My Son Cut Me Out of His Birthday Photo, So I Put a "For Sale" Sign on the House He Was Living In — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00"Can you step out? This is a family
- 0:02photo."
- 0:03My son said it loudly enough that the
- 0:05whole back half of the restaurant turned
- 0:07around.
- 0:09I was holding a glass of iced tea,
- 0:11standing exactly where the photographer
- 0:14had told me to stand, which was beside
- 0:16my son at his own 35th birthday dinner.
- 0:19I had spent a month planning that
- 0:21evening. I booked the private corner of
- 0:23a steakhouse on James Street North in
- 0:26Hamilton, paid the $600 deposit with my
- 0:29own Visa, and ordered the maple bourbon
- 0:32cake from the bakery Justin loved as a
- 0:34boy.
- 0:35And now he was waving two fingers at me,
- 0:38the way you'd wave off a waiter.
- 0:40Beside him stood his wife, Caitlin.
- 0:43Beside her stood her parents, Ronald and
- 0:46Deborah Porter, who had driven in from
- 0:48Oakville, and had so far contributed a
- 0:51bottle of wine and a lot of opinions
- 0:53about the lighting. The photographer, a
- 0:55young man Caitlin had hired, lowered his
- 0:58camera and looked at his shoes. "Mom,"
- 1:02Justin said with a little sigh, as if I
- 1:04were the one making this awkward. "Just
- 1:06for this one. It's for the family."
- 1:09Ronald smiled. Deborah smiled. Neither
- 1:11smile went anywhere near their eyes.
- 1:14Caitlin reached up and straightened
- 1:16Justin's collar.
- 1:18I did not ask him who had paid for the
- 1:20steak he'd just eaten. I did not remind
- 1:23him that I worked double shifts to raise
- 1:24him, or that I drove him to hockey at
- 1:275:00 in the morning in a Corolla with no
- 1:29heat.
- 1:30I set my glass on the table, nodded, and
- 1:33stepped out of the frame.
- 1:35The flash went off. They laughed and
- 1:38crowded around the little screen on the
- 1:40back of the camera. Nobody looked for
- 1:42me.
- 1:43So I went to the coat check, took my
- 1:45wool coat and my purse, and walked out
- 1:48the front doors into the cold October
- 1:50air. I wasn't crying. What I felt was
- 1:53strange and clear, like a window someone
- 1:55had finally wiped clean.
- 1:58I drove home along the lake road with
- 1:59the radio off.
- 2:012 hours later, I was standing in my
- 2:03kitchen with the kettle on when my phone
- 2:06buzzed on the counter.
- 2:08It was Caitlin. He keeps asking why you
- 2:10left. People noticed. It's really
- 2:12embarrassing for him.
- 2:14I read it twice, then I deleted it,
- 2:16poured my tea, and sat down at the
- 2:18table.
- 2:20The embarrassing part hadn't even
- 2:22started yet.
- 2:23I should explain about the house. It was
- 2:25a four-bedroom brick house in Burlington
- 2:28on a street of maples, and the deed said
- 2:30Gail Elliott and nothing else.
- 2:33My husband, Wayne, and I bought it in
- 2:351994.
- 2:37After he died 3 years ago, every room
- 2:39seemed to echo. When Justin and Caitlin
- 2:42asked if they could move in for a year
- 2:44or two to save for a down payment, I
- 2:46said yes before they finished the
- 2:48sentence.
- 2:50With Toronto prices the way they are,
- 2:52how could I not?
- 2:54A year turned into two.
- 2:56Somewhere in there, I became the
- 2:57housekeeper.
- 2:59I bought the groceries, cooked supper,
- 3:01and did their laundry because Caitlin
- 3:03always forgot to switch it over.
- 3:06I picked up her boots from the middle of
- 3:07the front hall. They were good leather
- 3:09boots, and they sat there like a small,
- 3:12expensive insult.
- 3:14That night, I picked them up one more
- 3:16time and put them in the closet.
- 3:18Then I went up to my bedroom, the only
- 3:21room in that house that still felt like
- 3:23mine, and sat on the edge of the bed.
