, a tired kind
4:47woman named Ms. Okafor, walked us to the
4:49car. She hoards food, she told us
4:50quietly. Don't take it personally.
4:52She'll grow out of it. That first night
4:53Britney hid a granola bar under her
4:55pillow. I found it the next morning
4:56wrapped in a sock. I did not take it
4:58away. I set a second one beside it and
5:00said nothing. She stared at me for a
5:01long time. Then she put her small hand
5:03in mine. I have carried that morning for
5:0526 years. I want you to understand that.
5:08I did not adopt a villain. I adopted a
5:09little girl who counted the exits in
5:11every room. Tom taught her to ride a
5:13bike in the church parking lot on
5:14Dorothy Lane. He ran behind her for an
5:16hour bent double, one hand on the seat.
5:18When she finally pedaled off alone, she
5:20screamed with joy. Tom cried harder than
5:22she did. Josh was born 2 years later. I
5:24was 34. Britney, 6 years old, carried
5:27him around like a doll for months. She
5:29called him her baby. For a while, we
5:31were the family on the Christmas card. I
5:32can't point to the day it changed. She
5:34grew older and she figured something
5:35out. She figured out we were afraid.
5:37Afraid of losing her. Afraid she'd
5:38decide she didn't belong. Every book on
5:40adoption warned us she might test the
5:42walls. What the books didn't say was
5:43what to do when she found out the walls
5:45would bend. They bent. A phone at 11, a
5:47used Honda Civic at 16, $6,800 cash for
5:51a spring break trip she swore was
5:52chaperoned. Every time she pushed, we
5:54gave. Every time we gave, she pushed a
5:56little harder. She was charming. I'll
5:58say that, too. She could walk into a
5:59room and make it hers. Teachers adored
6:01her. Waiters adored her. She had a way
6:03of tilting her head and saying, "I just
6:04feel like you don't understand me." And
6:06I would lie awake wondering how I'd
6:07failed her. The first real crack came
6:09when she was 15. The principal at
6:10Fairmont High called me at work. Britney
6:12had been skipping class. A note excusing
6:14her absences had been turned in signed
6:16Diane Whitaker. It was my handwriting,
6:18not perfect, close enough that I stood
6:19in that office and stared at it for a
6:21full minute. Britney said she hadn't
6:22written it. Then she said she wrote it
6:24because I never let her do anything.
6:25Then she cried, big tears right on cue.
6:28And I apologized to her. Think about
6:29that. I apologized to my daughter for
6:31being forged. That night in the kitchen
6:33Tom said, "She signed your name, Di.
6:34She's a kid." I said. He didn't answer.
6:36I wish he had. I wish I had let him. At
6:3819, she dropped out of Sinclair
6:40Community College after one semester. At
6:4222, she moved into a two-bedroom at
6:44Ashford Commons in Kettering. Tom set up
6:46an automatic transfer from our joint
6:47checking account. "One else $150 every
6:50month for rent until she finds her
6:51footing," he said. That was eight years
6:53ago. She never found it. She never
6:54looked. At 24, she came to us with a
6:56business plan, a hair extension boutique
6:58on Wilmington Pike. She needed $12,000
7:01and she needed Tom to cosign the loan
7:03because her credit was bad. Nobody asked
7:05how a 24-year-old had bad credit. Tom
7:07signed. The shop opened in April and
7:09closed in September. She said the
7:11landlord cheated her. I never saw a
7:12single receipt. The bank called Tom that
7:14winter. He paid the balance, $9,600, out
7:16of his retirement savings. He told me in
7:18the garage with his back to me holding a
7:20wrench he wasn't using. "It's just
7:21money, Di." It was never just money. I
7:23understand that now. It was a lesson she
7:25was learning. She was learning that our
7:26names were something she could spend.
7:28Tom's diagnosis came on August 19, three
7:30years before he died, stage four colon
7:32cancer. He was 58. The oncologist at
7:34Kettering Health drew a diagram on a
7:36paper cup because Tom said he understood
7:37things better in drawings. We sat in the
7:39parking lot afterward for an hour
7:41without speaking. Then Tom said, "Well,
7:42I'm not done yet." He did chemo every
7:44other week, 71 treatments in 3 years.
7:47Josh drove him to every single one. He
7:49traded shifts. He burned vacation days.
7:51Once he sat 11 hours in a waiting room
7:53after a bad reaction because he refused
7:55to leave. He held his father's hand. He
7:56brought a speaker and played Tom's old
7:58Creedence records. He told terrible
8:00jokes until Tom laughed so hard the
8:01nurses came to check on them. Britney
8:03did not come to one, not one. She said
8:05hospitals made her uncomfortable. On
8:06Tom's 59th birthday, she sent a text,
8:09"Hope you're feeling better." followed
8:10by a smiley face. Tom read it twice and
8:12set the phone face down on the table.
8:14"That's nice of her," he said. His voice
8:16had a flatness I had never heard. That
8:17Thanksgiving, 10 months before he died,
8:19we sat at our table in Beaver Creek. Tom
8:21was pale and thin, wearing a cardigan
8:23that used to fit him. I had made turkey
8:25and sweet potatoes and his mother's
8:27stuffing. Josh and his wife Nina brought
8:28pie. Britney brought Kyle. Kyle Dunmore
8:30was 34, leather jacket, gelled hair. He
8:33said he worked in investments and never
8:35said which ones. He drove a black German
8:37sports car that cost $60,000 new. He
8:39parked it across two spaces in front of
8:41my house. He looked at my dining room
8:43like he was pricing the chairs. Halfway
8:45through dinner, Britney set down her
8:46fork. "I'm just going to say it," she
8:47said. "I'm tired of pretending. When you
8:49two die, I'm going to inherit
8:51everything, and I'm finally going to
8:52live the life I deserve." She said it
8:54like she was reading the weather. Nobody
8:56moved. The candles flickered. Nina
8:57stared at her plate. Josh's jaw went
8:59tight. Tom set down his own fork. He
9:01looked at her for a long moment.
9:03"Britney, I'm sitting right here." "I'm
9:04just being honest, Dad." She shrugged.
9:06"Somebody has to be." She reached for
9:08the rolls. Kyle laughed once, softly,
9:11like it was a good joke. Tom did not eat
9:13another bite. That night he sat on the
9:14edge of our bed, thin shoulders hunched,
9:16and said, "Di, we need to talk about the
9:18will." We sat down with Mr. Bains that
9:20April after Tom's next scan. Tom wanted
9:23to be clear. "I don't want to punish
9:24her," he told him. "I want to give her a
9:26reason. If she works for 5 years, she'll
9:28learn what money costs. Then it will
9:29mean something. If she can't or won't,
9:31Josh should have it. Josh earned it."
