YouTube2Text

My Husband Called Me Useless After 22 Years. Then the Company Owner Said, My Mother Knows You. — Transcript

by Whispered Truths · 7,519 words · 1,444 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00After 22 years of marriage,
  2. 0:03my husband brought his mistress into our
  3. 0:05living room and told our children,
  4. 0:07"She has a career. Your mother just
  5. 0:09lived off me."
  6. 0:12I remember looking at the woman standing
  7. 0:13beside him.
  8. 0:15She was wearing a cream-colored coat and
  9. 0:16carrying a leather handbag that probably
  10. 0:18cost more than our washing machine.
  11. 0:21Her name was Natalie Brooks. I'd met her
  12. 0:23twice before.
  13. 0:25Once at Mark's company Christmas party,
  14. 0:27where she'd complimented my earrings,
  15. 0:29and once at a charity dinner, where
  16. 0:31she'd told me how lucky I was to have a
  17. 0:32husband who worked so hard.
  18. 0:35Apparently, she'd been doing her part to
  19. 0:37keep him busy.
  20. 0:38My daughter, Emily, was the first to
  21. 0:41speak.
  22. 0:42"Dad, why is she here?"
  23. 0:44Mark folded his arms. "Because I'm tired
  24. 0:47of hiding things. Natalie and I are
  25. 0:49together. Your mother and I are getting
  26. 0:51divorced." Ben, my 18-year-old son,
  27. 0:54stared at him.
  28. 0:56"You're bringing your girlfriend into
  29. 0:57our house to tell us that" "I thought
  30. 0:59you deserved the truth."
  31. 1:01I almost laughed. After nearly a year of
  32. 1:04lying,
  33. 1:05Mark had suddenly developed a passion
  34. 1:08for honesty.
  35. 1:09Emily looked at Natalie.
  36. 1:11"Could you please leave?"
  37. 1:14Natalie glanced at Mark, waiting for
  38. 1:16instructions.
  39. 1:17That bothered me more than it should
  40. 1:19have. Even in my living room, she
  41. 1:21expected him to make the decisions.
  42. 1:24"Maybe that's best," Mark said. She
  43. 1:26touched his arm before leaving.
  44. 1:29A small gesture, familiar, comfortable.
  45. 1:32I wondered how long she'd been touching
  46. 1:34his arm while he told me he was working
  47. 1:35late.
  48. 1:37When the front door closed,
  49. 1:39Ben turned to his father.
  50. 1:41"How could you do this to Mom?"
  51. 1:43Mark sighed. "Ben,
  52. 1:45marriage is complicated."
  53. 1:47"No, what you just did was pretty
  54. 1:49simple." "Watch your tone."
  55. 1:51I finally spoke.
  56. 1:53"Mark, how long?"
  57. 1:56He looked irritated.
  58. 1:57"Does that really matter?"
  59. 1:59"To me, it does."
  60. 2:01He studied the carpet.
  61. 2:03"About 11 months."
  62. 2:05"11 months."
  63. 2:06Last February, we'd celebrated our
  64. 2:09anniversary at a little restaurant in
  65. 2:11Worthington.
  66. 2:12He'd given me a necklace. I'd worn it
  67. 2:14that evening. I reached up and unclasped
  68. 2:16it. Then I put it on the coffee table.
  69. 2:19Mark watched me.
  70. 2:21"You're being dramatic."
  71. 2:23"No," I said. "I'm taking off a
  72. 2:25necklace."
  73. 2:27That was the last thing I said to him
  74. 2:28that night.
  75. 2:30Mark packed a suitcase while the
  76. 2:31children stayed in the kitchen with me.
  77. 2:34Emily cried quietly.
  78. 2:36Ben kept opening and closing a cabinet
  79. 2:38because he couldn't seem to find
  80. 2:39anything else to do with his hands.
  81. 2:41Before Mark left,
  82. 2:43he announced that he'd already rented an
  83. 2:45apartment in Dublin. He said we'd
  84. 2:47discuss the house and finances with our
  85. 2:49lawyers.
  86. 2:50Then he walked out. 22 years, and he
  87. 2:53managed to leave with one suitcase and
  88. 2:55the good winter coat I'd bought him.
  89. 2:58I wish I could tell you I immediately
  90. 2:59felt liberated. I didn't. I felt 52
  91. 3:03years old. I felt unemployed. And I felt
  92. 3:06terrified. I'd worked as an
  93. 3:08administrative assistant at a small
  94. 3:10medical clinic before Emily was born.
  95. 3:13Mark and I had agreed that I'd stay home
  96. 3:15while the children were young. We
  97. 3:16weren't wealthy,
  98. 3:18but his income covered our expenses.
  99. 3:20By the time Ben arrived, returning to
  100. 3:22work seemed less practical. Then Mark's
  101. 3:25father became ill. For 3 years,
  102. 3:29I handled his appointments, medications,
  103. 3:31groceries, and insurance paperwork.
  104. 3:33Mark visited him on Sundays.
  105. 3:36After his father died,
  106. 3:38Mark thanked me.
  107. 3:39He actually said, "I couldn't have done
  108. 3:41it without you."
  109. 3:43I used to believe he meant that. Over
  110. 3:45the years, I also managed our household
  111. 3:47finances, school activities, home
  112. 3:50repairs, and the thousand small things
  113. 3:52that keep a family functioning.
  114. 3:54Mark earned the paycheck. I made sure
  115. 3:56the paycheck didn't disappear into late
  116. 3:58fees,
  117. 3:59forgotten appointments, and broken
  118. 4:01appliances.
  119. 4:02Apparently,
  120. 4:04that arrangement had become embarrassing
  121. 4:06once Natalie appeared. Three weeks after
  122. 4:09he left, I met with a divorce attorney
  123. 4:11named Diane Ellis. She explained that
  124. 4:14our assets, retirement accounts, and the
  125. 4:17length of our marriage would all matter.
  126. 4:19She also explained that 22 years of
  127. 4:21marriage didn't guarantee I could keep
  128. 4:23our house. I needed income, so I started
  129. 4:26looking for work. My first resume was
  130. 4:28terrible. Under employment history, I
  131. 4:31had one job ending in 2005.
  132. 4:34Under relevant experience,
  133. 4:36I had 21 years of doing things nobody
  134. 4:39had paid me to do.
  135. 4:40I stared at the screen for nearly an
  136. 4:42hour.
  137. 4:43Then my friend Susan Bell came over.
  138. 4:46Susan had worked at the Westerville
  139. 4:48Library for years and had never been
  140. 4:50especially diplomatic. She looked at my
  141. 4:53resume.
  142. 4:54Margaret Collins,
  143. 4:56you managed an entire household, raised
  144. 4:59two children,
  145. 5:00cared for your father-in-law, and kept
  146. 5:03Mark from accidentally poisoning himself
  147. 5:05with expired lunch meat.
  148. 5:07That's not exactly a professional
  149. 5:08qualification. It should be. Have you
  150. 5:11seen the man operate a dishwasher? I
  151. 5:13laughed, then I cried.
  152. 5:15Susan moved the tissue box closer
  153. 5:17without making a big production of it.
  154. 5:19Eventually,
  155. 5:21we started sorting through my old
  156. 5:22papers. I found certificates from
  157. 5:24computer classes, volunteer records, and
  158. 5:27a thick blue folder labeled Northside
  159. 5:29Community Center.
  160. 5:30For years, I'd helped coordinate
  161. 5:32workshops for older deaf residents,
  162. 5:35working alongside volunteers who used
  163. 5:36American Sign Language.
  164. 5:38I'd learned ASL gradually, attending
  165. 5:41evening classes and practicing with
  166. 5:43people at the center.
  167. 5:45I wasn't a professional interpreter,
  168. 5:47but I'd become comfortable enough to
  169. 5:49have conversations, organize events, and
  170. 5:51help develop practical communication
  171. 5:53materials. Inside the folder were
  172. 5:55handouts, illustrations, and staff
  173. 5:58training exercises we'd created
  174. 6:00together. One of the documents had a
  175. 6:02title I'd chosen,
  176. 6:04"Communication is a right, not a favor."
