My Husband Got My Sister Pregnant While We Were Doing IVF — Mom Said I Should Be Happy For Them — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00My husband got my younger sister
- 0:01pregnant while he and I were doing IVF,
- 0:04and my mother told me I should be happy
- 0:06for them. She said it in my own kitchen
- 0:08three days after my second embryo
- 0:10transfer failed. She was holding a plate
- 0:13of lemon bars she baked to comfort me,
- 0:15and she set them down right next to my
- 0:17box of progesterone syringes. At least
- 0:19there's going to be a baby in this
- 0:21family, she said. Be happy for them,
- 0:24Noelle. She had known for nine weeks.
- 0:27What none of them knew was that I had
- 0:28already found the sticky note in my
- 0:30husband's truck written in my mother's
- 0:32handwriting. My name is Noelle Calloway.
- 0:35I was 36 that fall, living in the Dundee
- 0:38neighborhood of Omaha, Nebraska, and I
- 0:41worked as an outpatient pharmacist at a
- 0:43hospital on the west side of town. My
- 0:45whole job was reading labels, patient
- 0:47name, drug, dose, prescriber, date. If
- 0:52one line on a prescription didn't match
- 0:54another, I caught it before it reached
- 0:56someone's mouth. I was good at it. I
- 0:59liked being good at it. Two years
- 1:01earlier, my husband and I had started
- 1:03IVF. We had tried on our own for almost
- 1:06three years before a reproductive
- 1:07endocrinologist sat across from us and
- 1:10used the words diminished ovarian
- 1:11reserve. I remember Rhett holding my
- 1:14hand in that office and saying, then
- 1:16we'll do whatever it takes. I believed
- 1:18him. We opened a joint savings account
- 1:21at our credit union and named it Baby
- 1:23Fund. I set it up so that any withdrawal
- 1:26over $5,000 needed both our signatures.
- 1:29I told Rhett it was so neither of us
- 1:31could ever touch it in a weak moment.
- 1:34He laughed and called me the most
- 1:35romantic accountant he'd ever met. The
- 1:38day of our first transfer, I bought a
- 1:40little Meyer lemon tree in a clay pot
- 1:42and put it in our kitchen window. I told
- 1:44him that by the time it gave us lemons,
- 1:46we'd have a kid to make lemonade with.
- 1:49He kissed my forehead. The tree never
- 1:51fruited, neither did the transfer. The
- 1:54first one failed in the spring of that
- 1:56year. I found out on a Tuesday between a
- 1:58flu shot clinic and a lunch didn't eat.
- 2:01Ret came home early with a bag of the
- 2:02chocolate pretzels I liked and held me
- 2:04on the couch while I cried. He said, we
- 2:07have one more embryo. We have a fund. We
- 2:10have time. I remember thinking I had
- 2:13married the right man. I remember that
- 2:15now the way you remember a house you
- 2:16used to live in. I grew up in a brick
- 2:19house in Benson with my parents, Bettina
- 2:21and Leland, and my sister Paisley, who
- 2:23was five years younger than me. My
- 2:25father sold farm equipment for 30 years.
- 2:28My mother ran the house, the church bake
- 2:30sales, and every opinion within a mile
- 2:33of it. Paisley was the baby, and she
- 2:35never stopped being the baby. When I was
- 2:3716, I worked at a frozen custard stand
- 2:40all summer to buy my own prom dress.
- 2:42When Paisley turned 16, mom drove her to
- 2:45Kansas City and bought her one for $400.
- 2:48When I asked about it, mom said, you
- 2:51never wanted a fuss, Noel. Your sister
- 2:53does. When Paisley dented dad's truck
- 2:56backing out of the church lot, dad said
- 2:58accidents happen. When I put a scratch
- 3:01on the same truck a year earlier, I paid
- 3:03for the touch-up paint myself. Mom
- 3:05called me the dependable one. She said
- 3:07it the way some people say tall. Fact,
- 3:10not a compliment. The only person in
- 3:13that house who ever made me feel chosen
- 3:15was my grandmother, Opal, dad's mother.