9:32The lake house went to Josh because of
9:34the dock. Every summer of his childhood
9:36he was out on it. Last year, when Tom
9:38couldn't lift a hammer, Josh rebuilt all
9:4040 ft himself, $3,100 in lumber. He
9:42never asked to be repaid. He just showed
9:44up on Saturdays. Tom also wrote Britney
9:46a letter. He wouldn't tell me what it
9:47said. He wrote it in June at the kitchen
9:49table, in pencil first, then in ink over
9:513 days. He sealed it and handed it to
9:53me. Give it to her when she's earned it,
9:54he said. I locked it in the top drawer
9:56of his workbench in the garage. I told
9:58myself I'd know when. Hold on to that
9:59letter. I did. Tom died on Thursday,
10:01October 9th at 4:12 in the morning in a
10:03hospital bed we had set up living room.
10:05The last day was quiet. The hospice
10:07nurse came in the morning. Josh sat on
10:08the couch. Tom drifted in and out.
10:10Around 3:00 that afternoon, he opened
10:12his eyes and said, "Is she coming?"
10:13"She's on her way," I said. It was a
10:15lie. I had called Britney four times.
10:16She texted back, "Busy today. We'll try
10:18later." He looked at the ceiling.
10:20"She'll come for the money," he said. I
10:21thought he was being bitter. He was
10:22being accurate. She arrived at 9:40 that
10:24night, heels, her perfume, a spiral
10:26notebook in her hand. I stood up when I
10:28saw her, so hopeful I felt sick with it.
10:30She walked right past me. She leaned
10:31over the bed. Tom's eyes were half open.
10:34His breathing had that sound I'd been
10:35told to expect. She put her lips close
10:37to his ear. "Dad," she whispered,
10:39"where's the safe deposit box key?" I
10:41have replayed that sentence for over a
10:43year. She did not say hello. She did not
10:45say I love you. She did not say goodbye.
10:46I screamed at her. I have never screamed
10:48at anyone like that, before or since. I
10:50told her to get out of my house. Josh
10:52was on his feet standing between her and
10:54the bed. She rolled her eyes. "Relax,
10:55Mom. I'm just being practical." She
10:57wrote something in the notebook. Then
10:59she left. Tom died 6 and 1/2 hours later
11:01holding Josh's hand and mine. She was
11:03not there. She never asked how it went.
11:05was Monday, October 13th at Routsong
11:07Funeral Home. The room was full of Tom's
11:09former students, grown men in ties who
11:11had learned to weld from him. Britney
11:12arrived late in a red dress, bright fire
11:14engine red. Aunt Carol, Tom's older
11:16sister, looked her up and down in the
11:18receiving line. "Black is depressing,"
11:20Britney said. "Dad wouldn't want us to
11:21be depressing." At the reception in the
11:23church hall over ham sandwiches and
11:25lemon bars, she found me by the coffee
11:27urn. "So, how fast can the will get
11:28processed?" she asked. Kyle says the
11:30sooner the better. Something inside me
11:32went cold. It was not rage. Rage is hot
11:34and I would have known what to do with
11:36it. This was quiet and clear like ice
11:38forming on a pond. I didn't scream
11:39again. I got ready. The next morning I
11:41called a locksmith. $385 to change every
11:44lock in the house. Front door, back
11:45door, garage, basement. Brittany still
11:47had a key from when she was 16. I had
11:49never asked for it back. That afternoon
11:51I went to Kroger for groceries. When I
11:53came home, my neighbor Marge Delaney
11:54waved me over the fence. Marge is 71 and
11:57has lived next door for 22 years. She
11:59notices everything. "Diane," she said
12:01lowering her voice, "while you were
12:02gone, I saw a woman at your back door
12:04trying a key in the knob. It wouldn't
12:06turn. She tried it four or five times.
12:08She looked at me. Thin, blonde, camel
12:10coat. She looked exactly like your
12:11daughter." The next day I called Greg
12:13Pemberton, my financial advisor of 15
12:15years. He came to the house on October
12:1721st with a leather folder and a kind
12:19face. We moved everything into a trust.
12:21Accounts, property, savings, all of it.
12:23With rules Brittany could not talk
12:25around or forge around. "Are you sure?"
12:27Greg asked. "She's your daughter."
12:29"That's why I'm sure," I said, and I
12:31started a folder. A red accordion file
12:32from the office supply store on
12:34Wilmington Pike. Every voicemail, every
12:36text, every lie. I labeled the dividers
12:38by date. I wasn't angry yet. I was
12:40organized. 28 years of dental billing
12:43does that to a person. Three weeks later
12:45I sat in Mr. Bains' office and watched
12:47my daughter's chair hit the bookshelf.
12:49She called me 17 times that night. I
12:51counted them because I count things. The
12:52first came at 12:41 in the afternoon
12:55before I had even gotten home. I let it
12:57ring. I saved every voicemail. The first
12:58was crying. Loud, wet sobbing, the kind
13:00you do for an audience. "Mom, how could
13:02you? In front of Josh? In front of a
13:04stranger?" The fifth was angry. "You've
13:06been planning this. You and Dad. You
13:07planned to humiliate me." The ninth was
13:09cold. "I'll get a lawyer. You have no
13:11idea what I can do." The 12th was
13:12begging. "Mom, please. Just call me. We
13:14can fix this. I'll work. I'll try. Just
13:16tell them it was a mistake." The 17th at
13:182:14 in the morning was a whisper. "Dad
13:20would be ashamed of you." I played that
13:22one twice. Then I put it in the folder
13:23with the others. My hands were steady. I
13:25wish I could tell you it hurt less than
13:27it did. I didn't sleep. I sat in Tom's
13:29chair in the living room where the
13:30hospital bed had been. The carpet still
13:32had four small dents from its wheels. At
13:347:00 the next morning, someone pounded
13:35on my front door, not a knock, a pound,
13:37fist on wood. Kyle stood on my porch in
13:39his leather jacket, hair gelled. His
13:41black car sat in my driveway with the
13:43engine ticking. Over his shoulder, I saw
13:45Marge's curtain twitch. I kept the
13:46screen door latched. I did not unlatch
13:48it. "You destroyed our future," Kyle
13:50said. His voice was low and shaking.
13:52"You heartless old witch. She's been
13:54through hell and you do this? If you
13:55love her," I said, "tell her to get a
13:57job." His face twisted. He leaned closer
13:59to the screen. "You have no idea what
14:01you've done." "Then explain it to me."
14:03He didn't. He stepped back, jabbed a
14:04finger at me, and walked to his car. He
14:06backed out too fast and left black marks
14:08on my driveway. I stood there staring at
14:10those tire marks. One thought kept
14:12circling. Why does a man who drives a
14:13$60,000 car need my money so badly? I
14:17wrote the question on a slip of paper
14:18and put it in the folder. That was the
14:20first wall. She broke through the second
14:21one in six days. Brittany could not win
14:23in a courtroom, so she took the fight to
14:25the people who loved us. On Saturday,
14:27November 8th, she posted on Facebook a
14:29black and white photo of herself and Tom
14:31at her high school graduation. Under it
14:33she wrote, "Grieving my father while my
14:35own mother tries to erase me from his
14:37memory. Please pray for our family. Mom
14:39hasn't been herself since Dad passed.
14:41She's confused and making decisions that
14:42hurt everyone." 214 comments in a day.
