My Husband Got My Sister Pregnant — My Mom Asked Me To Donate My Frozen Embryos To Her Instead — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00My husband got my younger sister
- 0:02pregnant and my mother asked me to
- 0:04donate my frozen embryos to her instead.
- 0:06She had known for 11 weeks. She sat at
- 0:09the head of her dining table in
- 0:10Meridian, Idaho with a fertility clinic
- 0:13consent packet in front of her plate,
- 0:15every signature line marked with a pink
- 0:17sticky flag in her handwriting while my
- 0:20sister sat two chairs down with one hand
- 0:22resting on her belly. "You're getting
- 0:24divorced, Lindsay. You're never going to
- 0:26use them." my mother said. This way it
- 0:29all stays in the family. My husband
- 0:32nodded and said they were half his.
- 0:33Anyway, what none of them remembered,
- 0:35not even Derek, was the form he had
- 0:37signed at that clinic 3 years earlier.
- 0:40The one that said exactly who those
- 0:41embryos would belong to if our marriage
- 0:43ever ended. My name is Lindsay Abbott. I
- 0:46was 38 that summer, and I worked as a
- 0:49hydraologist for the state water
- 0:50department in Boise. Every winter I
- 0:53snowshoed into the mountains and
- 0:55measured snow. How deep it was, how
- 0:57heavy, how much water was locked inside
- 0:59it. Every spring I turned those numbers
- 1:02into a forecast of how much water the
- 1:04state would have in July. Every inch of
- 1:07snow on those mountains ends up as water
- 1:09in somebody's kitchen. You never meet
- 1:11those people. I owned a small craftsman
- 1:13house in Boise's North End with my
- 1:15husband and I had a retirement account
- 1:17I'd been feeding since I was 23. In my
- 1:20family, I was the reliable one. My
- 1:23sister Kayla was the one everybody
- 1:25worried about. I grew up in a split
- 1:27level house in Meridian with my parents
- 1:29Sharon and Ron Picket. My father was a
- 1:32fire captain who worked 48-hour shifts.
- 1:34So for most of my childhood, my mother
- 1:36ran everything. She ran the house and
- 1:39for 19 years the fire auxiliary, which
- 1:42meant every pancake breakfast in the
- 1:43department went through her. She had one
- 1:46phrase she used more than any other.
- 1:48stays in the family. Mostly, she said it
- 1:51when something of mine was about to
- 1:52become Kais. When I was 17, I spent two
- 1:56summers bagging groceries to buy a used
- 1:58green Subaru for $2400.
- 2:00I drove it all through college. The
- 2:03summer I was 23, home from my master's
- 2:05program in Moscow, Idaho. Kayla turned
- 2:0816, and my mother handed her my keys at
- 2:11breakfast. They have buses in Moscow,
- 2:13she told me. Kayla needs it more. It
- 2:16stays in the family. When I said I'd
- 2:19paid for it, my father looked at his
- 2:20coffee and said, "Your mom's got a
- 2:23point, kiddo." Kayla wrecked it 11
- 2:25months later, sliding through a stop
- 2:27sign on Eagle Road. Nobody was hurt.
- 2:30Nobody replaced it. But Kayla wasn't
- 2:32only that. When I was 14, I had my
- 2:35appendix out and I spent 4 days in the
- 2:37hospital scared and sore. Kayla was
- 2:40seven. She made me a snow globe out of a
- 2:42baby food jar, glitter, and a plastic
- 2:45deer from her toy farm, and she glued
- 2:47the lid shut so it couldn't leak on my
- 2:49blanket. She sat on the end of my
- 2:51hospital bed and shook it for me every
- 2:53time I woke up. I've kept that jar for
- 2:5524 years. Sits on my desk at work. My
- 2:59father gave me the other thing I loved.