- 3:18She lived with us for the last four
- 3:19years of her life in the back bedroom
- 3:22with a wooden rocking chair she'd nursed
- 3:23both of her sons in. On Saturday, she
- 3:26taught me to make lemon bars, extra
- 3:28zest, a thin, almost burnt crust. Your
- 3:32mother makes them too sweet, she'd
- 3:34whisper. Ours are honest. She signed
- 3:37every card she ever gave me with the
- 3:39same silver fountain pen engraved with
- 3:41her initials. After she died, mom kept
- 3:44it in her desk drawer. Before she died,
- 3:47she told mom the rocking chair was for
- 3:49my first baby's nursery. Mom promised. I
- 3:52heard her. Paisley wasn't all bad. When
- 3:55I was 12, I broke my arm falling off the
- 3:57monkey bars, and I couldn't sleep from
- 3:59the throbbing. Paisley was seven. She
- 4:02dragged her pillow and blanket into my
- 4:04room, lay down on the hardwood floor
- 4:06next to my bed, and held my good hand
- 4:09until I fell asleep. She did that for 11
- 4:11nights. I never forgot it. I think
- 4:14that's why I forgave her for so many
- 4:16things later. I met Rhett Sorenson at a
- 4:18friend's Fourth of July party when I was
- 4:2028. He was the sales manager at a truck
- 4:23dealership on West Dodge Road, and he
- 4:26could talk to anybody about anything.
- 4:29He brought me a paper plate of
- 4:30watermelon without asking if I wanted
- 4:32one, and he remembered I didn't like the
- 4:34seeds, so he'd pick them out. We married
- 4:37when I was 30 in a small chapel in
- 4:39Benson with Paisley as my maid of honor.
- 4:42My best friend Priya Natarajan, a high
- 4:44school chemistry teacher who swore like
- 4:46a sailor and cried at every wedding,
- 4:48gave a toast that made Rhett blush. For
- 4:50three years we were happy. Then the
- 4:52fertility appointments started, and our
- 4:54marriage became a calendar of blood
- 4:56draws, ultrasounds, injections, and
- 4:59waiting. I gave myself shots in the
- 5:01stomach every night at 9:00. Rhett used
- 5:03to hold the ice pack for me. Somewhere
- 5:05in the second year he stopped. That was
- 5:08around the time Paisley started needing
- 5:10him. She'd been renting a chair at a
- 5:12hair salon in Exarben Village and was
- 5:14always short on something. Her car
- 5:17battery died. Her landlord raised the
- 5:19rent. Her ex wouldn't return her TV. And
- 5:22every time mom called me first, can
- 5:25Rhett run over there? You know how she
- 5:27gets. I said yes because I always said
- 5:29yes. Rhett would grab his keys and go.
- 5:32He started coming back later. First an
- 5:35hour, then three. He'd say Paisley
- 5:38needed help moving furniture or she'd
- 5:40been crying about her ex and he didn't
- 5:42want to leave her alone. In May I
- 5:44noticed he'd started keeping his phone
- 5:46in his back pocket even at home. In June
- 5:49he stopped coming to my ultrasound
- 5:51appointments. He said the dealership was
- 5:53short staffed. When I asked if something
- 5:55was wrong, he said, you're spiraling,
- 5:58Noel. The hormones are making you see
- 6:00things. I wanted that to be true so
- 6:02badly that I let it be. Then there was
- 6:05the smell. Paisley used a coconut
- 6:07keratin spray at the salon. It was the
- 6:09kind of smell that got into fabric and
- 6:11stayed. In August, I started noticing it
- 6:14on Rhett's work shirts when I did the
- 6:16laundry. Not perfume, just coconut and
- 6:19heat.
- 6:20He said the dealership had hired a new
- 6:22receptionist who wore a lot of lotion. I
- 6:25wrote down the receptionist's name in my
- 6:27head. A week later, I stopped by the
- 6:29dealership with lunch. The front desk
- 6:31was staffed by a 60-year-old man named
- 6:33Hank. On Labor Day at Dad's backyard
- 6:36cookout, Paisley wouldn't eat the
- 6:38bratwurst. She said she was going
- 6:40vegetarian. Mom brought her a ginger ale
- 6:43before she'd even asked for one. I
- 6:45noticed. I filed it away. That's what
- 6:48pharmacists do. We notice, we file, and
- 6:51we don't say anything until we're sure.
- 6:53In September, our second transfer was
- 6:55scheduled. It was our last frozen embryo
- 6:58from the first retrieval. Before the
- 7:00transfer, my clinic told me I'd need
- 7:02about $4,000 in medications. I asked
- 7:05Rhett to put it on his health savings
- 7:07account card from work the way we had
- 7:08for the first cycle. He told me the
- 7:10account was nearly empty. $212, he said.