14:45Hearts, prayer hands. People I had known
14:4730 years wrote things like, "Stay
14:49strong, sweet girl," and "Grief makes
14:51people do strange things." The word
14:53confused was in there. I noticed. I
14:55wrote it on a divider in the folder. It
14:56felt like nothing at the time. On
14:58Monday, Aunt Carol called. She was 66
15:00and lived in Columbus, and she had cried
15:02harder than anyone at the funeral.
15:03"Diane, honey, Brittany's just
15:05heartbroken. She says you've been
15:06forgetful, confused. She says you
15:08promised her the lake house and then
15:09took it back." I never told her that.
15:11"She says Tom promised it to her on his
15:13deathbed." "Carol," I held the phone
15:15away from my face and breathed. I was on
15:17one side of that bed. Josh was on the
15:19other. Brittany showed up at 9:40 at
15:20night and asked where the safe deposit
15:22key was. Those were the only words she
15:24said to him. Silence. Then, she wouldn't
15:26say that. She did. I just think, Carol
15:28said carefully, that you should be kind,
15:30whatever happens. She's all Tom had left
15:32of his own. Josh is what Tom had left.
15:35You know what I mean. I did. In Tom's
15:36family, blood was a kind of religion.
15:38Britney, adopted, had spent her whole
15:40life working around it. Now she was
15:42using it. Carol wanted to be fair. She
15:44had been handed a story where fair meant
15:45believing the crying woman. I wasn't
15:47angry at Carol. I was angry at how
15:49skillfully it had been done. By Friday,
15:51four women from church had left
15:52casseroles on my porch. None of them
15:54rang the bell. One included a card that
15:56said, "Thinking of you in this confusing
15:57time." I stood in my kitchen holding it
15:59and almost laughed. In six days, the
16:01widow who changed the locks had become a
16:03confused old woman, and the daughter
16:05who'd been locked out had become a
16:06saint. Josh found me at the table with
16:08the card in my hand. "Mom, you don't
16:10have to fix this." "I know." "You don't
16:12have to prove anything to those people."
16:14"I know," I said. I wasn't sure it was
16:15true. I had been the calm one my whole
16:17life, and now calm was being read as
16:19weakness. I slid the card into the
16:21folder, right next to the word confused.
16:23The third wall came on Tuesday, November
16:2525th, the day before Thanksgiving. Josh
16:27called me from Indian Lake. His voice
16:28was shaking. "Mom, are you sitting
16:30down?" I was not. I was standing in a
16:32grocery aisle holding a can of pumpkin.
16:34"Britney and Kyle are at the lake house
16:35with two people I've never seen. They're
16:37measuring the walls." I abandoned the
16:39cart. It took me 50 minutes to drive
16:40there. I don't remember any of it. The
16:42lake house was a low brown cottage with
16:44a screened porch, 20 ft from the water.
16:46Tom's father built it in 1974. Tom and I
16:48spent 30 summers there. His initials
16:50were carved in the doorframe with a
16:51pocket knife. Josh's height marks
16:53climbed the kitchen wall in ballpoint
16:55pen. When I pulled in, three vehicles
16:56sat in the gravel. Kyle's black car, a
16:58gray sedan, a white pickup with a logo I
17:01couldn't read. Through the screen, I saw
17:02a woman in a puffer vest holding a laser
17:04measure against the living room wall,
17:05calling out numbers. A man in a
17:07quarter-zip stood by the fireplace
17:09taking photos with his phone. Britney
17:10pointed at the ceiling and said, "This
17:12can all come out." Kyle stood in the
17:13kitchen with his arms crossed. Josh
17:15stood in front of him, a foot from his
17:16face, hands open at his sides. That's
17:18Josh. He is furious with his hands open.
17:20"Tell your brother," Kyle said, "that
17:22this lake house belongs to Britney. Her
17:24dad promised." "It doesn't," Josh said.
17:26"It's mine. It's in the will. You heard
17:27it read." "I heard your mother rewriting
17:29things. That's not the same." "You have
17:3110 minutes to leave," Josh said, "or I'm
17:33calling the sheriff." Kyle smirked. It
17:34was Britney's smirk. I wondered which of
17:36them had taught the other. I'd like to
17:37see you try. Josh pulled out his phone.
17:39He had the Logan County Sheriff's Office
17:41saved from the summer he built the dock.
17:43He held the phone to his ear and waited.
17:45Kyle stepped back. He forgot the coffee
17:46table behind him. His heel caught a
17:48chair leg and he went down hard, arms
17:50flailing, landing on the floor between
17:51the couch and the wall. It was loud. The
17:53woman in the puffer vest stopped
17:54measuring. The man in the quarter-zip
17:56lowered his phone. Every stranger in
17:57that room turned to look at Kyle sitting
17:59on the floor. "Friends of yours?" Josh
18:01asked them, still holding the phone. The
18:03man in the quarter-zip cleared his
18:04throat. "We were told this was a
18:05family-approved walk-through." "It
18:07isn't," I said. It came out steady. I
18:08stepped through the screen door. "This
18:10is private property. The owner of this
18:12house is my son. Please leave." They
18:13left in 4 minutes. Nobody argued. The
18:15woman in the vest gave Britney a strange
18:17look on her way out, flat and
18:18calculating, like a shopkeeper who has
18:20just realized a customer's card is going
18:22to decline. Britney stared at her shoes.
18:24Kyle got up off the floor with his ears
18:26burning and walked out without a word.
18:27Britney went last. At the door she
18:29turned and said, low enough that only I
18:30could hear, "You don't know what you've
18:32done." "You keep saying that," I said.
18:34"Nobody will tell me what I've done."
18:35She left. After the cars were gone, Josh
18:37found a business card on the kitchen
18:38counter, tucked under the coffee maker.
18:40Heavy cream stock, navy lettering,
18:42Harbor Point Capital. Marcus Doll, Asset
18:44Review. A phone number with a 614 area
18:46code. On the back, someone had written
18:48in blue ballpoint, 60D. "Mortgage guy?"
18:50Josh said. "Appraiser? Somebody Kyle
18:52hired?" "Probably a contractor," I said.
18:54Kyle had told the neighbors they were
18:55remodeling. "Or a realtor." I put the
18:57card in the folder behind the divider
18:59for November 25th. I did not think about
19:01it again for 6 weeks. I should have.
19:03I'll tell you that plainly. It sat there
19:04an inch from my fingers while I worried
19:06about everything else. Then came
19:08December. The first snow fell on the
19:09fourth. I strung Tom's old Christmas
19:11lights along the porch because he would
19:12have wanted them up. I stood on the
19:14ladder in my coat and felt him in every
19:16staple. Josh and Nina came for dinner
19:17that Sunday. Nina announced over sweet
19:19potatoes that she was 3 months pregnant.
19:21I cried in the pantry for 10 minutes,
19:23happy and heartbroken at once. Britney
19:25went quiet, too quiet. No calls for
19:28almost 3 weeks. In my weaker moments, I
19:30let myself think it was over. On Friday,
19:32December 19th at 10:15 in the morning, I
19:35was sitting at my kitchen table when the
19:37phone rang. A woman from the fraud
19:38department at my credit card company.