  177. 6:07Susan flipped through it. "This is good
  178. 6:10work." It was volunteer work. "So?" I
  179. 6:14shrugged. "Mark always called it my
  180. 6:16little project." Susan closed the
  181. 6:18folder.
  182. 6:19Mark also thought putting an empty milk
  183. 6:21carton back in the refrigerator counted
  184. 6:23as grocery management. I smiled. But
  185. 6:27after Susan left, I kept looking at
  186. 6:29those papers. One memory came back.
  187. 6:32About 9 years earlier,
  188. 6:34Mark had asked me to email him the
  189. 6:36workshop files.
  190. 6:38"I'd like to show a few people at work
  191. 6:40what you've been doing," he'd said.
  192. 6:42I'd been so pleased. For once,
  193. 6:46he seemed interested.
  194. 6:48I sent everything that evening. A week
  195. 6:51later,
  196. 6:52when I asked whether his coworkers liked
  197. 6:54it, he said he'd been busy. I never
  198. 6:57mentioned it again. Now,
  199. 6:59sitting at the dining room table with my
  200. 7:01unfinished resume,
  201. 7:03I placed the old blue folder beside my
  202. 7:05laptop. I didn't know whether any
  203. 7:08employer would care about that work, but
  204. 7:10I was running out of things to put on
  205. 7:11the page. For 22 years, Mark had been
  206. 7:15the person who decided what counted as a
  207. 7:17contribution. And the frightening part
  208. 7:20was how easily I'd started believing
  209. 7:21him. By the middle of April, I'd applied
  210. 7:24for 38 jobs. I had a spreadsheet to
  211. 7:27prove it. Susan said that alone should
  212. 7:29qualify me for an office position. Five
  213. 7:32companies had interviewed me. None had
  214. 7:34hired me. One manager asked whether I
  215. 7:37knew how to use modern office software.
  216. 7:39I I him I'd completed a recent Excel
  217. 7:41refresher course. He nodded politely.
  218. 7:44Then spent the rest of the interview
  219. 7:46talking as though I'd arrived from 1987.
  220. 7:49Another employer told me they wanted
  221. 7:51someone with more recent experience. I
  222. 7:54understood that.
  223. 7:55What bothered me was the way people
  224. 7:57sometimes treated my employment gap as
  225. 7:59evidence that I'd spent 21 years sitting
  226. 8:01on a couch. Meanwhile, my checking
  227. 8:04account was getting thinner. Mark was
  228. 8:06contributing toward household expenses
  229. 8:08under a temporary financial arrangement,
  230. 8:11but that didn't mean money was
  231. 8:12comfortable. The house needed
  232. 8:14maintenance. The legal bills were
  233. 8:16growing.
  234. 8:17And my car had developed a noise that
  235. 8:19sounded like a coffee grinder full of
  236. 8:20loose screws.
  237. 8:22The mechanic said the repairs would cost
  238. 8:24$1,180.
  239. 8:26I thanked him, drove home carefully, and
  240. 8:29spent that evening wondering whether a
  241. 8:30car could survive on positive thinking.
  242. 8:34On a Tuesday morning, I had an interview
  243. 8:36at Wickham Supply in Dublin. It was a
  244. 8:39family-owned company that distributed
  245. 8:40industrial equipment and replacement
  246. 8:42parts. Nothing glamorous. Exactly the
  247. 8:45kind of place I wanted. They needed an
  248. 8:47administrative coordinator who could
  249. 8:49handle customer correspondence,
  250. 8:51scheduling, and inventory records.
  251. 8:54I'd spent the weekend reviewing Excel
  252. 8:56formulas and practicing answers to
  253. 8:58interview questions.
  254. 8:59The night before,
  255. 9:01Ben sat beside me at the kitchen table.
  256. 9:04"Ask me something," I told him.
  257. 9:07He looked at my practice sheet.
  258. 9:09"Tell me about a time you handled a
  259. 9:11difficult person."
  260. 9:13We stared at each other, then he said,
  261. 9:16"Actually, Mom, maybe skip that one.
  262. 9:19You've got 22 years of material."
  263. 9:22I laughed hard enough to spill my tea.
  264. 9:25The next morning, I arrived 15 minutes
  265. 9:28early.
  266. 9:29The building was clean and ordinary,
  267. 9:31with a row of chairs near a reception
  268. 9:32desk and framed photographs of delivery
  269. 9:34trucks along the wall.
  270. 9:36A young receptionist sat behind the
  271. 9:38counter. Her nameplate read Kelly.
  272. 9:42She checked me in and told me to wait.
  273. 9:44A few minutes later,
  274. 9:46an elderly woman entered carrying a
  275. 9:48canvas tote and a folder.
  276. 9:50She had neatly combed silver hair, a
  277. 9:53navy cardigan,
  278. 9:54and the determined expression of someone
  279. 9:56who had already dealt with enough
  280. 9:57nonsense before lunch. She approached
  281. 9:59Kelly's desk. The woman pointed to a
  282. 10:02handwritten note, then began signing.
  283. 10:05I recognized American Sign Language
  284. 10:07immediately. Kelly didn't.
  285. 10:10Ma'am, I need you to tell me who you're
  286. 10:13here to see.
  287. 10:14The woman held up her note.
  288. 10:16Kelly glanced at it.
  289. 10:18Do you have an appointment?
  290. 10:20The woman signed again and tapped the
  291. 10:22paper.
  292. 10:23Kelly raised her voice.
  293. 10:24An appointment?
  294. 10:27I felt my shoulders tighten. Speaking
  295. 10:29louder doesn't help someone understand a
  296. 10:31language they aren't using.
  297. 10:33The woman patiently pointed to the note
  298. 10:35again. Kelly turned toward another
  299. 10:37employee.
  300. 10:38She's been waving her hands at me for 5
  301. 10:41minutes. I don't know what she wants.
  302. 10:44The woman looked down at her folder.
  303. 10:46I recognized that expression. Not
  304. 10:48confusion, exhaustion.
  305. 10:51I stood and approached from where she
  306. 10:52could see me.
  307. 10:54When I had her attention,
  308. 10:55I signed.
  309. 10:57Would you like some help?
  310. 10:59Her face changed. She answered quickly.
  311. 11:02Too quickly for me, actually.
  312. 11:04I smiled and signed.
  313. 11:06Sorry, a little slower, please.
  314. 11:09She repeated herself. Her name was
  315. 11:12Eleanor. She had an appointment with her
  316. 11:14son, Daniel Whitcomb,
  317. 11:16and wanted someone to tell him she'd
  318. 11:17arrived.
  319. 11:19I asked whether she minded me relaying
  320. 11:21the information.
  321. 11:22She nodded. I turned to Kelly.
  322. 11:25She's here to see Daniel Whitcomb. She
  323. 11:27has an appointment, and his name and the
  324. 11:29time are written on that paper.
  325. 11:32Kelly looked uncomfortable. Well, I
  326. 11:34couldn't understand her.
  327. 11:36That's why she wrote it down.
  328. 11:38I didn't raise my voice. There wasn't
  329. 11:40any point.
  330. 11:41Eleanor signed something else. I caught
  331. 11:43most of it, but one sign was unfamiliar.
  332. 11:47I asked her to repeat it. She pointed
  333. 11:49toward the printer behind Kelly.
  334. 11:52Then I understood.
  335. 11:53She'd said the printer seemed better at
  336. 11:55reading written instructions than the
  337. 11:57front desk.
  338. 11:58I laughed.
  339. 12:00Kelly frowned.
  340. 12:02What did she say?
  341. 12:03I considered a diplomatic translation.
  342. 12:06Then I remembered Mark telling me I
  343. 12:08needed to stop being so agreeable.
  344. 12:11She made a joke about your printer.
  345. 12:13Kelly stared at us.
  346. 12:15Eleanor gave me a small, satisfied
  347. 12:17smile.
  348. 12:19A door opened down the hallway. A man in
  349. 12:21a blue shirt and gray slacks stepped
  350. 12:23into the reception area. He looked to be
  351. 12:25around 50.
  352. 12:27Eleanor.
  353. 12:29The woman turned toward him. He began
  354. 12:31signing. His movements were quick and
  355. 12:33natural. Eleanor responded, pointing
  356. 12:36toward me several times.