- 7:15He'd had some dental work. I didn't
- 7:17argue. I paid $4,100 from my own
- 7:20savings. The transfer happened in late
- 7:23September. 11 days later, on a Monday,
- 7:26the clinic called. My blood test was
- 7:28negative. I sat in my car in the
- 7:30hospital parking garage and screamed
- 7:32into my coat sleeve so nobody would hear
- 7:34me. Then I went back inside and filled
- 7:36prescriptions for six more hours because
- 7:38people were waiting. The next morning,
- 7:41my car was in the shop, so Rhett took a
- 7:42demo from the dealership and I borrowed
- 7:44his truck to get to work. When I reached
- 7:47for my sunglasses in the center console,
- 7:49I found a white pharmacy bag folded in
- 7:51half. It wasn't from my pharmacy. It was
- 7:54from a chain store on West Broadway in
- 7:56Council Bluffs, just across the river in
- 7:59Iowa. Pharmacists don't open other
- 8:01people's prescription bags, but I didn't
- 8:04have to. The label was facing up.
- 8:07Prenatal vitamins with DHA, a 30-day
- 8:09supply of doxylamine and pyridoxine,
- 8:12a common prescription for morning
- 8:14sickness in pregnancy. Patient name,
- 8:17Paisley Caraway. The receipt was stapled
- 8:19to the back. It had been paid with a
- 8:22card ending in 4417.
- 8:24I knew that number. It was Rhett's
- 8:26health savings account card. The same
- 8:28account he'd told me had $212 in it.
- 8:32Stuck to the back of the receipt was a
- 8:34yellow sticky note. 10 words in looping
- 8:36blue ink I've been reading on birthday
- 8:38cards my whole life. Use Rhett's HSA
- 8:41card. It's medical. Nobody checks. Love,
- 8:44Mom. I didn't cry. I sat in the driver's
- 8:48seat of my husband's truck with the
- 8:49engine off and read that note four
- 8:51times. Then I took photos of everything,
- 8:54the label, the receipt, the note. I
- 8:57folded the bag back exactly the way I'd
- 8:59found it and put it back in the console.
- 9:02That night, after Rhett fell asleep, I
- 9:04logged into the HSA portal on our
- 9:06laptop. I'd set up the account myself
- 9:08two years earlier so I could submit our
- 9:10IVF claims. My password still worked.
- 9:13The balance was $212 just like he'd
- 9:16said. He just hadn't said why. In
- 9:19August, it had been over 3,000. There
- 9:21had been no dental work. Instead, there
- 9:24had been 11 charges, a women's clinic in
- 9:27Council Bluffs, an ultrasound center,
- 9:30the pharmacy on West Broadway twice,
- 9:33$2,960
- 9:34in all. The first charge was dated 9
- 9:37weeks earlier. I took screenshots of
- 9:40every line. Then I lay down next to my
- 9:42husband and listened to him breathe
- 9:44until the sun came up. On Wednesday
- 9:46evening, Rhett came home at 6:15 with a
- 9:49bag of Rouses from the Place on Dodge.
- 9:52He set them on the counter and started
- 9:53telling me about a customer who tried to
- 9:55trade in a truck with a raccoon living
- 9:57in the engine. I let him finish the
- 9:59story. Then I set my phone on the
- 10:01counter between us. It showed the photo
- 10:04of the prescription label, only the
- 10:06label. Is my sister pregnant? I asked.
- 10:10He looked at the screen. The color left
- 10:12his face so fast it was almost a medical
- 10:14event. Noel, that's not.
- 10:17Is she pregnant, Rhett? He sat down on a
- 10:19bar stool. Yes. Is it yours? He didn't
- 10:23answer. That was an answer. How long?
- 10:27Since March. Seven months. Seven months
- 10:30of 9:00 injections that he stopped
- 10:32helping with. Where? Her apartment.
- 10:36Sometimes a motel in Council Bluffs.
- 10:39Were you going to tell me? We were going
- 10:41to wait, he said, until after the
- 10:44transfer. Your mom thought if it worked,
- 10:46it would be easier for you. You'd have
- 10:48your own baby to focus on. I looked at
- 10:51him for a long time. My mom thought.
- 10:54He rubbed his face with both hands.
- 10:57She's known since Paisley found out.
- 10:59She's been helping. She said you'd fall
- 11:01apart if you found out during the
- 11:03injections. How long has she known?
- 11:06Since the end of July. I counted without
- 11:09wanting to. Nine weeks. My mother had
- 11:12sat in my kitchen during my injections.
- 11:15She had asked me how I was feeling. She
- 11:17had prayed over me at church on the
- 11:19Sunday before my transfer with her hand
- 11:21on my shoulder, and she had known. You
- 11:24told me I was spiraling, I said. I'm
- 11:27sorry, he said. I'm so sorry. I never
- 11:31meant for any of this to happen. You
- 11:33drove across a river to a motel. That's
- 11:36not something that happens to a person.