- 3:01On his days off, he took me snowshoeing
- 3:04at Bogus Basin and taught me how to dig
- 3:06a snow pit and read the layers like
- 3:07pages in a book. I became a hydraologist
- 3:10because of those Saturdays. I think
- 3:12that's why it hurt so much later how
- 3:14quiet he was. I met Derek Abbott at a
- 3:17trivia night at a tap room on Grove
- 3:19Street when I was 29. He was the
- 3:21manager. When my team won, he brought us
- 3:24a flight with my name chocked on the
- 3:25paddle spelled wrong, then came back
- 3:27with a second one spelled right. He
- 3:30could make a room of strangers feel like
- 3:31regulars. We married when I was 31 at a
- 3:34lodge in Macall on the lake. Kayla was
- 3:37my maid of honor. Her toast about the
- 3:39snow globe made half the room reach for
- 3:41napkins. We started trying for a baby
- 3:44when I was 33. Two years later, a
- 3:47reproductive endocrinologist at a clinic
- 3:49on Curtis Road told us my egg reserve
- 3:51was low for my age and that if we wanted
- 3:54biological children, IVF was our best
- 3:56chance. We did two retrievalss that
- 3:59year. I gave myself shots in the stomach
- 4:01every night at 8 and Dererick held the
- 4:03ice pack. At the end, we had five
- 4:06embryos frozen in a tank at the clinic.
- 4:08The embryologist gave us a printed photo
- 4:10of them. Five tiny gray circles under a
- 4:13microscope, and I stuck it to our
- 4:15refrigerator with a magnet shaped like
- 4:17Idaho. Before anything was frozen, the
- 4:20clinic made us fill out a disposition
- 4:22agreement. It was 11 pages long. Page
- 4:25seven asked, "What should happen to any
- 4:27remaining embryos if we divorced?" There
- 4:29were four boxes. Discard them. Donate
- 4:32them to research. Give control to the
- 4:35male partner. Give control to the female
- 4:37partner who could use, donate, or
- 4:40discard them at her sole discretion. I
- 4:42hesitated with the pin. Dererick reached
- 4:45over and checked the last box himself.
- 4:47Your eggs, your body, your call, he
- 4:50said. I trust you, Lind. Then we both
- 4:53signed and initialed it. And I put my
- 4:55copy in the fireproof box in our closet
- 4:57with our passports and the deed to the
- 4:59house. And I never thought about it
- 5:01again. Our first transfer when I was 36
- 5:04failed. Our second the next year worked.
- 5:07I was pregnant for nine weeks. On
- 5:10October 9th, I lost the baby in an
- 5:12urgent care bathroom while Derek drove
- 5:14from the tap room. In December, I needed
- 5:16surgery to remove scar tissue from my
- 5:19uterus, and my doctor told me to wait at
- 5:21least 6 months before trying again. We
- 5:24scheduled our third transfer for August.
- 5:26Three embryos were still in the tank.
- 5:28The tap room threw a Halloween party 3
- 5:30weeks after the miscarriage, and
- 5:32Dererick hired Kayla's business for it.
- 5:35She ran a mobile cocktail cart out of a
- 5:37converted horse trailer, and she was
- 5:39always one slow month away from losing
- 5:41it. My mother had asked me to arrange
- 5:43it. She's your sister, Lindsay. Help her
- 5:47out. I stayed home that night under a
- 5:49blanket, and Dererick texted me photos
- 5:51of the costume contest until almost
- 5:54midnight. Then the photos stopped. That
- 5:56winter, Derek started closing the tap
- 5:58room himself three, then four nights a
- 6:01week. In December, he missed my
- 6:03postsurgery appointment because of what
- 6:05he called an inventory crisis. He
- 6:08started keeping his phone face down on
- 6:10the arm of the couch. He came home
- 6:12smelling like orange peel and bitters,
- 6:14and when I mentioned it, he laughed and
- 6:15said he smelled like work. In March, I
- 6:18brought up the August transfer and he
- 6:19said, "Maybe we don't rush. Maybe next
- 6:22year." When I asked why, he said,
- 6:25"You've been through enough, Linds.
- 6:27You're still grieving. You're not seeing
- 6:29things clearly." I believed I was the
- 6:31problem. That's what grief does. It
- 6:34makes you doubt your own measurements.
- 6:36In April, Kayla stopped drinking. At my
- 6:39birthday dinner, she ordered sparkling
- 6:41water and told everyone she was doing a
- 6:43sober spring because it was trending. At
- 6:45Memorial Day, she wore a loose linen
- 6:48shirt in 90° heat. My mother, who asked
- 6:51Kayla questions about everything, didn't
- 6:53ask a single one. In early May, my
- 6:55mother called me at work. She said she'd
- 6:58been thinking about how hard the year
- 6:59had been, and she wanted to pay the
- 7:02annual storage bill for my embryos
- 7:04herself. $795.