  357. 12:38The man looked at my visitor badge.
  358. 12:40Then he looked directly at me.
  359. 12:43Are you Margaret Collins? Yes.
  360. 12:46He looked back at Eleanor, who signed
  361. 12:49something with considerable emphasis.
  362. 12:52Then he said the words I would remember
  363. 12:53for the rest of my life.
  364. 12:55My mother has been looking for you.
  365. 12:58I had absolutely no idea what to say.
  366. 13:01I'm sorry. Your mother?
  367. 13:03He smiled. I'm Daniel Whitcomb. This is
  368. 13:06my mother, Eleanor.
  369. 13:09Would you mind coming into my office for
  370. 13:10a few minutes? I glanced toward the
  371. 13:13receptionist.
  372. 13:14My interview is at 10:00.
  373. 13:16I know. You're on our schedule.
  374. 13:19That made me slightly nervous.
  375. 13:21Had I somehow failed an interview before
  376. 13:22it even started? Daniel added,
  377. 13:25Your application mentioned volunteer
  378. 13:27work at Northside Community Center. My
  379. 13:29mother has been trying to reconnect with
  380. 13:31someone from that program.
  381. 13:33Eleanor signed something.
  382. 13:34Daniel smiled. She says I'm explaining
  383. 13:37too slowly.
  384. 13:39I followed them into a conference room.
  385. 13:41Eleanor opened her folder and removed an
  386. 13:43old photograph.
  387. 13:45It showed a group of volunteers standing
  388. 13:47in front of a community center banner. I
  389. 13:49recognized myself immediately.
  390. 13:51My hair was darker and I was wearing a
  391. 13:54purple sweater I'd completely forgotten.
  392. 13:56Standing two people away was Eleanor.
  393. 13:59"Oh my goodness," I said.
  394. 14:02I looked at her.
  395. 14:03"You were at the Tuesday workshops." She
  396. 14:06nodded enthusiastically. I signed. "I
  397. 14:08remember you now."
  398. 14:10She squeezed my hand. Then she removed
  399. 14:12several photocopied pages. One showed a
  400. 14:15drawing of two hands beside a speech
  401. 14:17bubble.
  402. 14:18I'd drawn that little symbol years
  403. 14:20earlier. It wasn't particularly
  404. 14:22artistic. One thumb was noticeably too
  405. 14:24long.
  406. 14:25I'd once joked that the hand looked like
  407. 14:27it belonged to a basketball player.
  408. 14:30There it was.
  409. 14:31Reproduced on crisp new paper.
  410. 14:34Daniel explained that Whitcomb Supply
  411. 14:36was considering a customer accessibility
  412. 14:38training program.
  413. 14:40His mother had been reviewing some of
  414. 14:41the proposed materials.
  415. 14:43"She recognized portions of this," he
  416. 14:46said. "She believes you worked on the
  417. 14:48original program."
  418. 14:50"I did with several volunteers."
  419. 14:53Eleanor nodded. Daniel slid another page
  420. 14:56toward me.
  421. 14:58"Mom wants to know whether you gave
  422. 15:00anyone permission to present this work
  423. 15:02as something they developed."
  424. 15:05I looked at the familiar illustrations,
  425. 15:08then at the unfamiliar company logo
  426. 15:10printed above them.
  427. 15:12"No," I said. "I didn't."
  428. 15:15And just like that,
  429. 15:17I forgot every answer I'd practiced for
  430. 15:20my job interview. Daniel didn't tell me
  431. 15:22to accuse anyone. He didn't offer me a
  432. 15:25job or promise to punish whoever had
  433. 15:26used the material. He asked questions.
  434. 15:30Where had the program started? Who had
  435. 15:32helped create it?
  436. 15:34Did the community center still exist?
  437. 15:37I explained that Northside had operated
  438. 15:39a small outreach program for older deaf
  439. 15:42residents. We weren't teaching people
  440. 15:44how to be deaf or telling them what they
  441. 15:46needed.
  442. 15:47We were helping local service workers
  443. 15:49communicate more effectively with people
  444. 15:51who used different methods of
  445. 15:52communication.
  446. 15:54The deaf volunteers told us what
  447. 15:55actually happened at pharmacies, service
  448. 15:58counters, and community offices.
  449. 16:01I helped organize their suggestions into
  450. 16:03handouts, communication cards,
  451. 16:06and short training exercises.
  452. 16:09Eleanor had participated in several
  453. 16:11workshops. I'd known her simply as
  454. 16:14Eleanor. She'd later remarried.
  455. 16:16And although I vaguely remembered
  456. 16:18hearing about it, I hadn't connected her
  457. 16:20with the Whitcomb name. At one point,
  458. 16:24she signed that she still had my drawing
  459. 16:26of the strange-looking hand.
  460. 16:28I apologized for the oversized thumb.
  461. 16:31She signed back,
  462. 16:33"Very useful if you need to hitchhike."
  463. 16:36I laughed. Daniel watched us with an
  464. 16:38expression I couldn't quite read. Then
  465. 16:41he explained the problem.
  466. 16:43Whitcomb Supply was reviewing proposals
  467. 16:45for employee training. One vendor had
  468. 16:48submitted a program describing years of
  469. 16:50development and testing with deaf
  470. 16:51seniors.
  471. 16:53His mother recognized the illustrations
  472. 16:55in some of the examples.
  473. 16:56She wanted to verify the history before
  474. 16:59the company made a decision.
  475. 17:01"Who submitted it?" I asked.
  476. 17:04Daniel turned the proposal toward me.
  477. 17:06The company was Lakeview Business
  478. 17:07Solutions. I knew the name. Mark worked
  479. 17:10there. I looked farther down the page.
  480. 17:12Under project lead, I saw Natalie
  481. 17:15Brooks.
  482. 17:16For a moment, I wondered whether I was
  483. 17:18reading it correctly.
  484. 17:20Then Daniel asked,
  485. 17:22"Do you know Ms. Brooks?"
  486. 17:24I looked at him.
  487. 17:25"She's the woman my husband left me
  488. 17:27for."
  489. 17:28He stopped moving.
  490. 17:29Eleanor looked between us.
  491. 17:31Daniel signed a brief explanation.
  492. 17:34Eleanor's expression changed from
  493. 17:35curiosity to something considerably less
  494. 17:38friendly.
  495. 17:39I almost felt sorry for Natalie. Almost.
  496. 17:42Daniel closed the folder.
  497. 17:44"That creates a conflict we need to
  498. 17:46handle carefully."
  499. 17:48He explained that the company's
  500. 17:49purchasing team would need to review the
  501. 17:51proposal independently.
  502. 17:53I could provide information about the
  503. 17:54origins of the material,
  504. 17:57but I shouldn't be involved in deciding
  505. 17:58whether Lakeview received the contract.
  506. 18:01He also said my job application would
  507. 18:03remain with the human resources team. I
  508. 18:05appreciated that. I didn't want a
  509. 18:07position handed to me because his mother
  510. 18:09liked me.
  511. 18:10After all, I'd already spent months
  512. 18:12hearing that I only got by because
  513. 18:14someone else supported me.
  514. 18:16My interview happened later that
  515. 18:18morning. It wasn't a disaster. I
  516. 18:20answered questions about scheduling,
  517. 18:22customer communication, and record
  518. 18:24keeping.
  519. 18:25But when the interviewer demonstrated
  520. 18:27their inventory system,
  521. 18:29I struggled. I left knowing I needed
  522. 18:31more practice.
  523. 18:33That afternoon, I sat in my car outside
  524. 18:36a grocery store and cried. Not because
  525. 18:38of the interview,
  526. 18:39because the woman Mark had chosen over
  527. 18:41me was apparently building a
  528. 18:42professional reputation using work I'd
  529. 18:45helped create while he was calling me
  530. 18:46useless.
  531. 18:48I called Susan.
  532. 18:50"Are you sitting down?" I asked.
  533. 18:53"Margaret, I'm 59. Sitting down is one
  534. 18:55of my specialties."
  535. 18:57I told her everything.
  536. 18:59She listened without interrupting. When
  537. 19:02I finished, she asked,
  538. 19:04"Do you know for certain Natalie stole
  539. 19:06it?"