19:40Mrs. Whittaker, I'm calling about two
19:42charges to Ashford Commons Property
19:43Management, $150 on November 4th and
19:46$790 on December 2nd. Together, that's
19:49$1,190.
19:51Did you authorize these? No. Do you know
19:52who lives at that property? I looked at
19:54the folder on the table. My daughter.
19:55[clears throat] There was a pause. The
19:56kind of pause people take when they've
19:58had this call before. Ma'am, would you
19:59like to file a police report? I said
20:01yes. It took half a second and it was
20:03the hardest word I said that year. Here
20:05is what I understood after I hung up.
20:06She had known my card number since she
20:08was 19 when I paid her phone bill. I had
20:10changed every lock in the house. I had
20:12moved my savings into a trust and I
20:14never once thought about the Visa in my
20:15wallet. $1,190. I would have given it to
20:18her if she had asked. That was the thing
20:20I couldn't get past. If she had come to
20:21my door and said, "Mom, I can't make
20:23rent." I would have found a way. She
20:24didn't ask. She took. The next morning,
20:26Saturday the 20th, I sat in the
20:28Beavercreek Police Station in a plastic
20:29chair while a young officer named
20:31Ramirez typed my report. He asked if I
20:33understood I was accusing my daughter of
20:34a crime. I do, I said. Are you sure? She
20:37has known my card number since she was
20:3819. He nodded and kept typing. I signed
20:41at the bottom. My signature looked like
20:42someone else's. Maybe it was. By 3:00
20:45that afternoon, my phone lit up. I let
20:46it ring four times and picked up. What
20:48kind of mother calls the cops on her own
20:50daughter? She was screaming so hard the
20:52phone crackled. The kind whose daughter
20:53steals from her, I said. I was going to
20:55pay you back. With what? Silence. Then a
20:57small, ugly laugh. You'll see. Soon,
20:59you'll see. She hung up. I wrote down
21:01what she said, word for word. I'm not
21:03proud of how quickly I had learned to do
21:04that. I filed it under December 20th. I
21:06stood in my kitchen afterward for a long
21:08time. The house was quiet except for the
21:10refrigerator. I thought, "She is going
21:11to do something worse." I was right. On
21:13Monday, December 22nd at 9:30 in the
21:15morning, my phone showed Mr. Bains'
21:17number. "Diane," he said. His usual
21:18gravel sounded thin. "Your daughter just
21:20left my office. She came to see you
21:22without an appointment. She asked for a
21:23private conversation about a family
21:25matter. She sat down, folded her hands,
21:27and asked whether a widow could be
21:28declared unfit to manage her own
21:30finances." The refrigerator hummed. I
21:32sat down. "What did you tell her?" "That
21:34it's possible through the probate court,
21:35a guardianship petition. She would need
21:37to show incapacity, and she would need a
21:39physician's evaluation." He paused. I
21:41heard him breathe. "Diane, she already
21:42had one." My stomach dropped through the
21:44floor. She didn't hand it to me. She
21:45held it up folded and let me read the
21:47top. Doctor's letterhead. Your name,
21:49Diane Marie Whitaker. Progressive
21:51cognitive decline. Paranoid behavior.
21:52Inability to manage her own affairs.
21:54That's not true. I know it isn't. I've
21:56known you for 30 years. He said it
21:58gently. Who is Dr. Raymond Voss? I've
22:00never heard the name. He has a practice
22:01on Salem Avenue, Voss Family Wellness.
22:03I've called twice. No one picks up. I
22:05stared at the wall calendar. Tom's
22:07handwriting was still in the square for
22:08the 27th. Dentist, 2:00 p.m. He never
22:11made that appointment, either. I had
22:12never met that doctor in my life. I had
22:14never sat in his office. I had never
22:16been asked a single question. And
22:17somewhere on some desk, a man I had
22:19never met had signed his name to a paper
22:21saying I was losing my mind. So, who did
22:23my daughter pay to say it? Quick pause
22:24from the story. If you enjoy these
22:26stories, consider taking a listen to our
22:28Spotify show linked in the description
22:30for early access to new stories in
22:32better audio quality. Now, back to the
22:33video. Mr. Bains and I spent that week
22:36building a wall. He told me the petition
22:37would be filed in Green County Probate
22:39Court right after the holiday. It was.
22:41On December 29th, a deputy came to my
22:43door with a summons while Marge watched
22:45from her porch. Notice of hearing on
22:47application for appointment of guardian.
22:49Applicant, Brittany Ann Whitaker.
22:51Respondent, Diane Marie Whitaker. The
22:53hearing was set for Tuesday, January
22:5427th at 9:00 on in the morning. I read
22:57my own name next to that word,
22:58respondent, four times. On January 5th,
23:00I sat for 3 hours with Dr. Priya Nair, a
23:03geriatric neurologist at Miami Valley
23:05Hospital who Mr. Bains trusted. Memory
23:07tests, clock drawings, logic puzzles,
23:09questions about my medications, my bank,
23:12my mother's maiden name. At the end, she
23:14put down her pen and said, "Mrs.
23:15Whittaker, I wish my own mother tested
23:17this well. 30 out of 30." She agreed to
23:19testify. That should have felt like
23:21winning. It didn't. A question kept me
23:23awake at night. Not whether Britney
23:24would lose, why she would do something
23:26so reckless. A forged doctor's letter is
23:28a felony. Any judge would see through
23:30it. And what would it get her? A house
23:32she couldn't touch until I died, held in
23:33a trust she couldn't reach anyway. It
23:35made no sense. People don't take that
23:37kind of risk for a reward that far away.
23:38Something had a clock on it. On the
23:40night of January 8th, I finally sat down
23:42at the kitchen table to sort the folder.
23:43Every divider in order, every voicemail
23:45transcribed. As I turned to November
23:4725th, a cream-colored card slipped out
23:48and landed face up on the table. Harbor
23:50Point Capital. Marcus Doll, asset
23:52review. I turned it over. Blue ink. 60D.
23:5460 days from when? For what? I would
23:56like to say I had a plan. I didn't. I
23:58picked up my phone and dialed the number
24:00on the card. It was 8:40 at night. I
24:01expected voicemail. It rang three times.
24:04"Harbor Point, this is Marcus." "Mr.
24:05Doll, this is Diane Whittaker." The line
24:07went quiet. Not empty quiet, careful
24:10quiet. Then he said, "Mrs. Whittaker,
24:12well, this is a relief. I had started to
24:14think we'd never reach you." He spoke as
24:16if we were already in the middle of a
24:17conversation. I said nothing. Silence is
24:19a tool. I learned that from 28 years of
24:22dental billing. People rush to fill it.
24:24I understand things have been
24:25complicated with the guardianship, he
24:26said. "Your daughter told us the hearing
24:28is the 27th. She said once the
24:30conservatorship is in place, the estate
24:32releases quickly. We're prepared to be
24:33flexible on the timeline, but I do need
24:35to remind you that the note comes due
24:37February 15th. That's the hard date.