- 7:07"Let me do something for you, honey,"
- 7:09she said. I cried at my desk. I thought
- 7:12it was the kindest thing she'd done for
- 7:13me in years. On Thursday, July 10th, I
- 7:17was standing in the Boise River and
- 7:18waiters taking flow measurements below
- 7:20Barber Park when my phone buzzed in my
- 7:23chest pocket. Years earlier, I turned
- 7:26off delivery notifications on our shared
- 7:28Amazon account because Dererick ordered
- 7:30brewing supplies constantly. That week,
- 7:33I turned them back on to track a
- 7:35refrigerated package of medication for
- 7:37my August transfer. It wasn't my
- 7:39medication. It was a delivery photo. A
- 7:42huge flat box leaned against a blue
- 7:44apartment door. Hanging on that door was
- 7:47a wreath of dried lavender. I had made
- 7:49that wreath with my own hands and given
- 7:51it to Kayla when she moved into her
- 7:53apartment in Garden City. I sat down on
- 7:55the riverbank in my waiters and opened
- 7:57the order. A convertible crib in natural
- 8:00pine, $389
- 8:03charged to our joint credit card. There
- 8:05was a gift message for our peanut. Can't
- 8:08wait to meet you, D. Then I opened the
- 8:11order history and found the archived
- 8:13orders. Derek had hidden 14 of them
- 8:16since the end of March. Pregnancy tests
- 8:18on March 29th. Prenatal vitamins,
- 8:22maternity leggings, a pregnancy pillow,
- 8:25a baby monitor, a book called the
- 8:27expectant father. Most had gone to an
- 8:30Amazon locker near the tap room. The
- 8:32crib had been too big for a locker.
- 8:35$3,486.19.
- 8:38All of it charged to the card we used
- 8:40for our IVF bills. I read that statement
- 8:43every month. Every charge just said
- 8:45Amazon MKTP. And Derek ordered brewing
- 8:48supplies every week. I never looked
- 8:50twice. I trusted the one number in my
- 8:53life I never measured. I screenshotted
- 8:55every order. I finished my flow
- 8:57measurements because somebody downstream
- 8:59needed them. Then I drove home and sat
- 9:02at my kitchen table under the photo of
- 9:03our embryos and waited. Derek got home
- 9:06at 10:40. I had my laptop open to the
- 9:09delivery photo. I turned it toward him.
- 9:12Who's the peanut, Derek? He looked at
- 9:14the screen for a long time. It's for a
- 9:17bartender's baby shower, he tried. Your
- 9:20buddy lives at Kayla's address, I said.
- 9:23And he signs his notes. D. He sat down
- 9:25across from me and rubbed his jaw. She's
- 9:28due December 5th, he said. When did it
- 9:31start? The Halloween party. The math did
- 9:34itself. 3 weeks after I lost our baby in
- 9:37an urgent care bathroom. You told me I
- 9:40wasn't seeing things clearly, I said. I
- 9:43didn't want to hurt you while you were
- 9:44healing. So, you waited until I healed
- 9:47so you could hurt me then. Does mom
- 9:49know? I asked. He hesitated just long
- 9:52enough. Kayla told her in April. After
- 9:55her first ultrasound. When in April, the
- 9:58last Sunday. I asked him to leave. He
- 10:01packed a gym bag and walked out at
- 10:0311:15. I heard his truck turn left at
- 10:06the end of the street toward Garden
- 10:08City. He went to her. Of course, he went
- 10:11to her. I sat on the kitchen floor with
- 10:13my back against the dishwasher and
- 10:15called my best friend Tasha Morrow, a
- 10:18ski patroller at Bogus Basin. She came
- 10:20over with a bag of huckleberry licorice
- 10:22and sat on the floor next to me in the
- 10:24dark. Around 2:00 in the morning, she
- 10:26said, "Tell me the numbers." She knew I
- 10:29survived on numbers. End of April, I
- 10:32said. My mom has known since the end of
- 10:34April and she paid your storage bill in
- 10:37May. Tasha said, "We both sat with that
- 10:40for a minute. My mother called me at 7
- 10:42the next morning. Kayla had already told
- 10:45her everything. I wanted to tell you,
- 10:47Lindsay." I did, but Kayla had some
- 10:50spotting in May, and the doctor said,
- 10:52"No stress, and you were still so
- 10:54fragile. You paid my storage bill," I
- 10:57said. "Because I love you," she said.
- 11:00and her voice cracked like she was the
- 11:01one who had been hurt. Then she said,
- 11:04"Come to dinner Sunday. Your dad's home.