- 11:39He had nothing to say to that. I asked
- 11:41him to stay somewhere else. He took a
- 11:43duffel bag and left at 8:40. At 11:52
- 11:47that night, my phone lit up with a text
- 11:49from Paisley. Please don't hate me. Mom
- 11:52said you'd understand eventually. You
- 11:54always do. I read it twice. Eventually.
- 11:58As if my heartbreak were an appointment
- 12:00I'd simply been late for. I didn't
- 12:02answer. I didn't mention the HSA. I
- 12:05didn't mention the sticky note. I needed
- 12:08to see what they would do when they
- 12:09thought they knew everything I knew.
- 12:11Then I sat on the kitchen floor under my
- 12:13lemon tree and cried until my stomach
- 12:15hurt, and I called Priya. She didn't
- 12:17come in. She honked twice in the
- 12:19driveway, drove me to an all-night diner
- 12:22on Dodge Street, and ordered me a stack
- 12:24of pancakes I never touched. She ate
- 12:26half of them herself. Around 1:00 in the
- 12:29morning, she pointed her fork at me and
- 12:31said, "So what's the plan, Caraway?" I
- 12:34said, "There isn't one yet. I need to
- 12:37wait." On Thursday afternoon, my mother
- 12:39came over with the lemon bars. She
- 12:41didn't knock. She had a key. She found
- 12:44me at the kitchen table sorting my
- 12:46leftover medication into a bin to return
- 12:48to the clinic, and she set the plate
- 12:50down beside the box of syringes. She sat
- 12:53across from me and reached for my hand.
- 12:55"I know this is hard, sweetheart," she
- 12:57said, "but at least there's going to be
- 13:00a baby in this family. Be happy for
- 13:02them, Noel." I pulled my hand back. "You
- 13:05knew for 9 weeks. Your sister was
- 13:08scared. I was doing injections every
- 13:10night, which is exactly why I didn't
- 13:13want to upset you." I looked at the
- 13:15lemon bars. I looked at the syringes. I
- 13:18didn't say one word about the receipt in
- 13:20Red's truck. She took my silence the way
- 13:23she'd always taken it as agreement.
- 13:25"Paisley needs us right now," she said.
- 13:28"You've always been the strong one."
- 13:30Then she stood up, smoothed her skirt,
- 13:32and said, "Your father's 65th is Sunday
- 13:35at the steakhouse. We'll all talk there
- 13:37like adults. Please come." She left the
- 13:40lemon bars. I threw them away. Then I
- 13:43took them out of the trash and threw
- 13:44them away again in the outside bin
- 13:46because I didn't want to smell them. I
- 13:48went to Dad's birthday dinner that
- 13:50Sunday. It was at an old steakhouse on
- 13:52Center Street with red leather booths
- 13:54and waiters in white jackets. Mom had
- 13:57reserved a corner table. Paisley sat
- 13:59next to Red. She wore a loose green
- 14:02dress, and when she reached for her
- 14:04water, I saw that her stomach had
- 14:06started to round. Dad sat at the head of
- 14:08the table, looking at his menu like it
- 14:11was written in another language. Nobody
- 14:13said happy birthday. Mom waited until
- 14:16the steaks came. Then she folded her
- 14:18hands. We all know why we're here, she
- 14:21said. This isn' what any of us planned,
- 14:24but there's a baby coming in April, and
- 14:26that baby is my grandchild. We have to
- 14:28start thinking practically. Paisley
- 14:31started crying quietly. Rhett put his
- 14:33arm around her. He did it right in front
- 14:36of me like it was the most natural thing
- 14:38in the world. Mom looked at me. The kids
- 14:40are going to need a real place. Paisley
- 14:43can't raise a baby in a studio
- 14:44apartment. Rhett's commission isn't what
- 14:47it used to be. She reached into her
- 14:49purse, took out a printed form from our
- 14:51credit union, and smoothed it flat
- 14:54beside my plate. Then she laid Grandma
- 14:56Opal's silver fountain pen on top of it.
- 14:59It was a withdrawal request for the baby
- 15:01fund, $31,000.
- 15:04Rhett's signature was already on it. The
- 15:06line for my signature was empty. Sign it
- 15:09with Grandma's pen, Mom said. She'd want
- 15:12this. You can't use that money right now
- 15:15anyway, she added gently. Not after this
- 15:18last cycle. And it was always meant for
- 15:20a baby. Now there is one. I stared at
- 15:23the form. Then I looked at my father.