- 3:26The photograph wasn't about a
- 3:27photograph. It was a picture of how they
- 3:30saw me.
- 3:31The sponsor, the help, the woman who
- 3:34stands in the background and pays. And
- 3:37the worst part was that I had taught
- 3:38them to see me that way. Every time I
- 3:40swallowed a remark, every time I paid
- 3:43for something and said, "Don't worry
- 3:45about it."
- 3:46I was showing them where my place was.
- 3:49Neither of them called. Justin probably
- 3:52figured I'd sleep it off and have bacon
- 3:54on by Sunday morning like always.
- 3:57I had never given him a reason to think
- 3:59otherwise.
- 4:00I opened my nightstand drawer, took out
- 4:02the little notebook where I keep my
- 4:04passwords and account numbers, and
- 4:06started a list.
- 4:08It wasn't a list of things to shout
- 4:10about. I didn't want an apology because
- 4:13an apology costs nothing, and they'd get
- 4:15over feeling sorry by Tuesday.
- 4:18I wanted something that would last.
- 4:20Sunday morning came in bright through
- 4:22the kitchen blind. Normally by 9:00, I
- 4:25had the bacon going and the coffee
- 4:27dripping.
- 4:28When Justin and Caitlin came down at
- 4:309:30, puffy-eyed and a bit hungover,
- 4:34they found a cold stove and a spotless
- 4:36counter. The big espresso machine, the
- 4:39one I'd bought myself for Christmas, was
- 4:41unplugged and sitting in a cardboard box
- 4:44on the dining table.
- 4:46"Mom?" Justin rubbed his face. "Where's
- 4:48breakfast?"
- 4:50"I'm not making breakfast," I said quite
- 4:52cheerfully wiping the counter.
- 4:54Caitlin pulled her silk robe tighter.
- 4:57"Why is the coffee machine in a box? I
- 4:59need my latte."
- 5:01"I'm decluttering. You two will need to
- 5:03sort out your own meals from now on. I'm
- 5:06stepping back."
- 5:07Justin finally looked at me properly.
- 5:10"Are you still mad about last night?
- 5:12Come on, Mom. Caitlin's parents hardly
- 5:15ever get a picture with us. You made it
- 5:17weird by leaving."
- 5:19I dropped the cloth in the sink.
- 5:21"I had a lovely time at the dinner, but
- 5:23I realized something.
- 5:25You're building your own family and I
- 5:27respect that. So, I'm giving you the
- 5:30independence you obviously want."
- 5:32I picked up my purse and keys.
- 5:35"Where are you going?" Caitlin said,
- 5:37looking at the empty coffee pot as if it
- 5:40had personally betrayed her.
- 5:42"Out. Oh, and I emptied your laundry
- 5:44hamper onto your bed. It was getting
- 5:46full. Enjoy your Sunday.
- 5:49I went to Tim Hortons, bought a medium
- 5:51double-double, and sat in the parking
- 5:53lot watching the geese.
- 5:55I'll admit I enjoyed it more than I
- 5:57should have.
- 5:59The coffee was never the real wake-up
- 6:01call. That was scheduled for Tuesday.
- 6:04On Tuesday morning, I sat at the
- 6:06computer with a mug of plain drip coffee
- 6:08and logged into my bank.
- 6:10When Justin and Caitlyn moved in, I'd
- 6:13added Justin as an authorized user on my
- 6:15Visa. The rule was emergencies only,
- 6:18like a dead battery or a burst tire.
- 6:20Over the past 6 months, though,
- 6:22emergency had stretched to cover
- 6:24groceries, a leather jacket for Caitlyn,
- 6:27and a string of date night dinners.
- 6:30I'd paid every statement without a word
- 6:33because I didn't want to fight.
- 6:35I clicked manage cardholders, selected
- 6:37Justin's name, and pressed remove.
- 6:40It took less than 30 seconds.
- 6:42At a quarter past 2:00, my phone rang.
- 6:44Justin.
- 6:46Mom, did you do something to the card?
- 6:48Caitlyn's at the Loblaws and it got
- 6:50declined.
- 6:52In front of everyone.
- 6:53Yes. I canceled it.
- 6:55What? Why? She's got a whole cart of
- 6:57food.