- 11:07We need to talk about what happens next
- 11:09as a family." I almost said no. Then I
- 11:12thought about the 14 hidden orders and
- 11:14how long they'd all been planning
- 11:15without me. And I wanted to see the
- 11:17plan. On Sunday, July 13th, I drove to
- 11:20Meridian. 11 weeks to the day after
- 11:23Kayla had told my mother. My mother had
- 11:26made finger stakes. Kayla sat next to
- 11:28Derek. She wore a fitted blue dress. And
- 11:31for the first time in months, she wasn't
- 11:33hiding anything. My father sat at the
- 11:36far end of the table, still in his
- 11:38department polo, 5 weeks from retirement
- 11:41after 31 years. Halfway through dinner,
- 11:43my mother at the head of the table,
- 11:45wiped her hands, reached under her
- 11:47chair, and set a thick packet beside her
- 11:50plate. Known embryo donation, recipient
- 11:52information, and consent. She had
- 11:55printed it from their website. Every
- 11:57signature line had a pink sticky flag.
- 11:59And on each flag in her round
- 12:01handwriting, it said Lindsay. I've
- 12:03thought about this a lot. She said,
- 12:06"Those embryos are Dererick's children,
- 12:08too. They're going to be this baby's
- 12:10brothers and sisters. You're getting
- 12:12divorced, Lindsay. You're 38. You're
- 12:15never going to use them. So instead of
- 12:17leaving them in a freezer for a marriage
- 12:19that's over, you can give them to Kayla.
- 12:21They grow up together with their
- 12:24father." She put her hand flat on the
- 12:26packet. This way it all stays in the
- 12:28family. I looked at Kayla. She was
- 12:31looking at her plate, but her hand was
- 12:33on her stomach. "Kayla wants this?" I
- 12:36asked. "Kayla's always wanted a big
- 12:39family," my mother said, answering for
- 12:41her the way she always had. Dererick
- 12:44leaned forward. "They're half mine,
- 12:46Lind," he said quietly. "I'm not trying
- 12:49to be cruel. I just think it's the right
- 12:51thing. Derek's already set up a consult,
- 12:54my mother added. Tuesday, August 19th.
- 12:58All you have to do is come and sign. I
- 13:00turned to my father. Did you know about
- 13:03Derek and Kayla? He set down his fork.
- 13:06Your mother told me in June, he said.
- 13:10She said she was handling it. Is this
- 13:12you handling it, Dad? He looked at the
- 13:14packet, not at me. Your mom's thought it
- 13:17through, kiddo. He said it was the same
- 13:19voice he'd used about the Subaru 15
- 13:22years earlier. I looked at my name on 12
- 13:24Pink Flags. You said you paid my storage
- 13:27bill to do something for me, I said to
- 13:29my mother. I did, she said. And because
- 13:32I did, I think I've earned a say in what
- 13:34happens to them. I've been keeping them
- 13:37alive. Kayla finally looked up. Lindsay,
- 13:40I never wanted to take anything from
- 13:42you. Somebody carried a crib up three
- 13:44flights of stairs to your door, Kayla. I
- 13:47said somebody wanted something. I didn't
- 13:50say yes. I didn't say no. I said, "Don't
- 13:53book anything else in my name." And I
- 13:56walked out to my car. Through the screen
- 13:58door, I heard my mother say, "Let her
- 14:00sulk. She'll be fine by your father's
- 14:03party. She always is." The party was the
- 14:06Saturday before the consult station 4.
- 14:10My mother had been planning it for a
- 14:11year. On Tuesday, I sat across a desk
- 14:14from Miriam Moduya, a family law
- 14:16attorney with an office above a bakery
- 14:18on Banick Street, three blocks from the
- 14:20capital. She had a policy of not talking
- 14:23until she'd read everything. I gave her
- 14:25the screenshots and the packet with the
- 14:27pink flags. Then I handed her the
- 14:3011-page disposition agreement from our
- 14:32fireproof box. She read it twice. Idaho
- 14:35doesn't have a statute on frozen
- 14:37embryos, she said. But most courts in
- 14:40this country that have faced this
- 14:41question enforced the agreement the
- 14:43couple signed before anything was
- 14:45frozen. Yours is clear. Initialed on
- 14:48every page. He checked the box himself.