- 15:26Did you know, Dad? He set down his fork.
- 15:29Your mother told me about the baby two
- 15:31weeks ago, he said. She said it was
- 15:34handled. Handled? Let's not make a
- 15:37scene, Noel, he said quietly. Not
- 15:40tonight. Be happy for them, Mom said.
- 15:43That's all I'm asking. Be happy for your
- 15:46sister. I looked at all of them, my
- 15:49mother, my father, my husband with his
- 15:52arm around my sister, my sister crying
- 15:54into her napkin. For people who had
- 15:57already decided my IVF money would buy a
- 15:59crib for my husband's baby, not one of
- 16:02them had asked if I was okay. Paisley
- 16:04finally looked up at me, mascara
- 16:06smudged. It's not like I planned it,
- 16:08Noel, she said. You don't plan seven
- 16:11months, I said. You schedule them. She
- 16:14flinched. Rhett tightened his arm around
- 16:17her. At the next table, a family was
- 16:19singing happy birthday to a little boy
- 16:22in a cowboy hat. Nobody at our table had
- 16:24sung to my father. I picked up grandma's
- 16:27pen and turned it over in my fingers.
- 16:29The silver was warm from mom's purse.
- 16:32What time Friday? I asked. Mom blinked.
- 16:36Then she smiled. Ten, she said. The
- 16:38credit union on 72nd Street will make it
- 16:42official and start healing. I put the
- 16:44pen and the form in my purse. Nobody at
- 16:47that table noticed I hadn't said yes. On
- 16:49the way out, she pressed a foil wrapped
- 16:51slice of dad's birthday cake into my
- 16:53hands. For later, she said. I knew you'd
- 16:56come around. You always do. She thought
- 16:59I'd come around. She was right about one
- 17:02thing. I'd be there Friday at 10. Rhett
- 17:05called me that night from his friend's
- 17:07couch. He used his gentle voice, the one
- 17:10he'd used in the fertility clinic
- 17:11waiting room. Your mom's right, Noel, he
- 17:14said. I know how this sounds, but you
- 17:17can't do another cycle right now anyway.
- 17:20The money's just sitting there. Let it
- 17:22go somewhere it can help. Somewhere it
- 17:24can help you, I said. It's for a baby,
- 17:27he said. That's what it was always for.
- 17:30It was for our baby, Rhett. He was
- 17:33quiet. Then he said, you'll sign Friday,
- 17:36right? Your mom already told Paisley's
- 17:38landlord she'd be out by November. I
- 17:41said, I'll be there at 10 and hung up
- 17:43before he could hear what was in my
- 17:45voice. On Monday morning, I sat across
- 17:47the desk from Gideon Sabo, a family law
- 17:50attorney with an office above a bike
- 17:52shop in the old market.
- 17:54He had gray hair in a ponytail, wore
- 17:56cowboy boots with a suit, and listened
- 17:58for 15 minutes without saying a word.
- 18:01Then he leaned back. Nebraska is a no
- 18:03fault state, he said. The affair won't
- 18:06get you a dime by itself, but money is
- 18:09different. If a spouse spends marital
- 18:11funds on someone outside the marriage,
- 18:14the court can count that against them.
- 18:16That's called dissipation. My HSA paid
- 18:19for my sister's prenatal care, I said,
- 18:22and he told me it was empty, so I paid
- 18:24for my own fertility drugs. Gideon
- 18:26looked at my screenshots for a long
- 18:28time. An HSA can only pay for the
- 18:31account holder, a spouse, or a
- 18:33dependent, he said. Your sister isn't
- 18:36any of those. That's a non-qualified
- 18:38withdrawal. He'll owe income tax on it
- 18:41and a 20% penalty between him and the
- 18:44IRS. That's his problem, not yours. For
- 18:47your divorce, it's $2,960
- 18:50of marital money he spent on his
- 18:52girlfriend. And the baby fund? It needs
- 18:55both signatures above 5,000. He can't
- 18:58drain it without you, but don't count on
- 19:00keeping all of it. It's marital savings.
- 19:04You'll likely split it with credit for
- 19:06what he wasted. He filed the divorce
- 19:08petition on Wednesday along with a
- 19:10motion asking the court to keep the
- 19:12joint accounts untouched until the case
- 19:14was resolved.
- 19:16He sent a copy of the motion to the
- 19:18credit union by certified mail. Keep
- 19:20your mouth shut and your folder full, he
- 19:23said. If they want you in a room, go.