24:38After that, we exercise the lien."
24:40"Remind me," I said. My voice came out
24:42flat. "What the note is for?" "The
24:43advance. $90,000 against her anticipated
24:46inheritance. With fees and accrued
24:47interest, as of today, it stands at
24:49$131,400."
24:51I put my hand over my mouth. He kept
24:53going. He was the kind of man who
24:54explains things nervously when he thinks
24:56he's being helpful. "We have a copy of
24:57the will on file. June 2nd, 2022. Sole
25:00beneficiary, Britney Whitaker. Mr.
25:02Whitaker's signature notarized. That's
25:04what secured it. And the physician's
25:05letter was a nice addition. It gave us
25:07confidence in the timeline. When was the
25:08advance made? March 12th. March 12th.
25:10Tom was alive on March 12th. He'd had
25:12his 61st treatment that week. Josh had
25:14driven him. Tom had told a joke about
25:16the nurse's glasses. Who signed the note
25:17with my daughter? Mr. Kyle Dunmore as
25:19co-borrower. I waited. I let the quiet
25:21fill the room. Mrs. Whitaker, Doll said
25:23slowly, forgive me. I'm not sure I'm
25:25speaking with the person I think I'm
25:26speaking with. I'm Diane Whitaker, Tom
25:28Whitaker's widow. I'm sitting at my
25:29kitchen table. I am not incapacitated. I
25:32am not in a guardianship. And I'm
25:33recording this call. Ohio is a one-party
25:35consent state. Ma'am, I don't My
25:37husband's will is dated July 24th of
25:39last year and it's on file with his
25:40attorney. There was no will in 2022. Tom
25:43never signed anything notarized that
25:44year. What you're holding is a forgery,
25:46Mr. Doll. You loaned $90,000 against a
25:49forged document and a doctor's letter
25:50about a woman who has never met that
25:52doctor. The county prosecutor will want
25:54to know how that happened. So will your
25:55insurers. You can send me your file
25:57tonight and cooperate or someone will
25:59subpoena it and you can explain it to
26:00them. For 9 seconds, I listened to a
26:02grown man breathe. At 11:52 that night,
26:05my email chimed. 41 pages, a PDF, no
26:08message, just a subject line, file. I
26:10read all of it at the kitchen table in
26:11Tom's chair with a pot of decaf going
26:13cold. There was the loan agreement,
26:15March 12th, signed Britney A. Whitaker
26:17and Kyle R. Dunmore. There was the
26:18forged will, my husband's name at the
26:20bottom in a shaky blue scrawl that was
26:22almost right, almost. Tom always crossed
26:24his T's with a long tail. This one
26:26didn't. There was the doctor's letter
26:27dated December 12th signed by Raymond
26:29Voss, M.D. And there was a ledger of
26:31where the $90,000 had gone. $31,400
26:35to a car lease company, $18,000 to
26:37something called Dunmore Digital
26:39Ventures, back rent, a designer handbag,
26:41and $2,500 to Raymond Voss, M.D. with
26:44the memo line consultation. Then there
26:46were the texts. Lenders keep
26:47screenshots. Harbor Point had kept
26:49everyone. October 9th, 9:41 p.m. Britney
26:52to Doll, he's not going to make it
26:53through the night. I'm at the house now.
26:55Just need the original will from the
26:56box, then we're clear. 9:41. I checked
26:58the time three times. At 9:40, she had
27:00leaned over my husband's bed. Her lips
27:02were next to his ear. His eyes were half
27:04open. She said, "Dad, where's the safe
27:06deposit box key?" And in the very next
27:07minute, she was texting a lender, the
27:09notebook. I had wondered about that
27:10notebook for months. It was not a
27:12notebook of grief. It was a checklist.
27:14There was a second text from Kyle,
27:15December 14th. Once the old lady's
27:17declared we're set, get Voss to write it
27:19up again if he has to. I read it twice.
27:21Old lady, I was 58 and everything
27:23rearranged itself. Every piece. The safe
27:25deposit key wasn't only greed, it was a
27:27plan. The forged will was older than the
27:29real one. So, she needed the real one
27:31gone before anyone read it. She believed
27:33it was in that box. She had no idea Mr.
27:35Bains had held the original since July.
27:37The red dress. How fast can the will be
27:39processed? The key in my back door. The
27:41rent on my card. The strangers measuring
27:43my walls while she said, "This can all
27:45come out." All of it belonged to a clock
27:47she had started in March when Tom was
27:48still alive, still making terrible
27:50jokes, still asking whether she was
27:52coming. She hadn't only wanted his
27:53money, she had already spent it. Seven
27:55months before he died, she sold his
27:57death for $90,000. Every day after that,
28:00she needed him to hurry. I thought about
28:01Tom on that last afternoon. She'll come
28:03for the money. I put my head down on the
28:05table and cried, not loudly. I cried the
28:07way you do when you find out someone you
28:09love has been gone and away for a very
28:10long time and you are only learning it
28:12now. Then I wiped my face, made a fresh
28:14pot of coffee, and printed all 41 pages
28:17twice. Tom, I thought, you knew. The
28:19Green Court sits in Xenia in a brick and
28:21stone building with tall windows and
28:23radiators that knock. Tuesday, January
28:2527th, 9:00 in the morning, sleet on the
28:27courthouse steps. I wore my navy suit,
28:29the one from Tom's retirement dinner.
28:31Josh walked beside me. Nina held his
28:32other arm, one hand resting on her
28:34belly. Marge came in her church coat
28:36carrying a purse the size of a cat and
28:38refused to sit anywhere but the front
28:39row. Mr. Bains carried two bankers
28:41boxes. Dr. Nair arrived with a folder
28:44under her arm and shook my hand once,
28:45firmly. Brittany was already there. She
28:47sat at the petitioner's table in a plain
28:49black dress. Black, I noticed. Her hair
28:51was pulled back and she wore no makeup.
28:53She had dressed for the role. Beside her
28:55sat an attorney named Feld with the
28:56rumpled look of a man who'd been paid in
28:58advance. Kyle sat in the gallery behind
29:00her, jaw set, arms folded. Brittany
29:02turned when I walked in. Her eyes were
29:04red. Real or not, I couldn't tell. She
29:06looked at me the way you look at someone
29:07you're about to bury. Judge Patricia
29:09Halloran presided, 60, silver bob,
29:11reading glasses on a chain. She had
29:13handled guardianship petitions for 20
29:15years. She heard everything and believed
29:17nothing until she saw paper. Feld called
29:19Brittany first. She swore to tell the
29:21truth. She held the Bible with both
29:22hands. "Ms. Whittaker," Feld said,
29:24"would you describe your mother's
29:25behavior since your father's death?" She
29:27took a shaky breath. "She's not herself.
29:29She forgets things. She left the stove
29:30on twice. She called me by the wrong
29:32name. She changed all the locks in the
29:34house and told the neighbors I was
29:35trying to break in." She dabbed her eye.
29:37"I'm scared for her. She's all alone in
29:39that big house. I just want her safe."