- 14:51He did. Then legally, nobody gets those
- 14:54embryos unless you decide they do. Not
- 14:56your sister, not your mother, not your
- 14:59husband. Clear doesn't mean cheap,
- 15:01though. If he fights it, it will take
- 15:04months and you'll pay me for every one
- 15:05of them. Idaho is a community property
- 15:08state. Most of what you built gets split
- 15:10down the middle, affair or not. The
- 15:13Amazon charges are different. That's
- 15:15community money spent on someone outside
- 15:17the marriage. We can ask the court to
- 15:19charge it against his share. What do I
- 15:22do now? Nothing loud. Don't sign
- 15:25anything. Don't tell them about this
- 15:27form. Don't file yet. Once we file, his
- 15:30lawyer will want every document you
- 15:32have, and I want to see everything
- 15:33first. Request your full medical record
- 15:36from the clinic. Every page, including
- 15:38phone notes. You have a legal right to
- 15:41it. Why the phone notes? Because your
- 15:44mother showed up 3 days after you found
- 15:46out with every page already flagged.
- 15:48Nobody gets that organized in 3 days. I
- 15:51think somebody's been talking to that
- 15:52clinic for a while. I requested my
- 15:55records that afternoon. Then I called
- 15:57the clinic and canceled my August
- 15:59transfer. Then I sat in my car outside
- 16:01Miriam's office for 40 minutes with the
- 16:04engine running. The next four weeks were
- 16:06quiet on the outside. Kayla sent
- 16:08nothing. My mother texted me every few
- 16:11days. Have you looked at the packet?
- 16:13Then Derek says the clinic wants both of
- 16:15you there by 9:00. Then dad's party is
- 16:18Saturday at 5. Kayla's doing the drinks.
- 16:21Please don't make it about you. I
- 16:23answered none of them. Then 10 days
- 16:26before the party, my cousin Jenna
- 16:27called. She was in the auxiliary with my
- 16:30mother. People are talking, she said.
- 16:33Everybody knows Derek moved out and
- 16:35somebody saw Kayla at the OB's office
- 16:37with him. Your mom's getting ahead of
- 16:39it. She's telling everyone you're fine
- 16:41with it, that you're giving Kayla your
- 16:44embryos, that it's a beautiful story. I
- 16:47didn't say anything, Lind. Jenna said
- 16:50she's going to say it at your dad's
- 16:52party. If you're standing there giving
- 16:54your blessing, nobody can call it a
- 16:56scandal. I separated my paycheck into a
- 16:59new account in my own name. I kept going
- 17:01to work. In August, there's no snow to
- 17:04measure, so I measured rivers. Water
- 17:06still moved downhill whether my family
- 17:08was falling apart or not. My records
- 17:10arrived on Friday, August 8th, as a PDF
- 17:13of 206 pages. I read it in my car at
- 17:17work. On page 181, I found a telephone
- 17:21encounter note dated Friday, May 2nd, 5
- 17:24days after Kayla told my mother. Caller
- 17:27identified herself as patients mother.
- 17:30Sharon Picket asked about the process
- 17:32for releasing patients remaining embryos
- 17:34to patients sister. Informed caller that
- 17:37we cannot discuss patient information
- 17:39and that any donation must be initiated
- 17:42by both patients. Caller then asked
- 17:44whether embryos could be released if
- 17:46patient was not in a state to decide and
- 17:48whether a physician's letter regarding
- 17:50patients mental health after her
- 17:52pregnancy loss would be sufficient.
- 17:54Informed caller this is not possible.
- 17:57Caller stated that patient will agree it
- 17:59is a family decision. My hands went cold
- 18:02in a 90° car. I scrolled back up to the
- 18:05date May 2nd. 3 days later my mother had
- 18:09called me at my desk and offered to pay
- 18:11my storage bill. I called Miriam. She
- 18:14read the note while I waited. Bring it
- 18:16Saturday, she said. Bring all of it. You
- 18:19don't have to use it. But if they put
- 18:21you on a stage, you should know what
- 18:23you're holding. Tasha offered to come in
- 18:25with me. I told her I'd rather have
- 18:28somebody waiting in the parking lot with
- 18:29the engine running. On Saturday, August
- 18:3216th, I drove to station 4 in Meridian
- 18:35with a gift for my father in a bag on
- 18:37the passenger seat. It was a framed
- 18:39print of a snow pit profile I dug at
- 18:41Bogus Base in the winter before. Every
- 18:44layer labeled in my handwriting. In my
- 18:46work tote, I had a blue folder. After
- 18:48Jenna's call, I knew I would need it.