- 19:25Just don't sign anything with anybody's
- 19:27pen but mine. I asked Priya to come with
- 19:30me Friday. She took a personal day. She
- 19:33said she wouldn't miss it for anything.
- 19:35The credit union was a low brick
- 19:37building on 72nd Street with a
- 19:39drive-through and a bowl of free
- 19:41lollipops on the counter. A loan officer
- 19:43named Bev Lindahl, a soft-spoken woman
- 19:46with reading glasses on her head, let us
- 19:48into a small conference room with a
- 19:50framed photo of the Platte River on the
- 19:52wall. My parents were already there.
- 19:54Paisley sat beside Rhett. Mom had
- 19:57brought a bakery box of cinnamon rolls
- 19:59like this was a family brunch. She
- 20:01smiled when she saw me. Then she saw
- 20:04Priya and the smile thinned. This is a
- 20:06family matter, she said. Priya is my
- 20:09family, I said and sat down. Bev opened
- 20:12a folder. Before we start, she said
- 20:14carefully, I need to let everyone know
- 20:17that on Thursday we received I'll
- 20:19explain it, I said. Bev nodded and sat
- 20:22back. I took out my own folder. I laid
- 20:25down the first page. This is my divorce
- 20:27petition filed Wednesday, and this is a
- 20:30motion asking the court to freeze our
- 20:32joint accounts until the divorce is
- 20:34settled. The credit union got a copy
- 20:36yesterday. Bev nodded. That's correct.
- 20:40This account needs both signatures for
- 20:42anything over $5,000,
- 20:44and we've also received notice from the
- 20:46court. I won't be processing anything
- 20:48today. Rhett stared at the paper. You
- 20:51filed. You spent 7 months of motel
- 20:54nights in Council Bluffs. I said, I
- 20:57filed. Mom's voice went thin. Noel, this
- 21:01is not what we discussed. We didn't
- 21:03discuss anything, Mom. You decided. I
- 21:06laid down the second page. It was a
- 21:08printout of the HSA transactions. 11
- 21:11lines. This is Rhett's health savings
- 21:14account. In September, he told me it had
- 21:17$212 in it, so I paid $4,100 for my IVF
- 21:21drugs out of my own savings. Here's
- 21:23where the money actually went. A women's
- 21:26clinic in Council Bluffs. An ultrasound
- 21:28center. Prenatal vitamins. Morning
- 21:31sickness medication. $2,960
- 21:35for Paisley's pregnancy. Rhett went red.
- 21:38I was going to pay it back. To who? I
- 21:41asked. Me or the IRS? Paisley looked at
- 21:45him. You said that card was from your
- 21:47work. You said it was free. It's not
- 21:50free, I said. It's marital money, and
- 21:53it's not allowed to pay for you. Then I
- 21:56laid down the third page. It was an
- 21:58enlarged photo of the yellow sticky
- 22:00note. Use Rhett's HSA card. It's
- 22:03medical. Nobody checks. Love, Mom. My
- 22:06mother looked at it and went completely
- 22:08still. My father leaned forward and
- 22:11picked it up.
- 22:12He held it close to his face. He'd been
- 22:14reading that handwriting on grocery
- 22:16lists for 40 years. He knew it the way
- 22:19he knew his own name. Then he set it
- 22:21down and cleared his throat. Your My was
- 22:24trying to help, he
- 22:26"Let's not make a scene, Noel." Paisley
- 22:28turned and stared at him. Then the words
- 22:31came out of her fast, like they'd been
- 22:33waiting nine weeks. Mom said Noel
- 22:35wouldn't notice. She said Noel would be
- 22:38too busy with her shots to look at any
- 22:40statements. The room went silent. Even
- 22:43the air conditioner seemed to stop. Bev
- 22:45quietly took off her reading glasses.
- 22:48Rhett stood up. "Noel, can we please
- 22:50just talk about this at home? Not in
- 22:53front of strangers." "You don't live at
- 22:55my home anymore," I said. "And you made
- 22:58strangers part of this when you used the
- 23:00pharmacy in another state." Mom finally
- 23:03found her voice. "I was trying to help
- 23:05your sister. I was trying to help
- 23:07everyone. You should be happy that You
- 23:10told me to be happy for them, mom," I
- 23:12said. "You just forgot to mention I was
- 23:15paying for it." She opened her mouth.
- 23:18Nothing came out. My father turned the
- 23:20photo face down on the table, as if that
- 23:23would make it say something else. I
- 23:25closed my folder and stood. "Bev, thank
- 23:27you," I said. "Sorry about your Friday."