29:41It was good. It was very good. If I
29:43hadn't been there, I would have believed
29:45her. The judge wrote something down. Mr.
29:46Bains stood for cross. He did not hurry.
29:48He took off his glasses, cleaned them on
29:50his tie, and put them back on. "Ms.
29:52Whittaker, do you currently work?" "I'm
29:54between opportunities." "When did you
29:55last hold employment?" "12 years ago,
29:57briefly." "Did you visit your father
29:59during his cancer treatment?"
30:00"Objection," Feld said, "relevance."
30:02"I'll allow it," Judge Halloran said.
30:03"Briefly." "I was overwhelmed," Brittany
30:05said. "Hospitals make me anxious."
30:07"Understood," Mr. Bains nodded. "Ms.
30:08Whittaker, do you have any debts?" "No."
30:10"None at all?" "None." "Do you have any
30:11financial arrangement, contract, loan,
30:13or agreement of any kind involving your
30:15mother's property or estate?" She looked
30:16at Feld. He looked at his legal pad.
30:18"No," she said, "none." "Under oath?"
30:20"Yes." Mr. Bains took a document to the
30:22bench and handed a copy to the clerk.
30:23"Your Honor, I'd like to mark exhibit
30:25nine." Then he walked back and laid a
30:26single sheet on the ledge of the witness
30:28box. "Ms. Whittaker, do you recognize
30:30your signature on page four?" She looked
30:32down. Her face did something I had seen
30:33only once before in that conference room
30:35when her chair hit the bookshelf. It
30:37emptied. "That's I don't an advance
30:39agreement, March 12, Harbor Point
30:40Capital, $90,000, Borrower, Britney A.
30:43Whitaker. Co-borrower, Kyle R. Dunmore.
30:45Collateral, anticipated inheritance from
30:47the estate of Thomas Whitaker. The room
30:49went very quiet. The radiators ticked.
30:51Feld half rose. Your honor, I have not
30:53seen this document. I imagine you
30:55haven't, said Judge Halloran. She was
30:57reading. She read the whole page slowly.
30:59When she looked up, she wasn't looking
31:00at me. Ms. Whitaker, you were asked
31:02under oath whether you had any such
31:04arrangement. I didn't think it counted.
31:05Her voice was very small. It's just
31:07paperwork. Exhibit 10, Mr. Bains said. A
31:10will dated June 2nd, 2022, submitted to
31:12Harbor Point as security, purportedly
31:14signed by Thomas Whitaker. Mr.
31:16Whitaker's actual will is on file with
31:18this court, dated July 24th of last
31:20year. Exhibit 11, a letter from Raymond
31:22Voss, MD, dated December 12th. Dr. Nair,
31:25would you tell the court whether Dr.
31:26Voss has ever examined Mrs. Whitaker?
31:28Dr. Nair stood. He has not. His office's
31:30own scheduling records produced by
31:32subpoena show Mrs. Whitaker was never
31:34his patient. She explained calmly, the
31:3630 out of 30, the clock drawing, the 3
31:38hours. The judge nodded slowly. Marge
31:40testified next. She swore in with one
31:42hand on the Bible and the other on her
31:44purse. I saw her at that back door on
31:46October 14th, a Tuesday, trying a key
31:48that didn't fit. Camel coat. I told
31:50Diane the same day. The judge asked if
31:51she was certain. Honey, I've lived next
31:53to that girl since she was eight. I'd
31:55know her walk in the dark. Josh
31:56testified about the lake house, the
31:58measuring tape, the strangers, the card
32:00on the counter. That was when Britney
32:01snapped. It happened fast. Feld leaned
32:03over to whisper. She shoved his hand
32:05away. She stood up from the gallery
32:06bench, where she had moved to sit behind
32:08him, before the bailiff could say a
32:09word. Red patches bloomed on her neck.
32:11You don't understand, she said. I had no
32:13choice. He was dying and it was going to
32:15be mine anyway. Everybody knew. They
32:17wouldn't give me anything. Not Dad. Not
32:19her. I needed something until it came.
32:21Kyle said they'd break his hands. It was
32:22mine. It was always going to be mine.
32:24Mine. Mine. Mine. Nobody moved. Behind
32:27me, a wooden bench creaked. Kyle was
32:29standing. He didn't look at anyone. He
32:30walked out of the courtroom and a
32:32bailiff followed him without being
32:33asked. Ms. Whitaker, said Judge
32:35Halloran. Her voice had gone quiet,
32:36which is different from soft. I strongly
32:38advise you to stop talking and speak
32:40with your counsel. Your Honor, Feld said
32:42standing. He looked like he wanted to
32:43disappear into the floor. My client
32:45withdraws the petition. I imagine she
32:47does. The judge took off her glasses.
32:49The petition is dismissed with
32:50prejudice. Costs to the petitioner. I am
32:52referring these exhibits to the Green
32:53County Prosecutor. Mrs. Whittaker, would
32:55you like to be heard? I stood. My knees
32:57held. I looked at the judge, then I
32:59looked at my daughter. Only briefly,
33:00Your Honor. I want the record to show
33:02one thing. I never wanted this. I wanted
33:04a daughter who would come to her
33:05father's funeral in black. The judge
33:06nodded. So noted. I found Britney in the
33:08hallway by the elevator. Josh stood a
33:10step behind me, hands open. She sat on a
33:12wooden bench with her coat in her lap
33:14and mascara running down her face.
33:16Nobody stood near her. It was strange to
33:17see. She had never been alone in a
33:19hallway in her life. She looked up. The
33:20performance was gone. What was left was
33:22worse. She looked 4 years old. You
33:23planned this, she whispered. You set me
33:25up, you and Dad. You laid a trap. I laid
33:27a condition, I said. One job, 5 years.
33:30It was a door, Britney. It was the only
33:31door we had left, and your father
33:33insisted we leave it open. You went
33:34around it. I needed money. You needed to
33:36ask. You never once asked. My voice
33:38shook and I let it. If you had come to
33:40me in March, I'd have sat at the kitchen
33:42table with you. Tom would have, too. We
33:44would have figured it out. Instead, you
33:46sold your father while he was still
33:47breathing. That's not You signed every
33:49page. She stared at her hands. I'm going
33:51to tell you something, I said. I need
33:53you to hear it once. I have loved you
33:55since you were 4 years old and you hid a
33:56granola bar under your pillow. I loved
33:58you when you forged my name. I loved you
34:00when you didn't come to one single
34:01treatment. I will love you until I die,
34:03but I will not fund your destruction of
34:05me. Not $1, not one more signature, not
34:07one more lie I pretend not to hear. Her
34:09mouth opened. Nothing came out. You
34:11never asked what he wanted, I said. Not
34:13once in 30 years. Not what he wanted for
34:15you. Not what he wanted from you. You
34:17only ever asked what he had. Mom, I'm
34:19done, Britney. The elevator opened. I
34:21stepped inside. Josh followed. As the
34:22door slid shut, I saw her over his
34:24shoulder, small on that bench, hands
34:26over her face. I did not reach out. It
34:28was the hardest thing I have ever done.