  540. 19:07"I know she didn't create the original
  541. 19:09material."
  542. 19:11"That's not quite the same thing.
  543. 19:13I hated that Susan was right. She
  544. 19:16continued, "Find out what happened, then
  545. 19:18get angry properly."
  546. 19:20That evening,
  547. 19:22I searched through my old computer
  548. 19:24files. My laptop had been replaced
  549. 19:26several years earlier, but I'd kept an
  550. 19:28external hard drive in a desk drawer.
  551. 19:30Naturally, it had 17 folders named
  552. 19:33things like old files, backup, and
  553. 19:35backup final.
  554. 19:37I would have fired myself as my own
  555. 19:38office assistant eventually.
  556. 19:41I found the Northside materials.
  557. 19:43There were early drawings, workshop
  558. 19:45agendas, feedback forms,
  559. 19:47and several versions of the training
  560. 19:49handbook. Some of the examples in
  561. 19:51Natalie's proposal matched the old
  562. 19:53documents almost word for word.
  563. 19:55Then I found an email from Mark.
  564. 19:58It was dated 9 years earlier.
  565. 20:00"Send me the workshop files when you get
  566. 20:02a chance. I'd like to show a few people
  567. 20:04at work what you've been doing."
  568. 20:06Underneath was my reply.
  569. 20:09Attached.
  570. 20:10"Thanks for taking an interest. Let me
  571. 20:13know what they think."
  572. 20:14I sat with that email open for a long
  573. 20:16time. I remembered where I'd been when
  574. 20:19he sent it, at the kitchen table,
  575. 20:22with Ben doing a puzzle beside me.
  576. 20:24I'd been excited. I'd even told Susan
  577. 20:27that Mark was finally recognizing my
  578. 20:29volunteer work.
  579. 20:31Now I couldn't stop wondering what he'd
  580. 20:33actually wanted.
  581. 20:35The next day,
  582. 20:36I called Linda Parker, the former
  583. 20:38Northside program coordinator.
  584. 20:41Linda was 61 and had retired to a small
  585. 20:44house outside Delaware,
  586. 20:46Ohio. She remembered me immediately.
  587. 20:49"Maggie Collins.
  588. 20:51Are you still making those terrible
  589. 20:53cookies?" They weren't terrible. They
  590. 20:56were very educational. You learned never
  591. 20:58to substitute applesauce for everything.
  592. 21:01We laughed. Then I explained why I was
  593. 21:03calling. Linda's tone became serious.
  594. 21:06She still had archived newsletters and
  595. 21:08workshop records. She agreed to look
  596. 21:11through them.
  597. 21:12Two days later,
  598. 21:14she emailed several documents.
  599. 21:17One newsletter described our project and
  600. 21:19listed the contributors.
  601. 21:21My name appeared alongside Eleanor's and
  602. 21:23other volunteers.
  603. 21:25Natalie wasn't mentioned. More
  604. 21:27importantly, the newsletter described
  605. 21:29the same testing sessions Natalie was
  606. 21:31claiming as part of her own professional
  607. 21:33development work.
  608. 21:35Daniel told me the vendor decision was
  609. 21:37about 5 weeks away.
  610. 21:39I began preparing a factual account with
  611. 21:41dates, documents,
  612. 21:43and the names of people who could
  613. 21:44confirm what happened.
  614. 21:46I wasn't certain who owned which rights
  615. 21:48to the materials.
  616. 21:50The community center had distributed
  617. 21:51them widely and multiple people had
  618. 21:54contributed.
  619. 21:55But one thing seemed clear.
  620. 21:57Natalie hadn't run those original
  621. 21:59workshops,
  622. 22:00and she hadn't designed the original
  623. 22:02program. Late one evening,
  624. 22:05I opened Mark's email again. The words
  625. 22:08were still there.
  626. 22:09I'd like to show a few people at work
  627. 22:11what you've been doing. I'd spent years
  628. 22:13thinking that was a compliment. Now I
  629. 22:16wondered whether it had been the first
  630. 22:17time Mark realized my unpaid work might
  631. 22:20be useful to somebody else.
  632. 22:23The first person to tell me I might not
  633. 22:25have a straightforward legal case was my
  634. 22:27attorney.
  635. 22:28Diane Ellis read through the papers I'd
  636. 22:30brought to her office. She was a
  637. 22:32practical woman with short gray hair and
  638. 22:34a desk that always looked as though a
  639. 22:36filing cabinet had exploded on it.
  640. 22:39"These documents support your
  641. 22:40involvement," she said, "but they don't
  642. 22:42automatically establish that you
  643. 22:44personally own every part of the
  644. 22:46program."
  645. 22:47I know.
  646. 22:49The nonprofit distributed the materials
  647. 22:51and several volunteers contributed.
  648. 22:54There may be permissions and ownership
  649. 22:55questions we need to clarify.
  650. 22:58So Natalie can just claim she invented
  651. 23:00it?
  652. 23:01That's a different issue. Her statements
  653. 23:02about experience and testing can be
  654. 23:04challenged with evidence.
  655. 23:07Diane tapped the newsletter.
  656. 23:09Stay with what you know, Maggie. Don't
  657. 23:11make accusations you can't support.
  658. 23:14I left her office feeling both reassured
  659. 23:16and frustrated. I wanted one person to
  660. 23:19say, "You're right. They're wrong.
  661. 23:21Here's what happens next."
  662. 23:23Apparently,
  663. 23:24adulthood doesn't work that way,
  664. 23:27especially when lawyers are involved.
  665. 23:30Meanwhile, my car was getting worse.
  666. 23:33The mechanic confirmed the repairs would
  667. 23:35cost $1,180.
  668. 23:38I had legal bills, groceries, and a
  669. 23:40house that seemed determined to break
  670. 23:42something new every week. And Whitcomb
  671. 23:44Supply hadn't offered me a job. The HR
  672. 23:47manager called to say I'd done well in
  673. 23:48the customer service portion of the
  674. 23:50interview, but needed stronger skills
  675. 23:52with their inventory software.
  676. 23:55She encouraged me to complete additional
  677. 23:57training in return for another
  678. 23:58assessment. I thanked her. Then I sat at
  679. 24:01the kitchen table and stared at the
  680. 24:03wall.
  681. 24:04Mark had always handled setbacks by
  682. 24:06telling me to be practical. For the
  683. 24:08first time in my life, I couldn't stand
  684. 24:11the word.
  685. 24:123 days later,
  686. 24:14Natalie called. I nearly declined. Then
  687. 24:16curiosity won.
  688. 24:18She asked to meet at a coffee shop near
  689. 24:20Polaris.
  690. 24:22"I think we should resolve this like
  691. 24:24adults," she said.
  692. 24:26I wondered whether she'd used that line
  693. 24:28before or after sleeping with somebody
  694. 24:30else's husband.
  695. 24:32I agreed to meet her the next morning.
  696. 24:35Natalie arrived wearing a tailored
  697. 24:36jacket and carrying a slim folder. She
  698. 24:39looked nervous,
  699. 24:41though she tried to hide it behind a
  700. 24:42professional smile.
  701. 24:44"Maggie, I know things between us are
  702. 24:46complicated.
  703. 24:48That's one word for it.
  704. 24:50She glanced around the shop.
  705. 24:52I didn't come here to talk about Mark.
  706. 24:54That's convenient. She opened the
  707. 24:56folder. She said she'd learn from the
  708. 24:58Northside materials and incorporated
  709. 25:01some of their ideas into a new
  710. 25:02commercial program. She insisted her
  711. 25:05proposal included substantial additional
  712. 25:07work. Then she offered me $2,500
  713. 25:10for consulting assistance along with an
  714. 25:12agreement covering the use of my
  715. 25:14contributions.
  716. 25:16I read the first page. The document
  717. 25:18contained several statements about
  718. 25:19permissions, releases, and future
  719. 25:22claims. I didn't understand all of it.
  720. 25:25"What exactly am I agreeing to?" I
  721. 25:27asked. "That we've resolved any
  722. 25:29disagreement about the material."
  723. 25:32"Does the Northside Committee get
  724. 25:34anything?"
  725. 25:35Natalie hesitated. "This arrangement
  726. 25:37would be with you."