- 23:31Bev gave me the smallest nod. "Ma'am,
- 23:33I've seen worse," she said, "but not
- 23:36much." Priya and I walked out past the
- 23:38bowl of lollipops. In the parking lot, I
- 23:41sat in the passenger seat of her car and
- 23:43shook so hard my teeth chattered. Priya
- 23:45turned the heat on high and didn't say a
- 23:47word. After five minutes, she handed me
- 23:50a lollipop she'd stolen from the
- 23:52counter. It was cherry. I laughed so
- 23:54hard I cried. On Monday, my mother left
- 23:57a voicemail. She didn't apologize. She
- 24:00said I had humiliated her in front of a
- 24:02stranger at the credit union and that
- 24:04Paisley hadn't stopped crying all
- 24:06weekend. She said the stress wasn't good
- 24:09for the baby. At the end, her voice
- 24:11softened. "I only ever wanted everybody
- 24:13to be happy," she said. I saved it and
- 24:16sent it to Gideon. Then I went to work
- 24:19and checked labels for nine hours, and
- 24:21not one of them lied to me. The divorce
- 24:23took seven months. Rhett's lawyer argued
- 24:26that the baby fund was half his. Gideon
- 24:28showed the court every HSA charge and
- 24:30every text where Rhett told me the
- 24:32account was nearly empty. In the end,
- 24:35the judge divided the baby fund but
- 24:37credited me for the money he'd wasted.
- 24:39walked away with $18,460,
- 24:43the full $31,000 I'd saved for, not the
- 24:46$4,100 I'd spent on drugs for a transfer
- 24:49that failed. We sold the house in Dundee
- 24:52and split what was left after the
- 24:53mortgage. I hated signing those papers.
- 24:56I signed them anyway with Grandma Opal's
- 24:59silver pen. It was the first thing that
- 25:01Pen had signed in years that she would
- 25:02have wanted. The last time I saw Rhett
- 25:05in person was the day he came to pick up
- 25:07his things before the closing. He walked
- 25:09through the empty kitchen and stopped at
- 25:11the window. "You're taking the lemon
- 25:13tree," he asked. "I paid for half of
- 25:16it." I looked at him. Two years of
- 25:18injections, two failed transfers, a
- 25:20motel in Council Bluffs, and that was
- 25:22what he wanted to negotiate. "You can
- 25:25have half the pot," I said. He almost
- 25:28smiled. Then he saw I wasn't joking.
- 25:31He picked up his box of old dealership
- 25:33trophies and left without saying
- 25:35goodbye. Rhett got a letter from the IRS
- 25:37the following spring about his health
- 25:39savings account. Taxes and a 20% penalty
- 25:42on every dollar he'd spent on Paisley.
- 25:45He called me about it once as if I could
- 25:47make it go away. I let it go to
- 25:49voicemail. My father never called. He'd
- 25:52spent 40 years not making scenes, and he
- 25:55wasn't going to start with me. Mom
- 25:57didn't get off as easily as she'd
- 25:59planned. That winter, when Rhett and
- 26:01Paisley asked their church for help with
- 26:03rent, Rhett showed the pastor a copy of
- 26:05the sticky note to explain where the
- 26:07health savings money had gone. He wanted
- 26:09it understood that he hadn't come up
- 26:11with the idea alone. By Christmas, half
- 26:14the congregation knew whose handwriting
- 26:16it was. My cousin Wesley told me Mom
- 26:18stepped down from running the church
- 26:20bake sale, a job she'd held for 22
- 26:22years. She told everyone it was her
- 26:25back. Rhett and Paisley rented a
- 26:27two-bedroom duplex in Council Bluffs. It
- 26:30was supposed to be fresh start. By
- 26:32February, Wesley said they were fighting
- 26:34about money every night. Rhett's
- 26:36commission had dropped. Paisley's salon
- 26:39chair rent was overdue. The baby was
- 26:41born in April, a healthy girl, 7 lb 9
- 26:45oz. I was glad she was healthy. I meant
- 26:48it. By August, Paisley had moved back
- 26:51into my parents' basement with the baby.
- 26:53Rhett paid child support through the
- 26:55state. Mom spent her days rocking her
- 26:57granddaughter in the same nursery chair
- 26:59she had once promised to give me.