34:30I have done harder things since. None of
34:32them felt more like leaving a piece of
34:34myself behind. Josh was wrong when he
34:36said in the elevator that it was over. A
34:38courtroom ends, a family doesn't. By
34:40Thursday, everyone knew. Small towns
34:42hold their breath and then talk all at
34:43once. Aunt Carol called at 8:00 in the
34:45morning. She didn't say hello. "Diane, I
34:47read the exhibits." She was crying.
34:49"They're public record. Someone at the
34:50courthouse sent me copies. Honey, Tom's
34:52signature on that will is wrong. Any of
34:54us could have seen it. I said terrible
34:56things to you. I told half the family
34:57you were confused. I am so sorry." say
35:00it was fine. It wasn't. I said, "Thank
35:02you for calling." She became my fiercest
35:04ally that winter. She drove down from
35:05Columbus every other weekend and sat
35:07with me at the kitchen table. She posted
35:09a long message on Facebook apologizing
35:11publicly to her sister-in-law and
35:13deleting every prayer she'd posted for
35:14Britney. 280 comments. Some of them were
35:17ugly. She deleted none of them and
35:19answered everyone. It cost her dearly. I
35:21have never forgotten it. Not everyone
35:23came around. Carol's daughter Denise
35:24wrote me a three-page email about
35:26forgiveness. Tom's brother Ray called to
35:28say blood is blood and that I had a and
35:30in Tom's own. I reminded Ray that he had
35:32missed the last three months of Tom's
35:33treatments and every one of his
35:35birthdays since the diagnosis. He hung
35:37up. Two women from church stopped
35:38speaking to me. One sent a card that
35:40said only "Pray" on it. The pastor, a
35:41soft-spoken man named Lyle, came by on a
35:43Tuesday, sat in Tom's chair, and asked
35:45nothing. He just drank his coffee and
35:47let the silence be. That is how sides
35:49get chosen, not in one dramatic moment,
35:51in a hundred small ones. A casserole
35:53delivered or not. A call returned or
35:54not. Then came the allies I never
35:56expected. Marcus Doll gave a deposition
35:58to the county prosecutor on February
36:002nd. His lawyers had told him to
36:01cooperate and for once a man took good
36:03advice. Harbor Point withdrew its lien
36:05claim on the lake house on February 10th
36:07and wrote off the loan against my
36:08estate. They still had a claim against
36:10Britney and Kyle personally. That was
36:11not mine to pay. Mr. Bains made that
36:13very clear. A woman named Lorraine
36:15Dunmore called me from Toledo, Kyle's
36:17mother. She had read about the case in
36:19the paper. "I'm so sorry," she said in a
36:21raspy smoker's voice. "I raised him
36:23better than this. I don't know where it
36:25went wrong." She mailed me a check for
36:26$500 the next week. For your trouble,
36:29the note said. I never cashed it. I keep
36:30it in the folder. Kyle's black car was
36:32repossessed on February 3rd in front of
36:34his sister's house in Huber Heights. The
36:36lease was in Britney's name. Kyle agreed
36:38to testify in exchange for a reduced
36:39charge and he texted Josh a single line
36:41the next day. I'm out. Tell your mom I'm
36:43sorry. Josh didn't reply. I wouldn't
36:45have either. The money side of it took
36:47its own toll. Mr. Bains' bill for the
36:49hearing and the response came to
36:50$14,600.
36:52Josh offered to split it and I refused.
36:54Tom had always said a family shouldn't
36:55keep a ledger. I understood that better
36:57now because for months I had been
36:58keeping one on my own daughter.
37:00Assistant Prosecutor Dana Kessler, a
37:02brisk woman in her 30s, met with me on
37:04February 19th. She explained the counts:
37:06forgery, identity fraud, unauthorized
37:08use of a credit card. 11 charges in
37:10total. Once the deposition was in, she
37:12wanted me to understand what I was
37:13agreeing to. Mrs. Whittaker, she said,
37:15your daughter could go to prison. Do you
37:17want to proceed? I looked at the folder.
37:19I had never said the answer out loud. I
37:20want her to answer for it, I said. I
37:22don't want her destroyed. I know those
37:24aren't always the same thing. They
37:25aren't, Kessler said. But sometimes I
37:27can help make them closer. Dr. Voss was
37:29another story. The state medical board
37:30opened an investigation in March. In
37:32June, they suspended his license. Dr.
37:34Nair told me quietly over coffee that he
37:36had signed 11 similar letters for 11
37:39other families. I never learned how many
37:40of those families had been as lucky as
37:42mine. Then Britney made her last
37:44desperate moves. On Friday, February
37:466th, a woman called Greg Pemberton's
37:48office saying she was me. She said her
37:50phone was acting up and she needed
37:51$40,000 wired to an account she would
37:53text him. Greg listened. Greg has known
37:55my voice for 15 years. He asked her one
37:58question. Diane, what did we have for
37:59lunch the day we set up the trust?
38:01Silence. Then a click. He called me at
38:03once. That wasn't you, he said. His
38:05voice was hoarse with anger. That was
38:06her. Diane, I'm so sorry. I should have
38:08caught it sooner. You caught it, I said.
38:10That's all that matters. The other move
38:12came two nights later. Sunday, February
38:148th at a quarter to midnight. Someone
38:15pounded on my front door. Not a knock, a
38:17pounding, fists and palms, the whole
38:19house shaking with it. Mom, open the
38:21door. I was already on the stairs. I
38:23stopped on the third step in my robe in
38:25the dark. I did not go to the door. I
38:27know you're in there. I saw the light.
38:28Mom, please. Her voice cracked. I'm
38:30going to be homeless. Kyle left. They're
38:32going to evict me. You're killing me. Do
38:34you understand that? You are killing
38:36your own daughter. I sat down on the
38:37stair. I listened for 22 minutes. I know
38:40because I watched the clock on the
38:41mantel. She pounded. She screamed. She
38:44called me every word she had. Then she
38:45stopped screaming and that was worse.
38:47She slid down my front door. I heard the
38:49sound of her sliding down the wood and
38:51then I heard her crying. The real kind.
38:53The kind without an audience. The kind I
38:55had not heard since she was six and had
38:57a fever. I went to the door. I put my
38:58palm flat against the wood. Mom, she
39:00whispered. She must have felt it or
39:02heard the floorboard. I'm here, I said.
39:04I'm not opening it. Please, I don't have
39:05anywhere to go. You have a lease until
39:07March 31st. Your brother offered you his
39:09couch last week. You hung up on him.
39:11That's not fair. It's true. Dad would be
39:13ashamed of you. I closed my eyes. It was
39:15the 17th voicemail in person. I thought
39:16about saying nothing. Instead, I said,
39:18Your father wrote you a letter Britney
39:20in June. It's in a drawer. It's yours
39:22when you've worked for five years.
39:23Silence. What letter? She whispered.