  727. 25:39"But other people worked on it."
  728. 25:41She leaned back.
  729. 25:43"Maggie, you should be grateful. $2,500
  730. 25:46for something you did for free."
  731. 25:49There it was.
  732. 25:50The same belief Mark had expressed in
  733. 25:52our living room. If nobody paid you the
  734. 25:54first time,
  735. 25:56your work apparently belonged to whoever
  736. 25:58found a way to charge for it later.
  737. 26:01I wanted to tell her exactly what I
  738. 26:02thought. Instead,
  739. 26:04I asked,
  740. 26:06"Where did you get the original files?"
  741. 26:08She looked uncomfortable.
  742. 26:11"Mark provided some reference
  743. 26:12materials."
  744. 26:14"Did he tell you I helped create them?"
  745. 26:17"He said they were family materials. I
  746. 26:19assumed he knew what he was talking
  747. 26:20about."
  748. 26:22"Then why is your name listed as the
  749. 26:23project developer?" She closed the
  750. 26:25folder.
  751. 26:27"Because I developed the commercial
  752. 26:28proposal."
  753. 26:30That wasn't an answer, but I didn't
  754. 26:32argue.
  755. 26:33I asked to take the agreement home.
  756. 26:35Natalie seemed relieved.
  757. 26:37"Of course." Then she added,
  758. 26:40"I'd appreciate it if we could keep this
  759. 26:42from becoming something unpleasant."
  760. 26:44I looked at her.
  761. 26:45"11 months with my husband didn't bother
  762. 26:47you, but an unpleasant conversation
  763. 26:50does?"
  764. 26:51Her face tightened.
  765. 26:53For once,
  766. 26:54she had nothing ready to say.
  767. 26:57I drove home with the folder on the
  768. 26:58passenger seat. That evening, I placed
  769. 27:01Natalie's agreement beside my car repair
  770. 27:03estimate, $2,500,
  771. 27:06enough to fix the car, pay part of my
  772. 27:08attorney's bill, and buy groceries
  773. 27:10without checking my balance in the
  774. 27:11parking lot.
  775. 27:13I took out a pen.
  776. 27:14I wish I could tell you I immediately
  777. 27:16refused on principle. I didn't. I
  778. 27:19thought about signing. I thought about
  779. 27:21how tired I was.
  780. 27:23Then I read the part where I would be
  781. 27:25making assurances about the rights being
  782. 27:27granted and agreeing not to pursue
  783. 27:29certain claims. I couldn't speak for the
  784. 27:32other volunteers or the nonprofit, and I
  785. 27:34wasn't comfortable signing statements I
  786. 27:36didn't fully understand.
  787. 27:38I sent the document to Diane. She called
  788. 27:41the next afternoon.
  789. 27:43Don't sign this as written.
  790. 27:45That's what I thought. No, you were
  791. 27:47considering it. That's why you sent it
  792. 27:49to me.
  793. 27:50I smiled despite myself. She explained
  794. 27:53that we could try to negotiate fair
  795. 27:55compensation and proper credit without
  796. 27:57giving away rights I might not possess.
  797. 28:00I declined Natalie's offer in writing.
  798. 28:03That weekend,
  799. 28:04Mark came by to collect some belongings.
  800. 28:07He noticed the Northside document spread
  801. 28:09across my dining table.
  802. 28:11His expression changed.
  803. 28:13You're still doing this?
  804. 28:15Doing what?
  805. 28:16Trying to interfere with Natalie's
  806. 28:18project.
  807. 28:19I looked at him.
  808. 28:21Did you give her my files?
  809. 28:23I shared some reference materials.
  810. 28:25Did you tell her where they came from?
  811. 28:27She knew they were old community
  812. 28:29materials.
  813. 28:30Did you tell her I worked on them?
  814. 28:33Mark made an impatient sound. Maggie,
  815. 28:35those were handouts. Natalie turned them
  816. 28:38into something businesses can actually
  817. 28:39use.
  818. 28:41I stared at him.
  819. 28:42We made them for people to use.
  820. 28:45You know what I mean.
  821. 28:47No, I really don't. He picked up his
  822. 28:49coat.
  823. 28:51You're acting like she stole the
  824. 28:52Declaration of Independence.
  825. 28:55I almost laughed. Mark had always been
  826. 28:58good at making something sound
  827. 28:59ridiculous when he didn't want to
  828. 29:01discuss it.
  829. 29:02She told Whitcomb Supply she designed
  830. 29:04and tested that program.
  831. 29:06She improved it.
  832. 29:08That wasn't my question. He rubbed his
  833. 29:10forehead. You're just angry about us.
  834. 29:14I didn't deny it.
  835. 29:16Yes.
  836. 29:17Mark, I am angry about us.
  837. 29:20But that doesn't make her resume true.
  838. 29:23He looked toward the door.
  839. 29:25Companies don't pay people just because
  840. 29:26they were nice volunteers.
  841. 29:29I let that sentence sit between us.
  842. 29:32Then I said,
  843. 29:33You knew those people worked on it.
  844. 29:36You knew I worked on it.
  845. 29:38He didn't answer.
  846. 29:40After he left,
  847. 29:42I sat alone for a while.
  848. 29:44The following morning,
  849. 29:46Natalie sent me a short email repeating
  850. 29:48her offer.
  851. 29:49One sentence caught my attention. As
  852. 29:52Mark explained,
  853. 29:53he previously supplied the source
  854. 29:55materials used in developing our
  855. 29:57training proposal.
  856. 29:58I read it twice.
  857. 30:00It wasn't proof that Mark had committed
  858. 30:01some elaborate scheme,
  859. 30:03but it established that he had supplied
  860. 30:05the materials. I forwarded it to Diane.
  861. 30:08Then I contacted Linda and asked for
  862. 30:10permission to share relevant archived
  863. 30:12records with Whitcomb's procurement
  864. 30:14team.
  865. 30:15She helped me identify which materials
  866. 30:17we could provide and which contained
  867. 30:19personal information that needed to be
  868. 30:21removed.
  869. 30:22By Friday,
  870. 30:24I had prepared a straightforward written
  871. 30:25account. No insults.
  872. 30:28No accusations about Natalie's personal
  873. 30:30life. Just dates, documents,
  874. 30:33and an explanation of who did what
  875. 30:35before sending it.
  876. 30:37I went to a community lunch Eleanor had
  877. 30:39invited me to attend. I hadn't seen some
  878. 30:42of those people in years. My signing was
  879. 30:44slower than I remembered at one point.
  880. 30:48I mixed up two signs and accidentally
  881. 30:50made a comment about a sandwich when I
  882. 30:52meant to ask about a schedule.
  883. 30:54Eleanor laughed so hard she had to put
  884. 30:56down her napkin.
  885. 30:57Then she signed,
  886. 30:59"I make three mistakes before breakfast.
  887. 31:02You're allowed four."
  888. 31:04We spent two hours talking. Someone
  889. 31:07asked about Emily. Someone else
  890. 31:09remembered Ben as a little boy who used
  891. 31:11to hide under the folding tables. Nobody
  892. 31:13asked what I earned. Nobody asked why my
  893. 31:16marriage had failed.
  894. 31:18They wanted to know whether I'd come
  895. 31:19back the following month. Driving home,
  896. 31:22I realized something.
  897. 31:24Natalie hadn't just taken credit from
  898. 31:26me.
  899. 31:27She'd taken credit from people who'd
  900. 31:28trusted us to represent their
  901. 31:29experiences accurately.
  902. 31:32That mattered more than my anger at
  903. 31:33Mark.
  904. 31:35I sent the documents that evening.
  905. 31:37Monday morning, Mark called.
  906. 31:39"What did you send Whitcomb Supply the
  907. 31:41information they requested?"
  908. 31:44"You have no idea what you've just cost
  909. 31:45me."
  910. 31:47I looked at the mechanic's estimate
  911. 31:48still sitting on my table.
  912. 31:50"I haven't cost you anything."
  913. 31:52"Mark, not yet."
  914. 31:54Then I ended the call.
  915. 31:56My hands were shaking,
  916. 31:58but I didn't call back.