- 18:50The crew had pulled both engines onto
- 18:52the apron and filled the bay with
- 18:54folding tables and about 80 people. A
- 18:56sheetcake shaped like a helmet sat on a
- 18:58table under a banner my mother had
- 19:00ordered. 31 years, Captain Ron. Kayla's
- 19:04horse trailer bar was parked by the open
- 19:06bay door, strung with lights, serving
- 19:08huckleberry lemonade. She was 24 weeks
- 19:11along in a white sundress. Dererick was
- 19:14behind the bar with her cutting limes.
- 19:16My father hugged me when I came in.
- 19:19Thanks for coming, kiddo. He said, I
- 19:21gave him the print. For one second, he
- 19:24looked like the man who had taught me to
- 19:26read snow. Then my mother tapped the
- 19:28microphone. She thanked the Chiefs and
- 19:30told the story of the night my father
- 19:32carried a golden retriever out of a
- 19:34burning duplex. Then she raised her
- 19:36glass of lemonade. And Ron and I have so
- 19:39much to celebrate this year. She said,
- 19:41"We're going to be grandparents in
- 19:43December. Applause." People turned
- 19:46toward Kayla. Kayla smiled and waved
- 19:48from the bar. Dererick put his arm
- 19:51around her. A few people looked from
- 19:53Derek to me trying to make the math
- 19:55work. My mother kept going. And our
- 19:57Lindsay, who has been through so much
- 19:59this year, has decided to give her
- 20:01little sister the most beautiful gift
- 20:03one sister can give another. Those three
- 20:05little embryos Lindsay and Derek made
- 20:07are going to have a home with Kayla and
- 20:09Derek. Those babies are going to grow up
- 20:11together because in this family,
- 20:14everything stays in the family. She
- 20:16looked straight at me and smiled. We're
- 20:18signing on Tuesday. Nobody clapped. 80
- 20:21people stood holding paper plates. Then
- 20:24everyone looked at me. I put my tote on
- 20:26the cake table next to the helmet and
- 20:28took out the blue folder. I didn't need
- 20:30the microphone. I never agreed to that,
- 20:33Mom. I said, I didn't say yes at your
- 20:36dinner and I'm not signing on Tuesday.
- 20:39My mother's smile stayed on her face a
- 20:41second too long. Lindsay, sweetheart,
- 20:44this isn't the place. You picked the
- 20:46place, I said. I took out the first page
- 20:48and set it on the table where everyone
- 20:50near the cake could see it. This is the
- 20:53agreement Derrick and I signed before
- 20:54our embryos were frozen. If we divorce,
- 20:57they're under my soul control. Mine to
- 20:59use, donate, or discard. Dererick
- 21:02checked that box himself. Derek came out
- 21:04from behind the bar. Lindsay, that's
- 21:07just a clinic form. It doesn't mean
- 21:09anything in a divorce. My attorney says
- 21:12it does, I said. And you initialed every
- 21:15page. My mother's voice went high and
- 21:17bright the way it did when she was
- 21:19losing a room. I was only trying to make
- 21:22the best of a terrible situation. I
- 21:25never went behind your back. I set down
- 21:27the second page. This is from my medical
- 21:30record at the clinic. A phone call on
- 21:32May 2nd from you. 5 days after Kayla
- 21:36told you she was pregnant 10 weeks
- 21:38before I knew anything. I didn't read
- 21:40the whole thing. I read one line. Caller
- 21:43asked whether embryos could be released
- 21:45if patient was not in a state to decide
- 21:48and whether a physician's letter
- 21:49regarding patients mental health after
- 21:51her pregnancy loss would be sufficient.
- 21:54Oh my god, said Carol Benning, the
- 21:56auxiliary treasurer who had worked
- 21:58beside my mother at Pancake Breakfast
- 22:00for 19 years. 3 days after that call, I
- 22:03said, you phoned me at work and offered
- 22:06to pay my storage bill so you could have
- 22:07a say. Derek turned to my mother. He
- 22:10looked confused. Sharon, you told me the
- 22:13clinic said it was just paperwork. He
- 22:15said, "You said you had a doctor at
- 22:17church who'd write the letter if she
- 22:19said no." Kayla stood frozen behind the
- 22:21bar with the lemon in her hand. "What
- 22:24letter?" she said. "Mom, what letter?"
- 22:27My mother didn't answer her. For the
- 22:29first time in my life, my mother didn't
- 22:31have the next sentence ready. I looked
- 22:34at my father. He was holding the snow
- 22:36pit print against his chest with both
- 22:38hands. Sharon," he said very quietly.