- 6:59I went over my finances this week, I
- 7:01said, tracing the rim of my mug. You're
- 7:04both adults with your own family. It's
- 7:06no longer appropriate for me to cover
- 7:08your daily expenses.
- 7:11You could have warned us.
- 7:13You both have jobs, Justin. You don't
- 7:16need a warning to pay for your own
- 7:17groceries.
- 7:19I hung up. 10 minutes later, the front
- 7:21door slammed and Caitlyn stomped into
- 7:24the hall carrying one small bag instead
- 7:26of her usual six.
- 7:28That was incredibly spiteful, Gail, she
- 7:31snapped, dropping it on the floor.
- 7:33Not Mom, Gail.
- 7:34She'd never once used my name that way
- 7:36and I noticed.
- 7:38Pick up the bag, Caitlyn. We'll talk
- 7:40when Justin gets home.
- 7:42He walked in at 5:30.
- 7:45They'd clearly been texting all
- 7:46afternoon because they came into the
- 7:49living room as a team and sat down on my
- 7:51sofa like a delegation.
- 7:53"Mom, we need to talk about your
- 7:55attitude."Justin began.
- 7:57"Sit."I said, though they already had. I
- 8:01stayed standing and held one sheet of
- 8:03paper."Since you moved in, I've covered
- 8:05the mortgage, the property taxes, the
- 8:07utilities, and most of the groceries.
- 8:11The agreement was that you'd be saving
- 8:12for a home of your own. After this past
- 8:15weekend, I realized I've been treating
- 8:17you like children, which isn't fair to
- 8:20anyone."
- 8:21I handed him the page. He read it and
- 8:23his eyes went wide.
- 8:25"Starting the first of next month, rent
- 8:27is $2,200. That covers your share of the
- 8:31hydro, water, and internet. You buy your
- 8:34own food and do your own chores. If that
- 8:37doesn't suit you, you have 60 days to
- 8:39find another place."
- 8:41Caitlin snatched the page out of his
- 8:43hand."$2,200? We can't afford that.
- 8:47We're saving."
- 8:48"You both earn good salaries. In this
- 8:50neighborhood, a full floor with its own
- 8:53bathroom and parking would run you more
- 8:55than that.
- 8:56I'm being generous."
- 8:58"This is our home, too."she said."No."I
- 9:02said quietly and looked straight at her.
- 9:05"This is my home. You're tenants. And
- 9:07tenants who leave the owner out of the
- 9:09family photo don't get to live here for
- 9:11free."
- 9:12Justin stared hard at his socks."Mom,
- 9:15please. We never meant to hurt your
- 9:17feelings."
- 9:18"My feelings aren't hurt, Justin. My
- 9:21eyes are open. The first of the month is
- 9:232 weeks away. Let me know."
- 9:26I went into the kitchen and ran the tap,
- 9:29partly so they could hear that I wasn't
- 9:31listening. They still thought I was
- 9:33bluffing.
- 9:342 weeks went by. They paid the 2200 by
- 9:37e-transfer
- 9:39on the 1st with a message line that said
- 9:41only rent.
- 9:43Caitlin slammed cabinets whenever I
- 9:45walked past and I let her. Saturdays
- 9:47belonged to me again. I read. I walked
- 9:50down to the water. I went to the market
- 9:52in Hamilton and bought one chop, not
- 9:54four.
- 9:55Then, on the second Saturday of that
- 9:58month, the Porters came by for a visit.
- 10:00I was out back repotting ferns with the
- 10:03kitchen window open above me. And voices
- 10:05carry well in a brick house in November.
- 10:08"Solid bones,"Ronald said."Good lot,
- 10:11too."
- 10:12"It really is,"said Caitlin."Once Gail
- 10:15goes into a retirement home, or, you
- 10:17know, passes, Justin and I are going to
- 10:20gut the whole main floor, knock out this
- 10:22wall, open the kitchen to the dining
- 10:24room. Her bedroom upstairs becomes the
- 10:27nursery. We've already priced it."
- 10:29"Smart to have a plan,"Deborah agreed.
- 10:32"She can't rattle around in this big
- 10:34place forever."