  917. 32:00The next 3 weeks were not nearly as
  918. 32:02exciting as people imagine revenge
  919. 32:04should be. Nobody was arrested. Nobody
  920. 32:07burst into my house waving legal papers.
  921. 32:09Mostly,
  922. 32:10people sent emails.
  923. 32:12Whitcomb Supply's procurement team asked
  924. 32:14Lakeview Business Solutions to clarify
  925. 32:17several statements in its proposal.
  926. 32:19Natalie had claimed her team developed
  927. 32:21and tested the training program with
  928. 32:23deaf seniors.
  929. 32:25The company requested dates,
  930. 32:27participating organizations, and
  931. 32:29supporting records.
  932. 32:31Lakeview submitted additional
  933. 32:32explanations. Some were vague. Others
  934. 32:35described work that had clearly happened
  935. 32:37before Natalie joined the project. The
  936. 32:40committee arranged a final vendor
  937. 32:41clarification meeting. Daniel told me I
  938. 32:43wouldn't need to attend. Frankly, that
  939. 32:46was a relief.
  940. 32:47I had no desire to sit across a
  941. 32:49conference table from my husband and his
  942. 32:51girlfriend while strangers examined our
  943. 32:53family history. I gave a written
  944. 32:55statement describing my role at
  945. 32:57Northside. Linda provided archived
  946. 32:59records with the community
  947. 33:01organization's authorization. Eleanor
  948. 33:03and another former volunteer, Ruth,
  949. 33:06agreed to discuss the original
  950. 33:08workshops. The company arranged
  951. 33:10appropriate ASL interpreting support for
  952. 33:12the meeting. I continued applying for
  953. 33:15work and practicing inventory software.
  954. 33:17At one point,
  955. 33:19Susan asked whether I was disappointed
  956. 33:21not to be at the meeting.
  957. 33:22A little, I admitted. You wanted to see
  958. 33:25Natalie's face?
  959. 33:27Maybe.
  960. 33:29Susan nodded.
  961. 33:30That's normal. Just don't let that
  962. 33:33become your retirement plan.
  963. 33:35On the day of the meeting, I worked
  964. 33:37through a practice inventory exercise at
  965. 33:39the library. I entered two product codes
  966. 33:42incorrectly, fixed them, then
  967. 33:44accidentally deleted a row. It was a
  968. 33:47remarkably ordinary afternoon
  969. 33:49considering that my husband's
  970. 33:50professional future might have been
  971. 33:52unraveling 20 minutes away. I learned
  972. 33:55what happened gradually from the
  973. 33:57official findings shared afterward and
  974. 33:59from Eleanor's account. Natalie had
  975. 34:02arrived with Mark and another
  976. 34:03representative from Lake View. She came
  977. 34:06prepared with a polished presentation.
  978. 34:08According to Eleanor, Natalie was
  979. 34:11perfectly confident when discussing
  980. 34:12customer satisfaction, employee
  981. 34:15efficiency, and training outcomes.
  982. 34:18The difficulties began when the
  983. 34:20committee asked about her claimed
  984. 34:21development process.
  985. 34:23A procurement manager asked which deaf
  986. 34:25community organizations had participated
  987. 34:27in the testing.
  988. 34:29Natalie named a general outreach
  989. 34:31initiative but couldn't provide records
  990. 34:34matching the dates in her proposal.
  991. 34:36Eleanor asked a more specific question
  992. 34:38through the interpreter.
  993. 34:40What changes did deaf participants ask
  994. 34:43you to make after the first test?
  995. 34:45Natalie described adding written
  996. 34:47communication cards and changing certain
  997. 34:50staff instructions.
  998. 34:51Those same changes appeared in the North
  999. 34:53Side documents from 9 years earlier. The
  1000. 34:56committee had copies.
  1001. 34:58One member asked Natalie whether she was
  1002. 35:00describing the original North Side
  1003. 35:01program or a separate test her team had
  1004. 35:04conducted.
  1005. 35:05Natalie said the commercial program had
  1006. 35:07been adapted from earlier materials.
  1007. 35:10That was different from what her
  1008. 35:11proposal claimed.
  1009. 35:13Then the committee asked why the
  1010. 35:14proposal presented the work as developed
  1011. 35:16and tested under Natalie's leadership.
  1012. 35:19She responded that Mark had supplied the
  1013. 35:21source materials. Mark reportedly said,
  1014. 35:24"I never told anyone Natalie created the
  1015. 35:27original documents."
  1016. 35:29Natalie turned toward him.
  1017. 35:31"You told me nobody was using them
  1018. 35:33anymore."
  1019. 35:34The committee chair asked them to answer
  1020. 35:36separately.
  1021. 35:37The question wasn't whether old material
  1022. 35:40could ever be adapted for a new purpose.
  1023. 35:42Of course it could. The question was
  1024. 35:45whether Lakeview had accurately
  1025. 35:46described its team's experience and the
  1026. 35:49testing it had performed. Ruth, who had
  1027. 35:52helped conduct the original workshops,
  1028. 35:55confirmed that the exercises Natalie
  1029. 35:56discussed came from the North Side
  1030. 35:58project.
  1031. 36:00Eleanor explained how the group had
  1032. 36:01developed the materials. She also
  1033. 36:03explained that the volunteers had wanted
  1034. 36:05their work shared. They simply hadn't
  1035. 36:08expected someone else to describe their
  1036. 36:09work as her own professional testing.
  1037. 36:12Eleanor signed one sentence that Daniel
  1038. 36:14later told me had stayed with everyone
  1039. 36:16in the room.
  1040. 36:17"We shared our work so people could use
  1041. 36:19it, not so they could erase us."
  1042. 36:22There was no grand speech after that.
  1043. 36:24The committee continued asking
  1044. 36:26questions. Mark acknowledged supplying
  1045. 36:28the materials to Natalie. He maintained
  1046. 36:30that he believed they were available for
  1047. 36:32adaptation.
  1048. 36:34That might have been true, but his
  1049. 36:35belief didn't establish that Natalie had
  1050. 36:37carried out the testing she claimed.
  1051. 36:40The meeting ended without a dramatic
  1052. 36:41announcement. A week later, Whitcomb
  1053. 36:44Supply notified Lakeview that its
  1054. 36:46proposal hadn't been selected. The
  1055. 36:49procurement findings identified
  1056. 36:51unsupported representations about
  1057. 36:53program development and testing as a
  1058. 36:55significant concern. A different
  1059. 36:57provider would be considered, and
  1060. 36:59Whitcomb would involve its community
  1061. 37:01advisors in developing an appropriate
  1062. 37:03training program.
  1063. 37:04Lakeview began an internal review. Mark
  1064. 37:07was temporarily removed from proposal
  1065. 37:09preparation and client-facing
  1066. 37:11presentations.
  1067. 37:13Later,
  1068. 37:14I learned the promotion he'd been
  1069. 37:16expecting had gone to another manager.
  1070. 37:18Natalie was removed from the Whitcomb
  1071. 37:20account.
  1072. 37:21She left Lakeview later that summer.
  1073. 37:24I never found out whether she resigned
  1074. 37:26or was encouraged to go.
  1075. 37:28I didn't particularly care.
  1076. 37:30What I cared about was what happened the
  1077. 37:31following Saturday.
  1078. 37:33We'd accepted an offer on the house, and
  1079. 37:35I was sorting through the remaining
  1080. 37:37closets.
  1081. 37:38Emily and Ben came to help. Mark arrived
  1082. 37:41around noon to collect a box of tools
  1083. 37:43and some old records. He walked into the
  1084. 37:45kitchen while I was wrapping dishes.
  1085. 37:48You really went through with it. I kept
  1086. 37:51folding newspaper around a serving bowl.
  1087. 37:53With what? Sending those documents,
  1088. 37:56getting Natalie investigated. Whitcomb
  1089. 37:58investigated its vendor.
  1090. 38:01You knew what would happen.
  1091. 38:03I knew they were asking questions. I
  1092. 38:05answered them.
  1093. 38:07Mark pulled out a chair, but didn't sit.
  1094. 38:10I lost a promotion over this.
  1095. 38:13I set down the bowl.
  1096. 38:15Did you lose it because I sent the
  1097. 38:17documents?