39:25You'll know it when you read it. Nothing
39:27else came through the door. After a long
39:28time, I heard her stand up. Her
39:30footsteps on the porch. A car door
39:32somewhere in the dark. An engine. I
39:33stayed on that floor until my legs went
39:35numb. Then I went to the garage. I
39:36turned on the single bulb over Tom's
39:38workbench and opened the top drawer. The
39:40envelope was there. Cream paper. Her
39:41name in Tom's careful hand. The pencil
39:43ghost still faintly visible beneath the
39:45ink. I did not open it. I sat on his
39:47stool with the envelope on my knee and I
39:49let myself say it. I miss her. Not the
39:51woman who screamed at my door. Not the
39:52woman in the red dress. I miss the
39:54Britney who might have existed. The one
39:56who might have stood at Tom's bed and
39:57said goodbye. The one who might have
39:59called on Sundays. The one who pedaled
40:00off alone in a church parking lot on
40:02Dorothy Lane screaming with joy while a
40:04man ran behind her with his hand still
40:06out. Grief is a strange animal. It
40:08doesn't wait for someone to die. It
40:09shows up for people who are alive and
40:11breathing in an apartment across town. I
40:13sat in my husband's workshop with his
40:15tools hanging in their outlines on the
40:16pegboard and I mourned a daughter who
40:18was not dead. I turned off the light and
40:19went to bed. On April 14th, Britney
40:21stood in a Green County courtroom and
40:23pleaded guilty to one count of forgery,
40:25a felony of the fifth degree, and one
40:27count of unauthorized use of a credit
40:29card. The other counts were dismissed.
40:30Judge Ambrose sentenced her to 24 months
40:33of community control, 200 hours of
40:35community service, restitution of
40:36$1,940, which she paid me in a cashier's
40:39check, and one more condition, which the
40:41assistant prosecutor asked for and I did
40:43not. "Verifiable full-time employment,"
40:45the judge read, "to be maintained for
40:47the duration of community control." I
40:49sat in the gallery and heard my own
40:50conditions spoken by a stranger. I
40:52nearly laughed, then I didn't. I looked
40:54at the back of my daughter's head. She
40:55stood very still. She did not turn
40:57around. It was not the ending I wanted,
40:59but it was one I could live with. It has
41:00been a year and 6 days since Tom died. I
41:02still live in the house on Cedar Street.
41:04I kept it as he wanted. Last spring I
41:06painted the living room a soft yellow,
41:08the room where the hospital bed once
41:09stood. The carpet dents are gone. I
41:11still look for them sometimes. Josh and
41:12Nina have a son, Thomas, born August
41:143rd. We call him Tommy. He has his
41:16grandfather's ears and a grip like a
41:18shop vise. Every Saturday the three of
41:20them drive to the lake house and Josh
41:21has started building a second dock. He
41:23measures it in inches, the way Tom did,
41:25and mutters the same words under his
41:26breath. I take a watercolor class at the
41:28Kettering Recreation Center on Tuesday
41:30nights. I am terrible. I love it. Marge
41:32and I walk the neighborhood at 6:30
41:34every morning, rain or not. Aunt Carol
41:36comes down on the second Sunday of the
41:37month. Greg sends me a card each
41:38October. Mr. Bains never sent another
41:40bill after the first one, and I've never
41:42asked why. I sleep through the night
41:43now. That's new. Britney started work on
41:45May 19th at a distribution center in
41:47Vandalia, second shift, stocking shelves
41:49for a pet food company. The judge's
41:51condition required it, and I would like
41:52to tell you she took it gracefully. She
41:54did not. She was fired from the first
41:56job in 11 days for missing shifts. She
41:58was let go from the second one after a
41:59shouting match with a supervisor. The
42:01third one stuck. She works from 2:00 in
42:03the afternoon until 10:30 at night. She
42:05hates it. Her feet hurt. I know because
42:06she told me. In July, at 11:47 one
42:09night, I got a a from a number I hadn't
42:11seen in months. First check that didn't
42:13come from anybody. $587,
42:15thought you should know. I read it 11
42:17times. I typed five replies. I sent the
42:19sixth. I'm glad. Take care of your feet.
42:21I did not send money. I did not offer
42:23help. That was the hardest sentence I
42:24ever left out. In September, she came to
42:26dinner one Sunday. She sat at the far
42:28end of the table where Tom used to sit
42:29and I noticed she'd chosen it without
42:31seeing it. She did not mention Kyle. She
42:33did not mention the courtroom. She ate
42:35quickly and never looked at the empty
42:36chair by the window. She stayed 43
42:38minutes. At the door, she stopped with
42:39her keys in her hand. "I'm still mad at
42:41you," she said. "I know. I hate that you
42:43were right." "I didn't want to be," I
42:44said. She nodded. She didn't hug me. I
42:46didn't ask her to. By my count, she has
42:48about 1,300 days left on her father's
42:50condition. If she finishes, she gets the
42:52house when I'm gone and the savings and
42:54everything Tom wanted her to have. If
42:55she doesn't, it goes to Josh and I will
42:57have made my peace with that, too. I
42:59don't know which way it will go. Some
43:01days, I think she'll make it. Other
43:02days, I remember the way she said mine,
43:04mine, mine and I don't. I have learned
43:06to live in that not knowing. It's a
43:08smaller room than the one I lived in
43:09before, but it has a door that opens.
43:11Every Thanksgiving, I still set an extra
43:13plate. Then I put it back in the
43:14cupboard. I do it quietly, the way you
43:16tap a wall to check that it's still
43:17there. I have thought a lot about what I
43:19learned. Here it is. Love is not a debt
43:21anyone owes you. Neither is a will. You
43:23cannot inherit a person. You can only be
43:25present while they are alive enough to
43:26give themselves to you. And by the time
43:28the papers are read, it is far too late
43:30to start. A will is not a list of what
43:32you're owed. It is the last thing
43:33someone says to you when they can't say
43:35anything else. The title of this story
43:36calls our condition brutal. It wasn't.
43:38It was the kindest thing we could think
43:40of. It was a way to hand her a reason.
43:42Britney smirked at a lawyer and told him
43:43to skip the reading because she already
43:45knew what was in it. She didn't. She
43:46never read one word of what her father
43:48and I wrote. She never read him, either,
43:49all those years lying in that bed with
43:51his hand open on the blanket waiting for
43:53her to come. I don't say that to punish
43:54her. I say it because it's the truest
43:56thing I know and it took losing both of
43:58them to see it clearly. I lost my
43:59husband. I lost the daughter I thought I
44:01was raising. I lost the one I thought I
44:02might get back. It turns out grief can
44:04hold all three without breaking. I did
44:06not expect that. In the top drawer of
44:08Tom's workbench, there is still a sealed
44:09envelope with her name on it. It's been
44:11there for 15 months now. I check on it
44:13sometimes, the way you check on a
44:14sleeping child. If she earns it, she can
44:16read it. I hope she does. I hope it is
44:18the first thing she ever really reads.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of My Spoiled Daughter Smirked At The Lawyer, "You Can Skip The Reading, I Already Know What's In It," by QuokkaReads, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,648 words across 1,472 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.