- 10:36I stopped with a handful of soil halfway
- 10:38to the pot. I wasn't angry.
- 10:41What I felt was cold and steady, like
- 10:44when you finally add up a bill you've
- 10:45been avoiding.
- 10:47They weren't saving for their own house.
- 10:49They were waiting for mine. They'd been
- 10:51walking my floors and measuring my walls
- 10:54and counting the days.
- 10:56I washed my hands at the outdoor tap,
- 10:58dried them on my jeans, and scrolled my
- 11:01phone to Nancy Hunter, who'd been in my
- 11:03book club for 15 years and had sold real
- 11:06estate in Halton for 20.
- 11:09"Nancy, it's Gail. Free for coffee this
- 11:12week? I've got a property to list and
- 11:14I'd like it done quickly and quietly."
- 11:17The The wall they wanted to knock down
- 11:19was going to stay exactly where it was.
- 11:22Nancy came on Tuesday while Justin and
- 11:24Caitlin were at their downtown offices.
- 11:28She walked through with a clipboard and
- 11:30a measuring tape, running her palm along
- 11:32the original's oak banister.
- 11:35Gail, you've kept this place
- 11:36beautifully. The market's tight right
- 11:38now. Low inventory, lots of buyers.
- 11:42Price it right and we'll see multiple
- 11:44offers inside a week.
- 11:46That's what I was hoping to hear.
- 11:48Where will you go?
- 11:50There's a 55 plus condo building down by
- 11:53the lake in Burlington. The ones with
- 11:55the wrap around balconies.
- 11:58I want something smaller. No snow
- 12:00shovel, no gutters, no one's boots in my
- 12:02hallway.
- 12:04Nancy laughed. I know the building. I
- 12:07can get you in to see a unit this
- 12:08afternoon.
- 12:10We sat at the kitchen table and I signed
- 12:12the listing agreement without a second
- 12:14thought. No open houses. I told her I
- 12:18wasn't going to have strangers parading
- 12:20through my living room while I still
- 12:22lived in it. So, private showings only
- 12:24with notice. She took the photographs of
- 12:27the exterior and said the sign would go
- 12:30up Friday morning.
- 12:32At the door she hesitated. Do the kids
- 12:34know?
- 12:35Not yet. They've been dreaming about a
- 12:37place of their own, Nancy.
- 12:40I'm just giving them the push.
- 12:42She looked at my face for a moment.
- 12:44She'd been in the business long enough
- 12:46to know when not to ask. I spent the
- 12:49afternoon wrapping my mother's China in
- 12:51newspaper and humming.
- 12:54Friday morning, a man in a pickup
- 12:56hammered a post into my front lawn and
- 12:58hung a white sign from it.
- 13:00I sat on the porch in my cardigan with a
- 13:02cup of tea and watched the street wake
- 13:04up. Justin and Caitlin worked from home
- 13:07on Fridays and usually came down around
- 13:109:00.
- 13:11At quarter past the front door opened.
- 13:13Justin stepped out for a parcel, glanced
- 13:15up and stopped.
- 13:17The box slid out of his hands.
- 13:19Mom, what is that? Why is there a sign
- 13:22on the lawn?
- 13:23Caitlin came out behind him, laptop
- 13:25still open in her arms. all the color
- 13:28left her face.
- 13:29"Good morning,"I said."I'm selling the
- 13:31house."
- 13:33"You can't!"she shrieked."We live here!"
- 13:36"You rent a floor here, month to month.
- 13:38I own the house, and it's too much
- 13:40upkeep for one person. I'm downsizing."
- 13:44Justin gripped the railing like it might
- 13:46float away.
- 13:47"Where are we supposed to go? We
- 13:49haven't saved enough for what we want."
- 13:52"You both earn excellent money."
- 13:54I took a sip of tea."You'll qualify for
- 13:57a lovely apartment while you keep
- 13:59saving. The buyers will want a 30-day
- 14:01closing, I expect. I'd start packing
- 14:04this weekend."
- 14:06"This is about the photo,"he said, and
- 14:08his voice cracked on it."One stupid
- 14:10picture at my birthday."