  1098. 38:18Or because your company didn't like what
  1099. 38:20those documents showed?
  1100. 38:22He stared at me.
  1101. 38:24You couldn't stand seeing Natalie
  1102. 38:26succeed.
  1103. 38:27I shook my head.
  1104. 38:29I could have lived with her success. I
  1105. 38:31couldn't live with her taking credit for
  1106. 38:32something she didn't do.
  1107. 38:34She did work on the proposal.
  1108. 38:37Then she should have taken credit for
  1109. 38:39that work.
  1110. 38:40Mark turned toward Emily
  1111. 38:42who was labeling a box.
  1112. 38:44You see what I mean? She's turned this
  1113. 38:46into a personal vendetta.
  1114. 38:49Emily put down the marker. No, Dad.
  1115. 38:52He looked surprised. She continued. Mom
  1116. 38:55gave up her career to raise us. You took
  1117. 38:57her work, gave it to your girlfriend,
  1118. 39:00and still called her a burden.
  1119. 39:02Mark opened his mouth.
  1120. 39:04Emily didn't let him interrupt.
  1121. 39:07I remember those workshops.
  1122. 39:09Mom used to bring us to the center after
  1123. 39:10school. I remember people coming to our
  1124. 39:13house to work on those materials.
  1125. 39:15Mark looked at Ben.
  1126. 39:17Ben was standing in the doorway with a
  1127. 39:19box of kitchen towels.
  1128. 39:21Don't look at me, Ben said. It wasn't
  1129. 39:23complicated when you said she lived off
  1130. 39:25you.
  1131. 39:26For the first time in months,
  1132. 39:28Mark seemed unsure what to say.
  1133. 39:31He finally turned back to me.
  1134. 39:33You enjoyed embarrassing me.
  1135. 39:35I considered the question.
  1136. 39:37There had been moments when I absolutely
  1137. 39:39wanted him embarrassed. I'd imagined
  1138. 39:42Natalie losing her confidence in front
  1139. 39:43of that committee more than once.
  1140. 39:46I'm not proud of every thought I had
  1141. 39:47during those months, but I wasn't going
  1142. 39:49to pretend I hadn't had them.
  1143. 39:52I wanted people to know the truth, I
  1144. 39:54said. Are you happy now?
  1145. 39:57I looked at him.
  1146. 39:58No,
  1147. 39:59Mark.
  1148. 40:00I was happy when I thought you were
  1149. 40:02proud of me.
  1150. 40:03He lowered his eyes.
  1151. 40:05That was the closest he came to
  1152. 40:07understanding what he'd done.
  1153. 40:10I went back to packing.
  1154. 40:11Emily carried a box to her car.
  1155. 40:14Ben followed. Mark stood in the kitchen
  1156. 40:16for another minute before picking up his
  1157. 40:18tools. I didn't ask him to stay.
  1158. 40:21For 22 years,
  1159. 40:23he'd been the one who decided what
  1160. 40:24counted as work.
  1161. 40:26That afternoon, he finally learned he
  1162. 40:28wasn't the only person keeping score.
  1163. 40:31I wish I could say everything became
  1164. 40:33easy after that.
  1165. 40:35It didn't.
  1166. 40:36The house still had to be sold. The
  1167. 40:38divorce still had to be settled. And my
  1168. 40:41car still needed $1,180 worth of
  1169. 40:43repairs.
  1170. 40:45Apparently, personal growth doesn't
  1171. 40:47impress an aging transmission.
  1172. 40:50But things began changing in ways I
  1173. 40:51could actually measure.
  1174. 40:53I completed another software course
  1175. 40:55through the community college when
  1176. 40:57Whitcomb Supply invited me back for a
  1177. 40:59second assessment.
  1178. 41:01I didn't panic at the inventory screen.
  1179. 41:03Well, not as much.
  1180. 41:06I entered the correct product codes,
  1181. 41:08caught a scheduling conflict, and
  1182. 41:11explained how I'd handle a customer
  1183. 41:12whose delivery was delayed.
  1184. 41:15Two days later,
  1185. 41:16HR called with an offer, administrative
  1186. 41:19coordinator.
  1187. 41:20A modest salary,
  1188. 41:22health benefits, paid time off, and a
  1189. 41:2590-day training period.
  1190. 41:27I asked them to email the details. Then
  1191. 41:30I called Susan.
  1192. 41:31They offered me the job.
  1193. 41:33She was silent for a moment. Then she
  1194. 41:35said,
  1195. 41:36"Does that mean I can stop pretending
  1196. 41:38your practice interviews are fun?" I
  1197. 41:40laughed. Yes.
  1198. 41:43"Thank God. You're a lovely woman,
  1199. 41:45Maggie, but your answers about conflict
  1200. 41:48resolution were getting exhausting."
  1201. 41:51I started work in June.
  1202. 41:53My first week was humbling. I made
  1203. 41:55mistakes.
  1204. 41:56I asked questions that probably sounded
  1205. 41:58ridiculous.
  1206. 41:59One afternoon, I entered the wrong
  1207. 42:01shipping address and had to call a
  1208. 42:03customer before the order went out. My
  1209. 42:06supervisor helped me fix it. Then she
  1210. 42:08said,
  1211. 42:09"That's why we double-check."
  1212. 42:11She didn't tell me I was too old. She
  1213. 42:13didn't ask why I'd been home for 21
  1214. 42:15years. She showed me how to correct the
  1215. 42:17mistake and moved on.
  1216. 42:20It was a surprisingly wonderful feeling.
  1217. 42:23The divorce took longer.
  1218. 42:24Diane negotiated with Mark's attorney
  1219. 42:26over the house proceeds, retirement
  1220. 42:29accounts, and financial support. There
  1221. 42:32were documents to review, figures to
  1222. 42:34verify, and several conversations I
  1223. 42:36would gladly have traded for a root
  1224. 42:38canal.
  1225. 42:39In September, we reached a settlement.
  1226. 42:42It wasn't everything I wanted, but it
  1227. 42:44accounted for the length of our
  1228. 42:46marriage, our financial circumstances,
  1229. 42:49and the years I'd spent outside paid
  1230. 42:51employment. The house was sold after
  1231. 42:54paying the mortgage and selling
  1232. 42:56expenses.
  1233. 42:58The remaining proceeds were divided
  1234. 43:00according to our agreement. The
  1235. 43:01settlement also addressed retirement
  1236. 43:03assets and support while I rebuilt my
  1237. 43:06earning capacity.
  1238. 43:08I rented a small two-bedroom townhouse
  1239. 43:10in Westerville.
  1240. 43:11The kitchen was narrow, the closets were
  1241. 43:13small, the second bedroom doubled as a
  1242. 43:15guest room and a place to keep the files
  1243. 43:17I'd finally learned not to throw away.
  1244. 43:21Susan visited the first weekend.
  1245. 43:23She stood in the living room and looked
  1246. 43:24around.
  1247. 43:25It's smaller than your old place.
  1248. 43:28So is my grocery bill. She nodded.
  1249. 43:32Getting rid of Mark may be the first
  1250. 43:33successful budget cut you've ever made.
  1251. 43:36We laughed, and for the first time in a
  1252. 43:38long while,
  1253. 43:40I wasn't laughing just to keep from
  1254. 43:41crying.
  1255. 43:43Emily and Ben helped me move.
  1256. 43:45Ben found an old family photograph in a
  1257. 43:46box of books. It showed the four of us
  1258. 43:49at a park when he was about five.
  1259. 43:51Mark was holding him on his shoulders.
  1260. 43:53Emily had lost one of her front teeth.
  1261. 43:56I was laughing at something outside the
  1262. 43:57frame.
  1263. 43:58Ben held up the picture.
  1264. 44:01Do you want me to throw this away?
  1265. 44:03I shook my head. No.
  1266. 44:06Really.
  1267. 44:07Your childhood wasn't a mistake just
  1268. 44:09because your father made one.
  1269. 44:11He looked at the photograph again.
  1270. 44:13Then he placed it carefully on my
  1271. 44:15bookshelf.
  1272. 44:16The children maintained their own
  1273. 44:18relationships with Mark.
  1274. 44:20I didn't interfere. They knew what he'd
  1275. 44:23done.