- 27:02Paisley called me once late on a Tuesday
- 27:04night. Her voice was shaking. She said
- 27:07the baby wouldn't stop crying and asked
- 27:08whether I could tell her what medicine
- 27:10was safe for a fever. I told her to call
- 27:13the pediatrician's after-hours line. I
- 27:15gave her the number. She said, "You're a
- 27:18pharmacist. You could just tell me." "A
- 27:21baby with a fever needs a doctor
- 27:23tonight, not a guess from her aunt over
- 27:25the phone," I said. "Call the number."
- 27:28And Paisley, I'm not your safety net
- 27:30anymore. She hung up. A week later, she
- 27:33sent me a long text. She said she missed
- 27:36the sister who used to take care of
- 27:38everything. I thought about the
- 27:397-year-old lying on my bedroom floor
- 27:42with her pillow, holding my good hand
- 27:44for 11 nights. Then I wrote back, "I
- 27:47hope she feels better. Please don't ask
- 27:49me for things anymore." Mom sent one
- 27:51card. On the front was a photo of the
- 27:54baby in a yellow dress. Inside she had
- 27:56written, "Be happy for us, Noel. Life is
- 27:59too short." I put it through the
- 28:01shredder at work. That summer, I used
- 28:04part of my settlement to freeze my eggs
- 28:06at a different clinic downtown. I did
- 28:08the injections alone at 9:00 at night
- 28:11with Priya on speakerphone narrating a
- 28:12terrible reality show to distract me.
- 28:15The retrieval gave me 14 eggs. The nurse
- 28:18told me it was better than they'd
- 28:19expected. I don't know if I'll ever use
- 28:22them. I don't have to know yet. For the
- 28:24first time in years, a future belonged
- 28:26only to me. In September, Wesley pulled
- 28:29into the hospital parking lot in his
- 28:31pickup and lowered something wrapped in
- 28:34blankets from the bed. It was Grandma
- 28:36Opal's rocking chair. Taped to the arm
- 28:39was an envelope in Paisley's
- 28:40handwriting. Grandma promised this to
- 28:42you. Mom didn't keep her word. I'm
- 28:45trying to get one thing right. I'm
- 28:47sorry. Pete. Wesley said Paisley had
- 28:50carried it up from the basement herself
- 28:52while mom was at church. I ran my hand
- 28:54along the worn spot on the arm where
- 28:56Grandma used to rest her coffee. I
- 28:58didn't call Paisley. I didn't forgive
- 29:01her, but I took the chair home. I rented
- 29:04a small bungalow near Memorial Park. I
- 29:06brought the lemon tree with me. It had
- 29:09sat in the window of the old house for
- 29:10two years without doing anything but
- 29:12surviving. I almost left it on the curb.
- 29:15In the new place, I put it in a
- 29:17south-facing window and forgot about it.
- 29:20Then one morning in October, almost
- 29:22exactly a year after the credit union, I
- 29:25came into the kitchen and saw a small
- 29:26yellow lemon hanging from the lowest
- 29:28branch. One lemon, bright as a light
- 29:31bulb. I stood there in my socks and
- 29:33cried. Then I called Priya and made her
- 29:36drive over before work just to look at
- 29:38it. She stood in my kitchen in her
- 29:39school lanyard, holding her coffee,
- 29:42staring at that lemon like it was a
- 29:44science fair project that had actually
- 29:45worked. Two years, she said. Two years
- 29:49it just sat there. It was waiting for
- 29:51the right window, I said. She looked at
- 29:54me over her mug. Yeah, she said. Weren't
- 29:57we all? That weekend I made lemon bars,
- 30:00my grandmother's recipe, not my
- 30:02mother's. Extra zest, a thin crust. I
- 30:06ate the first one in Grandma's rocking
- 30:08chair by the window next to the lemon
- 30:10tree. Priya ate four. I thought about
- 30:13everything my family had told me. You've
- 30:15always been the strong one. Let's not
- 30:17make a scene. You're spiraling. It's not
- 30:20like I planned it. Be happy for them. I
- 30:23had been strong because nobody let me be
- 30:25anything else. I didn't make a scene. I
- 30:28made a folder. I wasn't spiraling. I was
- 30:31reading the labels. Nobody plans seven
- 30:34months. They choose them one motel night
- 30:36at a time, and my mother told me to be
- 30:39happy for them. I tried to be happy for
- 30:41everyone else for 36 years. That one
- 30:44little lemon was the first thing in a
- 30:46long time I'd grown for myself. So now I
- 30:48was never happy for them. But this year
- 30:51for the first time I'm happy for me.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of My Husband Got My Sister Pregnant While We Were Doing IVF — Mom Said I Should Be Happy For Them by When Love Betrays, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,482 words across 761 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.