- 14:12I looked at my son. I felt a pang. I
- 14:15won't pretend I didn't, but under it was
- 14:17something that felt a lot like peace.
- 14:20"The photo only showed me where I stand,
- 14:22Justin.
- 14:23I'm stepping out of the frame, exactly
- 14:25like you asked."
- 14:27It sold in 4 days. A cash offer 40,000
- 14:31over asking, closing in 30 days. My
- 14:34lawyer, a sensible woman named Dawn
- 14:36Ford, handled the paperwork, and I
- 14:38signed everything at her office in a
- 14:40single morning.
- 14:42What followed was a performance in three
- 14:44acts. First came the charm. Caitlyn
- 14:47suddenly cooked supper. She bought me a
- 14:49bouquet of grocery store tulips. She
- 14:52cornered me in the upstairs hall with a
- 14:54tight smile and a rush of words."Gail,
- 14:57we know we've taken you for granted. If
- 14:59we pull the listing, we can sit down and
- 15:01talk about boundaries. We want you
- 15:04here."
- 15:05"The sale is firm, Caitlyn,"I said."My
- 15:07condo is already secured. Thank you for
- 15:10the flowers."
- 15:11Act two was resentment. They spent
- 15:14evenings tossing things into boxes,
- 15:16slamming doors, and complaining loudly
- 15:19about first and last month's rent on a
- 15:21two-bedroom. I ignored every word of it.
- 15:24I was busy packing my own life and
- 15:27leaving behind anything I didn't want to
- 15:29carry.
- 15:30There was one more surprise, and Caitlyn
- 15:32brought it on herself. Three days before
- 15:35closing, a man from a kitchen design
- 15:37firm showed up at the door with a rolled
- 15:40set of drawings and a very awkward
- 15:42expression. Apparently, Caitlyn had
- 15:45signed a contract for the main floor
- 15:47renovation weeks earlier with a
- 15:49non-refundable deposit of $11,000 and
- 15:53had given him my address and my plans as
- 15:56if they were hers. He'd come to confirm
- 15:58the demolition date.
- 16:00I let him in, offered him a coffee, and
- 16:03showed him the sale agreement and the
- 16:05sign on the lawn. He turned pale,
- 16:07apologized to me three times, and went
- 16:09out to his van to call his office.
- 16:12The deposit, the contract clearly said,
- 16:15was forfeited if the client lost access
- 16:17to the property. Caitlyn had paid it on
- 16:19her credit card. She'd also quietly
- 16:22promised her parents the Porters
- 16:24Heritage Room in the new floor plan, and
- 16:27Ronald had already told half his golf
- 16:29club about it.
- 16:31Justin made his last attempt that same
- 16:33week. He stood in the kitchen doorway
- 16:36looking small and tired.
- 16:38"Mom, please. This is tearing the family
- 16:40apart."
- 16:42I pressed tape down on a box of
- 16:43cookbooks."No, Justin. It's reorganizing
- 16:46the family into its right places. You
- 16:49and Caitlyn are the core now. I'm the
- 16:52extended family, and nobody lives with
- 16:54the extended family."
- 16:56She had nothing to say to that.
- 16:58Moving day was a Saturday. Their rented
- 17:01truck idled in the driveway while they
- 17:03loaded it in silence.
- 17:05When it was done, Justin came into the
- 17:07empty hall and held out his house keys.
- 17:10"We're heading to the new place.
- 17:13Drive safely."
- 17:15He looked around at the bare walls.
- 17:17Will you come visit? When I'm invited, I
- 17:20said and smiled.
- 17:22A month later, I was sitting on the
- 17:24balcony of my condo with the lake spread
- 17:26out below me, flat and silver in the
- 17:28morning light. The place was pristine
- 17:31and furnished exactly the way I liked
- 17:33it. No boots in the hall, no one else's
- 17:36laundry.
- 17:37The money in my accounts was mine and
- 17:39nobody's plans.
- 17:41Justin and Caitlin had landed in a
- 17:43two-bedroom rental on the east end of
- 17:46Hamilton. Without my cushion, the
- 17:49arithmetic of their spending caught up
- 17:51with them. I knew because on a gray
- 17:53Thursday in January, my buzzer rang and
- 17:56when I looked at the little screen by
- 17:58the door, Caitlin was standing in the
- 18:00lobby with her collar turned up and her
- 18:03mouth set in a thin line.