- 22:42"You told me she'd agreed." My mother
- 22:45said, "Ron, she would have eventually."
- 22:48My father looked at her for a long
- 22:49moment. Then he walked out of the bay
- 22:52and stood beside Engine 4 in the sun
- 22:54with his back to all of us, still
- 22:56holding the print. I put the pages back
- 22:58in the folder. "You always said it stays
- 23:00in the family, Mom." I said, "Not this.
- 23:04These were never yours to keep in the
- 23:06family." Then I looked at Kayla.
- 23:08Congratulations on your baby. I mean
- 23:10that. But you're not getting mine. I
- 23:13picked up my tote and walked out through
- 23:15the open bay door, past the trailer bar,
- 23:18past the lemonade, past 80 people who
- 23:20parted for me like water around a rock.
- 23:23In the parking lot, Tasha had the engine
- 23:25running. She took one look at me, pulled
- 23:27out before I'd even buckled and said,
- 23:29"Only numbers? Two pages." I said,
- 23:33"That's all it took." She drove me home
- 23:35the long way along the river and neither
- 23:38of us turned on the radio. On Monday,
- 23:40Miriam filed for divorce. On Tuesday,
- 23:43August 19th, nobody went to the clinic.
- 23:46Miriam sent the clinic a letter with a
- 23:48copy of the disposition agreement and a
- 23:50request that no embryo be moved,
- 23:52released, or thawed without a court
- 23:54order. The clinic director called back
- 23:56that afternoon. They had flagged my
- 23:58mother's name. Nobody would be
- 24:00discussing my embryos with Sharon Picket
- 24:02ever again. Dererick fought. His lawyer
- 24:05argued that the agreement was signed
- 24:07under emotional pressure during
- 24:08fertility treatment, that circumstances
- 24:11had changed, and that Dererick now had a
- 24:13stable family ready to raise the
- 24:15embryos. Miriam handed the judge the 11
- 24:18pages with Dererick's initials on
- 24:19everyone, his check mark in the box, and
- 24:22his gift message on the crib order. The
- 24:25hearing took less than an hour. In
- 24:27March, the judge enforced the agreement.
- 24:29The three embryos were mine to decide
- 24:32and nobody else's. Because Dererick had
- 24:34fought a contract he'd signed and
- 24:36initialed himself, the judge ordered him
- 24:38to pay $6,000 of my attorney's fees. His
- 24:42own checkmark cost him more than
- 24:44anything I could have said. The rest of
- 24:46it wasn't a clean win. Idaho split
- 24:48almost everything down the middle. I
- 24:51kept the north end house, but I had to
- 24:52refinance to buy out Derrick's half, and
- 24:55I paid him $58,000 I'd spent 8 years
- 24:58building. The judge counted the $3,486
- 25:02from the Amazon orders against his
- 25:04share. My legal bill came to $13,900.
- 25:08And even after Derek's $6,000, the rest
- 25:11was mine. I pay it again. I mailed my
- 25:14mother a check for $795
- 25:16the week after the party. In the memo
- 25:18line, I wrote storage. Paid in full. She
- 25:22cashed it. My mother resigned as
- 25:24president of the fire auxiliary in
- 25:26September after 19 years. She said it
- 25:29was because of dad's retirement. After
- 25:32Carol Benning told the auxiliary what
- 25:33she'd heard in that bay, nobody believed
- 25:36her. Kayla's cocktail cart had lived on
- 25:38department events, retirement parties,
- 25:41and auxiliary fundraisers. By October,
- 25:43the bookings had stopped coming. She
- 25:46sold the horse trailer in November.
- 25:48Kayla had a boy on December 2nd, £7 1
- 25:51oz. Jenna, who still went to family
- 25:54dinners, told me his name was Hudson and
- 25:56that he was healthy. None of this was
- 25:58his fault, and I hoped he'd never hear
- 26:01about it. My father called me once on
- 26:03New Year's Day. He didn't apologize
- 26:06exactly. He said, "I hung your snow pit
- 26:09in the garage over my workbench." Then
- 26:12he said, "I should have asked you back
- 26:14at dinner. I should have asked you what
- 26:16you wanted." Yes, I said. You should
- 26:19have. He said he knew. Then he said, "My
- 26:22mother wanted me to come for Sunday
- 26:24dinner." I said, "No, he didn't argue.
- 26:28He's still married to her. He still goes
- 26:30home to her every night. That's his
- 26:32choice to live with." In February, Kayla
- 26:35came to my office. She was waiting in
- 26:37the lobby with the baby asleep in a car
- 26:39seat at her feet. She looked exhausted.