  1276. 44:24They were old enough to decide what they
  1277. 44:25wanted from him.
  1278. 44:28Emily apologized for initially thinking
  1279. 44:30I was pursuing the issue just to hurt
  1280. 44:32Natalie.
  1281. 44:33I told her she hadn't been entirely
  1282. 44:34wrong.
  1283. 44:35Part of me had wanted Natalie hurt.
  1284. 44:38Part of me had wanted Mark humiliated.
  1285. 44:41I just hadn't allowed those feelings to
  1286. 44:43decide what evidence I submitted or what
  1287. 44:45I said about them.
  1288. 44:47That distinction mattered to me.
  1289. 44:49Later that fall,
  1290. 44:51I heard Mark and Natalie were no longer
  1291. 44:53together. A mutual acquaintance
  1292. 44:55mentioned it. I didn't ask for details.
  1293. 44:58Mark had kept his job, but he'd lost the
  1294. 45:00promotion and no longer handled the kind
  1295. 45:02of client proposals he once considered
  1296. 45:04his specialty.
  1297. 45:06He sent me a message one evening. I know
  1298. 45:08I said things I shouldn't have said in
  1299. 45:09front of the kids. I'm sorry. I read it
  1300. 45:12twice. Then I replied,
  1301. 45:14"You didn't just say it, Mark. You
  1302. 45:16believed it for years."
  1303. 45:17He didn't answer. I didn't need him to.
  1304. 45:20At Whitcomb Supply, something else was
  1305. 45:22happening.
  1306. 45:23After rejecting Lakeview's proposal,
  1307. 45:26Daniel's company began developing a new
  1308. 45:28accessibility training program. This
  1309. 45:30time, they involved deaf community
  1310. 45:32members directly.
  1311. 45:34Eleanor and several other advisers were
  1312. 45:36paid for their time reviewing procedures
  1313. 45:38and testing materials. The company also
  1314. 45:41worked with the former Northside
  1315. 45:42organization to establish appropriate
  1316. 45:44permissions and credit for any older
  1317. 45:46resources it used. My role was mostly
  1318. 45:49administrative. I arranged meetings,
  1319. 45:52tracked revisions, and coordinated
  1320. 45:54schedules. Occasionally, I helped
  1321. 45:56clarify communication between staff and
  1322. 45:59advisers. Though professional
  1323. 46:01interpreting was arranged when needed,
  1324. 46:03it wasn't glamorous, but I loved it.
  1325. 46:06One afternoon, Daniel brought a freshly
  1326. 46:09printed training guide to my desk.
  1327. 46:11Thought you might want to see this.
  1328. 46:14I opened it. The first few pages
  1329. 46:16described the program and acknowledged
  1330. 46:18the organizations and people who had
  1331. 46:20contributed. There was a line near the
  1332. 46:22bottom, developed with contributions
  1333. 46:25from Margaret Collins and the North Side
  1334. 46:27Deaf Seniors Committee.
  1335. 46:29I looked at it for a long time. No one
  1336. 46:32had written me a huge check. No one had
  1337. 46:34named a building after me. There was
  1338. 46:37just my name
  1339. 46:38printed beside the people who'd actually
  1340. 46:40done the work.
  1341. 46:42Eleanor was visiting that afternoon. She
  1342. 46:45came over and noticed what I was
  1343. 46:46reading. She signed,
  1344. 46:48"They spelled your name right." I
  1345. 46:50smiled, "For once." She laughed. Then
  1346. 46:54she pointed to the credit line and
  1347. 46:55signed something else. I asked her to
  1348. 46:57repeat it.
  1349. 46:59She did. "Slowly. Now people know who
  1350. 47:02helped."
  1351. 47:03I nodded. "Yes." I signed. "They do."
  1352. 47:07We stood there for another moment
  1353. 47:09looking at the page. Then Eleanor took
  1354. 47:11the guide and began checking the rest of
  1355. 47:13it for mistakes. Sentimentality had
  1356. 47:16never stopped her from proofreading. A
  1357. 47:18few weeks later,
  1358. 47:20we attended a community gathering
  1359. 47:21together. Some of the people there
  1360. 47:23remembered the old North Side workshops.
  1361. 47:26Others were younger volunteers who'd
  1362. 47:28only recently joined. Eleanor introduced
  1363. 47:30me to a woman who was helping organize a
  1364. 47:32new program. When the woman asked how we
  1365. 47:35knew each other, Eleanor told her about
  1366. 47:37the workshops years earlier. Then she
  1367. 47:40told her about meeting me again at
  1368. 47:41Whitcomb Supply. I laughed at the
  1369. 47:43memory. "That wasn't exactly my best
  1370. 47:46day."
  1371. 47:47Eleanor looked amused. She signed, "You
  1372. 47:50helped me anyway."
  1373. 47:52I thought about that on the drive home.
  1374. 47:54At the time,
  1375. 47:56I'd been worried about the interview.
  1376. 47:58I'd been worried about money.
  1377. 48:00I'd been worried that 21 years outside
  1378. 48:02the paid workforce had made me
  1379. 48:04invisible.
  1380. 48:05I hadn't known Eleanor was connected to
  1381. 48:07the company.
  1382. 48:08I hadn't known she'd been looking for
  1383. 48:10me.
  1384. 48:10I'd simply seen someone being treated
  1385. 48:12badly and remembered what I could do to
  1386. 48:14help.
  1387. 48:15That didn't make me extraordinary.
  1388. 48:17It made me the same person I'd been
  1389. 48:19before Mark left.
  1390. 48:21Only now
  1391. 48:23I was beginning to recognize her again.
  1392. 48:25One Thursday evening in October,
  1393. 48:28I was sitting in my townhouse reading a
  1394. 48:30library book when my phone buzzed. A
  1395. 48:32message from Mark.
  1396. 48:35Do you still have the number for the guy
  1397. 48:36who used to fix our washing machine?
  1398. 48:40I stared at it.
  1399. 48:4222 years.
  1400. 48:44I'd scheduled the repairs, remembered
  1401. 48:46the appointments, paid the bills, and
  1402. 48:49kept track of every appliance in that
  1403. 48:51house.
  1404. 48:52Mark had never once needed to find a
  1405. 48:54repairman's phone number. I searched my
  1406. 48:56contacts, found it, sent it to him.
  1407. 49:00A minute later,
  1408. 49:01he wrote, "Thanks."
  1409. 49:03I set the phone down and laughed. Not
  1410. 49:06because I wanted him to suffer. Not
  1411. 49:08because fixing a washing machine was
  1412. 49:10some great moral test.
  1413. 49:12But because after everything he'd said
  1414. 49:14about me,
  1415. 49:15there was something wonderfully ordinary
  1416. 49:18about that message.
  1417. 49:20Mark had believed earning the paycheck
  1418. 49:22meant he carried the whole family.
  1419. 49:24He'd never noticed how much someone else
  1420. 49:26was carrying.
  1421. 49:28I still had difficult days.
  1422. 49:30I still missed parts of the life we'd
  1423. 49:31built.
  1424. 49:32Sometimes I missed the house.
  1425. 49:34Sometimes I missed having another person
  1426. 49:36there when something went wrong. And
  1427. 49:38sometimes I was angry all over again.
  1428. 49:40But I had work I enjoyed. I had my
  1429. 49:42children, my friends,
  1430. 49:44and a small home I could afford.
  1431. 49:46I had people who valued my time. And I
  1432. 49:49no longer needed Mark's approval to
  1433. 49:51believe that my years had meant
  1434. 49:52something.
  1435. 49:53He said I couldn't survive without him.
  1436. 49:556 months later,
  1437. 49:57he still couldn't figure out how to run
  1438. 49:58a washing machine without me.
  1439. 50:00If you've ever had someone make you feel
  1440. 50:02like the years you gave didn't matter,
  1441. 50:04I'd love to hear your story. And if
  1442. 50:06you're starting over later in life,
  1443. 50:09I hope you give yourself credit for
  1444. 50:10everything you've already learned.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of My Husband Called Me Useless After 22 Years. Then the Company Owner Said, My Mother Knows You. by Whispered Truths, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,519 words across 1,444 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.