- 18:05I let her come up. I didn't offer her a
- 18:07coat hook.
- 18:08She stood in my sunny living room and
- 18:11looked at the lake the way she used to
- 18:13look at my kitchen.
- 18:14Measuring it. Then, she looked at me.
- 18:18I'll get straight to it, Gail. That
- 18:20kitchen company won't release the
- 18:2111,000. It's on my card at 22%and the
- 18:26rent on the new place is eating us
- 18:27alive. My parents can't help. Dad's been
- 18:31humiliated at the club and Mom says it's
- 18:33my mess. She swallowed. You just sold a
- 18:36house for 40 over asking. You could
- 18:39clear the card without even noticing.
- 18:41We're family.
- 18:43Family, I said.
- 18:45Yes.
- 18:47The last time I stood in a room with
- 18:48your family, I was asked to step out of
- 18:51the picture. I kept my voice level. And
- 18:54a few weeks after that, you hired a
- 18:56contractor to tear out my kitchen and
- 18:58gave him my address. You signed that
- 19:01contract in my name in my house without
- 19:04asking me one question. Her cheeks went
- 19:07red. I never meant for it to go that
- 19:09far.
- 19:10You priced my death, Caitlin.
- 19:12I under my own kitchen window and heard
- 19:15you do it.
- 19:16She opened her mouth and nothing came
- 19:18out. For the first time since I'd known
- 19:20her, she had no tidy phrase ready. After
- 19:22a long moment, her chin trembled."I'm
- 19:25sorry,"she said, so quietly I almost
- 19:28missed it."I'm sorry, Gail."
- 19:31"Thank you. I believe you mean it
- 19:33today."I walked to the door and held it
- 19:35open.
- 19:36"But I won't be paying that card
- 19:39and I won't be co-signing anything. That
- 19:41debt is the price of the plan you made.
- 19:44Please don't come here again unless
- 19:45Justin brings you for a reason I've
- 19:47chosen."
- 19:48She walked past me without another word.
- 19:51I heard the elevator chime and then the
- 19:53hall was quiet.
- 19:55I stood there with my hand on the cool
- 19:57brass handle and I felt no triumph at
- 19:59all, only a door finally closed the way
- 20:02it should have been closed a long time
- 20:04ago.
- 20:05Justin still came for coffee once a
- 20:08month. He knocked now instead of walking
- 20:10in and he asked how I was doing before
- 20:13he told me what he needed.
- 20:15On his most recent visit, I noticed
- 20:17something on his phone case as he set it
- 20:19down, a tiny printed copy of the
- 20:21birthday photo. He saw me looking.
- 20:24"I got it printed at the drugstore,"he
- 20:26said quietly."Look at it, Mom. There's a
- 20:29space on the left side. It's the exact
- 20:31width of a person."I kept staring at
- 20:34that gap and I finally figured out whose
- 20:36it was.
- 20:38I didn't say anything.
- 20:40"I know Caitlyn came to see you,"she
- 20:42told me."I'm not asking you to change
- 20:44your mind."He rubbed his thumb along the
- 20:47edge of the case."I think I finally see
- 20:50how much you were caring for us. I was
- 20:52selfish."
- 20:53It was the closest thing to a real
- 20:55apology I'd had from him since he was a
- 20:57boy. I took it with a nod.
- 21:00"We all have to grow up sometime,
- 21:02Justin. Sometimes it takes a change of
- 21:05scenery."
- 21:06I walked him to the door, hugged him,
- 21:08and watched him go down the long
- 21:10carpeted hall.
- 21:11Then I locked up and went back inside to
- 21:13my quiet, bright, wonderful home.
- 21:17Stepping out of that photograph was the
- 21:19best decision I ever made because once I
- 21:22was out of their picture, I finally had
- 21:24room to paint my own.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of My Son Cut Me Out of His Birthday Photo, So I Put a "For Sale" Sign on the House He Was Living In by Granite Revenge, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,529 words across 570 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.