- 26:42I sat down across from her. "Mom wants
- 26:45to update her will," she said. "And
- 26:48mine. If something happens to me, she
- 26:50wants you to be Hudson's guardian. She
- 26:53says, "You're the only one who could
- 26:54handle it." I looked at my nephew asleep
- 26:57in his car seat. Then I looked at my
- 26:59sister. "No," I said. Kayla blinked.
- 27:03"You didn't even think about it. I've
- 27:05been thinking about it my whole life," I
- 27:07said. "Every time something broke in
- 27:10this family, it got handed to me. My
- 27:12car, my husband, my embryos, now your
- 27:16son. I'm not the family's backup plan
- 27:18anymore, Kayla. She cried a little. I
- 27:21walked her to the elevator and went back
- 27:23to work. She and Derek lasted until
- 27:26April. He moved into a studio apartment
- 27:28above the tap room, and Kayla and the
- 27:30baby moved into my old bedroom in
- 27:32Meridian. Jenna said my mother had
- 27:34painted it yellow. After the judge's
- 27:37order, I sat with the clinic's counselor
- 27:39for three sessions. I didn't want to use
- 27:42embryos that would make Derek the father
- 27:44of my children. I didn't want them
- 27:46thawed and gone either. And I would
- 27:48never let them be raised by the two
- 27:49people who had lied to me while I
- 27:51grieved them. Not after five tiny gray
- 27:53circles had lived on my refrigerator for
- 27:563 years. The clinic had an anonymous
- 27:58embryo donation program for couples
- 28:00who'd been trying for years and had run
- 28:02out of options. In May, I signed the
- 28:05papers alone with my own pen at my own
- 28:07kitchen table. I would never know who
- 28:10received them. That was the whole point.
- 28:12My mother found out in June. Dererick's
- 28:15lawyer had to be notified. She texted me
- 28:17for the first time in 10 months. You
- 28:20gave my grandchildren to strangers. I
- 28:22typed one reply. You tried to give them
- 28:25to Kayla. I gave them to people who
- 28:27asked. Then I blocked her number. In
- 28:30July, two summers after I sat on the
- 28:32bank of the Boise River in my waiters
- 28:34and saw a crib leaning against my
- 28:36sister's door, the clinic forwarded me
- 28:38an envelope with no return address.
- 28:40Inside was a card with a pressed wild
- 28:42flower on the front. Inside in neat blue
- 28:45handwriting, it said, "We waited 7
- 28:47years. We don't know anything about you
- 28:49except that you said yes. Our daughter
- 28:51was born in April. She sleeps with her
- 28:54arms over her head like she's cheering.
- 28:56We hope your life is full of good
- 28:58things. Thank you from the bottom of our
- 29:00hearts." I read it at my kitchen table
- 29:03until I could read it without crying.
- 29:05Then I took the photo of the five gray
- 29:07circles off the refrigerator, put it in
- 29:09the drawer with the card, and hung
- 29:11something new under the Idaho magnet. It
- 29:13was a print out of that spring snow
- 29:15survey from the Boise River Basin, the
- 29:18deepest snow pack we'd measured in 6
- 29:20years. The next morning, I drove up to
- 29:22Barber Park with my flow meter, and
- 29:24stood in the river in my waiters. The
- 29:26water was cold and fast, the last of the
- 29:29snow melt. Somewhere downstream, it was
- 29:31going to fill a reservoir, water a
- 29:33field, come out of a kitchen faucet in a
- 29:36house I'll never see for a family I'll
- 29:38never meet. On my desk at work, Kayla's
- 29:40snow globe was still there. I'm not a
- 29:43person who throws away a 7-year-old's
- 29:45kindness, but I'd stopped shaking it. My
- 29:48mother spent my whole life telling me
- 29:50that everything stays in the family. My
- 29:52car, my husband, my children, if she
- 29:55could have managed it. But snow doesn't
- 29:58stay where it falls. It melts and runs
- 30:00downhill to people it will never meet.
- 30:02And that's the whole point of it. I
- 30:04measured snow for a living for 15 years
- 30:07before I understood that. Some things
- 30:09you don't keep and you don't hand them
- 30:11to the people who took everything else.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of My Husband Got My Sister Pregnant — My Mom Asked Me To Donate My Frozen Embryos To Her Instead by When Love Betrays, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,392 words across 756 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.